Eugenics and Education: Implications of Ideology, Memory, and History for Education in the United States

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Eugenics and Education: Implications of Ideology, Memory, and History for Education in the United States Abstract WINFIELD, ANN GIBSON. Eugenics and Education – Implications of Ideology, Memory, and History for Education in the United States. (under the direction of Anna Victoria Wilson) Eugenics has been variously described "as an ideal, as a doctrine, as a science (applied human genetics), as a set of practices (ranging from birth control to euthanasia), and as a social movement" (Paul 1998 p. 95). "Race suicide" (Roosevelt 1905) and the ensuing national phobia regarding the "children of worm eaten stock" (Bobbitt 1909) prefaced an era of eugenic ideology whose influence on education has been largely ignored until recently. Using the concept of collective memory, I examine the eugenics movement, its progressive context, and its influence on the aims, policy and practice of education. Specifically, this study examines the ideology of eugenics as a specific category and set of distinctions, and the role of collective memory in providing the mechanism whereby eugenic ideology may shape and fashion interpretation and action in current educational practice. The formation of education as a distinct academic discipline, the eugenics movement, and the Progressive era coalesced during the first decades of the twentieth century to form what has turned out to be a lasting alliance. This alliance has had a profound impact on public perception of the role of schools, how students are classified and sorted, degrees and definitions of intelligence, attitudes and beliefs surrounding multiculturalism and a host of heretofore unexplored ramifications. My research is primarily historical and theoretical and uses those material and media cultural artifacts generated by the eugenics movement to explore the relationship between eugenic ideology and the institution of education. Eugenics and Education: Implications of Ideology, Memory, and History for Education in the United States By Ann Gibson Winfield A dissertation submitted to the Graduate Faculty of North Carolina State University In partial fulfillment of The requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy Educational Research, Leadership, and Policy Analysis Raleigh, NC 2004 Approved By: _________________________________________________________ Dr. Anna V. Wilson, Chair _________________________________________________________ Dr. Peter A. Hessling _________________________________________________________ Dr. Paul F. Bitting _________________________________________________________ Dr. Kenneth H. Brinson Biography I was born on December 16, 1962 in Williamstown, Massachusetts and moved at the age of three months to New York City. In 1970, I moved with my mother to the islands of British Columbia Canada where I learned to pick oysters, run on log booms, follow salamanders, and love the ocean. I lived in various island locales until the age of eleven when we moved to Vancouver. I attended alternative schools, by choice, through high school, graduated in 1980 and moved back to the “states.” After taking time off to work I was determined to attend the University of California and set about beefing up my credentials by attending Community College in Oakland, California. I attended the University of California Santa Cruz from 1985 to 1988, majoring in cultural anthropology. Following my graduation, I worked for twelve years in the non-profit sector as an organizer in the San Francisco Bay Area and a legislative assistant in Sacramento, California. During this period I became a mother to Lucian, now twelve, an event that has provided me with my greatest joy and has defined and focused my life ever since. In 1997, I decided to return to graduate school and entered a program that allowed me to get a Masters in Education and teacher certification simultaneously. I was drawn to the field of education in part because much of my time in the non-profit sector was concerned with community education and empowerment as well as educating and training hundreds of college students to raise money, conduct press conferences, set up meetings between community leaders and citizens, etc. During the three years it took to get my Masters degree I worked full time as an office manager and drove over 400 miles per week between three cities. ii Toward the end of that program, in the summer of 1999, I attended a class on curriculum theory and met my future advisor, mentor and chair of my committee Dr. Anna Wilson. The introduction to curriculum theory resulted in a major paradigm shift for me and I decided to continue my education with the goal of receiving a Ph. D. in Curriculum Studies. Now, I am nearly at the end of that journey and my love and passion for my chosen field has only deepened. Theory, philosophy, and interdisciplinary approaches all combine to provide me with a rich foundation from which to think about human society and the interactions therein. iii Dedication I could not have completed this work without the love and support of my friends and family. My mother, Camille Nichols, has been there in all ways intellectual and emotional. Her deep and unwavering love for me throughout my life has allowed me to construct a worldview that is based on love and hope. My father, John Winfield has provided me with the spirit and tenacity to strive. He has modeled an approach to living that simultaneously does not let up and yet takes every opportunity to scratch behind a dogs ear and notice a beautiful sky. My stepmother, Leigh Callahan has given me the purest love and appreciation and has shown me that kindness is metabolic. My son, Lucian Winfield McCoy, has infused my life with joy and humor, pre-teen perspective and Spongebob Squarepants