For the Safety of All

Home , Turnberry (golf course)

Northern Lighthouse Board

84 George Street Edinburgh EH2 3DA

Switchboard: 0131 473 3100 Fax: 0131 220 2093

Ref: Website: www.nlb.org.uk Email: [email protected]

[Date]

Martyn Mclaughlin

Dear Martyn

Freedom of Information Act 2000

Thank you for your request for information under the terms of the Freedom of Information Act relating to leasing of some of the NLB buildings comprising the Turnberry Lighthouse. Following an exchange of emails the wording of the request was agreed, on the 8th February 2019, as shown below

Your request has been handled in accordance with your ‘right to know’ under section 1(1) of the Freedom of Information Act 2000 (FOIA), which entitles you to be provided with any information ‘held’ by a public authority, unless an appropriate exemption applies.

Having reviewed your request I can now advise that the required information is supplied below.

Your request I am writing to request under the Freedom of Information (Scotland) Act 2002 that the Northern Lighthouse Board (NLB) disclose all electronic and paper correspondence exchanged with Trump Turnberry, SLC Turnberry Limited, Golf Recreation Scotland, and the Trump Organisation relating to the lease of NLB properties associated with Turnberry lighthouse between 1 April 2014 and 1 April 2015.

Our Response In order to place the communications in context it is worth noting that, for some time, prior to the negotiations with the Trump organisation, NLB had been discussing the sale of our buildings at Turnberry with the previous owners of the hotel, the accommodation building having already been sold by NLB in March 1992. However, following consultation with local users NLB made the decision to retain the light at Turnberry, all be it with a reduced light range. Maintaining a light at this location meant the tower would not be available to purchase.

The purchase of the Turnberry Hotel complex by the Trump organisation was completed in April 2014. The property leased to the Trump organisation comprises the old Utility and Services building and the building formerly used to provide welfare facilities (for NLB staff whilst working on site). An electronic copy of the lease documentation is attached.

The associated email contains all correspondence retained in our estates files relating to the lease of NLB properties associated with Turnberry lighthouse between 1 April 2014 and 1 April 2015.

For the safety of all

I hope you find the information provided useful. If however you are dissatisfied with this response, wish to request an internal review of our decision, or want to make a complaint about how your request has been handled, you should write, within 40 working days of the date of this letter, clearly marked FAO the Director of Business Services at:

Northern Lighthouse Board 84 George Street Edinburgh EH2 3DA Email: [email protected]

If following internal review you are still dissatisfied with the response and wish to request further review of our decision, or to make a complaint about how your request has been handled, you should write to the Information Commissioner who can be contacted at:

Information Commissioner’s Office Wycliffe House Water Lane Wilmslow Cheshire SK9 5AF www.ico.gov.uk

Yours sincerely,

Trish Donaldson Compliance Officer Northern Lighthouse Board Email: [email protected]

Privacy Notice NLB take seriously the protection of your privacy and confidentiality, and understand that you are entitled to know that your personal data will not be used for any purpose unintended by you. In line with our Data Retention Policy and the associated document retention schedules, the records related to this request will be retained on our live internal system for 2 years before being archived. Archived copies may be retained indefinitely in the public interest. Redacted versions of Freedom of Information requests are made available in line with NLB’s publication scheme on our website, you can read our Website Privacy Notice via the following link: https://www.nlb.org.uk/Terms/Privacy/.

financial benefits of transferring maintenance costs of the operational lighthouse tower from NLB to SLC Turnberry whist maintaining all necessary access rights.

In answer to your question NLB has achieved good value for money with this lease. Two otherwise redundant buildings have been rented out to the sole potential tenant along with responsibility for their maintenance. The operational lighthouse remains in NLB's control but its fabric is maintained at no cost to NLB. In summary this arrangement offers a significant saving to the ship-owners who pay Light Dues. Trish Donaldson

Subject: URGENT Scotsman - Trump Turnberry - REPLY REQUIRED BY 1PM TOMORROW

From: Martyn Mclaughlin [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: 30 May 2019 12:43 To: Trish Donaldson Subject: Re: FW: URGENT Fwd: Scotsman ‐ Trump Turnberry ‐ REPLY REQUIRED BY 1PM TOMORROW

Hi Trish - that's no problem at all, thanks again.

Martyn Mclaughlin

On Thu, May 30, 2019 at 12:33 PM Trish Donaldson wrote:

Good afternoon Martyn

Following our conversation I have advise Mike Bullock that you are planning to quote the last two paragraphs of his letter in your article. We both think that to use only these would miss some important factual data and would ask that you use the following as a quote instead:

At the outset NLB’s intention was to set a fair and equitable agreement for the property which protected NLB’s buildings in the long term and reduced costs attributed to payers of Light Dues and when setting the rent took into account all factors not least the burden taken on by the Resort for the care and maintenance of the lighthouse tower and buildings. A lighthouse of this type is repainted at an interval of 8 to 10 years and on each occasion costs around £120,000. This saving has already been realised once as programmed painting was undertaken by the Resort as part of the work to create the half‐way house. In addition, responsibility for routine general maintenance of the tower, buildings and the care of the dome access system lies with the Resort.

When determining the rent NLB requested a report and a rental valuation from the UK Government Valuation Office Agency, this provided a ball park rental range of £600 to £1500. The figure was discussed both within NLB and with our solicitors and £1200 was determined to be a reasonable return given the significant additional financial benefits of transferring maintenance costs of the operational lighthouse tower to SLC Turnberry whist maintaining all necessary access rights.

1 no cost to NLB. In summary this arrangement offers a significant saving to the ship‐owners who pay Light Dues.

Kind regards

From: Trish Donaldson Sent: 30 May 2019 12:03 To: '[email protected]' Subject: RE: URGENT Fwd: Scotsman ‐ Trump Turnberry ‐ REPLY REQUIRED BY 1PM TOMORROW

Good morning Martyn

Your email below has been forwarded to me as a follow on to your earlier Freedom of Information Request. Please find attached our response.

Kind regards

Trish

______

From: Martyn Mclaughlin Sent: 29 May 2019 11:20 To: > Subject: Scotsman ‐ Trump Turnberry

Hi Karen

Martyn from The Scotsman here, thanks for chatting a moment ago. As mentioned on the phone, I’m working on a story concerning the NLB and I’d be grateful for a response to it.

The story’s predominantly based on disclosures under the Freedom of Information act sent to me by your colleague, Trish Donaldson, who was a great help.

It’s about the lease arrangements between the NLB and SLC Turnberry Litd, the parent company at Donald Trump’s Turnberry hotel and golf resort in South Ayrshire.

Trish was very helpful in breaking down the ownership issues surrounding famous Turnberry lighthouse, pointing out that while SLC Turnberry owns the accommodation block, the remainder belongs to the NLB, and that the lease applies to the utility and services building, and the former welfare building, on the site.

My story is focusing on how Mr Trump’s company is paying just £100 a month to rent the buildings at the lighthouse complex, while charging guests £1,400 a night to stay at a luxury suite there. I understand one of the NLB buildings has been converted into a ‘halfway house’ where golfers and guests can purchase food and drink. Given NLB is a public body, and the buildings leased to SLC Turnberry form part of the Turnberry resort,I’m keen to ask whether the arrangement is value for money, I’d be grateful if the NLB could tell me:

2  Does it believe the amount it is charging SLC Turnberry represents value for money?

 How did the NLB settle upon the £1,200 annual lease charge sum?

My deadline is 1pm tomorrow (Thursday 30 May). I hope the above is clear, but if you need to chat through anything, you can reach me on 0141 236 6440.

