Acta Universitatis Upsaliensis Uppsala Studies In

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Acta Universitatis Upsaliensis Uppsala Studies In Acta Universitatis Upsaliensis Uppsala Studies in Media and Communication 15 The Performance of Participation in Russian Alternative Media Discourse, Materiality and Affect in Grassroots Media Production in Contemporary Russia Kirill Filimonov Dissertation presented at Uppsala University to be publicly examined in Lecture Hall 1, Ekonomikum, Kyrkogardsgatan̊ 10, Uppsala, Friday, 12 February 2021 at 13:15 for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy. The examination will be conducted in English. Faculty examiner: Prof. Dr. Bart Cammaerts (London School of Economics and Political Science). Abstract Filimonov, K. 2021. The Performance of Participation in Russian Alternative Media. Discourse, Materiality and Affect in Grassroots Media Production in Contemporary Russia. Uppsala Studies in Media and Communication 15. 200 pp. Uppsala: Acta Universitatis Upsaliensis. ISBN 978-91-513-1091-6. This doctoral dissertation analyzes participation in alternative media, taking the reader to the Russia of the late 2010s. Bringing together discourse theory, media and communication studies and political theory, it approaches participation in media production through the lens of performativity. The conceptualization of participation as a performance helps explore the material, embodied and spatial enactments of discourses that sustain the fragile and unstable process of production. The data of this study comprise several months of participant observations, interviews with media producers, and textual analysis of media content. The research employs a case-study method and focuses on media that explicitly delegate their participants the right to co-decide on matters of content production and internal organizing process. The three cases under study are Russia’s oldest anarchist medium Avtonom, the student medium DOXA, and the web-based zine Discours. Data analysis integrates qualitative content analysis and a discourse-theoretical approach, informed by Ernesto Laclau and Chantal Mouffe’s discourse theory alongside its subsequent developments within the Essex School. The study looks into the distribution of power in alternative media amidst an internal diversity, material constraints, and an antagonistic relationship with the state. The analysis constructs a model of participation, which shows its embeddedness into multiple and partially overlapping communities. A vibrant sociality and the potential for a further expansion of the media communities emerge as two of the key conditions of the participatory process. Furthermore, participation is supported by an ongoing performance of a multiplicity of identities, in which the more elitist articulations of journalism are intertwined with some empowering and counter- hegemonic notions of media production, media producers, and the audience. Retaining a critical-explanatory focus, the dissertation explores the limits of power-sharing, such as the persistence of journalistic professionalism, the scarce resources of the media and vulnerability inflicted by the state. The static representation of the state as the major confronting force reveals the paradoxical nature of social antagonism: while mobilizing the limited resources, it also reduces participatory intensities and triggers a politics of trust that restricts access to media production. This dissertation offers a number of theoretical and empirical contributions to several fields. Some of its key insights relate to participation beyond institutional politics, the hybridity of mainstream and alternative media, the interconnection of discourse, materiality and affect, and an empirical applicability of discourse theory. Keywords: discourse theory, performativity, participation, alternative media, journalism, state, materiality, affect Kirill Filimonov, Department of Informatics and Media, Kyrkogårdsg. 10, Uppsala University, SE-751 20 Uppsala, Sweden. © Kirill Filimonov 2021 ISSN 1651-4777 ISBN 978-91-513-1091-6 urn:nbn:se:uu:diva-427501 (http://urn.kb.se/resolve?urn=urn:nbn:se:uu:diva-427501) To my mother Irina and my sister Ilona Contents Chapter 1. Introduction ................................................................................. 15 1.1. Foreword and research questions ................................................ 15 1.2. Setting the scene: Key developments in Russia in the 21st century ................................................................................................ 18 1.2.1. Political developments ........................................................... 18 1.2.2. The state and the media .......................................................... 21 1.3. Case studies ................................................................................ 24 1.4. Disposition .................................................................................. 26 Chapter 2. Poststructuralism and discourse theory ....................................... 28 2.1. Embedding the study within social constructionism ......................... 28 2.2. Discourse studies and ontology ......................................................... 30 2.3. Poststructuralist approaches to discourse .......................................... 32 2.4. Discourse theory and its key concepts ............................................... 34 2.4.1. Discourse and articulation .......................................................... 34 2.4.2. Contingency and dislocation ...................................................... 35 2.4.3. The subject and its positions ...................................................... 37 2.4.4. Antagonism and constitutive outside ......................................... 38 2.4.5. Hegemony and war of position .................................................. 