1614142674228 JCI Vol 43 Issue 3 2019.Pdf
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Journal of Communication Volume 43 Number 3 July 2019 Inquiry Contents Editorial Editor’s Introduction 223 Volha Kananovich Articles Sinking Strangers: Media Representations of Climate Refugees on the 225 BBC and Al Jazeera Elida Høeg and Christopher D. Tulloch Outside the Sports Closet: News Discourses of Professional Gay Male 249 Athletes in the Mainstream Leigh M. Moscowitz, Andrew C. Billings, Khadija Ejaz, and Jane O’Boyle Containing the Third-Party Voter in the 2016 U.S. Presidential Election 272 Ryan Neville-Shepard Branding the Revolution: Havana Club Advertising and the Fight for 293 Cuban Authenticity Christopher A. Cha´vez and Ricardo J. Valencia Media Marathoning Through Health Struggles: Filling a Social Reservoir 313 Lisa G. Perks Book Reviews Democracy in chains: The deep history of the radical rights stealth plan for 333 America, Nancy MacLean Reviewed by Brian Michael Goss The mark of criminality: Rhetoric, race, and gangsta rap in the war-on-crime 339 era, Bryan J. McCann Reviewed by Jeffrey O.G. Ogbar jci journal of communication inquiry Executive Editor Thomas P. Oates University of Iowa Managing Editor Volha Kananovich University of Iowa Book Reviews Editor Ryan Stoldt Sign up for FREE updates University of Iowa Advisory Board Tessa Adams about the latest research! Mir Ashfaquzzaman Brian Ekdale Mehrnaz Khanjani journals.sagepub.com/action/registration Melissa Tully Travis Vogan Tyler Solon Williams Rachel Young Register online at Ge Zhu Editorial Board SAGE Journals and Mark Andrejevic Lawrence Grossberg Shane Moreman start receiving… University of Iowa University of North Carolina, California State University, Fresno Lisa Barr Chapel Hill Hillel Nossek Western Illinois University John Haman College of Management, Israel New Content Alerts Ralph Beliveau University of Iowa Erin O’Gara University of Oklahoma Jay Hamilton ClearWay Minnesota . Receive table of contents Jack Z. Bratich University of Georgia Jeremy Packer alerts when a new issue Rutgers University Shawn Harmsen North Carolina State University University of Iowa is published. Bonnie S. Brennen Radhika E. Parameswaran Marquette University James Hay Indiana University University of Illinois, Matthew Cecil Subin Paul . Receive alerts when forthcoming Urbana-Champaign University of Iowa Wichita State University Amani Ismail Craig Robertson articles are published online Kuan-Hsing Chen American University in Cairo Northeastern University National Tsing Hua University, Taiwan before they are scheduled to Beverly A. James Amit M. Schejter Mia Consalvo University of New Hampshire, Durham Pennsylvania State University appear in print (OnlineFirst articles). Concordia University Robin Johnson Charles C. Self Gene Costain Sam Houston State University University of Oklahoma University of Central Florida Matthew A. Killmeier Yu Shi Announcements Patrick J. Daley University of Southern Maine Pennsylvania State University, University of New Hampshire, Durham Carolyn Kitch Harrisburg . Receive need-to-know information about a journal such as calls for papers, Rachel E. Dubrofsky Temple University Helene Shugart special issue notices, and events. University of South Florida Hye Jin Lee University of Utah Ana C. Garner University of Iowa Shayla Thiel Stern Marquette University Luigi Manca University of Minnesota, Twin Cities Search Alerts Dina Gavrilos Benedictine University James F. Tracy University of St. Thomas Christopher R. Martin Florida Atlantic University . Create custom search alerts based on recent search keywords or terms. Todd Gitlin University of Northern Iowa Mary Douglas Vavrus Columbia University Graduate Robert McChesney University of Minnesota School of Journalism University of Illinois, Marina Vujnovic Theodore L. Glasser Urbana-Champaign Monmouth University Stanford University Lisa McLaughlin Liesbet van Zoonen journals.sagepub.com Mirerza Gonzalez-Velez Miami University of Ohio Loughborough University, UK University of Puerto Rico Angela McRobbie Andrea Weare Goldsmiths, University of London University of Nebraska, Omaha Brian Goss Saint Louis University-Madrid JJCI43_3_cover.inddCI43_3_cover.indd 2 003-06-20193-06-2019 117:28:357:28:35 Editorial Journal of Communication Inquiry 2019, Vol. 43(3) 223–224 Editor’s Introduction ! The Author(s) 2019 Article reuse guidelines: sagepub.com/journals-permissions DOI: 10.1177/0196859919852491 journals.sagepub.com/home/jci The July issue of Journal of Communication Inquiry takes the reader on a jour- ney spanning diverse geographic contexts and media forms. In the opening article, Elida Høeg and Christopher D. Tulloch analyze the representations of climate refugees by two global news organizations: the BBC and Al Jazeera. The findings show