DOCSLIB.ORG

Participatory Video and Reflexivity the Experiences of Eight Adult Learners

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Participatory Video and Reflexivity the Experiences of Eight Adult Learners Participatory Video and Reflexivity The Experiences of Eight Adult Learners Kyung-Hwa Yang Department of Integrated Studies in Education Faculty of Education, McGill University Montreal, Canada August 2012 A thesis submitted to McGill University in partial fulfillment of the requirements of the degree of Doctor of Philosophy. © Kyung-Hwa Yang 2012 ii CONTENTS Abstract vi Résumé vii Acknowledgements ix 1 Introduction 1 Background 3 The Evolution of Participatory Video 6 Framing the Thesis 21 Research Questions 31 Strategy of Inquiry 32 Situating Myself 33 Organizing the Thesis 35 2 Reflexivity in and through Participatory Video 37 Is Reflexivity Good for Participatory Research? 39 What does Participatory Video Have to Do with Reflexivity? 50 Summary of Chapter 60 3 The Project 63 Context 64 Process 68 My Approach to Analysis 96 Summary of Chapter 104 4 Inside the Project: Processes and Outcomes 105 The Presentation 106 Reading the Primary Text, Ready, Set, and Engage 108 The Process of Participatory Video Making 112 What Difference Can Participation Make? 119 Summary of Chapter 124 5 The Voice of the Participants and Reflexivity 125 Contextualizing the Data 126 Producer Text 1: What the Participants Had to Say about Participatory Video 127 Producer Text 2: What the Participants Had to Say through Participatory Video 134 iii Ethical Advantages and Challenges of Participatory Video 141 Summary of Chapter 144 6 Learning as Experience 147 Learning in the Context of Participatory Video 148 The Participant Text: The Experience of Learning 150 Negative Experiences 161 Agency and Reflexivity 166 Summary of Chapter 171 7 Locating the Researcher in Participatory Video 173 Positionality in Feminist Participatory Research Scholarship 174 Positionality of the Researcher in Participatory Video: My Own Story 177 Researcher-as-Facilitator 180 Researcher-as-Educator 187 Concerning the Researcher‘s Ethical Responsibilities 196 Summary of Chapter 202 8 Toward a More Engaging, Enriching, and Educational Method 205 Summary of the Thesis 206 Responding to My Research Questions 209 Contribution to Knowledge Advancement 211 Limitations 215 Moving Forward 216 REFERENCES 218 APPENDICES 243 I. Research consent form 243 II. The research proposal of the participatory video project 245 III. Interview guide 248 IV. Interview consent form 249 V. Survey questionnaire 251 iv LIST OF FIGURES Figure 3.1. The reasons for engagement 76 Figure 3.2. A still photo from the interview between Shilanda and Star 78 Figure 3.3. Roadmap 85 Figure 3.4. A map of Chicago neighbourhoods 88 Figure 5.1. The relationships among the researcher, participants, and interviewees 142 LIST OF TABLES Table 3.1. Introduction to the participants 66 Table 3.2. An overview of the sessions 69 Table 3.3. An overview of the interview data set 91 Table 3.4. Survey responses 93 Table 3.5. Data sets 96 Table 4.1. The content of the film, Ready, Set, Engage 111 Table 4.2. Planned procedures 112 Table 5.1. The questionnaire for individual reflection essays 126 v Abstract Participatory video is generally referred to as a process in which participants work together to create a video about their common experiences as a way of inquiring into challenges in their lives. While media activists, policy makers, and academics have used various techniques of participatory video to bring about change in participants‘ lives, participatory video, as a research tool, has yet to be studied. I explore its methodological complexity based on a participatory video project I conducted with eight adults for 11 weeks on a topic they chose. Building on John Fiske‘s cultural studies framework, I analyze the process of the project, the participants‘ experiences, and my own experience in the project. In doing so, I test and suggest a method of analyzing participatory video. The notion of reflexivity is central to my analysis. A typical understanding of reflexivity, however, is problematic to participatory research because it focuses on researchers, disregarding the important role participants‘ reflexivity also plays in the process of inquiry. Hence, I argue that it is crucial to understand participants‘ reflexivity. My thesis is based on this argument. The purpose of the thesis is to gain a deeper understanding of participatory video vis- à-vis the notion of reflexivity and vice versa. In my findings I emphasize three aspects of participatory video: (1) Participatory video can bring to light grassroots experiences. However it may overlook unequal power distribution among participants. Hence, I argue that researchers may need to intervene actively in the process of making the video, and yet act cautiously in order to prompt the participants to reflect on their assumptions more deeply and to safeguard against silencing marginalized voices; (2) Participatory video can allow participants to experience incidental, social, and critical learning. Based on this observation, I call for attention to the potential