39 2.4.6. Towards the non-discursive in discourse theory ........................ 41 2.5. Performance as discursive-material bridge ........................................ 42 2.6. Affect, discourse and performativity ................................................. 45 2.7. Power ................................................................................................. 47 Chapter 3. Participation and its performances .............................................. 51 3.1. Defining participation through power ............................................... 51 3.2. Participatory intensities ..................................................................... 52 3.2.1. Representative models of democracy ........................................ 54 3.2.2. Maximalist-participatory models of democracy ........................ 55 3.2.3. Participation and democratic leadership .................................... 57 3.3. Participation as a performance .......................................................... 58 3.4. Participation and affect ...................................................................... 60 Chapter 4. Alternative media, journalism and the state ................................ 64 4.1. Alternative media and journalism ...................................................... 64 4.1.1. Hegemonic discourses on journalism ........................................ 66 4.1.2. Counter-hegemonic discourses on journalism ........................... 68 4.2. Alternative media and the state ......................................................... 74 4.2.1. Hegemonic discourses on the state ............................................ 75 4.2.2. Counter-hegemonic discourses on the state ............................... 76 Chapter 5. Methodology, method and research design ................................. 79 5.1. Research methodology ...................................................................... 79 5.1.1. Situating the study in the qualitative research paradigm ........... 79 5.1.2. Discourse theory as a qualitative methodology ......................... 80 5.1.3. Case study .................................................................................. 82 5.1.4. Ethnographic participant observations ....................................... 83 5.1.5. Interviews ................................................................................... 84 5.1.6. Qualitative content analysis ....................................................... 85 5.2. Research design and ethics ................................................................ 86 5.2.1. Data collection ........................................................................... 86 5.2.2. Application of DTA ................................................................... 90 5.2.3. The coding process .................................................................... 91 5.2.4. Ethical considerations ................................................................ 92 5.2.5. Positionality ............................................................................... 93 5.2.6. Research quality, validity and reliability ................................... 93 5.2.7. Limitations of the method .......................................................... 95 Chapter 6. Configuring participation: Subject positions in alternative media production ........................................................................................... 97 6.1. Multiplicity of subject positions ........................................................ 98 6.2. Articulations and performances of professional journalism in alternative media practice ....................................................................... 100 6.2.1. Articulations of professional journalistic discourse ................. 100 6.2.2. Enactments of journalistic
Recommended publications
  • February 5, 2021 AMS and ICM 20221 the Next International Congress Of
    February 5, 2021 AMS and ICM 20221 The next International Congress of Mathematicians is scheduled to take place in Saint Petersburg, Russia in July 2022. The upcoming ICM represents unique challenges for the American Mathematical Society in terms of its commitments to upholding fundamental human rights, promoting free, open, tolerant and demo- cratic society as well as ensuring free exchange of scientific information and free scientific collaborations across borders and cultures. For the last twenty years Rus- sia labored under the increasingly oppressive and authoritarian regime of Vladimir Putin. Internal opposition has been suppressed and effectively purged from political representation. The government controls most of mass media and, increasingly, the internet as well. Opposition leaders, such as Alexei Navalny, have been subjected to persecution, murder and assassination attempts by government agents, both at home and abroad. The state exercises increasingly repressive and discriminatory anti-LGBT policies, including the infamous 2013 \gay propaganda" law. The case of Azat Miftakhov exemplifies Russia's human rights problems. Mif- takhov, a mathematics PhD student at the Moscow State University, was arrested in February 2019 in Moscow on a putative vandalism charge related to a political protest action. The only physical damage during that protest was a broken window. Miftakhov, who pleaded not guilty to the charges, was held in pretrial confinement for almost two years and subjected to significant mistreatment and possible torture by the authorities. Numerous mathematical and scientific organizations, including the AMS, and other groups of academics, both internationally and within Rus- sia, spoke in support of Miftakhov. Nevertheless, on January 18, 2021 a court in Moscow found Miftakhov guilty of hooliganism and handed him a grossly excessive sentence of six years in prison.
