Dinosaur in a Haystack

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Dinosaur in a Haystack Dinosaur In a Haystack DIH 1. Happy Thoughts on a Sunny Day in New York City ............................................. 1 DIH 2. Dousing Diminutive Dennis’s Debate (or DDDD = 2000) .................................... 2 DIH 3. The Celestial Mechanic and the Earthly Naturalist ................................................ 3 DIH 4. The Late Birth of a Flat Earth ................................................................................. 4 DIH 5. The Monster’s Human Nature ................................................................................ 5 DIH 6. The Tooth and Claw Centennial ............................................................................. 6 DIH 7. Sweetness and Light ............................................................................................... 7 DIH 8. In the Mind of the Beholder .................................................................................... 8 DIH 9. Of Tongue Worms, Velvet Worms, and Water Bears .......................................... 10 DIH 10. Cordelia’s Dilemma ............................................................................................ 12 DIH 11. Lucy on the Earth in Stasis ................................................................................. 14 DIH 12. Dinosaur in a Haystack ....................................................................................... 15 DIH 13. Jove’s Thunderbolts ............................................................................................ 18 DIH 14. Poe’s Greatest Hit ............................................................................................... 19 DIH 15. The Invisible Woman .......................................................................................... 21 DIH 16. Left Snails and Right Minds ............................................................................... 22 DIH 17. Dinomania ........................................................................................................... 23 DIH 18. Cabinet Museums: Alive, Alive, Oh! ................................................................. 24 DIH 19. Evolution by Walking ......................................................................................... 24 DIH 20. The Razumovsky Duet ........................................................................................ 25 DIH 21. Four Antelopes of the Apocalypse...................................................................... 26 DIH 22. Does the Stoneless Plum Instruct the Thinking Reed? ....................................... 26 DIH 23. The Smoking Gun of Eugenics ........................................................................... 28 DIH 24. The Most Unkindest Cut of All .......................................................................... 29 DIH 25. Can We Complete Darwin’s Revolution? .......................................................... 30 DIH 26. A Humongous Fungus Among Us ...................................................................... 33 DIH 27. Speaking of Snails and Scales ............................................................................ 34 DIH 28. Hooking Leviathan by Its Past ............................................................................ 36 DIH 29. A Special Fondness for Beetles .......................................................................... 38 DIH 30. If Kings Can Be Hermits, Then We Are All Monkeys’ Uncles ......................... 40 DIH 31. Magnolias from Moscow .................................................................................... 41 DIH 32. The First Unmasking of Nature .......................................................................... 43 DIH 33. Ordering Nature by Budding and Full-Breasted Sexuality ................................. 44 DIH 34. Four Metaphors in Three Generations ................................................................ 45 DIH 1. Happy Thoughts on a Sunny Day in New York City On May 10, 1994, an annular eclipse occurred in parts of New England. In an annular eclipse, the moon is farther away from the earth than usual, and a “ring” (Latin, annulus) of sunlight remains around the moon at totality. Gould describes his anger with himself in not being able to travel to New Hampshire to see the best view, due to a prior commitment in New York City that day. New York would be exposed to a partial solar 1 eclipse, which is not nearly as dramatic. His frustration turned to joy, however, as he walked the streets of Manhattan during the phenomenon. While it never became truly dark, the character of the light did change quite noticeably. Further, every small aperture, from a hole in an awning to gaps between leaves on sidewalk trees, produced an image of the crescent sun via the “pinhole camera” effect. New Yorkers, legendary for always being in a hurry, stopped along the sidewalks in large numbers to marvel at these effects. One of the most diverse groups of humanity on the planet came together to share a fascination and a smile with dozens of strangers. Gould, always the humanist, quickly became more taken with the reactions of his fellow New Yorkers than he would have been with a better view of the eclipse – and he was a big fan of eclipses. The first thing that people must have in order to appreciate science, he argues, is a curiosity about the natural world. Based on this, he concludes, science at the level of the common man is alive and well in the United States. He is also pleased to note that there are events that do not involve tragedy that can bring us together, across all