DOCUMENT RESUME

ED 070 146 80 EA 004 652

AUTHOR Hanson, Gordon, Comp. TITLE Accountability: The State of the Knowledge. INSTITUTION State Dept. of Education, Madison. SPONS AGENCY Bureau of Elementary and Secondary Education (DHEW/OE), Washington, D.C. PUB DATE [72] NOTE 12p.

EDRS PRICE MF-$0.65 HC-$3.29 DESCRIPTORS *Bibliographies; *Educational Accountability; *Evaluation IDENTIFIERS *Assessment; Elementary Secondary Education Act Title V; ESEA Title V

ABSTRACT This publication comprises a 144-item bibliography of articles, documents, and books on the subject ofaccountability. The 40 cited ERIC documents are listed separately. (JF)

1 Accountability: The State Of The Knowledge

PAP TM( NI 01 III Al lit 10111:ANON e. WI I I AIII (II I ICI Of 1 (/11CA !ION

Cornprierl le; Gordon 11.inrrir l'or Vrtiscon1 ;11, Surto Af.sessownt Phrgrrirn For Di rtr :blown Under 11:1, A!..per.orr Of IJ;,por Mid INest Region Into ,r;urte Project Priblic 1.dvi 89 10, Title V. Ser505, .rs arnrror led). ACCOUNTABILITY

"Accountability '70"Compact, v. 4, , pp. 4-27.

Accountability: Review of Literature and Recommendations for Implementation. North Carolina Department of Public Instruction, Divisions of Planning Research, and Development, .

Allen, James E. "How is Education Being Held Accountable?" College Board Review, n. 82, W 1971-72, pp. 8-9, 24-25.

Antonelli, George. " Accountability and Brom Bones." New Voices in Education v. 1 n. 2, Spring 1971, pp. 15-17.

Austin, G.R. "Educational Accountability: Hallmark of the 1970's." Science Teacher, v. 38, , pp. 26-8.

Bain, Helen. "Self Governance Must Come First: Then Accountability." Phi Delta Kappan, v. 51, , pp. 413.

Bair, Medill. "Developing Accountability in Urban Schools: A Call for State Leadership."Educational Technology, v. 11, , pp. 38-40.

Baker, E.L. "Instructional Objective Exchange: Assistance in Goal-Referenced Evaluation."Journal of Secondary Education, v. 45, April 1970, pp. 158-162.

"Balanced Presentation of Accountability."American Vocational Journal, v. 46, Feb. 1971, pp. 88-90.

Barber, V.R. "Accountability, Bane or Boom?" School and Community, v. 57, April 1971, pp. 114-15.

Barro, Stephen M. "An Approach to Developing Accountability 9easures for the Public Schools." Phi Delta Kappan, v. 52 n. 4, , pp. 196-205.

Beavan, K. "Accountability Octopus Gains New Territory." Times Educational Supplement, v. 2871, May 29, 1970, pp. 11.

Bhaerman, Robert. "Accountability: How Can It Really Work for the Teacher?" School Progress, v. 40 n. 2, , pp. 27-29.

Borich, G.D. (Ed.) "Accountability: Symposium."Journal of Research and Development in Education, v. 5, Fall 1971, pp. 1-96.

Bowers, C.A. "Accountability from a Humanist Point of View."Educational Forum, v. 35 n. 4, , pp. 479-86.

Briner, C. "Administrators and Accountability."Theory Into Practice, v. 8, , pp. 203-6. Cass, J. "Accountability to Whom? For What?" Saturday Review, v. 54, March 20, 1971, pp. 41.

Catallozzi, J. "Accountability and Responsibility in Education." Journal of Education, v. 154, , pn. 21-9.

Chavez, S.J. "Performance Accountability in Teacher Education." Audiovisual Instruction, v. 16, , pp. 56-7.

Costa, Arthur L. "Who's Accountable to Whom?"Educational Leadership, v. 28, October 1970, pp. 15-19.

