Best Buys are bolded below and summarized in a separate section
WINERY* WINE / APPELATION & YEAR AWARDS & RECOGNITION RATINGS PRICE MSRP
Clos 56 Pomerol 13/14/15 15 95%Merlot-5CF 15 RP=? 12 Gault&M=16 (88) 12 Bettane&D=15 11 WineFront=90 10 Vinum=14 Ad Francos Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 RP=? 14 WE=92 10 WE=90 09 Bettane&D=14.5 A Nos Amours Par Fourcas Bordeaux 14/15/16 16 TWCI=90 14 TWCI=88 14 $25 Zachys 10 RP=88 09 RP=86-88 Dom de l’A Cotes de Castillon 13/14/15/16 16 RP=87-89 16 TWCI=93 15 80%Merlot-20CF 15 RP=87-89 15 $18-30WineS 15 WS=92 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=92 14 $50 WE 14 W&S=88 14 $47 W&S 10 70%Merlot-25%CF-5%CS 10 TWCI=91-93 10/09 ST=89 09 RP=90-92 08 WS=88 08 $26 WS 08 JJB=90-92 08 RP=89-91 Ch d’Abzac Bordeaux Sup 14/15/16 16 Silver LA 17 15 Gold LA 17 15 LA=92 13 Gilbert&G=77 12 Gilbert&G=85 12 Gold Macon 14 12/11 JR=16 (88) 11 Gold Challenge 14 10 Silver Concours Feminalise 13 10 Gilbert&G=85 09/08 Gold Bordeaux 11/10 Ch d’Achambeau Graves 13/14/15 15 RP=88-90 15 $13 K&L 15 JS=91 15 CT=89.7 (3) 10 Gold Concours Feminalise 14 10 Gault&M=13.5 Ad Francois Bordeaux 13/14/15 14 RP=86
10 RP=88 10 $20 RP Francs Cotes de Bordeaux 14/15 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=92 14 $45 WE
Adaugusta St-Emilion 13/14/15 Merlot-CF 15 TWCI=88-90 10 ST=86 09 Great Value at $25 WBlB 09 WBlB=90 09 ST=87 Ad Vitam Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 RP=87-89 10 RP=87 10 $20-25 RP 10 JR=14.5 (82) 09 RP=88-90 08 RP=86-88 Ch d’Agassac Haut Medoc Cru Bourgeois Sup 13/14/15/16 16 RP=86-88 16 TWCI=89 15 RP=86? 15 $10-17WineS 15/14 TWCI=88 1
15/14 JR=16 (88) 14 Editor’s Choice WE 14 WE=90 14/13 $25 WE 14 RP=84 14 $20 wine.com 14 JS=92 14 $18 K&L 13 Editor’s Choice WE 13 WE=90 13 RP=85-87 13 JR=15 (82) 12 Gold Paris 14 12 TWCI=86 12 Editor’s Choice WE 12 WE=91 12 $29 WE 12 JR=16 (88) 11/10 Silver decanter 15 11 JR=15.5 (86) 11 Cited Wine Hachette 15 11 WE=90 10 W&S=90 10 WS=90 10 WE=90 10 RP=88 10 ST=86 10 TWCI=87 09 One of 10 Best Values Decanter 09 Decanter=4star 09 $25 TW&M 09 Decanter=16.5 09 TWCI=89
Ch D’Aiguilhe Castillon Cotes de Bordeaux 13/14/15/16/17/18 18 JS=92-93 18 $25 wine.com 18 JD=91-93 18 Decanter=92 16 WS=91-94 16 JS=90-92 16/15 TWCI=93 16/15 RP=90-92 15 85%Merlot-15CF 15 RP=90-92 15 $25 JJB 15 Smart Buy #5 Top Value < $30 WS 15 WS=91-94 15 $25 wine.com 15 JCLee=91 15 $26 Zachys 15 JDunnick=92 15 $27 K&L. 15 Decanter=91 15 $28 Millesima 14 #18 Top Values < $30 WS 14 WS=91 14 $30 WS 14 80%Merlor-CF 14 RP=90-92 14 $24 WHouse 14 WE=91 14 TWCI=90 14 JR=15 (84) 13 WS=87 14 $25 WS 13 RP=87-89 13 TWCI=87 12 Editor’s Choice WE 12 WE=90 12 $18 WE 12/11 Very Suiccessful Hachette 16/15 12 JR=16 (88) 12/11 TWCI=90 11 JR=16.5 (90) 10 80%Merlot-20%CF 10 RP=91 10 Vin Remarquable Hachette 14 10 ST=89 10 TWCI=90-92 10/09/08 TWCI=91 09 Very Successful Hachette 13 09 ST=89 09 RP=88-90 08 RP=90-92 08 WS=88 08 $22 WS 08 JJB=88-91 Ch D’Aiguilhe Querre Cotes de Castillon 13/14/15/16 16 RP86-88 14 RP=87 13 RP=81-83 12 Editor’s Choice WE 12 WE=90 12 $18 WE 10 WS=89 10 $14 WS 10 RP=87 09 Outperformed Price JJB 09 JJB=91-93 09 RP=88-90
