1 February 3, 2011 Ms. Lynn Boettger Regulatory Officer Mackenzie
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Engineering Department, 4 Capital Drive, Hay River, NT X0E 1G2 Phone: 867-874-5279 February 3, 2011 Ms. Lynn Boettger Regulatory Officer Mackenzie Valley Land and Water Board 7th Floor, 4910 – 50th Ave. P.O. Box 2130 Yellowknife, NT X1A 2P6 Email: [email protected] Dear Ms. Boettger: Re: MV2009X0040 & MV2009L4-0004 – Public Hearing Presentations – Northwest Territories Power Corporation Type A Water Licence and Land Use Permit The Northwest Territories Power Corporation (“NTPC”) has prepared its public hearing presentations, in accordance with the revised workplan distributed by the Mackenzie Valley Land and Water Board. The following documents are attached to this cover letter, as discussed at the Pre-Hearing Conference on January 31, 2011: 1. Resumes of the Hearing participants: NTPC continues to review the specific issues and presentation from the intervenors in order to determine the appropriate representatives to appear at the hearing. The specific individuals attending the hearing on behalf of NTPC will be identified and introduced at the opening of the hearing. Resumes are provided in the attached for key personnel on various aspects of the project: Daniel Roberts – Director Engineering, NTPC Damian Panayi – Wildlife Biologist, Golder Associates Ltd. Patrick Bowman – Principal and Consultant, InterGroup Consultants Ltd. 1 Chris Grapel – Principal Specialist, EBA Lara Reggin – Senior Geologist, Project Director, EBA 2. Hearing Presentation: A copy of the presentation NTPC intends to speak to at the start of the hearing is attached. 3. Summary of Environmental Management Plans: As part of the hearing record, a substantial number of environmental management plans affecting various aspects of the project have been filed. To aid participants in reviewing the substantial hearing record on these matters, NTPC has prepared an index (with hyperlinks) to the various plans that have been filed. 4. Index to NTPC Reply to Interventions: As discussed during the pre-hearing conference, NTPC hereby attaches a summary of the intervenor recommendations received and NTPC’s responses. This document is intended as an index to the information filed January 28, 2011. 5. Bluefish Lease Area Map: To assist parties in understanding the land tenure, and the effect of the existing lease on the requested approvals in the Land Use Permit and Water Licence, NTPC has provided an updated map showing the boundaries of the lease. If you have any questions regarding the attached please feel free to contact me at (867) 874-5283 or by email at [email protected]. Daniel Roberts Project Manager Northwest Territories Power Corporation Cc: Distribution List 2 MV2009L4-0004 and MV2009X0040 Type A Land Use Permit and Water License Applications Bluefish Dam Replacement Project – Summary of Environmental Management Plans This document summarizes all plans that NTPC has adopted to address environmental aspects of the Bluefish project. The plans in many cases reflect multiple rounds of revision through the Mackenzie Valley Land and Water Board (“MVLWB”) review process, incorporating comments from intervenors and Board staff. Documents in some cases reflect normal and longstanding NTPC practice and policy (e.g., spill reporting) and in other cases are specific to the Bluefish project. Each of the plans noted below have been adopted by NTPC for this project. Absent further revisions arising from consensus at the MVLWB hearing, NTPC commits to follow the terms and practices of the plans as filed and will similarly direct its contractor on the project to similarly follow suit. For clarity, the terms of the below noted plans will govern all activities on the project, whether occurring pursuant to the proposed Type A Water Licence, the proposed Type A Land Use Permit, or the existing Lease. 1. Abandonment and Restoration Plan (draft) http://www.mvlwb.ca/mv/Registry/2009/MV2009X0040/Plans/MV2009X0040%20‐ %20Draft%20Abandonment%20and%20Restoration%20Plan%20‐%20Oct01‐10.pdf o Submitted: October 15, 2010 o Summary: This Plan provides information on the steps and procedures that will be taken to close and abandon the Bluefish Hydro facility should: ¾ NTPC no longer require the facility, nor wish to maintain it on care and maintenance; and ¾ no other organization agrees to assume responsibility for operation of the hydro power facility. 