DOCSLIB.ORG

Breakthrough in PNB Fraud Case

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Breakthrough in PNB Fraud Case India Breakthrough in PNB fraud case, international business head of Gitanjali Gems traced to US ED begins process to extradite Sunil Varma, who fled days before PNB scam broke last year, involving diamond merchants Mehul Choksi & Nirav Modi. ANANYA BHARDWAJ 2 August, 2019 5:54 pm IST A Gitanjali Gems Ltd. Giantti store in Mumbai | Dhiraj Singh | Bloomberg New Delhi: In a major development in the Punjab National Bank (PNB) fraud case, the Enforcement Directorate (ED) has traced the location of the international business head of Gitanjali Gems, Sunil Varma, to the US and started the process of extraditing him. According to a source in the agency, Varma had fled the country just days before the nearly Rs 14,000-crore PNB scam broke last year in January, involving diamond merchants Mehul Choksi and Nirav Modi. Choksi is the owner of Gitanjali Gems. The same ED source said that extradition of Varma will be a big step as he had played a “crucial role” in executing the letters of undertaking (LoUs) that were fraudulently obtained. Varma was also named in the ED chargesheet filed in a Mumbai court last year in July. An LoU is not a loan but a guarantee given by a bank in India to an overseas bank, stating that it would meet the liability if the firm borrowing from it (foreign bank) defaults. Diamond firms use LoUs for securing cheap, low-interest “buyer’s credit” in dollars overseas, mostly to purchase rough diamonds. Banks are always supposed to cover their LoUs against collaterals, which allegedly wasn’t done in this fraud case. A Foreign Letter of Credit, on the other hand, is given to banks overseas to ensure that payment can be made to foreign suppliers. “He (Varma) was even summoned in the case after his role in the fraud was ascertained. He, however, fled the country by then,” an ED source said. The ED has also requested Interpol to issue a Red Corner Notice (RCN) against Varma, which is still pending. Also read: CBI sent most requests for Interpol red corner notices the year Nirav Modi, Choksi fled Choksi, his aides bigger defaulters than Nirav Modi According to the ED’s chargesheet, Choksi, who is also the owner of Gili India and Nakshatra, is the key conspirator who devised the entire mode of fraud in connivance with other accused to cheat Punjab National Bank. Investigation revealed that PNB issued 143 LoUs and 225 Foreign Letters of Credit, amounting to Rs 4,886.72 crore, to three of Choksi’s companies between March and May 2017. While 143 LoUs were worth Rs 3,008.72 crore, the 225 Foreign Letters of Credit amounted to Rs 1,798 crore. This would, in effect, make Choksi the bigger defaulter than his nephew and high- profile diamantaire Nirav Modi, a CBI source said. The three companies to which these LoUs and Foreign Letters of Credit were issued were Gitanjali Gems, Gili India and Nakshatra. According to ED, just like in the Nirav Modi case, the proceeds generated from the fraud were siphoned off and laundered by Choksi through various entities for personal gains. Varma’s role Varma was the chief financial officer (CFO) of Gitanjali Gems and in-charge of the company’s day-to-day operations along with administrative affairs. According to a source in the agency, his primary role was to coordinate and look after all international operations and deals overseas. He also looked into the accounts, audits, tax-related matters, business strategies of the company, the source added. “Since he was dealing with business overseas, he was also dealing with issuance of LoUs of the company and the banks abroad too. His role is extremely crucial in the case,” the same source said. A commerce graduate from Mumbai University (earlier known as University of Bombay), Varma also holds a management degree from the University of Chicago. According to an agency official, Varma joined Gitanjali Gems in December 2009 as its CFO and went on to become the company’s director in 2012. He was again promoted after a year and made in-charge of all international operations and deals overseas. Also read: Mehul Choksi says extradition talk is fake news, have faith in Antigua ThePrint is now on Telegram. For the best reports & opinion on politics, governance and more, subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram. Subscribe to our YouTube channel. TAGS enforcement directorate Gitanjali Gems PNB Scam .
