BBC - the Editors: Part of the Conspiracy?
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
BBC - The Editors: Part of the conspiracy? http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/theeditors/2007/02/part_of_the_cons... This page has been archived and is no longer updated. Find out more about page archiving. « Previous | Main | Next » Part of the conspiracy? Richard Porter | 17:12 UK time, Tuesday, 27 February 2007 Comments Share this page 845 Share Facebook Twitter The 9/11 conspiracy theories are pretty well known by now. The BBC addressed them earlier this month with a documentary, The Conspiracy Files, shown within the UK. Until now, I don't think we've been accused of being part of the conspiracy. But now some websites are using news footage from BBC World on September 11th 2001 to suggest we were actively participating in some sort of attempt to manipulate the audience. As a result, we're now getting lots of emails asking us to clarify our position. So here goes: 1. We're not part of a conspiracy. Nobody told us what to say or do on September 11th. We didn't get told in advance that buildings were going to fall down. We didn't receive press releases or scripts in advance of events happening. 2. In the chaos and confusion of the day, I'm quite sure we said things which turned out to be untrue or inaccurate - but at the time were based on the best information we had. We did what we always did - sourced our reports, used qualifying words like "apparently" or "it's reported" or "we're hearing" and constantly tried to check and double check the information we were receiving. 3. Our reporter Jane Standley was in New York on the day of the attacks, and like everyone who was there, has the events seared on her mind. I've spoken to her today and unsurprisingly, she doesn't remember minute-by-minute what she said or did - like everybody else that day she was trying to make sense of what she was seeing; what she was being told; and what was being told to her by colleagues in London who were monitoring feeds and wires services. 4. We no longer have the original tapes of our 9/11 coverage (for reasons of cock-up, not conspiracy). So if someone has got a recording of our output, I'd love to get hold of it. We do have the tapes for our sister channel News 24, but they don't help clear up the issue one way or another. 5. If we reported the building had collapsed before it had done so, it would have been an error - no more than that. As one of the comments on You Tube says today "so the guy in the studio didn't quite know what was going on? Woah, that totally proves conspiracy... " Share this page 845 Share Facebook Twitter Comments 1 of 133 23.10.15 22:20 BBC - The Editors: Part of the conspiracy? http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/theeditors/2007/02/part_of_the_cons... 1. Jump to more content from this blog MoreAt 06:07 from PM on 27this Feb 2007,blog... miss daw wrote: About this blog NoTopical other buildingposts on fell this around blog the timeArchives of the report (approx 1657hrs)andCategories the Latest contributors solomon brothers building did not fall for approx another 30mins (1720hrs). Welcome to The Editors, a site The Great British class Past twelve months These are some of thewhere we, Hosteditors from across Whatcalculator source (14) told the bbc that theApril 47 storey 2013 (3)solomon building (wtc7)popular had topics this blogNews, will Steveshare ourHerrmann dilemmas collapsed?iPhone and iPad app March 2013 (1) covers. issues. HereRichard are tips Porter on taking update (42) February 2013 (1) but to join Kevinin, all Bakhurstyou need do 2. School Report News Day January 2013 (1) 1xtra asian network bbca comment.Peter Rippon At 06:09 PM on 27 Feb 2007, 2013 (7) December 2012 (3) Peter Horrocks gregor aitken wrote: news bbc news For the latest updates across B BBC Arabic and the November 2012 (3) Alistair Burnett explain that tragic piece of journalism on sunday the channel bbc news complexities of the Arab October 2012 (5) visit the BlogsJon Williamshomepage website bbc parliament seriouslyworld (18) what was that about September 2012 (2) bbc Helen Shreeve BBC World News moves to August 2012 (3) world news breakfast Andrew Roy You can find details of the BBC it Broadcastingwas a joke an House absolute(33) joke, whenJuly you2012 do (5) progs like that aboutbroadcasting such a serious house click issue it leaves us to wonder that either you are in on it or just bad journalists. Editorial Guidelines here. BBC News comes to June 2012 (7) college