DOCSLIB.ORG

The Original 2/1St Battalion a Quantitative Study of an Australian

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
The Original 2/1St Battalion a Quantitative Study of an Australian The Original 2/1st Battalion A Quantitative Study of an Australian Fighting Unit Richard Travers A thesis in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts by Research School of Humanities Faculty of Arts and Social Sciences August 2014 2 Table of Contents Acknowledgments 4 Figures 5 Tables 6 Abbreviations and Symbols 7 Prologue 8 Chapter 1 Introduction 9 What kind of men were the diggers? 9 The 2/1st Battalion 12 This study 14 Chapter 2 Historiography 16 Unit histories, culture and the quest for the stereotypical soldier Chapter 3 The Attestation Forms The attestation forms as evidence 42 Methodology 55 The 1933 Census Municipal Income Index 62 Chapter 4 The Second Australian Imperial Force 70 War of Empire 70 The 2nd AIF 71 Recruiting 75 3 The 2/1st Battalion 83 Summary 86 Chapter 5 The Demographics of the Original 2/1st Battalion 88 British subjects 89 Age 91 Employment status 100 Occupation 103 Religion 107 Previous militia service 111 Thirty-niners, or reinforcements? 111 Place of residence on enlistment 113 City vs country 119 Marital status 121 Younger vs older 123 The officers of the 2/1st Battalion 124 Officers vs the Battalion 128 Anti-Catholic bias? 132 From affluent suburbs? 136 Summary 140 Chapter 6 The Culture of the Original 2/1st Battalion 143 The culture of a military unit 143 Shared qualities of the original 2/1st Battalion 144 Summary 152 Chapter 7 Conclusion 154 4 Broader applications 154 Reporting evidence, or myth-making? 157 Chronology 160 Bibliography 167 5 Acknowledgments Sean Brawley has been outstanding as the principal supervisor of this work. He managed to create an environment that was at once welcoming and challenging, collegial and demanding. He was generous with his advice and his encouragement. He shared freely his deep knowledge of Australian military history, and yet he was careful to give me the latitude to develop my own ideas. He has been the model of a liberal academic, and a fine teacher. Shawn Ross, Genevieve Burnett, George Livanes and Mathew Radcliffe have been equally generous with their comments, advice and suggestions. Heather Flood and my children, Elizabeth, Lucy, Sophie and Henry, have given me their blessing and encouragement to indulge the luxury of studying history. I thank them all. Richard Travers August 2014 6 Figures Figure 1: Private Anderson's attestation form - front page. .................................................................................. 47 Figure 2: Private Anderson's attestation form - back page. .................................................................................. 47 Figure 3: The 1933 Census Municipal Income Index ........................................................................................... 69 Figure 4: City of Sydney boundaries 1932 - 1948 ................................................................................................ 72 Figure 5: My father, in Lieutenant’s uniform ....................................................................................................... 90 Figure 6: 2/1st Battalion, age on enlistment ......................................................................................................... 97 Figure 7: Age Cohorts Ist AIF vs 2/1st Battalion ............................................................................................... 103 Figure 8: Ken Clift's attestation form, front page ............................................................................................... 106 Figure 9: 2nd AIF NSW Enlistments to 26 April 1941, Employment by Industry ............................................. 109 Figure 10: 2/1st Battalion, Employment by Industry .......................................................................................... 110 Figure 11: 2/1st Battalion, religion ..................................................................................................................... 113 Figure 12: 2/1st Battalion, Employment by Industry, Protestants vs Roman Catholics ..................................... 115 Figure 13: 2/1st Battalion, dates of enlistment ................................................................................................... 117 Figure 14: 2/1st Battalion, 1939 enlisters vs 1940 enlisters, Religion ................................................................ 118 Figure 15: All Sydney Resident Members of the 2/1st Battalion, Place of Residence by Municipality .............. 120 Figure 16: Sydney Resident Protestant Members of the 2/1st Battalion, Place of Residence by Municipality ... 122 Figure 17: Sydney Resident Roman Catholics Members of the 2/1st Battalion, Place of Residence by Municipality ....................................................................................................................................................... 123 Figure 18: NSW Country Battalion members, by occupation ............................................................................ 125 Figure 19: Metropolitan Sydney Battalion members, by occupation ................................................................. 125 Figure 20: Marital status by age group ............................................................................................................... 127 Figure 21: Employment by Industry, older vs younger ...................................................................................... 128 Figure 22: 2/1st Battalion, rank, younger vs older............................................................................................... 