Ch Alcee Castillon Cotes de Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 Top Value < $30 WS 15 WS=90 15 $29 WS
2
15 RP=90-92 14 WS=89 14 RP=88-90 Alter Ego de Ch Palmer Margaux (Ch Palmer’s second wine) 15 RP=90-92 15 $64-80WAlert 15 WS=92 15 $70 WS 14 Decanter=90 13 WS=BT 10/09 ST=88 09 $55+ ST 10/09 51%Merlot- 49%CS 09 RP=89-92 09 WBlB=90 08 RP=89-90 08 WE=88-90 08 WS=87-90 08 JJB=87-89 07 ST=87 07 RP=87-89 07 WS=86-89 07 RP=87-89 Amiral de Beychevelle See: Ch Beychevelle
Ch Ampelia Cotes de Castillon 12/13/14/15 15 RP=90-92 14 WS=89 14 $16 WS 14 RP=84-86 10 RP=89 09 Great Value a4 $21 WBlB 09 WBlB=87 09 RP=87-89 Ch l’Ancien Lalande-de-Pomerol 13/14/15 15 RP=90-92 10 Bronze IWC 12 10 Merlot
Domaine Andron Haut-Medoc 13/14/15 14 WS=88 14 $30 WS 13 WS=87 14 429 WS Ch Aney Haut-Medoc Cru Bourgeois 12/13/14/15 15 CT=3.8 (2) 14 WS=88 14 $26 WS 14 RP=82 14 $26 Astor 14 WE=85 14 $24 KermitL 14 Vivino=3.8 (14) 13 WS=84 13 $25 WS 13 Gilbert&G=85 13 $22 WClub 12 Bronze Decanter 15 12 Gilbert&G=87 12 WE=85 12 $25 WE 11 Gilbert&G=88 10 Gold Bruxelles 13 10 Gilbert&G=86 10 JR=16 (88) 09 Gold Bordeaux 12 Ch Angelique Monbousquet St-Emilion 12/13/14/15 15 RP=85-87 14 RP=87 14 $13 RP 13 RP=83 Les Angelots de Gracia St-Emilion 12/13/14/15 Gloria’s second wine 15 80%Merlot-20CF 15 RP=90-92 15 $50 WAlert 08 RP=91-93 07 RP=80 07 ST=88 06 RP=89 06 ST=88-90 05 RP=91-93 Ch l’Angelus St-Emilion PGC 15 RP=95-97 15 $330-419 RP 15 WS=96 15 $365 WS 15 TWCI=98-100 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=97 14 $285 WE 14 WS=95 14 $247 WS 14 Decanter=95 13 Cellar Selection WE 13 WE=94 13 WS=91 13 $269 WS 12 Cellae Selection WE 12 WE=94 10 55%Merlot-45%CF 10 ST=91 3
10 TWCI=96-98 09 60%M-CF 09 WE=95 09 ST=92 09 WBlB=96 09 RP=96-100 09 Decanter=5star 09 Decanter=18.5/20 08 WE=94 08 RP=92-94 08 ST=90 08 WS=89-92 08 JJB=90-92/89-91 07 RP=92 07 WE=92 07 WS=88-91 07 ST=91 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 06 06 RP=95 06 Coup de Coeurs Hachette 06 06 WE=92/96/97 06 WE=94/95 06 Decent WD 06 WD=15-16/20 06 RP=92-95 06 ST=92-93 06 WS=93 05 Rec’d to Highly Rec’d W&S 4/06 05 W&S=96 05 Magnificently concentrated WW 06 05 WS=96 05 $295 WS 05 Magnificent SS in Decanter 06 05 RP=96-99 05 SS=19/20 05 ST=96 05 WW=96-98 05 WE=94 04 RP=92-94 04 WS=91 04 ST=91
See also their second label Carillon d’Angelus
Ch d’Angludet Margaux Cru Bourgeois Sup 12/13/14/15 14 WS=88 13 WS= 10 50%CS-38%Merlot-12%PV 10 ST=88 09 ST=88 09 $33+ ST 09 RP=88-91 08 WE=90-92 08 Decanter=4star 08 SS=16.5/20 08 RP=85-87 07 RP=87 07 WS=87 06 Top Pick K&L 06 RP=87 06 Cited Wine Hachette 10 06 WS=88 06 $29 WS 06 AG=88 06 WE=89 05 Rec’d to Highly Rec’d W&S 4/06 05 W&S=1-1½star 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 WS=90 05 $53 WS 05 ST=87-90 05 WE=88/88 05 RP=90-92 05 SS=17/20
