DOCSLIB.ORG

The Lancelot-Gawain Parallel in Malory's Le Morte

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
The Lancelot-Gawain Parallel in Malory's Le Morte THE LANCELOT-GAWAIN PARALLEL IN MALORY’S LE MORTE DARTHUR by DANIELLE RENEE TAYLOR Thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the Degree of Master of Arts (English) Acadia University Fall Graduation 2013 © by DANIELLE RENEE TAYLOR, 2013 This thesis by Danielle Renee Taylor was defended successfully in an oral examination on August 29th, 2013. The examining committee for the thesis was: ________________________ Dr. Michael Stokesbury, Chair ________________________ Dr. Kathy Cawsey, External Reader ________________________ Dr. Patricia Rigg, Internal Reader ________________________ Dr. Kevin Whetter, Supervisor _________________________ Dr. John Eustace, Head of Department I, Danielle Renee Taylor, grant permission to the University Librarian at Acadia University to reproduce, loan or distribute copies of my thesis in microform, paper or electronic formats on a non-profit basis. I, however, retain the copyright in my thesis. ______________________________ Author ______________________________ Supervisor ______________________________ Date Table of Contents Abstract v Note on quotations vi Acknowledgements vii Introduction 1 Chapter One: Background and Sources 6 Chapter Two: Establishing the Parallel 38 Chapter Three: Culmination of the Parallel 72 Conclusion 108 Bibliography 111 iv Abstract This thesis is an exploration of a parallel between Sir Lancelot and Sir Gawain found within Sir Thomas Malory’s Le Morte Darthur which has been previously overlooked in Malorian scholarship. The Lancelot-Gawain parallel runs through the entirety of Malory’s narrative, and is an important element in both his thematic structure and his characterization of both knights. By comparing and constrasting Lancelot with Gawain, Malory is able to emphasize Lancelot as the protagonist of his narrative and presents him as a flawed, but still noble knight. The thesis begins with an exploration of Malory’s sources, and some of the changes he has made in regards to Lancelot and Gawain. An in-depth study of the the early tales outlines the creation and ongoing construction of this parallel. The early examples create a model for the extensive and elaborate parallel found in the Sankgreall Quest and the fall of the Round Table. This parallel offers new insights into Malory’s characterization of Gawain and Lancelot, as well as his conception of knighthood. v Note on Quotations All quotations from Le Morte Darthur are taken from The Works of Sir Thomas Malory, ed. Eugène Vinaver, 3rd ed., rev. P. J. C. Field, 3 vols. (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1990). In quoting Malory, I do not reproduce Vinaver’s various emendation brackets. vi Acknowledgements I would first like to thank my family, especially my parents, Kirk and Sandra Taylor. Their unconditional love and support has given me the confidence and the opportunity to pursue my passion for English literature. In addition to my family I would like to thank my friends for always supporting and believing in me. I would especially like to thank my supervisor, Dr. Kevin Whetter for his help and guidance throughout the year. Working with Dr. Whetter has been a truly rewarding experience and his expertise and encouragement have helped me throughout this process. I am also grateful to the numerous professors who I have had the pleasure of working with this year. This includes Dr. Patricia Rigg in particular, for agreeing to be my internal reader. Her comments and suggestions were incredibly informative and helpful. I would also like to thank the Department Secretary, Christine Kendrick, for all of her help. vii Introduction Sir Thomas Malory’s Le Morte Darthur is one of the most widely known Arthurian texts, and has enjoyed both a popular and an academic following. As one of the main characters in this narrative, Gawain has been a source of contention for scholars of Arthurian literature. Seen often as an inconsistent character, Malory’s Gawain has not yet been fully examined for his role in the overall structure of the narrative. At times, Gawain is honoured as a great knight, while at other times he experiences great failures in his adventures. He also displays both positive and negative characteristics. Often, the different Gawains have been considered simply a result of the varying portrayals of this character found in Malory’s sources. However, Malory was very deliberate in his portrayal of Gawain, and the so-called “inconsistencies” between the “good” and the “bad” Gawain are choices that Malory has made that affect the overall structure of the narrative. In particular, and throughout Le Morte Darthur, Malory uses the various attributes of Gawain in parallel with Lancelot. The latter is Malory’s protagonist, but this does not make Gawain the antagonist. Rather, Malory uses the character of Gawain continuously to help establish and maintain Lancelot in this position by maintaining Gawain as a good, but flawed knight