Maryland Historical Magazine, 1978, Volume 73, Issue No. 4
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Historical Magazine Annual Report 1977-1978 Volume 73 Index Published Quarterly by The Museum and Library of Maryland History The Maryland Historical Society Winter 1978 MARYLAND HISTORICAL SOCIETY BOARD OF TRUSTEES J. Fife Symington, Jr., Chairman* Leonard C. Crewe, Jr., President* H. Furlong Baldwin H. Irvine Keyser, II James R. Herbert Boone Richard R. Kline Philip Carroll Mrs. Frederick W. Lafferty* Mrs. James F. Colwill Calvert C. McCabe, Jr.* James W. Constable Joseph H. McLain Owen Daly, II Robert G. Merrick, Sr.* Mrs. Gerson G. Eisenberg Robert G. Merrick, Jr. John G. Evans* John E. Motz Charles O. Fisher Thomas S. Nichols Mrs. Jacob France (Honorary) George M. Radcliffe* Louis L. Goldstein Richard C. Riggs, Sr. Louise Gore Richard C. Riggs, Jr.* Kingdon Gould, Jr. John D. Schapiro William Grant Jacques T. Schlenger* Benjamin H. Griswold, III Truman T. Semans Louis G. Hecht A. Russell Slagle T. Hughlett Henry, Jr. T. Rowland Slingluff, Jr. C. A. Porter Hopkins John T. Stinson Samuel Hopkins* Mrs. W. Wallace Symington, Jr. E. Ralph Hostetter T. Hammond Welsh, Jr. Elmer M. Jackson, Jr. William C. Whitridge Mrs. Harold Duane Jacobs William L. Wilson Louis P. Jenkins *Executive Committee MARYLAND HISTORICAL SOCIETY COUNCIL Helen Delich Bentley Mrs. Frederick W. Lafferty* Mrs. Calhoun Bond William B. Marye James W. Constable Calvert C. McCabe, Jr.* Leonard C. Crewe, Jr., President* Robert G. Merrick, Sr.* Owen Daly, II* Morgan H. Pritchett Mrs. Raymond P. Delano, Jr. George M. Radcliffe* John G. Evans* Richard C. Riggs, Jr.* Louis G. Hecht Jacques T. Schlenger* Edgar G. Heyl Truman T. Semans Allen C. Hopkins J. Fife Symington, Jr.* Samuel Hopkins* Charles L. Wagandt, II Bryden B. Hyde John Walton Mrs. William G. Kouwenhoven G. Luther Washington *Executive Committee Romaine Stec Somerville, Director Larry E. Sullivan, Head Librarian P. William Filby, Consultant The Maryland Historical Magazine is published quarterly by the Maryland Historical Society, 201 W. Monument Street, Baltimore, Maryland 21201. Contributions and correspondence relating to articles, book reviews, and any other editorial matters should be addressed to the Editor in care of the Society. All contributions should be submitted in duplicate, double-spaced, and consistent with the form outlined in A Manual of Style (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 19691. The Maryland Historical Society disclaims responsibility for statements made by contributors. nni-u v-" NAPOLiS, MARYLAND Vol. 73, No. 4 December, 1978 (ISSN 0025-4258) CONTENTS Annual Report 1977-1978 305 Thornton Anderson Maryland's Property Qualifications for Office: A Reinterpretation of the Constitutional Convention of 1776 327 Alison K. Hoagland Deer Park Hotel 340 Karel J. Kansky Augustine Herman: The Leading Cartographer of the Seventeenth Century 352 Charles Scarlett, Jr. A Tale of Ratiocination: The Death and Burial of Edgar Allan Poe 360 Edward E. Steiner Nicholas Ruxton Moore: Soldier, Farmer and Politician 375 Sidelights: Ruth Kimball Kent The Convivial Dr. Beanes 389 Alexandra Lee Levin A Wounded Confederate Soldier's Letter from Fort McHenry 394 Susan Rosenfeld Falb Matthias da Sousa: Colonial Maryland's Black, Jewish Assemblyman 397 Book Reviews: Carter, ed.. The Papers of Benjamin Henry Latrobe, Journals, 1795-1797, 1797-1798, by Elizabeth