Ch de l’Annonciation St-Emilion 13/14/15 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=91 14 $65 WE 12/11 WE=90 Ch Anthonic Moulis-en-Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=90+ 14 RP=88 14 $12-28 RP 12 Editor’s Choice WE 12 WE=91 12 $29 WE 10 RP=86 09 Gold Paris 11 09 WE=89 4
07 WE=90 07 $30 WE 06/05 Very Successful Hachette 10/09 05 IWR=91 Ch d’Anvichar Cotes de Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 Gold BofClass LA 17 15 LA=94 15 Decanter=87 14 Gold LA 17 14 LA=91 14 Decanter=84 14 Gilbert&G=84 Arbo See: Vignobles Arbo
Ch d’Archambeau Graves 13/14/15 15 RP=88-90 15 $13 K&L 10 Gault&M=13.5 07 Gault&M=15 05 Cited Wine Hachette 08 05 WS=84
Ch L’Archange St-Emilion 13/14/15/16 15 WS=91 14 WS=90 08 WS=87 07 Silver Brussels 09 07 WS=84-87 06 WS=89 06 $37 WS 05 WS=91 05 $41WS 05 NM=92
Ch d’Arce Castillon Cotes de Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 RP=90-92 15 $20WAlert 15 WS=89 15 $20 WS 14 WS=88 14 $36 WS 14 RP=90 Ch d’Arcins (Castel) Haut-Medoc 13/14/15 15 ws=86 15/14 $25 WS 15 RP=87+ 14 WS=86 14 RP=90 13 WS=83 13 $22 WS 10 Silver Decanter; Bronze IWC 12 10 RP=88 10 Bronze IWC 12 10 WS=87 10 $25 WS 10 CS-Merlot
Ch d’Argadens (Sichel) Bordeaus Superieur 13/14/15/16 16 $14 WineCh 15 WS=87 15 $14 WS 14 Best Buy WE 14 WE=88 14 $13 WE 14 WS=86 14 $16 WineCh 14 Decanter=87 12/11 Bronze Deacter 15 12 W&S=87 12 $17 WineCh 10 Bronze Paris 12 09 Comm’d IWC 13 09 Falstaff=90 Ch d’Argan Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=82? 13 Gilbert&G=81 10 Silver Challenge 13 10 JR=16.5 (90) 09 Silver Macon 12 09 JR=16 (88) ‘ 09 Bronze Bordeaux 12 08 Silver Challenge 10 Ch L’Argenteyre Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=90 13 WS=84 13 $17 WS 12 Editor’s Choice WE 12 WE=90 12 $20 WE 10 Rec’d Decanter 10 WS=90 10 $19 WS 10 Silver Paris 12 10 WE=87 10 Decanter=15 (84) Ch L’Argilus du Roi St-Estephe 13/14/15 15 RP=84 11 Cited Wine Hachette 15 10 Gilbert&G=86 09 Gold Bordeaux 12 Ch d’Armailhac Paulliac 5th Cru Classe 12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 JS=93-94 18 $50 wine.com 18 Decanter=94 18 JD=92/94 18 WS=91-94 15 60%CS-29Merlot-9CF-2PV 15 RP=89-91 15 WS=92 15 $47 WS 14 WS=91 14 $36 WS 5
13 WS=88 13 $39 WS 11 GDP=91 10 60%CS-23%Merlot-15%CF-2%PV 10 ST=86 10 JJB=91 09 ST=90 09 60%CS-24%M-14%CF-PV 09 RP=90-93 08 WS=89 08 RP=88-90 08 WS=89 08 JJB=86-88 08 JJB=85-87 07 RP=87 07 ST=90 07 WS=86-89 06 Very successful Hachette 10 06 RP=91 06 WE=88 06 ST=88-89 06 WS=89 06 AG=90
