The Italian Wars of Henry II Downloaded From

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

The Italian Wars of Henry II Downloaded From 602 October The Italian Wars of Henry II Downloaded from HE wars of Henry II had a very decisive effect upon French T influence in Italy and upon the fortunes of Italy herself for more than two centuries to come ; the grand duchy of Tuscany, for instance, owed its existence to one of them. Yet until http://ehr.oxfordjournals.org/ M. Lucien Romier published his two volumes on Les Origines Politique8 des Ouerres de JReligion1 there was no adequate account of the motives and diplomatic antecedents of these wars. The title of the book hardly gives a precise idea of its contents, which are really almost confined to the foreign policy of the reign, and the foreign policy as relating to Italy alone. There is to outward appearance a salient distinction between the Italian policy of Francis I and Henry H. The former aimed at conquest naked at University of California, San Diego on September 1, 2015 and unabashed, the latter at all events professed merely the pro- tection of weaker powers. Just as in Scotland Henry posed as the champion of the Stuarts, and in Germany of the Protestant princes, so in Italy he undertook the defence of the Farnesi of Parma, of the Sienese republic, and of Paul IV against Charles V or Philip II, and of the Corsican rebels against Genoa. M. Romier shows how far in each case these pretensions were genuine, or how far they merely served to veil schemes of conquest. At the Dase of all the diplomacy is the feud of the Constable Montmorenci and the house of Guise, who in turn dominated the king's vacil- lating will and sluggish intellect. In proving the constant relation of this feud to Italian politics M. Romier has broken entirely fresh ground. Italian intervention is really the barometer of the success or failure of the Guises at the French court. If Mont- morenci would have war at all, its sphere should be the north- eastern frontier of France, but Italy attracted all the old Angevin ambitions inherited by the house of Guise from Ren6 of Lorraine. The marriage of Duke Francis to Anna dTEste doubtless gave a strong stimulus, but it was an effect rather than a cause. Among its results was the addition of yet another group of Italian courtiers to that which had become naturalized under Francis I, and to that which was gathering round the queen. The factions which were mainly responsible for these Italian wars, and which were in turn stimulated by them, had no small 1 Two volumes, Paris, Iibrairie Perrin et Compagnie, 1911, 1913. 1915 THE ITALIAN WARS OF HENRY II 603 share in determining the outbreak of civil and religious war. Though Montmorenci found himself on the same side as his rivals when Catholicism was at stake, yet his party lived on under the leadership of his nephews, the Chatillons. After his death his two elder sons, successively heirs to his office, though catholics themselves, revived the policy of opposition to the Guises, while the younger brothers joined the Huguenots. Thus M. Homier may fairly give to his subject the title Les Origines Politiques des Downloaded from Ghierres de Religion, which at first sight seemed somewhat far- fetched. The importance, therefore, of this somewhat obscure chapter of history becomes so great that English readers may welcome a fuller account of his conclusions than could be con- tained in a short review. It is to be hoped, however, that such http://ehr.oxfordjournals.org/ a summary will not deter them from recourse to the book itself, which is delightful reading owing to the writer's love for person- ality and his consequent skill in character-drawing, illustrated in every chapter. The volumes are anything but a dry record of diplomatic intrigue. For a government inclined towards intervention in Italy there was an agency and an army ready to hand. Two of the author's freshest chapters deal with the cardinal protectors at Rome, and at University of California, San Diego on September 1, 2015 the Florentine, Neapolitan, and other exiles, whose chief centres were Lyons, Rome, and Venice, with the little state of Mirandola as a military base. The official function of the protectors was to propose candidates for benefices in consistory, but practically, as diplomatic agents, they stood above the ambassadors, and decided French policy in no small degree. The titular pro- tector from 1548 until Henry IPs death was Hippolyto dTEste, whose wealth, splendour, and family connexion gave him an influence scarcely justified by his narrow intellect and jealous punctilio. It is to his credit, however, that, in spite of his close Guisard connexion, he was usually on the side of moderation. During his absences from Rome substitutes were appointed. Thus we read