DOCSLIB.ORG

(2015) Objective Aesthetic Values in Art. Phd Thesis, University Of

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
(2015) Objective Aesthetic Values in Art. Phd Thesis, University Of 1 OBJECTIVE AESTHETIC VALUES IN ART Ben McGorrigan, BSc, MA Thesis submitted to the University of Nottingham for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy JULY 2015 2 Abstract This dissertation defends an answer to the question: to what extent, if any, are aesthetic values in art objective? I defend what I call Moderate Aesthetic Objectivism, which can be summarised as follows. A work of art has a certain aesthetic value if and only if a human critic, in the circumstances ideal for the aesthetic experience of that work, would experience the work as having that aesthetic value. ‘Experience’ here is meant in a broad sense, encompassing imagination and understanding as well as perception. We should regard such a critic as someone who would detect the aesthetic value rather than make it the case that the work had that value. Experiencing a work as being aesthetically valuable in a certain way involves having an aesthetic experience which is itself valuable. Such an experience will be pleasurable, often in complex ways. Although critics in ideal circumstances for the aesthetic experience of a work detect aesthetic values rather than making it the case that the work has certain aesthetic values, the work only has those values because the resultant aesthetic experiences had by such critics are themselves valuable. The aesthetic values of a work are, however, realised by properties of the work which dispose it to cause such valuable aesthetic experiences for humans in the circumstances ideal for the aesthetic experience of the work. Those properties are what is aesthetically valuable in the work, and they are objective in the sense that their existence and character is independent of whether they are detected or responded to. This account therefore retains elements of both subjectivist and objectivist 3 approaches to aesthetic value. It can, I argue, make sense of our conflicting intuitions about the objectivity or subjectivity of aesthetic values in art. 4 Acknowledgments I am grateful to everyone who has helped me with this work directly or indirectly. Thanks are especially due to my parents for being as supportive as anyone could wish, my supervisor Greg Currie for being generous with his time and insight, and my partner Rachel for making me happy. I am also extremely grateful to fellow postgraduate students and staff (past and present) at the University of Nottingham Philosophy department; especially those who have provided me with written or verbal feedback or with whom I have enjoyed many debates and discussions. I have also learned much from visitors to the department, my undergraduate students, and my family and friends, all of whom have helped me develop this thesis in some way or another. I am also indebted to many of my former teachers and other role models. 5 Contents Preface ............................................................................................................... 8 1. Objectivity .................................................................................................... 12 1.1 Epistemic and Ontological Objectivity ........................................... 12 1.2 Art Works and their Properties ...................................................... 17 1.3 Aesthetic Objectivism .................................................................... 22 1.4 Cognitive Command ....................................................................... 35 2. Aesthetic Values in Art ................................................................................. 44 2.1 Art................................................................................................... 44 2.2 Aesthetic Values in Art ................................................................... 48 2.3 The Paradox of Taste ..................................................................... 53 2.4 Aesthetic Judgments ...................................................................... 62 2.5 Aesthetic Experience...................................................................... 68 3. Humean Response-Dependence .................................................................. 78 3.1 The Standard of Taste .................................................................... 78 3.2 Equally Valid Aesthetic Experiences .............................................. 84 3.3 The Real Problem ........................................................................... 93 3.4 Response-Dependence .................................................................. 98 3.5 Dispositionalism ........................................................................... 114 3.6 Anti-Dispositionalism ................................................................... 117 6 4. Aesthetic Value Empiricism ........................................................... 129 4.1 Aesthetic Value Empiricism ............................................. 