Getting Close to Absolute Zero

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Getting Close to Absolute Zero incorporate into the lattices of these materials junction between an s- and a p -state super- Clearly, much work remains to be done, (nonmagnetic impurities come free). Another conductor. However, a poor junction would but (the data now available at least refute the test is based on the fact that a “supercurrent” also kill a supercurrent, and good junctions conventional wisdom of a dichotomy be- would not flow through a loop containing a are extremely difficult to prepare. tween superconductivity and a tendency Getting Close to Absolute Zero iquid helium-4 and helium-3 rank with ature limit is set not by freezing (as it is for a heated still where helium-3 evaporates vacuum as sine qua nons for many normal liquids) but by a rapid decrease in preferentially. For economy the helium-3 is L scientific experiments. Some phenom- vapor pressure. condensed and the liquid returned to the ena occur only at temperatures achievable Even lower temperatures (down to about system. The photograph shows author Jef- with these unusual liquids, and others be- 0.005 kelvin) can be reached with a “dilu- frey O. Willis examining a UPt3 whisker in come much more tractable to theoretical tion” refrigerator. This device exploits the the cryostat of the Physical Metallurgy interpretation. natural tendency of liquid helium-3 to Group’s dilution refrigerator. A dewar con- Gaseous helium-4 occurs on the earth as a “evaporate” into the “mechanical vacuum” taining liquid helium encloses the cryostat product of alpha decay and is found in of liquid helium-4. (These two liquids, despite when the refrigerator is operating, About reasonable concentrations in some natural both consisting of isotopes of the same ele- twenty-four hours are required to cool a gas fields. It was first liquefied in 1908 by ment, interact very weakly because one sample to the desired temperature. Heike Kamerlingh Onnes (whose discovery (helium-4) follows Bose-Einstein statistics Temperatures in helium-3 and helium-4 of superconductivity soon followed). Tem- and the other follows Fermi-Dirac statistics.) evaporation refrigerators are determined peratures between about 1 kelvin and the The atoms of helium-3 absorb heat (cor- simply by measuring the vapor pressure. boiling point of liquid helium (4.2 kelvins) responding to the heat of evaporation) as Thermometry in a dilution refrigerator in- can be attained simply by pumping on the they cross the phase boundary between these volves use of a material whose magnetic liquid. The atoms crossing the liquid-vapor two dissimilar liquids. The lower temperature susceptibility is known to be quite closely phase boundary absorb heat, and the remain- limit is set not by a decrease in the “vapor inversely proportional to the temperature. ing liquid cools. Somewhat lower tem- pressure” as the temperature falls but by a The susceptibility versus temperature curve peratures (routinely down to between 0.5 and decrease in the heat of “evaporation.” for this material is calibrated against vapor 0.3 kelvin, depending on the system) can be The accompanying diagram illustrates pressure measurements in a helium-3 evapo- reached by pumping on liquid helium-3. (This schematically the continuous operation of a ration refrigerator. and lower temperatures stable but naturally extremely rare isotope is dilution refrigerator. Liquid helium-3 dis- are obtained by extrapolation. ■ a by-product of the manufacture of nuclear solves in liquid helium-4 in the mixing weapons.) For both liquids the lower temper- chamber, and the dilute solution is pumped to 66 Spring 1984 Los ALAMOS SCIENCE.