Cunningham, L.L. "Our Accountability Problems." Theory Into Practice, v. 8, October 1969, pp. 285-92.

Daniel, Fred K. "Moving Toward Educational Accountability, Florida's Program." Educational Technology, v. 11, January 1971, pp. 41-43.

Darland, D.D. "Profession's Quest for Responsibility and Accountability." V. 52, , pp. 41-4.

Davies, Ivor K. "Developing Accountability in Instructional Systems Technology." Programmed Learning and Educational Technology, v. 8 n. 3,, pp. 151-160.

Davies, D. "Relevance of Accountability." The Journal of Teacher Education, v. 21, Spring 1970, pp. 127-33.

Deck, L. Linton, Jr. "Accountability and the Organizational Properties of Schools." Education Technology, v. 11, January 1971, pp. 36-37.

Dolmatch, Theordore B. "Who Will be Accountable for Accountability?" School Library Journal, , pp. 19-21.

Duncan, Merlin G. "An Assessment of Accountability:The State of the Art." Educational Technology, v. 11, January 1971, op. 27-30.

Durstein, Richard M. "An Accountability Information System." Phi Delta Kappan, v. 52, December 1970, pp.236-239.

Durost, Walter N. "Accountability: The Task, The Tools, and the Pitfalls." Reading Teacher, v. 24 n. 4, January 1971, pp.291-304.

Dyer, Henry S. "Toward Objective Criteria of Professional Accountability in the Schools of ." Phi Delta Kappan, v. 52, December 1970, pp. 206-211.

English, F. and J. Zaharis. "Are Accountability and Governance Compatible?" Phi Delta Kappan, v. 52, February 1'171, pp.374-5. 3

Finley, Carman J. "National Assessment: Reports and Implications for School Districts". National Elementary Principal, v. 50 n. 3, January 1971, pp. 25-32.-

"Florida Accountability Plan Focuses on the Principal". Nations Schools, v. 86, November 1970, pp. 54-5.

Fox, Edward J. and William B. Levenson."In Defense of the Harmful Monopoly." Phi Delta Kappan, v. 61, , pp. 131-135.

Gaines, Edyth J. "Accountability: Getting Out of the Tangled Web." Nations Schools, v. 88 n. 4, October 1971, pp. 55-58.

Garvne, Robert J. "Accountability: Comments and Questions." Educational Technology, v. 11, January 1971, pp. 34-35.

Gillis, T.A. "Meeting the Challenge of Accountability."North Central Association Quarterly, v. 46, Fall 1971, pp. 255.

Cooler, D.D. and A.D. Grotelueschen. "Curriculum Development Accountability." Educational Leadership, v. 29, , pp. 165-9.

Guthrie, J. and R.W. Taylor (Eds.). "National Assessment: A History and Sociology: Excerpts from New Models for American Education." School and Society, v. 98, December 1970, pp. 471-7.

Hammond, Robert L. "Accountability Through Context Evaluation of Reading Performance."Journal of Research and Evaluation in Education, v. 5 n. 11, February 1971, pp. 31-6.

Hanson, M. "On Stability, Change, and Accountability."National Association of Secondary School Principals Bulletin, v. 55, October 1971, pp.15-24.

Harlacker, E.L. aad E. Roberts. "Accountability for Student Learning." Junior College Journal, v. 41, larch 1971, pp. 26-30.

Haynes, Solon E. and Charles E. Coyne. "Accountability in Teacher Education." NASSP Bulletin, v. 55 n. 359, December 1971, pp. 68-74.

Henclay, StephenP. "Implements to Accountability." Administrators Notebook, v. 20 n. 4,December 1971, pp. 1-4.

Hitchens, H. Jr. "Accountability."Audiovisual Instruction, v. 16, May 1971, pp. 116.

House, E.R. "Training Non-Research Personnel to Conduct Evaluations."Contemporary Education, v. 40, , pp. 324-8.