sociological lines. Happy thoughts! DIH 2. Dousing Diminutive Dennis’s Debate (or DDDD = 2000) Gould had more interest than most in the transitions of centuries and millennia. He offers no formal justification for this interest: he is not a numerologist, nor is he a believer in near-term “end times.” [I speculate that it may stem from his self-identified goal of continuing his rewarding but no doubt exhausting monthly essay-writing “streak” through the end of the millennia, but no farther.] He begins this essay with the answers to some basic questions. First, “millennium” has two n’s because it is a contraction of the Latin words mille (thousand) and annum (years); annum has two n’s, so millennium does also. Second, he points out that the term technically refers a thousand-year period of time, rather than the transition between such periods. Moreover, the traditional (biblical) use of the term is as the beginning of a thousand year reign of Christ, culminating in the end of the world, rather than the end the group of years that all posses the same digit in the thousand’s place. Gould then proceeds to discuss the question of whether the 20th century ends on December 31, 1999 or December 31, 2000. Phrased another way, is the year 2000 the last year of the 20th century, or the first year of the 21st century? Gould’s quick answer is that it is actually arbitrary. He gives us the history of the problem’s origin, which is due to a sixth-century Monk named Dionysius Exiguus (literally “Dennis the Short”). Dennis was assigned the task of developing a formal Christian chronology by the Pope. In addition to a few technical errors, such as getting the date of Christ’s birth wrong with respect to the Roman calendar by a few years, he made one big one that is the source of the problem at hand. Rather than defining the eighth day after Christ was born as the beginning of year zero, he chose it to be the beginning of year one. (He did this for B.C. numbers as well – the previous year was 1 BC, not 0 BC, so in numerical terms the date changed from –1 to +1 just after Jesus’s birth.) This has given no end of headaches to Roman scholars, astronomers, and others over the years. It also leaves us with the logical position that if a century is to contain one hundred years, then the end of the first century 2 must be 100 and not 99. This problem ripples through directly to today, although Gould tells us that Europeans did not really start struggling with the issue of what year the century ended until the 1699 – 1701 transition. The “common sense” position is that the centuries change at the “odometer moment.” Gould’s autistic son presented him an excellent rationale for this view: the first century simply had ninety-nine years instead of one hundred. Why not? Gould argues that both views are equally valid, because it is a human construction, rather than an external reality, that is involved. If there is no correct answer to this debate, then can we learn anything? Gould answers yes: we can learn something about societies of the past in the arguments they used in each case. He argues that the “elites” (e.g., the presidents of the Ivy League colleges) have traditionally sided with the logical position of 00-to-01 as the correct moment. The “man on the street” generally prefers the view of 99-to-00 for the transition; Gould actually references the song “1999” by Prince in this category, in addition to references from earlier centuries. DIH 3. The Celestial Mechanic and the Earthly Naturalist This essay discusses the concept of determinism in nature through the perspectives of two great 18th century French scientists, Georges Buffon (1707-1778) and Pierre-Simon Laplace (1749-1827). Gould begins with Laplace, who survived and even thrived during the French Revolution, and contributed greatly to several fields of science and mathematics. One of his great accomplishments was to use Newtonian mechanics to solve a set of challenging problems in
Recommended publications
  • Ten Misunderstandings About Evolution a Very Brief Guide for the Curious and the Confused by Dr
    Ten Misunderstandings About Evolution A Very Brief Guide for the Curious and the Confused By Dr. Mike Webster, Dept. of Neurobiology and Behavior, Cornell Lab of Ornithology, Cornell University ([email protected]); February 2010 The current debate over evolution and “intelligent design” (ID) is being driven by a relatively small group of individuals who object to the theory of evolution for religious reasons. The debate is fueled, though, by misunderstandings on the part of the American public about what evolutionary biology is and what it says. These misunderstandings are exploited by proponents of ID, intentionally or not, and are often echoed in the media. In this booklet I briefly outline and explain 10 of the most common (and serious) misunderstandings. It is impossible to treat each point thoroughly in this limited space; I encourage you to read further on these topics and also by visiting the websites given on the resource sheet. In addition, I am happy to send a somewhat expanded version of this booklet to anybody who is interested – just send me an email to ask for one! What are the misunderstandings? 1. Evolution is progressive improvement of species Evolution, particularly human evolution, is often pictured in textbooks as a string of organisms marching in single file from “simple” organisms (usually a single celled organism or a monkey) on one side of the page and advancing to “complex” organisms on the opposite side of the page (almost invariably a human being). We have all seen this enduring image and likely have some version of it burned into our brains.