who is not developed in complete contrast with Lancelot but rather in parallel. The parallel between both knights is used in order to either raise Lancelot’s status, such as when he outshines Gawain as a knight, or to mitigate any of Lancelot’s failings by having them pale in comparison to Gawain’s faults. Through both of these knights, Malory shows a consistent interest in the way in which his characters must try to uphold the ideals of knighthood, and the difficulties of always 1 performing well on each adventure. It is this Lancelot-Gawain parallel that I outline within my thesis. In my thesis, I use the term parallel to refer to an ongoing connection Malory creates between Lancelot and Gawain. This parallel exists in a number of forms. In some instances, there is a direct comparison between both knights. In other instances, the parallel explores a specific and deliberate constrast between Lancelot and Gawain. In all instances, Lancelot and Gawain are in parallel positions as prominent knights. While both Lancelot and Gawain are key figures in Malory’s narrative, there has yet to be an in-depth study of the parallel between them within the text of Le Morte Darthur. This study offers a new way to explore the characterization of both knights. Gawain is not simply a bad knight to Lancelot’s good knight, nor is he a character without positive attributes. Many of these positive attributes are overlooked when Gawain is studied only in opposition to Lancelot. By exploring the characters in parallel throughout the narrative, and not just their literary heritage, it is evident that there are similiarites as well as differences between the two knights. Beverly Kennedy is the one scholar who comes closest to the type of study I propose, with her work Knighthood in the Morte Darthur. Kennedy compares these two knights as epitomes of “True” knighthood (Lancelot), and “Heroic” knighthood (Gawain). In comparing them, Kennedy examines key passages and events in Malory’s text which I also examine. However, a number of Kennedy’s interpretations do not appear to have enough textual evidence to support the assumptions she makes, and her categories of knighthood are not presented as equal in terms of their worthiness. It is more than evident that in her opinion, the Heroic Knight represents an older type of knighthood based more upon family loyalty. For Kennedy, that type of knighthood is not as honourable as the True or Worshipful 2 categories. By identifying Gawain as a Heroic Knight, Kennedy highlights his negative qualities while overlooking many of the positive attributes which are evident when he is studied in parallel to, and not in contrast with, Lancelot. Beyond the fact that I disagree with some of her conclusions, Kennedy differs from my study, as she uses Lancelot and Gawain to compare and contrast her categories of knighthood while I look specifically at how Malory uses Gawain in order to promote Lancelot as a successful knight in terms of military prowess and courtly behaviour. In addition to Kennedy, there are some critics who have studied Lancelot and Gawain in comparison in terms of Malory’s alterations to his sources. P. J. C. Field, Robert H. Wilson, and Ralph Norris are all examples of scholars who give examples of Malory’s tendancy to transfer positive actions or speeches associated with Gawain to Lancelot. However, these scholars do not go beyond source study, and do not examine the overall parallel between the knights that exists throughout Le Morte Darthur. As a result, they overlook the literary consequences of theses alterations. No one has given meaningful attention to the overall parallel and the ways in which it functions within the narrative. As such, the characterization of Gawain is understudied or misinterpreted. He exists not as an antagonist or in mere opposition to Lancelot. Gawain’s characterization is very deliberate, and he has a number of quailities which Malory highlights which are worthy of further study. In the first chapter of this thesis, “Background and Sources,” I outline Malory’s use of his sources. This chapter not only highlights Malory’s changes to his sources, but it also highlights the emphasis on parallels that exist in Le Morte Darthur and other Arthurian texts. In addition, Malory’s alterations from his sources in his creation of a 3 parallel between Gawain and Lancelot indicate a level of artistry which is not always afforded to him by modern scholars. In Chapter Two, “Establishing the Parallel,” I explain how Malory first creates the parallel between Lancelot and Gawain early in his narrative. I then highlight the various elements in the first five tales of Le Morte Darthur which help to extend the parallel and explain how Malory establishes the link between Lancelot and Gawain. The parallel gives insight into the characterization of both knights, as Malory humanizes both knights, having them struggle through their understandings of knighthood and facing both success and failure in their journeys.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Queen Guinevere
