A Status Review of Gypsum Wild Buckwheat
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
A Status Review of Gypsum Wild Buckwheat New Mexico •- September 1993 Prepared for. Prepared by: U.5. Fish and Wildlife Service Paul J. Knight 3530 Pan American Highway, NE Marron Taschek Knight, Inc. Albuquerque, NM 87107 2615 Rio Rancho Blvd. Corrales, NM 87048 CONTENTS 1.0 INTRODUCTION. .. 1 1 .1 Background and History ............. .-................ 1 1.2 Research Approach and Data Acquisition. .. 1 2.0 DISTRIBUTION AND CURRENT STATUS OF POPULATION SITES .. 3 2.1 Distribution and Current Status of Population Sites . .. 3 2.2 Summary and Discussion of Distribution and Status of Populations. 11 3.0 DEMOGRAPHIC TRENDS ............................... 12 3. 1 General Overview . .. 12 3.2 Demography and Population Trends . .. 12 3.3 Summary and Discussion of Demographic Trends from Plots I, 2 & 3 . .. 22 4.0 POPULATION SIZE AND DENSITY ........................ 28 4.1 General Overview. .. 28 4.2 Summary and Discussion of Population Size and Density. .. 32 5.0 LAND OWNERSHIP, PATENTS, AND LAND CLAIMS. .. 34 5.1 General Overview ................................... 34 5.2 Summary and Discussion of Land Ownership of Gypsum Wild Buckwheat Populations .....................37 6.0 STATUS OF POTENTIAL THREATS TO GYPSUM WILD BUCKWHEAT FROM MINERAL EXPLORATION, CLAIMS, AND GAS LEASES . .. 40 6. 1 General Overview . .. 40 6.2 Mineral Deposits, Claims, Oil and Gas Leases . .. 40 6.3 Summary and Discussion of Mineral Deposits, Claims, Oil and Gas Leases ........................... 47 7.0 STATUS OF POTENTIAL THREATS TO GYPSUM WILD BUCKWHEAT BY CATTLE GRAZING, ORV USE, AND BRANTLEY RESERVOIR . .. 51 7. 1 General Overview . .5 1 7.2 Status of Cattle Grazing ...............................51 7.3 StatusofORVTraffic ................................ 52 7.4 Status of Brantley Reservoir . .53 7.5 Summary and Discussion of Potential Impacts and Threats of Grazing Pressure, ORV Traffic, and Brantley Reservoir ........ 54 8.0 CONCLUSIONS AND COMMENTS 1 FIGURES 1 Known Populations of Gypsum Wild Buckwheat . .. 2 2 Known Distribution of Gypsum Wild Buckwheat . .4 3 Estimated Occupied Habitat of Gypsum Wild Buckwheat . .5 4 Seven River Hills Population of Gypsum Wild Buckwheat ......... 6 5 Black River Population of Gypsum Wild Buckwheat ............. 8 6 Ben Slaughter Draw Population of Gypsum Wild Buckwheat . .10 6a Physiographic Distribution of Monitoring Plots at Seven River Hills. .13 7 Size Class in cm of Plot 1 1987, 1988, 1989, and 1993 . .15 8 Size Classes of Eriogonum gypsophilum Plot 1 1987 and 1993 . .16 9 Size Classes of Eriogonum gypsophilum Plot 2 1987-1993 . .18 10 Size Classes of Eriogonum gypsophilum Plot 2 1987 and 1993 . 19 11 Size Class of Eriogonum gypsophilum Plot 3 1987-1993 .........20 12 Size Class of Eriogonum gypsophilum Plot 3 1987 and 1993 ...... 21 13 Size Class of Plots 1, 2. and 3 1987-1993 . .23 14 Median Size Class Values 1987-1993 ......................24 15 Average Size Classes Plots 1.2, and 3 in 1987 and 1993 vs. Plot 4 .. 26 16 Total Number of Plants in Monitoring Plots 1987-1993 and Average Number of Plants Per Square Meter in Monitoring Plots 1987-1993 ..........................29 17 Habitat Categories Utilized in Calculating Population Size of Gypsum Wild Buckwheat at Seven Rivers Hills ............. 31 18 Estimated Population Size of Gypsum Wild Buckwheat ..........33 19 Land Status at the Seven Rivers Hills Gypsum Wild Buckwheat Population Site . .. 35 20 Land Status in the Ben Slaughter Draw Population of Gypsum Wild Buckwheat . .36 21 Black River Gypsum Wild Buckwheat Population Ownership Map ..38 22 Estimated Population Size and Land Ownership of Gypsum Wild Buckwheat. .39 23 Known Distribution of Gypsum Wild Buckwheat . .41 24 Chemical Analysis of Castille Formation Gypsum Yeso Hills ..... .43 25 Oil and Gas Leases at the Seven Rivers Hills Gypsum Wild Buckwheat Population Site . .45 26 Oil and Gas Leases at the Ben Slaughter Draw Population of Gypsum Wild Buckwheat . .46 27 Black River Gypsum Wild Buckwheat Population Oil and Gas Leases ..........................48 28 Oil and Gas Leases at Gypsum Wild Buckwheat Population Sites .. .50 29 Brantley Lake Floodpool Impact .........................55 30 Status of Gypsum Wild Buckwheat .......................59 Appendix A Mineral Claim Information Pocket Maps 1,2 and 3 ii 1.0 INTRODUCTION In the summer of 1993, the C.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) sponsored a study to evaluate the current status of Eriogonum gypsophilum (Gypsum wild buckwheat). The purpose of the study was to conduct a status survey of all known populations of gypsum wild buckwheat, and its scope included determination of the current status and distribution of the species, demographic trends, and an evaluation of the threats to the species. The study was conducted in southeast New Mexico in coordination with the Carlsbad Resource Area office of the Bureau of Land Management (BLM) and the New Mexico Energy, Minerals and Natural Resources Department. 