of Jean de Bellay, in politics a Montmorencist, but now too old and ill for much initiative, but retaining his full senses as to the danger of an adventurous policy. He becomes in time garrulous and bibulous, and is pulled up by the pope as a bore, when he speaks in consistory. Cardinal Tournon has left a bad reputation from his part in the wars of religion, but M. Romier regards him as the cleverest and most patriotic of the diplomatists who managed French affairs in Italy. Ultramontanism attached him to the Guises, but his interests were loyally French. It would seem that the protectors, if only from the splendid ease and luxury of their position, would be inclined to diplomatic rather than to military methods. After all, in time of actual war they would lose much of their influence. A protectorate of the smaller 604 THE ITALIAN WARS OF HENRY II October states against Spain would be their aim rather than conquest, as it was that of other reasonable French politicians down to d'Argenson. An exception was Cardinal Alessandro Farnese, hand in glove with Piero Strozzi and the cardinal of Lorraine, an adven- turer looking only to personal interests, more closely linked to the condottiere than to the cardinal group. It must be confessed, too, that Tournon, though he reconciled Henry II and Julius III, had paved the way for the revolution of Siena, though he was Downloaded from opposed to the offensive alliance with Carafa in 1555. The exiles, needless to say, never left the French court alone. They were weakened by their difference in aims, the Neapolitans urging an Angevin reconquest of Naples, the Tuscans the liberation of Florence from Cosimo de' Medici. The latter, at all events, http://ehr.oxfordjournals.org/ were not of the starveling type. Henry II was financed by the Strozzi and the Guadagni-del-Bene banks, much as was Charles V by the Fugger and the Welser. They had, moreover, the warm support of the queen. Piero Strozzi, violent and unbalanced as he was, gave glamour to the cause by the pure-hearted patriotism which devoted thereto his whole life and huge fortune. From the very beginning of the reign the dualism between Montmorenci and the Guises in Italian politics became apparent. When Pier at University of California, San Diego on September 1, 2015 Luigi FarneBe, lord of Parma and Piacenza, was assassinated by his nobles, and Piacenza occupied by the imperialists, the outraged father and suzerain, Paul III, appealed to Henry II. The king was sympathetic, because Pier Luigi's younger son, Orazio Farnese, was engaged to his natural daughter Diane, and had won his warm affection. The cardinal of Lorraine was sent to Rome, and negotiations went merrily forward. But his absence gave Montmorenci his opening, and he contrived to delay the war. This was not merely because he disliked Italian complications, and especially Guise influence with the Farnesi, but because his strong Gallican principles were opposed to papal reforming activity. In this Henry II, essentially conservative, heartily concurred. French cardinals were indeed sent to the council of Bologna, but they made uncomfortable demands upon the pope, and resented any innovations, even the most obviously salutary reforms. Hence the political alliance with the pope was delayed, and he in despair united Parma and Piacenza to the church, at the expense of his sons Ottavio and Orazio. Ottavio, as is well known, attempted to occupy Parma in his father's face, provoking a violent quarrel. Paul III on his death-bed, under the influence of Cardinal Alessandro Farnese, restored the city to his son, and this grant was confirmed by the cardinals during the conclave. The delay in the conclave was caused purely by the scandalous division among the French cardinals, Montmorenci ordering his party to elect a Spaniard rather than a Guisard. Henry II at 1915 THE ITALIAN WARS OF HENRY II 605 length insisted on their combining to elect a neutral, and the result was the pontificate of Julius III, the Cardinal del Monte. The new pope was an indolent gourmand, neglecting his duties for bis gardens and his vineyards. To the messenger inquiring, Beatissime Pater, eras erit consistorium ? he would reply, Cras erit vinea. Unfortunately he combined with much humour and amiability a violent temper subject to equally rapid reaction. The war of Parma was a war of two tempers, explosive on the Downloaded from pope's part, obstinate on that of the French king. Not but what either side had genuine grievances. Julius, in his desire to pro- pitiate the emperor, transferred the council from Bologna to Trent, and even proposed to grant him Parma and Piacenza as a papal fief. The king at once promised protection to Ottavio http://ehr.oxfordjournals.org/ Farnese and carried his Gallican revolt to the very borderland of schism.