130 4.2 The Heresy of the Separable Value .................................. 140 4.3 Aesthetic Experience........................................................ 149 4.4 The Non-Aesthetic Values of Aesthetic Experiences ....... 160 5. Relativism and Faultless Disagreements........................................ 175 5.1 Aesthetic Relativism ......................................................... 176 5.2 Aesthetic Sensibilities ...................................................... 178 5.3 Faultless Disagreements .................................................. 182 5.4 Cultural Variation ............................................................. 191 6. Aesthetic Scepticism ...................................................................... 201 6.1 Aesthetic Error Theory ..................................................... 201 6.2 Non-Cognitivism ............................................................... 205 7. Aesthetic Testimony ....................................................................... 219 7.1 Aesthetic Objectivism and Testimony ............................. 220 7.2 Transmission Testimony and Evidential Testimony ......... 221 7.3 Pessimism about Aesthetic Testimony ............................ 224 7.4 The Acquaintance Principle ............................................. 236 7.5 Optimism about Aesthetic Testimony ............................. 241 8. Conclusions .................................................................................... 255 7 8.1 The Paradox of Taste Revisited ........................................ 255 8.2 Aesthetic Values in Art ..................................................... 257 8.3 Humean Response-Dependence ..................................... 265 8.4 Anti-Objectivism............................................................... 269 8.5 Moderate Aesthetic Objectivism ..................................... 273 Bibliography ....................................................................................... 278 8 Preface This is a dissertation in Aesthetics, the branch of philosophy concerned with beauty, ugliness and related values such as elegance and garishness. This dissertation can be classed as primarily a work of Meta-Aesthetics: a division of Aesthetics which can be understood by analogy with Ethics. In Ethics, we have the following divisions: Applied Ethics is the philosophy of which actions are morally good, bad, better or worse in particular situations, for example in the ethics of abortion. Normative Ethics is the philosophy of what makes an action morally good, bad, better or worse, for example Consequentialism states that the consequences of actions are what determine their moral value. Meta-Ethics is the philosophy of Ethics, covering issues such as whether moral values exist, whether they are objective, and whether moral judgments are cognitive. Similarly, in Aesthetics we can identify the following three divisions: Applied Aesthetics is the philosophy of whether and to what extent particular objects are beautiful or ugly (or otherwise aesthetically valuable or disvaluable). Normative Aesthetics can be identified as the philosophy of what makes objects beautiful or ugly. Meta-aesthetics can be seen as the philosophy of Aesthetics, covering issues such as whether aesthetic values exist, whether they are objective, and whether aesthetic judgments are cognitive. 9 In this dissertation I am interested in what aesthetic values are and to what extent they are objective, and these are issues in Meta-Aesthetics but the answers I defend involve normative aesthetical claims about broadly what makes works of art aesthetically valuable. The dissertation is structured as follows: there are two introductory chapters; followed by two chapters in which I develop what I am calling Moderate Aesthetic Objectivism; followed by three chapters dealing with some of the main objections and challenges to the view; followed finally by a concluding chapter in which I summarise the claims I have made and the arguments for them. Chapter 1 introduces concepts of objectivity and Objectivism and the notion of cognitive command as an indication of objectivity and an explanation of convergence in judgment. Chapter 2 introduces concepts of art, aesthetic value, taste, and aesthetic value judgment. I present an apparent paradox involving conflicting intuitions about the objectivity or subjectivity of aesthetic values in art, and I introduce two major historical attempts to address this problem: David Hume’s ‘standard of taste’ and Immanuel Kant’s critique of ‘judgments of taste’. My own account is a development of certain aspects of each of these theories.1 Chapter
Load more

Recommended publications
  • The Role of Cultural Value in the Historical Sociology of Pierre Bourdieu Tony Bennett
