DOCSLIB.ORG

The Life and Work of Thomas LAYCOCK 1812-1876 Frederick

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text

Load more

The Life and Work of ThOMAS LAYCOCK 1812-1876 Frederick Ernest James University College London A thesis presented to the University of London in candidature for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy. 3 ABSTRACT Following an introduction giving the reasons for writing on Thomas Laycock, there are two chapters of personal biography making use of his unpublished personal Journal. An account is then given of his papers on hysteria and the thinking which led from hysteria to reflex brain function. Next a chapter is devoted to Laycock's writings on public health and his involvement with Edwin Chadwick in the preparation for the City of York of The Report on the state of Large Towns and Populous Districts. Laycock always had a special interest in medical psychology and extended reflex action to explain some of the phenomena of mental illness and memory. An account is also given of his various other writings related to psychiatry. He was aware that extending reflex function to the brain would result in various philosophical and theological problems and Laycock's opinions are given on these issues together with a brief account of his classical work Mind and Brain. Having a great interest in medical psychology, also being a lecturer at the York Medical School and later Professor of the Practice of Physic at Edinburgh, it was natural he should be a pioneer in the teaching of the subject. Many fascinating ideas are to be found in Laycock's writings on general medicine, especially his use of neurology to explain oedema and certain types of pulmonary disease. A trophic nervous system was thought to cause tissue pathology which was a reversion to a lower evolutionary type. In his last decade Laycock wrote consolidating many of his previous ideas but attempted to bring these into line with then current scientific advances. A selection of his unpublished writings is examined in the same chapter. 2 In his lifetime Laycock was not an influential person but he impressed a few of his more able students, several of whom were to become professionally distinguished. The careers of these are described. After some conclusions a bibliography, with notes. is provided of published and unpublished works used in this thesis. 3 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS It is a pleasure to acknowledge help received from many, without which this work would not have been possible. Dr Michael Barfoot has very generously shared with me his extensive knowledge of nineteenth century Edinburgh medical affairs, his wide knowledge of Thomas Laycock and has given encouragement to finalise this thesis. Dr. Kathleen Webb has provided much information relating to nineteenth century York and Dr Joyce Gaibraith details of Laycock's involvement with the York Medical Society. Dr Louise Yeoman of the National Library of Scotland has supplied ihotocopies of the correspondence between George Combe and Thomas Laycock together with related information. Joy Pitman, archivist to the Royal College of Physicians of Edinburgh, has supplied photocopies of manuscript material in the Thomas Laycock Collection at the College, a complete list of the collection and other information. Sue Gold has given great assistance in finding and maldng available relevant books and Sally Bragg has kindly facilitated various administrative arrangements. The Weilcome Trust kindly made a grant towards two visits to Edinburgh and many journeys to London. Finally my thanks are due to Professor W.F.Bynum who has guided my reading, supervised my studies and suffered my inept word processing in many earlier drafts. 4 CHAPTERS 1. Introduction Reasons for writing on Thomas Laycock: Structure of Thesis. 2. Biography, Earlier years Family background and school days: Profession and professional training: London visit and examinations: Medical students in Laycock's time: Qualifications: Radical Politics and Medicine: Appointment to York County Hospital: Laycock starts his medical writing: The Göttingen visit: Laycock's views on M.Ds: The York Medical Society: The York Dispensary: York Medical Schoc British Association for the Advancement of Science. 3. Biography, Later years A vacancy at the York County Hospital: The Edinburgh Appointment: A family disease: Anne Laycock' s death: Last days: Thomas Laycock's character and reputation. 4. Birth of a new concept. Laycock's Hysteria Papers: Observations on the hysteria papers: Mesmerism: Reflex function of the brain and the birth of neuropsychiatry: Laycock, George Combe and Phrenology: William Carpenter and Cerebral Reflexes: Other writers on Cerebral Reflexes. 5 5. Political Medicine Background of the public or State health movement of 1848: Thomas Laycock's association with public health: Public health and the City of York: Fevers: Epidemiology: The British Medical Association: Medical Act 1858. 