Many thanks Martyn

Martyn Mclaughlin

JPIMedia Limited Registered in England and Wales no. 11573611 Registered Office: Third Floor, 1 King William Street, London EC4N 7AF

Opinions expressed in this email are those of the writer and not the company. E-mail traffic is monitored within JPIMedia Limited and messages may be viewed. This e-mail and any files with it are solely for the use of the addressee(s).If you are not the intended recipient, you have received this e-mail in error. Please delete it or return it to the sender or notify us by email at [email protected]

Click here to report this email as spam.

This email has been virus scanned by MailControl - www.mailcontrol.com

JPIMedia Limited Registered in England and Wales no. 11573611 Registered Office: Third Floor, 1 King William Street, London EC4N 7AF

3 Trish Donaldson

From: Mike Bullock Sent: 07 October 2014 11:52 To: Eric Trump Cc: [email protected]; Subject: RE: Turnberry Lighthouse

Eric, many thanks for the email. If you are happy to do it, yes I think it would be good for your team to take the outline developed so far and draw up a draft agreement. Once that is ready we can review, then reconvene to discuss.

Very best regards

Mike

Mike Bullock Chief Executive Northern Lighthouse Board 84 George Street Edinburgh EH2 3DA dd: 0131 473 3112 email: [email protected] Visit our Website www.nlb.org.uk The Northern Lighthouse Board is the General Lighthouse Authority for Scotland and the Isle of Man

From: Eric Trump [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: 06 October 2014 20:22 To: Mike Bullock Cc: [email protected]; Subject: RE: Turnberry Lighthouse

Mike,

Thanks so much for the reply – this makes complete sense.

Per your offer below, a longer term on the little bathroom area would really be appreciated! We plan to spend a significant amount of money restoring the entire structure and it would be comforting to know, that in return, we would enjoy its continued use and not have to worry about the program changing at a later date, when you and I might no longer be around, etc.

If this make sense, would you like us to take the first crack at writing an actual agreement along the lines of the below emails and send it to you for your review?

The teams are on the ground and before they get to distracted with the much bigger hotel, golf courses and spa, it would be great to get this one going.

Eric

1 By the way, it is interesting seeing the pictures and the ladder in the space. When I suggested opening it to the public, I was under the impression it was a circular staircase. I agree 100% that this wouldn’t be possible from a safety standpoint so why don’t we eliminate that concept.

From: Mike Bullock [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Monday, October 06, 2014 12:14 PM To: Eric Trump Cc: [email protected] Subject: RE: Turnberry Lighthouse

Eric, many thanks for your email in which you raised a number questions. Hopefully this mail will answer these and add some greater clarity.

 The purpose of the document is to set out the ‘headline’ parameters for a legal agreement between the Northern lighthouse Board (NLB) and your organisation. What you received was very much our first take on a ‘working document’ which combined elements from your letter of intent and input from my experts and we would welcome input from your team to either agree, propose changes or include any additional parameters that are believed to be necessary. To be clear it is not a ‘form’ as such but merely a convenient format which allows us to clearly set out the main points which, once we have reached a mutually agreed position, we can turn over to our respective lawyers to draw up the formal legal lease agreement document in accordance with Scots law.

 As drafted we proposed an initial period of 10 years but if this agreement is not terminated, it will continue to run in perpetuity until either party serves notice of termination. It’s a point of Scots Law, when a lease runs out it automatically renews itself for the same period under the same conditions. Any agreement would need to opt out of this legal point to enforce a strict 10 year period, however, we do not intent to include such an opt out clause, which will allow our contract to automatically renew. We could consider a period of more than 10 years if this helps demonstrate our partnership commitment.

 The maintenance obligation will involve responsibility for all defect repair and routine maintenance to agreed specification levels, with a minimum requirement of annual maintenance of the HCL dome fall arrest system (this is a safety system for personnel working at height), preparation and painting of all external ferrous painted areas and any paint system failure areas every 3 years and preparation and painting of all external painted surfaces every 10 years and we are currently preparing the detailed specification for you to review and to include in the final agreement. We are similarly working on the details for signage but in the interest of keeping things moving I was keen to get the first draft to you and your team.

 As we are a public body and funded by our users (ie the Ship Owners), we are rightly obligated to protect our assets and funds and demonstrate to our users we achieve this in a cost effective and efficient manner. In the context of our property at Turnberry, this means we must protect our risk through the lease arrangements that we will have with your organisation. Please be assured our intention is to find a fair and equitable agreement

2 which takes into account all factors not least the full repairing arrangement and something I am sure we can work together to find common ground.

I’ve enclosed two photographs which show the current access arrangements we have for our tower, as the door leading from our former property was blocked some time ago. We will need to consider how we best achieve public access but I’m sure you will agree, for safety reasons, we cannot allow members of the public to scale a vertical ladder, again this is something we can work together on to find a safe alternative. Finally, many thanks for the offer of meeting up next week, unfortunately I am already committed to other activity.

Very best regards

Mike

From: Eric Trump [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: 29 September 2014 21:32 To: Mike Bullock Cc: [email protected] Subject: FW: Turnberry Lighthouse

Mike,

Hope you are doing great and enjoyed your travels!

Ralph sent the Draft Heads of Terms which I am guessing is a form document. Do you want our team to plug in the terms as discussed in the below email that followed our call (please see attached). Specifically our maintenance obligation doesn’t seem to be spelled out, signage, etc and this seems to be more of a short term lease rather than an endowment of a building in perpetuity. Just let us know – happy to edit and turn this back to you.

Hope you are doing well. I am going to be over at Turnberry on the 13 and 14th of October – if you happen to be nearby, I would love to meet you in person,

All the best,

Eric

From: Porciani, Ralph Sent: 14 August 2014 17:13 To: Mike Bullock Cc: Subject: RE: Turnberry Lighthouse

Good Mike, and

Please see the attached documents from Eric, the plan is draft 1 and is very much a work in progress, although it is very much favoured by Eric

Please review and let me have any comments you wish to feed back, I am happy to take a call and could even get Eric to dial in.

Kind regards Ralph RALPH PORCIANI GENERAL MANAGER TRUMP TURNBERRY +44(0) 1655 334 126 telephone

From: Mike Bullock [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: 07 August 2014 13:25 To: Porciani, Ralph Cc: Subject: Turnberry Lighthouse

Ralph, many thanks for the conference call with Eric earlier today, in my former life I spent three years working in the Pentagon and came to very much admire the American way of using enthusiasm and openness to get things done. I am heading out on two weeks leave later this afternoon so please keep copied in on any email traffic. We look forward to seeing your proposals, but in the meantime I thought you would appreciate sight of the draft ‘Information Panel’ for Turnberry we have been working on. I fully appreciate that your company will have its own corporate style and we would be very happy to work with your media/communication team to produce something that looks right for Turnberry. My lead for Communication is who is copied on this email.

Very best regards

Mike

Mike Bullock Chief Executive Northern Lighthouse Board 84 George Street Edinburgh EH2 3DA dd: 0131 473 3112

4 email: [email protected] Visit our Website www.nlb.org.uk The Northern Lighthouse Board is the General Lighthouse Authority for Scotland and the Isle of Man

Northern Lighthouse Board 84 George Street Edinburgh EH2 3DA

Email: [email protected] Web: www.nlb.org.uk Phone: 0131 473 3100 Fax: 0131 220 2093

Northern Lighthouse Board (Oban) Gallanach Road Oban, Argyll PA34 4LS

Email: [email protected] Phone: 01631 562146 Fax: 01631 565871 ********************************************************************** This email and any files transmitted with it are confidential and intended solely for the use of the individual or entity to whom they are addressed. The content of e-mail and files transmitted may not belong to or be the opinion of the Northern Lighthouse Board and the Northern Lighthouse Board cannot be responsible for such.

Please think green, do not print out this email unless it is necessary.