    The Historical Universal: The Role of Cultural Value in the Historical Sociology of Pierre Bourdieu Tony Bennett The definitive version of this article is published in: Bennet, T. 2005, ‘The Historical Universal: The Role of Cultural Value in the Historical Sociology of Pierre Bourdieu’, The British Journal of Sociology, 56(1): 141-164. The definitive version of this article is published in: http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1468-4446.2005.00051.x/abstract (institutional or subscribed access may be required) The journal British Journal of Sociology is available online: http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/journal/10.1111/(ISSN)1468-4446 (institutional or subscribed access may be required) Copyright remains with the publisher, Blackwell Publishing. Disclaimer Please note that this is an electronic, pre-print version of this article produced by the Institute for Culture & Society, University of Western Sydney, in accordance with the requirements of the publisher. Whilst this version of the article incorporates refereed changes and has been accepted for publication, differences may exist between this and the final, published version. Citations should only be made from the published version. User Agreement Copyright of these pre-print articles are retained by the author. Users may download and/or print one copy of any article to facilitate their own study or non-commercial research. Wider circulation and distribution of the material and/or use of it in profit-making activities is prohibited. URLs to access this pre-print version can
    [Show full text]
  • The Work of Art in the Age of Digital Reproduction and Mediated Reality
    Ulla Karttunen The Work of Art in the Age of Digital Reproduction and Mediated Reality. The Work of Art in the Age of Digital Reproduction and Mediated Reality. Ethics and Aesthetics in the dream and cream world of every-extending publicity Ulla Karttunen * University of Eastern Finland Shift in publicities My focus is on the public, published, reproduced sides of reality – existing in the contemporary world is something more than immediate presence, it very often also means touching what is already mediated. Reality, as public and social, consists not only of persons, actions and social structures; it is also made up of images and words, reflections and reproductions. I shall call these reproduced parts of reality-mediated realities. * [email protected], [email protected] Art, Emotion and Value. 5th Mediterranean Congress of Aesthetics, 2011 479 Ulla Karttunen The Work of Art in the Age of Digital Reproduction and Mediated Reality. Art and science are traditional forms of reflecting and interpreting reality, but in today’s society there are also many forms of mediated reality that did not exist just a short while ago. Public realms of words and images have undergone enormous change, massive growth, and a kind of virtual urbanization. In spite of silent villages, consisting of prayer books, textual newspapers and religious imagery, we have today real publiCITIES: crowded centres and favelas consisting of advertisements, reality shows, magazines, lifestyle books, music videos, blogs and so on. This development has been made possible by various technical discoveries, inventions from photography and cinema to computers and digital reproduction. In the 19th century advertising, marketing, entertainment, celebrity culture and similar fields were either non-existent or minimal if we compare their coverage today.1 These areas are generally based on visual enjoyment, so aesthetics (with its visual orientation criticized in anti-ocularcentric2 philosophy) could have dealt with them.
    [Show full text]
  • Computational Media Aesthetics for Media
    COMPUTATIONAL MEDIA AESTHETICS FOR MEDIA SYNTHESIS XIANG YANGYANG (B.Sci., Fudan Univ.) A THESIS SUBMITTED FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY NUS GRADUATE SCHOOL FOR INTEGRATIVE SCIENCES AND ENGINEERING NATIONAL UNIVERSITY OF SINGAPORE 2013 ii DECLARATION I hereby declare that this thesis is my original work and it has been written by me in its entirety. I have duly acknowledged all the sources of information which have been used in the thesis. This thesis has also not been submitted for any degree in any university previously. XIANG YANGYANG January 2014 iii ACKNOWLEDGMENTS First and foremost, I would like to thank my supervisor Profes- sor Mohan Kankanhalli for his continuous support during my Ph.D study. His patience, enthusiasm, immense knowledge and guidance helped me throughout the research and writing of this thesis. I would like to thank my Thesis Advisory Committee members: Prof. Chua Tat-Seng, and Dr. Tan Ping for their insightful com- ments and questions. I also want to thank all the team members of the Multimedia Analysis and Synthesis Laboratory, without whom the thesis would not have been possible at all. Last but not the least, I would like to express my appreciation to my family. They have spiritually supported and encouraged me through the whole process. iv ABSTRACT Aesthetics is a branch of philosophy and is closely related to the nature of art. It is common to think of aesthetics as a systematic study of beauty, and one of its major concerns is the evaluation of beauty and ugliness. Applied media aesthetics deals with basic media elements, and aims to constitute formative evaluations as well as help create media products.