Myer, Anna L. "From Gold Stars to Green Stamps." Audiovisual Instruction, v. 16, May 1471, pp. 4, 6-8. 4

Irvine, D.J. "Meeting the Demands for Accountability." National Association of Secondary School Principals Bulletin, v. 55, November 1971, pp. 80-6.

Johnson, A. "Behavioral Objectives and Educational Responsibility."Today's Speech, v. 19, Fall 1971, pp. 35-8.

Johnson, R.B. "Objectives - Based Accountability Procedures for Classroom Use." Educational Technology, v. 11, , pp. 49-51.

Jordan, B. "Educational Accountability: A Crucial Question."Junior College Journal, v. 41, March 1971, pp. 23-5.

Kruger, W. Stanley. "Accountability and the Educational Program Auditor." Planning and Changing, v. 1 n. 3, October 1970, pp. 110-114.

Lembo, Diana L. "Approaches to Accountability." School Libraries, v. 21 n. 1, Fall 1971, pp. 15-19.

Lessinger, L.M. "Accountability for Results: A Basic Challenge for America's Schools."American Education, v. 5, , pp. 2-4.

"Accountability in Public Education." Today's Education, v. 59, , pp. 52-3.

"The Powerful Notion of Accountability in Education."Journal of Secondary Education, v. 45 n. 8, December 1970, pp. 339-47.

"Accountability and Curriculum Reform." Educational Technology, v. 10, May 1970, pp. 36-7.

"How Education Audits Measure Performance."Nations Schools, v. 85 n. 6, , pp. 33-34.

"Focus on the Learner: Central Concern of Accountability in Education."Audiovisual Instructor, v. 15, June 1970, pp. 42-4.

"Accountability in Education." Educational Technology, v. 11, January 1971, pp. 11-13+.

Every Kid A Winner - Accountability in Education.Simon and Schuster, 1970.

"Teachers in an Age of Accountability." Instructor, v. 80, May 1971, pp. 19-20.

Lieberman, M.(Ed.) "Overview of Accountability; Symposium." Phi Delta Kappan, v. 52, December 1970, pp. 194-239.

Light, R.J. and P.V. Smith. "Choosing A Future: Strategies for Designing and Evaluating New Programs."Harvard Educational Review, v. 40, , pp. 1-28. Long, T.E. "Human Resources Development: Who is Accountable?"American Vocational Journal, v. 47, , pp. 39-43.

McComas, J.D. "Accountability: How Do We Measure Up?"Educational Technology, v. 11, January 1971, pp. 31.

McGee, Robert T. "Accountable Leadership."Clearing House, v. 46 n. 3, November 1971, pp. 170-2.

Meade, E.J. Jr. "Accountability and Governance in Public Education." Education in , v. 9, , pp. 48-51.

"The School, The Principal: Governance and Accountability." NASSP Bulletin, v. 52, , pp. 191-200.

Morris, John E. "Accountability: Watchword for the 70's." Clearing House, v. 45 n. 6, February 1971, pp. 323-8.

Moellenburg, Wayne P. "National Assessment: Are We Ready?" Clearing House, v. 43 n. 8, , pp.451-454.

Nash, Robert J. "Accountability--The Next Deadly Nostrum in Education?" Society and School, v. 99 n. 2337, December 1971, pp.501-4.

Norris, Eleanor L. "The National Assessment." American Education, v. 5 n.8, October 1969, pp. 20-3.

Norton, R.E. "Relationship Between Evaluation and Accountability." American Vocational Journal, v. 47, February 1972, pp.61-5.

Olson, T.A. and L. Marvin. "Evaluation: One State's Approach; Illinois." American Education, v. 6, May 1970, pp. 33-34.

Pierce, Wendahl H. et. al. "Accountability through National Assessment. Accountability '70: Education Commission of the States Annual Meeting (4th, Denver, Colorado, July 8-10, 1970)." First General Session. Compact, v. 4 n. 5, October 1970, pn. 4-12.