129 Figure 23: 2/1st Battalion, Officers vs the Entire Battalion ................................................................................ 133 Figure 24: Employment by Industry, officers vs 2/1st Battalion ........................................................................ 134 Figure 25: The Officers of the 2/1st Battalion in Palestine, 1940 ....................................................................... 135 Figure 26: 1st Battalion, Promotion by Religion, from Blair ............................................................................. 138 Figure 27: 2/1st Battalion, Promotion by Religion ............................................................................................. 138 Figure 28: 2/1st Battalion Roman Catholics, employment by industry .............................................................. 139 7 Tables Table 1: Age cohorts of Long's sample of 14,953 men ........................................................................................ 51 Table 2: Income bands, municipality of Alexandria ............................................................................................. 65 Table 3: Sample index calculation for the municipality of Alexandria ................................................................ 67 Table 4: The 1933 Census Municipal Income Index ............................................................................................ 68 Table 5: 1933 Census Municipal Income Index showing unemployment levels .................................................. 71 Table 6: 2nd AIF gross monthly recruitment figures 1939 ................................................................................... 84 Table 7: 6th Division original structure ................................................................................................................ 85 Table 8: 2nd AIF gross monthly recruitment figures 1940 ................................................................................... 86 Table 9: 2/1st Battalion, Place of Birth ................................................................................................................. 94 Table 10: Birthplace of members of the 2/1st Battalion compared to the birthplace of all NSW males .............. 95 Table 11: 2/1st Battalion, average age on enlistment ......................................................................................... 100 Table 12: Comparison of average ages ............................................................................................................... 102 Table 13: Increase in the average age of the Union Army, from Gould ............................................................. 102 Table 14: Summary of the occupation studies .................................................................................................... 111 Table 15: Summary of the data on religion ........................................................................................................ 113 Table 16: 2/1st Battalion, place of residence on enlistment ............................................................................... 118 Table 17: Roman Catholics as a percentage of the male population .................................................................. 124 Table 18: 2/1st Battalion, marital status on enlistment, compared to that of the 1st AIF, from Butler .............. 126 Table 19: Original 2/1st Battalion, officers' brief details .................................................................................... 132 Table 20: Residence in metropolitan Sydney, officers vs other ranks ................................................................ 142 Table 21: Summary of the residence data ........................................................................................................... 143 Table 22: City of Sydney, breakdown of neighbourhoods ................................................................................. 144 Table 23: Adjusted summary of
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Major General James Harold CANNAN CB, CMG, DSO, VD
    Major General James Harold CANNAN CB, CMG, DSO, VD [1882 – 1976] Major General Cannan is distinguished by his service in the Militia, as a senior officer in World War 1 and as the Australian Army’s Quartermaster General in World War 2. Major General James Harold Cannan, CB, CMG, DSO, VD (29 August 1882 – 23 May 1976) was a Queenslander by birth and a long-term member of the United Service Club. He rose to brigadier general in the Great War and served as the Australian Army’s Quartermaster General during the Second World War after which it was said that his contribution to the defence of Australia was immense; his responsibility for supply, transport and works, a giant-sized burden; his acknowledgement—nil. We thank the History Interest Group and other volunteers who have researched and prepared these Notes. The series will be progressively expanded and developed. They are intended as casual reading for the benefit of Members, who are encouraged to advise of any inaccuracies in the material. Please do not reproduce them or distribute them outside of the Club membership. File: HIG/Biographies/Cannan Page 1 Cannan was appointed Commanding Officer of the 15th Battalion in 1914 and landed with it at ANZAC Cove on the evening of 25 April 1915. The 15th Infantry Battalion later defended Quinn's Post, one of the most exposed parts of the Anzac perimeter, with Cannan as post commander. On the Western Front, Cannan was CO of 15th Battalion at the Battle of Pozières and Battle of Mouquet Farm. He later commanded 11th Brigade at the Battle of Messines and the Battle of Broodseinde in 1917, and the Battle of Hamel and during the Hundred Days Offensive in 1918.
