IN THE SUPREME COURT OF OHIO
Charles E. Wilson et al.,
Relators, Case No. 2012-0019
V.
Governor John Kasich et al.,
Respondents.
Appendix of Exhibits to Affidavit of Lloyd Pierre-Louis
VOLUME 1 of 2
Lloyd Pierre-Louis (Bar # 0068086) WespBarwell/Pierre-Louis Co., LLC 6400 Riverside Drive, Suite D Dublin, OH 43017 Phone: (614) 341-7576 ext. 4 Fax: (614) 388-5693 [email protected]
Counsel for Relators CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
A copy of the foregoing was served via e-mail and regular U.S. Mail this 17`t' day of
January 2012, upon the following:
Aaron Epstein Richard Coglianese Pearl Chin Jeannine R. Lesperance Assistant Attorneys General Constitutional Offices Ohio Attorney General 30 East Broad Street, 14th Floor Columbus, Ohio 43215 aaron.epstein ohioattornev eneral.gov Jeannine.Lesperance ,OhioAttorneyGeneral.gov richard.co lianese ,ohioattorneyg e neral.g o nearl.chin ,ohioattomeyg e neral.gov
Counselfor State Respondents
Mark Braden Robert Tucker Baker Hostetler 65 E. State Street, Suite 2100 Columbus, Ohio 43215 mbraden^a^,bakerlaw.com [email protected]
Special Counselfor State Respondents
Lloyd Pierre-Louis (Bar # 0068086) Wesp/Barwell/Pierre-Louis Co., LLC
Counsel for Relators
2 Table of Contents for Appendix of Exhibits to Affidavit of Lloyd Pierre-Louis
1 2011 06 02 Braden Schedule of Meetings with All Republican LPL 000001 Apportionment Board Members 2011 07 01 Ernail from DiRossi to Mann about meeting witb 2 LPL 000002 Braden and all Republican members of Apportionment Board 3 2011 07 01 Email from Mann to IIansen re redistricting meetings LPL 000003 - 000004 4 2011 07 01 Email from Mann to Rench re redistricting meetings LPL 000005 - 000008 5 2011 07 01 Email from Mann to Rench re redistricting meetings LPL 000009 - 000010
6 2011 07 01 Email from Morrison to Mann re redistricting, attaches LPL 000011 - 000013 t4vo maps 7 2011 07 05 Email from DiRossi to Mann about saheduling meeting LPL000014 - 000018 with Governor's staff 8 2011 07 05Emai1 fiom jody@ to Flasher et al. re Time sensitive LPL 000019 - 000020 issue for OHROC RSCC - Apportionment data 9 2011 07 05 Email from Mann to DiRossi re redistricting meetings LPL 000021 - 000023 10 2011 07 05 Email from Mann to Rench re redistricting meeting LPL 000024 - 000027
11 2011 07 05 Email from Mann to LenzoF W Time sensitive issue LPL 000028 - 000029 for OHROC RSCC - Apportionment data 12 2011 07 05 Email from Mann to Rench re redistricting meetings LPL 000030 - 000034
13 2011 07 07 Braden Schedule of Meetings with All Republican LPL 000035 - 000036 Apportionment Board Members and list of staff
14 2011 07 07 Email from DiRossi to Schuler re 2011-07-07 LPL 000037 - 000038 Announcement of Redistricting Subcommittee Hearings (DRAF "T)
15 2011 07 07 Mann Calendar entry for meeting with Auditor and LPL 000039 staff from other members 2011 07 07 Mann Calendar entry for meeting with Governor's 16 LPL 000040 staff and staff from other members
17 2011 07 07 Mann Calendar entriy for meeting with Secretary of LPL 000041 State and staff from other members 2011 07 08 Email from Mann to Crrodhaus re Reappor-tionment 18 Board Document (attaches Reapportionment History and LPL 000042 - 000078 Template.doc) 2011 07 08 Email from Mann to Hansen et al. re Ohio Deviation 19 LPL 000079 - 000138 Charts and Maps (attaches Redistricting Handbook wlvoter data)
20 2011 07 08 Email from Mann to Huffman re Ohio deviation charts LPL 000139 and maps
21 2011 07 08 Email from Mann to Rinehart re Ohio deviation charts LPL 000140 and inaps 22 2011 07 10 Email from Benson to DiRossi et aI. re Ohio LPL 000141- 000142 Apportionment and Redistricting political data
23 2011 07 11 Einail from Adams to Mann re Request for written LPL 000143 - 000144 confirmation of home address 24 2011 07 11 Email from DiRossi to Mann re GeoCode efforts LPL 000145 - 000146 25 2011 07 11 Email from Mann to Borges (about Ohio deviation LPL 000 147 - 000149 charts and maps)
26 2011 07 11 Emailfrom Mann to Yoho re Incumbent Home LPL 000150 - 000156 Precincts.xls 27 2011 07 12 Email from Moirow to Mann re Guestroom quote LPL 000157
28 2011 07 12 Email from Seaburn to Mann re Tax exemption LPL 000158 certificate for Doubletree 29 2011 07 13 Einail between Heather Mann, Halle Pelger, and Ray LPL 000 159 - 000162 DiRossi setting up meeting 30 2011 07 14 Email from Mann to Boor re Double tree suites LPL 000163 - 000165 2011 07 14 Email from Mami to Grodhaus re 2 week deadlineto 31 notice apportion board, transmits 2001 Reapportionment History LPL 000166 and Template
32 2011 07 14 Letter from Troy Judy and Schuler to Flanders re LPL 000 167 - 000168 Double Tree invoice
33 2011 07 17 Email from Maag to Mann re Member Home LPL 000169 Addresses - Needed by COB Monday 34 2011 07 17 Email from Mann to Lenzo and others about revising LPL 000170 - 000187 rLiles per previous meeting
35 2011 07 ] 8 Email from Hall to Mann re Member Home Addresses LPL 000 187 - 000189 - Need by COB Monday 36 2011 07 24 Email fi-om DiRossi to Mann re Dear John doe LPL 000 189 - 000192 37 2011 07 24 Email from Mann to DiRossi re Dear John doc LPL 000193 - 000195
38 2011 07 24 Email from Mann to DiRossi re Master Redistricting LPL 000196 Database 34 2011 07 24 Email from Mann to staff of redistricting committee LPL 000197 (GOP only) re documents for staff meeting
40 2011 07 25 Email from Mann to Grodliaus re Apportionment LPL 000798 board schedule 41 2011 07 25 Email from Rench to Mann re Debrief for Beth LPL 000199
42 2011 07 27 Email from Mann to Lenzo, Troy, Grodhaus and LPL 000200 DiRossi (about when to share rules with Deinocrats)
43 2011 07 28 Email from Grodhaus to Mann approving sharing LPL 000201 information with Democratic members
-2- 44 2011 07 28 Email from Mann to Lenzo, Grodhaus,DiRossi and LPL 000202 Bairon re Setting up official contact information
45 2011 07 28 Email from Mann to Lloyd re Task force address & LPL 000203 authorized persons
46 2011 07 29 Email from Mann to Barron and others following up LPL 000204 - 000205 on meeting the week before 47 2011 07 31 Email from DiRossi to Yoho re House Seats by Index LPL 000206 - 000209 48 2011 07 31 Email from Mann to Yoho transmitting house4- LPL 000210 - 000216 chb.xlsx
49 2011 08 01 Email from Mann to Grodhaus and others re sign off LPL 000217 and misc (about whether to share rules with Democrats)
50 2011 08 01 Email from Mann to Yoho et al. transmitting LPL 000218 - 000224 house4chb.xlsx
51 2011 08 02 Email from Lejizo to Mann re Apportionment Board LPL 000225 - 000228 Public Records Policy 52 2011 08 02 Email from Schuler to DiRossi (about 3 chiefs at LPL 000229 bunker visit) 53 2011 08 03 Email from Boston to Lenzo, Dittoe, Mann and LPL 000230 - 000232 Kraemer re Redistricting press release
54 2011 08 03 Email from Mann to Pelger, Barron and Augsburger LPL 000233 -000240 (about apportionment board meeting script) 55 2011 08-04 Apportionment Board Meeting Script LPL 000240 - 000246
56 2011 08 04 Einail from Grodhaus to Mann re 2011-08-04 LPL 000247 appointment board meetingscript
57 2011 08 04 Email from Mann to Augsburger re Documents for LPL 000248 - 000249 tomorrow 58 2011 08 04 Email from Morefield to DiRossi re Plotter LPL 000250
59 2011 08 05 Email from Augsburger to Mann and DiRossi re LPL 000251 (David Yost) 60 2011 08 08 Email from Mann to Benson (about index) LPL 000252 - 000259 61 2011 08 08 Email from Mann to Yoho re Copy of house aug08 chb LPL 000260 - 000268 62 2011 08 08 Email from Mann to Yoho re Maptitude LPL 000269 - 000271
63 2011 08 09 Ernail from Augsburger to Mann re Request for LPL 000272 - 000273 Allocation 64 2011 08 09 Email from David Potts to Brenda Rinehart re August LPL 000274 meetings for Franklin County map outside of public meetings
65 2011 08 12 Email from Griffin to Grodhaus noting that Grodhaus LPL 000275 - 000277 was Governor's official designee on Apportionment Board
66 2011 08 15 Email from DiRossi to Schuler re Menu of redistricting LPL 000278
-3- items for Niehaus
67 2011 08 16 Email from DiRossi to Schuler noting Troy and Matt LPL 000279 as House and Senate Designees
68 2011 08 17 Email from Lisa Griffin noting Apportionment Board LPL 000280 - 000282 designees
69 2011 08 18 Email from DiRossi to Mann transmitting edits to LPL 000283 - 000286 2011-08 Regional Hearings Script 70 2011 08 19 Email from Augsburger to DiRossi scheduling meeting LPL 000287 71 2011 08 20 Email from Mann to Schuler re Meetings LPL 000288 --000289 72 2011 08 20 Email from Mann to Troy re meetiugs LPL 000290 73 2011 08 22 Email from DiRossi to Auman re Blade article LPL 000291
74 2011 08 22 Email from DiRossi to Mann (inquiring about LPL 000292 - 000293 handouts) 2011 08 23 Email from Hawley to Mann Fwd On behalf of 75 [email protected] My Ohio House Districts LPL 000294 - 000295 from Empty Plan 1 2011 08 23 Email from Hawley to Mann re Fwd On behalf of 76 [email protected]:OH.US My Ohio House Districts LPL 000296 from Einpty Plan I
77 2011 08 23 Roll call sheet showing Grodhaus and Pelger as LPL 000297 official designees on Apportionment Board 2011 08 24 Email from Hawley to Mann re On behalf of 78 [email protected] My Ohio House Districts LPL 000298 - 000299 from Empty Plan I 74 2011 08 26 Public hearing - quote by Husted about illegality of LPL 000300 - 000301 secret meetings 80 2011 08 29 DiRossi Calendar Entry for meeting with Auditor Yost LPL 000302
81 2011 08 29 DiRossi Calendar Entry for meeting with Senator LPL 000303 Niehaus
82 2011 08 29 Email from DiRossi to Mann re Meeting with Ray and LPL 000304 Heather 83 2011 08 29 Mann Calendar Entry for meeting with Auditor Yost LPL 000305 and Troy
84 2011 08 30 Email from Mann to DiRossi re Lucas and LPL 000306 - 000309 Montgomery county request 2011 08 30 Email from Nlann to DiRossi re McGregor comments 85 LPL 000310 in DDN - "someone didn ' t get the menio" 86 2011 09 01 Email from DiRossi to Mann re FW 12-0901-0130- LPL 000311 mapO
-4- 87 2011 09 02 Email from Yoho to Mann re OH RBV LPL 000312 - 0003 13
88 2011 09 04 Email from DiRossi to Troy re Appartionment Plan LPL 000314 countdown
89 2011 09 05 Email from DiRossi to Licursi (discusses Bacon results LPL 000315 in Bexley and Whitehall) 90 2011 09 05 Email from Law to DiRossi re 32nd district LPL 000316 - 000317
91 2011 09 06 Calendar Item Weekly Redistricting Meeting with LPI, 000318 attendees 92 2011 09 06 Calendar entrv frorn Auditor Yost's calendar showing LPL 000319 meeting with DiRossi and Mann 93 2011 09 06 DiRossi Calendar Entry for meeting with Auditor Yost LPL 000320 44 2011 09 06 DiRossi Calendar Entry for meeting with Senator LPL 000321 Niehaus 95 2011 09 06 Email from Bensen to Yoho re OH RBV LPL 000322 - 000325 96 2011 09 08 Email from Carey to Mann re 93rd district LPL 000326
97 2011 09 08 Email from Mann to DiRossi re Summit County LPL 000327 - 000329 Pairing Options.xlsx
98 2011 09 12 Email from Augsburger to Rinehart about meeting in LPL 000330 usual place with Apportionment Board staff 99 201109 13 Email from Mann to Troy re House dems pull support LPL 000331 from May primary bill over redistrictuig 100 2011 09 13 Email from Watff to Mann re Meetinig Request LPL 000332 -00334
101 201109 14 DiRossi Calendar Entiy for meeting with Senator LPL 000335 Niehaus 102 2011 09 15 DiRossi Calendar Entry for meeting with Auditor Yost LPL 000336
103 2011 09 15 DiRossi Calendar Entry for meeting with Senator LPL 000337 Niehaus
104 2011 09 16 DiRossi Calendar Entry for meeting with Senator LPL 000338 Niehaus and Speaker Batchelder 105 2011 09 16 Email from Baker to Man re District Map LPL 000339
106 2011 09 16 Email from DiRossi to Schuler and Flasher re House LPL 000340 - 000341 seat in the 13th district 107 2011 09 16 Email from Smith to Mann re Weekly redistricting LPL 000342 meeting 108 2011 09 16 Email from Yoho to Dittoe re More Geocodes LPL 000343 - 000344
109 2011 09 17 Email from Mann to DiRossi re MASTER DISTRICT LPL 000345 - 000347 FILES.xIs 110 2011 09 18 Email from Mann to Troy 11 et a]. re Index Analysis of LPL 000348 Proposed Districts
-5- ,. .. m _ ^®_ m _ 2011 09 19 DiRossi Calendar Entry for meeting with Secretary of 11 I LPL 000349 State
112 2011 09 19 Nlann Calendar Entiy for nieeting with Secretary LPL 000350 Husted at the bunker
113 2011 09 20 Email from Mann to others noting that the Board had v000351- 000352 internally decidecl to pass plan on Sept. 28
114 2011 09 20 Mann Calendar Entry for meeting with Carle, Lenzo, LPL 000353 Judy, and Schuler
115 2011 09 21 Email from Page to DiRossi (requesting Sen Manning LPL 000354 meeting location)
116 2011 09 22 Email from DiRossi to Schuler, Troy, Dittoe, Barron, LPL 000355 - 000356 Lenzo and McClelland re Plan roll out toinorrow
117 2011 09 22 Email from Dittoe to Mann re Darnsehroder McLean LPL 000357 - 000359 numbers
118 2011 09 22 Email from Mann to DiRossi transmitting 2011-09-26 LPL 000360 - 000361 Apportion Plan Sponsor Testimony.docx
119 2011 09 22 Email from Mann to °Troy re Damschroder McLean LPL 000362 - 000366 numbers
120 2011 09 22 Letter from Rep Bill Hayes to Batchelder re new LPL 000367 - 000369 proposed FID 72 map
121 2011 09 23 Email from Mann to Troy (about member calls LPL 000370 received)
122 2011 09 23 Email from Jacobson to DiRossi re fix for Balderson LPL 000371- 000372 Hottinger
123 2011 09 23 Email from DiRossi to Iiughes (about looking for new LPL 000373 honie)
124 2011 09 23 Email from DiRossi to Sen Jim Hughes re location of LPL 000374 Columbus Ward 70
125 2011 09 23 Email from Dittoe to Mann re Proposed maps for LPL 000375 - 000376 legislative reapportionment 126 2011 09 23 Email from Fiore to DiRossi re (Licking County) LPL 000377 - 000378
127 2011 09 23 Email from Jacobson to DiRossi re fix for Balderson LPL 000379 Hottinger 128 2011 09 23 Email from Mann to Cortez re Rep. Hqlhngton LPL 000380 from Mann to Grossman transmitting mann- 129 2011 09 23 Email LPL 000381 dirossi-legaldefinition
130 2011 09 24 Email from Augsburger to Potts re number of splits in LPL 000382 - 000383 staff proposal
131 2011 09 24 email from DiRossi to Dittoe et al re The super LPL 000384 - 000385 partisan dernocratic maps
-6- 132 2011 09 24 Email from DiRossi to Lenzo re FYI LPL 000386 2011 09 24 Email from Lenzo to DiRossi, Blessing and Mann re 133 LPL 000387 Pillich comments in Enquirer 2011 09 24 Email from Mann to Schuler re 2011-09-26 134 Apportionment Board Meeting Script (2012 01 10 627 pm Pages LPL 000388- 000397 from Scan001) 2011 09 24 Email from Mann to Schuler, Barron, Augsburger, 135 Pelger, Lenzo, Troy and Grodhaus re Apportionment board LPi, 000398 -000407 meeting script
136 2011 09 24 email from Ray DiRossi to various staff and gop staff LPL 000408 - 000409 re the super partisian democratic map 2011 09 25 Email from Augsburger to Potts, Rinehart , Breeze and 137 LPL 000410 - 00041 1 Tanner re Treatment of incumbent African-American members 138 2011 09 25 Email from Griffin to Mann re Minority Excel LPL 000412 - 000414
139 2011 09 25 Email from Mann to Republican Board Members and LPL 000415 - 000420 staff with Plan Comparison and draft questions 140 2011 0925 Email from Mann to Yost re Indexes LPL 000420 - 000425 141 2011 09 26 Apportionment Board Meeting Script LPL 000426 - 000429 142 2011 09 26 Email from DiRossi to Troy J re SE ohio options LPL 000430 - 000431
143 2011 09 26 Email from Henne to Dittoe re Proposed Maps for LPL 000432 Legislative Reapportionment
144 2011 09 26 Email from Mann to Stacy re Franklin county house LPL 000433 - 000434 districts question 145 2011 09 26 Email from Schuler to Mann re Damschroder numbers LPL 000435 - 000436 146 2011 09 26 Slagle testimony before Ohio Apportionment Board 9- 26-11 LPL 000437 - 000440
147 5911 09 27 Email from Johnson to DiRossi re House Districts 58 LPL 000441
2011 09 27 Email from Mann to Frost et al re Angelskin Patton 148 LPL 000442 Demeter Numbers ^g11 09 27'Email from Munroe to DiRossi re House Districts 58 149 LPL 000443
150 2011 09 27 Email from Wagner to Kaiser About Republican LPL 000444 - 000445 Concerns with Hohnes County
151 2011 09 27 Email from Yost to Redistricting re Technical LPL 000446 amendment to joint secretaries plan 152 2011 09 28 Apportionment Board Meeting Script LPL 000447 - 000450
153 2011 09 28 Email from Borgemenke to Damschroder and Pelger re LPL 000451 - 000456 From Lake County Board of Elections Director
-7- _ _ ^. _ _
154 2011 09 28 Email from Lenzo to Mannand DiRossi re 93rd LPL 000457 district 155 2011 09 28 Email from Mann to DiRossi transmitting Suggested LPL 000458 - 000461 Comments for Auditor Yost.docx.
156 2011 09 28 Email from Mann to DiRossi attaching Suggested LPL 000462 - 000465 Comtnents for Auditor Yost.docx
157 2011 09 28 Email from Mann to Troy transmitting SHAPE LPL 000466 FILE.zip
158 2011 09 28 Email from Mann to Yoho re Amendment A to LPL 000467 Secretaries Plan.zip
159 2011 09 28 Email from redistricting to Dittoe, Lenzo, Troy and LPL 000468 Grodhaus re Amendment to joint secretaries plan
160 2011 09 28 Email from Slonaker to Mann, Troy and Lenzo re LPL 000469 Reapportionment 2011 09 29 Email from DiRossi to Schuler re Redistricting and Liz 16t LPL 000470 as acting chief of staff 2011 09 29 Email from Mann to DiRossi re Amended with 162 Comments - transmitting 2011-09-30 Apportionment Board LPL 000471 - 000473 Meeting Script.doc 163 2011 09 29 Email from Mann to Dittoe et al re Indexes.xlsx LPL 000474 - 000478
164 2011 09 29 Email from Thatcher to Mann re Legal Definition LPL 000479 - 000480 revision 165 2011 09 30 Apportionmett Board Meeting Script LPL 000481 - 000483 166 2011 09 30 Email from DiRossi to Mann re After todays hearing LPL 000484 - 000486
167 2011 10 01 Email from Lenzo to Troy, Hawley, Dittoe, Yoho and LPL 000487 Mann re PD comment on emergency apportionment board meeting
168 2011 10 03 Email from Mann to Lenzo and DiRossi re LPL 000488 Reapportionment 169 2011 10 05 Email from Mann to Hall re District 70 LPL 000489 - 000490
170 2011 10 05 Email from Schneck to Dittoe re Carey column for LPL 000491 - 000493 review 171 2011 10 18 Email from Pelger to Potts re Thank You LPL 000494 172 Appor-tionment Board Hearing Transcript Aug 4, 2011 LPL 000495 - 000525 173 Apportionment Board Hearing Transcript Sept 26 2011 LPL 000526 - 000630 174 Apportionment Board Hearing Transcript Sept 28 2017 LPL 000631 - 000682 175 Apportionment Board Hearing Transcript Sept 30 2011 LPL 000683 - 000695 176 Auditor notes from Columbus public hearing LPL 000696 - 000697
177 Augsburger Calendar entries showing weekly redistricting LPL 000698 meetings
-8- 178 1 Cutting Butler, Mongomery and Franklin Counties LPL 000699 -000701
Handwritten comments by Auditor or staff re Mann-DiRossi map 179 2 LPL 000702 - 000703 180 Handwritten comments by Auditor or staff re Mann-DiRossi map LPL 000704 - 000709 181 Handwritten notes by Auditor or staff LPL 000710 - 000712
182 Mann Calendar Appointments Related to Redistricting (dated LPL 000713 -000735 2011 08 18 through 2011 10 07) 183 N1ann Calendar Entry for Weekly Redistricting Meetings LPL 000736 184 Ohio State Senate and State Flouse Districting Maps from 2010 LPL 000737 -000738 185 DiRossi records on splits, population, and NI-IBVAP LPL 000739 - 00752 186 Political Indices pulled from DiRossi Apportionment Records LPL 000753 - 000774 187 Undated 2011 Proposed House Indexes produced by Chad Hawley LPL 000775 - 000782 188 Undated 2011 Proposed Senate Indexes produced by Chad Hawley LPL 000783 - 000786 189 Undated Alternative Map Configurations from Troy Judy Records LPL 000787 - 000794 190 Undated Analysis of Alternative Map Configurations LPL 000795 - 000810 191 Undated Analysis of Alternative Map Configurations2 I LPL 000811 - 000827 192 Undated Analysis of Splits in Final House and Senate Plans LPL 000828 - 000830
193 Undated Meeting Cancellation Referring to Big 3 Meeting on LPL 000831 Redistricting
194 Undated Meeting Invitation to Weekly Redistricting Meetings and LPL 000832 - 000833 Showing Attendees PROPOSED AGENDA FOR MARK BRADEN VISIT THURSDAY, JUNE 2,2011
9AM - 9:30AM Redistricting data presentation by Dr. Salling to House & House Majority Caucus Room Senate Leadership, Governor Kasich (or designee), Auditor 15`h Floor Riffe Building Yost (or designee), Secretary Husted (or designee), Mark Braden, and staff TBD
9:45AM - 10:30AM Overview of apportionment process and discussion with Mr. House Majority Caucus Room Braden as Counsel to Legislative Task Force with Governor 151h Floor Riffe Building Kasich (or designee), Auditor Yost (or designee), Secretary Husted (or designee), Mark Braden and staff TBD
I 1 AM - 12PM Meeting with Attorney General staff (Mary Mertz & Michael Speaker's Conference Room Hall), Speaker Batchelder, and staff TBD 14'h Floor Riffe Building
12:00PM - 1:00PM Lunch with Mark Braden, Members, and Staff TBD TBD
1:00PM - 5:00PM Hold for meetings with Staff, Members, etc. TBD
LPL 000001 Heather Mann
From: Ray DiRossi [[email protected]] Sent: Friday, July 01, 2011 9:37 PM To: [email protected] Subject: Re: Meeting with Auditor Yost & Mark Braden ok - good clarification
On Fri, ]ul 1, 2011 at 9:34 PM, Heather Mann
» » » > >
1
LPL 000002 , HeAth
ings
77 ar;utF$ t3i jY ;$trs GalumbusPRrio 4: (^1^}} d66=^^^^ - ^7F
day are kiest in t.he aiter
er next is best!
bear 8etfi:
LPL 000003 ^,U^CQ41?ii9^ kl^f L^C^ ^'^5314^^'SBIS6^ I Ff#y, IA y?^^ ap';t t3^}^r ^+ilk 7 ^ttd fi1d^ la
it ^wretitEr^taj f h#se,d^y,s. ^tlg^it ^bw th ntJ.'Pie
Schuterand Tresy-lud} aFrrrot^eoirg lip iC tptizar your desfgnQe puldbe, pFesor"at. s wP- oo udok
H^ot^er
Re,. ,_ .. I^c^t^se J Obiiz H6t ^77 SruftS Mi0h wfreef; l4t# EE 4^otuttbus, ohiio 4$2 0,9 4} 4t384194 _ {ti4,} ^^9-359tt -, rox (614) ;M-5$19° s21iet,rhah^
TfrG iF&orma3MM,m bwfrd^^ni17I aLtapr04Yv g^SpG4(sAtr1P; §4 ^^9VCf?K Yb- ^i'f^ t!+$tt0[. jNE^..°C'* (SOU
LPL 000004 er N, iMartn '[-:^E 1ottf lq UtfpGMf +
tar:i^f"pres jg`h 5 1mtf? F ibt5vr, C7hiFs 43215 '^^^ 456-9.1 94= t7ifiioe ?6142;759-3594:'° F-ig {614}36'WQ -Ceil ^a€her.^riaiin(c^c^^rr^#^fe e^t^.[s^
,- aufy n 20:
HeA#hsrhl, 1flaPM,E RedistiicGirsqD"G;taf RA l.2ep F.."at Ropubl cara MWcus ousa^ of RepresentgbV?.s: ib Hdg?t Strept 14th F'#oar bus. QWa4329'6 486-91-94 - C}ffic,O 19-3594 : Fax 9-Cetl
i LPL 000005 ThaYik-`{CStIF i4eather Ma€itt
Na'432t 94: r 0#}e2 34 -FaX=
'7r'ie'srmirmattai? nIY FPF thE JeEUi irye En6i$l80{Bj `s^cA*ik+a5rot79E^ ^Fnt ie 4p( eaosi( iia3r,^nt, Sd
e ^arde:[YYt 3vly {71r 21 aiehei
ly 14' Dand;9;30 am? S,ent. FCaaY'r 3utgr 01, 1011 11^ 12 1°is '^Ie^9^rer,l^a^zn(sa3st afI,t ^G; ^rtki9iaits, ^idchr3et Subjeo^jz Re: redistrie,tir+g Meetini
T,he Gay^.r.^ierr t^ out nf towfi Oekt fvSs r^^n;Th^rsd^y,is 4iesE
F na#ty,?rd
Thanks F{dotti
p ori a.ec}nversaktoh'ftoy }ia seavriiow, rk'0taden a monsu{tant crff tkre d"ata/teehri.icat i^rsd of'redisti`icttrig. They . il, io in Colum ay 1Wy7'and? W641sf.itke tn make them avalbbte for en itsdividual ineetiffigWi! t aslhe 6thaf d merr ^ers) cheisedays, Right now theY are b!t}(keiisxff`B'c r staff^`reir^irr^ fl^ar f^st^^sd; iday ning, bUt a$ toiiY.SG we cah move those Ortlt)nd w Plea'5eAdV6seif t1lF!6o i$: a'tikvtW..Adt m
u1eraW7r'i?y rgdt"ttricti" peks; r ybur desiglie 2Ye a }'e aii5ptd wbrk: foP y; p5 sometirhe +sr) i?ti fjlial(Y„ not thaf ytr,u 1#aue e, ab etrffee or Iurje
N.. Mahn;'Esq. t ng t3ir^C^c?r & pop. LegalC Rep.ublican Gaucus use of F?epcesettatives ^Sh #°tigh 1401 Plocit Unrrbtls, Ohib 43245 (614) 466-9194 - bfflw {6S4} 7 i9-3594 - Fax (614) 362-6819 - Gell heather ri3a ii ahr-st3f-- oham c^WtoaNjjtAt=rL^'AQTrF ,4tarnae ia tiiiae-ma`rt is e i3i3(MOt^s€w entiYytn wR ay 4uGrk proauciandlnr aRrd`uab)z iaw, If itte read
LPL 000007 4 LPL 000008 'Htathar
be avoi
Ike Grod€4aos, Matt:Carle ant#i,wat
day are bestii pae
LPL 000009 on i'ioy had inrifh yau Acsc& ohlca A)t #Yal TheY wi amb€3si'-huYSdw auaftmbIe f^r ^r^^€^r3rv ^ual iait eting satithffte § h Ri^t^, rie}r they -aYe h1v'tke4 rzff far s6 ff ^Wr r mt^ve#^^,seai^atafa^LL ^le`^se.as#vrse ^there
ekty statt m" AOti6it0yF't spO :t ScFiuler ar d T^a^?ttrJ$ ab^au^ ^ef^'tnE ttle ngx^t t^^s Wee1s ^ou Rr ypu5 ^3e^ighe^ eXiu9'd h'o pt ese re a riigfr(ar te .^i:3^edU1e'? ^ WasYh Ps sRrt^etirne ofi mzmaw
k#eaN r' €,etl s^rPcting ^ tNo,p3a Re,pubD r3f io Hovse 77SQ0t,3 High S! Gotucnpus CJ1iiO 43 4} 465>0194 - z31St€ 14) 719-,3594 - Fax
T71eU7f2ffPSafiG e.otO`trai; 0'Fs rospml*£34 'L-(^il iel@;mN
ia LPL 000010 ann, He
F'rom: Morrison, Christine [[email protected]] Sent: Friday, July 01, 2011 12:19 PM To: Mann, Heather Subject: RE: redistricting stuff
Definitely.
From: Mann, Heather [matlto:[email protected]] Sent: Friday, July 01, 2011 12:19 PM To: Morrison, Christine Subject: RE: redistricting stuff
Well, in any event, no crisis, just need to get that meeting scheduled and if you could call me over the weekend need to run something by you.
Heather N. Mann, Esq. Redistricting Director & Dep. Legal Caunsel House Repub4ican Caucus Ohio House of Representatives 77 South High Street, 14th Floor Columbus, Ohio 43215 (614) 466-9194 - Office (614) 719-3594 - Fax (614) 352-5819 - Cell heather. mann(rpo h r. state. oh. us
CONFfD NTtALnY__lJ6T11C€ The infCrmation contained irt ihis e-mai! is intended only for the use of the individual or entity to whlCh it is addressed and it may contain inforlYtation that is pdvileged, confidential, attorney rvork product andfor exempt rrom dbsdosure under applicable law. 1`tRe reader of thls message is not the intended recipient (or tne emoloyee or agent responsible to deliver itto the intended reCipient), youare hereoy notified that any dfssemina6on. distrlbu6on, or copying of this e-mzil is prohibited. If yoa have received !his e^mail in error, please notify the sender by return e-mail. .-._._..,_.. .. .-___-_ ._._.___.. .._____..., -.-_-. . . . From : Morrison, Christine [rnailto:[email protected]] Sent: Friday, July 01, 2011 12:15 PM To: Mann, Heather Subject: RE: redistricting stuff
Yep. It's not pretty. We are not actually checking the signatures, the local BOEs will do that. We physically stamp each petition and record the number of signatures on each petition_ 1,500 boxes. -. -__.___ From Mann, Heather [ma4to:[email protected]] Sent: Friday, July 01, 2011 12:16 PM To: Morrison, Christine Subject; RE: redistrir.tng stuff
Are you like, actually checking petitions? I have tttis vision of you up to your knees in paper...
Heather N. Mann, Esq. Redistrichng Director & Dep. Legal Counsel House Republican Caucus Ohio Hou'se of Representatives 8
LPL 000011 77 South High Street, 14th Floor CoEumbus, Ohio 43215 (614) 466-9194 - Office (614) 719-3594 - Fax (614) 352-5819 - Cell heati?er.mann a^ohr_state.oh.us
CQNFIDLNTtFIl7Y YQI4CE . The information corvainetl in th!6 email is intended only for the use of the individuat or enti€y to wi+;ch it is addressed and K rnay contan information that is privlleged, (or the employee or agent cnnUdentiat, a±torney work prodtict andlor exempt from disclosure under applicable law If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient responsible to deliver H€o the tnlended recipfent}, you ere hereby neiiified that any dissemination., distribution, or copying of this e maei is prohibited. !f you have received this e-mall in error, Geaee eotify the sender by return e-mai3.
.__._._ ....._._.__ :...._.___- ...___....._. . _ .._..... Frorn: Morrison, Christine [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Friday, luly 01, 2011 12:13 PM To: Mann, Heather Subject: RE: redistricting stuff
Thanks Heather. I will get back to you. I saw that you returned my call but I was knee deep in petitions. --. ... .^ __._ . ._..._ From Mann, Heather [mallto:Heather.Mann(c_ilohr.state.oh.us] Sent: Friday, luty 01, 2011 12:15 PM To: Morrison, Christine Subject: redistricting stuff
Christine,
Just following up on my voicemai[ on a few redistricting-related matters.
First, attached for your records is the letter from the Task Force Co-Chairs authorizing the funds for the public process website. Mark Flanders indicated to me that they are going to be issuing guidance to the Co-Chairs and any other party receiving funds on what LSC needs in terms of invoices, documentation, etc. Along the same lines, we wanted to ask if you had any information on the planned content of the website.
Second, Mark Braden - the special counsel to the Task Force and the Apportionment Board -uvill be in Columbus next Thursday, Juty 7 and Friday, July 8th. We'd like to set up individual meetings with the Apportionment Board members and their key staff with Mr. Braden and John Morgan, who will be consulting. Would the Secretary be availabfe to meet at time and place of his convenience during that timeframe?
Thank you, Heather Mann
Heather N. Mann, Esq. Redistricting Director & Dep. Legal Counsel House Republican Caucus Ohio House of Representatives 77 South High Street, 14th Floor Columbus, Ohio 43215 (614) 466-9194 - Office (614) 719-3594 - Fax (614) 352-5819 - Cell heather.mann ohr state-ohus
GONFIISEfdT1ALITY NOTICE The inforination contained ia thls e-mai! is intended only for the use of the individeal or entity to which it is addressed and it may contain information that is pdvAeged, confidentiat, atlomey vrork product andlor exempt from disclosure under applicable law. If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient (or the employee or agent
9
LPL 000012 resp©nsitiie to detiVer i: rc 4he lntended recipienq, you are hereby notified that any tliss¢minatinn, elst6buti6n, or cuPYfng of :his email ts prohibi?etl it }rou have receivetl thls e-Inail in e[rcr, p7ease eotlty thesende by re4+rn e-maiL
10
LPL 000013 Heather Mann
From: Ray DiRossi [[email protected]] Sent: Tuesday, July 05, 2011 5:01 PM To: Heather N. Mann - gmail Subject: Re: FW: redistricting meetings
I can not do 9:15 a.m. 10:30 a.m. for Yost meeting is my first avail lets scheduled I do want to be there for it Ray On Tue, Jul 5, 2011 at 11:51 AM, Mann, Heather
Ray- this is the only time this Thursday that the Governor's staff are available. Is there ANY way you could make the 9:15? If not, do you wantrne to take it, or do you want me to attempt to reschedu]e so that you can be there? The Gover-nor will not be on this meeting.
Heather N. Mann, Esq.
Redistricting Director & Dep. Legal Counsel
House Reputtlican Caucus
Ohio House of Representatives
77 South High Street, 14th Floor
Colmnbus, Ohio 43215
(614) 466-9 i 94 - Office
(614) 719-3594 - Fax
(614) 352-5819 - Cell
he2ther minn(r^ohr state oh.us
cZF'tnI?M7 AUry No
rvcontaininformt,m8zupn,lcuicm6Vutlttn,v ?lclntormationco, ncA'< r LPL 000014 From: Rench, Karrie [mailto:Karrie Rench(dgovernor ohioeov] Sent: Tuesday, July 05, 2011 11:49 AM To: Hansen, Beth; Mann, Heather Subject: RE: redistricting meetings Heather- Beth/IVlike/Matt can all do 9:15 am on Thursday. Where will the meeting be held? Our offices? Karrie ,Rench Assistant to the Chief of Staff Oftice of Ohio Governor John R. Kasich 614-644-0941 Karrie.Rench(anovernor.ohio ov mrw Qovernor.ohio.POv response to it may constitute a public record and thus may be publicly available to anyone who requests it. This message and any From: Hansen, Beth Sent: Friday, July 01, 2011 2:42 PM To: 'He,ather Mann(a?ohr state.oh.us ; Rench, Karrie; Carle, Matt; Cirodhaus, Michael Subject: Re: redistricting meetings Karrie Can you check with Mike and Matt on Thursday? Mopnday 7/11 does not work. T, Th or F? From: Mann, Heather [mailto:Heatber Mann(nlohr state.oh.us] Sent: Friday, July 01, 2011 11:53 AM To:Hansen,Beth Subject: RE: redistricting meetings LPL 000015 Would Thursday, July 7t1i from 9:15-10:15 work for your contingent? I will suggest 3PM for the weekly meetings starting on the 11Y1i and get back to you. Any morning the week after next is fine. 8:30/9AM Monday the 11`h? Heather N. Mann, Esq. Redistrieting Director & Dep. Legal Counsel House Republican Caucus Oltio House ofRepresentatives 77South High Street, 14th Floor Colunibus, Oliio 43215 (614) 466-9194 - Office (614) 719-3594 - Fax (614) 352-5819 - Cell }heather mann^cr)ohr state.olr.us CONFIij HNTIA}. f fY N QT.PCF lltenforntationem¢udinthlsc-mil. tendedonl }r th macfth mdi dna'orcnttnrh vl From: Hansen, Beth [mailto:Beth Hansen(c^,governor ohio.QOV] Sent: Friday, July 01, 2011 11:12 AM To: Mann, Heather; Rench, Karrie; Carle, Matt Cc: Grodhaus, Michael Subject: Re: redistricting meetings The Govenior is out of town next week. But Mike Grodhaus, Matt Carle and I would like to tnet with Braden aaid Morgan. Thursday is best LPL 000016 Weekly meetings on Monday are best in the afternoon. 3? Finally, I'd love to grab coffee - week after next is best! Thanks Heather From: Mann, Heather [mailto:Heather Mann@obr state.oh.us] Sent: Thursday, June 30, 2011 02:47 PM To: Hansen, Beth Subject: redistricting meetings Dear Beth: I am following up on a conversation Troy had with you about a planned Ohio visit from Mark Braden and John Morgan, the consultant on the data/technical end of redistricting. They will be in Columbus Thursday, July 7 ( and Friday, July 8. We would like to make them available for an individual meeting with the Governor as well as the other apportionment board members) those days. Right now they are blocked off for staff training that Thursday afternoon and Friday moming, but of course we can move those around. Please advise if there is a time that might work. Additionally, I spoke with Matt $chuler and Troy Judy about setting up a weekly staff meeting on redistricting starting in the next two weeks, at which you or your designee could be present. Is there a regular time that would work for your schedule? I was thinking perhaps sometime on Mondays? Finally, not that you have any spare time, but would you like to grab coffee or lunch sometime in the next two weeks? Thank you, Heather Mann Heather N. Mann, Esq. Redistricting Director & Dep_ Legal Counsel House Republican Caucus 4 LPL 000017 Ohio House of Representatives 77 South High Street, 14th Floor Columbus, Ohio 43215 (614) 466-9194 - Office (614) 719-3594 - Fax (614)352-5819-Cell. heather.mannfaobr state.oh.us CONFIDENTIALITYNOTICE which it is addressed and it may contain information that is privileged, confidential, attorney The information contained in this e,mail is intended only for the use oft6e individual ur entity to (or the employee or agent responsible to deliver it to the intended work product eud/or excmpt Irom disclosure under applicable law. Ifthe reader otthis message is not the intended recipient have received this ^mail in erroq please notify the sender by return e-mail. recipicnt), you are hereby notified that any disscmination, distribution, or copying of this e-mail is prohibited. Ifyou 5 LPL 000018 Heather Mann From: [email protected] Sent: Tuesday, Jufy 05, 2011 5:41 PM To: Vaughn Flasher; Ray DiRossi; yohoQohiohousegop.com Cc: Heather N. Mann - gmail; Matt Schufer; Troy Judy Subject: Re: Time sensitive issue for OHROCtRSCC - Apportionment data our indexes: For the 2010 elections, we used the elections listed below for 2008 Obama/McCain 2006 Taylor/Sykes 2006 Dann/Montgomery 2004 Bush/Kerry -----Original Message----- From: "Vaughn Flasher" This will be the first in the string of emails. I have copied lody so please copy her going forward on the indexing i ssue, since she does our indexing. ------Original Message------From: Ray DiRossi To: yoho^ohioho se^on.com To: Vaughn Flasher Cc: Heather N. Mann - gmail Cc: Matt Schuler Cc: Troy 7udy Subject: Time sensitive issue for OHROC/RSCC - Apportionment data Sent: 7ul5, 2011 5:27 PM Ben / Vaughn I hope this email does not prompt a massive string of emails but if further detailed conversations are warranted/needed - please advise. Heather and I had a conference call today to discuss data issues and one of the most pressing issues that we have identified is standardizing political indexes for the upcoming Apportionment of house and senate districts. As the respective Chiefs of Staff and other principals (Speaker and President) get into evaluating districts - we all need to be on the same page with regards to what statewide non judicial races comprise our "political index." Can you both provide the quick list of what races you used to "index" districts leading up to the November 2010 races? Also - are there any 2010 statewide that you feel should be added to make a more precise index? We can use just about any race from the last decade. LPL 000019 We would recommend not using any judicial races, congressional races or state legislative races for the statewide indexes. Some possible contests that have been suggested that you might already be using. 2010 Kasich/Strickland 2008 Obama/McCain 2006 Taylor/Sykes 2006 Dann/Montgomery 2004 Bush/Kerry Please advise what races you currently use or would like to see used.. Dne last thing... by way of example - in 2000 we used the following 4 races averaged 1996 Clinton/Dole statewide 1998 Taft/Fisher statewide atewide 1998 Deter.s/Donofrio statewide (minus Summit and Hamilton counties) 2000 Bush/Gore s Ray LPL 000020 tYter - ikelNtattcoii FtidiIr..7uty 01, 201 r,Mann@Ao{3r.s' Ret r. di _. IM9, ou check avEth Mlkt^anc3 LPL 000021 C6$ tamb-os,-fJh'so 43 (694). # 9494 - 60, (624)71:9 359d - F0 5899 -C.^_j teCh: i LPL 000022 ^rt a cerM^:rs6fian TrdY liadWItit yb u -JPou fhe €^alee^f^riital end rtf tdistrIcttng: T Wdi cr^^k^ ^l^m ^va^^6l^ fssP ^^ ^ndividua^ ^L, elo yA. 'R^,^i^ ^isztN^^r^y ^re bla^kec4 of t#urse^4?iE €atirrn'iv^ tklr)-s^aFPS(^rtf^.'Pie^se; tehe 64iit03tia Zti3d1 dEi (644) ^OT4} 36Z ^046r, e pt(V^.ei3, 5Pk4eOPAROAL vgrene"-1i?!s LPL 000023 Mann, Heather From: Mann, Heather Sent: Tuesday, July 05, 2011 1:44 PM To: Rench, Karrie Subject: RE: redistricting meetings Karrie, Unfortunately, the only time we could get a meeting with the Auditor and his contingent was at 1t7:30AM on Thursday. We can make this meeting with the Governor's office contingent work anytime Thursday. Thank you, Heather Mann Heather N. Mann, Esq. Redistricting Director & Dep. Legal Counsel House Republican Caucus Ohio House of Representatives 77 South High Street, 14th Floor Columbus, Ohio 43215 (614) 466-9194 - Office (614) 719-3594 - Fax (614) 352-5819 - Cell heather mannAohr.state.oh.us CONFiDENTIALlTY NOTlCE contained in this e-mail is intended only for the use of the individual or eo-tity to which it is addressed and it may contain information that is privileged, The information (or the employee or agent confideniial, attorney work product and/or exempt from disclosure under applicable taw. If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient responsible to deliver it to the intended recfpient), you are hereby notified that any dissemination, distribution, or copying of this e-mail is prohibited. If you have received this e-mail Inerror, please notify the sender by return e-maH. From: Rench, Karrie [mailto.Karrie [email protected] Sent: Tuesday, ]uly 05, 2011 1:17 PM To: Mann, Heather Subject: RE: redistricting meetings Heather - There have been some scheduling conflicts on our end. Would Mark and John be able to meet at 10:30 on Thursday instead of 9:15 am? Karrie Rench Assistant to the Chief of Staff Office of Ohio Governor John R. Kasich 614-644-0441 Karrie RenchC^a a;overnor.ohio.eov wvuw.¢overnor ohio.¢ov This message and any response to it may constitute a public record and thus may be publicly available to anyone who requests it. ------_-- From: Mann, Heather [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Tuesday, ]uly 05, 2011 11:55 AM To. Rench, Karrie; Hansen, Beth Subject: RE: redistricting meetings LPL 000024 9:15AM, your offices on the 30th Floor. Heather N. Mann, Esq. Redistricting Director & Dep. Legal Counsel House Republican Caucus Ohio House of Representatives 77 South High Street, 14th Floor Columbus, Ohio 43215 (614) 466-9194 - Office (614) 719-3594 - Fax (614) 352-5819 - Cell heather.manngohr state oh.us GONFIDENTtALITY NOTICE The information contained in this e-maif is intended onlyfor the use of the individua( or entity to which it is addressetl and it may contain information that Is privileged, confidential, attorney work product and/or exempt from disclosure under applicable Izw. If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient (or the employee or agent responsible to deliver it to the intended recipient), you are hereby notified that any dissemination, distribution, or copying of this e-mail is prohibited. If you have received this e-mail in error, please notify the sender by return e-mail. From: Rench, Karrie [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Tuesday, July 05, 2011 11:49 AM To: Hansen, Beth; Mann, Heather Subject: RE: redistricting meetings Heather - Beth/Mike/Matt can all do 9:15 am on Thursday. Where will the meeting be held? Our offices? Karrie Rench Assistant to the Chief of Staff Ofifice of Ohio Governorlohn R. Kasich 614-644-0941 Karrie [email protected] www eovernor ohio.¢ov This message and any response to it may constitute a public record and thus may be publicly avoilabte to anyone who requests it. From: Hansen, Beth Sent: Friday, July 01, 2011 2:42 PM To:'[email protected]'; Rench, Karrie; Carle, Matt; Grodhaus, Michael Subject: Re: redistricting meetings Karrie Can you check with Mike and Matt on Thursday? Mopnday 7/11 does not work. T, Th or F? From: Mann, Heather [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Friday, July 01, 2011 11:53 AM To: Hansen, Beth Subject: RE: redistricting meetings Would Thursday, July 7`h from 9:15-10:15 work for your contingent? 2 LPL 000025 I will suggest 3PM for the weekly meetings starting on the 11T" and get back to you. Any morning the week after next fine. 8:30/9AM Monday the 11th? Heather N. Mann, Esq. Redistricting Director & Dep. Legal Counsel House Republican Caucus Ohio House of Representatives 77 South High Street, 14th Floor Columbus, Ohio 43215 (614) 466-9194 - Office (514) 719-3594 - Fax (614) 352-5819 - Cell heather mannQohr,state oh.us CONFIDENTIALITYNOTICE The information contained in this e-mail is intended only for the use o£ the individual or entity to which it is addressed and it may contain information that is privileged, confldential, attorney work product and/or exempt from disclosure under applicabfe Iaw. If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient (or the employee or agent responsble to deliver it to 5ie intended recipient), you are hereby notified Biat any disseminatfon, distribution, or copying of this e-mail is prohibited. If you have received this e-maif in error, please notify the sender by retum e-mail. From: Hansen, Beth [maflto:[email protected] gov] Sent: Friday, July 01, 2011 11:12 AM To: Mann, Heather; Rench, Karrie; Carle, Matt Cc: Grodhaus, Michael Subject: Re: redistricting meetings The Governor is out of town next week. But Mike Grodhaus, Matt Carle and I would like to met with Braden and Morgan. Thursday is best Weekly meetings an Monday are best in the afternoon. 3? Finally, I'd love to grab coffee - week after next is best! Thanks Heather -- Prom: Mann, Heather [mai!to:[email protected]] Sent: Thursday, June 30, 2011 02:47 PM To: Hansen, Beth Subject: redistricting meetings Dear Beth: I am following up on a conversation Troy had with you about a planned Ohio visit from Mark Braden and John Morgan, the consultant on the data/technical end of redistricting. They will be in Columbus Thursday, July 7 and Friday, July 8. We would like to make them available for an individual meeting with the Governor (as well as the other apportionment board members) those days. Right now they are blocked off for staff training that Thursday afternoon and Friday morning, but of course we can move those around. Please advise if there is a time that might work. Additionally, I spoke with Matt Schuler and Troy Judy about setting up a weekly staff meeting on redistricting starting in the next two weeks, at which you or your designee could be present. Is there a regu!artime that would work for your schedule? I was thinking perhaps sometime on Mondays? 3 LPL 000026 Finally, not that you have any spare time, but would you like to grab coffee or lunch sometime in the next two weeks? Thank you, Heather Mann Heather N. Mann, Esq. Redistricting Director & Dep. Legal Counsel House Republican Caucus Ohio House of Representatives 77 South High Street, 14th Floor Columbus, Ohio 43215 (614) 466-9194 - Office (614) 719-3594 - Fax (614) 352-5819 - Cell heather mann(a?ohr state.oh.us CONFIDENTIALLTYNOTICE The information contained in this e-mail is intended only for the use of the individual or entity to which it is addressed and it may contain information that is privileged, conf^dential, allorney work product andlor exempt from disciosure under applicable law. If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient (or the employee or agent responsible to deliver it to the intended recipient), you are hereby notified that any dissemination, distribution, or copying of this e-mail is prohibited. If youhave received this e-mail in error, please notify the sender by return e-mail. LPL 000027 Heather Mann From: Heather Mann [[email protected]] Sent: Tuesday, Juiy 05, 2011 6:23 PM 'Michael Lenzo' To: for OHROCIRSCC - Apportionment data Subject: FW: Time sensitive issue ^.» Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, Ohio 43206 (614) 352-5819 's;eathernma€tr:ORmai.l. com -Original Message----- • From: Iody[capi olstratetiesRrea com fmailto•'tody(^raptotstrateRmes^.com1 Sent: Tuesday, 3uly 05, 2011 5:41 PM To: Vaughn Flasher; Ray DiRossi; yoho@wohiohouseYop-com Cc: Heather N. Mann - gmail; Matt Schuler; Troy Judy Subject: Re: Time sensitive issue for OHROC/RSCC - Apportionment data For the 2010 elections, we used the elections listed below for our indexes: 2008 obama/McCain 2006 Taylor/Sykes 2006 Dann/Montgomery 2004 Bush/Kerry -original Message----- coPF3> From: "Vaughn Flasher" This will be the first in the string of emails. I have copied Jody so please copy her going forward on the indexing issue, since she does our indexing. ------Original Message------From: Ray DiRossi To: •oh ohiohouseROO.com To: Vaughn Flasher Cc: Heather N. Mann - gmail Cc: Matt Schuler Cc: Troy Judy Subject: Time sensitive issue for OHROC/RSCC - Apportionment data Sent: Jul 5, 2011 5:27 PM Ben / Vaughn 1 LPL 000028 I hope this email does not prompt a massive string of ernails but if further detailed conversations are warranted/needed - please advise. Heather and I had a conference call today to discuss data issues and one of the most pressing issues that we have identified is standardizing political indexes for the upcoming Apportionment of house and senate districts. As the respective Chiefs of Staff and other principals (Speaker and President) get into evaluating districts - we all need to be on the same page with regardsto what statewide non judicial races comprise our "political index." Can you both provide the quick list of what races you used to "index" districts leading up to the November 2010 races? Also - are there any 2010 statewide that you feel should be added to make a more precise index? We can use just about any race from the last decade. We would recommend not using any judicial ra[es, congressional races or state legislative races for the statewide indexes. Some possible contests that have been suggested that you might already be using. 2010 Kasich/Strickland 2008 obama/McCairi. 2006 Taylor/Sykes 2006 Dann/Montgomery 2004 Bush/Kerry Please advise what races you currently use or would like to see used.. one last thing... by way of example - in 2000 we used the following 4 races averaged 1996 Clinton/Dole statewide 1998 Taft/Fisher statewide 1998 Deters/Donofrio statewide (minus Summit and Hamilton counties) 2000 Bush/Gore statewide Ray LPL 000029 4} A6 '{&a4} 7i :(b414},352- h^t,^ra s tlo 1 1:3£7ANF: Thank VOOT rid: Mannr EsR; LPL 000030 i[a F3^a ^i t^epr^ser^^€i^ h C4t}7 H^t^ SEre`et3 i^4Rt^ ^ fo#1 office 64}.^^2^$^^^^^i} ptf[ a,. L^! nd 41 pPr. §a^ woYICS`bO^`i u^d g^^ ^.rr^ting^'itit the auditnt Ortd h"s ^ontjngent wa.s at ^o ^^An^ ot^ ^hur^day.° ^ov^rn^?^ 5 a#^ic^ c^r+ttn^ent wark arsy^6ine Thu€silaY= Heoth6r N.:tvlsnn, Esq:. Redistriot't,ng: Directior & Dep. Le^, Hiallse keppWItOan Gaa eus Ootlss x)f Represenkattves uth tilign Strt:et< 14t .Floor itls Oftio 4321-v 466-P!;94- pffice 7S'3-3594 - LPL 000031 tWA? 4&f^- j0d) 749-35 Yt'i' I n.ss2-6 ti^thet 9^ar^ ai mpt i, KaRie €tt?aPttr:KOrrWRent ^8r ^(y 05, ^?11'11.49 AM # dta -9;15;M, rtri Tbu+:s 1tielr! ? Ou LPL 000032 Hcruie of Reprs yoU ery n„ 6^tp2NISFmI41DttE LPL 000033 Wrivqrsaf?on V#r034 WAb yciu ahcha4VpE^OtleSa F i^%Q Y)st€-rram rvuaric esra?^ra tsru-a, t^YafY^chnis^l^itd^aF^tdiSTt^c^iiig.m ThWO^'LittWUmtiu^?fjfrtsd^y>^^ty7aostF ^ t^em ^vailabt^ fi^r a€s•^^j^^ua.l'tas^^^ fl^^atR.ttie cz'avptool jAs We1t as tlseat33es «f eSay^: Rigttt^iawfh&yare^f^?^k^d;d^fas^^trair+iqgfW;rhutss4a^ aftefftQo int e We ras mc^u^* t1f^^; und. ^^ ^duise ±F Fhereis zi,tfM$ tfat tctight wcsrk. sPow uaah moft 5ct ^t^^r 0t}^ ^rcay ludy ^b^^t s^^tit1^: ohichyou br yQUr des'&ee^CQiaid k#ar^Pf g perhaps ^etrft^ti^^' ^ c tY#e^d d ybu fiWI acl^'nAamm. ^tjjr743;Dtleetoe &Bep. L^g^.i ^t ^ 3^ep^i'612^ an ^^ircu^ SOni #ZepriBseniativOs ^jr Squfh N^jh'Sk ^t, '1+3tfi F#oar iii 43215 LPL 000034 REDISTRICTING MEETINGS AGENDA THURSDAY, JULY 7, 2011 10:30AM - 11:15AM Meeting with Auditor Yost's Office, Mark Braden, John 88 East Broad Street, Morgan, and House & Senate Staff 5th Floor 11:30AM - 12:30PM Meeting with Governor's Office, Mark Braden, John Morgan, 77 South High Street, Riffe and House & Senate Staff Center, 30th Floor (South Conference Room) 12:30PM - 1:30PM Lunch - Location TBD 1:45PM - 2:45PM Meeting with Secretary of State's Office, Mark Braden, John 180 East Broad Street, 16th Morgan, and House & Senate Staff Floor 2:45PM - 5:30PM Redistricting Training - Mark Braden, John Morgan, and 77 South High Street, Riffe House & Senate Staff Building, 15th Floor Conference Room 6PM - 7:30PM Dinner TBD FRIDAY, JULY 8, 2011 8AM - 11 AM Redistricting Training - Mark Braden, John Morgan, and 77 South High Street, Riffe House & Senate Staff Building, 15th Floor Conference Room 11:30AM - 12:30PM Lunch TBD 1:30PM - 5PM, Meetings TBD LPL 000035 STAFF & TITLES Governor's Office • Governor John Kasich • Beth Hanson, Chief of Staff • Michael Grodhaus, Chief Legal Counsel • Matt Carle, Policy Director Auditor's Office • Auditor Dave Yost • Brenda Rinehart, Chief of Staff • Mary Amos, Legislative Director • Matt Borges, Consultant Secretary of State's Office • Secretary Jon Husted • Scott Borgemenke, Chief of Staff • Jack Christopher, Deputy Secretary of State • Elizabeth Shuster, Legal Counsel • Christine Morrison, Legislative Director Ohio Senate • Matt Schuler, Chief of Staff • John Barron, Majority Legal Counsel • Ray DiRossi, Redistricting Staff Ohio House of Representatives • Troy Judy, Chief of Staff • Mike Lenzo, Majority Legal Counsel • Heather Mann, Deputy Legal Counsel & Redistricting Director LPL 000036 Heather Mann From: Ray DiRossi [[email protected] Sent: Thursday, July 07, 2011 7:35 AM To: Matt Schuler sbc email Cc: Troy J.; Heather 4I- Mann - gmail of Redistricting Subcommittee Hearings (DRAFT) Subject: Re: 2011-07-07 Announcement one comment on the actual release.. The following statement causes me some conern "Ensuring an opportunity for public input is an important part of crafting a fair and legal Congressional redistricting plan," stated Chairman Huffman. I take this to mean that if the plan is adopted WITHOUT public imput - the its NOT legal Since these hearings will be well before a bill comes out with actual proposed districts - the dems are going to hit us on moving the actual bill through the legislature quickly once its introduced.. they will say its without public imput even though we have hearings because the public wont come and testify I would change that statement to say "Ensuring an opportunity for public input is an important part the Congressional redistricting process," stated Chairman Huffman. Ray On Wed, 7ul 6,^2@11 at 7:04 PM, Mann, Heather > I will be engaged in a series of meeting all day tomorrow, so the best > way to reach me is by cell ( 614.352.5819) or email > (heather [email protected]). > > > Sincerely, > > Heather Mann > > > > y i LPL 000037 > Heather, N. Mann, Esq. > > Redistricting Director & Dep. Legal Counsel > > House Republican Caucus > > Ohio House of Representatives > > 77 South High Street, 14th Floor > > Columbus, Ohio43215 > (614) 466-9194 - Office > > (614) 719-3594 - Fax > (614) 352-5819 - Cell > > heather.mann(dohr.state.oh.us > > > > CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE > The information contained in this e-mail is intended only for the use > of the individual or entity to which it is addressed and it may > contain information that is privileged, confidential, attorney work > product and/or exempt from disclosure under applicable law. If the ( or the employee > reader of this message is not the intended recipient > or agent responsible to deliver it to the intended recipient), you are > hereby notified that any dissemination, distritiution, or copying.of > this e-mail is prohibited. If you have received this e-mail in error, please notify the sender by return e-mail. 2 LPL 000038 Mann, Heather Meeting with Auditor Yost"s Office, Redistricting Counsel/Consultant (Mark Braden & John Subject: Morgan); and GA Redistricting Staff (Heather Mann & Ray DiRossi) Location: Auditor Yost's Office, 88 East Broad Street, 5th Floor Start: Thu 7/7/2011 10:30 AM End: Thu 7/7/2011 11:30 AM Show Time As: Tentative Recurrence: (none) Meeting Status: Not yet responded Organizer: Mann, Heather Mary Amos Augsburger; Braden, E. Mark; [email protected]; [email protected]; Required Attendees: Mike; Barron, John; John Matthew T. Schuler ( [email protected]); Troy J; Lenzo, B. Morgan [email protected]) 1 LPL 000039 Mann, Heather Meeting with Governor's Office (Beth Hanson, Mike Grodhaus, Matt Carle), Redistricting Subject: Counsel/Consultant (Mark Braden & John Morgan); and GA Redistricting Staff (Heather Mann & Ray DiRossi) Riffe Center, 30th Floor (South Conference Room) Location: Start: Thu 7/7/2011 11:30 AM End: Thu 7/7/2011 12:30 PM Show Time As: Tentative Recurrence: (none) Meeting Status: Not yet responded Mann, Heather Organizer: Lenzo, Mike; Braden, E. Mark; [email protected]; Matthew T. Schuler Required Attendees: Troy J; ([email protected]); Barron, John; [email protected]; John B. Morgan Qm o rg a n@ a p p l i e d res ea rch coo rd i n ate s. co m) I LPL 000040 Mann, Heather Meeting wfth Secretary's Office, Redistricting Counsel/Consultant (Mark Braden & John Subject: Morgan); and GA Redistricting Staff (Heather Mann & Ray DiRossi) (Kate Huffman 387-7323); Location: 16th Floor, 180 East Broad Street, Columbus Ohio Start: Thu 7/7/2011 1:30 PM End: Thu 7/7/2011 2:30 PM Show Time As: Tentative Recurrence: (none) Meeting Status: Not yet responded Mann, Heather Organizer: [email protected]; Braden, E. Mark; [email protected]; Lenzo, Mike; Troy J; Required Attendees: Matthew T. Schuler ([email protected]); John B. Morgan [email protected]); [email protected]; Barron, John 1 LPL 000041 From: Mann, Heather To: Grodhaus, Michaefi cc: "raydiross®"` Lenzo, Mike; Troy 3; Hansen, Bethj Carle, Matt: Subject: Reapportionment Board Document Date: Friday, July 08, 2011 8:00:58 AM Attachments: Reapportionment History & Template.doc Dear Michael: Attached is the document that I handed out in our meeting today (page numbers added). I will have a copy of my binder of past materials upon which these templates are based brought up to you later today. Please let us know how we can be of further assistance. Sincerely, Heather Mann Heather N. Mann, Esq. Redistricting Director & Dep. Legal Counsel House Republican Caucus Ohio House of Representatives 77 South High Street, 14th Floor Columbus, Ohio 43215 (614) 466-9194 - Office (614) 719-3594 - Fax (614) 352-5819 - Cell heather. mann ?ohr.state.oh. us CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE The information contained in this e-mail is intended only for the use of the individual or entity to which it is addressed and it may contain information that is privileged, confidential, attorney work product andlor exempt from disclosure under applicable law. It the reader of this message is not the intended recipient (or the employee or agent responsibie to deliver it to the intended recipient), you are hereby notified that any dissemination, distribution, or copying of this e-mail is prohibited. If you have received this e-mail in error, please notify the sender by return e-mail. LPL 000042 REAPPORTIONMENT BOARD HISTORY & TEMPLATE Anportionment Timeline 2001 Cycle: In 2001, the Apportionment Board met a total of 14 times: • July 20, 2001:,Governor's office beld interrtal planning meetingi on July 20, 2001 to discuss logistics of initial meeting. • July 19, 2001: Governor's Office issued notices 2 of the initial meeting. • July 30, 2001: Govemor's office issued press release3 announcing initial meeting of the Apportionment Board for Thursday, August 2, 2001 (3 days advance notice). • Thursday, August 2, 2001: The Apportionment Board held an initial organizational meeting' at the Ohio Senate Law Library at 10AM. The meeting was led by Govemor Taft. Indicia of Office and Letters of Appointment were presented. Votes were held to appoint a Chair, Vice Chair, Secretary, and Court Reporter. Amendments to the Rules were discussed and adopted. Timelines for apportionment board meetings, regional public hearings, and plan submission deadlines were discussed and voted upon. 24, 2001: 10 regional meetings to receive • Monday, August 20, 2001 - Friday, August public testimony were held at university colleges from around the state - University of Toledo, University of Findlay, Cleveland State, University of Akron, Walsh University, University of Cincinnati, University of Dayton, OSU-Newark, Columbus State. • Monday, September 24, 2001: 9AM deadline to submit proposals to Apportionment Board Secretary. • Wednesday, September 26, 2001: The Apportionment Board heard testimony on submitted plans from the Ohio Republican Party, Sen. Herington & Rep. DiPiero, NAACP, CARE PAC, Private Citizen, and Scott Borgemenke/Majority of the Board. • Monday, October 1, 2001: The Apportionment Board voted 4-1 (Senator Herington voted no) to adopt the Majority plan. • Wednesday, October 3, 2001: Governor Taft announced an emergency meeting to adopt technical changes to the apportionment plan. See Draft agenda See Draft notice See DraYl press release 4 See Draft organization meeting script 1 LPL 000043 • Monday, October 4, 2001: The Apportionment Board voted 4-0 to adopt technical changes to the apportionment plan. Roster of Attendees & Witnesses at 2001 Regional Hearings 1. University of Toledo a. Apportionment Board Secretary & Member Designeess b. Bonnie W. Smith (League of Women Voters of Ohio) c. Floyd B. Johnson (Ohio Conference of NAACP Branches) d. Janet Rogolksy (Sylvania citizen) e. Leo Martinez (Greater Toledo Urban Leauge) f. WilliAnn Moore (Toledo Branch of the NAACP 2. University of Findlay a. Apportionment Board Secretary & Member Designees b. Ralph C. Wise (Fostoria citizen) c. Gary Frueh (Allen County Democratic Party) d. Beverly McCoy (Allen County Democratic Party) 3. Cleveland State University a. Apportionment Board Secretary, Senate Minority Leader Leigh Herington, Other Member Designees b. Mike Cook (Solon citizen) c. Eleanore Ramsay Dees (League of Women Voters of Ohio) d. Robert Zimmerman (Shaker Heights citizen) e. Floyd Johnson (Obio Conference of NAACP Branches) f. Gerald Henley (Cleveland Branch of the NAACP) g. Mary Rose Oakar (State Representative) h. Paul Oyasky (Mayor of Euclid) i. Joe Cimperman (Cleveland City Councilman) j. Cindy Marizette (Executive Director of Cuyahoga County Democratic Party) 4. Cleveland State University a. Apportionment Board Secretary, Senate Minority Leader Leigh Herington, Other Member Designees b. Rick Owens (Akron Unified Convnunity Council) c. Annalisa Stubbs Williams (Akron citizen) d. Kurt O. Landefeld (Peninsula citizen and former HD45 Democrat candidate) e. Dorothy Marsh (Akron citizen) f. Dan Zawacki (Director of Communications, Committee Advocating Redistricting Equity or CARE PAC) g. Gerry Hall (Akron League of Women Voters) h. Dan Colantone (Akron Regional Development Board) i. S.N. Shriver (3800 Group Coalition) 5. Walsh University a. Apportionment Board Secretary, Senate Minority Leader Leigh Herington, Other Member Designees b. Steve DiLoreto (Stark County citizen) 5 Designees were Carried Glaeden (Governor Taft); Norman Cummings, Jim Nathanson, David Kennedy (Secretary Blackwell); D. Michael Grodhaus, Lana Ruebel (Auditor Petro); and Brett Buerck (Speaker Householder) 2 LPL 000044 c. Curt Braden (Chairman, Stark County Republican Party) d. Michael McElfresh 6. University of Cincinnati a. Apportionment Board Secretary, Secretary Blackwell, Senate Minority Leader Leigh Herington, Other Member Designees b. Kathy Fryer Helmbock c. Phil Macklin (Oxford Township citizen) d. Mary Kay Gardner (League of Women Voters) e. Robert Richardson, Jr. (University of Cincinnati student body) f. Floyd Johnson (Ohio Conference of NAACP Branches) g. Alice Schneider (Cincinnati Women's Caucus) h. Phil Macklin i. Gwen Marshall (Southwest Ohio Green Party) j. Jessica Hogg (United Way & Community Chest) k. Chris Dennison 7. Walsh University a. Apportionment Board Secretary, Senate Minority Leader Leigh Herington, Other Member Designees b. John Mitchel (Beavercreek resident) c. Bryan Bucklew (VP of Advocacy & Development, Dayton Area Chamber of Commerce) d. Carol McKeever (Field Director, CARE PAC) e. Lisa Hughes (Miamisburg City Council) f. Peter Lurker (Chair, Germantown Village) g. Lowell Draften (Trustee, German Township) h. Deb Wenig (Greater Dayton Area Leaugue of Women Voters) i. Robert McClain (Trustee, German Township) j. Gene Lindley (Preble County Republican Party) k. Jane Brooks (Springfield resident) 1. Toney Adams (Springfield resident) m. Dan Harkins (Springfield resident) 8. Muskingum College a. Apportionment Board Secretary, Senate Minority Leader Leigh Herington, Other Member Designees b. Frank S. Sentich, Jr. (Richmond resident) c. Joshua Lee Wolf (Cincinnati resident) d. David L. Horn (Athens County resident) e. Carolyn Fisk (Athens County citizen) f. Tom McGuire (Member, Federal Hocking Local School Board) 9. Ohio State University - Newark Branch a. Apportionment Board Secretary, Senate Minority Leader Leigh Herington, Other Member Designees b. Steve Harrington (Newark resident) c. Terry McCoy (President, Ohio League of Women Voters) d. Billie Allen (Newark resident) 3 LPL 000045 e. J. Michael King (Chairman, Licking County Board of Elections & Licking County Democratic Party) 10. Columbus State Community College a_ Apportionment Board Secretary, Secretary Blackwell, Senate Minority Leader Leigh Herington, Other Member Designees b. Catherine Turcer (Ohio Citizen Action) c. Bud McTaggart (Communication Workers of America) d. Peg Rosenfeld (League of Women Voters) e. Ray Miller (State Representative) f. Joyce Beatty (State Representative) g. Charleta Tavares (Member, Columbus City Council) h. Floyd Johnson (Ohio Conference of NAACP Branches) i. J.D. Richardson (Columbus resident) Budeet & Expenditures Allocation of Funds to the Legislative Caucuses In the last round of redistricting, funds were allocated to the four legislative caucuses to spend as they saw fit. •At the Dec. 19, 2001 Redistricting Task Force meeting, the Task Force authorized: be spent by each of the joint House-Senate • $300K ($150K to each joint caucus) to Republican and Democrat caucuses between now and July 1, 2001 on hardware, software, and/or consulting in supporting of the apportionment process to be spent between Dec. 19, 2000 and July 1, 2001. The caucuses were given the discretion to split their allotment equally ($75K to each individual caucus).6 be spent in a similar fashion on congressional a$120K ($60K to each joint caucus) to redistricting between Dec. 19, 2000 and Mar. 31, 2002.7 • Authority to the Chiefs of Staff for House/Senate Republican and Democrat caucuses to jointly approve expenditures. The following charts were provided by the Legislative Service Commission illustrate how the joint caucus allocations of $150K for apportionment and $60K for congressional redistricting were spent in 2000. Historical Appropriations & Expenditures for the Legislative Task Force on Redistricting The following charts present appropriation and expenditure amounts for GRF appropriation item 035407, Legislative Task Force on Redistricting, from FY 1996 to FY 2013, and (2) LSC Redistricting Expenditures related to the 2000 redistricting cycle by fiscal year, vendor, and amount. $ 6 12/19/00 Redistricting Task Force Minutes ' Redistricting Task Force to LSC Director Robert Shapiro, attached). "LSC Memo R-129-0713-1; Connie Seaburn, LSC Staff LPL 000046 Le islative Task Force on Redistrictin Aro riatio 996-FY^ 2013 ^ FY Original Carryover/ Transfer ^ Actual Appropriat ion Encumbrances Out* tion Expenditures from Prior Year ,500 $435,023 1996 $992,500 $0 $0 7,500 $163,563 1997 $497,500 $0 $0 =1,096,,6,183183 $363,798 1998 $830,000 $266,183 $0 $ $1,042,785 $104,748 1999 $310,400 $732,385 $0 $0 $2,400,000 $610,044 $2,400,000 $0 $0 $0 2000 $327,060 2001 $2,100,000 $750,000 $0 $69,958 $2,780,042 $1,145,405 $971,855 2002 $2,000,000 $2,452,467 $3,000,000 $307,062 $0 2003 $0 $173,450 $0 $0 $173,450 $8;200 $91,800 $0 2004 $100,000 $0 $0 $0 $91,800 $0 2005 $0 $91,800 $0 $0 $0 2006 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 2007 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 2008 $0 $0 $0 $0 2009 $750,000 $0 $0 $0 $750,000 $268,600 $750,000 $750,000 $0 $0 $1,500,000 2010 $0 2011 $750,000 $1,231,400 $0 $0 $1,981,400 2012** $750,000 Upto $],981,400 2013** $750,000 $3,244,691 Total Expenditures Since FY 1996 *$3,000,000 was transferred to the Attorne y General's Office 153, As Introduced **FY 2012 and FY 2013 figures represent a ro riations in H.B. 5 LPL 000047 M }},^^ +O ^ N O O O O . O d,^^^^s lD W Vl ^ cr yr '^ ^ _ O+ lO O N OA +O ^ N . ^ O ^ 5^y 'tJ°1 {.i t elk^ il.h {1 N hc^t ^;;, .^'t^'P M a^+ M ^^`f }+ h t^' r ^G It 1`*,'.',y` t {^ ! ti k N O R r.t Ik' 2^dM^A^1 cg; ON # t• .^^a . ^ ^, ^R ^^° ^}fih 0r^. '^sX tW' r.^LPU,FYM^ . t^k5y{^F^5 , . `p W Vl tSh^z ^nr }1Fn ^^^^r ^t O 4':3 RkT^^}^t S S •*• ^^^}k i i Ft. y^l t3 rJF^^^ g q' t ko t r i t3 ar^'p^', . p p p +^ r ^ 1dD ^v" 93" fL`y . 3 . 30- ffy 6 y^^m t,*ntt O O O O O hfiFry j^^ A#° O O O O O 1G P,. ^^^ J fJy Y$ Rt^ Ail ^fr ^ a 1+ •,rl{ ht^f^^t -'s 4 w SG`S..T?. .21 S St: ^. . .S 'jw' Qf t^ w U ^ o F ^ 8 E ^* q ^ y oj ^+ t ^ °^ ^ ^ C ^ pp O O O O + {tdF t; ^' '^ N ^ U O U oti vM' m ^c N ' N o O O O ;: Y^ w >^ >^ w o 0 0 81 w ^a w w w w w ^ ^ o 0 I I ' I ^^ ti; o 0 0 SC x^?=: o 0 0 0 0 0 o m^ N N O N O O N ^ O p 3^ p : ` V O ^O O `v^ O ^n O ^O +D O l^ 1^ t^ O o^ oo O^ W-+ O O r ^ ^ M V ^D ^ O O O O r ^ M O O O ^ ^ ^^ ^^ n N t^ ^n t^ O \D N N ^ N ^ U t^ q ' ^ ti N M r M M O O O r" o O O ^ ^ ^ rp ° 0 0 0 0 0 ^ O oo n N vl N w . Y w ^ . O ^ w w rn 'O 'O D U fJ ti y U ^ r:. ^ ti 3 w 6' C-^ ^ aJ y Nt6 O' U q V vi .V v^!i v • aa L1w FC7 Fc7 . ..^aa G1 ^ C] ^ 'd w .^ w .o w '° u- •° u, a w ^ r w w J^ w C o o C o O C o O C O o C o 0 o 0 o O o C o o ^ N N N O O ^ N N ^ N N N N ^ N N O O N N O N N N y N 3 M O y3 t^l O M[^l O M 3 M^ y3 M O y3 M O U O^ N U O^ N M ,-^. ~ N N^ -+ N U O^ N U O-+ N U O-+ N W .-i .--i O ^ N O N O N ^ N O N O Gp '--^ -+ O Pa .-. :-r O N ^ N .-+ O CQ •--^ ... O Ca ^.-. O W•--^ .-. O O [^ O T O .r O O^ O ^ O a w^q`• m v:y::^ p SD oVO °o °p M ^ lD O M (th^x^ ^, ^ ^ 4 # . O' C. O ^}`^X?•u..x' ^ o^o a O „ ^ E r, o y .c ar 'N^ m r^ ^i H ^S•rV N ^^ 3 rtY" ^4^3fu.x"e': N ^SRYtI"?-^4^fr s f ^^r r N ^ a o M a s xa w^. .K7r,g r =. ^^ ^u(r ^ ^ E4 Y,Ly ^t q x , T•dZF t rusm O 4 f;a„^r*^^^ i.0 O <,xi p O r.^ . ^a` P{l ' ^ p 0 c $'N ^4 M ------ YI r^ ^ yt .{y, l..^h t^^.i ry N ^ U o F N U vi F Y A F ^ U. ^ F' H ^^^`N54^^ ^ y O e> G N W ^ b ^ :. ^" a> V] x ^: m > > w m o Ca C7 m C] W '^. Ca W a w Ca ^ -o ^c,, aw ^ w 'Ow pw ^p^') ^: O N N N O O O O O O O O O O O O p F`j b ' ^ N N ^ N .ia, }.^`^ ": N qO N ^ '3 M O '3 M M '3 M^ '3 M O L M^ M ^ ^ . r+ N N \O .--^ N ^^y^ `. .-N. p .-+ O ^-+ O -^ O \N ^® N O W^.~+ O (^ ^^ O M l0 N o0 vl 00 00 lp N P O1 ti ^'' vy^'^ ^^^^{*itii^^., tD o0 ^ 00 v^ r`^ ^X N N O ^O Nv'1 ^ M T2 ^ F 'ii . .4 .^rYfj1 ^ t^s O O 0 El Fi t 00 ^O N .FI^ ^?^ . M f^ t^^, v O }^ N Y 3 iS Y ^='. O O , crr' ryrv jt {r 9X x'w ^ ^^Y Y N t yc:.. .. '..' . .ed T I^ I^ ^ N ^O O M O N ^ ^ . ^ O O h I^ O o ^n ^ ^ co 0o r. M ^N". n n ^ -; o o u F ^d "VI k;? IJtjp^ f°h . I{ytl.ft^i, i, h p v^`3 ^IV "1 iv^ ^ '.., ^)Sc.le . l{ l^i ^,f }( _ y`^ y^ . J 4Y C i y%F-Fy.'i,u T . f a43 1 "k 2 r ^ltYV . ' -..^3 . Y! ^3 . r n !. M CL,q vz,} ^IV n 17 s! s ^ ^ N ^ . r, ^ o rl rTa'ti o ^ p Vl Q W ^ ^ ,n ^n v o o m L' U^ Ur^ `7 U^ Ur^ ^° '.Ur7 Ur w w w w w w w w N Ol .^ N O^ N O\ 01 4i SK . U O^. Ol i+ N Ol 61 Y N O1. Q^ N Q^ pi N 01 ^ O ^^ ^ N 01 ^ S \ ^G" ^ m; . N O^ ,-. "O .\o " ^ - \ O \ M 3 \ M ^ 3 \ \ 3^ ^n , p • . ^ .-r M A ^ ^ M ^ ' ^ ^ \ ~ ^ ^ \ ~ ^ ^. ^ ^ ~ M ^ N `-' M p, N m ^ p p . ^ . O o ^ O ^ rpp - O ^ -+ N O O O ^ 00 m m N p 00 00 C ^ M ^ ^ ^ O V d ^ N O O 'G M M p 00 G\ O ^ M ^pr N ^ N o d^ . . 00 00 O - ti M O ^ O ^lD ^ O N^ O M O ti W M N ^ M ^ 0 ^ l d ^ V l) ^ yN y N Y bY 3^ ^ ^ y. i^ i i w i i w w w w w 0 0 0 a^ ^ ^ O O ^. N aJ OA ^ a> O^ N al 01 Q a°i°^+ °^i O aJ U_ ^ ZM 3 Cm t . C D^ O .^O O 3 O ^ 3rz O N •--^ . O N ^ ^ O ^O p o O t ^ ^ O t O ^oo ^oo ^oo mo ^ a.ir.•o Cl^eo P7 ^-.•o W ^.-,o °O1, P'.ir^°°+v^o+ W ^•^o l ^ O M V1 t^ V N M \O N ^ N O n O O ^ N ^ 06 r V^ O O V1 ^ ^ ^ W M ^O N N ^Vi O O b O V O O O O p^p O O ^ O ^p r V o6 p M F 3 ^ ^O U ^ i0 N U ^ N O 'Oq L^' WI ^ O O ^ ^ V ^ . ^ p ^ .^ ^' .^J ^ a^i O ^ ^ ^ ^ . ° c7 cn c7 CO w vi d ^" C4 a. d. ^" U ^a°' ^' ti^ zU zU U^ E- o^ . U ti o a. d w w w y4 w ^. >-^ w ^'-^ w w w w p O p O .--^ O O O p o O O O O O N ® O 0 ^ R ^ O\} O O O . O p N N N. Y a^ O O oo . m vi ^n ^ 3 \ N_ ® ^ O ^n O N O N O N O ? N N N N N N N N N^ N,^ N^, ^^..^ N "'"^ .--^ N ^ N ^ N O^ O -+ O --^ O ^ O ^ O^ p O^ O O T O O^ O =; O ti p .^. O m p V] o FQ 1^ ^ O O^ O N Vl Vl ^ V V1 ^D O O O o0 O O^ O O oo d' N O D0 O O N M d' ^vi n .O O O G r vl ^O v). R ^ . Vl . ^ N N ^ ^ ^ ^OO lNV M M C iD ^ ^..N vl Cw ^ ^^p N '^r 4 ^ Fr^n 6 o v v ^oO ^ N a ^M O ^ N v1 O O W O OM ^' O O O O ^ ^, vl r ^ ^.j ^ V1 ^ 00 N w W W T w W O O .C N N y N N 0 N : o j v^ ' rn C y ^r ' N ai C s^ °1 3.° o m ^ c v ^ ^ v T d p ^ v 2$ v^ o 's. c o i. o Ga C'^ C': o m .K' '^ic m o ro C W w ,7 ° .°, ai wU w^wU law cG ^ U5 c^ 0d r4 O O 00 O O O Q O O O O O O O O N N O ` N N N N N O O ^ ^ N O O -^o .