America in a Mirror: Caricature As History
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
VO L. 1, N O .3 T HE CLEMENTS LIBRARY ASSO C IATES APRlL. 1995 AMERICA IN A MIRROR: CARICATURE AS HISTORY Caricature has a long tradition in moralize, or to focu s public opinion on unexpected incongruitie s. "A good American popular culture. Pictures that any target he chooses. His only obliga caricaturi st needs no great talent in any use exaggeration and wit to make a tion is to use his art to express an idea, other artistic direction ," cartoonist political point, a social comment, or a and to make that idea accessible and Boh un Lynch insists. "He is governed moral judgment have had a peculiar engaging to the broadest audience. only by his own sense of truthful power over our imagination. misrepre sentation." Whatever the rhetoric, As rhetori c or pole mic, written or spoken, it has American caricature has an often been the cartoon, honorable tradition. journalism's most devastat Cartoonists have exposed ing weapon, that has made abuses of power, the an issue or an individual corruption of government, stick in the public mind. and the hypocrisy of "Caricature," according society. At their most to editorial cartoonist trivial, cartoons provide a Draper Hill,"is not a running commentary on synonym for satire, or even events, people, attitudes, a genre of drawing. It is a and preoccupation s, their language of exaggeration , a influence no more than one method of projecting inner factor in any given politi cal characteristics,' real or climate. They reflect the imagined, into appear momentary shifts in public ances ," The cartoonist sentiment. At its most combin es caricature with a skillful, American caricature code - a set of symbols or has been moral satire. When emblems, the visual Thomas Nast exposed the metaphors that speak to corruption of Boss Tweed, or people living in a particular . crusaded for minority rights, time and place. Conse or denounced the futility of quently, caricature is war, he followed a tradition ephemeral. When we no Cartoonist Grant Hamilton used nursery rhyme imagery to make a that began in the Reforma longer understand its code, simple point - corruption is bipartisan. Republican Boss Platt licks tion with Luther 's satirical when its message has lost the platter of New York state patronage clean; seated is Democratic woodcuts, and continued its immediacy, it loses its Boss Croker. his stomach bulging. From Judge, November 19, /898. with Bruegel, Callot, impact on our imaginations. Hogarth, Goya, and Yet, it is this transient Daumier. quality that makes cartoons so valuable Caricature, as art historian Ronald Although the idea of caricutura as historical evidence , as a vernacular Paulson has written, has two components exaggerating a human form for comic record of our political values and social - the repre sentational and the rhetori effect - began in late sixteenth century mores. Becau se caricature is designed cal. As pictu res of people, objects, or Italy. printed caricature , as a form of fur print, for popular con sumption in the scenes, caricature ranges freely around political and social commentary, is the cheapest format, it is the most genuinely artisti c conventions. It takes familiar invention of eighteenth century England. democratic art. It is the perfect device settings and human emotions or the As a popular political culture developed forcriticism. The cartoonist doesnot images of allegory, folklore, history, or in the relatively free climate of mid have to justify his point of view; he can fanta sy, compresses them into one eighteenth century England, the demand use his art to report , accuse, entertain, picture, and makes us laugh by the fur information and for comment grew. - continued 011 page /2 Above: "A Conference between the Devil and Doctor Dove," by Henry Dawkins (Philadelphia, 1764), is one ofthe earliest American political cartoons. Doctor Dove, a writer ofscurrilous verse for Pennsylvania 's Proprietary Party, is shown kneeling before the Devil (his own demon's tail visible beneath his coatta ils), "Thou Great Prince ofDarkness, assist me in my Undertakings." Satan replies, "Well done, thou Good and Faithful Servant." From the origin ofcaricature in the satirical woodcuts ofthe Reformation, the Devil has been a common motif. Below : Pirating material from English sources was standa rd practice in colon ial publishing. Paul Revere lifted "The able Doctor; or America Swallowing the Bitter Draught" from the London Magazine. He appropriated the cartoon to the radical cause by adding the word TEA, publishing it in 1774 to mobilize supportfor Boston when Parliament passed retaliatory legislation following the notorious tea party. PAGE 2 THE QUARTO Cartoons in the /790s were the work ofanonymous amate urs. They were relentlessly political in content, often cluttered in design . "Congressional Pugilists " (/798) records an unedifying moment in American history when