    Ingvarsdóttir 1 Hugvísindasvið Queen Guinevere: A queen through time B.A. Thesis Marie Helga Ingvarsdóttir June 2011 Ingvarsdóttir 2 Háskóli Íslands Hugvísindasvið Enskudeild Queen Guinevere: A queen through time B.A. Thesis Marie Helga Ingvarsdóttir Kt.: 060389-3309 Supervisor: Ingibjörg Ágústsdóttir June 2011 Ingvarsdóttir 3 Abstract This essay is an attempt to recollect and analyze the character of Queen Guinevere in Arthurian literature and movies through time. The sources involved here are Welsh and other Celtic tradition, Latin texts, French romances and other works from the twelfth and thirteenth centuries, Malory’s and Tennyson’s representation of the Queen, and finally Guinevere in the twentieth century in Bradley’s and Miles’s novels as well as in movies. The main sources in the first three chapters are of European origins; however, there is a focus on French and British works. There is a lack of study of German sources, which could bring different insights into the character of Guinevere. The purpose of this essay is to analyze the evolution of Queen Guinevere and to point out that through the works of Malory and Tennyson, she has been misrepresented and there is more to her than her adulterous relation with Lancelot. This essay is exclusively focused on Queen Guinevere and her analysis involves other characters like Arthur, Lancelot, Merlin, Enide, and more. First the Queen is only represented as Arthur’s unfaithful wife, and her abduction is narrated. We have here the basis of her character. Chrétien de Troyes develops this basic character into a woman of important values about love and chivalry.
    [Show full text]
  • Echoes of Legend: Magic As the Bridge Between a Pagan Past And
    Winthrop University Digital Commons @ Winthrop University Graduate Theses The Graduate School 5-2018 Echoes of Legend: Magic as the Bridge Between a Pagan Past and a Christian Future in Sir Thomas Malory's Le Morte Darthur Josh Mangle Winthrop University, joshmangle94@gmail.com Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.winthrop.edu/graduatetheses Part of the Literature in English, British Isles Commons Recommended Citation Mangle, Josh, "Echoes of Legend: Magic as the Bridge Between a Pagan Past and a Christian Future in Sir Thomas Malory's Le Morte Darthur" (2018). Graduate Theses. 84. https://digitalcommons.winthrop.edu/graduatetheses/84 This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the The Graduate School at Digital Commons @ Winthrop University. It has been accepted for inclusion in Graduate Theses by an authorized administrator of Digital Commons @ Winthrop University. For more information, please contact bramed@winthrop.edu. ECHOES OF LEGEND: MAGIC AS THE BRIDGE BETWEEN A PAGAN PAST AND A CHRISTIAN FUTURE IN SIR THOMAS MALORY’S LE MORTE DARTHUR A Thesis Presented to the Faculty Of the College of Arts and Sciences In Partial Fulfillment Of the Requirements for the Degree Of Master of Arts In English Winthrop University May 2018 By Josh Mangle ii Abstract Sir Thomas Malory’s Le Morte Darthur is a text that tells the story of King Arthur and his Knights of the Round Table. Malory wrote this tale by synthesizing various Arthurian sources, the most important of which being the Post-Vulgate cycle. Malory’s work features a division between the Christian realm of Camelot and the pagan forces trying to destroy it.
    [Show full text]
  • Summary of the Perlesvaus Or the High History of the Grail (Probably First Decade of 13Th Century, Certainly Before 1225, Author Unknown)
    Summary of the Perlesvaus or The High History of the Grail (probably first decade of 13th century, certainly before 1225, author unknown). Survives in 3 manuscripts, 2 partial copies, and one early print edition Percival starts out as the young adventurous knight who did not fulfill his destiny of achieving the Holy Grail because he failed to ask the Fisher King the question that would heal him, events related in Chrétien's work. The author soon digresses into the adventures of knights like Lancelot and Gawain, many of which have no analogue in other Arthurian literature. Often events and depictions of characters in the Perlesvaus differ greatly from other versions of the story. For instance, while later literature depicts Loholt as a good knight and illegitimate son of King Arthur, in Perlesvaus he is apparently the legitimate son of Arthur and Guinevere, and he is slain treacherously by Arthur's seneschal Kay, who is elsewhere portrayed as a boor and a braggart but always as Arthur's loyal servant (and often, foster brother. Kay is jealous when Loholt kills a giant, so he murders him to take the credit. This backfires when Loholt's head is sent to Arthur's court in a box that can only be opened by his murderer. Kay is banished, and joins with Arthur's enemies, Brian of the Isles and Meliant. Guinevere expires upon seeing her son dead, which alters Arthur and Lancelot's actions substantially from what is found in later works. Though its plot is frequently at variance with the standard Arthurian outline, Perlesvaus did have an effect on subsequent literature.