    [Show full text]
  • RUSI of NSW Paper
    Jump TO Article The article on the pages below is reprinted by permission from United Service (the journal of the Royal United Services Institute of New South Wales), which seeks to inform the defence and security debate in Australia and to bring an Australian perspective to that debate internationally. The Royal United Services Institute of New South Wales (RUSI NSW) has been promoting informed debate on defence and security issues since 1888. To receive quarterly copies of United Service and to obtain other significant benefits of RUSI NSW membership, please see our online Membership page: www.rusinsw.org.au/Membership Jump TO Article INSTITUTE PROCEEDINGS The Australian Army’s 2nd Division: an update1 an address to the Institute on 24 September 2013 by Brigadier Peter Clay, CSC Deputy Commander 2nd Division, on behalf of Major General S. L. Smith, AM, CSC, RFD Commander 2nd Division Vice-Patron, Royal United Services Institute, New South Wales Brigadier Clay details how the Australian Army’s 2nd Division, which contains most of the Australian Army Reserve, has progressed in achieving its force modernisation challenges under Army’s Plan Beersheba and outlines the delivery of a multi-role Reserve battle group for Army by the year 2015. Key words: Plan Beersheba, Total Force, Multi-role Reserve Battle Group, Exercise Hamel/Talisman Sabre, Army Reserve. On behalf of Commander 2nd Division, Major General very little change to their respective organisational Steve Smith, in this paper I will provide an update on the manning, with the exception of 11th Brigade, which has Division’s progress in integrating into the Army’s ‘Total inherited the vast majority of 7th Brigade’s Reserve assets Force’1 under Plan Beersheba2.
    [Show full text]
  • The Thermopylae Line
    CHAPTER 6 THE THERMOPYLAE LINE ENERAL Wavell arrived in Athens on the 19th April and immediately e Gheld a conference at General Wilson's quarters . Although an effectiv decision to embark the British force from Greece had been made on a higher level in London, the commanders on the spot now once agai n deeply considered the pros and cons . The Greek Government was unstable and had suggested that the British force should depart in order to avoid further devastation of the country. It was unlikely that the Greek Army of Epirus could be extricated and some of its senior officers were urging sur- render. General Wilson considered that his force could hold the Ther- mopylae line indefinitely once the troops were in position.l "The arguments in favour of fighting it out, which [it] is always better to do if possible, " wrote Wilson later,2 "were : the tying up of enemy forces, army and air , which would result therefrom ; the strain the evacuation would place o n the Navy and Merchant Marine ; the effect on the morale of the troops and the loss of equipment which would be incurred . In favour of with- drawal the arguments were : the question as to whether our forces in Greece could be reinforced as this was essential ; the question of the maintenance of our forces, plus the feeding of the civil population ; the weakness of our air forces with few airfields and little prospect of receiving reinforcements ; the little hope of the Greek Army being able to recover its morale . The decision was made to withdraw from Greece ." The British leaders con- sidered that it was unlikely that they would be able to take out any equip- ment except that which the troops carried, and that they would be lucky "to get away with 30 per cent of the force" .
    [Show full text]
  • 10Th Battalion (Australia)
    Article Talk Read Edit View history Search Wikipedia Participate in an international science photo competition! Main page Contents 10th Battalion (Australia) Featured content Current events From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia Random article Donate to Wikipedia For other uses, see 2/10th Battalion (Australia). Wikipedia store The 10th Battalion was an infantry battalion of the Australian Army that served as 10th Battalion part of the all-volunteer Australian Imperial Force during World War I. Among the first Interaction units raised in Australia during the war, the battalion was recruited from South Help About Wikipedia Australia in August 1914 and formed part of the 3rd Brigade, 1st Division. After basic Community portal training, the battalion embarked for Egypt where further training was undertaken until Recent changes the battalion was committed to the Gallipoli campaign. During the landing at Anzac Contact page Cove, it came ashore as part of the initial covering force. Members of the 10th Battalion penetrated the furthest inland of any Australian troops during the initial Tools fighting, before the Allied advance inland was checked. After this, the battalion What links here helped defend the beachhead against a heavy counter-attack in May, before joining Lines of the 9th and 10th Battalions at Mena Camp, Related changes Egypt, December 1914, looking towards the pyramids. the failed August Offensive. Casualties were heavy throughout the campaign and in Upload file The soldier in the foreground is playing with a Special pages November 1915, the surviving members were withdrawn from the peninsula. In early kangaroo, the regimental mascot Permanent link 1916, the battalion was reorganised in Egypt at which time it provided a cadre staff Active 1914–1919 Page information to the newly formed 50th Battalion.