-^o --^o ^o No 00 00 00 00 00 00 - o -o - o -^o -^o N O M N M M '1M It) Budget Recommendation The below sample budget utilizes the 2000 Republican partisan breakdown as a rough model and assumes a historical budget of $180K (both legislative reapportionment & congressional redistricting). A major assumption is that outside legal counsel would not be paid out of the Republican caucus allocation, but rather as counsel for the whole Apportiontnent Board would be paid out of the remainder of the line item. Estimated Cost Cate o Descri tion $120,000 Consultant Consultant budget would include Apportionment Board Secretary, IT, and other consultants. $7,000 Space/Rent Options include renting hotel space (such as the Doubletree, which is $80/night government rate) or a short term lease from a downtown office building. Includes furniture rental if needed and utilities. $500 Travel Mileage reimbursement for various meetings, travel for statewide hearin s, etc. $1,000 Maintenance & su lies Pa er, ink cartrid es, ete. $30,000 Technology/Computers Four desktop Maptitude licenses $5,000 each) Legal counsel's Computers recommendations included 2 desktop stations with two monitors each, one laptop with an extra monitor, and a high- quality prihter. Licenses would range about $5K each, assume 4 licenses (one per workstation and one extra 180,000 15 LPL 000057 Draft Stiinshine - Statewide Apportioning Board Members July X, 2011 The Honorable Bill Batchelder Speaker Ohio House of Representatives 77 South High Street, 14`" Floor Columbus, Ohio 43215 Via hand delivery Dear Speaker Batchelder: Pursuant to the provisions of Article X, Section I of the Ohio Constitution, this letter serve,s as notice of the initial meeting of the 2011 Board of Apportioning Persons. The meeting will be held at 10:00 a.m. on Thursday, August 2, 2011 in the Senate Finance Hearing Room. I look forward to seeing you there. Sincerely, John Kasich Governor 16 LPL 000058 Draft Stiinshine Notice - Minority Leaders July 23, 2011 The Honorable Armond Budish Minority Ohio House of Representatives 77 South High Street, l4`h Floor Columbus, Ohio 43215 Via hand delivery Dear Leader Budish: Pursuant to the provisions of Article X, Section I of the Ohio Constitution, this letter serves as notice of the initial meeting of the 2011 Board of Apportioning Persons. The meeting will be held at 10:00 a.m. on Thursday, August 2, 2011 in the Senate Finance Hearing Room. Please choose an appointee, along with Leader Cafaro, one person to serve on this Board. I am enclosing a prior letter of appointment for your information. Thank you for your assistance and I look forward to seeing your designee there. Sincerely, John Kasich Govemor 17 LPL 000059 Draft Press Release - Announcement of Initial Apportionment Board Meeting STATE APPORTIONMENT BOARD TO MEET Regional Public Hearings to be Held Across Ohio COLUMBUS (July 30, 2011) - As required by state law, Governor John Kasich will convene the 2011 Board of Apportioning Person on Thursday, August X, 2011 at 10 a.m. in the Senate Finance Hearing Room at the Ohio Statehouse. Governor Kasich, Auditor of State David Yost, Secretary of State Jon Husted, House Speaker Bill Batchelder, and Senate Minority Leader Capri Cafaro will comprise the Board. The purpose of the meeting is to elect a Chair, Vice Chair, and Secretary for the Board. They will also adopt rules and procedures for the submission and comment of apportionment plans and for the notice and format of the regional hearings that will be held throughout Ohio. The Board must complete and public its work by October 5. The Board meets once every 10 years following the results of the federal decennial census. The five-member Board is responsible for redrawing boundaries for each of the 99 Ohio House and 33 Ohio Senate districts to reflect population changes. The Apportionment Board, established by Article 11 of the Ohio Constitution, consists of the Governor, Auditor of State, Secretary of State, and two members, one appointed by the majority party and one appointed by the minority party of the Ohio General Assembly. ### 18 LPL 000060 Draft Regional Hearing Schedule APPORTIONMENT BOARD PROPOSED REGIONAL HEARING SCHEDULE Monday, August 22, 2011 10:00AM - 12:0oPM Toledo University of Toledo College of Law Toledo, Ohio 43606 3:30PM - 5:30PM Findlay University of Findlay Findlay, Ohio Location TBD Tuesday, August 23, 2011 9:00AM -11:o0AM Cleveland Cleveland State University Maxine Goodman Levin College of Urban Affairs 1717 Euclid Avenue Cleveland, Ohio 44115 1:00PM - 3:00PM Akron University of Akron Akron, Ohio 44325 Location TBD 4:00PM - 6:00PM Canton Walsh University 2020 Easton Street N.W. North Canton, Ohio 44720 Wednesday, August 24, 2011 10:00AM -12:00PM Cincinnati University of Cincinnati Braustein Hall Cincinnati, Ohio 45221 2:00PM - 4:00PM Dayton University of Dayton Arena Lounge at the University of Dayton Arena Dayton, Ohio 45469 Thursday, August 25, 2011 9:00AM - 11:OOPM New Concord Muskingum College 163 Stormont Street New Concord, Ohio 43762 Friday, August 26, 2011 9:00AM - 11:00AM Newark The Ohio State University - Newark 1179 University Drive Newark, Ohio 43055 19 LPL 000061 2:00PM-4:00PM Columbus Columbus State Community College 550 East Spring Street Columbus, Ohio 43215 20 LPL 000062 Draft Agenda for Planning Meeting for Initial Apportionment Board Meeting ON AUGUST X, 2011 PLANNING MEETING FOR INITIAL MEETING OF APPORTIONMENT BOARD 1. Introductions 11. Pre-Apportionment Meeting Requirements a. Governor, Auditor, and Secretary of State oaths and bonds - to be provided by the Secretary of State's Office b. Letters of appointments for General Assembly members c. Agenda (see proposed 2011 agenda) i. Decision of who will be Chairman 1. Who will make motion 2. Who will second ii. Decision of who will be Vice Chairman 1. Who will make motion 2. Who will second iii. Decision of who will be Secretary 1. Who will make motion 2. Who will second iv. Discussion regarding attorney representation v. Decision on a court reporting agency (large for fast turn-around) vi. Decision on place for public review of apportionment plans (after deadline) 1. Who will make motion 2. Who will second ii. Decision on rules and procedures (hand out proposed rules) 1. Review and decide now or set deadline for proposed amendments? viii. Decision on date, time, and place of next meeting of the 2011 Apportionment Board 1. Decide now or set deadline to get back with members' availability? III. Public Participation IV. Miscellaneous Issues a. Sunshine Notice of Initial Meeting, regional and October meetings 21 LPL 000063 praftAgenda for Initial Apportionment Board Meeting AGENDA FORFIRST APPORTIONMENT BOARD ON AUGUST X, 2011 Attendees: John Kasich, Governor David Yost, Auditor Jon Husted, Secretary of State Bill Batchelder, House Speaker Capri Cafaro, Senate Minority Leader 1. Call to Order II. Election of Chair of Apportionment Board 111. Present Indicia of Office and Letters of Appointment IV. Selection of Secretary to the Board of Apportioning Persons V. Election of Vice Chair of Apportionment Board VI. Present Indicia of Office and Letters of Appointment VII. Announcement of Attorney Representation VIII. Appointment of official Court Reporter IX. Adoption of Rules and Procedures X. Designation of place for public review of proposed apportionment plan XI. Establishing time, date, and place of next meeting XII. Adjourn 22 LPL-000064 Draft Initial Apportionment Board Meeting Agenda & Script INITIAL APPORTIONMENT BOARD 1VIEETING.SCRIPT 1. Call to Order GOVERNOR KASICH: Pursuant to Article 11, Section 1 of the Ohio Constitution, I hereby call to order this meeting of the 2011 Board of Apportioning Persons. There is a quorum of members present, but for the record, would each member of the Board please indicate their presence by stating their name. [Members state names and titles] This meeting is called pursuant to Article II, Section 1 of the Ohio Constitution, which requires that after each decennial census, the Ohio Board of Apportioning persons - including the Governor, Secretary of State, Auditor of State, and two persons selected by the leadership of the General Assembly convenes between August 1 and October I of the year the census figures are released to establish the district lines of the Ohio General Assembly. Article I 1 of the Constitution governs the procedures for this apportionment, and we will therefore proceed under its provisions. II. Election of Chair o he Apportionment Board GOVERNOR KASICH: Members have been provided with a copy of the proposed agenda for this meeting, which was distributed in advance. The first item on the agenda is the selection of a chair. MEMBER: Mr. Governor, I move that Governor Kasich be named chair of the Apportionment Board. GOVERNOR KASICH: We have a motion. Is there a second? MEMBER: I second the motion. [Names member] seconds. The nomination has been made and GOVERNOR KASICH: [all say seconded. Are there any other nominations? If not, all if favor signify by saying aye aye]. Those opposed? Motion is carried,l will serve as chair. IIi. Present Indieia of Office and Letters of Appointment 23 LPL 000065 GOVERNOR KASICH: The next item of business is for the members of the Board to verify their membership on the Board by presenting their letters of appointment, in the case of legislative apportioning persons, and oaths of office in the case of other members. The Chair will now receive these documents. I would like to indicate for the record that I have the certificates of office for Secretary of State Husted, Auditor David Yost, and myself as Govemor. I also have a letter from Senator Cafaro, Minority Leader of the Ohio Senate, and Armond Budish, Minority Leader of the Ohio House, choosing and appointing [Senator/Representative X] to serve on this Board. The Chair has now received the appropriate documentation from each member, and it all appears to be in order. IV. Election of Secretary of Apportionment Board GOVERNOR KASICH: The next item on the agenda is for the selection of a secretary to the Board of Apportioning persons. The Secretary will keep the minutes, call the roll, and record all votes and maintain custody of all the records of the Apportionment Board, including the proposed plan to be filed with the Board. I will now entertain a motion for secretary. be named Secretary of the Apportionment Board. MEMBER: Mr. Chairman; I move that [name] GOVERNOR KASICH: We have a motion. Is there a second? MEMBER: I second the motion. second the motion. The nomination has been made GOVERNOR KASICH: [Names member] and seconded. Are there any other nominations? Is there any discussion of the nomination? If Those opposed? Motion is carried, [name] not, all if favor signify by saying aye [all say aye]. the custodian of the records, the documentation will serve as Secretary. I will now give [name], provided to me. V. Election of Vice Chair of Apportionment Board GOVERNOR KASICH: The next item on the agenda is the selection of a vice chair to the Board of Apportioning persons. I nominate [name] to serve as vice chair of the 2011 Apportionment Board. Is there a second? MEMBER: I second the motion. seconds the motion. The nomination has been made GOVERNOR KASICH: [Names member] 24 LPL 000066 and seconded. Are there any other nominations? Is there any discussion of the nomination? If Those opposed? If not, will the Secretary not, all if favor signify by saying aye [all say aye]. please call the role. [calls SECRETARY: For the selection of [name] as Vice Chair of the Apportionment Board, roll]. [Name] is selected Vice Chair of the Apportionment Board by a vote of X-X. VI. Announcement of Attorney Representation GOVERNOR KASICH: Historically, the Attorney General has represented the Board and all persons serving on the Board. Attomey General Dewine has appointed Mark Braden to be here today to be available to the Board. I would like to ask Mr. Braden to identify himself on the record. MARK BRADEN: Mr. Chairman, Members of the Board, I am Mark Braden, Counsel to the Board. GOVERNOR KASICH: Thank you, and welcome. VII. Appointment of Official Court Reporter GOVERNOR KASICH: At this point, given the official and historic nature of our proceedings, we need to appoint an official court reporter for the proceedings of the Apportionment Board. Accordingly, I will now entertain a motion to appoint an official court reporter for these proceedings. MEMBER: Mr. Chairman, I move that the firm of [name] be the official court reporter for the 2001 Apportionment Board and that said court reporter please prepare and provide each member of the Board a copy of the transcript of each of our meetings. MEMBER: I second the motion. seconds the motion. The nomination has been made GOVERNOR KASICH: [Names member] and seconded. Are there any other nominations? Is there any discussion of the nomination? If Those opposed? If not, will the Secretary not, all if favor signify by saying aye [all say aye]. please call the roll. SECRETARY: For the appointment of [name] as official court reporter for the 2001 Apportionment Board, [calls roll]. The motion carries X-X. C,OV-PuNrJR K-ASICH: Thank you. For the record, I'd like to ask our court reporter, who is here from the firm of [name], to please identify [his/her]self. 25 LPL 000067 [firm name] in [city], Ohio. REPORTER: My name is [name], court reporter with VIII. Adoption of Rules and Procedures GOVERNOR KASICH: This brings us to our next agenda item, which is the adoption of the rules of the 2011 Apportionment Board. All the members should have a copy of the proposed rules which I provided to each of you in advance of today's meeting. These proposed rules are, in essence, a revised version of the rules of the 2001 Apportionment Board which are on file with les as a block unless there the Legislative Service Commission. Otu' intention is to vote on the ru I would entertain a motion regarding the rules. is an amendment. At this time [If there is n motion to adopt the proposed rules as a block] MEMBER: Mr. Chairman, I move that we vote to adopt Rules X-X. MEMBER: Second. GOVERNOR KASICH: The motion has been made and seconded. Any discussion? If none, the Secretary will call the roll. The motion carries X-X. SECRETARY: On the motion to adopt Rules X-X [calls roll]. I [If there is a motion to amend the proposed rules] GOVERNOR KASICH: The motion has been made and seconded. Any discussion? MEMBER: Move to amend. moves to amend. Please describe your amendment. GOVERNOR KASICH: [name] blember proceeds to describe amendment. GOVERNOR KASICH: The amendment has been moved. MEMBER: Second. GOVERNOR KASICH: The motion has been made and seconded. Any discussion? If none, the Secretary will call the roll. SECRETARY: [calls Poll]. The motion to amend passes X-X. GOVERNOR KASICH: Is there further discussion on the proposed rules as amended? If not, will the secretary please call the roll on the motion to adopt the proposed rules. 26 LPL 000068 SECRETARY: [calls roll]. The motion to adopt rules X-X as amended passes X-X. GOVERNOR KASICH: The niles have been adopted. I instruct the Secretary of the Board to certify and file these rules forthwith as prescribed by the Ohio Revised Code. The rules we have just adopted provide for provide for a series of public hearings around the state to receive public input and comment on the apportionment plan. At this point I would entertain a motion to establish a schedule of these public hearings. MEMBER: Mr. Chairman, I had earlier distributed a proposed schedule stating the times and places for ten public hearings to be held in various locations around the state from August X to August X. I would move that we adopt the proposed schedule as the schedule of public hearings as required by our rules. GOVERNOR KASICH: Is there a second? MEMBER: Second. GOVERNOR KASICH: The motion has been made and seconded. Any discussion? If none, the Secretary will call the roll. SECRETARY: On the motion to adopt the public schedule of hearings, [calls roll]. The motion carries X-X. GOVERNOR KASICH: The Secretary is instructed to make the schedule available to the press and the public. IX. Designation of place for public review of proposed apportionment plan GOVERNOR KASICH: As I understand it, we need to designate a place or places where the public may review the plans of apportionment that are filed with the Board, pursuant to our own rules and procedures. Is there a motion on the designation of a place for public review of submitted plans? MEMBER: Mr. Cbairman, I move that the Board designate a website with the address of [URL] where public may review the plans that were submitted to the Board. MEMBER: Second. GOVERNOR KASICH: The motion has been made and seconded. Any discussion? If none, the Secretary will call the roll. SECRETARY: On the motion to designate the place where the public may view apportionment plans, calls roll]. The motion carries X-X. . 27 LPL 000069 GOVERNOR KASICH: The Secretary is instructed to make the website as the designated place for public review of plans available to the press. X. Establishing time, date, and place of next meeting time I will entertain a motion to establish the date and place of GOVERNOR KASICH: At this the next meeting of the 2011 Apportionment Board. of the Board be set for MEMBER: Mr. Chairman, I move that the next meeting [date/time/location]. MEMBER: Second. GOVERNOR KASICH: The motion has been made and seconded. Any discussion? If none, the Secretary will call the roll. SECRETARY: On the motion to set the date and location of the next Apportionment Board The motion carries X-X. meeting for [date/time/location]; [calls roll]. XI, Adjourn GOVERNOR KASICH: Any further business to come before the 2001 Apportionment Board? If not,1 will entertain a motion to recess the Board until [time/date/location]. MEMBER: Mr. Chairman, so moved. MEMBER: Second. GOVERNOR KASICH: The motion has been made and seconded. All in favor? Opposed? Thank you, the 2001 Apportionment Board is adjourned. 28 LPL 000070 2001 APPORTIONMENT BOARD RULES 11-01-01 Rule to Provide for Notification of Meeting (A) This rule is adopted in compliance with, and under authority of, section 121.22(F) of the Revised Code as amended, and effective November 28, 1975. (B) Any person may determine the time and place of all regularly scheduled meetings, and the time, place, and purpose of all specially scheduled meetings, of the state of Ohio apportioning persons by one of the following methods: (1) Writing to the Secretary of Apportioning Persons, c/o The Ohio Legislative Redistricting Task Force, The State House, Columbus Ohio 43215. (2) Calling the following telephone number during normal business hours (8:30 a.m. to 5:00 p.m., Monday through Friday): (614) 444-6680. (3) Consulting the public bulletin boards located on the 181h and 29'h Floors of the State Office Towner, 30 East Broad Street, Columbus, Ohio. (4) Any representative of the news media may obtain notice of all meetings of the apportioning persons by requesting in writing that such notice be provided. Such notice will be given, however, to one representative of any particular publication or radio or television station. A request of such notification shall be addressed to: Secretary to the Board of Apportioning Persons, c/o The Ohio Senate, Legislative Redistricting Task Force, The State House, Columbus, Ohio 43215. The request shall provide the name of the individual media representative to be contacted, the media representatives' mailing or e-mail address, and a maximum of two telephone numbers where the media representative can be reached. The Secretary shall maintain a list of all representatives of the news media who have reqnested notice of the meetings pursuant to this Chapter. In the event of a special meeting not of an emergency nature, the secretary shall notify all media representatives on the list of such meeting by doing at least one of the following: (a) Sending written notice, which must be mailed no later than four days prior to the date of the special meeting; (b) Notifying such representatives by telephone no later than twenty-four hours prior to the day of the special meeting; such telephone notice shall be complete if a message has been left for the representative, or, if after reasonable effort, the secretary has been unable to provide such telephone notice. (c) Informing such representative personally no later than twenty-four hours prior to the special meeting. 29 LPL 000071 (d) Notifying such representative by electronic mail, no later than twenty-four hours prior to the special meeting. In the event of a special meeting of an emergeney nature, the secretary shall notify all media representatives on the list of such meeting by providing either ( the notice described in paragraph (B)(4)(b) or B)(4)(d) of this rule or notifying the clerk of the state house press room. In such event, however, the notice need not be given twenty-four hours prior to the meeting, but shall be given innnediately upon the scheduling of such meeting. In giving the notices required by paragraph (B)(4) of this rule, the secretary may rely on assistance provided by any member of the secretary's staff, and any such notice is complete if given by such member in the manner provided in paragraph (B)(4) of this rule. person may receive notice of all meetings of the apportioning process. The secretary (C) Any shall maintain a list of all sucb persons who have requested such notifieation. In order to receive notification by electronic mail, such person must, in writing, provide the secretary with an e-mail address. In order to receive notification by mail, such person must provide to the secretary sufficient quantity of self-addressed, stamped envelopes for the mailing of the notices. Such notice of regular meetings shall be mailed no later than seven calendar days prior to the day of the meeting and such notice of special meetings shall be mailed as soon as possible prior to the meeting. The secretary may require persons requesting notice under paragraph (B)(B) of this rule to select from among categories of the public business of apportioning persons, which categories have been previously established by the secretary. Effective: 8-13-01 Certification 8-3-01 Date Promulgated under: Cb. 111.15 Statutory authority: Ohio Constitution, Art. XI, Sec. I Rule Amplifies: Sec. 121.22 Prior effective dates: 3/4/76, 9/7/91 011-01-02 "Apnortionment Board" Defined The term "Apportionment Board" is adopted for use in this chapter to designate the five persons directed by the Constitution of the State of Ohio, Article XI, Section 1, to establish the boundaries of House of Representatives and Senate districts in the federal decennial census 2000. Such persons, collectively, shall be referred to in this chapter as "Members" and, individually, as "Member." The rules stated herein, as supplemented by general parliamentary principles, shall be the rules of procedure of the Apportionment Board. Effective: 8-13-01 30 LPL 000072 Certification 8-3-01 Date Promulgated under: Ch. 111.15 Statutory authority: Ohio Constitution, Art. XI, Sec_ I Rule Amplifies: Ohio Constitution, Art. XI, Sec. 1 Prior effective dates: 9/7/91 011-01-03 Ooen Meetin>ss All meetings and public hearings of the 2001 Apportionment Board shall be held in accordance with the "Sunshine Law," section 121.22 of the Revised Code, and pursuant to rule 011-0-01 of the Administrative Code, as amended. Effective: 8-13-01 Certification 8-3-01 Date Promulgated under: Ch. 111.15 Statutory authority: Ohio Constitution, Art. XI, Sec. 1 Rule Amplifies: Ohio Constitution, Art. XI, Sec. 1 Prior effective dates: 9/7/91 011-01-04 Officers-Participation ofMembers; Minutes The Apportiomnent Board shall, by majority vote, election a Chair and a Vice Chair. The Board shall also elect, by majority vote, a Secretary of the Board, who does not have to be a Member. The Vice Chair shall assume the duties of the Chair when the Chair is unable to attend the meeting. Each Member shall be entitled to participate in all voting and debates, regardless of position held on the Apportionment Board. Minutes of each meeting of the Apportionment Board shall be maintained by a court reporter chosen by the Board by majority vote. At each meetingbf the Apportionment Board, the minutes of the previous meeting shall be circulated among the members and adopted by majority vote. Upon any Member's request, a transcript shall be provided upon completion and verification. Effective: 8-13-01 Certification 31 LPL 000073 8-3-01 Date Promulgated under: Ch. 111.15 Statutory authority: Ohio Constitution, Art. XI, Sec. I Rule Amplifies: Ohio Constitution, Art. XI, Sec. 1 Prior effective dates: 9/7/91 011-01-05 Calling of Meetings After the initial meeting of the Apportionment Board, at which the Board is convened, a meeting of the Apportionment Board may be called upon twenty-four hours notice. Such call and notice to each member of the apportionment board shall be issued by the Chair, or may be dispensed with if a motion to recess the meeting designates a time certain for continuation of the meeting. However, a meeting may be called by the Chair, upon proper notice, prior to a previously designed meeting, should the chair deem it necessary. Effective: 8-13-01 Certification 8-3-01 Date Promulgated under: Ch. 111.15 Statutory authority: Ohio Constitution, Art. XI, Sec. 1 Rule Amplifies: Ohio Constitution, Art. XI, Sec. 1 Prior effective dates: 9/7/91 011-01-06 uorum A majority of the five Members of the Apportionment Board constitutes a quorum. A majority of the quorum is empowered to act for the Board, provided, however, that a majority of the Board is required for the adoption of a plan of apportionment. All questions not committed by this chapter to the Chair's discretion, and all motions before the Apportionment Board shall be determined by majority vote. Members of the Apportionment Board or their designees may, from time to time, conduct public bearings referred to in role 011-01-08 of the Administrative Code absente a quorum of members. Effective: 8-13-01 Certification 8-3-01 Date Promulgated under: Ch. 111.15 32 LPL000074 Statutory authority: Ohio Constitution, Art. XI; Sec. 1 Rule Amplifies: Ohio Constitution, Art. XI, Sec. 1 Prior effective dates: 9/7/91 011-01-07 Consultation with Counsel and Other Advisors Members of the Apportionment Board may consult with their respective legal counsel and other advisors for a period not exceeding ten n7inutes and not to exceed three such consultations per meeting of the Board. However, the chair of the Apportionment Board may consult as often as the chair deems necessary with any legal counsel or other advisors regarding the rules and procedures. Effective: 8-13-01 Certification 8-3-01 Date Promulgated under: Ch. 111.15 Statutory authority: Ohio Constitution, Art. XI, Sec. I Rule Amplifies: Ohio Constitution, Art. XI, Sec. 1 Prior effective dates: 9/7/91 011-01-08 Public Hearines The Apportionment Board shall direct the Secretary of the Board to organize a series of public hearings in at least five locations around the State of Ohio for the Board Members or their designees to receive public comment and input on the apportionment process. The Secretary of the Board shall notify the Members o the Apportionment Board or their designees of the time, date, and location of each public hearing as soon a possible and in no event less than twenty-four hours prior to each public hearing. The Secretary of the Board shall notify the various media entities and other pertinent persons or organization of the public hearings not less than twenty-four hours prior to the public hearings. The Secretaiy of the Board shall preside over these public hearings. Members of the Apportionment Board need not be present at these public hearings. Each Member of the Apportionment Board may designate an individual(s) to represent the Member at any or all of these public hearings. Any individual so designated to represent a Member of the Board shall have no voting rights. No official business or action of the Apportionment Board, other than the receiving of public comment and input, shall take place at the public hearings referred to in this rule. Effective: 8-13-01 Certification 33 LPL 000075 8-3-01 Date Promulgated under: Ch. I 11.15 Statutory authority: Ohio Constitution, Art. XI, Sec. 1 Rule Amplifies: Ohio Constitution, Art. XI, Sec. 1 Prior effective dates: 9/7/91 011-01-09 Apnortionment Plans Any person or organization may submit for the consideration of the Apportionment Board a detailed plan for the apportionment of the members of the Ohio General Assembly. Apportionment plans submitted for consideration should be complete for the entire state, with legal definitions of the proposed boundaries. Partial apportionment plans which propose the minority districts need not be complete for the entire State, but should include legal definitions of the boundaries of adjacent districts. Plans submitted to the Board for consideration shall be submitted to the secretary of the board at the address specified in Rule 011-0-01 of the Administrative Code. Ten paper copies of each plan shall be submitted. In addition to the required paper copies, plans may be submitted electronically via electronic mail to an e-mail address to be announced by the Secretary, or on a CD-ROM Disk with and indication of the format it is in to the address specified in rule 011-1-01 of the Administrative Code. The Secretary of the Board shall deliver promptly, but in no event later than 12:00 P.M., September 25, 2001, to the Members of the Apportionment Board one copy of each plan submitted and shall retain the remaining copies for review by the public at a place or places designated by the Board. Effective: 8-13-01 Certification 8-3-01 Date Promulgated under: Ch. 111.15 Statutory authority: Ohio Constitution, Art. XI, Sec. 1 Rule Amplifies: Ohio Constitution, Art. XI, Sec. 1 Prior effective dates: 9/7/91 011-01-10 Consideration of Apportionment Plans- Adoption of Plan The Apportionment Board shall reconvene during the week of September 24, 2001, to consider the various plans submitted to the Board and shall meet on or before October 1, 2001, to adopt an appropriate plar, for the apportionment of the members of the Ohio General Assembly. 34 LPL 000076 During the meeting or meetings of the Board the week of September 24, 2001, a sponsor of a play may personally or through a representative present the substance of their plan to the Members of the Apportionment Board for a period not to exceed ten minutes, unless extended by a majority of the Board. The public may offer testimony or comment not to exceed five minutes on any apportionment plan before the Board, unless extended by a majority of the Board. The Chair of the Apportionment Board may limit testimony or comment on plans before the Board as the Chair deems necessary. Any person wishing to testify on a given plan must provide notice to the Chair or the Secretary of the Board prior to the meeting scheduled to consider the various plans submitted. Members of the Apportionment Board may ask questions of those persons testifying on the various apportionment plans before the Board during the meeting scheduled to consider those plans. Members of the Board may request testimony from experts during this meeting. Only those persons sponsoring an apportionment plan may offer amendments to said plan for the consideration of the Members of the Apportionment Board. The Chair of the Apportionment Board may offer amendments on behalf of those persons sponsoring apportionment plans who are not members of the Apportionment Board. Effective: 8-13-01 Certification 8-3-01 Date Promulgated under: Ch. 1 I 1.15 Statutory autbority: Ohio Constitution, Art. Xl, Sec. 1 Rule Amplifies: Ohio Constitution, Art. Xl, Sec. I Prior effective dates: 9/7/91 011-01-11 Publication of Apportionment Plan When the apportionment plan is determined and adopted by a majority vote of the Apportionment Board, the Governor shall arrange for publication of such apportionment plan no later than October 5, 2001. Certification 8-3-01 35 LPL 000077 Date Promulgated under: Ch. 111.15 Statutory authority: Ohio Constitution, Art. XI, Sec. I Rule Amplifies: Ohio Constitution, Art. XI, Sec. 1 Prior effective dates: 9/7/91 011-01-12 Reconvening the Apportionment Board Should further action be necessary pursuant to Article XI, Section 13 of the Constitution of the State of Ohio, this Apportionment Board shall reconvene at the request of the Goverrtor subject to this chapter. Effective: 8-13-01 Certificatio 8-3-01 Date Promulgated under: Ch: 111.15 Statutory authority: Ohio Constitution, Art. XI, Sec. 1 Rule Amplifies: Ohio Constitution, Art. XI, Sec. I Prior effective dates: 9/7/91 36 LPL 000078 From: Mann, Heather To: Hansen, Beth; Grodhaus, MichaelL Carle Matt• Subject: Ohio deviation charts and maps Date: Friday, July 08, 2011 7:27:34 AM Attachments: OH 10HABR. pdf OH lOXABR.pdf OH10YABR:pdf 39pIHRHO.pdf 39pfHDEV.pdf 39pIYDEV.pdf 39pIXDEV.pdf 39pIYRHO.pdf 39ptXRHO.pdf Dear Beth, Michael, and Matt: Attached are the maps and data sets that I brought to the meeting yesterday. I wanted to make sure we shared the full set with you (we provided these to the Auditor and Secretary's offices as well). Please do not forward these to other parties at this time. Thank you, Heather Mann Heather N. Mann, Esq. Redistricting Director & Dep. Legal Counsel House Republican Caucus Ohio House of Representatives 77 South High Street, 14th Floor Columbus, Ohio 43215 (614) 466-9194 - Office (614) 719-3594 - Fax (614) 352-5819 - Cell heather.mannoohr.state.oh.us CONFIDENTIA! I fY NOTICE The information conlained in this e-mail is inkended only for the use of the individuat or entily to which it is addressed and it may contain information that is oriv6eged, confitlential, attorney wosk product andtor exempt from disclosure under applicable law. If the reader of this message is noi the intended recipieoi (or the employee or agent responsible to deliver it to Ihe intended recipienQ, you are hereby notified that any dlssemination, distribution, or copying of this e-mail is prohibited If you have received this e-mafl in error, please notify the sender by return e-mall, LPL 000079 Potitical Districts Redistricting Handbook for OHIO Page 39.Y.1 Racial Subgroups for STATE SENATE Hancock, FuHon, Putnam, Defiance*, Williams.,. Hite, Cliff (R) 2010 VAP Y of Pop 2010 Pap. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 264,784 75.4% 351,303 1,712 0.49% Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn P. Oth MRT 2010 Pop 92.3 0.9 5.0 0.2 0.6 0.0 0.1 1.0 0.9 3.9 0.2 0.6 0.0 0.0 0.6 2010VAP 93.9* Lucas*, Wood, Erie, Ottawa** Wagoner, Mark (R) 2010 VAP Y of Pop 2010 P.P. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 281,297 77.4% 363,296 13,705 3.92% Pac Oth MRT ^ Wht Blk Hsp InA 0.sn 2010 Pop 88.7 4.2 3.7 0.2 1.6 0.0 0.1 1.5 2910 VAP 90.5* 3.9 3.0 0.2 1.5 0.0 0.1 0.9 Franklin* Bacon, Kevin (R) 2010 VAP % af Pop 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 306 ,538 74.7 % ^ 410,561 80.970 17.44% Oth MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI Wht Bik Hsp Ind Asn Pac 2010 Pnp 67.9 21.0 4.6 0.2 3.3 0.0 0.2 2.7 -0.3 0.3 0.0 0.0 0.1 2010 VAP 71.9* 19.1 3.9 0.2 3.3 0.0 0.1 1.5 O 5 Butler 4 Cates, Gary (R) 2010 VAP % of Pop 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 275,526 74.8% 368,130 16,539 5.30% Asn Pac Oth MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI ^ Wnt BIk Hap nd 2010 Pop 84.3 7.2 4.0 0.2 2.4 0.1 0.1 1.8 2010VAP 86.6* 6.6 3.2 0.2 2.4 0.1 0.1 1.0 0.3 0.2 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.0 Montgomery*, Miami'. Darke* Beagle, Bil{(R) 2010VAP %ofPap 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 242.159 76.1 % 318,239 -31,352 -8.97% Wbt Blk Hsp nd Asn Pac Oth MRT WB WI WA WP WO Bt 0.2 2.2 2010 Pop 64.9 29.4 2.10.2 0.2 1.0 0.9 0.0 0.0 0.1 1.4 0.4 0.2 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.1 2010 VAP 67.8 * 27.9 1.7 Montgomery* 6 Lehner, Peggy (R) 2010VAP hofPOp 2010 Pap. Abs Dev, Rel Oev. 260.347 77-3°%. 336,772 -12,819 -3.67%. We WI WA WP WO BI ^ Wbt. Blk Hsp nd Asn Pac Oth MRT 2010 Pop 87.7 5.8 2.1 0.2 2.2 0.0 0.1 1.9 2010VAP 89.5* 5.3 1.7 0.2 2.2 0.0 0.1 1.1 0.3 0.3 0.3 0.0 0.0 0.0 Hanlilton', Warren Jones, Shannon (R) 2010 VAP % of Pop 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 281,239 74,2% 378,958 29,367 8.40% ^. Wht BIk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Otb MRT 2010 Pop 87.7 4.9 2.2 0.1 3.5 0.0 0.1 1-5 2010VAP 88.8* 5.0 1.8 0.1 3.2 0.0 0.10.9 HamiMton' Seitz, William (R) 2010 VAP %of Pop 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Bel Dev. 255.408 75.7"e 337,451 -12,140 - 3A7% Pac Oth MRT ^ Wht Blk Hsp Ind Aso 2010 Pop 76.0 17.5 2.4 0.1 1.9 0.1 0.2 1.8 16.0 2.0 0.1 1.9 0.1 0.1 0.9 2010VAP 78.9* . ':!arniiiorP t:ear (D) 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 230.305 77.14a 293.658 -50.933 -14.57:%, Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Qth MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI 2010 Pop 47.9 45.0 2.9 0.2 1.6 0.1 0.2 2.2 2010VAP 52.5* 41.3 2.5 0.2 1.8 0.1 0.1 1.4 05 0.2 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.2 R) Demographic and Politlcal Guides. All Rights Reserved. Copyright (c) 2011. Palidata. www polidzta.org POLIDATA ( PL94-171 Redistricting Data from U S. Bureau of the Census. 2000 Gensus dzta from various sources. Stale population:11,536,504, 33 members, ideal is 349,591. I. Population for 2010 from give a rough approximation of the recial breaks for the current district. The overall size of each pie is scaled to the ideal populOther,oMWts Race^ tYpe 2. Pie Chatls starfng at 3 bckck): White, Black, Hispanic, Am. Indian, Asian, Pacific Islander, are in the following counter-clockwise order ( 4.3. RacialThe sllces breaks zre for RxcelHispan¢ Origin Combination. MRT is Multi-Racial Total persons. The sum of these, aside from rountling, shoultl be 100 percent. * for predominant group. are included if MRT is over 1%. White-Black, White-Am.lndian, White-Asian, White-Paci(c, White-Olher and Black-Am Indian. 5. Additional breaks 139pIYRH0-pspleb12-RC151 LPL 000080 Redistricting Handbook for OHIO Political Districts Racial Subgroups for STATE SENATE Page 39. Y.2 Greene, Clark, Madison 10 Widener, Chris (R) 2010 VAP % of Pop 201DPap. AbsDev. RelDev. 2E5,756 77:7% 343,341 -6,250 -1.79% Intl Asn Pac Oth MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI ^ Wht Blk Hsp 2010 Pop 85.7 7.7 2.3 0.2 1.7 0.0 0.2 2.2 201oVAP87.2 7.6 1.9 0.2 1.7 0.0 0.1 1.3 0.30.2 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.1 L uca E3.cvvn. Euna ;D) 2010VAP %afPOp 2010POp. AbsDev. RelDev. 314,125 -35,466-10.15% 23°,OiO 76.iwo WA WP WO BI Wht BIk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Ottr MRT WB WI 23f0 Pop 63.9 24.6 7.3 0.3 1.1 0.0 0.2 2.7 2010 VAP 68.4* 22.8 5.7 0.3 1.2 0.0 0.1 1.5 05 0.2.0.2 0.0 0.0 0.1 Allen, Darke", Streiby, Mercer; Champaign.:. 12 Faber, Keith (R) 2010 1 Abs Dev. Rel D.V. 2010 VAP % of Pop 346,477 -3,".14 -0.89% 259^162 74.9`;: ^ Wht elk HsP Ind Asn Pac Olh MRT 2010 PoV 91.7 4.3 1.6 0.2 0.6 0.0 0.1 1.5 2010 VAP 93.1' 4.1 1.2 0.2 0.6 0.0 0.1 0.8 13 mznnicn, Gay;'e (D) 2010 P.P. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 0 VAP % of Pop 5.98% 280,332 75.7% 370,509 20,918 Wht Bik Hsp Ind Asn Pac 01h MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI 2610 Pop 82.4 6.7 7.8 0.2 0.8 0.0 0.1 2.01.1 03 0.2 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.1 2010 VAP 85.2" 6.4 6.2 0.2 0.8 0.0 0.1 Clermont, Scioto. erovvn. Lawrence. Adams 14 Niehaus, Tom (R) 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010 P.P. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 286,844 75.3% 380,921 31,330 8.96% ^ Wht Blk HsP lod Asn Pzc 0fh MRT 0.6 0.0 0.1 1.3 2010 Pop 95.1 1.5 1.2 0.3 2010VAP 95.8* 1.5 0.9 0.3 0.6 0.0 0.0 0.9 Prankiin' Tavarss. Chrleta B. (D) 2010 VAP % of Pop 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 282,014 77.3% 364,680 15,089 4.32% Oth MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac 2010 PoP 52.7 36.9 4.8 0.3 2.2 0.1 0.2 2.8 2010VAP 57.8' 33.4 3.9 0.3 2.5 0.1 0.1 1.9 06 0.2 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.2 16 Hughes, Jim (R) 2010 VAP b of Pop 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 296.320 76:3% 388,173 38,582 11.04% Oth MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac 80.3 6.0 5.0 0.2 6.0 0.1 0.2 2.3 2010 Pop 5.5 4.1 0.2 6.0 0.0 0.1 1.4 0.3 0.4 0.4 0.0 0.0 0.1 2010VAP 82.8* Ross, Lawrence, Jackson, Highland, Pickaway', Gallia, 17 Daniels, David T. (R) 2010 VAP Y of Pop 2010 Pop. Abs11,220 Dev. Rel Dev. 3.21% 274,252 76.0% 360,811 Wht BIk FisP Intl Asn Pac Oth MRT 2.8 1.0 0.3 0.4 0.0 0.1 LS 2010 PoP 94.0 0.0 0.0 0.9 94.4* 3.1 0.8 0.3 0.4 ^ 2010VAP Lake, Geauga. Cuyahoga' 18 GrendeH, Timothy (R) . 201o VAP %of Pop 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 266,028 77.0% 345.273 -4,318 -1.24% Ind Asn Fac Oth MRT Wht Blk Hsp 0.0 0.1 1.2 2010 PoP 91.8 2.8 2.7 0.1 1.4 2.7 2.0 0.1 1.4 0.0 0.1 0.6 G) 21 93.2 R) Demographic and Political Guides. All Rights Reserved. CopYfight (c) 2011. Polidata, www politlata org POLIDATA ( for 2010 from PL94-171 Redistncting Oata hom US. Bureau of Me Census. 2000 Census data from various sources. State population:11,536,504v,pe33 members, ideal is 349,591. 1. Population the give a rough approximation of+he tacial breaks for the current disnict. The overall size of each piets scaled pa 2. Pie Chens ci clslandeq101M1eq MtulGRacel^ are in the following counter-clockwise arder (starling at 3 o'olock): W hite, Black, Hispanic, Am. Indian, Asian, 3. The slices are for Race/Hispanic Origin Combination. MRT is Multi-Racial Total persons. The sum of these, aside from rounding, should be 100 pement.' for predominant group. 4. Racial breaks brezks are included if MRT is over 1%. Wh'rfe-Black, White-Am.lndian, White-ASian, White-Pacific, White-0ther and Black-Am Indian. 5. Atlditionzl 199pIYRH0-psp1eEl2-KC15I LPL 000081 Political Districts Redistricting Handbook for OHIO Page 39.Y.3 Racial Subgroups for STATE SENATE Delaware, Richland,Knox, Ashland', Morrow 19 Jordan, Kris (R) 2010 VAP %of Pop 2016Pop. AbsDev. RelDev. 301,481 74.2% 406,557 56,966 16.30! Pac Oth MRT Wht Bik Hsp Ind Asn 0.0 0.1 1.5 2010 Pop 90.0 4.4 1.6 0.1 2.1 2010VAP 91.0* 4.5 1.3 0.2 2.0 0.0 0.1 0.9 Muskingum, Washington, Coshocton. Athens'... 2010VAP %ofPOp 20 Stewart, Jimmy (R) 2010 Pap. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 280,495 78.4% 357,708 8,117 2.32% Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI ^ Wlrt BIk Hsp 2010 Pop 94.2 2.1 0.9 0.2 0.8 0.0 0.1 1.7 2010 VAP 94.9' 2.1 0.7 0.2 0.8 0.0 0.1 1.1 0.3 0.1 0.1 0.0 0.0 0.0 ahO:7z'. 21 ..^:1 `, SyirieyA. (C? 2010 VAP^% of Pop 2Ui0 P.P. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 212,591 75.8% 280,358 -69,233 -19.80'-0 MRT WB WI WA WP WO Bi Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth 0.2 2.4 0.0 0.2 1.8 2010 Pop 34.8 53.2 7.4 1.4 0.4 0.2 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.2 0 2010 VAP 38.8 50.2 6.4 0.2 2.9 0.0 0.1 Medina, Ashlani Wayne. Halmes 22 Obhof, Larry (R) 2010VAP %oiPOp 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 273,023 73.7% 370,237 20,646 5.91% MRT Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac 00t 1.0 2010 Pop 95.4 1.1 1.4 0.1 0.8 0.0 0.1 0.7 2010 VAP 96.2' 1.1 1.1 0.1 0.8 0.0 0.0 t:ui 2010 VAP % of Pop $Kin02'I, r4ilf.h38i J, (0) 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 244,920 78.5`v 311,985 -37600 -10 76°%0 WP WD BI Wht Blk Hap Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT WB WI WA 2010 Pop 77.5 9.0 8.8 0.2 2.3 0.0 0.2 1.9 2010VAP 81.2' 7.9 7.1 0.2 2.3 0.0 0.1 1.1 .0.30.20.20.00.00.1 Cuyahoga' 2D10 VAP % of Pop 24 Patton, Thomas (R) 2010 P.P. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 280,39B 78,0;a 359,580 9,989 2.86 % Ind 'ASn Pac Oth MRT G) WM Blk HsP 0.0 0.1 1.2 zotOPOp 69.5 3.6 2.1 0.1 3.4 3.4 1.7 0.1 3.2 0.0 0.1 0.7 2010 VAP 90.8 C=.^ehoga' 2$ TU;rfeGldfoa D) 2010VAP %ofPap 2010 PoR Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 234,090 76.4 %. 306355 -43,235-12-37°0 Wht Bik Hsp 9nd Asn Pac Oth MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI 2010 Pop 34.8 59.9 1.6 0.1 1.6 0.0 0.2 1.8 2010VAp 38.3 57.3` 1.4 0.1 1.6 0.0 0.1 1.2 0.4 0.1 0.1 0.0 0.0 0.2 ' Sandusky, Seneca', Ottawa', Marion, Crawford, Union... 26Gillmor, Karen (R) 20to VAP % ot Pop 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dem 263,535 75.8% 347,603 -1,982 -0.57% Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT G Wht Blk Hsp 2010 Pop 91.5 2.6 3.4 02 0.8 0.0 0.1 1.4 2010VAP 92.9` 2.7 2.6 0.2 0.8 0.0 0.0 0.8 Summit 27 LaRose, Frank (R) 2010 VAP %of Pop 2010 PaP. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 267,438 7E.8°, 348,274 4,317 -0-3840 WI WA WP WO 81 Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT WB G Wht Blk Hsp 2010 Pop 85.8 8.3 1.4 0.2 2.4 0.0 0.1 1.8 20002010VAP VAP 88.0 88.0 7.4 7.4 1.1 1.1 0.2 0.2 2.2 2.2 0.0 0.0 0.1 0.1 1.0 1.0 02 0.2 02 0.0 0.0 0.1 c) 2011. Polidata. www polidata org R) Demographic and Pofiticzl Guides. AII RigM1ts Reserved. Copyright ( POLIDATA1. Population ( for 2010 from PL94-171 Redistricting Data from U S. Bureau of the Census. 2000 Census data from various sources. State population: 11,536,504, 33 members, tdeaf is 349,581. give a rough approximafion of the raclal breaks for the current district. The overall size of each pie is scaled [o the ideal popula6un for this district type. 2. Pie Charls starfing at 3 o'cbck): White, Black, Hispanic, Am. Indian, Asian, Pacific Islander, Other, Mulli-Race. ( 3. The slices are in the following counter-olockwise order and Bla^k-Am Ind art 100 percent.' for pretlominant group. 4. Raclal breaks are for RacelHispanic Origin Combination. MRT is MuXi-Racaf Tolal persons. Th^hite-Pac fc^ WMte-0ther 5. Additional breaks are included if MRT is over 1%. White-Black; White-Am.lndian, WhRe-Asian, p9pIYRHo-psp1ed12-KC161 LPL 000082 Redistricting Handbook for OHIO Political Districts Racial Subgroups for STATE SENATE Page 39.Y.4 " . Sktmrr:E°, Fo[ia,1a {D) . . . 2010 VAP °h of PoP. 28 Sawy?s,Th0ma2 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dem 278,509 78.5% 354,926 5,335 1.53 % ind Asn Pac Oth MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI Wht Blk Hsp 2010 Pop 79.0 15.5 1.6 0.2 1-6 0.0 0.1 1.9 2010VAP 81.2' 14.3 1.4 0.2 1.7 0.0 0.1 1.2 0.3 0.2 02 0.00.0 0.1 Stark' 2010 VAP % of Pop 29 Oels[ager, Scott (R) 2010 Pap. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 259.935 77:0% 337.506 -12,035 -3.46',5 - Ofh MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI Wht Blk HsP Ind Asn Pac 2010 Pop 87.6 7.6 1.6 0.2 0.7 0.0 0.2 2.0 2010 VAP 89.8 6.8 1.3 0.2 0.7 0.0 0.1 1.1 0.3 0.1 0.1 0.0 0.0 0.1 Cr„um5 J i^;zra'az .e3'srs:Jn,H7rt^ror..- 2010VAP %ofPOp 3C- i/Lfi15or=...7%s'e?D) 2010 P.P. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 266,185 78.6"o y^ 338,710 -10,881 -3.11% . . . ^..../ Wht BlkHsp Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT 2010 Pop 94.0 2.9 13 0.1 0.3 0.0 0.1 1.3 2010VAP 94.7 3.0 1.1 0.1 0.3 0.0 0.0 0.7 Licking, Fairfield, Perry. Hocking, Pickaway 2010 VAP % of Pop 31 SchafPer, Tim (R) 201p Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 301,729 74.7% 403,786 54,195 15.50% Oth MRT Wht BIk Hsp Ind Asn Pac 3.7 1.4 0.2 0.7 0.0 0.1 1.6 2010POP 92.3 0.0 0.1 D.9 2010 VAP 93.6 3.3 1.1 0.2 0.7 . . . 'i:u,r:bus;.Ashiabuia 2010 VAP % of Pop Ca13 2010Pop. AtisDev. RelDev. . . . 241,170 77.3% 311,809 -37,782 -10.81% Wht BIk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Ottr MRT 0.0 0.1 1.7 2010 Pop 89.0 6.6 2.0 0.2 0.4 201o VAP 90.7 6.3 1.5 0.2 0.4 0.0 0.0 0.9 . n1a<,^,rJr0. Siark"'. Carroll, Tuscar;sas" " 2010VAP %ofPOp 33 Schia;mnl, -cce (U) 201DPOy. AbsDev. RelDee 252,631 78.1% 323.425 -26,166 -7.481- Wht BIk Hsp hd Asn Pac Oth MRT 2010PoP 81.7 12.1 3.7 0.2 0.60.0 0.1 1.6 2010 VAP 84.0' 11.2 3.1 0.2 0.6 0.0 0.1 0.9 c) 2011. Folidata. www polidata.org is 349,591. R) Demograpbic and Political Guides. All Rights Reserved. Copyright ( POLIDATAi. Populafion ( for 2010 (rom PL94-171 Retlistricting Data irom D S. Bureau of the Census. 2000 Census data from various sources. State populalion: 11,536,504, 33 members, ideal c pie t mion 2 . Pie Charts give a rough appraximation of Rie racial breaks for the cunent district. The overaN size of ea PatificdlslandeclOtM1eroMUlYS Race^ ryPe starting at 3 o'clock): White, Black, Hispanic, Am.hIr are in the following counterclockwisa order ( 3. TheRzcial slices breaks are for RaceJHispanic Origin Combination. MRT is Multi-Racial Total persons. The sum of these, aside from rounding, should be 100 percent.' for predominant group. WhiteAFher 5. Additional breaks zre included if MRT is over 1%, VJhite-Black, WhiYe-Am.lndian, WhMe-Asian, Whife-Pacific, and Black-Am Intllan. H9plvarvo-psPled12-rcm51 LPL 000083 Political Districts Redistricting Handbook for OHIO Page 39.Y.5 Racial Subgroups for STATE SENATE Ranked by 2010 Minority Voting Age Population for Selected Subgroups Asian Oistrlct Minority HSpILat Black ED Member 1-6 CugaFa:ga` . 61 4 57.3 a Iner'vna(G) . 7 -v 5n2 23 0.2 eri S i @ S ^[.h, y trc., "(D) 2_5 45.3 ka` klamhtan` 4^ 4 Frankfi7` . K=aineY. Eric `t (0) 9.9 3i4 2.5 42.2 ntgomery' , Miami', Darke' Tavares. Chreta B- (D) 32.3 1 .7 27.9 1.0 Mo Beag le, Blll(R) 1.2 Lilcas` 31,6 5.7 228 4row^., E6rla iDl Franklin' 28.1 3.9 19.1 3.3 (R) . 1.9 Harn Iton' Bacon, Kevin 21.1 2 .0 16 0 illiam (R) 14.3 = 7 Surr ^ polidata.org and Political GuiOes. All Rights Reserved. Copynght (c) 2011. Polidzta. PL94-171 Redistricting Data from U S. Bureau ofthe Cersus.2000 Census dato from vanous soumes. Sfate population:11,536,504, 33 members, ideal is 349,591. POLIDATA (R) Demographic rype. 1. Population (or 2010 6om overall size af each pie is swled to the ideal population for tM1ls is Ic for fie current districL The Asian, Pzcifc Isiznder, Other, MuIGRzce . 2. Ple Charts give a rougM1 approximalion of tlie radal breaks (statling at 3 o'cbck): White, Bleck, Hispanic, Am. lntlian, S The slices are in the followin9 counter-clockwise ortler RaceMispznic OriginGombinatlon. MRT i^h`Qi^m.lndiam White Asun,hWhite-Pacifc, Whita-Other antl BIa9k-Am Ind be 1 00 percenL"for pretlominantgroup. 4. Racial breaks are for 5 Atlditional breaks are included if MRT is over 1%. White-Black, [d9PIYRH0-P5ple02-1 LPL000085 Political Districts Redistricting Handbook for OHIO Page 39.X.1 Distrtct Populations for STATE HOUSE Columbiana 1 Newbold, Cralg (R) 2010 VAP %of Pop 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Ret Dev. g4 >57 78.196 107.841 -9,689 -7.46% Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn P. OIh MRT 2010 Pop 94.9 22 1.3 02 0.3 0.0 01 1,2 2010 VAP 953' 2.3 1.2 0.2 0.3 0.0 0.0 0.7 Delaware 2 Brenner,Andrew(R) 2010VAP %orPOp 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 123,710 71.0% 174,214 57,684 49.50% Wht Bik Hsp Ind Asn P. Oth MRT 2010 Pop 88.4 3.3 2.1 01 4.2 00 0.1 1 7 0.0 0.1 0.9 2010VAP 89.8 3.2 1.7 0.1 4.1 rArayne Amstutz, Ran (R) 2010 VAP %of Pop 2010 Pop. AbsDev. Rel Dev. 85, â 7s 74.6-0 114.520 -2,010 -1..3'% ^ Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn P. Olh MRT 2010 Pop 94.7 1-5 1.6 0.1 0.8 0.0 01 1.3 2010 VAP 95.5' 1 4 1.3 0.1 0.8 0.0 0.1 0.8 Allen 4 Hufiman, Malt (R) 2010VAP %ofPop 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 80 S86 76. i -% 100,331 .10,199 -8.7530 Wht Bik Msp fnd Asn Pac Olh MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI 2010 Pop 82.5 11.8 2.4 02 0.7 0.0 0.3 2.3 2010VAP 85.0' 11.0 1.9 0.2 0.7 0.0 0.1 1.1 0.4 0.1 0.1 0.0 0.0 01 Fairf!eld 5 Stebellon. Gerald (R) 20100 VAP % of Pop Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 146,156 29,626 25.42% 107,747 7 3 To Wht BIk Hsp Ind Asn Pae Oth MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI 2010 Pop 69.2 5.9 1.7 0.2 1.1 0.0 0.1 1.7 2010 VAP 91.1 5.3 1.4 0.2 1.0 0.0 0.1 1.0 02 0.2 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.0 W Wood 6 Gardner, Randy (R) 2010VAP %afPOp 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 98,213 78.3% 125,488 8,958 7.69% Wht Blk Rsp Ind Asn Paa Oth MRT 2010 Pop 90.1 2.3 4.5 02 1.5 0.0 0.1 1.3 2010VAP 91.3' 2.5 3.6 0.2 1.5 00 0.1 0.9 Creancga' 2010VAP %OfPOp 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 19,0i9 77.1% 1172.553 -13,973 -1199'a Whl Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI 2010 Pop 42.6 52.2 1.7 0.2 1.2 0.0 02 1.9 2010VAP 47.9' 47,9 1.4 0.1 1.3 0.0 0.1 1.2 0.40.1 0.1 0.0 0.0 0.2 Cu^ailc's 2010VAP 2010 P.P. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. %ofFop45? 7 6 b,c 10-966 -11,564 -992°6 ' . Whl BIk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI 2010 Pop 36.2 57.1 1.8 0.1 2.8 0.0 0.2 1.6 2010VAP 38.1 56.1 1.5 0.1 2.7 0.0 01 1.2 0.4 0.1 0.1 0.0 00 02 uyahogv' °osd 2010VAP %afPOp 2010 Pop- Abs Dev. Rel Dem 73.002 7s 8:6 9's.568 2„02 -1971`YU - Wht BIk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Olh MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI 2010POp 37.5 55.0 1 8 0.2 3.4 0.0 0.2 2.0 2010 VAP 39.9 52.6 1.7 0.2 4.0 0.0 0.2 1.5 0 5 0.3 0.3 0.0 0.0 0.2 ^Ff R) Demographic and Political Guides. All Rights Reserved. Copyrighl (c) 2011. Politlata, vmw polldata org POLIDATA ( from various sources. State population: 11,536,504, 99 members, itleal is 116$30. for 2010 from PL94-171 Retlistrlcling Data Irom U 5. Bureau of the Census. 2000 Census dala 1. Population districl. The overall size of each pie is scaled to the Ideal population for this dislrict lype. give a rough approximalion of the devialionfrom the 20101dezl Populzlion for Ihe currenl 2 Pie Charts extra populalion). A While pie, or a Grey slice, indicates a negalive deviation (short populafion). intlicales apositive devialion ( 3. A Grey pie, or a Whilelor RacelHispanic slice, Origin Combination-MRT is Mulli-Racial Tolal persons. The sum of tlrese, asitle from rounding, should be 100 percent.' for predominant group. 4 Raclal breaks are White-ASian, While-Pacific, White-Other and Black-Am Indian. 5. Additional breaks are included it MRT is over 1%. Whlte-Black, While-Amindian, 139pIXDEV-pspledl2-kF301 LPL 000086 Redistricting Handbook for OHIO Political Districts District Populations for STATE HOUSE Page 39.X.2 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010 P.P. Abs Dev- Rel Dev 71 448 7'- 0% 92,627 -23,903 -2051% Asn Pac Oih MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI Wht BIk Hsp Ind 2.6 0.0 0.2 1.9 2010 Pop 32.9 47,4 14.8 0.3 0.4 0.1 0.1 0.0 0.0 0.2 2010 VAP 37.0 . 45.4' 12.8 0.3 3.0 0.0 0.2 1.3 . . Cuqahoga" t Il;an- Sandlc (17) - 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010POp. AbsDSv_ Re1Dev. 08,241 72.55 94,t63 -22,367 -19-t9i'e Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI 2010 Pop 33.9 57.1 5.7 0.2 1.3 0.0 0.1 1.7 2010VAP 39.3 52.7 4.8 0.2 1.6 0.0 0.1 1.30.4 0.1 01 00 0.0 0.2 . . Cuxnnoc•,a' ' . 2010 VAP %of Pop 2010POp. AbsDev. RelDev. _ 74,5b7 754% 98.837 -17,693 -15.16°6 Whi Blk Hsp InJ Asn Pac Olh MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI 2010 Pop 25.1 70.9 1.4 0.2 0.7 0.0 0.1 1.5 2010 VAP 28.3 68.6' 1.1 0.2 0.7 0.0 0.1 1.0 0.3 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.2 ;;uyahog3. AN[1r)IJ, fv'ir4iC i , 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010 Pop- Abs Dev. Ret Dev. 77 , 01 '7 5% 99,462 -17,068-14.65% Wht BIk Hsp Intl Asn Pac Oth MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI 2010 Pop 67.5 14.3 13.2 0.3 1.9 0.0 0.3 2.5 2010 VAP 72.3' 12.7 10.9 0.3 1.9 00 0.2 1.6 0.4 0.3 0.3 0.0 0.0 0.1 :;:ry`ahaga' 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dem 80,578 778`c 103,628 -12.902 ;1 07% - - Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI 2010 Pop 74.6 11.0 9.6 0.2 2.4 0.0 0.1 2.0 2010 VAP 79.0 9.6 7.6 0,2 2.4 0.0 0-1 1.1 0.3 0.2 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.1 Cupaho:}a' LeGC^,c,. ^ ^r.Othy (D; 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010POp. AbsDev. RelDev. 37,241 SOl% 108.895 -7,635 -6.554, Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Olh MRT 0.0 0.1 1.2 2010 POP 89.4 2.4 4.1 0.1 2.6 2.2 3.2 0.1 2.5 0.0 0.0 0.7 2010VAP 91.2 Cuyahoga' 16 Baker, Nan (R) 2010 VAP %of Pop 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Re1 Dev. 92,308 78.2% 118,044 1,514 130% Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn P. Oth MRT 0.0 0.1 1.2 2010 PoP 91.7 1.4 2.6 0.1 2.7 0.0 0.1 0.7 2010 VAP 92.6' 1.4 2.2 01 2.7 Cuyahoga' 2010 VAP %ofPOp 17 Anfelski, MarleOe (R) 2DtOPOp- AbsDev. Re1Dev. 96,693 77.6% 124,619 8,089 694% Wht eik Hsp Ind Asn - Pzc Oth MRT 2010 Pop 86.0 6.7 1-5 0.1 4.5 00 0.1 1.2 2010 VAP 87.6" 6.2 1.2 0.1 4.1 0.0 0.1 0.7 Cuyahoga' 18 Dovilla, Mike (R) 2010 VAP %or Pop 2010 Pop- Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 91,391 78.2% 116,917 387 0.33% Whl BIk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT 2010 POP 91.1 2.4 2.2 0.1 2.8 00 0.1 1.3 2010VAP 92.2 2.3 1.8 0.1 2.7 0.0 0.1 0.8 40 (c) 2011. Polidala. www politlata.org POLIDATA (R) Demographic and Political Guitles. AII Rights Resemed. Copyright 1. Populalion for 2010 from PL94-171 Redts)ricting Data from U S. Bureau ol Ihe Census. 2000 Census tlala from various saurces. Slate populatiorv. 11,536,504, 99 members,for thisideal tlislrid is 116,530. iype. give a rough approximation of Ihe deviation from the 20101dez1 Populallon for theaurrenl district. The overall size of each pie isscaled fo the Ideal populallon 2. Pie Charis (shorl populalien) (extra populalion). A White pie, or a Grey slice, indicates a negative deviation 3. A Grey pie. or a White slice, indicates a positive deviation s The 5 Additional breaks WMte-Other and Black-Am Ind auo0 percenl. g` for predominant group W hilte'Am Intlaua W hte-ASian, Whte-Pacfcs ere mcludeJ 11pa MRT O is g over 1% hl Whitz-Black: i 1]9pIX0 EV-pspleUl2-K Fln1 LPL 000087 Political Districts Redistricting Handbook for OHIO Page 39.X.3 District Populations for STATE HOUSE Franklin' 2010 VAP % o( Pop 19 Gonzales, Anne (R) 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 115,646 73.6% 157,070 40,540 34.79% RT WB WI WA WP WO BI d Asn Pac Oth M Whl Blk Hsp In 205 3.0 0.2 2.1 0.0 0.2 2.7 2010POp 71.2 0.3 0.3 0.0 0.0 0.1 18.0 2.5 0.2 2.1 0.0 0.1 1.5 0 5 W 2010 VAP 75.6' 2010 VAP %OfPOp CdnF},i^^BCI tivi 2010POp. AbsDev. RelDev. 99426 752% 132,198 15,668 13.45% WI WA WP WO BI ik Hs p Ind Asn Pac OVh MRT WB Wht B 27 2010P0p 68.7 20.4 4.4 0.2 3.2 0.0 0.2 0.3 03 0.0 0.0 0 2 19.1 3.7 0.2 3.2 0.0 0.1 1.5 05 4010VAP 721* Frankiin' of Pop 21 Dutyey, Mike (R) 2010 VAP % 2010POp. 0.bsDev. RelDev. 91,466 75.4% 121,293 4,763 409% Bt MRT WB WI WA WP WO Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth 4 . 8 0. 0 0. 3 2.6 2010 Pop 62.8 22.4 6.9 0. 2 2010 VAP 66.9' 20 4 5.9 0.2 4.8 0.0 0.2 1.6 0 5 0.3 0.3 (10 0.0 0.1 ; onk8n 2010VAP°hofPOp k(0) 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 99,058 786% 125,989 9 ,459 8.12% Wht 81k Hsp hrtl Asn Pac Oth MRT WB W1 WA WP WO BI 2010POp 77.5 6.5 4.3 01 9.0 0.0 03 2.3 2010VAP 803 6.0 3.6 0.1 8.4 0.0 0.2 15 0.3 0.5 0.5 0.0 0.0 0.0 Ranklin' 2010VAP %ofPOp 23 Vrostiman Cher•i (R) ^ 2010Pap. AbsDev. RelDev. 100,845 74.3% 135,650 19,120 16.41% Asn Pac Olh MRT WE WI. WA . WP .WO BI Wht Blk Hsp Ind 2010POp 84.3 4.5 5.1 0.2 3.6 0.1 0.1 2.1 0.3 03 0.0 0.0 0.1 4.1 4.1 0.2 3.6 0.1 0.1 1.2 0.3 2010 VAP 86.7 Frasa r'.: 2010VAP %ofPop Oc,lgs,'.e, Tc9 (t)) 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 96,417 76.2% 126,534 10,004 8.58% WB WI WA WP WO BI Whf elk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Ofh MRT 2010POp 78.9 7.1 5.5 0.2 5.7 0.0 0.2 2.4 a 2010VAP 81.2* 6.4 4.6 0.2 6.0 0.0 0.1 1.5 0.4 0.40.40.0 0.00.1 Fra',kii'I. 2010 VAP %af Pop 2D10 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 98,722 76.6Y 128,B72 12,342 10.59% Asn Pac 0th MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI Wht Blk Hsp Ind 2010 PoP 75.1 13-8 5.5 0.3 2.4 0.1 02 2 7 2010VAP 79.2' 11.9 4.3 0.3 2.60.1 0.1 1.6 0 5 0.2 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.1 Ft.rrtiln• 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rei Dev- 88 ,211 161% 115,970. -s56 -0.48% WB WI WA WP WO BI Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Ofh MRT 2010 Pop 368 53.3 4.7 0.3 1.5 0.0 0.3 31 0.8 0.2 0.2 0.0 00 0.3 500' 40 0.3 1.7 0.0 02 2.2 O 2010 VAP 41.6 2010 VAP %of Pop 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 95,081 79.3% 119,834 3,304 2-84% Wht BIk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI 2010 Pop 44.0 45.9 4.1 0.3 2.7 0.1 0.2 2.7 2010VAP 50.7* 40.2 3.4 0.3 3.2 0.1 0.2 1.9 06 0.3 0.3 00 0.0 0.3 POLIDATA (R) Demographic and Potilical Guides. All Righls Reserved. Cupyrighl (c) 2011. Polidala. www polidaia.org I Fopulalion lor 20101rom PL94-171 Redistricting Data nom U S. Bureau of the Census- 2000 Census data from various sources Stale population: 11,536,504, 99 members, ideal is 116,530. 2. Pie Charts give a rough approximation of the deviation Irom the 20101deal PopuWtion for the current dislricl. The overa llsize o( each pie is - scaled to the ideal population for this dislrlcf lype. pie, or a W hile slice, indicaies a posilive deviation (exlra populalion). A White pie. or a Grey slice, indicates a negative devialion (short populalion). 34. ARaclalGrey breaks are lur RacelHispanic Origin Combination. MRT is Muiti-RaclalTotal persons. The sum of these, aside from rounding, should be lOD percent.' for predominant group. 5 Additianal breaks are included if MRT is over 1% White-Black, While-Am.indlan, WMIe-Asian, White-Paailia, While-Other and Black-Am Indian. (39p1Y0EV-psPI0l2-KF301 LPL 000088 Redistricting Handbook for OHIO Potitical Districts District Populations for STATE HOUSE Page 39.X.4 Hainiit:m' 2010 VAP % of Pop 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 82,785 759 % 109A05 -7,525 -646°e Pac Oth MRT W8 WI WA WP WO BI Wht Bik HsP Intl Asn 26.2 4.8 0.1 40 0.1 0.3 2.3 2010 Pop 62.3 0.3 02 02 0.O 0.0 01 2010VAP 65.8* 24.7 40 0.1 3.9 0.1 02 1.2 Hamilton' 2010 VAP %of Pop 29 Slessiog, Louss (R) 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 85,54f 75.1 % 113,937 -2,593 -2231, WB WI WA WP WO BI Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac pt2 21 2010Pop 69.9 24.8 1_8 02 100.1 0'1 0.1 0.3 10 O.t 0.1 00 0.0 01 2010VAP 74.2* 22.0 1.4 02 1.1 Hamilton' 2010 VAP %of Pop 30 A9ecklenborg, Bob {R) 2010 Pap- Abs Dev. Ral Deov. 87,026 76.0,5 114,509 -2,021 ^ Wht Blk Nsp Ind 0s9 00 01 MRT 2010 POP 95.1 1.8 0.9 0.1 0.0 0.1 0.6 2010 VAP 960'1.7 0.7 0.1 0.8 lizrr:lh.,., 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010POp AbsDea RelDev. 7061n '23% 97.992 _13,538 -15.91`0 Wht Blk HsP Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI , 2010 PoP 55.4 37.3 3.6 0.2 0.7 0.1 0.2 2.4 05 0-1 0.1 0.0 0.0 01 0.1 0.1O 1.3 201oVAP 01.3' 33.0 3.1 0.2 08 i+.r.!^II{ort 2010VAP %ofPop 2010POp. AbsDev. RelDea 83,112 804`,A 103,395 -13,135 -11.2945 Wht Blk HsP Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI 2010 PoP 43.6 47.9 2.7 0.2 3.0 0.0 0.2 2.2 2010 VAP 49.5' 42.6 2.4 0.2 3.5 0.0 0.2 1.6 0 5 0.3 0.3 0.0 0.0 0.2 `,ia"i!ton` 2010 VAP %of Pop 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 76,377 ]05'%6 9-271 -19.259 16..`:3`•s WB WI WA WP WO BI WM BIk Hsp Ind Asn Pac OtM1 MRT 2010PO1, 44.8 49.5 2.4 0.2 0.8 0.0 02 2.0 0.4 O.l 0.1 0.0 0.0 02 2010VAP 47.6 47.7' 2.1 02 0.9 00 0.1 1 -3 Hamilton' 2010 VAP %of Pop Stnutberg, Peter (R) 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 82.755 77.5% 106,816 .9,714 -8-31% Wht BIk Hsp Ind Aso Pac Oth MRT WB Wt WA WP WO BI 2010 POP 85.6 8.4 2.0 0.1 2.0 0.0 0.2 1.7 2010 VAP 86.8 81 1.7 0.1 21 0.0 0.1 1.1 0.3 0.3 0.3 0.0 0.0 0.1 HarniVOn' 2010VAP %ofPop 35 Maag, Ron (R) 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rei Dev. 95,451 742% 128,703 12,173 1045% Wht elk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Olh MRT a 2010 Pop 90.0 2.8 2.3 01 3.2 0.0 0.2 1.4 2010 VAP 91 0' 2.8 1 9 0.1 3.2 00 0.1 0.8 Montgomery' 2010VAP %ofPOp 3ri Henne, Michael;R) 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dea. 34P44 76. `+'k^ 111,134 -5.396 -4-63% Wht Blk HsP Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT WB Wf WA WP WO BI 2010PoP 663 8.3 1.6 0.2 14 0.0 0.1 2.0 2010VAP 88.3 7.6 13 0.2 1.4 0.0 01 1.1 03 0.2 0.2 0.0 0.0 O1 . POLIDATA (R) DemograpNo znd Polillczl Guides-All Rlghts Reserced. CopyrlgM (c) 3011. Polidzla. www polida aorg tleal 11116.530 1 population lor 2010 from PL94-171 Redistricting Data imm U S Bureau of Ihe Census.2000 Census dala from various sources. Slale populalion: 11,536,504. 99 members, i 2. Ple chartsgive a rough approximalion of Ihe tlevianon from Ihe 20101dea1 Population for the current districl The overall slze oY each pie is scaled to Ihe idea4populalion for this dislrid type 3 A Grey pie, or a WM1ile slice. indiczies a posilive deviation (exlra populalbn). A While pie, or a Grey slice, indicales a negalive Oevialion (sM1orl populallon). 4 Racial brezks are for RacelHispaoic Origln Combination. MRT is Multl-Racial Tntal persons. The sum of these, aside trom rountling, should be 100 percenl.' for predominant gmup. r znd Black-Am Indian. 5. Additional breaks are indutletl if MRT is over 1%. Whlte-Black, White-Am Intlizn, White-ASian, While-PZCific, While-Othe 139pIXDEV-pspledl]-KF]el I LPL 000089 Political Districts Redistricting Handbook for OHIO Page 39.X.5 District Populations for STATE HOUSE Montgomery' 37 Butler.Jim (R) 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010 Pop Abs Dev. Rel Dea 88 50[ 7- 3ye 114.471 2,059 -1.77°0 Asn Pac Oth MRT WB WI WA WPWO BI Wht Blk Hsp ind 0.0 0.1 1.8 201nPOp 87.8 5.5 2.3 0.2 2.3 0.0 0.1 1.1 0.3 0.3 0.3 0.0 0.0 0.0 2010VAP 89.5 4.9 1.9 02 2.4 Montgomery' 38 Blair, Terry (R) 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. RelDev. 86,901 78 2! 111,167 5,363 -4-60'0 Wht Blk HsP Ind Asn Pac Olh MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI 0.0 0.1 1.9 2010 Pop 88.8 3.7 2.3 0.2 2.9 2010VAP 90.6 3.4 1-9 0.2 2.7 0.0 01 1.2 03 0.3 0.3 0.0 0.0 0.0 0=?oniu.ommry' . 2010 VAP %af Pop 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 7"t,647 77.3?6 92.59e -23,936 ->.054`b Whi Btk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT WB WI WA WP WO Bt 2010POP 45.6 47.3 3.4 0.20.7 0.0 02 2.6 00 0.1 1.8 06 0.2 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.2 2010VAP 50.0' 44.1 2.8 0.3 0.8 I:AOm,311On; 2010VAP %olPOp 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 79,880 ` ".',:, 105.?8? -10733 -n 22%0 Hsp Ind Asn Pac Olh MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI Wht Blk 2010 PaP 48.7 45.1 2.0 0.2 1.1 0.0 0.2 2.6 00 0.t 1.6 05 02 02 00 0.0 0.2 2010VAP 52.2' 43.1 1.6 0.2 1.1 Summit' 41 Siaby, Lynn (R) 20t0 VAP %of Pop 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 98,047 77.5% 126,531 10,001 8.58% Wht BIk Hsp InA Asn Pac Oth MRT 2010 Pop 84.6 8.8 1.3 0.1 3.6 0.0 0.1 1.5 8.3 1.1 0.1 3.3 0.0 0.1 0.8 2010 VAP 86.4' 2010 VAP %Of Pop 42 Roegner, K,15flna (R) 2010POp. AbsDev. Re1Dev. 87,569 76.8% 114,C54 -2,576 -213% 0fb MRT . Wht elk Hsp Ind Asn Fac 2.5 1.5 0.1 2.2 0.0 0.1 1.3 2010 POP 92.3 2.4 1.1 0a 2.0 0.0 0-1 0.8 ^ 2010 VAP 93.5' Summlt' 43 McKerrney, ToUd (R) 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010 Pop Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 98,993 78.2°la 126,65810,128 8.69% Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Olh MRT 2010 Pop 95.2 1.6 0.9 0.2 0.8 0.0 0.1 1.2 2010VAP 96.0 1.4 0.7 02 0.9 0.0 0.0 0.8 2010 VAP r%of Pop 2610POp. AbsDev. RelDev- 80,289 7^.4`", 103672 -1>.858-11.03'^b Wht Bik Hsp Ind Asn P. Olh MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI 2010 Pop 46.0 45.2 2.7 0.2 2.6 0.0 0.33.1 2010VAP 50.7` 42_1 2.3 0.2 2.6 0.0 0.2 1.9 07 02 0.2 0.0 00 0.3 rmt 2010 VAP r^%of Pop 2010 Pop Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 61,8222 p6 n 107.689 - 8.8:1 :'.F99b Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI 2010POp 80.2 14.0 1.5 0.3 13 0.00.2 2.7 2010 VAP 84.2' 11.7 1.2 0.3 1.2 0.0 0.1 1.4 O S 0.2 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.1 c) 2011. Polidzlo wwvu polidata.org R) Demographic and POlitical Guides. All Rights Reserved. Copyright ( POLIDATA ( for 2010 from PL94-111 Retlislricting Dala from U S. Bureau ol the Census. 2000 Census tlata from various sources. Slate population: 11,536,504, 99 members, itleal is 116,530. 1. Populalion give z rough approximallon al the deviation from the 2010 Wezl Populalion ror the current district. The overzll size of each pie is scaled lo the ideal populalion for this district lype 2. Pie Charts exlrz populalion). A While pie, or a Grey slice, indicates a negative deviation (short populalion). ar a While slice, indicates a positive deviation ( 3. AGrey pie, RacelHispanic Origin Combination MRT is Multi-Racial Tala1 persons The sum of these, aside from rounding, shauld be 100 percent.' for predominant group 4 Racial breaks zre tor 5. Additionzl brezks are included if MRT is over 1%. White-Black, White-Am.lntlian, While-Asian, White-Pacific, While-0Iher and Black-Am Indlan. 139pIM0EV-pfplcdr3-KF301 LPL 000090 Redistricting Handbook for OHIO Politicat Districts District Populations for STATE HOUSE Page 39.X.6 Lucas' 46 Sears. Barbara (R) 2010 VAP %of Pop 2010 Pop. Abs Dea Rel Dem 96,668 75.7 % 127,69011,1609.58% Wht Bik Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT 0.0 0.1 1.4 2010 Pop 88.4 4.2 3.1 0.1 2.6 00 0.1 0.8 2010VAP 90.2' 3.9 2.4 0.1 2.5 2010 VAP %of Pap 2010Pop. AbsDev. RelDev. 77.z56 'i529b 102,904 -1:i,626-11.69% Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Olh MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI 2010 POP 67.4 17.1 10.7 0.3 1.1 0.0 0.2 31 2010VAP 72.9' 15.6 8.3 0.3 11 0.0 0.1 1.5 06 02 02 0.0 0.0 0.1 Lucas" 2010VAP %ofPOp q. da?i SRik-1 ( 2010POp_ AbsDev. RelDev- 7Q 212 762% 103,896 -12,634-10.94 % Olh MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI Wbt Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac 2010 Pop 39.5 50.2 5.5 0.3 1.4 0.0 0.2 2.8 1.7 0.0 0.1 1.8 07 0.2 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.2 2010VAP44.3 474 4.4 0.3 ac;li ^eoli I l "n^: 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 82442 768°;; 107.32"s -9,205 79C'^ - Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI 2010 PoP 84.1 6.8 5.9 0.2 0.7 0.0 0.1 2.2 2010VAP87.4 6.0 4.4 0.2 0.7 00 0.1 1.2 0.30.2 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.0 Sark' 50 Hagan, Chr6fina (R) 2010 VAP % 01 POP 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dem 37,491 763% 4.718 -1,812 "569b Ind Asn Pac 0th MRT G Wht Blk Hsp 2010 POP 96.2 1.1 1-1 0.1 0.4 00 0.1 1.0 2010 VAP 96.9 1.1 0.8 0.1 0.4 0.0 0.0 0.6 Slark' 2010 VAP %of Pop 51 9churlnG, Kirk (R) 2010POp. AbsDev. RelDev. 96,324 784°/a 122,852 6,322 5.42% Wht BIk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT 2010 POP 90.2 4.8 1.6 0.2 1.4 0.0 0.1 1.7 2010VAP 91.8 4.4 1.3 0.2 1.3 0.0 0.1 0.9 Si;,rk' 2010 VAP % of Pop :i:E51JCk. sl°j?'r•^ f. (!') 2010 PoP_ Abs D.V. Rel Dev. 76 ,20 i62Y 99 o36 -16,594 -14:24% Wht 61k Hsp Ind Asn Pac Olh MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI 2010POp 74.6 18.6 2.2 04 0.3 0.0 0.3. 3.6 201DVAP 79.0' 16.5 1.6 0.4 0.4 0.0 0.1 1.8 07 0.1 0.1 0.0 0.1 0.2 6utler' 2010VAP %ofPOp 53 Oerickson, Timothy (R) 2010 POp. AbsDev. RelDev. 92.884 786% 118,174 1,644 1.41 0 Wpl Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Olh MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI 2010 POp 91.5 3.6 1.5 0.1 16 0.0 0.1 1.6 2010VAP 92.5' 33 1.3 02 1.7 00 01 1.1 0.3 0.2 0.2 00 0.0 0.0 Butler' 2010VAP %ofPOp 54 Combs, Courlney (R) 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev- H6,530 75.6`-ir it4.483 -1.047 .176u. MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI Wht BIk HsP Intl Asn Pac Olh . 1 2 . 1 2010 Pop 81.4 9.3 5.6 0.2 1.3 0. 1 0 2010VAa 84.3 8.7 4.4 0.2 1.3 0.1 0.1 1.1 0.4 0.2 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.0 POLIDATA (R) Demographic and Polilical Guides, All Righls Reserved. Copyright (c) 2011. Polidala. wvuw Polidala org 1. Populalian for 2010 from PL94-171 RedlsVicting Data from U 5. Bureau ot Ihe Census. 2000 Census dala from various sources. Slale populatloo:11,536,504, 99 members, ideal is 116.530. 2. Ple Chatls give a rough approximation of the devialion from the 2010 Ideal Populalion for the current dislrict. The overall size o( each pie is scaled to the ideal populalion for Ibis disVicl type 3.S A Grey Adtlitlonal pie, or a While slice, indiczies abreaks positive devialion (exlra a populalion). 