City and County of San Francisco Convention Facilities Department
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
City and County of San Francisco Convention Facilities Department Climate Action Plan Data year: Fiscal Year 2010‐2011 Climate Liaison: John Noguchi Date: March 31, 2012 1. Introduction 1 2. Departmental Profile 2 3. Departmental Carbon Footprint 3 4. Other Sustainable Practices 9 5. Community Wide Impact 11 1. INTRODUCTION In FY 10‐11, the Department’s total energy consumption, from electricity, natural gas, and steam, resulted in the emission of approximately 3,153.26 metric tons of carbon dioxide equivalent (CO2e). The total cost incurred by the department for energy use was $2,123,001.24. The Department’s GHG Emissions from Unleaded Gasoline was 389.3 gallons consumed, resulting in 3.43 metric tons of CO2. The cost incurred to the Department was $1,405.07. The Department also consumed 74.7 CNG which resulted in 0.46 metric tons of CO2. The cost incurred to the Department was $122.17. The Department’s overarching climate goals and implementation plan is to meet the Mayor’s challenge of reducing energy consumption in the City owned Moscone Center by 50%. The 2010 Energy Study identified savings of up to 41% with an undetermined additional savings that will be created by the retro commissioning project. In addition, the restroom renovation and potential cistern projects can save an estimated 2M gallons of water per year. The Department is also focused on education and cultural change for the occupants, managers and visitors at the Moscone Center. There are several initiative underway to drive these behavioral changes that will significantly reduce consumption at the facility. Our intent is to implement capital projects as well as no cost/low cost process changes that will dramatically shift the focus on energy efficiency at Moscone. The Moscone Center will continue to be a leading venue in sustainability and maintain an award winning history: 2009 US EPA Environmental Achievement Award for a sustainable building that protects the environment 2004 EPA/DOE Green power Award for on‐site generators 2001 Governor’s Environmental and Economic Leadership Award, State of California 2001 Wrap Award for outstanding achievement as a commercial recycler 2000 Wrap Award for outstanding achievement as a commercial recycler 1999 Wrap Award for outstanding achievement as a commercial recycler 1 City and County of San Francisco Convention Facilities Department Climate Action Plan Data year: Fiscal Year 2010‐2011 Climate Liaison: John Noguchi Date: March 31, 2012 2. DEPARTMENTAL PROFILE DEPARTMENT MISSION The Convention Facilities Department’s primary responsibilities include the overall management and operations of the Moscone Center as well as management of the allocation of public funding to the San Francisco Travel Association in its mission to promote San Francisco as a world class destination for conventions and visitors from around the world. In addition, the Director oversees the City Hall Events Department responsible for the marketing, sales and daily operations for all special events at City Hall. DEPARTMENT BUDGET At present, the Convention Facilities Department manages a total annual budget of approximately $71 million which includes operating costs of the Moscone Convention Center and the City Hall Special Events Department. Debt service on the Moscone Center is also included in this annual budget allocation, as well as utility costs for all Moscone Center facilities. NUMBER OF EMPLOYEES The Department has six full times employees. FACILITIES The Department occupies office space in the Moscone Convention Center, 747 Howard Street, 5th Floor, San Francisco, CA 94013. The Moscone Center covers more than 20 acres on three adjacent blocks. It features more than 2 million square feet of building area including over 700,000 square feet of exhibit space, up to 106 meeting rooms, and as many as three ballrooms, and nearly 123,000 of prefunction lobbies. The Department also occupies office space in San Francisco City Hall, 1 Dr. Carlton B. Goodlett Place, Room 495, San Francisco, CA 94102. A National Historical Landmark, San Francisco City Hall occupies two City blocks and contains over 5500,000 square feet of space which includes the executive and legislative bodies and a number of City departments, as well as public assembly spaces for government, community and special events. VEHICLES The Department maintains two service vehicles, a 2004 Chevrolet 2500 can used primarily for pick‐up and drop‐off of supplies and transporting equipment between buildings, as well as a 1997 Ford 450 light duty truck used for delivery of materials to recycling facilities and donated goods to charity. The van uses CNG, while the truck is gasoline powered. 