Paleomagnetic Indications for a Late Paleozoic Age for Part of the Watrous Formation, Williston Basin, Southern Saskatchewan
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Paleomagnetic Indications for a Late Paleozoic Age for Part of the Watrous Formation, Williston Basin, Southern Saskatchewan 1 1 2 Randolph J Enkin , Judith Baker , and K. G. Osadetz Enkin, R.J., Baker, 1. , and Osadetz, K.G. (2001): Paleomagnctic indications for a Late Paleozoic age for part of the Watrous Formation, Williston Basi n, southern Saskatchewan; in Summary of In vestigations 200 1, Volume I, Saskatchewan Geological Survey, Sask. Energy Mines, Misc. Rep. 2001-4.1. l. Introduction Saskatchewan, Manitoba, and the adjacent United States of America (Figure I). The basin contains The Williston Basin is a Phanerozoic epicratonic basin several significant petroleum provinces and mineral about 800 km in diameter underlying southern deposits (e.g. Burrus et al., 1996), and has thus been the focus of detailed exploration. SASKATCHEWAN MANITOBA However, there remain profound uncertainties concerning the origin, tectonics, and even _..-. Petroleum ..... Province stratigraphy of the basin. These uncertainties hamper the Depth to base of understanding of its petroleum Carboniferous (m) systems. The Watrous Formation (Milner and Thomas, 1954) is composed of red bed siliciclastics and anhydrites (Christopher, 1984; Edwards et al., 1994 ). The formation onlaps a major regional unconformity underlain by the deeply eroded Paleozoic carbonate succession (Figure 2). These usually " tight" rocks are commonly cap rocks to the Mississippian subcrop oil fields. The formation has been a minor ----- oil producer, from more sandy porous lithologies, as typified by the Waskada Field in southwestern Manitoba that was discovered in 1980. The Watrous Formation is informally split into "upper" and " lower" members. The upper Middle Devonian member is dominated by '""'"''~ anhydrites and is considered to be of Jurassic age (Christopher, 1984). The lower member has been correlated to the Lower Figure 1 (detail) Jurassic upper Spearfish Formation which crops out in North Dakota. Others suggest this member may be as young as Middle Jurassic (see Edwards et al., 1994). Figure 1 .. Regional setting, major tectonic elements, and petroleum provinces ofthe Williston Basin. Basi11form-lines are indicated by the depth to the base ofth e Carbo11iferous Madison Group. I Geological Survey of Canada - Pacific, 9860 West Saanich Road, POB 6000, Sidney, BC V8L 482. 2 Geological Survey of Canada, 3303 - 33rd Street NW, Calgary, AB T2L 2A7. 72 Summary ofInv estigations 200/, Volume I (km) Fonnation is underlain by the 0 100 200 300 Charles Fonnation of the Carboniferous Madison Group. NNE SSE N s 2. Methods We drilled 2.5 cm diameter minicores perpendicular to the core axis. Since the original core _o was almost vertical, our E minicores were taken parallel to ~ the near- horizontal strata. Where c .2 CRETACEOUS the rock was massive and red j .!! pigmented, we sampled every 2 w to 3 ft (60 to 90 cm). Magnetic remanence was JURASSIC measured on an Agico JR5-A TRIASSIC spinner magnetometer. Magnetic PERMIAN susceptibilities were measured using a Sapphire SI2-B meter. We measured both full core and minicore susceptibility. Thermal demagnetizations were performed with an ASC TD-48 furnace, over 12 to 15 steps up to 700°C. Imperial* Herald Magnetic remanence directions 1-31-1-20W2 were determined by Principal .~I:. =- I. Triassi<;. .. Component Analysis, using programs developed by the first lower tJ r-re~ian author (available on request). Watrous { 'VVVV'\, tf] I~:~~sylvanian 3. Results The core of the lower Watrous - - consists mostly of red to orange Figure l - Section of Williston Basin illustrating the Phanerozoic stratigraphic mudstone to siltstone with rare succession after Burrus et al. (1996). Location ofthis section is indicated in Figure I. beds of sandstone. Common The interpreted stratigraphic position ofthe lower member ofthe Watrous in the ripple marks and cross bedding analyzed core is shown in the inset in the lower left-hand corner ofthe diagram. indicate shallow-water deposition. Reduction spots are In an attempt at better determining the age of this non common, and usually have sharp fossiliferous formation, we sampled core from an oil edges. They are early diagenetic features, and exploration well for paleomagnetic study. The apparently have not been altered by subsequent fluid observed magnetic inclination gives the paleolatitude at motions. which the rocks were situated at the time of magnetization. By comparing the paleolatitude history Characteristic demagnetization curves are plotted in of the site, derived from North America's apparent Figure 3. The natural remanent magnetizations (NRM) polar wander path (APWP), with the observed are typical of red sediments (geometric mean paleolatitude, we can detennine the age of the 5.34 mA/m ±48%). The samples are relatively magnetization. If the magnetization