100percen4'forpred A White pie, or a Grey slice, indicales a negative devialion ominanl (short population) group Racial oreRa indarta W hile-Asian hWhle-Pac ific,White-O[herandBlacgkAmIntlan included f MRT O ie over ^°/bl Whoe-Black, ' WhlltetlAm I39pIxDEV-psplodt2-KF901 LPL 000091 Political Districts Redistricting Handbook for OHIO Page 39.X.7 District Populations for STATE HOUSE Butler' 55 Coley, Bill (R) 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 96,112 70.9% 135,473 18,943 16.26% MRT BIk Hsp nd Asn Pac Olh Wht 1.8 8.6 4.7 0.2 4.0 0.1 0.2 2010 PoP 80.4 0.1 0.1 09 2010VAP 82.9 7.8 4.0 02 4.0 6 ,iams>, ,.,. 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 84 42p 73 145 ti3,"-0" . -3,427 -2-94% WB WI WA WP WO BI Pac Oth MRT ^ Wht BIk Hsp nd Asn 0.6 0.0 0.1 32 2010 Pop 64.2 14.4 17.1 0.3 0.6 0 .2 02 00 0 .0 0 . 1 07 00 0.1 1.7 2010VAP 69.9' 13.2 141 03 I010VAP %ofPOp 2010 Pop. Abs Oev. Rel Dev. 103 , 752 75.8% 136,935 20,405 17.51 % MRT 61k Hsp Ind Asn Pac Olh Wht . 4.1 3.2 0.2 1.4 0.0 0. 1 1 7 2010POP 89,4 1.3 0.0 0.0 0.9 2D10VAP 91 .2" 3.9 2.5 0.2 Huron', Lorain', Seneca' 2010VAP %ofPOp 58 Boose. TOrry (R) 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 91,655 76.1% , 120,471 3,941 3.38% Pac Oth MRT Wht Blk Hsp nd Asp 0.3 0.0 0.0 1.2 S 2010POp 91.5 2.5 4.2 0.2 0.3 0.0 0.0 0.7 2010VAP 92.5" 3 .0 3 . 1 0.2 ?Jaiw!ting ' 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010Pop. AbsDev. RelDem uq,1-2 794k: 112,255 -4,275 -3.67°5 ^ Pac Oth MRT Wht BIk Hsp Ind Asn 1.1 0.0 0.1 10 . - , 2010POP 91.3 3.9 2.4 0.1 1.0 0.0 0.0 0.6 2010 VAP 92.6' 3.7 1.9 0.1 . . Flahor.,l..u7 2010VAP %afPOp 2010 PoR Abs Dev- Rel Dev- 7159g 77.3% 95.1.58 -21 . 372 -18.34"•0 Oih MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Wht 2.4 8.5 0.3 0.4 0.0 0.2 2010 Pop 54.9 33.4 05 0.1 0 . 1 0 . 0 0 . 0 0 . 2 0.4 00 0.1 1.4 2010VAP 59.5' 30.8 7.5 0.3 . . L rvli, f4inh u sl^'F ' uv r = w 2010VAP %ofPOp j,'Ira:(9) 2010 PaR Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 84 8r1 77 J% 116,012 -518 -0.449$ Pac Oih MRT O . Whl Blk Hsp Ind Asn 0.4 0.0 0.1 1.4 2010?op 94.3 2.6 1.0 0.2 03 0.0 0.0 0.7 2010 VAP 95.4' 2.5 0-8 0.2 Lart. 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010 PoP- Abs Dev. Rel Dev- 88.646 79.2% 111,790 -4,740 -4-0'?'/o Pac Oth MRT Whl Bik Hsp Iritl Asn 1.3 0.0 0.1 1.2 2010 PoP 92.7 3.3 1.3 0.1 1.3 0.0 0.0 06 2010VAP 93.7 3. 1 1 .0 0 . 1 l.ake' 63 Young,ROniR) 2010VAP %olPOp 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev . 90, 469 76.5`/0 118,251 1,721 1 48 % Pac Oth MRT Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn 0.9 0.0 01 1.5 2010 PoD 89.1 2.9 5.4 0.1 0.9 0.0 0.0 0.8 2010VAP 91.6' 2.6 39 0.1 POLIOATA (R) Demographic and Political Guides. AII Rights Reserved Copyright (c) 2011. Polidala, vJww polidata.org sources. Slale population: 11,536,504, 99 members, itleal is 116,530. the Census- 2000 Census datzfrom various 1. Populalion for 2010 from PL94-171 Redistricting Data irom U S. Bureau of 2 Pie Charls give a rough approximallon of the deviatlon from the 20101deal Populatian lor the currentdislrict. The overallslze ot each pie is scaled to the ideal population for this distrlcttype 3. A Grey pie, or a White sllce, intlicates a positive devialion (exlra populalion). A While pie, or a Grey slice, indicales a negalive deviation (short populalion). Am Ind Total persons h le-PZC f cf W hhe-Other and Blac9k-Am Ind an 100 percenL' for predominant group 5. Adtl t onzl brezks are IR ncluded Pa MRT s over o 1%. 1 is Redistricting Handbook for OHIO Political Districts District Populations for STATE HOUSE Page 39.X.8 Trum"eii" 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010 PoP Abs Dea Re10ev. 77,644 76.79c 101,187 -15,343 -13.17% Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Olh MRT 2010POP 83.1 12.8 1.4 0.2 0.5 0.0 0.2 1% 11.8 1.1 0.2 0.5 0.0 0.1 0.8 2010VAP 85.5" . Trunl'ua11.. 2010VAP %ofPOp ^F..el t ,a[G) 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. ReI Dev, rf1.z0,t 7g Sm_ 102,284 -14,246 -12 23Y Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Olh MRT 2010Pup 92.5 4.1 7.3 0.1 0.4 0.0 0.1 1.4 2010VAP 93.6 39 1.0 0.1 0.5 0.0 0.0 0.8 Clermont' 2010VAP %o1POp 66 Uecker, Joe (R) 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 101,662 73.8% 137,778 21,248 18.23% Whi BIk Hsp Ind Asn Pac OIh MRT 2010 Pop 94.0 1.4 1.7 0.2 1.2 0.0 0.1 1.3 2010 VAP 95.0" 1.4 1.4 0.2 1.2 0.0 01 (.8 Warren" 2010 VAP % 01 Pop 67 Ber,k,Peter(R) 2010Pop. AbsDev. RelDe¢ 103,033 71.8% 143,439 26,909 23.09% Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Ofh MRT 2010 PoP 87.1 4.0 2.3 0.1 4.8 0.0 0.l 1.4 2010 VAP 88.3 4.6 1.8 (.2 4.3 0.0 0.1 08 Pnnnge C 2010VAP %ofPop 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dea 99,227 796% 124,596 8,066 6.92% Wht Blk HsP Intl Asn Pac Olh MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI 2010POP 90.1 4.9 1.4 0.2 1.6 0.0 0.1 1.7 2010VAP 91.P 4.6 1.2 0.2 1.7 0.0 0.1 1.0 0.3 0.2 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.0 Medina 60 Batchelder, William (R) 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010 Pop- Abs Dev- Rel Dev. 97, 305 743% 130,902 14,372 12.33 % Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT 2010POP 94.6 1.3 1.7 0.1 1.1 0.0 O.l 1.1 2010 VAP 95.7' 1 2 1.3 0.1 1.0 0.0 0.0 0.6 Greene' 2010VAP %oPPOp 90 Martin Jarrod (R) ' 2010 PoP. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 97,258 78.5% 123,974 7,444 6-39% MRT WB WI WA WP WO 61 Wht Blk Hsp Intl Asn Pac Oth 2010 POP 82.9 8.4 2.3 0.2 3.5 01 0.2 2.51.5 0.4 0.4 04 0.0 0.0 01 2010 VAP 84.1 8.6 1.9 0.2 3.5 0.1 0.1 Llcking' 71 HOIIieJer, Jap (R) 2010 VAP %of Pop 2010POp. AbsDev. RelDev. 95,457 75.2% 126,98610,456 897% Asn Pac Olh MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI Whl Blk Hsp Ind 0.0 0.1 1.9 2010POP 91.5 4.0 1.5 0.3 0.8 00 0.1 10 02 0.1 O.t 0.0 0.0 0.0 2010 VAP 92.9" 3.7 1.2 0.3 0.8 Clark' 72 n"Gregor, Ross(R) 2010VAP %afPOp 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Ref Dev. 5g p62 76.1 1% 102,568 -13962 -1; 98% Asn Pac Oth MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI Wht BIk Hsp Ind 00 01 2.6 201DPOp 81.8 11.1 3.4 0.33 0.60.6 0.0 0.1 1.4 05 010.1 0.0 0.0 0.1 . "e ;' 2otovAP 84.5 ' 10 . 5 2 .6 0 POLIDATA (R) Demographic and Political Guides. All Rights Reserved. Copyrighl (c) 2011. Polidata. www polidzla.org 'Reo ,504, 99 00 achpiasscaledlolhebidalpopuafonforlMSdistr¢IbypeO for0the 2PIeOhatlsgvearougM1apprvoimalonofthefdeviDZlioaofom 2 3 A Grey pie or a While slice, indicales a positive deviation (exlra population). A White pie, or a Grey slice, indicales a negative deviation (short populatlon). 4 m ,rounding, should be 100 percenL' for pretlominant group RacelHispznic Orlgin Combinatlon. MRT Is Multi-Racial Total persons. The sum of these; aside fro are for Racial breaks While-Am.lnian,d White-ASIan. White-Pacitiq Whife-Other and Black-Am Intlian. I3qplxoev-psp1oel2-er3o1 5. Addllianal breaks are induded if MRT is over 1%_ White-Black. LPL 000093 Political Districts Redistricting Handbook for OHIO Page 39.X.9 District Poputations for STATE HOUSE lei::hlad 2010VAP %ofPOp 73 Goya;. 1ay L-'; 2010Pop. AbsDev. RelDev. 81,qi2 7?6gi 105.536 '!P,994 -243% MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI Asn Pac - Oth Wht Blk Hsp Ind 1.9 1 4 0.2 0.5 0.0 0.1 2010 Pop 85.3 106 1.0 0. 3 0. 1 0 . 1 0.0 0.0 0. 1 1.2 0.2 0.5 0.0 01 2010VAP 86.2' 10.8 Daflance', Fulton, Wfli]ams 2010VAP %ofPOp 74 GooCMrin, Bruce (R) 2010 P.P. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. B9,127 75.3`/0 118,430 1,900 1.63% Asn Pac Olh MRT Wht Btk Hsp Ind 0.4 0.0 0.0 0.9 2010 Pop 90.6 1.0 6.9 0.2 0.4 0.0 0.0 0.5 2010 VAP 92.5 1.0 5.3 0.2 Defiance', Henry, Paulding, Putnam, Van Wert 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev .83,395 74.43'k 1122019 -4,511 -381%, Pac Oth MRT Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn 0.3 0.0 00 0.7 2010Pop 93.5 0.5 4.8 0.2 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.5 O 2010 VAP 95.0 0.4 3.7 02 Auglaize°, HancOCk, Hardin 2010VAP %ofPOp 76 Sprague, Robert (R) 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 92,262 76.3% 120,854 4,324 3.71 % MRT Hsp ind Asn Pac Oth Wht Blk 1.2 11 3.3 0.2 1.2 0.0 0.1 2010Pop 92.9 0.7 1.1 2.5 0.2. 1.2 0.0 00 0 2010VAP 94.2 Darke', Me;cer, Prebie 2010 VAP %of Pop 77 Buchy,Jlm (R) 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. ReI Dev. 88,925 74 9`/0 118,691 2,161 1-85% Asn Pac Oth MRT WM Blk Hsp Ind 0.9 0.4 1.2 0.2 0.4 0,1 0.1 2010 Pop 96.8 0.4 0.0 0.0 0.6 2010 VAP 97.5' 03 0.9 0.2 Auglalze`, Champaign, Shelby 2010VAP %ofPOp 78 AdamS,JOhn(R) 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rei Dev. 89,651 733% 121,455 4,925 4.23 0 Pac Olh MRT Wht elk Hsp Ind Asn 0.6 0.1 0.1 1.5 2010 Pop 94.8 1.6 1.2 0.2 0.6 0.1 0.0 0.8 2010VAP. 95.8' 1.5 09 0.2 Darke', Miarni 79 Adams, Rlchard (R) 2010VAP %ofPop 2010POp. AbsDev. RelDev - 90,632 75.6% 119,858 3,328 2.86°io Pae Oth MRT Wht 61k Hsp Ind Asn 1.0 0.0 0.1 1.5 2010 Pop 94.2 1.8 12 02 1.0 0.0 0.0 0.8 2010 VAP 95.4' 1.7 0.9 0.2 Erie _nai,l,- 2010VAP %ofPOp 1010POp. AbsDev. ReiDev. . 86,411 785ce 1110.118 -6,412 -550q Pac Oth MRT Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn 0.5 0.0 0.1 1.9 2010 Pop 87.5 6.2 3.7 0.2 0.5 00 00 09 2010VAP 89.8' 5.7 2.9 0.2 Ottavva', Sandusky, Seneca 2010VAP %olPap 81 Dannschroder, Rex (R) 2010 Pop. ' Abs Dev. Rel Dem 88, 709 761% 116,551 21 0-02°0 Asn Pac Ofh MRT Wht Bik Hsp Ind 0.4 00 0.1 1.6 2010 POp 88.4 2.5 6.9 0.1 (15 0.0 0.0 0.8 2010 VAP 90.8 2.3 5.4 0.2 POLIDATA (R) Demographic and Politiczl Guirles. All Rfghts Reserved. Copydght (c) 2011. Polidata, www polidata.arg tleat Is 116,530 1 Populatlon for 2010 from PL94-171 Redistricling Data from U S. Bureau of the Census.2000 Census dzta from vafious sources.5tate populatton:11,536,504, 99 members, i 2 Pie Charts 91ve a rough approximatlon of the deviation from the 2010 Ideal Population for the current districl. The overall size ol each pie is scaled to the tdeal population for this district lype. Grey slice, indicates a negative deviation (short population). 3. A Grey pie, or a White slice, indicates a positive deviation(exlra population). A While pie, or a 4 Racial breaks are for Race/Hispanic Origin Combination. MRT is Multi-Raciat Total persons The sum of these, aside from rounding, shoutd be 100 percenL' for predominanf group. 5. Additional breaks are included if MRT Is over 1%. WMte-Black, WhiteAm.Indian. White-Asizn, Whlte-Pacific, White-Olher aad Black-Am Intlian. 139pIxOGv-pspletll2-KF3e1 LPL 000094 Redistricting Handbook for OHIO Politicat Districts District Populations ror STATE HOUSE Page 39.X.10 Crawford, Marton', Wyandot 82 McClaln, Jeffrey (R) 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Ret Dev. R6,044 7`.1%. 111,625 4,935 Whl elk KsP Intl Asn Pac 01h MRT 0.0 0.1 1.2 2010 Pop 92.4 3.6 2.0 0.1 0.4 0.0 0.0 03 2010 VAP 93.2' 4.0 1.5 0.1 0.4 Logan, Marlon°, tlnion 2010VAP %o(POp 83 Burke, Dave (R) . 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. ReI Dev. 88,782 74.3% 119,433 2,903 2.49% Wht Blk Hsp nd Asn Pac Olh MRT 2010 POP 93.8 1.7 1.2 0.2 1.5 0.0 0.1 1.4 2010 VAP 943 1.9 1.0 0.2 1.4 00 0.0 0.8 Clark', Greene', Madlson 84 HacketE Robert(R) 2010 VAP % of Pop 2010 Pop. Abs'Dev. ReI Dev. 90,438 77.4% 116,799 269 0.23% Whi Blk Hsp nd Asn Pac Olh MRT 0.1 1-5 S 2010 Pop 92.2 3.9 1.4 0.2 0.7 0.0 4.2 1.1 0.2 0.7 0.0 0.1 0.9 2010VAP 92.8 Fayeite, Pickaway,ROss 2010 VAP %of Pop 85 Peter5on,6Yah (R) 2010 Pop Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 96,608 76.9% 125,655 9,125 7.83% . . . Pac Oth MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI Wht Blk Hsp nd Asn 0.0 0.1 1.7 2010 Pop 90.8 5.4 1.2 0.2 0.4 0.0 0.1 1.0 0.3 0.1 0.1 0.0 0.0 0.0 2010VAP 91 0' 6.3 1.0 0.3 0.4 Clinton, Hiohland, Pike 86 Rosenbergef,Cilff(R) 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010 Pop- Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 85,864 751 % 114.328 -2,192 -1.88% Pac Oth MRT WB VVI WA WP WO BI Wht Blk Msp Ind Asn 0.0 0.1 1.5 2010 POp 95.3 1.5 0.9 0.3 0.3 0.0 0.0 1.0 02 0.1 0.1 0.0 0.0 0.0 2010VAP 96.1' 1.6 0.7 03 0.3 Gallia,Jackson, Lawrance`, Ross',Vinton 2010 VAP %of Pop 87 Evans, Clyde (R) 2010 Pop. Abs Dev Rel Dev 91.780 76-0% 120,B18 4,288 3.68% Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Olh MRT 2010P0p 95.9 1.30.8 0.3 0.4 0.0 0.1 1.2 2010 VAP 96.5 1.3 0.6 0.3 0.4 , 0.0 0.0 0.9 Adams": BroV9n, Ciernlont' 2010 VAP %of Pop 88 Bubp.Danny(R) 2010 Pop_ Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 92,294 75.5% 122,323 5,793 497"0 Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT S 2010 PoP 97.1 0.6 0:8 0.2 0.2 0.0 0.1 1.0 2010 VAP 97.6 0.6 0-6 0.2 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.7 Adarns', Lawrence', Scioto 2010 VAP %of Pap 89 Johnson, Terry (R) 2010Pop. AbsDev. Re1Dev. 92,888 76.9% 120,820 4,290 3.68 0 Whi BIk Hsp rnd A. Pac Olh MRT WB Wi WA WP WO BI 40 2010 Pop 94.3 2.5 1.0 04 0.3 0.0 01 16 2010VAP 948' 26 0.7 0.4 0.3 00 0.0 1.1 02 01 0.1 0.0 00 0.0 AShland`, Knox, Morrow, Richland 2010 VAP %of Pop 90 Ruhl„Nargaret Ann (R) 2010POp. AbsDev. RelDev. 95,859 756`/0 126.807 10,277 8.82% 61k Hs Ind Asn Pac Olh MRT Whl P 2010 Pop 96.1 0.8 1.1 0.2 0.6 0.0 O.t 1.1 2010VAP 96.8 08 0.9 0.2 0.6 0.0 0.1 07 Politlala, www polidata org R) Demographic and Polilical Guides. AII Rights ReserveC. Copyright (c) 2011 POLIDATA ( for 2010 from PL94-171 Redislnciing Dala from D 5 Bureau of the Census. 2000 Censusdata fromvarlous sources. 9ate populalion:1L536,504, 99 members, ideal Is 116.530. 1. Populalion give a rough approximallon of the devialion from Ihe 20101deal Population for Ihe current tlislrlet. The overall size of each pie ii scaled to Ihe ideal populalion for Ibls tlistricl type shod populali(n). 2. Pie Charls extra population). A White pie, or a Grey slice, indiczles z negalive devialion ( a While slice, indiczles a posilive devialion ( 4.3. RadalA Grey breas pie, or are for RacelHispanic Origln Combination MRT is Multl-Raclal Total persons. The sum of Ihese. aside from rounding, should be 100 percenL' for predominanl group. 5. Adtlihonal breaks zre Induded'd MRT is over 1%. White-Black, While-Am.lndian, White-ASian, White-Pacific, White-Olher and Black-Am Indlan. hqoixoEV-vspleml-xESOI LPL 000095 Political Districts Redistricting Handbook for OHIO Page 39.X.77 District Populations for STATE HOUSE Hocking, Ltcking' , Perty, Pickaevay 2010 VAP % of Pop 91 Hayes, 6ill (RI 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Deva 98,525 75.4% 130,644 14,114 12.11% Asn Pac Oth MRT Wht Blk Hsp Ind 0.90.8 0.2 0.3 0.0 0.1 1.2 2010POp 96.5 0 0.8 0.9 0.7 0.3 0.2 0.0 0. 2010 VAP 97.1' .yan, VJashingi.s 2010VAP %ofPOp Vhiipo_^ 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 99 , 655 81.0% 123,037 6,507 5-58% MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oih Wht 00 01 1.9 2.2 1.1 0.2 1.5 2010 Po 92 .9 0 . 4 0 . 2 0 . 2 0 . 00 . 0 0 1. P 1.7 0.0 O.t 1.5 2010VAP 93.2 23 1.0 0.2 Guernsey, Monroe, Muskinguni , Nob3e, W'ashington 93 Thompson,Andy(R) 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 91,518 78.4% 116,725 195 0. 17% Aso Pac Oih MRT WM Blk Hsp Ind 0.4 0.0 0.1 12 2010 POp 96.3 1.10.7 0.2 0.4 0.0 0.1 0. 8 2010 VAP 96.8 1.2 0.5 0.2 Coshocton. Muskingum ' 2010 VAP %of Pop 9G 8aiderson, Troy (R) 2010POP. AbsDev. RelDev. 89,322 757% 117,946 1,416 1.21% WB WI WA WPWO BI Pac Olh MRT Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn 03 0.0 01 2 .0 2010 Pop 93.6 3.0 0.8 0.2 0.4 0 .1 0. 1 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.3 0.0 0.1 1 . 1 2010 VAP 94.8' 2.9 0.5 0.2 l3P,iY9Cr1t'. ;eP(Br50p 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010 PoR Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 8$,331_ 79.9,4. :06.820 -6.710 $.33% Asn Pac Olh MRT Wht Bik Hsp nd 0.3 0.0 0.1 1.5 2010 Pop 92.5 4:5 0.9 0.1 0.3 0.0 00 0. 8 2010VAP 93.8 4.1 0.7 0.1 f3eimont', Harrison. Tuscaraw'as' 2010VAP %ofPOp 96 Landis, Al (R) 2010 Pop. Abs Dev- Rel Dev 96 , 596 77.9`/0 124,049 7,519 6.45°0 Pac Olh MRT Wht Bik Hsp nd Asn 0.1 1.1 2 ,2 1 .6 0.1 0.4 0.1 2010 Pop 94 . 5 0.7 2.5 1.4 0.1 0.4 0.1 0.0 0 2010VAP 94.9 Ashland', Holmes. Medina 2010 VAP %of Pop 97 Haii, Dave (R) 2010 Pap . Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 90, 343 774% 124,815 8,285 7.11% Asn Pac Olh MRT Wht BIk Hsp nd 0.4 0.0 0.0 0.8 2010POp 97.0 0.6 1.0 0.1 0.5 0.0 0.0 0.6 2010 VAP 97 4' 0.6 0.8 0.1 Cuyahoga',Geauga' 2010 VAP %of Pop 98 Hollinglon. Rfchard (R) 2010PaP- AbsDem RelDe¢ ¢7 .013 75.5% 115.232 -1,296 -1.i1 0 Oih MRT Bik Hsp Irq Asn Pac Whl 0.9 22 1.2 0.1 1.9 0.0 0.1 2010POp 93.7 0.5 2.2 1.0 0.1 1.9 0.0 0. 1 O 2010VAP 94.2' Ash!abula, Trumbull 2010VAP %ofPOp 99 Kazbw POLIDATA (R) Demographic and Polilical Guitles. All Rights Reserved Copyrighl (c) 2011. Polidi www polidata.org. 1 Populallon for 2010 irom PL94-171 Redistricting Dala from U 5. Bureau of the Census.2000 Census data fromvarious sources. Slaie popvlation:11.536,504, 99 members, itleal is 116.530. 2. Pie Charts ghe a rough approximalion of the devialion from the 2010 Ideal Populztion for the current districl. The overail size of each pie is scaletl lo Ibe Itleal popula0on fOr this district lype White pie, or a hGrey slice. indicztes a negalive devialio100 1 pe¢ 3Grey pie,A or a While enl' slice,intlkales a posiiive for devialion (extra population).prednminant A a houitl be group 5.Addl1breaks nalbzks : Reculigsprinc . MRT is t lheran tlgBlack-Am indian 169pIN0Ev-pspledl2-KF301 LPL 000096 Redistricting Handbook for OHIO Political Districts District Populations for STATE HOUSE Page 39.X.72 Population per Member with Deviation from Ideal Population for 2010 Ranked by 2010 TolPop AsbDev RelDev District . ED Member Delae.rare 174 , 214 57,684 49.50 2 Brenner, AndreW (R) Franklin' 157,070 40.540 34 . 79 19 Gonzale=_, Anne (R) Fairfieid 146,156 29,626 2542 5 Stebelion , Geraid (IZ) Warren' 143 ,439 26,909 23.09 67 Beck, Peer (R) Ciermonf' 137 , 778 21,248 1823 66 Decker,Joe(R) D, rni .,r 13 5. 9 3 5 2 . 40 5 17 . 51 ,.-.dy- (D) 19, 120 16 .41 Franklin' Grossman Cheryl (R) 135,650 23 18,943 1 6. 26 Butler' Coley,.Btil(R) 135,473 55 , -ag 1 ;.. 66"u 1 3.45 Frarkiio. .ILp Medina 21 130,902 14.372 12.33 69 Batchelde„ William (R) I{ocking, Licking' , Perry, Pick y 130 , 644 14,114 12.11 91 Hayes, BIB (R) rankiin' 12887% 12 .342 10.54 25 Hamilton' 128 , 703 12, 173 10-45 35 fNaag, Ron (R) Lucas' 127,690 11,160 9 . 58 46 Sears , Barbara (R) 126,986 10,456 8 97 l icklny' 71 Holtlnger,, Jay (R) Ashtand' . Knox , Morrow, Richland 126,807 10,277 8.82 90 Ruhl, MargaretAnn(R) Summit' 126 , 658 10,128 8.69 43 McKenney,Tcdd (R) 1J65 iC.O", 8.5; Frankfie 21 - esl ^ d [U,. 10,001 8.58 Summit" Slaby, Lynn (R) 126:531 41 r: r.,y29 4 !qrr Fayeth,Picka:aay, Ross 125,655 9 ,125 7.83 85 Paterson, Bob (R) Wood 125,488 8,958 7.69 Gardner, Randy (R) , Holmes, Medina 6 124,815 8.285 7. 11 Ashland' 97 Iialt. Dave (R) , Cuyahoga' 12 4 . 619 8,089 6 94 An1eIsA Marlene (R) r t :"m 17 '4,596 d.066 b'>2 ., 1 rsde K r tlL . 45 Beirlont' . Harrison. Tuscarawas' 124,049 7,519 6. 96 AI(R) Landis , 7,444 639 Greene' 70 6Sart;n. Jarrod (R) 123,974 r h , ti,, A I o r ^=est:exrton 123 03, n ,.:)1 i: . `i8 5 pq3y i 1 (Dr Slark' 122 ,852 6 322 542 51 Schoring, KirK (R) Adams', Brown, Clermont ' 122.323 5,793 4.97 88 Bubp C anny (R) Auglaize, Champaign, Shelby 121,455 4,925 423 78 Ad'ams. John (R) Franklin' 121.293 4,763 409 21 Duffey , PHLke (R) glalze` . Hancock, Haidin 120,854 4,324 3 71 Au 76 sprague, Roben (R) 4,290 3-68 Adams', Largence', Scioto Johnson,Terry(R) 120,820 ' , Ross ' , Vinton 89 4,288 3.68 Gallia. Jackson. Lawrence 120,818 ' 87 Evans, Clyde (R) 3,941 3.38 Huron'. Lorain', Seneca Boose, Terrv (R) 120,471 , 58 3,328 286 Darke` Miami Adams, Richard (R) 119,858 79 . „` :3 . 3t74 2.84 anxrm' A6eddiri ,, rr,1r ^i 2, 2,903 2-49 Lagaq Marlon', Union Burke, Dave (R) ^ 119,433 Darke'. Mercer, Preble 83 118.691 2,161 1.85 77 Buchy , Jim (R) Defiance . FuHon, Williams 118,430 1,900 1-63 74 Goodwin , Bruce(R? Lake ' 118,251 1,721 1.48 63 Young, Ron (R) Butler' 118,174 1,644 1.41 Derickson, Titnothy (R) Cuyahoga' 53 118 , 044 1,514 1.30 16 Baker.Nan(R) Coshoclon, Muskingum' 117946 1.416 1.21 94 Balderson , Troy (R) Cu ahoga' 1t6,917 387 033 y t8 Dovilla.MJke(R) Clark, Greene', Madison 116,799 269 0. 23 84 HackeC;.Roberl(R) Guernsey , Monroe, MuSkingum', Noble, Washington T16,725 195 0. 17 93 Thompson, Andy (R) 0ttawa' , Sandusky,5eneca' 116,551 21 002 1 81 Datnsclroder. Rex (R) r 7 Var,uri-1 .'tik' . Tc [ +..-_ )17 - t8 0 .34 l-n . tr} 1 1 c„i3 5`.`6 '1.•iA. iiel c i', , Geauga' -1,298 -1. 11 Cuyahoga' Hoilington Rlchard(R) 115,232 98 , -1,812 -1.56 Stark' Hagan, Chrlstlna iR) 114 718 50 114 , 520 2,010 -1.73 Wayne 3 Amstuiz, Ron (R) Hamillon' 114.509 -2.021 -1.73 Meckienborg, Bob (R) 30 114 , 483 -2.047 -1 76 Butler' S4 Combs, Courtney (R) Montgomery' 114, 471 -2,059 -1-77 37 Butier, Jlm (R) Cllnton, Highiand, Pike 114,338 -2192 -1.88 Roeenberger. Cli!t (R) Summil' 86 114,054 -2476 -213 Roegner, Kristlna (R) Ham[Itun' 42 111937 -2,593 -2. 23 29 BlesSing, Louis (R) 1 ..21 2 Pai . ^ . . •. ^%75 t67 V ^'t' Paulding , Putnam , Van Wer! 4,511 3-87 Defiance" . Henry, W'achimana Lynn (R) 117,019 75 1LJ?, . p._ . . tY Crakvford. h9allon ' , Wyartdot 11t.625 4905 421 Jefney (R) 82 "?cClain. 111.167 -5,363 -4.60 AIontgornery ' , 1"erry (R) 38 BIar -5,396 -4.63 Montgomery' 36 Henne, Mtchael(R) 111,t34 110.':13 12 sr, r ;D r",i^ .`025 n.u i> c) 2011, Politlala, www polidala.org R) Demographk and Political Guides. AII Rights Reserved copyright ( Ideal is 116.530 POLIDATA ( tor 2010 from PL94-171 Redislriding Dala from U 5. 6ureau of the Census. 2000 Cenius data from various sources.5late populalion: 11,536,504, 99 members. 1 Populalion give a rougM1 approxima(on of the tlevialion from the 2010 Itleal Population for Ihe current tlislrict. The overall size of each pie is scaled lo Ihe ideal population for this dslricl type. 2. Pie Charls a Grey slice. (extra populalion). A W hite pie, or Indicales a negative devr gzliolnouldobep1001 percent.' for pretlominant group. 3 A Grey pie, or a White slice, indicates a posilive devialion i( a MRT D is g aver 1% ! White-81ack, rWhite - Am indian 'aWhile-ASianhWhle-Pacfic, While-Otherand6lack-Amindian 139p1%pEV-psplctllbKF301 5 AddlYOalbnntluded breaks are p LPL 000097 Potitical Districts Redistricting Handbook for OHIO Page 39.X-73 District Populations for STATE HOUSE Ashtabuta, Trumbull 108,338 -8,192 7.03 99 Kozbwskl, Casey (R) Cotumbiana 107 ,841 ^8 ,699 -7.46 1 Newbold, Crafg (R) ^ 1Q8%- 881i 114 nmlt' 45 .":8m1 h t 5 tii .lf 32J POLIDATA (R) Demographic and Political Guides. AII Rights Reserved. Copyright (c) 2011, Pdlitlzto www po6dztz.org ulation:11,536,5D4, 99 members. ideal is 116,530. 1. Population for 2010 from PL94-171 Redistricting Dala from U S. Bureau ol lhe Census. 2000 Census tlala from varioussources.5late pop 2 Pie Charls give a rough approximation of the deviallon trom the 2010 Ideal Population lor the currenl district. The overall size ot each pie is scaled lo the ideal population for this dislrict lype. 3. A Grey pie, or a W hlle slice, intlicales a positive devialion (exlra populalion). A While pie, or a Grey slice, indicates a oegative deviation (sharl populalmn) ' for predominant group m ifMR^isover^%IWhite- aak,IWMlet'Aalnda¢aWhVe-ASianhWhVe-Pacific,Wfife-OherantlBla9k-Amindbn100percent. S.Additonalbreakszrencludedp 139pl%OEV-pspledt2-KF3a1 LPL 000098 Redistricting Handbook for OHIO Potiticat Districts District Populations for STATE HOUSE Page 39.X.14 Ranked by Member (Last Name) with Deviation from Ideal Population for 2010 To1POp AsbDev RelDev Dislrict ED Member 4,925 4-23 Auglaize', Champaign, Shelby 78 Adams, John (R) 121 ,455 1328 2. 86 Darke°, Miami Adams, Richard (R) 119,858 79 114,520 -2,010 -1.73 Wayne 3 Amstutz , Ron (R) C hoga' 124 ,619 8,089 6-94 l.rya 17 Anielskt, Madene (R) ., c^c.. 14.bs S 1-arlyp'n' ., ..c) a 11634 10 14 h^,} Eirr^ W Cuyahoga' 118,044 1,514 1.30 16 , Baker, Nan (R) 1,416 1.21 Coshocton Muskingum' Balderson, Troy (R) 117,946 94 , -i5^., Ceyahoya' Sa:r.... r .. U) Medina 130,902 14372 1 233 69 Batcheltle., Wllllam (R) 439 26,909 23.09 Warren' 67 Beck,Peter(R) 143 , 5,363 -460 Monlgomery' 38 Blair, Terry (R) 111,167 937 2,593 -2.23 Flamiiton' 29 Blessinq, Louis (R) 113 , ' 3,941 3-38 Huron`_ Lorain', $eneca 58 Boose,Terry (R) 120.471 96L t y.lntga'. Ayd i u ^' 0 174,214 57,684 49.5 Delaware 2 Brenner Androw (R) Adams', Brown, Clermont' 122 , 323 5,793 4 97 88 Bu6p,Danny(R) Darke', Mercer, Preble 1 1 8, 691 2,161 1.85 ?7 Buchy,J;m (R) C"yanoga' t). ttJ-'.9e5 56,3 c. 92 '- tvor: P cucdL7 Logan, Marion'. Union 119,433 2 , 903 2 .49 83 Burke, Dave (R) omery' 114,471 -2,059 -1.77 Nlontg 37 Butler, Jim (R) . rcckala" . k 1 'B9 2 1 )) ll. l: 7 Sa anki!n' Di fr1 ^aQ!° ^r ty 8 )'•6 111 2 18,943 16. 26 Buller' Coleg BIII (R) 135,473 55 114,483 -2,047 -1-76 Bctter' 54 Combs, Courtney (R) Otlawa ' ,Sandusky,5eneca' 116,551 21 0.02 81 Darnschroder, Rex (R) haga' DeG no!ryib, 1 L <-'-`-. +'sS 6.30 3 1,644 1-41 Builer' DeticksOn, Timothy (R) 118,174 53 116,917 387 0.33 Cuyahoga' Dovilla, Mike (R) 18 97 z.i2 IS;'.i" :1 HarrdLor^' 31 -.fir;i t J n.::e (!J) Franklin' 121.293 4.763. 4 .09 21 Duffey, MrRe (R) Jackson , Lawrence , Ross', V[nton 120,818 4,288 3.6 8 Gallla , 87 Evans, Clyde (R) :ucar: 2.9C4 ' i>2C" .11 u9 ' 1 . 79^ : 7ji. . " ' . ahnga' 1.i>28 1^yp?. ^ 1J7 IPI I . r)• 125,488 8,958 7.69 Wood G dner . Randy (R) 6 ar P. & 4rarlidfn' 20 NI^rl 8 (D' ri I 1Xfi°..}efl5on n 1li c 3.'; , r^ Cemi t (D) '5 -i.,,hu. g Gert< n d (Dy klin' 157,070 40,540 34.79 F ran 19 Gonzales_ Anne (R) Deflance , Fulton, Williams 118 430 1.900 1 63 74 Goodwin , Bruce(R) 4 i : l al' S iCr, etic 1q.R9d 9•13 C ` 73 Gcpa i..is`, `r)) Franklin' 135,650 19,120 1641 23 Grossman, Cheryl (R) ark' , Greene' , Madison 116,799 269 023 Cl 84 Hacketl , Robert (R) 114,718 -1,812 -1.56 Stark* Hagan. Christina (R) 50 } ?•q f; "Ohinini' 6 - . f i'y' I h iL7', 11 Ashland' , Holmes , Uledlna 97 124,815 8285 7. Hall, Dave (R) 12 . 11 Hockitlg , Licking' , Parry. Plckaway Hayes,Bill(R) 130,644 14,114 91 11;4r. - - rl a& ': a : k;in` 26 i..; .y (2). 11 1 , 134 5 , 396 -4-63 Montgomery ' 36 Henne, Michael (R) Cuyahoga", Geauga" 115, 232 -1 ,298 -1 11 98 Floflinglon. Richard (R) Licking ' 126,986 10,456 8. 97 71 Holtlnger,Jay(R) 106.331 -10.199 -5 75 Allen 4 Huftman, Mati (R) Lavaence'. Scloio 120,820 4,290 3.68 Adams' . 89 Johnson,Tercy (R) . Trumbull 108,338 -6,192 - 7 .03 Ashtebula 99 Kazlom^ski, Casey (R) Belmont', Harrison, Tuscarawas' , 049 74519 6-45 96 Landis,At(R) 124 10? tp u nbvd? , tsr y 3L 'C 5 L>r k^ i c tD} 9z iC,if; .^t dl' 7 Lwr ^ 12,173 104 5 Hamdton' Maag, Ron (R); 128,703 35 i't ••, i.?i 3) ?ria , sie ^Ji 1 );3`i 123 ,974 7.444 6.39 Greene' 70 Marltn, Jarrod (R) Crawford, Marton', Wyandol 111,625 4 905 -421 82 McCIaln , Jeffrey(R) Clark' 102 . 568 -13 962 -11.98 72 McGregor. Ross(R) Summit' 126 658 10,128 8.69 43 McKeaney.Todd(R) . 114.509 -2,021 -1.73 Hamil:on` 30 Mecklenhorg, Bob (R) gu•. .^;.r ' 1C c8° E.8-41 -73V ^ =i^r ia, ) 10 . I; J^2 - SG 41 (C; 7 46 107,841 -8,689 Columbiana t Newbold, Craig (R) POLIDATA (R) Demographic and Polilical Guides. AII Righls Reserved Lopyrighl (c) 2011. Polidata. wwve polidala org T,536,504, 99 members, ideal is 116YSp3e0. from various sources. 51ate population: i 1. Populali0n lor 2010 from PL94-171 Redistricting Data IrOm U S. Bureau ol the Census. 2000 Census dala 2 Pie Charls give a rough approximalionol the deviation trom the 20101deal Populalionior the currenl dislrid. The overall size of eacH pie is scaletl lo the ideal populalion for this dislricl l short populafion). , or aGrey slice, indicales a negative deviation ( ar a While slice, indicates a positive devialion (extra populaiion). A While pie 3. A Grey breakspie, are ior RzcelHispanic Origin Combinalion. MRT is Multi-Racial Totzl persons. The sum of these, aside from rounding, should be 100 percent' for predominant group. 4. Racial White-Other and Black-Am intllan. Indian , White-ASian , Whife-PaciOC 139p1%DEV-piPlatl12-KF301 5. Additional breaks are Inclutled if MRT is over 1%. While-Black. While-Am. LPL 000099 Political Districts Redistricting Handbook for OHIO Page 39.X.75 District Poputations for STATE HOUSE 1 .2 . :'8.1 1az,r, 12 23 11 2 111,1 ' (ul C r c ri. C- +' o;^3ng SIarK ", Tusc 'a+a> ;fi2 .:;18 0.1d !Jke)'. 1^9ar:: , 1tb. Cut^hog.T'. 01 r '.6?7 . ;: -2G„ 1 ) ">atrron s'(d) 9125 7 . 83 Fayelle Pickavday RoY 85 Peterson, Bob (R) 125655 A I h V'eig<, t4ol Tn Ut >hlixa'.en r.:3,037 5 .58 92 o ':Pt b 646 H mi;pn" li r ^t t 2Lr 11 ;T^, r ^ 2 7 - 2 94 C' ^ 56 Ranos nn , ,91 I,259 -1£,.5 FI ItltCti .cece -a r03 Summlt' 33 114.054 -2A76 -2 . 13 Roegner , IUlstlna (R) Clinton, Highland, Pike 42 114,338 -2.192 -1 ,88 86 Rosenbergef,Cliti(R) Ashland' , Knox, Morrom, Richland 126,807 10,277 8 .82 Ruhl , Margaret Ann (R) Stark' 90 122,852 6,322 5 42 51 Schuring , Kirk (R) Lucas' 127,690 11,160 9-58 46 Sears, Barbara (R) Summit ' 126 ,531 10.001 8.58 Slaby, Lynn (R) Sr2rk' 41 p POLIDATA (R) Demographic and Po6lical Guldes. AII Righls Reserved Copyrighl (c) 2011 Polidala wevw politlata org ulation:11,536,504, 99 mem6ers, itleal is i1b,530. 1. population for 2010 from PL94-171 Retlistricling Data from U 5. Burezu uf the Censu5.2000 Census data from vzrious sources-Slale popple the for the a current ialee a negalive tlev al on (shorl populat on)deal population for this dislricl type. 2 Ple Charls give a rough approximallon of the deviation from the 20101deal PopulalionPoe 3. A Grey pie, or a While slice, intllcales a positive deviation (exlra populalion). A White Grey ng, should be 100 Percent ' for predominant group. 4 Raclal breaks are for RacelHispznic Origin Combinatlon MRT is Mugi-Racial Total persons. The sum of (hese, aside from roundi 5. Addilionai breaks are included if MRT Is over 1%. Whlte-Black, White-Am.lndian, White-Asian, Whife-Pacifc. White-Other and Black-Am Indian I]9P1%DEV-pSpleJ12-KF301 LPL 000100 Redistricting Handbook for OHIO Political Districts District Poputations for STATE HOUSE Page 39.X.16 Ranked by 2010 Minority Voting Age Population for Selected Subgroups Minority Hsp/Lal Black Asian Disiricl ED Member 07 30, 2.: h 4.V 17 1.7 0.9 .3 .IIyi111Jiia' . :-i3iY:la^UH G.^ tSOilirsl.^.cri' Sunnmi, s.2 Franki'rY lis`ecirlj .4n,` r'Le1,2^ . iirr'InCar i iriahr,^inu 6p HaqaR R. t f)'IebJJS, L3 I itii4t^., e!tllle 2e A,°,(ir:^, t 5.9 204. 4.8 Franklin' 21 Dufley, Mike (R) L9r(i ;1' 14-9 13.2 56Ramu, Jao{J) 3.2 Lrank;nn' t'a:" ti p 4n ! I1 10 4 12.7 -, 9 CUVen' n:xe, n.ic (t:a 8 , ^15 6 '.2 I.UCa>' Hamipon' F:adr. a r`;) 2.9 1 4 22.0 1-1 .29 Blessing, Louis (R) 24.4 2.5 18.0 2.1 Franklin' 19 Gonzales,Anne (R) SCUk" 2`i t1 1 .8 16 .^ qc ^ah raa' oi:7 11,^ ( ankiir: '{ipZ'1 no Ph ei`Uc 6 1 Fin tkiSl' Caret hn ..' J` f.ntln 9L.8 &b C! ^r0 d 17.1 40 7.8 4.0 Butler' 55 Coley, Bill (R) 15-9 1.9 8-6 3.5 Greene' 70 Martin, Jannd (R) 159 4-4 8.7 1 .3 Butler' 54 Combs, Coustney (R) q59 1"11 '.2 '3acr:ri* " Zcr} ); ,5 coe,in r 15.5 2.6 10.5 0.6 Clark' 72 McGregor,Ross (R) ?5.0 1.9 11.0 0-7 Allen 4 Huffman, Matl (R) 11 8 T, rumbuFl' c 4 t3:.; l^(Ui 2.8 i.7 ;8 0.5 Riche^ri .,ayG'7 13.7 1.1 8.3 3.3 Summit' 41 Siaby, Lynn (R) 13.4 4.1 4.1 36 Franklin' 23 Grossman, Cheryl(R) 13 2 1.7 8.1 2.1 Hamilton' 34 Staulberg. Pete; (R) 12.6 ti "-. f.G 0.7 9'i SzeV 1 t e'x (pj 12A 1.2 6.2 4.1 Cuyahog[f 17 AnielsK, Marlene (R) 11.8 1 8 4.6 4.3 Warren' 67 Beck, Peter (R) 11.7 1.3 7.6 1.4 Montgomery' 36 Henne, Michael(R) 106 1.9 4.9 24 Montgomery' 37 Butler,Jim (R) 1..,.^ JJ 4% (15 flri .'.Itao-va' 6W NilY. , L(AOSfD^ 10.1 1 7 3.2 41 Delaware 2 Brenner, Andrew (R) 9.8 2.4 3.9 15 Lucas' 46 Sears, Badlara (R) 95 19 34 2.7 Montgomery 38 Elair, Terry (R) 9 2 5-4 2.3 0.5 Ottawa',Sandusky,Seneca' 81 Darnschrotler, Rex (R) 9.1 1.0 63 04 Fayette, Picka',way, Ross 85 Peferson, Bob (R) 9.0 1.4 5.3 1.0 Fairfield 5 Stebelton, Gerald (R) 8_9 1.9 2.8 37 HamiOon' 35 Maag,Ron(R) .4.8 i 2 s.b ?.7 norizrv. 08 Cly`li en (L1, = 07 Lui 'ii: (ill 8,8 3.6 2.5 1.5 Wood 6 Gardner, Randy (R) ':uyanr.^n' 07 .-2S . : rle r .r,th. (D) 83 3.9 2.6 09 Lake' 63 Yaung, Rom;R) 8.2 1.3 44 1.3 Stark' 51 Schuring, Kirk (f2) 7.8 1.8 2.3 2.7 Cuyahoga' 18 Doy11a, Mike (R) 7.7 1.3 3.3 1.7 Butler' 53 Dedckson. Tlmoflly (R) 7.4 5.3 1.0 04 DefianE:e'. Fulton. Williams 74 Goodwln, Bruce (R) 7.3 2 4 3.5 0.3 Ashtabula, Trumbull 9- Koalowskh Casey (R) ° 9 7 19 3rhanorMirg' ,9 Oz1 2 7,3 3.1 30 0.3 Huron', Lerain', Seneca' 58 Boose Terry (R) 7.2 11 4.2 07 Clark', Greene'_ Madlson 84 Hackeft, Robert (R) 7.2 2.2 14 27 Cuyahoga' 16 Baker,Nan(R) 7.1 1.2 3.7 0.8 Licking' 71 Hollinger, Jay (R) 7 7 ..^ n, i rr:e(LI) c367 t5 4.0 0-4 Crawford,!Aarior,".Wyando[ 82 A1CClaln,Jeffrey (R) R) Demographic and Polilical Guides. All Rights Reserved Copyrighi (c) 2011. Polidata. www potdala org lation:11.536,504, 99 members, Idezi is 116,530. POLIDATA ( Redisiricring Dztz from U S Burezu of ihe Census. 2000 Ceosus dara from various sources. slale popu 1. Population givefor 2010 aroughfmm approximation PL94-171 oflhe deviationiromthe 2010IdealPOpulalionforthe currentdistricL The overallsize oleach piels scaletllolheideaipopulationforthis dislricYtype . 2.PIe Chads While slice.indicales a posilive devialion(exlrz populalion). A White pie,ora Grey slice.indicates z negative devialion(shorlpopulaiion) 3.Fl Grey pie.ora CGmb -Radial 5. Additonalbkeaks aare mdutledP MRTOisgover 1%IWhite-Blaak,IWfide^Am IndiaqaWh te Asian,hWhlle-Pan ic, Whife-Olher and Btac9k-Am Intl an 00 percenL' for predominantI]9pIXnEV-pspktlll-KFlOI group. r LPL 000101 Politicaf Districts Redistricting Handbook for OHIO Page 39.X.17 District Populations for STATE HOUSE 65 11 2.4 2.0 SummiP 42 Roegner, (rlstina (R) TumhlAp 65 C>r!en Sr 1 c 1 :3 '._ake' t .;,On 60 3 r'Rk?:On a' , Geauga' l0 2,2 19 C uye hog 98 I loiltng on Richard (R) 5-8 Augiaize', Hancock, Hardin . 5.7 25 1 1 1 . 2 Sprague, Robcrt (R) Logan,Marion'.Union 76 5.3 10 19 1 _ 4 83 Burke, Dave (R) l mont'. H a rrison , TuscarawaS' 5-2 1.4 25 04 Be L andis , Al (R) on, Nluskin gum' 9G 0 5 p 9 0.3 Coshoct Balderson , Troy (R) 51 Lawrence', Scioto 94 03 2.6 03 Adams", 89 .lohnson Terry (R) 5 -1 Clermont' 5.1 14 14 12 Uecker,.tme(R) enry. Paulding, Putnam , Van Werl 66 3-7 04 02 Deflance' , H Wachtmann, Lynn (R) 50 75 1.2 23 0. 3 Columbiana (R) 4 7 1 Newbold, Craig 0. 1 -7 1 -0 Dae', POLIDATA (R) Demographic and PoliticalGuldes. AII Rights Reserved Copyright (c) 2011. Polidata. www polldala.org from various sources. State population: 11,536,504, 99 members, ideal Is 116,530. 1. Populatfon for 2010 Itom PL94-171 Redlstricting Data Irom U S. Eureau of the Census. 2000 Census data 2 Pie Charls give a rough approximation of the deviation from Ihe 2010Itleal Population forthe current district. The overzll size of eacM1 pie isscaletl In the Ideal population for this disVic4fype Grey slice, indicates a negztive deviafion (shnrt population). 3. A Grey pie, or a White sliae, indicates a positive tlevizlian (extra populafion). A While pie, or a 4 Racial breaks are for RacelHispanic Origin Combinatlon. MRT is Mulli-RZcial Total persons. The sum of these, asNe Irom roundng, should be 100 percent.' for pretlominant group. 1%. W hite-Black, White-Am.lndian, W hite-Asian, White-Pacifq W hite-Olher and Black-Am Indian 5 Atldltional brezks are included if MRT is over 159p1%DEV-ps01e412-KF301 LPL 000102 THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY BLANK LPL 000103 Political Districts Redistricting Handbook for OHIO Page 39.V.7 District Populations for STATE SENATE Hancock, Fuiton, Putnam, Defiance*, Williams... Hite, Cliff (R) 2010 VAP b of Pap 2010PDp. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 264,784 75.4% 351,303 1,712 0.49% Wht Blk Hsp nd Asn Pac Oth MRT 0.9 5.0 0.2 0.6 0.0 0.1 1.0 2010 Pop 92.3 0.9 3.9 0.2 0.6 0.0 0.0 0.6 0 2010 VAP 93.9 Lucas', Wood, Erie, Ottawa'" Wagoner, Mark (R) 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010 P.P. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 281,297 77.4% 363,296 13,705 3.92% Wht Blk Hsp nd Asn Pac Oth MRT 1.6 0.0 0.1 1.5 2010 Pop 88.7 4.2 3.7 0.2 90.5* 3.9 3.0 0.2 1.5 0.0 0.1 0.9 2010VAP Franklin' Bacon, Kevin (R) 2010VAP %afPOp 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 306,538 74.7% 410,561 60,970 17.44% Wht Blk Hsp nd Asn Pac OtM1 MRT WB Wt WA WP WO Bi 2010 PoF 67.9 21.0 4.6 0.2 3.3 0.0 0.2 2.7 2010VAP 71.9" 19.1 3.9 0.2 3.3 0.0 0.1 1.5 0 5.0.3 0.3 0.0 0.0 0.1 6 Butler 4 Gates, Gary (R) 2010 VAP % of Pop 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 275,528 74.8% 368.130 18,539 5.30% Wht BIk Hsp nd Asn Pac Oth MRT WB WI WA WP WO Bi 2010 Pop 84.3 7.2 4.0 0.2 2.4 0.1 0.1 1.8 • 2010VAP 86.6` 6.6 3.2 0.2 2.4 0.1 0.1 1.0 0.3 0.2 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.0 Montgomery', Ntiamt. Darke" 5 eeagle, Blli (R) 2010 VAP % af Pop 2910POP- AbsDev. RelDev. 242,159 76.1% 318,239 -31,352 -8.97% Wht Blk Hsp nd Asn Pac OthMRT WB WI WA WP WO BI 2010 Pop 64.9 29.4 2.1 0.2 0.9 0.0 0.2 2.2 2010 VAP 67.8' 27.9 1.7 0.2 1.0 0.0 0.1 1.4 0.4 0.2 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.1 Montgomery' 6 Lehner, Peggy (R) 2010 VAP %of Pop 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 260,347 77.3% 336,772 -12,819 -3.67"0 nd Asn Pac Oth MRT WB WI WA WP WO Bi ^ Wht Blk HsP 2010Pap 87.7 5.8 2.1 0.2 2.2 0.00.0 0.1 1.11.9 0.30.30.30.00.00.0 2010VAP 89.5' 5.3 1.7 0.2 2.2 Namitton*, Warren 2010 VAP % of Pop 7 Jones, Shannon (R) 2010 P.P. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 281,239 74.2% 378,958 29,367 8.40% Ind Asn Pac Olh MRT Wht Blk Hsp 87.7 4.9 2.2 0.1 3.5 0.0 0.1 1.5 2010 Pop 88.8 5.0 1.8 01 3.2 0.0 0.1 0.9 2010 VAP 4) Hamilton' 8 Seitz, William (R) 2010 VAP °6 of Pop 2010 P.P. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 255,408 75.7ti, 337,451 -12,140 -3471,t, Wht Bik Hap Ind Asn P. Oth MRT 2010 Pop 76.0 17.5 2.4 0.1 1.9 0.1 0.2 1.8 0 2010 VAP 78.9' 16.0 2.0 0.1 1.9 0.1 0.1 0.9 9 Ra+ '%^-tt:ri 2010VAP hofPOP 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 23,0305 771% 298658 -50 433 -1457% Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI Wht Blk Hsp 45.0 2.9 0.2 1 5 0.1 0.2 2.2 2010 PuP 47.9 „_. 2m0VAP 52.5' 41.3 2.5 0.2 1.8 0.1 0.1 1.4 050.2 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.2 and Poldical Guitles. All Rights Resened. Copyright (c) 2011. Polidata. www polldala.org POLIDATA1. Population (R) for Demographic 2010 from PL94-171 Redislricting Data from U S. Bureau of Me Gensus. 2000 Census data Irom various sources. State papulation: 11,53fi,504, 33 membeis, ideal is 349,591. short population)tleal population for this district type. The give a rough approximation of the tleviation from the 2010 Ideal Population for the current disth d cates e ne st live tlev af l 2 Pie Charts pie, or a Grey slice,ln 9a on ( or a White slice. indicates a posdtve deviation (extra population). A White 4.3. RacialA Grey breaks ple, are tor RacelHispanic Origin Combination: MRT is Mulli-Racial Total persons. The sum of these, aside from rountltng, sM1OUId be 100 percenL"for predominant group. are included if MRT is over 1%. White-Black, White-Am.Indian. White-ASian, White-Pacific, White-Other and Blzck-Am Indian. 5. Additional breaks 149pIYDEV-pspleal3-KF3U1 LPL 000104 Redistricting Handbook for OHIO Political Districts District Populations for STATE SENATE Page 39. Y.2 Greene, Clark, Madison 2010VAP %ofPOp 10 Widener. Chds(R) 2010 P.P. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 265.758 77 4`;5 343,341 -6,250 A,.79% WI WA WP WO 91 V . Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT WB 7.7 2.3 0.2 1.7 0.0 0.2 2.2 2010 Pop 85.7 0.0 0.1 1.3 0.3 0.2 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.1 2010VAP 87.2" 76 1902 1.7 Ler-;a' 2010 VAP % of Pop 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 239.010 76.1 % 314,125 v5,466 -10.15`m Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT W8 WI WA WP WO BI 2010 Pop 63.9 24.6 7.3 0.3 1.1 0.0 0.2 27 0.0 0.1 1.5 05 0.2 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.1 2010VAP 68.4*22.8 5.7 0.3 1.2 Allen, Darke', Shelby, Mercer, Champaign... 12 Faher,Keith(R) 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010 PoP. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 259,462 74.9. c 346,477 -3,1t4 -0.89°0 Wht Elk Hsp Ind M. Pac 011, MRT 2010POp 91.7 4.3 1.6 0.2 0.6 0.0 0.1 1.5 2010VAP 93.1 4.1 1.2 0.2 0.6 0.0 0.1 0.8 Lorair. kituoK, Ser^eca 2010VAP hofPop 2010POp. AbsDev. Re1Dev. 280,332 75.7% 370,509 20,918 5.98% Wht BIk Hsp IndAsn Pac Oth MRT W8 WI WA WP WO BI 2010Pap 82.4 6.7 7.8 0.2 0.8 0.0 0.1 2.0 2010 VAP 85.2 64 6.2 0.2 0.8 0.0 0.1 1.1 0.3 0.2 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.1 Clermont, S.loto8rown, Lawrence, Adams 14 Nfehaus, Tom (R) 2010 VAP % cf Pop 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 286,844 75.3% 380,921 31,330 8.96% Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT 2010 Pop 95.1 1.5 1.2 0.3 0.6 0.0 0.1 1.3 2010 VAP 95.8' 1.5 0.9 0.3 0.6 0.0 0.0 0.9 Fraak6n" 15 TFNas;.'s, C. Jeta !i. (L) 2010 VAP %of Pop 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 282,014 77.3% 364,680 15,089 4.32% WB WI WA WP WO BI Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac ON MRT 2010 Pop 52.7 36.9 4.8 0.3 2.2 0.1 0.2 2.8 201o VAP 57.8' 33.4 3.9 0.3 2.5 0.1 0.1 1.9 06 0.2 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.2 Franklin' 16 Hughes. Jim (R) 2010 VAP %of Pop 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 296,320 76.3% 388,173 38,582 11_04% Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI 2010 Pop 80.3 6.0 5.0 0.2 6.0 0.1 0.2 2.3 2010 VAR 82.8 5.5 4.1 0.2 6.0 0.0 0.1 1.4 0.3 0.4 0.4 0.0 0.0 0.1 Ross, Lawrence, Jackson, Highland. Plckaway', GaIIIa, 17 Daniels, David T. (R) 2010 VAP % of Pop 2010 P.P. Abs Oev. ReI Dev. 274,252 76.0% 360,811 11,220 3.21% . . ' , Wht 61k Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT - 2010 Pop 94.0 2.8 1.0 0.3 0.4 0.0 0.1 1.5 2010 VAP 94.4 3.1 0.8 0.3 0.4 0.0 0.0 0.9 Lake.Geauga,Cnyaho9a' 18 Grendell. Timothy (R) 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010 Pop. Abs Dev_ Rel Dev. 256.0°8 77.OYc 346273 -4.318 -124°0 Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT 0.0 0.1 1.2 201UPOp 91.8 2.8 2.7 0.1 1.4 2.7 2.0 0.1 1.4 0.0 0.1 0.6 2010VAP 93.2 (c) 2011. Polidata. wwmv polidata.org POLIDATA (R) Demographic and Political Guides. AllDatafrom Rights Reserved.U S. Bureau Oopyrght of the Census.2000 Gensus datzfromvarious sources.5tate population:11.536,504, 33 members. ideal is 349,591. type. t. Population for 2010 from PL94-171 Redistricting ize pieshod populztlon)deal population for this district give a rough approximation of the deviation from the 2010 Ideal Papulation for the current distriz ne s 2- Pie Chads exlra populztion). A Whife pie, or a Grey slice, indicates gative dev ( or a White slice, indicates a positive deviation ( 3. A Grey pie, are for RacelHispanic Origin Combination. MRT is Multi-Racial Total persons. The sum of these, aside from rounding, should be 100 percent. " for predominant group. 4. Racial breaks 5.AdditionalbreaksareincludedifMRTisoveri%.White-Black,White-Am.Intlian,White-Asian,White-Pacific.White-OtherandBlack-AmIndian. D9p1voev-pspbel2-rcv307 LPL 000105 Potitical Districts Redistricting Handbook for OHIO Page 39.Y.3 District Populations for STATE SENATE Delaware, Richiand, Knox, Ashland', Morrow 19 Jordan KdsfR) 2010 VAP % of Pap ' ' 2010 Pop. Abs Oev. Rel Oev. 301,481 74.2% 406,557 56,966 16.30% Wht Bik Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT 2010 Pop 90.0 4.4 1.6 0.1 2.1 0.0 0.1 1.5 2010 VAP 91.0 4.5 1.3 0.2 2.0 0.0 0.1 0.9 Muskingum, Washington, Coshocton, Athens*... 20 Stewart; Jimmy (R) 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 280,495 78.4% 357,708 8,117 2.32"/0 Pac Oth MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn 0.0 0.1 2010 Pop 94.2 2.1 0.9 0.2 0.8 0.0 0.1 1.1 0.3 0.1 0.1 0,0 0.0 0.0 2010 VAP 94.9' 2.1 0.7 0.2 0.8 Duyei'tc;;.a' 21 StnLh,S't;i''-*rY!t(CJj 2010 VAP % of Pop 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 212,591 75.8°,c 280.358 -69,233 Pac Oth MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI Wht Blk Hsp Ind Mn 0.0 0.2 1.8 2010 PoP 34.8 53.2 7.4 0.2 2.4 0.0 0.1 1.4 0.4 0.2 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.2 2010VAP 38.8 50.2* 6.4 0.2 2.9 Medina, Ashfarid*, Wayne, Holmes 22 Obttof, Larry (R) 2010 VAP % of Pop 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 273,023 73.7% 370,237 20,646 5.91% MRT Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth 1.0 2019 Pop 95.4 1.1 1.4 0.1 0.8 0.0 0.1 0.7 2010VAP 96.2* 1.1 1.1 0.1 0.8 0.0 0.0 Cuy2hcga* /? 201DVAP %OfPOp 2010 P.P. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 244,920 78.5%a 311.985 37,606-10.76"-e Asn P. Oth MRT WB WIWA WP WO BI Wht Bik HsP Ind 2010 Pap 77.5 9.0 8.8 0.2 2.3 0.0 0.2 1.9 201oVAP 81.2* 7.9 7.1 0.2 2.3 0.0 0.1 1.1 0.3 0.2 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.1 Cuyahoga' 2010 VAP % of Pop 2010 P.P. Abs Dev, Rei Dev. 280,398 78.0% 359,580 9,989 2,86% Wbt Blk Hsp Intl Ace Pac Oth MRT 2010 Pop 89.5 3.6 2.1 0.1 3.4 0.0 0.1 1.2 2010VAP 90.8* 3.4 1.7 0.1 3.2 0.0 0.1 0.7 {7uyaheea'. 201DVAP %ofPOp 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 234.090 76.4 %,, 3196.356 -43,235 -12.37% WB WI WA WP WO BI Wht Bik HsP Ind Asn Pac 01h MRT 2010 PoF 34.8 59.9 1.6 0.1 1.6 0.0 0.2 1.8 0.0 0.1 1.2 0.4 0.1 0,1 0.0 0.0 0.2 2010VAP 38.3 57.3 1.4 0.1 1.6 Sandusky, Seneca", Oitawa', kAarlon, Crawford, Union... 26 Gilimor, Karen (R) 2010 VAP % of Pop 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dee 'e63^535 75.8% 347509 1,982 -0.57°^0 Pac Oth MHT Wht 81k Hsp Ind Asn 0.0 0.1 1.4 2010 Pop 91.5 2.6 3.4 0.2 0.8 0.0 0.0 0.8 0 2010VAP 92.9 2.7 2.6 0.2 0.8 3ummit* of Pop 27 LaRose,Frank(R) 2010 VAP % 2010 P.P. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 2617138 76.8% 348274 -1,317 -0.38% Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn P. Oth MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI 2010Pap 85.5 8.3 1.4 0.2 2.4 0.0 0.1 1.8 2010VAP 88.0* 7.4 1.1 0.2 2.2 0.0 0.1 1.0 02 02 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.1 Guitles. AII Rights Reserced. Copyright (c) 2011, Polldata. www polidata.org antl Political data irom various sources- Siate popula6on:11,536,504, 33 members, ideal is 349,591. POLIDATA (R) Demographic the Census. 2000 Census 1. Populatlon for 2010 from PL94-171 Redistricting Data fmm US. Bureau of pie th, for this district type. of the deviation from the 20101deal Population for the current dlstric a ne short popuWt on^deal population 2. Pie Chzrts give a rough approximation A White pie, or a Grey slice, i diates gastive ( 3 A Grey pie, or a White slice, indicztes a positive devution ( extra population). zside from roun, should be 100 percent `for pretlominant group. MRT is MuXi-Racial Total persons. The sum of these, 4. Racial breaks are for Race/Hispanic Origin Combination- and Black-Am Indian. it MRT is over 1%. White-Black, White-Am.Indian, VJhite-ASizn, W hile-Pacifc, White-Other 5. Additional breaks are included t39pIY0EV-pspletllP-MY00t LPL 000106 Redistrictrng Handbook for OHIO Potiticat Districts District Poputations for STATE SENATE Page 39.Y.4 ^umrrut'. P or.eiPe 2010VAP %ofPop 2010 P.P. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 278,509 78.5°(0 354,926 5,335 1.53% WP WO BI Wht BIk Hsp Ind Asn P. Ottt MRT WB WI WA 2010 Pop 79.0 15.5 1.6 0.2 1.6 0.00.0 0.1 0.1 1.2 1.9 0.3 0.2 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.1 2010 VAP 81.2* 14.3 1.4 0.2 1.7 Stark' 29 Oelslager, Scott (R) 2010VAP % otPop 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 259.935 77.0% 337.506 12,085 WB WI WA WP WO el Wht BIk Hsp Intl Asn P. Oth MRT 2010 Pop 87.6 7.6 1.6 0.2 0.7 0.0 0.2 2.0 201oVAP 89.8 6.8 1.3 0.2 0.7 0.0 0.1 1.1 0.3 0.1 0.1 0.0 0.0 0.1 ^e@,ni)ian,. ferson, F'rsrri,>n... 3(1 2010VAP % of Pop ...... 2010 PaP. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 266.n85 78.6`6 338 710 - 0,881 -3.11`; ^ . Wht Blk HsP Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT 2010 Pop 94.0 2.9 1.3 0.1 0.3 0.0 0.1 1.3 2010 VAP 94.7' 3.0 1.1 0.1 0.3 0.0 0.0 0.7 Licking, Fairfield, Perry, Hocking. Pickaway Schaffer,Ttm (R) 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 301,729 74.7% 403,786 54,195 15.50% Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT 2010 Pop 92.3 3.7 1.4 0.2 0.7 0.0 0.1 1.6 2010 VAP 93.6' 3.3 1.1 0.2 0.7 0.0 0.1 0.9 Tnarnbull, Ash3a6::lz GBPbru. i:apri'Dj 2010 VAP % of Pop 2010 Pap. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 221,170 77.3% 311,809 37,782-10.81% Wht BIk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT 2010Pop 89.0 6.6 2.0 0.2 0.4 0.0 0.1 1.7 2010 VAP 90.7' ' 6.3 1.5 0.2 0.4 0.0 0.0 0.9 rc:aianic9, Stark'. -:'ar:cli. Tosaar2WZS" 33 Bcmasoni, ace.(V} 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010 Pop. AbsDev. Rel Dev. 252,631 78.1`%0 323.425 -26,166 -7 4$'/ ^ Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac 01b MRT 0.0 0.1 1.6 2010 Pop 81.7 12.1 3.7 0.2 0.6 2010 VAP 84.0' 11.2 3.1 D.2 0.6 0.0 0.1 0.9 POLIDATA(R)DemographicandPOliticalGUides.AllRightsReservetl.Copyright(c)2011-Polidata.wvn,POlidataorg 33members,itlealls349,591. Redistricting Data from U s. Burezu of the Census.2000 Census data from various sources. Staie p population: 11,536,504, 1. Population for 2010 fromPL94-171 sbod populationIdeal population for this district type. approximation of the deviation from the 2010 Ideal Popula0on for the current districdi ates e na eilve tlev e(on 2. Pie Charts give a rough A White pie, or a Grey slice, in 9 ( in0icates a positive tleviation (extra population). and Black-Am Intlbe 100 percent.' for predominant group. 3. A Grey pie, ar a White slice, The sum of these, s^_ ^her 4. Racial breaks are for RacelHispanlc Origin Combination. MRT is Multi-Racial Total persons- 5. Additional breaks are induded if MRT is over 1%. White-Black, White-Am.lndian, White-Asian, White-Pacifc, rsyplvoeV-pspieal2-xvao7 LPL 000107 Politicaf Districts Redistricting Handbook for OHIO Page 39. Y.5 District Poputations for STATE SENATE Ranked by 2010 Population per Member with Deviation from Ideal Population for 2010 TotPop AsbDev RelDev Disviet ED Member Franklin' 410 ,561 60,970 17,44 nd', Morrow 3 Bacon, Kevin (R) Delaware, Rfchland, Knox, Ashla 406, 557 56 ,966 16.30 19 Jordan, Kris (R) Lickina, Fairfield, Perry, Hocking, Pickaway 403 ,786 54,195 15.50 Schaffer, Tim (R) Franklin' 31 , 173 38,582 11,04 Hughes, Jim (R) 388 Cierniont, Scioto, Brown, Lawrence, Adams 16 380,921 31,330 8.96 Niehaus, Tom (R) Hamifton* , Warren 14 378.958 29.367 840 7 Jones,Shannon(R) 209'.8 5,9e I_erain, Hu.on', Sen.^ce iaye 3r0,5a^. Ashland', Wayne, Holmes 13 20,646 5.91 Medina , Larry (R) 370,237 22 Otrhof, 368,130 18 ,539 5.30 Butler 4 Cates, Gary (R) 364.630 4-32 ;'ranki.n' 1 7 -, evares C: neta B. tt'--i Lucas', Wood , Erie. Ottawa" 363,296 13,705 3.92 Jackson, Highland, Pickaw'ay". Gallia, ... , Mark (R) Ross, Lawrence , 2 Wagoller 360,811 11,220 3.21 17 Daniels, David T. (R) Cuyahoga* 359.580 9,989 2.86 .. Patton, Thomas (R) Musktngum, Washington. Coshocton , Athens' : 24 357,708 8,117 2.32 20 Stewart Jimmy (R) u ... Portage 1 ).i. 92F. . 5 3.:5 1 liams... iePfer rhC';aFIG} Hancock , Fulton , Putnam, Deflance" , Wil 28 *. 351 ,303 1,712 0.49 Hite, Cliff (R) Summit' I 274 -1 ,317 -0.38 ion ... Frank (R) 348, Seneca", Ottawa', Marion, Crav,rford, Un 27 LaRose , -1 ,982 -0 .57 Sandusky, 347.609 , , Shelby, Mercer, Champaign... 26 Giflmor , Karen (R) -3,114 -0.89 Alien Darke" Faber, Keith (R) 346,477 Lake, Geau9a,Cuyahoga" 12 345,273 -4,318 -1 .24 Grendeil, Timothy (R) Greeoe. Clark, Madison 18 343,341 -6,250 -179 4Nldener, Chr{s (R) o m aa.va Tw.Ca av,a . on lamwon.. 10 3318 , 00 o',8°`. 3.9 1 30 vPliro Ja^on (u) Stark" 337 ,506 12,085 -346 Oelslager, 6cott (R) Hamiiton' 29 337,451 -12,140 -3.47 Seitz. Wlllam (R) gomery" 8 336,772 12,819 3.67 Mont , Peggy (R) t ai I ig . +;[ar sli, Tus a"3was° 6 Lehner - ^.166 Z-M1' s23.425 hilami'. Darke" 33 Sch7avoni. doe (G) -31,352 -8.97 tvlontgomerp" . 5 Beagle, Bill (R) 318 ,239 ^ 4 1 2`i -t"sAl P-cw t 5 . ' G) rty7 ga` 11 1985 rJE if176 23 Sxn?: 1 fi de1J.lD) "tt).L 1 nl. ll . +'J`hid-HIi2 } 3 ? i r",a,i t .' SI 32 c*ar clE,I !D 2.31 ro4a^ uresr Mii7a tC1 ;t)>.5`,•v ' 25 i 4.b58 ^C,,9,'.3 < mvww Poridata org POLIDATA (R) Demographic and Political Guides. AII Rights Resened. Copyright (c) 2011. Polidata. 11,536,504, 33 members, ideal is 349,591- 2000 Census tlata from vxrious sources. State populafion: 1. Population for 2010 from PL94-171 Redistricting Data from U S. Bureau of the Census. population for this tlistrict type. Population for the current distrian Th e seem eviation from the 2010Ideal shod popula[ion)deal Pie Chads give a rougM1 apPmximation of the tl s a negative tleviahn ( (extra populafion). A White pie, or a Grey slice, 1011 percenL * for pretlominant group. 3. A Grey ple, or a W hite slice, indicates a positive deviation from roundin Origin Gbmbination. MRT iV h 4. Racial breaks are for Race/Hispanic MRe^AmIndan^ White Asian, W hfie-Pa fc^ WMte-0ther and Bla^k-Am Indbe if MRT is over 1%. White-Rlack, 5. Additional breaks zre included iJ9pIYaEV-pspletll2-KFJfII LPL 000108 Redistricting Handbook for OHIO for STATE SENATE Political Districts District Poputations Page 39.V.6 Ranked by Member (Last Name) with Deviation from Ideal population for 2010 District TotPop AsbDev ReiDev ED Member 17.44 Franklin' 410 561 60,970 ke' Bacon, Kevin (R) Montgomery' , Miami' . Dar 3 318.239 -31,352 -8.97 5 Beagle, Bilt(R) Lucas' 1. -125 3548ti -1i..5 N oxm i.:-.di T -buil Asrl?abuLa 3i 80" 82 G,.aro r' n} 539 6.30 Butler Gallia.... 368, 130 18 , Ross, Lawrence, Jackson, Highland , Pickanvay' , 4 Gates, Gary (R) , 3.21. 3 60,811 11 220 Allen, Darke', Shelby. Mercer, Champaign ... 17 Danlels, David T. (R) 477 -3, 114 -039 , Union... 346, Sandusky, Seneca', Otlawa ', Marion, Craet4ord 12 Faber, Keith (R) -1,982 -0.57 347,609 Lake, Geauga,Cuyahoga' 26 Gillmor, Karen (R) -4,318 -1.24 Williams ... 345 ,273 Hancock, Fulton, Putnam, Def^ance* , 18 Grendeli, Tlmothy (R) 1,712 0.49 351 .303 ' q Hite, Cliff (R) 388.17 3 38,582 11.04 Frankiin Hughes, Jim (R) 8 40 Hamilton', Warren 16 378,958 29,367 Delaware. Rlchian.d, Knox, Ashland' , Morrow 7 Jones,Shannon(R) 58,966 16.30 406,557 F{arr.il4ofi 19 Jordan, Kris (R) 35S J0Xi3 -1:4.5' Summi!' J 'fHam j (JC 348,274 -1,317 -0.38 27 LaRose Franrt(R) , -3.67 Montaomery* 336 ,772 12 819 er n i'-°'oc' , 6 Lehner . Peggy(R) 20 918 5.98 31/1-1 ;02 , Clern ont Scioto, Brown, Lawrence, Adams 3 . ftAuitn y "`dyfV (Lt)_ 31330 8.96 380,921 Medina, Ashland', Wayne. Holmes 14 NieOaus Tom (R) , 20,646 5,91 370 237 Stark* 22 Obhot, Larry (R) 337,506 -1 2 ,085 3 .46 Oelslager Scott (R) 80 2.86 Cuyahoga 29 9 5 laaf 24 Pattan Thomas (R) 3 - , e2G :, 335 1^.1;3 -iatoy ^u:rostt; Licking , Palrfleid PcrryHockina Pickaway 403,786 54 , 195 15.50 o']U c °' Scheffer Tim (R) I o..ln&S12n'n (., - T- 31 323 ,"26 26.166 -7 •48 3chl2r Lu (D) Hamilton ' 33 337,451 12,140 -3.47 11 ryc oAi' g Seltz VVllllam (R) 1,985 7 6 )6 .75 n v .'.(a) i..60 60.^1a ' 271, 58 Muskingum, Washington. Coshcc ton, Athens' ... 2. SnjJ, iit 357,708 . 8,117 2.32 Fra^k6:^' . 20 Stewart, Jimmv (R) n 5^,FC 5 nRtl. C . 53 735 ..3' L yaft,ecw' . .,Gn 3iS Lucas' Wood Erie , Ottawa"' (c) 2011. Polidata. wwm polidata_org ulation' 1t,536,504, 33 members, ideal is 349.591. R) Demographic and Political Guides Ali Rights Reserved Copyri9ht this district type. POLIDATA1. Population ( for 2010 from PL94-171 Redistricting Data hom U S. Bureau of ihe Census. 2000 Census data from various swrws. Stat P eop lation for f short populaGO udeal popu 2. Pie Charls give a rough approximation of the deviation fmm the 20101deal Population for t acGrensldicerlind cates a elgztive deviafion ( exira populzllorl). A White pie, o Y O percen[.' for predomisnP voeV-oPnlemz-kf3o7 pie. or a White slice, intlicates a positive deviation ( 3. A Grey O 4. Rzciat breaks are for RacelMspanlc OngN Combinz0on. MRT is Multi-Racial TotaNphyte-Asian, hWhile-Pac fc. White-Other and n6lack-Am Ind aa 5. Additional breaks are Induded 4 MRT is over 1%. White-Black, White-Am.lndian, LPL 000109 Political Districts Redistricting Handbook for OHIO Page 39.Y.7 District Poputations for STATE SENATE Ranked by 2010 Minority Voting Age Population for Selected Subgroups District Minorify HsplLat Black Asian ED Member 1.6 1 .4 573 ^t= Nina (U) 2"s "urn,r. 6.4 50.2 ^( 2" 21 Snft^, Stllrley A. {D) 25 41.; 1,8 h*-m^y Fric H r01 n o 32 4 a 5 Frankiin Tavares,Chrieta ^Fi.(D ) 422 Montgomery', Miami`, Darke' 15 323 1.7 27.9 1-0 5 Beagle, Bill (R) 31.0 5 .7 22.8 1.2 i .;cos' ?:rrnun, ^na (01 Franklin' 11 28.1 3 .9 19.1 . 3.3 3 Bacon. Kevln (R) 2.0 16.0 1.9 Hamilton' 18521 1 S.nmt Pc.'-ao= 8 Seitz, Wdham(ft) 1,4 11.3 1.7 18.7 28 sa,rmta:,Tne,mas(D) 7.i 7a 2.3 ^u}bn.Fa ^;ki:hdz- 47ciaetJ.^ Dj Franklin ard4LZ,., 2.3 17.3 4.1 5.5 6.0 16 Hughes Jlm(R) ,H1 31 2 0, fi F'-eon t rK, aroi-'s- to-un.t uer S necz. 33 -Fa'trla^n „loe tD1 f2 0,4 9.n 13 h=.:ar,ning Gzyl2 {(}) . 1} o. . Butler . 13.6 3.2 6.6 2 4 Cates, Gary (R) Greene, Clark, Madison 4 92.8 1 .9 76 1.7 Widener , Chris(R) Summit' 10 12.0 1.1 7.4 2.2 27 LaRose , Frank (R) HamSlton', Warren 11.1 1.8 5.0 3.2 Jones, Shannon (R) Montgomery' 7 10 .6 1.7 5.3 2.2 6 Lehner, Peggy (R) 1.3 6.8 0.7 Stark* 29 (R) 10.2 1.5 Wood, Erie, Ottawa" Oelsiager, Scott 9.6 3.0 3.9 Lucas°, 2 ii,'.i tabu`.a Wagqner, Mark (R) i 5 6.3 '),4 Tr:+rriot;li, 32 Gair,rc.. Caprl (O? 9.2 1 - 7 34 32 buyahoga' 24 Patton, Thomas (R) . 9 0 1,3 4.5 2.0 Delaware, Richland, Knox, Ashland', Morrow Sandusky, Seneca', Ottawa', Marion, Crawford, Union... 19 Jordan, Kris (R) 2.6 2 7 0.8 Gillmor, Karen (R) 71 Allen, Darke', Shelby, Mercer, Champaign... 26 7,0 12 41 0.6 12 Faber. Keith (R) 2 .0 2. 7 1.4 Lake, Geauga. Cuyzhoga* Grendell, Timothy ( R 6 .9 Licking, Fairfield, Perry, Hocking, Pickaway 18 ) - 6.3 1.1 3.3 0.7 31 Schaffer, Tim (R) 0.6 Hancock, Fulton, Putnam, Deflance', Willlams... 6 .2 3.9 0.9 Ross, Lawrence, Jackson, Highland, Pickaway', Galiia. ... 1 Flite,Cflff(R) 0.8 31 0A T. (R) 525.5 poicuT ut'na f scaa wes :jefit;son r13msoa.. 1 7 Daniels David .1 i • 0 7 3 ,rrso i sen (D) 5.0 0.7 2.1 0.8 20 Stewart, Jimmy (R) 0.9 1.5 0.6 CleSmooL Scioto, hBrown, Law encenAdamss .., Metlina. Ashland', Wayne, Holmes 14 Niehaus , Tom (R) 4'2 } 1 1} 0.8 22 Obttoi, Larry (R) 3'8 c) 2011. Polidata, www polidata org ideal is 349,591. R) Demographic and Politicai Guides. AII Rights Reserved. Copyright ( POLIDATA1. Popltlalinn ( for 2010 from PL94-171 Redistricnng Data from U 5. Bureau of the Census. 2000 Census data from various sources. State opulation: 11,536,504. 33 members, ct. scand give a rough approxlmxtion of the deviation irom the 2010 Ideal Population for th e current I. Pie Charts I cef!ind cales e neigaWeode'viati n(short popu at oe)deal population for this district type- or a White srice, indicztes a posi4ve deviation (exha population). A White pie, or a Grey s yside from rounding, should be 100 percen[. * for predominant group. 3. A Grey pie, The ARacialbrezhsareforRacelHispanicOriginCOmbination.MRTisMvltFRacialTOtah^e-Asian, are included if MRT is over 1%. White-Black, White-Am.lndian, W 5. Addilional breaks iJ9p1YeEV-papletl12-KF301 LPL 000110 THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY BLANK LPL 000111 Political Districts Redistricting Handbook for OHIO Page 39.H.1 District Populations for CONGRESS Cincinnatf and western suburbs 2010VAP %ofPOp 1 Chabot, Steve (R) 2010PaP AbsDev. Re1Dev. 454,654 76A`m 598.699 -122,333 -16.97% Wht Bik Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI 2010 Pop 63.4 30.4 2.6 0.2 1.3 0.1 0.2 1.9 2010 VAP 66.9' 28.0 2.2 0.2 1.5 0.1 0.1 1.1 0.4 0.2 0,2 0.0 0.0 0.1 Cincinnati* and eastern suburbs; Porism2^iD VAPa% of'POp Schmidt. Jean (R) 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 507,813 75.4Ri:. 673,873 -47,159 -654`•S Wht BIk Hap Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT 2010 Pop 89.7 4.4 1.8 0.2 2.2 0.0 0.1 1.5 2010 VAP 90.7' 4.4 1.5 0.2 2.1 0.0 0.1 0.9 Dayton*, Kettering 2010 VAP % of Pop 3 Turner, Michae! R. (R) 2010 P.P. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 468.682 76.2% 610,899 s80,133-11.11% WM Bik Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI 2010 Pop 77.6 16.6 1.9 0.2 1.8 0.0 0.1 1.8 2010 VAP 79.5' 15.8 1.5 0.2 1.7 0.0 0.1 1.1 0.3 0.2 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.1 Mansfieid; Lima; Findlay; Marion 2010 VAP % of Pop 4 Jordan, Jim (R) 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 480,530 75 9% 632.,171 -88,261 -12.24% Wht Blk HsP Ind Asn P. Oth MRT 2010Pop 90.3 5.1 2.0 0.2 0.7 0.0 0.1 1.6 2010VAP 91.6* 5.1 1.6 0.2 0.7 0.0 0.1 09 Bowling Green; Tifpn; Fremont; Defiance 2010VAP %ofPOp Latta, Robert E. (R) 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rei Dev. 475.585 75.8`.'. 627,799 -93,233 -1293'i Wht Bik HsP Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT .1 2010 Pop 91.6 1.4 5.1 0.2 0.6 0.0 0.1 1 2010 VAP 93.2 1.4 4.0 0.2 0.6 0.0 0.0 0.7 Boardman; Athens; Steubenville; Marietta 2010VAP %ofPap Johnson, Bill (R) 2010Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 492.816 79.0°7 623,742 -97,290 -13.49% VJbt Blk Hap Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT 2010 Pop 94.1 2.5 1.1 0.2 0.7 0.0 0.1 1.3 2010 VAP 94.7* 2.5 0.9 0.2 0.7 0.0 0.0 0.9 Springfield; Cofumbus'; Beavercreek; Lancaster 2D10 VAP %of Pap 7 Austria, Steve (R) 2010 Pap. Abs Dev- Rel Dev. 516,786 75-6%, 683,371 -37.661 -5 22'/0 Oth MRT WB WIWA WP WO BI Wht Bik HsP Ind Asn Pac 2010 PoP 83.7 10.1 2.4 0.2 1.3 0.0 0.2 2.1 2010VAP 85.7 9.5 1.9 0.2 1.3 0.0 0.1 1.2 0.3 0.2 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.1 Hamifton'; Middlotown'; Dayton' 2010VAP %ofPOp John A. (R) Boehner, 2010 Pop- Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 497,791 75.C% 663,644 37,388 i .96%, Pac Oth MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI Wht Bik Hsp Ind Asn 0. 1 1 .8 6.0 3.1 0.2 1.8 0.1 2010PaP 86.9 5.4 2.5 0.2 1.8 0.0 0.1 1.0 0.3 0.2 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.0 2010VAP 89.0* TCiedo;Sar..Gusk:; 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 476.030 76.91= 619,010 -102,022 -14.15% WA WP WO BI Blk Hsp Intl Asn Pac Oth MRT WB WI Wht 15.0 5.4 0.2 1.2 0.0 0.1 22 2010 Pop 75.7 12 0.4 0.2 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.1 14.0 4.2 0.2 1.3 0.0 0.1 2010VAP 79.0' POLIDATA (R) Demographic and Political Guides. All Rights Reserved. Copyright (c) 2011. Polltlala. www polidata.ory embers, itleal is ]21,032. 1. Population for 2010 from PL94-171 Redistricting Dala from U S. Bureau of the Gensus. 2000 Census data from vanous soumes. State population: 11,536,504, tfi m type. 2. Pie Chzrts give a rough approximation of the deviation hom the 2010Itleal Population for the current district. a nell aGve dev al on (short poVUlztion)deal population for this district 3. A Grey pie, or z White slice, indicates a positive deviation (extra popuiation). A Wbite pie, or z Grey slice, i aside from rounding, should be 100 yercenc `for pretlominant gmup The 4. Rzcial breaks are tor RaceMlspanic Orlgln Gombinatlon. MRT ii M ' Whlte-Pac fic. WhiteAther and Bleck-Am Indian. hiteAm IndanaWhte-ASian. 5. Additional breaks are includetl H MRT is over 1%. White-Black, [39pIH0EV-pspletl12-KF34] LPL 000112 Redistricting Handbook for OHIO Poiitical Districts District Populations for CONGRESS Page 39.H.2 Cie^ularld" 3nd wr;strsrr, suburbs . 2010vAP rofPOp `Jew?ts J. (C) i0 Kuunlcb, 2010 PoOAbs Dev. Rel Dev. 466;916 77.9% 599,205 -121,827 -16.90% WB WI WA WP WO BI Pac Otb MRT Wht BIk Hsp Ind Asn 0.0 0.1 1.7 8.3 7.5 0.2 2.2 0.3 02 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.1 2010 Pop 80.0 0.0 0.1 1.0 2010VAP 83.4` 7.1 6.0 0.2 2.1 ,_ st,err; suburbs 2010 VAP % af Pop 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 415,585 76.9`.1. 640,432 -180,600 -25.05a-', Pac Oth MeT W6 Wl WA WP WO BI Wht Bik Hsp Ind Asn 2010 Pop 33.6 59.3 2.6 0.2 2.3 0.0 0.2 1.7 2010VAP 37.256.4* 2.3 0.2 2.6 0.0 0.1 1.2 0.4 0.1 0.1 0.0 0.0 0.2 Columbus* and eastern suburbs 2010VAP %ofPOp 12 Tiberi, Patrick J. (R) 2010 PopAbs Dev. Rel Dev. 557,957 73.8% 756,303 35,272 4.89% Oth MRT WB Wl WA WP WO BI Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac 21.7 3.5 0.2 3.6 0.0 0.2 2.3 2010 Pop 68.5 0.0 0.1 1.4 0.4 0.2 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.1 4D 2010 VAP 71.3` 20.4 2.9 0.2 3.5 CLqdt:n02. 2010VAP °7oofPOp 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 494,205 761% 649.102 -71,930 -9.98`4 MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI Whl BIk Hap Ind Asn Pac Olh 2010 Pop 79.6 11.8 4.6 0.2 1.7 0.0 0.1 1.9 2010VAP 82.4* 10.9 3.7 0.2 1.7 0.0 0.1 1.0 0.30.20.20.00.00.1 Norlhern Shore; Geauga Co.; 6tenter; Stow 2010VAP %ofPOp 14 LaTaureHe. Steven C. (R) 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 494,815 76.31l. 648,128 -72,904 -10:11% Wht Bik Hsp Ind Asn Pac OtN MRT 2010 Pop 90.8 3-6 2.3 0.1 1.8 0.0 0.1 1.3 2010 VAP 92.2 3.5 1.8 0.1 1.7 0.0 0.0 0.7 Columbus' and western suburbs 2010 VAP % af Pop Stivers, Steve (R) 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 528,874 77.6°0 681,567 -39,475 -5.47% WB WI WA WP WO BI Ind Asn Pac Ofh MRT Whf Blk HsP . 2010 Pop 79.8 9.2 4.5 0.2 3.6 0.1 0.2 2.2 0.4 0.3 0.3 0.0 0.0 0.1 2010 VAP 82:2" 8.4 3.7 0.2 3.9 0.0 0.1 1.4 Canton: Medina; Allianee* 2010 VAP % of Pap 16 Renacci, Jim (R) 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 491171 76,2'A 644691 -:'6,341-1Qo`9°io Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT 2010 Pop 90.8 4.9 1.5 0.2 0.7 0.0 0.1 1.7 2010VAP 92.4 4.5 1.2 0.2 0.7 0.0 0.1 0.9 ^n(CY!` 4^ ctO'idl : Ft "Hn K°r.1 2010 VAP h of Pop 2010POP^ AbsDev. RetOev_ 471,408 78.6`b 600,111 -120,921 -116E7°m Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI 2010 Pop 82.1 12.0 2.7 0.2 1.0 0.0 0.1 1.9 2010VAP 84.5' 10.9 2.2 0.2 1.1 0.0 0.1 1.1 0.3 0.2 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.1 Zanesville; Chillicothe; Newark' 2010 VAP % of Pop 18 Gibbs, Bob (R) 2010Ppp. AbsDev. RelDev. 493_934 75.6°,6 653167 -6.',8c5 -9.41`< Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT 94.9 1.9 1.0 0.2 0.3 0.0 0.1 1.5 2010 Pop 2010VAP 95,7* 1.9 0.8 0.2 0.3 0.0 0.0 0.9 POLIDATA (R) Demographic and Political Guides. AII Rights Reserved. Copyright (c) 2011- Polidata. wwr+ polNata.org sources 504, 16 members, itleal is 721,032. 1. Population for 2010 hom PL94-171 ftetlistricting Data from U 5. Bureau ot the Census. 2000 Gensus da from varioussitive .dev State afi nlpopuiationa1;536, (short pop aton)tleal population for [his district type. g a rough approxlmation of the deviation from tbe 20101deal PopulaGOn for thz cunent tlistrictdi ates a ell9a 2 Piz Charts ive 3. A Grey pie, or a White slice, indicates a posibve tleviation (extra population). A While pie, or a Grey slice, in 4. Raclal brezks zre for RacelNispanic Origin Combination.-MRT is Mu1ti-Racial TotaWh R Asian, While Pzc fc, White-Ofer and Black-Am Ind zrt 00 percent" for predominanf group. 5. Addillonal breaks ara included if MRT is over 1%. White-Black, White-Am.lndian, I39pirvoev-pspiedt2-kr307 LPL 000113 Political Districts Redistricting Handbook for OHIO Page 39.H.3 District Populations for CONGRESS Ranked by 2010 Population per Member with Deviation from Ideal Population for 2010 Distdct TotPop AsbDev RetOev ED Member 272 4.89 Columbus" and eastern suburbs 756,303 35 , k ; Lancaster Tiberi, Patrick J. (R) Springfield; Columbus' ; Beavereree 12 683 ,371 -37,661 -5.22 n suburbs Austria, Steve (R) , Columbus' and wester P 7 681 ,557 -39 475 -5.47 bs; ortsmouth; SharonviAe" Stivers, Steve (R) 159 Cincinnzti" and eastern subur 15 673,873 -47 , -6.54 ' hmidt, Jean (R) 7 96 Hamilton'; Middletown '; Dayton 2 Sc 663,644 -57,388 - . Boefiner, John A. (R) Zanesvtlle Chillicothe, Newark' 8 653,167 -67,865 -9.41 Cuy2hogaFs1S" 18 Gibbs, Bob (R) 649.102 .-1.93^; 9.=8 Northern Shore; Geauga Co.; Mentor. Stow 11 3ett} i'?t -10.11 648, 128 -72,904 Canton; Medina;Alltance ' 14 LaTourette, Steven C. (R) -76,341 -10.59 644 ,691 Dayton', Kettering 16 Renacci, Jim (R) 640899 -80 ,133 -11-11 ion ner, Michael R. (R) . M ansfiefd; Lima; Findlay. Mar 3 Tur 632,771 -88,261 -1 2 24 Jordan, Jim (R) -12,93 Bowling Green; Tiffin; Fremont: Defiance 4 627,799 -93 ,233 Latta, Robert E. (R) Boardman; Athens; Steubenville; Marietta 5 623,742 -97,290 -13.49 6 Johnson B.I! (R) -1 4-15 ' k e0n a ' 'U b19,010 '102,022 'en ; Keo; Ka(Y^r, t.9cr^, CD) 77 K. c. v'ounust rn Izr, 9 E06.=11 -1t(1,'.,2- 1 - , 3,an,Tr'-C" C e-lx3"andwti,st r zr:-'s r 589205 -1<11827 -16.90 'vennis.l.(Dj Cincinnati' and wester, suburbs i Y icini h 598 ,699 -122,333 -16.97 Chabot, Steve (ft) CI i.r.d"candeww .u.. 540,432 -180,600 -25.05 , Fud9e â.lacctaL-{Di c POLIDATA (R) Demographic and P°IIII°efGuides. All Rights Reserved. C°pyrlght l) 2011. Polidata, v+ww polidata org 1. Population for 2010 from PL94-171 RedisVic6ng Data fmm US. Bureau of Ne Census 2000 Census data irom various sources- State population: t1,536,504. 16 members, ideal is 721,032. 2. Pie Cbarts give a rough approximation °t the deviallon from RMe 20101deal Populafion forthe arren[ distrldd cztes a neiga(ve devuf n(short populafi°^^deal population for th9 disptrict type. 3. A Grey pie, or a White slice, Indicates a posltive deviation (exha population). A White pie, or a Grey slice, ln 4. Racial breahs are for RaceMispanic Origin C°mbination. MRT is Muki-Racial TotaW hee Asian, Whke-Pac fm, Whi[e-Other and Bla k Am Indbe 100 pemenL " for predominant ou 5. Addition°I breaks are induded if MRT is over 1%. Whlte-Black, White-Am.intlian, IJ9pIHaEV-pspledl2-KF391 LPL 000114 Redistricting Handbook for OHIO Political Districts District Populations for CONGRESS Page 39.H.4 Ranked by Member (Last Name) with Deviation from Ideal Population for 2010 District TotPop AsbDev Re1Dev ED Member Springfield; Co(umbus'; Beavercreek Lancaster -37,661 -5.22 683,371 Middletown`; Dayton' 7 Austria, Steve (R) ^57 388 -7 96 Hamilton*; John A. ( R) 663644 Cincinnafi' znd western suburbs 8 Boehner; 598,699 -122,333 -16.97 Chabot, Steve (R) 25.05 CI veta'- ' and oa .t - Subv:rhs I J40 C32 _180 g0C ' FudBe. Marcia L . tD) Zanesvtlle; Chillicothe . Newark' 653,167 -67,865 -9.41 Gibbs, Bob (R) Boardman: Athens; Steubenville; Marietta 18 623 ,742 -97,290 -13.49 6 Mansfield; Lima; Findlay; Marion Johnson, Bill (R) 632,771 -88 ,261 -12.24 4 Jordan,Jim(R) (1. g22 Toiua Szrd° .ky 6.-^',018 v '^antur fi1 cv(D? E' -dN-'uL.^rbs S ?2182? -16.`JU StoW 10 r.adr.lc Cen.4,,3.(D) Northern Shore; Geauga Co.; Mentor; 648,128 -72,904 -10.11 fance LaTOUrette, Steven C. (R) Bowling Green: Tiffin; Frar.wnt; De 14 627 79H -93,233 -12.93 Laita. Robert E(R) Canton ; Medina Alllance ' 5 644:691 -76,341 i059 (R) 'n;.a` w^ -1!^arren;hent 16 Renaccl, Jim ?20°,25 1677 Anrn Ye p7yan,Tlm (Di 600 ^ 1" Cincmnatl and eastern suburbs; Portsmouth; Sharomrille" 673 ,873 -47,159 -6.54 Schmidt, Jean (R) -5147 CoWmbus' and western suburbs 2 681 ,557 -39,475 Stvers. Steve (R A1c :ain' ; Iyr:a:Cuyahoy3 15 615, 142 -71 ,930 -938 t10e, BettY (Di Cotumbus' and eastern suburbs ?3 S0 756,303 35,272 4.89 Tiberi. Patrick J. (R) Dayton', Kedering 12 640,893 -80,133 -11.11 3 Turner. Michael R. (R) POLIDATA (R) Demographic and Political Guides. All Rights Reserved. Copyright (c) 2011. Polidala. www polidatz.org 16 members, itleal is 721,032: 2000 Gensus data from various sources. Srate population: 11,536 , 504 , population for this Burezu of the Census. 1. Population for 2010 from PL94-171. Redistricting Dafa from t1 5. PopulatbnPfor ffie 2. Pie Charts give a rough apProximaGon of the deviation from the 2010Itleal cates e negafive tleviatonl (short poDUla[ion)deal dis[ric[ rype. exYra population). or e G e^sti e,rlind . 