This message has been scanned for viruses by BlackSpider MailControl

This electronic message transmission contains information from the Company that may be proprietary, confidential and/or privileged. The information is intended only for the use of the individual(s) or entity named above. If you are not the intended recipient, be aware that any disclosure, copying or distribution or use of the contents of this information is prohibited. If you have received this electronic transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately by replying to the address listed in the "From:" field. This e-mail message, and any attachments to it, are for the sole use of the intended recipients, and may contain confidential and privileged information. Any unauthorized review, use, disclosure or distribution of this email message or its attachments is prohibited. If you are not the intended recipient, please contact the sender by reply email and destroy all copies of the original message. Please note that any views or opinions presented in this email are solely those of the author and do not necessarily represent those of the company. Finally, while the company uses virus protection, the recipient should check this email and any attachments for the presence of viruses. The company accepts no liability for any damage caused by any virus transmitted by this email.

Click here to report this email as spam.

This email has been virus scanned by MailControl - www.mailcontrol.com

5 Northern Lighthouse Board 84 George Street Edinburgh EH2 3DA

Email: [email protected] Web: www.nlb.org.uk Phone: 0131 473 3100 Fax: 0131 220 2093

Northern Lighthouse Board (Oban) Gallanach Road Oban, Argyll PA34 4LS

6 Trish Donaldson

From: Sent: 04 November 2014 13:01 To: Mike Bullock Cc: Subject: RE: Turnberry Lighthouse

Good Afternoon Mike

No objection and it would assist the lease progress and help them make their planning application.

I’ve checked with Area Maintenance Engineer and is our RLK for Turnberry. would be the best placed person to give them access etc. I’ve copied both and into my email for awareness.

mobile number is and it would be easiest if John agreed a mutually convenient date/time directly with Kind regards

From: Mike Bullock Sent: 04 November 2014 12:39 To: Cc: Subject: Fwd: Turnberry Lighthouse

I guess we wouldn't have any objection this request? How would we go about it - is there an RLK for this station we could ask?

Best regards

Mike

Sent from my iPad

Begin forwarded message:

From: < @trumpturnberry.com> Date: 4 November 2014 12:23:32 GMT To: Mike Bullock Cc: " @trumpnational.com" < @trumpnational.com> Subject: Turnberry Lighthouse

Good Afternoon Mike,

I wonder if you can assist, we have a surveyor coming onsite next week and wondered if it would be possible to get access to the small store area and the tower for him to look at services etc.

Trish Donaldson

From: @trumpturnberry.com> Sent: 04 November 2014 13:25 To: Mike Bullock Cc: @trumpnational.com; Subject: Re: Turnberry Lighthouse

Mike,

Much appreciated.

Regards,

John

On 4 November 2014 13:14, Mike Bullock wrote:

, we should be able to help. Our Retained Lighthouse Keeper (RLK) for Turnberry is (in effect NLB’s local representative who visits stations to carry out routine checks and maintenance) but as the role is part-time he may have other commitments. Probably the best way ahead is for you to give a call on his mobile on and set up a mutually convenient date/time directly with him. Let me know if you need anything else.

Best regards

Mike

Mike Bullock

Chief Executive

Northern Lighthouse Board 84 George Street Edinburgh EH2 3DA dd: 0131 473 3112 email: [email protected]

Visit our Website www.nlb.org.uk

1 The Northern Lighthouse Board is the General Lighthouse Authority for Scotland and the Isle of Man

From: [mailto: @trumpturnberry.com] Sent: 04 November 2014 12:24 To: Mike Bullock Cc: @trumpnational.com Subject: Turnberry Lighthouse

Good Afternoon Mike,

I wonder if you can assist, we have a surveyor coming onsite next week and wondered if it would be possible to get access to the small store area and the tower for him to look at services etc.

I would be most appreciative if you could oblige us someone to come and open these areas for us.

REGARDS,

Director of Engineering

+44(0) telephone +44(0) mobile +44(0) facsimile

MAIDENS ROAD TURNBERRY, KA26 9LT, SCOTLAND

Luxurycollection.com/Turnberry

IMPORTANT: As of 1st November, my email address will change to @trumpturnberry.com

Click here to report this email as spam.

This email has been virus scanned by MailControl - www.mailcontrol.com

Northern Lighthouse Board 84 George Street Edinburgh EH2 3DA

Email: Enquiries@n b.org.uk Web: www.n b.org.uk Phone: 0131 473 3100 Fax: 0131 220 2093

Northern Lighthouse Board (Oban) Gallanach Road Oban, Argyll PA34 4LS

This email and any files transmitted with it are confidential and intended solely for the use of the individual or entity to whom they are addressed. The content of e-mail and files transmitted may not belong to or be the opinion of the Northern Lighthouse Board and the Northern Lighthouse Board cannot be responsible for such.

Please think green, do not print out this email unless it is necessary.

This message has been scanned for viruses by BlackSpider MailControl

REGARDS,

Director of Engineering

+44(0) telephone +44(0) mobile +44(0) facsimile

MAIDENS ROAD TURNBERRY, KA26 9LT, SCOTLAND

3 Luxurycollection.com/Turnberry

IMPORTANT: As of 1st November, my email address will change to @trumpturnberry.com

from my conversation with Ralph a couple of weeks ago I think you are correct on the plan and the need to resurrect planning permission. Any data would be welcome! The call is at 1200.

Thanks

Mike

Sent: 06 August 2014 17:36 To: Mike Bullock Subject: Re: Turnberry Lighthouse

Thank you Mike From memory previous owners wanted to build some exclusive self contained accommodation in the hotel grounds which might include our property or former property. I was not involve in this discussion but will check the file and hopefully give you more background tomorrow before your call. If planning consent was given in 2009 it may be about to lapse which might be part of the reasoning for contact? Kind regards

Sent from my iPhone

On 6 Aug 2014, at 17:26, "Mike Bullock" wrote:

FYI. I’ll keep you posted.

Mike

Mike Bullock Chief Executive Northern Lighthouse Board

1 84 George Street Edinburgh EH2 3DA dd: 0131 473 3112 email: [email protected] Visit our Website www.nlb.org.uk The Northern Lighthouse Board is the General Lighthouse Authority for Scotland and the Isle of Man

From: Porciani, Ralph [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: 06 August 2014 17:20 To: Mike Bullock Subject: Re: Turnberry Lighthouse

Hi Mike I will call you, I am not totally sure the full extent of what the previous owners had planned, I will understand it more by the time we call as I have an appointment with the architect who did them then. I will ensure that we get a copy to you before hand. Regards Ralph

RALPH PORCIANI GENERAL MANAGER

TRUMP TURNBERRY +44(0) 1655 334 126 telephone MAIDENS ROAD TURNBERRY, KA26 9LT, SCOTLAND luxurycollection.com/Turnberry

On 6 Aug 2014, at 17:08, "Mike Bullock" wrote:

Ralph, 1200 would work best. Will you call me or should I call you? I presume the 2009 plans were for the buildings in the Hotel’s ownership rather than for the Lighthouse itself?

Mike

From: Porciani, Ralph [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: 06 August 2014 17:03 To: Mike Bullock Subject: Re: Turnberry Lighthouse

Hi Mike No worries about the name, Eric wanted to share some plans that were done for the lighthouse in 2009 with you with a view to progressing them forward. Would 11:30 or 12:00 work. Ralph

RALPH PORCIANI GENERAL MANAGER

TRUMP TURNBERRY +44(0) 1655 334 126 telephone MAIDENS ROAD TURNBERRY, KA26 9LT, SCOTLAND luxurycollection.com/Turnberry

On 6 Aug 2014, at 15:30, "Mike Bullock" wrote:

Ralph, I have just realised I have spelt your name wrong – a consequence of having a close buddy whose name is spelt “Ralf” – please accept my sincere apologies.