2. Aquatic Monitoring Plan (draft) (http://www.mvlwb.ca/mv/Registry/2009/MV2009X0040/Public%20Hearings/MV2009X0040%20- %20NTPC%20Response%20to%20Interventions%20-%20Part%201%20of%204%20-%20Jan28- 11.pdf) o Submitted: January 28, 2011 o Summary: This Plan describes monitoring of suspended sediment downstream of construction, water quality monitoring, and rescue of stranded fish during isolation of the construction site. Northwest Territories Bluefish Dam Replacement Project Page 1 Power Corporation Summary of Environmental Management Plan 3. Decommissioning Plan for the Existing Bluefish Dam (http://www.mvlwb.ca/mv/Registry/2009/MV2009L4- 0004/app/addl_info_Oct15/Decommissioning%20Plan%20for%20Old%20Bluefish%20Dam.pdf) o Submitted: October 15, 2010 o Summary: provides a conceptual description of the sequence of decommissioning activities and schedule for closure of the old Bluefish dam. 4. Emergency Preparedness Plan (draft update to existing plan) (http://www.mvlwb.ca/mv/Registry/2009/MV2009L4- 0004/app/addl_info_Oct15/Emergency%20Preparedness%20Plan.pdf) o Submitted: October 15, 2010 o Summary: this document covers pre-emergency planning, emergency response, training and practice, in the event of an emergency or infrastructure failure at Bluefish Hydroelectric Facility. 5. Hazardous Materials Management Plan (http://www.mvlwb.ca/mv/Registry/2009/MV2009L4- 0004/app/addl_info_Oct15/Hazardous%20Materials%20Management%20Plan.pdf) o Submitted: October 15, 2010 o Summary: the purpose of this Plan is to provide a consolidated source of information on the safe and environmental sound transportation, storage, and handling of the major hazardous products used at the Bluefish Hydroelectric Facility. The Plan is specific to the Bluefish Hydroelectric Facility and is intended to supplement the NTPC Hazardous Waste Management Plan which addresses hazardous waste transport and disposal. 6. Incinerator General Operational Plan (http://www.mvlwb.ca/mv/Registry/2009/MV2009L4- 0004/Public%20Hearings/MV2009L4-0004%20- %20NTPC%20Response%20to%20Information%20Requests%20-%20Jan06-11.pdf) o Submitted: January 7, 2011 o Summary: the Plan is intended to provide general guidance on environmental practice for the use of the Bluefish camp solid waste incinerator, including maintenance, monitoring and reporting. 7. Sediment and Erosion Management Plan (draft) (http://www.mvlwb.ca/mv/Registry/2009/MV2009L4-0004/Plans/MV2009L4-0004%20- %20Sedument%20and%20Erosion%20Management%20Plan%20-%20Jan13-11.pdf) o Submitted: January 13, 2011 o Summary: the Plan proposes actions and structures to control sediment and erosion during construction of the new dam and spillway at Bluefish Hydro. Northwest Territories Bluefish Dam Replacement Project Page 2 Power Corporation Summary of Environmental Management Plan 8. Spill Contingency Plan (http://www.mvlwb.ca/mv/Registry/2009/MV2009X0040/Public%20Hearings/MV2009X0040%20- %20NTPC%20Response%20to %20Interventions%20-%20Part%202%20of%204%20-%20Jan28- 11.pdf) o Submitted: January 28, 2011 o Summary: this Plan outlines measures to prevent spills of hazardous materials, and responses and reporting procedures in the event of a spill at Bluefish Hydro. 9. Waste Management Plan (http://www.mvlwb.ca/mv/Registry/2009/MV2009X0040/Plans/MV2009L4-0004%20- %20Waste%20Management%20Plan%20-%20Aug%2009.pdf) o Submitted: September 14, 2009 o Summary: outlines waste management goals, prevention/reduction planning, communication, monitoring, storage, transport and disposal of waste produced at Bluefish Hydro. 10. Hazardous Waste Management Plan (http://www.mvlwb.ca/mv/Registry/2009/MV2009X0040/Plans/MV2009L4-0004%20- %20Waste%20Management%20Plan%20-%20Aug%2009.pdf) o Submitted: September 14, 2009 o Summary: This Plan provides a guide for storing, transporting and disposal of hazardous wastes produced at NTPC operations. 11. Wastewater Management Plan (draft) (http://www.mvlwb.ca/mv/Registry/2009/MV2009X0040/Public%20Hearings/MV2009X0040%20- %20NTPC%20Response%20to%20Interventions%20-%20Part%201%20of%204%20-%20Jan28- 11.pdf) o Submitted: January 28, 2011 o Summary: This Plan outlines wastewater management at the Bluefish camp during construction. The two sources of wastewater will be the construction camp, and washwater from the concrete plant. The Plan includes details of wastewater storage, testing, decanting, and reporting. Northwest Territories Bluefish Dam Replacement Project Page 3 Power Corporation Summary of Environmental Management Plan Northwest Territories Bluefish Dam Replacement Project Page 4 Power Corporation Summary of Environmental Management Plan Index to NTPC Reply to Interventions (Jan 28, 2011) Recommendation Response Page DFO 1. Minimum flow criteria downstream of the new dam to the inlet of Prosperous Lake should be incorporated into the water licence for the Issues exist with flow data prepared to date; recommend be left to be 16‐17 operation of the dam. Absolute minimum flow is recommended as 1.0 m3/s. Monthly minimum flows are recommended to equal those addressed with DFO, once corrected data available provided by Hayco (2009). DFO 2. A variable flow hydrograph within and between years maintaining the current practice of routinely