    [Show full text]
  • Paths from the Philosophy of Art to Everyday Aesthetics
    Paths from the Philosophy of Art to Everyday Aesthetics Edited by Oiva Kuisma, Sanna Lehtinen and Harri Mäcklin Paths from the Philosophy of Art to Everyday Aesthetics © 2019 Authors Cover and graphic design Kimmo Nurminen ISBN 978-952-94-1878-7 PATHS FROM THE PHILOSOPHY OF ART TO EVERYDAY AESTHETICS Eds. Oiva Kuisma, Sanna Lehtinen and Harri Mäcklin Published in Helsinki, Finland by the Finnish Society for Aesthetics, 2019 6 Contents 9 Oiva Kuisma, Sanna Lehtinen and Harri Mäcklin Introduction: From Baumgarten to Contemporary Aesthetics 19 Morten Kyndrup Were We Ever Modern? Art, Aesthetics, and the Everyday: Distinctions and Interdependences 41 Lars-Olof Åhlberg Everyday and Otherworldly Objects: Dantoesque Transfiguration 63 Markus Lammenranta How Art Teaches: A Lesson from Goodman 78 María José Alcaraz León Aesthetic Intimacy 101 Knut Ove Eliassen Quality Issues 112 Martta Heikkilä Work and Play – The Built Environments in Terry Gilliam’s Brazil 132 Kalle Puolakka Does Valery Gergiev Have an Everyday? 148 Francisca Pérez-Carreño The Aesthetic Value of the Unnoticed 167 Mateusz Salwa Everyday Green Aesthetics 180 Ossi Naukkarinen Feeling (With) Machines 201 Richard Shusterman Pleasure, Pain, and the Somaesthetics of Illness: A Question for Everyday Aesthetics 215 Epiloque: Jos de Mul These Boots Are Made for Talkin’. Some Reflections on Finnish Mobile Immobility 224 Index of Names 229 List of Contributors 7 OIVA KUISMA, SANNA LEHTINEN & HARRI MÄCKLIN INTRODUCTION: FROM BAUMGARTEN TO CONTEMPORARY AESTHETICS ontemporary philosopher-aestheticians
    [Show full text]
  • Applied Aesthetics
    1 UNIT 3 APPLIED AESTHETICS: WESTERN PERSPECTIVE Contents 3.0 Objectives 3.1 Introduction 3.2 World of Music/ Applied Aesthetics of Musicology 3.3 Applied Aesthetics in Mathematical Domains 3.4 Application of Aesthetics in Information Field 3.5 Applied Aesthetics related to Digital Art and a Host of varied fields 3.6 Application of Aesthetics in Other Fields 3.7 Let Us Sum Up 3.8 Further Readings and References 3.0 OBJECTIVES “Applied Aesthetics is the application of the branch of philosophy of aesthetics to cultural constructs” Applied aesthetics seems to derive a new shape, an enriched stature, thus aesthetics is made ever moving, ever growing by additions of some sort at each step. Invigorated in strength, enriched numerously with precious additions and constructs, it compares well with life itself, which according to the Veda is ‘gigantic’, Prano Virat, it is ever growing, ever flowing like a river or stream, without a break to look back, or to beat a retreat, it is not like a stagnated pool of water, which gives foul smell; it is refreshed each moment, it always gives fresh look of novelty, poise, patience. By applying aesthetics to various aspects of life and nature, it aims is to make it more suited to enlarge it into gigantic Bunyan tree of knowledge and also to make it an interdisciplinary and multi-dimensional branch of study. As above mentioned, it is a philosophy though some have called it ‘a science of beauty’. The question is, should it be treated as ‘philosophy’ or ‘science’ or both.