Ch Arnaucosse (Magrez) Bordeaux CS-Merlot 14/15/16 16 Silver LA 17 15 Silver LA 16 14 Silver LA, Paris 15 14 WE=88 14 Gilbert&G=83 13 Bronze Bordeaux 14 12 Best Buy WE 12 WE=88 12 $10 WE 11 WE=87 10 Silver Paris 11 Ch Arnaule Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 RP=90 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=92 14 $50 WE 10 RP=86 Ch des Arnauds Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 WE=85 15/14 $10 WE 14 Best Buy WE 14 WE=87 14 $20 wine.com 14 Silver Paris 15 13 Gold Bordeaux 14 12/11 Very Successful Hachette 16 12 Bronze Bordeaux 13
Lalande de Pomerol Ch des Capucins 14/15 12 Editor’s Choice WE 12 WE=91 12 $20 WE 12 Gilbert&G=87 10 Bronze Macon 12 Caves Arnozan Bordeaux Res des Chartons 12/13/14 14 WS=83 14 $25 WS
Aromes de Pavie St Emilion St-Emilion 12/13/14/15 15 66%Merlot-21CF-13CS 15 RP=86-88 15 $83 WAlert 15 WS=90 Ch les Arromans Bordeaux 14/15 12 Best Buy WE 12 WE=87 12 $12 WE 10 WS=87 10 $12 WS 10 WE=88 10 $15 WE
Ch l’Arrosee St-Emilion GC 12/13/14/15 12 JCLee=90 12 $80/1.5Costco 11 TWCI=92 11 $40 K&L 11 JCLee=86 10 Cited Wine Hachette 14 10 ST=88 10 $45 ST 10 JR=16 (88) 10/09/08 TWCI=90 09 One of 10 Best Values Decanter 09 Decanter=4star 09 Decanter=17/20 09 ST=88 09 RP=92-94 09 JR=16.5 (90) 08 WS=91 08 RP=90-93 08 WE=89-91 07 ST=86-88 07 RP=89-91 6
Ch D’Arsac Margaux 13/14/15 16 RP=89-91 15 RP=87-89 14 WS=87 14 $20 WS 13 Editor’s Choice WE 13 WE=92 13 $20 WE 13 WS=85 10 WS=90 10 $22 WS 10 RP=88
Ch D’Arthus Bordeaux 13/1415 14 Decanter=85 14 $11.24 Cost+ 14 Vivino=3.3 (124) Dom d’Arton La Croix d’Argon Res Cotes de Gascogne 14 WE=90 14 $13 WE 12 Silver Paris 14 12 WE=88 11 WE=89 10 RevueFR=13 Ch d’Arveyres Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15 14 Bronze LA 16 14 W&S=NR 14 $18 W&S 12 Gault&M=14.5 10 Bronze LA 13 09 Silver LA 15 09 Gault&M=13 Ch Ascension St-Emilion 13/14/15 15 WS=87 15 $38 WS
Les Asteries St-Emilion GC 12/13/14/1516 16 TWCI=92 15 83%Merlot-17CF 15 RP=92-94 15 $98 WAler 14/13/12 Cellar selection WE 14 WE=94 14 $150 WE 13 WE=93 13 $130 WE 12 WE=93 12 $200 WE 10 83%Merlot-17%CF 10 ST=92 09 80%M-20%CF 09 ST=90 09 WE=93 09 RP=95-97 08 ST=90 08 RP=94-96 07 RP=90 07 85%Merlot-15%CF 07 ST=88 06 Cellar Selection WE 06 WE=92 06 $135 WE 06 RP=93+ 06 ST=89-92 06 WS=90 06 $150 WS 05 Cellar Selection WE 05 WE=94 05 $189 WE 05 RP=92-94 05 ST=92 05 WS=90 05 $190 WS 04 Editor’s Choice WE 04 WE=91 04 WS=88 04 $188 WS
Ch de L’Aubrade Bordeaux 14/15 15 Gold LA 17 15 LA=93 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=86 15 $10 WE 15 WS=93 14 Cited Wine Hachette 17 14 WS=84 14 $12 WS 14 Gold LA 17 14 LA=92 Bordeaux Sup 14/15 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=89 15 $14 WE 14 Silver LA16 14/12 Very Successful Hachette 17 14/12 Gilbert&G=84 12 Gault&M=14 09 Vin Remarquable Hachette 12 09 Silver Bordeaux 11 Auget (Cave de Rauzan) Bordeaux 13/14/15 14 W&S=86 14 $18 W&S 13 W&S=N$ 13 $10 W&S 09 Gold LA 10 Ch Auguste (Vign Mejier) Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15 14 Best Buy WE 14 WE=88 14 $10 WE 10 Gold LA 12 10 LA=91 10 WE=88 10 $15 WE Domaine de l’Aurage Cotes de Castillon 13/14/15/16 16 RP=89-91 15 RP=90-92 15 $25-31WineS 10 85%Merlot-15%CF 10 TWCI=88-90 Aurore de Dauzac Mergaux 13/14/15 15 RP=88-90 14 Falstaff=92 7