Recommended publications
  • On the Definition of the Measurement Unit for Extreme Quantity Values: Some Considerations on the Case of Temperature and the Kelvin Scale
    ON THE DEFINITION OF THE MEASUREMENT UNIT FOR EXTREME QUANTITY VALUES: SOME CONSIDERATIONS ON THE CASE OF TEMPERATURE AND THE KELVIN SCALE Franco Pavese 1 1 Torino, Italy E-mail (corresponding author): [email protected] Abstract Many quantities are attributed a range of values that can apparently extend to infinity (on one side or both sides). In this respect, the definitions of their measurement units do not place any constraint to the maximum (or minimum) value for their validity. In general, that happens because those extreme values are far from being reached on the earth, or presently in experiments. However, since the same units are used also in fields of physics, chemistry or technology where they could occur—namely in the description of the universe in one sense, and in pico-nanoscale or particle physics in another sense—the issue of extreme values (not in statistical meaning here) is not irrelevant. The question placed and discussed in this paper is whether the present kelvin scale, based on Lord Kelvin’s second definition (our currently accepted concept of temperature), applies over a full range between bounds (0, ∞) or not, and about the concept of temperature in itself in the extremes regions. The aim, however, is not to provide an answer, but to suggest there are difficulties with the application of current concepts at extremes of temperature. Keywords: kelvin scale; Lord Kelvin proposals; extreme temperatures; temperature definition; unit definition 1 Introduction Many quantities have a range of values that can apparently extend to infinity (on one side or both sides). In this respect, the definition of their measurement units does not place any constraint to the maximum (or minimum) value for its validity.
    [Show full text]
  • Dry Dilution Refrigerator for Experiments on Quantum Effects in the Microwave Regime
    1 453 Dry Dilution Refrigerator for Experiments on Quantum Effects in the Microwave Regime A. Marx, J. Hoess, and K. Uhlig Walther-Meißner-Institut Garching, Germany 85748 ABSTRACT At the Walther-Meißner-Institut (WMI), a new cryogen-free 3He/4He dilution refrigerator (DR) has been completed; the cryostat will be employed to cool experiments on superconducting quantum circuits for quantum information technology and quantum simulations. All major components have been made at the WMI. The DR offers a great amount of space at the various stages of the apparatus for microwave components and cables, e. g., the usable space at the mixing chamber has a height of more than 60 cm and a diameter of 30 cm (mixing chamber mounting plate). To cool the cables and the cold amplifiers, the DR is equipped with a separate 4He-1K-loop which offers a cooling power of up to 100 mW near 1K. The refrigeration power of the still is 18 mW at 0.9 K; and the diameter of its mounting plate is 35 cm. The cryostat rests in an aluminum trestle on air springs to attenuate building vibrations. It is pre cooled by a Cryomech PT410-RM pulse tube cryocooler (PTC) which is mechanically decoupled from the vacuum can of the cryostat by a bellows assembly. The two stages of the PTC are thermally connected to the DR via copper ropes. There are no nitrogen cooled traps with this DR to purify the gas streams of the 3He and 4He loops; instead, charcoal traps are mounted inside the DR at the first stage of the PTC.
    [Show full text]
  • The Third Law of Thermodynamics Or an Absolute Definition for Entropy. Part
    The third law of thermodynamics or an absolute definition for Entropy. Part 1 : the origin and applications in thermodynamics. Accepted for the revue: “La Météorologie ” / Revision 2 - December 2, 2019. by Pascal Marquet. Météo-France, CNRM/GMAP, Toulouse. Abstract This article describes the third law of thermodynamics. This law is often poorly known and is often decried, or even considered optional and irrelevant to describe weather and climate phenomena. This, however, is inaccurate and contrary to scientific facts. A rather exhaustive historical study is proposed here in order to better understand, in another article to come, why the third principle can be interesting for the atmosphere sciences. 1 Introduction Before being able to study in a second part the properties of entropy in the atmosphere, it is necessary to recall in this first part why its calculation poses certain problems in thermodynamics, problems whose solution passes through the invention and the application of the third law of thermodynamics which introduces a kind of absolute in the calculation of entropy. And the idea that certain absolutes may exist had preceded the establishment of the third law. 2 The notion of absolute temperature Thermodynamics teaches us that the notion of temperature corresponds to the measurement of the energy of the microscopic agitations of atoms or molecules in the solids, liquids or gases which constitute the environment which surrounds us, and therefore in particular in the atmosphere. Carnot (1824) was able to establish the existence of universal things, supposing that the perpetual motion of thermal machines was impossible. He first highlighted the existence of a maximum efficiency that depends only on the temperatures of the bodies between which these machines operate.