    [Show full text]
  • Aesthetic Theory
    Draft Introduction The concept of philosophical aesthetics has an antiquated quality, as does the con- cept of a system or that of morals. This feeling is in no way restricted to artistic praxis and the public indifference to aesthetic theory. Even in academic circles, essays relevant to aesthetics have for decades now noticeably diminished. This point is made in a recent dictionary of philosophy: "There is scarcely another philosophical discipline that rests on such flimsy presuppositions as does aesthet- ics. Like a weather vane it is 'blown about by every philosophical, cultural, and scientific gust; at one moment it is metaphysical and in the next empirical; now normative, then descriptive; now defined by artists, then by connoisseurs; one day art is supposedly the center of aesthetics and natural beauty merely preliminary, the next day art beauty is merely second-hand natural beauty.' Moritz Geiger's description of the dilemma of aesthetics has been true since the middle of the nineteenth century. There is a double reason for this pluralism of aesthetic theo- ries, which are often even left unfinished: It resides on the one hand in the funda- mental difficulty, indeed impossibility, of gaining general access to art by means of a system of philosophical categories, and on the other, in the fact that aesthetic statements have traditionally presupposed theories of knowledge. The problem- atic of theories of knowledge returns directly in aesthetics, because how aesthetics interprets its objects depends on the concept of the object held by the theory of knowledge. This traditional dependency, however, is defined by the subject matter itself and is already contained in the terminology."1 Although this well describes the situation, it does not sufficiently explain it; the other philosophical disciplines, including the theory of knowledge and logic, are no less controversial 332 DRAFT INTRODUCTION 333 and yet interest in them has not flagged to a similar extent.
    [Show full text]
  • Journal of Scottish Thought
    Journal of Scottish Thought Volume 10 Published by the Research Institute of Irish and Scottish Studies University of Aberdeen 2018 ISSN 1755 9928 Editor: Endre Szécsényi © The Contributors This volume of The Journal of Scottish Thought developed from a conference hosted by the Research Institute of Irish and Scottish Studies, University of Aberdeen. The Journal of Scottish Thought is a peer reviewed, open access journal published annually by the Research Institute of Irish and Scottish Studies at the University of Aberdeen. Correspondence should be addressed to The Journal of Scottish Thought, 19 College Bounds, University of Aberdeen, AB24 3UG. Printed and bound by CPI Group (UK) Ltd, Croydon, CR0 4YY. CONTENTS Editorial Note v Ronald W. Hepburn’s Agnosticism Mary Warnock 1 Is the Sacred Older than the Gods? Guy Bennett-Hunter 13 Religious Experience, Imagination and Interpretation: A Case Study Peter Cheyne 26 The Voice of Cordelian Ethics: Imagination and the Loss of Religion Michael McGhee 52 Aesthetic and Moral James Kirwan 69 Aesthetic Experience, Metaphysics and Subjectivity: Ronald W. Hepburn and ‘Nature-Mysticism’ David E. Cooper 90 Constructing the Aesthetics of Nature Cairns Craig 102 Ronald W. Hepburn on Wonder and the Education of Emotions and Subjectivity James MacAllister 123 Wonder and the Everyday: Hepburnian Considerations and Beyond Arto Haapala 139 Notes on Contributors 153 Editorial Note On 18–19 May 2018, a symposium was held in the Research Institute of Irish and Scottish Studies at the University of Aberdeen to commemorate the tenth anniversary of the death of Ronald W. Hepburn. The speakers of this event – Arnar Árnason, Guy Bennett-Hunter, Pauline von Bonsdorff, Isis Brook, David E.