    [Show full text]
  • Researching Academic Freedom Researching Researching Academic Freedom
    UNIVERSITY PRESS International human rights law protects the freedom indispensable for scientific research – a prerequisite for innovation and the pursuit of knowledge. However, empirical research on the protection and violation of academic freedom remains scarce. This volume seeks to fill that gap by introducing case study guidelines as well as four sample case studies in which the authors applied these guidelines in their research on academic freedom in Brazil, Egypt, Ireland, and Russia. The book also includes an inventory of available data sources on academic freedom, providing guidance on how to utilize and contextualize these data in country- level assessments. The research guidelines and case studies presented here are the result of an international, collaborative endeavor. Collectively, the authors seek to promote systematic, comparable research on academic freedom, while also fostering a community of scholars committed to developing this nascent field of interdisciplinary human rights research. FAU Studien zu Menschenrechten 5 Katrin Kinzelbach (Hrsg.) Researching Academic Freedom Researching Researching Academic Freedom Guidelines and Sample Case Studies ISBN 978-3-96147-369-4 FAU UNIVERSITY PRESS 2020 FAU Katrin Kinzelbach (Hrsg.) Researching Academic Freedom Guidelines and Sample Case Studies FAU Studien zu Menschenrechten Band 5 Herausgegeben vom Centre for Human Rights Erlangen-Nürnberg – Interdisziplinäres Zentrum der FAU (CHREN) Katrin Kinzelbach (Hrsg.) Researching Academic Freedom Guidelines and Sample Case Studies Erlangen FAU University Press 2020 Bibliografische Information der Deutschen Nationalbibliothek: Die Deutsche Nationalbibliothek verzeichnet diese Publikation in der Deutschen Nationalbibliografie; detaillierte bibliografische Daten sind im Internet über http://dnb.d-nb.de abrufbar. Bitte zitieren als Kinzelbach, Katrin (Hrsg.). 2020. Researching Academic Freedom.
    [Show full text]
  • Political Repression and Political Prisoners in Russia 2018–2019
    Political Repression and Political Prisoners in Russia 2018–2019 Memorial Human Rights Centre Programme for the Support of Political Prisoners. 2020 Contents 1. Introduction. Politically motivated prosecutions and political prisoners: methods, criteria and statistics . 6 1.1. The term ‘political prisoner’ as used by Memorial Human Rights Centre. 6 1.2. Statistics of the Memorial Human Rights Centre . 11 1.3. Victims of politically motivated prosecution ������������������������������������������������ 13 1.4. Rights violated by politically motivated prosecution ���������������������������������� 18 1.5. Articles of the Criminal Code as instruments of politically motivated prosecution . 20 1.6. Other approaches to the concept of ‘political prisoners’ . 25 2. Targets of politically motivated prosecution ������������������������������������������������������������ 28 2.1. The definition of a target of politically motivated prosecution. Classification of prosecutions in terms of targets . 28 2.2. Groups prosecuted as part of the political repressions in the years 2018-2019 . 29 2.2.1 Political prisoners (not prosecuted on account of their religion) and their subgroups . 29 Politicians and political activists ����������������������������������������������������������������������������� 29 Participants in public protests �������������������������������������������������������������������������������� 30 Human rights defenders and lawyers ����������������������������������������������������������������������� 31 Journalists ��������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������
    [Show full text]
  • Société Mathématique De Tunisie Newsletter Juin 2021