6. Psychiatry Administrative Psychiatry: Forensic Psychiatry: Classification: Treatment: Memory and its organic defects: Religious insanity: Alcoholism: Statistics and insanity: The Unconscious. 7. Psychology, Philosophy, Religion and Ethics Psychology: Philosophy: Laycock examines the consequences of brain reflexes: Religion and Thomas Laycock: Ethics: Mind and Brain. 8. Thomas Laycock and Medical Education Apprenticeship and hospital bases training: Combined training in medicine and surgery: Lectures at York: Teaching at Edinburgh: Psychiatric Education: Laycock as a teacher: Laycock, the Medico Psychological Association: Training and education. 9. General Medicine. Proleptics or periodic illness: Medical textbooks: Pulmonary disease: Dropsies: Nervous dropsies of centric origin involving the trunk and limbs: Reflex dropsies involving the so called sympathies: Tissue pathology and therapeutics: Clinical (3astro- intestinal disease: Haematology: Dermatology: Scurvy: Laycock and Bennett. 6 10. The Last Decade and Unfinished Works. New thoughts in physiology: Can a body and mind relationship be investigated?: Laycock and Carpenter: Some unpublished writings. 11. Some Famous Students and Thomas Laycock's influence. John Hughlings Jackson: Sir David Ferrier: Sir James Crichton- Browne: Sir Thomas Clouston: Sir Jonathan Hutchinson: Sir Byrom Bramwell: Sir Thomas Lauder Brunton: Thomas William McDowall: John Mimer Fothergill: The sequelae to Thomas Laycock's ideas and works. 12. Conclusions Personal character: Public Health: Reflex Brain Function Neurology: General and Psychological Medicine: Medical Education: Thomas Laycock's influence. Bibliography. 7 CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION This is a biographical study of Thomas Laycock, physician, and examines his life and writings in the changing medical and social scene of the mid-nineteenth century. Reasons for writing on Laycock As a doctor he had an extraordinary career. Starting life as an apprentice in a small Yorkshire town, he rose, without wealth or patronage, to be Professor of Medicine in the University of Edinburgh. At the time Edinburgh was the premier clinical teaching school in the United Kingdom and Laycock's rise was a typical Samuel Smiles self help story, a story well worth telling in its own right. There can be few medical men of the period who wrote and contributed to such diverse fields of medical endeavour. Although not a topic for which he is widely known, Laycock was very active in the early days of public health, the City of York especially benefiting from his work. It was an issue on which he wrote and co-operated with that legendary figure of public health, Edwin Chadwick. Intimately related to public health is statistics and it was therefore appropriate that Laycock should publish on that subject and, at one time, be secretary of the Statistical Section of the British Association for the Advancement of Science. For Laycock public health embraced many matters of medical administration such as the registration of all medical practitioners and coroners' Courts. 8 The single most important work for 'hich Thomas Laycock is remembered is the extension of reflex action from the spinal cord to the cerebral hemispheres, thereby initiating the movement of medical psychology. Beveridge (1) writes: Laycock was the first to argue that a science of mental life was possible, that mind could be studied using the principles of medical psychology... .he sought to develop a scientific cerebral psychology which would unite philosophy and physiology. It is this which has led in recent years to a revival of interest in Laycock by those authors dealing with nineteenth century neurophysiological concepts (2 and 3). The development of reflex brain tfunction and unconscious cerebration had profound implications for philosophy and theology; implications which were not neglected by Laycock, for many of his writings relate to these matters. Controversies about the nature of the will, consciousness and the precise relationship between body, mind and spirit were to continue throughout Laycock's life, matters to which he gave considerable thought. Reflex brain function was used to explain many obscure phenomena, hysteria, mesmerism, somnambulism, dreaming and much of psychiatry especially hallucinations. Insanity was a subject in which Laycock had a special interest, not only in its theory and practice but in its teaching. He was well acquainted with the asylum situation, he promoted the interests of asylum medical officers, was an early member of the Medico- Psychological Association and eventually its President. As a lecturer at the York Medical School and then as Professor of Medicine at Edinburgh Laycock was a pioneer in psychiatric teaching to medical students.
Recommended publications
  • Stereotactic Neurosurgery in the United Kingdom: the Hundred Years from Horsley to Hariz