a Vermont Congressman accused ofcowardice spat in the fa ce ofhis colleague from Connecticut. They Jought with. cudgel andfire tongs until separated. Graphic satire was an important compo nent in periodicals during the first decades ofthe nineteenth century. The Echo, published by RichardAlsop (Boston, /807- / 8/2), was openly hostile to Jefferson. It ran a particularly vicious series ofcartoons by Tisdale and Leney in 1807. One was "Infan t Liberty Nursed by Mother Mob." A slattern holds an infant to huge breasts laheled "whiskey " and "rum," In the background Jefferson 's "republican mob" storms a public building. THE CWARTO PAGE 3 Right : William Charles hod learned the engraver's trade in London be/ore emigrating to Philadelphia in 1808, and he borrowedf reelyfrom the work ofGillray. A popular,prolific artist duri ng the War of 1812, Charle s helped make the cartoon part ofour national political life. In "John Bull Making a Nell' Batch ofShips to Send to the Lakes" (1814), Charles ridicules the Brit ish loss oftheir entire Great Lakes fleet to the Am ericans. King George sputters, "What, What, What!" 10 his right a man warns, " You had bette r keep both your ships and guns at home. If you send all you 've got to the Lakes, it will only makefun for the Yankl')'s to take them." Below: Philadelphian Edward Clay's social satire (ca. 1830) conlmUS a Quaker ofplain but elegant dress. accompanied b.v his ... - ' -. ..- -r-w- ;""!P'! .- """'''''1'--:- lovely dau ghte r, with WI Irish immigrant j[OJ!ll d l !llJ.L lIlalW Li) It IIfIIJ ~ATCH .r SHIPS to send fa tll£ 71. A!KE$ carrying his worldly possessions 0 11 his back. clay pipe stuck in the band of his high -crowned hat. A guest, mounted 011 a well-bred horse, is welcomed to the Quaker 's prosperous home. But the Irishman, asking directions to Phila delphia, is given a condesc ending answer, one that belies the Quaker reputation jar tolerance. 1 S l1.y. tJais u n 't tA~ roa -d: eq F r irn. rf. thft JiNt t"Us me a. (ie d na tlt.~ " thte PAil~'fky ..4"'''6)1 . i.. it .' M ks me .1. 9U. ~stU,1t.l t ru. ly tht.J is the road ./ PAGE 4 THE Q\)ARTO Technology revolutionize d the popular marketfor cartoons in the J820s. Commercial lithography, a relatively inexpensive, flexible process by which impressi ons are taken f rom designs inked on stone, replaced the difficult process ofengraving on metal. Prints could be mass produc ed on cheap, single sheets. The result was a floo d ofpolitical cartoons during the Jacksonian Era (1828-1840). In his fir st message to Congress, President Jackson proposed sending Native Americans to unoccupied land west of the Mississippi. By May J830, the Indian Removal Bill had become law. An anonymous artist, with. masterful san'Wim, drew Jackson as the Great Father. THE Q1JARTO PAGE 5 Above: Lola Montez , celebrated "European" beauty, mistress variously of Liszt, Dumas, and a Bavarian king, arrived on the New York stage in 1852, billed as a "Spanish dancer." No amount ofpublicity could disguise her limited talent. Johnston records the "enthusiastic reception ofLola by an American audience" - one Quaker, who hardly dares to look, and one dismayed gentleman, peering over his New York Herald, whose pages endlessly had promoted Lola. David Claypool Johnston had ambitions to become America 's Cruikshank. Although the quality ofhis draftsmanship was uneven, his caricatures, published as book illustrations and single sheets, show he had an eye for human foibles and the ability to translate them into witty drawings. Left: Johnston '.'I ingenious cartoon envelope allowed him to change a politician '.'I express ion with the pull ofa tab, a device he used to comment on the results ofseveral presidential electio ns. His 1849 version, Metamorphosis: A Locofoco Before, and After, the Late Elec tion, shows a radical Democrat reacting to the news that Whig candidate Gen. Zachar)' Taylor has defeated Democrat Lewis Cass "Hurra For Cass.''' changes to "What.' Old Zack Elected." PAGE 6 THE QlJARTO Comic almanacs began to appear in the 1830s. a welcome relieffrom the moralizing fare ofconventional almanacs. From them evolved the illustrated humorous weekly. Yankee Notion s: or, Whittlings from Jonathan's Jack-kn ife, is representative ofthe genre. Chauvinistic, racist, bigoted, its favorite targets were foreign immigrants, Jews.Blacks, and women. Racial stereotypes used in facial features and dialects were standard devicesf or cartoonists like Augustus Hoppin. His coverfor Febraury; 1853, had Jonathan and son Junior commenting on the stupidity of a "[ urriner" who has fa llen through the ice. T HE QUARTO PAGE 7 O jd. :i\Inrtn lhitn n nin. a n d h e r- Peu uy Brtl111 d .... Above: Vanity Fair, America 's Punch during the 1850-60s, owed its popularity on the eve ofthe Civil War to the cartoon s ofHenry Louis Stephens, as they refl ected the controversies tear ing the nation apart, During the 1860 presidential campaign, Stephens caricatured Douglas as a pious hypocrite.