Leap of Confidence Primagest Stay Relevant in a Changing World Deal-By-Deal Fundraising Is Great in Theory, but Often Difficult in Practice Page 7 Page 14

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Leap of Confidence Primagest Stay Relevant in a Changing World Deal-By-Deal Fundraising Is Great in Theory, but Often Difficult in Practice Page 7 Page 14 Asia’s Private Equity News Source avcj.com January 20 2015 Volume 28 Number 03 EDITOR’S VIEWPOINT Slower growth in China does not mean fewer opportunities for PE Page 3 NEWS Alibaba, Carlyle, CDC, CPPIB, Hamilton Lane, IDG, India Value Fund, Multiples, OTPP, Vision Knight, SoftBank, TA Associates, Sequoia, Tiger Global, Yunfeng Page 4 DEAL OF THE WEEK Macro headwinds blow Peoplebank off course Page 13 PORTFOLIO J-Star helps Japan’s Leap of confidence Primagest stay relevant in a changing world Deal-by-deal fundraising is great in theory, but often difficult in practice Page 7 Page 14 FOCUS DEAL OF THE WEEK Blood on the street Bang for their buck China’s mobile taxi-booking app battle Page 11 ChrysCapital nets 2x return on ING Vysya Page 13 4th Annual Private Equity & Venture Forum Indonesia 2015 24 March, Grand Hyatt Jakarta GLOBAL PERSPECTIVE, LOCAL OPPORTUNITY avcjindonesia.com SIGN UP NOW! Volatility, Opportunities and Jokonomics: AND US$200 A new landscape for PE (until 6 FEB only)SAVE We are delighted to bring your attention to the NEW speakers already confirmed for the 4th Annual AVCJ Indonesia Forum. Taking place on 24 March 2015 in Jakarta, this year’s agenda will adopt a lively and interactive format, addressing the significant potential as well as challenges PE is facing in this unique but volatile market. Join local and regional private equity leaders to debate whether Indonesia is still THE hot market in Southeast Asia and how deal activity can be increased over the next 12 months. NEW speakers just confirmed include: Wilson Cuaca Hian Goh Partner Founding Partner EAST VENTURES NSI VENTURES Ming Maa William Tanuwijaya Investment Analyst Co-Founder and CEO SOFTBANK TOKOPEDIA 2014 DELEGATE COMPOSITION Attended by 40+ limited partners 30+ speakers Over 170 participants from 12 countries from Indonesia and overseas and more than 110 companies BY TYPE OF COMPANY BY TITLE BY COUNTRY Chairman / CEO / Managing Director / Europe and U.S., 2% Limited Partners, General Partners, Managing Partner, 12% Partner / COO, 37% Indonesia, 44% 26% 29% Others - Asia, 6% Hong Kong, 12% Others LPs GPs Principal / (Association, VP / Associate, Gov't, etc.), 5% 30% Investment Banks, 5% Corporates, 10% Professional Director / Chief Singapore & Services, 25% Representative, 21% Malaysia, 36% Registration: Yeni Kittrell T: +852 3411 4836 E: [email protected] Sponsorship: Anil Nathani T: +852 3411 4938 E: [email protected] Enquiry Scan this QR code with Join your peers your phone to access the avcjindonesia.com #avcjindonesia event website 4th Annual Private Equity & Venture Forum EDITOR’S VIEWPOINT Indonesia 2015 [email protected] 24 March, Grand Hyatt Jakarta Managing Editor Tim Burroughs (852) 3411 4909 Staff Writers Andrew Woodman (852) 3411 4852 PE adapts to the Winnie Liu (852) 3411 4907 Creative Director Dicky Tang Designers Catherine Chau, Edith Leung, Mansfield Hor, Tony Chow new normal Senior Research Manager Helen Lee Research Associates CHINA’S ECONOMY GREW AT ITS SLOWEST its own ecosystem. There is now not only a Herbert Yum, Jason Chong, GLOBAL PERSPECTIVE, LOCAL OPPORTUNITY avcjindonesia.com Kaho Mak SIGN UP pace in 24 years in 2014 with GDP expanding healthy mix of international and local funds by 7.3%. Most economists regard the current but also a diversified blend of funds targeting Senior Marketing Manager ANDNOW! Sally Yip situation as a symptom of a “new normal” as different investment themes from early-stage Volatility, Opportunities and Jokonomics: Circulation Administrator US$200 China continues its transition from the world’s angel funds to turnaround funds. The country