Mike

From: Mike Bullock Sent: 06 August 2014 15:21 To: 'Porciani, Ralph' Subject: RE: Turnberry Lighthouse

3 Ralf, thanks for the email, I’d be delighted to have a chat with him – can you give me an indication of the agenda? I’m in office tomorrow with a number of meetings scheduled but can adjust to suit your end but please note I have to leave to catch a flight mid-afternoon. Let me know what time works for you and who will call who.

Best regards

Mike

Commodore M P Bullock Chief Executive Northern Lighthouse Board 84 George Street Edinburgh EH2 3DA dd: 0131 473 3112 email: [email protected] Visit our Website www.nlb.org.uk The Northern Lighthouse Board is the General Lighthouse Authority for Scotland and the Isle of Man

From: Porciani, Ralph [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: 06 August 2014 14:46 To: Mike Bullock Subject: Turnberry Lighthouse

Good Afternoon Mike I have our owner Eric Trump with us tomorrow and wondered if we could set up a time for a 10 minute call. Hopefully this is achievable without interfering with you schedule to much. Kind regards Ralph

RALPH PORCIANI GENERAL MANAGER

TRUMP TURNBERRY +44(0) 1655 334 126 telephone MAIDENS ROAD TURNBERRY, KA26 9LT, SCOTLAND luxurycollection.com/Turnberry This electronic message transmission contains information from the Company that may be proprietary, confidential and/or privileged. The information is intended only for the use of the individual(s) or entity named above. If you are not the intended recipient, be aware that any disclosure, copying or distribution or use of the contents of this information is prohibited. If you have 4 received this electronic transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately by replying to the address listed in the "From:" field.

Click here to report this email as spam.

This email has been virus scanned by MailControl - www.mailcontrol.com

Northern Lighthouse Board 84 George Street Edinburgh EH2 3DA

Email: Enquiries@n b.org.uk Web: www.nlb.org.uk Phone: 0131 473 3100 Fax: 0131 220 2093

Northern Lighthouse Board (Oban) Gallanach Road Oban, Argyll PA34 4LS

Email: [email protected] Phone: 01631 562146 Fax: 01631 565871 ************************************************************* ********* This email and any files transmitted with it are confidential and intended solely for the use of the individual or entity to whom they are addressed. The content of e-mail and files transmitted may not belong to or be the opinion of the Northern Lighthouse Board and the Northern Lighthouse Board cannot be respons ble for such.

Please think green, do not print out this email unless it is necessary.

This message has been scanned for viruses by BlackSpider MailControl

Northern Lighthouse Board 84 George Street Edinburgh EH2 3DA

Email: Enquiries@n b.org.uk Web: www.nlb.org.uk Phone: 0131 473 3100 Fax: 0131 220 2093

Northern Lighthouse Board (Oban) Gallanach Road Oban, Argyll PA34 4LS

Email: [email protected] Phone: 01631 562146 Fax: 01631 565871 ************************************************************* ********* This email and any files transmitted with it are confidential and intended solely for the use of the individual or entity to whom they are addressed. The content of e-mail and files transmitted may not belong to or be the opinion of the Northern Lighthouse Board and the Northern Lighthouse Board cannot be respons ble for such.

From: Porciani, Ralph To: Mike Bullock Cc: Subject: RE: Turnberry Lighthouse Date: 07 August 2014 23:11:35

Good Evening Mike Thank you so much for your time today, it was really important for us to get Eric connected with you so that we can progress with the development plans for the lighthouse dwellings. As soon as we have the updated plan I will send it directly to you along with the communication pieces. Have a wonderful vacation. Best wishes Ralph

RALPH PORCIANI GENERAL MANAGER TRUMP TURNBERRY +44(0) 1655 334 126 telephone

From: Mike Bullock [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: 07 August 2014 13:25 To: Porciani, Ralph Cc: Subject: Turnberry Lighthouse

Very best regards

Mike

Northern Lighthouse Board 84 George Street Edinburgh EH2 3DA

Email: [email protected] Web: www.nlb.org.uk Phone: 0131 473 3100 Fax: 0131 220 2093

Northern Lighthouse Board (Oban) Gallanach Road Oban, Argyll PA34 4LS

Please think green, do not print out this email unless it is necessary.

This message has been scanned for viruses by BlackSpider MailControl

Click here to report this email as spam.

This email has been virus scanned by MailControl - www.mailcontrol.com Trish Donaldson

From: Mike Bullock Sent: 07 October 2014 11:52 To: Eric Trump Cc: ; [email protected]; Subject: RE: Turnberry Lighthouse

Very best regards

Mike

From: Eric Trump [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: 06 October 2014 20:22 To: Mike Bullock Cc: ; [email protected]; Subject: RE: Turnberry Lighthouse

Mike,

Thanks so much for the reply – this makes complete sense.

If this make sense, would you like us to take the first crack at writing an actual agreement along the lines of the below emails and send it to you for your review?

The teams are on the ground and before they get to distracted with the much bigger hotel, golf courses and spa, it would be great to get this one going.

Eric

From: Porciani, Ralph Sent: 14 August 2014 17:13 To: Mike Bullock Cc: Subject: RE: Turnberry Lighthouse

Good Mike, and

Please see the attached documents from Eric, the plan is draft 1 and is very much a work in progress, although it is very much favoured by Eric

Please review and let me have any comments you wish to feed back, I am happy to take a call and could even get Eric to dial in.

Kind regards Ralph RALPH PORCIANI GENERAL MANAGER TRUMP TURNBERRY +44(0) 1655 334 126 telephone

From: Mike Bullock [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: 07 August 2014 13:25 To: Porciani, Ralph Cc: Subject: Turnberry Lighthouse

Very best regards

Mike

Mike Bullock Chief Executive Northern Lighthouse Board 84 George Street Edinburgh EH2 3DA dd: 0131 473 3112

4 email: [email protected] Visit our Website www.nlb.org.uk The Northern Lighthouse Board is the General Lighthouse Authority for Scotland and the Isle of Man

Northern Lighthouse Board 84 George Street Edinburgh EH2 3DA

Email: Enquiries@n b.org.uk Web: www.nlb.org.uk Phone: 0131 473 3100 Fax: 0131 220 2093

Northern Lighthouse Board (Oban) Gallanach Road Oban, Argyll PA34 4LS

Please think green, do not print out this email unless it is necessary.

This message has been scanned for viruses by BlackSpider MailControl

Click here to report this email as spam.

This email has been virus scanned by MailControl - www.mailcontrol.com

5 Northern Lighthouse Board 84 George Street Edinburgh EH2 3DA

Email: Enquiries@n b.org.uk Web: www.nlb.org.uk Phone: 0131 473 3100 Fax: 0131 220 2093

Northern Lighthouse Board (Oban) Gallanach Road Oban, Argyll PA34 4LS

84 George Street Edinburgh EH2 3DA

Direct Tel: +44 (0) 131 473 3131 Direct Fax: +44 (0) 131 473 2436 Mobile: +44 (0) 7771 703272

Switchboard: +44 (0) 131 473 3100 Web: www.nlb.org.uk

From: Airon, Ankit [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: 07 April 2014 19:30 To: Subject: Turnberry Lighthouse.

Dear Mr

Hope you are well!

I wanted to know if your organisation had concluded the assessment of the Lighthouse building as we would be interested to know of any movement on that front. I would be grateful if you could let me know the progress of situation at your end

Many thanks and regards

Ankit

ANKIT AIRON DIRECTOR OF FINANCE +44(0) 1655 334 130 telephone +44(0) 1655 331 706 facsimile MAIDENS ROAD TURNBERRY, KA26 9LT, SCOTLAND luxurycollection.com/turnberry

Click here to report this email as spam.