of journalism Burma (9) May 2012 (4) credit crunch daily politics Mr.Expanded Porter, put distribution your house in in order, the bbc is a public service and fourth estate complete archive ipm nations and regions news nothe a propogandaUS for BBC Worldmachine for the state. Subscribe to The Editors News (17) editors newsnight 3. You can stay up to date with The Mozilla Festival and the newsnight scotland At 06:13 PM on 27 Feb 2007, Editors via these feeds. fellowship newsround one o'clock Tom wrote: announcement (11) news panorama pm Sorry but this is nowhere near an acceptable explanation. I suggest you look The Editors Feed (RSS) Election stats - new mobile politics show question into this further and provide us with a more detailed explanation of hoq this has The Editors Feed (ATOM) record (8) happened to stop incriminating yourselves. What a pathetic response.time radio 1 radio five Election night (39) If you aren't sure what RSS is you'll live radio scotland six 4. our beginner's guide to RSS o'clock news storyfix ten At 06:22 PM on 27 Feb 2007, Nick Hatton wrote: o'clock news the andrew Sorry that doesn't wash, and I'm disgusted that you are publicly fundedmarr show via thea world at one licence fee. the world this weekendElsewhere at the BBC today weather working SERVE THE PUBLIC !!! lunch world service 5. world tonight young At 06:25 PM on 27 Feb 2007, voters' question time Newswatch: Click here to watch and Justin Ross wrote: take part in the Newswatch If there was no conspiracy on your part, then tell the public who told BBC News programme Mobile site Terms of Use About the BBC Privacy Accessibility Help Cookies Contact the BBC BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for Parental Guidance the content of external sites. Read more. 6. At 06:25 PM on 27 Feb 2007, TV Blog justin wrote: BBC have been BUSTED well & truely & this your lame attempt at trying to explain it? Other news blogs This is karma for the hit piece you done the other week & yes you are accomplices to this crime for the communist style propaganda piece you pulled! News Editors BBC has lost all credibility & MILLIONS know it :) Sport Editors Doubt your let this message through your "censorship" but know this BBC you Journalism Labs have been exposed well & truely 911 WAS AN INSIDE JOB TELL THE TRUTH! BBC Internet Blog Radio 4 Blog 7. Peston's Picks At 06:25 PM on 27 Feb 2007, Nick Robinson's Newslog Eric wrote: Stephanomics I dont think anyone is accusing the bbc as part of this. Its whoever gave the Mark Easton's UK report to the bbc. What wire service sent this out? Mark Mardell's America 8. Nick Bryant's Australia At 06:26 PM on 27 Feb 2007, Andrew Harding on Africa Simon wrote: Gavin Hewitt's Europe "We didn't get told in advance that buildings were going to fall down. We didn't Soutik Biswas' India receive press releases or scripts in advance of events happening." dot.Rory Science: Jonathan Amos So why then, is the reporter reporting that the Saloman Building (WTC7) has 2 of 133 23.10.15 22:20 BBC - The Editors: Part of the conspiracy? http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/theeditors/2007/02/part_of_the_cons... come down when it is clearly visible behind her as she speaks? Richard Black on environment Today: Tom Feilden "If we reported the building had collapsed before it had done so, it would have Fergus Walsh's medical files been an error" Newsnight: Paul Mason Newsnight: Mark Urban An error? That does not explain how someone knew the building was coming down before it actually had done. Torin Douglas Will Gompertz's arts WTC7 stood for hours, and for someone to put out information that it would Phil Coomes on photojournalism come down within 20 minutes is a little suspicious, don't you think? Magazine Monitor Mark D'Arcy in Westminster Not to mention it is the 3rd building in history to collapse due to fire, the first NI: Mark Devenport two being WTC 1 and 2 *rolls eyes* Scotland: Brian Taylor 9. Scotland: Douglas Fraser At 06:30 PM on 27 Feb 2007, Wales: Betsan Powys Steve Emsley wrote: Martin Rosenbaum on FOI So... 5 Live Breakfast Newsnight 1. You lost the tapes of one of the most important events in US history? PM programme (iPM) REALLY? The citizens of the UK should all stop paying their TV tax as this is the World Tonight: Robin Lustig most ridiculous and irresponsible thing I have ever heard. It is probably NOT TRUE as American broadcasters keep ALL FOOTAGE in controlled vaults/rooms. 2. You anchor CLEARLY states that WTC 7 has collapsED while it is still in the shot.