Prudence Lau (until 6 FEB only)SAVE A new landscape for PE factory to the world’s most attractive nascent is also spawning its own strain of LPs as Subscription Sales Executive consumer market. Indeed, most PE industry insurance companies slowly enter the fray. Jade Chan We are delighted to bring your attention to the NEW speakers already confirmed for the professionals envisage no detrimental impact on • Chinese corporations are also embracing PE 4th Annual AVCJ Indonesia Forum. Manager, Delegate Sales their pace of investment. and VC as competitors and partners. It is used Pauline Chen Taking place on 24 March 2015 in Jakarta, this year’s agenda will adopt a lively and interactive Private equity in China certainly enjoyed a to be that Chinese companies were either Director, Business Development format, addressing the significant potential as well as challenges PE is facing in this unique but more bountiful 2014 than the economy as a funded by PE or purchase exiting portfolio Darryl Mag volatile market. Join local and regional private equity leaders to debate whether Indonesia is still whole. Assets under management blew past the companies. Now we see companies creating Manager, Business Development THE hot market in Southeast Asia and how deal activity can be increased over the next 12 months. $200 billion mark as Chinese GPs added another their own venture divisions. Anil Nathani, Samuel Lau $25 billion of fresh capital. • Exits are on the rise, or at least they are in Sales Coordinator In terms of investment, AVCJ Research has certain areas. The bumper Alibaba Group IPO Debbie Koo NEW speakers just confirmed include: records of 743 deals worth more than $34 is representative of the massive demand for billion, a near $14 billion gain on 2013. These VC investments in the country. The success of Conference Managers Wilson Cuaca Hian Goh Jonathon Cohen, Sarah Doyle, data exclude capital that Chinese private equity the first and second-generations start-up is Partner Founding Partner Conference Administrator firms invest outside of China. Cross-border deals also spawning a new breed of entrepreneurs Amelie Poon EAST VENTURES NSI VENTURES amounted to $7 billion in 2014. looking to do build their own businesses. Conference Coordinator My sense is that Chinese private equity is These are just a few of the many reasons why Fiona Keung, Jovial Chung healthier today than it was even a few years Chinese private equity will perform under the Ming Maa William Tanuwijaya Publishing Director ago and there are plenty of opportunities for new normal. However, as we all know, challenges Allen Lee Investment Analyst Co-Founder and CEO investors to target. remain and more will undoubtedly emerge. This SOFTBANK TOKOPEDIA • There seems to be less competition from is still a comparatively young market. upstart renminbi-denominated funds run by unqualified opportunists. Sure, a few popping Incisive Media up every now and then, but not at the rate Unit 1401 Devon House, Taikoo Place 2014 DELEGATE COMPOSITION 979 King’s Road, Quarry Bay, that threatens to disrupts the market, as was Allen Lee Hong Kong T. (852) 3411-4900 Attended by 40+ limited partners 30+ speakers Over 170 participants from 12 countries the case a few years back. Publishing Director F. (852) 3411-4999 • The Chinese PE industry is slowly building Asian Venture Capital Journal E. [email protected] from Indonesia and overseas and more than 110 companies URL. avcj.com BY TYPE OF COMPANY BY TITLE BY COUNTRY Beijing Representative Office China PE fundraising and investment No.1-2-(2)-B-A554, 1st Building, Chairman / CEO / Managing Director / Europe and U.S., 2% No.66 Nanshatan, Limited Partners, General Partners, Indonesia, 44% Managing Partner, 12% Partner / COO, 37% 60,000 Chaoyang District, Beijing, 26% 29% Others - Asia, 6% 250,000 People’s Republic of China Hong Kong, T. (86) 10 5869 6203 200,000 F. (86) 10 5869 6205 12% E. [email protected] Others LPs GPs Principal / VP / Associate, 40,000 (Association, 150,000 Gov't, etc.), 5% 30% Investment 100,000 The Publisher reserves all rights herein. Reproduction in whole or Banks, 5% US$ million 20,000 US$ million in part is permitted only with the written consent of Corporates, AVCJ Group Limited. 