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Government of India V Modi Judgment
    IN THE WESTMINSTER MAGISTRATES’ COURT BEFORE DISTRICT JUDGE (MC) SAM GOOZÉE Appropriate Judge The Government of India (Requesting State) V Nirav Deepak Modi (Requested Person) JUDGMENT Table of Contents Background & Chronology of Proceedings Page 2 The Challenges to Extradition Page 4 The Requests Page 5 Prima Facie case Page 9 Admissibility of evidence Page 14 Prima Face Case – CBI Request Page 18 Conclusions on Prima Facie Case – CBI Request Page 31 Conclusion on Prima Facie Case – ED Request Page 36 Prima Facie Case – CBI Supplementary Request Page 36 Conclusion on Prima Facie Case – CBI Supplementary Request Page 42 Extradition Offences Page 45 1 Human Rights Challenges – Article 6 ECHR Page 53 Conclusions Article 6 Challenge Page 58 Human Rights Challenges – Article 3 ECHR & s.91 EA 2003 Page 61 Conclusions Article 3 Challenge Page 74 Conclusions – s.91 EA 2003. Page 79 Procedural Requirements and Decision Page 80 Background and Chronology of proceedings 1. This is an extradition request submitted by the Government of India, the Requesting State(“GOI”) for the extradition of Nirav Deepak Modi, the Requested Person (NDM). The request is governed by the Provisions of Part 2 of the Extradition Act 2003 (“EA 2003”). India is a designated Part 2 country by virtue of the Extradition Act 2003 (Designation of Part 2 Territories) Order 2003. 2. The return of NDM, an Indian national, is sought for the purposes prosecution. On the 27th July 2018, the GOI issued a request for the extradition of NDM. Initially, NDM was subject to two sets of criminal proceedings. The first set of proceedings are brought by the Indian Central Bureau of Investigation (“the CBI case”).
    [Show full text]
  • BUDGET 2021 Response to the National Budget Statement
    BUDGET 2021 Response to the National Budget Statement Abstract How unlawful privatization of the people’s money to foreign friends of the finance minister, condoned by an unjust parliamentary majority, is destroying the economy of Dominica and creating unnecessary poverty, suffering and pain for the people. Hon. Lennox Linton Leader of the Opposition INTRODUCTION Citizens of Dominica, The 2021 National Budget is Government`s income and expense statement for the financial year July 1st, 2021 to June 30th, 2022. It entails how the government will raise its funds and where and how the funds will be used. Through the approval of Parliament, the budget provides Government with the money it needs to deliver its policies and run vital services in areas such as Health, Education, Economic Development, Housing, Livelihood Sustainability, Environment Protection and Public Infrastructure. The budget impacts the economy at large and the everyday lives of all Dominicans. In our Parliamentary Democracy it is a critical instrument of social justice. BUDGET DEBATE IN AN UNJUST PARLIAMENT As I reflected carefully on what I believe is our shared commitment across the parliamentary divide to build a prosperous, peaceful, secure and just society, a Magistrate’s concern in court on July 27th, 2021 kept coming back to me: “The Prosecution has brought the administration of justice in Dominica into disrepute”. In other words, those involved in regulating access to the criminal justice system and prosecuting criminal conduct in the public interest, in the 1 opinion of a sitting Magistrate, have brought the administration of justice into disrepute. We want prosperity, peace, security and justice.