1.1 Backeround and Historv Eriogonum gypsophilum was originally collected in 1909 and was first published by Wooton and Standley (1915). For nearly 70 years the plant was known from only the type locality at the Seven Rivers Hills, just north of Carlsbad, New Mexico (Figure 1). The gypsum wild buckwheat was listed by the USFWS as a threatened species on January 19, 1981. At that time the plant was still known only from the type locality at the Seven Rivers Hills. Critical habitat was designated for the species. The recovery plan stated that the plant was stable but was threatened by off-road-vehicle (ORV) use of the habitat, trampling or grazing by cattle, and the raised water level resulting from establishment of the nearby Brantley Reservoir. In 1987 two new population sites were reported for gypsum wild buckwheat. Both of these sites are located over 30 miles south of the Seven Rivers Hills, in the Yeso Hills of Eddy County, New Mexico. The northernmost of the sites is located along the Black River just south of Black River Village. The southern site is located in the drainage of Ben Slaughter Draw just north of the Texas border. Between 1988 and the present, all three population sites have been the subject of a number of studies and surveys which have contributed greatly to the body of knowledge of this species. 1.2 Research Approach and Data Acquisition This study began in July of 1993 with a review of all of the literature on gypsum wild buckwheat. The next phase of the study required the compilation of all available data on land use and potential development in the area. Data on land ownership, mineral claims, and oil and gas leases were acquired at the BLM Office in Santa Fe, N.M., the Carlsbad Resource Area office in Carlsbad, N.M., and the County Court House in Carlsbad. Data were also collected at the University of New Mexico Herbarium and from consultation with Dr. Richard Spellenberg (NMSU) and Robert Sivinski (New Mexico Department of Energy, Mineral and Natural Resources). Alex Sanders (a mining engineer with extensive knowledge of gypsum mining) and the BLM biologists in the Carlsbad Resource Area office were also consulted during this study. Field evaluations occurred in August and September of 1993. 1 New Mexico Seven Rivers Hill s Black F!iver Ben Slaughter o 50 Draw Miles I Figure 1. Known PopuJations of Gypsum Wild Buckwheat 2.0 DISTRIBUTION AND CURRENT STATUS OF POPULATION SITES 2.1 Distribution and Current Status of Population Sites Gypsum wild buckwheat is currently known from three locations in Eddy County, New Mexico (Figure 2). The first is in the Seven Rivers Hills, approximately 9 miles north of Carlsbad at T20S, R25E, S24 and T20S, R26E, S 19 (Map I-see rear pocket). The population here is estimated to cover approximately 109 acres (Figure 3). The second population site is located just south of Black River Village at T24S, R26E S35 and T25S, R26E, Sections 2 and 3 (Map 2). It contains the largest of the populations, estimated to cover approximately 288 acres (Figure 3). The last population is located in the drainages of Ben Slaughter Draw and Hay Hollow at T26S, R26E Sections 16,17,18 and T26S, R25E, Sections 24 and 25 (Map 3). It is the smallest of the populations, estimated to cover approximately 80 acres (Figure 3). Seven Rivers Hills The Seven Rivers Hills population is located on the lowlands, lower slopes, steep slopes, and hilltops of the eastern end of the Seven Rivers Hills (Figure 4, Map 3). Its estimated 109 acres of occupied habitat are distributed into two large, irregularly shaped segments, surrounded by a half dozen smaller isolated enclaves of plants. The Seven Rivers Hills is northernmost of the population sites and has the widest range of topographic and physiographic variation of any of the the sites where gypsum wild buckwheat occurs. The plants range from 3290 feet to approximately 3600 feet in elevation. They are distributed in several different habitats: on the lowland areas where gypsum material from the steep hillsides has eroded to form a bajada of unconsolidated gypsum, on the steeper hillsides (particularly in areas subjected to past erosion or disturbance), and on the tops of the hills (most abundant near the crest of the hill where the gypsum substrate has eroded to form a looser soil). The plants prefer areas where the gypsum bedrock has eroded, forming a looser, less rocky materiaL These sites are generally on flat lands or on gentle slopes, The rocky hillsides are the poorest habitats. The hard gypsum bedrock on many portions of the slopes does not afford sites for establishment of the plants. Gypsum wild buckwheat plants on steep slopes are generally restricted to either drainages or depressions or along trails where the gypsum bedrock has weathered to produce loose gypsum soiL The Seven Rivers Hills habitat occurs in Chihuahuan Desert. The areas surrounding the hills are dominated by creosote bush and occasionally mesquite.