10% Professional Director / Chief Singapore & 50,000 ISSN 1817-1648 Copyright © 2015 Services, 25% Representative, 21% Malaysia, 36% 0 0 Registration: Yeni Kittrell T: +852 3411 4836 E: [email protected] 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 Sponsorship: Anil Nathani T: +852 3411 4938 E: [email protected] Enquiry Assets under management Investment Fundraising Source: AVCJ Research Scan this QR code with Join your peers your phone to access the event website avcjindonesia.com #avcjindonesia Number 03 | Volume 28 | January 20 2015 | avcj.com 3 NEWS LP warns of potential co- ($6.5 billion) to support start-ups in emerging ASIA PACIFIC industries. The fund – to be managed by several investment bubble professional managers based on open tendering CIC’s Olivia Ouyang joins Co-investment could represent the next bubble process – will target equity investments in early- for global private equity says Erik Hirsch, global stage innovative firms. It will also partner with OTPP CIO for global fund-of-funds Hamilton Lane. He local or leading industry players’ corporate arms Ontario Teachers’ Pension Plan (OTPP) has hired said that while 2014 had been a strong year for on certain deals. Olivia Ouyang, formerly managing director and private equity fundraising globally – with about head of emerging markets at China Investment $486 billion raised, according to Preqin – it still Tiger Global backs P2P Corp. (CIC), as a Hong Kong-based director of fell short of record numbers seen in the years funds and co-investments. Ouyang joined CIC in preceding the global financial crisis. However, lending site Dianrong 2010 and during her time there was responsible he also noted that the asset class had matured Tiger Global Management has invested an for private equity fund, co-investment and direct undisclosed sum in Dianrong.com, a Chinese VC- investments in Europe and emerging markets. backed peer-to-peer (P2P) online lending service platform.
Recommended publications
  • Real Estate Pledge Funds: an Alternative in the Alternative Space
    2013 Real Estate Pledge Funds: An Alternative in the Alternative Space THE CHALLENGING FUND-RAISING ENVIRONMENT of Background and Structure the past few years for the alternative asset market has drawn Pledge funds are often contractual arrangements taking the increasing attention to fund-raising alternatives, including a form of individual “investment” or “participation” agree- revival of interest in “pledge fund” structures.1 Pledge funds, ments between the sponsor and each investor. Pledge funds once more popular as precursors to true blind pool funds, can also be structured as sponsor-managed limited partner- UPDATE fell out of favor during the frothy fund-raising period of the ships or LLCs, with the participating investors admitted as mid-2000s. However, as fund sponsors have seen the fund- limited partners or members. Whether a pledge fund is raising market tighten and investors increase their interest structured as a contractual arrangement or as a partnership in “direct” investments, a market has begun to develop for or another vehicle, a new vehicle would typically be formed pledge funds. These fund structures can present an attrac- to facilitate each investment, admitting only those investors tive midpoint between the direct investment model and a that have opted in to make the investment. Investors that fully committed blind pool, enabling sponsors to have some opted out of the investment are therefore shielded from any amount of certainty in funding their deals and allowing in- exposure resulting from an investment they do not make. vestors to retain discretion over their investment decisions by being able to opt in or opt out on a deal-by-deal basis.