14 RevueFR=15.5 13 RP=85 13 $28 RP 13 Gault&M=15.5 13 RevueFR=15.5 Ch Ausone St-Emilion PGC 10/11/12/13/14/15/16/17/18 19 60%CF-40Merlot 18 JS=99-100 18 $790wine.com 18 RP=98-100 18 JD=96-99 18 Decanter=98 17 90% M-10%CF 17 WineS=97 16 TWCI=99 16 JR=17+ 16/15 TWCI=99 15 RP=95-97 15 TWCI=99 15 JR=18.5 (93) 15 G&M=19 15 Falstaff=97-99 15 RevueFR=19.5 15 JCLee=98 15 TWCI=98-100 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=97 14 $530 WE 14 JR=17 14 G&M=18.5 14 TWCI=97 14 Falstaff=94 14 RevueFR=19 14 JCLees=97 14 Decanter=95 13 TWCI=94 13 JR=17.5 13 JS=93 13 WineCellar=94 13 RevueFR=18 12 Coups de Coeur 3 stars Hachette 16 12/11 TWCI=96 12 Cellar Selection WE 12 WE=95 12 $650 WE 12 JR=18 12 JCLee=97 12 RP=96 12 Vinous=95 12 RevueFR=18 11 Coups de Coeur 3 stars Hachette 15 11 JR=17 11 JCLee=95 11 Vinous=92 11 RevueFR=18.5 11 Falstaff=96 10/09 TWCI=97 10 JR=17.5 10 JCLee=98 10 JS=98 10 RP=97 10 Falstaff=100 10 WS=94-97 09 One of Top 15 Decanter 09 Decanter=5star 09 Decanter=19.5/20 09 WBlB=97 09 WE=98 09 ST=94 09 RP=97 09 Vinous=97 09 One of Top 32 JJB 09 JJB=98-100 09 JR=18 09 G&G=97 09 JCLee=97 09 WS=97-100 08 TWCI=98 08 ST=92 8
08 RP=98 08 WS=94 08 $1200 WS 08 WE=97 08 JCLee=96 08 JR=15.5 08 WBlB=96 07 Cellar Selection WE 07 WE=95 07 RP=94 07 WS=91 07 $865 WS 07 ST=92 07 WBlB=93 07 TWCI=94 06 Cellar Selection WE 06 WE=96/97 06 RP=98 06 ST=92-95 06 WS=93 06 $1400 WS 06 TWCI=97 06 JR=17.5 (93) 05 Great Wine W&S 4/06 05 W&S=3-3½stars 05 Velvety, long, seductive WW 06 05 WS=100 05 $2000 WS 05 Outstanding SS in Decanter 06 05 TWCI=100 05 RP=98-100 05 SS=20/20 05 ST=98+ 05 WW=95-98 05 WE=98 04 52% CF-48%M 04 RP=95-97 04 Collectible WS 3/31/07 04 WS=95 04 $350 WS 04 ST=93+ 04 Top 10 WW 06 04 WW=95-96 04 TWCI=95 03 Coups de Coeur 2 stars Hachette 07 03 WS=96 03 $750 WS 03 ST=95+ 03 TWCI=100
See also their second wine: La Chapelle d’Ausone
Ch d’Auzanet Bordeaux Cuvee des Abeilles 14/15/16 15 Gold LA 17 15 LA=92
Avant-Garde Bordeaux Sup 14/15/16 15 RP=88 15 $25 Zachys 12 WE=86 12 WS=87 12 $15 WE Bad Boy (Ch Thunevin) Mauvais Garcon 13/15/16 16/15 TWCI=89 15 RP=87-89 15 $17 RP 14/13 TWCI=87 13 JR=16 (88) 12 TWCI=88 11/10/09/08 TWCI=89
Ch Badette St-Emilion GC 13/14/15 16 TWCI=93 16 $35 JJB 15 92%Merlot-5%CF 15 RP=92-94 15 $25 Zachys 15 JS=93/93 15 $35 JJB 15 TWCI=92 15 Vinous=91 14 RP=91 14 $35 JJB 14 TWCI=87 12 Very Successful Hachette 16 12 TWCI=89 Ch Clos Badon Thunevin St-Emilion GC 12/13/14/15/16 16/15 TWCI=92 15 RP=87-89 15 $23 RP 14 TWCI=89 13 JR=16.5 (90) 13/12 TWCI=88 12 Vin Remarquable Hachette 16 12 JCLee=88
9