    [Show full text]
  • SAMUELS JEWELERS, INC.,1 Case No
    Case 18-11818-KJC Doc 669 Filed 02/20/19 Page 1 of 136 IN THE UNITED STATES BANKRUPTCY COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF DELAWARE In re: Chapter 11 SAMUELS JEWELERS, INC.,1 Case No. 18-11818 (KJC) Debtor. PHASE I REPORT OF JOHN J. CARNEY, EXAMINER LANDIS RATH & COBB LLP BAKER & HOSTETLER LLP Adam G. Landis (No. 3407) Jorian L. Rose Jennifer L. Cree (No. 5919) Tracy Cole 919 North Market Street, Suite 1800 Susrut A. Carpenter Wilmington, DE 19801 Jason I. Blanchard Telephone: (302) 467-4400 Lauren P. Lyster Facsimile: (302) 467-4450 45 Rockefeller Plaza Email: landis@lrclaw.com New York, New York 10111 cree@lrclaw.com Telephone: (212) 589-4200 Facsimile: (212) 589-4201 Delaware Counsel to John J. Carney, Esq., Email: jrose@bakerlaw.com as Examiner tcole@bakerlaw.com scarpenter@bakerlaw.com jblanchard@bakerlaw.com llyster@bakerlaw.com Counsel to John J. Carney, Esq., as Examiner BAKER & HOSTETLER LLP ALVAREZ AND MARSAL DISPUTES John J. Carney AND INVESTIGATIONS, LLC 45 Rockefeller Plaza William B. Waldie New York, New York 10111 Richard Bunyan Telephone: (212) 589-4200 600 Madison Avenue Facsimile: (212) 589-4201 New York, New York 10022 Email: jcarney@bakerlaw.com Telephone: (212) 763-9568 Examiner Financial Advisor to the Examiner, John J. Carney February 20, 2019 1 The last four digits of the Debtor’s federal tax identification number are 6316. The Debtor’s mailing address is 2914 Montopolis Drive, Suite 200, Austin, Texas 78741. {1219.001-W0054389.} Case 18-11818-KJC Doc 669 Filed 02/20/19 Page 2 of 136 TABLE OF CONTENTS Contents I.
    [Show full text]
  • AIBEA's Banking News
    AIBEA’s Banking News 19 APRIL 2018 NEWS BULLETIN FROM ALL INDIA BANK EMPLOYEES’ ASSOCIATION 1 Nationalise ICICI Bank and Axis Bank: AIBEA to Centre VINSON KURIAN, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, APRIL 17 BUSINESSLINE The All-India Bank Employees Association (AIBEA) has demanded that the Centre take immediate steps to nationalise both ICICI Bank and Axis Bank after the recent unsavoury developments. Merely changing the top executives will not suffice, according to CH Venkatachalam, General Secretary, AIBEA. He also opposed the demands for privatisation of public sector banks. Public deposits ―Everyone is now aware what is the reality about private sector efficiency. ICICI Bank and Axis Bank together have deposits of the public to the tune of Rs. 9 lakh crore, which we need to safeguard,‖ he said. ―There have been repeated cases of suppression of bad loans and under- provisioning. All these unethical things have been going on for a long time.‖ Venkatachalam noted that ever since the Punjab National Bank-Nirav Modi fraud came to light, there has been strong demand from different corners for the privatisation of public sector banks. The only argument was that the PNB fraud has taken place because of the inefficiency of public sector ownership of banks. Bad Loans in Private Banks Bank - Gross NPA/ crores ICICI Bank Ltd. 45051 Axis Bank Ltd. 22662 HDFC Bank Ltd. 8176 Jammu & Kashmir Bank Ltd. 6232 Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. 3715 Yes Bank Ltd 2974 IDFC Bank Limited 2777 2 Karur Vysya Bank Ltd. 2663 Federal Bank Ltd. 2161 Karnataka Bank Ltd. 1784 South Indian Bank Ltd. 1775 IndusInd Bank Ltd.
    [Show full text]
  • A Case Study on Punjab National Bank Scam
    Journal of Xi' an Shiyou University, Natural Science Edition ISSN : 1673-064X A Case Study on Punjab National Bank Scam (Is it only a scam or failure of the combined banking system?) Dr. Meda Srinivasa Rao Dr. B. Kishore Babu Professor, KL Business School, Professor, KL Business School Koneru Lakshmaiah Education Koneru Lakshmaiah Education Foundation, Foundation Vaddeswaram, Vaddeswaram, Andhra Pradesh-522502 Andhra Pradesh-522502 Abstract: The “biggest bank loot scam in 70 years” in independent India happened in one of the largest Public Sector Bank that had trembled entire banking sector. Punjab National Bank (PNB) India’s second largest public sector bank released a disaster on Valentine's Day i.e. 14th February 2018 by revealing a scam of Rs.11,400 crore directed by one of the country's richest businessman of the diamond, Nirav Modi. He ranked 85th on Forbes’s 2017 list of India’s richest people. Nirav Modi had directed and executed the scam with the support of Deputy Manager of PNB Mumbai branch named Gokul Nath Shetty and clerk Manoj Kharat. Modi and his Uncle Mehul Choksi schemed with these two people. They had facilitated the issuance of unauthorized LOU (Letter of Undertaking) to Modi and his company without following an appropriate procedure. The post scam had impacted shares of PNB by evaporating the market capitalization value worth of Rs.8000 crore due to that the entire banking sector was under shocking waves. Whistleblower had transcribed to the Prime Minister’s Office (PMO) at 2016, notifying the government for the “biggest bank loot scam in 70 years” but no prompt action was taken by the government.