    [Show full text]
  • REBOOT Innovative Twists on Old Ideas
    Baker & McKenzie Global Private Equity REBOOT Innovative twists on old ideas Baker & McKenzie Global Private Equity – Insights 2014 | 1 INSIGHTS 2 | Baker & McKenzie Global Private Equity – Insights 2014 Baker & McKenzie Global Private Equity – Insights 2014 | 3 In this issue... FOREWORD Simon Hughes. Global Chair of Private Equity, Baker & McKenzie. 6 REBIRTH OF OLD IDEAS Abenomics and the Art of Rejuvenation. J-Star’s Gregory R Hara summarises the impact which Abenomics is having on the Japanese PE market. 8 Spain Steps Up. Riverside’s Marcos Llado discusses the re-energising of the Spanish PE market. 12 East Side Story. Mid Europa Partners’ Michelle Capiod on untapped PE potential in CEE. 16 Tracking the Upswing. PwC’s Peter Whelan and James Anderson look at the strong demand for IPO exits by PE houses. 20 The Clean Generation. Sustainable Development Capital’s L. Warren Pimm surmises the coming to age of the renewables sector. 26 AFRICA RISES The Pan-African Investor. Development Partners International’s Runa Alam discusses multi-country African deals. 33 The Regulator. COMESA’s Willard Mwemba discusses the implications of Africa’s attempt at a European Commission. 39 The Country Hopper. Investec’s William Alexander looks at mid-market country-by-country African deals. 43 4 | Baker & McKenzie Global Private Equity – Insights 2014 INNOVATIVE TWISTS Burning Bridges. Increasingly, M&A transactions are being financed directly with high yield bond issuances. 48 I Owe Who? Goldman Sachs’ Denis Coleman shares his thoughts on what 2014 has in store for the leveraged finance market. 52 Easier to Swallow. PwC’s Blaise Jenner on the changes to IFRS regarding consolidating minority investments.
    [Show full text]
  • Leveraged Buyouts, and Mergers & Acquisitions
    Chepakovich valuation model 1 Chepakovich valuation model The Chepakovich valuation model uses the discounted cash flow valuation approach. It was first developed by Alexander Chepakovich in 2000 and perfected in subsequent years. The model was originally designed for valuation of “growth stocks” (ordinary/common shares of companies experiencing high revenue growth rates) and is successfully applied to valuation of high-tech companies, even those that do not generate profit yet. At the same time, it is a general valuation model and can also be applied to no-growth or negative growth companies. In a limiting case, when there is no growth in revenues, the model yields similar (but not the same) valuation result as a regular discounted cash flow to equity model. The key distinguishing feature of the Chepakovich valuation model is separate forecasting of fixed (or quasi-fixed) and variable expenses for the valuated company. The model assumes that fixed expenses will only change at the rate of inflation or other predetermined rate of escalation, while variable expenses are set to be a fixed percentage of revenues (subject to efficiency improvement/degradation in the future – when this can be foreseen). This feature makes possible valuation of start-ups and other high-growth companies on a Example of future financial performance of a currently loss-making but fast-growing fundamental basis, i.e. with company determination of their intrinsic values. Such companies initially have high fixed costs (relative to revenues) and small or negative net income. However, high rate of revenue growth insures that gross profit (defined here as revenues minus variable expenses) will grow rapidly in proportion to fixed expenses.