of participatory video as a tool for adult learning; and (3) The researcher‘s positionality matters in conducting participatory video. It can interfere with the process of knowledge construction and influence the participants‘ experiences with projects. The thesis sheds light on the concept of positionality in the study of participatory video. vi Résumé La vidéo participative (participatory video) est une méthodologie dans laquelle des participants produisent une vidéo sur eux-mêmes pour analyser les problèmes de leurs vies et en chercher des solutions. Divers groupes, des journalistes aux décideurs, et même dans le milieu académique, utilisent des techniques variables de vidéo participative. Toutefois, la vidéo participative, comme méthode de recherche, doit être plus explorée pour en construire une connaissance plus fine qui puisse favoriser ses applications. J‘explore la complexité méthodologique de la vidéo participative en analysant un projet que j‘ai conduit avec huit adultes pendant 11 semaines sur un sujet choisi par les participants. En me basant sur le cadre analytique que John Fiske a proposé pour le domaine des études culturelles, j‘analyse le processus du projet, les expériences des participants, et mon expérience. Ce faisant, je teste et suggère une méthode pour analyser la vidéo participative. La notion de réflexion est importante dans mon analyse. Elle, cependant, est typiquement discutée de la part des chercheurs, jetant le rôle de la réflexion des participants que joue dans le processus d‘enquête participative. J‘insiste sur l‘importance d‘entendre leur réflexion. Ma thèse est basée sur cet argument. L‘objet de la thèse est d‘acquérir une compréhension plus profonde par rapport à la notion de réflexion, ou vice versa. Sur cette base, je souligne trois aspects de la vidéo participative. Premièrement, la vidéo participative peut donner à voir les expériences des gens tout en faisant fi de la répartition inégale de pouvoir entre participants. Par conséquent, je soutiens que les chercheurs doivent intervenir activement dans le processus de production de la vidéo, tout en agissant avec prudence afin d‘inciter les participants à réfléchir profondément sur leurs hypothèses et de permettre aux voix marginalisées de s‘exprimer. Deuxièmement, la vidéo participative peut permettre aux participants de faire des apprentissages induits (au niveau de la connaissance de soi, par exemple), sociaux (dans l‘interaction avec les autres), et critique (prendre conscience de sa capacité à résoudre ses problèmes). Dérivée de cette observation, j‘insiste sur le potentiel de la vidéo participative comme outil d‘apprentissage des adultes. Finalement, je considère que l‘espace positionnel du chercheur est important dans la vii conduite de la vidéo participative. Il peut interférer avec celui des participants et influer le processus de la construction des connaissances. Mes résultats mettent en lumière le concept de l‘espace positionnel dans l‘étude de la vidéo participative. viii Acknowledgements I would like to give special thanks to my co-supervisors, Ratna Ghosh and Claudia Mitchell, even though this would fall short from acknowledging the extent of their contributions to the thesis. Like the weather, there have been good days and bad days over the last four years. The early days were tough, but Ratna Ghosh provided me with a niche where I could rest and begin to engage in scholarly conversations. She has shown me that optimism is key to success. Claudia Mitchell has also inspired me. Her support and intellectual stimulation have been invaluable to the thesis. While her academic influence may be solidly recognized throughout the thesis, I also like to note that I enjoyed walking with her ―over the mountain‖ on the way home, sharing my joys, frustrations, and other thoughts. Some of the conversations are reflected in the thesis. Anila Asghar, my thesis committee member, has impelled me to write in higher precision and to remain critical of my own writing. We have become critical friends to each other. Michael Hoechsmann, one of my initial committee members, cheered me on all the time, even before I began my research. Aziz Choudry, a professor in my department (DISE), is a generous knowledge bank. Whenever I asked for literature, he gave it to me. Lise Winer, Director of the Graduate Program of DISE, has been a source of inspiration lately. She has shown me how one can apply the idea of equity to everyday work in academia. Alison Crump, a doctoral candidate in my cohort, supported me with her editorial comments on the thesis. Acknowledgements are due to all of you. Outside the Department, Ladislaus Semali, a professor at Penn State University in the United States, has offered valuable insight into my study from the perspective of adult education. Kang Myung-Goo, a professor at Seoul National University in Korea, is my intellectual father. When I was in college, he guided me to realize what people can do with media. In Chicago, Amy Thomas Elder, Director of the Odyssey Project, has shown me what an adult educator should be like.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • African Slavery in Documentary Films Why Now?