Recommended publications
  • The Historical Context of the Age of Gold: France 1560–1660
    Vincentian Heritage Journal Volume 11 Issue 1 Article 1 Spring 1990 The Historical Context of the Age of Gold: France 1560–1660 James Hitchcock Follow this and additional works at: https://via.library.depaul.edu/vhj Recommended Citation Hitchcock, James (1990) "The Historical Context of the Age of Gold: France 1560–1660," Vincentian Heritage Journal: Vol. 11 : Iss. 1 , Article 1. Available at: https://via.library.depaul.edu/vhj/vol11/iss1/1 This Articles is brought to you for free and open access by the Vincentian Journals and Publications at Via Sapientiae. It has been accepted for inclusion in Vincentian Heritage Journal by an authorized editor of Via Sapientiae. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Professor James Hitchcock The Historical Context of the Age of Gold: France 1560-1660 B JAMES HITCHCOCK French history as defined for these purposes has a quite precise beginning - 30 June, 1559, when King Henry II, in the midst of the celebrations of his daughter's marriage to Philip II of Spain, entered the lists to try his knightly skills. His opponent's lance broke. A splinter 4 slipped through the visor of the king's helmet and penetrated his eye. He lingered for almost two weeks, then left his kingdom in the hands of his widow, Catherine de Medici, with the throne nominally occupied by his fifteen-year-old son Francis II. Although the strong foundation of French monarchy had already been laid, in fact the century 1560-1660 was largely one of turmoil and apparent disintegration, except for a few decades at the precise time of the greatest flourishing of the seventeenth-century Catholic revival.
    [Show full text]
  • Richard Guise: Englishman Or French Duke
    Richard Guise: Englishman or French duke ROSLYN CARTWRIGHT 1 n 1793 the name Guise appears in New South Wales colonial records. It continued to be noteworthy for more than 60 years until the traumatic events of Ithe early 1850s crushed the family’s dynastic aspirations and plunged them into erroneous folklore and, ultimately, obscurity. However, with the development of the south-western Sydney area, the name has been resurrected with the naming of Guise Public School at Macquarie Fields and Guise Avenue at Casula, both on old Guise land grant sites. These now join the lesser known Guy Forest, Guises Creek, ‘Guises Flat’, Guys Hill, Guise Hill, Guises Lake, Guises Ridge, Guises Waterholes and 2 Guise Road as reminders of an unusual and mysterious family. The mystery begins in 1789, in England, when Richard Guise joined the newly formed New South Wales Corps and was eventually promoted to the rank of 3 sergeant. (Sergeant Richard had two descendants also named ‘Richard’. To distinguish between the three of them they are hereafter designated as Richard; his son, Richard senior; and his nephew, Richard junior.) The combination of the significant year of 1789 and the French origins of the surname ‘Guise’ helped create a fallacy that is perpetuated in inadequately researched histories, articles and guides until the present. On 14 July 1789 the Paris mob raided the Bastille prison and many French nobles became émigrés fleeing the revolutionaries. On 14 October of that year 4 Richard was enlisted in the British Army. This timetable of events proved too convenient an explanation of his obscure background: Because of the destruction of records at the time of the French Revolution, it is a hopeless task to trace the parents of Sergeant Richard Guise, born in 1757.
    [Show full text]
  • A Little Tour in France
    A LITTLE TOUR IN FRANCE with ninety-four illustrations by JOSEPH PENNELL LONDON WILLIAM HEINEMANN 1900 Preface Preface The notes presented in this volume were gathered, as will easily be perceived, a number of years ago and on an expectation not at that time answered by the event, and were then published in the United States. The expectation had been that they should accompany a series of drawings, and they themselves were altogether governed by the pictorial spirit. They made, and they make in appearing now, after a considerable interval and for the first time, in England, no pretension to any other; they are impressions, immediate, easy, and consciously limited; if the written word may ever play the part of brush or pencil, they are sketches on "drawing-paper" and nothing more. From the moment the principle of selection and expression, with a tourist, is not the delight of the eyes and the play of fancy, it should be an energy in every way much larger; there is no happy mean, in other words, I hold, between the sense and the quest of the picture, and the surrender to it, and the sense and the quest of the constitution, the inner springs of the subject—springs and connections social, economic, historic. One must really choose, in other words, between the benefits of the perception of surface—a perception, when fine, perhaps none of the most frequent—and those of the perception of very complex underlying matters. If these latter had had, for me, to be taken into account, my pages would not have been collected.