    [Show full text]
  • Lancelot - the Truth Behind the Legend by Rupert Matthews
    Lancelot - The Truth behind the Legend by Rupert Matthews Published by Bretwalda Books at Smashwords Website : Facebook : Twitter This ebook is licensed for your personal enjoyment only. This ebook may not be re-sold or given away to other people. If you would like to share this book with another person, please purchase an additional copy for each person. If you're reading this book and did not purchase it, or it was not purchased for your use only, then please purchase your own copy. Thank you for respecting the hard work of this author. First Published 2013 Copyright © Rupert Matthews 2013 Rupert Matthews asserts his moral rights to be regarded as the author of this book. ISBN 978-1-909698-64-2 CONTENTS Introduction Chapter 1 - Lancelot the Legend Chapter 2 - Lancelot in France Chapter 3 - Lancelot in Britain Conclusion Introduction Of all the Knights of the Round Table, none is so famous as Sir Lancelot. He is both the finest of the Arthurian knights, and the worst. He is the champion of the Round Table, and the reason for its destruction. He is loyal, yet treacherous. Noble, but base. His is a complex character that combines the best and worst of the world of chivalry in one person. It is Sir Lancelot who features in every modern adaptation of the old stories. Be it an historical novel, a Hollywood movie or a British TV series, Lancelot is centre stage. He is usually shown as a romantically flawed hero doomed to eventual disgrace by the same talents and skills that earn him fame in the first place.
    [Show full text]
  • The Adventures of Sir Lancelot Du Lake
    1 The Adventures of Sir Lancelot du Lake There was held a feast of the Round Table at Caerleon, with high splendour; and all the knights thereof held many games and jousts. And therein Sir Lancelot increased in fame and worship above all men, for he overthrew all comers, and never was unhorsed or worsted, save by treason and enchantment. When Queen Guinevere had seen his wondrous feats, she held him in great favour, and smiled more on him than on any other knight. And Lancelot thought on her as fairest of all ladies, and done his best to win her grace. So the queen often sent for him, and bade him tell of his birth and strange adventures: how he was only son of great King Ban of Brittany, and how, one night, his father, with his mother Helen and himself, fled from his burning castle; how his father, groaning deeply, fell to the ground and died of grief and wounds, and how his mother, running to her husband, left himself alone; how, as he thus lay wailing, came the lady of the lake, and took him in her arms and went with him into the midst of the waters, where, with his cousins Lionel and Bors he had been cherished all his childhood until he came to King Arthur’s court; and how this was the reason why men called him Lancelot du Lake. Anon it was ordained by King Arthur, that in every year at Pentecost there should be held a festival of all the knights of the Round Table at Caerleon, or such other place as he should choose.