This email has been virus scanned by MailControl - www.mailcontrol.com

Northern Lighthouse Board 84 George Street Edinburgh EH2 3DA

Email: [email protected] Web: www.nlb.org.uk Phone: 0131 473 3100 Fax: 0131 220 2093

Northern Lighthouse Board (Oban) Gallanach Road Oban, Argyll PA34 4LS

Please think green, do not print out this email unless it is necessary.

This message has been scanned for viruses by BlackSpider MailControl

3 Trish Donaldson

From: Sent: 13 November 2014 18:54 To: Mike Bullock Subject: Re: Trump/NLB - Lighthouse at Turnberry [AS-MATTERS.FID1630667] [CMCK- UK.FID8905731]

Mike I received an email from this afternoon which I have just read. Lesley has asked me to call her which I will do tomorrow morning and I can update you after this. There are some points they are still going on about rent valuations and fair rent etc and I don't yet have a full response that could be sent to the Trump Org solicitor. Apologies

Sent from my iPad

On 13 Nov 2014, at 16:48, Mike Bullock wrote:

Fiona, did we get anything back from ?

Mike

From: Sent: 05 November 2014 07:54 To: Mike Bullock Subject: RE: Trump/NLB - Lighthouse at Turnberry [AS-MATTERS.FID1630667] [CMCK-UK.FID8905731]

Good Morning Mike I had a teleconference with our Solicitors yesterday and 30 mins specifically about Turnberry.

The document that has arrived from Trump includes allowing them to make structural changes to our Tower and many other things that were never discussed. I’ve given all our correspondence and a brief on our position with this. Over the next few days, will go over all of this and come back to

1 me on Mon 10th Nov with a hopefully response for us to approve and then allow to deal with their Solicitors directly, with the aim of them agreeing the terms of the lease.

I’m disappearing today on a BIMCO contract training course and back on Monday 10th.

I’m very sorry for the delay and hope I have not held CEC up in any way. I hope this is okay? Kind regards

From: Mike Bullock Sent: 05 November 2014 07:46 To: Eric Trump Cc: Subject: RE: Trump/NLB - Lighthouse at Turnberry [AS-MATTERS.FID1630667] [CMCK-UK.FID8905731]

Eric, many thanks for the email. I’m not aware of anything at this stage but will get back to you if there is.

All the best

Mike

From: Eric Trump [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: 04 November 2014 19:35 To: Mike Bullock Subject: FW: Trump/NLB - Lighthouse at Turnberry [AS-MATTERS.FID1630667] [CMCK- UK.FID8905731]

Mike,

Hope you are doing great!

Just let me know if you need anything (in terms of the below) on my end – I am happy to talk through any open items to the extent there are any. Given we have the Woman’s Open Championship coming up in August, it would be great to have the lighthouse fully refurbished by that date. The event will be broadcast all around the world and it would be great to have it brand new and looking spectacular.

All the best,

CMS Cameron McKenna LLP | 191 West George Street | Glasgow G2 2LD | United Kingdom www.cms-cmck.com www.law-now.com From: Sent: 24 October 2014 11:02 To: . @ .co.uk' Cc: 'George Sorial'; '[email protected]'; '[email protected]'; '[email protected]' Subject: Trump/NLB - Lighthouse at Turnberry [CMCK-UK.FID8905731]

I act on behalf of the Trump Organisation and understand that you have been appointed by The National Lighthouse Board in connection with the deal which has been agreed for use of the Turnberry lighthouse.

I attach a draft Offer and Lease which reflect the recent discussions between Eric and Mike. There are still some blanks to be completed such a conveyancing description of the property, full designation of your clients and a technical description of the light, but I am hopeful that the drafts are a reasonable starting point.

I believe both parties are keen to keep the legal documentation as short as possible whilst obviously still covering the salient points. However, you will see that I have added reference to a separate pre-emption agreement and a standard security to ensure the right of first refusal is capable of being properly enforced. My intention is that both documents will be very simplistic but I thought it best to raise the proposition with you and your clients before spending additional time drafting those at this stage.

I look forward to hearing from you once you have had an opportunity to review the Offer and Lease with your clients. In the meantime, please do give me a call if there is anything you wish to discuss.

Regards

Partner

@cms-cmck.com

CMS Cameron McKenna LLP | 191 West George Street | Glasgow G2 2LD | United Kingdom www.cms-cmck.com www.law-now.com

*************************************************************************

CMS has 58 offices around the world, located in Aberdeen, Algiers, Amsterdam, Antwerp, Barcelona, Beijing, Belgrade, Berlin, Bratislava, Bristol, Brussels, Bucharest, Budapest, Casablanca, Cologne, Dubai, Duesseldorf, Edinburgh, Frankfurt, Geneva, Glasgow, Hamburg, Istanbul, Kyiv, Leipzig, Lisbon, Ljubljana, London, Luxembourg, Lyon, Madrid, Mexico City, Milan, Moscow, Munich, Muscat, Paris, Prague, Rio de Janeiro, Rome, Sarajevo, Seville, Shanghai, Sofia, Strasbourg, Stuttgart, Tirana, Utrecht, Vienna, Warsaw, Zagreb and Zurich.

4 CMS Cameron McKenna LLP is a member of CMS Legal Services EEIG (CMS EEIG), a European Economic Interest Grouping that coordinates an organisation of independent law firms. CMS EEIG provides no client services. Such services are solely provided by CMS EEIG’s member firms in their respective jurisdictions. CMS EEIG and each of its member firms are separate and legally distinct entities, and no such entity has any authority to bind any other. CMS EEIG and each member firm are liable only for their own acts or omissions and not those of each other. The brand name "CMS" and the term "firm" are used to refer to some or all of the member firms or their offices. Further information can be found at www.cmslegal.com

CMS Cameron McKenna LLP is a limited liability partnership registered in England and Wales with registration number OC310335. It is a body corporate which uses the word "partner" to refer to a member, or an employee or consultant with equivalent standing and qualifications. It is authorised and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority of England and Wales with SRA number 423370 and by the Law Society of Scotland with registered number 47313. A list of members and their professional qualifications is open to inspection at the registered office, Mitre House, 160 Aldersgate Street, London EC1A 4DD. Members are either solicitors or registered foreign lawyers. VAT registration number: 974 899 925. Further information about the firm can be found at www.cms- cmck.com

The contents of this e-mail (including any attachments) are confidential and may be legally privileged. If you are not the intended recipient of this e-mail, any disclosure, copying, distribution or use of its contents is strictly prohibited, and you should please notify the sender immediately and then delete it (including any attachments) from your system. Notice: the firm does not accept service by e-mail of court proceedings, other processes or formal notices of any kind without specific prior written agreement.

*************************************************************************

Anderson Strathern Asset Management Limited is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. Anderson Strathern LLP is licensed by the Law Society of Scotland for incidental financial business.

This email has been sent from Anderson Strathern LLP, Anderson Strathern Business Services Limited or Anderson Strathern Asset Management Limited, together "Anderson Strathern". Anderson Strathern has offices in Edinburgh, Glasgow, Aberdeen and Haddington. For further information on the services we provide, our staff, current legal developments, events, career opportunities and a full list of partners, visit our website at www.andersonstrathern.co.uk Please note that the contents of this email are privileged and/or confidential. If you are not the intended recipient, please notify the sender and ensure that this email is deleted and not read, copied or disclosed to anyone else. It is your responsibility to scan this email and any attachments for computer viruses or other defects. We do not accept liability for any loss or damage which may result from this email or any file attached. Email is not secure and can be intercepted, corrupted or amended. We do not accept liability for errors or omissions arising as a result of interrupted or defective transmission. Email entering or leaving Anderson Strathern's system is subject to random monitoring and recording by the firm. Telephone calls may be recorded for compliance and training purposes. All business is transacted for and on behalf of Anderson Strathern LLP or Anderson Strathern Business Services Limited or Anderson Strathern Asset Management Limited.