    [Show full text]
  • The Italian Wars
    198 Chapter 7 CHAPTER 7 Allegiance and Rebellion II: The Italian Wars The Italian Wars, with the irruption of the kings of France and Spain and the emperor into the state system of the peninsula, complicated questions of al- legiance for the military nobility throughout Italy. Many were faced with un- avoidable choices, on which could hang grave consequences for themselves and their families. These choices weighed most heavily on the barons of the kingdom of Naples and the castellans of Lombardy, the main areas of conten- tion among the ultramontane powers. The bulk of the military nobility in these regions harboured no great affection or loyalty towards the Sforza dukes of Mi- lan, Aragonese kings of Naples or Venetian patricians whose rule was chal- lenged. Accepting an ultramontane prince as their lord instead need not have occasioned them much moral anguish, provided they were left in possession of their lands. They might, indeed, hope that a non-resident prince would allow them a greater degree of autonomy. But there could be no guarantee that those who pledged their loyalty to an ultramontane prince would receive the bene- fits and the recognition they might have hoped for. Although the ideas, expec- tations and way of life of the Italian rural nobility had much in common with their German, French and Spanish counterparts who came to Italy as soldiers and officials, the ultramontanes generally assumed the air of conquerors, of superiority to Italians of whatever social rank. Members of different nations were often more conscious of their differences in language and customs than of any similarities in their values, and relations between the nobilities of the various nations were frequently imbued with mutual disparagement, rather than mutual respect.
    [Show full text]
  • Middmunc 2020
    MiddMUNC 2020 MiddMUNC 2020 JCC: The War of the Three Henry’s Background Guide MiddMUNC 2020 Table of Contents Letter from the Secretary General .............................................................................................................................................1 Letter from the Crisis Director .....................................................................................................................................................2 Letter from the Chairs ..........................................................................................................................................................................3 Background ....................................................................................................................................................................................................5 The Reformation ..............................................................................................................................................................................................5 French Wars of Religion Begin .................................................................................................................................................................5 The Massacre of Wassy and Its Aftermath ..........................................................................................................................................6 Saint Bartholomew’s Day Massacre .......................................................................................................................................................7
    [Show full text]
  • Military History of Italy 1 a Missing Peninsula?
    The Military History of Italy 1 A Missing Peninsula? Why We Need A New Geostrategic History Of the Central Peninsula of the Mediterranean Twenty-two years ago, in the introduction to his famous Twilight of a military tra- dition, Gregory Hanlon reported the irony with which his colleagues had accepted his plan to study the Italian military value 1. The topic of the Italian cowardice, however, predates the deeds of the Sienese nobility in the Thirty Years War that fascinated Hanlon to transform a social historian into one of the few foreign specialists in the military history of modern Italy. In fact, it dates back to the famous oxymoron of the Italum bellacem which appeared in the second edition of Erasmus’ Adagia , five years after the famous Disfida of Barletta (1503) and was then fiercely debated after the Sack of Rome in 1527 2. Historiography, both Italian and foreign, has so far not inves- tigated the reasons and contradictions of this longstanding stereotype. However, it seems to me a "spy", in Carlo Ginzburg’s sense, of a more general question, which in my opinion explains very well why Italians excel in other people’s wars and do not take their own seriously. The question lies in the geostrategic fate of the Central Mediterranean Peninsula, at the same time Bridge and Front between West and East, between Oceàna and Eura- sia, as it already appears in the Tabula Peutingeriana : the central and crucial segment between Thule and Taprobane. An Italy cut transversely by the Apennines extended ‘Westwards’ by the Ticino River, with two Italies – Adriatic and Tyrrhenian – marked by ‘manifest destinies’ that are different from each other and only at times brought to- gether 3.
    [Show full text]
  • The Massacre at Paris
    A Digital Anthology of Early Modern English Drama emed.folger.edu Discover over four hundred early modern English plays that were professionally performed in London between 1576 and 1642. Browse plays written by Shakespeare’s contemporaries; explore the repertoires of London’s professional companies; and download plays for reading and research. This documentary edition has been edited to provide an accurate and transparent transcription of a single copy of the earliest surviving print edition of this play. Further material, including editorial policy and XML files of the play, is available on the EMED website. EMED texts are edited and encoded by Meaghan Brown, Michael Poston, and Elizabeth Williamson, and build on work done by the EEBO-TCP and the Shakespeare His Contemporaries project. This project is funded by a Humanities Collections and Reference Resources grant from the NEH’s Division of Preservation and Access. Plays distributed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License. img: 1­a ismigg: :[ N1­/bA] sig: A2r ln 0001 THE ln 0002 MASSACRE ln 0003 AT PARIS: ln 0004 With the Death of the Duke ln 0005 of Guise. ln 0006 As it was played by the right honorable the ln 0007 Lord high Admiral his Servants. ln 0008 Written by Christopher Marlowe. ln 0009 AT LONDON ln 0010 Printed by E. A. for Edward White, dwelling near ln 0011 the little North door of St. Paul’s ln 0012 Church at the sign of ln 0013 the Gun. img: 2­a ismigg: :A 22­vb sig: A3r wln 0001 THE wln 0002 MASSACRE wln 0003 AT PARIS.