philosophy. My friend Debbie McMullen has been my beacon in a foggy, stormy sea. She has unwaveringly been there to show me the way back to real life, to warmth and companionship. My thanks go also to my aunt Edith, who has provided an articulate and pithy political commentary concerning family, national, and global affairs. My committee, Dr. Paul Bitting, Dr. Peter Hessling, and Dr. Ken Brinson have inspired and incited my courage, reigned in my purple pomposity, and provided a wholly professional graduate experience. Most of all, this dissertation is dedicated to my friend, mentor, comrade, and committee chair, Dr. Anna Wilson. Anna is a phenomenal teacher who from the first challenged me to reach within to my deepest depths and question what I think I know. Anna recognized me as a voice, treated me as a respected colleague, gave me room to do things my own way, and guided me to navigate academia in an accurate, thoughtful, purposeful manner. A consummate professional, Anna nevertheless shares herself with her students in a way that truly models what it iv means to live a life that speaks truth to power. I dedicate this to all of you who have loved and supported me so well through this process. Thank you. v Table of Contents CHAPTER 1...................................................................................................................... 1 IDEOLOGY, TOOLS, AND PERSPECTIVE ............................................................... 1 What is Eugenics? ........................................................................................................................................ 2 Fear of the 'Other' ............................................................................................................ 3 The Dilution of Genetic ‘Stock’ ...................................................................................... 4 Immune to Invalidation ................................................................................................... 6 Dissemination Campaign................................................................................................. 7 Sterilization of the Unfit.................................................................................................. 8 Progressive Roots ............................................................................................................ 9 Eugenics and Education............................................................................................................................. 11 The ‘Fathers’ of Curriculum.......................................................................................... 11 Testing as a Tool............................................................................................................ 12 Why it Matters............................................................................................................................................ 12 How it Matters............................................................................................................................................ 13 Collective Memory........................................................................................................ 13 Role of Collective Memory ........................................................................................... 15 Researcher Perspective .............................................................................................................................. 16 Family Background ....................................................................................................... 17 Education....................................................................................................................... 18 Political Life .................................................................................................................. 22 Emotional/Social ..........................................................................................................
Recommended publications
  • The Technological Imaginary of Imperial Japan, 1931-1945
    THE TECHNOLOGICAL IMAGINARY OF IMPERIAL JAPAN, 1931-1945 A Dissertation Presented to the Faculty of the Graduate School of Cornell University in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy by Aaron Stephen Moore August 2006 © 2006 Aaron Stephen Moore THE TECHNOLOGICAL IMAGINARY OF IMPERIAL JAPAN, 1931-1945 Aaron Stephen Moore, Ph.D. Cornell University 2006 “Technology” has often served as a signifier of development, progress, and innovation in the narrative of Japan’s transformation into an economic superpower. Few histories, however, treat technology as a system of power and mobilization. This dissertation examines an important shift in the discourse of technology in wartime Japan (1931-1945), a period usually viewed as anti-modern and anachronistic. I analyze how technology meant more than advanced machinery and infrastructure but included a subjective, ethical, and visionary element as well. For many elites, technology embodied certain ways of creative thinking, acting or being, as well as values of rationality, cooperation, and efficiency or visions of a society without ethnic or class conflict. By examining the thought and activities of the bureaucrat, Môri Hideoto, and the critic, Aikawa Haruki, I demonstrate that technology signified a wider system of social, cultural, and political mechanisms that incorporated the practical-political energies of the people for the construction of a “New Order in East Asia.” Therefore, my dissertation is more broadly about how power operated ideologically under Japanese fascism in ways other than outright violence and repression that resonate with post-war “democratic” Japan and many modern capitalist societies as well. This more subjective, immaterial sense of technology revealed a fundamental ambiguity at the heart of technology.
