00paw0606_CoverNOBOX_00paw0707_Cov74 5/29/12 5:51 PM Page 1
Scientist and humanist: Princeton Erez Lieberman Aiden ’02
Alumni Questions for Krugman
Weekly Political campaigns: June 6, 2012 An expert’s view
WHAT KILLED THE DINOSAURS? Paleontologist GertaKeller has her own theory
Web exclusives and breaking news @ paw.princeton.edu SR_IVYLEAGUE_AD.pdf 1 3/29/12 1:10 PM
COMPETITIVE
C
M
Y
CM
MY
CY
CMY
K
120532_SpartanRace.indd 1 3/29/12 2:40 PM 01paw0606_TOCrev1_01paw0512_TOC 5/22/12 11:26 AM Page 1
Princeton Alumni Weekly
An editorially independent magazine by alumni for alumni since 1900
JUNE 6, 2012 VOLUME 112 NUMBER 14 President’s Page 2 Inbox 5 From the Editor 6
Campus Notebook 14 Erez Lieberman SAM Popular majors • Ban on freshman Aiden ’02, page 26. OGDEN Greek affiliation to begin in fall • Class of 2016 • Incom i n g grad students • Students seek committee to oversee Renaissance man 26 investments • Google Chairman Eric In the decade since he graduated, Erez Lieberman Aiden ’02 has Schmidt ’76 speaks on campus • Cornel West *80 retires with a splash • Faculty proved many things, including: A scientist can be a humanist, too. retirements • More • PAW ASKS: Paul By Jocelyn Kaiser ’88 Krugman, about the Fed • ON THE
CAMPUS: What I wish I learned • Stu - The dissenter 32 dents win engineering competition • Most paleontologists are convinced that the impact from an asteroid FROM PRINCETON’S VAULT: Reunions buttons was the sole cause of the mass extinction of the dinosaurs. Princeton’s Sports 23 Gerta Keller has a different theory. Swimmers train for Olympic trials • By Joel Achenbach ’82 EXTRA POINT: Competing in grad school • Men’s lacrosse update • Sports shorts A Moment With 40 Journalist and campaign observer Kathy Kiely ’77 What’s n ew @ PAW ONLINE Perspective 41 AFRICAN A CAPPELLA Gregg Lange ’70’s New nation, old traditions Watch and listen to Rally ’Round the Cannon By Sandya Das *08 Umqombothi, a new addition A column Alumni Scene 42 to the student music scene. about time, Mary Solanto ’73 develops program for time cap- ADHD • STARTING OUT: Eric Salazar ’11 • REUNIONS 2012 sules, and TIGER PROFILE: Robert Root-Bernstein ’75 View slide shows of the passing along *80 finds science and art do mix • festivities, beginning June 4. wisdom to READING ROOM: The life of an independ- future Tigers. ent doctor • New releases • Website helps alumni find jobs ART-SCIENCE CONNECTION Class Notes 46 Take Robert Root-Bernstein PAW on iTunes ’75 *80’s survey for scientists Listen to Rally ’Round Memorials 65 who create art. the Cannon as a podcast. Princeton Exchange 70 Final Scene 72 ALUMNI BLOGS Our list of blogs by
ON THE COVER: Photo illustration by Sean McCabe. Photograph Princetonians includes more of Gerta Keller by Peter Murphy. than 200 links. THE PRESIDENT’S PAGE New Approaches to Engineering rinceton has long held that the study of engineering Today, the engineering school is more likely to frame its should be firmly embedded in a liberal education work in terms of four broad areas of social need — energy, the and that prospective engineers should have broad environment, health, and security — than to define its mission exposure to the humanities and social science dis- using departmental metrics. While its departments continue ciplinesP before they graduate. Conversely, in recent years, the to provide our faculty and students with an intellectual and University has made a concerted effort to increase the techno- administrative home, they are less a retreat than a jumping logical literacy of non-engineers, not least through the work off point — one that leads to some of the most exciting courses of the Keller Center, which was established, in part, with the and research projects on our campus. To give you just a taste, goal of teaching such students “about concepts in engineer- Professor of Chemical and Biological Engineering Bruce Koel ing and science and instilling in them a solid understanding has brought his expertise in surface chemistry to the Princeton of technology and how it affects the world.” At Princeton, we Plasma Physics Laboratory, where he and his colleagues are expect our undergraduates to think deeply, but we also want endeavoring to develop a reactor lining that will sustain the them to roam widely, exploring a broad range of questions super-high temperatures required by the fusion process and and approaching them from as many angles as possible. the clean and abundant energy it promises. Molecular biology This cross-pollination has been facilitated not only by major Shivani Sud ’12 has been working with Professor of our relatively small size and single faculty but also by far- Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering Wole Soboyejo to reaching changes in how Princeton — and academia as a develop a simple screening system for cervical cancer with whole — pursues the discovery and dissemination of knowl- the goal of improving detection in developing countries. And edge. Although our basic organizing principle