    [Show full text]
  • Table of Content
    ZZ LONDON INTERNATIONAL MODEL UNITED NATIONS 2017 Joint Cabinet Crisis London International Model United Nations 18th Session | 2017 Table of Content 1 ZZ LONDON INTERNATIONAL MODEL UNITED NATIONS 2017 Table of Contents I. Introduction 3 II. General Context 4 III. Religious Dynamics 6 IV. Political Dynamics 18 V. Territorial Dynamics 21 VI. The French Court 27 VII. The English Court 31 VIII. The Scottish Court 39 IX. The House of Hapsburgs 46 2 ZZ LONDON INTERNATIONAL MODEL UNITED NATIONS 2017 WELCOME TO CRISIS We are thrilled to welcome you this year’s Crisis at LIMUN 2017! Great things are lying ahead of you; namely, a Historical Crisis recreating the dynamics between Scotland, England, Habsburg Spain and France, starting 1557. But before we let you delve into depths of medieval courts and courtships, here is a few words about us. Our names are Camille, Roberta and Dorota and we like to think of ourselves as a Dynamic Crisis Trio. Coming from three different corners of Europe (although currently all of us are conveniently stationed close to London), we’re united by our love for crisis, MUN and female empowerment. You might see a fair bit of the last one in our crisis, as the two young queens hopefully rise to power… Or will they? Their destiny is in your hands! Now onto specifics about the team (and yes, we’re all very experienced). Camille Bigot is a graduate student at the University of Cambridge. As your Crisis Director, she looks forward to meeting all of you. She currently undertaking a Master in Criminology having previously read two other masters in International Relations & Anthropology and Gender Studies.
    [Show full text]
  • Armies of the Italian Wars of Unification 1848–70 (1)
    Men-at-Arms Armies of the Italian Wars of Uni cation 1848–70 (1) Piedmont and the Two Sicilies Gabriele Esposito • Illustrated by Giuseppe Rava GABRIELE ESPOSITO is a researcher into military CONTENTS history, specializing in uniformology. His interests range from the ancient HISTORICAL BACKGROUND 3 Sumerians to modern post- colonial con icts, but his main eld of research is the military CHRONOLOGY 6 history of Latin America, • First War of Unification, 1848-49 especially in the 19th century. He has had books published by Osprey Publishing, Helion THE PIEDMONTESE ARMY, 1848–61 7 & Company, Winged Hussar • Character Publishing and Partizan Press, • Organization: Guard and line infantry – Bersaglieri – Cavalry – and he is a regular contributor Artillery – Engineers and Train – Royal Household companies – to specialist magazines such as Ancient Warfare, Medieval Cacciatori Franchi – Carabinieri – National Guard – Naval infantry Warfare, Classic Arms & • Weapons: infantry – cavalry – artillery – engineers and train – Militaria, Guerres et Histoire, Carabinieri History of War and Focus Storia. THE ITALIAN ARMY, 1861–70 17 GIUSEPPE RAVA was born in • Integration and resistance – ‘the Brigandage’ Faenza in 1963, and took an • Organization: Line infantry – Hungarian Auxiliary Legion – interest in all things military Naval infantry – National Guard from an early age. Entirely • Weapons self-taught, Giuseppe has established himself as a leading military history artist, THE ARMY OF THE KINGDOM OF and is inspired by the works THE TWO SICILIES, 1848–61 20 of the great military artists, • Character such as Detaille, Meissonier, Rochling, Lady Butler, • Organization: Guard infantry – Guard cavalry – Line infantry – Ottenfeld and Angus McBride. Foreign infantry – Light infantry – Line cavalry – Artillery and He lives and works in Italy.