    [Show full text]
  • Journal of Forensic and Investigative Accounting Volume 11: Issue 2, Special Edition, 2019
    Journal of Forensic and Investigative Accounting Volume 11: Issue 2, Special Edition, 2019 Gem of the Indian Banking Fraud: A Case of Systemic Control Failures at Punjab National Bank Gagan Kukreja Sanjay Gupa* Introduction Punjab National Bank (PNB) is one of the largest public sector banks in India. The government owns 65.01% of its equity as on March 31, 2017 (PNB, 2017). According to Top Banker 2017 report of Dun and Bradstreet (2017, p 107), the PNB ranks third among all Indian banks and second among the Indian public sector banks in terms of business size (total of advances and deposits), which exceeds USD 160 billion as of March 31, 2017. The core strengths of the bank are its brand image with 122 years of experience, its more than 100 million customers, its strong deposit base, its consistently growing operating profit, and its low cost of operations, and its extensive rural and urban branch network, stable asset quality and rapid digitalization. As on March 31, 2017, PNB had an aggregate asset size of USD 111 billion, equity of USD 6.5 billion and net income of USD 204 million. The banks total capital ratio (regulatory capital to risk weighted assets) was close to twelve percent (PNB, 2017). Before we delve into the details of the PNB fraud, we need to understand how the trade is financed by banks in India. Some frequently used terms in import-export finance are explained below. Letter of Undertaking (LoU) and Foreign Letter of Credit (FLC) (“hundi” in Hindi) A LoU is a letter of guarantee issued by a bank on behalf of its customers to foreign branches of other banks, who offer credit to these customers.
    [Show full text]
  • GITANJALI GEMS LIMITED (The Company Was Incorporated on August 21, 1986 As a Private Limited Company Under the Companies Act
    CMYK FINAL PROSPECTUS Dated February 27, 2006 Please read Section 60B of the Companies Act, 1956 100% Book Built Issue GITANJALI GEMS LIMITED (The Company was incorporated on August 21, 1986 as a private limited company under the Companies Act. For details of changes in name, please refer to “History and Certain Corporate Matters” beginning on page 90 of this Prospectus) Registered Office: 801/802 Prasad Chambers, Opera House, Mumbai 400 004 Tel: (91) (22) 2363 0272; Fax: (91) (22) 23630363 Contact Person: Kishor Baxi; Tel: (91) (22) 2363 5344 E-mail: ipo@gitanjaligroup.com; Website: www.gitanjaligroup.com PUBLIC ISSUE OF 17,000,000 EQUITY SHARES OF RS.10 EACH OF GITANJALI GEMS LIMITED (“GITANJALI GEMS” OR THE “COMPANY” OR THE “ISSUER”) FOR CASH AT A PRICE OF RS.195 PER EQUITY SHARE, AGGREGATING RS.3,315 MILLION (THE “ISSUE”). 150,000 EQUITY SHARES OF RS.10 EACH WILL BE RESERVED IN THE ISSUE FOR SUBSCRIPTION BY PERMANENT EMPLOYEES AND DIRECTORS OF THE COMPANY WHO ARE INDIAN NATIONALS AND ARE BASED IN INDIA (THE “EMPLOYEE RESERVATION PORTION”, AND THE ISSUE OF EQUITY SHARES OTHER THAN THE EMPLOYEE RESERVATION PORTION, THE “NET ISSUE”). THE FACE VALUE OF THE EQUITY SHARES IS RS.10. THE ISSUE WILL CONSTITUTE 28.81% OF THE FULLY DILUTED POST-ISSUE CAPITAL OF THE COMPANY. ISSUE PRICE : RS. 195 PER EQUITY SHARE OF FACE VALUE RS.10 EACH. THE ISSUE PRICE IS 19.5 TIMES THE FACE VALUE In case of revision in the Price Band, the Bidding/Issue Period shall be extended for three additional working days after such revision, subject to the Bidding/Issue Period not exceeding 10 working days.