    [Show full text]
  • A Beautiful Future for Aesthetics: Three Avenues of Progress
    A Beautiful Future for THE AMERICAN SOCIETY FOR AESTHETICS: Aesthetics: Three Avenues AN ASSOCIATION FOR AESTHETICS, CRITICISM, AND THEORY OF THE ARTS of Progress John Dyck VOLUME 37 NUMBER 1 SPRING 2017 CUNY—The Graduate Center What is the future of the ASA? Where is it going? Where should it be 1 A Beautiful Future for Aesthetics: Three going? I will make some suggestions about how the ASA can ensure Avenues of Progress, by John Dyck a healthy and beautiful future not only for itself as an organization, 4 Suggestions for the ASA: Creativity, but also for philosophical aesthetics and philosophy of art. I will Diversity, and Disciplinary Study, by outline three main opportunities. First, I will suggest fruitful new Sarah Gokhale directions of research within philosophical aesthetics. Second, I will show how the ASA can be fruitful within the academy at large, 6 News from the National Office encouraging interdisciplinary work in aesthetics. Finally, I will show how the ASA can spread its wings beyond the academy, engaging the 7 Conference Reports public regarding aesthetics. Pursuing any of these avenues helps to ensure a healthy future for the ASA and aesthetics. 8 Aesthetics News 9 Calls for Papers What do I mean by a ‘healthy future’ for the ASA? Mainly, I mean a well-populated future. This involves, first, number of members; the 12 Upcoming Events ASA will be well-populated if it has lots of members. But it also means diversity of membership. Sherri Irvin has recently shown that aes- Active Aestheticians 15 thetics has a diversity problem, in particular regarding publication.1 The ASA needs active members who identify as minorities in terms of their ethnic, gender, and sexual orientation, and ability status.
    [Show full text]
  • Xiv*—Making Sense of Relative Truth
    March 15, 2005 Time: 04:38pm MacFarlane.tex xiv*—making sense of relative truth by John MacFarlane abstract The goal of this paper is to make sense of relativism about truth. There are two key ideas. (1) To be a relativist about truth is to allow that a sentence or proposition might be assessment-sensitive: that is, its truth value might vary with the context of assessment as well as the context of use. (2) Making sense of relativism is a matter of understanding what it would be to commit oneself to the truth of an assessment-sensitive sentence or proposition. nalytic philosophers tend to regard relativism about truth A as hopelessly confused, easily refuted, and even a sign of deficient intellectual character. This attitude is not entirely unreasonable. Proponents of relativism have focused much more on motivating their doctrine than on making sense of it, or even stating clearly what it is to be a relativist about truth. But if relativists have underestimated the difficulties here, their opponents have overestimated them. It is possible to make good sense of relativism about truth—or so I hope to show. In the first part of this paper, I will try to say exactly how the relativist’s position should be stated. Relativism about truth, I will argue, is the view that truth (of sentences or propositions) is relative not just to contexts of use but also to contexts of assessment. The philosophical challenge is to explain what this talk of ‘truth relative to a context of assessment’ means. In the second part of the paper, I will meet this challenge—not by giving a definition (that is not how one should expect to illuminate fundamental concepts like truth), but by giving assessment- relative truth a role to play in a normative account of assertion.
    [Show full text]
  • Research CV David Davies I Academic History 1) Degrees
    Research CV David Davies I Academic History 1) Degrees Sought and Obtained: Ph.D. in Philosophy, University of Western Ontario (1987). M.A. in Philosophy, University of Manitoba (1979). B.A. in Politics, Philosophy, Economics, Oxford University (1970). 2) Theses and Dissertations: Ph.D. Dissertation (Western Ontario, 1987): The Infirmities of Externalism: Putnam and Dummett on the Realist Programme in Metaphysics and the Philosophy of Language. Supervisor: Prof. Robert Butts M.A. Thesis (Manitoba, 1979): The Aesthetic Relevance of Artistic Acts. Supervisor: Prof Michael Stack. (3) Areas of Interest and Specialisation: Areas of Current Research and Specialisation: Philosophy of Art (especially Ontology and Epistemology of Art; Phil. of Literature; Phil. of Film; Phil. of Photography; Phil. of the Visual Arts; Phil. of the Performing Arts; Phil. of Music); Metaphysics; Philosophy of Language; Philosophy of Mind. Other Areas of Interest and Competence: Philosophy of Science; Philosophy of Social Science; Philosophy of Cognitive Science; Ethics; Kant. II Publications Books and Monographs Philosophy of The Performing Arts (Oxford: Wiley Blackwell, 2011), in the series Foundations of the Philosophy of the Arts. Aesthetics and Literature (London: Continuum, 2007). Art as Performance (Oxford: Blackwell, 2004) [Chinese translation by Fong Jun (Nanjing: Jiangsu Meishu Chubanshe (Jiangsu Fine Arts Publishing House), 2008] Edited books Blade Runner, co-edited with Amy Coplan, edited collection of papers in the series ‘Philosophers on Film’, (London: Routledge, 2015). (Introduction, 1-30, co-authored with Amy Coplan.) The Thin Red Line, edited collection of papers in the series ‘Philosophers on Film’. (London: Routledge, August 2008). (‘Introduction’, 1-9) Contemporary Readings in the Philosophy of Literature, co-edited with Carl Matheson, (Toronto, April 2008).