    Journal of Global Slavery 5 (2020) 1–21 brill.com/jgs African Slavery in Documentary Films Why Now? Francesca Declich University of Urbino Carlo Bo [email protected] Marie Rodet SOAS, University of London [email protected] The last two decades have witnessed much scholarly debate around discursive and non-discursive legacies of African slavery, as well as a growing interest in memories of slavery from the African continent.1 At the same time, an increas- 1 A large body of publications has emerged on slavery in the African continent, including among others: Martin A. Klein, “Studying the History of Those Who Would Rather Forget: Oral History and the Experience of Slavery,”History in Africa 16 (1989): 215; Edward A. Alpers, “Recollecting Africa: Diasporic Memory in the Indian Ocean World,”African Studies Review 43 (1) (2000): 83–99; Rosalind Shaw, Memories of the Slave Trade: Ritual and the Historical Imag- ination in Sierra Leone (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2002); Eric E. Hahonou and Baz Lecocq, “Introduction: Exploring Post-Slavery in Contemporary Africa,”International Journal of African Historical Studies 48, no. 2 (2015): 181–192; Alice Bellagamba, Sandra E. Greene, Martin A. Klein, African Slaves, African Masters. Politics, Memories, Social Life (Trenton NJ: Africa World Press, 2017); Alice Bellagamba. “Yesterday and today. Studying African slav- ery, the Slave Trade and their Legacies through Oral Sources,” in Alice Bellagamba, Sandra E. Greene, Martin A. Klein, eds., African Voices on Slavery and the Slave Trade. Vol 2: Sources and Methods (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2016), 174–197; Alice Bellagamba. “Living in the shadows of slavery”, OPEN DEMOCRACY (2016) https://www.opendemocracy .net/beyondslavery/alice‑bellagamba/living‑in‑shadows‑of‑slavery, accessed on 10 Novem- ber 2019; Marie Rodet, “Escaping Slavery and Building Diasporic Communities in French Soudan and Senegal, ca.
    [Show full text]
  • African Slavery on Documentary Films: Why Now?
    This is the accepted version of an article published by Brill in the Journal of Global Slavery. Available online: https://doi.org/10.1163/2405836X-00501008 Accepted version downloaded from SOAS Research Online: https://eprints.soas.ac.uk/32829/ African Slavery on Documentary Films: Why Now? Francesca Declich, University of Urbino Carlo Bo, [email protected] Marie Rodet, School of Oriental and African Studies, [email protected] The last two decades have witnessed much scholarly debate around discursive and non- discursive legacies of African slavery, and a growing interest on memories of slavery for the African continent.1 At the same time, an increasing amount of video material has been produced giving a voice to enslaved populations and their descendants in Africa and the global diaspora. This has included the production of documentaries as well as fiction films based on historical facts.2 As part of this movement, the Centre international de recherches sur les esclavages (CIRESC/France) in collaboration with the Laboratório de História Oral e Imagem, Federal University of Fluminense (LABHOI Brazil) and Centre interuniversitaire d’études sur les lettres, les arts et les traditions de l’Université de Laval (CELAT/Canada) have been 1 A large body of publications has emerged on slavery in the African continent, including among others: Martin A. Klein. “Studying the History of Those Who Would Rather Forget: Oral History and the Experience of Slavery.” History in Africa 16 (1989), 215; Edward A. Alpers. “Recollecting Africa: diasporic memory in the Indian Ocean world.” African Studies Review 43 (1) (2000), 83–99; Rosalind Shaw.