    [Show full text]
  • Pt1~~'~ Sillman, Joseph Blalk, John Vl- I\Orkmg 36 Hours and the Next Team Now
    Search for school planetarium director continues left for a teachmg pOSitIOn at mechamcal abIlIty, ImagInatIOn of the Community Performmg moo the curricula for elementary, By Margie Reins Smith aren't scheduled for any tIme Macomb CommunIty College He and creatIvIty for development of Arts Center and dedicated on middle and high school students StaN Writer soon - perhaps not until Septem- teaches phySICSand astronomy. programs, and a teachers' certIfi- Oct 27, 1982. Director Tim m Grosse Pomte. Planetariums are supposed to ber The $225,000 bUlldmg,which "It was an excltmg thmg," said Grosse Pomte IShavmg trouble cate. Skomeczny was hired away from Bob Thomson, director of the be dark Not 24 hOUl& a day, how. seats 36 people and features a Robert Welch, director of Secon- findmg another dIrector Accord- ever Not locked up tIght, wIth- SpItz projector and a 24-foot Roosevelt High School m Wyan- mg to VIncent LoCIcero, presI- planetarIUm at Adler Elemen- dotte, which had been forced to dary Curriculum In Grosse out VISltOls,wIthout dllectOl or dome, was constructed With dent of the Grosse Pomte school tary School m Southfield smce It close Its planetanum because of Pomte "I have nothmg but money flom the estate of BenJa board, planetarIum directors are opened m 1968, said he backed students the system's financial troubles praise for what has happened Grosse Pomte's foul and a-half mm Long a rare breed The pOSItIOnIS a mto the pOSitIOn "I taught as SkOnIeczny began an ambItIous there " The publIc school faclhty, one very speCialIzed field, Involvmg tlonomy m OhlO for five years year-old planetanum at NOlth senes of commumty programs The faCIlItywas closed last Au.
    [Show full text]
  • Corporate Morality and Management Buyouts
    Washington and Lee Law Review Volume 41 | Issue 3 Article 6 Summer 6-1-1984 Corporate Morality and Management Buyouts Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarlycommons.law.wlu.edu/wlulr Part of the Business Organizations Law Commons, and the Securities Law Commons Recommended Citation Corporate Morality and Management Buyouts, 41 Wash. & Lee L. Rev. 1015 (1984), https://scholarlycommons.law.wlu.edu/wlulr/vol41/iss3/6 This Note is brought to you for free and open access by the Washington and Lee Law Review at Washington & Lee University School of Law Scholarly Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Washington and Lee Law Review by an authorized editor of Washington & Lee University School of Law Scholarly Commons. For more information, please contact [email protected]. CORPORATE MORALITY AND MANAGEMENT BUYOUTS In response to a perceived opportunity for corporate management to share in the success of their companies,' management groups have been increasingly active in acquiring ownership of public companies through the use of manage- ment buyout transactions.' A management buyout transaction is any process by which the management of a public corporation acquires enough of the cor- poration's outstanding shares to convert the formerly public corporation into a private company. 3 By using the corporation's assets as collateral for loans to finance the buyout, corporate management alone or with other investors can leverage" a buyout of the corporation without risking substantial personal assets.5 Leveraged buyouts, therefore, are particularly attractive to manage- ment as a technique for acquiring significant equity interests in the companies for which they labor.6 In addition to providing management with an attrac- tive method of acquiring corporate ownership, management buyouts frequently result in gains in corporate performance by creating greater incentives for 1.
    [Show full text]
  • The Pe & M&A Quarterly
    JUNE 2020 JUNE 2020 | ISSUE 4 THE PE & M&A QUARTERLY Quarterly News, Trends and Developments Off the Record “The COVID-19 pandemic has adversely affected all sectors in India and across the globe, except a few. Though initially it was expected that the pandemic would end in a few months, it appears that it will continue for a longer period. Many PE firms and strategic investors have paused or deferred or slowed down their investment plans for the next 6 to 8 months. However, there are exceptions in case of a few. The deal making activity in India appears uncertain for the remainder of this year. On the M&A side, domestic deals are being evaluated. It is getting harder to close transactions in view of mismatch in expectations of the seller and buyer. The present situation has forced them to realign their objectives and expectations. In signed deals, material adverse change clauses are being evaluated, and in new deals it is being made as exhaustive as possible to ensure possible exit in case of change in environment. The overall structure of doing deals is going through a change and the focus is shifting to value creation and sustainability. There is a reasonable possibility that towards the end of the year, if we return to some sense of normalcy, there will be a significant increase in M&A and PE activity.” Satish Kishanchandani, Managing Partner FEATURED JUDGEMENT Banyan Tree Growth Capital vs Axiom Cordages Limited and Ors. 1 ISSUE 4 JUNE 2020 LEGAL UPDATES NON-FATF MEMBERS ALLOWED TO REGISTER AS CATEGORY I-FPI SEBI Updates April 07, 2020: The Securities and Exchange Board of India (“SEBI”) has relaxed the rules with respect to SNAPSHOT offshore funds seeking to get registered under the • For all relevant COVID-19 relaxations in “properly regulated” Foreign Portfolio Investor (“FPI”) compliances permitted by SEBI, visit our category.