    Stereotactic Neurosurgery in the United Kingdom: the Hundred Years from Horsley to Hariz

    LEGACY STEREOTACTIC NEUROSURGERY IN THE UNITED KINGDOM: THE HUNDRED YEARS FROM HORSLEY TO HARIZ Erlick A.C. Pereira, M.A. THE HISTORY OF stereotactic neurosurgery in the United Kingdom of Great Britain Oxford Functional Neurosurgery, and Northern Ireland is reviewed. Horsley and Clarke’s primate stereotaxy at the turn Nuffield Department of Surgery, of the 20th century and events surrounding it are described, including Mussen’s devel- University of Oxford, and Department of Neurological Surgery, opment of a human version of the apparatus. Stereotactic surgery after the Second The John Radcliffe Hospital, World War is reviewed, with an emphasis on the pioneering work of Gillingham, Oxford, England Hitchcock, Knight, and Watkins and the contributions from Bennett, Gleave, Hughes, Johnson, McKissock, McCaul, and Dutton after the influences of Dott, Cairns, and Alexander L. Green, M.D. Jefferson. Forster’s introduction of gamma knife radiosurgery is summarized, as is the Oxford Functional Neurosurgery, Nuffield Department of Surgery, application of computed tomography by Hounsfield and Ambrose. Contemporary University of Oxford, and contributions to the present day from Bartlett, Richardson, Miles, Thomas, Gill, Aziz, Department of Neurological Surgery, Hariz, and others are summarized. The current status of British stereotactic neuro- The John Radcliffe Hospital, Oxford, England surgery is discussed. KEY WORDS: Atlas, Computed tomography, Functional neurosurgery, History, Radiosurgery, Stereotactic Dipankar Nandi, Ph.D. frame, Stereotactic neurosurgery Imperial College London, and Charing Cross Hospital, Neurosurgery 63:594–607, 2008 DOI: 10.1227/01.NEU.0000316854.29571.40 www.neurosurgery-online.com London, England Tipu Z. Aziz, M.D., D.M.Sc. Pigmaei gigantum humeris impositi Sir Victor Alexander Haden Horsley (1857– Oxford Functional Neurosurgery, plusquam ipsi gigantes vident 1916) (Fig.
  • Medical Society) ; Mr. JH Fisher (President Of

    Medical Society) ; Mr. JH Fisher (President Of

    143 was likened to some modest but learned dame of ROYAL SOCIETY OF MEDICINE : ancient lineage visiting the house of her illustrious grown-up daughter. ’l’he latter lived in a sumptuous REVIVAL OF THE ANNUAL DINNER. mansion and was dressed in gorgeous raiment, but, like many a titled lady of fashion, had sometimes a little in her dressmaker’s bills. She THE annual dinner of the of Medicine difficulty paying Royal Society was still unmarried, having not yet come across that was held on at the Hotel Victoria, Thursday, July 6th, wealthy philanthropic suitor, be he British or London, when Sir John Bland-Sutton, whose successful American, who would doubtless bring with him that of office as President is to a term drawing close, rich endowment which she so sore needed. But Mr. over a company of the Society and a presided large Berry ’hoped that such an one might be on his way Tepresentative list of guests. to her. of after the The first event the occasion, drinking Sir THOMAS HORDER proposed the toast of " The of the was the of the Jenner loyal toasts, presentation Guests" and Sir Alfred Mond with an excellent Medal to Dr. John C. McVail. This medal was supplied theme on which to frame a when he 1896 and is on the recommenda- reply suggested instituted in awarded that the of Health " to Section of and State Medicine Ministry ought get busy," tion of the Epidemiology the value of treat- of the to whose work has been despite acknowledged expectant Society " persons ment in serious cases.
  • The Politics of Medicine in Manchester, 1788-1792: Hospital Reform and Public Health Services in the Early Industrial City