    [Show full text]
  • CHAPTER XXII on Their Return to Egypt the Australian Formations Were Sent to the Suez Canal Zone and Helped to Form There A
    CHAPTER XXII EGYPT : REORGANISATION OF THE A.I.F. ON their return to Egypt the Australian formations were sent to the Suez Canal zone and helped to form there a new defensive front for Egypt. Simultaneously with this service the force was reorganised : the infantry into five divisions, forming, with the New Zealand Division, two army corps destined for the Western Front ; the light horse into the Anzac Mounted Division and other mounted units which became part of a British force which fought for the rest of the war in Egypt, Sinai, and Palestine. The self-government of the force in all matters of internal administration was established, though not yet entirely recognised by all the authorities that dealt with it; in the medical service the new director, his powers being now confirmed by the Commonwealth Govern- ment but not fully admitted by the War Office, collected the new medical staff of the A.I.F., hastened clearance to Australia, finalised reforms in the dental and nursing services, and carried out in the A.A.M.C. units a reorganisation, which embodied several experiments of interest. * * 8 The closing of the Gallipoli campaign opened for the A.I.F. a new phase in its history, with service in a much wider and more diversified sphere of action. The next Return to three months were occupied in a complete Eemt reconstruction and reorganisation of the force, carried out while the troops were taking their part in the dispositions for the new strategic situation. The mise-en-scine of the reorganisation was the neighbourhood of the Suez Canal.
    [Show full text]
  • The Final Campaigns: Bougainville 1944-1945
    University of Wollongong Thesis Collections University of Wollongong Thesis Collection University of Wollongong Year The final campaigns: Bougainville 1944-1945 Karl James University of Wollongong James, Karl, The final campaigns: Bougainville 1944-1945, PhD thesis, School of History and Politics, University of Wollongong, 2005. http://ro.uow.edu.au/theses/467 This paper is posted at Research Online. http://ro.uow.edu.au/theses/467 The Final Campaigns: Bougainville 1944-1945 A thesis submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the award of the degree Doctor of Philosophy from University of Wollongong by Karl James, BA (Hons) School of History and Politics 2005 i CERTIFICATION I, Karl James, declare that this thesis, submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the award of Doctor of Philosophy, in the School of History and Politics, University of Wollongong, is wholly my work unless otherwise referenced or acknowledged. The document has not been submitted for qualifications at any other academic institution. Karl James 20 July 2005 ii Table of Contents Maps, List of Illustrations iv Abbreviations vi Conversion viii Abstract ix Acknowledgments xi Introduction 1 1 ‘We have got to play our part in it’. Australia’s land war until 1944. 15 2 ‘History written is history preserved’. History’s treatment of the Final Campaigns. 30 3 ‘Once the soldier had gone to war he looked for leadership’. The men of the II Australian Corps. 51 4 ‘Away to the north of Queensland, On the tropic shores of hell, Stand grimfaced men who watch and wait, For a future none can tell’. The campaign takes shape: Torokina and the Outer Islands.
    [Show full text]
  • 7468 .The London Gazette, December 28, 1877
    7468 .THE LONDON GAZETTE, DECEMBER 28, 1877. Name. Rank. Regiment. Amount. £ s. d. Clarke, Alexander . ... • Private ... •« 1st West India Regiment 074 Cock, Thomas Private ... •• 2nd Battalion, 10th Regiment .. 1 12 7 Conn, Robert ... ... .. Private ... .. .1st Battalion, 3rd Regiment 9 1 11 Connell, Thomas .*. .. Private 72nd Regiment 10 15 t Dwyer, Simon ... ... .. Private ... .. 45th Regiment ... ..i .. 3 11 5 Fitzpatrick, John Private ... .. 108th Regiment... ' ... .. 23 19 6 Flinn, Thomas Private 44th Regiment 14-5 Gillott, H. ... - ... Gunner ... .. 2nd Brigade, Royal' Artillery .. 459 Goodwill, John .... ... Private ... .. 96th Regiment ... ... .. 315 Griffiths, Theodore Private ... 45th Regiment ... ' ... 6 9 O Hill, Thomas E.... ... .. Private 80th Regiment 1 11 7 Hogan, Patrick Private ...• 1st Battalion, 2 1st Regiment .. 32 7 2 Hoy, Thomas Private 94th Regiment 0 18 11 Mansell, Charles... ... .. Gunner ... .. 9th Brigade, Royal Artillery .. 3 9 10 Matthews, Patrick Gunner .. .. 16th Brigade, Royal Artillery .. 464 May, George; ... ... .. Private .. .. 62nd Regiment 3 13 5 Mehan, Daniel Private .. .. 66th Regiment ... ... .. 3 14 3 Murray, James ... ... Private .. •> 45th Regiment ... ... 104 McGrath, Richard Private .. ' ... 40th Regiment ... 2 11 4 McKay, James ... Private 2nd Battalion, 19th Regiment ... 15 4 5 McKenna, Patrick ... ... Private .. ... 2nd Battalion, 1st Regiment ... 529 McKeon, Bartholomew ... ... Gunner .. ... 5th Brigade, Royal Artillery ... 29 19 6 McKinstry, William Gunner .. Depot Brigade, Royal Artillery... 32 12 5 McWhiney, Thomas ... ... Private .. 36th Regiment ... ... ... 542 Nicholas, James Gunner ... Dep6t Brigade, Royal Artillery... 138 O'Farrell, Michael Warder Military Prison ... ...' • ... 424 Parker, Thomas Gunner ... .... 3rd Brigade, Royal Artillery ... 0 17 4 Peel, Thomas ... • ... ... Private ... - ... 1st Battalion, 17th'Regiment ... 4 17 6 Prendible, Charles Private 85th Regiment 212 9 Rabbitt, James B.