    [Show full text]
  • The Handbook of Financing Growth
    ffirs.qxd 2/15/05 12:30 PM Page iii The Handbook of Financing Growth Strategies and Capital Structure KENNETH H. MARKS LARRY E. ROBBINS GONZALO FERNÁNDEZ JOHN P. FUNKHOUSER John Wiley & Sons, Inc. ffirs.qxd 2/15/05 12:30 PM Page b ffirs.qxd 2/15/05 12:30 PM Page a Additional Praise For The Handbook of Financing Growth “The authors have compiled a practical guide addressing capital formation of emerging growth and middle-market companies. This handbook is a valuable resource for bankers, accountants, lawyers, and other advisers serving entrepreneurs.” Alfred R. Berkeley Former President, Nasdaq Stock Market “Not sleeping nights worrying about where the capital needed to finance your ambitious growth opportunities is going to come from? Well, here is your answer. This is an outstanding guide to the essential planning, analy- sis, and execution to get the job done successfully. Marks et al. have cre- ated a valuable addition to the literature by laying out the process and providing practical real-world examples. This book is destined to find its way onto the shelves of many businesspeople and should be a valuable ad- dition for students and faculty within the curricula of MBA programs. Read it! It just might save your company’s life.” Dr. William K. Harper President, Arthur D. Little School of Management (Retired) Director, Harper Brush Works and TxF Products “Full of good, realistic, practical advice on the art of raising money and on the unusual people who inhabit the American financial landscape. It is also full of information, gives appropriate warnings, and arises from a strong ethical sense.
    [Show full text]
  • December 2011 Investment Summary
    Marketing, Media, Technology, and Service Industries M&A & December 2011 Investment Summary Expertise. Commitment. Results. TABLE OF CONTENTS Overview of Monthly M&A and Investment Activity 3 Monthly M&A and Investment Activity by Industry Segment 7 Additional Monthly M&A and Investment Activity Data 24 About Petsky Prunier 34 M&A & INVESTMENT SUMMARY DECEMBER 2011 2 MARKETING, MEDIA, TECHNOLOGY, AND SERVICE INDUSTRIES Transaction Distribution • A to ta l of 261 deal s worth approximat el y $10.7 billion were announced in Decemb er 2011 • Digital Media/Commerce was the most active segment with 78 transactions • Software & Information was the highest value segment worth approximately $6 billion • Strategic buyers announced 142 deals for approximately $10.9 billion (54% of total volume) • VC/Growth Capital investors announced 107 deals for approximately $1.3 billion • Buyout investors announced 12 deals for approximately $807 million DECEMBER2011 BUYER/INVESTOR BREAKDOWN Transactions Est. Value Strategic Buyout Venture/Growth Capital # % $MM % # $MM # $MM # $MM Digital Media/Commerce 78 30% 1,816.0 17% 31 818.1 3 431.4 44 566.5 Marketing Technology 66 25% 1,811.3 17% 34 1,557.3 3 50.0 29 204.0 Software & Information 53 20% 5,944.3 56% 32 5,641.5 2 127.6 19 175.2 Agency/Consulting 37 14% 601.5 6% 30 356.4 2 17.2 5 228.0 Digital Advertising 17 7% 136.9 1% 8 91.1 0 0.0 9 45.8 MktiMarketing Servi ces 7 3% 130.4 1% 5 80. 4 1 15. 0 1 35.