    [Show full text]
  • Philosophy of Social Efficiency. John Deweys Complex Analyses of the Values of Science, Technology, and Democracy for Education in a Technological World Are Examined
    DOCUMENT RESUME ED 051 002 08 SO 000 860 AUTHOR Wirth, Arthur G. TITLE The Vocational-Liberal Studies Controversy Between John Dewey and Others (1900-1917). Final Report. INSTITUTION Washington Univ., St. Louis, Mo. Graduate Inst. of Education. SPONS AGENCY Office of Education (DHEW), Washington. D.C. Bureau of Research. PUB DATE Sep 70 GRANT OEG -0 -8- 070305 -3662 (085) NOTE 349p.; Report will be published as Education in the Technological Society: The Vocational-Liberal Studies Controversy (1900-1917), International Textbook Co., 1972 EDRS PRICE EDRS Price MF-$0.65 HC-$13.16 DESCRIPTORS Comprehensive High Schools, Democratic Values, *Educatfonal Change, *Educational History, *Educational Philosophy, Educational Policy, Educational Sociology, General Education, *Industrialization, Occupational Guidance, Political Influences, Public Education, School Community Relationship, Social Change, Social Values, Socioeconomic influences, *Vocational Education IDENTIFIERS *Dewey (John) ABSTRACT The present study looks at an example of institutional change directly resulting from the industrialization process --the industrial or vocational education movement. The thesis of this study is that an understanding of the debate over how schools should adapt to industrialization will reveal the nature of basic value choices which the American people were forced to face under the pressures of adjusting to technology. Part I examines some of the origins of educational changes related to the industrialization. Next the responses of selected interest groups are considered: business, as represented by the National Association of Manufacturers; the American Federation of Labor; liberal urban reform forces of the progressive era; and, the formation of typical progressive pressure group--the National Society for the Promotion of Industrial Education (NSPIE), which worked to promote school reform programs at state and national levels.
    [Show full text]
  • A Theory-Based Approach to Market Transformation
    A Theory-based Approach to Market Transformation Carl Blurn.rtein, University of Cal#ornia En!ergy Institute, Berkeley, CA Seymour Goldstone, California Energy Commission, Sacramento, CA Loren Lutzenhiser, Washington State University, Pullman, WA ABSTRACT Market transformation (MT) programs face numerous challenges in identifying targets, undemanding markets, and intervening effective y in them. Traditional energy efficiency progmm approaches generally lack the tools necessary to meet those challenges. New energy market realities and new public purposes roles for government that emphasize market connectivity will require more sophisticated forms of MT that focus on murkets rather than end-users. One such approach, being developed by the California Energy Commission, stresses the importance of theory-based MT, with tight linkages between existing theory, program design, empirical testing of crucial assumptions, evaluation, and theory development. Feedback and itetative learning are involved at all stages. Because a clear understanding of market dynamics is crucial to this approach, multidisciplinary research plays a key role. Introduction In this paper we sketch an approach to market transformation (MT) appropriate to the new realities of the 21st Century. We first discuss sources of MT thinking and assess the usefulness to ~ interventions of energy efficiency strategies and research agendas inherited from the period of efficiency resource acquisition. Our main point is that, as a result of changes in energy efficiency programs, what we need to know to conduct successfid programs has also changed. This provides the context for our description of a systematic strategy for MT being developed by the California Energy Commission (CEC). This strategy has the advantage of recognizing the need for new knowledge, careful program design, pilot testing, and real-time evaluation with feedback loops.
    [Show full text]
  • State Facilitated Violence Against Black Women in North Carolina Through the Lens of Eugenic Sterilization
    STATE FACILITATED VIOLENCE AGAINST BLACK WOMEN IN NORTH CAROLINA THROUGH THE LENS OF EUGENIC STERILIZATION By Brenda Onyango APRIL 20, 2016 Under the Supervision of Dr. Wahneema Lubiano In Partial Completion of the Requirements for Graduation with Distinction Trinity College of Arts and Sciences 1 For Anarcha, Lucy, Betsy, my mothers, and my sisters. 2 Table of Contents: 2 Table of Contents 3 Glossary 4 Abstract 6 Introduction 10 Literature Review of Eugenics Board Documents 37 Eugenics and Genetics 43 Founding Mothers: Coloniality and Black Women’s Bodies 54 Where Do We Go from Here 58 Coda 64 References 3 Glossary Asexualization – defined by the Eugenics Board as castration or ovariectomy (Eugenics Board, 1946) Castration – removal of the testes (Dictionary.com) Coloniality of power – concept developed by Anibal Quijano that describes enduring colonial relationships (starting with the ‘discovery’ of America until today) among European nations and former colonies, the use of race in social structures, and the hegemony of knowledge (Mignolo, 2000; Martinot, n.d.); i.e. colonialism without colonies (p. 32 of this work) Evolution – on the micro level, evolution is change in gene frequency in a population from one generation to the next; on the macro level, evolution is speciation or taxonomic change over time (University of California Museum of Paleontology, 2016) Eugenics – a science1 that deals with the improvement (as by control of human mating) of hereditary qualities of a race or breed (Merriam-Webster) Evolutionary fitness – relative ability of an individual organism to survive and leave its genes in the next generation (University of California Museum of Paleontology, 2016) Genes – basic unit of hereditary.