    [Show full text]
  • Stephen Jay Gould Papers M1437
    http://oac.cdlib.org/findaid/ark:/13030/kt229036tr No online items Guide to the Stephen Jay Gould Papers M1437 Jenny Johnson Department of Special Collections and University Archives August 2011 ; revised 2019 Green Library 557 Escondido Mall Stanford 94305-6064 [email protected] URL: http://library.stanford.edu/spc Guide to the Stephen Jay Gould M1437 1 Papers M1437 Language of Material: English Contributing Institution: Department of Special Collections and University Archives Title: Stephen Jay Gould papers creator: Gould, Stephen Jay source: Shearer, Rhonda Roland Identifier/Call Number: M1437 Physical Description: 575 Linear Feet(958 boxes) Physical Description: 1180 computer file(s)(52 megabytes) Date (inclusive): 1868-2004 Date (bulk): bulk Abstract: This collection documents the life of noted American paleontologist, evolutionary biologist, and historian of science, Stephen Jay Gould. The papers include correspondence, juvenilia, manuscripts, subject files, teaching files, photographs, audiovisual materials, and personal and biographical materials created and compiled by Gould. Both textual and born-digital materials are represented in the collection. Preferred Citation [identification of item], Stephen Jay Gould Papers, M1437. Dept. of Special Collections, Stanford University Libraries, Stanford, Calif. Publication Rights While Special Collections is the owner of the physical and digital items, permission to examine collection materials is not an authorization to publish. These materials are made available for use
    [Show full text]
  • World History
    2012 Nw Boks n World History Harvard University Press New DENG XIAOPING AND THE TRANSFORMATION OF CHINA EZRA F. VOGEL ★ A New York Times Book Review Editors’ Choice ★ A Washington Post Best Book of the Year ★ An Economist Best Book of the Year ★ A Wall Street Journal Book of the Year No one in the twentieth century had a greater impact on world history than Deng Xiaoping. And no scholar is better qualified than Ezra Vogel to disentangle the contradictions embodied in the life and legacy of China’s boldest strategist—the pragmatic, disciplined force behind China’s radical economic, technological, and social transformation. “Vogel has gone to enormous lengths to document his subject…Vogel’s painstaking research provides plenty of fascinating detail…On the ways through which Deng set about the enormous task of rebuild - ing the gutted economy, shattered by decades of turmoil under Mao Zedong, Vogel is exhaustive.” —SIMON ELEGANT, TIME “Deng led a long and remarkable life, packed with drama and global significance, one that deserves to be dissected in detail…There’s no question that Vogel has gone farther than anyone else to date in telling Deng’s story. For that he is to be applauded; there is a whole hoard of valuable material here that we probably would not have gained otherwise.” —CHRISTIAN CARYL, FOREIGN POLICY “Ezra Vogel’s encyclopedic Deng Xiaoping and the Transformation of China is the most exhaustive English retelling of Deng’s life. Vogel…seems to have interviewed or found the memoirs of nearly every person who spoke with Deng, and has painstakingly re-created a detailed and intimate chronology of Deng’s roller-coaster career.” —JOSHUA KURLANTZICK, THE NATION “From arguably the most important scholar of East Asia, this is an important book on the force behind China’s transformation in the late twentieth century, whose full fruits are visible only today.
