Recorded in Clonick Hall at the Oberlin Conservatory of , July 2013, and supported in part by the Oberlin Conservatory of Music.

Technical Team Martha de Francisco, producer The Music for and Cello Ryan Miller, recording and balance engineer Robert Murphy, piano preparation

Instruments Cello by Johannes Cuypers (1799) Copy of a 5-octave , ca. 1800 by (op. 5 sonatas and variations) Copy of a from 1819 by Paul McNulty (later sonatas)

DAVID BREITMAN | FORTEPIANO TANYA ROSEN-JONES TANYA NI00 6362 NI 0000 JAAP TER LINDEN | CELLO My first encounter with the world of Beethoven was his Seventh Symphony. I was a Disc One twelve-year-old boy and immediately overwhelmed by his enormous, inescapable, and boundless energy as well as by his irresistible tenderness and generosity. Sonata op. 5 no. 1 in F major My second encounter was with the two late cello sonatas played by Pablo Casals 1 Adagio sostenuto 2:44 in his later years. Even as a young man I was attracted to the way older musicians 2 Allegro 15:07 play. It is as if their life experience changes and enriches their grasp of the music. 3 Rondo: Allegro vivace 7:20 Tenderness and generosity are joined by humility, and these milder qualities now get an equal share of the spectrum previously dominated by passion, energy and power. 4-16 Twelve variations on “Ein Mädchen oder Weibchen,” op. 66 10:30 I thought—and still think— that one has a better chance of finding this balance later in life when one has “lived a little.” Sonata op. 5 no. 2 in G minor My third encounter was with Beethoven’s violin sonatas. What a tremendous 17 Adagio sostenuto e espressivo 4:58 discovery that was! Especially the depth and apparent wisdom “beyond his years” of the slow movements in the early sonatas took my breath away, moving me to tears. 18 Allegro molto più tosto presto 10:45 And then David and I started on our journey of discovery with our sonatas. Unlike 19 Rondo: Allegro 9:54 the violin sonatas, the cello sonatas span all of Beethoven’s creative periods: from the opus 5, his early period, through opus 69, his middle period, to the last ones 20-32 Twelve variations on “See the conqu’ring hero comes,” WoO 45 13:25 from his late period. This presented us with a special challenge during our work: immersing ourselves in the world of the young virtuoso composer/ pianist Beethoven TOTAL: 74:43 yet sometimes on the same day confronting the completely different demands of the late Beethoven. Speaking of the virtuoso Beethoven, in the first two sonatas he usually gives himself (the keyboard player) that role, while in the variations — and in occasional flashes in the sonatas — he shows that, thanks to the proximity of the great cellists Duport and Romberg, he knew perfectly well what the cello was capable of. With the last three sonatas the cello and piano are presented as perfectly equal partners for the first time. So here we are, a frozen moment taken out of an ongoing process, the eternal conflict when making a recording. But what an amazing, exciting, and challenging time David and I had! —Jaap ter Linden 2 7 TANYA ROSEN-JONES Disc TwoDisc 5-12 14 19 16 18 15 13 17 4 3 2 1 Allegro fugato Adagio con molto sentimento d’affetto Allegro con brio Sonata op. 102 no. 2inDmajor Allegro vivace Adagio —Tempo d’Andante Allegro vivace Andante Sonata op. 102 no. 1inCmajor Seven variations on“BeiMännernwelche Liebefühlen,” WoO 46 Allegro vivace Adagio cantabile Scherzo: Allegro molto Allegro manontanto Sonata op. 69 inAmajor TOTAL: 72:07 13:04 6:50 8:02 4:39 5:43 5:24 7:24 2:39 2:29 9:52 1:30 4:31 3 A Project with Deep Roots

I first became interested in historical keyboards as a piano student in Boston in the 1970’s. Boston was then, and is still, an early music center, and I had frequent opportunities to hear renaissance and baroque ensembles in concert. I eventually decided to take some lessons with Robert Hill, freshly returned from Amsterdam where he had been studying with . The first early piano I encountered was one that Robert’s brother Keith built and brought to Boston. My first reaction after playing a few passages was “Ah! Beethoven’s cello sonatas!” I had been struggling with the G minor sonata, and it became obvious to me that the brilliant passagework for the piano—which drowns out the cello unless played mp instead of ff as Beethoven indicates—would work perfectly if only I had a piano like this… That finally happened in 1987, when I began doctoral studies with at . Since then I have had the rare privilege—with excellent instruments and fabulous colleagues—of rediscovering the monuments of Classical chamber music (sonatas and trios of Haydn, Mozart and Beethoven) in historical style. I first met Jaap ter Linden at the Royal Conservatory in The Hague in 2002. I was visiting European Early Music departments on my sabbatical leave from Oberlin, looking for places for our students to continue their studies after graduation. At the same time, Jaap and his violinist colleague Elizabeth Wallfisch were looking for a fortepianist with whom to play trios. And so the Oberlin Fortepiano Trio was born. I had known of Jaap for years, from his many recordings of Baroque repertoire, but I didn’t know of his love and affinity for music of the early nineteenth century. Some of the most rewarding hours of my life were spent with those two, working on the great trios by Beethoven, Schubert, and Mendelssohn. Finally, it has been both an honor and a delight for me that both of these players approached me with the idea of recording the Beethoven sonatas for their respective instruments. It’s been a great journey. —David Breitman

JENNIFER MANNA 5 BEETHOVEN: THE MUSIC FOR PIANO AND CELLO DAVID BREITMAN, FORTEPIANO | JAAP TER LINDEN, CELLO NI 6362

15:11 9:52 25:11 13:25 27:41 19:23 25:37 10:30 74:43 72:07 TOTAL: TOTAL: TOTAL: TOTAL: CELLO | 2018 Wyastone Estate Limited Wyastone Estate 2018 Limited Wyastone Estate 2018 Made in the UK by Nimbus Records P © http://www.wyastone.co.uk FORTEPIANO — JAAP TER LINDEN — JAAP FORTEPIANO |

Disc Two in A major 69 op. Sonata 46 WoO Liebe fühlen,” on “Bei Männern welche variations Seven 1 in C major no. 102 op. Sonata 2 in D major no. 102 op. Sonata Disc One 1 in F major 5 no. op. Sonata 66 op. oder Weibchen,” on “Ein Mädchen variations Twelve 2 in G minor 5 no. op. Sonata 45 WoO comes,” hero conqu’ring on “See the variations Twelve

1-3 1-4 5-12 4-16 17-19 17-19 13-16 20-32 DAVID BREITMAN DAVID

The Music for Piano and Cello and Piano for The Music Ludwig van Beethoven Ludwig

BEETHOVEN: THE MUSIC FOR PIANO AND CELLO DAVID BREITMAN, FORTEPIANO | JAAP TER LINDEN, CELLO NI 6362