    SOCIÉTÉ MATHÉMATIQUE DE TUNISIE NEWSLETTER JUIN 2021 Ce bulletin est aussi disponible sur http://www.tms.rnu.tn Pour contribuer une information ou une annonce, prière envoyer votre texte à: [email protected] Nouvelles Notifications Nouveau Numéro du journal "Tunisian Journal of Mathematics TJM ": Vol. 3, No. 3, 2021 est disponible sur le site du journal: https://msp.org/tunis/2021/3-3/index.xhtml Abonnement gratuit à deux revues de l'Institut Henri Poincaré dans les pays en voie de déve- loppement : L'Institut Henri Poincaré à Paris propose des abonnements gratuits pour au moins cinq ans à ses deux revues Annales IHP C (Analyse non linéaire - analyse non linéaire), Annales IHP D (Combinatoire, Physique et leurs interactions), aux bibliothèques des pays en dé- veloppement. A partir de 2022, ces deux revues seront publiées par EMS Press sous le modèle Subscribe to Open: https://ems.press/subscribe-to-open L'appel à candidatures est ouvert jusqu'au 15 octobre 2021 et les candidatures doivent se faire sur le site web https://sondages.ihp.fr/index.php/698883 The Adhering Organizations of the International Mathematical Union (IMU) : This is a follow- up of to Circular Letter 1/2021 inviting your nominations for President and Secretary General of the IMU for the next term 2023–2026. The Nominating Committee (CL 26/2020), chaired by Wendelin Werner, unanimously proposes IMU President: Hiraku Nakajima, Japan IMU Secretary General: Christoph Sorger, France The election will take place at the 19th IMU General Assembly on 3–4 July 2022 in Saint Petersburg,
    [Show full text]
  • An Open Letter in Support of Azat Miftakhov, a Mathematician
    An open letter in support of Azat Miftakhov, a mathematician Multiple sources confirm that on February 1, 2019 Azat Miftakhov, a graduate student of the Moscow State University Faculty of Mechanics and Mathematics, was detained on suspicion of manufacturing explosives. He was tortured by the police and the Federal Security Service | according to another detainee Daniil Galkin, by the time he got a hold of Azat, he \didn't look like a human being" anymore. The police used torture to force a testimony out of Miftakhov. Security forces are concealing his location from his lawyer Svetlana Sidorkina; she hasn't been able to contact him for the time being. According to the lawyer and other detainees, Azat may have tried to cut his veins as a result. Detailed information on this case is given by the Russian media such as Meduza (http: //alturl.com/nq53k) and OVD-Info (http://alturl.com/ycuai). Azat Miftakhov has just started his mathematical career: his first mathematical paper On weak convergence of finite-dimensional and infinite-dimensional distributions of random processes was published in 2016. We, the representatives of the mathematical community and ones in solidarity with them, are extremely concerned about the current situation. We demand to know the location and health status of Azat immediately, and that he is granted access to his lawyer. We also demand instantaneous cessation of torture of Miftakhov and other detainees, as well as a transparent and fair trial. Update: Azat Mivtakhov has been found in the Balashikha police station in Moscow. The investigator claims he was arrested at 19:10 on February, 2.
    [Show full text]
  • Societe Mathematique De Tunisie Newsletter Avril 2021
    SOCIETE MATHEMATIQUE DE TUNISIE NEWSLETTER AVRIL 2021 Ce bulletin est aussi disponible sur http://www.tms.rnu.tn Pour contribuer une information ou une annonce, prière envoyer votre texte à: [email protected] Nouvelles Notifications Appel à candidature au « Prix jeune chercheur » 2021: L'Académie Tunisienne des Sciences, des Lettres et des Arts Beït al-Hikma annonce le lancement de la troisième session du « Prix jeune chercheur » dans chacun des domaines des Sciences mathématiques, physiques et naturelles, des Sciences humaines et sociales, des Lettres, des Arts et des Études islamiques. Le dernier délai pour le dépôt des candidatures est fixé au 30 avril 2021 Le règlement et les conditions d'attribution du Prix sont disponibles sur le site web de l’Académie: www.beitalhikma.tn Un monde meilleur pour les mathématiciens : Une contribution à la Journée internationale des mathématiques (IDM 2021), dimanche 14 mars 2021, dont le thème est Mathématiques pour un monde meilleur. Comme toutes les entreprises humaines, les mathématiques s’épanouissent mieux dans un environnement libre, ouvert et tolérant qui favorise le libre échange d’information scientifique et des collaborations libres par-delà les frontières et les cultures. Malheureusement, de nombreux collègues n’ont pas droit à de telles conditions, et certains d’entre eux sont privés d’une manière ou d’une autre de leurs libertés et de leurs droits fondamentaux. Le cas d’Azat Miftakhov illustre les problèmes des droits humains en Russie. Miftakhov, un docto- rant en mathématiques à l’université d’état de Moscou, a été arrêté en février 2019 à Moscou sur de prétendues charges de vandalisme, liées à un acte de protestation politique.