    [Show full text]
  • Lecture Notes In
    August 2, 2013 – Catholicism & Counter-Reformation Lecture Lakeside Institute of Theology Ross Arnold, Summer 2013 Church History 2 (TH2) 1. Intro – Forces Leading to Reformation 2. Reformation Begins – Luther 3. Other Reformers – Zwingli, Anabaptists, Calvin, Knox 4. Growth of Protestantism 5. Catholicism & Counter-Reformation 6. Orthodoxy, Rationalism and Pietism 7. Beyond Christendom 8. Materialism & Modern Times; Final Exam Reformation in the Low Countries • Near the mouth of Rhine River were a group of territories called the Seventeen Provinces (later the Netherlands, Belgium and Luxembourg), under control of Charles V. • Protestantism came early to these Low Countries – the first two Protestant martyrs burned in Antwerp in 1523. • Little unity among the Provinces – French-speaking south; Flemish- speaking center; Dutch-speaking north. • 1555 Charles V put the Provinces under his son, Philip, who became king of Spain in 1556, as Philip II. At his point, the Provinces became secondary and subservient to Spain. • During this time, while there were Lutherans and Anabaptists, a great many Calvinist preachers came into the area – so the region eventually became predominantly Calvinist. • Charles V had opposed Protestantism – issuing edict after edict against it. Tens of thousands were martyred, especially Anabaptists. Yet still Protestantism spread. • Philip was even more intolerant than his father. In 1556 he returned to Spain and left his half-sister Margaret of Parma as Regent of the Provinces, supported by Spanish soldiers. Reformation in the Low Countries • Philip also arranged for Catholic bishops in the Provinces to have inquisitorial powers, which frightened everyone. • Philip proved duplicitous, promising tolerance while actually instructing Margaret to ruthlessly enforce the decrees of the Council of Trent against Protestantism.
    [Show full text]
  • The Guisian by Simon Belyard
    Scène Européenne Traductions Regards croisésintrouvables sur la Scène Européenne - Métathéâtre, théâtre dans le théâtre et folie The Guisian by Simon Belyard Translated, with Introduction and Notes, by Richard Hillman Référence électronique Introduction to The Guisian by Simon Belyard [En ligne], éd. par R. Hillman, 2019, mis en ligne le 07-10-2019, URL : https://sceneeuropeenne.univ-tours.fr/traductions/guisian La collection TRADUCTIONS INTROUVABLES est publiée par le Centre d’études supérieures de la Renaissance, (Université de Tours, CNRS/UMR 7323) dirigé par Benoist Pierre Responsable scientifique Richard Hillman ISSN 1760-4745 Mentions légales Copyright © 2019 - CESR. Tous droits réservés. Les utilisateurs peuvent télécharger et imprimer, pour un usage strictement privé, cette unité documentaire. Reproduction soumise à autorisation. Contact : [email protected] Introduction Richard Hillman CESR - Université de Tours There are solid grounds, I believe, for encouraging historians of early modern English drama to make the acquaintance of Simon Belyard’s tragedy The Guisian (1592)—something this trans- lation aims at facilitating—but these do not necessarily extend to the literary merit of the play (depending, of course, on one’s understanding of that criterion). Certainly, viewed in relation to much neo-Senecan French Humanist tragedy of the later sixteenth century, as epitomised by the work of Robert Garnier, it risks appearing clumsy and derivative. Nor, as far as I know, is it suspected of influencing subsequent dramatists.1
    [Show full text]
  • Unity Deferred: the "Roman Question" in Italian History,1861-82 William C Mills
    Unity Deferred: The "Roman Question" in Italian History,1861-82 William C Mills ABSTRACT: Following the Risorgimento (the unification of the kingdom of Italy) in 1861, the major dilemma facing the new nation was that the city of Rome continued to be ruled by the pope as an independent state. The Vatican's rule ended in 1870 when the Italian army captured the city and it became the new capital of Italy. This paper will examine the domestic and international problems that were the consequences of this dispute. It will also review the circumstances that led Italy to join Germany and Austria in the Triple Alliance in 1882. In the early morning of 20 September 1870, Held guns of the Italian army breached the ancient city wall of Rome near the Porta Pia. Army units advanced to engage elements of the papal militia in a series of random skirmishes, and by late afternoon the army was in control of the city. Thus concluded a decade of controversy over who should govern Rome. In a few hours, eleven centuries of papal rule had come to an end.' The capture of Rome marked die first time that the Italian government had felt free to act against the explicit wishes of the recendy deposed French emperor, Napoleon III. Its action was in sharp contrast to its conduct in the previous decade. During that time, die Italians had routinely deferred to Napoleon with respect to the sanctity of Pope Pius IX's rule over Rome. Yet while its capture in 1870 revealed a new sense of Italian independence, it did not solve the nation's dilemma with the Roman question.
    [Show full text]