    [Show full text]
  • The Institute of Cost Accountants of India Daily
    THE INSTITUTE OF Telephones : +91-33- 2252-1031/1034/1035 COST ACCOUNTANTS OF INDIA + 91-33-2252-1602/1492/1619 (STATUTORY BODY UNDER AN ACT OF PARLIAMENT) + 91-33- 2252-7143/7373/2204 CMA BHAWAN Fax : +91-33-2252-7993 12, SUDDER STREET, KOLKATA – 700 016. +91-33-2252-1026 +91-33-2252-1723 Website : www.icmai.in DAILY NEWS DIGEST BY BFSI BOARD, ICAI June 7, 2021 SBI to keep up the momentum of stressed assets recovery: Dinesh Kumar Khara: State Bank of India (SBI) will put in all efforts in FY22 to keep up the momentum of recovery made in stressed assets in FY21, according to Chairman Dinesh Kumar Khara. This will be aided by the roll-out of pre-packaged insolvency for resolution, resumption of courts and formation of National Asset Reconstruction Company Ltd (NARCL). India’s largest bank will make judicious use of all recovery options at its disposal, he said. However, Khara underscored that it is too early to call a possible deterioration of asset quality in banks due to the second wave. “The Bank over the last two financial years was dealing with a steep rise in stressed assets. All-round effort in managing stressed accounts initiated in FY2019 was carried through in FY2020 as well. “However, the outbreak of the pandemic and subsequent lockdown in FY2021 altered the dynamics of stressed asset recovery. Bank had to grapple with disruption in normal proceeding at NCLT due to Covid-19 infections,” the SBI Chief said in the latest annual report. Furthermore, the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) mandated a standstill clause for some portfolios.
    [Show full text]
  • SAMUELS JEWELERS, INC. Debtor. Chapter 11 Case No. 18
    Case 18-11818-KJC Doc 142 Filed 08/27/18 Page 1 of 16 IN THE UNITED STATES BANKRUPTCY COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF DELAWARE In re: Chapter 11 SAMUELS JEWELERS, INC.1 Case No. 18-11818 (KJC) Debtor. Requested Hearing date: September 13, 2018 at 9:30 a.m. (ET) Requested Objection Deadline: September 7, 2018 at 4:00 p.m. (ET) PUNJAB NATIONAL BANK’S MOTION FOR ENTRY OF AN ORDER DIRECTING THE APPOINTMENT OF AN EXAMINER PURSUANT TO 11 U.S.C. §1104(c) Punjab National Bank (“PNB”), by and through its undersigned counsel, hereby moves this Court (the “Motion”) for the entry of an order directing the appointment of an examiner in the above-captioned Chapter 11 case, substantially in the form attached hereto as Exhibit A, under sections 105(a) and 1104(c) of title 11 of the United States Code, 11 U.S.C. §§ 101-1532 (the “Bankruptcy Code”) and Rule 2007.1 of the Federal Rules of Bankruptcy Procedure (the “Bankruptcy Rules”): PRELIMINARY STATEMENT 1. PNB seeks the appointment of an examiner, pursuant to section 1104(d) of the Bankruptcy Code. The Debtor in this case is 100% owned by Gitanjali Gems, Ltd. (“Gitanjali”) whose chairman and director is Mehul Choksi (“Choksi”). Both Gitanjali and Choksi have been implicated in the largest bank fraud (the “Fraud”) in the history of the Republic of India. They have been indicted by Indian authorities, and Choksi is currently an international fugitive from justice.2 PNB is the largest victim of that Fraud. 1 The last four digits of the Debtor’s taxpayer identification number are 6316 and its address is 2914 Montopolis Drive, Suite 200, Austin, Texas 78741.