    [Show full text]
  • Your Presentation Is the Keynote Presentation for the Block
    1984 RUSI VIC BLAMEY ORATION By Major General Ken G. Cooke, ED There must be something special about a man who on the centenary of his birth and thirty-three years after his death can still trigger a gathering of so many people, including so many busy and distinguished people, in a Melbourne park on a Tuesday morning in January. So let us take a few minutes to review briefly the life of Thomas Alfred Blamey to try and determine just how this can be. He was born on 24th January, 1884 on the outskirts of Wagga Wagga, the seventh of the ten children of Richard and Margaret Blamey. His father had tried his luck at farming, both in Queensland and New South Wales, but as was often the case the ventures ended in disaster due to the old traditional enemies of drought, bush fire and fluctuating cattle prices. He then settled in Wagga where he earned his living as a contract drover. His was a pioneer family so typical of the time and it exemplified the strength of our immigrant stock both before and since. Young Tom was educated in Wagga, first at the Government school and then for the last two years at the Grammar school to which he won a place on his pure ability. His upbringing generally was as you would expect. He had to help around the family property before and after school and on vacations he worked as a tar- boy in the local shearing sheds. As he grew older he went on several droving trips to help his father.
    [Show full text]
  • Moshe Goldberg Eulogy 2
    EULOGY FOR MOSHE (MORRY) GOLDBERG GIVEN AT HIS FUNERAL ON SUNDAY 20 JANUARY 2013 Morry Asher GOLDBERG was born at Jerusalem, Palestine on 12 APRIL,1926 and originally enlisted and served in the Militia as N479345 prior to enlisting and serving as NX178973 PRIVATE Morry GOLDBERG in the 2nd/48th Australian Infantry Battalion AIF at Cowra NSW on 1st July 1944, then just 18 years of age. During his service with the Battalion, Morry was promoted to Corporal, taking part in its heavy fighting against the Japanese on Tarakan as part of Operation ‘Oboe’ in the South West Pacific Theatre. Morry was discharged on 10th March, 1947. The 2/48th Battalion AIF was an infantry battalion of the Australian Army raised in August 1940 at the Wayville Showgrounds in Adelaide, under the command of Lieutenant Colonel Victor Windeyer, (later Major General Sir Victor Windeyer, KBE, CB, DSO and Bar, PC KC) a former Militia officer 9and later a Judge of the high Court of Australia) who had previously commanded the Sydney University Regiment. Together with the 2/23rd and 2/24th Battalions the 2/48th Battalion formed part of the 26th Brigade and was initially assigned to the 7th Division, although it was later transferred to the 9th Division in 1941 when it was deployed to the Middle East. While there, it saw action during the siege of Tobruk where it suffered the loss of 38 men killed in action and another 18 who died of their wounds and the Second Battle of El Alamein before being returned to Australia in order to take part in the fighting in New Guinea following Japan’s entry into the war.