    [Show full text]
  • Ten Years of Participatory Cinema As a Form of Political Solidarity with Refugees in Italy
    arts Article Ten Years of Participatory Cinema as a Form of Political Solidarity with Refugees in Italy. From ZaLab and Archivio Memorie Migranti to 4CaniperStrada Annalisa Frisina 1,* and Stefania Muresu 2,* 1 Department of Philosophy, Sociology, Education and Applied Psychology, University of Padua, Via Cesarotti 10/12, 35123 Padova, Italy 2 Independent sociologist and film-maker, Association 4CaniperStrada, 07100 Sassari, Italy * Correspondence: [email protected] (A.F.); [email protected] (S.M.) Received: 12 October 2018; Accepted: 3 December 2018; Published: 6 December 2018 Abstract: This paper introduces the context of European mobilizations for and against refugees and how participatory cinema has become a way of expressing political solidarity with refugees in Italy. We present and discuss ten years of the artistic work of ZaLab and Archivio Memorie Migranti and focus on two film projects of 4CaniperStrada. Central to the production of participatory cinema in Italy is challenging the mainstream narrative of migration through the proactive involvement of asylum seekers, with their political subjectivity, by using a self-narrative method. Keywords: documentary films; participatory video; refugees; political solidarity; Italy 1. Introduction As Della Porta underlines in her book on European mobilizations for and against refugees’ rights (2018), in the last decade securitization of migration has led to a reduction in the legal channels of migration and a proliferation of legislation to limit and hierarchize citizenship, with the criminalization of undesirable migrants and the normalization of detention and deportation as instruments of governance. Repression has expanded from the targeting of migrants to the legal persecution of activists from grassroots groups and NGOs.
    [Show full text]
  • Video Research: Documenting and Learning from Hiv and Aids Communication Strategies for Social Change in Ghana
    VIDEO RESEARCH: DOCUMENTING AND LEARNING FROM HIV AND AIDS COMMUNICATION STRATEGIES FOR SOCIAL CHANGE IN GHANA by Heiko Decosas BA Communications, SFU 2006 PROJECT SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF MASTER OF COMMUNICATION In the School of Communication © Heiko Decosas 2010 SIMON FRASER UNIVERSITY Summer 2010 All rights reserved. However, in accordance with the Copyright Act of Canada, this work may be reproduced, without authorization, under the conditions for Fair Dealing. Therefore, limited reproduction of this work for the purposes of private study, research, criticism, review and news reporting is likely to be in accordance with the law, particularly if cited appropriately. Declaration of Partial Copyright Licence The author, whose copyright is declared on the title page of this work, has granted to Simon Fraser University the right to lend this thesis, project or extended essay to users of the Simon Fraser University Library, and to make partial or single copies only for such users or in response to a request from the library of any other university, or other educational institution, on its own behalf or for one of its users. The author has further granted permission to Simon Fraser University to keep or make a digital copy for use in its circulating collection (currently available to the public at the “Institutional Repository” link of the SFU Library website <www.lib.sfu.ca> at: <http://ir.lib.sfu.ca/handle/1892/112>) and, without changing the content, to translate the thesis/project or extended essays, if technically possible, to any medium or format for the purpose of preservation of the digital work.