    The Politics of Medicine in Manchester, 1788-1792: Hospital Reform and Public Health Services in the Early Industrial City

    Medical History, 1984, 28: 227-249 THE POLITICS OF MEDICINE IN MANCHESTER, 1788-1792: HOSPITAL REFORM AND PUBLIC HEALTH SERVICES IN THE EARLY INDUSTRIAL CITY by J. V. PICKSTONE and S. V. F. BUTLER* The affairs of the Infirmary and Lunatic Hospital continued till Michaelmas 1790 when a particular scrutiny was made into the Rules and Government of the Charities; and so many additions and altera- tions made in them that almost an entire New System was introduced. Six Physicians and Six Surgeons were then appointed to manage the whole business of their profession. Compleat Assistance was provided for the Poor in every Malady to which they are Subject and for which the Art of Man has yet found a remedy.' BY 1790, the Manchester Infirmary had existed for almost forty years. It had been founded in 1752, one of a series of voluntary hospitals which had spread across the provinces in the 1750s and 1760s.2 They were the central charities in increasingly prosperous towns, means by which leading citizens could demonstrate a collective responsibility for the poor, and arenas in which physicians and the better-qualified surgeons could establish a public presence and demonstrate their skills. In 1780, there was little to distinguish Manchester's Infirmary from those in many county towns, which were to continue little changed for a century or so. The Infirmary revolution of 1790 came about because Manchester had begun to change rapidly. The 1780s saw a large inflow of capitalists and labourers, and with them came professional men, including Scottish-trained physicians anxious to use their scientific training to create successful careers among the rising bourgeoisie.
  • The Concept of the Reflex in the Description of Behavior 321

    The Concept of the Reflex in the Description of Behavior 321

    THE CONCEPT OF THE REFLEX IN THE DESCRIPTION OF BEHAVIOR 321 The present paper was published in the Journal of General Psychology, I I 2 * s here the editor. ( 93 > 5' 4 7~45$) an^ reprinted by permission of INTRODUCTORY NOTE THE EXTENSION of the concept of the reflex to the description of the behavior of intact organisms is a common practice in modern theorizing. Nevertheless, we owe most of our knowledge of the reflex to investigators who have dealt only with "preparations," and who have never held themselves to be con- cerned with anything but a subsidiary function of the central nervous system. Doubtless, there is ample justification for the use of relatively simple systems in an early investigation. But it is true, nevertheless, that the concept of the reflex has not emerged unmarked by such a circumstance of its development. In its extension to the behavior of intact organisms, that is to say, the his- torical definition finds itself encumbered with what now appear to be super- fluous interpretations. The present paper examines the concept of the reflex and attempts to evaluate the historical definition. It undertakes eventually to frame an alterna- tive definition, which is not wholly in despite of the historical usage. The reader will recognize a method of criticism first formulated with respect to scientific Ernst Mach in The Science and concepts by [ of Mechanics} per- haps better stated by Henri Poincare. To the works of these men and to Bridgman's excellent application of the method [in The Logic of Modern Physics] the reader is referred for any discussion of the method qua method.
  • British Imperial Medicine in Late Nineteenth-Century China and The

    British Imperial Medicine in Late Nineteenth-Century China and The

    British Imperial Medicine in Late Nineteenth-Century China and the Early Career of Patrick Manson Shang-Jen Li Thesis submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy, Imperial College. University of London 1999 1 LIliL Abstract This thesis is a study of the early career of Patrick Manson (1844-4922) in the context of British Imperial medicine in late nineteenth-century China. Recently historians of colonial medicine have identified a distinct British approach to disease in the tropics. It is named Mansonian tropical medicine, after Sir Patrick Manson. He was the medical advisor to the Colonial Office and founded the London School of Tropical Medicine. His approach to tropical diseases, which targeted the insect vectors, played a significant role in the formulation of British medical policy in the colonies. This thesis investigates how Manson devised this approach. After the Second Opium War, the Chinese Imperial Maritime Customs was administered by British officers. From 1866 to 1883 Manson served as a Customs medical officer. In his study of elephantiasis in China, Manson discovered that this disease was caused by filarial worms and he developed the concept of an intermediate insect host. This initiated a new research orientation that led to the elucidation of the etiology of malaria, yellow fever, sleeping sickness and several other parasitological diseases. This thesis examines Manson's study of filariasis and argues that Manson derived his conceptual tools and research framework from philosophical natural history. It investigates Hanson's natural historical training in the University of Aberdeen where some of his teachers were closely associated with transcendental biology.
  • BIOLOGICAL SYSTEMATICS and EVOLUTIONARY THEORY By