    [Show full text]
  • Redalyc.Relativism: a Conceptual Analysis
    Eidos: Revista de Filosofía de la Universidad del Norte ISSN: 1692-8857 [email protected] Universidad del Norte Colombia Villa, Vittorio Relativism: A conceptual analysis Eidos: Revista de Filosofía de la Universidad del Norte, núm. 13, julio-diciembre, 2010, pp. 166-191 Universidad del Norte Barranquilla, Colombia Available in: http://www.redalyc.org/articulo.oa?id=85418392009 How to cite Complete issue Scientific Information System More information about this article Network of Scientific Journals from Latin America, the Caribbean, Spain and Portugal Journal's homepage in redalyc.org Non-profit academic project, developed under the open access initiative Relativism: A conceptual analysis Vittorio Villa resumen abstract En este trabajo primero trataré In this paper, first, I will try to de formular una definición conceptual give a conceptual definition of relati- de relativismo con el propósito de vism, with the aim of singling out identificar los elementos básicos the basic elements common to the comunes a las concepciones relati- most relevant relativist conceptions. vistas más relevantes. Calificaré de I will qualify as “relativistic” all con- “relativistas” todas las concepciones ceptions in which all or a relevant part en las que todos o una parte relevante of its criteria and beliefs necessarily de sus criterios y creencias dependen depend on a given context. Secondly, necesariamente de un contexto dado. I will deal with some critical obser- Luego trataré algunas observaciones vations against relativism. From críticas contra el relativismo. Desde this point of view, a problem arises este punto de vista, se genera un from the fact that many relativists problema del hecho de que muchos would like to have the chance of relativistas desearían poder expresar expressing some objective judgments.
    [Show full text]
  • Horror Movie Aesthetics
    HORROR MOVIE AESTHETICS: How color, time, space and sound elicit fear in an audience. Thesis Presented by Xiangyi Fu to The Department of Art + Design In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Fine Arts in Information Design and Visualization Northeastern University Boston, Massachusetts May, 2016 2 ABSTRACT Fear is one of the most basic and important human emotions. At very beginning of movie history in 1895, when the audience first saw the Lumieres Bothers’ The Arrival of a Train at La Ciotat Station on the big screen, almost the entire audience tried to escape from the theater. The image of the approaching train caused fear. To intensify feelings of fear in the audience, film artists use sound, lighting, timing, motion and other stylistic devices. Among the wide range of film genres, especially horror movies aim to trigger a physiological and psychological response of fear in the audience. Within the genre, horror films differ widely from each other based on their time period, sub-genre, and regional differences including religious and cultural motifs. There many different ways of investigating how horror movies accomplish to terrify and horrify an audience, for example, via an analysis of plots, characters, and dialogue. This thesis examines what constitutes the different cinematic styles of horror movies – color/ lighting, time/motion, spatial relationships, and sound – in different horror movies. The result of my research is presented in an interactive visualization of cinematic aesthetics that enables a cinematic student to explore the patterns of how those elements are applied on the screen and can ultimately trigger and influence an audience’s mood.
    [Show full text]