remains the this spring, a record number of students enrolled in Technol- academic department, be it English, chemistry, or politics, ogy and Society, a course jointly developed by Professor of teaching and research are no longer coterminous with indi- Electrical Engineering Sharad Malik and professors of history vidual disciplines. For all Michael Gordin and Angela Creager and Associate Profes- their value in ground- SKI sor of Sociology and Public Affairs Betsy Armstrong *93. In W ing students in specific this class, engineers have an opportunity to weigh the social ways of thinking, these implications of their disciplines, while non-engineers can fields — once largely develop a fuller appreciation of technology’s power and limita- self-contained — have tions — from nuclear energy to genetically modified organisms developed highly porous to Internet regulation. FRANK WOJCIECHO borders. And nowhere To nurture such ventures, the school has created six major is this more apparent interdisciplinary centers in addition to the Keller Center: than in our School of the Andlinger Center for Energy and the Environment, the Engineering and Applied Center for Information Technology Policy, the Combustion Science. Energy Frontier Research Center, the Gigascale Systems Re- Indeed, were we to search Center, Mid-Infrared Technologies for Health and the establish a school of this Environment, and the Princeton Institute for the Science and kind today, I doubt we Technology of Materials. Their creation reflects the complex- would recreate its six de- ity of the challenges our faculty and students are address- partments, whose length- ing — challenges that can only be successfully confronted on a ening names attest to the Mechanical and aerospace engineering collaborative basis. One of the biggest, of course, is developing widening scope of their graduate student Ismaiel Yakub and sustainable energy sources and uses that both meet the world’s civil and environmental engineering activities. The Depart- major Megan Partridge ’14 join forces requirements for economic growth and preserve our fragile ment of Chemical En- to demonstrate a ceramic filter system global ecosystem. I am happy to report that some 90 members gineering, for example, that promises to remove pathogenic of our faculty, including representatives of all six engineering became the Department bacteria from African drinking water departments, are working on this monumental problem under cheaply and effectively. of Chemical and Biologi- the umbrella of the Andlinger Center. Similarly, the Center cal Engineering in 2010, much as civil engineering added for Information Technology Policy has brought together some “environmental” to its title and mechanical engineering added of the best minds in the engineering and Woodrow Wilson “aerospace” in previous years. The convergence of biology and schools to further research on and find practical solutions to a engineering reflects significant changes in both disciplines, be host of critical concerns relating to everything from electronic it the introduction of high-throughput computation in the for- voting machines to technology-informed government transpar- mer or the development of organic electronics in the latter, but ency to the relationship between digital technology and social this “meeting of minds” is by no means unique. Throughout inequality. the Engineering Quadrangle and across the University, our And this, I predict, is just the beginning of the blurring faculty and students are working at the intersection of many of disciplinary boundaries, both inside and outside the engi- fields, often under the aegis of joint appointments or inter- neering school. disciplinary certificate programs. In the words of Dean Vince Poor *77, “The most inventive and effective solutions often come from unexpected interactions between disciplines.”
THE ALUMNI WEEKLY PROVIDES THESE PAGES TO THE PRESIDENT The Possibilities are Endless
“For me, the best part of Princeton is access to the faculty members. I get to sip tea with Nobel laureates and other experts in their fields, joining the global debates on ethics, energy, and everything in between. Through these interactions, I have grown as a critical thinker and as a world citizen.”
CHRISTINA CHANG ’12 AUSTIN, TX
A summer internship abroad was a defining experience for Christina, who discovered that she could serve society by combining her interests in chemistry and public engagement. For her senior thesis, Christina is examining bio-inspired catalysts to purify water. Christina founded the Women in Science Colloquium and the Princeton University Chemical Society, and volunteers at Community House teaching science to underserved children. Next year, she will attend Imperial College London and Cambridge University as a Marshall Scholar to conduct inorganic chemistry research and Photo: Bentley Drezner study sustainable energy. ” Your support of Annual Giving helps sustain the Princeton experience today and for future generations.