    [Show full text]
  • Letters to the Editor
    LETTERS TO THE EDITOR AMS and ICM 2022 gained particular attention of mathematicians around the The next International Congress of Mathematicians is world. scheduled to take place in Saint Petersburg, Russia in July All these issues raise the question of how the AMS and 2022. The upcoming ICM represents unique challenges for the US mathematical community should respond to the the American Mathematical Society in terms of its commit- upcoming ICM 2022. There have already been public calls ments to upholding fundamental human rights, promot- for a boycott of the ICM. Personally, I hope that a boycott ing free, open, tolerant and democratic society as well as will not become necessary. However, an open discussion of ensuring free exchange of scientific information and free the matter in the AMS is certainly needed. In my view, the scientific collaborations across borders and cultures. For situation cannot be treated as a logistical issue but rather should be approached primarily as a question of values the last twenty years Russia labored under the increasingly and principles. oppressive and authoritarian regime of Vladimir Putin. In a January 2021 letter to the International Science Internal opposition has been suppressed and effectively Council, the Executive Committee of the International purged from political representation. The government Mathematical Union wrote: “The IMU rejects all boycotts controls most mass media and, increasingly, the internet of scientific events (as does the ISC) and all attempts to as well. Opposition leaders, such as Alexei Navalny, have link scientific activities to political and societal issues.” I been subjected to persecution, murder and assassination believe the AMS cannot adopt such an absolutist approach.
    [Show full text]
  • Prisoners of Conscience 2021
    #FreeThemAll PRISONERS OF CONSCIENCE Political Prisoners from East and Southeast Europe ANALYSIS Imprint Publisher Friedrich Naumann Foundation for Freedom Regional Office for East and Southeast Europe Tsar Kaloyan Street No 8, Floor 5 1000 Sofia, Bulgaria Contacts Phone + 359 2 969 60 10 Email [email protected] 2021 Contents 1. MARFA RABKOVA, BELARUS 4 2. NEDIM TÜRFENT, TURKEY 5 3. OSMAN KAVALA, TURKEY 6 4. YURY DMITRIEV, RUSSIA 7 5. AZAT MIFTAKHOV, RUSSIA 8 6. ZARIFA SAUTIEVA, RUSSIA (INGUSHETIA) 9 7. EMIR-HUSSEIN KUKU, UKRAINE 10 8. POLAD ASLANOV, AZERBAIJAN 11 9. ELCHIN ISMAYILLI, AZERBAIJAN 12 #FreeThemAll 4. PROFILES OF PRISONERS OF CONSCIENCE MARFA RABKOVA BELARUS n September 17, officers from the Interior Ministry were predominantly peaceful. Some people are now missing, Odetained a Belarusian human rights advocate, Marfa others have been found dead. Rabkova, and her husband. Later, officers searched their home in Belarus’ capital, Minsk, and confiscated some In October, Amnesty International expressed concern about personal property, including their laptops and cell phones. the criminal persecution of Rabkova and called for her immediate release. In the meantime, Viasna announced that A week later, Rabkova was charged with planning to incite other members of the organization had also been detained. riots, an accusation which both Belarusian and international human rights advocates see as unjust and fabricated. If “Marfa Rabkova has committed no crime and there are no convicted, she faces up to three years in jail. grounds for her prosecution,” reads the statement. “Her arrest, detention, and prosecution are retaliation for her Rabkova coordinates the Volunteer Service of Viasna, a human rights work, and constitute a major breach of Belarus’ Minsk-based human rights organization which also monitors obligations under international human rights law.” elections and protests.
    [Show full text]