11 JR=16 988) 11/10 TWCI=89 10 ST=86 09 Coup de Coeur 3 stars Hachette 13 09 WE=91 09 ST=89 09 RP=87-90 09 JR=17 (92) 09/08 TWCI-90 08 Vin Remarquable Hachette 12 08 RP=89-91 07 Very Successful Hachette 11 07 RP=87-90 07 ST=87 06 RP=90 06 ST=87-89 06 JR=15.5 06/05 WS=89-91 06/05 TWCI=90 Clos des Baies St-Emilion GC 12/13/14/15/16 16 TWCI=91 15 70%Merlot-30CS 15 RP=90-92 15 $48 WineS 15 TWCI=90 14 JCLee=88 13 TWCI=88 13 JCLee=86 12 Vin Remarquable Hachette 16 12 TWCI=89 11 Very Successful Hachette 15 11 JR=15 (84) 10 70%Merlot=30%CF 10 ST=87 10 Vin remarquable Hachette 14 09/08 very Successful Hachette 13 09 WE=88 08 100%Merlot 08 ST=89 Ch Balac Haut-Medoc Cru Bourgeois 13/14/15 15 RP=88 14 RP=87 14 $9 RP 14 Gilbert&G=88 12/11 Very Successful Hachette 16/15 12 WE=88 12 $15 WE 12 Silver Bordeaux 14 12 JR=15.5 (86) 11 JR=16 (88) 10 Bronze Bordeaux 13 08 Coup de Coeur 2 stars Hachette 12 Cote de Baleau St-Emilion GC 13/14/15 16/15 TWCI=90 16 423 K&L 16 $24 wine.com 15 RP=92-94 15 $22-28WAlert 15 Vinous=93/93 15 $22 JJB 15 WS=92 15 $27 K&L 15 JS=92 15 WSW=92 14 JCLee=88 14 TWCI=87 13 TWCI=85 12 JR=14.5 (82) 12 TWCI=87 12 JCLee=86 11 TWCI=88 11 JR=14.5 (82) 10 Cited Wine Hachette 14 10 TWCI=90 10 JR=11 (88) Ch Balestard la Tonnelle St-Emilion GC 15 WS-92 15 RP=? 15 $22-75 15 TWCI=89-91 13 RP=84 10 ST=88 09 Great Value at $29 WBlB 09 WBlB=90 09 ST=87 09 RP=89-92 08 RP=90-93 07 RP=87 07 WS=83-86 06 RP=85 06 WS=88 10
05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 WE=88/88 05 WS=87 Ch Ballan-Larguette Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 WS=83 15 $15 WS 14 Silver LA 16 14 Gilbert&G=84 14 $23 B&M 13 WE=86 13 $15 WE 12 WE=86 12 JR=16 (88) 11 WE=83 11 $20 WE 10 Gold Paris, LA; Bronze Macon 11 10 LA=92 10 55%CS-28%Merlot-17%CF 10 WE=88 10 $15 WE 10 WW=88 10 RC=87
Balthus Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15 15 RP=? 14 RP=89 09 RP=88-90+ 09 Great Value WBlB 09 WBlB=87 08 RP=90-93
Bantegies & Fils Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux Ch Bertineroe 14/15 14 WS=86 14 $14 WS 13 Cited Wine Hachette 15 10/09 Very Successful Hachette 13/12
Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux Haut Bertinerie 14/15 14 WS=87 14 $24 WS
Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux Haut Bert Elegance 14/15 14 WS=87 14 $18 WS
Ch Baracan Cadillac Cotes de Bordeaux 14/15 15 WE=90 15 $17 WE 14 WS=87 14 $17 WS 14 WE=88 14 Gilbert&G=86 10 WE=88 09 Bronze Bordeaux 11 Ch Barbe Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 Cellar Sel WE 15 WE=90 15 $40 WE 14 Editor’s Choice WE 14 WE=92 14/12 $45 WE 12 Editor’s Choice WE 12 WE=90
Ch de Barbe Blanche Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 WS=87 15/14 $22 WS 14 WS=86 14 RP=85-87 13 WS=81 13 $23 WS Lussac-St-Emilion 13/14/15 15 RP=85-87 14 WS=84 14 $28 WS 13 WS=85 13 $35 WS Ch Barde-Haut St-Emilion GC 12/13/14/15 18 JS=95-96 18 $38 wine.com 18 JD=94-96 18 Decanter=94 18 RP=92-94 15 WS=93 15 $39 WS 15 RP=92-94 15 $35-42 RP 15 TWCI=93-95 14 #16 Top Value < $30 WS 14 WS=91 14 $28 WS 14 JS=94 14 $30 JJB 14 Vinous=94 13 WS=88 13 $29 WS 13 RP=88 11 WS 90-93 11 RP 90-92 11 NM 90-92 10 90%Merlot-10%CF 10 ST=87 10 TWCI=91-93 09 65%CS-35%Merlot 09 RP=93-95 09 ST=90 09 WBlB=92 09 WS=89-92 08 Great Value WBlB 08 WBlB=91 11
