Guided by the Inner Light: a Historiometric Study of Quaker Education in the State of New York
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
St. John's University St. John's Scholar Theses and Dissertations 2020 GUIDED BY THE INNER LIGHT: A HISTORIOMETRIC STUDY OF QUAKER EDUCATION IN THE STATE OF NEW YORK Joseph John Crotty Follow this and additional works at: https://scholar.stjohns.edu/theses_dissertations GUIDED BY THE INNER LIGHT: A HISTORIOMETRIC STUDY OF QUAKER EDUCATION IN THE STATE OF NEW YORK A dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of DOCTOR OF EDUCATION to the faculty of the DEPARTMENT OF ADMINISTRATIVE AND INSTRUCTIONAL LEADERSHIP of THE SCHOOL OF EDUCATION at ST. JOHN’S UNIVERSITY New York by Joseph John Crotty IV Submitted Date: ___________ Approved Date: ___________ _________________________ _________________________ Joseph John Crotty IV Seokhee Cho, Ph.D © Copyright by Joseph John Crotty IV 2020 All Rights Reserved ABSTRACT GUIDED BY THE INNER LIGHT: A HISTORIOMETRIC STUDY OF QUAKER EDUCATION IN THE STATE OF NEW YORK Joseph John Crotty IV The following historiometric analysis examined the historical experiences of Quaker educational institutions during the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. The researcher utilized artifacts (n = 34) related to Quaker education in New York State in order to ascertain to what extent Quaker testimonies, including integrity, community, simplicity, equality, and peace, were influenced by salient historical experiences, such as war, racial equality, and economic equality. The researcher utilized structural coding to facilitate the conveyance of qualitative data into quantitative data in order to measure statistical differences. MANOVA results examined the significance of the difference among artifacts with different levels of description. MANOVA results established significant differences for the historical experience of war in Quaker educational institutions 2 ([Pillai’s Trace = 1.226], F(15, 84) = 3.872, p < .000, = .409) and the historical experience of racial equality in Quaker educational institutions ([Pillai’s trace = 1.095], 2 F(15, 84) = 3.221, p < .000, = .365). Stepwise multiple regression analyses indicated that the historical experience of racial equality predicted 46.5% of the realization of the Quaker testimony of community at Quaker educational institutions (adjusted 푅2 = .514), 70.3% of the realization of the Quaker testimony of equality in Quaker educational institutions (adjusted 푅2 = .703), and 47.6% of the realization of the Quaker testimony of peace in Quaker educational institutions (adjusted 푅2 = .476). The study of historical experiences of Quaker educational institutions and subsequent realization of the Quaker testimonies contribute a myriad of critical discourses regarding the history of Quaker education, the practice of historiometric analysis in educational research, and most importantly, the development of a positive school culture. Through the experiences of war, and advocacy for racial and economic equality, Quaker educational institutions formulated responses and civic action based upon the Quaker testimonies of community, equality, and peace. Further studies should be carried out with a more viable sample size to validate the findings of the present study. For example, a researcher should conduct a historiometric study of Quaker schools in a particular region or country to gain a greater sample size, which would increase the statistical validity of the study. DEDICATION Dedicated to Joseph John Crotty III, Theresa Crotty, Angelica Crotty, Dr. Paul Van Wie, Dr. John Staudt, Dr. Joseph Coladonato, Clare Hayes, Liza Laurino-Siegel, Barbara Klein, Muriel Delabar, Kathleen Saville, Melissa Furino, and Jordan Salhoobi. ii TABLE OF CONTENTS Dedication: . ii List of Tables . v Chapter 1: Introduction . 1 Purpose of the Study . 7 Theoretical/Conceptual Framework . 9 Significance/Importance of the Study . 14 Research Questions . 16 Definition of Terms . 18 Chapter 2: Literature Review . 22 Theoretical Framework . 22 Review of Related Research . 28 Chapter 3: Methods & procedures . 43 Research Questions . 44 Research Design and Data Analysis . 46 Data Sources . .. 50 Instruments . 