    [Show full text]
  • Bibliografia Delle Opere Di S.J. Gould Tradotte in Italiano
    Milano, Agosto 2015 Bibliografia delle opere di S.J. Gould tradotte in italiano L’elenco e’ redatto da Paolo Coccia e Marco Ferraguti utilizzando il web e le opere di Gould che ciascuno di noi possiede. Copyright , P. Coccia, email pacoccia[sboom]@libero.it e M. Ferraguti, email marco.ferraguti[sboom]@unimi.it Per comunicare con noi togliere [sboom] Potete utilizzare le citazioni presenti nella nostra bibliografia. Vi preghiamo di segnalare il nostro lavoro in questo modo: Paolo Coccia e Marco Ferraguti (2015). Bibliografia delle opere di S.J. Gould tradotte in italiano. Pikaia, il portale dell’evoluzione, Sezione “Omaggio a Gould”. Sito web visitato il ……. Segnaliamo inoltre: -Una prima versione della bibliografia e’ stata pubblicata su Systema Naturae nel 2004: Paolo Coccia e Marco Ferraguti (2004). BIBLIOGRAFIA GOULDIANA IN ITALIANO. Systema Naturae, Vol. 6, pp. 19-29 rintracciabile online al sito web http://www.biologiateorica.it/pdf/art2004/Coccia.pdf -il portale Pikaia http://www.pikaia.eu -la traduzione dei “Pennacchi” di Ferraguti http://www.einaudi.it/content/download/10149/68741/version/1/file/gould-lewontin.pdf I siti web sono stati visitati il 10 Agosto 2015. Le più recenti aggiunte e correzioni sono state evidenziate in rosso. I libri pubblicati da Gould hanno ora riprodotta la copertina. Sommario Libri pp. 2 - 14 Articoli e capitoli di libri pp. 15 - 17 Recensioni pp. 18 - 18 Prefazioni, Introduzioni, Postfazioni pp. 19 - 19 Interviste pp. 20 - 20 Articoli e libri su S.J. Gould pp. 21 - 24 Tesi universitarie pp. 25 - 29 1 Libri Gould, S. J., 1977. Ever since Darwin.
    [Show full text]
  • Cumulative Index
    Stephen Jay Gould’s Essays on Natural History: A Cumulative Index Hyperlinks A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z A Word of Introduction. This large file comines the indeces of all ten volumes of Stephen Jay Gould’s collections of essays reprinted from Natural History magazine. The goal is to reduce the effort to locate the reference to a particular person, item, or event; and similarly, to allow the reader to find all references to (say) Luis Alvarez in all volumes in one place. The row of hyperlinks will take you directly to the beginning of each letter’s section. To see this list at all times, click on the “bookmarks” icon in Adobe (found on the upper left of the screen). The file itself is also searchable, so you may seek the key word of your interest directly. As with all of these tasks, the identifying nomenclature is given as three or four letters followed by a number. The letters identify the volume; ESD refers to “Ever Since Darwin,” for example. (The entire sequence is listed below, in chronological order.) Similarly, the number refers to the order in which the essay appears in that volume, following Gould’s own numbering scheme. For ease of identification, I include the essay’s title as well. ESD: Ever Since Darwin. TPT: The Panda’s Thumb. HTHT: Hen’s Teeth and Horse’s Toes. TFS: The Flamingo’s Smile. BFB: Bully for Brontosaurus. ELP: Eight Little Piggies.