    BIOLOGICAL SYSTEMATICS and EVOLUTIONARY THEORY By

    BIOLOGICAL SYSTEMATICS AND EVOLUTIONARY THEORY by Aleta Quinn BA, University of Maryland, 2005 BS, University of Maryland, 2005 Submitted to the Graduate Faculty of The Kenneth P. Dietrich School of Arts and Sciences in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy University of Pittsburgh 2015 UNIVERSITY OF PITTSBURGH KENNETH P. DIETRICH SCHOOL OF ARTS AND SCIENCES This dissertation was presented by Aleta Quinn It was defended on July 1, 2015 and approved by James Lennox, PhD, History & Philosophy of Science Sandra Mitchell, PhD, History & Philosophy of Science Kenneth Schaffner, PhD, History & Philosophy of Science Jeffrey Schwartz, PhD, Anthropology Dissertation Director: James Lennox, PhD, History & Philosophy of Science ii Copyright © by Aleta Quinn 2015 iii BIOLOGICAL SYSTEMATICS AND EVOLUTIONARY THEORY Aleta Quinn, PhD University of Pittsburgh, 2015 In this dissertation I examine the role of evolutionary theory in systematics (the science that discovers biodiversity). Following Darwin’s revolution, systematists have aimed to reconstruct the past. My dissertation analyzes common but mistaken assumptions about sciences that reconstruct the past by tracing the assumptions to J.S. Mill. Drawing on Mill’s contemporary, William Whewell, I critique Mill’s assumptions and develop an alternative and more complete account of systematic inference as inference to the best explanation. First, I analyze the inadequate view: that scientists use causal theories to hypothesize what past chains of events must have been, and then form hypotheses that identify segments of a network of events and causal transactions between events. This model assumes that scientists can identify events in the world by reference to neatly delineated properties, and that discovering causal laws is simply a matter of testing what regularities hold between events so delineated.
  • Arrested Development, New Forms Produced by Retrogression Were Neither Imperfect Nor Equivalent to a Stage in the Embryo’S Development

    Arrested Development, New Forms Produced by Retrogression Were Neither Imperfect Nor Equivalent to a Stage in the Embryo’S Development

    Retrogressive Development: Transcendental Anatomy and Teratology in Nineteenth- Century Britain Alan W.H. Bates University College London Abstract In 1855 the leading British transcendental anatomist Robert Knox proposed a theory of retrogressive development according to which the human embryo could give rise to ancestral types or races and the animal embryo to other species within the same family. Unlike monsters attributed to the older theory of arrested development, new forms produced by retrogression were neither imperfect nor equivalent to a stage in the embryo’s development. Instead, Knox postulated that embryos contained all possible specific forms in potentio. Retrogressive development could account for examples of atavism or racial throwbacks, and formed part of Knox’s theory of rapid (saltatory) species change. Knox’s evolutionary theorizing was soon eclipsed by the better presented and more socially acceptable Darwinian gradualism, but the concept of retrogressive development remained influential in anthropology and the social sciences, and Knox’s work can be seen as the scientific basis for theories of physical, mental and cultural degeneracy. Running Title: Retrogressive Development Key words: transcendentalism; embryology; evolution; Robert Knox Introduction – Recapitulation and teratogenesis The revolutionary fervor of late-eighteenth century Europe prompted a surge of interest in anatomy as a process rather than as a description of static nature. In embryology, preformation – the theory that the fully formed animal exists
  • THE WARRINGTON DISPENSARY LIBRARY* By