    [Show full text]
  • Implications for Democratic Education
    The End of Efficiency: Implications for Democratic Education FRANCINE MENASHY Ontario Institute for Studies in Education University of Toronto ABSTRACT: This paper provides an examination of the concept of efficiency and its application to current educational initiatives and reforms. It is shown that several movements in education are primarily based on a narrow conception of efficiency, giving rise to serious ethical concerns. Beginning with an examination of the term efficiency and common misconceptions of its meaning, manifestations of the efficiency movement in education are then described, followed by their ethical implications in terms of democratic education and equity issues. It will be concluded that the problematic consequences of efficiency initiatives in schools are mainly due to the application of an overly narrow conception of efficiency. RESUME: lei, le concept d la competence et de sa pratique dans les reformes et les initiatives actuelles de l'enseignement, sont analyses. 11 y est demontre que plusieurs mouvements dans l' enseignement s'appuient d' abord sur une conception limitee de la competence soulevant ainsi, des problemes importants d'ordre ethique. Le papier commence par une analyse du mot "competence" et des conceptions erronees de sa signification, ensuite par la description des manifestations du mouvement de competence dans l'enseignement, puis par leurs mises en action ethiques en termes d'enseignement democratiques et de questions d'equite. On en conclura queles consequences problematiques des initiatives de competence dans les ecoles sont principalement dues a la mise en pratique d'une conception de la competence qui est plus que limitee. The label efficient is rarely given as a pejorative.
    [Show full text]
  • Journal of Business and Management
    Vol. 17 No. 1 J. B.M. Journal of Business and Management Editors Cristina M. Giannantonio, Ph.D. Amy E. Hurley-Hanson, Ph.D. Published by Chapman University’s Argyros School of Business and Economics WDSI Sponsored by the Western Decision Sciences Institute WDSI WESTERN DECISION SCIENCES INSTITUTE The Western Decision Sciences Institute is a regional division of the Decision Sciences Institute. WDSI serves its interdisciplinary academic and business members primarily through the organization of an annual conference and the publication of the Journal of Business and Management. The conference and journal allow academicians and business professionals from all over the world to share information and research with respect to all aspects of education, business, and organizational decisions. PRESIDENT Mahyar Amouzegar California State University, Long Beach PRESIDENT-ELECT Nafisseh Heiat Montana State University-Billings PROGRAM CHAIR/VICE PRESIDENT FOR PROGRAMS/PROCEEDINGS EDITOR John Davies Victoria University of Wellington VICE PRESIDENT FOR PROGRAMS-ELECT Sheldon R. Smith Utah Valley State College VICE PRESIDENT FOR MEMBER SERVICES David Yen Miami University of Ohio SECRETARY/TREASURER Richard L. Jenson Utah State University DIRECTOR OF INFORMATION SYSTEMS Abbas Heiat Montana State University - Billings IMMEDIATE PAST-PRESIDENT G. Keong Leong University of Nevada, Las Vegas REGIONAL VICE PRESIDENT Vijay Kannan Utah State University Journal of Business and Management – Vol. 17, No. 1, 2011 Journal of Business and Management Volume 17, Number 1 2011 EDITORS Cristina M. Giannantonio, Chapman University Amy E. Hurley-Hanson, Chapman University J. B.M. Journal of Business and Management EDITORS Cristina M. Giannantonio, Chapman University Amy E. Hurley-Hanson, Chapman University EDITORIAL BOARD Nancy Borkowski Florida International University Krishna S.
    [Show full text]
  • Nativism, Eugenics, and White Nationalism: a Casual Or Causal Relationship?
    Nativism, Eugenics, and White Nationalism: A Casual or Causal Relationship? David Sowell Democracy and Diversity Series, April 26, 2017 David Sowell is Professor Emeritus of History from Juniata College. want to share a political cartoon to introduce this topic (see Figure 1). The cartoon suggests that, as I history marches on, nativism marches in place. It remains central to our history. Catholics, Chinese, Jews, Mexicans, and now maybe Syrians have encountered a nativist backlash in their migration to the US. This suggests a relationship, at least in this cartoonist’s mind, that nativism permeates United States history. Should we go beyond this assertion and link eugenics and white nationalism to that nativist character of our society? This is the question that I have been asked to address as a historian. Figure 1: Barry Deutsch, “History Marches On; Nativism Marches in Place.” Ampersand. Dollars & Sense 273 (November/December 2007): 4. 175| Juniata Voices Before I can continue, we must think about casual and causal relationships. Nativism, eugenics, and white nationalism are casually related. When we read the cartoon, we can readily see their casual relationships. But, for a causal relationship, one thing must cause another. It is not enough to state there is a causal relationship; one must demonstrate it in a convincing manner to the reader. A causal relationship is much more difficult to determine and identify. Can we causally assert a relationship between eugenics and alt-right, or should we say that they are similar in some way that cannot be said to lead to the other? Should our language be more casual, or should we qualify our intellectual analysis as rooted in a firm historical analysis? My sense is that as members of the liberal arts community, we should be careful about what kind of language we use.