    [Show full text]
  • The Combat Effectiveness of Australian and American Infantry Battalions in Papua in 1942-1943 Bryce Michael Fraser University of Wollongong
    University of Wollongong Research Online University of Wollongong Thesis Collection University of Wollongong Thesis Collections 2013 The combat effectiveness of Australian and American infantry battalions in Papua in 1942-1943 Bryce Michael Fraser University of Wollongong Research Online is the open access institutional repository for the University of Wollongong. For further information contact the UOW Library: [email protected] Faculty of Arts School of History and Politics The combat effectiveness of Australian and American infantry battalions in Papua in 1942-1943 Bryce Michael Fraser, BA. This thesis is presented as the requirement for the Award of the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy University of Wollongong March 2013 CERTIFICATION I, Bryce Michael Fraser, declare that this thesis, submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the award of Doctor of Philosophy, in the Department of History and Politics, University of Wollongong, is wholly my own work unless otherwise referenced or acknowledged. The document has not been submitted for qualifications at any other academic institution. B M Fraser 25 March 2013 ii TABLE OF CONTENTS LIST OF TABLES AND FIGURES iv ABBREVIATIONS vii ABSTRACT viii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS x Introduction: 1 Chapter 1: Theory and methodology 13 Chapter 2: The campaign and the armies in Papua 53 Chapter 3: Review of literature and sources 75 Chapter 4 : The combat readiness of the battalions in the 14th Brigade 99 Chapter 5: Reinterpreting the site and the narrative of the battle of Ioribaiwa 135 Chapter 6: Ioribaiwa battle analysis 185 Chapter 7: Introduction to the Sanananda road 211 Chapter 8: American and Australian infantry battalions in attacks at the South West Sector on the Sanananda road 249 Chapter 9: Australian Militia and AIF battalions in the attacks at the South West Sector on the Sanananda road.
    [Show full text]
  • Churchill, Wavell and Greece, 1941*
    Robin Higham Duty, Honor and Grand Strategy: Churchill, Wavell and Greece, 1941* In our previous works, then Capt. Harold E. Raugh and I took too limited a Mediterranean view of the background of the Greek campaign of 6-26 April 19411. Far from its being Raugh’s “disastrous mistake,” I argue that General Sir Archibald Wavell’s actions fitted both traditional British practice and the general policy worked out in London. In 1986 and 1987 I argued after long and careful thought since 1967 that Wavell went to Greece as part of a loyal deception of Prime Minister Winston Churchill, whose bellicose way at war was the antithesis of Wavell’s own professionalism. Further, whereas Raugh took the narrow military view, mine was a grand-strategic approach relating ends to means. My argument here is that a restudy of the campaign in Greece of 6-27 April 1941 utilizing the Orange Leonard ULTRA messages reconfirms my thesis that going to Greece was a deception and that far from being the miserable defeat which Raugh imagined, the withdrawal was a strategic triumph in the manner of a Wellington in Spain and Portugal or of the BEF’s in France in 1940. For this Wavell deserves full credit. In this respect, then, the so-called campaign in Greece must be seen not as an ignominious retreat in the face of superior forces, but rather as a skilful, carefully planned withdrawal and ultimate evacuation. It was a successful, though materially costly, gamble. * This paper was accepted for publication in late 2005 but delayed by the Balkan Studies financial crisis.
    [Show full text]
  • Last Counter-Attack and a Controversial Relief The
    CHAPTER 8 LAST COUNTER-ATTACK AND A CONTROVERSIAL RELIEF HE men of the Tobruk garrison had always thought that the term o f T their confinement would be the time taken to drive off the besiegers . In the midsummer month of July when the prospect of relief by a frontie r offensive seemed indefinitely remote, General Blarney proposed anothe r kind of relief : relief by sea . His request provoked a strong disagreement between the British and Australian Governments ; but confidences were so well kept that to all but one or two of the Australians who were in the fortress the first intimation that their going thence had been th e subject of controversy was the publication after the war of Sir Winston Churchill's The Grand Alliance, in which he gave his own account of the dispute. There he declared that it gave him pain to have to relate the incident, but to suppress it indefinitely would have been impossible . "Besides, " he wrote, "the Australian people have a right to know what happened and why." 1 For that very reason it was unfortunate that, i n relating the differences between the two Governments, Sir Winsto n Churchill quoted extensively from his own messages to successive Aus- tralian Prime Ministers but did not disclose the text of their replies . If the Australian people had depended solely on Sir Winston Churchill 's account for knowledge of what happened and why, they might have been left with some erroneous impressions . In particular it might have been inferred that when Mr Fadden's Government insisted that the relief o f the 9th Division should proceed, it did so not because of a strong convic- tion based on broad considerations advanced by its military advisers bu t because it had been induced by "hard pressure from its political opponents " to turn a deaf ear to Churchill's entreaties .
    [Show full text]