This year’s Annual Giving campaign ends on Saturday, June 30, 2012. To contribute by credit card, please call our 24-hour gift line at 800-258-5421 (outside the U.S., 609-258-3373), or use our secure website at www.princeton.edu/ag. Checks made payable to Princeton University can be mailed to Annual Giving, Box 5357, Princeton, NJ 08543-5357.
All gifts to Annual Giving are part of Princeton’s five-year campaign. A PLAN FOR PRINCETON (2007-2012)
04-9,13paw0516_InboxMastEditor_Letters 5/18/12 8:56 PM Page 4 PRINCETON Princeton CORKSCREW Alumni
Weekly An editorially independent magazine by alumni for alumni since 1900
JUNE 6, 2012 Volume 112, Number 14 WINE SHOP EDITOR Marilyn H. Marks *86 MANAGING EDITOR W. Raymond Ollwerther ’71 ASSOCIATE EDITORS Jennifer Altmann Katherine Federici Greenwood
DIGITAL EDITOR The Princeton Corkscrew Wine Shop Brett Tomlinson SENIOR WRITER We like good wine too. Mark F. Bernstein ’83 CLASS NOTES EDITOR Fran Hulette ART DIRECTOR Marianne Gaffney Nelson PUBLISHER Nancy S. MacMillan p’97 ADVERTISING DIRECTOR Colleen Finnegan STUDENT INTERNS Laura C. Eckhardt ’14; Taylor C. Leyden ’12; Rosaria Munda ’14; Allison S. Weiss ’13; Briana N. Wilkins ’12 P PROOFREADER 4 Joseph Bakes
WEBMASTER River Graphics PAW BOARD Annalyn M. Swan ’73, Chair Richard Just ’01, Vice Chair Constance E. Bennett ’77 *James Barron ’77 Anne A. Cheng ’85 Susan Gordon Ingela Kostenbader *Robert K. Durkee ’69 *Margaret Moore Miller ’80 Sales Associate Sales Associate *Nancy J. Newman ’78 609.688.4813 609.902.5302 David Remnick ’81 RESIDENTIAL BROKERAGE William W. Sweet *75 Charles Swift ’88 PrincetonRealEstate.net • PrincetonHome.com *ex officio &ROGZHOO%DQNHU&RUSRUDWLRQ&ROGZHOO%DQNHULVDUHJLVWHUHGWUDGHPDUNRI&ROGZHOO%DQNHU&RUSRUDWLRQ $Q(TXDO2SSRUWXQLW\&RPSDQ\(TXDO+RXVLQJ2SSRUWXQLW\2ZQHGDQG2SHUDWHGE\157,QFRUSRUDWHG LOCAL ADVERTISING/PRINCETON EXCHANGE Colleen Finnegan Telephone 609-258-4886, [email protected]
Our advertisers report an excellent NATIONAL ADVERTISING REPRESENTATIVE response to their ads in the Princeton Lawrence J. Brittan Telephone 631-754-4264, Fax 631-912-9313 For Rent Exchange: Princeton Alumni Weekly (I.S.S.N. 0149-9270) is an editorially independent, nonprofit magazine supported by class subscrip- tions, paid advertising, and a University subsidy. Its purpose is to “We’ve been thrilled by the response report with impartiality news of the alumni, the administration, the faculty, and the student body of Princeton University. The rate from our ad in the PAW.” views expressed in the Princeton Alumni Weekly do not necessarily Rent your second represent official positions of the University. The magazine is published twice monthly in October, March, and April; monthly “I receive many inquiries from in September, November, December, January, February, May, June, home through the and July; plus a supplemental Reunions Guide in May/June. my ad.” Princeton Alumni Weekly, 194 Nassau Street, Suite 38, Princeton, NJ 08542. Tel 609-258-4885; fax 609-258-2247; email Princeton Exchange! [email protected]; website paw.princeton.edu. Printed by Fry Communications Inc. in Mechanicsburg, Pa. • have a great European villa? Contact Colleen Finnegan, Advertising Annual subscriptions $22 ($26 outside the U.S.), single copies $2. All orders must be paid in advance. Copyright © 2012 the Trus - • a classic New England cottage? Director at [email protected] tees of Princeton University. All rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited. Periodicals • a home at the Jersey shore? or 609.258.4886. postage paid at Princeton, N.J., and at additional mailing offices. Postmaster: Send Form 3579 (address changes) to PAW Address Changes, 194 Nassau Street, Suite 38, Princeton, NJ 08542.