3. A Grey pie, or a W hite sllce, inAlcates a positive deviation ( A Whife y aside from rountling, should be 100 percent.' for predominant gmup 4.RacialbreaksareforRecelHispanicOrigioCOmbinafion.MRTisMuM-RacialTOtaMM^sian.M1White-PacficSWM1ite-OtherandBlack-Amindiaa tasplnoev-psvleala-kFSO7 included if MRT is over 1%. WhHe-Black, White-Am.lndizn, 5. Adddional breaks are LPL 000115 Political Districts Redistricting Handbook for OHIO Page 39.H.5 District Populations for CONGRESS Ranked by 2010 Minority Voting Age Population for Selected Subgroups Aslan, District inorlty . HsplLat Black ED Member 26 Cle.elan3'andeasienrsuburbs 6Z I)g; ; 2.3 S64@ } } Fradge.N9zrcia L. (Dl 281 15 33.2 22 mbes' and eastern suburbs t Cbabot, Steve (R) 2.9 20.3 3.5 Colul , . . (R) 28.5 1 Toiedo: Sarics5y 12 Tiberi Patrir k J 21.0 4^2 .3 t n`, Kettering 9 Kaptuq tJua cq (D} 15 158^40 1.7 Dayte i h l R. (R) 20.4 bus' and western suburbs 3 Turner, M c ae 3. 7 B 4 3.9 Golum 17'7 r" I-:El ria s) L v+'all" 1G Stivers, Steve (R) .7.6 ,i9 h.7 Aflro s 13 ^uor 3et}' iC, 7_.4 Icvsic a and - 5tem uc DF 9 . (D) ,6ro s. cov.P;ita .^ Kent 0 n ^'tt n cnlsJ 2.1 n . t` An o"" n r ,.5.5 '; Beavercreek; Lancaster t Rrkn.Tlrt.,? . 1.9 9.5 1.3 Springfle{d, Columbus (R) t42 Hamilton'; Middietown': Dayton` 7 AustrSa , Steve 2 .5 5 4 1 .6 (R) 1 LO ortsmouth; Sharonville 8 Boehner, John A. 1.5 4.4 2.1 Ciacinnati- P Schmidt, Jean (R) 9'2 . L} aeFindley, Mzrion 2 8.6 1.6 5.1 0 7 Jordan, Jim (R) 1.7 NorNern Shore; Geauga Co.; Mentor; Stow 4 7.8 1 .8 3.5 LaTOUr tte, Steven C. (R) Cantoq Medina; Alliance' 14 e 7.6 1.2 4.5 0.7 Renacci , Jim (R) Bowling Greerr, Tiffm; Fremont; Defiance 16 6.9 4 0 t.4 0.6 LaYta, Robert E. (R) . Boardman; Athens; Steubenville; Marietta 5 5.2 0 .9 25 0 7 Johnson, Bs0 (R) 1 9 Zanesville; Ch111fcothe; Newark" 6 4.1 0 .8 . p.3 18 Gibbs, Bab (R) www polldata.ory and Pol'fical Guides. All Rights Reserved- Copyright (c) 2011. Polidata. n 536,504, 16 members, ideal is Y21,032. POLIDATA (R)for Demographic 2010 from PL94-171 Redistricting Dzta from U S. Bureau of the Ceosus. 2000 Census data fiom vzous sources. Sta[e population: 11, 1. Population e the e nelgative tleviation (shotl populaGOn)deal population {or this district type. 2 Ple Charts give a rough appmximation of the deviation hom the 2010 oo A`NMten for o r acGrey sGce, indichh (extra popu1af ). "for predominant group. 3. A Grey pie, nr a White slice, iodicates a positive deviation p1e^ asMe from rounding, should be 100 percent. 4. Racial bmaks are for RacelHispanic Origin Combinzflon. MRT is Multi-RaclzlTntaere-Asian,hWh te-Pac fic, White-Other znd Black-Am Indian. 1%. White-Black, White-Am.lndian, 5, Additional breaks are includeE if MRT is over 139pIH0EW psPled@-KF]n) LPL 000116 THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY BLANK LPL 000117 Political Districts Redistricting Handbook for OHIO Page 39.H.1 Racial Subgroups for CONGRESS Cinctnnafi" and western suburbs ChabOt, Steve (R) 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Ret Dev. 454,854 760%:. 598,699 -122,333 -1607cZ, WB WI WA WP WO BI Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Olh MRT 2010 Pop 63.4 30.4 2.6 0.2 1.3 01 02 1.9 0.4 0.2 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.1 2010 VAP 66.9* 28.0 2.2 0.2 1.5 0.1 0.1 1.1 Cincinnefi' and eastern suburbs: Portsmouth; Sharonvilie' 2010VAP %o(POp 2 Schmldt, Jean (R) 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 507.833 .'S44i 573,8i3 7,159 354% ^ Wht &k Hsp Ind Asn P. Oth MRT 4.4 1.8 0.2 2.2 0.0 0.1 1.5 2010 Pop 89.7 90.7 4.4 1.5 0.2 2.1 0.0 0:9 09 w.w 2010VAP Dayton", Kettenng 3 Turnar, Michael R. (R) 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev_ 488,682 'u.-..u 540.899 -80,133 -11 11^a WB WI WA WP WO BI Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT 201oPOp 77.6 16.6 1.9 0.2 1.8 00 01 1.8 0.3 0.2 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.1 2010VAP 79.5' 15.8 1:5 0.2 1.7 0.0 0.1 1.1 IVansfleid: Lima; Findlay: Marian 4Jordan,Jlm (R) 2010 VAP %of Pop 2010 Pop- Abs Dev Rel Dev. 480,530 7^,.9", 632,771 -88,261 -1224r,3 Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT 2010POp 90.3 5.1 20 0.2 0.7 0.0 0.1 1.6 2010VAP 91.6' 5.1 1.6 0.2 0.7 0.0 0.1 0.9 Bowling Greem TIIPin; Fremont: Deflance Latin, Robert E (R) 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev 475.5S5 74.$^c 627,799 -93,233 - i 29s:b Whl BIk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT 2010 Pop 91.6 1.4 5.1 0.2 0.6 0.0 0.1 11 2010VAP 93.2' 1.4 4.0 0.2 0.6 0.0 00 0.7 C3oardmanrAlnens; Steubenville; Marletta Johnson. BIII(R) 201DVAP %ofPop 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 492,816 79.G°io 823.742 -97,290 ?3 49% Whl Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Olh MRT 0.0 0.1 1.3 2010Pop 94.1 2.5 1.1 0.2 0.7 - 0.0 0.0 0.9 2010 VAP 94.7 2.5 0.9 0.2 07 Springlle{dCobambus'Beavercreek: Gancasler 7 Austrla, Steve (R) 2010 VAP %of Pop 2010 POp. Abs Dev Rei Dev. 516,78e 756%, 683.371 -37,661 -5.22".6 Wht Blk Hsp fnd Asn Pac Oih MRT WB WI WA WP WO 81 *.^. 2010POp 63.7 10.1 24 0.2 1.3 00 0.2 2.1 2010 VAP 85.7' 95 1.9 0.2 1.3 0.0 01 1.2 0.3 (P2 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.1 Hamitlon'; b1iddletown°Dayten' Boehner,John A.(R) 2010 VAP %of Pop 2010POp. AbsDev. HelDev. 497,7Gi 7`^0`.'b Gc3.544 -57.389 -796% Whl Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI $ O1 01 1.8 2010 Pop 86.9 6.0 3.1 0.2 1 2010VAP 89.0' 5.4 2.5 02 1.8 0.0 0.7 1.0 0.3 02 02 00 0.0 00 i 0`e,'.0. iandUS4 ' 2010 VAP % of Pop 2010 Pop. Abs Dev Rel Dev. 476.t'3ii r5 9 %. 619,010 -102,022 -1415v MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Olh 2010 Pop 75.7 15.0 5.4 0.2 1.2 0.0 0.1 2.2 14.0 4.2 0.2 1.3 00 01 1.2 0.4 0.2 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.1 2010 VAP 790' POLIDATA (R) Demograpbic and Polilical Guides. AII Rights Reserved. Copyright (c) 2011. Polidata. www polidala org - 1. Populallnn Inr 2010 hom PL94-171 RedisVlcling Data from U S 6ureau of the Census. 2000 CenSus data from various sources. State populatio¢ 11.536,50G, 16 members, itleal Is 721,632. 2 Pic Charis givc a rough approximatien of the racial breaks for the currenl dislrict. The overall size of each pie is scaled to the Ideal population for this district type 3.1'fie slices are in the following counter-clockwise order (slarling at 3 o'clock): White. Black. Hispanic, Am. Indian, Asian, Pacilic Isla^nd „oWdbe 001i ercenL' for edominant group. ifMRTO is 9overol % IWhlote-BIaRk.White-Amindian^Wheile-ASianhWhte-Pacm^Whte-OflherantlBlack-Amindian. p p ^Addlio albreaksa^e^cludedp 109pIHRHa-pspledt2-KCt51 LPL 000118 Redistricting Handbook for OHIO Politicat Districts Racial Subgroups for CONGRESS Page 39.H.2 ,feveanc!' aod a^ester.m subu*i^s KuckrCh- Dermiz Uj 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010 Pop Abs Dev. Ret Dev. +:66,916 7`9% 59Q.205 -121,827 -16.90% W6 WI WA WP WO 61 Wbt Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT 2010PoP 80.0 83 7.5 0.2 2.2 0.0 0.1 1.7 0.3 0.2 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.1 2010 VAP 83.4' 7.1 6.0 0.2 2.1 0.0 0.1 1.0 fitJ2tot T 1 c,terr ibart): f.+.lys I d - .)1 2010 VAP %of Pop 2010 Pop Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 415,585 769% 540,432 -180.600 25.05",0 Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Dth MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI 2010 Pop 33.6 59.3 2.6 0.2 2.3 0.0 0.2 1.7 37.2 56.4' 2.3 0.2 2.6 0^.0 0.1 1.2 04 -0.i 0.1 0.0 0.0 02 2010 VAP - Columbus' and eastern suburbs 2010VAP %ofPOp 12 l"IbeH, PaklckJ. (R) 2010POp AbsDev. RelDev. 557.957 73.8% 756,303 35,272 4.89% WP WO BI Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac OIh MRT WB WI WA 2010Pop 68.5 21.7 3.5 02 36 00 0.2 2.3 204 29 0.2 3.5 0.0 0.1 1.4 0.4 0.2 0.2 0.0 00.01 2010VAP 71.3' o .^re( r ly r 2010 VAP %of Pop 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 494,201 =6 1ca or -,,o_ 71930 9989'= - - Wht Blk Hsp Ind Aso- Pac Oth MRT WB WI WA WP WO Bt r 2010 Pop 79.6 11.8 4.6 0.2 1.7 0.0 0.1 19 0.2 0.2 0.0 00 O.t 2010VAP 82.4' 10.9 3-7 0.2 1.7 0.0 0.1 1.0 0.3 Northern Shore Geauga Co.'. P./entor; Stow LaTouretie, Steven C. (R) 2010VAP %ofPOP 2010 Pop- Abs Dev. Rel Dev. e9481_5 76.39'0 648,128 -72°0 410-1 i% Wht BIk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT 2010 Pop 90.8 3.6 2.3 0.1 1.8 0.0 0.1 1.3 2010 VAP 92.2 3.5 1.8 0.1 1.7 0.0 0.0 0.7 Oolumbus'andwesternsuburbs 2010VAP %of Pop 15 Siiver5, Sieve (R) 2010 POp. AbsDev RelDev. 52£874 77.690 a81,557 -39.475 -r147% ^. Wht BIk HsP Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT WB WI WA WP WO 61 2010 PoP 79.8 9.2 4.5 0.2 38 0.1 0.2 22 2010 VAP 82.2' 8.4 31 0.2 3.9 0.0 0.1 1.4 0.4 0.3 0.3 0.0 0.0 0.1 Canton' h1edina: Alliance' 16 Renaccl, Jim (R) 2010VAP %ofPap 2010POR AbeDev. RelDev. A91.i71 76.2'.6 h4i,691 r^,3+11054`ib Wht Blk Hsp nd Asn Pac Oth MRT 2010 Pop 90.8 4.9 1.5 0.2 0.7 0.0 0.1 1.7 2010 VAP 92.4 4.5 1.2 0.2 0.7 0.0 0.1 0.9 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel 0ev. 471,408 78.6% 600, 111 120.921 -16.7795 Wpl elk Hsp nd Asn Pac Oih MRT ' WB Wt WA WP WO 61 2010 Pop 82.1 12.0 27 02 1.0 0.0 0.1 1.9 2010VAP 84.5' 109 2.2 0.2 1.1 0.0 0.1 1.1 0.3 0.2 02 0.0 0.0 0.1 Zanesviile; Chilllcothe New'ark' 2010VAP%olPOp 18 Gibbs, Bob (R) 2010POp- AbsDev. Re1Dev. _Sq39 75.G% fzi3.16` :.7,SU5 -9.a1`Yo Wht Blk Hsp nd Asn Pac Oth MRT 2010 Pop 94.9 1.9 1.0 0.2 0.3 0.0 0.1 1.5 19 0.8 0.2 0300 00 0.9 2010VAP 95.7` POLIDATA (R) Demographic and Polltical Guides. All Rights Reserved. Copyright (c) 2011. Polidata. www polidata.org 1. Population for 20101rom PL94-171 Retllstrictiog Data from U 5. Bureau ol the Census. 2000Census dala Irom various sources. 51ate population.-11,536,504, 16 members, ideal is 721,032. 2 Pie Charts give a rough approximation of the racial breaks lor 0e curreni distriq The overallsiae oleach pie is scaled to the Idezl population for thls districl lype 3: The slices are in the following coonter-clockwise order (slzrting a130'clock): While, Black, Hispanic, Am.lndian. Asian. Pacific Islander, Olher, Mulli-Race. S.AddifonzlbreaksarencluAedf MRTOisgoverl%,Wh^e-Bla ak,IWhtet'AmindaqaWhite-AsianhWhOe-PaciflqWMte-OflherandBlaa9k-AmIndbe1000ercenl.'forpredominanlgroup.139pIHRHO-pspletll l-KC 151 LPL 000119 Political Districts Redistricting Handbook for OHIO Page 39.H.3 Racial Subgroups for CONGRESS Ranked by 2010 Minority Voting Age Population for Selected Subgroups District Minority HsplLat Black Asian ED Member !=vela n I n r,a5tern s:36urbs â 23 Sb J . %`? 628 c Clncinnah andwesternsuburbs 11 rvrdge r L u) - 33.2 2.2 29.0 1 . 5 Chabol, Steve ( R) Columbus ' and eastern suburbs 1 28 5 2.9 20.4 3.5 12 'r!berl. Patrick J. (R) 4 ) teG 13 1OteAa. e k_.4ur 3 -Jg) 4 1.5 15.8 1.7 Day[on', Kettering 20- ColumbusT and western suburbs 3 Turner , Michael R- (R) 8.4 3.9 17 . 7 3.7 Fa i^i . 15 Slivers, Sieve (R) 0 POLIDATA (R) Demographic and Political Guides. AII Rights Reserved Cupyright (c) 2011. Polidala. www polidata org lation: 11.536.504, 16 members, ideal i5121.032: 1 Population for 2010 from PL94-171 Redistricting Datz from U S. Bureau of the Census. 2000 Census tlata from various soorces. 9zte popu 2 Pie Charts give a rough approximation oftbe racial breaks tor the current districl. The overall size of each pie is scaled to the Ideal population ror this dislricl type. 3. The slices are in the following counfer-dockwisebrder (siarling a13 o dock): White. Black, Hispanic, Am Indian, Asian, Paci(¢ Islander, Other, Mulli-Race 5. Addilioozl breaks a or Ra luded J MRT Is over 1%IWh^e-Black,IWhIteIAm.IndiartaWhite Asian,hWhOe-Pacif cs WhHe-Other and Blazk-Am Indbe 100 percent for predominant group t39pIHRH0-pspleUl2-KCr51 LPL 000120 THIS PAGEINTENTIONALLY BLANK LPL 000121 Lr) 8z O o + ' Q kf^ ^ O W ^ 10 + 1 O 'N ^ r ^ vx ^ p c F Potitical Districts Redistricting Handbook for OHIO Page 39:X.1 Racial Subgroups for STATE HOUSE Colutnblana 2010VAP %ofPop @Pwbeld, Craig (R) 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 84,257 78.1e 107,811 M1,689 -746% Ind Asn Pac Olh MRT ^rw^. Wht elk HsP 2010POp 94.9 22 1.3 02 0.3 0.0 0.112 2010VAP 95.3" 23 1.2 0.2 0.3 0.0 0.0 0.7 Delaware 2010VAP %afPOp 2 6rsP.ner, Anrfrew (R) 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 123,710 71.0`/0 174,214 57,684 49.50% WIM Bik FISP Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT 2010 POp 88.4 3.3 2.1 0.1 4.2 0.0 0.1 1.7 2010 VAP 89.8" 3.2 1.7 0.1 41 0.0 01 0.9 Wayne 2010 VAP %of PoP Amslutz, Ron (R) 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 85375 74.6% 114,520 -2,010 1 73% Wht Blk Hsp lod Asn Pac Oth MRT zaloPOP 947 1,5 1 6 0.1 08 0.0 0.1 t 3 2010VAP 95.5' 1.4 1.3 0.1 0.8 00 0.1 0.8 Allen 2010VAP %ofPOp 4 Huffman, Malt (R) 2010 POpAbsDev. RelDem ;20,88e '6.i'?c t06,331 :0,199 -875% Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Poe Oth MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI 2010p Po 82.5 11.8 2.4 0.2 0.7 0.0 0.10.3 1.1 2.1 0.4 0.1 0.1 0.0 0.0 01 2010VAP 85.0 110 t9 0.2 07 Fairfield 2010VAP %ofPOp Stebellon, Gerald (R) 2010 Pop: Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 107,747 73.7 % 146.156 29,626 25A2% WA WP WO BI Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT WB WI 2010POP 89.2 5.9 1.7 0.2 1.1 0.0 0.1 1.7 02 0.2 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.0 1.0 0.0 0.1 1.0 21110 VAP 91.1 53 1.4 0.2 Waod 2010 VAP %ofPOp 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 98,213 78.3% 125,488 8,958 7.69% ^ Wht Blk HsV . Ind 02 15 0a0 MRT 2010 PoP 90.1 23 4.5 0.0 0.1 0.9 2010 VAP 91.3' 25 3.6 02 1.5 2010 VAP %of Pop Yukt 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 79,0_9 l11.0 102553 -12 977 11.999% Whl Blk HsP Ind Asn Pac Olh MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI 2010Pop 426 52.2 1.7 0.2 1.2 0.0 0.2 1,9 2010VAP 47.9' 479 1.4 0.1 1.3 0.0 0.1 1.2 04 0.1 0.1 0.0 0.0 0.2 2010 VAP^%^of Pop 3010Pop- AbsDev. ReIDe¢ 80,45e, 7 66% 104!66 . 11,56-+ °.92% Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Dth MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI 2010 PoP 36.2 57.1 1.8 0.1 28 0.0 0.2 1.8 2010VAP 38.1. 561' 15 0.1 27 0.0 0.1 1 2 0.4 O.t 0.1 00 0.0 0.2 ) . 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010 Pop Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 73 O0; 78OY 93.562 22962 -19]1`Yo Wht BIk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT 18 WI WA WP WO 81 55.0 1.8 0.2 3.4 0.0 0.2 2.0 0.0 00 02 2010Pop 315 ,..,, 2010VAP 399 52.6* 1.7 0.2 4.0 0.0 0.2 1.5 05 0.3 0.3 (c) 2011. Polldala. www politlata org 99 members, ideal is 115.530. R) Demographic and Polibcal Gvides. All RigMS Reserved Copyright POLIDATA ( U 5 Bureau of Ihe Census. 2000 Census data from various sources. Slate populalion: 11,53b,504, from 1 Populalion forgive 20101rom a rough appmximalionof PL94-171 Redistricting the racial Data breaks for the corrent distrid. The overall size ot each pie is scaled lo the ideal population for this district type 2. Ple Charts starting al 3 o'clock): While. Black. Hispanic, Am.Indian. Asian. Paci(ic Islandeq Othec Mulli-Race 3. The slicesare in the following counfer-clockwise order ( s SAddillonaibreakszarelocluded(aMRTOisovert%bi^5on.^^ i 139pIXRHO-pspledl2-KC151 LPL 000125 Redistricting Handbook for OHIO Political Districts Racial Subgroups for STATE HOUSE Page 39.X.2 Cuyzho9a° 2010VAP %ofPop 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 71.348 77 Ggt 92,627 23,c33-2057^, Whl BIk HsP Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI 2010 Pop 32.9 47.4 14.8 0.3 2.6 0.0 0.2 1.9 2010VAP 37.0 454' 12.8 03 3.0 0.0 0.2 1.3 0.4 0.1 0.1 0.0 0.0 0.2 Ci.yahoga' 2010VAP %ofPop 2010 Pop. Abs Deu Rel Dea 68 2- 4 1 '25`br 94-163 2 2,367 .19 19.= Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Olh MRT WB WI WA WP WO Bl 0.0 0.1 1.7 2010 Pop 33.9 ' 57.1 5.7 0.2 1.31.6 0.0 0.1 1.3 04 0.1 0.1 0.0 0.0 0.2 2010 VAP 393 52.7 4.8 . ,uya:^rgsi' 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010Pop. AbsDev. RelDev. 7L557 75.`+% 98^s7 -17,6,o-i,..18% - ^ Whi Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI 2010POp 25.1 70.9 1.4 0.2 0.7 00 0.11.5 2010VAP 28.3 68.6 1.1 0.2 0.7 0.0 0.1 1.0 0.3 0.0 0.0 00 0.0 0.2 Cuyahog,v D 2010VAP %OfPOp 2010 Pop- Abs Oev- Rel Dav- ?7 ;01 77 5%h 99,462 1%.d6_8 1465-•^ Asn Pac Oth MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI Wht BIk Hsp Ind 00 0.3 2.5 2010POp 67.5 14.3 13.2 0.3 1.91.9 0.0 0.2 1.6 04 0.3 0.3 0.0 0.0 O.t 2010VAP 72.3' 12.7 10.9 0.3 Giyehaga' 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dea 80,578 778ia 103.628 -12.902 110 7G Wht Blk Hsp intl Asn Pac Oth MRT WB WI WA WP WO el 2010POP 74.6 11.0 9.6 0.2 2.4 00 0.1 2.0 2010 VAP 79.0' 96 7.6 0.2 2.4 0.0 0.1 1.1 0.3 0.2 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.1 C,:.ya`locta' 2010VAP %DfPOp 2010 Pop- Abs Dev- Rel Dea 87,241 80.1 °o 106.895 7,635 -655`!-^ Asn Pac Olh MRT Whl Blk Hsp led 0.0 0.1 1.2 2010 PoP 89.4 2.4 4.1 0.1 2.6 2010 VAP 91.2' 2.2 3.2 0.1 2.5 0.0 0.0 0.7 Cuyahoga' 16 Baker, Nan (R) 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dea 92,308 78 2% 118,044 1,514 1.30% ^ Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac 0th MRT 2010 POp 91.7 1.4 2.6 0.1 2.70.0 0.1 1-2 2010 VAP 92.8 1 4 2.2 0.1 2.7 0.0 0.1 07 Cuyahoga' 17 Anielskt, Marlene (R) 3010 VAP %of Pop 2010 PoP. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 96.693 77 6% 124.619 8,089 6 94% Ind Asn Pac Olh MRT ^ Whl BIk HsP 2010 POp 86.0 6.7 1.5 0.1 4.5 0.0 0.1 7.2 1.2 01 4.1 0-0 0.1 0.7 2010VAP 87.6' 62 Cuyahoga' DOvtlla, Mike (R) 2010 VAP % of Pop 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Bel Dev 91 397 78 2% 116917 387 0.33% Wht Elk Hsp Intl Asn Pac Olh MRT 2010 PoP 91.1 2.4 22 01 2.8 0.0 0.1 1.3 2010 VAP 922' 2.3 1.8 0.1 2.7 0.0 0.1 08 POLIDATA (R) Demographic and Political Guldes. All Rights Reservetl. Copyright (c)2011. Polidata. www polidala org 1 Populzllan ror 2010 from PL94-171 Redistricling Data from U S. Bureau of the Census. 2000 Census dala from verious sources. 9ate popul2lion:1L536,504 99 membe5, ideal is.116.530. 2. Pie Charls give a rough apprnximalion of the racial breaks for the currenl dislricL The overaA size oI each pie is scaledlolhe ideal population for this dislricl lype 3 The sliaes are in rhe following counler-clockwise order (starling at 3 o'clock): While, Black, Hispanic, Am, Indian, Asian, Pacific Islander, Olher, MuRi-Race. 4. Racial breaks are for RacelHispanic Origin Combination. MRT is Multi-Racial Tolal persons The sum of these, asltle from rounding, should be 100 percenl.' for Predominant group 5 Additional breaks are IncWded if MRT Is over 1%. White-Black, While-Am.Indian, White-ASian, White-Pacllic. While-Other and Black-Am Indian. p9nlxarvo-pspleal2-xc151 LPL 000126 Redistricting Handbook for OHIO Political Districts Racial Subgroups for STATE HOUSE Page 39.X 3 Franklin' 19 Gonzales, Anne(R) 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. ReI Dev. 2010 VAP %of Pop 157,070 40,540 34.79% 115,646 73.6% Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Olh MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI 2010 PoP 71.2 20.5 3.0 0.2 2.1 0.0 0.2 2.7 2010 VAP 75.6' 18.0 2.5 0.2 2.1 0.0 0.1 1.5 0 5 0.3 0.3 0.0 0.0 0.1 Fta=.klif: 2010 VAP % of Pop Dev. Rel Dev. 2010 Pop- Abs 99,426 75.2% 132,198 15,668 13.45 0 WA WP WO BI Whl BIk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Olh MRT WB WI 2019 PoP 68.7 20.4 4.4 0.2 3.2 0.0 0.2 2.7 2010 VAP 72.1' 19.1 3.7 0.2 3.2 0.0 0.1 1.5 050.3 0.3 0.0 0.0 0.2 Franklin' 21 Duttey, Mike (R) 2010VAP °%ofPOp 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 91,466 75.4% 121,293 4,763 4-09% WB WI WA WP WO BI ^Wht BIk HsP Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT 2010POP 62.8 22.4 6.9 0.2 4.8 0.0 0.3 2.6 05 0.3 0.3 0.0 0.0 0.1 2010 VAP 66.9' 20.4 5.9 0.2 4.8 0.0 0.2 1.6 f raNcfa' 2010 VAP %of POp 2010 Pop. Ab5 Dev. Rel Dev. 99,058 78.6°/a 125989 9,459 8.12% WI WA WP WO BI Wht Blk Hsp Ind AsnPac Oth MRT WB 2010 Pop 77.5 6.5 4.3 0.1 90 0.0 0.3 2.3 0.3 0.5 0.5 0.0 0.0 0.0 2010 VAP 80.3' 6.0 3.6 0.1 8.4 0.0 0.2 1.5 Franklin' 23 Grossman, Oheryl(R) 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 100,845 74-3Yo ^ 135,650 19.120 1641o WI WA WP WOBI Wht BIk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Ofh MRT WB 5 . 1 0. 2 3 .6 0.1 0.1 2.1 2010 Pop 84.3 4 .5 0.30.30.3 0.00.00.1 2010VAP 86.7' 4.1 4.1 0.2 3.6 0.1 0.1 1.2 . P;ar:Ylirf' CeISS{e, Tcd (i:; 2010 Pop Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 2010 VAP % of Pop 96.417 76.2% 126,534 10,004 858% Wht BIk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI 2010 Pop 78.9 7.1 5.5 0.2 5.7 0.0 0.2 2.4 2010VAP 81.2' 6.4 46 0.2 6.0 0.0 01 1.5 0.4 0.4 0.4 0.0 0.0 0.1 . Ftsl.,., gt:.f t i (D! 2010VHP 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. ReI Dev. %ofPop. 128,872 12,342 10-59°6 98,722 76 6% WA WP WO BI ^ . Whf Blk HsP Intl Asn Pac Ofh MRT WB WI 2010 PDp 75.1 13.8 5.5 0.3 2.4 0.1 0.2 2.7 0.3 2.6 01 0.1 1.6 05 0.2 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.1 2010 VAP 791' 11 9 4.3 FfznKilrt .,, i'raCy(D) 2010VAP %afPOp 2010 Pop- Abs Dev. Rel Dea gg.211 16 1 q,b 11!i9 74 .v".48ie Ind Asn Pac Olh MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI ^ Wht Blk Hsp 2010 Pop 368 533 47 03 1.5 0.0 0.3 3.7 2010VAP 41.6 500 4.0 0.3 1.7 00 0.2 2.2 0.8 0.2 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.3 l7 2U10 VAPr %of ^ Pap 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 95,081 79.3% 119,834 3,304 2.84% Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT WB WI WA WP WO Bt G Wht Blk HsP 2010PoP 44.0 45.9 4.1 0.3 2.7 0.1 0.2 27 2010VAP 50-7' 40.2 3.4 0.3 32 0.1 0.2 1.9 06 0.3 0.3 0.0 0.0 0.3 (c) 2011. Polidala. www polidata.0rg (R) Demographic and Politlcal Guides. All Rights Reservetl. Copyrighl POLIDATA1 Population for 2010 from PL94-171 Redislricting Dala from U S. Bureau ol lhe Census. 2000 Census dala Irom varioussources. Sfale populatlon: 11.53b,504, 99 members, ideal is 116.530 2. Ple Charts give a rough approximalion of the racial breaks for the currenl disfricl. The overall size of each pie Is scaled lo the ideal population for thls district lype. starting at 3 o clock): White. Black, Hispznic. Am. Indizn, Asizn, Pacific Islznder, Other. Mulli-Race 3. The slices are in the following counfer-clockwise order ( 4. Racizl brezks are for RacelHispanic Origin Combination. MRT is Multi-Racial Total persoos. The sum of these,aside from rounding, should be 100 percent.' for predominant group 5. Addlli0nal hreaks are included If MRT Is over 1%. While-Black, White-Am.lndian. While-Asian, While-Pacitic, While-Other and Black-Am Indian. 139pIXRHO-psplcdl2-KC151 LPL 000127 Redistricting Handbook for OHIO political Districts Racial Subgroups for STATE HOUSE Page 39.X.4 ilNnliftOn 2010VAP %ofPOp 24 Vh1GlLC. nl '., 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 82.785 75 09&. 1C9.i05 -7,525 -6465i WI WA WP WO Bi Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT WB G Wht Bik Hsp 2010 Pop 62.3 26.2 4.8 0.1 4.0 0.1 0.3 2.3 0.3 0.2 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.1 201oVAP 65.8' 24.7 4.0 0.1 3.9 0.1 02. 1.2 Hamilton' 2010 VAP %of Pop Louis ( R) 29 Blessin0, 2010Pop. AbsDev - Re1Dev. 85,69-` %51% 113,931 -2,593 -2.23'0 WB WI WA WP WO Bi Pac Oth MRT Wht Blk Nsp Ind Asn 1.0 0. 1 0.2 2.1 2010 PoP 69.9 24.8 1.8 0.2 0.3 0.1 0 .1 0.0 0.0 0.1 210 1.4 0.2 1 .1 0.1 0.1 1.0 ^ 2010VAP 74.2* Hamllton' 2010VAP %ofPop 30 MeckienbOrg, Bob (R) 2010 Pop- Abs Dev- Rel Dev- 87,026 7@0ro t:c.50° -1021 :-73%. Ind Asn Pac Ofh MRT ^ WM Blk HsP 2010 pnp 95.1 1.8 0.9 0.1 09 0.0 0.1 10 2010 VAP 96.0' 1.7 0.7 0.1 0.8 0,0 0.1 0.6 iamiik,rl' 2010VAP %ofPOp Lt":'ss ;ii/ 4rf2^a0S. 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 70,6 16 72.3% 97 9q2 -18,538 -1591 % Wht BIk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT WB WI WA WP WO Bi 2010 PoP 55.4 37.3 3.6 0.2 0.7 0.1 0.2 2.4 2010 VAP 61.3' 33.0 3.1 02 0.8 0.101 05 1.3 0.1 0.1 0.0 0.0 O.t ;ta n1ltc;r. 2010VAP %ofPop ,w.:ai!ory, Dala (p:. 2010 Pop-. Abs Dev. Re Dev- 83112 804'% 895 -13.13b -1tP7°'v Wht Blk Hsp Intl Asn Pac Oth MRT WB WI WAWP WO Bi 2010 Pop 43.6 47.9 2.70.2 0.2 3.5 3.0 0.0 0.0 0.2 0.2 1.6 2.2 0 5 0.3 0.3 0.0 0.0 0.2 2010 VAP 49.5 42.6 2.4 Hamiin 2010VAP %afPOp 2010 Pop. Abs Dev- Rel Dev. 76,377 5°a 97,271 1 9,259 -1653 ,^, Wht BIk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT WB WI WA WP WO el 2010 PoP 44.8 49.5 2.4 0.2 0.8 0.0 0.2 2.0 2010VAP 47.6 47.7 2.1 0.2 0.9 000.1 1.3 0.4 0.1 O.t 0.0 0.0 0.2 Hamilfon' 2010VAP %ofPOp 34 Stautberg, Petar(R) 2010 Pop_ Abs Dev. Rel Dem 82,755 77bio 1L5.816 9.714 83a% WM1I BIk Hsp fnd Asn Pac Olh MRT WB WI WA WP WO Bi 2010 Pop 85.6 8.4 2.0 0.1 2.0 0.0 0.2 1.7 2010VAP 86.8' 8.1 1.7 0.1 2-1 0.0 01 9_1 0.3 0.3 0.3 0.0 0.0 0.1 tiamiiton' VAP %of Pop ROn (R) 2010 35 MaaGJ: 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 95,451 742% 128.703 12,173 10.45 % Ind Aso Pac Ofh MRT ciWhl Blk Hsp 2010 POP 90.0 2.8 2.3 0.1 3.2 0.0 02 1.4 2010VAP 91.0' 2.8 1.9 0.1 3.2 00 0.1 0.8 MonigOmery' 2010VAP %ofPOp 36 Henne, Michael(R) 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. . 84U44 r6.44o 111.134 .5396 -d.63^X, Wht BIk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT WB WI WA WP WO Bt 2010 Pop 863 8.3 1.6 0.2 1.4 0.0 0.1 2.0 2010VAP 883 7.6 1.3 0.2 1.4 00 01 1.1 0.3 0.2 0.2 00 0.0 0.1 POLIDATA (R1 Demographic and Porilical Guides. AII Rights Reserved Copyrighl (c) 2011. Polidala. www polidala.org 1. Populallon for 2010from PL94-171 Redistricting Dalz from U 5. Burezu af Ihe Census. 2000 Census data Irom varlous sources. Stafe populzfiorr.11,536,504, 99 memhers, ideal is 116,530. 2 ulalion lor IM1is tlislricl lype . Pie Charts glve a rough approximalion o( the racial breaks for the currenl dl5trict. The overall size ot each pie is scaled to the Idezl pop 3. The slices are in the followidg counter-dockwise order (starling at 3 o'clock)'. White,Black . Hlspanic. Am. Indizn. Asian, Pacific Islander. Other, Mulli-Race 4 Racial breaks zre for RacelHispznic Otlgin Combinalion. MRT IsMutti-Racial Total persons. The sum of these, asitle from rountling, should be 100 pe¢enf.' for predominani group 5 Additional breaks are included If MRT is over 1%. White-Black. While-AmIndian, Whlte-AStan, White-Pacific, White-Olher and Black-Am Indian. IsyplxRUO-p5piem2-xalsl LPL 000128 Politicat Districts Redistricting Handbook for OHIO Page 39.X.5 Racial Subgroups for STATE HOUSE h4ontgomery° 37 Butler,Jlm (R) 2010 VAP %Of Pop 2010 PoPAbs Dev. Rel Dev. 88.502 77 3%e il9 4'.1 -2A59 -1..`-7% WB WI WA WP WO BI Wht BIk Hsp Ind Asn Pac 0th MRT 2010POp 87.8 5.5 2.3 0.2 2.3 00 01 1.8 0.3 0.3 0.3 0.0 0.0 0.0 2010 VAP 89.5' 4.9 1.9 0.2 2.4 0.0 0.1 1.1 MOntgomery' 38 Blair, Terry (R) 2010 VAP %of Pop 2010 FoR Abs Dev. Rel Dev_ 86, 901 '82% 111.167 -5,363 -7.ii WB WI WA WP WO BI Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oih MRT 2010POp 88.8 3.7 2.3 0.2 2.9 00 0.1 1.9 0.3 0.3 0.3 0.0 0.0 0.0 0 2010VAP 90.6' 3.4 1.9 0.2 2.7 0.0 0.1 12 !Aa.^tis0 2010 VAP %of`Pop 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 71„647 77.4i0 92.*94 ^.eR36 -20.51% WB WI WA WP WO BI Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT 2010 POp 456 47.3 3.4 0.2 0.7 00 0.2 2.6 06 0.2 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.2 2010VAP 50.0' 44.1 2.8 0.3 08 0.0 0.1 1.8 LlOntgOe,ory" 2010VAP %ofPap 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 79,880 70.5% 10578` .10 74"s -922% WI WA WP WO BI Asn Pac Oth MRT WB Wht BIk Hsp Ind zoloPOp 48.7 45.1 2.0 02 1.1 00 0.2 2.6 2010 VAP 52.2' 43.1 1.6 0.2 1.1 0.0 0.1 7.6 O S 0.2 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.2 Summii' 41 Slaby, Lynn (R) 2010 VAP % of Pap 2010 Pep. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 98.047 77.5% - 126,531 10.001 8.58% Intl Asn Pac Olh MRT ^ . Wht Blk Hsp 2010POp 84.6 8.8 1.3 0.1 3.6 0.0 0.1 1.5 2010 VAP 86.4' 8.3 1.1 0.1 3.3 0.0 0.1 0.8 Summlt' 2010 VAP %of Pop 42 ROegner, Kristina (R) 2010 Pop. AbsDev. Rel Dev. 87569 76.8% 114,054 -2,476 -2.1340 Ind Asn Pac 0th MRT ^ Whl Blk Hsp 2010 Pop 92.3 2.5 1.5 0.1 L2 0.0 0.1 1.3 2010VAP 93.5' 2.4 1.1 0.1 2.0 0.0 0.1 0.8 Summlt' 43 McKenney,TUdd(R) 2010 VAP 96 of Pop 2010POp. AbsDev. Re1Dev. 98,993 78.2% 126,658 10,i28 8-69% Ind Asn Pac OIh MRT ^ . Whl Blk Hsp 2010POp 95.2 1 6 0.9 02 0.8 0.0 0.1 1.2 2010 VAP 96.0' 1.4 0.7 0.2 0.9 0.0 0.0 0.8 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 10 pBp 7'.4", ' 103,672 -',2,858-11 03`3 . . . Wht BIk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Olh MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI 2010Pop 46.0 452 2.7 0.2 2.6 0.0 0.33.1 2010VAP 507' 42_1 23 02 2.6 0.0 0.2 1.9 07 0.2 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.3 . : !:mt 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010 PoP Abs Dem AeI Dev- 8',822 ic0% 107Ai89 8.81-1 -75° o . . . Wht BIk Hsp Intl Asn Pac Oth MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI 2010POp 80.2 14.0 1.5 0.3 1.3 0.0 0.2 2.7 2010 VAP 84.2' 11.7 1.2 0.3 1.2 0.0 0.1 1.4 05 02 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.1 c) 2011. Polldala. www polidatz.org R) Demographic and Political Guides, All Righls Reserved. Copyright ( POLIDATA1. Populalion ( for 2010 from PL94171 Redisiricting Data Irom U5. Bureau of the Census. 2000 Census dala Irom various sources.5late populalion: 11,536,504, 99 members, ideal is 116,530. give a rougb approximallon of the raclal breaks for the current dlslricl. The overall size of each pie is Scaled to the ideal populalion lor Ihls tlislricl lype. 2 Pie Charls starling a13 6clock): While. Black. Hispanic. Am.Intlian. Asian, Pacifc Islantleq Olhec Mulli-. are in the following counler-clockwise order ( 3.4 RaolalThe slices breaks are for RacelHispanic Origin Combination. MRT is Multi-Racial Total persons The sum of these, aside from rounding, should be 100 percenl.' for predominant group. 5. Addilional breaks are included if MRT is over 1%. Whiie-Black, White-Am Indian, While-Asian, While-Paclfic, White-Other and Black-Am Indian 139pIXRHO-psplcU4-KC151 LPL 000129 Redistricting Handbook for OHIO Potiticaf Districts Racial Subgroups for STATE HOUSE Page 39.X.6 Lucas' 46 Saars, Barbara (R) 2010 VAP %of Pop 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 96,668 75.7% 127,690 11,160 9.58°ia Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT ^ . Wbt elk Hsp 2010 PoP 88.4 4.2 3.1 0.1 2.6 0.0 0.1 14 2010 VAP 90.2 3.9 2.4 0.1 2.5 0.0 0.1 0.8 Lucas" 2010VAP %ofPap 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 1;',356 ':5:.2% 102,904 13,626 1169°i, Whl Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Olh MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI 2010POp 67.4 17.1 10.7 0.3 1.1 0_0 0'2 31 06 0.2 0.2 OA 0.0 0.1 0.0 0.1 1.5 2010VAP 72.9' 15.6 8.3 0.3 1.2 Lâca- ksAfc:rr Ma:-.(D) 2010VAP %ofPop 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 7q 2't 76.2 1103.89c i2,634 -10.8455 Whl Elk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Olh MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI. 2010 Pop 39.5 50.2 5.5 0.3 1.4 0.0 0.2 2.8 2010VAP 443 474 4.4 0.3 1.7 00 0.1 1.8 07 0.2 0.2 0.0 0.0 02 ,sJ!tcrli, t.iui't:9,w (rr: 2010VAP %otPOp 2010 POR Abs Dev Rel Dev. g2,442 768% 107,325 0',205 -7.90'S Pac Olh MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI Whl Blk HsP Inrl Asn 0.0 01 2.2 2010 Pap 84.1 6.8 5.9 02 0.7 0.0 0.11.2 0.3 0.2 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.0 2010 VAP 87.4' 6.0 4.4 0.2 0.7 Stark' 50 Hagan, Christina (R) 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev 87,491 76.3% 114,718 -1,812 -1-56"yo Wht BIk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT 1.1 1.1 0.1 0.4 0.0 0.1 1.0 2010 Pop 96.2 - 1.1 0.8 0.1 0.4 0.00.0 0.6 2010VAP 96.9' ' slark' 2010VAP %ofPOp 51 Schuring, Kirk (R) 2010 Pap. Abs Dev. ReI Dev. 96,324 78.4% 122,852 6,322 5.42% Ind Asn Pac Olh MRT ^ Whl elk HsP 2010 Pop 90.2 4.8 1.6 0.2 1.4 0.0 0.1 1:7 2010VAP 91.8' 4.4 1.3 0.2 1.3 0.0 0.1 0.9 <_laart:' 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. ReI Dev. 76,120 762'b 99,936 -16,594 -14 24°b Wht BIk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI 2010POp 74.6 18.6 22 0.4 0.3 0.0 0.3 3.6 2010VAP 790' 16.5 1.8 0.4 0.4 0:0 0.1 1.8 07 0.1 01 00 0.1 0.2 Butler" 53 Dcrickson, Timothy (R) 2010 VAP %af Pop 2010Pop. AbsDev. RelDev. 92,884 78.6% 118,174 1,644 1.41% Ind Asn Pac Olh MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI Wht Blk HsP 2010 Pop 91.5 3.6 1.5 0.1 1.6 0.0 01 1.6 0.3 0.2 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.0 2010VAP 92.5' 3.3 1.3 0.2 1.7 0.0 01 1.1 6utier' 54 COmbs, Courtney (R) 2010VAP %bfPOp 2010 Pop Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 86,530 75-6% 114,493 <,G47 -1.75% WB WI WA WP WO BI Whl Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Olh MRT 2010 Pop 81.4 9.3 5.6 02 1.3 0.1 0.1 2.1 2010VAP 84.3 8.7 4.4 0.2 1.3 0.1 0.1 1.1 0.4 02 0.2 00 0.0 0.0 G R) Demographic and Polifczl Guides. All Rights Reserved Copyright (c) 2011. Pulidata. www polidala.0rg 99 members, ideal is 116.530. 1.POLIDATA PopulaGon( for 2010 from PL94-171 Redistricting Dala from U S. Bureau of the Census. 2000 Census dala Irom various sources. Stale population: 11,536,504, - 2 Pie Charls give a rough apprnximation of the racial breaks for the correnl dislricl. The overartsize ol each pie is scaled to Ihe ideal population for this district lype. slarting a13 o'dock)'. While. Black, Hispanic, Am. Indian. Asiah, PaciOC Islander. Olheq Mulli-Race. 3. The slices aro in Ihe following couNer-clockwise order ( 4 Racial breaks are for RacelHispanic Origin Combination. MRT is Mulli-Racial Total personsThe sum ofthese, aside from rounding. should be 100 percent.' for predominant group 5. Additional breaks are included if MRT is over 1%. Whi(e-Black, White-Am.Indian, While-Asian, WhilePacllic, White-Olher and BlackAm Indlan. isqplxlatl0-psplemakc151 LPL 000130 Political Districts Redistricting Handbook for OHIO Page 39.X.7 Racial Subgroups for STATE HOUSE Bu[ler' 55 Coley, Bill (R) 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010POP. AbsDev. Re1Dev. 96112 709% 135,473 18,943 16.26% ^ . . . Wht Blk HsP Ind Asn Pac OIh MRT 2010 PoP 80.4 8.6 4.7 02 4.0 0.1 0.2 1.8 2010 VAP 82.9 7.8 4.0 0.2 4.0 0.1 0.1 0.9 .. . . _o=zin' Ro:nr,^ ^,ri R?) 201DVAP %ofPOp 2010 Pop Abs Dev. Rel Dev. g4 Q25 '511b 1i3'!P3 -.,,•'<7 .29p% ^ Hsp Ind Asn Pac Olh MRT WB WI WA WP WO 81 ^ Whl Bik 2010 Pop 64.2 144 17.1 0.3 0.6 0.0 01 3.2 2010VAP69.9' 13.2 14.1 0.3 0.7 00 0.1 1.7 0.6 0.2 0.2 0.0 00 0.1 2010 VAP % of Pop 2010 Pap. Abs Dev. Rel Dev_ 103,752 75 B% 136.935 20,405 1751°6i Whl BIk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT 2010POP 89.4 4.1 3.2 0.2 1.4 0.0 0.1 1.7 2010VAP 91.2' 3.9 25 0.2 1.3 0.0 00 0.9 . Huron', Lorain', Seoeca' 58 Boose, Terry (R) 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev 91,655 76.1% 120,471 3,941 3.3890 Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT 2010 Pop 91.5 2.5 4.2 112 0.3 (10 0.0 11 3.0 3.1 0.2 0.3 0.0 00 0.7 0 2010VAP 92.5` f.rz'wt:i^g. Fierber;v..`eop31, IQ1 2010 VAP %of Pop 2010POp. NbsDav- RelDev. 8o1F2 7;3,4no ?1255L 4,275 3 -0- ,.. . W ht BIk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT 0.1 1.1 00 0:1 1.0 2010POP 91.3 3.9 2.4 2010VAP 92.6' 3.7 1.9 0.1 10 0.0 0.0 0.6 ;al3nent^' 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010 POp. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 71 5q6 7' 3% 95.158 21,372 ifi 349b Whl Blk Hsp Ind Asn PacOth MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI 2040 Pop 54.9 33.4 8.5 0.3 0.4 0.0 10.2 2.4 2010 VAP 59.5' 30.8 7.5 0-3 0.4 0.0 0.1 14 05 0.1 0.1 0.0 0.0 02 e Ir)1 ii'rk l _Sark' i .., . ,. =v. Pferk (D) 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev 89,881 71 5^b 116,1)12 -0 44vo . . . ^ Wht Blk % HsP Intl Asn Pac Oth MRT 0.0 01 1.4 2010 Pap 94.3 26 10 0.7 0.4 3010VAP 95.4' 2.5 0.8 0.2 03 00 0.0 0.7 Ik, 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010 PoP- Abs Dev- Rel Dev. 88,546 7920'.. /9D -4,7;0 .4.071^; Whl BIk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT 2010 Pop 92.7 3.3 1.3 0.1 1.3 0.0 0.1 1.2 2010VAP 93.7 3.1 1.0 0.1 1.3 0.0 00 0.6 Lake' 63 Young.Ron(R) 2010 VAP %of Pop 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 90,469 76.5 % 118,251 1.721 1 4896 Wht elk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Ofh MRT 2010 POp 69.1 29 54 0.1 0.9 0.0 0.1 t5 2010 VAP 91.6' 2.6 3.9 0.1 09 00 0.0 0.8 c) 2011. Poliil www polidata.org R) Demographic and Politkal Guitles. All Rights Reserved. Copyrighl ( 1.POLIDATA Population ( for 2010 from PL94-171 Redistricting Dala from U 5. Bureau of Ihe Census. 2000 Censusdala from various sources. Slale population: 11,536,504, 99 members, ideal is 116,530 tor (his dlslricl lype. give a rough approximatlon of the racial breaks forthe current districL The overall size of each pie is scaletl to the ideal populaGon 2. Pie Charls stzrling at 3 o'dock): While. Black, Hispanic, Am. Indian. Asizn. Pacific Islander, Olher. Mulli-Race are in the following counter-clockwise order ( 4_3. TheRacial slices breaks are for RacelHlspanic Origin CDmbination. MRT is Multi-Rzcial Tolal persons The sum of Ihese, aside from rountling, shouldbe 100 percent.' forpretlominanl group. 5. Additionzl breaks are included if MRT is over 1%. While-Black, White-Am.Indlan, White-Asian, Whife-PZC'Ric, White-Other and Black-Am Indizn. 139piXRHQ-psprcdl2-Kc t 5l LPL 000131 Redistricting Handbook for OHIO Political Districts Racial Subgroups for STATE HOUSE Page 39.X.8 T;a„6ulr 201 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Ret Dev. 0 VAP %ofPop 101,t8- ,^,343-13.173c 77:b4d 'S.7°,. Whl Blk Hsp ntl Asn Pac OIM1 MRT 2010POP 83.1 12.8 1.4 0.2 0.5 0.0 0.2 1.8 2010 VAP 85.5' 11.8 1.1 0.2 05 0.0 0.1 0.8 TrGml::,.;, 2010 VAP %of Pop 2010 Pop., Abs Dev. Ret Dev. i02,2i:1 -14,24612 .23%f. Whl 81k Hsp nd Asn Pac Olh MRT 2010 Pop 92.5 4.1 1.3 0.1 0.4 0.0 0.1 1 .4 2010 VAP 93.6' 3.9 1.0 01 0.5 0.0 0.0 0.8 Clermonl' 66 Uecker,Joe(R) 2010VAP %of Pop 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. tOt,b62 73 8%- 137.718 21,248 1823% ^ Wht Blk HsP ntl Asn Pac 0tM1 MRT . . . 2010 POP 940 1.4 1.7 0.2 1.2 0.0 0.1 1.3 2010VAP 95.0 1.4 1.4 0.2 1.2 00 0.1 0.8 VJarren' 67 Beck,Peter(R) 2010VAP %ofPOP 2010 Pop. Abs Dev Rel Dzv. 103,033 71.0% ^ 143430 26,909 23.09% Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT 2010 Pop 87.1 4.0 2.3 0.1 4.8 0.0 0.1 14 2010VAP 88.3 4.6 1.8 0.2 43 0.0 0.1 0.8 P er:age 201 2010 Pop. Abs Dev ReI Dev. 0VAP %af Pop79.6i 124,596 8,066 6.92% 99,227 Wht Blk Hsp nd Asn Pac Oth MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI 2010 PoP 90.1 49 1.4 0.2 1.6 0.0 0.1 1.7 2010VAP 91.1' 4.6 1.2 0.2 1.7 0.0 0.1 1.0 0.3 0.2 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.0 Medina 69 6atchel&e[ VVilliam (R) 2010 VAP %of Pap 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 97,305 74.3 % 130,90214,372 12.33% Whl Blk HsD Intl Asn Pat OIh MRT 201oPOP 94.6 1.3 1.7 0.1 1.1 0.0 0.7 1 .1 2040VAP 95.7' 1.2 1.3 0.1 1.0 0.0 0.0 0.6 E.. Greene' 70 k-!attin, JairOd (R 2010 VAP %of Pop 2010o pR Abs Oev Rel Dev 97.258 78.5/0 123,974 7,444 6.39% - Whl Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI 2010 Pop 82.9 8.4. 2.3 0.2 3.5 0.1 0.2 25 2010VAP 841 8.6 1.9 0.2 3.5 0.1 0.1 1.5 0.4 0.4 0.4 00 0.0 01 LIr,king' 71 HoOinger, Jay (R) 201 2010 Pop Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 0VAP %ofPap 126,986 10,456 8.97'0 95A57 75.2% Olh MRT WB WI WA WP WO el ^ Whl Blk H57 lod Asn Pa0 4.0 1.5 03 0.8 0.0 0.1 19 210POP 91 5 10 02 0.1 0.1 0.0 0.0 0.0 2010VAP 92.9 3.7 1.2 0.3 08 0.0 0.1 Clark' 72 McGregor, Ross (R) 201 2010POp. AbsDev- RelDev. 0VAP % pt POp i02.568 -t' 9t2 -1.198% '=S ,G62 16t % WP WO BI Wht Blk Nsp Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT We WI WA 2010 Pop 81.8 11.1 3.4 0.3 06 0.0 0.2 2.6 2010VAP 84.5' 10.5 2.6 03 0.6 0.0 01 1.4 05 0.1 0.1 00 0.0 01 POLIDATA (R) Demograpbic and Political Guides. All Rights Reserved Copyright (c) 2011. Polidala. wvuw polldataorg 1 Population for 2010 (rom PL94-171 Redlslricling Data from U 5. Bureau of Ihe CenSUS. 2000 Census data from varlous sources. State pnpulalion: 11.53fi,504, 99 members, ideal is 11b,530. 2 Pie Charls give a rough approximation ol the racial breaks Ior the current distritl. The overall size of each pie is scaled to the ideal population for Ihis disVlct type. 3 The slices are in the fDllovuing counfer-clockwise order (starting a13 o'clock): White. Blzck. Hispanic, Am. Indian, Asian, Pacific Islantler. Other, Multi-Race. 4. Racial brezks are for Race/Hispanic Origin Combination. MRT is Mulli-Raolal Totzl persons The sum of these, aside from rounding, should be 100percent' for predominant group. 5 Addilionzl breaks are included il MRT Is over t%. While-Black; WhiteAm.Indian, White-Aslan, While-Pacific, White-OIM1er and Black-Am Intlian. IayplxrsHO-psplemz-knsl LPL 000132 Political Districts Redistricting Handbook for OHIO Page 39.X.9 Racial Subgroups for STATE HOUSE :R3::hl:+i):1 2010 VAP %of Pop 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 81 916 1- 61_ 10',S36 ^0„9.a .9 - 4'4$."^, . . Whl Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Olh MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI 2010POp 85.3 10.6 1.4 0.2 05 00 0.1 1.9 2010 VAP 86.2' 10.8 1.2 0.2 0.5 0.0 0.1 1.0 0.3 0.1 0.1 O.O O.O 01 Deplance". Fulton, V4ilNams 74 Goodwin, Bruce (R) 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 89,127 75.3% 118,430 1,900 1.63% ^ WM 81k Hsp Ind Asn Pac Olh MRT 210POp 90.6 1.0 69 0.2 0.4 0.0 0.0 0.9 2010 VAP 92.5 1 0 5.3 0.2 0.4 0.0 0.0 0.5 DePiance', Henry, Paulding, Putnam, Van VJerl 75 WachOnann,Lynn (R) 2010VAP %ofPop 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. ReI Dev. 83.39574.4^a. ..^,.019 -4.811 -3.8?[,0 Wht Blk Hsp nd Asn Pac Olh MRT 00 0.0 0.7 2010POp 93.5 0.5 4.8 0.2 0.3 2010 VAP 95.0 0.4 3.7 0.2 0.2 0.0 0.0 05 Augiaize', Hancock. Hardin 76 Sprague, Robert(R) 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010 Pop. Abs Dev Rel Dev. 92:262 763% 120,854 4,324 3.7190 `.... J Wht BIk HsP nd Asn Pac Olh MRT 1.3 3.3 02 7.2 0.0 0.1 1 2 2010POP 92.9 201oVAP 94.2 1.1 2.5 0.2 1.2 0.0 00 0.7 D'arke', Iclercer, Prebie 77 BuChy,Jim (R) 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 88,925 74.9'/0 118,691 2,161 1.85% Wht Blk HsP nd Asn Pac Otb MRT 2010 Pop 96.8 (14 12 0.2 0.4 0.1 0.1 0.9 2010 VAP 97.5' 0.3 0.9 012 0.4 0.0 0.0 0.6 Auglaize', Champaign, Shelby 78 AdamS, John (R) ' . 2010 VAP %of Pap 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 39,651 73.8% 121,455 4,925 4.23% Ind Asn Pac OIh MRT G) Wht Blk Hsp 2010 PoP 94.8 }.6 1.2 0.2 0.6 0.1 Ot 1.5 2010 VAP 95.8 1.5 0.9 0.2 0.6 0.1 0.0 0.8 Darke', h6iami 79 Adams, Richard ( R) 2010 VAP %of Pop 2010 Pop. Abs Dev Rel Dev. 90.632 75.6Yo 119,858 3,328 2 86% Wht Bik HsP Ind Asn Pac Olh MRT 2010POp 94.2 1 .8 1 2 0.2 1.0 0.0 01 1.5 2010 VAP 95 4' 1.7 0.9 0.2 1.0 0.0 0.0 0.8 . . Ene,^Oaad'v c:8 2010 VAP %of Pap 2010POp. AbsDev. RelDem $6,416 785% 110.1 .. 18 -6.452 -5.50.., Whl Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Olh MRT 2070 PDp 87.5 6.2 3.7 0.2 05 0.0 0.1 1.9 2010VAP 89.8 57 2.9 0.2 0.5 0.0 0.0 0.9 Ottav Ind Asn Pao Olh MRT G Wht Blk HsP 2010 Pop 88.4 2.5 6.9 0.1 0.4 00 0.1 1.6 2010 VAP 90.8' 2.3 5.4 0.2 0.5 0.0 0.0 0.8 (c) 2011. Polldala. www politlafa.org tleal is 116,530. (R) Demographic and Political Guides. All Rights Reserved Copyright 1.POLIDATA Populallon for 2010 fram PL94-171 Redislricling Dala Irom U 5. Burexu of tM1e Census. 2000 Census dalafrom various sources. State populalion: 11,536.504, 99 members, i the ideal population for IM1is district type. 2 Pie Charts give z rough approximalion of the racial breaks br the currenl9lstricl: The overall size of each pie is scaled to slarting at 3 o clock). While, Black. Hispanic. Am, Indian, Asian, Pacific Islander, Other. Mulli-Race 3. The slices zre in the following counter-clockwise order ( 4. Racial breaks zrefor RaceMispanic Origin Combination. MRT is Mulli-Racial Total persons. The sum of these, aside from rounding, should be 100 percenl' for predominant group. 5 Additional breaks are included if MRT Is over 1%. White-Black. White-Am.lndian, Wllile-Asian, Whlle-PZcific, While-Other and elackAm Indian. 139p1%RHO-pipled12-KC15I LPL 000133 Redistricting Handbook for OHIO Politicat Districts Racial Subgroups for STATE HOUSE Page 39.X.10 Craw;ord, Marion', Wyandot 2010 VAP %af Pop 82 McClain, Jeffrey (R) 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 86.04J 71.118 :11.62`0 -4 GO5 -..2156 .^ Wht 61k HsP Ind Asn Pac 01h MRT 2010 POp 92.4 3.6 2.0 0.1 0.4 0.0 0.1 1.2 2010 VAP 93.2' 4.0 1.5 0.1 0.4 0.0 0.0 0.7 Logan, Marion`, Union 2010 VAP %of Pop Burke, Dave (R) 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 88.782 74.3`/0 119,433 2,903 2.49% Ind Asn Pac Olh MRT ^ Wht Blk HsP 2010 Pop 93.8 1.7 1.2 02 1.5 00 0.1 210VAP 94.7 1.9 1.0 011.4 0.0 0.0 0.8 Clark', Greene', Madlson 2010 VAP %of Pop 84 HackeU,Robert;R) 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 90,438 77_4% 116,799 269 0.23% ^ Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT 0.0 01 1.5 2010 PoP 922 3.9 1.4 (12 0.7 2010 VAP 92.8' 4.2 1.1 0.2 0.7 00 0.1 0.9 Fayeite_ Pickaway, Ross 85 Peteison, Bob (R) 2010VAP %of Pop 2010 Pop- Abs Dev. Rel Dev 96,608 76.9% 125,655 9,125 7.83°0 Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI 5.4 1 2 0.2 04 0.0 0.1 1.7 2010210POp VAP 90.8 910' 6.3 1.0 0.3 0.4 0.0 0.7 1.0 0.3 O.t 0.1 0.0 0000 Clinton, Highland. Pike .2010 VAP %of Pop 86 Rosenberger, Cliff (R) 2010 Pop- Abs Dev Rel Dev- 85,864 75.146 t14.338 -1,192 -'-889k WP WO 61 Asn Pac Oth MRT WB Wf WA Wht BIk spH Ind 2010 POp 95.3 1.5 0.9 0.3 0.3 0.0 0.1 1.5 02 01 0.1 0.0 0.0 0.0 2010VAP 96.1 1,6 0.7 0.3 0.3 0.0 0.0 1.0 GalOa, Jackson, Lawrence", Ross', Vinton 87 EVans, Clyde (R) 2010 VAP %of Pop 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. ReI Dev. 91,780 76 0% 120,818 4,288 3.68% ^ Whi Blk Hsp Idd 3 054 0.0 Ot MR2 2010POp 95.9 1.3 0.8 0 2010 VAP 96.5' 1.3 0.6 0.3 0.4 0.0 0.0 0.9 Adams', Brown, Ciermont' 2010 VAP %of Pop 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 92,294 75.5% 122,323 5,793 497% Ind Asn Pac 01h MRT ^ Whi elk HsP 2010 Pop 97.1 0.6 0.8 0.2 02 00 0.1 1.0 2010VAP 97.6 0.6 0.6 0.2 0.2 0.00.0 0.7 A.dams', Lawrece', Scloto R) 2010 VAP %of Pop 89 Jahnson, Terry ( Dev- 92 888 76-9% 20 10 Pop. Abs Dev Rel 120.820 4,290 3.6B% MRT WB WI WA WP WO 61 Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Olh 2010 Pop 943 2.5 10 0.4 0.3 0.0 0.1 1.6 2010VAP 94.8' 2.6 0.7 0.4 0.3 D.0 0.0 1.1 02 O.t 0.1 0.0 0.0 0.0 Ashland', Knox, Morrow, Rlchland VAP %of Pop Ann (R) 2010 90 Ruht, Margaret 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 95,859 75.6% 126,807 10,277 882°k Asn Pac Ofh MRT E^ Wht Blk HsP Ind 02 0.6 0.0 0.1 1.1 [F 2010 Pop 96.1 0.8 1.1 2010 VAP 96 8' 0.8 0.9 0.2 0.6 0.0 0.1 07 c) 2011. Polidata, www polldafa.org R) DemograpNC and Political GuMes. All Rights Reserved. Copyright ( members, ideal is 11fi.530. P1 OLIDATA ( ensUS rule 9 givefor e roughfrOm approxunal'lon olf IheBraClal brezks for Ih ecu ent dlMricl The overa101 sze of each pieOmm is sSaletl molhe itlealfpopulavon fo nlhis disfiric^lype 2 P epChsrts starting a13 otlock). White. Black. Hispanic. Am.Indian. Asian, Paciflc Islander.Olher, Mulli-Race- ( munding, should be 100 percent' for predominant group. 3. The slices are'm [he following counter-clDCkwise ortler ae from 4 Racial breaks are for RacelHispanic Origin Combination. MRT Is Multi-Racial Totaf persons. The sum of these, sid 5. Adtlitional breaks are included if MRT is Dver 1%. White-Black. White-Am.Indian, White-Asian, White-Pacific, Whlle-O[her and Blzck-Am Indian. IoqPlxRno-p•plemz-xc151 LPL 000134 Political Districts Redistricting Handbook for OHIO Page 39.X.71 Racial Subgroups for STATE HOUSE Hocking, Llrking", Perry, Pickaway 91 Hayes, BIII (R) 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010 Pop. Abs Dev Rel Dev. 98.525 75.4`/0 130,644 14,114 12.11% Wht Elk Hsp ind Asn Pac Oth MRT 0.0 0.1 1.2 2010 Pop 96.5 0.9 0.8 0.2 0.3 0.0 0.8 2010VAP 97.1 0.9 0.7 0.3 0.2 0.0 F.tley-ie' ^ o lan.t. i qfrc¢ ,^h.il'In^, D•. bb', r.r: 2010 VAP %of Pop 2010 PoPAbs Dev Rel Dev. 99,655 81.0 % 123,037 6,507 5.589; Oth MRT WB Wl WA WP WO 81 Wht Elk Hsp Ind Asn Pac 1.5 0.0 0.1 1.9 2010POp 92.9 2.2 1.1 0.2 .04 0.2 0.20.0 00 0.1 1.7 0.0 0.1 1.5 2010VAP 932 2.3 1.0 0.2 Guernsey, IJlorvoe, Muskingum`, Noble, Washington 93 Titomp5on, Andy (R) 2010 VAP %of Pap 2010 Pop. AbsAev. Rel Dev. 91,518 78A% 116,725 195 0.17% Olh MRT Wht BlkHsp Intl Asn Pac 0.4 00 0.1 1.2 2010 PDp 96.3 1.1 0.7 0.2 0] 0.8 96.8' 1.2 0.5 0.2 0.4 0.0 S 2010 VAP CoShocton. Muskingum' 94 Halderson, Troy (R) 2010 VAP %of Pop 1010Pop. AbsDev. RelDev. 89.322 757% 117,946 1,416 1.21 % Oth MRT WB WI WA WP WO BI ^ . Wht BIk Hsp Ind Asn Pac 0.3 0.0 0.1 2.0 2010 Pop 93.6 3.0 0.8 0.2 0.1 1.1 0.4 0.1 0.1 0.0 0.0 0.0 2010 VAP 94.8 ` 2-9 0.5 0.2 0-3 0.0 l5, 9r,ort'. ,. on 2010VAP % fPOp 2010POp. AbsDe¢ RelDev. 85,3.. 2 7%°ro 106.820 9,71C -6 's3% Oth MRT ^ Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac 0.3 0.0 0.1 1.5 2010 Pop 92.5 4.5 0.9 0.1 0.0 0.8 2010 VAP 93,8" 4.1 0.7 0.1 0.3 0.0 Beimont', Harrisun, TuscaraWas' 96 Landis, Al (R) 2010 VAP %of Pop 2010 Pop. Abs Dev. Rel Dev. 96,596 77.9% 124.049 7,519 fi 45% Olh MRT Wht Bik Hsp Ind Asn Pac 0.4 0.1 0. 1 11 2010 POp 94.5 22 1.6 0.1 0.1 0.0 0.7 2010 VAP 94.9 2.5 1.4 0.1 0.4 Ashland', Holmes, Medina 97 HaO,Dave(R) 2010VAP %ofPOp 2010 Pop. Abs Dev- Rel Dev. 90,343 724% 124,815 8,285 7.11% Olh MRT Q Wht elk HsP Ind Hso Pac 0.0 0.8 2010 POp 97.0 0.6 t0 0.1 0.4 0.0 0.0 0.6 2010 VAP 97.4" 0.6 0.8 0.1 0.5 0.0 Cuyahoga',GCauga' 98 Holliltgion. Richard (R) 2010VAP %of Pop 2D10 Pop- Abs Dev. Rel Dev- 47 01? ., ^ 115.232 i,293 :.11`1^ Pao Olh MRT ^ Wht elk Hsp Intl Asn 01 09 2010 POP 93.7 22 1 2 01 1.9 0.0 01 0.5 2010VAP 94.2' 2.2 1.0 0.1 1.9 0.0 Ashtahula, Trumbull 99 Kozlowski, Cascy (f2) 2010 VAP %oI Pop 2010Pop- AbsDev. RelDev. 82,p23 7599e 108338 ^0.';92 -?.039b MRT Wht Blk Hsp Ind Asn Pac Oth 04 00 0.0 1.7 2010 Pop 912 33 32 0.2 00 0.0 0.9 2010VAP 92.6' 3.5 2.4 0.2 0.3 POLIDATA (R) Demographic and Polilical Guides. AII Rights Reserved. Copyrigbl (c) 2011.9o6dalz. www polidata.org 99 members, ideal is 116,530 1 Popula0on for 2010 from PL94-171 Redisldcling Data from U S. Bureau of the Census. 2000 Census dala fmm various sources. State populatiom 11,536,504, 2 Pie Charls give a roughapproximafion of the racizl breaks for tbe currenl tlislricl. The overall size of each pie is scaled lo the ideal populalibn for tbis dlslricr lype. 3. The slices are in Ihe lollowing counler-clockwise order (sfarling al 3 0 clock). White, Black, Hispanic. Am. Indian. Asian, Pacific Islander,Other. Mulli-Race. 4 Racial breaks are for RacelHispanic Origln Combination. MRT is Mulli-Racial Total persons. The sum of Ihese, aside from rounding, should be 100 perceni.' for predominant group. 5. Addilional breaks are induded if MRT is over 1%. White-Black, Whlte-Amlndian, While-Asian, White-PacJk, White-Other and Black-Am Indian. 139pIXRHO-psplctlll-KCtS LPL 000135 Redistricting Handbook for OHIO Politicat Districts Racial Subgroups for STATE HOUSE Page 39.X,12 Ranked by 2010 Minority Voting Age Population for Selected Subgroups Black Asian DStrlci ED Member Mlnorily Hsp/Lat d, P { -sd i;ci;t.wd. @iike Rj.ecee. Ailciz. Yvi R) Demographic and Polilical Guides. All Righ[s Reserved Copyright (c) 2011. Polidata, www polidata org POLIDATA ( Census data Uam vzrfous sources. Stzte populz0on: 11,536.504, 99 members, ideal is 116.530. 1. Populzqon for 20101rom PL94-1 71 Redistriding Dztz from U 5. Bureau of the Census. 2000 give arougb approximatlon oflheraclalbreaksforlhe currenldisiricL The overalisize oleach pieis sczledlo Neitlealpopulalion forthls dislricltype. 2 Pie Charrs are in the following counler-clockwise order (starling a13 oHock)-. While, Black, Hispznic. Am. Indian, Asian, Pacdic Islander, Other, Multi-Race. 3 The slices these, aside from rounding, should be 100 percenf.' for predominant group. 4 Racial breaks are for Race/Hispanic Origin Combination. MRT is Multi-Raclal Talalpersons. The sum of 5 Additionalbreaks arefncludedrfMRTis over 1%.White-Black,Whlte-Am.Indian,White-Asizn,White-Pacific,White-Otherand Black-AmIndian. 134prxltHO-pspicali-ka11 LPL 000136 Political Districts Redistricting Handbook for OHIO Page 39.X.73 Raciat Subgroups for STATE HOUSE 0.3 Ashtabula, Trumbull 99 Kozlowskl , Casey (R) 7 3 2 4 35 ^ 3 . o , . I Nfairo;N.^.^ -.eibP v 2< 4j JD) 0.3 Huron', Lorain' Seneca' 58 Boose, leqy (R) 73 3.1 4 0 7.2 1.1 0. 7 Clark' , Greene' , Madison 84 Hackett, Robert (R) 4 2 2 2 2 . 7 Cuyahoga' 16 Baker. Nan (R) 7.2 . 1:4 71 'I 2 3 7 0.8 Licking' 71 tlottinger, Jay (R) + 6.5 1 0 2.3 i.7 ren .t r c-c=rn a ^inn . I'iliiiU ) t F t` •%i f d Marion' , Wyandot 82 McCiain, Jeffrey (R) 67 1.5 4-0 04 Craw or , SummiP 42 Raegner,Kdstina (R) 6.5 1.1 24 2.0 1.0 39 b.F 'ptnhtt' 6 5 6:; ?3 anc' 62 r d: 6.1 1n 9.1 1inri n ir v. Cer,il..^ .:1 6t 2.! 1 9 C uyzt oga ' , ceauga' 98 Holkngton, Richard (R) 5.8 1-0 2.2 ^ 25 . 1 .2 Augiaize' , Ha.ncock , Hardin 76 Sprague, Robcrt (R) 53 1 1 1.4 Logan,Marlon',Union 83 Burke, Dave (R) 53 1-0 1.9 0.4 Belmont ' , Harrison, Tuscarawas' 96 Lattdis. AI (R) 5 2 1.4 2.5 0-3 Coshocton, Muskingum' 94 Balderson, Troy (R) 5.1 0.5 2.9 03 Adams ' , Lawrence ', 9ctoto 89 Johnson, T¢rry (R) 5.1 0.7 2-6 Ciermont` 66 Uecker, Joe (R) 5.1 1.4 1 4 1.2 Defiance' , Henry, Paulciing, Putnam, 4'an tvart 75 Wachtmann, Lynn (R) 5.0 33 04 0.2 2.3 03 Columbiana 1 Newbold, Craig (R) 4.7 1.2 0.9 1.7 1.0 Darke ' , Miami 79 Adams , Richard (R) 46 „ 3 r1 ..... ,rK;b7 45 1.3 1.4 Wayne 3 Amstulz, Ron (R) 45 08 1.2 Medina 69 Batchelder. Wi9iam (R) 4.2 1.3 1-0 Au.gta ize'. Cham aign. Sheiby 78 Adams,John(R) 4.1 0.9 1.5 06 Summit' 43 McKenney,Todd(R) 40 0-7 14 09 Hamliton ' . 30 Meckienborg; Bob (R) 4.0 0-7 1.7 0.8 3,9 07 1.6 0.3 Clinton, Highland, Pike 86 Rosenberger, Cliff (R) , 3.5 0.6 1.3 04 Ga141a,Jackson, Lawrence ' . Ross ' Vinton 87 Evans , Clyde (R) 0.6 Ashland' Knox, Morrarv, Richiand 90 Ruhl. Margaret Ann (R) 3.3 09 0.8 32 05 12 0.4 Guernsey, Monroe, Muskingum ', Noble, bNas hington 93 'I"hompson, Andy (R) 1.1 0.4 Stark' 56 Hagan, Christlna (R) 3.0 0.8 0 9 0 2 Hocking, Licking' , Perry, Pirkaway 91 Hayes , Biti (R) 2.9 0 7 . . Ashland'. Hclmes. Medina 97 Hall, Dave(R) 26 0-8 06 0.5 0.9 03 0.4 Darke' , 0rierce[, Preb;e 77 Buchy,J;m (R) 2-4 Adams ' , P,ro•,.vn, Clerment ' 88 Bubp, Danny (R) 2.3 0.6 06 0.2 POLIDATA (R) Demographic and Polilical Guides. All Rights Reserved. Copyright (c) 2011 Polidatz. www polidata.org 1- Population for 2010 from PL94-171 Redistriciing Data from U S. eureau of Ihe Census. 2000 Census data from various sources. Slate populalion: 11.536.504, 99 members, ideal Is 116.530. 2. Ple Charts give a rough approximation ollhe racialbreakslorthe currentdistrict.The overallsize oleach pie is scatedtolhe idealpopulalioniorlhls disVictiype. 3 The slices are in the following counler-clockwise order (siarting at 3 o'clock): While. Black, Hispanic, Am. Indian, Asizn, Pzcific Islander, Other, Mulli-Race. 4. Racial breaksare for RacelHispanic Origin Combination. MRT is Mullt-Racial Total persons The sum of these, aside from rounding, should be 100 percent. ' for predominant group. 5.Addllionalbreaks are included if MRT is overt%White-Black.White-AmIndian,White-Asian,White-Pacific,While-Olherand Black-Amindian. 139pIXPHO-pSpkJ13-KC151 LPL 000137 THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLV BLANK LPL 000138 LPL 000139 p-df, 3BpjRR,HO,pd^ ;^ H7ept!€Y-*l$Rkdpof Attac4gd dat-isezs hi whi0i1(ha^^Ft tli€ Ah F 4) z'^Oh 4€ta°z, kstrrku, pip^%f {aY!^`^^ ^^Ie LPL 000140 Heather Mann From: Clark Bensen/POLIDATA [[email protected]] Sent: Sunday, July 10, 2011 4:44 PM 'Ray DiRossi'; 'Heather N. Mann - gmait'; 'Troy J.'; 'Matt Schuler sbc email'; 'Benjamin Yoho'; To: 'Vaughn Flasher'; [email protected]; 'Michael Lenzo' Cc: 'Braden, E. MarR' Subject: RE: Ohio Apportionment and Redistricting political data P()LIDA`I'A rg^ i)emographia and Political f uides ; wm w^olidata.u s POLIDATA V Political Data Analysis C ^k^^^v. tidata.org Pt>LIIJA"fA CR- at CafePress j wzx ;u r.afettress.comJposi PGL,II7A'fA^R at Lulu [wnmv.fulu cotnlp< ^` sdata C;iark Bensen I PE)LII3A1'A LLC J TeI: 703-690_4066 Vermont Office: I303 Hayward Road i P.O. Box 530 1 Uorinth, VT 05039 Vir<=inia Office: 3112 Cave Court ! Lake Ridge, VA 22192 efax: 202-318-0793 j email: clarl=^r,poiidata.or: From: Ray DiRossi (mai(to ravdirossiCavamadLcom^ Sent: Sunday, July 10, 2011 4:22 PM Benjamin Yoho; Vaughn Flasher; To: Heather N. Mann - gmail; Troy J.; Matt Schuler sbc email; iodyrcapitolstratecaiesgrg cor^+; Michael Lenzo Cc: Braden, E. Mark; Ctark Bensen - polidata Subject: Ohio Apportionment and Redistricting political data ( Based on previous emails, we seem to have agreement on using the 5 races listed below equally weighted) to comprise our index number for apportionment and redistricting. In races where there are minor party candidates - I have excluded those minor party candidates and weighted the 2 majors to 100%. If there are no objections to these 5 races, I have ec'd Clark Bensen and counsel on this email so that they can make sure we have these races in our political data to be used with Maptitude. Using these 5 races -- the Statewide Republican Index by my calculation is 49.56% Ray 2004 Presidential Busb(Kerry Bush won 50.81 to 48.70 Using only 2 Major parties - Bush won 5 1.05 to 48.94 2006 Auditor TaylorlSykes Tavlor won 50.64 to 49.36 I LPL 000141 2006 AG Danrv'Montgomery Dann won 52 C 1 to 47.39 2008 Presidential Obaina/McCain Obarna won 51.50 to 46.91 Using only 2 ivlajor parties - Obaina won 52.33 to 47.66 2010 Kasic hfStrick land Kasich won 49.04 to 47.04 Using only 2 Major parties - Kasich won 51.04 to 48.96 LPL 000142 PAann, Heather From: Adams; Richard Sent: Monday, July 11, 2011 9:58 AM To: Mann, Heather Subject: RE: Request for written confirmation of home address Richard Adams 1075 Hillcrest Drive Troy, OH 45373 Arielle Adkins Legislative Aide Representative Adams Ohio House Of Representatives District 79 ^.._ ^._.._....-..__...-__.._ From; Mann, Heather Sent: Sunday, July 10, 2011 4:33 PM Subject: FW: Request for written confirmation of home address Dear Members & Staff: If you are receiving this email, t have not received or cannot locate correspondence from you confirming the member's home address per my email of June 3'° Please send by member (not staff) email or written correspondence confirmation of your home address to my attention as soon as conveniently possible. Please call me if you have any questions. Sincerely, Heather Mann Heather N, Mann, Esq. Redistricting Director & Dep. Legal Counsel House Republican Caucus Ohio House of Representatives 77 South High Street, 14th Floor Columbus, Ohio 43215 (614) 466-9194 - Offce (614) 719-3594 - Fax (614) 352-5819 - Cell heather.mannPohr state oh us CONFIDENTVLLITY NOTICE The infotmadon contained in ttis e-mai[ is intended only'or the use of the indivioaal or entity to which it is addressed ard it may contain iafo[[nation that is privileged, pmduct antllor exempt from disdosure under applicable law. If ihe reader of this messaoe is not the intended reopient (or the employee or agent catfidential, attorney work responsrble to deliver if to the intended rec)pient), you are hereby ooti5ed that ar.y dissemination.. d:stdbution, or cnpyi^9 of thi5 e-mail is prchibited. If you have received€his e-mait in error, please noUty the sender by return e-mail Frorn: Mann, Heather Senr Friday, June 03, 2011 3:29 PM To: Members_GOP 144 LPL 000143 Cc: Staff_GdP Subject: Request for written confirmation of home address Dear Republican Members & Staff: In order to update our information, we would like to request written confirmation from each Republican member of their home address. Please send to my attention by member email or hard copy letter by Friday,lune 10. Sincerely, Heather Mann Heather N. Mann, Esq. RedistrictPng Director & Dep, Legal Counsel House Republican Caucus Ohio House of Representatives 77 South High Street.14th Floor Calurr bus, Ohio 43215 (614) 466-9194 - Office (614)719-3594Fax (614) 352-5819 - Cell heather mann@Ohr state oh us CUNFiDENT1AUTY NUTtGE The information contained Ln this e-maii is intended only for the use of the individual or enfity to whith tt is addressed and'R may contain informalion that is privileged, product and(or exernpt #rom disclosure under applicable law. If the reader of this message is no LPL 000144 Heather Mann From: Ray DiRossi [email protected] Monday, July 11, 2011 152 PM Sent: To: Heather Mann Subject: Re: GeoCode efforts ok thats fine tva'ote: On Mon, Jul 1 f, 20 t 1 at 1:28 PM, Ilcather Mann chc^t e t2ttnn 0°zumail.com> Yes. It's going to take him a few days. Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Colttmbus, Ohio 43206 6141 352-381.9 heatt?e mann c, gTnaili otrt ---Original Message----- From: Ray DiRossi (mailto:ravdirossifa2ontail.carti] Sent: Sunday, July 10, 2011 9:39 AM To: Heather N. Mann - gmail Cc: Troy J. Subject: Re: GeoCode efforts Are you also communicating with Ben Yoho on adding to the database past and future opponents of current republican state reps Ray wrote: On Sun, Jul 10, 2011 at 9:34 AM, Ray DiRossi > L-Ieather > Have you request'ed this info from Ilouse clerk? > > We need the attached spreadsheet ftlled out for every ntember of the > House (Republican and Den7ocrat) using the field structure I have set > forth > > These need to be their official residences - no P.O. boxes or > alternative mailing addresses > but their otficiai addresses > > lm working to campile for the SPnate > > We also need this for every member of the Congressional delegation t LPL 000145 > Thanks > Ray LPL 000146 ann, Heath Frorn: Mann, Heather Sent: Monday, July 11, 2011 11:03 PM To: Borges, Maft Subject: RE: Re: Where is your office? Heather N. Mann, Esq. Redistricting Director & Dep. Legal Counsel House Republican Caucus Ohio 14ouse of Representatives 77 South High Street, 14th Floor Columbus, Ohio 43215 (614) 466-9194 - Office (614) 719-3594 - Fax (614) 352-5819 - Cell heathermann ,ohrstateohus CQNFp^M"W-LITY_NO))TlOE The information contained snthis e-maii is intended onFy for tne use of the indiwduai or en€ify'o which it is addressed and 1: maycontain information that is privileged, confidential, atlotney work product andlor exempt 6om dlsciosore under applicabie law. If the reader of tNs message is not the intended recipient (or the employee or agent responsible to defver it to the intended reeJpienij, you are here4y notified tha[ any dissem{natlon dist[ibution, or cop'yfng of this e-mait is prohibited. If you have recemed this e-mail in error, p:ease notify the sender by retum e-mail .,..__._.... _-....-._ ..-^..._ _ ...,..__ --__ From: Borges, Matt [marlto:[email protected]] 6ent:: Monday, July 11, 2011 9:53 PM To: Mann, Heather;'MAAugsburger^a)auditor.state.oh.us' Ccc '[email protected] ; Lenzo, Mike; '[email protected]' Subjecr Re: We can meet at my office, if you'd like. I can have lunch brought in. From: Mann, Heather [maiEto:[email protected]) Sent: Monday, July 11, 2011 08:37 PM To: Mary Arrtos Augsburger Thursday noon works for me. Heather N. Mann, Esq Redistricting Director & Dep. Legal Counsel House Republican Caucus Ohio House of Representatives 77 South High Street, 14th Floor Columbus, Ohio 43215 (614) 466-9194 - Office (614) 719-3594 - Fax (614) 352-5819 - Ce(3 heathe• mann(r ohr state.oh.us CONF f,OF NTEALI7Y NOTIC E LPL 000147 or entity to addresiyd! r: this er^aii i5:ntended Gn=y ier €hc use o. 're incividuat wh ^npf o€ agen7 eordnined he rea e ,^s ^t i tteeyh erdetl n cipleno(or the e rpfoyee ccnfltlr.^.faf, attorney wa€rt prcduct antlfer exe: Tit Forr• disclosure under applreabe taw. ft t bl respo^%5+b^e to dellver a[a 8^e !nEendetl redprent), you're hereby notified that arry dissernlnatlo^, dfstrlbu4irn, o€ copying f this ^mar is preh;`,ed if you have receiaed this e-mail in error, please notify tPe sende° by return e-masl From: Mary Amos Augsburger [maiYto:[email protected]'ate.oh.us] Sent: Monday, July 11, 2011 3:54 PM To: Mary Amos Augsburger; Mann, Heather Cc: '[email protected]'; Lenzo, Mike; Troy 3; Borges, Matt Subject: RE: d1'huxsday at noon work? <713ps -- az bad_ Matt is notavailable on F'riday so Yvo From: Mary Amos Augsburger Sent: Monday, July 11, 2011 3:51 PM To: Mann, Heather Cc: 'raydirossi@gmaiLcom'; L.enzo, Mike; Troy 3; Borges, Matt Subject: RE: tAi I-IeaclTer, and I are both avaitable during the lunch hour either day. I l'tave a tsaining session both of those davs, but Mart Would either of those times wo:li? From: Mann, Heather [mailtn:[email protected]] Sent: Monday, )ufy J.1, 2011 2:11 PM To: Mary Amos Augsburger Cc:'raydirossi@gmaiLoom'; Lenzo, Mike; Troy ) Subject: RE: Mary, What is your availability this Thursday or Friday? Ray Dirossi and Mike Lenzo and/or Troy Judy may join us on the meeting as well. Thank you, Heather Mann Heather N. Mann, Esq. Redistricting Director & Dep. Legal Counsel House Republican Caucus Ohio House of Representatives 77 South High Street, 14th Floor Columbus, Ohio 43215 (614) 466-9194 - Office (614) 719-3594 - Fax (614) 352-5819 - Cell heather.mann&ohr state oh.us CONFtEE1,1T1A ITY NOTiCE which !t is addressed ead it nxa 1 cnnlaln inlom2tion tha rs FrPv I4e.', The info[maPion containe@ in this e mai! is inte,rded only for the €.se of the indlvidual or enfay to s not f=he intended recip'^ent (or the emp'o/ceor agent exempt from disdosure underapplicsCle Eaw..t -he re der of this rnc szge i conftlentiat, attorney wnrk orod:;et andior EMi4 e-;nall !s prohloited If yov h`v_ r.,cerYed ihs cnded recip:en*:1, you are he,2bi noHP.ed that eny assaminet:oc, C stnhuticn, er cogrng of respensitrta to de!rver It ro the nt' e.ma:l sr^ error. please no@ty the sender by return e-mafl 2 LPL 000148 From: Mary Amos Augsburger [maif[o:[email protected]] Sent: Monday, July 11, 2011 10:54 AM To: Mann, Heather Subject: RE: Ohio deviation charts and maps soine possible dates/times, I'1l Tharzlcs, EIeathei-! Whe.n cou wou7d `ike to meet witdi ,N{;ctt attd me% I£ vou send me check .eith Ibfatt on avai.labilitY'. Any federal tax advice contained herein or in any attachment hereto is not intended to be used, and cnnnat be used, to (1) avoid penalties imposed under the lnternal Revenue Code or (2) support the promotion or marketing of ruly transaction or matier_ This legend has been affixed to comply with U.S. Treasury Regulations governing tax practice. LPL 000149 Heather Mann From: Heather Mann [heathernmann@gmaiLcam] Monday, July 11, 2011 11:28 PM Sent: To: 'Benjamin Yoho' Cc: 'Troy Judy';'Ray DiRossi,'Michael Lenzo' Incumbent Home Precincts.xlsx Subject: pttachments: Incumbent Home Precincts.xEsx QearBen: Attached is an updated incumbent home address list, which may be subject to change further given appointments and anticipated vacancies in the House. We will need to get addresses for likely candidates and opponents to add to this database for the larger redistricting database Ray - I had already pulled the Senate and Congressional addresses a few months ago, but this list has not been verified against the Clerks' data. -Heather Mann I LPL 000150 I Con ess 2 Con g ess Austria Steve 2537 Obetz Drive 3 Con ress Boehncr John 7371 Charter Cu Ln. 4 Cottaress Fud e Marcia 269l0 Eme y Rd. 6992 "I'R 466 7ba Gibbs Robert 6 Con^* ess Johnson Bill 3755 Hunters Hill 7 Con ress Jordan Jim 1709 State Route 560 South 1841 Dority Rd. Democrat 8 Con ress Kaptur Marcy 12217 Milan Ave. Democrat 9 Con gess Kucinich Deruiis 7082 Oak St. Re ublican 10 Con =ress La1'ourette Steven 1528 Muirfield Dr. Re ublican 11 Congress Latta Robert 521 Lceds Gates L.n. Re ublican 12 Con ress Renacci Jim 1504 Taft Ave. Re ubhcan 13 Con ress Ryan Tim 771 Wards Corner Road Re ublican 14 Con ress Schmidt ]ean 372 W. 2nd Avenue Re ubiican 15 Conress Stivers Steve 3825 Royal Rock Rd_ Democrat 16 Congress Sutton Betty 6830 Mabo anv Dr. Re ublican 17 Congress Tiberi Pat 5815 Stone Lake Dr. Re ubGcan I8 Con ss Tumer Michael 347 S. Siate Rt 14 Re ublican I House Newbold Craig 8824 Clearview Lake Court Republican 2 House Brenner Andrew 4456 Wood Lake Trail Re ublican 3 House Amstutz Ron 2220 Merit Drive R ublican 4 House Huffman Mattlrew 536 East Allen Street Republican 5 House Stebelton Gerald 409 S. Mitchell Road Republican 6 House Gardner Ran 479 Pierson Dr. Democrat 7 House ^ Yuko Kenny 6 Kenw©od Court Democrat 8 House Budish Armond 3418 WashingtonBlvd. Democrat 9 House Boyd Barbara 867 East Blvd Democrat 10 House Patmon Bill 12518 Fairhill Road Democrat 11 House Williams ^ Sandra 4467 Lee Road, A t. 303 Democrat 12 House Barnes John 1305 Betle Ave. Democrat 73 House Antonio Nickie 3525 Carrrnunn Ave. Democrat '14 House Fole Michael 2700 Tuxedo Drive Democrat 15 House DeGeeter Timoth 4477 Mallard Circle R ublican 16 House Baker Nan 17150 Alexander Road Re ublican 17 House Anielski Marlene 62 Harna Street Re publican 18 House Dovilla Michael 335 Wildwood Drive R nblicau 19 Elonse Gonzales Anne 4983 Mead Way Drive Democrat 20 House Garland Nancy 645 Farrin tan Drive Re ublican 21 House Duffey Mike 357 E. Torrence Rd. Democrat 22 Hause Camev John 3143 Park Street Republican 23 House Grossman Che 1 1230 Oakland Avenue Denocrat 24 House Celeste Ted 1128 Hi land Street Democrat 25 House Stinziano Michael 1732 Cole St. Democrat 26 House Heard Tracy 75 N. Ohio Ave. Democrat 27 House Weddin ton Carleton 9910 Forest len Drive Democrat 28 llouse Pillich Connie 3153 McGill Lane Republican 29 House Blessing Louis 6648 Powner Farm Dr. Re ublican 30 House Nlecklenbore Bob 4990 RelEeum Ave. Democrat 31 House Driehaus Denise 917 Davton St., Apt. 2 Democral 32 House Mallory Dale 208I SernourAve. Democrat 33 House Reece Alicia 7571 A ers Road Reublicaa 34 1louse Stautberg Peter 2075 S. State Route 123 Re ublican 35 House ^Maa Ron 8447 Diamond Miil Road Republican 36 House Henae Michael LPL 000151 1401 Devereaux Drive Re ublfean 3 7 1-louse Buder J im 10280 Grand Vista Drive Re ubGcan 3 8 Housc Btnir Te 69 Horace St. Democrat 39 House Luckie Cla on 3636 Wales Dr. Deniocra[ 40 House W'itabtnn Rotand 527 Chesw ck Com^t Re ublican 41 House Slaby L nn 2222 East Streetsboro Road Re u(itican 42 House Roe >ner Kristina 5706 Sherw'ood Forest Drive Re ublican 43 House McKennev Todd 133 Furnace Run Rd pemocrat 44 House S kes Vemon 2055 Cramer Ave. Democrat 45 House Milkovich Zack 3650 B rnwick West ^113 Re ublican 46 tlonse Sears Barbara 2054 Belvedere Deinocrat 47 House Fedor Teresa 2910 Collin ood Blvd. Detnocrat 48 House Ashford Michael 1660 Grand Bav Drive Dcmocrat 49 House Szollosi Matt ll787 Marlboro Ave. NE 50 House Ha an Christina Republican 1817 Devonshire Drive NW Republican S t House Sclturiom Kirk 4725 Greenbriar 5. NE :pemocrat 52 House Slesnick Ste Iten 2700 Oxford Millville Road Re ublicao 53 House Dericksoti Timoth 1.846 New London Rd. Re ublican 54 House Combs Courtn 6959 Rock S rin s Drive Re ublican 55 House Conditt Mar mret 1928W.38thSt. Democrat 56 House Ramos Dan 338OIiveStrect Democrat 57 House Lundy Matt 5054 State Route 601 Re ublican 58 House Boose Ter 2940 Whis erin Pines Dr. Democrat 59 House Gerber Ron 562 Madera Ave Democrat 60 House Ha an Robert 460 Antigua Rd. SW pemoerat 61 House Oke Mark 372 E. 328th St. Democrat 62 House Fende Lorraine 6893 Mildoo Drive Republican 63 House Youn Ron 4061TodAve.NW Democrat 64 [4ouse Letson Tom 7450 Northview Drive Democrat 65 House O'Brien Sean 2981ndianview Drive Re ublican 66 House Uecker Joe 7234 Abilene Trail Re ublican 67 House Beck Peter 646 Ada Street Democrat 68 House CI de Kathleen 435 East Smith Re ublican 69 House Batchelder Bill 2098 Fairknoll Drive Re ublican 70 House Martin Jarrod 894 Jottathan Lane Republican 71 House Hottin er Jay 38 W. Hi h Street #3B Re ublican 72 House McGregor Ross 617 HolidaDrive Democrat 73 House Go a] Jay 11932 Harris Road Republican 74 House Goodwin Bruce 550 Euclid Avenue Re ublican 75 House Wachtmann L n 830 S. Main Street Republican 76 House S ra ue Robcrt 281 Do wood Court Republican 77 House Buclt y Jim 1509 Bon Air Circle Republican 78 House Adams Jolm 1075 Hillcrest Drive Republican 79 tiouse Adams Richard 2035 Cedar Point Dr. Democrat 80 House Murrav Dennis 1014 Birchard Avenue Re ublican 81 House Damschtoder Rex 5.55 Sunset Drive Re ubtican 82 House McClain Jeffre 860 We ewood Drive Re tiblican 83 Housc Burke David 2050 Palouse Drive Re . ublican 84 House Hackett Robert 5564 Grassy Branch Road Re ublican 85 House Peterson Bob 7027 State Route 350 West Re ublicaa 86 House Rosenberger Cliff 238 McGee Lane Re ublican 87 1-Initse Carev John 307 N. Market Street Re ublican 88 House Bub pannv 74-A McDaniet Road Re ub!ican 89 House Johnson 'I'errv 3 Swin le Avenue Re ublican 90 House Ruhl Mar et 58CorbinDriveN_ Re ublican 91 House Hayes Bill LPL 000152 Debbie 48 Hudson Ave. Democrat 92 1 3o1 se t'hil3ips Andrew 729 6tlt Street Republican 93 House Tbontpson r 2945- Dresden Road Repulrlican 94 I lousese I Batdetson T Lou Sciotn Dr., Apt. A Democrat 95 Plouse ^ Gentile V Harrold Street N W 96 House [ Landis A] ^R^oblican 368 E. Jackson Street 97 House Hall Dave Repubkican 13792 County Line Road 98 House HolS.ingon Richard Rep ublican 5718 North Richntond Road 99 House [ Kozlowski Castry Republican 2714 WestnioorRoad Senate Hite Cliff Rep ublican 1 333I Pelham Rd. Senate WaSoner Mark Rep ublican 2 5325 Ponderosa Drive Senate Bacon Kevin Republican 8265 Cherry Laurel Dr_ Senate [ Coley William Republican 601 Revelstoke Court RepubGcan 5 Senate I Beagle Bill peggy ar;ueri 533 Lockerbie Ln. Republican Senate [ Lehner Senate [Jones Shannon 800 Valley View Pt. Republican 2097Beech Grove Dr. Senate Seitz Bill Repubtican 3 Lenox Ln. Sepate [ Kearney° Eric Dcmocrat 9 4887 Peacock Rd. t0 Senate [ Widener Chtis Republican 2461 Warren Stt Senate Brown Edna Democrat 7025 Dibble Rd. 12 Senate Faber Keith Rep ublican 5380 Barton Rd. 13 Senate [ Manning Ga, le Republican 1 131 Little Indian Creek 14 Senate [ Niehaus Tom Republican 1237 Medford Rd. 15 Senate ITa es Charleta Democrat 4319 Fairoaks Dr. 16 Senate Hu hes Republican 440 North Street Senate . DanieLs David Republican 7413Tatfersall Street 78 Senate [Grendell Titn Republican 161 Stonebend Ch. 59 Senate Jotdan Kris Re ublican 42995 School Lot Road 20 Senate Stewart rny Reptiblican 13901 Woodworth Ave, 21 Senate Smith Shirley Democrat 5206 Crown Pointe Dr. 22 Senate Obhof LanY Rep ub[ican . 