Social Connection and Well-Being During COVID-19
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Chapter 6 Social Connection and Well-Being during COVID-19 Karynna Okabe-Miyamoto & Sonja Lyubomirsky University of California, Riverside World Happiness Report 2021 The COVID-19 pandemic has impacted life shifted due to the pandemic is especially important worldwide. Globally, governments have attempted given its unknown trajectory. Indeed, although to slow the spread of the disease by promoting vaccines are being distributed globally, it is “social distancing” guidelines, including staying at unclear when daily life will revert to pre-pandemic least 6 feet (2 meters) away from anyone outside times, given the persistence of spikes in cases one’s household.1 Early in the implementation of worldwide. Furthermore, published literature social distancing, the World Health Organization reviews about past pandemics have revealed that (WHO) announced that the term “physical quarantining or separating those who may be distancing” better captured the essence of the infected to minimize the spread of a disease leads guidelines, such that people should remain to long-lasting negative psychological effects—a physically but not socially distant from others.2 finding that is important to keep in mind as the The same recommendation was independently pandemic continues.7 Accordingly, the goal of this decided by the (World Happiness Report Editors) chapter is to advance understanding of how the on the same day, at the March 20 virtual launch of COVID-19 pandemic has impacted overall well- World Happiness Report (WHR) 2020. Although being and social connection across the globe by the term “social distancing” continues to be reviewing relevant research published in 2020. widely used (including within peer-reviewed journals), because the topic of this chapter is about maintaining connections while distancing, Psychological well-being we adopt the WHO and WHR recommendation during COVID-19 to use “physical distancing.” The negative psychological impact of COVID-19 Physical separation curtails the spread of the has been observed across the world. In a virus, yet the practice of physical distancing U.S. study examining people’s experiences inherently limits people’s in-person social from January 2020 (N = 1,010) to June 2020 interactions, which may narrow their sense of (N = 3,020), reports of happiness and life social connection.3 The reduction in the physical satisfaction saw one of the largest declines during availability of social connections is concerning, as the pandemic, along with mental and physical over a century of research has proven how crucial health, together with more modest declines in social connection is for well-being.4 Aware of the meaning in life and overall flourishing.8 In a study potential negative consequences to well-being that followed about 2,000 respondents in the U.K. posed by COVID-19 and its sequelae, researchers from June 2019 to June 2020, researchers found in the social, behavioral, and clinical sciences have that positive emotions (i.e., happy, energetic, published urgent calls for action to mitigate the inspired, optimistic, and content) became less disease’s potential harms.5 One noteworthy and prevalent and some negative emotions (i.e., sad, particularly relevant potential harm discussed by stressed, scared, frustrated) worsened during the these researchers is the possible increase in social initial outbreak in March, but most eventually isolation and strife in intimate relationships, which recovered to pre-pandemic levels during the can be exacerbated by the many sources of stress lockdown in May.9 Interestingly, other negative (social, financial, health, etc.) associated with emotional states actually declined (i.e., loneliness, the pandemic. However, it is important to note apathy) or remained stable (i.e., boredom) during that physical distancing—which permits social the month of the outbreak but began rising as interaction with housemates, digital interactions the lockdown progressed. with the outside world, and is imposed on entire Although the negative psychological impact of regions, not solitary individuals—is not the same the COVID-19 pandemic is readily apparent, some as social isolation.6 people are doing surprisingly well. In France, As such, COVID-19 has imposed a myriad of researchers surveyed participants three times consequences for health and well-being globally. between April 1 and May 6, 2020, and found that Understanding how and why well-being has these respondents, especially those who had low 133 World Happiness Report 2021 exposure to the disease, reported increases in Protective factors for positive well-being health and well-being during the quarantine, Psychological Characteristics. First, a number of regardless of income level.10 Other research found psychological characteristics, such as extraversion, no change in life satisfaction from before to grit, gratitude, and resilience, have been shown during the pandemic. In a sample of adults mostly to be protective factors for well-being during from the U.S. and U.K. (N = 336), respondents COVID-19. reported no changes to their life satisfaction from Personality. Some researchers have investigated mid-February to late May 2020.11 the role that personality may play in protecting people’s well-being during the pandemic. A Protective factors and risk factors snowball sampling study that included 516 U.S. adults who responded to a survey between April for positive and negative well-being and June 2020 demonstrated that extraversion In light of the growing research on the pandemic, was negatively associated with distancing, while particular patterns have emerged about who is conscientiousness, agreeableness, and neuroticism faring better or worse. Here we outline several were positively related to distancing.12 However, protective factors and risk factors for positive as distancing behavior increased, extraversion and negative well-being during COVID-19 (see was related to more positive affect, less negative Figure 6.1). affect, and greater life satisfaction. This pattern Figure 6.1: Psychological well-being during COVID-19 PROTECTIVE FACTORS RISK FACTORS Positive psychological characteristics: Intolerance for uncertainty Gratitude, resilience, grit, flow Pre-existing mental health conditions: Personality: Extraversion Clinical diagnosis of depression, anxiety, & others Psychological Quality of relationships Engaging in distancing Connectedness, positivity resonance Quality of relationships: Loneliness, poor social support, abuse Quantity of relationships: Larger social networks Types of relationships: Social Parent, child Prosocial behavior Social media use Social media use Daily activities: Online news sources: Physical activity, time outdoors Consulting more sources, more time spent consulting sources Time Use Demographic factors: Demographic factors: Older age Disease risk factors, occupation type Vulnerable groups: Financial insecurity, food insecurity, Circumstantial lower SES 134 World Happiness Report 2021 of results may be accounted for by extraverts satisfaction, while increases in loneliness were engaging in relatively more online social activities, associated with decreases in life satisfaction.16 such as virtual chatting. Thus, having an extraverted Furthermore, a survey of 1,059 participants in personality appears to serve as a unique protective the U.S. (in April and May 2020 for community- factor for individuals’ well-being during COVID-19. dwelling adults and in March and April 2020 for Positive Psychological Characteristics. Research undergraduates) found that positivity resonance, also suggests that several positive psychological or shared feelings of positivity and caring for characteristics may protect well-being, broadly another, explained the relationship between trait defined, during the pandemic. For example, in a resilience and better mental health during the cross-sectional study of 878 community-dwelling pandemic.17 Similarly, researchers have found that older adults (60 to 80 years old) in Spain surveyed higher levels of relatedness (i.e., connectedness) three weeks after lockdown instructions, the three during COVID-19 were associated with greater variables that showed significant associations well-being.18 The same research team conducted a with personal growth and purpose in life were single-timepoint intervention study of 215 MTurk gratitude, resilience, and good family functioning.13 workers, aimed at increasing psychological needs. Accordingly, although older adults are at a higher In this study, the sense of relatedness mediated risk for contracting COVID-19, those with psycho- the relationship between the psychological needs logical resources appear to be buffered from intervention (i.e., asking participants to provide declines in personal growth or purpose in life, instances when they felt a sense of autonomy, regardless of whether they are “young-old” competence, and relatedness during the pandemic) (60 to 70) or “old-old” (71 to 80). and mental well-being. Similarly, a study following 86 undergraduates Quantity of Social Relationships. In addition from before their university’s campus closure to the quality of one’s social relationships, the (January 27 to March 10, 2020) to the end of the number of relationships people have access to semester (April 30 to May 20, 2020) found that during COVID-19 has also been related to well- gratitude and grit were associated with greater being. In a study of 902 Austrians surveyed once well-being, while grit was also associated with in late April 2020, researchers