    [Show full text]
  • An Arthurian Drama
    EXCALIBUR: AN ARTHURIAN DRAMA RALPH ADAMS CRAM EXCALIBUR: AN ARTHURIAN DRAMA Table of Contents EXCALIBUR: AN ARTHURIAN DRAMA...........................................................................................................1 RALPH ADAMS CRAM..............................................................................................................................1 Advertisement:...............................................................................................................................................1 Prologue.........................................................................................................................................................2 Act I................................................................................................................................................................6 ACT II..........................................................................................................................................................44 i EXCALIBUR: AN ARTHURIAN DRAMA RALPH ADAMS CRAM This page copyright © 2002 Blackmask Online. http://www.blackmask.com • Advertisement: • Prologue • Act I • ACT II Advertisement: Excalibur is the introductory drama of a contemplated trilogy founded on the Arthurian legends as the perfect embodiment of the spirit and impulse of that great Christian epoch we call Mediævalism. The attempt is again madehowever inadequately to do for the epic of our own race, and in a form adapted to dramatic presentation, a small measure of that which
    [Show full text]
  • Structure, Legitimacy, and Magic in <Em>The Birth of Merlin</Em>
    Early Theatre 9.1 Megan Lynn Isaac Legitimizing Magic in The Birth of Merlin Bastardy, adultery, and infidelity are topics at issue in The Birth of Merlin on every level. Unfortunately, most of the critical examination of these topics has not extended beyond the title page. In 1662 Francis Kirkman and Henry Marsh commissioned the first known printing of the play from an old manuscript in Kirkman’s possession. The title page of their version attributes the play to Shakespeare and Rowley, and generations of critics have quarreled over the legitimacy of that ascription. Without any compelling evidence to substantiate the authorship of Shakespeare and Rowley, many critics have tried to solve the dilemma from the other end. Just as in the play Merlin’s mother spends most of the first act inquiring of every man she meets whether he might have fathered her child, these scholars have attempted to attribute the play to virtually every dramatist and combination of dramatists on record. Beaumont, Fletcher, Ford, Middleton, and Dekker, among others, have all been subjected to the literary equivalent of a blood-test; analyses of their spelling and linguistic preferences have been made in an effort to link them to The Birth of Merlin.1 Unlike the hero of the drama, however, the play itself is still without a father, though it does have a birthdate in 1622, as has been demonstrated be N.W. Bawcutt.2 Debates over authorship are not particularly uncommon in early modern studies, but the question of who fathered the legendary Merlin, the topic of the play, is more unusual and more interesting.
    [Show full text]
  • Lancelot, the Knight of the Cart by Chrétien De Troyes
    Lancelot, The Knight of the Cart by Chrétien de Troyes Translated by W. W. Comfort For your convenience, this text has been compiled into this PDF document by Camelot On-line. Please visit us on-line at: http://www.heroofcamelot.com/ Lancelot, the Knight of the Cart Table of Contents Acknowledgments......................................................................................................................................3 PREPARER'S NOTE: ...............................................................................................................................4 SELECTED BIBLIOGRAPHY: ...............................................................................................................4 The Translation..........................................................................................................................................5 Part I: Vv. 1 - Vv. 1840..........................................................................................................................5 Part II: Vv. 1841 - Vv. 3684................................................................................................................25 Part III: Vv. 3685 - Vv. 5594...............................................................................................................45 Part IV: Vv. 5595 - Vv. 7134...............................................................................................................67 Endnotes...................................................................................................................................................84
    [Show full text]
  • Introduction: the Legend of King Arthur
    Department of History University of Wisconsin-Eau Claire “HIC FACET ARTHURUS, REX QUONDAM, REXQUE FUTURUS” THE ANALYSIS OF ORIGINAL MEDIEVAL SOURCES IN THE SEARCH FOR THE HISTORICAL KING ARTHUR Final Paper History 489: Research Seminar Professor Thomas Miller Cooperating Professor: Professor Matthew Waters By Erin Pevan November 21, 2006 1 Copyright for this work is owned by the author. This digital version is published by McIntyre Library, University of Wisconsin – Eau Claire with the consent of the author. 2 Department of History University of Wisconsin-Eau Claire Abstract of: “HIC FACET ARTHURUS, REX QUONDAM, REXQUE FUTURUS” THE ANALYSIS OF ORIGINAL MEDIEVAL SOURCES IN THE SEARCH FOR THE HISTORICAL KING ARTHUR Final Paper History 489: Research Seminar Professor Thomas Miller Cooperating Professor: Matthew Waters By Erin Pevan November 21, 2006 The stories of Arthurian literary tradition have provided our modern age with gripping tales of chivalry, adventure, and betrayal. King Arthur remains a hero of legend in the annals of the British Isles. However, one question remains: did King Arthur actually exist? Early medieval historical sources provide clues that have identified various figures that may have been the template for King Arthur. Such candidates such as the second century Roman general Lucius Artorius Castus, the fifth century Breton leader Riothamus, and the sixth century British leader Ambrosius Aurelianus hold high esteem as possible candidates for the historical King Arthur. Through the analysis of original sources and authors such as the Easter Annals, Nennius, Bede, Gildas, and the Annales Cambriae, parallels can be established which connect these historical figures to aspects of the Arthur of literary tradition.