is primary, we can efficiently magnetized (Koenigsberger ratio KN= date the age of sediment deposition. NRM/induced magnetization = 1.34 ±45%) compared to similar rocks which usually have KN < 1. However, We sampled the Imperial Herald core (1-31-1-20W2; about half of the magnetization is a drilling induced 49.1 °N, I 04.5°W, approximately 160 km south of overprint. This component, roughly parallel to the Regina), because it lies near the centre of the Williston direction ofminicoring, is removed by heating to 150° Basin and has excellent recovery of the lower member or 200°C. The remaining magnetization remains very of the Watrous Fonnation. The Watrous Formation was stable to about 500°C. The dominant magnetic carrier picked between depths of 5206 and 5593 ft (1586.8 is clearly hematite (with a Curie Temperature Tc = and 1704.7 m), and the bottom 110 feet (33.5 m) were 680°C), as most of the stable magnetization unblocks almost continuously recovered. The Watrous between 600° and 700°C heating, well above the Tc of magnetite, 580°C. The remanence direction held by the hematite is easily determined by line-fitting this high Saskatchewan Geological Survey 73 lower Watrous Group A: 5515 feet attempted to orient the core NN • Lower N 6.25mA/m using the faint present-fi eld eo nupper overprint which survived the drilling overprint. The resolution is low, but we find north-west declinations in the A group, and southerly declinations in the B group. This indicates that the A group is truly normal polarity, while the B group has reverse o , oo 300 soo 1oo·c polarity and is not a normal polarity magnetization from lower Watrous Group A: 5546 feet when North America was NN situated in the southern eo 3 75mA/m hemisphere. The mean inclination of group A is 25.1° ±4.1° , N = 49, Fisher precision k = 14.9 (method of Enkin and Watson, 1996). This 6 75'C observed inclination is consistent with the expected inclination derived from the North American APWP for ages between 209 to 3 1 1 Ma lower Watrous Group B: 5570 feet (Pennsylvanian through Triassic) NN ea 6.1mA/m (Figure 5). Note, in particular, that North America drifted rapidly northward during latest Triassic and Early Jurassic time, and that the expected incl ination fo r all more recent times is far steeper than what we observe. 675'C Thus we can be sure that these rocks did not suffer a post 0 100 300 500 Triassic remagnetization. lower Watrous Group B: 5576.5 feet f he observed polarity is normal, NN eo 5.92mAlm and during most of Pennsylvanian and Permian times, the geomagnetic field has persistent reverse polarity, a period known as the Kiaman Reverse Chron. Thus we conclude that the age of this interval of the Watrous Formation is between latest Pennian to Triassic time (260 to 209 Ma), likely during one Figure 3 - Typical demagnetization characteristics oflo wer Watrous Formation nonnal polarity chron. specimens, illustrated as orthogonal projections, stereographs, and magnetic intensity as a/unction oftherma l demagnetization step. The B group has significantly shallower inclination (- 13 .5° temperature segment. About 20% of the samples were ±3.8°, N = 25, k = 34.7). This result is consistent with unsuitable, since the remanence was demagnetized at the North American APWP between the ages of 351 much lower temperatures and gave either incoherent and 303 Ma (Mississippian th rough Pennsylvanian) directions, or only drilling overprint directions. (Figure 5). There are reversals before the Kiaman Reverse Chron, so it is not possible to constrain the age The observed remanence directions clearly separate using magnetic polarity as confidently as with th e A into two groups (Figure 4). The A group, from depths group. But since we observed no reversals in this of5484 to 5560 ft (167 1.5 to 1694.7 m), has positive interval of the core, we consider it likely to have post (down) inclinations, while the 8 group, from 5563 to dated the start of the Kiaman at about 3 15 Ma. 5583 ft ( 1695.6 to 1701.7 m), has negative (up) inclinations. The declinations are random. However, from core segments which we could piece together, we 74 Summary of Investigations 200 I, Volume I concerning the age and correlation of that formation, N and in this respect the present report is no exception". •Lower They go on to say, " We maintain the tradition". While A Upper recognizing the preliminary nature of our study, we feel confident in saying that the lower Watrous 1, recovered in the Imperial Herald core was not • deposited after Triassic time, and is most likely latest • Permian to Triassic in age. Furthermore, a period of • • tens of millions of years is missing near the bottom of • the Watrous in this core. The lowest 20 ft (6. 1 m) is of • ) Paleozoic, probably mid-Pennsylvanian, age. + Our study on sub-Watrous portions of the core • • indicates that only the red sediments retain stable • • magnetizations. The possibility exists that the Charles I • • • Formation has suffered pervasive remagnetization during Permian time.