1.6800 Detaware Ave. 23 Senate SkindelE Michael Rcpubliean- 17157 Rabbit Run Drive 24 Senate [Patton Tom Republiean 16204 Sunny Gen Ave. 25 Senate {Ttirner Nina Democrat 514 Hedgegate North Court 26 Senate [Gillmor Karen Republican 3800 Rosemont Blvd; 109-C [LaRose Frank Rep ublican 27 Senate . Tom 1298 N tloward St. Democrat 28 Senate [Sawye ,.__ Scott 1585 Yorkshire Trace Ave. Republican 29 Nenate oelsl e .tason 149 Homestead Drive Democrat 30 Senate Wilson . Tim 1173 Stone Run Ct. Republican 31 Senate [Schaffer Cari 600 Warner Rd. Democrat 32 Senate lCafaro Joe 3765 Mercedes P1. Democrat 33 Senate iSchiavoni LPL 000153 Beavercreek Ohio 45434 West Chester Ohio 45069 Warrensville Hts. Ohio 44128 44639 Lrakeville OH 44514 Poland Ohio Urbana Ohio 43078 Toledo Ohio 43615 Cleveland Ohio 44111 13ainbrid e Ohio 44094 43402 Bowtina Green Ohio Wadswotth Otiio 44281 44446 Niles Ohio Loveland Ohio 45140-9049 Columbus Ohio 43201-3312 Co.je Ohio 44024 43021 Galena Ohio Ohio 45429 Centerville 044 Ohio 44408 COLUMBIANA VIL D Columbiana 01807 Ohio 43065 POWELLCI'IYH Powell 0028 Wooster Ohio 44691 WOOSTER CITY 3 C 0020 Lizna Ohio 45805 LIMA 4A LAN 3B Lancaster Ohio 4313() LANCASTER CITY 3 B Bowlin Green Ohio 43402 44143 RIHT03B Richrriond Hei hts Ohio RICHMOND HEIGHTS 03 B BCHw`DOOH Beachwaod Ohio 44122-7501 BEACHWOOD 00 H CLEVELAND kIEIGHTS 03 F CLHT03F Cleveland Hts. Qkiio 44 1 1 8-2 543 44108 CLEVE081 Cleveland Ohio CLEVELAND 081 CLEVE06R Cleveland Ohio 44120-1018 CLEVELAND 06 R CLEVEOIH Cleveland Ohio 44128-2957 CLEVELAND 01 H LAKWD03B Lakewood EEE Ohio 44107-2679 LAKEWOOD03B CLEVEI9R Cleveland Ohio 44111-2912 CLEVELAND 19 R Ohio 44134 PARMA 04 D PARMA04D Paniia WLKV06B Westlake Ohio 44145-6303 W'ESTLAKE06 B WALTON HILLS 00 A WALTNOOA Walton Hills Ohio 44 1 46-5 023 BEREA05C Berea Ohio 44017-2440 BEREA 05 C 03201E Westerville Ohio 43081-5729 WESTERVILLE I E 01082G New Albany Ohio 43054-9697 COLS 82 G 18201B Worthin ton Ohio 43085-3531 WORTH I B Columbus Ohio 43214-3837 Ohio 43123-3225 GROVE CITY I B 09101B Grove Ci 070006 Grandview Heiohts Ohio 43212-3317 GRANDVIEW B 43201 Columbus Ohio 01005A Columbus Ohio 43205 COLS 05 A Qhio 43203-1950 COLS 07 B 010078 01007B Columbus 4003 Ohio 45242 MONTGOMERY L' Mont ome 5903 Ohio 4525 1-3 1 1 1 COLERAtN C Cincinnati 7313 Cincinnati Ohio 45248-2972 GREEN M 452383806 CINCINNATI 25 E ^ Cincinnati Ohio Ohio 45214 CINCINNATIIBA g^^ Cincimtati 0703 Ohio 45237-4757 CINCINNATI 7 C Cincinnati 5605 Cincinnati Ohio 45255-3914 ANDERSON E 0069 Lebanon Ohio 45036-8941 0069 SAL T W Clayton Obio 45315-9665 CLAY B LPL 000154 5419 Dayton Ohio 4 Ohio 4 5458 Centervit4e 0092 Ohio 454tr2 D^lYTON 7 B Dayton 0394 Ohio 45405-1845 ^HARRISON J Dayton 4420 Ohio 44321-3096 COPLEY TWP F Coz3ev 2970 Ohio 44236-3413 HUDSON 3 E Hudson 3204 Ohio 44319-4257 NEW FRANKLIN 2 B Akron 0480 Ohio 44307-2259 AKRON 3 N^ Akron 1600 Ohio 44312 AKRON 10 A Akron 05006 Mauinee Ohio 43537-9738 MONCLOVA 6 0107 D Ohio 43614-3003 TOLEDO 7D Toledo 0110D Toledo Ohio 436 1 0-1449 TOLEDOIOD 0700 1 Ore=ou Ohio 43616-1152 OREGON 1 Ohio 44601 Altiance 173 Canton Ohio 44708-1907 IACKSON 1'WPS Canton Ohio 44714-i137 Oxford Ohio 45056 45013 Hamilton Ohio Libe Tw - Ohio 4561I Lorain Ohio 44053 44035 El ria Ohio Norn.walk Ohio 44857 Canfield Ohio 44406 44504 Yonno town Ohio Carrollton Ohio 44615 Willowick Ohio 44095-3308 44077 Painesville Ohio Warren Ohio 44485 Brookfield Ohio 44403-9644 Miami Townshi Ohio 45140 45040 Mason Ohio Kent Ohio 44240 Medina Ohio 44256 45431 D.a ori Ohio 43055 Newark Ohio 45502 S rin field Ohio Mansfield Ohio 44904-1820 Defiance Ohio 43512 43545 Na oleon Ohio 45840 Findla , Ohio 45331 Gteenville Ohio Sidne Ohio 45365 45373 Tro Ohio 44870 Sandusk Ohio 43420 Fremont Ohio U er Sandusk Ohio 43351 43040 M sville Ohio 43140 London Ohio 45169 Sabina Ohio Ciarksville Ohio 45113 Wetlston Ohio 45692 Westtinion Ohio 45693 McDermott Ohio 45652 Mount Vernon Ohio 43050 43023 Granville Ohio LPL 000155 Athens Ohio 45701 Marietta Ohio 45750 Zanesv9lle Obio 43701 Stetibenvflle Ohio 43953 Dover Ohio 44622 Millersbur Ohio 44654 Huotin g Valle Ohio 44022 Pie ont Ohio 44U82 Ohio 45840 Findlay 0800 1 O€tawa tiills Ohio 43606-2469 OTTAWA HILLS 1 Columbus Ohio 43231-4033 Middletown Ohio 45069 Ohio 45371-2761 Ti Ci 0632 Ohio 45429 KETTF.RING 3 0 Retterinn 0162 3 rinr?.boro Ohio 45056 0162 CLC T MA 7323 Cincinnati Ohio 45233 GREEN W Cincinnati Ohio 45229 S rin =I4eld Ohio 45502-8718 0108 F Toledo Ohio 43629-1325 TOLEDO 8F Oltio 45822-2814 Celina 1540 Ohio 44039 N RIDGEVILLE 4 C Noith Rid eville 0106 New Richtnond. Ohio 45157 OHIO TOWNSHIP B 01028D Columbus Ohio 43209-2840 COLS 28 D 01022A Columbus Ohio 43214 COLS 22 A GREENFIELD I NE 01 Greenfreld Ohio 45I23-1338 Ohio 44026-2036 Chesterland 02101 Po'ivell Ohio 43065 ORANGE TWP B 05 Alban Ohio 45710-8980 COLUMBIA Cleveland Ohio 44112-1919 Med.ina Ohio Lakewood Ohio 44107 Stron sville Ohio 44736-6243 Cleveland Ohio. 44128-3771 T'iffin Ohio 44883 44333 Fairlawn Ohio Akron Ohio 44310 North Canton Obio 44709-4855 Columbiana Ohio 44408-9559 Lancaster Ohio 431.30 Plubbard Ohio 44035 44406 Can6eld Ohio LPL 000156 ^ann, Heather grom: [email protected] Sent: Tuesday, July 12, 2014 2:40 PM To: Mann, Heather Subject Guestroom quote... Attachments: image001.jpg; image002.jpg; irnage003.9if Heather, Fo#lowing up on our conversation this morning, our government rate is $94 per night for a standard room. -fhere would also be a 16.75% tax on top of the $94. The rate is based on availability. Please let me know if you have any other questions or if you would like to make a reservation. Regards, Cara Morrow Revenue Manager HyattOn Capitol Square 75 East State Street Columbus, Ohio 43215 P- 614.365.4514 cara [email protected] The information contained in this communication is confidential and intended onfy for the use of the recipient nanied above, and niay be legally privileged and exempt froni disclosure under applicable law. If the readee of this message is not the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that any dissemination, distribution or copying of this communication is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error, please resend it to the sender and delete the original of it from your computer system. Opinions, conclusions and other information in this message that do message and copy not relate to our official business should be understood as neither given nor endorsed by the company. 243 LPL 000157 Mann, Heather From: [email protected] Sent: Tuesday, Jufy 12, 2011 12;36 PM To: Mann, Heather Subject: Tax Exemption Certificate for Doubletree Attachments: tax exempt form doubletree.pdf Hello, Heather. I've attached the Tax Exemption Certificate you requested.... Connie Seaburn Fiscal Officer Legislative Service Commission 77 South High Street, 9th Floor Columbus, OH 43215-6136 614/466-1523 614/995-4965 (fax) cseaburn lsc.sLate.oh.us (See attached file: tax exempt form doubletree.pdf) 224 LPL 000158 Hotrnail Print Message Page I of 4 RE: Heather Mann iheathernmann@qmaitco :? Wed 7/13/11 11'14 PM Halte Pelger' ([email protected]) Rar DiRoss' (raydirossfr@gmaiLcom) Ha4!e, .4re vou free to meet after 1PM with Ray and = cn RiU=y' Heather N. Mann 327 City Park,lveniae, Rpt.'3 Coiumhus, GYuo 43266 (^141352-5829 heathernmann@Dgmai).can7 From: [email protected] (mailto:[email protected] Sent: Wednesday, July 13, 2011 7:55 PM Ta: Halle Pelger; Heather Mann Subject: Fw: Heather. As promised below is k IaIIe s contact infonnation. Her work emad hpelger(a sr>s.statc.oh Ilalle 3333fn^hotmaiLcom 1614202^104J Sent from my Verizon Wireless BtackFSerrm Frovai: "Mann. Heather" 'I leather'vlamr'ci oh .state.oh.us? leO... 12/21i201 I hrt^lM1114ti h1n134 mail live cnm/mail/PrintMessates.asnx?cnids=6d56t$40-adc7-I SOS-1055 LPL 000159 Page 2 of 4 Hotmail Print Message Date: Ak'ed, 1= Jul 2011 19i -0400 9 o Monisoit C-lkristin ^Momson a,SOS_state ol us>; Suott Borgeuienke (tiBORUEML ^t,,(iMAII .COM) Cc:'raydirossi(cv,gmail.com' Subject: Please forward the attached to Halie- i left a message for her to meet evith Ray and I to:nUrrow o= Friday on redistricting and I will work directly with her going',orward. Heather N Mann, Esq. Redlstricting Direator& Dep- Legal Coursei House Republican Caucus Ohio House of Represen`,a'ives 77 South i;igh Straet, 14'.n =1oor Columbus, Ohio 43215 {614i466-9194-Cffice (614)719-3594 Fax (614) 352-581 S - Celt heather.mann@ohr state oh us a .' ^, vr Erc rn : e 2 0 . c d '^ ^ . 5 F fPf J S P ^n n aC 'sA f h^^Jin C f 'I fE .^ I ^r. 3 ^cf R / . +Chd ^f^!F ...il}3C... r u.3 IE "'^ td..Y From: [email protected]:oh.us [mailto:cmorrisonCsos.state.oh.usI Sent: 4Nednesday,luly 2, 20115:341 PM To: Mann, Heather Subject: Re: 1 2/2 112 01 1 httr,llhll ;4n, hlnl14 mail liva enm/rnaii/PrintMessa51e.caunx?cnidS=6d^61X'4D-adc7-11eO_. SOS-1056 LPL 000160 I'age 3 of 4 Hotmail Print Message Yes. Sent from nrv izon Wireless BlackBerry From: "Matin, Heather" Date: Wed. 13 Jul 2011 17:25:51 -0400 To: Monison, Christine Subject: Heather N. Mann, Esq. Redistricting Director & Dep. Legal Counsel House Republican Caucus Ohio House of Representatives 77 South High Street, 14th Floor Columbus. Ohio 43215 (614) 466 °194- Office (614) 719-3594 - Fax (614) 352-5819 - Cell heathe:rnann@ohr state oh: us xONF;DENTIf A.ITY NQT!uE r r0 T+52 snie..dea c,iy e"10 -I^ ^ t i" 2d sc oo[ 9 ' ^.eu a e I 'ela e o rc ne ei h r iaged e Ila attc eivo F^huc ^ ^ e eiGti cnc c rasp^ s ^ I lo [. ' er th r eadad r t y 'e .nteaoaC [CCiGen or f.. e+1ployel, Ce n- tly- ti>+r r r u, ^^ ,. 's ..,n,ercopyn ..thisa-rri =oro.,eoACdif;-l na"e acsvrtl-, s_ma. ln_ ,. e s. httn://51134w.b1u134.mail.live.eom/mail/PrintMessat?es.asgx?cpids=6d56f840-adc7-l 1e0... 12/21 /201 1 SOS-1057 LPL 000161 Page 4 of 4 Hotmail Print Message 12/21f2011 I ;4w hbnt't4 mm I 14ve en,n/maiUPrintMeseaees.asnx?enids=6d561840-adc7-11e0..: SOS-1058 LPL 000162 Heather From: Mann, Heather Sent: Thursday, July 14, 2011 8:36 AM To: Carrie Boor Subject: RE: Double Tree Suites Attachments: image001.jpg; image002.gif When you say the tax is exempted at the bottom, are you saying that the amount k cited was incorrect? Heather N. Mann, Esq. Redistricting Director & Dep. Legal Counsel House Republican Caucus Ohio House of Representatives 77 South High Street, 14th Floor Columbus, Ohio 43215 (614) 466-9194 - Office (614) 719-3594 - Fax (614) 352-5819 - Cell heatfier mann(dohr state.oh.us coNl=toENrAtJTt N_o7cE 'ihe information contalned i', fts e-mail is Intended only for the use of the individual or entity to which it is addressetl and it rnay contain information that is prieileged c-onfidential, attomey work protluot anc9or exempl from disclosure under appficabte law. If the reader Cf tnis message i5 not the iniended recipient (orthe emplayee cr agent responsible to deliver'd to the intended reciplent), you are hereby notified that any dissc-rnination, dlstdhutfon, or copymg of thise-mall is prohlbiied- Ef you have received thls e-mail in error, please nobfy ibe sender by return e-maiL .. ..-__.., ...... _. . _.__.. .__....-___ From Carrie Boor [mailto Carrie.Boor@hilton com Sent: Thursday, July 14, 2011 8:05 AM To: Mann, Heather Subject: RE: Double Tree Suites Hi Fleather, 1 can revise, but yes that is what the price would be. However, notice the tax is added at the bottom of the form, so I can exempt that as we31 with your attached form. Let me know what you would like me to do for you. No problems! ;) Carrie 9oorl Doubletree G est Suites Columbus 50 S. Front reet I Columbus, 0H 43215-4145 Phone: 614-228-4600 ext. 1951 Fax: 614-358-8228 carrie.boorC^rhilton.¢om ^ 4vww_co[umbu55uit^,dou_.b,fetree com Twitter: hfto-//trr+tter com/DoubletreeGals hW '/ldoubletreecolumbusdowntov+n, btoosnot. com,' From: Mann, Heather [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Wednesday, July 13, 2011 11:03 PM To: Carrie Boor Subject: FW: Double Tree Suites LPL 000163 i think we may be able to just pay out outright for all the static costs (room rental, moving furniture, tax) minus the variable costs which could be billed monthly (like internet). Can you please send me a revised invoice ASAP that shows what the statics costs would be? 4tr would this just be $9,e14.89 -$905.45 (estimated costs for internet), which leaves me with a difference of $8709.44? Heather N. Mann, Esq. Redistricting Director & Dep. Legal Counsel House Repubiican Caucus Ohio House of Representatives 77 South High Street, 14th Floor Columbus, Ohio 43215 (614) 466-9194 - Office (614) 719-3594 - Fax (614) 352-5819 - Cell heather mann(a7ohr.state.oh^us CONFIDeNTWLiT'f NDTlCE Tne informa8on contained 3n this e-mail is intended only for the use of the individual or entiCy to whfch it is adtlressed and it may contain inlormatlon that is prfviiegec the intended reci confideniial, attomey work Frodocl and/or exempt from disclosure under applicabfe law. If the reader of this message is not pient (or the emptoyee or agent responsfble to deliver it to the tntended recipient), you are hereby notified that any d€ssemination. distribution, or copying of this e-marE is prohlblted It you have reGei'+ed this e-mail in enor, please ncUfy the senderby return e-mail, .._._ _.....__._ . ..^._.._ .._._ .. __ _- _ ^^..._.. From : Carrie Boor [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Tuesday, July 12, 2011 11:25 AM To: Mann, Heather subject: Double Tree Suites IIi kleatber, It was a please meeting you and Mr. Di'Rossi. I left a message for you earher. Here is a sample invoice with charges listed, a direct bill application and wben you are completing this please fill out all areas, they do not accept attachxnents. Also there is a cc form for the credit card number that must match the tax exempt form, also any check that is paying for the bill needs to match the tax exempt number. At this time we cannot aecomnsodate a double room for the entire stay, utifortunately the convention group has already reserved all of them for the first week of August. We can move the king bed to the end of the wall to open up the room or we can remove and put the roll away in the room. As soon as I receive a call from housekeeping that an 01 room is available to show, I will contact you. Please let me know if you have any other questions and I look forward to working with all of you. Carrie Boorl ales Manager Doubletree G est Suites Columbus 50 S. Front S reet I Columbus, OH 43215-4145 Phone: 614-228-4600 ext. 1951 Fax: 614-358-8228 [email protected] I yvww.columbussuites,doubletree.com 7witter: http,//twittercom/lJoubfetreeCals htfp lJdoublet(eeco_mbpsd0vrntown_blo9t^Pc2 coml LPL 000164 -nnot be nsed'=o f¢r!n, dowrnen:, or atrheni;cate a co:ztraci. F{iiton and tks af*8jates accept ee This transmission is not a digiEat or eledrenic signatnre and ^ L`20rldvade 4 ropnetary 7n d Cor.f-denFaii ari5in¢ m canneC[i0n riith ihs transnrission. 6^ 2011 FQI!on From: Mann, Heather To: Grodhaus, Michael; cc: "raydirossi gmail com"; Troy 3; Lenzo, Mike; Hansen, Beth; Subject: 2-week deadline to notice apportionment board members Date: Thursday, July 14, 2011 9:07:17 AM Attachments: Reapportionment History & Template.doc Dear Michael: Ray astutely noted the constitutional deadline under the Section 11.01 - "The governor shall give [members of the apportionment board] two weeks advance notice of the date, time, and place of such meeting. " Therefore, I would suggest by weeks' end that the Governor's office send out notices to the Auditor, Secretary, Cafaro/Budish, and Batchetder/ Niehaus of the apportionment board meeting (see sample letters from pp. 16-17 of the attached document, and in your binder after the tab labeled "July-August 2001 pre-meeting documents." We'll probably want to time this with the press release as well. Thank you, Heather Mann Heather N. Mann, Esq. Redistricting Director & Dep. Legal Counsel House Republican Caucus Ohio House of Representatives 77 South High Street, 14th Floor Columbus, Ohio 43215 (614) 466-9194 - Office (614) 719-3594 - Fax (614) 352-5819 - Cell heather.manng ohrstate.oh.us CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE The information contained in this e-mail is intended only for the use of the individual or entity to which it is addressed and it may contain information that is privileged, confidential, attorney work product andlor exempt from disclosure under applicableiaw. If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient (or the employee or agent responsible to deliver it to the intended recipient), you are hereby notified that any dissemination, distribution, or copying of this e-mail is prohibited. It you have received this e-mail in error, please notify the sender by return e-mail. LPL 000166 The Ohin Hoas'e nf The Ohio Senate Repreaentatives President Tom Niehaus Speaker Hill Batchelder Ohio Statehouse 77 South High Street, 14'" Floor Columbus, Ohio 43215 Columbus, Ohio 43215 (614) 466-8082 (614) 466-8140 July 14, 2011 Mark Flanders, Director Ohio Legislative Service Commission 77 South High Street, 9`h Floor Columbus, Ohio 43215-6136 Dear Director Flanders: On June 16, 2011, the Co-Chairs of the Legislative Task Force on Redistricting, Reapportionment and Redistricting granted authority to the Chiefs of Staff for the respective Republican and DemocratCaueuses to approve payment for expenses incurred for redistricting efforts prior to December 31, 2011 in an amount not to exceed $150,000 per each pair of caucuses. Pursuant to that authority, we approve payment to Double Tree Guest Suites in the amount of $7250.00 as a down payment for attached invoice which estimates total costs of $8,464.38 from Double "1'ree Guest Suites for rental of a room for redistricting activities between July 17, 2011 and October 15, 2011. We will authorize future payment of these costs in installments upon our receipt and approval of interim invoices from the Double Tree Guest Suites. Please contact us with any questions or need of further information. Sincerely, roy Judy Chief of Sta`ff Ohio House of Representatives LPL 000167 Invoice No. Doubie Tree Suites by Hilton Cotunrbas Downtowa 50 South Front Street Cotumbus Ohio 43215 IINVOICE Misc Customer Date 7114/2011 Legislative Task Force on Redistricting c!o Mr. Ray DtRossi Name Order No. Address 77 S. High St., 14th Floor ZIP 43215 Rep Canie Booi City Cotumbus State OH FOB Phone 614-466-9294 Unit Price TOTAL Description Qty $7 ,200 . 00 $ 7 ,200.00 I Guest Room July 18-Ociober 15.2011 90 Days 48600 $ - State Tax ($7,280 X 6.75%) exempt with form or after 30 continue stay $ 0 $ 720 .00 $ - 0 City Tax (:e7,280 X 10%) exempt after 30 days continueous stay Parking @ 12.00/per day /per car $ _ tnternet charge $9.95 per day, not per connection $905 .45 $ 1 $ 50. 00 $ 50.00 1 Removal of guest room furniture $50.00 1 time charge Client Please return a copy of the invoice with Payment SubTotal $ 7.250.00 Shipping Tax Rate(s) 6.75% $ 489.38 Payment Check f0.00% $ 725.00 TOTAL 8,464.38 Comments $7250.00 totat estimated costs. C Name Mr. Di'Rossi CC # credit application to be completed '^^.^'L.'i y,1.7ti:4'' • 1"(-1' ^^F^' ^ f ^';:r(',-: . Expires 30 days of contiuous stay. The extended stay for the Legislative Task Force on Tax rate will be exempt after timret b^charged on a usage basis per Redistricting wi0 be trom Juty^^ th The gueat QOOrrn fum ^re charge is a a one at 614-228-4600 Ptease contact Canie 8oor, Sales Manager, with any questions extension 195. LPL 000168 Mann, HeaYher From_ [email protected] Sunday, .}uly 17, 2011 6:54 PM Sent: To: Mann, Heather Subject: Fte: Member Home Addresses - Need by COB Monday Heather, My home address: 2075 south State Route 123 Lebanon, OH 45036 Ron ---- "Mann wrote: > Dear Members & Staff: > > As of Sunday, July 17, E still have not received written confirmation of home addresses for the following members: > > Rep. Amstutz > Rep. Bubp > Rep.Damschroder > Rep. Goodwin > Rep. Hall > Rep. Maag j > I need this written confirmation to come directly from the member's email or on letterhead signed by the Representative. If you had already sent this to me and I mistakenly misplaced it, I apologize and must ask for a duplicate copy. ' > Thank you kindly, > Heather Mann > > - > Heather N. Mann, Esq. > Redistricting Director & Dep. Legal Counsel House Republican Caucus > Ohio House of Representatives > 77 South High Street, 14th Floor > Columbus, Ohio 43215 > (614) 466-9194 - Office > (614) 719-3594 - Fax > (614) 352-5819 - Cell > heather mann'@ohr state.oh.us > CONFIDENTIALITYNOTICE > The information contained in this e-mail is intended only for the use of the individual or entity to +h l F. - 3- add^ t"''d =•nd it may contain information that i., pr'v L- •, confidential, attorney work product and/or exempt from disclosure under applicable law. If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient herebylnotifiedaghat any responsible to deliver it to the intended recipient), you ar t dissemination, distribution, or copying of this e-ma{urns epmai^lbited. If you have received this e-mail in error, please notify the sender by e > 350 LPL 000169 From: Mann, Heather To• Lenzo, Mike; Grodhaus Michael• raVdirossi gmail.com; Clemens Laura; Troy T"Barron John"7 "Braden, E. Mark"; Subject: Revisions to Apportionment Board Rules Date: Sunday, July 17, 2011 7:54:22 PM Attachments: 2001 Apportionment Board Rules (mark-up).doc All: Attached is an electronically marked-up Word version of the apportionment board rules per our meeting on Friday. A few general notes: Consistent references: The rules were not consistent in their references to the Secretary in proper case, so I changed every reference to Secretary throughout the rules to be in proper case. Similarly, the existing rules under 011 -01 -02 state that "Apportionment Board" means blah,blah... so I consistently used the term Apportionment Board throughout. Notification deadlines: In the first rule, I used some of the previous wording to make a distinction on timelines for notice of regularly scheduled meetings, specially scheduled meetings, and public hearings (the "roadshow"). Open meetings law does not require 24-hour notice for meetings of an emergency nature, which was recognized in the existing wording of the rule, so I simply parroted the existing rule language to follow the new notification methods. Publication of plans: In the budget, they amended Sec. 107.09 to state that "[i] mmediately after the determination of each decennial apportionment for members of the general assembly the governor shall cause such apportionment to be published for four consecutive weeks or as provided in section 7.16 of the Revised Code, in three newspapers, one in Cincinnati, one in Cleveland, and one in Columbus." I've excerpted R.C. 7.16, below - basically it allows a state agency if required under statute to comply with certain public notice requirements to do the first run in its entirety in a newspaper. The second run can be in an abbreviated format and subsequent runs can be eliminated if the requirements of R.C. 7.16 are met. Therefore, I parroted the new rule language after R.C. 7.16. That will save us a few Grover Clevelands. Records Retention Schedule: We didn't quite flesh this out at our meeting, so further direction is needed. I've asked LSC to research exactly what kind of advance approval would be required by the Ohio Historical Society if we adopted a records retention schedule for the board. LPL 000170 Official email/phone/address for the Board: I've asked LSC to quickly look into providing us with a phone line, address, and email for the apportionment board. Mike, do you think the Governor's IT folks could designate a page on the Governor's website for apportionment, maybe http://qovernor.ohio.gov/ apportionment? Thanks, Heather Mann Heather N. Mann, Esq. Redistricting Director & Dep. Legal Counsel House Republican Caucus Ohio House of Representatives 77 South High Street, 14th Floor Columbus, Ohio 43215 (614) 466-9194 - Office (614) 719-3594 - Fax (614) 352-5819 - Cell [email protected] CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE The information contained in this e-mail is intended only for the use of the individual or entity to which it is addressed and it may contain information that is pdvileged, confidential, attorney work product and/or exempt from disclosure under applicable law. If the reader of this message or the employee or agent responsible to deliver it to the intended recipient), you are hereby notified that any is not the intended recipient ( dissemination, distribution, or copying of this e-mail is prohibited. If you have received this e-mail in error, please notify the sender by return e-mail. Sec. 7.16. (A) If a section of the Revised Code or an administrative rule recfuires a state agency or a political subdivision of the state to publish a notice or advertisement two or more times in a newspaper of general circulation and the section or administrative rule refers to this section, the first publication of the notice or advertisement shall be made in its entirety in a newspaper of general circulation and may be made in a preprinted insert in the newspaper, but the second publication otherwise required bv that section or administrative rule may be made in abbreviated form in a newspaper of general circulation in the state or in the political subdivision, as designated in that section or administrative rule and on the newspayer's internet web site, if the newsyaper has one. The state agency or political subdivision may eliminate any further newspaper publications required by that section or administrative rule, provided that the second, abbreviated notice or LPL 000171 advertisement meets all of the following requirements: (1) It is published in the newspaper of general circulation in which the first publication of the notice or advertisement was made and is published on that newspaper's internet web site, if the newspaper has one. (2) It includes a title, followed by a summary paragraph or statement that clearly describes the specific purpose of the notice or advertisement, and includes a statement that the notice or advertisement is posted in its entirety on the state public notice web site established under section 125.182 of the Revised Code. The notice or advertisement also may be posted on the state agency's or political subdivision's intemet web site. (3) It includes the internet addresses of the state public notice web site, and of the newspaper's and state agency's or political subdivision's internet web site if the notice or advertisement is posted on those web sites, and the name, address, telephone number, and electronic mail address of the state agency, political subdivision, or other party responsible for publication of the notice or advertisement. (B) A notice or advertisement published under this section on an internet web site shall be published in its entirety in accordance with the section of the Revised Code or the administrative rule that requires the publication. ; (C) If a state agency or political subdivision does not operate and maintain, or ceases to operate and maintain, an internet web site, and if the state public notice web site established under section 125.182 of the Revised Code is not operational the state agency or political subdivision shall not publish a notice or advertisement under this section but instead shall comply with the publication requirements of the section of the Revised Code or the administrative rule that refers to this section. LPL 000172 Deleted: 2001 al S APPORTIONMENT BOARU RULES Deleted: an Deleted: state of Ohio apportioning person ^I Deleted: Writing to the Secretary of Apporlioning ' Persons,e/oTheOhioLegislativeRedistriotjngTask 11-01-01 Rule to Provide for Notification of MeetinE Force, the Stzte House, Columbus Ohio 43215. Deleted: Formatted: Indent: LeR: 72 p4 N. bulle or numbering Certification Formatted: Undedine Deleted:l3-ol LPL 000173 Date Promulgated under: Ch. I 1 I.15 Statutory authority: Ohio Constitution, Art. XI, Sec. I Rule Amplifies: Sec. 121.22 Prior effective dates: 314/76, 9/7/91. 3/13101 LPL 000174 011-01-02 "AnUortionment Board" Defined The term "Apportionment Board" is adopted for use in this chapter to designate the five persons directed by the Constitution of the State of Ohio, Article XI, Section 1, to establish the boundaries of House of Representatives and Senate districts in the federal decennial census 20^ Such persons, collectively,. shall be referred to imthis chapter as "Members" and, individually, as "Member." The rules stated herein, as supplemented by 2obert's Rutes ef Qrder, shall be the rulesof procedure of the Apportionment Board. Certificatio 8-3-01 Date promulgated under: Ch. I 11.15 Statutory authority: Ohio Constitution, Art. XI, Sec. 1 Ru1e Amplifies: Ohio Constitution, Art: XI, Sec. I Prior effective dates: 9/7/91, ,=_8i1 l01 LPL 000175 011-01-03 OpenMeetines All meetings and public hearings of the; Ot] Apportionment Board sball be held in accordance with the "Sunshine Law," section 121.22 of the Revised Code, and pursuant to rule 01 I 01-0 of the Administrative Code, as amended. Certification 8-3-01 Date Promulgated under: Ch. 111.15 Statutory authority: Ohio Constitution, Art. XI, Sec. I Rule Amplifies: Ohio Constitution, Art. XI, Sec. I Prior effective dates: 9/7/91- 8/13/01 LPL 000176 011-01-04 Officers' ParticipationofMembers' Minutes The Apportionment Board shall, by majority vote, elect a Chair and a Vice Chair. The Board shall also elect, by majority vote, a Secretary of the Board, who does not have to be a Member. The Vice Chair shall assume the duties of the Cbair when the Chair is unable to attend the meeting_ Each Member shall be entitled to participate in all voting and debates, regardless of position held on the Apportionment Board. Minutes of each meeting of the Appottionment Board shall be maintained by a court reporter chosen by Ueleted:4tedehmeeo y, of the Board by majority vote ,tcl minutesrshall be circulated among the members and adopted by uotud the c Boa=B. Upon any Member's request, a transcript shall be majority upon Deleted:ofthcprevfou. eetmg p comPleot bt on a nd verification. Effective: 8-1-t^_1.' Promulgated under:. Ch. 111-15 Statutory authority: Ohio Constitution, Art XI, Sec. I Rule Amplifies: Ohio Constitution, Art. XI, Sec. I Prioreffectivedates:9f7/91 8/li; l LPL 000177 011-01-05 Calline of Meetines After the initial meeting of the Apportionment Board, at which the Board is convened, a meeting of the Apportionment Board may be called upon twenty-four hours notice. Such call and notice to each member of the Apportionment Board shall be issued by the Chair, or may bc dispensed with if a motion to recess the meeting designates a time certain for continuation of the meeting. However, a meeting may be called by the Chair, upon proper notice, prior to a previously designed meeting, should the Qhair deem it necessary. Certification 8-3-01 Date Promulgated under: Ch. 1 I 1.15 Statutory authority: Ohio Conslitution, Art. Xl, Sec. I Rule Amplifies: Ohio Constitution, Art. XI, Sec. I Prior effective dates: 9/7/91. Sr13/01 LPL 000178 011-01-06 uorum p¢teted: mzjonry of the qu empowered lo 1 A majority of thefive Members of the Apportionment Board constitutes a quorum. A;majority of the act for the Board, pmvided h r, Ihal a Board is required for an> officfal act:ons of th ° Bnard inctudinc but not linited tnthe adoption of a plan of apportionment All questions not committed by this chapter to the Chair's discretion, and all motions before the Apportionment Board shall be deterrnined by majority vote. Members of the Apportionment Board or their designees may, from time to time, conduct public hearings referred to in rule 011-01-08 of the Administrative Code absente a quorum of members. I Effective:8-t; 1 1 Certification 8-3-Ot Date Promulgated underi Ch. 111.15 Statutory authority: Ohio Constitution, Art. XI, Sec. I Rule Amplifies: Ohio Constitution, Art. Xl, Sec. 1 Prior effective dates: 9!7/91 8/13€01 LPL 000179 Deleted:oll-01-09 Coosnha6onwflhConneel I .- dOtheAdvaors¶ Members of Ihe Apportionmevt Board may consnlt Effective: 8-13-01 with Ihei...... cfive legal eonnsel and olher, advlsors for a period nnt exceeding ten minmes and notto ceed thrce sueh wnsaltations por nreeting ofthc Board. However, Ihe chair of (he Appnrtionment Board may consutt as oRen os the ehair daems Certification cessory wiN any legat eonnsel of athu advlsors regardinS the mles and prucedmes. 8-3-01 Date Promulgated under: Ch. 111.15 Statutory authority: Ohio Constitution, Art. XI, Sec_ I Rule Amplifies: Ohio Constitution, Art. XI, Sec. 1 Prior effective dates: 9/7/91 81 111/01_ LPL 000180 Deletetl:8 011-01-07 Public Hearin¢s- The Apportionment Board shall direct the Secretary of the Board to organize a series of public hearings in at least five locations around the State of Ohio for the Board Members or their designees to receive public comment and input on the apportionment process. The Secretary of the Board shall notify the Members of the Apportionment Board or their designees of the time, date, and location of eacb public hearing as soon a possible and in no event less than twenty-four houts prior to each public hearing. irE'Llescribd b The Secretary of the Board shall pror rd< noiicCDf the public hearings i^the 011-O1 0 k not lessthan twenry-four hours prior to the public alnig_ raphs B or (731! 3 of rul hearings. The Secretary of the Board shall preside over these public hearings. Members of the Apportionment Board need not be present at these public hearings. Each Membet of the Apportionment Board may designate an individual(s) to represent the Member at any or all of these public hearings. Any individual a Member ofihe Board shall have no voting rights. No official business or so designatedto represent action of the Apportionment Board, other than the receiving of public comment and input, shall take place at the public hearings referred to in this rule. Effective: 5-14_71 Certification 8-3-01 Date Promulgated under: Ch. 111.15 Statutory authority: Ohio Constitution, Art. Xl, Sec. I Rule AmpliSes: Ohio Constitution, Art. XI, Sec. 1 Prior effective dates; 9/7/91 8 13/01 LPL 000181 :..:LD!Ieted: 9 ^ 011-O1-0^, Al?nortionment Plans Any person or organization may submit for the consideration of the Apportionment Board a detailed plan for the apportionment of the members of the Ohio General Assembly. Apportionment plans submitted for consideration should be complete for the entire state, with legal definitions and ^°isual rer°-entations of the proposed boundaries. Partial apportionment plans which propose the minority districts need not be complete for the entire State, but should include legal definitions of the boundaries of adjacent districts. Deleted:s Plans submitted to the Board for consideration shall be submitted to the sjecretary of the Spard at the address specified in gile 011-0-01 of the AdmlDtstrative Code b12 N P:tl. on Se tember Deleted: b . In addition to the required paper Deleted: R 22 201I . Ten paper copies of each plan shall be submitted stored medium such as a I)VI9R(3M Disk or copies , plans may be submitted ona n electrolilcallv of the Deleted: electronically via- I tr -c mail to an c Slash drive with an indieation of tbe format it is in to the address specified in rule 011 1-01 mail add t b aunom-d by th Scireary or on Administrative Code. The Secretary of the Board shall deliver promptly, but in no event later aCD-ROMD kwilhan I than '^f.M., September 212011, to the Members of the Apportionment Board one copy of Deleted: 12:00 blic at a each plan submitted and shall retain the remaining copies for reviewby the pu Dele[ed: ...... placeplaces or website designated by the Board. Deleted: 5 Deleted: 01 Effective: 8 J4-71 Deleted: or Deleted: 13-01 Certification 8-3-01 Date Promulgated under: Ch. 1 11. 15 Statutory authority: Ohio Constitution, Art. XI, Sec. I Rule Amplifies: Ohio Constitution, Art. XI, Sec. I Prior effective dates: 917/91 k&'13.O1 LPL 000182 ^ Ol I-01-O9 Consideration of Auoorhonment Plans' Adontion of Plan ll reconvene during the week of September 24, 2001, to consider The Apportionment Board sha the various plans submitted to the Board and shall meet on or before October 1, 2001, to adopt an appropriate plan for the apportionment of the members of the Ohio General Assembly. During the meeting or meetings of the Board the week of September 24, 2001, a sponsor of a play may personally or through a representative present the substance of their plan to the Members of the Apportionment Board for a period not to exceed ten minutes, unless extended by a majority of the Board. The public may offer testimony or conunent not to exceed five minutes on any apportionment plan before the Board, unless extended by a majority of the Board. The Chair of the Apportionment Board may limit testimony or comment on plans before the Board as the Chair deems necessary. Any person wishing to testify on a given plan must provide notice to the Chair or the Secretary of the Board prior to the meeting scheduled to consider the various plans submitted. Members of the Apportionment Board may ask questions of those persons testifying on the various apportionment plans before the Board during the meeting scheduled to consider those plans. Members of the Board may request testimony from experts during this meeting. Deleted: Only those persons sponsming an Onlp Memb'rs of the Anpottiomm nt Board may offer amemdments to an apnortionment PIan. apportionmeot plao may otF amendments m satd plan fur the coasiderztion ofthe Members of ihe Effective: 8-13-01 Apportianment Bonrd ¶ The Chair uf the Apportinnment Boarel may oiier mendmevtx on behalf of those pedons sponsoring apportioument pfans who are not memhers of the Apportionment BoudI Certification 8-3-01 Date Promulgated under: Ch. 111.15 Stamtory authority: Ohio Constitution, Art. XI, Sec. I Rule Amplifies: Ohio Constitution, Art . XI, Sec. I Prior effective dates: 9/7/91 LPL 000183 011-01-IQ Publication of Anoorhonment Plan When the apportionment plan is determined and adopted by a majority vote of the hall arran e for publication of such apportionment plan no Apportionment Board, the Govemor s October 5, 2011.F'rusuant t+? See % 1& of Use Ohio Revised t`ode the first nubhcatton of later than e in Clevetand mze uch apnodionment nlan 'hall be mad m ttc entirct' in tIn'ec n uSaaoer on n ep1it ted insert Thc sec-ou^9 in Cineinnati. cuid one in Cotumbns and mav be made tn a t Rub7ication shal] be made in abbreviated fonn in th-se nawsoaners pmsuant to See 7.16 i`Io nrther newsnaner nnblications are reauired iY the sec-ond, abbreviatact notiee meets tlze f r rementc of Sec 7 16.. Effective: 8-13-01 Certification 8-3-01 Date Promulgated under: Ch. 111.15 Statutory authority: Ohio Constitution, Art. XI, Sec. I Rule Amplifies: Ohio Constitution, Art. XI, Sec. I Prior effective dates: 917/91 LPL 000184 I 011-01-11 Reconvening the Annortionment Board Should further action be necessary pursuant to Article XI, Seetion 13 of the Constitution of the State of Ohio, this Apportionment Board shall reconvene at the request of the Governor subject to this chapter. Effective: 8-13-01 Certification 8-3-01 Date Promulgated under: Ch. I 11.15 Statutory authority: Ohio Constitution, Art. XI, Sec. I Rule Amplifies: Ohio Constitution, Art. XI, Sec. I Prior effective dates: 9/7/91 011-0I-12 Records Retentio Schedtde_, Formattetl: Font: Italic To be furtber deterrnined EPfective 8-13-01 CesYification 8-id-11 Date pioiml ated under Ch. ll L15 Statutorv autht ritv Ohio Constitntion Art. XL Se' Kute Am lihes' Ohio Consntuhon-:'1rt Xl. Scc_ I. Prior effeetlve detcs: none LPL 000185 ,.,, ...,.._. __ Any representative of the news media may obtain notice of all meetings of the apportioning persons by requesting in writing that such notice be provided. Such notice will be given, however, to one representative of any particular publication or radio or television station. A request of such notification sball be addressed to: Secretary to the Board of Apportioning Persons, c!o The Ohio Senate, Legislative Redistricting Task Force, The State House, Columbus, Ohio 43215. The request shall provide the name of the individual media representative to be contacted, the media representatives' mailing or e-mail address, and a maximum of two telephone numbers where the media representative can be reached. The Secretary shall maintain a list of all representatives of the news media who have requested notice of the meetings pursuant to this Chapter. In the event of a special meeting not of an emergency nature, the secretary shall notify all media representatives on the list of such meeting by doing at least one of the following: Sending written notice, which must be mailed no later than four days prior to the date of the special meeting; Notifying such representatives by telephone no later than twenty-four hours prior to the day of the special meeting; such telephone notice shall be complete if a message has been left for the representative, or, if after reasonable effort, the secretary has been unable to provide such telephone notice. Informing such representative personally no later than twenty-four hours prior to the special meeting. Notifying such representative by electronic mail, no later than twenty-four hours prior to the special meeting. In the event of a special meeting of an emergency nature, the secretary shall notify all media representatives on the list of such meeting by providing either the notice described in paragraph (B)(4)(b) or (B)(4)(d) of this rule or notifying the clerk of the state house press room. In such event, however, the notice need not be given twenty-four hours prior to the meeting, but shall be given immediately upon the scheduling of such meeting. In giving the notices required by paragraph (B)(4) of this rale, the secretary may rely on assistance provided by any member of the secretary's staff, and any such notice is complete if given by such member in the manner provided in paragraph (B)(4) of this rule. heather.mann 7(17(30116;13c60PM Pa9e 1:'Ltl^ele>a Any person may receive notice of all meetings of the apportioning process. The secretary shall maintain a list of all such persons who have requested suchRletQA®dW. In order to receive notification by electronic mail, such person must, in writing, provide the secretary with an e-mail address. In order to receive than seven calendar days prior to the day of the meeting and such notice of special meetings shall be mailed as soon as possible prior to the meeting. The secretary may require persons requesting notice under paragraph (B)(B) of this rule to select from among categories of the public business of apportioning persons, which categories have been previously established by the secretary. LPL 000187 Mann, Heather Dave Hall [[email protected]] From: Monday, July 18, 2011 8:10 AM Sent: Mann, Heather Ta: Re: Member Home Addresses - Need by COB Monday Subject: Hi Heather, My address is 358 East ]ackson St. Millersburg, Ohio 44654. Rep. Hall Original Message ----- From: "Mann, Heather" Dear Members & Staff: As of Sunday, July 17, I still have not received written confirmation of home addresses for the following members: Rep. Amstutz Rep. Bubp Rep. Damschroder Rep. Goodwin Rep. Hall Rep. Maag i need this written confirmation to come directly from the member's email or on letterhead signed by the Representative. Tf you had already sent this to me and I mistakenly misplaced it, I apologize and must ask for a duplicate copy. Thank you kindly, Heather Mann Heather N. Mann, Esq. Redistricting Director & Dep. Legal Counsel House Republican Caucus ohio t3ouse of Representatives 77 South High Street, 14th Floor Columbus, Ohio 43215 (614) 466-9194 - office 351 LPL 000188 (614) 719-3594 - Fax (614) 352-5819 - Cell heather mannohr state oh us CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE The information contained in this e-mail is intended only for the use of the individual or entity to which it is addressed and it may contain information that is privlaw. If confidential, attorney work product andlor exempt from disclosure under applicable the reader of this message is not the intended recipient (or the employee or agent responsible to deliver it to the intended recipient), you are hereby notified that any dissemination, distribution, or copying of this e-mail is prohibited. If you have received this e-mail in error, please notify the sender by return e-mail. 352 LPL 000189 Heather Mann From: Ray DiRossi [[email protected] Sent: Sunday, July 24, 2011 5:17 PM -to, Heather N. Mann - gmail Attachments: Dear John.docx Categories: Red Category LPL 000190 Dear John: Need updated data - Wapakoneta issue Need ward level data We want these (6) the.^rnes at these (5) levels (voting district, ward, county place, county subdivision and county) • Unified political index 0 08 presidential index • Macro AA pop- currently called "default VA AA pop" • Micro AA pop - currently called "sensitive VA AA pop" • Micro Hispanic . district fill theme We need 1 want to be able to Toggle or Flash between these (6) themes on the redistricting toolbox Why when we are looking at the county subdivision layer can we not see all incorporated areas and all county subdivisions - example in Miami County youcan only see the city of Piqua when looking at county subdivisions. However when we shift to the census place layer, we can see all of those cities, but now we can't select the townships. What Maptitude fimetion do we use to suggest alterations to districts Need HD SD and CD member and people of interests geocoded Wby are VA AA and VA HS different on the 3 maps (current I-IDs SDs and CDs) then census data - formula error? Populations and deviations are 100% accurate but VA AA and VA HS are different Updates to the Matrix/Spreadsheet - for alI CD HDs and SD Delete existing political data and add the "Unified potitical index" Also add Obama / McCain index on matrix How do I import dist:icts from another map intc a nray : afn wori<.ing ou`.% i.e. need to be able to assign areas by districts I have drawn portions of a VTD wben they are part of the same VTD How do I assign non-contiguous LPL 000191 How do I do a ret:alculation of the matrix after a long drawing session What is in the BAK. files? Ideallayaut: See "Exercise for Dear John" map in GA maps LPL 000192 Heather Mann From: Heather Mann [[email protected]] Sent; Sunday, July 24, 2011 4:08 PM To: 'Ray DiRossi Attachments: Dear John.docx Categories: Red Category Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, Ohio 43206 (614) 352-5819 heathernmann (a1gma ii.com LPL 000193 Dear .lohn: Need ward level data We want these themes at all layer levels (voting district, ward, county subdivision, county) • Unified political index, 08 presidentiat index, macro and micro AA pop, micro Hispanic, district fill theme • 1'he AA POP Theme is defaulting to the County subdivision level - we need it defaulting to the voting district or ward level. Actually we need the ability to toggle between "VA AA-VTD" and also "VA AA-Ward" and we have created I VA AA pop thc'mes - default VA AA pop and Sensitive VA pop • The saine thing for political theme - it is defaulting to the County subdivision level - we need it defaulting to the voting district or ward level - not county subdivision. Again - we need the ability to toggle between "Unified politieal-VTD" and also and "Unified Political-Ward" • Also on political - We need a specific theme - same break points forjust 08 Presidential ObamalMcCain •"08 Presidential-VTD" and also and "08 Presidential-Ward" flash district fill also? - this would be very helpful • Are we able to toggle / Why when we are looking at the county subdivision layer can we not see all incorporated areas, all county subdivisions - example in Miami County you can only see the city of Piqua. However, when we shift to the census place layer, we can see all of those cities, but now we can't select the townships. Why in many of the maps does the selection layer in the redistricting toolbox have several more layers in the drop down menu - like VTDs, census block etc. but in the selection layer on the main toolbar - there are only county, county subdivision, water and districts - does this matter - we definitely need ward layer - is Precinct layer the exact same as VTD Need updated data - Wapakoneta issue Wbat Maptitude function do we use suggest alterations Need HD SD and CD legislators geocoded Why are VA AA and VA HS different on the 3 maps (current HDs SDs and Cds) then census data - formula error? Populations and deviations are I00% accurate but VA AA and VA HS are different LPL 000194 "Unified political index" on tnatrix as a percentage and Obama % McCain index on matrix for all CDHSandSD How do I. import districts from another xnap into ainap I am working on? Need to be able to assign areas by districts I bave drawn How do I assign non-contigaous portions of a VTD when they are part of the same VTD How do I do a recalculation of the matrix after a long drawing session How do I check for contiguity of a district that I have drawn What is in the BAK files? Ideal layout: We want these themes available for toggle at all level LPL 000195 Heather Mann From: Heather Mann [[email protected]} Sent: Sunday, July 24, 2011 5:33 PM To: 'Ray DiRossi' Subject: Master Redistricting Database.xtsx Attachments: Master Redistricting Database.xlsx Categories: Red Category LPL 000196 Shea, Christopher From: Heather Mann [[email protected] Sent: Sunday, July 24,2011 12:53 PM To: Pelger, Halle; Mary Amos Augsburger Cc: Troy J: ; Michael Grodhaus; 'Lenzo, Mike';'Ray DiRossi' Subject: Documents for Tomorrow's meeting 2011-08-04 Apportionment Board Agenda.docx; 2011-08-04 Apportionment Board Meeting Attachments: Script.doox; 2011 Apportionment Board Proposed Regional Hearing Schedule.docx; 2011 Apportionment Board Rules (mark-up).doc; Apportionment Board Schedule - Historical & Proposed.docx Dear Mary and Halle: Please find attached the following documents in preparation for tomorrov/s staff meeting. We will discuss, in turn, the proposed general schedule, the rules, and the script. • Draft August 0 Agenda • Draft August 4t' Script • Draft Regional Hearing Script • Draft Apportionment Board Rules • Comparison chart of past schedules Sincerely, Heather Mann .«+ Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, Ohio 43206 (614) 352-5819 he athernma nn kaem ail.co m SOS-0074 LPL 000197 nn, Heather From: Mann, Heather Sent: Monday, Jufy 25, 2011 11:29 AM To: Michael Grodhaus Subject: Re: Apportionment Board Schedule Attachments: image002.jpa Mike, we can discuss in advance or at the meeting, but we are going to build in maximum flexibility leading up to the 1 st and even the 4th. Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBe From: "Grodhaus, Michael" Heather, I reviewed your revised schedule. You have proposed moving the meeting to hear testimony on the plans from Friday, September 23rd ta Monday, September 2bt°. That works for the Governor. However, the only other day that week that the Governor cauld meet with the rest of the Board to adopt the final plan is Wednesday, September 28"'. ,J D. Michael Grodhaus Chief Counsek Officeof Ohio Governortohn R. Kasich (514) 644-0825 I [email protected] www Kovernor.ohio.zov pubficly avoilable to anyone who requests it. This message and any response to k moy constitute a Fublic record and thus may be LPL 000198 {4lann, Heather Rench, Karrie [[email protected]] From: Monday, Juty 25, 2011 2:56 PM Sent: To: Mann, Heather Subject: De-brief for Beth image001.png;image002.jpg Attachments: Heather- I just spoke with Beth re: the 3 pm redistricting meeting. She asked if you could send any materials that you might have handed out at your 1 pm meeting to me. She would then talk with Mike G. and if she had more questions would contact you directly. Thanks€ Karrie Rench Assistant to the Chief of staf! Offce of Ohio 6overnor John R. Kasich 624-644-0941 KarrPeRench(rDgavernor.ohio,;go_v www.eovemor ohio.eov to anyone who requests R. constitute a public record and thus may be publicly available ih7s message and any response to 8 may 409 LPL 000199 Heather Mann From: Heather Mann ([email protected]) Sent: Wednesday, July 27, 2011 8:51 PM -to. 'Lenzo, Mike';'TroyJ'; Michael Grodhaus ([email protected]);'Ray DiRossi' We need to decide how soon to share the apportionment board rules with the Democrats. I suggest Monday. ^.: Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, Ohio 43206 (614) 352-5819 [email protected] LPL 000200 From: Grodhaus, Michael To: Barron , John; Heather Mann; Lenzo Mike; Ray DiRossi; Tro J.• cc: Griffin, Lisa; Subject: Re: sharing schedule of public hearings Date: Thursday, July 28, 2011 1:48:06 PM Same. Ok with that. Sent from my Verizon Wireless 4GLTE smartphone -- Reply message ----- From: "Barron, John" We're ok with it. From: Heather Mann [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Thursday, July 28, 2011 12:06 PM To: 'Lenzo, Mike'; 'Ray DiRossi'; Barron, John; 'Troy J.'; Michael Grodhaus Cc: 'Griffin, Lisa' Subject: sharing schedule of public hearings Lisa Griffin, who is setting up the apportionment board meetings, will be needing to set up hotel accommodations for the members of the apportionment board and their staff. This will require the issuance of letters from the Co-Chairs (Cafaro and Batchelder) as proof of commitment. Are you all okay if we share the schedule of public hearings with them at this juncture so that they know why we need to ask for overnight coverage on certain days? Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, Ohio 43206 LPL 000201 i-4eatkter Mann From: Heather Mann [heathemmann ar'7gmail.com] Sent: Thursday, July 28, 2011 1:26 PM^?govemor.ohio.gov);i; 'Ray DiRoss To; 'Lenzo, Mike'; Michael Grodhaus {Michaei.Grodhaus, 'jbarron@senate. state.oh.us' Subject: Setting up official contact information Attachments: 2011-07-26 Grodhaus ERF Authorization Letter for Mann.pdf; 2011-07-27 ECF PEN Selection Form.pdf All: I wanted to share with you where I was in setting up the official points of contact for the Apportionment Board. OfBcial address: Ohio Apportionment Board c/o Legislative Task Force on Redistricting 77 South High Street Columbus, OH 43215. Mailbox is in the basement of the Riffe. Lenzo, Barron, Mann, DiRossi are the designated persons, will add Governor's office if you like. 644-1114 (VM password isumt some point we will want to delegate to one person the Official phone number: authority to check messages. bttg:/Iredistricting.state.oh.us.....i and [email protected]. US still needs to confirm that we will Official email/domain: have use of this domain. Mike G, if we actually get this domain, we may be able to use this instead of the Governor's website for the official posting of meeting dates/times. Form that were Electronic Rules Filing: Attached are the Electronic Rules Filing Authorizationt E us can log inlandi actually file the rules submitted to set up our ECF access. Username:^, Password:^ny after the meeting with that information). I'm had some technology hurdles getting the rules prepared, but they will be uploaded shortly and I witk resend them to you all, plus the Auditor and Secretary's ofFce. Thoughts/suggestions/co nce m s? -Heather Mann ^.. Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Cotumbus, Ohio 43206 (614j 352-5819 he athernman njj^gm a i ico m 1 LPL 000202 Heather Mann From: Heather Mann ([email protected]] Sent: Thursday, July 28, 2011 9:54 AM To: 'jamesrlloyd cGdyahoo.com' Cc: '[email protected]';'Lenzo, Mike';'Ray DiRossi'; Michael Grodhaus ( [email protected]) Subject: Task Force address & authorized persons Dear lames: Here are the persons who are authorized to pick up mail for the Legislative Task Force on Redistricting mail slot in the basement of the Riffe. John Barron, Ohio Senate Mike Lenzo, Ohio House Heather Mann Ray DiRossi The established address is : Ohio Apportionment Board cJo Legislative Task Force on Redistricting 77 South High Street Columbus, Ohio 43215 Thank you kindly, Heather Mann Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, Ohio 43206 '(614) 352-5819 heathernmann(@gmail.com LPL 000203 From: Heather Mann To: ibarron@senate state oh us' "Lenzo, Mike"; "Troy J."; "Ray DiRossi' ; Hansen Beth; Grodhaus, Michael; Brey Diane; [email protected]; Mary Amos Auasburger7 Matthew T. Schuler; Subject: Revised Documents for Apportionment Board Meeting Date: Friday, July 29, 2011 10:07:12 AM Attachments: 2011-08-04 Apportionment Board Meeting Script.docx 011$0-01-07-Rule-N.pdf 011$0-1-01-Rule-AM.pdf O11$0-1-02-Rute-AM.pdf 011$0-1-03-RuIe-AM.pdf 011$0-1-04-Rule-AM.pdf 011$0-1-05-Rule-AM.pdf 011$0-1-06-Rule-AM.pdf 011$0-1-07-Rule-AM.pdf 011$0-1-08-Rule-AM.pdf 011$0-1-09-Rule-AM.pdf 011$0-1-10-Rule-AM.pdf Oli$0-1-11-Rule-AM.pdf OS 1$0-1-12-Rule-AM.pd 011-0-1-01-Rule-AM.pdf 2011-08-04 Apportionment Board Agenda.docx Please find attached per our meeting last week: • A set of the revised rules in the format in which they would be distributed next week and electronically filed through ECF. The effective date of the revised rules would be 8/14/11, ten days after the Apportionment Board meeting. . A revised Apportionment Board Meeting Script • A revised Agenda Note that "new" Rule -07 replaces the rescinded Rule -07. LSC advised me that this is preferable to renumbering all the subsequent rules. Mike Lenzo researched the records retention issue and noted the need to adopt a records retention schedule, or else all records of the Apportionment Board must be maintained in perpetuity. Therefore, the new Rule -07 adopts the DAS default records retention schedules (see http://apps.das.ohio.gov/rims/GeneraI/Genera1.asp . I have not uploaded these to ECF pending any further changes from the group. Please advise by Monday if you have further changes. LPL 000204 Sincerely, Heather Mann Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, Ohio 43206 (614) 352-5819 heathernmannC gmail.com LPL 000205 HeatherlNann From: Ray DiRossi [[email protected]] Sent: Sunday, July 31, 2011 1:57 PM To: Benjamin Yoho Cc: Troy J.; Heather N. Mann - gmail; Michael Lenzo Subject: House Seats bylndex.... Attachments: House - seats by index.xis Ben Here is a docaiment that I am using and thought you and others may want Its all 99 house seats ranked according to our unified index on their current districts ironically there are 59 seats on the unified index that are 50% or better for republicans We hold 6 of their seats that are indexed below 50% They hold 6 of our 50%+ seats at least they do now...... Ray LPL 000206 -73% 74.06%_ , ^ . ..._. 72 63%I 1.6896, 0 69.01%' 6719% 4.60% 1.84% 68.23%1 64 96°101 1.38%^ 1-41% 64.28%! 2.86% 1.88% 67.89%"_ _._.. ___ _- , 66 00% 6192%` 7_97%1 4 01% 65 33% 67 . 110 0.35% 0.85% 1.91% 0.96% 65.00%i 62.31% 2 64 88% 64 23%; 1.67% 0.92% 64.54Yo; 59.2801o! 3,24%i 1 .68% 1.15% 2 54% 64 23%' 6183%^ --- 64 16%, 64 96%, 1.56%0.94% 63 42%; 63.60%I 0.60% 0.59%_.- 63.15% 61.79%T 0.4694, 3.74% F ^--- 61.66% 60.94%! 3.30% 1.26% 61.40%I 60 23%; 0.81% 0.88% 61.34%; 59.44% 0.57% 0.78% I 61.0157.90%i 3.42% 1.85% 60.89°6i, 59.57%i 11.07%, 1.92% 60.84% 60.40% 4.25%, 1.09% 60 84%' 58.58% . 8784%- 4.38% - - - ^ 60.53%57.43% 8.68%1 1,95% _1 _ _^ ------__ 6015% 59.08%; 7.66%' 1.27% 60 149oj 57 79%4 5.33%1 1.369f& ca Ina! i .--SF. ^PR9l,: 146%! 1.28% ---...... ,_ . 59.13%: 59.76%n' 1.58°% 0.70% 59.03%, 5375%i 4.18% 4.06% _------58.69Y°; 55.61%1 3.73% 1.18% 58 51%; 55.39%I 4.96% 1.86% -.--- 58.33%: 55.97%; 2.24% 0.97% - - - _ SR 7S%' 5141%I 8.20% 1.71% 57.95W 52.91%I 22.15%,; 1.4170 57 16%; 53 59%; 1,01%' 5.33% - -^ _.... _ _-- 4.04%' 1.53% 56.57%,-._.- 54.55% _ 55 89%! 53 09% 1.22%1 1.29% 55 71% 56.36%' 6.32%f 0.98% 55.49% 55 35% 0.89%1. C f o=.. 54.36% . 54.15%; 10.93%I 1.21Y'o 1.27% 0.63% 54 22%1. 59 05%;: __.. 53 93% 47 494oj 18.12% 2.49% 53163%j 5232°/d 1.09% 0.81% --- - 53.42%, 48.36%; 1.41% 2.21% sa ^n°^ 5198%!, 2.95% , 0.54% LPL 000207 -- 3.98% 2.36% 52.94%!11 49 21%' 4 45%'.., 1.33% 52.$8%.._-...._- 49 51% 52.61% 49.200 ( 2 39% 1.79% .._,.._ . ...._.... _...... a , o 3.15 52.58%i 49 76%: 3 08h 0 5 . 2 .0547 74% 2.40% L. 51.84%! 48.57%1 2 42% 1-13% 4935%; 2.68%", 3.93% _..51.48% I 1 51 Zl%; 49 14%^.. _- 3 15%i 103% 51199'a; 45.60%'1 2.51%I 3.62% _ 3:97°/a - , 50.96%I 44 74%% 24.85%, 28 !Connie Pillich -D- (2016 _-_- 50 81%t 43.97%y 6.04% 3.59% 22 ilohn Carney D- (2016) _. - rn K5%I 47.10%!.. 3.97% 2 .47% 57 t IMatLundy -D- (2014) 50.54% 50.50%. 2.51%-_- 1.35% 50.47%' 47 67%' _ 6.27% 1.22% 50.44%( 47.13%: 8.36% 1.06°^ 50 32%105%II 53 . Z16%j 0.51% 23%'1 42:94%I 6.50b ; y.^7io - 49.59%' 49.75%1 1.45% 0.73% 48.38% 52.78% 2.419/6116% 2 61% 48.27% 46.82% 10_54%i 4814%. 4839% 2.53`a 0.81% 47.95%, 41.21%: 19.33% 3.68 % 47.62%1 39.69%; 20.68%^ 5.92% T 47.46% 53.220 ; 2.62% 0_74°rG 46.46% 43.28%._ 5.73%' 2.860 80 Dennis Murray -D_ (2016) 123% 45.68°ibi 42.61% 4.68% Clyde -D- (2018) 68 Kathleen 44 81%J 42.90%j 3.54%I 2 38% ^ _ 44 26°a 36 .22%'! 33.17%-_ , 3.10% 31 ' Denise Driehaus . D_ (2016) ; 43.79%; 42.25%i 2.25%' 3.24% 15 Tim DeGeeter-D-(2012) _ -_ _ ^------43 25%; 43,55% 2.37% 100% 92 Debbie Ph llips^ D- (2016)- - i --- 42 27%ti 39.02%` 12.04%^ 4.31% 25 !Michael Stmziano -D- (2018) _ , ---- 40.52% 46.61%. 4.14% . ° 95 Lou 6enti4e -D- (2018) _- -- ` _ 3874%1 42.33%i 3.77%1.89% 59 Ron Gerberry D- (2016) ---- 38.03%; 33.80%1 6.104.42% tt Szotlosi -D- (2014) ^_...._49 Ma 23 4n'/o 9.91% 7.65% 14 Mike Foley D (2014) ^--- 36 93%; 35.054o, 11.78%" 1.19% 45 I Zachlkih Miovc- D (2018) -- - - I - 3641% 32.619'0, 1b.63% 1.u70 52 Stephen Slesnick -D- (2016) (--- ^ _. ^- - 35.68%1 37.60%, 11.88% Z.48% 64 ,Tom Letson D- (2014) - -- ° _ _- _ 3523%I. 29.12% 15.87°l0 8.26% 47 '_Teresa Ledor-D-(2018)_ 32.48% 36.75%, 3.98%_ 0.99% 65 5ean O'Brien D_(2018) - -_ , 32.47%, 28.03% 43.21% 1.58% 40 Roland winburn -D- (2016) LPL 000208 .17%; 26.75% 13.769/614.15% 56 Dan Ramos -D- (2018) , 31.16%; 25.03%^ 13.46'% lU _Ud7'o 13 Nickie Antonio D- (2018) _.---- , --- 28 41%j 22.56%a 47.92% _-...._ _; 33 Ahcia Reece -D (2018) 26.92% 21.18%! 48.25% 1.40% 7 KennyYuko D (2012) 25.39%{ 18.14%{: 42.79,% 2A3% 32 Dale Mallory D- (2014) 23.40%1 18.73% 44.31% 2.85% 39 clayton Luckie D-(2014) 22.11°/n 16.99%; 42.38'Yol t.jt70 44 Vernon Sykes -D- (2014) 16R8%' 50.37%' 4.05% 26 Tracy Maxwell Heard D(2014) 21.86% + - 20.27% 14.45%i 47.77% 4_44%- ----48 Michael Ashford -0- (2018) 14.45%; 5 3.1s170 4.6z-ro 11 5andra Wdfiams -D-(2014) 19 62%; 19.54%i 13.97%: 56.51%^ 1.54% _ 8,ArmondBudish-D-(2014) .._- ,.....__ ; 19193o f 20.04 % 31.48%' 7_46% 60 Robert Hagan -D- (2014) L 18 79%i 13 63%! 46.23% 12.80% 10 ,Bill Patmon -D- (2018) 18 77% 14 21% 40.52% 340% 27 carlton Weddington -D- (2016) ..- _.....__ F ..___... 17.79% 12.56%i 52.82%1 1.65% 9 !Barbara Boyd-D-(2014) _ _ _..._-- 15.56%I 10.85% 68.87%1 1.13% 12 john Barnes -D- (2018) LPL 000209 Heather Mann Mann [[email protected]( From: Heather Sent: Sunday, July 31, 2011 10:21 PM To: 'Benyamin Yoho' Attachments: house 4 chb.xlsx This is what should be updated with candidates, opponents, and persons of interest. ^+> Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, Ohio 43206 (614)352-5819 heathernmann ^maiLcom LPL 000210 v a E 0 ^ o o M M o e-1 r't t() n ri OJ W N n^ Lt o i^ 1A m V m NNm a-r N V m n W l^ n V C] N a v ^n o N i0 O N O n .a ^t ad N N^ n uT m,..t ^p p^ .-^ o sn O V^i' 4 m d n N vl N^o m^ ^ n m m.--t .-+ .-t n Ol m'd C Ot N n N ^A .-^ •-s ^n NV^-MS m N V.n-[ tND rmt} V^ N M^ O N umi 0 nG ^o m m R K K K^ K^ Q 6 O Gl ^'il Q Q Q 2 a tC K LJ 2' D K Q Q 6 Q O K K Q Q Q K K K C^ Q W i^ ? 01 ^ N p _N N q ` o ^ ^ O R y ^ N A T Z v Y '° T T 0 to ^ N m u N^ N U N C'- L ^ W C p G ^ A "O c Y U E N R V C N y L L N V^ N O Am NQ N=rQ Q!1 N p^^ FR- lJ y R^ Cp R N R N R m S cJ < ¢^ C7 Gt Y¢ m ao C N C E -a w c o c z °A ^ 'LY E m^°ro E i p 01 y C ^ A y 9 Y 3m¢ °nmao°c0cou ^ ° x3am^n^^ ^xmm^ ^N z R m J^ < SR Vt J l7m@ T FRl R^ H N N R R R^ R ^ a R R R^ 7 J J J J J J J 3 J J J J J J J J' J J J 3 7 3 «d p3 p3 OJ Jp Jp 3O Jp Jp J° JO JO JO J?O O J OJ p p O Q p O O O O O O° O p O O O O p p° p O° F. x S S S S x S x x= 2== 2 S S x S S^ ^ o"^ N v+'S 4^ ^ N m M m Rl m m m M M M Ilt t0 n W°l o^ rvm V w1 ^1 n N N N N N N N N N N 9a =4 N he `3 ^'y ^^y ^^.y ti rf ^-e .-s Y ^ mvo No N m.-+ooov n n ut O ^a ^ ^ tfl rv^U u^ O dO O w e-1 N O V i!1 N m n rv o m!.n ^n ^^`9 n w r^. n o^ rn w e+ R N^-1 c4 e-1 ' d' ^^^ ^ K d" ^ ^ ^ K O Q 4 0 K ^ O^' d' ^ a[ K K K Q aC o. o cc ^^ ^ o cc o a ^^ cL ^ m a v c v c ru C ^ ^ y N L a ^o s_C N aG O m 1Q ^° . L Q ]0 a+ L N^ ^ G^ N N a Y ^ 7, '^ ^` C p^ L U m c." a ` s s d ^"= 23' ^^^ K F- V^) ^ d Y 31 F- U^ fl^L (- K J Y H"i nf m^^G ^(L3 X C C ^^ J^^n u^ N i' 00 O i C OS C m N a 3] > a^n X Gi ^^ o o 4^ 3^ V ^ C^^ b S tl^0 W y N? N m YO u O O^ O. J'B '6 v^ o^ U a Q^ o 0 16 o^ f4 -Y Q! a N Sw^^^n?'^v°SiLLa^n2_c ^ Q„ y- m ^nv,ac^u^_..^mUxooDum^x^t7c7^,,,ma N a+ ^v„ ^a+., N N a'i. ,v,^ „a, „°', ^°'., ^°^ ^' N ai a^ ai ai ar a. w m m a^ v N N ar N a, ar a ai v ut w w w N 3 3 3 J 3 3 J 3 3 J 3 J 3 3 3 3 J J 3 30 J0 30 30 3'>0 0 30 3 3 J 7 3 J J 3^ 3 J "3 J 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o a o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 2 S S S 2 S S S S S = S x S n n n n n n n n'n t-- o^ rv m^r ^n C^ z er ^^ ^^^^ a^ cc ©[e rz Gl ^ ac a c[ v g v i-a v c ^°° n^ y. v^ m n^C x v- >.Q ^ .R ^aw.CC^° o^^ F^ m= m oy C^a^^0 p a m o'^ Vu m m^ mv o ^ ac x .c c •- 0 4 o n^ D1 ^, e0 3 Z3 o O ^ ^^ m= p K u^^ R 2 6 ^ fn l4 J S S Y ' H 61 0) Q1 W Ul N 6Y N N W N^ N N v^i N N^ a 0 q q O O O O O D O O O O O O O 0 O O O S S S T S S S S 2= S 2 S 2= T 3 T*_ .-.0 •s r^ m d' en ^ ^ cG=Orn O,-. .`3 m t ut .O n, o^'c5^ : ..ooaooomoo m w W co wrnmmrnrnmtl*mmm 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ^^ L.C L .E ^-E L -^' L L L L L L.C L L E .E .C L L L L ^ L ryynoooooooooo00oooooaooooo000ooooocooooo00 ^E t L L,c ,c L L L L L ^ t v ^ N c x Z' ir x a = - °' c ° v - - - - w m ^^ c O ^ ^ q^ o c s x 7.° ^ n^ v >^ s a m c c c c c c o c c 7 c .A _ a, 0 3 m m m m o!o m m p m m a u E m v E E E+°^° c c c c c cc $ o a; o E^ N• E V v W v v^ v E > c^ 3o 03 o c m i^ o 0'u 0 'Uo c c'V c c'u c c'u a mT} m C v mT ,^. o p E^ o c^i v a'^ a'i ayi 'm ro w d^^ a+ y` u u a 3 ^ ^ m^ m a v v v ^ ^ a 3 3 m 3 z s' u ^ ^ u u u2 u 0 va ^ u o u o ^ m N N 'II ^ > y > v m N m 3 m > L1 vE y a^ ^^ p m c a O a a c^ v c 3 0 O K N O Q' Ti U v^ J O^ u c O m>^ m>^ a m^ m 3 a E v^ m :c c v E m E i c m a^ ` a to ' 0 1 y.C N O N l9 ?^ T T N vf m mi ry ~ m m RO O LLm u p^ O NT N5 O X N N t0 N f 2 d^n d o v R ^ a`i v 3 ^^ v w ia ^:25 a x 31E w a a= o a x uf w V 7i ^ w vi a^C w ^ m V O O O O 0 O O O O° 6 O O O O O 0 0 O O O O O O 0 00 D O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O D O oO O O O O Q l7 O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O 00000000000 C ^ R 6 N O F .Y v a° u'a 0 0O ^_ Y ^ m 3 a^'-- c^ ° o v^' xo E° `a ° 3^ c+«m-, a^ ovi c o o °w c c cm °p n° m ^ O O O 3 N a> ym 2 a zas ^n^oz'u.t^v^ vuoi^ zus°^a O U 2¢¢¢^ O aY m ^ 3 o p > z ^-o ^ '' c _^ v v a 3 v v ° -a _ rt^ Z y O _ v m n m v O U^ LL j Ol J' ^ Q ^ ia '°6 ^ VY Omt 3^ Q K^ pp ^ d N^ v^- C^^ O^ N p` i . Y Cl '6 L3 4 V v O ryYc O ^_ ^ a m?' Q V C G^ ^ M W M q°' 6^ p^p M O4 Q _y mR N a' M N` YC ia- 2i ^ cS O oDO C -_ in ^ C^ C N C^^ O05 O Y M m N N-6 .- N-O d^3ir ^ m R > v ^ v > ^ :c m 3 m L R L > m q (DO Z cG° 'S C) ^n ''s u u, ^n ^ u m m u c7 ^ 0 0 0 o o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 O O O O o O O O^O O O O O O o O O O o O X O N ^ ^ Y C ^ m m -o w w ^c = m c °> Y , C ^ b8 C E G UI +>n S C O ^^ ^^ > C R>°^ C> ^£ 2^^ Q% 91 N^U O m L N m N>p ^ 3 y v R^ 0 ? mo3 o ''t3 ZR wv -^ 3 a M m^ 3 Z v a^ ^' z o p c -6 v v ° c v y R q N in v^ > _ 0 p qp` 3= m o-R' y°a y^, ^ a^i c G a °^ K 6 R ^` R» N G) ^ R ^O ^ °^-O ° O V G Y_ iG V^ p C R-p L R p m^ O O -°y ^tr C v Q m v (A 3 i 1° vi u S^O [] vUi S w U Z lJ d From; Heather Mann To: Grodhaus, Michael; Hansen, Beth; "Lenzo Mike"; "TroV J."; "RaV DiRossi"; Subject: sign-off and miscellaneous Date: Monday, August 01, 2011 4:38:44 PM A few important issues on which Ray and I need sign-off/direction: . We had discussed sharing the rules and the schedule with the Democrats. Ray and I would suggest after COB this evening. Please advise. . The SOS has requested a brief spot on the Apportionment Board agenda to discuss the website. I think it would be good to have him do this when we make the motion for the SOS's website to be one of the two places where the public can view the rules. . Mark Braden will be here on Wednesdays and Thursday, just an FYI. Thanks, Heather M. Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, Ohio 43206 (614) 352-5819 heathernmannC gmail.com LPL 000217 Heather [[email protected]] From: Heather Mann 2011 Sent: Monday, August 01, 12:59 PM To: 'Benjamin Yoho'; 'roy J.' Attachments: house_4_chb.xisx Ben, Attached the updated database format for House incumbents, POis, and challengers. I need any candidate or other names added to this as soon as you have time so we can get them up on the screen. -Heather Mann Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Coluinbus, Ohio 43206 (614) 352-5819 heathern man n( agmail.com LPL 000218 E z 0 ° m m° m N o f^1 0^ a ^^^ n^ N op °.