    [Show full text]
  • Suppliers, Oems Ride Ups and Downs COMING SOON
    20121119-NEWS--0001-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 11/16/2012 6:14 PM Page 1 ® www.crainsdetroit.com Vol. 28, No. 48 NOVEMBER 19 – 25, 2012 $2 a copy; $59 a year ©Entire contents copyright 2012 by Crain Communications Inc. All rights reserved Page 3 Keeping up with the market: Makeover for Ann Arbor inn Duggan: City on wrong road Survey says: Health care Detroit costs rise, but more slowly Medical Good management, not Detroit Works Center CEO Mike Duggan Seneca Partners split is not yet or EFM, is what Detroit needs creates more VC options a declared candidate BY CHAD HALCOM the state to take over Belle for Detroit CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS Isle Park at a $6 million sav- mayor, but Second Stage Extra he says a If Mike Duggan gets to ings to the city, in part be- turnaround cast his own role as a can- cause it did not adequately ‘is not as far didate in next year’s De- address a cleanup plan for away as it neighborhood city parks. appears.’ troit mayoral race, it would likely be as the He thinks a state-appointed turnaround expert who emergency financial man- thinks the current turn- ager is all wrong for the around strategy isn’t work- city, wouldn’t take such a ing. position if asked, and won’t He opposes the 30-year comment on reports that Logistics firm finds it pays he’s been asked. to move into staffing, lease proposal in September for He finds it “hard to imag- Page 11 ine anything more mishan- dled” than the Detroit Innovation center aims to See Duggan, Page 22 boost small manufacturing, Page 13 VIDEO Mike Duggan on core issues facing Detroit, crainsdetroit.com/duggan Crainsdetroit.com: Come in, look around next week NATHAN SKID/CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS Crain’s Detroit Business is having a holiday open house! Online, that is.
    [Show full text]
  • Dell Undervalued in Sale Process
    Dell Undervalued in Sale Process In Re: Appraisal of Dell, Delaware Chancery Court, Civil Action In November 2012, Wall Street equity research analysts No. 9322-VCL (May 31, 2016) indicated a per share value of $8.50, which was well below the indications of interest. As a result, this prompted the Dell Inc. (“Dell” the “Company,” or the “Respondent”) received Committee to hire Boston Consulting Group (“BCG”) as an written appraisal demands from certain Dell shareholders independent advisor on the Company’s forecasts. KKR then (“Petitioners”) as a result of an allegedly low price for Dell’s pulled out of the competition to acquire the Company, which management buyout (“MBO”). prompted the Committee to reach out to other private equity firms. In early 2013, BCG prepared a base case forecast BACKGROUND assuming $3.3 billion in cost savings from a proposed MBO. In 2012, Dell began to make efforts to prove that its stock was BCG then assessed the likelihood of the cost savings in its worth more than the value determined by the stock market. forecasts with 25% of savings realized (“BCG 25% Case”) and In particular, the Respondent’s CEO marketed the Company in 75% of savings realized (“BCG 75% Case”). BCG concluded the financial media in a “sum of the parts” manner. This was that the BCG 25% Case was the most likely to occur given an attempt to get Dell’s stock price closer to the level from the the Company’s track record of cost-saving initiatives. In the Company’s internal valuations. However, this was not achieved meantime, the effort to reach out to other private equity firms since the Company was not able to meet its aggressive forecast yielded no additional offers.