08 RP=91-93 08 WS=90-93 08 ST=88 07 RP=90-92 07 WS=85-88 07 ST=89 Ch Baret Pessac-Leognan 11/12/13/14 14 WS=88 14 $35 WS 13 RP=84-86 08 WS=89 07 Com’d Decanter 10 07 WS=84-87 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 WS=88 05 WS=89
Le Baron de Brane Margaux 13/14/15/16 Ch Brane Cantenac 2nd wine 16 Vivino=3.8 (6) 15 RP=86-88 15 $22-50 RP 15 TWCI=87 15 Vivino-4.1 (14) 14 Vivino=3.9 (46) 13 Vivino=3.6 (30) 13 $30 WineCh 12 TWCI=85 11 TWCI=84 10 TWCI=87 09 RP=87-88 09 435 TW&M 09 Great Value at $21 WBlB 09 WBlB=87 09 Gilbert&G=90 09 JCLee=91 08 Gikbert&G=89 05 WS=83 05 $34 WS Ch la Barotte Bordeaux 13/14/15 Merlot-CS-CF $9-14 WineS
15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=85 15 $10 WE 12 Bronze Bordeaux 13 11 WE=87 Bordeaux Cuvee Prestige 13/14/15 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=87 15 $11 WE
Ch Barrabaque Cuvee Prestige Canon-Fronsac 13/14/15 15 RP=84-86 15 $16-28 RP 14 RP=84-86 14 $14 WineCh 12/11 Very Successful Hachette 16/15 12 Decanter=90 11 WS=89 10 RP=87 09/08 Vin Remarquable Hachette 13 09 RP=87-89 09 WS=88 07 Coup de Copeur 2 stars Hachette 11 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 RP=90 06 Coup de Coeur Hachette 10
Ch Barrail Saint Andre St-Emilion GC 13/14/15 15 Vinous=86-88 14 RP=88 14 JCLee=85 12 Vinous=89 11 Falstaff=91 11 ST=87-90 Ch Barreyres Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15 15 Silver LA 17 15 WS=86 15 $15 WS 14 Silver LA, Paris, VinalesInt’l 16 14 WS=85 14 $22 WS 14 Decanter=90 14 WE=88 13 Comm’d Decanter 15 13 WE=84 12 Silver LA 16; Macon 14 12 Gault&M=14 12 Cited Wine Hachette 16 11 Silver Bordeaux; Bronze Paris 13 11 WE=90 10 Bronze Macon 13 09 Bronze Decanter 12 08 Silver Bordeaux 10 Haut Medoc 12/13/14/15 15 WS=88 15/14 $25 WS 15 RP=82
12
14 WS=88 11 JR=16.5 (90) 10 Bronze Decanter; Comm’d IWC 12 10 WS=88 10 $25 WS 10 JR=16 (88) 10 Gilbert&G=86 09 JR=16.5 (90) 08 Cab Sauv; Bronze Challemge 10 08 Gilbert&G=85 07 Comm’d Decanter, IWC 09 Ch Barthez Haut Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=83? 14 WS=88 14 $16 WS 14 RP=79-81 Barton & Guestier Bordeaux Merlot-CS 14/15/16 16 Vivino=3.5 (74) 15 Vivino=3.6 (369) 14 W&S=NR 14 $10 W&S 14 WE=87 14 Vivino=3.4 (341) 13 Vivino=3.4 (235) 12 Vivino=3.4 (1023) 11 Bronze Japan 13 11 Vivino=3.5 (971) 10 Best Buy WE 10 WE=85 10 $10 WE 10 Bronze IWSC 12 10 WE=87 10 $18 WE 10 Vivino=3.5 (380) 09 Vivino=3.4 (153) 08/07 WE=84 Bordeaux Sup Laurent Prada 14/15/16 16 Silver LA 17 14 Silver LA 17 14 BTI=84 Bordeaux Les Charmes de Magnol 13/14/15 15 Bronze LA 17 13 W&S=NR 13 $15 W&S 12 Cited Wine Hachette 16 12 Gilbert&G=81 12 Comm’d IWC 15 12 $12 WineCh 11 WE=85 10 Bronze IWC 11 08 Comm’d IWC 10 08 WE=85 Bordeaux Passeport 14/15 15 WS=84 