Hobbs Blackert • Michener, Chesapeake, by Drew Gruenburg • Fecher, Mencken: A Study of His Thought, by George H. Douglas • Douglas, H. L. Mencken: Critic of American Life, by H. George Hahn • Hammett, History of St. Mary's County, Maryland, by Lorena S. Walsh • Crowe and Tise, eda.. The Southern Experience in the American Revolution, hyCnrtis Carroll D&vis 399 BOOKNOTES 407 NEWS AND NOTICES 408 VOLUME 73 INDEX 409 BALTIMORE CITY SPRING Number 6, DRAWN FROM NATURE BY AUG. KOLLNER LITH. BY DEROY — PRINTED BY CATTIER NEW-YORK & PARIS, PUBLISHED BY GOUPIL, VIBERT & CO. ENTERED. .1848 BY AUG. KOLLNER. .NEW-YORK. ** Lithograph, printed with buff tint. 19.3x27.7 cm. From Views of the Most In- teresting Objects ([1848?]), pi. 6. MdBE, MdBJ-G, MdBPM, MdHi, Merrick, VBHo. Some copies are hand colored. Annual Report 1977-1978 Museum and Library of Maryland History Maryland Historical Society 306 MARYLAND HISTORICAL MAGAZINE TRUSTEES J. Fife Symington, Jr., Chairman* Leonard C. Crewe, Jr., President* Vice Presidents Secretary Calvert C. McCabe, Jr. Mrs. Frederick W. Lafferty George M. Radcliffe Treasurer Richard C. Riggs, Jr. John G. Evans Mrs. W. Wallace Symington, Jr. Counsel Jacques T. Schlenger The officers listed above constitute the Executive Committee H. Furlong Baldwin Mrs. Harold Duane Jacobs James R. Herbert Boone Louis P. Jenkins Mrs. James Frederick Colwill H. Irvine Keyser, II James W. Constable Joseph H. McLain Leonard C. Crewe, Jr. Robert G. Merrick, Sr. John M. Curley, Jr. Robert G. Merrick, Jr. Mrs. Gerson G. Eisenberg John E. Motz John G. Evans Richard C. Riggs Charles O. Fisher John D. Schapiro Mrs. Jacob France (Honorary) Jacques T. Schlenger Louis L. Goldstein Truman T. Semans Louise Gore A. Russell Slagle Benjamin H. Griswold, III T. Rowland Slingluff, Jr. Louis G. Hecht John T. Stinson T. Hughlett Henry, Jr. J. Fife Symington, Jr. C. A. Porter Hopkins J. Millard Tawes Samuel Hopkins T. Hammond Welsh, Jr. E. Ralph Hostetter William C. Whitridge Elmer M. Jackson, Jr. William L. Wilson The Executive Committee and the Committee Chairmen constitute the Council. COMMITTEES Committee on Addresses G. Luther Washington, Chairman J. Walter Fisher, Vice Chairman Mrs. Louis Azrael Lester S. Levy Edgar G. Heyl John Poe Tyler Committee on Buildings and Grounds Allen C. Hopkins, Chairman Richard W. Ayers, Vice Chairman Martha Bokel Francis H. Jencks Arthur M. Gompf Frank H. Weller, Jr. Annual Report 307 Committee on Education Morgan W. Pritchett, Chairman D. Randall Beime, Vice Chairman Ludlow H. Baldwin Mrs. Francis S. Key Mrs. Philip Briscoe Thomas G. Pullen, Jr. Rebecca E. Carroll James A. Sensenbaugh Gerson G. Eisenberg Nettie B. Taylor Committee on Finance Truman T. Semans, Chairman John T. Stinson, Vice Chairman Benjamin H. Griswold, III Thomas S. Nichols Robert G. Merrick, Jr. William C. Whitridge John E. Motz Committee on the Gallery William V. Elder, III, Chairman Arnold Rothschild, Vice Chairman Harry D. Berry, Jr. Robert H. McCauley, Jr. Mrs. Gerson G. Eisenberg Mrs. Allan J. Mead Mrs. Mac K. Griswold J. Jefferson Miller, II Eugenia C. Holland Elisabeth C. G. Packard Bryden Bordley Hyde Richard H. Randall, Jr. R. McGill MackaU Gregory Weidman Committee on Genealogy and Heraldry John Walton, Chairman George B. Wilson, Vice Chairman Anna M. Cartlidge Jon Harlan Livezey John G. Diuguid Freeman E. Morgan, Jr. Mrs. Norris Harris Ella Rowe Phebe Jacobson Milton Rubincam Henry M. Kelly A. Russell Slagle J. Seeger