    [Show full text]
  • UBO & MPD Glossary
    UBO & MPD Glossary December 2011 Aniline Point – The aromatics content of a hydrocarbon A. mixture. Abnormal Pressure - Reservoir pore fluid pressure that Annulus Friction Pressure (AFP) – Difference is not similar to normal saltwater gradient pressure. The between bottomhole pressure and choke pressure due to term is usually associated with higher than normal friction; a function of flow rate, hole geometry, surface pressure, increased complexity for the well designer and roughness, fluid properties. an increased risk of well control problems. Abnormal – American Petroleum Institute. pressure gradients exceed a 10-ppg equivalent fluid API density (0.52 psi per foot). Gradients below normal are API Gravity - arbitrary measurement of density adopted in called subnormal. 1921 by the American Petroleum Institute and the Bureau Absolute Pressure - pressure measured with respect to of Standards. zero pressure; the sum of atmospheric pressure and gauge Apparent Power - combination of real and reactive pressure. power. Absolute Temperature - temperature measured with Apparent Viscosity - Slope of the shear stress versus respect to absolute zero, in degrees Rankine or degrees velocity gradient for a fluid. For Newtonian fluids, the Kelvin. apparent viscosity equals the absolute viscosity. Absolute Viscosity - dynamic relationship between a Aromatics – Ring group chemical structure. Most force and the fluid motion. common are benzene, toluene, and xylene. Absolute Zero Temperature - temperature that B. prevents molecular motion. Back Pressure Valve - A flow control valve to provide - rate of change in velocity. Acceleration backflow control when running or pulling a string. Active data - continually updated data, based on latest Backup – Redundant equipment available to complete an operational data. operation in the event the primary equipment fails.
    [Show full text]
  • Thermodynamics the Study of the Transformations of Energy from One Form Into Another
    Thermodynamics the study of the transformations of energy from one form into another First Law: Heat and Work are both forms of Energy. in any process, Energy can be changed from one form to another (including heat and work), but it is never created or distroyed: Conservation of Energy Second Law: Entropy is a measure of disorder; Entropy of an isolated system Increases in any spontaneous process. OR This law also predicts that the entropy of an isolated system always increases with time. Third Law: The entropy of a perfect crystal approaches zero as temperature approaches absolute zero. ©2010, 2008, 2005, 2002 by P. W. Atkins and L. L. Jones ©2010, 2008, 2005, 2002 by P. W. Atkins and L. L. Jones A Molecular Interlude: Internal Energy, U, from translation, rotation, vibration •Utranslation = 3/2 × nRT •Urotation = nRT (for linear molecules) or •Urotation = 3/2 × nRT (for nonlinear molecules) •At room temperature, the vibrational contribution is small (it is of course zero for monatomic gas at any temperature). At some high temperature, it is (3N-5)nR for linear and (3N-6)nR for nolinear molecules (N = number of atoms in the molecule. Enthalpy H = U + PV Enthalpy is a state function and at constant pressure: ∆H = ∆U + P∆V and ∆H = q At constant pressure, the change in enthalpy is equal to the heat released or absorbed by the system. Exothermic: ∆H < 0 Endothermic: ∆H > 0 Thermoneutral: ∆H = 0 Enthalpy of Physical Changes For phase transfers at constant pressure Vaporization: ∆Hvap = Hvapor – Hliquid Melting (fusion): ∆Hfus = Hliquid –