Provus, Malcolm. "Toward a State System of Evaluation." Journal of Research and Development in Education, v.3 n. 4, Summer 1970, pp. 87-96.

Rajpal, P.L. "Relationship Between Expenditures and Quality Characteristics of Education in Public Schools." Journal of Educational Research, v. 63, October 1969, pp. 57-9.

Ratliff, F.E. "Accountability at What Cost?"English Journal, v. 60, April 1971, pp. 485-90.

Rice, D. et. al. "Educational Evaluators; Model for Task Oriented Position Development."Contemporary Education, v. 41, January1970, pp. 115-118. 6

Robinson, D.W. "Accountability for Whom? For What ?" Phi Delta Kappan, v. 52, December 1970, pp. 193.

Roush, Robert E. et. al. "Accountability in Education: A Priority for the 70's." Education, v. 92 n. 1, September-October 1971, pp. 113-7.

Saylor, Galen. "National Assessment: Pro and Con."Teachers College Record, v. 7 n. 4, May 1970, pp. 588-97.

Schure. A. "Accountability and Evaluation Design for Occupational Education." Educational Technology, v. 11, March 1971, pp. 26-27.

Schwartz, Ronald. "Accountability."Nations Schools, v. 85; June 1970, pp. 31-34.

Schwartz, R. and L.M. Lessinger. "Accountability."Nations Schools, v. 85, June 1970, pp. 31-34.

Shane, Harold G. "The Rediscovery of Purpose in Education."Educational Leadership, v. 28, April 1971, pp. 581-584.

Stenner, J. "Accountability by Public Demand." American Vocational Journal, v. 46, February 1971, pp. 33-7.

Stocker, Joseph. "Accountability and the Classroom Teacher."Today's Education, v. 60 n. 3, March 1971, pp. 41-56.

Sweigert, Ray L. Jr. "Assessing Educational Needs to Achieve Relevancy." Education, v. 91 n. 4, April-May 1971, pp. 315-8.

Tally, Roy D. Accountability in Education - A Review of the Literature. Northern Colorado Educational Board of Cooperative Series, 1972.

Thomsen, Donald R. "Accountability."Colorado Journal of Education Research, v. 10 n. 3, Spring 1971, pp. 16-22.

Turner, J.A. "Nameof the Game is Accountability." Education Canada, v. 10, December 1970,pp. 20-1.

Turkett, A. Keith. "Accountability: A Controversial Issue in Education." Kappa Delta PiRecord, v. 8 n. 2, December 1971, pp. 51-2.

Tyler, Ralph W. "National Assessment - Some Valuable Ey-Products for Schools." National Elementary Principal, v. 48 n. 6, May 1969, pp. 42-48.

Tyler, Ralph W. "Testing for Accountability." Education Digest, v. 36 n. 7, March 1971, pp. 12-14.

Underwood, K.E. "Before You Decide to be Accountable, Make Sure You Know For What." American School Board Journal, v. 158, September 1970, pp. 32-3. - 7

Voegel, G.H. ''t:countability and Performance Continued, Implications and Supporting Staff." Audiovisual Instruction, v. 16, May 1961, pp. 16-18.

White, F.J. Jr. "Autonomy and Accountability." New York State Education, v. 58, January 1971, pp. 48.

Wildaysky, Aaron. "A Program of Accountability for Elementary Schools." Phi Delta Kappan, v. 52 n. 4, December 1970, pp. 212-216.

Williams, Lois. "Governance Is Integral to Accountability."Today's Education, v. 60 n. 4, April 1971, op. 59-60.

Womar, Frank B. and Marjorie M. Mastie. "How Will National Assessment Change American Education?"Phi Delta Kappan, v. 53 n. 2, October 1971, pp. 118-120.