    [Show full text]
  • Science, Progressivism, and "Practical Idealism:" Reflections on Efficient Imperialism and Federal Science in Australia, 1895-1915"
    Article "Science, Progressivism, and "Practical Idealism:" Reflections on Efficient Imperialism and Federal Science in Australia, 1895-1915" Roy MacLeod Scientia Canadensis: Canadian Journal of the History of Science, Technology and Medicine / Scientia Canadensis : revue canadienne d'histoire des sciences, des techniques et de la médecine , vol. 17, n°1- 2, 1993, p. 7-25. Pour citer cet article, utiliser l'information suivante : URI: http://id.erudit.org/iderudit/800362ar DOI: 10.7202/800362ar Note : les règles d'écriture des références bibliographiques peuvent varier selon les différents domaines du savoir. Ce document est protégé par la loi sur le droit d'auteur. L'utilisation des services d'Érudit (y compris la reproduction) est assujettie à sa politique d'utilisation que vous pouvez consulter à l'URI https://apropos.erudit.org/fr/usagers/politique-dutilisation/ Érudit est un consortium interuniversitaire sans but lucratif composé de l'Université de Montréal, l'Université Laval et l'Université du Québec à Montréal. Il a pour mission la promotion et la valorisation de la recherche. Érudit offre des services d'édition numérique de documents scientifiques depuis 1998. Pour communiquer avec les responsables d'Érudit : [email protected] Document téléchargé le 14 février 2017 07:52 Science, Progressivism, and "Practical Idealism:" Reflections on Efficient Imperialism and Federal Science in Australia, 1895-1915 Roy MacLeod Introduction1 The task of Empire is the... scientific conquest of its physical, and, shall we not be bold and say, ultimately
    [Show full text]
  • A Comparison of American, Canadian, and European Home Energy Performance in Heating Dominated – Moist Climates Based on Building Codes Stephanie M
    University of Massachusetts Amherst ScholarWorks@UMass Amherst Masters Theses 1911 - February 2014 2014 A Comparison of American, Canadian, and European Home Energy Performance in Heating Dominated – Moist Climates Based on Building Codes Stephanie M. Berkland University of Massachusetts Amherst Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarworks.umass.edu/theses Part of the Construction Engineering Commons, and the Other Architecture Commons Berkland, Stephanie M., "A Comparison of American, Canadian, and European Home Energy Performance in Heating Dominated – Moist Climates Based on Building Codes" (2014). Masters Theses 1911 - February 2014. 1173. Retrieved from https://scholarworks.umass.edu/theses/1173 This thesis is brought to you for free and open access by ScholarWorks@UMass Amherst. It has been accepted for inclusion in Masters Theses 1911 - February 2014 by an authorized administrator of ScholarWorks@UMass Amherst. For more information, please contact [email protected]. A Comparison of American, Canadian, and European Home Energy Performance in Heating Dominated – Moist Climates Based on Building Codes A Thesis Presented by STEPHANIE BERKLAND Submitted to the Graduate School of the University of Massachusetts Amherst in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of MASTER OF SCIENCE February 2014 Environmental Conservation © Copyright by Stephanie Berkland 2014 All Rights Reserved A COMPARISON OF AMERICAN, CANADIAN, AND EUROPEAN HOME ENERGY PERFORMANCE IN HEATING DOMINATED – MOIST CLIMATES BASED ON BUILDING CODES A Thesis Presented by STEPHANIE BERKLAND Approved as to style and content by: ________________________________ Simi Hoque, Chair ________________________________ Paul Fisette, Member ________________________________ Benjamin Weil, Member ________________________________ Anton Kraler, Consulting Member Curt Griffin, Department Head of Environmental Conservation ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I would like to thank my advisor, Dr.