    [Show full text]
  • Lecture 15 November 7, 2019 1 / 26 Counting
    ...Thermodynamics Positive specific heats and compressibility Negative elastic moduli and auxetic materials Clausius Clapeyron Relation for Phase boundary \Phase" defined by discontinuities in state variables Gibbs-Helmholtz equation to calculate G Lecture 15 November 7, 2019 1 / 26 Counting There are five laws of Thermodynamics. 5,4,3,2 ... ? Laws of Thermodynamics 2, 1, 0, 3, and ? Lecture 15 November 7, 2019 2 / 26 Third Law What is the entropy at absolute zero? Z T dQ S = + S0 0 T Unless S = 0 defined, ratios of entropies S1=S2 are meaningless. Lecture 15 November 7, 2019 3 / 26 The Nernst Heat Theorem (1926) Consider a system undergoing a pro- cess between initial and final equilibrium states as a result of external influences, such as pressure. The system experiences a change in entropy, and the change tends to zero as the temperature char- acterising the process tends to zero. Lecture 15 November 7, 2019 4 / 26 Nernst Heat Theorem: based on Experimental observation For any exothermic isothermal chemical process. ∆H increases with T, ∆G decreases with T. He postulated that at T=0, ∆G = ∆H ∆G = Gf − Gi = ∆H − ∆(TS) = Hf − Hi − T (Sf − Si ) = ∆H − T ∆S So from Nernst's observation d (∆H − ∆G) ! 0 =) ∆S ! 0 As T ! 0, observed that dT ∆G ! ∆H asymptotically Lecture 15 November 7, 2019 5 / 26 ITMA Planck statement of the Third Law: The entropy of all perfect crystals is the same at absolute zero, and may be taken to be zero. Lecture 15 November 7, 2019 6 / 26 Planck Third Law All perfect crystals have the same entropy at T = 0.
    [Show full text]
  • Ch. 3. the Third Law of Thermodynamics (Pdf)
    3-1 CHAPTER 3 THE THIRD LAW OF THERMODYNAMICS1 In sharp contrast to the first two laws, the third law of thermodynamics can be characterized by diverse expression2, disputed descent, and questioned authority.3 Since first advanced by Nernst4 in 1906 as the Heat Theorem, its thermodynamic status has been controversial; its usefulness, however, is unquestioned. 3.1 THE HEAT THEOREM The Heat Theorem was first proposed as an empirical generalization based on the temperature dependence of the internal energy change, ∆U, and the Helmholtz free energy change, ∆A, for chemical reactions involving condensed phases. As the absolute temperature, T, approaches zero, ∆U and ∆A by definition become equal, but The Heat Theorem stated that d∆U/dT and d∆A/dT also approach zero. These derivatives are ∆Cv and -∆S respectively. The statement that ∆Cv equals zero would attract little attention today in view of the abundance of experimental and theoretical evidence showing that the heat capacities of condensed phases approach zero as zero absolute temperature is approached. However, even today the controversial and enigmatic aspect of The Heat Theorem is the equivalent statement 1 Most of this chapter is taken from B.G. Kyle, Chem. Eng. Ed., 28(3), 176 (1994). 2 For a sampling of expressions see E. M. Loebl, J. Chem. Educ., 37, 361 (1960). 3 For extreme positions see E. D. Eastman, Chem. Rev., 18, 257 (1936). 4 All of Nernst's work in this area is covered in W. Nernst, The New Heat Theorem; Dutton: New York, 1926. 3-2 lim ∆S = 0 (3-1) T → 0 In 1912 Nernst offered a proof that the unattainability of zero absolute temperature was dictated by the second law of thermodynamics and was able to show that Eq.