Wynne, Edward. Pol!lics of School Accountability. McCutchen, Berkeley, . R

ACCOUNTABILITY - ERIC FILES

ERIC documents may be obtained in either Microfiche (4F) - 4" x 6" sheet of microfilm on which up to 70 pages of text are reproduced or Hard Cover (HC) - reproduction of the document nn paper at the original size. Individual documents cost 65 cents per title for fiche and $3.29 for each 1n0 page increment (101-200 pages, $6.58; 201-300 pages, 59.87; etc.) for orders of hard copy titles. Orders must include accession number (e.g. ED number), type of reproduction (MF or HC), and the number of copies. Payment must accompany orders under $10.00. Orders should be sent to:

ERIC Document Reproduction Services Post Office Drawer 0 Bethesda, Maryland 20014

Badal, Alden W. aad Edwin P. Larsen. Measurement in Education: On Reporting Test Results to Community Groins. National Council on Measurement in Education, East Lansing, Michigan. 12 pp., May 1970. ED 051 297

Bell, Terrel H. Accountability: A Constructive Force in Education. Keynote address given before Northwest Association of Secondary and Higher Schools Annual Convention. 10 pp., December 7, 1971. ED 057 505

Bhaerman, Robert. A Paradign for Accountability. (Quest paper 12). Washington, D.C.: American Federation of Teachers, 10 pp., 1970. ED 041 870

Brain, George B. National Assessment -- Evaluation and Accountability. Paper presented at National Association of State Boards of Education Meeting. 14 pp., 1970. ED 046 064

Clark, Richard and John Rosenbach. Program Evaluators Handbook: Developing Solutions. State University of New York, Albany. State Educational Department. 60 pp., 1969. ED 043 672

Donnelly, Charles R. Accountability to Legislative Bodies. Speech delivered Fifty- Fifth Annual Meeting of the Northwest Association of Secondary and Higher Schools. 12 pp., December 6, 1971. ED 057 769.

Duke, W.R. Control of Accountability Through Planning, Programming, Budgeting, Evaluation Systems. 18 pp., , 1971. ED 055 364 9

Elliott, Lloyd H. Accreditation or Accountability: Must We Choose? Paper delivered at the meeting of the Middle States Association of Collegiate Registrars and Offices of Admission. 18 pp., 1970. ED 047 603 EvaluatingoetlAccountabialy. Maryland State Department of Education, Baltimore. Division of Compensatory, Urban, and Supplementary Programs. 21 pp., 1971. ED 055 06A

Farquhar, J.A. Accountability, Program Budgetinji, and the California Information System: A Discussion and A Proposal. Rand Corporation, Santa Monica, California. 34 pp. 1971. ED 050 4°8

Farrell, Edmund J. Implications of National Assessment Writing Results. Speech given at the Annual Meeting of the Association of AmericanPublishers, Inc., Washington, D.C. 7 pp., April 1971. ED 050 119.

Forsberg, James R. Accountability and Performance Contracting.Analysis and Bibliography Series, No. 13. Oregon University, Eugene.ERIC Clearing- house on Educational Administration. 15 pp., 1971. ED 055 336

Cooler, Dennis D. and Arde ?,rotelueschen. Process Accountability in Curriculum Development. Illinop University, Urbana. Center for Instructional Research and Curriculum Evalul,i;ioo. 11 pp., 1970. ED 040 757

Henclay, Stephen P. Deterrents to Accountability. Paper presented at Western Canada Educational Administrator's Conference. 20 pp., October 1971. ED 055 365.