June 6, 2012 Princeton Alumni Weekly • paw.princeton.edu 04-9,13paw0516_InboxMastEditor_Letters 5/18/12 8:56 PM Page 5
Inbox BUZZ BOX Inbox When Ph.D.s need a job “Princeton should be at the forefront of the policy outside the ivory tower debate around how the United States and the world Every story, letter, and memorial at community can best make innovative information paw.princeton.edu offers a chance to comment accessible and useful to the public.” Alumni posted comments at PAW — John L. Hines Jr. ’77 Online on an April 4 Campus Notebook 1s that should have been 0s. The idea of the computer story about ending We completed the interpreter very the stigma for jobs The MANIAC computer I remem- successfully, and received top grades. — outside academia for ber it well (feature, April 4)! In the But undergraduates never got to use it. Ph.D.s in the human i - spring of 1958 a classmate, Ned Irons As was noted, the computer was retired ties, often considered a ’58, and I did our senior project (engi- soon after we graduated, and donated “Plan B.” neering students’ equivalent of a thesis) to the Smithsonian. GLORIA ERLICH *77 wrote on that computer, the only computer in The article mentions the use of the that she had found a satis- Princeton. The task was programming MANIAC computer to do calculations fying career as an inde- an interpreter a program written in for a thermonuclear device. Operation — pendent scholar, publishing two books the native language of the computer Ivy, the joint task force that detonated — and many articles. “But this alternative to provide a simplified programming the first hydrogen device, was under is possible only with independent language for students (a “user-friendly the command of my father, Maj. Gen. wealth or on what I call a ‘matrimonial interface,” in today’s terminology). P.W. Clarkson. fellowship,’ ” she said. We were not welcome at the Insti- BILL CLARKSON ’58 STEWART A. LEVIN ’75 commented that tute. The scientists’ concept of appro- Manhattan Beach, Calif. when those with graduate degrees in priate use of the computer was to read the sciences want to return to academia in a small amount of data, compute for During my senior year (1957–58), I after working in industry, they often a long time to produce an important managed a group of Princeton students P encounter an attitude that “they haven’t result, and output a small amount of who were the night operators on the paid their dues.” What isn’t recognized, 5 data. Since our project involved a great Institute machine. Night meant some- he said, is that for private workers, “job deal of input and output, they accused thing like 5 to 11 p.m. The computer security is a thing of the past and the us of using their computer as a punch- had 40 CRTs for memory, and we had hours are just as long, and publication press! But since our allotted time was an oscilloscope that could tune in on preparation is done on your own time.” midnight to 6 a.m., not many of them the 32-by-32-bit grid on any of the DAVID FINKELSTEIN *90, vice president of had to suffer through our disrespectful tubes. Our most important task was to a think tank in Washington, D.C., had use of their machine. make sure that no one bit “lit up,” a bit of good news: “I am Plan B!” he The 40 CRTs (Williams Tube mem- because if it did (for example, if the wrote, “and I am looking to recruit new ory) had some strange characteristics. program was in a very tight loop), it Ph.D.s in Chinese history or Chinese As mentioned in the article, they were could burn out that bit in all 32 tubes, studies.” very humidity-sensitive. On dry nights and that would be a disaster. they would acquire “spurious bits” — continues on page 8
WE’D LIKE TO HEAR FROM YOU Reunions 2012 @ PAW O N LI N E EMAIL: [email protected] MAIL: PAW, 194 Nassau Street, Suite 38, After Reunions, view Editors will choose the funniest, most sentimen- Princeton, NJ 08542 tal, and most creative reader-submitted images PAW ONLINE: Comment on a story at photo galleries of to run in the July issue and at PAW Online. On paw.princeton.edu the festivities at Facebook, our prize for readers’ choice will be PHONE: 609-258-4885; FAX: 609-258-2247 given to the paw.princeton.edu — Letters should not exceed 275 words, and may photo that and share your favorite be edited for length, accuracy, clarity, and receives the civility. Due to space limitations, we are pictures and short most “likes.” unable to publish all letters received in the videos with PAW. print magazine. Letters, articles, photos, and comments submitted to PAW may be pub- lished in print, electronic, or other forms. JOHN O’NEILL ’13
paw.princeton.edu • June 6, 2012 Princeton Alumni Weekly 04-9,13paw0516_InboxMastEditor_Letters 5/18/12 8:56 PM Page 6
Inbox