    [Show full text]
  • TABLOID-10 The-Pill-Eugenics-PRINT
    Love in a Mist — 2019 THE PILL, EUGENI C S, AND STERILIZATIONErin Blakemore, “The First Birth Control Pill Used Puerto Rican Women as Guinea Pigs,” History, May 9, 2018, history.com/news/birth-control-pill-history-puerto-rico-enovid. The information in this publication weaves together the history of the pill within a legacy on eugenics and its consequent laws The Pill that naturalized sterilization among the rural poor and ethnic groups. This included Native American and Puerto Rican women who were forced or coerced into sterilization and made test- Sanger thought that women would never be free until they had subjects for reproductive research beginning in 1956 led by the ability to control their own bodies. But her views on birth Dr. Gregory Pincus, a graduate of and assistant professor at control were also rooted in philosophies that would raise modern Harvard University. eyebrows. Historians agree that Sanger supported eugenics, a the- Paradoxically, abusive eugenics trials on Puerto Rican women ory that “undesirable” populations could be reduced or eliminated would bring to term the invention of the synthetic pill, which by controlling their breeding. would become one of the most effective tools for women to In Sanger’s case, that “undesirable” group was “the mentally control their reproductive choices. and physically defective.” Using eugenic language of the era, Sanger argued that birth control could help wipe out “the greatest present menace to civilization” — people living in extreme poverty and those with mental illnesses and physical disabilities. That interest in eliminating extreme poverty drove Sanger to look for, and invest in, more modern forms of birth control.
    [Show full text]
  • The Philadelphia Progressives: a Test of the Hofstadter-Hays Theses
    THE PHILADELPHIA PROGRESSIVES: A TEST OF THE HOFSTADTER-HAYS THESES By BONNiE R. Fox* THE period of American history from approximately 1900 to 1917 is marked by a national response to changing conditions in American society. The "Gilded Age" had witnessed an accelera- tion of the forces of industrialization and urbanization, accompanied by a vast influx of European immigrants, which contributed to the creation and aggravation of many political, economic, and social problems. During this period, some private groups and some municipal and state governments began to try to cope with the new complexities; and with the coming of the twentieth century, history records increased legislative action by the federal govern- ment also. The wave of "progressivism" that swept the country with varied intensities in different areas is characterized by three major categories of reform efforts: politically, a desire to broaden the base of democracy through electoral and administrative re- forms; economically, a desire for governmental regulation or ownership of certain monopolistic enterprises in the public interest; and, socially, a quest for justice to increase the dignity and al- leviate the conditions of the downtrodden masses. Reform move- ments differed in various sections of the country, on various gov- ernmental-administrative levels, in leadership, and in the problems on which they focused. Because of marked differences among pro- gressive movements and yet their coincidence of time and general sentiment in the desire for some change, there have been numerous scholarly investigations in the historiography of progressivism.' Historians generally seem to concentrate their interpretive de- bates on three major issues. First, was there a progressive move- ment? Was there a distinctive era in time characterized by certain *Miss Fox is a graduate student at Columbia University.
    [Show full text]
  • Historiographic Perspectives of Context and Progress During a Half Century of Progressive Educational Reform
    Historiographic Perspectives of Context and Progress During a Half Century of Progressive Educational Reform Ellen Durrigan Santora University of Alabama Related waves of contemporary school reform and historians of education, mostly educators, produced inspir- curriculum critique have revitalized interest in the history of ing histories that sought to ennoble the new profession of progressive education. Most recently those efforts to improve teaching. However academic arguments of relevance, society through education have centered on the restructuring presentism, and utility came to haunt both historical tradi- of schools and classrooms for more equitable educational tions. Academic historians debated the value of presentism opportunities and more cooperative forms of learning. Among while, educators debated the relative merit of functional and theorists, there is a resurgent concern about social reconstruc- non-functional scholarship. The 1930s represented a tion as an ideology of education with a vision and commit- watershed as the Depression created fertile ground for the ment to democratic principles and values. In addition, the functionalists in departments of education and progressive poststructural critique has renewed social reconstructionist historians with a sense of the present in the AHA (Appleby, efforts to dislodge formalism, objectivity, social Darwinism Hunt, & Jacob, 1994; Breisach, 1983; Cohen, 1976). The two and social efficiency as principle tenets of schooling (see traditions came together in the thirties for the common Stanley, 1992). purpose of outlining a reconstructed program for social An historiographic understanding of how sociocultural studies education in the schools (Bowers, 1969; Kliebard, change and the political context of schooling have influenced 1987). Yet their paths once again diverged.
    [Show full text]