Hiemstra, Roger Paul. Educational Investments and Economic Crowth: A Case Study in Continuing and Community Education. Michigan University, Ann Arbor. Ph.D. Thesis. 316 pp., 1972. ED 049 447

Jaeger, Richard M. Evaluation of National Educational Programs: The Coals and the Instruments. Bureau of Elementary and Secondary Education(DREW /OE), Washington, D.C. 20 pp., . ED 041 949

Johnson, Mae C. (Ed.) et. al. Accountability: To Whom? For What? Maryland University, College Park. Reading Center. 101 pp., 1971. ED 055 753

Keyslering, Leon H. Achieving nation -wide Educational Excellence: A Ten-Year Plan to Save the Schools. Conference on Economic Progress, Washington, D.C. 99 pp., . ED 033 879

Klein, Stephen P. The Uses and Limitations of Standardized Tests in Meetingthe Demands for Accountability. (UCLA Rvaluation Comment, January 1971.) University of California, Los Angeles. 20 pp., 1971. ED 053 175

Kruger, W. Stanley. Implications of Accountability for Educational Program Evaluation. Paper presented at the Invitational Conference onMeasurement in Education, University of Chicago.Chicago, Illinois. 14 pp., 1970. ED 043 665. - 10 -

Larsen, 0.P. Increasing AccountabilityThrough Involvement of Professional and Lay croups. Speech given before Western Canada Educational Administrators Conference. 24 pp., October 1971.

Lennon, Rodger T.Accountability and Performance Contracting,. Speech presented at American Educational Association Annual Meeting. 21 pp., February 1971. ED 049 520

Lessinger, Leon. Engineering Accountability for Results into Public Education. Waahington, D.C.Office of Education. 32 pp., 1970. ED 040 155

Lessinger, Leon et. al. NAPPA Papers on Accountability: To Whom, For What And By What Criteria?Indianapolis, Indiana:National Association of Pupil Personnel Administrators. 28 pp., 1970. ED 053 417

McConnell, T.R. Accountability and Autonomy.California University, Berkeley. Center for Research and Development in Higher Education. 25 pp., February, 1971. ED 057 760

Merrimarm, Howard O. Case Study of an Accountable School District.Speech given before New Jersey School Board Association annual workshop. 25 pp., , 1971. ED 055 361

Mullen, David J. (Ed.) Accountability. Georgia Association of Elementary School Principals, Athens; Georgia University, Athens. Bureau of Educational Studies and Field Services. 94 pp., 1971. ED 057 507

Proceedings of the Conferences on Educational Accountability. Educational Testing Service, Princeton, New Jersey. 108 pp., March 1971. ED 050 183

Proceedings of the Conferences on Educational Accountability. Educational Testing Service, Princeton, New Jersey. 67 pp., June 1971. ED 051 313

Rhodes, Lewis A. Educational Accountability; Getting It All Together. Background paper for seminar on Accountability of the Annual TexasConference for Teacher Education. 14 pp., 1970. ED 045 566

Richburg, James R.The Movement for Accountability in Education. 12 pp., November 1971. ED 058 145

Robertson, E. Wayne. (Ed.) Educational Accountability Through Evaluation. Educational Technology Publications. Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey. ED 054 221

Saretsky, Gary et. al.Accountability: A Bibliography. Indiana University, Bloomington.ERIC Clearinghouse on reading. 16 pp., 1971. ED 055 757

Sourcebook for Implementing Accountability..Educational Innovators Press, Tuscon, Arizona. 42 pp., 1971. ED 056 989

State Educational Assessment Programs. Educational Testing Service, Princeton, New Jersey. 100 pp., 1971. ED 056 102 Wear, Maurice and Byron Basom. Accountability in Education. Educational Adminis- tration Workshop. Summer, 1970. Wyoming University, Laramie. College of Education. 89 pp., . ED 055 359.

Wescott, J.P Accountability and Management.Speech given before Southern Association of College and Schools annual convention. 15 pp., July 1971. ED 055 318

Wilson, Donald F. The Practitioner and Accountability: Speech presented at National School Boards Association Annual Meeting, Atlanta, Georgia. 11 pp., 1971. ED 049 528

Womar, Frank B. Measurement in Education: National Assessment Says. National Council on Measurement in Education, East Lansing, Michigan.8 pp., October 1970. ED 051 298

Research Issues Arising from the National Assessment ofEducational Progress. Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the AmericanEducational Research Association, New York, New York. 17 pp., February 1971. ED 052 244