    [Show full text]
  • Writing and Literary Study Spring 2010 the Chivalrous Sir Gawain If
    Ahmed 1 Sarin Taslima Ahmed College Writing II: Writing and Literary Study Spring 2010 The Chivalrous Sir Gawain If a man does not open the door for a woman, she may think chivalry is dead or forget that it ever existed at all. Today's woman is not a damsel in distress, but rather stands on equal ground with her masculine counterpart. She has no need to acknowledge that there was ever a time when men lived and died for the sake of honor. However, around 1066 a.d. to 1485 a.d., that was exactly what European knights, and those around the world, did (Achlin). Of these brave soldiers, the most famous were the Knights of the Round Table, subjects of Camelot and King Arthur. Perhaps the most acclaimed knights are dubbed Sir Lancelot and Sir Gawain. Lancelot is still known as the greatest of all knights, the perfect knight, but based on Gawain's actions in Sir Gawain and the Green Knight by the Pearl Poet and those of Lancelot in The Once and Future King by T.H. White, I've come to the conclusion that Gawain is a greater model of chivalry than Lancelot. Following the code of chivalry, Gawain is faithful to God, his King, and he is respectful to women. Lancelot is very talented, but he does not feel the need to follow the laws of knighthood, and ends up disregarding King Arthur, Queen Guinevere and even God because of it. "Two virtues above all else were held to mark the good knight and bring him honor.
    [Show full text]
  • Frank Martin's Interpretation of the Tristan and Isolde Myth
    MARTA SZOKA (Łódź) Frank Martin’s Interpretation of the Tristan and Isolde Myth: Following the Trail of a Certain Novel Some people may frown at a juxtaposition of the Tristan and Isolde myth, one of the greatest sources of artistic inspiration in Euro­ pean culture, and its numerous musical representations with a novel by Charles Morgan, a minor writer known today almost exclusively to English literature scholars. If, however, we assume that the practice of musicology, apart from the analysis of music in terms of purely sonic structures, embraces also critical reflection, then we can put forward a perspective which will - to quote Polish poet Zbigniew Herbert - ‘open up a dialogue with the maker of the work, with his unique inner world, his love, passion and dilemmas, and also the path of perfection charac­ teristic of him and given to him’.1 I set out to scrutinise Frank Martin’s work in view of certain cul­ tural and psychological issues, as well as the social aspect of myth. Taken out of its complex context, the music score is forced to be an autonomous organism, and thus the multidimensional sense of art in the modern world becomes forgotten. Bearing an artistic and cultural message, a work of art is a carrier of meanings beyond the author’s in­ tent - meanings to be reached and understood. Moreover, this process of reaching out toward meaning does not exhaust itself in a single act of cognition, supposed to establish a certain truth once and for all. I would like to adopt here Hans-Georg Gadamer’s premise of the ‘inexhaustibil­ ity’ of the meaning of art as well as the ever renewed process of its un­ derstanding.2 1 Zbigniew Herbert, ‘Willem Duyster (1599-1635) albo Dyskretny urok soldateski’ [Willem Duyster, or the Discreet charm of the soldiery], Zeszyty Literackie 68 (1999), 18.
    [Show full text]
  • The Logic of the Grail in Old French and Middle English Arthurian Romance
    The Logic of the Grail in Old French and Middle English Arthurian Romance Submitted in part fulfilment of the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Martha Claire Baldon September 2017 Table of Contents Introduction ................................................................................................................................ 8 Introducing the Grail Quest ................................................................................................................ 9 The Grail Narratives ......................................................................................................................... 15 Grail Logic ........................................................................................................................................ 30 Medieval Forms of Argumentation .................................................................................................. 35 Literature Review ............................................................................................................................. 44 Narrative Structure and the Grail Texts ............................................................................................ 52 Conceptualising and Interpreting the Grail Quest ............................................................................ 64 Chapter I: Hermeneutic Progression: Sight, Knowledge, and Perception ............................... 78 Introduction .....................................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]