51 Procedures for Collecting and Analyzing Data . 52 Chapter 4: Results . 54 Results . 55 Chapter 5: Discussion . 88 Implications of Findings . 88 Relationship to Prior Research . 105 iii Limitations of the Study . 111 Recommendations for Future Research . 113 Recommendations for Future Practice . 114 Appendix A: IRB Certification . 116 Appendix B: Data Collection . 117 References . 274 iv LIST OF TABLES Table 1 Artifacts Collected for Historiometric Analysis . 50 Table 2.1 Descriptive Statistics for the Historical Experience of War . 55 Table 2.2 The Historical Experience of War and the Realization of the Quaker Testimony of Integrity . 57 Table 2.3 The Historical Experience of War and the Realization of the Quaker Testimony of Community . 58 Table 2.4 The Historical Experience of War and the Realization of the Quaker Testimony of Simplicity . 58 Table 2.5 The Historical Experience of War and the Realization of the Quaker Testimony of Equality . 59 Table 2.6 The Historical Experience of War and the Realization of the Quaker Testimony of Peace . 59 Table 2.7 Descriptive Statistics for Each Significant Dependent Variable by Historical Experience of War. 60 Table 2.8 One-Way Multivariate Analysis Summary for the Historical Experience of War. 62 Table 3.1 Descriptive Statistics for the Historical Experience of Racial Equality. 63 Table 3.2 The Historical Experience of Racial Equality and the Realization of the Quaker Testimony of Integrity . 65 Table 3.3 The Historical Experience of Racial Equality and the Realization of the Quaker Testimony of Community . 65 Table 3.4 The Historical Experience of Racial Equality and the Realization of the Quaker v Testimony of Simplicity . 66 Table 3.5 The Historical Experience of Racial Equality and the Realization of the Quaker Testimony of Equality . 66 Table 3.6 The Historical Experience of Racial Equality and the Realization of the Quaker Testimony of Peace . 67 Table 3.7 Descriptive Statistics for Each Significant Dependent Variable by Historical Experience of Racial Equality . 67 Table 3.8 One-Way Multivariate Analysis Summary for the Historical Experience of Racial Equality. 70 Table 4.1 Descriptive Statistics for the Historical Experience of Economic Equality . 71 Table 4.2 The Historical Experience of Economic Equality and the Realization of the Quaker Testimony of Integrity . 72 Table 4.3 The Historical Experience of Economic Equality and the Realization of the Quaker Testimony of Community . 74 Table 4.4 The Historical Experience of Economic Equality and the Realization of the Quaker Testimony of Simplicity . 74 Table 4.5 The Historical Experience of Economic Equality and the Realization of the Quaker Testimony of Equality . 74 Table 4.6 The Historical Experience of Economic Equality and the Realization of the Quaker Testimony of Peace . 75 Table 4.7 Descriptive Statistics for Each Significant Dependent Variable by Historical Experience of Economic Equality . 76 Table 4.8 One-Way Multivariate Analysis Summary for the Historical Experience of vi Economic Equality . 78 Table 5 Summary of Multiple Regression Analysis for Historical Experiences influencing the Quaker Testimony of Community . 82 Table 6 Summary of Multiple Regression Analysis for Historical Experiences influencing the Quaker Testimony of Equality . 85 Table 7 Summary of Multiple Regression Analysis for Historical Experiences influencing the Quaker Testimony of Peace . 87 vii CHAPTER 1 Introduction The Religious Society of Friends is a religious denomination that was founded in seventeenth-century England in the aftermath of the English Civil War. The Religious Society of Friends, also known as Quakers or Friends, was established in 1647 by an English shepherd and shoemaker named George Fox, who appealed to all individuals to yield to the Light of Christ and seek pureness within their hearts and intentions. The principle theological teachings of Quakerism emphasized that the Light of Christ was inherent within all individuals, which enabled them to experience “leadings” of conscience, which facilitated the development of ethical practices, known as “testimonies,” among followers, including integrity within speech and actions, simplicity in dress and lifestyle, class and gender equality, and pacifism, which would.