perspective of national security. I agree Debating illegal immigration: Alumni weigh in with Professor Massey on several The April 25 cover story on sociology professor Douglas Massey *78 and his 30 years of points. Worrisome, though, is the sig- research into Mexican immigration drew a large number of letters to the editor and com- nificant number of non-Mexican, non- ments posted at PAW Online. To read more alumni views or to add your own, go to Latino individuals (that we know of — paw.princeton.edu. likely only 5 to 10 percent of the true number) who seek access across the Dr. Douglas Massey *78 is patently U.S.-Mexican border. The number of illogical in blaming enhanced border apprehended Pakistani, Afghan, Iran- security for the net growth in illegals ian, Yemeni, and Somalian individuals over the decades, saying they just caught attempting to enter the United couldn’t go home like they used to States through the Southwest border in (cover story, April 25). Once our failing 2003 caused great shock and concern economy and closing welfare loopholes in law enforcement, the Department of ceased to attract them, they sure found Defense, and in the Congress. their way home quickly enough. Also, Law enforcement apprehended more he assumes that efforts to stem the flow than 200 “OTMs” (Other Than Mexi- northward had no effect on the level of cans) in 2003 alone. Were they intent gross in-migration, and there is no on some nefarious activity? Can any proof of that. political leader ignore the chance that Those of us in border states are pay- they are? I think not. ing billions in disproportionately high Thus, while the professor believes state taxes to feed, educate, medicate, that the Southwest border is simply an and incarcerate the folks who are here issue of Mexican immigration that can- illegally. Illegal immigrants account for not be answered with security (I’m a grossly disproportionate percentage “There are certainly no sympathetic), he exists in an academic of our federal prison population. easy or one-step solutions, bubble that lacks access to information There is a crisis, but it is not con- but nothing useful can on the greater threat. Let me finish P trived. The border states are going with this important caveat. No country 6 broke trying to cope with this federal even begin to happen can or will have a true “secure” border. failure, while being fought in court until voters and policy Fences, more technology, and other when they try to enforce even the fed- symbols truly do ignore the greater eral laws. I was not shocked to discover makers alike educate issue of economic imbalance. Having in the article that Dr. Massey had been themselves about what’s said that, no U.S. political leader can an adviser to Sens. Daniel Moynihan really going on.” morally ignore the potential risk that and Edward Kennedy, two who proba- open borders present to the country — bly were more impressed with Dr. — Peter Severson ’09 the thorny issue of illegal migration is a Massey’s “scientific method” than was I. subset within a multi-jurisdictional BILL LEIGH ’64 has been the rise of gangs and gang cul- problem. I hope that the professor will The Woodlands, Texas ture. It would be interesting if someone acknowledge this reality. could study that connection. If the facts ANDRE HOLLIS ’88 This analysis rings very true from what support it, showing that U.S. immigra- Vienna, Va. I know of the lives and families in my tion policy is a cause of the prevalence community, where I serve a church and increasing influence of gangs (His- The article on Professor Massey makes made up primarily of Latino/Latina panic and other) should get the atten- good and enlightening points. What it immigrants. It is they who suffer when tion of the conservative community. didn’t contain, though, was reference to a “crisis” is exploited for political gain. (For the record, I am a registered violent crime along the Mexican bor- THE REV. DANIEL ERDMAN ’73 Republican and a conservative in the der related to drug-cartel activity, Albuquerque, N.M. nonpolitical sense of the word.) which I believe has increased dramati- ANDREW D. FORTNEY *90 cally in recent years, costing many As one who lives at the epicenter of Fresno, Calif. more lives — mostly Mexican, but also central California agribusiness and sees American. This would seem to argue firsthand the effects of U.S. immigra- From 2001 to 2003 I served as the for “stricter border enforcement” from tion policy on a daily basis, I believe deputy assistant secretary of defense for a different perspective than simple that Professor Massey speaks the truth. counternarcotics. I spent a great deal of immigration control. Another unintended, but very real, con- time, effort, and resources on under- ANDREW WILCOX ’73 sequence of U.S. immigration policy standing the border issues from the San Rafael, Calif.