    [Show full text]
  • MODULE 11: GLOSSARY and CONVERSIONS Cell Engines
    Hydrogen Fuel MODULE 11: GLOSSARY AND CONVERSIONS Cell Engines CONTENTS 11.1 GLOSSARY.......................................................................................................... 11-1 11.2 MEASUREMENT SYSTEMS .................................................................................. 11-31 11.3 CONVERSION TABLE .......................................................................................... 11-33 Hydrogen Fuel Cell Engines and Related Technologies: Rev 0, December 2001 Hydrogen Fuel MODULE 11: GLOSSARY AND CONVERSIONS Cell Engines OBJECTIVES This module is for reference only. Hydrogen Fuel Cell Engines and Related Technologies: Rev 0, December 2001 PAGE 11-1 Hydrogen Fuel Cell Engines MODULE 11: GLOSSARY AND CONVERSIONS 11.1 Glossary This glossary covers words, phrases, and acronyms that are used with fuel cell engines and hydrogen fueled vehicles. Some words may have different meanings when used in other contexts. There are variations in the use of periods and capitalization for abbrevia- tions, acronyms and standard measures. The terms in this glossary are pre- sented without periods. ABNORMAL COMBUSTION – Combustion in which knock, pre-ignition, run- on or surface ignition occurs; combustion that does not proceed in the nor- mal way (where the flame front is initiated by the spark and proceeds throughout the combustion chamber smoothly and without detonation). ABSOLUTE PRESSURE – Pressure shown on the pressure gauge plus at- mospheric pressure (psia). At sea level atmospheric pressure is 14.7 psia. Use absolute pressure in compressor calculations and when using the ideal gas law. See also psi and psig. ABSOLUTE TEMPERATURE – Temperature scale with absolute zero as the zero of the scale. In standard, the absolute temperature is the temperature in ºF plus 460, or in metric it is the temperature in ºC plus 273. Absolute zero is referred to as Rankine or r, and in metric as Kelvin or K.
    [Show full text]
  • Principles of Dilution Refrigeration
    Principles of dilution refrigeration A brief technology guide 3He 4He About the authors Dr Graham Batey Dr Gustav Teleberg Chief Technical Engineer ULT Product Manager United Kingdom Sweden Graham completed his PhD Gustav Teleberg gained in Low Temperature Physics his PhD in cryogenics at Nottingham University for astronomy at Cardiff in 1985 and joined Oxford University where he Instruments designing top developed miniature loading plastic dilution refrigerators to run in pulsed dilution refrigerators and heat switches for telescope magnets, a rotating dilution refrigerator, and dark applications. He joined Oxford Instruments in 2007 as matter systems installed deep underground. He was a Cryogenic Engineer where he worked on developing involved in designing Oxford Instruments’ KelvinoxTM the Cryofree® dilution refrigerator that today is known range of dilution refrigerators and the world’s leading as TritonTM. He also worked on several patented cryogen free range of dilution refrigerators – TritonTM, technologies for rapid sample exchange and heat which in 2010 received the Queen’s award for pipes for accelerated cooling. innovation. In 2011, Graham received ‘The Business & Innovation’ award from the Institute of Physics and was elected Fellow of the IOP. Dilution refrigerators Principles of dilution refrigeration By Graham Batey and Gustav Teleberg Published by: Oxford Instruments NanoScience Tubney Woods, Abingdon, Oxon, OX13 5QX, United Kingdom, Telephone: +44 (0) 1865 393200 Email: [email protected] www.oxford-instruments.com/nanoscience © Oxford Instruments Nanotechnology Tools Limited, 2015. All rights reserved. Dilution refrigerators History The dilution refrigerator was first proposed by Heinz London in the early 1950s, and was realised experimentally in 1964 at Leiden University.