-i° n En ^n ° n^n ,-a ^n d' Qt n W n n^ O ei n u1 i0 ° N° t^ e'1 ^(1 b1 tfi n V m N fin e-! O N° v v o rn N W e1 a-1 lD nv+ n N u`ni ^^o s^ m N e^f .ni T Om) I^R t^D d^ p^ N n v m v N m o n ^^ N a .m-I m N d^' eni tND m Q W m f^^'f m m ar^m^xxrzcaaoor npnoo^^rzaorro^coca©nn^^rnnnrrrc^^ccct .O ` ^ Y c O u+ O a N m O C lV v a9J v c c X C^_O U V ^ C-j ..A + C u ^ R Z ou ^ L ^'] c O 0 a C y^ O c ^ i m O O^ N m' C) O E Of ` ' -O C C C E - C L u V E ^e ^ C m L L N uv mcsn ¢ a ^^ ^ F-u ^;.v¢ ^^^^Y ¢mm ^ 2 :5 az^ c m a E v c o E ^ Rl "n R[O C?^ N N N a a..C ^ Y L O ^ 9 bQ c YJ ^ Y y z s^° cc Ep v v o'-"a E ,-6 c o W l7 Y^> c^^ ^ 0 6} c N a^ y W^_ m^ Y^6 C^2u :n p3y ai E 3 d m^ 3 o m 3 m¢°^ © 0 U' Q tJ t9 fJ ^il x^S 2 m:2 Q^^ v^ S x m m.^ 3zm`axint7>mma. Qi 0) N ^J E1 QI 4^ N ^ ^) 1V U) Q1 G1 91 O) d Q3 RJ ^ N N N v^i N N N N ^/^ N VI N N N N Vi N N H y^j y^j ^^ N N N^1 N N O O O C O O O O_O O_O O O O (y 3 3 3 j 3 3 3 S 3 3 _ D 30 O O O O O O _O _O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O f. x 2 x x S x S 2 S= ^n tp n oo rn O.-^ Nm ^3 s^o n m O^ .w N.rt v u+ 's'- i`r.1 G^ o - rv m Y (n m m f^1 m m iC a-1 N M v^Il l0 i^ fA Q^ 4 ^y ^.{ ^y e-i ^-t H H rf c'^ N N N N N N N N N N(V1 M C^l m n vwr rv a 0--^ aiui O) 'cF O N O N Cl N O W V^'^ ^ m m.-+ m tn m m o f^. m^.n h r vt O^D O+ o^ eD tV cO ^I1 O V O O OD .-i N O P N N m{^ N O m vl ^/1 N^ O h m trt N N ti O O O ^^^-i o o^ o o o rc K a^ rc ^ ^ O^c ^ r> o n z ^ O rc ^ O^^^^ ^^'^ ^^^ rc a a cc ecc m T d W C ^ v^^ m .w c avi a v ^ w m ^ ^ a c T C' "O C.Y .D QI V a^ N O^..^ ^p OJ N m F- ^ GG V uc0 2 hw°^2 .°^ i o-^n-°.AYm ^ J Y 1- > N G c aTi s _ na ,a; o ^ c y c m m 3^^ T i Q) ^ ' j p C C_ V X^ ^~-' p A N N N T^ C O a .X .Y E U 'J C7A O V ^ V tO f0 U^ N C 3^. R1 y^_A ^^ O V O O ^ p. O '6 -4 SS A m^ N_ ^ O^ ^ bR 3 N" E ^C E C O^ m Y y c_ .^ OJ U^ _ ^"6 N O^p V N W D O to ^ O N O N SO V ID ^ S ^ C7 ZJ V1 fYl Q Q S O LL T J b a N O V V ^ J iA C7 ^ Vl K^L Vl ^ N LL Q tA S N N N a) N UJ N U) y 4^ U) N R) N N N'V N U! v v^i ^an v^i V^1 ^^^^i. ^.Ui VI U OJ N N^ N ^ N N 1N J^ Y) ^/1 N VI N vl N 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 'o 0 30 'o 'o 0 0^0 o 30 0 S S S S S S S S S S S S S S S S= S x S=.. . K. . w'. r M O^ _ _= S S S S S S S S r r 1^ t^ t^ 3^ !^ h h(^ N Ul. u5 V5 N N ^ J1 ^It t^ t0 tD tU tD ^O t0 t0 l0 l4 3 V V V V C Q V G V V ^ On ip p^ 0^0 t5 mV N m O^Y oo^nno^o o cc ^ rc ^^^ c m m^r m d 3 -D T y « ^ c ^ ^ m a=O ^ >^ ^.a', .G ^ v R= N G" p ^ V m ^ O F c2 a] O Q m J Q O 4 m ^ v ^ v -o ra m c ^ x O m D o >, s C y t„' D^ o in G O- =^ '^ C 3 m 0 0 ^ S V' J S S Y N U1 N N N N Ji N ^ VI VI ^f ^ N N @ 3t N YI V1 3 3 3 3 J'^ 3 J 3^ J 3 3 3 J^'3 ^>'3 D D O O O O D O O O O O O O O O O O O O S S S S S S S S S S S S S S S S S S S S com mmoowcom mmmc ,n a+mrn m mrnm O O O O O O O O O_ O O O O O O O O O O O 9 O O O O O O 0 O O O O O O O O O O O L L L L L L L L L L L t t L L L.G L.C Lz L.C L S L L L NON.^ OOOOOOOOt LLL L L.C .C O L OOt O OO OOOO OOOOOOOO OO OO OO OO OOO O m L L m ^ C 2 N w ^ C O G G C C ^ C s T ^ 9 ^ g V -5.^Q .fl .=O ^ C C G C C C O G C^ C ^n °c° O 3 m m m m o m m!O Y m« 4 y ^ a a E E E 00 _c c c_c c c m O o m o in t0 ' ^>>> ^ > ^*' _ v > =u oi > v m ar x v n' `° `m °'i d ?O p o N 0 3' o 9a O C C C G G C ^ R tO Gl N a3 003 ^ . c5:9 m° ^ m u u u u S u a 3 3 m 3 z 3 u^^ u u u^ u u'u ^ ^ » u d u d V ^J m ^ v ° v o O v m v m "+ K> u___ v-a ^>_ m ^ j> a.a a v ? d Q- a: -' o y ^ O O ^ m 2 > ai ^^D v p d p^ w t oj d < > 32^ m ¢ T3 4 4? ^^i 4` ^¢-6 K a m^^ ^ J Y> t N O a O O-6' N t' d lJ y N O^ O C N ^ N^^^^ d^ J d^ «^ O^ 9 K O Q ^ a a C A ^ a C', N m m tn .L ^ C ^j O +' m L a.^ a_ 0 3 L m ;_ ¢ w E m m x c a m^ o` y L w O E `v d O-- - _ +- }- OO l0 T vi d d V` S V FO- ^ Q= zi 2 w D U Z^^2 d K^ O vOi Q u, 0 0 0 0 0 0 o p o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 p p p o p a o o O O o o p o o O o 0 0 o p o 0 0 o n o o O o () o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o n o 0 0 0 o n o 0 0 0 0 o n o O o 0 0 o n o a 3 a c s_' 'D o ar 9 ar p cu 4) ^ N C G^ 4 y.T, C m¢r m D 3^ L y F N ^ O N^^ N O= ^ v o^ o c c c E ° 0 m O O 0 0 0^ m m v^ `c c - E S^_^ ^ m O^ m^ N^ a^i -p_ ma^ m G N'o O ^p p^ ^ Y Y O O OZn °wz°uiu'Sa3 oz V V^ Q 4 4 F- ` O 6 V 4 m ^ ^ ^ p m o O x ^ W Z p j N M o ^ ^ > p z > Z v-a v^ ^ 3 0 0- ^ j v>^^ v ^ i> v`m_ - v° ^ v, v^^ a' .^rc v, z 3 a>'i r a, Y^ c v' ^ p> v^ ^ CI ° ,. Y N'6 K ,Q v O^ O °°°LY° > > ^N wY m 5^^^ m 3a 2 ^ 3 in 3 m°1 c >d -c^-Q E .G m L^ N O^ m o i^ o z° 3 o 32 a >^ z° ^ a a w^ 0 3 i i'^ ° m Zi V u^ vr ti U m^ U C7 ^ O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O 00000000000000000000 ^ O v .^^. c y c °Y on Tn ^ m=^ ^_ C C^ J v y i c A b7 G 3 C 1 N C^> On y v a^.. ^ O ^ o o C ^+ ar c> C v^.O y va U1 T^ X^ y(] 3 C U1 '^ >>, C ^ E V al al Ct^ O m t Cm^ N Q G p d N IL ^^L JO N 2 ^^ G^ CI Q 4 N N Cl G 2 C1 l6 a oi o 0 0 ^ m w ^ . Z w rop C C ^^ t m v m^ Z v Q v a K O ^ Q}'n C^ ^ 3 m v v d ^ Q w'c a in c ^ u_ ^ Qy n 3 ^^ N(6 N^^ Oy N 3^ O^ i C Y ^^^C .^ o'3 t.n .^ m. 0 4 a ^ c >w R ro;° V CO N> d V' ^^ Z C Vi V S tp Q N S u^ VZ From: Michael Lenzo To: Heather Mann; Barron, John; Mann, Heather John Barrow Braden E. Mark Grodhaus, Michael; michael grodhaus@amail com• Kutschbach, Kim Subject: Apportionment Board Public Records Policy Date: Tuesday, August 02, 2011 6:46:28 PM Attachments: Apportionment Board Public Records PolicV.doc Everyone: Attached is the Apportionment Board Public Records Policy that I have drafted to govern the costs charged to those making requests for copies/ inspection. Please let me know if you have any comments or suggestions. The policy is based off of the House's policy. -Mike LPL 000225 APPORTIONMENT BOARD PUBLIC RECORDS POLICY It is the policy of the Apportionment Board that openness leads to a better informed citizenry, which leads to better govemment and better public policy. It is the policy of the Apportionment exemptions to openness are to be Board to strictly adhere to the Ohio Public Records Act. All construed narrowly and any denial of public records in response to a valid request should be accompanied by an explanation, including legal authority, as outlined in the Ohio Revised Code. If the request for public records is in writing, the explanation of denial must also be in writing. This public records policy is effective for public records requests received on and after August 4, 2011, and will remain in effect until amended by the Apportionment Board. PUBLIC RECORDS Section 1. Definition of a public record The Apportionment Board, in accordance with the Ohio Revised Code, defines records as including the following: Any document - paper, electronic (including, but not limited to, e-mail), or other format - that is created or received by, or comes under the jurisdiction of a public office that documents the organization, functions, policies, decisions, procedures, operations, or other activities of the office. All records of the Apportionment Board are public unless they are specifically exempt from disclosure under the Ohio Revised Code. Any questions as to whether or not a record is a "public record" should directed to the records officer of the Apportionment Board. Section 1.1 Organization and Maintenance It is the policy of the Apportionment Board that, as required by Ohio law, records will be organized and maintained so that they are readily available for inspection and copying. Record retention schedules shall be readily available to the public at the Ohio House of Representatives Clerk's Office in the Ohio Statehouse. PUBLIC RECORDS REQUESTS AND RESPONSES Section 2 Evaluation of a Public Records Request Each request for public records should be evaluated for a response using the following guidelines. Section 2.1 Identification of a Public Records Request Although no specific language is required to make a request, the requester must at least identify the records requested with sufficient clarity to allow the public office to identify, retrieve, and I LPL 000226 review the records. If it is not clear what records are being sought, the records custodian must contact the requester for clarification, and should assist the requester in revising the request by informing the requester of the manner in which the office keeps its records. Section 2.2 Method of Public Records Requests and Identity of Requester The requester does not have to put a records request in writing, although written requests are preferred for accuracy, and does not have to provide his or her identity or disclose the intended use of the requested public record. of Public Records for Inspection and Production of Copies Section 2.3 Availability Public records are to be available for inspection during regular business hours, with the exception of published holidays. Public records will be made available for inspection promptly. Copies of public records must be made available within a reasonable period of time. "Prompt" and "reasonable" take into account the volume of records requested, the proximity of the location where the records are stored, and the necessity for any legal review of the records requested. Section 2.4 Time Constraints for Satisfying Public Records Requests Each request should be evaluated for an estimated length of time to gather the records. If feasible, routine requests for records should be satisfied as soon as reasonably possible. All requests for public records should either be satisfied or acknowledged in writing by the Apportionment Board within five business days following the office's receipt of the request. If a request will not be satisfied within five business days, the acknowledgement must include at least the following: • A request for clarification (if necessary) • An estimated cost if copies are requested. Section 2.5 Denial of Public Records Requests Any denial of public records requests must include an explanation, including legal authority. If portions of a record are public and portions are exempt, the exempt portions are to be redacted and the rest of the record released. If there are redactions, each redaction must be explained with citations to the legal authority used for the redaction. COSTS FOR OBTAINING COPIES OF PUBLIC RECORDS Section 3 Charges for Copies and Postage Those seeking public records will be charged the actual cost of making copies, as follows: Section 3.1 The charge for paper copies (8.5" x 1" one-sided, black ink) is 10 cents per page. 2 LPL 000227 3.2 The charge for downloaded computer files to a compact or digital video disk is $1 Section per disk. Section 3.3 There is no charge for e-mailed documents. 3.4 Requesters may ask that documents be mailed to them. They will be charged the Section actual cost of postage and mailing supplies. 3 LPL 000228 rage t ot t t,mat^ - xt_: RE: I message Tue, Aug 2, 2011 at 7:40 PM Matt schuter ---Original Message--- From: Ray DiRossi <_,+dirosiCcOomail Qam> Sent: Tuesday, August 02, 2011 6:04 PM To: Matt Schuler sbc email Is the 3 chiefs at bunker visit tomorrow at 11:30 or 3? Ray littps://inail.google.con^/mail/?ui-2&ik-2cd7e5^5^E'^^--`Pt&cat Redistricting%20'Em... 10/14/2011 hael From: Boston, Shannon Wednesday, August 03, 2011 7:46 AM Sent: Mike; Dittoe, Michael; Mann, Heather; Kraemer, Alex To: Lenzo, Subject: RE: redistricting press release Troy said it is okay to send. Will release later this niorning. Sha7113.o7.i Boston Deputy Director of Majarity Communications Ohio 1louse of Representati.ves - From: Lenzo, Mike Sent: Tuesday, August 02, 2011 1:07 PM To: Boston, Shannon CC: Dittoe, Michael; Mann, Heather; Kraemer, Alex Subject: Re: redistricting press release This is a Troy question. 2011, at 12:38 PM, "Boston, Shannon" NFike, do you mind taking a look at this as well? Thank you Shannon Boston Deputy Director of Majority Communicatious Ohio House of Representatives _------.. ---... From: Mann, Heather Sent: Tuesday, August 02, 2011 12:37 PM To: goston, Shannon; Kraemer, Alex Cc: Dittoe, Michael Subject: Re: redistricting press release sending - I'm not sure we wanted to highlight our members Pis chcck with Lcnzo before involvement more than necessary. Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry 132 LPL 000230 Frc>m: "Boston. Shannon" Date: 'I'ue, 2 Aug 2011 S 2:.34:54 -0400 'fo: Kraetner, Alex«1tex.Kraener(c^^ohr.statc.ah.us> Cc: Dittoe, Michael Subject: redistrieting press release Alex, here is a rough draft of the redistricting press release you requested. State Representative Cheryl Grossman 23rd Ohio House District Alex Kraemer For Immediate Release: Contact: August 2, 2011 (614) 466-9690 Rep. Grossman to Serve on Redistricting Subcommittee CdLUMBUS-Assistant House Majority Whip Cheryl Grossman (R-Grove City) was recently appointed by Speaker of the Ohio House William G. Batchelder (R-Medina) to serve on the C-louse Subcommittee on Redistricting, which will be holding official hearings in September to determine the new congressional districts. Throughout the month of August, Rep. Grossman will be traveling thronghout the district and state to obtain public feedback on the redistricting process and gain valuable insight from the constituents of the 23ia House District. 133 LPL 000231 QUOTE In Ohio, Congressional district plans are enacted by the Ohio General Assembly thraugh the legislative process and codified in the Ohio Revised Code 3521.01. -30- 134 LPL 000232 eather N1ar Frone: Heather Mann [heathernmanr,@gma1.[romJ Sent: Wednesday, August 03, 2011 5:42 PM 'Hatle Pelger'; `[email protected]'; 'Barron, John'; Mary Amos Augsburger To: ( M AAugsburger@au d itor.state. o h. u s) Attachments: 2011-08-04 Apportionment Board Meeting Script_docx Per your request, the most recent version of script. Will send full updated packet later tonight- Technical changes to rules and public records policy will be only substantive changes. +^* Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, Ohio 43206 (614) 352-5819 heathernmann Rmail.cam LPL 000233 1NrrtA1. APPORTIONI'it;NT BOARD MEETING :YCR1P'r Call to Order GOVERiNOR KASICH: Pursuant to Article 11, Section 1 of the Ohio Constitution, 1. hereby call to order this meeting of the 2011 Board of Apportioning Persons_ There is a quorum of members present,, but for the record, would each member of the Board please indicate their presence b,v stating their name. [Members state names and titles] This meeting is called pursuant to Article li, Section 1 of the Ohio Constitution, which requires that after each decennial census, the Ohio Board of Apportioning persons - including the Govemor, Secretary of State, Auditor of State, and two persons selected by the leadership of the General Assc rnbly convenes between August 1 and October 1 of the year the census figures are released to establisb the district lines of the Ohio General Assembly. Article 11 of the ^dures for this apportionment, and we will therefore proceed under Constitution governs the proca. its provi.sions. LI. Present Indicia of OftTee and Letters of Appointment GOVERNOR KASICH: Members bave been provided with a eopy of the proposed agenda for this meeting, which was distributed in advance. The first item of business is for the members of the Board to verify their membership on the Board by presenting their letters of appointment, in the case of legislative apportioning persons, and oaths of office in the case of otber menibers. We will now receive these documents. I would like to indicate for the record that I have the certificates of office for Secretary of State Husted, Auditor David Yost, and myself as Governor. I also have a letters from House Speaker Bill Batchelder, Senate President Tom Niehaus, Senate Minority Leader Capri Cafaro, and House Minority Leader Annond Budish, choosing and to serve on this Board. appointing [SenatorlRepresentative X and SSenator,Representative Y] We now have received the appropriate documentation from each inember, and it all appears to be in order. Iti. P.lectloaa of Chair of the Apportionment Board GOV FRNOR KASICH: The next item on. the agenda is the selection of a chair. Govemor, I move that Governor Kasich be nanieil chair of the SECRETARY HUSTED: Mr. LPL 000234 Apportionment Board. GOVERNOR KASICII: We have a motion. Is the-re a second? AUDITOR YOST: I second the motion_ GOVERhIOR KASICH: Auditor Yost seconds. The nomination has been made and seconded. [all sav ayel. Those Are there any other nominations? If not, all if favor signify by saying aye opposed? Motion is c:airicd, I will serve as chair. iv. Selection of Secretary of the Apportionment Board GOVERNOR KASICH: The next item on the agenda is for the selection of a secretary to the Board of Apportioning persons. The Secretary will keep the rninutes, call the roll, and record all votes and maintain custody of all the records of the Apportionment Board, including the proposed plan to be filed with the Board. I will now entertain a motion for secretary. SECRETARY HUSTED: Mr. Chairman, I move that [naine] be named Secretary of the Apportionment Board. GOVERNOR KASICH: We have a motion. Is there a second? AUDITOR YOST: 1 second the motion. GOVERNOR KASICH: Auditor Yost seconds the motion. The nomination has been made and seconded. Are there any other nominations? Is there any discussion of the nomination? If not, Those opposed? Motion is carried, [namel will all if favor signify by saying aye [atl say aye]. the custodian of the records, the documentation serve as Secretary. I will now give [name], provided to ine. V. Election of Vice Chair of the Apportionment Board GOVERNOR KASICH: The next item on the agenda is the selection of a vice chair to the Board of Apportioning persons. I nominate Auditor Yost to serve as vice chair of the 2011 Apportionment Board, Is there a second? SECRETARY HUSTED: I second the mo'ior. GOVERNOR KASICH: Secretary Husted seconds the motion. The nomination has been made and seconded- Arc there any other nominations? Is there any discussion of the nomination? If Those opposed? If not, will the Secretary not, all if favor signify by saying aye [all say aye]. LPL 000235 SL.CRETARY. For the selection of Auditor Yost as Vice Chair of dxe Apportionment Board, Apportionment Board by a vote of X-X. [calls roll]. Auditor Yost is selected "Srice Cbair of the Vi. Announcement of Attorney Representation GOVERNOR KASICI-I: Historically, the Attorney General has represented the Board and all persons serving on the Board. Attorney General Mike DeWine has appointed Mark Braden to be here today to be available to the Board. I would like to ask Mr. Braden to identify himself on the record. MARK BRADEN: Mr. Chairman, Mennbers of the Board, I am Mark Braden, Counsel to the Board. GOVERNOR KA.SICH: Thanl: you, and welcome. VII. Appointment of Offlcial Court Reporter GOVERNOR KASICH: At this point, given the olficial and historic nature of our proceedings, we need to appoint an official court reporter for the proceedings of the Apportiomnent Board. Accordingly, I will now entertain a nrotioti to appoint an official court reporter for these proceedings. [name] be the official court SFCRETARY HUSTED: Mr. Chairman, I move that the firm of reporter for the 2001 Apportionment Board and that said court reporter please prepare and provide each member of the Board a copy of the transcript of each of our meetings. AUDITOR YOST: I second the motion. GOVERNOR KASICH: Auditor Yost seconds the motion. The nomination has been made and seconded. Are there any other nominations? Is there any discussion of the nomination? If not, Those opposed? If not, will the Sec•retary please all if favor signify by saying aye [all say aye]_ call the roll. SECRETARY: For the appointment of [name] as official court reporter for the 2001 Apportionment Board, [calls roll]. The motion carries X-X. GOVERNOR KASICH: Thank you. For the record, I'd like to ask our court reporter, who is here from the firm of [name], to please identify [his/her]sel£ in [cih>], Ohio. REPORTER: My name is [name], court reporter witb [farm name] 3 LPL 000236 VIII_ Adoption of Rules and Procedures GOVERNOR KASICI-I: This brings us to our next agenda item, which is the adoption of the rules of the 2011 Apportionment Board. All the members should have a copy of the proposed rules which I provided to each of you in advance of today's meeting. These proposed rules are, in essence, a revised version of the rules of the 2001 Apportionment Board which are on file with the I.et;islative Service Cominission. Our intention is to vote on the rules as a block unless there is an amendment. At this time I would entertain a motion regarding the rules. [7f there is n motion to adopt the proposed rules as a block] SECRETARY HUSTED: Mr. Chairman, I move that we vote to adopt Rules X-X. AUDITOR YOST: Second. Any discussion? lf none, the GOVERNOR KASICH: The motion has been made and seconded. Secretary will call the roll. roln. The motion carries X-X. SECRETARY: On the motion to adopt Rules X-X [calls (If'there is a motion to amend the proposed rules] motion. has been made and seconded. Any discussion? GOVERNOR KASICH: The MEMBER: Move to amend. moves to amend. Please describe your amendment. GOVERNOR KASICH: [nan:el Member proceeds to describe amendment. GOVERNOR KASICH: The amendment has been moved. MEMBER: Second. Any discussion? If none, the GOVFRNOR KASICH: The motion has been made and seconded. Secretary will call the roll. SECRET'ARY: [calls rol1J. The motion to amend passes X-X. there further discassion on the proposed rules as amended? If not, GOVERNOR KASICH: Is will the secretary please call the roll on the mofion to adopt the proposed rules. `I'he motion to adopt rules X-X as amended passes X-X. SECRETARY: [calls roll]. 4 LPL 000237 ------^_.. ------been- -- adopted. 1 instruct the Sec.retary of the Boar d to f OVER:NOR KASICH: .'I`he rules have by the Ohso Rev7sed Code. certify and file these rutes forthwith as presctibed IX. Adoption of Public >fIearing Schedule GOVERNOR KASICH: The rules we have just adopted provide for provide for a series of public hearings around the state to receive public input and comment on the apportionment plan. At this point I would entertain a motion to establish a schedule of these public hearings. SECRETARY HUSTED: Mr. Chairman, a proposed schedule had earlier been distributed stating the times and places for eleven public hearings to be held in various locations around the state from August 22 to August 26, 2011. 1 would move that we adopt the praposed schedute as the scbedule of public hearings as required by our rules. GOVERNOR KASICH: is there a second? AUDITOR YOST: Second. GOVERNOR KASICH: The motion has been made and seconded. Any discussion? If none, the Secretary will call the roll. SECRETARY: OnYhe motion to adopt the public schedule of hearings, [calls rolfl. The motion carries X-X. GOVERNOR KASICH: The Secretary is instructed to make the schedule available to the press and the public. X. Adoption of public records policy GOVERNOR KASICH: 'Ilre rules also call for the Apportionment Board to adopt a public records pursuant to Ohio Revised Code 149.43. A proposed public records policy was distributed to members earlier and is in your folders. Do I have a motion on the proposed policy? SECRETARY HUSTED: Mr. Chairman, I move that the Board adopt the proposed pub3ic records policy. AUDITORA YOST: Second. The motion has been made and seconded. Any discussion? If none, the GOVERNOR KASICH: Secretary will call the roll. 5 LPL 000238 [calLs roll]. The motion carries SE C'RETARY: On the cnotion to adopt the public records policy, X-X. GOVERNOR KASICH: The Secretary is instructed to make the records policy available to the public and the press. XI. Designation of place for public review of proposed apportionment plan GOVERNOR KASICH: At this time, I would like to ask Secretary Husted to provide us overview of the Secretary's redistricting website. SECRETARY HUSTED: [discusses website]. GOVERNOR KASICH: The rules call for the apportionment board to designate a place or places where the public may review the plans of apportionment that are filed with the Board. Is there a motion on the designation of a place for public review of submitted plans? SECRETARY HUSTED: Mr. Chairman, I move that the Board designate a website with the address of www.reshapeobio.ora and a physical space adjacent to the Ohio House of Representatives Chambers, 2°d Floor Statehouse, Columbus Ohio 43215 where the public may review the plans that wcre submitted to the Board. AUDITORA YOST: Second. GOVERNOR KASICH: The motion has been made and seconded. Any discussion? If none, the Secretary will call the roll. SECRETARY: On the motion to designate the place where the public may view apportionment plans, [calls roll]. The motion carries X-X. GOVERNOR KASICH: The Secretary is instructed to make the location and website as the designated places for public review of plans available to the press. XII. Establishing time, date, and place of next meeting GOVERNOR.KASICH: At this time. I will entertain a motion to establish the date and place of -- 1 the next meeting of the 2011 Apportionment Board_ SECRETARY HUSTED: Mr. Chairman, I move that the next mceting of the Board be set for Monday, Sept. 26,2011 at 9AM in the Ohio Senate Finance Hearing Room. 6 LPL000239 -...-_....___.-_ _------.__ AUDITOR YosT: Second. GOVERNOR KASICH: The motion has been made and seconded. Any discussion? If none, the Secretary will call the roll. SECRETARY: On the motion to set the date and location of the next Apportiontnent Board Room. The meeting for Monday, Sept. 26, 201 1 at 9AM in the Ohio Senate Finance Hearing motion can-ies X-X- XIII. Adjourn GOVERNOR KASICH: Any further business to come before the 2011 Apportionment Board? Sept. 26, 2011 at 9AM- If not, I will entertain a motion to recess the Board until Monday, SECRETARY kIUSTED: Mr. Chairman, so inoved. AUDITOR YOST: Second. GOVERNOR KASICH: The motion has been made and scxonded. All in favor? Opposed? Thank you, the 2011 Apportionment Board is adjourned. 7 LPL 000240 INITIAL APPORTIONMENT BOARD MEETING SCRIPT 1. Call to Order GOVERNOR KASICH: Pursuant to Article 11, Section I of the Ohio Constitution, I hereby call to order this meeting of the 2011 Board of Apportioning Persons. There is a quorum of inembers present, but for the record, would each member of the Board please indicate their presence by stating their name. [Members state names and titles] This meeting is called pursuant to Article II, Section 1 of the Ohio Constitution, which requires that after each decennial census, the Ohio Board of Apportioning persons - including the Governor, Secretary of State, Auditor of State, and two persons selected by the leadership of the General Assembly convenes between August 1 and October 1 of the year the census figures are released to establish the district lines of the Ohio General Assembly. Article 11 of the Constitution governs the procedures for this apportionment, and we will therefore proceed under its provisions. II. Present Indicia of Office and Letters of Appointment GOVERNOR KASICH: Members have been provided with a copy of the proposed agenda for this meeting, which was distributed in advance. The first item of business is for the members of the Board to verify their membership on the Board by presenting their letters of appointment, in the case of legislative apportioning persons, and oaths of office in the case of other members. We will now receive these documents. I would like to indicate for the record that I have the certificates of office for Secretary of State Husted, Auditor David Yost, and myself as Governor. I also have a letters from House Speaker Bill Batchelder, Senate President Tom Niehaus, Senate Minority Leader Capri Cafaro, and House Minority Leader Armond Budish, choosing and to serve on this Board. appointing [Senator/Representative X and Senator/Representative Y] We now have received the appropriate documentation from each member, and it all appears to be in order. III. Election of Chair of the Apportionment Board GOVERNOR KASICH: The next item on the agenda is the selection of a chair. Kasich be named chair of the Apportionment MEMBER: Mr. Govemor I move that Governor I LPL 000241 Board. GOVERNOR KASICH: We have a motion. Is there a second? MEMBER: I second the motion. The nomination has been made and GOVERNOR KASICH: [Names member] seconds. If not, all if favor signify by saying aye [all say seconded. Are there any other nominations? aye]. Those opposed? Motion is carried, I will serve as chair. IV. Election of Vice Chair of Apportionment Board GOVERNOR KASICH: The next item on the agenda is the selection of a vice chair to the Board as vice chair of the 2011 Apportionment of Apportioning persons. I nominate [name] to serve Board. Is there a second? MEMBER: I second the motion. seconds the motion. The nomination has been made GOVERNOR KASICH: [Names member] and seconded. Are there any other nominations? Is there any discussion of the nomination? If Those opposed? If not, will the Secretary not, all if favor signify by saying aye [all say aye]. please call the role. [calls SECRETARY: For the selection of [name] as Vice Chair of the Apportionment Board, roll]. [Name] is selected Vice Chair of the Apportionment Board by a vote of X-X. V. Selection of Secretary of Apportionment Board GOVERNOR KASICH: The next item on the agenda is for the selection of a secretary to the Board of Apportioning persons. The Secretary will keep the minutes, call the roll, and record all Apportionment Board, including the votes and maintain custody of all the records of the with the Board. I will now entertain a motion for secretary. proposed plan to be filed be named Secretary of the Apportionment Board. MEMBER: Mr. Chairman, I move that [name] GOVERNOR KASICH: We have a motion. Is there a second? MEMBER: I second the motion. second the motion. The nomination has been made GOVERNOR KASICH: [Names member] and seconded. Are there any other nominations? Is there any discussion of the nomination? If Those opposed? Motion is carried, [name] not all if favor signify by saying aye [all say ayel 2 LPL 000242 will serve as Secretary. I will now give [name], the custodian of the records, the documentation provided to me. VI. Announcement of Attorney Representation GOVERNOR KASICH: Historically, the Attorney General has represented the Board and all persons serving on the Board. Attomey General DeWine has appointed Mark Braden to be here today to be available to the Board. I would like to ask Mr. Braden to identify himself on the record. MARK BRADEN: Mr. Chairman, Members of the Board, I am Mark Braden, Counsel to the Board. GOVERNOR KASICH: Thank you, and welcome. VII. Appointment of Official Court Reporter GOVERNOR KASICH: At this point, given the official and historic nature of our proceedings, we need to appoint an official court reporter for the proceedings of the Apportionment Board. Accordingly, I will now entertain a motion to appoint an official court reporter for these proceedings. MEMBER: Mr. Chainnan, I move that the firm of [name] be the official court reporter for the 2001 Apportionment Board and that said court reporter please prepare and provide each member of the Board a copy of the transcript of each of our meetings. MEMBER: I second the motion. seconds the motion. The nomination has been made GOVERNOR KASICH: [Names member] and seconded. Are there any other nominations? Is there any discussion of the nomination? If Those opposed? If not, will the Secretary not, all if favor signify by saying aye [all say aye]. please call the roll. SECRETARY: For the appointment of [name] as official court reporter for the 2001 Apportionment Board, [calls roll]. The motion carries X-X. GOVERNOR KASICH: Thank you. For the record, I'd like to ask our court reporter, who is here from the firm of [name], to please identify [his/her]self. in [city], Ohio. REPORTER: My name is [name], court reporter with [firm name] VIII. Adoption of Rules and Procedures 3 LPL 000243 GOVERNOR KASICH: This brings us to our next agenda item, which is the adoption of the rules of the 2011 Apportionment Board. All the members should have a copy of the proposed rules which I provided to each of you in advance of today's meeting. These proposed rules are, in essence, a revised version of the rules of the 2001 Apportionment Board which are on file with the Legislative Service Commission. Our intention is to vote on the rules as a block unless there is an amendment. At this time I would entertain a motion regarding the rules. [If there is n motion to adopt the proposed rules as a block] MEMBER: Mr. Chairman, I move that we vote to adopt Rules X-X. MEMBER: Second. motion has been made and seconded. Any discussion? If none, the GOVERNOR KASICH: The Secretary will call the roll. [calls roll]. The motion carries X-X. SECRETARY: On the motion to adopt Rules X-X [If there is a motion to amend the proposed rules] Any discussion? GOVERNOR KASICH: The motion has been made and seconded. MEMBER: Move to amend. moves to amend. Please describe your amendment. GOVERNOR KASICH: [name] Member proceeds to describe amendment. GOVERNOR KASICH: The amendment has been moved. MEMBER: Second. The motion has been made and seconded. Any discussion? If none, the GOVERNOR KASICH: Secretary will call the roll. SECRETARY: [calls roll]. The motion to amend passes X-X. there further discussion on the proposed rules as amended? If not, GOVERNOR KASICH: Is will the secretary please call the roll on the motion to adopt the proposed rules. X-X as amended passes X-X. SECRETARY: [calls roll]. The motion to adopt rules rules have been adopted. I instruct the Secretary of the Board to GOVERLIOR KASICH: The by the Ohio Revised Code. certify and file these rules forthwith as rescribed 4 LPL 000244 IX. Adoption of Public Hearing Schedule GOVERNOR KASICH: The rules we have just adopted provide for provide for a series of public hearings around the state to receive public input and comment on the apportionment plan. At this point I would entertain a motion to establish a schedule of these public hearings. MEMBER: Mr. Chairman, I had earlier distributed a proposed schedule stating the times and places for eleven public hearings to be held in various locations around the state from August 22 to August 26, 2011. I would move that we adopt the proposed schedule as the schedule of public hearings as required by our rules. GOVERNOR KASICH: Is there a second? MEMBER: Second. GOVERNOR KASICH: The motion has been made and seconded. Any discussion? If none, the Secretary will call the roll. The motion SECRETARY: On the motion to adopt the public schedule of bearings, [calls roll]. carries X-X. GOVERNOR KASICH: The Secretary is instructed to make the schedule available to the press and the public. X. Designation of place for public review of proposed apportionment plan I understand it, we need to designate a place or places where the GOVERNOR KASICH: As public may review the plans of apportionment that are filed with the Board, pursuant to our own rules and procedures. Is there a motion on the designation of a place for public review of submitted plans? [URL] MEMBER: Mr. Chairman, I move that the Board designate a website with the address of House of Representatives Chambers, 2°d Floor and a physical space adjacent to the Ohio where public may review the plans that were submitted to the Statehouse, Columbus Ohio 43215 Board. MEMBER: Second. motion has been made and seconded. Any discussion? If none, the GOVERNOR KASICH: The Secretar,l will call the roll. 5 LPL 000245 SECRETARY: On the motion to designate the place where the public may view apportionment plans, [calls rolZ]. The motion carries X-X. GOVERNOR KASICH: The Secretary is instructed to make the website as the designated place for public review of plans available to the press. XI. Establishing time, date, and place of next meeting GOVERNOR KASICH: At this time I will entertain a motion to establish the date and place of the next meeting of the 2011 Apportionment Board. MEMBER: Mr. Chairman, I move that the next meeting of the Board be set for Monday, Sept. 26, 2011 at 9AM. MEMBER: Second. GOVERNOR KASICH: The motion has been made and seconded. Any discussion? If none, the Secretary will call the roll. SECRETARY: On the motion to set the date and location of the next Apportionment Board meeting for [date/time/location], [calls rollj. The motion carries X-X. XII. Adjourn GOVERNOR KASICH: Any further business to come before the 2011 Apportionment Board? If not, I will entertain a motion to recess the Board until Monday, Sept. 26, 2011 at 9AM. MEMBER: Mr. Chairman, so moved. MEMBER: Second. GOVERNOR KASICH: The motion has been made and seconded. All in favor? Opposed? Thank you, the 2011 Apportionment Board is adjourned. 6 LPL 000246 Mann, Heather From: Grodhaus, Michael [[email protected]] Sent: Thursday, August 04, 2011 9:44 AM To: Mann, Heather Subject: RE: 2011-08-04 Apportionment Board Meeting Script Attachments: image001.png; image002.jpg Heather, Where did the 9:00 am come from for the 9/26 meeting? D. Michael 6rodhaus Chief Counsel off'rce of Ohio Governor John R. Kasich (614)644-0825 michael grodhauspeovernor.ohio.KO www.aovernocohtv-eov be pubYrcly avaifable to anyone who requests it. 7his message and any response to it may constitute a public record and thus may ,...._...... _.___._ . ___.__. _ ..._.._ _-_-___. From Mann, Heather [mailto:Heather Mann@ohr state.oh.us] Sent: Thursday, August 04, 20119:40 AM To: Halle Pelger ([email protected]); 'Mary Amos Augsburgef; Grodhaus, Michael; Lenzo, Mike; [email protected] Subject: 2011-08-04 Apportionment Board Meeting Script Updated for name of court reporter- 502 LPL 000247 Heather Mann From: Heather Mann [heathernmann@gmaiLcom] Sent: Thursday, August 04, 2011 613 PM To: 'Mary Amos Augsburger' Subject: RE: Documents for Tomorrow pkay - thanks. Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, Ohio 43206 (614) 352-5819 h eathernma nn2gmai l.corn Fromc Mary Amos Augsburger (mailto^MAAuosburpert^auditor state.oh.usl Sent: Thursday, August 04, 2011 6:11 PM To: Heather Mann Subject: RE: Documents for Tomorrow it's in the next e-mail I sent. From: Heather Mann [maiito heathemmann(a^amaiE.coml Sent: Thursday, August 04, 2011 6:10 PM To: Mary Amos Augsburger Subject: RE: Documents for Tomorrow Mary, Was there originally an attachment to this email? Sincerely, Heather Mann ^+. Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, Ohio 43206 (614) 352-5819 heathemmann mailcam From: Mary Amos Augsburger [mailto•MAAugsburerguditor state.oh.usl Sent: Thursday, August 04, 2011 11:35 AM To: Heather Mann; ravdirossi(a omail.com Subject: FW: Documents for Tomorrow fTeather and Ray, ud suu^zcstions fro=n _1ud.itor Yost on the public records policv. At[ached pic:a.se nnd sorc cor h4uv LPL 000248 Prom: Mann, Heather [maltoHeatherMann ohr,state.oh.us S^ertt. Wednesday, August 03, 2011 7:30 PM To: Halle Pelger (h 1 er sas state.oh.us); halEe3333^Dhatrnail com; ra dirossiCc^gmail com; Braden, E. Mark; Troy 1; Lenzo, Mike; 'Barron, Iohn'; Mary Amos Augsburger Subject: Documents for Tomorrow All: Please find attached the most recent versions of the agenda, script, and rules. We will have prepared binders for the members tomorrow_ Sincerely, Heather Mann Heather N. Mann, Esq. Redistricting Director & Dep. Legal Counsel House Republican Caucus Ottio House of Representatives 77 South High Street, 14th Floor Columbus, Ohio 43215 (614) 466-9194 - Office (614) 719-3594 - Fax (614) 352-5819 - Cell heather mannCtDohr state.oh.us CONEIDENTIALIrYNOTICE, it ts addressed and it may ceniain information that is pdvileged. or enti[y to whlch (or the employee or agent The in(amation corntained in Ihis e-mail is intended only for the use of the indivldoai ntessaye is not :he intended recipienf 9 the reader of this K you have received this confdenlial. attor'ney work product andfor exempt fr©mdisclosureunder applicahie Iaw. disinbution, or copying of this e-mail is proMLited. responsibiu to deliver it to the intended redpient), you are hereby noSfied that any dissemination, e-mail in error, piease no5ty the sender by retum e-mail. LPL 000249 eather Mann Ctint Morefield [[email protected] From: 2011 4:06 PM Sent: Thursday, August 04, [email protected] To: [email protected]; Jan Cook Cc: Subject: Re: Plotter Do you know what time you'll be back? On'rhu, Aug 4, 2011 at 2:1 t PM, ` wrote: Clint We are at the actual hearing at 230 in senate finance. We will be back at bunker later today. A#ter the ltearing is over. Let's try and get it over there later today Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry From: Clint Morefield LPL 000250 ragetoii Vmatt - xererences to RuaRor Ray DiRossi References to Auditor 1 message Fri, Aug 5, 2011 at 8:42 Mary Amos Augsburger Ili 1-3eather and Ray, 1'hanks again for organizing vesterdav's meeting. We appreciate all of your work. We just noticed that the tnost of out apportionment materials refer to Auditor Yost, as "David Yost." FYI for future meetings - he prefers "Dave" rather than "David." We're going to contact the media outlets that also referenced him as David so they know as well. 'I hank.s! jGiarv Mary Amos Augsburger D:rector of ?o+ic9 & Pu'blic :^ffairr Auditor of state Dave Yost sia:e.;,h.us https://mail.google.com/mail/?ui=2&ik=2cd7e5f5aa&x2he"t&cat=Redistricting%20Em... 10/14/2011 Page t of 2 ,'.imail - FV: Ray DiRossi FW: 1 message Heather Mann Clark, Sorry - I have another updated list of House addresses. This includes our persons of interests, potentiaE candidates D &R. Thank you, Heather Mann ,.. Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, Ohio 43206 [6141 352-5819 heathernmannCa^amait com From: Benjamin Yoho (mailto:benyaho(a)gmail.comt Sent: Monday, August 08, 2011 10^57 AM To: Heather Mann Cc: Troy J Subject: Heather, attached is the updated list of address for potential candidates and opponents. httpsJhnait.google.com!mait,?ui°-2&ik='2cd7e55^},"tlfgli^3fpt&cat=Redisiricting°ro20);m 10,t`20f1 utnalt - r vv: Page 2 of 2 Thanks, Ben house_4_chb(1 ).xfs 51 K littps://mail.google.conv'mail/?ui=2&ik- ^cd7c552^^X^a^^53pt&car Redisiricting%2Qf;m... 1(3'14i7611 ^v s° ^ O M O OD N O m a0 O .-i .-^ Ul n.-^ ^ m ^ r^n N°o n u' .-+ ^n v rn n co r r c o N d r N I^(1 N^U 6l T e-I h 1f} tp O •-i Yl c0 VR r V M N M N m O h S( ^D N a' M Ul n C n N m 01 V UI "^ ^-1 ^-i H h 01 M[O C Ol N n O OJ f^-! O tP V^ M CO ^ V.-i m N V•--P tD M tl lJ m M N M W O N V^ Cf z ^rr^ooo ooonocesrc^cceo^oooc^or^ceooc^^^a^o at6.cc^^^ y c y c > v ai o v ^ _ ro 0 C„` .p c v'^ °i c ^_ ^ o 3 La > T ^ r`o ^ v ro Y =_ ^ v u v c 4 L u?^ ^"r` ^ O m 0: ^ N^^ j p^ u i' ^ m^ u c z Y i L N u r° iu o p o t^4^^17¢^c¢min v^ ¢ z^ c ^ p o ^ C y d ^ G ^ ^ N 3^ N C! 2.°a o0 E -_16 °Jo c > o _ v m^ z ve ^ x m m.^ N p3j dE J v t6 3'S O f6 y N C 'a i t9 V^n x^'S "a J z m 4 x in U` Y m m 62 m Q v v v v v a. v v v v w v v N v N v v v v m v v v v N N,v,^ ^°; ^°J ^°'i °^ ^^ s^ o o O o = O o 0 0 0 0 O o O o o Q o o o 0 0 0 0o oa o 0 0 00 oo 0 0 0 0 0 0 x x x x x z x x x x x x S x x x= =m x== x= x x'^ = x y== x= x x 31 ao I^ CC N O.-^ N m V^P, lD n N Ol ^ O N N M d' tn^^^ ^4 H^,.^ ^ MN`µ QI^-i !i 6^N N NN NM N NC N N N N^VI M M Hi M M M(» M m }t e-^ N M C N^D n W T Q W n M O^ O^-1 N M C" Ul W h W 61 O^-f N M c Ul tD ^`+ W m 1 ^Li n W Ol O^^^^,y c^ N mti^"q V N' ^y ^-1 ri N N N N N N N N N N M M M C/I m M m l+J M r4 N M'C 3 Q_ ^ O u N p^ C' O N O N M^O^ QV O^^^^ M Q^ Qt n H; N f+ O M^f1 O^ MOl Cp ^11 O r ul tll M M VkO(!^ Q N^n tp V n MtT W10 O Q rl N:^ R O M ^D ^ v5 0o N^ O ul N i0 T n n ^y n r cn O^O Ot N tp N lD ^/1 d Q O^^n ti N O Q ^A M n N O fR 1n ^/1 ^/) N^ N r W O) W ^D N N r M O O O O^ M^+l N N ti N M N hl H N'^ ^T N^^^ p O O O a ^ O a a O a fL 2 a U a a a^ a cG ' a O 0 p[K cC a O 0 CC C) a a a a p G 6. C U ^C ^T ^N md y C ^ O ^ p ^ u G^ C^ N G ^ d C } } 3 C QE L V 9 C p m vmi ^O " L O iD u} N Y" ^ c E m N i aL+ ^ c-,. -a c x a m ^•° = aa+ E o"' m^`O^ `v o oC`6 `o 0 o v o v'^ G a G h a a G J a F' Vl -^ d Y ^ J Y^} N m F^^ V ^ F V^ C d p c v ^ en y o ,,, ^ c c nr _c °c° a`ani 3 L m^' E E c O c O O > p_ ^ a q N^ QI 0! 3' m ^G ^ N u Y Y_ m'6 L O^ ^ Ol N O O m^ O W^ SN YQ vLL}' O ^^ Q7 V 9^ G= G^ J Vl C^ Q Q > m ^ T d^^ ^= N in 0 V ^ 1 CG J ^ > Vi 2' ^L N Gc VI Y. Q V1 ^ al w o^ w 6^ o^ a^ v a al v w al m. a m N s N dt m N a a^ o^ Q+ v w a^ a+ N ¢^ u^ ^ N N O N^ N N Sp O O O O O O O O O O O O j^ J 3 3.^3 Y^^ 3 3 ^ 3 3 3 7 3 9^^ 3^ 3 3== 3 S S S S 2 S S S S S S S S S S= S S S S S S= S= S= S S= S S S S S S= S S ^--1 N M d' tll t0 t^ N ^l Q^'1 N M Q Yt W r IX3 6) On rt r N n M hV I(1n n.^D ^^ Q ^^-1 N!'^1 ^ N tDV Vh QW Q^n 6^ O u} vT Ill Lh tfl Ill N tF1 V5 ^O ^D lO ^O tD ^D tD tD N r Q Q v Q a c i'^. W O^ O rt N M Q Ul N r W Q1 o rt N(^1 O n W^ Vl ^D^n .n in .n ^o ^ u> .o ^o w^^^o ^ h h n h n ^^ r i/r ^o r o^ cT o.-t rv m a p,^c Q N v mv v v a a Q v^n :rt :n _2 vt !n K m o0 0^ O^ ^+l o o ro N o0 v^ K in vz o V n oo n N W K n^D 61 N m N ut K 1l1 iD N m i^ n u1 m .o ^ L . v 3 C N p a _ s s L c^^ ^ v m^ m L m N N^ 0 a D q Q W p Q O[Z u fl K^ ^ K m ^ 0 F^- ^ ip R ^ N C ro `6 ^ c c Y o v o 0 ^. ^ c^« o.°1v o ^ v.n an 3 «£ U ^ U v w v s t s ^- o= aci c m o 0 3 ra '-' ba r6 aa o`m ^ o^ S os. !L- ' ^ p^ J x a tG u^ 2 l7 ^ S S^. v v v ai v v v v^ v v v v v v vw v v v ^ 3 3 3 3 3 3 7^ J 3 3^ 3; J^ 3 3^ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o a o a o x x x x x x= x x x x x x= x x x s x p.-^ rV m K in tD n W O^ o•+ N m a' ^+1 ^O n ^D T o] o0 op co 0o co co OJ oo M Ol m m O^ T m Ql 01 m m .ti N M K ^`1 t^ n W Q^ O.-1 fti M tF ^/1 tp n 00 Qt W w W W N P Ot O: O^ Ct al ol 01 Ol apo 00 W 00 W o] 3 a M.^-M v^i r^+M .^-+ ^^ O '+ M V V^ W/1 ^`^'N ti O O O V u 6^ NO^^^ m O d, ^O't ^y yO ,.y V N^y y Oy eiq^ .-t4~ .-O O O O N rV N N N rV N N N NN N N O M K a R "' a c v v v c c v v v v a v v v v v v v ^ a v c v v c a v v v v v v v^ v a a e v a _O O O_ O_ O_ O° O°°_ O O O O O_ O_ O O O 6 q O O O o O O O_ o_ O_ O O O O O O O O O .C L L L L L S L.C .C L L L L .G L.C L.G L L L t L L L L L L L L L inm.C O LO L.GO O LO LO LO O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O Q O O O O O O O O ^ L L m m v N S y N yLD -G O GL C C O C Y > L ^ L V^ a j1 .21 O^^ G C C^ O C c> ^ ^^ +-^ 0 3 m m m m O m m m o m^¢ t £ a^ v EE E°p c S c c c c c o o ai o E oi .n m- E ^ ai m w a aE«« v C^> c 3° 3 ' '" " >? 3 o m c^ u 1O >v o'i 'a a' ^ a'^ a; m ai v o 0 0't o 0 0 o c c c c c c a m m y m 3£^ m° ^ m u u u ^ u a 3 3 m 3 z u^^ v u u^ v ^ u u 7^ v^ u o u u° a° N N m a o _° o v v i> ' ^ ? ^ . .+ ¢ > y u- y a «. > >. -° a . n d-_ o ^ ^o N '' ^ o m a a q> ^^ v o^ ^ v >`t a n GE i a 4 J.4e ^ C^ V° o a ^ u Ol O m G c a a'6 a m a^'- 'O K-° rv^ N ^ 3 m- a c^ v m a rc 'q i c O v^ 3 m "6 co w- E w " c v 'v '° ^^ :c c v o^ Yo Y c o.^ '= o¢ °° a c m 3-a c in ^ v c r°`o 0 y^ O« 6^ O C ro Km ^^ Q+ ^ v 2 v^-6 y._ ^ :S2 ^ o O o o v^^^ N lp N'^ N d O W^ 6_^ m ^p ^^ Ol m ^ Q 2? ^ u W 0. O S V 2 ^ d K O N Q Vi O O V` 2 W V^^ W N d Y^ W LL m V f- M o 0 o w .-a u^ rn ^n I^ v^ ..+ueNg ^ v °a M^O n u^ .-i ^O m r-rv n v ^^n O o O O O p O O O O O o O O O O O O p O O O p O O O O p O O p O O D O O O o O O 00000000000 0000000000000000000000000000^ a s cp O^c ^ O ^^ u O N C ^ a ^e -p H m ^ ' . ^ w > > C C a0 y C m v on o 3^ u^ci Y^ cp c o n c ^ m o m a ^> C C ^ O O C V O o ^ o c c c E p a m U3 ta0 -C d-o 0 ' Q V Q O o^ N N d ia o v - Mo m IC ^^['i1 d rs m ic E l p q z^.r q z w^n u.'^ zp v ^ m^^ x g o^=¢¢a V u 0 ^ j m ._ z m ^ q m O q d w w Z •.+ o a^ ^ m > ai > 6^^° b n. e>i^ N q` O r>^ m^.p G N U`> ^^0 3 d^ o° a' Q m -pb m:n v^.^ Q^'^ p Z y a 4^ v" O c'^ p o>+^ o U^ . s al 'O K 4 ^^ O m O c o'- m m^ ai . ^ a^ _ E o '° t T cc Z c p•- i; v mo m 3s p u a`^ 3 a ma ^ C C^ ^ vni W N!L oQ' q" W O Q"C m 4 N N m S^ ^ q2 m c U OI N^ 3 C E C^i C C q m d N d m ^' m f6 0 5 S.n+ vi m S ocD OZa ^ O O N O O 6M1 m N M N O^^'* O ti M N V N N ^ t^ N ul O V e^-I .i ^ O O^ n^ Q^1 ^O ^ O O N op v m O t^D t0 0 "'vva^`^vv 0 vovcv ooaavoaa 0 aJ J 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o a o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 O O O O U O O O O O O O O O O O O O D b z c y c on m .u v`°i v v o o^^ ^ '^ >¢ci ^ c o ^o op C^ R R C L^ N N u a N L m^ y O ^ N a O rc a z m m-a c m m L m ^' ro c Z m o, m^^ c° ^ N a^ > c Q; N ^^ ^ N i N m Q N'^ c t c Q }^ ^^^ m v QQ v 'p O` L M` D' ` U o ^35 O C N "6 ^n >. OC 0 D V C y -p u c N a^n m^^^u C o j L 9^ m^ o a a vi x w u z v m v'i 5 a t7 "' ^ z ^ v!'i u x i^ Heather Mann Heather Mann (heathernmann@gmai[co 1 From: Ivtonday, August 08, 2011 12:27 PM Sent: 'Benjamin Yoho' To: Copy of house_aug08_chb.xis Subject: Copy of house,_aug08_ chb.xls Attachments: Can you denote who these candidates are democrat and which are not? LPL 000260 ^v Z o M o w o0 0 .-' .a ^n r °..° r^n in o r ^n ^" r. a m N m ^.Mn v rn r co n r v-as a o. d G l0 0 ^ r N cQ o N O^ n rv m OMi O lh ^ N e-t n^+t Ol `"^ ^^ O^1 ^ r^^.i r1 l0 d n N Ul N^ Q^ ^ d, ^ N^ ^'1 3^ n m M^-i ei a-! n G1 m y' CO a^^^o^rc^aaan aoana^^^^o^a^oc^nnar^^nnn^^^^rc 0 0 E -o a t ^.x ^^ u ^ m C ei ^ v z Z c y E °n 3maLLomso°c^7U'^QVU'`u:ni3am^a^z^n^xmm ^zmaiv,c^r'm^n o ^ c v N^ R C N y m ^ o E 3 o m a^ ^ m 3 v o ^ v^ Z^ Cl V N-O^ C O^ -Q C Y V^ C C C E ^ L ^ E ^ V 1- L 1- V V ^ cL Q Z LL V 4 rt ^ V' ^ Y 4[O ^] N^ v v as v v v v v v v v v v v y a+ v» v v v c h » » » » ^ ^^ '^ '^ 3^ J>> 3 3 J^ v v v y v vvi ».vi^ °1 v 3 3 3 0 0 o O o 0 0 O O O C_ S S G! 7> 3 3 3>>> J> O O O O O S 2 S S S S S S S S _. Y O C O D O O D O DO S S Ot O N N M C' Cl :b. .. _. S S S S^- S S S S M m M M M M M(+i RY C4 M F=. S S S S S S S S S N N N N N ^ N 1^ W Ol O^^ N M M M M M m M 01 .O ';-t N M O vt ^p N.:N .N N N N NN N N N M M M ^ r` h tn O t0 C1 ^ ^ N ip v? O d' O O ^ e-^ N O V Vl m f^ N O M ^ LN ul Ti ^.h-F oP u b`^ Ol 00 O O rv^^-t '-t V N.4 t0 ^l e^+t n N Ul .^-^ O O¢ rr a¢ o rc ¢ 0 m ¢ C, ^ a a : p 0 m 4 P C) 0 a O a ¢ cc C) rz ¢ ^ 0 o m O 0 c m a' o c E T s on C ^ c v- ai c^ a 3 u v c > c' x a 0 T W ^ m }-C ^ O ^.Y Y^ U'^ l7 T D ' C U^'6 9]- oCU ^ N s ^n p,^D C^ 3 E ap^ m C c ^ ^' ^ N ^ ^' m rvi o u D D >_C ro N ^ Y^_ ^'C N O^p ^ N W C 6 ¢ ^ m t9 S O u°^. T..^i Q:D I t,) al ^G S^ U' V` } Ul fL ^ UI ^ vl ti Q^ 2 N N C] U U C m C T N ^ C N ^^ N C N t Y p ^p U G N Y N C tli ^ ^ p ^ c E m m ^ ^ I T C 9 ip o D D 0 - a -, m J _1 2' f- ^l1 d Y c' U Y V1 F- U^ ^ 'Y -i Y F 1 N[P F- Si c Ul N N ^ 61 ^ N 0l N N N N ^ N y N^ N QI N a 41 ^ d N N N^ ^ 3 J 7^ 3 3^^ C 6) N N N N^1 N ^^ 3 3 O 0 0 0 D D 0 0 0 0 3^ 3 3 3 J 3 J J 3 3 3 O 3p p3 GC^^ O O 3C O O O O C 6 O O O C O D O O D C 0 0 0 S 2 2 S 2 2 2 2 S 2 S 2 S S S S S== 2 2 2 2 2 T 2 2=^^^ 2 O^S 2 N S m= 2 2 V 2= N ^-t N vm. N ^ ^ irt t^i^ u3^ W Vti: v ^J l^ ^L1 '.O ^ ^ ^ " h ^ h h n p`i N M V N^ h' ^`T' O ^ V^3 V^t C d' v C' V v^ N N ^O r^ Co m a.. N^ V ^ c• N m. v vt . ^tp h CO m a :. \D lD +D tD f^ h 1^ tph W 41 O.-+N N Ulm rfIll ut tt) t!t tn tp ^D tp tp '^ ^D a^-1 N m V U1 :^ Yt. YI . tf^ - a a v v o _ v -.v v e v ...... o ^+ ^ .n ca o n o, v o vt O O 06 N O^ K V ^I1 OI O n ^a m + N K p O 6 O c^ ^ r.C CL R' K ^ ^ ^ a o a cc p N U O v C .Y^O 3 u C w ^. s c a o o Q c O N m a o n o 0 0 - - ? N a+ O S ^ E ^ ^ V N^Y N ^l) i o ^ m p O O O 0 A U ^ ^ 3 U R Qy p t6 ^ C 3 ^ L ^ ^ LL 2 S V Y V^5 T U m ° cc x o C^:^M z a rc v T 2 m 3 s -p uf ? L sT R j L N a ^ n a n ^ m V y C C U^ C O G G W ^ m m^ o 0 0^ o^ o^o _ Q 6[G V Q Q 'tX ^ tt' ^ O K tD C3 n V- ^ m O Q 'v d p v o v m w u ^ v u u o a v v m m a^ cr ¢+ v c: aj N v m m ^Y 3 N N ^U aV U) 3 3 7 > > 3 O O o O O ^ o o =o S S S S S S O O O O O O O O O = S 2 S z z s S S S 07 rn in n_.-p :• .,_ 2 x = = x = rn m 0000 oa'o m m ^ rco m m o^ N m v o cz o 0 0 v;:^+i .co ^ rn cn m o 0 0 0 0 ca,n w.^ ^ ^',^ ro o^::ro m w W ^ m ^ O ^ rv Ql rl CQ n n O 'n N N 'y ti n M1 fn ON t0 N O N^ O O vn <7 ^ V) T vi a' m ^n m•-^ n^ w r3 CO N N R) fry t0 h N f*1 N N N ^ ^ (O rv'+ n n n ^' n^ m m 0 0 x K^ K K K K¢ ac m CC oc ¢= K K¢ K K K K o[ 2 5 0 N C C tp 2 ^ } ¢N C5 C N L O LL O N w m ^ ^ LL o m (ry m m 1^- ^ o m` S w^° _Y U 3 0 ^ x ^ a J v C m a ^ m ^° m i o > n oo i w ^ ai Cs > L '^ ^ j L oCU 2it^ru y L'O . ^ u O L^- p C a) > S] > o m w rC ^ O^ o. ^ Q Y ^ 1- Z K K O V^^= [^ K ^ Y ^ o0 ^ ro^ a^^ a a ti -a o v-a -a v v v v a ti'o v^ ad -o ti C C C C c C C^^ Ca c c^ c c s m m m m m CU mU eu ^p m m m m m m m!o V U V V C^J l1 V U V V U U lJ U V V V V V V U U V N N al 01 al al N N m al ¢+ d m N aJ m a! ^ a N ^ N N ^ r x x x s x x= x x x z x r= x= 3^ x x= x x x x x f:. O^^ sr.,:.¢'.:.d •.p... -`.: ,•. ^.• ;^ .... O W Vt N N .-i a^ rcY CO m Ol O^ ip n n OJ aa\tt^^ N N t^ t^'.} w f: [f} N v^l vni^vni 3nl ^i cNO W N p '-1 N rtl ^^ ^..!^t . t0 n W ^.:Ot 0.^. `i ^N :rtI . V Jt ^p 1^ Op (P Oth .i MN (n^ VM ^+1 ^rt 3^. ^^ ^^ o N P1 N W.W O a0 r^i :V V).rD r:r^ 4 i.l): C.m N.-a N. f+l N«-.DO :m V' ^I^ ,it o0 . e-i N ei O.CI.:O V ul V.M .-1rtt N O M'Q d' V O C; N w.b.:^',^ O N^M # O.-1..W y O O O O O O O O O O O O O O o O O O O O O O O D O O O O O O O o_ O O D O OZ OL OL ^C L L L L -C L L L.C L L L ^ L L ,^^ LO LO L.CO O -O LO LO LO LO LO LO LO LO LO LO LO LO ^O LO LO O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O c °II m T m a S O S v G o Y ^ v _ _ _ _ _ ` C (`J a o t'^ a 0 c C Z C n^ C O C C ^ C O^ Y 2 .n C-OU t3 5 Q.O m ^ o F C C C c C 0 a; m^ 0 3^o m ra ^c o m m m p ti a; ¢ i E a^ -o E E E°Q c c c c c c c o o a o . .v m > > c Lj al N 3 > c o 3 ^ c u 't. ^ .u E al ' E > W^ N m N m v N v D 0 O m O O O c c. C C G C L m rp w^a y o 0 0^^ o ^ v > w ?? m^ z^i u t7 t9 c.) u u^C 'u u'u U u ij _°; O n u ^ D cj _`0 'u a. U u o- ~S J-1 m 4 m O U ^ M N y O N> O N 01 . d ' K>' yv. `^ v mp 3 m a > v d` o m ^ o r^ `^ °1 ^ ai ^ m^>`Z > C^^ y . v t- ¢ o c ^ ¢>^¢ a > > c c ^.; Q o ,^, .. J N O! N- .(J O m Q C y^ D^ C U N Q y Q^;a W Q^^.O K"6 ^ v^ o G) w o C m n o£ ^c ^^`' >y a' cc 3 J^ i s O o °° i^ m> j o a^ m o'S ^ a "OC = ,; c^o _ m^ co w v o ^ c o c - o¢ c m 3a c ^ m :c - c v >^^ ^ a cY f^ ^n 4^n O ^ C7 S ^^n v o`v ^^ w a m'm v v ^+ ^`6 °^ S?3 ^ u`^. ui i O S V Z uo. 3 w u. J m u ^- cG Q in ui u^ c'c w vi a. Y N h m O o O D 0 o a O O O O O O O O O P Q O O O O o O O O O O O o 0 S L L L L a L 0 0 0 0 o O O O O O o 0 0 o o o o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ^ D ^ C u ^ O O O C ,^V_. . V N r_ U^ C1 0 N ^ ^ , y c C T p w O O O a a 0 o d ^ 0 J' j N o ar c ^ o r^ n ° ` ° D Y N N vi Z Q Z ivY y^e t6 0 0 > u 3 ^ ^: d Z dc.°3=a a j ¢1 o ^ N ^ ] = c N G N ] C vy ?a' 3 L ^ ' N L ^ N Q 0 F > v ^ 4 ^ Q Lv ^ 1 a+ o0 °r ^ 3'o ma ao R J ^ m 3? m v L w ry)^ Kk ^^11 ' N n d' d' .ti ON N!Y1 N.^^ " N .;,^y N:d':-N N N N d n S:O^ cD ^6O.a ^ O v ^"Q a: a rn' m m m m O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O a 0 a 0 0 0 0 0 L:E 0 0 o c o 0 0 0 0 0 C L L S.C L L L.E C .E S^ Q Q Q Q o Q o o o o Q o Q o 0 o iE Z ;C L L L S.C L.C O LD sO SO OS- O LO SO O O O O O O t7 O O O ^ a N a ^ C 0) > ^ 9 9 .12 G C a+ 14 ^_-^ « C ^ E d E E C C! > > d } > y ^ ^ > C > C N yII ^ N p ^ C N 3 ^ 3 C C R _O N C a^^ Q w C i m C N p .^ O N 6 O v v u c m-t N U Z u u^ V^ ^L N V} Q :5 tJ 3 J ^ l'1 Q ,ci c7 N a N 3 Z c v c m ^ v > 6 aa o^ 7 ^ ^ o v a C ^ > > C Q > ^ D N ^c U QoY ^ v O ^ d m ` ` c m O^s a N ^m^ R a Fil 3 3 7 Q C o u u 3 0 b m Z U m an o o O O o 0 o O O o O o 0 0 s L ^ s t L L t t :E Z p O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O Q O O O O O O O O O > C y m m o - ^ c ` o ti > C c C - aj n ^ :0 V Vc o3 ro L C^ o ^ ^ C G m C p O n U U m iJ ^ 2 2 4 H > Q> a 6 m ai O ai N p v o_ o ^ Y ^ - o ^ a` > 1° d o > u v i ^ v o °1 0 o^ -0 3 a N v o -c c o c m n u w a y a m 3 m CO 0 0 ^ E n - > O K a N G L ^ Q d V V U U^ Heather Mann From: Heather Mann [heathernmanna7gmail.com] Sent: Monday, August 08, 2011 12:13 PM To: 'Benjamin Yoho' Subject: FW: Maptitude Can you help me respond to the below? Neather N_ Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, Ohio 43206 (614) 352-5819 heathernmann@8mail_com -----Original Message----- Froni: Clark Bensen/POLIDATA (mailto•clarktapolidata.or^ Sent: Monday, August 08, 2011 11:58 AM To: 'Heather Mann' Subject: RE: Maptitude Good... Should I assume all the new House names are potential candidates? POLIDAT'A Demographic and Political Guides I www. olidata.us POLIDATA ® political Data Analysis ^ www olidata.org POLIDATA ® at CafePress I www cafepress.co^polidata POLIDATA ® at Lulu ( www lulu.com/olidata Clark Bensen I POLIDATA LLC I Tel: 703-690-4066 Vermont Office: 1303 Hayward Road I P.Q. Box 530 ( Corinth, VT 05039 Virginia Office: 3112 Cave Court I Lake Ridge, VA 22192 efax: 202-318-0793 1 email: clark2polidata.org -----Original Message----- F'rom: f+eather Mann Lmailto-heathernrann(dgmail.com Sent: Monday, August 08, 2011 11:51 AM To: 'Clark Bensen/POLIDATA'; ' Ray DiRossi' Cc: 'Braden, E. Mark'; ' ]ohn B. Morgan' Subject: RE: Maptitude y adept than I thought. We figured it out. Guess S r._- c g = ^*+ Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, Ohio 43206 (614) 352-5819 heathernmann(dgmail.com LPL 000269 priginal Message--- From: Clark Bensen/POLIDATA (rrtailto:clark(^polidata.or Sent: Tuesday, August 02, 2011 4:43 PM To: 'Ray DiRossi' Cc: 'tfeather N. Mann - gmail'; 'Braden, E. Mark'; '7ohn B. Morgan' Subject: RE: Maptitude Fixed Cafaro...oddly enough, I still needed to hand edit two other addresses, Homestead Drive t need to do previously... to Dr and White Birch Lane to Ln, which I d id no POLIDATA Demographic and Political Guides ^ www. ol i POLIDATA 0 Political Data ® Analysis i www.polidata.org POLIDATA ® at CafePress I www.cafepresscom/ olidata POLIDATA at Lulu www_lulu__ccm/ po lidata Clark Bensen I POLIDATA LLC I Tel: 703-690-4066 Vermont Office: 1303 Hayward Road I P.O. Box 530 I Corinth, VT 05039 Virginia office: 3112 Cave Court I Lake Ridge, VA 22192 efax: 202-318-0793 1 email: clark,^aoolidata.orR -----Original Message-- - - From: Ray DiRossi (mailto-raydirossi(?agmail.coml Sent: Tuesday, August 02, 2011 4:29 PM To: Clark Bensen/POLIDATA Cc: Heather N. Mann - gmail; Braden, E. Mark; John B. Morgan Subject: Re: Maptitude Cafaro is Hubbard Ohio 44425 On Tue, Aug 2, 2011 at 3:41 PM, Clark Bensen/POLIDATA > POLIDATA 0 Demographic and Political Guides I www,polidata.us POLIDATA > ® Political Data Analysis I, „y,w o7idata.or^ POLIDATA ® at CafePress > www cafepress com/polidata POLIDATA ^ at Lulu I www lulu com/polidata - LPL 000270 > Clark Bensen ^ POLIDATA LLC Tel: 703-690-4066 Verrnant Office: 1303 > Nayward Road P_0. Box 530 C Corinth, VT 05039 > Vi.rgirria office: 3112 Cave Court I Lake Ridge, VA 22192 > efax: 202-318-0793 1 email: clark2polidata.0rg > > mm > > LPL 000271 Heather Mann Mary Amos Augsburger [[email protected]] From: Sent: Tuesday, August 09, 2011 5:25 PM ,gmaiLcom To: Heather Mann; raydirossi(o) Cc: Brenda L. Rinehart Subject: Request for Allocation - draft2docx Attachments: Request for Allocat4on - draft2.docx tIi Heather and Ray, Attached is a draft of our request for an allocation tca cover our costs for software and a personnel services contact w-ith Niatt Borges - both relating to Auditor Yost's apportionment re.sponsibilities. I have not been involved in these discussions, but it's my understandang the leaders are comfortable with these allocarions, but I wasn't sure whether the request should be dltected to the co-chairs of the Task Force? Please advise. Appreciate your assi.stance 'I'hanks! ?Vlary LPL 000272 Dave Yost, Auditor of State August 8, 2011 The I-lonorable William G. Batchelder Spea k er, Ohio House of Representatives Co-Chair, Task Force on Redistricting, Reapportionme nd Demographic Research 77 South High Street -14th Floor Columbus, Ohio 43215 The Honorable Capri S. Cafaro Minority Leader, Ohio Senate Co-Chair, Task force on Redistricting, R Statehouse 1 Capitol Square, 3rd Floor Columbus, OH 43215 Dear Speaker Batchelder and onVedistricting, I am writing to re 511 to my office for use in Reapportionmen services related to performing my obtaining equipme ent Board. constitutio Dave Yost Auditor of State 88 East $roari Street, Fifth Floor, CsEucr=bus, Ohio 43215-3506 Phone: 614-466-4514 or800-282-8378 Fax: 614-466-4490 www.aud itor.sta te.oh.us LPL 000273 Page 1 of 1 From: David B. Potts Sent: Tuesday, August 09, 2011 1:03 PM To: Brenda L. Rinehart Mapping discussions Subject: Brenda, I want to make you aware that I have been working with Matt to develop a Franklin County map that contains ten districts. Today, Franklin County has eight districts. Matt and I met Friday in the Mapping Room. He gave me instructions to develop the ten districts which I did over the weekend. We met again yesterday to review the ten districts. He gave me some additional instructions which I have completed. He asked me to leave a hard copy of the plan so he can pick it up. I will drop it off with you. Dave I/I3AZD^I 000 51e:///E:/COUNSEL/_CASES%20ELECTIONS Wilson%20v.%20Kasich/Auditor%20RF... LPL 000274 From: Griffin, Lisa To: Grodhaus Michael; RE: Apportionment Board Regional Hearings Subject: Date: Friday, August 12, 2011 3:14:38 PM Thank you. Lisa Griffin Legislative Aide Ohio House o£Representatives 614-466-9068 From: Grodhaus, Michael [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Friday, August 12, 2011 2:34 PM To: Griffin, Lisa Subject: Re: Apportionment Board Regional Hearings Yes, I will need hotel rooms in Cleveland and Canton. Sent from my Verizon Wireless 4GLTE smartphone -- Reply message ----- From: "Griffin, Lisa" Michaei, Thank you for your email. I currently have you listed as attending the hearings as the designee for the Governor Monday through Wednesday and Diane attending on Thursday and Friday. I will not put you down for a hotel Sunday night per your email. Will you be needing a hotel room Monday night in Cleveland and/or Tuesday night in Canton? Please let me know if the above information has been updated. Thankyou! Lisa Griffin LPL 000275 Legislative Aide Ohio House of Representatives 614-466-9068 From: Grodhaus, Michael [mai!to:[email protected]] Sent: Tuesday, August 09, 2011 4:32 PM To: Griffin, Lisa Cc: Brey, Diane Subject: RE: Apportionment Board Regional Hearings Lisa, At present, I do not believe that the Governor will be attending any of the public hearings. The plan now is that I will attend the hearings scheduled for Monday through Wednesday, and our Deputy Chief Counsel Diane Brey wiil be attending the hearings on Thursday and Friday. I will not need a hotel room for Sunday night in Lima. That hearing starts at 10:00 am and it wi!l be easy for me to drive to Lima on Monday morning. D. Michael Grodhaus Chief Counsel office of Ohio Governor John R. Kasich (614) 644-0825 michael [email protected] www.governor.ohio.gov This message and any response to it may constitute a public record and thus may be publicly available to anyone who requests it. From: Griffin, Lisa [mai!to:[email protected]] Sent: Tuesday, August 09, 2011 3:19 PM To: Grodhaus, Michael Subject: Apportionment Board Regional Hearings Importance: High Mike, Good afternoon! Attached is the Apportionment Board Regional Hearing schedule LPL 000276 that was approved during last week's meeting. If possible, would you please let me know by Friday, August 12 whether Governor Kasich himself or a designee will be attending each of the hearings? Hotel arrangements will be provided for the Governor (or his designee) plus one staff member for the evenings of Sunday 8/21 in Lima, Monday 8/22 in Cleveland, and Tuesday 8/23 in Canton. Please also indicate who will need a hotel room reserved and for which nights. Also, I know security is a concern for the Governor. If he will be attending any of the meetings, I will let the universities know in order for their security to prepare and get in contact with the Governor's security team. Please let me know if I can answer any questions or be of further assistance. Thank you! Lisa Griffin Legislative Aide Ohio I-Iouse of Representatives 614-466-9068 LPL 000277 ragn I ui I lrlll9n - lvlcnu ui reUASUIGUI]g 16em5 AVr lv1Cilaus Ray DiRossi Menu of redistricting items for Niehaus 1 message Mon, Aug 15, 2411 at 7:14 PM Ray DiRossi Matt Here is a menu to choose from Counties with Rights graphic - A quick primer on what the constitional issue in NE ohio is HDs in SD 10 - Widener HDs in SD 14 - Niehaus HDs in SD 13 - Manning HDs in SDs 02 and 11 (Wagoner and Fedor) HDs in SDs 05 and 06 (Beagle and Lehner) HDs in SD 01, 12 and 26 - Hite, Faber and Burke HDs in SD 17 (Daniels) HDs in SO 22 (ObhoP} SW Ohio - SDs in Butler, Warren and Hamilton counties (S Jones, Coley, Seitz and Kearny) NE Ohio Constitutional Issues encompassing (SDs 24, 21, 23, 25, 18, 32, 33) and maybe SD 19 (Jordan) Franklin County 9 vs 10 HDs (SDs 03, 15 and 16) Summit County (SDs 27 and 28) LaRose and Sawyer HDs in SD 29 (Oelslager) HDs in SD 31, 20 and 30 - Schaffer, Balderson and Wilson 10/14/201 t https://maii.google.com/maiU9ui=2&ik=2cd7e5 LPL 000278^t&cat=Redistricting°u20Em... From: Ray DiRossi To: Schuler. Matt Cc: Hutras. Debby Subject: Aportionment Board schedule Date: Tuesday, August 16, 2011 10:48:00 AM Attachments: 2011 AB Regional Hearinos.doc< Matt on the attached document... Heather and I have divided up the days we will each be attending and presiding over the regional hearings We will both be at the 1st one in Lima and then we will split the remaining 10 I was assuming that Niehaus would attend the Cincinnati one for sure and maybe Dayton Hopefully this helps as you determine which days you will be attending as the designee... and what days Troy might be the designee... Ray MSchuler emails produced 000002 LPL 000279 From: Ray DiRossi To: Schul r Matt Cc: Hr t as Debbv Board Hearing Designe Subject: Fwd: Apportionment Date: Wednesday, August 17, 2011 11:42:18 PM Attachments: 2011 H arin Schedgle 8-17-11 with attend -- Forwarded message ------From: Griffin, Lisa <' ' a Griffin(o)ohr state oh us> Date: Wed, Aug 17, 2011 at 7:30 PM Subject: Apportionment Board Hearing Designees TO: "haatharnmann(Olqmall Com° Heather & Ray, Below (and attached) is a schedule of who will be attending each of the Apportionment Board Regional Hearings next week. Lisa Griffin 2011 APPORTIONMENT BOARD REGIONAL HEARING SCHEDULE Monday, August 22, 2011 Ohio State University - Lima 10:00AM - 12:00PM Lima Michael Grodhaus, Auditor Yost, Halle Pelger, Rep. Clyde, Senate designee University of Toledo 3:30PM - 5:30PM Toledo Michael Grodhaus, Auditor Yost, Halle Pelger, Rep. Clyde, Senate designee Tuesday, August 23, 2011 MSchuler emails produced 000005 LPL 000280 9:00AM - 11:00AM Cleveland Cleveland State University Michael Grodhaus, Auditor Yost, Halle Pelger, Leader Budish, Senate designee 1:00PM - 3:00PM Akron University of Akron Michael Grodhaus, Auditor Yost, Halle Pelger, Rep. Clyde, Senate designee 5:00PM - 7:00PM Youngstown Youngstown State University Michael Grodhaus, Auditor Yost, Halle Pelger, Leader Cafaro, Senate designee Wednesday, August 24, 2011 9:00AM - 11:00AM Canton Walsh University Michael Grodhaus, Auditor Yost, Halle Pelger, Sen. Skindell, Senate designee 3:00PM - 5:00PM Marietta Marietta College Michael Grodhaus, Auditor Yost, Halle Pelger, Rep. Clyde, Senate designee I Thursday, August 25, 2011 10:00AM - 12:00PM Dayton University of Dayton Diane Brey, Auditor Yost, Halle Pelger, Sen. Skindell, Senate designee 3:00PM - 5:00PM Cincinnati University of Cincinnati Diane Brey, Auditor Yost, Halle Pelger, Sen. Skindell, Senate designee Friday, August 26, 2011 MSchuler emails produced 000006 LPL 000281 9:00AM - 11:00AM Newark The Ohio State University - Newark Diane Brey, Auditor Yost, Matt Damschroder, Sen. Skindell, Senate designee 2:00PM - 4:00PM Columbus Columbus State Community College Diane Brey, Mary Amos-Augsburger, Matt Damschroder, Sen. Skindell, Senate designee Lisa Griffin Legislative Aide Ohio House of Representatives 614-466-9068 MSchuler emails produced 000007 LPL 000282 rage i or i Crmatt- tno subieCt) Ray DiRossi (no subject) 1 meSsage _.....^_..._.._.----.___. _._. _._.. Thu, Aug 18, 2011 at 5:47 PM Ray DiRossi updated wi,h my edits ¢. 2011-08 Regional Hearings Script.docx `- 20K https:%'m^til.google.com/mail ?ti ?Ri-=2ed7e5iPi7nnn2 3 pt&search=sent&zh==tilded.. 10i2i;201 APPORTTONNIENT BOARD REGIONAL HEARINGS SCRIPT 1. Call to Order & Introduction of Panel SPCR.ETAI2Y: We uow call to orcfer the [name location] regional hearing of the Ohio Apportio iment Board. As people arrive xk'ho would like to testify, we would ask that you please "fill out a witness slip on the table and provide them to the Lisa or Kyle [indicate .rtcrljJ. The 2011 Apportionment Board, which is responsible for drawing districKS for the Oh;o Senate and the Ohio Elouse of Representatives, held its initial meeting on August 4, 2011 _ At the meeting, the Board adopted rules which require a series of public heariu;s throughout the state to gatlter public input and comment and appoittted [Heather ;t4ann^Ra3; DzRossi l and I as Joint Secretaries of the Board. Seeing that the Vice Chair of the o-'lppot-tiotunent Board (State Auditor Dave Yost) is here with us today - I will ask if Auditor Yost would preside over this regional hearing. [flcrnd.s gavel to Auditor] H. Opening Statement AUDITOR YOST: I'hatik you. Will the Secretary pleasc call the roll, and during this attendance roll call would each member ptcase state their name and which office they represe.nt, if they are present as a designee. [secretcrry calls the roll] We would first like to thank [unfver•szty name and contaets] for hosting us today, as well as Lisa firiffn who coordinated arrangements for these hearings. I would like to remind everyone that the purpose of the hearing is to gather information; contments, and iatput regarding the upcoming reconf guration of the House and Senate district lincs. The Apportionment Board and the panel before you is not responsible for re-drawing Ohio's congressional districts. New eongressional districts will be established by the state legisfature as a bill that will be voted upon by the members of the Ohio House of Representatives and the Ohio Senate. That bill then would have to be signed or vetoes by the Governor. We would ask all of the witne.sses limit their comments and testi,mony to the matter before the Apportionment Board - that being the Ohio House and Ohio Senate districts. ^_T LPL 000284 We're here to tisten today. We're not here to debate you; we're not here to debate one anotlter. We're here to get input frotn Ohioans on the apporticnment process and how it impacts your comtnanities aaid yotu' representation in the Ohio General Assembly. Today - we have a timited amount of time for the hearing (f nppliccx6le see are crtso schedaiJcd to hcrv<+ a hearing hrter todav in (insert location), and we want to give everyone a full opportunity to offer their input. We are sche.julcd here for two hours. and we may ask witnesses to Innit their testimony in the interest of tinie and out of courtesy for other persons who wish to address the panel. In Ohio, as in most states, legislative reapportionment occurs in the years ending in' I", which are also the years in which the federal census figures are released by the U.S. Department of i C'ommerce- The eeistrs figures released this year indicate that Ohio has a population of 11,536,5[)4 people. 