• Abstract and Figures
• Public Full-text

Gravity with spin and electromagnetism with a nonsymmetric metric tensor Richard T. Hammond∗ University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill Chapel Hill, North Carolina and Army Research Office Research Triangle Park, North Carolina (Dated: January 17, 2019) It is shown the antisymmetric part of the metric tensor is the potential for the spin field. Various metricity conditions are discussed and comparisons are made to other theories, including Einstein’s. It is shown in the weak field limit the theory reduces to one with a symmetric metric tensor and totally antisymmetric torsion. It is also shown, due to gauge invariance, the electromagnetic field must be present. PACS numbers: 04.20.Cv, 04.20.Fy, 04.40.Nr Keywords: non-symmetric metric, torsion, spin I. INTRODUCTION However, the source used for composite bodies is al- ways some averaged out model of the true source, the One of the strongest motivations for developing elementary particles that make up matter. To have a theory with a nonsymmetric metric tensor comes a realistic theory, it must be formulated in terms from the nonsymmetric energy momentum tensor, of a source which is an elementary particle (macro- but first, let us address a common proof, appearing scopic averaging may be done later), and each el- in many textbooks, that the energy momentum ten- ementary particle has intrinsic spin. The electron, sor must be symmetric. These “proofs” assume the quarks, and the electron neutrino, and the two other angular momentum is orbital angular momentum, so families each have spin. Exempted here are the two the contribution from a small region is the density exchange particles with zero spin; the Higgs and the times the volume times the radius. As the volume quantum of torsion. With this proviso, since parti- goes to zero so does the contribution to the angu- cles have spin, the energy momentum tensor cannot lar momentum, which, as the proof shows, yields a be symmetric and so, we take the metric tensor to symmetric energy momentum tensor. However, if be nonsymmetric. the angular momentum is intrinsic spin the argu- More modern developments in physics, after the ment fails, as discussed in detail by Sciami.[1] In Einstein era, make the nonsymmetric metric tensor fact, Papapetrou showed the antisymmetric part of more cogent than ever. Anti-commuting variables, the energy momentum tensor is related to spin (by non-commutative geometry and superspace can be spin I will always mean intrinsic spin), [2],[3] and related to the antisymmetric part of the metric ten- so we are naturally led to consider a nonsymmetric sor. For example, for anti-commuting Grassmann metric tensor if spin is included. variables θµ, which satisfy dθµ, dθν = 0, the line { } µ ν The exception to this argument arises from gravi- element can be generalized to include φµν dθ dθ tation with a symmetric metric tensor with torsion. where φµν is the antisymmetric part of the met- In this case, as is known, the torsion can describe ric tenor. In the metricity conditions (discussed spin. However, the torsion arises from an antisym- fully below), the antisymmetric part of the metric arXiv:1901.05418v1 [gr-qc] 16 Jan 2019 metric source tensor and, as we will see below for tensor appears in the skew symmetric derivative, torsion of the string theory type, the source of tor- φµν,σ + φσµ,ν + φνσ,µ. The temptation to set this sion turns out to be the antisymmetric part of the to zero may have fueled attempts to interpret φµν metric tensor. Thus, we end up with a nonsymmet- as being related to the electromagnetic field, but to- ric energy momentum tensor. day we see this combination is used to define torsion These arguments also tell us what the physical in- (as discussed below) both from generalized gravity[4] terpretation of the nonsymmetric part of the metric and string theory.[5] tensor is, it is related to spin. However, all this as- The older work is well known. Soon after Einstein sumes the source has intrinsic spin. For bodies like published his theory of general relativity he, and the Earth or an apple the spins may add to zero. others, began serious investigations into the phys- ical theory based on a non-symmetric metric tensor gµν [6],[7],[8], a detailed review may be found in the literature.[9] For almost 100 years this search led to ∗ [email protected] many dead-ends and disappointing quagmires. Al- 2 though early investigations of Einstein sought to de- A. previous related work velop a fully geometric theory in which the energy momentum tensor was of a geometric origin, most It will be shown that the linearized version of the of his efforts sought to find a unified theory of grav- nonsymmetric theory developed below reduces to a itation and electromagnetism. Various researchers well studied theory with a symmetric metric tensor picked up the torch, including Schr¨odinger,[10] but and torsion of the string theory type, i.e., finally the light dimmed as it became evident these dark paths led nowhere. 