    [Show full text]
  • Approach to Absolute Zero 3
    SERIES I ARTICLE Approach to Absolute Zero 3. 0.3 K to a Few Milli-Kelvin R Srinivasan In part 2 of this series we dealt with the 3He cryostat. By R Srinivasan is a Visiting Professor at the Raman pumping on liquid 3He bath a temperature down to 0.3 K Research Institute after can be attained. To reach still lower temperatures in the retiring as Director of the milli-Kelvin region one uses a dilution refrigerator. In this Inter-University part the principles of operation of a dilution refrigerator Consortium for DAE Facilities at Indore. will be described. Earlier, he was at the Physics Department of Introduction liT, Chennai for many years. He has worked in The 3He cryostat was described in part 2 of this series of articles. low temperature physics By reducing the pressure on the 3He bath one can reach a and superconductivity. temperature down to about 0.3K. To reach still lower temperatures Debye and Giauque suggested the adiabatic The previous articles of this series were: demagnetization of a paramagnetic salt. This one-shot technique 1. liquefaction of gases, was used till the development of the dilution refrigerator in the December1996. late sixties and early seventies. The dilution refrigerator has the 2. Approach to absolute zero, advantage that it provides continuous refrigeration down to February 1997. about 10 lnilli-Kelvin. The development of the dilution refrigerator had to await the availability of the rare isotope, 3He, of helium in sufficiently large quantities. This became possible around the early sixties. As mentioned in part 2, 3He is a Fermion while the more abundant isotope 4He is a Boson.
    [Show full text]
  • Section 5 Further Thermodynamics
    Section 5 Further Thermodynamics 5.1 Phase equilibrium 5.1.1 Conditions for equilibrium coexistence It is an observed fact that the physical state of a system can sometimes be changed dramatically when its external conditions are changed only slightly. Thus ice melts when the temperature is increased from slightly below 0°C to slightly above this temperature. Different physical states of the same substance are referred to as phases and the study of transitions between phases is one of the most interesting problems in statistical thermodynamics. This is partly because the question of predicting when and how a phase transition will occur is still not a fully solved problem. There is the further point that a comprehensive understanding of phase transition phenomena might have wider application to such things as the outbreak of a war or a stock market crash. Very generally, phase transitions are due to interactions between the constituent particles of a system. The model-dependence of the behavior would suggest that full understanding can only come from a statistical mechanical study, not from thermodynamics. However there are many aspects of phase transitions which seem to be general and common to many systems. Macroscopic thermodynamics is of help here since it is model-independent and it connects seemingly unrelated properties of the system. This frees us to concentrate on the few thermodynamic variables of the system instead of getting bogged down in the microscopic detail. We start by considering the conditions for equilibrium to exist between two phases of the same substance — such as ice and water, for example.
    [Show full text]
  • Visualizing Bose-Einstein Condensates
    VISUALIZATIONV ISUALIZATION C ORNER Editor: Jim X. Chen, [email protected] VISUALIZING BOSE–EINSTEIN CONDENSATES By Peter M. Ketcham and David L. Feder OSE–EINSTEIN CONDENSATES ARE THE COLDEST SUB- ity to do so, and the result is the for- mation of tiny quantum vortices, each B STANCES EVER MADE. ALONG WITH THIS DISTINCTION, with a quantized amount of superflow around it. BECS HAVE OTHER INTRIGUING PROPERTIES: FOR EXAMPLE, THEY These quantum whirlpools are pro- duced in BECs by rotating the mag- BEHAVE MUCH LIKE LIGHT DOES IN AN OPTICAL FIBER. IN FACT, netic trap in which the BEC is con- tained—much like trying to stir your many research groups have produced Quantum Vortices coffee by squeezing the cup and spin- “atom lasers” formed from traveling Laboratory-produced BECs aren’t ning yourself around. BECs range BECs. They also behave similarly to quite as simple as the ones Bose and from a millimeter to a centimeter in superfluids, much like liquid helium or Einstein originally predicted because size, so you’d think it should be easy to superconductors. By studying BECs, they are made from real alkali atoms, detect the vortices simply by shining we’ve gained important insights into not ideal gases. For instance, unlike an light on the cloud, taking a photo- much more complicated, but closely ideal gas, atoms can’t pass through one graph, and noting the tiny holes in the related, systems. another. They interact strongly, and at- picture where the atom density has BECs created from dilute alkali va- tract each other if they get too close to- gone to zero in the vortex cores.
    [Show full text]