2 City and County of San Francisco Convention Facilities Department Climate Action Plan Data year: Fiscal Year 2010‐2011 Climate Liaison: John Noguchi Date: March 31, 2012 DEPARTMENT CONTACT INFORMATION Lead Staff Member and Departmental Climate Liaison John T. Noguchi Director, Convention Facilities Department Moscone Center Administration 747 Howard Street, 5th Floor San Francisco, CA 94013 415‐974‐4027 (direct) 415‐978‐5913 (fax) [email protected] 3. DEPARTMENT CARBON FOOTPRINT The Department has reviewed the information contained in the Department’s Google Docs carbon footprint spreadsheet: the list of facilities and the list of vehicles are correct; the energy and fuel consumption data is complete. With the assistance of the Department of the Environment, these verification were made possible by key managers at the Moscone Center: the Chief Engineer reviewed all the financial data available on energy use and this matched with PUC data in the Google Doc; the Director of Finance provided complete water records that were used by the Department of the Environment to fill in the Google Doc; the Director of Purchasing provided financial and other data on fuel consumption. 3a. FACILITIES – ENERGY AND WATER USE & REDUCTION MEASURES FACILITIES VERIFICATION The list of facilities that is being used by the Department of the Environment to calculate the FY10‐11 departmental carbon footprint has been reviewed by the Department. One correction needs to be made to the list. The Bill Graham Civic Auditorium/Brooks Hall complex is now under the Real Estate Department. As such, this report reflects data only for Moscone Center South, Moscone Center North and Moscone Center West. FISCAL YEAR 2010‐2011 CARBON FOOTPRINT FROM CONSUMPTION OF ELECTRICITY, NATURAL GAS AND STEAM In FY10‐11, the Department’s total energy consumption from electricity, natural gas and steam resulted in the emission of approximately 3,153.26 metric tons of carbon dioxide equivalent (CO2e). The total cost incurred by the department for energy use was $2,123,001.24. The following is a breakdown by energy source: Electricity: The Department consumed 25,106,174 kilowatt hours (kWhs) of electricity which resulted in the emission of approximately 370.70 metric tons of CO2e. The annual cost of electricity incurred by the Department was $1,375,011.85. 3 City and County of San Francisco Convention Facilities Department Climate Action Plan Data year: Fiscal Year 2010‐2011 Climate Liaison: John Noguchi Date: March 31, 2012 Natural Gas: The Department consumed 20,742 therms of natural gas which resulted in the emission of approximately 110.34 metric tons of CO2e. The annual cost of natural gas incurred by the department was $19,158.31. Steam: The Department consumed 27,979,100 pounds of steam which resulted in the emission of approximately 2,672.22 metric tons of CO2e. The annual cost of steam incurred by the Department was $728,831.08. The tables below show the energy consumption, cost, and greenhouse gas emissions for the department as a whole for the Moscone Center. Annual CFD Energy Use ‐ Moscone Center Energy CO2E Consumption Cost (tonnes) Electricity (kWh) 25,106,174 $1,375,011.85 370.7000 NG (Therms) 20,742 $19,158.31 110.3400 Steam (Lbs) 27,979,100 $728,831.08 2,672.2200 Totals 53,106,016 $2,123,001.24 3,153.2600 ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CONSERVATION The Department has oversight of four energy efficiency retrofit projects at the Moscone Center: Combining Chiller Plants to a single chilled water loop Adding (71) VFDs Installing motion sensors in all meeting rooms Installing air curtains at (8) entry ways The Department is also managing these additional energy efficiency and conservation projects or measures: Moscone Center Energy Study – Phase III Deliverables: commissioned by the Tourism Improvement District (TID) in August of 2010. The project consists of four phases: o Phase i: an existing building and energy conditions assessment 4 City and County of San Francisco Convention Facilities Department Climate Action Plan Data year: Fiscal Year 2010‐2011 Climate Liaison: John Noguchi Date: March 31, 2012 o Phase II: conduct an Energy Efficiency workshop with experts in the field of energy efficiency, design and construction. 18 attendees participated from the industry and resulted in over 35 project ideas o Phase II: develop an eQuest whole building energy model and modeling each of the projects determined to be implementable o Phase IV: develop a cost estimate for each project and a financial analysis for the estimated payback period. Completion of the Energy Study occurred on 1/31/11 with a final report to the TID and SMG (the City’s contracted operator of the Moscone Center). Ongoing meetings are underway between the City and SFPUC regarding financing and implementation plans. PUC funding for Moscone Commissioning. The SFPUC has secured financing and a contractor to provide retro commissioning and new equipment commissioning of the Moscone Center. This project is currently being scoped and scheduled to align with the ongoing major renovation project. Real Time Data Monitoring Program: in conjunction with the Department of the Environment, a program is being developed and scoped to better assist the City and Moscone users with the ability to track energy usage by event at Moscone Center.