Kerns Committee on the Library Edgar G. Heyl, Chairman Antonio R. Raimo, Vice Chairman Robert W. Black John A. Pentz Curtis Carroll Davis A. Russell Slagle Ralph L. DeGroff Lester S. Levy (Honorary) Bayly Ellen Marks Huntington Williams (Honorary) Braxton D. Mitchell 308 MARYLAND HISTORICAL MAGAZINE Committee on the Maritime Collection Helen Delich Bentley, Chairman Norman A. Rukert, Vice Chairman Lewis A. Beck, Jr. William B. Matthews, Jr. Hugh Benet, Jr. Robert E. Michel Donald W. Carroll, Sr. Rolfe Pottberg Randolph W. Chalfant George M. Radcliffe S. Vannort Chapman J. Dawson Reeder Ferdinand E. Chatard Philip B. Schnering John Goldsborough Earle Melbourne Smith Vera Ruth Filby Albert H. Trout William E. Hill L. Byrne Waterman Charles A. Masson Committee on Membership Michael Joyce, Chairman Mrs. Bryden Bordley Hyde, Vice Chairman Mrs. Wilbur Nelson Baumann D. Worthington Pearre Mary Helen Cadwalader Thomas G. Pullen, Jr. Edwin Warfield Gramkow W. Cameron Slack Louis G. Hecht Mrs. W. Wallace Symington, Jr. John P. Paca Andrew J. Young Committee on Publications Charles L. Wagandt, II, Chairman T. Rowland Slingluff, Jr., Vice Chairman John B. Boles Edward C. Papenfuse James H. Bready Benjamin Quarles Rhoda M. Dorsey Morris L. Radoff Jack Philip Greene Walter Rundell, Jr. Chester W. Gregory Arthur W. Sherwood Wilbur H. Hunter, Jr. Thomas B. Turner Mrs. Alexandra Lee Levin Committee on Public Relations Mrs. Calhoun Bond, Chairman Michael Joyce, Vice Chairman Mary Busch Vernon Stricklin Committee on Special Projects James W. Constable, Chairman Thomas W. Burdette, Vice Chairman Thomas H. G. Bailliere, Jr. Richard C. Granville F. Carter Birely Peter Jay, Jr. John P. Corderman Vernon Miller Carole S. Demilio Benjamin S. Schapiro Annual Report 309 Women's Committee Mrs. Richard H. Cromwell, Co-Chairman Mrs. William G. Kouwenhoven, Co-Chairman *Mrs. Joseph D. Beckley Mrs. John S. Kidder, Jr. •Mrs. Marcus M. Bernstein, Jr. Mrs. Henry F. LeBrun Miss Martha Bokel Mrs. Allan J. Mead Mrs. Calhoun Bond Mrs. Samuel S. Merrick Mrs. Walter B. Buck *Mrs. Nicholas B. Merryman of J Mrs. James Cantler *Mrs. Clarence W. Miles Mrs. Charles W. Cole, Jr. *Mrs. B. Frank Newcomer Mrs. William Page Dame Miss Elizabeth C. G. Packard Mrs. Curtis Carroll Davis Mrs. Richard C. Riggs •Mrs. Edward K. Dunn Mrs. S. Steven Sands, Jr. Mrs. Gerson G. Eisenberg Mrs. Truman T. Semans Mrs. W. T. Dixon Gibbs Mrs. George McLean Shriver Mrs. Elizabeth W. Glascock •Mrs. J. Nicholas Shriver, Jr. Mrs. Bryden Bordley Hyde Mrs. Paul P. Swett, Jr. Mrs. John S. Kerns, Jr. Mrs. W. Wallace Symington, Jr. •Associote Member THE STAFF Administration ••P. William Filby Director to March 31 Romaine Stec Somerville .... Director beginning April 1 Walter J. Skayhan, III Assistant Director/Adminis- tration Sandra W. Falls Administrative Assistant Maureen B. Joyce Director of Development NitaL. Schultz Director of Public Relations Kathleen T. Pyatak Secretary •Shirley Florie Secretarial Assistant •Mabel C. Herche Financial Manager Mary Lou Jones Accounting Manager Charmie McClendon Bookkeeper •Julian Kurzmann Financial Advisor Frank P. L. Somerville Director, Road Marker Program •Gary Browne Editor, Maryland Historical Magazine The Gallery Romaine Stec Somerville .... Assistant Director/Chief Curator to March 31, 1978 ••Eugenia Calvert Holland .... Gallery Curator Stiles Tuttle Colwill Assistant Gallery Curator •Elizabeth Hartley Eager Gallery Administrator Gerald Z.