1 Sµνσ ψ = (ψµν,σ + ψσµ,ν + ψνσ,µ) (1) ≡ [µν,σ] 3 Two notable approaches followed. One is the work of Sciama,[1] who showed the antisymmetric part of where the metric tensor is associated with intrinsic spin. 1 This followed work by Papapetrou and Belinfante S σ = Γ σ Γ σ (2) µν 2 µν − νµ who considered a nonsymmetric energy momentum σ tensor.[3] Sciama adopted Einstein’s variational ap- where Γµν is the affine connection and where ψµν is proach but did not associate the theory with electro- the antisymmetric torsion potential. The geometri- magnetism. Soon after, however, Sciama adopted a cal part of the action is simply symmetric metric tensor but considered spacetime to be endowed with torsion. This notion of classical spin in general relativity with a symmetric metric I = √ gd4xR (3) tensor was carried forward by Hehl and his collab- − Z orators in the 1970s and later others.[11] [12] [13] The other well-known approach is due to Moffat.[14] where R is the curvature scalar and, in that theory, He adopted Einstein’s equations with a nonsymmet- variations are taken with respect to a general po- tential defined by Φµν gµν + ψµν where gµν is the ric metric tensor, but he eschewed the notion of ≡ electromagnetism, taking the theory to be one of symmetric metric tensor.[12] This theory is very suc- gravitation only. It was shown if the metric tensor cessful. One of the most important results is that the was expanded about a background metric, the an- correct conservation law of total angular momentum tisymmetric potential appears without a derivative. is obtained if the source of torsion is intrinsic spin. This non gauge invariant term gave rise to ghosts, From this viewpoint, it was argued that torsion must but they were removed by adding cosmological type exist. A phenomenological source was constructed terms.[15] The revenant idea of the antisymmetric and the weak field limit of the torsion was found. part of the metric tensor being associated with spin This coincided exactly with the low energy limit of was described more recently.[16] the Dirac equation in spacetime with torsion, which is a very important confirmation of the theory. It was then shown strings are a natural source for the One of the problems with using a nonsymmetric material action, and it was further shown how the metric is the proliferation of tensors, such as in the correct equations of motion arise from strings. How- definition of the covariant derivative, the curvature ever, the notion of a general potential Φµν was not tensor, and its contractions that form scalars to be a geometrical foundation. It was simply a tidy way used in the Lagrangian. Einstein used transposi- of deriving the field equations. Variations with re- tion invariance as a guiding principle. This is not a spect to the general potential are identical to inde- physics principle, unless one interprets it as coming pendent variations of the metric tensor and torsion from a charge invariance,[17], but even if this fragile potential. However, it was suggestive. It certainly notion stood up, it is based on the idea the theory invites the question, can the theory be formulated in involves electromagnetism. Even recently, for exam- terms of a nonsymmetric metric tensor? In addition, ple, the notion that the antisymmetric part of the it is known the skew symmetric derivative appear- metric tensor is associated with nuclear forces has ing in (1) arises naturally in the nonsymmetric the- been considered.[18] ory when metricity conditions are used. Instead of thinking this is related to electromagnetism, as Ein- stein did, it is more natural that this may be related In the current paper it is shown the non- to spin, as will be seen in detail below. symmetric part of the metric tensor is associated This notion gives us very useful direction, and es- with spin. With this, physical principles are used to pecially what to expect in the weak field limit. Also, choose the appropriate terms so that the prolifera- the notion that the (dimensionless) antisymmetric tion of tensors is not an issue. part of the metric potential acts like a potential for 3 the field coincides with the idea that the symmetric II. AFFINE GEOMETRY part is like the potential of the gravitational field. Finally, one of the original complaints about the We begin by looking at a spacetime endowed with nonsymmetric theory was that the symmetric part an affine connection, more details may be found in and antisymmetric part transform separately, which the literature.[21] At this point there is no concept of was considered bad.

Load more

  12

Copy Link