    [Show full text]
  • Good Science Books Recommended by Various Teachers on NSTA's Listserv
    Good Science Books Recommended by various teachers on NSTA’s listserv - Apologies for not acknowledging individually those who contributed to this book list. - Have added details such as publisher, year, ISBN etc when these were easily accessible - Grateful for feedback (to [email protected] please) re errors etc. A million thanks. Herbert Tsoi, NSTA Life Member, Hong Kong. Author(s) / Editor(s) Name of book Publisher, Comments accompanying some of the original recommendations year of publication, ISBN Abbey, Edward Desert Solitaire Abbott, Edwin Flatland: A Romance of Many Dimensions The best introduction one can find into the manner of perceiving dimensions (Asimov). Thought provoking very short book. Ackerman, Diane A natural history of the senses Vintage Books, 1991. Ackerman, Diane The Moon by Whale Light: And Other Adventures Among First Vintage Books, 1992. Bats, Penguins, Crocodilians, and Whales ISBN 0-679-74226-3 Ackerman, Diane The Rarest of the Rare: Vanishing Animals, Timeless Vintage, 1997. ISBN 978- Worlds 0679776239 Adams, Douglas The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy Adler, Irving & De Witt, The Wonders of Physics: An Introduction to the Physical Golden Press, 1966. ASIN Cornelius World B0007DVHGQ Albom, Mitch & Stacy Tuesdays with Morrie: An Old Man, a Young Man, and Broadway Books; (October Creamer, Stacy Life's Greatest Lesson. 8, 2002) ISBN: 076790592X Alder, K. The Measure of All Things: The seven-year odyssey and Free Press, 2002. The story of the two astronomers/scientists commissioned by the French Academy hidden error that transformed the world of Sciences to measure the length of the prime meridian through France in order to determine the length of the prime meridian and, thereby, the meter.
    [Show full text]
  • Last Update June 2011
    Title Author Year Type American Indian Ways of Life, Illinois State Museum,No. 9 Deuel, Thorne 1958 ARCHAEOLOGY-pamphlet Ancient Ancestors of the Southwest Schaaf, Gregory 1996 ARCHAEOLOGY Ancient North America, 4th ed. Fagan, Brian M. 2005 ARCHAEOLOGY Archaeology: A Brief Introduction, 9th Ed. Fagan, Brian M. 2006 ARCHAEOLOGY Archaeology: Cambridge Illustrated History Bahn, Paul G. (ed.) 1996 ARCHAEOLOGY Atlas of the North American Indian Waldman, Carl 1985 ARCHAEOLOGY Bulletin #1 - Illinois Archaeology Illinois Archaeological Surv. 1959 ARCHAEOLOGY-pamphlet Bulletin #2 - Indian Mounds & Villages in Illinois Illinois Archaeological Surv. 1960 ARCHAEOLOGY Bulletin #3 - Chicago Area Archaeology Illinois Archaeological Surv. 1961 ARCHAEOLOGY Bulletin #4 - Reports on Illinois Prehistory Illinois Archaeological Surv. 1963 ARCHAEOLOGY Bulletin #5 - Middle Woodland Sites in Illinois Illinois Archaeological Surv. 1965 ARCHAEOLOGY Bulletin #6 - Hopewell & Woodland Site Archaeology in Illinois Illinois Archaeological Surv. 1968 ARCHAEOLOGY Bulletin #7 - Explorations Into Cahokia Archaeology Illinois Archaeological Surv. 1969 ARCHAEOLOGY Bulletin #8 - Mississippian Site Archaeology in Illinois Illinois Archaeological Surv. 1971 ARCHAEOLOGY Bulletin #9 - Late Woodland Site Archaeology in Illinois Illinois Archaeological Surv. 1973 ARCHAEOLOGY Central States Archaeological Journal, Vol. 28 No. 1-4 1981 ARCHAEOLOGY-pamphlet Central States Archaeological Journal, Vol. 29 No. 1 1982 ARCHAEOLOGY-pamphlet The Cherry Valley Mounds and Banks Mound 3, Memoir
    [Show full text]
  • Biological Determinism and the Essays of Stephen Jay Gould
    New Jersey Institute of Technology Digital Commons @ NJIT Theses Electronic Theses and Dissertations Fall 1-31-2000 A thumb on the scale : biological determinism and the essays of Stephen Jay Gould Kevin F. Ryan New Jersey Institute of Technology Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.njit.edu/theses Part of the Technical and Professional Writing Commons Recommended Citation Ryan, Kevin F., "A thumb on the scale : biological determinism and the essays of Stephen Jay Gould" (2000). Theses. 811. https://digitalcommons.njit.edu/theses/811 This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the Electronic Theses and Dissertations at Digital Commons @ NJIT. It has been accepted for inclusion in Theses by an authorized administrator of Digital Commons @ NJIT. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Copyright Warning & Restrictions The copyright law of the United States (Title 17, United States Code) governs the making of photocopies or other reproductions of copyrighted material. Under certain conditions specified in the law, libraries and archives are authorized to furnish a photocopy or other reproduction. One of these specified conditions is that the photocopy or reproduction is not to be “used for any purpose other than private study, scholarship, or research.” If a, user makes a request for, or later uses, a photocopy or reproduction for purposes in excess of “fair use” that user may be liable for copyright infringement, This institution reserves the right to refuse to accept a copying order
    [Show full text]
  • Renowned Scientist Stephen Jay Gould Speaks at UNH April 23
    University of New Hampshire University of New Hampshire Scholars' Repository Media Relations UNH Publications and Documents 4-9-2002 Renowned Scientist Stephen Jay Gould Speaks at UNH April 23 Sharon Keeler Follow this and additional works at: https://scholars.unh.edu/news Recommended Citation Keeler, Sharon, "Renowned Scientist Stephen Jay Gould Speaks at UNH April 23" (2002). UNH Today. 2168. https://scholars.unh.edu/news/2168 This News Article is brought to you for free and open access by the UNH Publications and Documents at University of New Hampshire Scholars' Repository. It has been accepted for inclusion in Media Relations by an authorized administrator of University of New Hampshire Scholars' Repository. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Renowned Scientist Stephen Jay Gould Speaks at UNH April 23 10/23/17, 1056 AM UNH Renowned Scientist Stephen Jay Institute for Gould Speaks at UNH April 22 the Study of Earth, Oceans, and By Sharon Keeler Space UNH News Bureau UNH College of Life April 9, 2002 Sciences and Agriculture DURHAM, N.H. -- In celebration of Earth Day and the UNH College inauguration of its new Ph.D. program in natural of Engineering resources and Earth systems science, the University of and Physical New Hampshire welcomes Stephen Jay Gould as its Sciences featured speaker Monday, April 22. American Gould, professor of geology and zoology at Harvard Association University, is referred to as one of America's premier for the Advancement science writers with more than 15 books in print. His of Science talk, "Geological Immensity and Human Insignificance: The Proper Scale of Our Ecological Crisis," takes place in Johnson Theatre in the Paul Creative Arts Center at 7 p.m.
    [Show full text]
  • Dinosaur in a Haystack: Reflections in Natural History Stephen Jay Gould
    Dinosaur in a Haystack: Reflections in Natural History Stephen Jay Gould Jonathan Cape (Random House), London 1996. ISBN 0-224-04472-9. vi,457, bibliography, index. Hardback £18.99, Penguin Paperback £9.99 Review by Kathryn Denning Stephen Jay Gould's two decades of experience in writing monthly contributions for Natural History magazine has produced yet another excellent collection of reflective essays, this time on subjects from evolutionary theory and paleontology to the place of the museum in society; from extinction to the manufacturing of 'common knowledge'; and from academic infighting to the wonder of comets. The engaging elegance of Gould's prose is legendary – it is for good reasons that he regularly wins science writing prizes and hovers on bestseller lists – and his books are well worth the attention of anyone interested either in his subject matter, or in the task of making science and history accessible to a wide audience. Gould has achieved popularity without trivialising his material, writes with minimal jargon and maximal clarity, and speaks to the specialist and nonspecialist simultaneously. Only a few members of our own discipline come close; archaeology would do well to have more popular exponents of this calibre and inclination. But why else should archaeologists, in particular, read Gould's work, in general? Because Gould sagely comments on the nature of history, of science, and of historical sciences, and many relevant insights jump from the pages of his books. Wonderful Life (1991), for example, compellingly demonstrates the power of contingency in history and evolution, and trenchantly exposes the false iconography of doctrines of evolutionary progress, which still pervade historical disciplines.