    THE WARRINGTON DISPENSARY LIBRARY* By

    THE WARRINGTON DISPENSARY LIBRARY* by R. GUEST-GORNALL What wild desire, what restless torments seize, The hapless man who feels the book-disease, If niggard fortune cramp his generous mind And Prudence quench the Spark of heaven assigned With wistful glance his aching eyes behold The Princeps-copy, clad in blue and gold, Where the tall Book-case, with partition thin Displays, yet guards, the tempting charms within. John Ferriar (1761-1815) THAT the thousand or more items comprising the Warrington Dispensary old library have been preserved intact is due to Sir William Osler, whose fame as a scholarly student of medical history is second only to his great repute as a clinical teacher, and also to the opportunity given him by his arrival in England in 1904 to take up his latest academic appointment as Regius Professor of Medicine at Oxford. If he was seized with a wild desire to possess the tempting charms of this unique collection it was because he wished to help to build up the library of the School of Medicine at Johns Hopkins which he had just left after fifteen years and which was still in its early days, having been founded in 1893; that no niggard fortune cramped this generous impulse was due to William A. Marburg who paid for them. In the words of Professor Singer, Osler was a true book lover to whom the very sight and touch of an ancient document brought a subtle pleasure, and he would quite understand what Ferriarl meant in the lines above; in fact he had an elegantly bound copy of the poem, printed in Warrington, which was given him with several other books from the same press by his friend Sir Walter Fletcher with the following note.
  • Lord Lister Ranks with That of Pasteur by Val- Coagulation

    Lord Lister Ranks with That of Pasteur by Val- Coagulation

    Book Revi ews Lord Lis te r . By Sir Rickman John Godlee, Bt., his graduation Lister went to Edinburgh for k .c .v .o ., m.s ., f .r .c .s . Ed. 3, revised and reset what was intended to be a short visit to the throughout. Oxford, at the Clarendon Press, clinics of that medical center. There he met Oxford University Press, Humphrey Milford, James Syme, then at the height of his brilliant 1924. career. The acquaintance ripened quickly into The biography of the founder of antiseptic the closest friendship. Lister stayed on to work surgery, by his nephew, Sir Rickman Godlee, with Syme, and in 1855 settled down to prac- has won the great success which was predicted tice in Edinburgh, and began his lectures on for it on its first publication in 1917. The present surgery there. In 1856 he married Syme’s is the third edition and presents but few addi- daughter and was elected assistant surgeon to tions or changes from those which have pre- the Edinburgh Infirmary. While actively engaged ceded it, a statement which should be regarded in clinical surgical work he still found time to as a tribute to the skill, fullness and accuracy work with his microscope and published some with which the work was originally written. papers showing the results of his investigations In English medical literature this biography of into the phenomena of inflammation and blood Lord Lister ranks with that of Pasteur by Val- coagulation. In i860 Lister received the appoint- lery Radot in French, and it is interesting that ment of regius professor of surgery in the two great men whose labors were so closely University of Glasgow, a great honor for so associated in their ultimate results should have young a man.
  • History of Psychiatry Special Interest Group Newsletter Issue 7, Autumn 2018 Eds