that both outlets tend to construct refugees as dehumanized, aggregated actors who are denied agency and operate as generic symbols of climate change whose ordeal is limited to the countries of the global South. Such portrayals, the authors argue, relieve developed countries from responsibility for the environmental crisis and reinforce the status quo in power relations between the global North and the global South. The conversation about the broader meaning-making role of the news media continues in the article by Leigh M. Moscowitz, Andrew C. Billings, Khadija Ejaz, and Jane O’Boyle, who analyze the news discourses that surrounded the coming-outs of two prominent professional gay male American athletes, the NBA’s Jason Collins and the NFL’s Michael Sam, in mainstream media outlets. The analysis shows that although media stories heralded these coming-out announcements as historic watershed moments that deserve celebration, the actual lived experiences of the gay athletes remained backgrounded whereas their physicality and athleticism were emphasized. Taken together, the authors conclude, such media narratives contributed to “safely containing gayness within traditional notions of orthodox masculinity” that are entrenched in the major American sports leagues as commercialized sports-media complexes. Seeking to interrogate news discourses as part of a broader cultural conver- sation, Moscowitz and colleagues in their analysis do not differentiate news articles from editorials, commentary, and other media texts that belong to today’s converged media landscape. Neither does the author of the next article, Ryan Neville-Shepard, who in a similar fashion performs a close textual reading of regular news stories and opinion pieces from a variety of news publications to understand how the third-party voter in the 2016 U.S. presidential election was constructed in the broader news media discourse. The findings reveal that the media coverage mostly followed the logic of what Neville-Shepard refers to as “rhetorical containment,” a form of marginalization of third-party voters that paints them as immature, uniformed, and naı¨ ve intruders who disrupt the 224 Journal of Communication Inquiry 43(3) political process. This contributes to further delegitimizing third-party candi- dates as falling outside the bounds of mainstream political discourse. Transitioning from the news media to strategic communication, Christopher A. Cha´ vez and Ricardo J. Valencia analyze the advertising strategies of two competing marketers of the Havana Club rum: Havana Club International, an enterprise of the Cuban government, and Bacardi, a private global corporation. Produced on behalf of the agents embedded within different political ideologies, the two campaigns both make claims for Cuban authenticity, which makes it possible to explore the specific mechanisms by which ideology can be enacted through advertising practice. In yet another transition, from media production to media consumption, Lisa G. Perks turns her attention to the concept of media marathoning, by approach- ing it as a strategy of coping with a health crisis. Drawing on in-depth interviews with media marathoners, Perks challenges the stereotypical representation of media marathoning as a socially isolating experience. Instead, she argues, the media marathoning experience helps cultivate meaningful connections with both real and fictive others, and by doing so, can function as a reservoir of social support and capital that preserves its value outside the immediate media con- sumption experience. The July issue is rounded out by reviews of two books that resonate with some of the central themes of the issue. In his review of Nancy MacLean’s Democracy in Chains: The Deep History of the Radical Right’s Stealth Plan for America, Brian Michael Goss invites us to cross-reference the book with external realities to find its central argument both well substantiated and timely: “Get ready for convulsions in the economic and political sphere in the proximal future as an antisocial set of doctrines become embedded.” Finally, Jeffrey O. G. Ogbar reviews Bryan J. McCann’s The Mark of Criminality: Rhetoric, Race, and Gangsta Rap in the War-on-Crime era, to conclude that, despite some criticism, the book makes a worthy scholarly contribution by offering the analysis of gansta rap through the lens of what McCann dubs “the mark of criminality,” which, despite functioning as a tool of oppressive utility, can prove useful for challenging racial subjugation. Many thanks to all those who helped this issue to completion, including the Advisory Board members, Executive Editor, our reviewers, and authors. Happy reading! Volha Kananovich University of Iowa, IA, USA Article Journal of Communication Inquiry 0(0) 1–24 Sinking Strangers: ! The Author(s) 2018