    [Show full text]
  • The Hedgehog, the Fox, and the Magister's Pox: Mending the Gap
    the HEDGEHOG, the FOX, and the MAGISTER’S POX [To view this image, refer to the print version of this title.] the HEDGEHOG, [To view this image, refer to the print version of this title.] MENDING THE GAP BETWEEN SCIENCE AND THE HUMANITIES the FOX, and the MAGISTER’S POX [To view this image, refer to the print version of this title.] STEPHEN JAY GOULD The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press Cambridge, Massachusetts • London, England 2011 Copyright © 2003 by Turbo, Inc. Foreword copyright © 2003 by Leslie Meredith All rights reserved Printed in the United States of America Published by arrangement with Harmony Books, an imprint of The Crown Publishing Group, a division of Random House, Inc. First Harvard University Press edition, 2011. Design by Lynne Amft Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Gould, Stephen Jay. The hedgehog, the fox, and the magister’s pox : mending the gap between science and the humanities / Stephen Jay Gould. — 1st Harvard University Press ed. p. cm. Originally published: New York : Harmony Books, c2003. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-0-674-06166-8 (pbk. : alk. paper) 1. Science—Social aspects. 2. Science and state. I. Title. Q175.5 .G69 2011 303.48’3—dc21 2011017925 For the American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS), a truly exemplary organization, serving so well as the “offi- cial” voice of professional science here and elsewhere. With thanks for allowing me to serve as their president and then chairman of the board during the millennial transition of 1999–2001. This book began as my presidential address in 2000.
    [Show full text]
  • The Exemplary Kuhnian: Gould’S Structure Revisited
    The Exemplary Kuhnian: Gould’s Structure Revisited BY GREGORY RADICK* STEPHEN JAY GOULD. The Structure of Evolutionary Theory. Cambridge, MA: Belknap Press, 2002. xxiv + 1433 pp., illus., index. ISBN: 0-674-00613- 5. $39.95 (hardcover). The Origin of Species recognized no goal set either by God or nature. Even such marvelously adapted organs as the eye and hand of man—organs whose design had previously provided powerful arguments for the existence of a su- preme artificer and an advance plan—were products of a process that moved steadily from primitive beginnings but toward no goal. Thomas S. Kuhn, The Structure of Scientific Revolutions (1962)1 Darwin reveled in this unusual feature of his theory—this mechanism for im- mediate fit alone, with no rationale for increments of general progress or com- plexification. The vaunted progress of life is really random motion away from simple beginnings, not directed impetus toward inherently advantageous complexity. Stephen Jay Gould, Life’s Grandeur (1996)2 The echo in Stephen Jay Gould’s way of expressing the contrast between goal-directed progress and Darwinian progress—for Thomas Kuhn, the very model of scientific advance—may or may not have been deliberate. Certainly Gould was candid about his debt to The Structure of Scientific Revolutions * Centre for History and Philosophy of Science, Department of Philosophy, University of Leeds, Leeds LS2 9JT, UK; [email protected]. The following abbreviations are used: SET, Stephen Jay Gould, The Structure of Evolutionary Theory; SSR, Thomas S. Kuhn, The Structure of Scientific Revolutions. 1. Thomas S. Kuhn, The Structure of Scientific Revolutions, 2nd ed.
    [Show full text]