'I'hat means that ideally each of t.be 99 House districts should contain 116,5.30 people, atld each of the 33 Senate districts should contain 349,590 peoptc. Anyone who has researched, or msdertakeat the actually drawing of legislative districts, krtows that this process involves far more than soinebody puttin4 roughiy the sanie number of people in each district. In Ohio, the General Assembly districts must conform to'traditional redistiicting principles and other requirements that are embodi.ed in Article XI of the Ohio Constitution. Article kI eontains specific rules governing the construction of these districts, ineiuding several tayers of sometimcs complex requirements. In addition to the Ohio C`onstitut.ion, the Board must also comply with all applicable federal laws, most notably the Voting Rights Act. Because these hearings are being bsld for the purpose of receiving your input in the process, we are not gaing to go over the details of the law. However, copies of Article XI of the Ohio Constittitfon, as well as other information such as population ehanges, the apportionment process, and laow the public may submit plans are available for you at the table. We enceurage you to pick these up and review them as they are the same guidelines the board has to follow as it draws legislative districts. A few other items before we begin: these proceedings will be transcribed by a court reporter so that the Board in its deliberations mav consider things that are said here today - so please speak clearly and loud enough for the panel and the audience members and our court reporter to hear. If you have written testimony, please subriit it to our staff so that it niay be included in the official record of the proceeding. We will make sure that all testimotty received at the hearing is available on the Secretary oi` State's Gvebsite at rvww.rEShapeohio._org. As the Secretaru ! Secretaty's designee is here with us today, I would ask for a brief overview of the website at this timc. III. Witnesses ^_ _--- I ( ^AI;DI- I ---OR: -We - will- ---- now -- beLin ------with our frst--- witness liere todaY_ 1VFraMrs_ narnc Ptease state LPL 000285 an<1 spe[) yaw' name for the recorcl. [N%itness ojfers teslimon},r AUDITOR: Thank you for yoar testimony. Are there any questions for the witness? Seeing none, I will now call Ivtr.JMrs. [name] to offer testimony. [PG'ifmss oj!ers fesiimony, etc.] IV. Adjourn AUDIOR: Are there any other wiinesses present to offer testintony? Seeing none, is there any further business to come before this regional hearing of the 2011 Apportionment Board? If not, we stand adjoui7ned untii our next regional hearing at [tinze, cTcre, location]. LPL 000286 From: Mary Amos Augsburqer To: Ray DiRossi; Subject: RE: Date: Friday, August 19, 2011 11:46:00 AM Thanks, Ray. I really appreciate it. I was checking on Sunday afternoon, but have not gotten final sign off yet. We'll plan on the 29th at 4:30. Mary From: Ray DiRossi [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Friday, August 19, 2011 11:46 AM To: Mary Amos Augsburger Subject: FYI I can and will adjust my personal conflict on August 29th for the 4:30 p.m. meeting So looks like 4:30 p.m. will work... Ray AOS email search produced 000032 LPL 000287 Heather Mann From: Heather Mann [[email protected]] Sent: Saturday, August 20, 2011 8:07 PM To: 'Schuler, Matt' Cc: 'Troy Judy; 'Matthew T. Schuler'; '[email protected]' Subject: RE: Meetings Follow Up Flag: Follow up Flag Status: Flagged Great! Troy is as well. I've blocked off both days in case we don't get through everything on Saturday O Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, Ohio 43206 (614) 352-5819 heathernmann email.com From: Schuler, Matt Imaitto:Matt [email protected] Sent: Saturday, August 20, 2011 7:53 PM To: Heather Mann Cc: Troy Judy; Matthew T. Schuler; raydirossi(agmail.com Subject: Re: Meetings i can be available both days. On Aug 20, 2011, at 11:24 AM, "Heather Mann" Dear Matt and Troy: Ray and I would like to set up a "decision tree" and timefrarne within to get specific direction on the various plans and options upon which we have worked. Each of you have had an initial walk-through on mostly the same areas, but we would like to reserve several hours of your time to jointly lay out the options with the other areas of the state and review slight modifications we have been making based on feedback. Based on these meetings, we ean generate a list of decision points upon which we need further direction in order to move forward. Trying to get the four of us during the work week will become increasingly difficult. Therefore, would either or botb of °: k; t.rirervir g t5ntcs ^ocrrk for you . Saturday, August 27`h -- I OAM to 2PM • Sunday, August 281h - I OAM to 2PM LPL 000288 Also, we would like to know how you envision getting feedback from Speaker Batchelder and President Niehaus. Do you see us doing further presentations to them jointly, relaying through you to them the need/information on final decisions, or a combination on both? In either event, should we ca7endar some times for meetings with them? Thank you, FIeather & Ray Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, Ohio 43206 (614) 352-5819 heathemmann Ca^ gmai l. eorn 4 LPL 000289 Heather Mann From: Heather Mann [heathernmann a gmaii.com) Sent: Saturday, August 20, 2011 11:24 AM To: 'TroyJudy'; MatthewT. Schuler (mschu([email protected]) Cc: [email protected]' Subject: Meetings Dear Matt and Troy: Ray and I would like to set up a°decision tree" and timeframe within to get specific direction on the various plans and options upon which we have worked. Each of you have had an initial walk-through on mostly the same areas, but we would like to reserve several hours of your time to jointly lay out the options with the other areas of the state and review slight modifications we have been making based on feedback. Based on these meetings, we can generate a list of decision points upon which we need further direction in order to move forward. Trying to get the four of us during the work week will become increasingly difficult. Therefore, would either or both of the following times work for you • Saturday, August 27`"-1OAM to 2PM • Sunday, August 281'-10AM to 2PM Also, we would like to know how you envision getting feedback from Speaker Batchelder and President Niehaus. Do you see us doing further presentations to them jointly, relaying through you to them the need/information on final decisions, or a combination on both? In either event, should we calendar some times for meetings with them? Thank you, Heather & Ray Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, Ohio 43206 (614) 352-5819 heathe rnma nnOem ait.co m LPL 000290 rage ut cimail - ltstade arttcte Ray DiRossi Blade article 2 messages ...... _ Jessica Auman hu ' www toledoblade comlPoEiticsl2011/08/22/Comments-sought-for-redrawinq- districts:html Ray DiRossi I really arn loving every minute of it ive been looking forward to this for 10 years [Cucted Pext h?ddenl https:!imail.google.com/mail eii=2& ik=2cd7e55LP^766^eglrpt&search-=sentS:'th=t 31 t28.., 1 tl/25t20i 1 , ...... ,...... vl...,ij Page 1. of 2 Ray DiRossi (no subject) 2 messages Ray DiRossi Do we need anything from Columbus? how are we doing on handouts? Ray Heather Mann We're doing okay on handouts. Thanks for checking. BTW. I have in a section of the binder 5-6 copies of the script in case you need extras for you or Yost, I also have in that section a list of anticipated attendees/designees (for when you cafl the roll); a "thank you list" so Yost knows who to thank at each location on the script; and an extra copy of the schedule so he can read the next location at the end of the meeting. Heather Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columous, Ohio 43206 (6141352-5819 From: Ray DiRossi [mailto:[email protected] Sent: Monday, August 22, 2011 8:25 PM To: Heather N. Mann - gmail Subject: https:iitnail.google.comlmaill?ui=3&ik-2ed7e5t^^7^00291L-pt&search=sentc^ th=131. f40... 7 0i25/2011 iail. - (no subleet) Faee 2 at 2 Do we need anything from Columbus? how are we doing on handouts? Ray https_(/maiLgoogle.com/3nail,'?eii=2&'t1.=2ed7eL5PL 0002^3^`^-^t&search=sent&th-131f%]0... 10,`25!2011 Heather Mann From: Chad Hawfey [ehad.hawley@gmail,coml Sent: Tuesday, August 23, 201 1 2:45 PM To: Heather Mann Subject: Fwd: On behaii of [email protected]: My Ohio House Districts from Empty PEani Attachments: AT700047.jpg; 668b7608Shapefite.zip; 668b7608_Maptitude.bak.zip Heather, Homework assignment. Find what to do with the excess part of Medina County. Tbank you, chad -----°--- Forwarded message ------From: <=reshaohio ohiosecretaryofstat gov> Date: Mon, Auj; 22, 2011 at 10:21 PM Subject: On bebalfofTROY.JUDY(LOHR.STATE.OH.US; My Ohio House Districts from Empty Planl To: chad.hawlev n,tYmail.com j % % % % % + pres pres ag_ ag_ cong cast pres pres ag^ ag_ cong II de rep dem rep dem ^ ep cgre cast gde gde gre gre ade ad re ag t Oi3 m08 -de - 08 -rep 08 dem 0$ rep ` 08 -dem 08 Og m -m p p m em p ep m08 08 08 08 08 e .1 2,64 2,86 119311 7 2 720 2,46 3,90 1,79 1,86 1,75 1,79 5,71 0 1 43.1 46. 6 47- 6 43 45' 7 39 46. 8 6,13 2,415 50.95 4155 46'2 5,05 0,88 - ' 47.59 6 75 0,60 5183 3 ,2 6 2 8370 5 04 77 033 1' 08 2 4 6 1 1 4 1 I 33,3 54.2 25,9 42.2 25,5 41.6 31,37 51.06 24,9 40.5 45,1 16,2 35. 25,9 57. 16,2 36. 24,0 53. I 61,4 27,03 44.00 6 47 7 57 9 60 5 80 3 5 24 6 09 16 95 19 46 84 10 17 24 LPL 000294 Heather Mann From: Chad Hawtey [chad.hawley@gmailcom] Sent Tuesday, August 23, 2011 3:07 PM To: [email protected] Fwd: On behalf of [email protected]: My Ohio House Districtsfrom Subject: Re: Empty PIan1 nope On Tue, Aug 23, 2011 at 2:49 PM, Heather Mann From: Chad Hawley Heather, 1-Tomework assignment. Find what to do with the excess part of Medina Co y- Thank you, chad --___----- Forwarded message ------From: ^ ° % % ° e 1[ cast pres presres pres pres ag_ ag_ r^- ago cong cong cr^p cong cast ^de _gov re govg a de ag ag_ ag OS de = p_rep dem 08 rep 08 d 8 08 r 0S m dem p p m emrep ep t m08 m08 08 08 08 OS OS e .1 47 1,75 45 1'79 2'86 2,46 3,90 1,79 46 1'86 46. 2,64 50.1 1'43 33.7 2,720 43.1 6,43 8 ''71 2912, 46.2 47.59 6,7 5 0,60 S,S^ 04 3,26 77 03 7,39 08 6,13 50.95 4,55 6 5,05 2 0,88 8 ,370 7 2 415 4 b I 1 24,9 40.5 45,1 16,2 35. 25,9 57. 16,2 36. 24,0 53. 1 61 ,4 27,03 33 ,3 54.2 25,9 42.2 25,5 41.6 31,37 7 44.00 5 51 .06 24 6 09 16 95 19 46 84 10 1 24 6 47 7 57 9 60 5 80 3 LPL 000296 OHIO APPORTIONMENT BOARD ROLL CALL DATE: 8/23/11 (University of Akron) Members/Designees Present Michael Grodhaus (Designee for Governor Kasich) 3 Auditor Dave Yost ^ Halle Pelger (Designee for Secretary Husted) 3 President Tom Niehaus ^ Re . Kathleen Clyde (Desi ee for Leader Budish LPL 000297 Heather Mann From: Chad Fiawley [[email protected]] Sent: Wednesday, August 24, 2011 6:27 AM To: Heather Mann Subject: Re: On behalf of [email protected]: My Ohio House Districts from Empty Plant Troy and 1. On Aug 24, 201], at 6:26 AM, Heather Mann Who did this? Troy already knows that there are only two ways to draw Medina. Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, Ohio 43206 (614) 352-5819 h eathe rn m a n n Caa m a i I. com From: Chad Hawley [mailto:chad [email protected]] Sent: Tuesday, August 23, 2011 2:45 PM To: Heather Mann Subject Fwd: On behalf of TROY JUDYCc^OHR.STATE.OH.US: My Ohio House Districts from Empty PEanl Heather, Homework assignment. Find what to do with the excess part of Medina County. 'I'hank vou, 5 LPL 000298 chad ------Forwarded message ------From: Error! Fflename not specilied. % ^ [1 % % % °^n % % gov gov ag_ 8+ pres pres ag_ ag_ cong cong gov gov de ag ag- pres pres ag ag cong cong de re ft All cast -de rep dem rep dem rep cast - de - re d rep de - dem 08 t Ot 08 m08 OS -1ep 08 08 rep - dem 08 _iep m P m o... r he m08 08 08 08 08 08 m p I ri 2,64 2, 86 1 ,93 2,46 3,90 1,79 46 1,86 47 1,75 45. 1,79 5 28 5,71 46.2 7 2,720 43.1 4 7, 39 2912 5,05 50'^ 0,88 47.59 6,75 0,60 5,83 3,26 ' 6, 3 03 1 50.95 4,55 8 370 1 5 4 1 04 1 77 3 4 7 6'12 ,415 4 6 1 36. 24,0 33,3 54.2 25,9 42.2 25,5 41.6 31,37 24,9 40.5 45,1 16,2 35. 25,9 57. 16,2 9 1.1 61,4 27,03 51 .06 46 84 10 17 7 6 47 7 44_00 57 9 60 5 80 3 5 24 6 09 16 95 19 6 LPL 000299 Proceedings 29 SENATOR SKINDELL: Thank you, Mr. Secretary. SECRETARY HUSTED: Any other questions? I would offer a couple of quick thoughts. First, I have heard it a couple of times today for lack of a map. This process is about the public hearing, public testimony. It's about taking input. I can reassure you that I have not even seen a draft of a map. And that's what this process is. It's about listening to people and getting their input. You know, I was hopeful in coming here today we might hear something from people that want to talk about why Worthington shouldn't be split up and why the, 14 you know -- those are virtues and why, those kinds of 15 things, helping us understand those intricacies about 16 why a community of interest or a jurisdictional 17 boundary, which in many cases jurisdictional 18 boundaries are odd shaped. They annex land not based 19 on geometry but based on usually economic need. And 20 sometimes those run uniquely down streets and don't 21 reach into neighborhoods and things like that. 22 So it's -- it can be complicated, and but 23 I just wanted to reassure you that there's no -- 24 well, we don't have some smoke-filled rooms. There 25 may be Mountain Dew and potato chips rooms and some ARMSTRONG & OKEY, INC., Columbus, Ohio (614) 224-9481 0933 LPL 000300 Proceedings 30 people -- MR. TOKAJI: It violates Ohio law to have smoke-filled rooms. SECRETARY HUSTED: Exactly. That was dealt with a few years ago but there's no map that I'm aware of that's floating around. I might say I guess I'm a little reassured by that, Secretary Husted, but not much because the really important thing is that interested members of the public have some time to review those maps and then to provide 11 public testimony on them before they become law and 12 that's what I'm really worried about under these 13 rules -- 14 SECRETARY HUSTED: The 23rd is a 15 deadline. You can submit them earlier. You know, if people want for consideration -- you know, it's just like you are allowed to turn your homework in before the deadline. You can do that and that deadline is to convenience people, to give them an ample amount of time to make sure they have an opportunity to submit. Something that this Board and your office in particular could do to facilitate that process would 23 be to strongly encourage in a public way on your 24 website and throughout whatever channels are 25 available people to submit plans, say, by September ARMSTRONG & OKEY, INC., Columbus, Ohio ( 614) 224-9481 SOS-0934 LPL 000301 Subject: CONFIRMED: Auditor Yost and staff visit Location: Redistricting office Start: Mon 8/29/2011 4:30 PM End: Mon 8129/2011 6:30 PM Recurrence: (none) Organizer: Unknown 1 LPL000302 Subject: confirmed: Meet with Niehaus re: Redistricting Start: Thu 8/25/2011 12:30 PM End: Thu 8/25/2011 2:30 PM Recurrence: (none) Organizer: Unknown 1 LPL 000303 LPL 000304 Heather Mann Subject: Meeting with Auditor Yost Start: Mon 8/29/2011 4:30 PM End: Mon 8/29/2011 5:00 PM Recurrence: (none) Meeting Status: Meeting organizer Organizer: Heather Mann Required Attendees: 'Troy Judy 1 LPL 000305 Heather Mann From: Heather Mann [[email protected]] Sent: Tuesday, August 30, 2011 10:22 AM To: 'Ray DiRossi Subject: FW: Lucas and Montgomery County Request Attachments: rbv_candidates_tpt.xtS Fieather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Cotuntbus, Ohio 43206 (614)352-5814 heathernmann ffigmait.COm From: Benjamin Yoho jmaiRo:beOyoh a mait,com Sent: Monday, August 29, 2011 6:04 PM To: M€3raden bakerlawcem; ctarkt^oolidata.org Cc: Troy 3; Heather Mann; Michael Lenzo Subyect: Lucas and Montgomery County Request Mr. Braden, attached is the updated excel sheet with the data you requested. I am still digging through local Ivlontgomery races and will send to you if [ find anything worth analyzing. Thanks, Ben Yoho LPL 000306 6 Cl 6 6 p 6 O 6 Q p^ p- p -^ p Q O p^ O rc p p Q^ p cY Q 4C 6 rl ^. > T? T T>> ^> ^ ^ o+ w m`v ^u ¢`r `v u^ v v w a E E E EE E E E E E E E ry O O O O O O O D O O O 00 09 e0 bD OR pp op oD on i^ ^0 ,i,?b (FS C C C C C G C C G G G C Nu 10u^/1 Tu tOu NR5u Nu^ Ru^ ICu Nu f0 u i0 u., IV fII u IC u N u^6 u f6 uN uI6 u u000 50 a 0 0 0 0 0 0 _} J J J J J J J J J J J J--_^ -^ --^ J-^ J J W. (n p^ O O m 3i O O O O O O .N-' .-i °^ w w x co m c v Y m m v v' v^r v v a^t ,^ v v v v a a N rtl N^ O) N C G C C C C iy ^ y O O O O O O c c C y u u u° CEE E E E o 0 E E E E E E>> ,3u u u u° u° u u° u° :22 m 43 °i m v v a a v o ry o'' T?^ .a. Y ^ 0 0 v v N v v a^ m N ci v v v ^.v. v'o 'a c c c c c c m m m O 6 O O ^^ ^^0 O 3^OO 3O 3O C C C^^^^p p O O C O C^^^9 O O3== D O O3 O3=^ O O^ O O O d v ^. S S^ h t" V U U U U U F- F- S T S S tA v^ VF N N ,^ m^ m m m^ ^a m-o m -m m^ - v ^ m m m A i m io m m m m m m `^ `^ a`i `a d y w v^ a+ w w^ a v ai c c c E E C c c c E E c c c c c c c c c c c E E E E E£ v v v v a`+ v v m^ a ui v v - v a m m ai m v m v w mv ` 2 C7 C7 l7 !7 t7 t7 fl- n` a` a a o`. c9 ^9 :7 C^ i7 :7 C7 l7 a n ci C9 !7 l7 C7 t7 l7 t7 C'J l7 ^^ ^^ iB ^ o o°° o c°i a' o o a o 0 o aO o O o 0 o O oo ro w ^o --+ f' O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O N O N O O Op O O O O O O O O O O ?y m ^ 3 r m m3^ m 3 el d m 3^ y> m m^: 2 2 LL LL LL ^ t L LL 2 2 W 2 :^ :^-. ^j 2 2 2 2 LL LL :F 2 2 s,. g LL LL 2 2 LL d s ^ 4 o c ^ m +yV- a . > 'o o c a^ 0 3 Tn x`a °'m c C ai c c o ro m m°' O ^ ai O^ m^° pA L ^+- 'a ^^ f6 Z 3 Z c ° w 3 ^• ^'o^ ^' 3^ o m cio ^- c^ o o aj o u n f) U c v o -a L ^ c c ^ i o m o aci u. ,v^. ^° w W^ l.R) w U w l) n M Q U tD ^ C w F- L Y U 2 5 O cl u. K> K 4^i L U: t!1 h H w nN, ^N ^^N w^ m^^ Mw O\O t!r ul Q^ N N N O tD lO M N S N h w V tO O O^ Ol O V1 N N V w N w O^ C^ M N N ^ w V u1 W ^ . . . ^^ W r'^ w^ O H~ N N^-i e-f ~^ N O w^ 1^ N O CT tfl C h N h N V] ^ tIl Q w N^ ^p ^p p^ W w C^ W V N h tli ^ Ol ^O !V V 00 h N m^ fl1 m-'^ O O1 O^ [m m(11 w oJ R tD O w V From: Heather Mann ([email protected] Sent: Tuesday; August 30, 2011 10:17 AM To: 'Ray D"€RossP Subject: FW: McGregor Comments in DDN - Someone Didn't Get the Memo Two more members for the wall! Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, Ohio 43206 (614) 352-5819 heathernmann PQmail.com From: Michael Lenzo [mailtn•mtenzoCmail.coml Sent: Monday, August 29, 2011 11:39 AM To: Troy Judy; Heather Mann; Nathan Sionaker Subject: McGregor Comments in DDN - Someone Didn't Get the Memo httn:/'www davtondailvnews com/news/eleetion/mans-will-determine-state-nWitics-for-ycars-1240340.htm1 W'hile the final congressional maps won't be available for several weeks, both Widener and McGregor said it would be a bad decision merge Austria's and Ttnner's districts. Including military and civilian jobs, Widener said Wright-Patterson Air Force Base is the largest employer in the state, and deserves as much representation as possible. "I think the two voices there for the largest employer in the state is critical," Widener said. McGregor noted that the Springfield region is the largest population center in the 7th congressional district, and said there is some concern it could lose clout if at is added to a district that includes Montgomery County. Still, once the maps are fmalized, McGregor said most voters won't pay much attention to them until the process starts again. "For something that's so important it only happens every 10 years," he said. 17 LPL 000310 Heather Mann From: Ray DiRossi [[email protected] Sent: Thursday, September 01, 2011 5:56 PM To: Heather Mann Cc: Lenzo, Mike; Troy J Subject: Re: FW: 12-0901-0130-map0.pdf this is pxactIy what i said I DIDNT watit to do not the content but external maps On Thu, Sep 1, 2011 at 4:h2 PM, E{eather Mann FYI, attached is one of the displays that Mark Braden wants to show the principals in the meeting tonlorrow. 1-Ieather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, Ohio 43206 614 352-58i9 heathernmannIagmail.com From: Braden, E. Mark (mailto;MBraden%)bakerlawcom Sent: Thursd•ay, September 01, 2011 3:16 PM 1'o: Nuven, Rosemarie . Cc: 'Heather Mann' Subject: FW: 12-0901-0130-snap0.pdf can you print in color for ine 13 LPL 000311 Heather Mann From: Benjamin Yoho ([email protected] 5ent: Friday, September 02, 2011 12:02 PM To: Heather Mann Subject: Re: OH RBV What exact data is be looking for.. I am confused. Please advise On Tbu, Sep 1, 2011 at 5:06 PM, Heather Mann ------Forwarded message ------From: Clark Bensen/POLIUATA Heather and Ray, Now that Ben Yoho lias given us some elections in which a minority candidate has run, can we task someone with procuring the data for them? I don't need any data for the general elections for the obvious races: legislature/congress/statewide but any priniary data for these races and the local races will be needed. In reality, there are only a handfirl for which data are needed: these are in BOLD in the attached xls file. The others I have already or aren't worth the work due to the margin. Thanks, clark POLIDATA ® Demographic and Politieal Guides I www.olidata.us POLIDATA f) Political Data Analysis I www-2olidata.org POI-IDATA ^L at CafePress I www.cafevress.com/Rolitiataolidata POLIDATA 9 at Lulu I wwwlulucom/polidata 14 LPL 000312 Clark Bc,'nsc;n 1 POLlDATA LLC I'I'el: 703-690-40FrCi 530 ; Vernront Office: 1303 Hayward Road ^ P.O. 23e>x Corinth, N'"I' 05039 Virginia Office: 3112 Cave Court 1 Lake Ridge, VA 22192 efax: 202-318-0793 1 email: cixrk(^polidaTa.ot^ Heather N. Manu 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, OH 43206 (614 352-5819 h eathernmann @gmail, cozn ts LPL 000313 vrnuu - Hl^ponionmem raau ooumaown..... eage t or t Ray DiRossi Apportionment Plan countdown..... 1 message ------Ray DiRossi Hey guys... Friendly reminder tha'. as of Monday (tomorrow) we will have 18 days until the maps are to be submitted And I would like a solid 7 days post fina( decisions ! pre unveiling to get everything polished checked and ready to introduce.. So that's 11 days from Monday This will allow time for geography checks, population verifications, getting the legal descriptions prepared, district by district statistics being compiled to be ready forthe scrutiny that will come... Le. number of county splits, number of split wards, and twps and ciBes etc Ray https:/^mail.google.com!mail(?ui=2&ik-2cd7e5 pt&search-sent&th=13235$... 10%25,2011 LPL 000314 Page 1 of I 11,ll[ll, - 1\C. Ray DiRossi Re: 1 message [email protected] Thanks, tn most of the maps I've drawn bexley and white ha13 out Its just a question of whether what gets added in it's a lace is any better ------Origina€ Message----- From: Jody Licursi To: Ray DiRossi To: Vaughn Flasher To: Matt Schuler Subject: RE: Sent: Sep 5, 2011 9:48 AM Bacon lost Bexley: Percent 42%/54%13'/0 - raw totals 2497,3185, 202 Bacon tost Whitehall: Percent 42%/53%/4% - raw totals 1847, 2335, 1991 (Pfeifer D, Yarborough I) ----Original Message---- From: [email protected] [mailto:[email protected]} Sent: Monday, September 05, 2011 7:35 AM To: Jody Licursi; Vaughn Ftasher; Matt Schuler Subject: Did bacon carry white ha8 and or bexley in his last election? If so by what margins.. Percentages Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry No virus found in this incoming message. Checked by AVG - www.avq.com Version: 8.5•449 / Virus Database: 271.1.1/3847 - Release Date: 09/03111 18 34:00 Sent from my Verizor Wireless BlackBerry https:/Imail.g(lot-ie.com.im^till".'Lli--&ik--'-ed7e5 LPL 0003^ pt&search='seut&th-1323b9... 10/25%?DI ] t'age I ot 2 (iniail - Re: 32r,d district Ray DiRossi [email protected]> Re: 32nd district 3 messages ____._-_._-___..------^----. Mon, Sep 5, 2011 at 7:26 PM Randylaw4ohio Ray, Who is your counter point for redistricting in the House? Thank you, Randy ---Origina€ Message---- From: Ray DiRossi Its starting to move forward slowly but surely Ray On Fri, Aug 12, 2011 at 12:58 AM, Randy Hope you are well hard to believe but the people who will actually be drawing the districts havent really started yet there are many people out there working on scenarios - but i dont expect any of them to be "inside' NE ohio may be messy with senate districts Trumbull could be paired up a number of different ways as we get closer into the process -:`ets talk again... Good to know you are Eooking at it.. Ray https:/.•'rnail.^oo^le.com mail '?ui 2^ it 2cd7e ^qajA^i^'=pt&seareh==sent&th=1323be... 10i2Si2011 (jmai€ - Re: 32nd district t'ape 2 ot 2 On Wed, May 25, 2011 at 3:49 PM, Randylaw4ohio ---- -_--...._.._._--... Tue, Sep 6, 2011 at 4:43 PM Ray DiRossi Hey Randy Its Mike Dittoe do you have contact info for hi Ray [Quoletl text h;den] Sep 6, 2611 at 4:58 PM [email protected] Pritps:J!mail.google.comJntruli?rki- &ik-2cd7elaa&Njtjy-pt&search=sent&thY1323be..- I0t'5/201 ] ^ a+0 N .t+ y N 2 , ... '3 x^ $z' '.^-. c v oc) s r x;^ m m C fY 1 b xaP 0 (6 ^ ?^ ^ ^ ^ N A5+ Y C 0 4. i C Q Q^ = f6 O 0 x s? 01 ^-- W T . T Q Q y L C p v V From: Mann, Heather To: Matthew T. Schuler; Barron, John; Ray DiRossi; Troy Judyi Rench, Karrie; Schuler Matt; Lenzo, Mike; Hansen, Beth; Mary Amos Augsburger; Heather Noelle Mann (heathernmani^); matthew. carte governor ohio gov Carle Matt; Subject: Weekly Redistricting Meeting When: Tuesday, September 06, 2011 5:00 PM-6:00 PM. Eastem Standard Time Where: Offsite LPL 000319 Subject: CONFIRMED: Apportionment Board Open House Location: Yost Visit Start: Tue 9/6/2011 5:00 PM End: Tue 9/6/2011 6:30 PM Recurrence: (none) Organizer: Unknown 1 LPL 000320 CONFIRMED: Meet with President Niehaus re: Apportionment and Redistricting Subject: Start: Tue 9/6/2011 6:30 PM End: Tue 9/6/2011 7:30 PM Recurrence: (none) Organizer: Unknown 1 LPL 000321 Heather Mann From: Clark BensenlPaL}DATA [ciark@po(ldata.org] Sent:, Tuesday, September 06, 2011 12:56 PM To: 'Benjantin Yoha Cc: 'Heather Mann'; 'Ray DiRossi' Subject: RE: OH RBV Ben, Understood. Yikes, 3,111 pages for Lucas... this will take some time to use at all. Alas, the Montgomery file vou sent is oniv the summarv for the county. I assume they also have a 2,xxx page detail by precinct. Thanks, Clark POLIDATA 1^) Demographic and Political Guides I www.polidata.us POLIDATA 9, Political Data Analysis I ww.olidata.ortz POLIDATA * at CafePress f www.cafepress.com/nolidata POLIDATA V at Lulu I www.lulu_comlpolidata Clark Bensen f POLIDATA LI_C f Tel: 703-690-4066 Vermont Office: 1303 Hayward Road I P.O. Box 530 1 Corinth, VT 05039 Virginia Office: 31 I2 Cave Court 4 Lake Ridge, VA 22192 efax: 202-318-0793 1email: elark cr; olidata.orR From: Benjamin Yoho [mailto:benyoho,^nagmait.com] Sent: Tuesday, September 06, 2011 12:21 PM To: Ctark 13eusen/POLIDATA Cc: Heather Mann; Ray DiRossi Subject: Re: OH RBV Clark, the SOS website does not have the data in excel format nor does the county BOE's. Here are the PDF reports that are available online. I have put in a public recrods request to the SOS, Lucas County and itiSontgornery County BOE's for the excel versions. Will keep you posted as things come in. Thanks, Ben Yoho 740-624-3417 On Tue, Sep 6, 2011 at 7:39 AIvI, Clark Bensen/POLIDATA What we need ',s the precinct-level results for the elections I mention. I'm not even sure the SOS has this information.. LPL 000322 A good starting poirit would bc the Obarna priinary far 2008. POLIDA`I'A t' Demographic and Political Guides ! www o&data.us POLIDA"I`A t Political Data Anxlgsis I www. olidata.or * POLIDA"I'A t at CafePress I www cafepress.coinipolidata POLTI7ATA. W at Lulu I www.lulu.com/polidata Clark Bensen I POLIDATA LLC JTet: 703-690-4066 Vermont Office: 1303 Hayward Road ` P.O_ Box 530 1 Corinth, V'T 05039 Virginia Office: 3112 Cave Court I Lake Ridge, VA 22192 efax: 202-318-0793 f email: c1^rkCo)polidata ar^ From: Heather Mann {mailto:feathernmann@amai{ com] Sent: Sunday, September 04, 2011 3:26 PM To: 'Clark Bensen/POLIDATA'; 'Braden, E. Mark' Cc: Ben Yoho; Troy J`; 'Michael Lenzo'; 'Ray DiRossi' Subject: FW: OH RBV Clark or Mark, Could you please follow-up with Ben on what exactly you need from the SOS? Ben's cell phone number ±2 740 624- 3417 and his email is benyoho@amaiLcom_ Thank you, Heather Mann a:. Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B LPL 000323 Columbus, Ohio 43206 614 3525819 [email protected] From: Benjamin Yoho (mailto:benjohoCdgmail.coml Sent: Friday, September 02, 2011 12:02 PM To: Heather Mann Subject: Re: OH RBV What exact data is he looking for.. I am confu,sed. Please advise On Thu, Sep 1, 201 1 at 5:06 PM, Heather Mann Ben, is this sometliing you could get for us'? ------Forwarded message ------From: Clark Bensen/POLIDATA Heather and Ray, Now that Ben Yoho has given us some elections in which a minority candidate has run, can we task someone with procuring the data for them? I don't need any data for the general elections for the obvious races: legislaturelcongresslstatewide but any primary data for these races and the local races will be needed. In reality, thera are onty a handful for which data are needed: these are in BOLD in the attached xls file. The others I have already or aren't worth the work due to the margin. Thanks, clark 3 LPL 000324 POLIDATA9, Demographic and Political Guides , www.uoliflata.us POLIDATA Cv Political Data Anatysis I wEVw ^data_org POLIDATA. t at C:'afePress ^ www.caferess.com/POlidata PQLII7ATAC^ at Lulu I wwwlulu.cominoiidata Clark Bensen f POLIDATA LLC f Tel: 703-690-4066 Vennont Office: 1303 Hayward Road { P.O. Box 530 1 Corinth, VT 05039 Vira nia Office: 3112 Cave C.ourt I Lake Ridge, VA 22192 efax: 202-318-0793 email: ciarkce,. olidata.org Heather N. Maan 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, OH 43206 (614) 352-5819 heatl7emm ann @tma 3i. co m 4 LPL 000325 Mann, Heather From: Carey, John Wednesday, September 28, 2011 10:59 AM Sent: Mann, Heather To: Subject: 93rd District Heather, d Can you give me a description of what parts of Lawrence and Vinton Counties will be in the 93` District? Thanks, John Carey 633 LPL 000326 eather Mann ([email protected] From: Heather Mann Sent_ Thursday, September 08, 2019 6:33 PM To: '[email protected]'; 'Troy J' Summit County Pairing Options.xlsx Subject: Attachments: Summit County Pairing Options.xlsx LPL 000327 N •^ S 'LS •^i 't7 O Q ^ qy t^^ d A9 MO N G .4 i O t-' x' OD .. M11 O O v^ ^ o w C : a o C^ p N ^'+ U U •^ b p ^ t^V .n^ T t3 o s. o c^ O N b o ., L N (! ^ °y" •-1 O f% rn ^ c^i ^-^ o c c v From: Mary Amos Auqsburqer To: Brenda L. Rinehart; Christina D. Baeppler; Subject: Confirmed for today at 4pm Date: Monday, September 12, 2011 9:46:00 AM We're confirmed to meet with apportionment board staff at 4pm today - the usual location. AOS email search produced 000002 LPL 000330 Heather ann From: Heather Mann [[email protected]) Sent: Tuesday, September 13, 2011 12:27 PM To: Troy J' Cc: 'Matt Huffman'; 'Ray DiRossi; '[email protected]' Subject: RE: House Dems Pull Support from May Primary BII over Redistricting I believe Averel had already done this as part of our preparation - I'tI check with Lenzo. Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, Ohio 43206 (614) 352-5819 heathernmann(agmail.com From: Troy J jmaiito:tro),11dyPomail.coml Sent: Tuesday, September 13, 2011 12:19 PM To: Heather Mann Cc: Matt Huffman; Ray DiRossi Subject: House Dems Pull Support from May Primary Bill over Redistricting Heather - given what they are saying about process, we need to make sure we compile those stats on hearings, witnesses, miles traveled, etc. Begin forwarded message: From: House Democratic Leader Armond Budish (D-Beachwood) sent a letter to House Speaker William Batchelder (R-Medina) Tuesday saying his caucus will no longer support legislation moving the 2012 primary to May in protest over plans by the House GOP to introduce a new congressional redistricting map and pass it this week. The primary delay legislation would need seven Detnocrat votes to pass as an emergency clause. Read more in Tuesday's flannah Report. You are receiving this alert because you are subscribed to actionTRACK. If you do not wish to receive these alerts, please email info(a rotundainc.com or call 1-614-227-5820. LPL 000331 Heather Mann From: Wolff, Halfie[[email protected]] Sent: Tuesday, Septembor 13, 2011 1:27 PM To: 'Heather Mann' Subject: RE: Meeting (Request Thank you Heather Hi::tEie 1Z. 'Wotf^- Sr. Legislative Aide Spc:aker Batchelder, 69th District Ohio House of Representatives 614.466.8140 From: Heather Mann [mailto:heathernmannna gmail.coml Sent: Tuesday, September 1.3, 2011 12:39 PM To: Wolff, Hallie; Lenzo, Mike Subject: RE: Meeting Request Halle; Any members who want to meet to discuss reapportionment should be directed ta Mike Lenzo. Sincerely, Heather M. .^x Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, Ohio 43206 (614) 352-5813 h eat h e rn ma n n Cu3 Rm a i I.co m From: Wolff, Hatlie [mailto^Hallie WolffCa^ohr state.oh.usl Sertt: Tuesday, September 13, 2011 10:13 AM To: '[email protected]' Cc: Florence, Beth Subject: Meeting Request Heather, Representative Staby would like to meet with someone from the Speaker's office to discuss reapportionment of his district..Nathan. commented you would be the person to go to. Can you please contact Beth Florence in Representative Slaby's office to touch base with her regarding this matter. Beth can be reached at beth.florencerstate.oh_usand 614-644-5085. Take care, 3-faCCie 'R. tiVoCff LPL 000332 Heather Mann From: Wolff, Haliie [[email protected] Sent: 7uesday, September 13, 2011 10:13 AM To: 'heathernmann r+ gmail.coni Cc: Florence, Beth Subject: Meeting Request Heather, Representative Slaby would like to meet with someone from the Speakei's office to discuss reapportionment of his distrlct. Nathan commented you would be the person to go to. Can you please contact Beth Florence in Representative Slab)(s office to touch base with her regarding this matter. Beth can be reached at beth.florencepphr.state.oh.us and 614-644-5085. Take care, 3-fa.(cie 72. -1Vo(.ff Sr. Legislative Aide Speaker Batchelder, 69th District Ohio House of Representatives 614.466.8140 LPL 000333 5r. Legislative Aide Speaker Batchelder, 69th Distriet Ohio House of Representatives 614.466.$140 LPL 000334 Subject: CONFIRMED: Niehaus with Ray Start: Wed 9/14/2011 9:30 AM End: Wed 9/14/2011 11:00 AM Recurrence: (none) Organizer: Unknown 1 LPL 000335 Subject: CONFIRMED: Meet with Yost and Braden Start: Thu 9/15/2011 4:00 PM End: Thu 9/15/2011 6:00 PM Recurrence: (none) Organizer: Unknown 1 LPL 000336 Meet with Niehaus at Bunker Subject: CONFIRMED: Start: Thu 9/15/2011 9:00 AM End: Thu 9/15/2011 10:00 AM Recurrence: (none) Organizer: Unknown 1 LPL 000337 Subject: CONFIRMED: Meet with Batchelder and Niehaus Start: Fri 9/16/2011 3:00 PM End: Fri 9/16/2011 6:00 PM Recurrence: (none) Organizer: Unknown 1 LPL 000338 lNann, HeatFrer From: Baker, Nan Sent: Friday, September 16, 2011 10:03 AM To: Mann, Heather Cc: Molski, Sara Subject: District Map Hi Heather. At your earliest convenience, please forward me the detailed district map. Thanks, Nan 623 LPL 000339 tail - Fw: house seat in the 13th district Page I oi'2 Ray DiRossi Fw: house seat in the 13th district 3 messages [email protected] FYI Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry From: Gayle Manning Hi Ray, I know they are looking for Republicans in Lorain COunty for Boose and I had discussed with Matt there were some in Lorain - people that live there but their kids attend Amherst School District, I have the names of the street - listed below -if that would help. We walked there a couple of times - good response from the people. I believe Heather Mann is working on the House but I do not have her e-mail address. Deerfield Estates: Antler Crossfng, Black walnut Trace, Buckhom Blvd., Buckskin Ln, Deer Valley trail, Doe Crossing, Fallow Way, Golden Rod Ln, Kyra Ln. Mantil Ln, Six Point LN, White Tait LN, Winter Foe Trail. Apple Orchard- Cooper Foster: Appleseed Dr., Baldwin Blvd, Bayberry Rd, Belmont Dr, Oberlin to Broadway, Rte 58 to Linn North Side, Dannie Dr., Debra Dr., Dorwood Dr., Fiesta Ct, Lemonwood Ct, Orchard Hill Blvd., Meadow Way, Quincy Adams Jaeger Rd.: Blush Dr, Camden Blvd, Courtyard Dr, Crossing Trail, Fields Way, Ct, Randolph, Salem Cr. Camden Ridge: Jenee Dr, Kingsbury Ct, Rosemount Ct, Santina Way, Viewcrest. Yorktown Ct, Pill Hill: Greenbriar Ln, Hillgrove Dr, Laura Ln, Longbrook Rd, Marlboro Ave, Normandy Dr, Rosecliff Dr, S. Park Dr, Yorktown Rd. Oak Point Rd.: Colony Ct, Eagle's Nest Dr, Fox Run, Hidden Creek Dr, Mallard Creek, Manhatten Dr, Mayflower Dr, Oak Point Estates, Oak Tree Dr, Providence Ct, Roe Ln, Squirrel Nest Dr, Staghorn Ln, Velvet Horn Williamsburg: Duxbury PI, Emerald Dr, Gargasz Dr, Gettysburg Dr.. Gtouchester Dr, Independence Dr, Jamestown Pt, Nantucket Dr, Urban Cir, Narranggnsett Blve, revere PI, Seven Pines Dr. Timberview Dr Kolbe Rd: Oakcrest Dr, Oakhilt Bivd, Spalding Ct N. Pointe Pkwy-Cooper Foster: Belifower Dr, Boxwood Dr Middle Ridge (east of 58), Old Lake Rd, Park Square Dr, Plymouth Or, reserve Cr, W. Erie to Beaver Creek, Oakhills, Beavercrest Dr, Hidden Creek free to call I hope this helps. I am sure that matt spoke to you about splitting North Ridgeville. Feel anytime. Thanks, G;z>. 4• Vaughn Flasher https:!,maiLgoogle,cocn/mail/?ui=2&ik-2cd7e552a7&view-pt&cat=Redistricting%20Em__ 10/18i2011 LPL 000340 Cp^iail - R4: house seat in the ] 3th district Page 2 of 2 purpose of her email From: raydiro^i(c^amail cnm Date: Sat, 17 Sep 2011 00:01:59 +0000 To: Matt SchuleP Fri, Sep 16, 2011 at 9:04 PM 3Natt Schuler Yeppers ii?ui•=2&i k=2cd7e552a7&vie^v=pt&cat=Redistricting%20Em _. 10118i201 1 https:!%mail.google.com/tnai LPL 000341 r Smith, Madeline [[email protected]) From: Sent: Friday, September 16, 2011 4_5t PM To: Mann, Heather Subject: Weekly Redistricting Meeting Attachments: image001.png; image002.jpg Hi Heather, ing due to his travel Just wanted to let you know that Matt Carle will be unable to attend Monday's redistricting me with the Governor. Thanks, Madeline Smith Madeline Smith Assistant to the Legislative Director and Cabinet Secretary ofrice of Ohio Governor John R. Kasich 614.644.4358(0) Madeiine Smith ¢ovemor ohio Aov vaww Kovernor.ohio-l:ov 624 LPL 000342 Heather ann From: Benjamin Yoho [[email protected] Sent: Friday, September 16, 2011 6:15 PM To: Michael Dittoe [email protected]) Cc: Troy J; Amy Kerschner ( Subject: Re: More Geocodes Mary Galinas (R) 9503 Elsmere Dr. Parrna, OH 44130 On Fri; Sep 16, 2011 at 4:33 PM, Michael Dittoe Linda Burhenne 7286 Callow Rd. Leroy, Ohio 44077 On'1'hu, Sep 15, 2011 at 10:59 AM, Beujamin Yoho Richard Fair (LJ) 4425 Merry Lane Toledo, OH 43615 Mike Robison (R) 31 18 Daytona Ave. Cincinnati, O71 45211 Jeff Krabill (R) 300 E. Water Street Sandusky, OH 44870 Andy Manning (R) 2472 Pistachio P1 Ravenna, OH 44266 Lou'herhar (R) 5595 Bootncr Rd Cincinnati, OH 45247 Tom Bryan (R) 690 North Nleadowcrest Circle Cincinnati, OH 45231 LPL 000343 Chn Mon, Sep 12, 201 l at 9:58 AM, Troy J We need to do more geocoding of candidates (R) and (D) of interest for mapping purposes: I. I-Iarlene Holland (R-HD 40) 2. Andy Manszing (R-HD 43) 3. Jeff Krabill (R-HD 80) 4. MikeR.obison (R-HD 31) 5. Richard Fair (R-HD 48) 6. WHO ELSE?? 2 LPL 000344 Heather i4lann From: Heather Mann [heathernrnann ta grrtaif.corri} Sent: Satnrday, September 17, 2011 10:17 PM T o: 'Ray DiRossi' Subject: MASTER"DISTRICTFILES.x3s Attachments: MASTER DISTRICT FILES.xPs LPL 000345 4831% 1;CraigNewbold-R (2018) 4831% 52.78% 2.41"`o L16% 64 73% 59.28% 3 24% 1 68% 64.73% ' 2iAndrew Brenner K(2018) (2016). 59 37% 56.13%, 1.46% 1 28% 5y 37% 3' Rott Amstutz -R 61.02% 4 Matt }lui'i4nan -R (2014) , 6102"l° 59.57%.. tt07°o 192% 57.79°Joi 5.33% 136% 60-45 % 5.GeraldStebelton R(2014) 6045% ^n 51.43% Gardner R(2016) 5143"0 45.50°/6 151% 3.6_l0- Randy 26.Sb°Ja 7;KennvYuko-I7-(2012) _....26 86%- - 21 .20%, , 48.25%1.40% P 56.51% 1.54% 19 37"0 S;ArmondBudish D(2014) I937/o 14,01°^ (2014) 17 59% 12.57%. 52.82"/0 165% 17.59% 9 Barbara Boyd D 18.79% -D- (2018} ^ _ 3 8 79% 13.57% 46.23% 12.80% 10'. BiIF Patmon 482% ".. 19.63°,`°. ql(g0t4) 1963% 14.45%' S315% 12 F7hBarnesaUS ( )I 15 46°l0 i 10.850% , 68 ;87% 1 13%P -.. 10.92°'0 i3^NickteAnfonio D(2018) 3116"fo 25.03°`oI 13.46°f° 3712% 33_440/,-_-- 9.91% 765% 14Mil 44 11[]ltllt? iE ^^ + • •I _ _ 43 Todd McKennev R- (2018) 49 59% i 49 75% 1 45% 49.59°,'a :. -,.,...nr .;nnn/ 22.11°Io wv_ verno_u ayKC. ,.. t^^.^^ ...._: 45Zach Milkovtch -D- (2018) 36.93% 35 08%1 11_78% 52.7 0 3-98°P ^^ -- 8°` 46'. BarbaraSears-R-(2016) 52.78% 4921"a ..- 18%_.. 15.87% ...... o- - 47;Teresa Fedor D (2018) 35.23 %, 29 . 20.27/0 48;MtcbaelAshford D (2018) 2027% I444% 47.77% 4.42°n- 37.96% 49SMatt Szollosi -I} (2fl14) 1 37 96°re 33.80°/u LPL 000346 1.16% 48.31°/0 IlCraig;dewbofd-R-(2018) 148.310N. .52.78%1 2,41°0 ° ' 1 U9°,^u U 81°/ 53.56%0 50,Clnntjna Ha.van, -K- (20<0) 53 56 /° 52.72% 1 33% 52.91°/o 51 x+itk SGhurntg R- (2018) F_-52 91`Yo 49 .51°G^ 445% 16.63% 1 77°/0 36.41°/0 52IStepben Slesnick -D- (2016) 36.41% 32.60% ! 1 26% 53 Tim Der ckson -R- (2016) 6 L62°l° 60.87°/° 330°0/° 60.74°i°' 54^' Courtney Combs -R- (2012) 60 74'^, 58.64°/0 8.84 4 38% 7,97% 65.84°l0 55 Margart Condttt R- (2020) 65.84% ! 61.92°l0i 4 O1°/° (2018) 1 13.76% 14.15°0 _--- 31 O8% 50 68°/0 57,D^ tRmLundy -D- (2014) _50 Y.° E47.10 °% 3 97.°ro ^ 52.80% 58 "feny Boose •R (2016) 52 80% 49.76% 3.08% 3 15°.0 38_81% 59Ron (`,erbcrry -D- 38A 1% 42.33%' 3.77% 1.89% 18 :95°l° 60;Robert Hagan -D. (2014) 18 95°fo 20.04°/°; 31.48% 7.46%-.. -•--_ __ . _ 48.07% 6t Mark Okey -D- (2014) 48.07% 48.38% 2.53°. 0.81°/0 51,21°/0 62,Lorraine Fende D(2012) 51.21% 149-13%I 3.IS°1o 1.03% 51 49% 63 ]Ron Young o -R- (2018)) 51 .49°% 4836° /o 3.68°l0 3.93% 64;Tom Letson -D- (2014 35 59% 37.57% 11.88% 1.08°0 3559% .--.--- --_- 32.42°>° 65jSeanO'Bnen-D (2018) 3242°0 36.75°l0 3.98% 0.99°l0 I7aeUecker-R-(2012) 6829°o'b4_96%' 138°0 1.41% 68.29% 66 _ 69.07% 67 Petcr Beck -R- (2018) 64 07°0 67.19°/0, 4.60 /° 1_84% 4.68% 45.70% 68`:Kathlcen C1yde -D- (2018) 4570% 42.61°l0l_ 1 23% - 691 Bill Batchelder -R- (2014) 55 91 °/o 53.09% t 22°/0 1.29°io 701,Jarrod Marnn -R (2016) 60 53°l° 57 44% 8.6810 2.954 71 IIay Holunger R(2014)_ -^_ 58 72° 0 55.._-. 58°io 3.73°l0_ ^]..1$%. _ . ._, .. -. .... 2 61% 72 f Ross McGreggor -R- (2014) 48 25% 46 82°/° 10.54% ..._ ----- ' -- -- -_. 1.21% 73 i3ay Goya1-D- (2014) 54 27°l° 54 t5°fo 10_93'% 0.46°/° 63.75"10 75 L,ynn Wachtmann -R (2014) 63 75% 61 79%1 3.740/o 2 54%°-.- 64_58% 76;Robert Sprague -R (2020) 64 58°0 61 82% 1.15°0 0.35% 0.85% 65.79°l0 77;Iim Buchy -R (2020) 165 79% 67 08% ^ 64 3 5 ° / ° I 64 96% 1.56°/0 . 0.94°/0 64.35°/0 -..__78!1ohtt Adans -R» (2014) 17% 64.22% 1.67% 0.92% 65.17% 79 jkhardR "Dick Adams -K (2016) 65 5.73°10 ' 2.86iu 46.52°/0 $0{Denms Iolurray -D- (2016) 46 s7% .43 34% _..--- 5.39°0 52,30°/0 811KexDamschroder-R(2018) 5230°°"4774°0j 2.40°io _ 1.53°0 56.78% 82 ^ Jeffre MeClaazn R (2016) 56,78 % f 54 55°° 4.04°l0 ^.y - 0.96% 1165.400/4 83: DorothY Pelanda (.- -R- 2020) 65 40"o ! 62 32% 1.91in 1_09% 6L11°/o 84^RobertHackett -R-(2016) 61.11%6039% 4.25% 0.98% S5.72% 85 ` ob Peterson -R- (2018) 55 72% 56 3!%i 6_32 % 0.70% 59.13% 86 Cliff Rosenberger -R (20181 59.13% 59 76°/0 -158% 0;63% 54.4I"/o 37 '^^: John Carey Jr. -R- (2018) 54 41 % E 59.05°/o i 1.27% 0.60% 0.59% 63.62% 8$Danny Bubp -R- (2012) 63.62% 163 60%1 1 0.74% 47.44°ru 89iTeay Johnson R(2018) 6% 2.62% --*.._ - -- 0.81% 61.64°/0 901,Margaret Ann Ruhl -R- (2016) ^ 61.64°l0 60 23°loi ' 0.88% - 55 67°,% ! 55 36%. 0.89°0 0.66°0 55.67% 91_._ Bill Hayes R- (2018) 43 06%y43 55°o 237% 11A0% 43 06% 92Debbie,... Philhps. _-_ -D (2016) ,-- 0.51% 50.43°/0 93Andrew 71 ompson R- (2018) 50.43% 53 00°/0t 1.I6°/o ---_ 2.95°/0 0.54°,0 53.20°/0 94'Brian Hill -R- (2020) 53.20% J 51 98% 4.14% --- 40.33% 95tLouGentile-D (2018)_ ^-4033°l° 46.61% I 0.75°/0 50.64% 96iAlt.andis-R-(2018) 5064%I5050°/ 2.4jO% 1.35% --_._-_ ----._ _ -_ - - 0.78% 61.56°/0 97'David Halt -R (2016) 6I 56°l0 59 43°l0; 0_57°/0 98 FRichard 1Iollington -R (2020) 58.31 °/o 55 64%! 2.24°0 0.97°io_ 58.31 % 3.54% ! 44.78% 99'Cas_.- Kozlowski R-(2016) .' 44.78°/°^42.89°/°! 2.38R/o LPL 000347 eather Mann From: Heather Mann [[email protected]] Sent: Sunday, September 18, 2011 12:19 PM 'Troy J'; 'Mike Dittoe'; Ben Yoho (benyoho@gmai€.corn);'Michael Lenzo`;'Chad Hawle+f To: Cc: 'Ray DiRossi' Subject: Index Analysis of Proposed Districts 2011 Proposed House Indexes.xls; 2011 Proposed Senate Indexes.xls Attachments: Attached is a helpful analysis of pre and post proposed House Districts. Propased House Districts UNIFIED ANALYIS Current House Districts Numberof5eats50+= 61 62(up1 seat) 57 (up 9 seats) Number of Seats 52+= 48 J 44 (up 8 seats) Number of Seats 55+ 36 Proposed House Districts 2008 Presidential lndex Current House Districts 53 (up 9 seats) Number of Seats 50+ = 44 45 (up 4 seats) Number of Seats 52+ 41 35(up4seats) NumberofSeats55+= 31 A few statistical blurbs: . We are now have a majority of seats that lean Republican (50% or better} on 2008 Presidential numbers. conditions, we had to win all seats above a • Previously, to retain a 50+ seat majority under 2008 Presidential year 49.14%; now we only have to hold 50 or more seats that are 50.94% or better. ..^ Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, Ohio 43206 (614) 352-5819 h e ath ernman nPama it.co m LPL 000348 10:45 a.m. CONFIRMED: Secretary of State visit Subject: Start: Mon 9/19/2011 10:45 AM End: Mon 9/19/2011 12:15 PM Recurrence: (none) Organizer° Unknown 1 LPL 000349 Heather Mann Subject: Secretary Husted mtg Location: Offsite Start: Mon 9/19/2011 10:45 AM End: Mon 9/19/2011 12:45 PM Recurrence: (none) 1 LPL 000350 From: Nichols, Robert To: Carle Matt; Grodhaus, Michael; Subject: RE: From Apportionment Board Date: Tuesday, September 20, 2011 11:08:49 PM It should read "later that week"... I'It correct it w/Gongwer tomorrow.... From: Carle, Matt Sent: Tuesday, September 20, 2011 11:06 PM To: Nichols, Robert Subject: Fwd: From Apportionment Board FYI... Sent from my iPhone Begin forwarded message: From: Heather Mann Mike & Matt: There was an article in today's Gongwer that stated: "Meanwhile, the Apportionment Board will unveil its proposed General Assembly district maps this Friday and allow a substantial time for public feedback, according to Gov. John Kasich's spokesman Rob Nichols. The panel, which includes the governor, secretary of state, state auditor, and two members of the legislature, will also hold a hearing on the proposed maps the following Monday and a second hearing the following week, he said. We invite the scrutiny, " Mr. Nichols said about the Apportionment Board's relatively slow time frame. LPL 000351 I just wanted to confirm/clarify this statement - the Board publicly adopted Sept. 26th as the date the Apportionment Board will meet next (to hear testimony on plans) and have internally adopted Sept. 28th as the date the Apportionment Board will meet to adopt a plan. The statutory deadline is October 1St, so we technically cannot go into the following week. Thank you, Heather Mann **^ Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, Ohio 43206 (614) 352-5819 heathernmann(a-) gmail. com LPL 000352 Heather Mann Subject: Matt Carle mtg Location: Offsite Start: Tue 9/20/2011 2:00 PM End: Tue 9/2012011 3:00 PM Recurrence: (none) Meeting Status: Meeting organizer Organizer: Heather Mann Required Attendees: Ray DiRossi; Michael Lenzo; Troy J; Matthew T. Schuler 1 LPL 000353 Page 1 of I c5nlatl - (no subject) Ray DiRossi (no subject) 1 message Wed, Sep 21, 2011 at 11:34 AM Aleah Page Where is senator manning supposed to meet you at 3:30? Ateah M. Page 614 778 7280 Sent from my iPhone hitps:ilmaiLgoogle.comlmai U?ui=2&ik=2ed7e552a7&view^pt&cat=Redistricting%2QEm... 10/ 1812011 LPL 000354 Fage t or 2 Gmail - PlGui roll out tomorrow Ray DiRossi Plan roll out tomorrow 4 messages Sep 22, 2011 at 11:45 PM Ray DiRossi Hey all... Heather and I just sent our plan to the printer a little while ago... We plan to put the maps out for display at the display area outside of the House clerks office tomorrow (Friday) at 11:00 a.m. my guess is media svoams - so it would be best to have spokespeople there We will be at the Clerks office most of the day waiting to receive plan submissions and then do distribution... Ray Michael Lenzo Any chance you could send me pdf files of the maps that were sent to printers so I have an electronic copy? Thank you! -Mike iQuoted text hddenl Troy J Now, I know we will sti11 have to wait in line with the rest of the fans, but do you think if Matt and i get there early enough and bring own maps, we can get them autographed with a picture?! Haha. Seriously though, you guys have done a tremendous job. Thank you for everything you've done for our institutioni [Quoted text hitldenl _-__- Fri, Sep 23, 2011 at 7:54 AM [email protected] httpsJlmai?.ooogle.conv'mail'?ui=2&ik-2ed7e5^S^^^Ag}ov pt&seareh=sent&th=1S2946_. 10?25!201 t Nage2ot2 (:imail - Plarl roll out tomorraw Ha!! Thanks Troy Heather and l printed out a set of large maps for you guys and speaker and president last night We wilt get them to you this am [Quated text Bitldeni Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry 16125(2011 https:; hnaii.google.com/mailf`'ui=2&ik=2ci17e5^gyw=t?t&.s'earch=sent&th=132436... Heather Mann From: Mike Dittoe [dittoemr@gmai!.comj Sent: Thursday, September 22, 2011 11:17 PM To: heathernmann@gm a i!.com Cc: Ben Yoho; Troy Judy Subject: Re: Damschroder/MeLean numbers giving you a hard time. You've been kicking ass! Haha I'm glad you enjoyed that heather! Just Hope you are feeling better! Thanks, Mike Dittoe 740.215.8214 - mobile 614.466.0863 - office Sent from my iPhone (3n Sep 22, 2011, at 10:46 PM, "Heather Mann" > That was worth a laugh at the end of a long day :) ----- ariginal > Message----- > From: Mike Dittoe »> >>> On Sep 22, 2011, at 8:45 PM, "Benjamin Yoho" LPL 000357 >>>> The switch scares me on the prez index for Rex » » >>>> Sent from my iPhone Sep 22, 2011, at 8:23 PM, "Fteather Mann" LPL 000358 >>>>> Territory switch Prez »»> » »> McClain »»> >>>>> 52.30 »»> >>>>> 47.74 »»> >>>>> 55.01 »»> >>>>> 51.80 »»> »»> 52.62 »»> >>>>> 48.16 »»> »»> Damschroder »»> >>>>> 56.78 »»> >>>>> 54.55 »»> >>>>> 57.78 »»> >>>>> 55.00 »»> »>v> 60,19 »»> >>>>> 58.77 »»> »»> »»> »»> ^*» »»> » » > Heather N. Mann »»> »»> 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B »»> » »> Columbus, Ohio 43206 »»> >>>>> (614) 352-5819 »»> » »> [email protected] »»> »»> »> > LPL 000359 Page I of I Cnnail - (no snbject) Ray DiRossi (no subject) I message 2011 at 1:08 AM Heather Mann Heather tJ- Mann 827 Ckty Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, Ohio 43206 t614k 352-5819 heathern mann(ojqmaiL com 2011-09-26 Apportion Plan Sponsor Testimony.docx ^ 12K https://mail.google.com/mail!?ui=2&ik=2cd7e552a7&view=pt&cat=Redistricting%20Em... 10/18/201I LPL 000360 Apportionment Plan Testimony Testimony • Keep it short • Compliance with VRA, Ohio Constitution, Ohio Constitution • County splits • Address NE Ohio constitution violation • Single member districts - requested in every hearing - consistent with precent • We believe that we created all the majority minority districts that could be created in House and Senate incomplianee with provisions of state constitution and population of . NSembers drawn in together - note if it helps us, if even LPL 000361 Heather Mann From: Heather Mann [email protected]) Sent: Thursday, September 22, 2011 3:33 PM To: 'Troy J' 'Mike 17ittoe'; Ben Yoho (benyohoCgrnaii.com) Cc: Subject: pamechroder/McLean numbers Per your request -! ran the numbers giving all of Crawford back to McClain and all of Seneca back to Damschroder minus two townships on the lower east side of Seneca to balance popufation. Damschroder's unifed index goes down marginatEy and his presidential numbers go down 40 basis points. Proposed Prez I Territory Territory Current Current Prez Proposed switch switch Prez Unified Umfied Unified 52.62 48.16 52.30 47.74 55.01 51.80 McClain 60_19 58.77 57_78 55.00 Damschroder 56.78 54.55 Heather N. Mann 827 Gty Park Aventie, Apt. B Columbus, Ohio 43206 (614) 352-5819 heathernmann ftmait.com LPL 000362 Heather Mann From: Troy J [troy.judy(rDgmait.com] 22, 2011 8:11 PM Sent: Thursday, September To: Heather Mann Cc: Mike Dittoe; Ben Yoho Subject: Re: DamschroderlMeLean numbers Should the two names be the other way around? I think they are the other way around. On Sep 22, 2011, at 3:32 PM, "Heather Mann" Peryour request - I ran the numbers giving all of Crawford back to McClain and all of Seneca back to Damschroder minus two townships on the lower east side of Seneca to balance population_ Damschroder's unifed index goes down marginally and his presidential numbers go down 40 basis points. Proposed Prez Territory Territory Current Current Prez Proposed switch switch Pre Unified Unified Unified 55.Q1 51.80 52.62 48.16 McClain 52.30 4734 SS.QO 60.19 58.77 Damschroder 56.78 54.55 57.78 Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, Ohio 43206 (614) 352-5819 heathernm ann2gmail.com LPL 000363 From: Heather Mann [heathemmann@gmait-comj Sent: Thursday, September 22, 2011 8:24 PM To: ,Troy 3. Cc: 'Mike Dittoa'; 'Ben Yoho' Subject: RE: DamschroderlMcLean numbers Sigh...yes...reverse names. Long days, little sleep. Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, Ohio 43206 (614)352-5819 heathernmann 8ma3 1.com From: Troy J mailto:tTr_Oyiudy*«maiLcom Sent: Thursday, September 22, 2011 8:11 PM To: Heather Mann Cc: Mike Dittoe; Ben Yoho Subject: Re: Damschroder/McLean numbers Stiould the two names be the other way around? ! think they are the other way around. On Sep 22, 2011, at 3:32 PM, "Heather Mann" Per your request - I ran the numbers giving all of Crawford back to McClain and all of Seneca back to Damschroder minus two townships on the lower east side of Seneca to balance population. Damschroders unifed index goes down marginally and his presidential numbers go down 40 basis points. Territory Territory Current Current Prez Proposed Proposed Prez switch switch Pre Unified Unified Unified 51.80 52.62 48.16 McClain 52.30 47.74 55.01 55.00 60.19 58.77 Oamschroder 56.78 54.55 57.78 ass Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, Ohio 43206 (614) 352-5819 heathern_mamz;^Igmail.corn 6 LPL 000364 Heather Mann From: Benjamin Yoho [[email protected]] Sent: Thursday, September 22, 2011 $ 45 PM To: Heather Mann Cc: Troy J; Mike Dittoe Subject: Re: Damschroder/McLean numbers The switch scares me on the prez index for Rex Scnt froln my iPhone On Sep 22, 201.1, at 8:23 PM, "Heather Mamt." Sigh...yes...n;verse naines. Long days, little sleep. Ileather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, Ohio 43206 (614) 352-5819 From: Troy 3 mailto:trqy [email protected] Sent: Thursday, September 22, 2011 8:11 PM To: Heather Mann Cc: Mike Dittoe; Ben Yoho Subject: Re: Damschroder/McLean numbers Sl7ould the two names be the other way around? I think they are the other way arotnid. On Sep 22, 2011, at 3:32 PM, "Heather Mann" Per your request --1 ran the numbers giving all of Crawford back to McClain and all of Seneca back to Damschroder minus two townsbips on the lower east side of Seneca to balance population. 1Dam.schroder's uniied index goes dowm marginally and bis presidential numbers go dow-n 40 basis points. 13 LPL 000365 Current Current Prer. I'rapvsed Propvsed Territory "1 f [Jnired Linified Prez switch sv Unified 4^ McC.lain 52.30 47.74 55.01 51.80 52.62 55.00 60.19 llamschroder 5638 54.55 57.78 **a Heather N. kfann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columnbus, Ohio 43206 (6I4) 352-5819 he ath ern en adrem a i I_ c om 14 LPL 000366 From the desk of State ftresentative B^aUes 195 Broad E. Sf., P.O. Box 958 Pataskala, 0I343062 September 22, 2011 Speaker Batchhelder, I am very pleased with the new house district I may have the honor of serving (New House District 72) in the future, if elected. Thanks to those who worked on the maps. While the new areas in I-ID72 include areas that I have had little or no previous contact with, I'm excited about meeting the fine folks in. Coshocton and Muskingum Counties and serving them in the Ohio House. I write to request reconsideration regarding the assigned areas to new HD72 within Licking County, which I understand would include as the map presently stands the fallowi-Alg, to wit: Towri.ships of Fallsburg, Perry, Hanover, Madison, Hopewell, Bowling Green, Licking, Franklin, Union, Harrison, the Villages of Hanover and I-Iebron, and the City of Heath. I am very passionate about representing Southwestern Licking County, an area where I have lived for more than 40 years. My wife makes some light of the fact that we move every 5 or 6 years, but not farther than 5 or 6 rniles from our old address. We've actually had seven different addresses in the Pataskala area. We also lived in neighboring Reynoldsburg, eo the immediate southwest of Pataskala, for several years where Carolyn and I both taught school and I servecl on School Board for a short time after leaving the teaching career for industry. My desire to represent Southwestern Liclcing County has had a bit of a setback in that I stand to lose Etna Township (out of current HD91) and did not have the City of Pataskala added to new HD72 as I had hoped and asked for. It is important to note that it was Etna Township, along with Harrison, that provided the votes for victory in the I1ffi hour during the 2010 campaign against Dan Dodd. My enthusiasm for the Soutbwestern part of Licking County (Etna Toi+-nship and City of Pataskala) stems from the foliowing facts: LPL 000367 I. My farnily I tas Iived in the area. for more than 40 years. 2_ I served as a School Board Member in Southwestern Licking Schools in the 1480's; my wife Carolyn before she retired taught School in all three of the elementary schools in Southwest Licking Schools (including Pataskala) as well as the Middle School; our son, Scott, served as a School Board Member in Southcvest Licking until just recently; our daughter, Saffie, taught at the Southwest Licking Middle School before her husband was transferred out of state; we raised aI1 three of our children in the Southwest Licking Schools; we have three grandchildren presently attending in those same schools now. Our two daughter-in-laws teach in the Southwestern Licking County schools, too. 3. Our cozulection with the City of Pataskala is also significant in that we previously lived in the City for 13 years; I've practiced law in Pataskala for over 33 years; my sons nciw practice law in Pa.taskala with me; I served as City I,aw Director from the time Pataskala merged with Liina Township (now the City of Pataskala) until 2002 and saw this new city through its infant stages, codified it's ordinances, created and established its Tv'Tayor s court, and attended all council meetings during my term. Presently, our son, Dan, serves on City Council in Pataskala. 4. In addition, our church life is centered around the Pataskala Community- I've beesi an Elder at Tri-Village Christian Church for more than 40 years, our children were raised and baptized in the church, Carolyn and I, along with other members of the family have been involved as members of the choir, the praise team, Sunday school teachers and members of the church board. The Tri Village Church is located in. Harrison Township (within new HD72), but very close to Pataskala.. A large part of the congregation lives in Etna Towrnship and the City of Pataskala. 5. Finally, I should mention that because of the many relationships we have established in the Southwest Licking Community (Etna Township and the City of Pataskala) a great deal of our support in both man power (door to door, mailings, fundraisers) and financial aid comes from these two conununities. My suggestion is to remove from proposed HD72 Fallsburg and Madison Townships as well as the City of Heath and add them back to Jay I Iottinger's District. These comrnuruties are in his present I-II7 71. Jay attends church and has mariv contacts in the City of Heath. I have few to none in comparison. LPL 000368 I woul.d then suggest that Etna Township (and portions of Reynoldsburg in Etna Toc'ir.ship, Licking County) and the City of Pataskala be added to the proposed I ID72. E.ssentially, the result would be tliat the areas in Licking County in new HD72 would be the same as current HD91, except the City of Pataskala would be added. Jay's district would remain the same as it is now, except he tivould not have the City of Pataskala and those portions of Reynoldsburg in Etna Township. If more population were needed, Franklin Township, which is adjacent to Heath, and(or Perry Township could be added to Jay's district as well_ Maps are attached (A) HD72 as proposed, (B) (Etna & Pataskala added - Fa.llsbury and Madison. removed and (C) like B, Franklin also removed). The un-shaded portions of Licking County are Hottinger s District. In future elections, the likelihood is that the person who will iun for the Hottinger seat will be a person from the GranviIle/ Newark/Heath area as nearly all of the county's etected offic.ials are from these cornmunities. As Pataskala grows, having Pataskala and Newark in the satne House District will, potentially, cause primary elections in the future as these communities do not relate to one another welL I say this because Republicans in Pataskala and Newark have a long history of a less than copasetic relationship. It is rumored that a westem I.icking County official may primary a sitting cornniission from Newark next year. Further, having Heath and Newark in the same district makes more sense from a community identity standpoint, as does keeping Harrison Township, Etna Township and Pataskala together. I am well aware that my request may be easier said than done, however, I would not be completely satisfied if I had not presented these mat`ters to you. Thank you for your consideration and lead.ership on this matter. Bill Hayes Representative 91 District Not printed at tax-payer expense LPL 000369 Heather Mann From: Heatlier Mann [email protected]) Sent: Friday, September 23, 2011 8_57 PM To: 'Troy J' Cc: 'Michael Lenzo Per your request, I am making a list of member calls I received today and yesterday. I took care of the easy ones, the others are listed below. €f you would like me to call them back I will, but I would like to prioritize preparing for next week and making any changes you and President Niehaus jointly direct Ray and I to implement. Kathy Cortez called me on behalf of Rep. Hollington and asked me to call him on his celt. She implied he might be upset with losing Chardon. Jay Hottinger - asked per his conversation with Speaker and Niehaus would like us to see if we can explore his issue -Heather Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, Ohio 43206 (614)352-5819 h eath e rn mann {a1Q ma il. com LPL 000370 Page 1 of 2 or Baiderson,'hottinger Ray DtRossi Senate districts stilE have same House districts as current. House districts changed as follows: Hayes District: Same parts of Licking, plus Coshocton and Perry Hilk District: Guernsey, Muskingum (except for Blue Rock, Brush Creek, Clay, Harrison, and Meigs Townships). New District: Same parts of Fairfield, Pickaway, Hocking, and Vinton, plus Morgan, Muskingum (only Blue Rock, Brush Creek, Clay, Harrison, and Meigs Townships) and one township (Trimble) in Athens County. Phillips district (same except loses Trimble Twp in athens county) If you do this, then the 71st and 72nd districts and Landis' district would be designated the 31 st Senate district, because Licking plus Perry is greater population than the combined Fairfield, Hocking, and (from what I can tell) the part of Pickaway that was in the old 31st District (if I have by chance on Pickaway miscalculated there are two ways to easily fix, but I don't think I have). Balderson would live in the 20th District. (So would Schaffer, but that's not an issue because he is not a candidate and can serve the remainder of his term even though he doesn't reside in the district Dbviousiy, because I do not have access to political index software, I have no idea how this might affect the political balance of the districts. I don't think the Senate will be affected signflcantly, I am uncertain about Hayes, though for example, I think that St Albans and Granville Twps. (minus Granville city) in the 71st District could be added to the 72nd district to help shore up Hayes if his numbers were to fall. Jeff Jacobson <1mj1961(ligmail.com> Fri, Sep 23, 2011 at 11:56 AM To: Ray Dirossi forgot to say: The only changes to the senate districts are trading all of Perry for northwest Muskingum/Zanesville (and the district numbers flip). Jeff Jacobson oh and the inclusion of Trimble township,,,, Sep 26, 2011 at 7:54 AM [email protected] 10/24/2011 https:'/mail.google.com/maiU?ni=2&ik=2cd7e552a7&view=pt&cat=Redistricting%20Fnt... LPL 000371 Page 2 of 2 C'imail - fix for Balderson/hotting I did something very similar. Let me get thtough today and I witl call Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry From: Jeff Jacobson https:L/mail.google.comlmaiU?ui=2&ik=2cd7e552a7&view=pt&cat=Redistricting%20Em... 10/24/2011 LPL 000372 Page 1 of I Gmail - FVv`: Ray DiRossi FW: I message Jim Hughes ---Original Message---- From: Jim Hughes (mailto:vote4tyuohes@aof comJ Sent: Monday, September 19, 2011 8:55 AM To. Jim Hughes; Katie Gregory Subject: PRIVILEGE AND CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE: Thfs message is intended only for use by the named addressee and may contain privileged and/or confidential information. If you are not the named addressee you should not disseminate, copy or take any action in reliance on it. If you have received this message in error please notify the sender and delete this message and any attachments accompanying it immediately. IRS CIRCULAR 230 DISCLOSURE, Unless expressly stated othennrise, any U.S. federal tax advice contained in this email, including attachments, is not intended or written by Wiles, Boyle, Burkholder & Bringardner Co., L.P.A., to be used, and any such tax advice cannot be used, for the purpose of avoiding penalties that may be imposed by the Internal Revenue Service. 2 attachments photo.JPG 40K ATT1458225.txt ^1K i k=2cd7e552a7&vieti*pt&cat=Redistrieting°lo20Em_. 10/24/2011 https//mail. google.eom!mait/?ui=2& LPL 000373 Page i of 1 Gmail - (no subject) Ray DiRossi [email protected]> (no subject) 1 message Ray DiRossi 10/24/2011 https:/lmail. google.com/mai t/?ui=2&ik-2cd7e552a7&view--pt&cat=Redistricting%20Em... LPL 000374 ann, Heather From: Dittoe, Michael Sent: Friday, September 23, 2011 12:30 PM Subject: Proposed Maps for Legislative Reapportionment Attachments: mage001.jpg; image002.png; image003.png; image004.png of Represa William G. Batchelder Speaker, ©hio House of Representatives Memorandum To: All Majority House Members From: Speaker Batchelder Subject: Proposed Maps for Legislative Apportionment llate: September 23, 2011 As you know, the deadline for all proposed maps to be submitted to the Ohio Apportiontnent Board for Consideration was at noon today. The following link will give you access to all proposed maps, including a legal description and other pertinent information of each: http i/www sos etate oh us^SO ^Reshape0hio/GADistricts/oronosed.asp All proposed maps, including the maps proposed by the joint Secretaries of the Ohio Apportionment Board, should be posted by early afternoon. If you have any questions about the material, please do not hesitate to cohtact me. Thanks, Michael Dittoe Director of Communications Office of Speaker William G. Batchelder 627 LPL 000375 Ohio Hovse of 12epce ajority Caucus 61,4.466.0863 office 740.215.8214 - mobile fiZa LPL 000376 i n?au - rcf.ry. /,Ls l,narrnian ot Lteking l,ounty Central Umt and on this email lJharrman ot... Yage ! ot 2 Ray DiRossi Ray. As Chairman of Licking County Central Cmt and on this email Chairman of LCGOP Executive CmttRod Yost, can we speak to you or Senator Niehaus today, this weekend, anytime regarding Licking County Senate House Districts? 3 messages Fri, Sep 23, 2011 at 5:40 PM Fiore, Billie We have been reviewing the proposed maps and have some concerns with the dramatic changes to the are needed, we have Senate and I-louse Districts involving Licking County. Whi1e we know changes on census data, demographics and other concerns over the eastern part of the newly drawn districts. Based things taken into consideration, the dramatic changes just do not seem necessasy. Even in a former marginal looking at data from 2004, 2006, 2008, 2010 ... we believe the diatricts in the out lining areas and changes in our area need further review. Licking County is the most populous county in these districts, the new districts are drawn our representation would be greatly minimized, or it would set up however the way a number of unnecessary and expensive primaries. Farthermore, Licking County has worked well with Perry County over the years in both a Senate and House District. Additionat6y, we are concerned about how part of Muskingum was carved out and placed in with Licking County for the Senate District which is now occupied by Senator Tim Schaffer, Representative Jay Hottinger and Representative Bill Hayes. We would hope Hayes' House district keeps Perry County and even given part of Pataskala City in Licking County. While we are not happy about losing Fairfield county in our Senate District we do recognize the population shifts and that it may have caused Fairfield to be split or removed from Licking, but for the Licking County to lose every this make sense numencally, other county in their existing Senate district, I, respectfully, just do not see how demographically or otherwise. This is not our first go around with reapportionment and I know changes impact all outlining districts and marginal areas. We have been through the last two rounds of reapportionment wih Licking and Athens county days 20 years ago and the current Licking/HockinglPickavay county days. for your consideration of other options, if they exist, to keep our Senate District more I would at least ask intact. 9 am available to discuss our concerns at any time over the weekend. Billie Fiore. Licking County Republican Central Committee Chair 614-296-8350 Thank you. Respectfully, Billie Fiore Rod Yost Licking County Republican Executive Committee Chair can also be reached at 740-334-1768 Ray DiRossi 1 6/25% https://mail.Lroogle.com/mail/?ui=2&ik=2cd7e551?7^7&^e^^y pt&search=sent&th 132983... 2011 ot... Page z ot 2 CTmail - Ray. As Chairman of I.icking County Central Cmt and. on this email C;hairman Billie I spoke to Rob early this a.m. IQaeted text hliaRnl Sat, Sep 24, 2011 at 11:33 AM Fiore, Billie Thank you. Please know that our concerns are not perceived concerns, but practical concern. We appreciate all that you do and know how much you put into this and everything all these years. Billie Confidentiality Note: This message is intended for use only by the individual or entity to which it is addressed and may contain information that is privileged, confidential, and exempt from disclosure under applicable law. If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient, or the employee or agent responsible for delivering the message to the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that any dissemination, distribution or copying of this communication is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error, please notify me immediateky at 014) 223-9300. Thank you. To ensure compliance with requirements imposed by the IRS, we inform you that, unless expressly stated otherwise, any U.S. federal tax advice contained in this communication (including any attachments) is not intended or written to be used, and cannot be used, for the purpose of (i) avoiding penalties under the Internal Revenue Code or (ii) promoting, marketing or recommending to another party any transaction or matter addressed herein. Go Green! Please don't print this email unless completely necessary. Thanks. Froin: Ray DiRossi (maitto:rayd'rossiPgmail caml Sent: Saturday, September 24, 2011 11:27 AM To: Fiore, Bittie Re: Ray. As Chairman of Ltcking County Central Gmt and on this email Chairman of LCGOP SubJect: Executive Cmt/Rod Yost, can we speak to you or Senator Niehaus today, this weekend, anytime regarding Licking County Senate House Distrlcts? IQt3oted texi huddeni https://mail. google.com(mail/?ui=2& ik=2cd7e5L'^^g-pt&smch=sent&th=132983... 