Biological Surfactants Vs. Polysorbates: Comparison of Their Emulsifier and Surfactant Properties
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by UPCommons. Portal del coneixement obert de la UPC DETERGENT INGREDIENTS y Lorena Rodríguez-López1, Myriam Rincón-Fontán1, Xanel Vecino2,3 , José Manuel Cruz1 and Ana Belén Moldes1 Biological Surfactants vs. Polysorbates: Comparison of Their Emulsifier and Surfactant Properties In this work two biological surfactants, a cell-bound biosurfac- stellte Biotensid zeigte aufgrund des relativen Emulsionsvolu- tant produced by Lactobacillus pentosus and a biosurfactant ob- mens (EV = 100%) nach einem Tag der Emulsionsbildung die tained from a fermented stream corn milling industry, were beste Emulgieraktivität, wobei der EV-Wert nach 15 Tagen der compared with two chemical surfactants (polysorbate 20 and Emulsionsbildung bei über 50% gehalten wurde. Die EV-Werte polysorbate 80) in terms of surface tension reduction, critical der Polysorbate erreichten weniger als 50%. Die CMC-Werte micellar concentration (CMC), oil spreading and emulsifying ca- des Biotensids aus dem Maisstrom und die der Polysorbate la- pacity. Biological surfactants showed a similar ability to reduce gen im Vergleich zum CMC-Wert des L. pentosus-Biotensids nä- the surface tension of water as polysorbates, which was in con- her beieinander, wobei beobachtet wurde, dass die Charakteris- formance with the results obtained in the drop collapse test. Re- tika und die Eigenschaften des Biotensids aus dem Maisstrom garding the ability to spread the oil on water, both biosur- denen der Polysorbate ähnlicher sind als denen des L. pento- factants produced similar results as polysorbates after 1 h. sus-Biotensids. Daher könnte vermutet werden, dass das Bio- However, after 24 h, polysorbates and biosurfactant from corn tensid aus Maisstrom ein guter Ersatz für die Polysorbate sein stream were more effective than L. pentosus biosurfactant, pro- könnte. ducing greater free oil areas. Concerning the emulsifying activity, in terms of relative emulsion volume (EV), the biosurfactant pro- Stichwörter: Polysorbate, Biotenside, Ölspreitungstest, Tropfen- duced from L. pentosus gave the best results (EV = 100%), after kollapstest, Emulgierfähigkeit 1 day of emulsion formation, keeping this value over 50% after 15 days of emulsion formation; whereas polysorbates gave EV values lower than 50%. The CMC values of the biosurfactant 1 Introduction from corn stream and of polysorbates were closer in comparison with the CMC value of L. pentosus biosurfactant, observing that Polysorbates are a family of surface-active compounds very For personal use only. the characteristics and properties of the biosurfactant from corn often used in cosmetic, pharmaceutical and food industry to stream are more similar to polysorbates than to L. pentosus bio- solubilize hydrophobic ingredients in water-based products surfactant. Thus, it could be speculated that biosurfactant from [1–3]. They are non-ionic oily liquids derived from ethoxy- corn stream would be a good substitute for polysorbates. lated sorbitan, esterified with fatty acids. Although they are considered as non-toxic compounds, the use of hazard state- Key words: Polysorbates, biosurfactants, oil spreading test, ments is recommended. For instance, the Classification, La- drop collapse test, emulsifier capacity belling and Packaging (CLP) regulation of European Union assign to sorbitan monooleate, ethoxylated (Tween 80), with a CAS number of 9005-65-6, the following hazard statement Biotenside gegen Polysorbate: Vergleich ihrer Emulgator- codes: H412, H302, H312, H315, H319, H332, H412 related und Tensideigenschaften. In dieser Arbeit wurden zwei Bio- with eye and skin irritation as well as aquatic toxicity [4]. tenside, ein zellgebundenes Biotensid aus Lactobacillus pento- Since 1 June 2015, CLP is the only legislation in force in sus und ein Biotensid, das dem fermentierten Strom einer Mais- the EU for classification and labelling of substances and Tenside Surfactants Detergents downloaded from www.hanser-elibrary.com by 147.83.132.102 on October 15, 2018 müllerei gewonnen wurde, mit den zwei chemischen Tensiden mixtures [5], revising and including the previous regulations Polysorbat 20 und Polysorbat 80 bezüglich der Reduktion der about dangerous substances: Dangerous Substances Direc- Oberflächenspannung, kritischen Mizellenbildungskonzentra- tive (67/548/EEC (DSD)), the Dangerous Preparations Di- tion (CMC), Ölspreitung und Emulgierfähigkeit verglichen. Die rective (1999/45/EC (DPD)) and Regulation (EC) No 1907/ Biotenside können die Oberflächenspannung von Wasser ähn- 2006 (REACH). lich wie die Polysorbate reduzieren, was mit den Ergebnissen Nowadays there is an increasing demand for cost compe- des