    [Show full text]
  • NVCA 2021 YEARBOOK Data Provided by Dear Readers
    YEARBOOK Data provided by Credits & Contact National Venture Capital Association NVCA Board of Directors 2020-2021 (NVCA) EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE Washington, DC | San Francisco, CA nvca.org | [email protected] | 202-864-5920 BARRY EGGERS Lightspeed Venture Partners, Venture Forward Chair Washington, DC | San Francisco, CA MICHAEL BROWN Battery Ventures, Chair-Elect ventureforward.org | [email protected] JILL JARRETT Benchmark, Treasurer ANDY SCHWAB 5AM Ventures, Secretary BOBBY FRANKLIN President and CEO PATRICIA NAKACHE Trinity Ventures, At-Large JEFF FARRAH General Counsel EMILY MELTON Threshold Ventures, At-Large JUSTIN FIELD Senior Vice President of Government MOHAMAD MAKHZOUMI NEA, At-Large Affairs MARYAM HAQUE Executive Director, Venture AT-LARGE Forward MICHAEL CHOW Research Director, NVCA and PETER CHUNG Summit Partner Venture Forward DIANE DAYCH Granite Growth Health Partners STEPHANIE VOLK Vice President of Development BYRON DEETER Bessemer Venture Partners RHIANON ANDERSON Programs Director, Venture SCOTT DORSEY High Alpha Forward RYAN DRANT Questa Capital CHARLOTTE SAVERCOOL Senior Director of PATRICK ENRIGHT Longitude Capital Government Affairs STEVE FREDRICK Grotech Ventures MICHELE SOLOMON Director of Administration CHRIS GIRGENTI Pritzker Group Venture Capital DEVIN MILLER Manager of Communications and JOE HOROWITZ Icon Ventures Digital Strategy GEORGE HOYEM In-Q-Tel JASON VITA, Director of Programming and CHARLES HUDSON Precursor Ventures Industry Relations JILL JARRETT Benchmark JONAS MURPHY Manager of Government Affairs
    [Show full text]
  • AIMA-Journal-Edition-126.Pdf
    AIMA JOURNAL Edition 126 |June 2021| aima.org AIMA JOURNAL EDITION 126 Message from AIMA’s CEO 0 4 Jack Inglis Five issues for traditional hedge fund managers to consider 0 when investing in digital assets 6 Simmons & Simmons Contents Central bank digital currencies and Britcoin: 10 Bitcoin’s legacy PwC Do you pass the ESG sniff test? 1 APEX 4 Stronger, smarter, faster: Investor relations moving forward 1 DiligenceVault 8 Operational resilience: Practical steps for building an operationally resilient firm 22 GD Financial Markets Hedge fund managers should reevaluate their approach to 26 side letter management amidst increased scrutiny ACA Group Pledge fund: An à la carte investment programme 3 Allen & Overy 0 Connecting the dots to achieve ‘operational resilience’ 3 Buzzacott 4 The virtues of private debt in a rising rate environment 3 Espresso Capital 8 The Australian middle market direct lending opportunity 4 Epsilon Direct Lending 2 Distressed investing in India: Coming of age 4 Edelweiss Asset Management 6 Developments in Jersey structuring and governance 5 Maples Group 0 Volcker Rule 2.0 is here to stay: Congress refuses to 5 exercise rights under CRA 4 K&L Gates 2 AIMA JOURNAL EDITION 126 Scrutiny due for undue charges 5 8 Clerkin Lynch LLP The way forward: How firms can meet their SFDR 62 obligations with less disruption AQMetrics Leveraging data and AI for innovation in asset 66 management KPMG in Canada Five steps to modernizing information security in a post- 7 Pandemic world 0 PUBLICATION PLAN 2021 SS&C Technologies Alternative investment managers: The brewing war for Q3 Edition 127 75 tech talent Deadline for submission 30th July RSM US Publication 20th Sept Cybersecurity and cyber insurance: The multimillion dollar Please confirm by the 9th July if you 7 ransomware industry and current state of play 8 wish to contribute to the Edition Howden Insurance Brokers 127 of the AIMA Journal.
    [Show full text]