    History of Psychiatry Special Interest Group Newsletter Issue 7, Autumn 2018 Eds

    News and Notes History of Psychiatry Special Interest Group Newsletter Issue 7, Autumn 2018 Eds. Lydia Thurston and Claire Hilton News and Notes HoPSIG Issue 7, Autumn 2018 Contents Editorial: Lydia Thurston 1 Articles Sir Clifford Allbutt: physician, educator and Commissioner in Lunacy. 2 RHS Mindham Work as therapy: a reminder from the fields of Worcestershire. 4 David Jolley Thomas Laycock (1812-1876): Medicine, Mind and Mental Diseases. 5 Edward H Reynolds Memoirs Deepa Parry-Gupta 8 Hugh Jolly 10 Archives and artefacts College Archives Update. Francis Maunze 12 College crest: when and where and for what purpose? 13 In the College Archives … Bubble wrapped: Sigmund Freud and Julius Wagner- Jauregg. Claire Hilton 13 Book reviews The Dark Threads by Jean Davison, reviewed by RHS Mindham 15 Does History Make Sense? Hegel on the Historical Shapes of Justice by T Pinkard, reviewed by George Ikkos 16 Podcast Review A History of Psychiatry Podcast Series by Rab Houston, reviewed by Julian Laverty 19 Picture quizzes 21 Dates for your diary 21 Newsletter t itle | Division/Faculty | Date 1 Editorial Lydia Thurston, Co-editor Welcome to the Autumn 2018 edition of News Hilton also reveals two more treasures from and Notes . It’s been a busy summer for the archives in the form of portraits of Freud HoPSIG. In June we hosted a session at the and Wagner-Jauregg. RCPsych International Congress in This issue also contains a review of two Birmingham. Our speakers were Claire Hilton, podcasts chosen from an online series Helen Killaspy and Thomas Craig, all of whom produced by Rab Houston, Professor of presented talks encompassed by our session Modern History at the University of St title, ‘The myths of deinstitutionalisation’.
  • School of Education Science, Education and Social Vision of Five

    School of Education Science, Education and Social Vision of Five

    School of Education Science, Education and Social Vision of Five Nineteenth Century Headmasters David Theodore Bottomley This thesis is presented for the Degree of Doctor in Philosophy of Curtin University October 2018 DECLARATION ii ABSTRACT The study investigates how science was used by five nineteenth-century headmasters at a time when the Church of England fought to maintain its historical control of elementary education and its associated Grammar schools resisted attempts to include science in their elementary or secondary curricula; when long hours in mills precluded poor children from education; when class attitudes biased Government enquiries into education and industrial training. It was a time when belief in laissez- faire economics conflicted with the exercise of moral judgements. The headmasters viewed their students as individuals and sought to equip them with worldviews. Their curricula were inspired by their visions for society. They used science, scientific method and practical learning. They liberated subjects from traditional boundaries to provide students with comprehensive understanding of areas of knowledge. They emphasised student self-learning and provided the facilities for it. There were similarities in their radical objectives and methods. They effectively interacted with local communities. Their methods mostly did not survive their school tenures but offer challenging thoughts for science teaching today. Key words: Science education; social positioning; nineteenth century. iii DEDICATION I gratefully remember my parents’ deep contribution to my education. In loving memory of Mrs. Ellen Bottomley (née Foxcroft), 1881-1969 and Rev. William Bottomley, 1882-1966. iv PERSONAL INTEREST IN THIS RESEARCH This study connects me with my Lancashire and Yorkshire parents and grandparents.
  • Sir Charles Scott Sherrington (1857–1952)

    Sir Charles Scott Sherrington (1857–1952)

    GENERAL ARTICLE Sir Charles Scott Sherrington (1857–1952) Prasanna Venkhatesh V Twentieth century bore witness to remarkable scientists who have advanced our understanding of the brain. Among them, Sir Charles Scott Sherrington’s ideas about the way in which the central nervous system operates has continuing relevance even today. He received honorary doctorates from twenty- two universities and was honoured with the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine in the year 1932 along with Lord Prasanna Venkhatesh V is Edgar Adrian for their work on the functions of neurons. He currently a graduate developed our modern notion of the reflex as a model for how student at the Center for the periphery and spinal cord connect sensation and action. Neuroscience working with Prof. Aditya Murthy. He is “...To move things is all that mankind can do, for such the sole working on voluntary control of reaching and executant is muscle, whether in whispering a syllable or in felling pointing movements. His aforest.” research interests are –Sherrington neural basis of motor control and animal Sherrington had the genius to see the real need to amalgamate the behavior. scattered ideas in neurophysiology at that time, to give a compre- hensive overview that changed our perception of brain functions. In a career spanning almost sixty-five years, he published more than three hundred and twenty articles and a couple of noteworthy books. He was a man of admirable qualities and greatness, which is evident from the enviable number of articles, commentaries and books that have been written about his life, his approach to science and the world in general.