Tropfenkollapstests übereinstimmte. Hinsichtlich der Fähig- titive and environment friendly alternatives to synthetic sur- keit, Öl auf Wasser zu spreiten, lieferten beide Biotenside nach factants, attracting scientists all over the world to study the 1 Stunde ähnliche Ergebnisse wie die Polysorbate. Nach 24 Stun- production of biological detergents, named biosurfactants, den waren jedoch die Polysorbate und das Biotensid aus dem with enormous commercial and healthcare potentials in the Maisstrom wirksamer als das L. pentosus-Biotensid, indem grö- current market with a higher ecological acceptance [6–11]. ßere freie Ölflächen erzeugt wurden. Das aus L. pentosus herge- Biosurfactants can be produced by microorganisms, bacter- ia, yeast or fungi, by biotechnological processes, being more 1 Chemical Engineering Department, School of Industrial Engineering – Centro biodegradable than chemical surfactants [12–14]. Moreover, de Investigación Tecnológico Industrial (MTI), University of Vigo, Campus As Lagoas-Marcosende, 36310 Vigo, Spain. as they are composed by lipids, carbohydrates and/or pro- 2 Chemical Engineering Department, Barcelona East School of Engineering teins, they should be more biocompatible and less irritant (EEBE), Polytechnic University of Catalonia (UPC)-Barcelona TECH, Campus than chemical surfactants and emulsifiers [6, 8]. These bio- Diagonal-Besòs, 08930 Barcelona, Spain. 3 Barcelona Research Center for Multiscale Science and Engineering, Campus surfactants can be extracellular or cell-bound [15–18]. For Diagonal-Besòs, 08930 Barcelona, Spain. instance, Lactobacillus pentosus produces a cell-bound glycoli- Tenside Surf. Det. 55 (2018) 4 ª Carl Hanser Publisher, Munich 273 Lorena Rodríguez-López et al.: Biological surfactants vs. polysorbates: comparison of their emulsifier popeptide biosurfactant that is able to reduce the surface whereas their emulsifying activities were evaluated based tension of water in 23 units [17, 19]. In previous works the on the capacity of the surfactants, under study, to stabilize biosurfactant produced by L. pentosus showed better emulsi- oil/water rosemary emulsions. fier capacity than polysorbate 20, when it was used as stabi- lizer agent of oil in water (O/W) emulsions containing ro- 2 Materials and Methods semary oil [20]. Moreover, recently a biosurfactant extract from a fermen- 2.1 Production of extracellular biosurfactant from corn stream ted stream of corn milling industry has been obtained, (BS from CSL) which is able to reduce the surface tension of water in more than 30 units, and it is composed by a hydrophobic chain of Corn steep liquor (CSL) was provided by Santa Cruz Bio- fatty acids with similar composition to the lipopeptide bio- technology with a solid content of 50% (LOT D2814). Then, surfactant produced from Bacillus subtilis [11, 18, 21]. 50 g were diluted in distilled water, achieving a concentra- However, before introducing these biological surfactants tion of 50 g/L. This solution was extracted with chloroform 8 in pharmaceutical and cosmetic formulations, it is impor- (CSL:CHCl3 1:2 v/v), at 56 C for 1 h, following the protocol tant to compare their surfactant and emulsifying activities established by Vecino et al. [21] and summarized in Fig. 1a. with the most common surfactants used in these industrial After that, the organic solvent was eliminated by vacuum sectors. From this point of view, polysorbates can be consid- distillation, using a rotatory evaporator R-210 (Buchi, Swit- ered as one of the most employed families of surfactants in zerland), and finally dissolved again in distilled water reach- cosmetic formulations [20]. ing a concentration about 0.9 mg mL–1, nine times above its Hence, in this work polyoxyethylene (20) sorbitan mono- critical micellar concentration (CMC). laurate (Tween 20) and polyoxyethylene (20) sorbitan mono- oleate (Tween 80) were compared with two biological surfac- 2.2 Production of cell-bound biosurfactant tants, obtained from controlled (L. pentosus biosurfactant) or from Lactobacillus pentosus (BS from L. pentosus) spontaneous (biosurfactant from corn stream) fermenta- tions. The comparison was in terms of surface tension capa- An inoculum of 1 mL of L. pentosus CECT-4023T (ATCC- city, using the drop collapse test and oil spreading test; 8041) obtained from the Spanish Type Culture Collection For personal use only. Tenside Surfactants Detergents downloaded from www.hanser-elibrary.com by 147.83.132.102 on October 15, 2018 Figure 1 Overview of the biosurfactant extraction from corn steep liquor (a) and production of biosurfactant from L. pentosus (b). 274 Tenside Surf. Det. 55 (2018) 4 Lorena Rodríguez-López et al.: Biological surfactants vs. polysorbates: comparison of their emulsifier (CECT) (Valencia, Spain) was grown in a 250 mL Erlen- the