    [Show full text]
  • Nirav Modi May Be Extradited Soon, but Over 300 Fugitives Evade Indian Laws at Present
    Nirav Modi may be extradited soon, but over 300 fugitives evade Indian laws at present India is currently looking for 313 fugitives, including 224 citizens, who have been issued red corner notices by Interpol as of now. Apart from Modi, the list includes Mehul Choksi, gangster Iqbal Mirchi’s widow Hajra Memon and others. Samrat Sharma New Delhi March 2, 2021 UPDATED: March 2, 2021 22:46 IST A demonstrator in Kolkata holds an effigy depicting Nirav Modi (Picture Credits: Reuters) n February 25, Indian agencies tasted major success in its nearly three-year battle against Nirav Modi when O a UK court cleared the first legal hurdle for the fugitive diamantaire’s extradition. However, India is looking for 313 fugitives, including 224 citizens, who have been issued red corner notices by the Interpol as of now. Apart from Modi, the list includes Mehul Choksi, gangster Iqbal Mirchi’s widow Hajra Memon and others. A red corner notice is Interpol’s request to law enforcement worldwide to locate and provisionally arrest individuals who are liable to extradition, surrender or similar legal action. The below graphic shows the list of fugitives accused of money laundering and wanted by India to be tried in her courts. As per government records, 72 citizens have fled the country after allegedly being involved in financial irregularities since 2015. Of these, India has managed to extradite only two fugitive economic offenders in the last six years, according to an RTI. The Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) and Enforcement Directorate (ED) have so far successfully convinced a UK court to extradite Modi, but the extradition of Choksi from Antigua appears to be a long shot.
    [Show full text]
  • 2Nd June 2021
    Daily News Discussion (DND) 2nd June 2021 Visit our website www.sleepyclasses.com or our YouTube channel for entire GS Course FREE of cost Also Available: Prelims Crash Course || Prelims Test Series T.me/SleepyClasses Table of Contents 1. Science & Technology ..........................................................................................1 1.1.Controlling NCD- key to fight Covid .................................................................................1 1.2.world’s first nano liquid urea ...............................................................................................3 2. Geography ...............................................................................................................7 2.1.IMD increases monsoon rain outlook to 101% ..............................................................7 3. Economy ..................................................................................................................8 3.1.Horticulture Cluster Development Programme (CDP) ................................................8 4. Polity .........................................................................................................................9 4.1.Disaster Management Act, 2005 ......................................................................................9 4.2.NCPCR tracks data on orphans .........................................................................................9 4.3.Legal issues involved in bringing Mehul Choksi back ...................................................10
    [Show full text]
  • Orient Press Ltd. T El. : 4028 5888
    Orient Press Ltd. Tel. : 4028 5888 1 CONTENTS Page No. The Board of Directors 2 Company Information 4 Notice to Annual General Meeting 5 Director’s Report 9 Management Discussion and Analysis 41 Report on Corporate Governance 48 Auditor’s report on Financial Statement 62 Balance sheet 66 Statement of Profit & Loss 67 Cash Flow Statement 68 Significant Accounting Policies & Notes forming part of Financial statements 70 Auditor’s report on Consolidated Financial Statements 103 Consolidated Balance sheet 109 Consolidated Statement of Profit & Loss 110 Consolidated Cash Flow Statement 111 Significant Accounting Policies & Notes forming part of Consolidated Financial statements 113 Salient features of Financial Statements of Subsidiaries/Associates/Joint Ventures 141 2 THE JOURNEY OF A PIONEER PROFILE OF DIRECTORS A brief profile of all the Board members are as under:- Mr. MEHUL CHOKSI A commerce graduate has been associated with the gems and jewellery industry for over three decades. He has wide experience in the diamond and Jewellery industry having an exposure to the entire range of activities, from buying roughs to processing, manufacturing and retailing of jewellery. He has been instrumental in bringing branded jewellery revolution in India and has launched several successful jewellery brands. He has also been a pioneer in corporatizing the jewellery industry in India. He steers the group vision and strategy with his deep knowledge and foresight Mr. DHANESH SHETH A Commerce Graduate has been associated with Gitanjali since its inception. He advises the company on procurement, processing, bagging and selling of rough and polished diamonds and other aspects of Business Development pertaining to diamond division of the Company.
    [Show full text]