June 6, 2012 Princeton Alumni Weekly • paw.princeton.edu 07,13paw0516_InboxMastEditorREV1_Letters 5/22/12 1:51 PM Page 7
Inbox I just returned from lunch with a work with projects related to human FROM THE EDITOR Latina member of my congregation. I rights and disability advocacy. Midway told her about this fascinating article through my year, I traveled to the U.S.- Professor Gerta Keller, that said “the number of illegal immi- Mexico border and spent a transforma- the subject of PAW’s cover story, is a grants is on the rise due to border tive week and a half in the Sonoran veteran paleontologist, one of only two security ... ” and she completed my desert, working with recently deported female professors on Princeton’s sentence for me: “because they can’t go migrants by night and visiting the Bor- 22-member geosciences faculty. Erez home.” One anecdote doesn’t prove a der Patrol in Douglas, Ariz., by day. Lieberman Aiden ’02, profiled in this thesis, but it doesn’t hurt. In one form or another, I found that issue, is a rising star in math and THE REV. RICHARD HONG ’81 immigration underlies most of the crit- genomics. Englewood, N.J. ical issues facing contemporary Mex- What do they have in common? A ico. On the U.S. side, the immigration willingness to carve out their own Mark Bernstein ’83’s piece on Professor system has morphed into a shamefully paths, despite the substantial risks. Massey was interesting and in some dysfunctional bureaucracy, with the Aiden is at the beginning of his ways informative. However, the profes- effect of amplifying rather than allevi- career, with a prestigious but untenured sor’s tone, and in a few instances his ating the tremendous indignities occur- position at Harvard. Even while he was misstatements of facts, suggest that the ring on both sides of the border. immersed in the study of the human immigration problem isn’t really a I commend Professor Massey’s genome, he has studied the humanities problem at all and no big deal. Profes- research to anyone looking to get a — taking on a linguistics project, for sor Massey states, for example, that clear view of the realities of Mexican example. “It seems to be possible to crossing the border illegally is not a immigration. There are certainly no study language change and these kinds crime, but is a civil infraction on the easy or one-step solutions, but nothing of seemingly nutty subjects without order of getting a traffic ticket. This is useful can even begin to happen until completely wrecking one’s scientific patently false. voters and policy makers alike educate career,” Aiden told PAW, though, to be As stated in Section 1325 in Title 8 themselves about what’s really going fair, not every young scholar has the of the U.S. Code, the “improper entry of on. Our shared border with Mexico is a support he does. an alien” such as crossing the border place filled with tragedy, but hope Keller, too, has gone her own way. “illegally” is a crime and punishable up remains. We owe it to ourselves and our While most paleontologists believe that to six months in prison for the first Mexican counterparts to cultivate that what’s known as the Chicxulub impact P offense and for two years for any subse- hope by working together earnestly on of an asteroid led to the extinction of 7 quent offense. This is hardly compara- this pivotal issue. the dinosaurs, Keller believes other- ble to getting a traffic ticket! PETER SEVERSON ’09 wise, arguing for her research at confer- It is correct that many illegals have Chicago, Ill. ences despite opposition and even entered the country legally and then ridicule. simply overstayed their visa. True, this As an alum working for the U.S. govern- Keller is “the sort of person for is not a crime and is only a civil infrac- ment in the immigration arena, it is whom universities were created,” the tion. However, even in these instances, good to see PAW shedding some light editor of the journal Geoscientist told to suggest that an “overstay” is like get- on the complexity of the system. One PAW. One of Aiden’s advisers said ting a traffic ticket is both wrong and correction to note: The INS no longer exactly the same thing, about him. misleading. An immigrant found to exists. That agency was disbanded under have entered the country legally but the Homeland Security Act and its func- Speaking of courage, who has overstayed his visa can be tions removed from the Department of few people had as deported — not the normal punish- Justice. Immigration functions now are much of it as ment for speeders. handled under three separate agencies Nicholas Katzenbach ALFRED L. EVANS ’62 within DHS. These are Immigration and ’43, a key member of Centreville, Md. Customs Enforcement (ICE), Customs the Kennedy and and Border Protection (CBP), and U.S. Johnson administra- If I wore a hat, I’d certainly doff it to Citizenship and Immigration Services tions and a towering Katzenbach ’43 Douglas Massey and the members of (USCIS, where I work). figure in civil rights. the Mexican Migration Project at Alumni also will be interested to He died May 8, at 90. In 2008, a faculty Princeton. His on-the-ground work and know that a Princetonian, Wen Cheng panel convened by PAW ranked him unsparing analysis are more necessary ’91, recently was named chief counsel No. 16 on its list of the most influential than ever in the ongoing battle over for the ICE New York district office alumni of all time. FRANK illegal immigration in the United — one of the largest districts in A memorial service will be held 11 WOJCIECHOWSKI States. After I graduated from Prince- DHS. a.m. Thursday, June 21, in Richardson ton, I spent a year living in the south- PETER SCHMALZ ’89 Auditorium. ern Mexican city of Cuernavaca to Essex Junction, Vt. — Marilyn H. Marks *86
June 6, 2012 Princeton Alumni Weekly 04-9,13paw0516_InboxMastEditor_Letters 5/18/12 8:56 PM Page 8
Inbox continued from page 5 spread, access, and use of knowledge I used that computer to do calcula- and to what extent they may be in tions on my senior thesis, and I suspect direct conflict with the University’s that it was one of the first Princeton fundamental mission. theses to use a digital computer. My With most of the value of U.S. busi- classmate, Ned Irons, tells me that he ness existing in intangibles, Princeton also used the machine for his thesis, should be at the forefront of the policy but I was unaware of that at the time. I debate around how the United States had to get my thesis done in a timely and the world community can best way, since the machine was disassem- make innovative information accessible bled for shipment to the Smithsonian and useful to the public. Partaking neu- shortly thereafter. It was exciting many trally in this wider conversation neces- years later to visit the Smithsonian and sarily, at a minimum, means examining see the desk at which I used to sit. the propriety and effectiveness of JERRY PORTER ’58 Princeton’s own patent policies. This Ardmore, Pa. examination of its own policies should be highly transparent and involve the
As a grad student in the mid-1950s, I entire University community. was fortunate to have access to the JOHN L. HINES JR. ’77 MANIAC computer as part of my the- Chicago, Ill. sis research. This excellent article brought back many fond memories. JOSH DRANOFF *56 *60 Drug laws an injustice Evanston, Ill. The April 25 issue had stories about a I was one of half-dozen or so juniors number of remarkable alumni, but I and seniors who actually wrote and ran was particularly impressed by Ben- little programs for this machine. There jamin West ’01, whose work as a public P was, of course, no such thing as pro- defender in New York City is truly “in 8 gramming or computer science classes the nation’s service” (Perspective). He back then, nor high-level languages or highlighted the gross racial disparities even assembler language — the pro- in how our laws are enforced, which grams were in machine language coded result in people of color being arrested in binary, on IBM punched cards! I and imprisoned at rates that far exceed can’t remember who was in that group the proportion of crimes that they
or who the poor grad student was who commit. He could have added that was our instructor. The experience much of this is due to our irrational taught me enough about programming drug laws — particularly evident in to avoid it for the rest of a very gratify- New York City, which for two decades ing career in engineering. Does any- has been the marijuana-arrest capital of body else remember that class 56 years the world, with about 50,000 arrests ago? annually for simple possession. HOWARD ROBBINS ’57 More generally, as a retired CIA Rockland, Maine European analyst, I am struck by the fact that the United States has more It was interesting to learn in “Daybreak people in jail for drug crimes (about of the digital age” that Princeton’s John 500,000) than all of Western Europe, von Neumann elected to forgo patent with its much larger population, has in claims on the computer he and his jail for any reason (about 440,000). team designed that launched the com- DICK KENNEDY ’63 puter revolution. Lorton, Va. Princeton should use the centennial anniversary of Alan Turing *38’s birth to open a conversation on the role of Questions about Greek policy patents in a university: whether, to what extent, and under what circum- I was not in a fraternity at Princeton, stances they contribute to the widest and as far as I know, nobody in my
June 6, 2012 Princeton Alumni Weekly • paw.princeton.edu 04-9,13paw0516_InboxMastEditor_Letters 5/18/12 8:56 PM Page 9
Inbox