Anderson Strathern LLP is a limited liability partnership registered in Scotland (SO301485) and having its registered office at 1 Rutland Court, Edinburgh, EH3 8EY. 'Partner' denotes a member of, and all business is transacted for and on behalf of, Anderson Strathern LLP. A list of members' names is open to inspection at each of our offices.

Anderson Strathern Business Services Limited is registered in Scotland (SC138174) and has its registered office at 1 Rutland Court, Edinburgh, EH3 8EY.

Anderson Strathern Asset Management Limited is registered in Scotland (SC376947) and has its registered office at 1 Rutland Court, Edinburgh, EH3 8EY.

This email message has been scanned for viruses by Mimecast. Mimecast delivers a complete managed email solution from a single web based platform. For more information please visit http://www.mimecast.com This e-mail message, and any attachments to it, are for the sole use of the intended recipients, and may contain confidential and privileged information. Any unauthorized review, use,

5 disclosure or distribution of this email message or its attachments is prohibited. If you are not the intended recipient, please contact the sender by reply email and destroy all copies of the original message. Please note that any views or opinions presented in this email are solely those of the author and do not necessarily represent those of the company. Finally, while the company uses virus protection, the recipient should check this email and any attachments for the presence of viruses. The company accepts no liability for any damage caused by any virus transmitted by this email.

Click here to report this email as spam.

This email has been virus scanned by MailControl - www.mailcontrol.com

6 Turnberry Lighthouse

Built in 1873 by pioneering Scottish lighthouse designer Thomas Stevenson, father of author Robert Louis Stevenson (made famous for works “Treasure Island,” “Kidnapped” & “Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr Hyde,”) this lighthouse was constructed in order to allow seafaring vessels the ability to safely navigate Scotland's treacherous coastline.

In 2014, in conjunction with his major renovation of the fabled Trump Turnberry Resort a partnership was formed between Donald J. Trump and the Northern Lighthouse Board, a subsidiary of the Scottish Government, to restore this lighthouse to its former glory. The lighthouse shines brighter than ever, maintaining its original purpose while at the same time, acting as one of the most famous images of Scotland and magnificent Scottish Golf. Letter of Intent

For the purpose of memorializing our current understanding with the Northern Lighthouse Board (“NLB”) concerning the Turnberry Hotel Lighthouse (the “Lighthouse”), the following concepts below should be incorporated into a more formal definitive agreement:

1. Trump Turnberry (“Trump”) and NLB recognize the proposed enhancements will preserve the Lighthouse and create a valuable amenity to be enjoyed by guests of the hotel, visiting tourists and members of the local community.

2. NLB shall continue to retain ownership of the Lighthouse’s tower and shall have the full use and access to that structure. Trump shall continue to own the interior spaces, including the bedrooms and the areas once inhabited by the Lighthouse "keeper." NLB will transfer the rights to use each of the two unoccupied storage/mechanical rooms (as highlighted in red on the Ground Floor Plan prepared by 3D Reid Architect, a copy of which is attached) to be used in conjunction with the proposed improvements pursuant to the attached renovation plan (Exhibit B, the "Renovation Plan").

3. In consideration of the foregoing, Trump agrees to incur all costs associated with the Renovation and the ongoing maintenance requirements associated with the Lighthouse structure.

4. In the event that NLB elects to dispose, transfer or sell the Lighthouse tower, the parties agree that Trump shall have a general right of first refusal over this area so as to maintain the historical integrity and continuity of the building.

5. As part of the Renovation Plan, Trump and NLB agree to display a high quality sign on the exterior of the Lighthouse, which specifically refers to a) the collaboration and partnership of NPL and Trump in connection with the Renovation Plan and its ongoing preservation and b) the great historical value of the Lighthouse and its continued use and likeness (draft of which is attached).

Notes Do not scale from this drawing. All dimensions to be checked on site prior to construction and any discrepancies reported to the Architect. Copyright reserved.

Dashed red line denotes areas which are under the control of SNACK the Northern Lighthouse Board BAR

Entrance to Lighthouse

Main Entrance

BUTLER'S EN-SUITE BEDROOM 1 PANTRY LOUNGE FEMALE WC

A Layers turned off 13/08/14 --

- first issue 08/08/14 -- Revisions

BEDROOM 2 CLOAKS Status Information

EN-SUITE Client Trump Hotel Collection TOILET

MALE Project WC TURNBERRY HOTEL THE LIGHTHOUSE --

Title PROPOSED GROUND FLOOR PLAN --

Scale Size Date Drawn Checked 1:50 A1 LM --

3DReid In-House, Callendar Boulevarde, Callendar Business Park, Falkirk, FK1 1YR. t : +44 (0)1324 611969 f : +44 (0)1324 611970 w : http://www.3dreid.com Belfast Birmingham Edinburgh Falkirk Glasgow London Manchester

Project No. Drawing No. Rev. 140239 (00)-101 A Notes Do not scale from this drawing. All dimensions to be checked on site prior to construction and any discrepancies reported to the Architect. Copyright reserved.

Lighthouse Area under the control of the Northern Lighthouse Board

BEDROOM 3 CLOAKS

TERRACE EN-SUITE SHOWER TERRACE A Layers switched off 13/08/14 -- - first issue 08/08/14 -- Revisions

Status Information

BEDROOM 4 Client Trump Hotel Collection

Project EN-SUITE TURNBERRY HOTEL THE LIGHTHOUSE --

Title PROPOSED FIRST FLOOR PLAN --

Scale Size Date Drawn Checked 1:50 A1 LM --

Project No. Drawing No. Rev. 140239 (00)-102 A Trish Donaldson

From: Porciani, Ralph Sent: 15 August 2014 14:56 To: Cc: Subject: RE: Turnberry Lighthouse

Hi Thank you for your note back, I had thought they were away, look forward to having a chat soon about it. Best wishes Ralph

RALPH PORCIANI GENERAL MANAGER TRUMP TURNBERRY +44(0) 1655 334 126 telephone

From: [mailto: @nlb.org.uk] Sent: 15 August 2014 10:06 To: Porciani, Ralph Cc: Subject: RE: Turnberry Lighthouse

Good Morning Ralph Thank you for providing these documents following the conference call.

Both Mike and are currently on leave, I will start to review in their absence to allow a response when both Mike and are back in the office. A conference call may be a good idea to continue our conversation and we will be in touch as soon as possible.

If there is anything meantime, please do not hesitate to contact me. Kind regards

Northern Lighthouse Board 84 George Street Edinburgh EH2 3DA Direct tel: 0131 473 3131 Direct fax: 0131 473 436 Email: [email protected]

From: Porciani, Ralph [[email protected]] Sent: 14 August 2014 17:12 To: Mike Bullock

1 Cc: Subject: RE: Turnberry Lighthouse

Good Mike, and

Please see the attached documents from Eric, the plan is draft 1 and is very much a work in progress, although it is very much favoured by Eric

Please review and let me have any comments you wish to feed back, I am happy to take a call and could even get Eric to dial in.