    [Show full text]
  • Understanding Film and Video As Tools for Change
    UNDERSTANDING FILM AND VIDEO AS TOOLS FOR CHANGE: Applying Participatory Video and Video Advocacy in South Africa by Julia Cain TABLE OF CONTENTS Acknowledgements ................................................................................................... iii Abstract ..................................................................................................................... iv Opsomming ................................................................................................................v Chapter 1: Introduction ...............................................................................................1 1.1 Background and purpose of the study ...........................................................1 1.2 Overview of the dissertation ..........................................................................3 1.3 Supplementary materials.............................................................................10 Chapter 2: Background to Kayamandi participatory video project ............................11 2.1 Introduction to Kayamandi informal settlement area....................................11 2.2 Habitat for Humanity International ...............................................................13 2.3 South African housing policy .......................................................................17 2.4 Initiating the Kayamandi Participatory Video Project ...................................21 Chapter 3: Historical context for emergence of participatory video..........................28 3.1 Emergence
    [Show full text]
  • Visual Methodology in Migration Studies
    IMISCOE Research Series Karolina Nikielska-Sekula Amandine Desille Editors Visual Methodology in Migration Studies New Possibilities, Theoretical Implications, and Ethical Questions IMISCOE Research Series Now accepted for Scopus! Content available on the Scopus site in spring 2021. This series is the offcial book series of IMISCOE, the largest network of excellence on migration and diversity in the world. It comprises publications which present empirical and theoretical research on different aspects of international migration. The authors are all specialists, and the publications a rich source of information for researchers and others involved in international migration studies. The series is published under the editorial supervision of the IMISCOE Editorial Committee which includes leading scholars from all over Europe. The series, which contains more than eighty titles already, is internationally peer reviewed which ensures that the book published in this series continue to present excellent academic standards and scholarly quality. Most of the books are available open access. More information about this series at http://www.springer.com/series/13502 Karolina Nikielska-Sekula • Amandine Desille Editors Visual Methodology in Migration Studies New Possibilities, Theoretical Implications, and Ethical Questions Editors Karolina Nikielska-Sekula Amandine Desille University of South-Eastern Norway Institute of Geography and Spatial Planning Drammen, Norway Universidade de Lisboa Lisbon, Portugal ISSN 2364-4087 ISSN 2364-4095 (electronic)
    [Show full text]
  • In/Art: an Inquiry Into Cultural Framing for the Twenty-First Century Evelyn Armstrong IDSVA
    Maine State Library Maine State Documents Academic Research and Dissertations Special Collections 2013 In/Art: An Inquiry into Cultural Framing for the Twenty-first Century Evelyn Armstrong IDSVA Follow this and additional works at: http://digitalmaine.com/academic Recommended Citation Armstrong, Evelyn, "In/Art: An Inquiry into Cultural Framing for the Twenty-first Century" (2013). Academic Research and Dissertations. Book 14. http://digitalmaine.com/academic/14 This Text is brought to you for free and open access by the Special Collections at Maine State Documents. It has been accepted for inclusion in Academic Research and Dissertations by an authorized administrator of Maine State Documents. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Armstrong IN/ART AN INQUIRY INTO CULTURAL FRAMING FOR THE TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY By Evelyn Ann Armstrong A dissertation submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Philosophy, Aesthetics and Art Theory Institute for Doctoral Studies in the Visual Arts Portland, ME July 2012 i Armstrong Accepted by the faculty of the Institute for Doctoral Studies in the Visual Arts in partial fulfillment of the degree of Doctor of Philosophy. ______________________________ Dissertation Director’s Name, Ph.D. Doctoral Committee Dr. George Smith Dr. Denise Carvalho July 3, 2012 ii Armstrong © 2012 Evelyn Ann Armstrong ALL RIGHTS RESERVED iii Armstrong That lyf so short, the craft so long to learne, Th'assay so hard, so sharp the conquerynge. ⎯Geoffery Chaucer The Parliament of Fowls 1.I; cf Hippocrates (Elizabeth Knowles, ed., The Oxford Dictionary of Quotations, 5th edition Oxford: Oxford University Press, 206 28).
    [Show full text]