extended family has ever been a mem- craft trial, where only a confession was to spread on Princeton’s campus. But ber of one, either. Greek organizations considered proof? What about hearsay I’m enough of a civil libertarian to be were starting to reestablish themselves evidence? Perhaps Princeton should very uncomfortable with the kinds of on campus during my undergraduate employ informants, seeking out Greek enforcement that would be required to years, and I wasn’t happy to see them. organizations they can join as freshmen make this policy stick. Ultimately, the That said, this policy and the sanctions (it could be a condition for admission, University needs to decide whether it is the committee is recommending or maybe a work-study job). I can see it going to treat students as adults or not. (“Tough penalties suggested for frosh- now: “I worked in the kitchen at Wil- ANAND GNANADESIKAN ’88 s’90 p’14 rush ban violators,” Campus Notebook, son College; what did you do?” “I was Severna Park, Md. April 25) seem like a wild overreach the mole who helped bring down that’s going to make a university I love Sigma Alpha Epsilon.” look absurd and abusive. These examples are absurd, but the Sad statistics on academics How does the University plan to jus- fact that they present real questions is tify scrapping basic notions of freedom the sad part. The cure definitely appears How painful to read your story, “USG of association? Let’s consider some of worse than the disease in this case. surveys academic life” (Campus Note- the situations Princeton certainly will JEFF SHUMAN ’87 book, April 25). Here we learn that encounter, including the penalty — Falls Church, Va. Princeton students spend only 26 not expulsion, but “suspension.” Until hours per week on coursework outside when? Until the offender recants? Will I am embarrassed for the University. of class. For courses that require more they consider a reduction in the penalty Value judgments by the social engineers than four hours per week of reading, if the offender denounces other frater- cannot be challenged! Both Orwell and students report that, on average, they nity/sorority members? Nothing Rand must be chuckling from their do only 53 percent of it. A majority Orwellian about that, is there? How respective places in the ethers. remain indignant, however, about a does the University intend to prove ROBERT NORTON ’65 University policy that tries to keep the “membership”? Presumably the Greek Bluffton, SC. number of A grades to 35 percent. organizations would not be providing Perhaps most disturbing is the com- lists of prospective members to the I hold no brief for frats, which I think ment of Michael Yaroshefsky ’12, the dean’s office. Would it be like a witch- would be a significant minus were they continues on page 13 P 9 JOHN CONSTABLE: Princeton and the Oil Sketches from the Gothic Revival: Victoria and Albert Museum 1870 - 1930 On view through June 10 On view through June 24
Exhibition organized byby the VictoriaVictoria and AlbertAlbert Museum, eum, , London. JohnJohn Constable,Constable, BrBritish,itish,, 1776–1837: SalisburyurSalisb y CathedrCathedralala from the South WWeWestest, ca.ca., 1820, , detail. on Oil on can canvas,nvvas, later lined. The VictorVictoriaia and AlbertAlbert Museum (319-1888). © VictorVictoriariia and AlberAlbertt Museum / V&A images. FreerF ee and open to the public Tuesday, Wednesday,WydauesT e, Fydadnes Friday, and Saturday,Syrida, ydaurta, , 10 a.m.–5 p.m.p.m. Cram and Ferguson,Ferguson,, ararchitects,chitects,, Boston, , fl. 1915–1941: proposedproposed interiorinterior of UniUniversityerv sity Chapel, artmuseum.princeton.edutmusar eum.princ eeton. du Thursday,ydaThurs , 10 0 a.m.–10 p.m.p.m. undated,, detail. WWaWatercoloratercolor on wwovevo e paperpaper.. UniUniversityerv Archives,Asity vchiAr es,, DeparDepartmenttment of RareRare Books and 609.258.37888837.58609.2 Sunday,, 1–5 p.m.ppyundaS .m. Special Collections, PrincetonPrinceton UniUniversityerv sity Library.Libraryy.
paw.princeton.edu • June 6, 2012 Princeton Alumni Weekly by Philip W Anderson (Princeton University, USA)
“Anderson has put together an entertaining and instructive collection of highly readable reviews, columns, talks, and unpublished essays on science and the scientists he has known. He is rarely inappropriately provocative, and he is a pleasure to read.” 2012 Guide to Physics Today
http://www.worldscibooks.com/physics/8141.html (+12/* PrincetonO www.worldscientific.com
“An invaluable action guide to creating opportunities for greater joy, OAuthors purpose, and meaning through self-expression.” –Library Journal THE CREATIVITY CURE A DO-IT-YOURSELF PRESCRIPTION FOR HAPPINESS O CARRIE BARRON, M.D., ‘81, & ALTON BARRON, M.D. “The Creativity Cure is a most welcome ȱȱȱȱ ¢ȯ addition to the literature on personal ¢ȱȂȱȱ and relationship transformation. I highly recommend that you read this book.” —Gay Hendricks, Ph.D., author of Conscious Living
AVAILABLE WHEREVER BOOKS Scan for 5 Tips to AND eBOOKS ARE SOLD Tap Into Your Visit TheCreativityCure.com Creative Self
¢ȱ ǯȱȱȂşŞ dz ȱȱȱȱ Beautiful Sanctuaries in ȱ dzȱ Nineteenth- and Early-Twentieth- ȯȱȱ Century European Literature ȱ ¢ǰȱȱȬ¢ȱȱ %
Author ads 6-2012 ALTERNATE .indd 2 5/17/2012 1:35:44 PM