Kind regards Ralph RALPH PORCIANI GENERAL MANAGER TRUMP TURNBERRY +44(0) 1655 334 126 telephone

From: Mike Bullock [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: 07 August 2014 13:25 To: Porciani, Ralph Cc: Subject: Turnberry Lighthouse

Very best regards

Mike

2 Northern Lighthouse Board 84 George Street Edinburgh EH2 3DA

Email: Enquiries@n b.org.uk Web: www.nlb.org.uk Phone: 0131 473 3100 Fax: 0131 220 2093

Northern Lighthouse Board (Oban) Gallanach Road Oban, Argyll PA34 4LS

Please think green, do not print out this email unless it is necessary. This message has been scanned for viruses by BlackSpider MailControl This electronic message transmission contains information from the Company that may be proprietary, confidential and/or privileged. The information is intended only for the use of the individual(s) or entity named above. If you are not the intended recipient, be aware that any disclosure, copying or distribution or use of the contents of this information is prohibited. If you have received this electronic transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately by replying to the address listed in the "From:" field.

Click here to report this email as spam. This email has been virus scanned by MailControl - www.mailcontrol.com

Northern Lighthouse Board 84 George Street Edinburgh EH2 3DA

Email: Enquiries@n b.org.uk Web: www.nlb.org.uk Phone: 0131 473 3100 Fax: 0131 220 2093

Northern Lighthouse Board (Oban) Gallanach Road Oban, Argyll PA34 4LS

3 This electronic message transmission contains information from the Company that may be proprietary, confidential and/or privileged. The information is intended only for the use of the individual(s) or entity named above. If you are not the intended recipient, be aware that any disclosure, copying or distribution or use of the contents of this information is prohibited. If you have received this electronic transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately by replying to the address listed in the "From:" field.

4 From: To: Mike Bullock Cc: Subject: Fwd: Trump Turnberry - Lighthouse Date: 18 December 2014 18:18:16 Attachments: image001.jpg

Good Evening Mike This is the first of two emails received today from our Solicitor. Kind regards

Sent from my iPad

Begin forwarded message:

From: < . @ .co.uk> Date: 18 December 2014 08:18:17 GMT To: < @nlb.org.uk> Subject: Re: Trump Turnberry - Lighthouse

Morning

I was just speaking with on this matter yesterday saying we had heard nothing further from the solicitors acting for the Trumps.

I am not in the office this morning but will drop a reminder to my counterpart later today. The matter rests with them to revert to us on the last set of comments I believe but I will confirm.

Kind regards

From: Sent: Thursday, December 18, 2014 08:12 AM To: ' @nlb.org.uk' < @nlb.org.uk> Subject: Fw: Trump Turnberry - Lighthouse

From: Eric Trump [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Wednesday, December 17, 2014 04:42 PM To: Mike Bullock Cc: ; Ralph Porciani ([email protected]) Subject: Trump Turnberry - Lighthouse

Mike,

I hope you are doing great!

I just wanted to touch base regarding the lighthouse lease. We are quickly approaching the Womans Open which takes place this summer and wanted to make sure the structure looked perfect prior to the tournament given the eyes of the world will be on Turnberry and the Lighthouse. There is significant interior / exterior work to be done on both our respective portions and it looks like we will be receiving updated planning warrants within the next few weeks. Additionally, I think the tournament would be an amazing time to announce our strategic alliance and joint efforts in revitalizing a National Landmark.

Is there anything that can be done on your end to facilitate this process which seems to have stalled in the water. Our teams are ready to begin work immediately.

I will be at Turnberry on January 13 – would love to meet you in person. I hope you are doing great and wish you and your family a happy holiday!

Eric

From: Mike Bullock [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Monday, September 29, 2014 9:59 AM To: Porciani, Ralph Cc: George Sorial; Eric Trump; Subject: RE: Lighthouse NLB - Update

Ralph, many thanks for the email. We have just had the ‘Heads of Terms’ back from our lawyers and the draft document is attached. Can I suggest you get your team to review, come back to us with any questions/points of clarification and when you are ready perhaps we can set up a teleconference to discuss?

Very best regards

Mike

From: Porciani, Ralph [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: 29 September 2014 14:22 To: Mike Bullock Cc: George Sorial; [email protected] Subject: RE: Lighthouse NLB - Update

Good Afternoon Mike

I trust my email finds you well and enjoying the extended summer.

Eric and I were just discussing the lighthouse plans and were wondering if you had heard anything from the lawyers on the Heads of Terms, once agreed we are egger to progress with finalising the plans.

All my very best Ralph

RALPH PORCIANI GENERAL MANAGER TRUMP TURNBERRY +44(0) 1655 334 126 telephone

From: Porciani, Ralph Sent: 06 September 2014 08:53 To: [email protected] Cc: George Sorial Subject: Lighthouse NLB - Update

FYI – back in the office now so here is the note below from Mike. R

RALPH PORCIANI GENERAL MANAGER TRUMP TURNBERRY +44(0) 1655 334 126 telephone

From: Mike Bullock [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: 05 September 2014 14:54 To: Porciani, Ralph Subject: RE: NLB - Update

Ralph, thanks for the call – once again I have spelt your name incorrectly below – apologies!

Mike

From: Mike Bullock Sent: 05 September 2014 14:45 To: 'Porciani, Ralph' Cc: Subject: NLB - Update

Ralf, we spoke very briefly on Wednesday (I caught you in the middle of another meeting) and you were going to call me back – I’ve just tried to call your mobile with no joy and subsequently tried your land line and I understand that you are out of office today. I know you were keen to speak before Eric visits next week, but unfortunately I will be at sea in one of our vessels until late on Wednesday. In the broadest terms (and without prejudice) the outline of your proposal looks reasonable. We have invited our lawyers to draw up Heads of Terms for an agreement between NLB and the Trump organisation which will be the basis for further discussion. I hope this will give you the necessary information to demonstrate that things are progressing.

Very best regards

Mike

Northern Lighthouse Board 84 George Street Edinburgh EH2 3DA

Email: [email protected] Web: www.nlb.org.uk Phone: 0131 473 3100 Fax: 0131 220 2093

Northern Lighthouse Board (Oban) Gallanach Road Oban, Argyll PA34 4LS

Please think green, do not print out this email unless it is necessary.

This message has been scanned for viruses by BlackSpider MailControl

Click here to report this email as spam.

This email has been virus scanned by MailControl - www.mailcontrol.com

Northern Lighthouse Board 84 George Street Edinburgh EH2 3DA

Email: [email protected] Web: www.nlb.org.uk Phone: 0131 473 3100 Fax: 0131 220 2093

Northern Lighthouse Board (Oban) Gallanach Road Oban, Argyll PA34 4LS

Trish Donaldson

From: Mike Bullock Sent: 19 December 2014 08:57 To: Eric Trump Cc: @ .co.uk; Ralph Porciani ([email protected]); @ .co.uk Subject: RE: Trump Turnberry - Lighthouse

Eric, many thanks for the email. There seems to be a bit of a disconnect here, as I understand it our Solicitor is awaiting a response from CMS (who are the lawyers acting for your organisation) to a communication sent on 17 November. In addition, in response to requests from your team for access to allow surveys to be conducted we have sent our Retained Lighthouse Keeper (our local representative) to the station on two occasions. I am not aware of anything on our side that might be holding things up but if there is please don’t hesitate to let me know. Many thanks for the offer of meeting up on 13 January but I’m afraid I will be tied up in a meeting with my colleagues from the other Lighthouse Authorities.

I hope you have a great holiday and very best wishes for 2015.

Mike

From: Eric Trump [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: 17 December 2014 16:43 To: Mike Bullock Cc: @ .co.uk; Ralph Porciani ([email protected]) Subject: Trump Turnberry - Lighthouse

Mike,

I hope you are doing great!

1 Is there anything that can be done on your end to facilitate this process which seems to have stalled in the water. Our teams are ready to begin work immediately.

I will be at Turnberry on January 13 – would love to meet you in person. I hope you are doing great and wish you and your family a happy holiday!