1012511)011 Heather Mann From: Jeff Jacobson Um}[email protected]] Sent_ Friday, September 23, 2011 12:22 PM To: Ray Dirossi; Heather Mann Subject: Re: fix for 8alderson/hottinger oh and the inclusion of Trimble township,,,, On Fri, Sep 23, 2011 at 11:56 AM, Jeff Jacobson 'Fhe only changes to the senate districts are trading all of Perry for northwest Muskingum/Zanesville (and the district numbers flip). nail,com> wrote: On Fri, Sep 23, 2011 at I 1:52 AM, Jeff Jacobson I-Iouse districts changed as follows: Hayes District: Same parts of Licking, plus Coshocton and Perry except for Blue Rock, Brush Creek, Clay, Harrison, and Meigs Hill District: Guet7€sey, Musk.ingum ( Townships). (only Blue New District: Saine parts of Fairfield, Pickaway, Hocking, and Vinton, plus Morgan, Muskingum Rock, Brush Creek, Clay, Harrison, and Meigs Townships) and one township (Trimble) in Athens County. Phillips district (saine except loses "I'rimble Twp in atliens county) If you do this, then the 71 st and 72nd districts and Landis' district would be designated the 31 st Senate district, (from what I can because Licking plus Perry is greater population than the combined Fairfield, Flocking, and (if I have by ebance on Pickaway miscalculatecl there tell) the part of Pickaway that was in the old 31 st District are two ways to easily fix, but I don't think I have). (So would Schaffer, but that's not an issue because he is not a Balderson would live in the 20th District_ candidate and can serve the remainder of his term even though he doesn't reside in the district. ndex software, I have no idea how this might affect the Obviously, because I do not have access to political i political balance of the districts. I don't think the Senate will be affected signficantly; I am uncertain about f, n,ds (idrzsil e city) in the 71st f3ay-os, though f:ar example, I think that St Albans and Granville `I°wps_ District could be added to the 72nd district to help shore up Hayes if his numbers were to fall. LPL 000379 Heather Mann From: Heather Mann [heathemmann@gmail_com] Sent: Friday, September 23, 20117.40 PM To: 'Cortez, Kathy' Subject: RE: Rep- Hoilington Kathy, I'm conveyed Rep- Hoflirtgton's request to discuss his district to Troy Judy. Sincerely, Heather Mann Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, Ohio 43206 (614) 352-5819 heathernma [email protected] From: Cortez, Kathy [mailto•kathkcortez(aohr state.oh.usl Sent: Thursday, September 22, 2011 4:04 PM To: '[email protected]' Subject: Rep. Hollington 216.598.1233 © THANKS! KATHY CORTEZ, LA TO REP. RICHARD R. HOiLINGTON, JR. 614.644.5088 LPL 000380 Heather Mann From: Heather Mann [[email protected]] Sent_ Friday, September 23, 2011 8:19 PM To: 'Ronald Grossman' Attachments: mann-dirossi-legaldefinitian_pdf Rep. Grossman: Attached are the legal descriptions for the districts (from the SOS website). It will help show the exact political subdivisions in your district. As you look at all the districts in Franklin County, you'B see the little noncontiguous pieces parts of township described all over - it's the nature of annexation in Columbus. The numbers for the distr 57.09% Unified Index 515% Presidential -Heather Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, Ohio 43206 (614) 352-5819 heathernmann gmaii.com LPL 000381 11_09_24 Mary-Apportionment staff.txt From: Mary Amos Augsburger Sent: Saturday, september 24, 2011 1:25 PM To: David B. Potts subject: Re: Apportionment staff i have the splits for the board staff maps - counties and political subdivions. ----- original Message ----- From: David B. Potts Sent: Friday, September 23, 2011 08:23 PM To: Mary Amos Augsburger subject: RE: Apportionment Staff Thanks. I'll keep checking my e-mail tomorrow. From: Mary Amos Augsburger sent: Friday, September 23, 2011 8:21 PM TO: David B. Potts subject: Re: Apportionment staff Let's go with it. I'll try to pin him down on the staff map prior to our meeting. ---- original Message ----- From: David B. Potts sent: Friday, september 23, 2011 08:20 PM To: Mary Amos Augsburger subject: RE: Apportionment staff Thanks. If Ray's answer is also acceptable, that would save me a lot of time. From: Mary Amos Augsburger Sent: Friday, september 23, 2011 8:18 PM To: David B. Potts subject: Re: Apportionment Staff I think so. I'll do a q uick review to make sure they are consistent with what is being reported. staff plan only splits 10 or 11 subdivisions (other than townships) - according to Ray. 5 of those are the big cities. ----- original Message ----- From: David B. Potts Sent: Friday, September 23, 2011 08:13 PM To: Mary Amos Augsburger subject: RE: Apportionment Staff would Auditor Yost accept the press reports on current districts splitting counties and municipalities? If so, it would eliminate one plan analysis. From: Mary Amos Augsburger sent: Friday, September 23, 2011 8:12 PM TO: David B. POtts subject: Re: Apportionment staff Just in case we don't get the info by sunday's meeting, I would. Is there anything I can do to help you? Page 1 AOS-000S. LPL 000382 11_09_24 MaryJapportionment staff.txt ----- original Message ----- From: David B. Potts sent: Friday, september 23, 2011 08:09 PM To: Mary Amos Augsburger subject: RE: Apportionment staff I am going through the plans now. should r continue? From: Mary Amos Augsburger Sent: Friday, september 23, 2011 7:46 PM To: David B. Potts subject: Apportionment staff FYI - they are putting together an analysis and questions for Dave. Not sure when we'll receive the information - at the earliest, some time on sunday. Just wanted to let you know! Page 2 AOS-0009 LPL 000383 t..rn au - t ne super partisan ttemocracic maps t'age t oe s Ray DiRossi The super partisan democratic maps 7 messages ------Sat, Sep 24, 2011 at 6:06 PM Ray dlRossi I just got my first look at the detailed house and senate democratic caucus maps With all of the aftacks coming at the maps Heather and I submitted claiming they were hyper partisan and blatant political gerrymander maps that simply attack democrats I just want to point out that they slammed us for negativefy affecting 9 democrats through forced primaries and geography changes..... See list below: Scolozi and Fedor Celeste and Stinziano Wilson and Sciavoni Garland and Gonzalez Driehaus and Tehrar Oakey and Thompson I just want to set the record stralght... and hope we get out there with this My initial analysis of t ow the Democratic House and Senate caucus maps treats republicans It pairs or negatively effects 28 Republicans! R's in forced primaries Maag and Beck Hottinger and Hayes Slaby and Roegner Peterson and Hackett Wachtman and Goodwin Johnson and Carey Hite and Wagoner Burke and Jordan Beagle and Widener Balderson and Sc'iaffer Patton and Obhoff R's in Dem districts Landis and Okey Thomson and Phillips Koz and Letson Butler and Lucky Baker and Foley Anielski and Budish Hope this is useful.... hftps:/lmaiLgoogle.coni/mail/?ui=2&ik 2cd7e5L^^7^^^^^^ pt&search-serit&th=13290... 10/25/20'11 rage t ot j i,rrian - i ne super parusan aemoeranc maps Sat, Sep 24, 2011 at 6:40 Mary Anios Augsburger Wow.... very useful! From: Ray DiRossi [mailto:raydirossi^a qmail.com] Sent: Saturday, September 24, 2011 06:06 PM To: Mike Dittoe ((7uDted iexl hiddent 2011 at 7:05 PM [email protected] I thought yost and you would want to know Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry From: Mary Amos Augsburger Mary Amos Augsburger I thought yost and you would want to know Definitely! From: raydirossiftmaif com [mailto:[email protected]) Sent: Saturday, September 24, 2011 0705 PM To: Mary Amos Augsburger tQmoted text hiidea) iQuoied text Kidde¢i 24, 2011 at 7:08 PM [email protected] Hopefully more to come https:/Imail.googlc.cocn/mail/?ui=2&ik=2cd7e5 LPL 000385 pt&search=sent&th=1329d7... l0/25?2011 (itnail - FYI rage i ot i Ray DiRossi FYI 2 messages ------Ray DiRossi Seneca sees shifts in latest proposals P(ease see Damschroders quotes on how the districts we submitted are not compact Ray Troy J 1'rn having trouble viewing the link. iouotea text hidtlen] https:/lmail.google.com/maiU?ui-2&ilc -2cd7el:vLa^6bv3wff =pt&search-=sent&th=1129d7... 10/25/2011 Heather Mann From: Michael Lenzo [[email protected]] Sent: Saturday, September 24, 2011 11:33 AM To: Ray DiRossi; Lou Blessing; Heather Mann Subject: PilRch Comments in Enquirer Rep. Connie Pillich, D-Montgomery, has a reconfigured district, but it doesn't appear Democratic influence will be lessened. Pillich, who is running for Congress in 2012, said she is studying the proposed map because "1 am still concerned about my constituents. I don't want them represented by an extremist." htt :Unews.cincinnati.com/articlef20110923(NEWS0 1 0813 0923 0062 Apparently no one can read an index? 4 LPL 000387 Heather Mann From: Heather Mann [[email protected]] Sent: Saturday, September 24, 2011 11:18 PM To: 'Matthew T. Schuler ;'[email protected]'; 'Mary Amos Augsburge'; Halle Pelger ([email protected]);'Lenzo, Mike'; Troy.l`,'Grodhaus, Michael'; ' [email protected] hio.gov' Subject: 2011-09-26 Apportionment Board Meeting Script Attachments: 2011-09-26 Apportionment Board Meeting Scr"rpt_.doc Atl: for Monday, which includes a report from the Secretaries on the plans Please see attached a revised version of the script received, a motion to accept all plans submitted, and a brief report on the technical amendment being prepared. If you have any additional changes, please let Ray or I know. Sincerely, Heather Mann Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, Ohio 43206 (614) 352-5819 heathernmannfo^gmail.com 1 LPL 000388 APPORTLONMEN'T BOARD MEE'TING SCRIPT SEPTEMBER 26,2011 (TESTIMONY ON PLANS) 1. Call to Order & Introducdon of Panel GOVERNOR KASICH: The meeting will now come to order. Pursuant to notice, I now reconvene the 2011 Ohio Apportionment Board. The Secretary will call the roll. SECRETARY: [calls roll] [Members state names and titles] SECRETARY: All membf-Ts are present; we have a quorum. GOVERNOR KASICH: Pursuant to the rutes adopted by the Board on August 4, 2011, the Secretary have circulated for review, to all members, transcripts from our initial meeting on August 4a` and the regional hearings held August 22 - 26. At this time, I will ask for a motion to dispense with the reading and adopt these transcripts as the official minutes. AUDITOR YOST: Mr. Chaimlan, I move that we dispense with the reading and adopt the transcripts as the official minutes of the previous meeting and the regional hearings. SECRETARY HUSTED OR PRESIDENT NIEHAUS: Second. GOVERNOR KASICH: The motion has been moved and seconded. Any objections? Seeing none, the minutes are adopted. The Board at its last meeting adopted rules for the submission of proposed apportionment plans for the taking of public comments and testimony regarding the plans so submitted. The purpose of this meeting is to allow the presentation of timely submitted plans and public testimony on those plans. Any person wishing to present a plan or offer testimony regarding a plan should frll out a witness form available on the table and give it to our staff. Those who helped draft and create submitted plans know what a tough job this is, and I would like to thank each of you for taking the time and effort to draft a plan for our consideration. To summarize our rules, any pcrson or organization that has submitted a proposed plan of apportionment will be al.iowea to have its sponsor personally, or thmugh a representative, present the substance of their plan to the board, for a period not to exceed 10 minutes unless extended by a majority of the board. In order to conduct this meeting in an orderly fashion under our rules, I will call each plan's sponsor or designated representative to present their plan. At the end of each sponsor's presentation, we will have time for questions by Board members as jecognized by the chair. I Once a plan has been presented, the public may offer testimony in the order designated by the Chainnan for a period not to exceed five minutes, unless extended by a majority of the board. 'I'he Chainnan may limit testimony as he deems necessary. I would ask witnesses to limit their testimony to the apportionment of state legislative districts, which is the sole charge of the Apportionment Board. At this time I would ask the Secretaries to report to the Board the number of plans that were received and whether they were submitted in accordance with the rules. SECRETARY: Mr. Chairman, four plans were submitted to the Board by the Friday, Sept. 23`a deadlinc. The rules adopted by the board required submissions to include hard copy and electronic versions of the legal definitions and visual representations of the proposed boundaries. One plan was submitted by the Joint Secretaries of the Apportionment Board with all board- required components. Two plans were submitted from the Ohio Campaign for Accountable Redistricting and included all components except a legal definition_ The fourth plan was submitted by the Senate and House Democrat caucuses and included all required components except a legal definition. SECRETARY HUSTED: Mr. Chairrnan, in the interest of considering all citizen input, I would like to move at this time that the Board accept these plans as submitted and receive testimony on them today. AUDITOR YOST: Second. GOVERNOR KASICH: The motion has been moved and seconded. Are there any objections? Seeing none, we will now proceed with testimony. II. Pnblic Testimony GOVERNOR KASICH: At this time I would like to call our first witness, the sponsor or representative of the plan submitted by Please state and spell your name for the record. [Sponsor presents plan to the Board] GOVERNOR KASICH: Any questions for the witness? [Direct questionsfrom the Board] GOVERNOR KASICH: Thank you for your testimony. [plan sponsor]. Our next witness is We will now take public testimony on the plan submitted by 2 LPL 000390 just [Secretary will hand you witness slips in turn for any public testimony on the plan presented] GOVERNOR KASICH: Any questions for the witness? Seeing none, I now call the sponsor or representative of the plan submitted by [E'tc_ until all plans have been pre,cented] Adjourn GOVERNOR KASICH: Thank you to all to who have offered testimony today. All plans submitted have now been presented to the board. I would like to give members of the Board until Wednesday to review the plans and consider testimony that has been offered bere. If any Member of the Board intends on offering an amendment to any plan, they may submit them in advance to the Secretaries at the redistricti^redistrioting.ohioMv email address, and they will be timely conveyed to members of the Board. I would ask the Secretaries to provide the Board with an update on some technical amendments to their submission_ SECRETARY: Mr. Chairman, we are preparing a technical amendment to our original submission that makes non-substantive corrections to the legal definifions such as the spelling of political subdivisions and references to various precincts, none of which makes any changes to the overall boundaries of the map itself We will endeavor to email this to members of the Board as soon as possible. GOVERNOR I{ASICH: Thank you. I will now entertain a motion to RECESS this meeting until Wednesday, September 28 at 10AM. AUDITOR YOST: Mr. Chairman, I move that the Board stand in RECESS until Wednesday, September 28 at t 0AM in the Senate Finance Hearing Room. SECRETARY HUSTED OR PRESIDENT NIEHAUS: Second. GOVERNOR KaSIC'kI' Will. the Secretary please call the roll? SECRETARY: [Calls roll and announces vote.] GOVERNOR KASICH: The motion passed. The Board stands in recess. 3 1)raft initial apporiionneent Board Meeting Agenda & ,Script INI't'IAI. APPORTIONMENT BOARD MEETING SC;R7PT Call to Order GOVERNOR KASICIIc Pursuant to Article 11, Section I of the Ohio Constitution, I hereby call ( to order this meeting of the 2011 Board of Apporti,oning Persons. 'Fhere is a quorum of members present, but for the record, would each meniber of the Board please indicate their presence by stating their name. [Members state names and titles] This meeting is called pursuant to Article II, Sec.-tion 1 of the Ohio Constitution, which requires that after each decennial census, the Ohio Board of Apportioning persons - including the Goverrlor, Secretary of State, Auditor of State, and two persons selected by the leadership of the Cseneral Assembly convenes between August 1 and October I. of the year the census figures are released to establish the district lines of the Ohio General Assembly. Article 1 I of the Constitution governs the procedures for this apportionment, and we will therefore proceed under its provisions. --- L II. Election of Chair of the Apportionment Board GOVERNOR KASICH: Members have been provided with a copy of the proposed agenda for item on the agenda is the selection of a this meeting, which was distributed in advance. The first chair. MEMBER: Mr. Govemor, I move that Governor Kasich be named chair of the Apportionment Board. GOVERNOR KASICH: We have a motion. Is there a second? MEMBER: I second the motion. GOVERNOR KASICH: [1Vames member] seeonds. The nomination has been made and If not, all if favor signify by saying aye [atl say seconded. Are there any other nominations? aye]. Those opposed? Motion is carried, I will serve as chair. III. Present Indieia of Office and Letters of Appointment 23 LPL 000392 GOVERNOR KASICII. "fhe next item of business is for the members of the Board to verify their membership on the Board by'presenting their letters of appoin,tment, in the case of legislative apportioning'persons, and oaths of office in the case of other members. '17ie Chair will now receive these documents. I would like to indicate for the record that I have the certificates of office for Secretary of State IIusted. Auditor David Yost, and myself as Governor. I also have a letter from Senator Cafaro, Minority Leader of the Ohio Senate, and Arrnond Budish, Minority Leader of the Ohio House, choosing and appointing [Senator/Representative Xj to serve on this Board. 'I'he Chair has now received the appropriate documentation from each member, and it all appears to be in order. IV. Election of Secretary of Apportionment Board GOVERNOR KASICH: The next item on the agenda is for the selection of a secretary to the Board of Apportioning persons. The Secretary will keep the minutes, call the roll, and record all votes and maintain custody of all the records of the Apportionment Board, including the proposed plan to be filed with the Board. I will now entertain a motion for secretary_ be named Secretary of the Apportionment Board. MEMBER: Mr. Chairman, I move that [mmme] GOVERNOR KASICI-I: We have a motion. Is there a second? MEMBER: I second the motion. second the motion. The nomination has been made GOVERNOR KASICH: [Names member] and seconded. Are there any other nominations? Is there any discussion of the nomination? If opposed? Motion is carried, [name] [all say aye1. Those not, all if favor signify by saying aye the custodian of the records, the documentation will serve as Secretary. I will now give [name], provided to me. V. Election of Vice Chair of Apportionment Board The next item on the agenda is the selection of a vice ebair to the Board GOVERNOR KASICH: of Apportioning persons. I nominate [name] to serve as vice chair of the 2011 Apportionment Board. Is there a second? MEMBER: I second the motion. seconds the motion. The nomination has been made GGVEP.NOR KASICH: tName.s mcmber•i__. 24 ---- __-._ --- and seconded. Are there anv other nomtnations? ls lherc, anv discussion of the nommat 'T'hose opposed? If not, will the 5ecretary not, all if favor signify by saytng aye (ald say aye]. please call the role. as Vice Chair of the Apportionment Board, [calls SLCRETARY: For the selection of [name] Chair of the Apportio,nment Board by a vote of X-X. rolC]. [Name] is selected Vice Vi. Announcement otAttorney Representation GOVERNOR KASICH: I-iistarically, the Attorney General has represented the Board and all persons serving on the Board. Attorney General Dewine has appointed Mark Braden to be here today to be available to the Board. I would like to ask Mr. Braden to identify himself on the record. MARK BRADEN: Mr. Chairman, Members of the Board, I am Mark Braden, Counsel to the Board. GOVERNOR KASICH: Thank you, and welcome. VIL Appointment of Offieial Court Reporter this point, given the official and historic nature of our proceedings, GOVERNOR KASICH: At we need to appoint an officiat court reporter for the proceedings of the Apportionment Board. Accordingly, I will now entertain a motion to appoint an official court reporter for these proceedings. court reporter for the MEMBER: Mr. Chairman, I move that the firm of [name] be the official 2001 Apportionment Board and that said court reporter please prepare and provide eacb member of the Board a copy of the transcript of each of our meetings. MEMBER: I second the motion. seconds the motion. The nomination has been made GOVERNOR KASICH: [?Vames member] and seconded. Are there any other nominations? Is there any discussion of the nomination? If Those opposed? If not, will the Secretary not, all if favor signify by saying aye [all say aye]. please call the roll. [name] as official court reporter for the 2001 SECRETARY: For the appointment of The motion carries X-X. Apportionment Board, [calls rolfl. Thank you. For the record, I'd like to ask our court reporter, who is GOVERNOR KASICH: _-___ r name , to lease identify jiris her] self. here from the .irnn of [. _ . ^--P ------25 LPL 000394 name] in [cityJ, Ohio. ^ REPOR [T R Mv n une is [namel, court reportc.r with [fr'rm VIII. Adoption of Rules and Procedures GOVERNOR KASICH: This brings us to our next agenda item, which is the adoption of the rules of the 2011 Apportionment Board. All the members should have a copy of the proposed. rules which I provided to each of you in advance of today's meeting. These proposed rules are, in essence, a revised version of the rules of the 2001 Apportionment Board which are on file with the Legislative Service Commission. Our intention is to vote on the rale.s as a block unless there is an amendment. At tbis time I. would entertain a motion regarding the rules. [If 't'here is n motion to adopt the proposed rules as a block] MEMBER: Mr. Cbairman., I move that we vote to adopt Rules X-X. ER: Second. GOVERNOR KASICH: The motion has been made and seconded. Any discussion? If none, the Secretary wTill call the roll. The motion carries X-X. SECRETARY: On the motion to adopt Rules X-X jcalls roll]. [If there is a motion to amend the proposed rules] GOVERNOR KASICH: Tbe motion has been made and seconded. Any discussion? MEMBEI2: Move to amend. moves to amend. Please describe your amendment. GOVERNOR KASICH: [name] Member proceeds to describe amendment. GOVERNOR KASICH: The amendment has been moved. MEMBER: Second. GOVERNOR KASICH: 'Che motion has been made and seconded. Any discussion? If none, the Secretary will call the roll. SECRETARY: [calls rolfl- The motion to aniend passes X-X. If GOVERNOR KASICFI: Is there further discussion on the proposed rules as amended'? If not, { will the secretary please call the roll on the motion to adopt the proposed rules. 26 LPL 000395 ---- _...... --- ____. SECRI T ARY: [calls roll] The motion to adopt rules X X as amendetl passes X X. GOVERNOR KASICtf: 1he rules have been adopted. I instruct the Secretary o('ihe Board to certify and file these rules t2irthwith as prescribed by the Ohio Revised Code. 1`he rules we have just adopted provide for provide for a series of public hearings around the state to receive public input and coinment on the apportionment plan. At this point I would entertain a motion to establish a schedule of these public hearings. MEMBER: Mr. Chairman, I had earlier distributed a proposed schedule stating the times and places for ten public hearings to be held in various locations around the state from August X to August X. I would move that we adopt the proposed schedule as the schedule of public bearings as required by our rules. GOVE.RIVOR KASICH: Is there a second? MEMBER: Second. GOVERNOR KA.SICF1: The motion has been made and seconded. Any discussion? If none, the Secretary will call the roll. The motion SECRETARY: On the mOtion to adopt the public schedule of hearings, [calls roll}. carries X-X. GOVERNOR KASICH: The Secretary is instructed to make the scltedule available to the press and the public. IX. Designation of place for public review of proposed apportionment plan GOVERNOR KASICH: As I understand it, we need to designate a place or places where the public may review the plans of apportionment that are filed with the Board, pursuant to our own rules and procedures. Is there a motion on the designation of a place for public review of submitted plans? MEMBER: Mr. Chairman, I move that the Board designate a website with the address of [URL] wbere public may review the plans that were submitted to the Board. MEMBER: Second. GOVERNOR KASICH: The motion has been made and seconded. Any discussion? If none, the Secretary will call the roll. SECRETARY: On the motion to designate the place where the public may view apportionment plans, (calls rolll The motion carnes X-X. 27 GOVERNOR 9GASICI1: The Secretary is instructed to make the website as the designated place for public review of plans available to the press. X. Establishing time, date, and place of next meeting GOVERNOR KASICII: At this time I will entertai,n a motion to establish the date and place of the next meeting of the 2011 Apportionment BoartL MEMBER: Mr. Chairman, I move that the next meeting of the Bo£rd be set for [dateltime/location]. MEMBE.R: Second. GOVERNOR KASICII: The motion has been made and seconded. Any discussion? if none, the Secretary will call the roll. d SECRETARY: On the motion to set the date and location of the next Apportionment Boar meeting for [dateitime/location], [calls roll]. The motion carries X-X. XI. Adjonrn GOVERNOR KASICH: Any further business to come before the 2001 Apportionment Board? If not, I will entertain a motion to recess the Board until [timeldate/location]. MEMBER: Mr. Chairman, so moved. MEMBER: Second. GOVERNOR KASICH: The motion has been made and seconded_ All in favor? Opposed? Thank you, the 2001 Apportionment Board is adjourned. 28 LPL 000397 Heather Mann From, Heather Mann (heathernmann@gmail_com] Sent: Saturday, September 24, 2011 11 _18 PM To: 'Matthew T. Schuler'; '[email protected]'; 'Mary Amos Augsburger ; Halle Pelger ([email protected]); 'Lenzo, Mike'; 'Troy J'; 'Grodhaus, Michael'; 'Matt. Ca rle@governor. oti3o.gov' Subject: 2011-09-26 Apportioriment Board Meeting Script Aftachments: 2011-09-26 Apportionment Board Meeting Script_.doc All: Please see attached a revised version of the script for Monday, which includes a report from the Secretaries on the plans received, a motion to accept all plans submitted, and a brief report on the technical amendment being prepared, if you have any additional changes, please let Ray or I know. Sincerely, Heather Mann .r. Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, Ohio 43206 (614) 352-5819 tLeathernmartn@&maii.com LPL 000398 t\PPOR't'YON'MENT BOA3tD ?VIEE'rING SCRIPT SEPTEMBER 26,2011 (TESYTNIONY ON PLANS) 1. Call to Order & Introduction of Panel GOVERNOR KASICH: The meeting will now come to order. Pursuant to notice, I now reconvene the 2011 Ohio Apportionment Board. The Secretary will call the roll. SECRETARY: [calls roll] [Members state names and titles] SECRETARY: All members are present; we have a quorum. GOVERNOR 1CA.SICH: Pursuant to the rules adopted by the Board on August 4,2011, the Secretary have circulated for review, to all members, transcripts from our initial meeting on August 4`h and the regional hearings held August 22 - 26. At this time, I will ask for a motion to dispense with the reading and adopt these transcripts as the official minutes. A[7Dl'I'OR YOST: Mr. Chairman, I move that we dispense with the reading and adopt the transcripts as the official minutes of the previous meeting and the regional hearings. SECRETARY HiJSTED OR PRESIDENT NIEHAUS: Second. GOVERNOR I{ASICH: The motion has been moved and seconded. Any objections? Seeing none, the minutes are adopted. The Board at its last meeting adopted rules for the submission of proposed apportionment plans for the taking of public comments and testiniony regarding the plans so submitted. The purpose of this meeting is to allow the presentation of timely submitted plans and public testimony on those plans. Any person wishing to present a plan or offer testimony regarding a plan should fill out a witness form available on the table and give it to our staff. Those who helped draft and create submitted plans know what a tough job this is, and I would like to thank each of you fnr taking the time and effort to draft a plan for our consideration. To sununarize our rules, any person or organization that has submitted a proposed plan of apportionment will be alluwed to have its sponsor personally, or through a representative, present the substance of their plan to the board, for a period not to exceed 10 minutes unless extended by a majority of the board. In order to conduct this meeting in an orderly fashion under our rules, I will call each plan's sponsor or desiguated representative to present their plan. At the end of each sponsor's presentation, we will have time for questions by Board members as recognized by the chair. LPL 000399 Once a plan lras been presented, the public may offer testimony in the order desiguated by the Chainnan for a period not to exceed five minutes, unless extended by a majority of the board. 'I'he Chainnan may limit testimony as he deems necessary. I would ask witnesses to limit their testimony to the apportionment of state legislative districts, which is the sole charge of the Apportiomnent Board. At this time I would ask the Secretaries to report to the Board the number of plans that were received and whether they were submitted in accordance with the rules. SECRETARY: NIr. Chairman, four plans were submitted to the Board by the Friday, Sept. 23'd deadline. The rules adopted by the board required submissions to include hard copy and electronic versions of the legal definitions and visual representations of the proposed boundaries_ One plan was submitted by the Joint Secretaries of the Apportionment Board with all board- required components. 7'wo plaus were submitted from the Ohio Campaign for Accountable Redistricting and included all components except a legal definition. The fourth plan was submitted by the Senate and House Democrat caucuses and included all re.quired components except a legal definition. SECRETARY HUSTED: Mr. Chairman, in the interest of considering all citizen input, I would like to move at this time that the Board accept these plans as submitted and receive testimony on them today_ AUDITOR YOST: Second. GOVERNOR KASICH: The motion has been moved and seconded. Are there any objections? Seeing none, we will now proceed with testimony. H. Public Testimony GOVERNOR KASICH: At this time I would like to call our first witness, the sponsor or representative of the plan submitted by Please state and spell your name for the record. [Sponsor pre.sents plan to the Board] GOVERNOR KASICH: Any questions for the witness? [Direct questions from the Board] GOVERNOR KASICH: Thank you for your testimony. Our next witness is We will now take ublic testimony on the plan submitted by [plan sponsor]: 2 LPL 000400 ( fust (Secretarv will hand you vvitness• slips 6n turn for any public testinaony on the plan presented'} I GOVERNOR KASICH: Any questions for the witness? Seeing none, I now call the sponsor or representative of the plan submitted by [Etc. urttil all plans have been presented] III. Adjourn GOVERNOR ICASICH: Thank you to all to who have offered testimony today. All plans subtnitted have now been presented to the board. I would like to give members of the Board until Wednesday to review the plans and consider testimony that has been offered bere. If any Member of the Board intends on offering an amendment to any plan, they may submit them in advance to the Secretaries at the redistricting^a redistrictinp.ohio.Qov email address, and they will be timely conveyed to members of the Board. I would ask the Secretaries to provide the Board with an update on some technical amendments to their submission. SECRETARY: Mr: Chaim3an, we are preparing a technical amendment to our original submission that makes non-substantive corrections to the legal definitions such as the spelling of political subdivisions and references to various precincts, none of which makes any changes to the overall boundaries of the map itself. We will endeavor to email this to members of the Board as soon as possible. GOVERNOR KASICH: Thank you. I will now entertain a motion to RECESS this ineeting until Wednesday, September 28 at 14AM. AUDITOR YOST: Mr. Chairman, I move that the Board stand in RECESS until Wednesday, September 28 at I OAM in the Senate Finance ITearing Room. SECRETARY HUSTED OR PRESIDENT NIEHAUS: Second. GOVERNOR RACICIT: Will the Secretary please call the roll? SECRETARY: [Calls roll and announces vote.] GOVERNOR KASICH: The motion passed. The Board stands in recess. LPL 000401 Draft Irriiial.4pportionmerzt l3oard Xleetdng.4genda & Script ISVPCIAL APPORTIONMENT.BOARD MEE'P1NG SCRIP'r I.. Call to Order r GOVERNOR KASICH: Pursuant to Article 11, Section 1 ofthe Ohio Constitution, I hereby call to order this rneeung ol' the 2011 Board of Apportio,lung Persons. 1 here is a quorum of members present, but for the record, would each. member of the Board please indicate their presence by stating their name. [Members state names and titles] T'his meeting is called pursuant to Article II, Section I of the Ohio Constitution, which requires that after each decennial census, the Ohio Board of Apportioning persons - including the Govemor, Secretary of State, Auditor of State, and two persons selected by the leadership of the General Assembly convenes between August I and October I of the year the census figures are released to establish the district lines of the Ohio General Assembly. Article i I of the Constitution governs the procedures for this apportionment, and we will therefore proceed under its provisions. 11. Election of Chair of the Apportionment Board GOVERNOR KASICH: Members have been provided with a copy of the proposed agenda for this meeting, which was distributed in advance. The first item on the agenda is the selection of a chair. MEMBER: Mr. Governor, I move that Governor Kasich be named chair of the Apportionment Board. GOVERNOR KASICH: We have a motion. Is there a second? MEMBER: I second the motion. seconds. The nomination has been made and GOVERNOR KASICH: [Names member] seconded. Are there any other nominations? If not, all if favor signify by saying aye [all say ayel. Those opposed? Motion is carried, I will serve as chair. III. Present Indicia of Office and Letters of Appointment 23 LPL 000402 GOV1:'sRNC)R KASICH: 'hh-e next item of bustness is for the members of the Board to veriTy their membership on the Board by presenting their letters of appointment, in the case of lc^islative apportioning persons, and oaths of office in the ease of other members_ The Chair will now receive these doeuments. I would hke to indicate for the record that I have the certiRcates of office for Secretary of State Hnsted, Auditor David Yost, and myself as Governor. I also have a letter frotn Senator Cafaro, Minority Leader of the Ohio Senate, and Armond Budish, Minority Leader of the Ohio House, choosing and appointing [SenatorllZepre.sentative Xj to set-ve on this Board. 'fhe Chair has now received the appropriate documentation from each member, and it all appears to be in order. IV. Election of Secretary of Apportionment Board GOVERNOR KASICH: The next item on the agenda is for the selection of a secretary to the Board of Apportioning persons. The Secretary will keep the minutes, call the roll, and record all votes and maintain custody of all the records of the Apportionment Board, including the proposed plan to be filed with the Board. I will now entertain a motion for secretary. MEMBER: Mr. Chairman, I move that [naine] be named Secretary of the Apportionment Board. GOVERNOR KASICH: We have a motion. Is there a second? MEMBER: I second the motion. GOVERNOR KASICH: [Names member] second the motion. The nomination has been made and seconded. Are there any other nominations? Is there any discussion of the nomination? If [nanze] not, all if favor signify by saying aye [all say aye]. Those opposed? Motion is carried, the records, the documentation will serve as Secretary. I will now give [name], the custodian of provided to me. V. Election of Vice Chair of Apportionment Board GOVERNOR KASICH: The next item on the agenda is the selection of a vice chair to the Board of Apportiorting persons. I nominate [name] to serve as vice chair of the 2011 Apportionment Board. Is there a second? MEMBER: I second the motion. seconds the rnotion. The nomination has been made GOVERNOR KASICII: [iVames member] 24 LPL 000403 __..._ aird seconded. Are there any other nominations? Is there any discussion of the nomination? 11 not, all if favor signifY bv saying aye [all say aye]. '1`hose opposed? If not, will the Secretary please call the role. [calls SECRE'fARIj: For the selection of [name] as Vice Chair of the Apportionrnent Board, rollj. [Name] is selected V ice Chair of the Apportionmen,t Board by a vote of X-X. VI. Annonncement of Attorney Itepresentation GOVERNOR KASICI[: I-listorically, the Attomey General has represented the Board and all persons serving on the Board. Attorney General Dewine has appointed Mark Braden to be here today to be available to the Board. f woald like to ask Mr. Braden to identify himself on the record. MARK BRADEN: Mr. Chairman, Members of the Board. I am Mark Bra.del, Counsel to the Board. GOVERNOR KASICII: Thank you, and welcome. VII. Appointment of Official Court Reporter GOVERNOR KASICH: At this point, given the official and historic natnre of our proceedings, we need to appoint an. official court reporter for the proceedings of the Apportionment Board. Accordingly, I will now entertain a motion to appoint an official eourt reporter for these proceedings. MEMBER: Mr. Chairman, I move that the firm of [name] be the official court reporter for the 2001 Apportionment Board and that said court reporter please prepare aad provide eacb member of the Board a copy of the transcript of each of our meetings. MEMBER: I second the motion. GOVERNOR KASICH: [Names member] seconds the rnotion. The notnination has been rnade and seconded. Are there any other nominations? Is therc any discussion of the nomination? If not, all if favor signify by saying aye [all say aye]. '1"hose opposed? If not, will the Secretary please call the roll. SECRETARY: For the appointment of [rurme] as official court reporter for the 2001 Apportionment Board, [calls rollE. The motion carries X-X. GOVERNOR KASICEI: Thank you. For the record, I'd like to ask our court reporter, who is here from the fi rm of [nanre], to please identifv jhis4her]seif. 25 LPL 000404 FI2LPOR IrR: Mv name is [runnc], evurt reporter u7kh [firrn natnel in [city], O VIII. Adoption of Rules and Procedures GOVERNOR KASICIIc This brings us to our next agenda item, which is the adoption of the rules of the 2011 Apportionment Board. All the members should have a copy of the proposed rules which. I provided to each of vou in advance of today's meeting. These proposed rules are, in essence, a revised version of the rules of the 2001 Appoitionment Board which are on file with the Legislative Service Commission. Our intention is to vote on the rvles as a block unless there is an amerulment_ At this time I would entertain a motion regarding the rules. [I, f there is n motion to adopt the proposed t-ules as a block] MEMBER: Mr. Chainnan, I move that we vote to adopt Rules X-X. MEMBER: Second. GOVERNOR KASICH: The motion has been made and seconded. Any discussion? If none, the Secretary will call the roll. motion carries X-X. SECRETARY: On the motion to adopt Rules X-X [calls roll]. The [If there is a motion to amend the proposed rules] GOVERNOR KASICH: 'f'he motion has been made and seconded. Any discussion? MEMBER: Move to amend. GOVERNOR KASICII: [name] moves to amend. Please describe your amendment. Member proceeds to describe amendment. GOVERNOR KASICFI: The amendment has been moved. MEMBER: Second. GOVERNOR KASICl-L• The ntotion has been tnade and seconded. AnY discussioii? If none, the Secretary will call the roll. SECRETARY: [calls rolt). The motion to aniend passes X-X. ^ GOVERNOR KASICIL Is there further discussion on the proposed rules as arnended? If not. will the secretary please call the roll on the motion to adopt the proposed rules. 26 LPL 000405 ___ _._.------X as amended passes X-X. SEGR} "I ARY: [calls rollJ - C"he _.cnotx ontc_r adopt rules X- GOVERNOR KASIC:II: The rules have been adopted. I instruct the Secretary of the Board to certify and file these rules forthwith as prescribed by the Ohio Revised Code. The rules we have just adopted provide for provide for a series of public hearings around the state to receive public input and comment on the apportionment plan. At this point I would entertain a motion to establish a schedule of these public hearings. M.EIvlI3ER: ;ufr. Chairman, I bad earlier distributed a proposed scliedule stating the times and places for ten public bearinl;s to be held in various locations around the state from August X to August X. I would move that we adopt the proposed schedule as the schedule of public hearings as required bv our rules. GOVERNOR KASICk-I: Is there a second? MEMBER. Second. The motion bas been made and seconded. Any discussion? If none, the GOVERNOR ICASICH: Secretary will call the roll. [calls roltj. '1'he motion SECRETARY: On the motion to adopt tbe public schedule of hearings, canies X-X. GOVERNOR KASICH: The Secretary is instructed to make the schedule available to the press and the public. IX. Designation of place for public review of proposed apportionment plan GOVERNOR KASICI-I: As I understand it, we need to designate a place or places where the public may review the plans of apportionment that are filed with the Board, pin'suant to our own rules and procedures. Is there a motion on the designation of a place for public review of submitted plans? MEMBER: Mr. Chairman, I move that the Board designate a website with the address of [URLj where public may review the plans that were submitted to the Board. MEMBER: Second. GOVERNOR KASICIi: The motion has been made and seconded. Any discussion? If none, the Secretary will call the roll. the public may view apportiotunent SECRETARY: On the motion to designate the place where planse [cnlGr rol11_ The motion carries X-X. ------27 LPL 000406 OVERNOR KASICH: I he Secretary is instl-ucted to make the website as the designated plaee for public review of plans availab[e to the press. X. Establishing time, date, and place of next meeting GOVERiNOR KASICH: At this time I will entertain a motion to establish the date and place of the next meeting of the 2011 Apportionment Board. MEMBER: Mr. Chairman, I move that the next meeting of the Board be set for [date/time%tocation ]. MEMBER: Second. GOVERNOR KASICH: The motion has been inade and seconded. Azry discussion? lf norte, the Secretary will call the roll. i SECRETnRY: On the motion to set the date and location of the next Apportionment Board The motion carries X-X. ^ meeting for [date/time/location], (calls rolfl. XI. Adjourn Anv further business to come before the 2001 Apportiomnent Board? GOVERNOR KASICH: [ti»aeldate/Iocatfon]. If not, I will entertain a motion to recess the Board until MEMBER: Mr. Chatrrnan, so moved. MEMBER: Second. GOVERNOR KASICH: The motion has been made and seconded. All in favor? Opposed? Thank you, the 2001 Apportionment Board is adjoumed. 28 LPL 000407 Page ] of 2 Hotmait Print Message The super partisan democratic maps . ,._ :-:. Ray DiRossi (raydirossi@gmaiLcom) SO ^ 1tSat 9/24/11 6:06 PM Mike Dttoe (dittoemr@ gmail.corn); John McClellarrd ([email protected]) _ Matt Schuler sbc email ([email protected]); Troy J. ([email protected]); Mary' Amos Augsburger ([email protected]); Halle Pelger ([email protected]); Ivtichael Lenzo ([email protected]); John Barron [email protected]); rnichael.grod'[email protected]; [email protected]; Heather N. Ivlann - gmail ([email protected]); Clark Benserr - policiata ([email protected]); Braden, E Mark ([email protected]); !ohn B. Morgan ([email protected]) Ijust got my first took at the detaiied'nouse and senate democratic caucus maps With all of the attacks coming at the maps Heather and I submitted claiming they were hyper partisan and blatant political gerrymander maps that simply attack dernocrats I just want to point out that they slammed us for negatively affecting 9 democrats through forced primaries and geography changes....- See list below^ Scolozi and Fedor Celeste and Stinziano Wilson and Sciavoni Gariand and Gonzalez Driehaus and Tehrar Oakey and Thompson I just want to set the record straight... and hope we get out there with this My initiaf analysis of how the Democratic House and Senate caucus maps treats republicans It pairs or negatively effects 28 Republicans! R's in forced primaries Maag and Beck Hottinger and Hayes Slaby and Roegner Peterson and Hackett Wachtman and Goodwin Johnson and Carey Hite and Wagoner Burke and Jordan Beagle and Widener Balderson and Schaffer Patton and Obhoff R's in Dem districts Landis and Okey Thomson and Phillips Koz anii Letson Butler and Lucky Baker and Foley e0_.. 12/21/2011 htrn-Nhl i 34w hln l;4mail.live.cnm/maiL'PrintMessaeesasnx?cnids=60698171-e60-17 SOS-1112 LPL 000408 Page 2 of 2 Flotmail Print Message Anielski and Budish Hope this is useful.... 1 2,121/2011 httn//hIt 34w hlnl ;4.mail.livecom/rnaiVPrintMessaees_asnx?cnids=60698171-e6f9-11e. - 80S 1113 LPL 000409 From: Mary Amos Augsburger Sent: Sunday, September 25, 2011 2:39 PM To: David B. Potts; Brenda L. Rinehart; Breeze; Tony Tanner FW: Treatment of Incumbent African-American Members Subject: From: Mary Amos Augsburger [mai[to:[email protected]] Sent: Sunday, September 25, 2011 1:09 PM To: Mary Amos Augsburger Subject: Fwd: Treatment of Incumbent African-American Members Sent from my iPad - please forgive any typos! Begin forwarded message: From: "Heather Mann" Here is a quick overview of how the submitted plans treat incumbent African-American members with respect to forced primaries. Our analysis is continuing, more to come. OCAR - Clarke OCAR - Fortner Joint Secretaries Democrat Caucuses • 8 minority members • 7 minority member Minority • No incumbent • Four minority pairings: HD 15: pairings: HD 31: Districts black members members pairings: ames vs . Anielski; Mallory vs.. Driehaus; drawn in with D 61: Luckie vs. B HD 46: Ashford vs. H,j, D bents. Butler; D 82: Ashford other incum r HD 1 Patmon vs. Fedor; DI6: Fedor; HD 20: vs. Williams; HD17: Williams vs. Patmon, Weddington vs. Weddington vs. SD 2: Turner vs. Stinziano vs. Celeste; Grossman; HD 39: Smith. HD 29: Mallory vs. Driehaus; HD 37: Luckie vs. Henne; HD Milkovich vs. Sykes; 36: Sykes vs. SD 9: Kearney vs. McKenney; SD 31: Seitz; SD 11: Brown Tavares vs. Schaffer vs. Wagoner; SD 25: Tumer vs. Smith *** Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, Ohio 43206 LPL 000410 ile:///FJ/...20v."/o20Kasich/Auditor%20RFP/11 09_25%20FW%20Treatment%20of%20Inmunbent"/^20African-American%20Members htm[1/11/2012 4:55:04 PM] (614) 352-5819 heatliernma ut uglnail c^ LPL 000411 ile:///Fl/_.20v.°/20Kasich/Auditor%20RFP/11_09 25%20FW%20Treatment%20of%20lnmimbent%20African-American%20Members bCm[t/11/2012 4:55:04 PM] Heather Mann From: Lisa Griffin [email protected]] Sent: Sunday, September 25, 2011 1:21 AM [email protected]; raydirossi@gmaiLcom To: Subject: Nfinority Excel Attachments: Minority Candidates Elected Ohio House and Senate.xlsx LPL 000412 r., ^ Q Q c Q N ^ q M t `i m m^ Qi q 1l fJ N q It N q ^H - H .. x. o N a u H °: a m N O r a' a H Q a r] H r2 m m m R^. m .-f O U +; c^ o C W N l0 h ^ p^ H N H .1 N N rn NI M W T 'Y q Q ^ ^ q N m.i rf U F W a -i N N N* O N Ol m .r m T ri r1 N N N !*} M rl M w c Q ^ Q q Q [p q .r^ q q q Q G N ^ m O v bmi rt^i 4^ N'6 O3 m ^ m w h .] W^' ^p`^ a, ^ a m w a N -1 N o ^^ m m w m r' f m 6^ N H rt N N M rr M n a w w Q Q Q Q q Q a ^ m q Q q m C >. q m qr 'D Q O ^' m Q qi ^ C 7. N O H r Y r Q ti U m O ^+r H Y O m H m C'O N^i rc U r3 n ti 3 A yf 'H a 3 Q. ^ F^ O ro ^.G N ^ N rtl N O S. O ^ X W h r"^C ^ a ca 7 ra a m [+ w^.^ rz m u, P O Y1 N ri N O N m W m m m .+ N N 'f ro u^ .+ .i .i N rv r^ rr m r: m v Q Q Q ^ m q q m C ?. q mu Q q Q o q o 'p ^ O Q C ?r 4f O S-r u r m m u H+-^ O m s+ w q ^ ^.^ N 3 ri i N N'6 3 Ra A Z Lt 7 O N ri N .. m_- P m ^ N N r+r M M Cf '1' d' ri m Q^ i N q Q q r q m q q Q T ^i m Q Q u r . u ry N O U m m U .t X n ^ w v a^ N ^ri t^6 rt ^ O?^ O N S f4 E L'^: Lti ^ h CJ c^ yr m N N M M ..i rm ar s Q Q Q ,r r; m Q N C. N.^ L i r ^ X.-Oi 20'. v m N ^ m • e ^ o s a E ^ w ^ N O M m ^y ...:m m N N r'1 Q q iA 1 h m O [^ m Q Q ^ p H ^ Qr m gy N G: m m w 7 N h S a o N i N y N N N fi [() p^ r1 ri N N C ti+ yqMf7 H ^ cr ^q m ^ 1I N 111 d' N u{ m 1 N N d' ^M N p A q b N T -+ N O + E ^ E ^a p o- pp N^n R E+ h Q o N N O 4^ ^) C C G' N +Ca ai p o x ^ - ^I W W ^- N p T tD N N M ^ aT aN q p 4 p pi Y Q Q ^ n M Q p ^a m r w T N y . .i ^ p D X p C0 s, o E u N d N Cr ^ N A^J O ^ H 0.U} W P1 G. N a° ^ a a a a N m o a^ m o a ^ c + n m t^ en m + n h N N N N N f^l m `Y ^T d' ^p N From: Heather Mann To: "Halle Pel er"• "Ma Amos Au sbur er" Grodhaus Michael "Lenzo Mike" tohn barron@senate state oh us "Matthew T. Schuler" dave@daveVOSt. com; "Braden, E. Mark", "Troy 3"; Halle Pelger; "Rav DiRoss;._ Subject: Sample Questions & Draft Comparison of Plans Date: Sunday, September 25, 2011 8:30:51 PM Attachments: Questions for 9 26-11 Apportionment Board Hearinq.docx Comparison Chart for Members.docx All: Please find attached a list of sample questions and a draft comparison chart of the submitted plans that Ray & I have put together for the Board Members. Please contact us if you have any questions. Sincerely, Heather & Ray *^* Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, Ohio 43206 (614) 352-5819 [email protected] LPL 000415 m N Q r N N O Q yT'Op. Q O'3 uL,' d Y^ x O 3d NTW q^ R.^.p.'^fti' ,_; VR o ^ h mviW p^ m15 ^,j dAo L°o 3 Fd$rc'`^arNn^^v. yc^E^yQ^^^q9dapa U C u D f2 W' O O vq y N h «(Y d U V J ^ u . 3 ^G . nai 0 a^ 6«^ 4 aHS^ dF^-°O^°'u • Uoz 'o • • E _„ m 5^'3 v.n G m 5 e.n q^^ v^ ^ <°v U Q ka . 3 a o^ e^ CY ^' x^ 3 U 3'..CS.v.^^•a^,3j^ 9 qQQQm. N a?xU a9 m E « «_ F^'^;qQe"y ^..xx^xq._^^^xad4aep pi T^ C' T O 3 ^'O T Q E ^ p^.` D.6 D E x Q m U'S 6 U t m o C. U Tn ^ U Q y Q U N « $.Oy ^ . j Y ^" E N Jp] 5. c cG o0 0 0^ d v c^ c c U U^ i^ ^ x U ^ L n y d 4 p N ua ~ o E^«x U 3^ Vdi E p= P ^.. y O .-r x O 9. T D L^'x ^ Ow C'O `^ e N> >ai v " u^u « p ap. N M v^i 9. u Y^ E 0.^'^ aai C V C.+'3 0" Q E" O ^ .-'3. ' r rF"n U^8 b .^O Q W^>i O^ ryT ^ TY UbUN Q O pP UU :^ U M.-NiGCLN NV^'G.vdiQ A R R T3 'p ^R ^= Y ^ V r P'3 9' j q H T Q 0 y rT' b JT• T V ^ r^ W 3 U C F ^ U P^ O^p ^.6 \O N . CG'd'6'O.nm QGCeCim^U^UZ'OmO00 N _ O^ L31^,-r+7r'Pie~iTM=.p C NY ^U FdyrLn•0. dp0. ^' N " a a 3 3 3 ^'^ oi U U oo Q¢ `d m o o E a 1O Q m n`^ ..a. ^ a. m^R m^a ,^ U U Q o y °' ^ o P. '- ^ '^ w.o. '"n'^'" mca i i '9=.^-' 0.o^M M^oa E^o.o°^}^^ ^R `N'=O^ a.^'` 'F.„ pP^.•a^^ 1 G R L T T r+ 3 O L Q q Q^ t6 Q a:-. Q O 0 0 O d U V U V Q F • • • N y .a o n ^ y °a' Q x o 3 x a ^".^.. "°' o R«co o^^ a. ?. ° c. o : U A x a !^ro 3>,.9_ fi 3^ap5 . E o ^ a ^uw ^'^N Od0 ^oLmiid pQvW^.3'a L^`pGUC'G'FS(n^FJ^OCOF mpp HOC P. .N c'do « y [i] 3-p'^ 3o3x%o HL _ omo-»o^xHGO Ho, q >^ o. L W F va m N N O L 3^ a A ^ a ^ m p ^ U U u p'p L" ^ ^^ " E r G O.3 H^ O ^ t^ ^ O C U 9' ^ G x U j'i N p ^ O . . G e"n '. m U ^B°' U i o^w«o.ooQd_^N ^. _FPC'd°^3>N O x N p 3y .^F U ^°^- ^ o ,uH, ro=«^u.x 3'6 i UOnu o i knla_F ^HO9.o°•v^aM..U3'°''^.ipo'^SCJ-^v^,-;2'oE°e,v-c^^o^dv^`" :^ ^. ^'i tFi Op V C G E'^ ^^' ^ .ai va M G.Ti ^.T^i N 3 m W R c V 1' Q L,a Q 3'VS'• p^• _T "^' O^?-+'QQc^ N a ,coapay.:c!_, r.r b'O G'dVp..U>[^«^CQ^ ^-.V.6v ..'^D U.ViaR'6 i30V Yr^^U.u Ml^P•ri m^O'M-Upo q^mt•VC!O^^OA^F ' T'S-' Q F' R. R i d O N V o V ^ i ^ O A a N ^. ^`nm Q Oa y d u N`^ '3 C ^ C7 ^.v. U v F U O^ O ui A 4^ 0 Q E U U" 'O'd x33 M 6'O OO .^iL q r^^U^ in^3'S^mWU'R_ '-3.5 ^NEOM' c.o Y ^'Ca^nSUe_y' .m rii vi " w:.N a, ^ d E ^ P o y 3 N m y_ ^o o ,_, '3', y H R°F °. m`° a e R`^ a .a+ o-M-^ v _ 3 . ^" n Q r6 -l. y,_, E p_a>i ^ h o N m 12 H (.)3 I3 I ^I ^ ^ q^^y ^ t^ia E Q ``-L C (a MO. r ^7« V A^.-^NU^TiQ^Cyd ..^J ' R F Oy>^ 1^L^a' N^ 'Y. ^ L: O Ve ]`G `^. F .N.. c [hu ^..-...o ^ y y 0'E .^iapVOt^3^o il12 aN]I I '^ ia.VLj..= = O n Y F^ ^ G ai o O ^+ C M ^ a+ 9 `i ^ = T T F' Q d N ^>i E N U C J O Q^ 30 q R q x C= r.--. ti Y W ^.r.i ^^ N U N U^ r . Q r i e^gFppo >^ Zpm d 3 . ° .,. d .,. d U m',Z A.H.^ 3xM ow° q Q U U U U Q H • • • = c Q ^v eu m ^3 N O G w Y U O Q T p'O r'1 3 F 0 p U m 3 ^ 1 '-w y^^ o a a v d O F.a '° 3 3 3 ^? ti a = y N Q c Q e m 3^ M a' 3 3`°° 3 ^'p q'.r 'y '.Z o c o ^ ^^ S v d d fa rii nR U^ U . 14^ m L^ o m o q Q V V U V Q H • 0 V 3 on L p '.= u. .C O 'F/. QA,i,] 0 U 4 q s >q .. N "^ '.L. G x T N O V '«t'! F G . . Q 'd y F ' ^:a^. ^ vt ' W a c ^ °-, v°o >Q3 c^ 0 5 ^ C tl .m Q^>4` '.; y U^ ax _ g ^ >p o c w v q O q e^oN F p."°. Ed^°C U ^tiv ^ E+'d N xOJ^ N¢•F T «^ n C N^ N A y >^ ^^Q ^ Ee^ U m OdVa?a'^.'1^'av.Dy'..N.ti E m ^ a o vFi o'^^ .vm^^°^ oeP]wV rvriv°iF xv^ Z Q P ^ .`6. > o Q G D c T E x T ° . o y O O^ R F _ q 1^A .C ^'. ^'^^' bp ^^ G m rq^+ O^ O tE NQ q Q ^ TS V]VSVI Q q ^ ^ ^c'^^'S>c:o c- 'o ° ' o N o^° a ai Q o 3 ^ oaaa xw - ^ ^x5xe5xx^d 0.aa Fo T C C O'y 3 `^C3 >^ F E '6 N y ^ O N^ 3? O^^y d^ N P..C C C. C p d au c c cc'^ "" o a ,5 o ^n >'x rn N m r Q 3 i-1 [-^ v o `^ ^` o G 'E s,.. c .c ° •• ^U a .^a c qw E 3 °o " :3 O q Q ^ [= y^o q ^ m ^ m c a i^i T ^ msvi " Q q Q ^, ° C v F vQw rn.n e' xxx G ' e > N ^ d q Q Q N Ta^. v, p. 6 " rT. . rR^ F ~ « E C T^ ' G p fb G O. "n ^« a._ Oue 'J eF 3eF ^ O E ^3F'- t P3 a CNpU`LN pF EQ'x^ mvN M° ^nF W..]Q> xv^ [^ja G C G ^ d d ° R F N N rC C ^ a ^ ] O \ r' 4'r Ci c C "o e ,J rv . `^°N 8 ° ° 3 :BUq a « = o- .°_ a au a :n m ,c° 'Y ^, '15 ^ ' V o m p C s o E _ c Eq = ao c ctey c^^ ^ , °^ EE :o."s o aaa o c'c y h,^ ^ ^ y F. s ° o ^ c o.v E s o Eo°^mvcsc^c r,o3,, "^'0=m^ '4 `vKOO'=a o Q.^._ F._ q. q ^ . F ^°Za.- C xtio ^' w^FU 3s o.Y. 0 G I F V A w O Fj ^ 'F U Nis y y V 3 ^ P 1^ r" N `o y^ E s o c c s s.-'..°J E o QUESTIONS FOR APPORTIONMENT BOARD HEARING - MONDAY, SEPTEMBER 26, 2011 General Questions • Did you follow the numbering system prescribed by the Ohio Constitution in Art. 11, Sec. 10 and Sec. 1I? • Did you provide for a mandatory single county district as provided for in Art. II, Sec. 9 & 10? • Does your plan provide for permissive single county districts as provided in Art. Il, Sec. 10? [IF YES, ask: "If you did, did you do it for all counties affected by this section?"] • Other than the single county districts, are all of the other districts in your plan within the permitted range of deviation under Art. 11, Sec. 3 and Sec. 4? Democrat Caucuses Plan • I have a series of questions I want to ask you about your plan regarding Art. 11, Sec. 7 that limits the number of split subdivisions between districts? o How many wards did you split in Akron (3) o How many wards did you split in Canton (0) o How many wards did you split in Cincinnati (8) o How many wards did you split in Cleveland (4) o It appears that Cleveland Ward 13 is in three separate House districts - what was your rationale for doing this? o How many wards did you split in Columbus (13) o Columbus Ward 33 is split into 3 House districts -what was your rationale for doing this? o How many wards did you split in Dayton (3) o How many wards did you split in Toledo (7) o Did you split more than one political subdivision in any district? o IF YES: In how many districts did you do this? o Because of these splits, do you believe these districts and your plan is in accordance with Art. 11, Sec. 7? • Were you able to construct districts in Northeast Ohio that complied with Art. 11, Sec. 8 and Sec. I 1? o IF NO: Can you explain why you were unable to do so and how you addressed this issue? o Do you consider this to be a single or multiple violations of the Obio Constitution? • What areas of the state had to lose districts or gain districts due to population shifts? o Did your plan change legislative districts lines to account for these population shifts? o By moving districts from areas losing districts, you had to draw certain incumbent members together. How many members did you pair? o How many member pairings were of members of the same party? How many pairings of members of the opposite party? (22 Republican members paired in 11 districts; 6 Republicans paired with 6 Democrats in 6 districts -for a total of 28 Republicans). LPL 000418 o So you're saying the issue of incumbency was not considered when you drew the plan? Sec. 7(D)? • Did you follow the contours of the current districts as provided for in Art. 11, • Is House District 80 in Erie and Ottawa contiguous? OCAR - Fortner • I have a series of questions I want to ask you about your plan regarding Art. 11, Sec. 7 that limits the number of split subdivisions between districts? o How many wards did you split in Akron (10)? o Akron Ward 5 is split into 4 House districts and Akron Ward 8 is in 3 districts - what was your rationale for doing this? o How many wards did you split in Canton (6)? o How many wards did you split in Cincinnati (17)? o How many wards did you split in Cleveland (11)? o How many wards did you split in Columbus (44)? o How many wards did you split in Dayton (10)? o How many wards did you split in Toledo (10)? o Toledo Ward 9 is in 3 House Districts - what was your rationale for this split? o Did you split more than one political subdivision in any district? o IF YES: In how many districts did you do this? o Because of these splits, do you believe your plan is in accordance with Art. 11, Sec. 7? • Were you able to construct districts in Northeast Ohio that complied with Art. 11, Sec. 8 and Sec. 11? o IF NO: Can you explain why you were unable to do so and how you addressed this issue? o Do you consider this to be a single or multiple violations of the Ohio Constitution? • What areas of the state had to lose districts or gain districts due to population shifts? o Did your plan change legislative districts lines to account for these population shifts? o By moving districts from areas losing districts, you had to draw certain incumbent members together. How many members did you pair? o How many member pairings were of inembers of the same party? How many pairings of members of the opposite party? o So you're saying the issue of incumbency was not considered when you drew the plan? • Did you follow the contours of the current districts as provided for in Art. 11, Sec. 7 (D)? • Is House District 80 in Erie and Ottawa contiguous? OCAR - Clark • I have a series of questions I want to ask you about your plan regarding Art. 11, Sec. 7 that limits the number of split subdivisions between districts? o How many wards did you split in Akron? o How many wards did you split in Canton? LPL 000419 o How many wards did you split in Cincinnati? o How many wards did you split in Cleveland? o How many wards did you split in Columbus? o How many wards did you split in Dayton? o How many wards did you split in Toledo? o Did you split more than one political subdivision in any district? o IF YES: In how many districts did you do this? o Because of these splits, do you believe your plan is in accordance with Art. 11, Sec. 7? • Were you able to construct districts in Northeast Ohio that complied with Art. 11, Sec. 8 and Sec. 11? o IF NO: Can you explain why you were unable to do so and how you addressed this issue? o Do you consider this to be single or multiple violations of the Ohio Constitution? • What areas of the state had to lose districts or gain districts due to population shifts? o Did your plan change legislative districts lines to account for these population shifts? o By moving districts from areas losing districts, you had to draw certain incumbent members together. How many members did you pair? o How many member pairings were of members of the same party? How many pairings of members of the opposite party? o So you're saying the issue of incumbency was not considered when you drew the plan? • Did you follow the contours of the current districts as provided for in Art. 11, Sec. 7 (D)? LPL 000420 Heather Mann Heather Mann [[email protected]] From: Sent: Sunday; September 25, 2011 11:26 PM To: '[email protected]' Subject: Indexes.xlsx Attachments: lndexes,xlsx Dear Auditor Yost: Please find attached the indexes list you requested. You'll note that there is not a presidential index for every Senate district, because not every Senate district runs in a presidential year. Sincerely, Heather Mann as: Heather N. Mann 827 City Park Avenue, Apt. B Columbus, Ohio 43206 (614) 352-5819 hea t hern ma nn ftm a it.com i LPL 000421 HD/SD 5 48.31% 52.78% IID 67 64.03% 58.49% I-ID 1 59.37% 56.13% 1-ID 4 61.02"/° 59.57% I1D 77 59.83°/a 56.60% HD 3 51.43°.>n 45.50% HD See Budish 7 Ken.ny Yuko -D- (2012) 8 Arm,ond Budish -D- (2014) 8 24.53% 19.47% 9 Barbara Boyd -D- (2014) 9 18.89% 13.31% 10 Bill Patmon-D- (2018) 10 16.20% 10.99% I 1 Sandra Wiltiams -D- (2014) 11 18.26% 13.08% 12 John Barnes -D- (2018) 12 20.68% 16-32% 13 Nickie Antonio -D- (2018) 13 30.67% 24.55"/0 14 Mike Foley -D- (2014) 14 40.46% 37.75% 15 Tim DeGeeterr-D-(2012) 15 42.57% 40.42% 16 53.34% 48.29% 6 52.42°1° 49.54% 7 52.65% 49.14% 19 56.92% 50.43% See 11D 20 Nancy Garland -D- (2016) Gonzalez 21 57.57°.% 49.69% 22 41.92% 34.85% }iD 22 John Camey -D- (2016) 23 57.00% 51.10°f° HD 18 30.76"/° 25.86% HD 24 Ted Celeste -D- (2014) See Celeste HD 25 Michael Stinziano -D- (2018) 26 25.88"10 19.65"/° IID 26 Tracy Maxwell Heard -D- (2014) 25 22.24% 16-00% HD 27 Carlton Wcddington -D- (2016) 28 56.93% 51.33% HD 28 Connie Pillich -D- (2016) 29 65.40% 62.29% HD 30 71.31% 68.89% HD See Terhar HD 31 Denise Driehaus -D- (2016) 32 31.96% 23.10% lID 32 Dale Mallory -D- (2014) 33 32.07% 25.28% HD 33 Alicia Reece -D- (2018) 27 64.88% 58.81% HD 54 63.82% 63.06% HD 40 57.73% 55.86% IID 41 58.29`0 54.81% HD 42 62.28% 59.44°/n HD 39 21.65% 16.66% HD 39 Clayton Luckie -D- (2014) 43 47.94% 46.10% HD 40 Roland Winbum -13- (2016) 38 52.47% 50_98% IID 37 52.91% 49.08% FiD 36 47.32% 46-40°!° IID LPL 000422 21,68% 111) 44 Vernnon Sykes -D- (2014) 34 27.17% 35 36.60"/0 34.56% HD 45 ZachMiikovich -D- (2018) 47 56.12% 52.35% HD 46 42.33°/a 37.57o/u tID 47 Teresa Fedor-D-(2018) 44 20.72% 14.77% tID 48 Michael Ashford -D- (2018) See Fedor HD 49 Man Szollosi -D- (2014) 54.100/o 52.87% HD 52.80% 49.86% HD 37.34% 33.23% HD 52 Stephen Slesnick -D_(201fi) 60.79% 60.26% 60.73% 58.600lo }ID 69.02% 65.50a/o fflD 35.28% 31,51% HD 56 Dan Ramos -D- (2018) 47.18"0 43.11% HD 57 Matt Lwtdy-D- (2014) 54,22"/0 50.85% HD 43,10% 46.91% HD 59 Ron Gerberry -D- (2016) 2156% 22.96o/n HD 60 Robet Hagan -D- (2014) See Thompson HD 61 Mark Okey -D- (2014) 46.70% 44.35% 74D 62 Lorrnine Fende -D- (2012) 55.19% 52.49% l-ID 36.80o/u 38.60% HD 64 Tom Letson -D- (2014) 33.37% 37.61% HD 65 Sean OPBrien -D- (2018) 68.63% 65.59% 11D 70.84% 67.31 % RD 43,75% 41.43% HP 57.62% 54.73% RD 61.00% 58.68% HD 59.02"/n 55.79% HD 50.20% 49.10% RD 55.71% 55.68% HD 60.55"/0 58.78% RD 61.08% 58_43"/a HD 63.73"/0 60.53% 69.01°/n 70.41% HD 62.63% 61.08% 65,13% 64.26% 46.90% 43b3% RD 80 De 55.01% 51.80% RD HD 86 6133% 57.70"/0 HD 74 60.81% 58.77% 11D 92 55.32% 55.99% HD 91 58.96o1n 59.45% HD 93 54.13% 59.12°% HP 66 64.22% 63_62% I-iD LPL 000423 90 49.17% 53.80% HD no ^ ^ ^ 68 64,00% 59.94% }1D 72 55.86o./n 53.86% HD 42.71% 92 Debbie Phillips -D- (2016) 94 41.88°./0 ^i U 95 50,87% 53.85°/n HD I fll^ , = 97 54.43% 55.08% iID 96 46.35% HD 95 Lou Gentile -D- (2018) 40.12% 98 54.09% 50.94% 11D 70 57.32% 55.64% HD 76 57.72%0 55.20% HD 99 46.89% 44.04% HD ME 24 49.97% HD Franklin Caunty (OPEN) 56.00% 54.68% HD SE Ohio (OPEN) Hocking base 78 54.76% 20 45.37"'0 lID Franklin County (OPEN) 51.43% 17 40.89% HD Franklin County (OPEN) 44.31% 45 32.21% HD Lucas County (OPEN) 36.93% 31 28,41% HD Hamilton County (OPEN) 34.55%n 61.74%n SD 31.54% 47.15% SD 52.02% SD 64.03% 61.73% SD 46.81% SD 59.38% 56.62% SD 66.71% SD 64,26% 60.47% SD 32.83% SD 9Eri Keamy -D- (2014) 57.38% 55.52% SD SD 11 Efln& Btpwn -D- (2018) 33.76% 64.54% 64.05% SD 45.59% SD 61.14% 61.36% SD SD 15 Charletta Tavares -D- (2018) 26.23% 56.96% 50.21%0 SD 56.16o/n SD 52.69% 50.06% SD 57.22% SD 56.48% 53.68% SD 29.59% SD 21 S ey Smith -D- (2014) 56.89% 55.34% SD 38.28% SD Mike Sl:mdell -D- (2018 52.80% 49,00% S17 19.33% SD 57.95% 54.72% SD 54.67% SD 37.50% 34.63% SD 28 Tom Sawyex-D-(2016) 48.68% SD 44.35% 47.67% SD 30 Jason Wilson -D- (2016) LPL 000424 . 56.43"/ SD 38.67% 40.14% SD 32 Capri Cafaro -D- (2016) 37 43% SD 33 Joe Schavoni -f)- (2018) APPORTIONMENT BOARD MEETING SCRIPT SEPTEMBER 26,2011 (TESTIMONY ON PLANS) 1. Call to Order & Introduction of Panel GOVERNOR KASICH: The meeting will now come to order. Pursuant to notice, I now reconvene the 2011 Ohio Apportionment Board. The Secretary will call the roll. SECRETARY: [calls roll] [Members state names and titles] SECRETARY: All members are present; we have a quorum. GOVERNOR KASICH: Pursuant to the rules adopted by the Board on August 4, 2011, the Secretary bave circulated for review, to all members, transcripts from our initial meeting on August 4'h and the regional hearings held August 22 - 26. At this time, I will ask for a motion to dispense with the reading and adopt these transcripts as the official minutes. AUDITOR YOST: Mr. Chairman, I move that we dispense with the reading and adopt the transcripts as the official minutes of the previous meeting and the regional hearings. SECRETARY HUSTED OR PRESIDENT NIEHAUS: Second. GOVERNOR KASICH: The motion has been moved and seconded. Any objections? Seeing none, the minutes are adopted. The Board at its last meeting adopted rules for the submission of proposed apportionment plans for the taking of public comments and testimony regarding the plans so submitted. The purpose of this meeting is to allow the presentation of timely submitted plans and public testimony on those plans. Any person wishing to present a plan or offer testimony regarding a plan should fill out a witness form available on the table and give it to our staff. Those who helped draft and create submitted plans know what a tough job this is, and I would like to thank each of you for taking the time and effort to draft a plan for our consideration. To summarize our rules, any person or organization that has submitted a proposed plan of apportionment will be allowed to have its sponsor personally, or through a representative, present the substance of their plan to the board, for a period not to exceed 10 minutes unless extended by a majority of the board. In order to conduct this meeting in an orderly fashion under our rules, I will call each plan's sponsor or designated representative to present their plan. At the end of each sponsor's presentation, we will have time for questions by Board members as recognized by the chair. LPL 000426 Once a plan has been presented, the public may offer testimony in the order designated by the Chairman for a period not to exceed five minutes, unless extended by a majority of the board. The Chairman may limit testimony as he deems necessary. I would ask witnesses to limit their testimony to the apportionment of state legislative districts, which is the sole charge of the Apportionment Board. At this time I would ask the Secretaries to report to the Board the number of plans that were received and whether they were submitted in accordance with the rules. SECRETARY: Mr. Chairman, four plans were submitted to the Board by the Friday, Sept. 23Td deadline. The rules adopted by the board required submissions to include hard copy and electronic versions of the legal definitions and visual representations of the proposed boundaries. One plan was submitted by the Joint Secretaries of the Apportionment Board with all board- required components. Two plans were subnritted from the Ohio Campaign for Accountable Redistricting and included all components except a legal definition. The fourth plan was submitted by the Senate and House Democrat caucuses and included all required components except a legal definition. SECRETARY HUSTED: Mr. Chairman, in the interest of considering all citizen input, I would like to move at this time that the Board accept these plans as submitted and receive testimony on them today. AUDITOR YOST: Second. GOVERNOR KASICH: The motion has been moved and seconded. Are there any objections? Seeing none, we will now proceed with testimony. II. Public Testimony GOVERNOR KASICH: At this time I would like to call our first witness, the sponsor or representative of the plan submitted by . Please state and spell your name for the record. [Sponsor presents plan to the Board] GOVERNOR KASICH: Any questions for the witness? [Direct guestions from the Board] GOVERNOR KASICH: Thank you for your testimony. Our next witness is We will now take public testimony on the plan submitted by [plan sponsor] 2 LPL 000427 [Secretary will hand you witness slips in turnfor any public testimony on the plan just presented] GOVERNOR KASICH: Any questions for the witness? Seeing none, I now call the sponsor or representative of the plan submitted by [Etc. until all plans have been presented] III. Recess GOVERNOR KASICH: Thank you to all to who have offered testimony today. All plans submitted have now been presented to the board. I would like to give members of the Board until Wednesday to review the plans and consider testimony that has been offered here. If any Member of the Board intends on offering an amendment to any plan, they may submit them in advance to the Secretaries at the redistrictine(a^redistricting.ohio.gov email address, and they will be timely conveyed to members of the Board. I would ask the Secretaries to provide the Board with an update on some technical amendments to their submission. SECRETARY: Mr. Chairman, we are preparing a technical amendment to our original submission that makes non-substantive corrections to the legal definitions such as the spelling of political subdivisions and references to various precincts, none of which makes any changes to the overall boundaries of the map itself. We will endeavor to email this to members of the Board as soon as possible. GOVERNOR KASICH: Thank you. I will now entertain a motion to RECESS this meeting until Wednesday, September 28 at IOAM. AUDITOR YOST: Mr. Chairman, I move that the Board stand in RECESS until Wednesday, September 28 at lOAM in the Senate Finance Hearing Room. SECRETARY HUSTED OR PRESIDENT NIEHAUS: Second. GOVERNOR KASICH: Will the Secretary please call the roll? SECRETARY: [Calls roll and announces vote.] GOVERNOR KASICH: The motion passed. The Board stands in recess. 3 LPL 000428 4 LPL 000429