Eric

From: Mike Bullock [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Monday, September 29, 2014 9:59 AM To: Porciani, Ralph Cc: George Sorial; Eric Trump; Subject: RE: Lighthouse NLB - Update

Very best regards

Mike

From: Porciani, Ralph [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: 29 September 2014 14:22 To: Mike Bullock Cc: George Sorial; [email protected] Subject: RE: Lighthouse NLB - Update

Good Afternoon Mike

I trust my email finds you well and enjoying the extended summer.

2 All my very best Ralph

RALPH PORCIANI GENERAL MANAGER TRUMP TURNBERRY +44(0) 1655 334 126 telephone

From: Porciani, Ralph Sent: 06 September 2014 08:53 To: [email protected] Cc: George Sorial Subject: Lighthouse NLB - Update

FYI – back in the office now so here is the note below from Mike. R

RALPH PORCIANI GENERAL MANAGER TRUMP TURNBERRY +44(0) 1655 334 126 telephone

From: Mike Bullock [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: 05 September 2014 14:54 To: Porciani, Ralph Subject: RE: NLB - Update

Ralph, thanks for the call – once again I have spelt your name incorrectly below – apologies!

Mike

From: Mike Bullock Sent: 05 September 2014 14:45 To: 'Porciani, Ralph' 3 Cc: Subject: NLB - Update

Very best regards

Mike

Northern Lighthouse Board 84 George Street Edinburgh EH2 3DA

Email: Enquiries@n b.org.uk Web: www.nlb.org.uk Phone: 0131 473 3100 Fax: 0131 220 2093

Northern Lighthouse Board (Oban) Gallanach Road Oban, Argyll PA34 4LS

Please think green, do not print out this email unless it is necessary.

This message has been scanned for viruses by BlackSpider MailControl

4 This electronic message transmission contains information from the Company that may be proprietary, confidential and/or privileged. The information is intended only for the use of the individual(s) or entity named above. If you are not the intended recipient, be aware that any disclosure, copying or distribution or use of the contents of this information is prohibited. If you have received this electronic transmission in error, please notify the sender immediately by replying to the address listed in the "From:" field.

Click here to report this email as spam.

This email has been virus scanned by MailControl - www.mailcontrol.com

Northern Lighthouse Board 84 George Street Edinburgh EH2 3DA

Email: Enquiries@n b.org.uk Web: www.nlb.org.uk Phone: 0131 473 3100 Fax: 0131 220 2093

Northern Lighthouse Board (Oban) Gallanach Road Oban, Argyll PA34 4LS

This e-mail message, and any attachments to it, are for the sole use of the intended recipients, and may contain confidential and privileged information. Any unauthorized review, use, disclosure or distribution of this email message or its attachments is prohibited. If you are not the intended recipient, please contact the sender by reply email and destroy all copies of the original message. Please note that any views or opinions presented in this email are solely those of the author and do not necessarily represent those of the company. Finally, while the company uses virus protection, the recipient should check this email and any attachments for the presence of viruses. The company accepts no liability for any damage caused by any virus transmitted by this email.

5 Trish Donaldson

From: < @voa.gsi.gov.uk> Sent: 24 February 2014 15:21 To: Subject: RE: Turnberry

Hi Ian

Ok I just wanted that aspect to feature in my report . I will make reference as outlined below.

‐‐‐‐‐Original Message‐‐‐‐‐ From: [mailto @nlb.org.uk] Sent: Monday, February 24, 2014 3:01 PM To: Subject: RE: Turnberry

Afternoon

I am checking with our Engineers Department if such a plan exists. It may be that custom and practice has altered with the changes at the Hotel/Golf Club. |Basically the route we use , through an area where the Green Keeping Staff keep their equipment, along the disused runway to a metalled track to the Lighthouse which traverses the Championship Golf Course is likely not to be shown on any legal document.

Kind regards

‐‐‐‐‐Original Message‐‐‐‐‐ From: C [mailto: @voa.gsi.gov.uk] Sent: 24 February 2014 08:36 To: '[email protected]' Subject: Turnberry

Hi Ian

I called last week when you were on leave. I wonder if you have a plan which identifies the route of access from main road to the subjects ?

Thanks.

Regards

This message is confidential and the information must not be used, disclosed, or copied to any other person who is not entitled to receive it. If you have received this message in error please notify the sender and then delete it.

The original of this email was scanned for viruses by the Government Secure Intranet virus scanning service supplied by Vodafone in partnership with Symantec. (CCTM Certificate Number 2009/09/0052.) On leaving the GSi this email was certified virus free. Communications via the GSi may be automatically logged, monitored and/or recorded for legal purposes.

This email has been virus scanned by MailControl ‐ www.mailcontrol.com

Northern Lighthouse Board 84 George Street Edinburgh EH2 3DA

Email: [email protected] Web: www.nlb.org.uk Phone: 0131 473 3100 Fax: 0131 220 2093

Northern Lighthouse Board (Oban) Gallanach Road Oban, Argyll PA34 4LS

Email: [email protected] Phone: 01631 562146 Fax: 01631 565871 ********************************************************************** This email and any files transmitted with it are confidential and intended solely for the use of the individual or entity to whom they are addressed. The content of e‐mail and files transmitted may not belong to or be the opinion of the Northern Lighthouse Board and the Northern Lighthouse Board cannot be responsible for such.

Please think green, do not print out this email unless it is necessary.

This message has been scanned for viruses by BlackSpider MailControl ‐ www.blackspider.com

2 This email was received from the INTERNET and scanned by the Government Secure Intranet anti‐virus service supplied by Vodafone in partnership with Symantec. (CCTM Certificate Number 2009/09/0052.) In case of problems, please call your organisation's IT Helpdesk. Communications via the GSi may be automatically logged, monitored and/or recorded for legal purposes.

Trish Donaldson

From: Eric Trump Sent: 29 September 2014 21:32 To: Mike Bullock Cc: [email protected] Subject: FW: Turnberry Lighthouse Attachments: Letter of Intent.docx; Exhibit B - Renovation Plan.pdf; Proposed Signage Language.docx

Mike,

Hope you are doing great and enjoyed your travels!

Hope you are doing well. I am going to be over at Turnberry on the 13 and 14th of October – if you happen to be nearby, I would love to meet you in person,

All the best,

Eric

From: Porciani, Ralph Sent: 14 August 2014 17:13 To: Mike Bullock Cc: Subject: RE: Turnberry Lighthouse

Good Mike, and

Please see the attached documents from Eric, the plan is draft 1 and is very much a work in progress, although it is very much favoured by Eric

Please review and let me have any comments you wish to feed back, I am happy to take a call and could even get Eric to dial in.

Kind regards Ralph RALPH

1 PORCIANI GENERAL MANAGER TRUMP TURNBERRY +44(0) 1655 334 126 telephone

From: Mike Bullock [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: 07 August 2014 13:25 To: Porciani, Ralph Cc: Subject: Turnberry Lighthouse

Very best regards

Mike

Northern Lighthouse Board 84 George Street Edinburgh EH2 3DA

Email: Enquiries@n b.org.uk Web: www.nlb.org.uk Phone: 0131 473 3100 Fax: 0131 220 2093

Northern Lighthouse Board (Oban) Gallanach Road Oban, Argyll PA34 4LS

Email: [email protected] Phone: 01631 562146 Fax: 01631 565871 ********************************************************************** This email and any files transmitted with it are confidential and intended solely for the use of the individual or entity to whom they are addressed. The content of e-mail and files transmitted may not 2 belong to or be the opinion of the Northern Lighthouse Board and the Northern Lighthouse Board cannot be respons ble for such.

Please think green, do not print out this email unless it is necessary.

This message has been scanned for viruses by BlackSpider MailControl

Click here to report this email as spam.

This email has been virus scanned by MailControl - www.mailcontrol.com