15 $12 WS 14 Best Buy WE 14 WE=87 14 $12 WE 14 WS=84 14 $11 WineCh 11 Bronze Japan 13 10 Bronze IWSC; Comm’d IWC 12 10 WE=85 08 WE=84 Bordeaux Thomas Barton Res 13/14/15 13 WS=84 13 $15 WS 11 WE=85 11 $15 WE 11 Bronze Decanter 14/13 11 W&S=85 11/10 WE=85 10 $12 WE Ch La Bastidette Montagne-Saint-Emilion 13/14/15 12 Best Buy WE 12 WE=90 12 $15 WE 12 Cited Wine Hachette 16 12 Gilbert&G=86 11 Gilbert&G=87 09 Silver Paris 11 Ch la Bastienne Montagne-Saint-Emilion 13/14/15 15 RP=85-87 15 Vinous=87-89 13 Vinous=85-87 10 Gold Paris 13 10 WE=90 10 $68 WE 09/08 Silver Paris 11/10 09 WE=88 08 Bronze Bordeaux 10 Ch Batailly Paulliac 5th Cru Classe 12/13/14/15 15 RP=93-95 15 $56 WAlert 15 WS=92 15 $68 WS 14 WS=90 14 $38 WS 13 WS=87 13 $76 WS 10 78%CS-19%Merlot-2%PV-CF 10 ST=90 09 WE=94 09 ST=89 09 WBlB=92 09 RP=90-92 09 Decanter=4star 09 Decanter=16.5/20 08 WS=90 08 RP=90-92 13
07 Value QRW Autumn 08 07 RP=88+ 07 WE=90 07 $35 WE 07 WS=83 06 Vert Successful Hachette 10 06 RP=91 06 WE=90 06 WS=87 05 Highly Rec’d W&S 4/06 05 W&S=2stars 05 Vin Remarquable Hachette 05 WS=90 05 ST=87-89 05 WE=89/89 Paulliac Lions de Batailly 13/14/15 15 WS=87
Ch Baudan Cru Bourgeois 13/14/15 15 RP=86
Ch Bauvallon Bordeaux 14/15 15 WS=83 15 $9 WS
Ch Beaulieu Comtes de Tastes Bordeaux Sup 12/13/14 14 Best Buy WE 14 WE=88 14 $12 WE 12 RP=79-81 11 RP=84-86 10 One of world’s best values RP 10 RP=84-86 09 WS=88-91 08 RP=86 08 CellarT=87 (13) 03 RP=89 Ch Beaumont Haut-Medoc Sup 14/15/16 16 RP=88-90 16 $14 K&L 16 WE=91-93 16 $15 wine.com 16 JS=91-92 16 TWCI=87 16 CT=87 (1) 15 Editor’s Choice WE 15/14 WE=92 15 $40 WE 15 RP=90-92 15 $15 K&L 15 TWCI=86 15 $15 wine.com 15 JR=16 (88) 15 CT=88 (2) 14 Editor’s Choice WE 14 WE=92 14 $25 WE 14 RP=88 14 $15 K&L 14 JS=90-91 14 TWCI=88 14 JR=16 (88) 14 JCLee=85 13 RP=82-84 13 JR=15 12 Comm’d Decanter 15 12 RP=86 12 WE=92ghhj 12/10 TWCI=85 11 Silver IWC 15 11 RP=79 11 WE=84 10 Very Successful Hachette 14 10 WS=88 10 $22 WS 10 Bronze Decanter 13 10 RP=87 10 JS=91 10 WE=90 09 Merlot-CS-CF 09 ST=87 09 Great Value WBlB 09 JS=90 09 Comm’d Decanter 12 09 WE=89-90 09 RP=85 Ch Beaumont Haut-Medoc Cru Bourgeois 13/14/15/16 16 TWCI=87 16 $15 K&L 16 $16 wine.com 15 RP=90 15 $16 K&L 15 TWCI=86 15 JCLee=90 15 JR=16 (88) 14 TWCI=88 14 $16 K&L 14 JR=16 (88) 14 JCLee=85 13 JR=15 12 Comm’d Decanter 15 12/10 TWCI=85 14
11 Silver IWC 15 11/10 Very Successful Hachette 15/14 10 Bronze DecaNTER 13 09 53%CS-46%Merlot-PV 09 WE=89 09 Silver Bodeaux 11 09 WS=87-90 09 Comm’d Decanter 09 ST=87-89 09 TWCI=86 08 SS=14.5/20 08 Decanter=3star Le Clos du Beau-Pere Pomerol 13/14/15 15 90%Merlot-10CF 15 RP=90-92 15 WS=89 14 WS=87 09 RP=87-88 08 WS=88 07 WS=83-86 06 WS=88 Clos Beauregard Pomerol 13/14/15/16/17/18 18 RP=93-95 18 $65 wine.com 18 JS=93-94 16 TWCI=91 15 RP=90-92 15 $50-61 RP 15 WS=91 15 $54 WS 15 TWCI=89 14 WS=87 14 TWCI=-88 13 WS=87 13 $43 WS 13 TWCI=84 12 TWCI=87 10 75%Merlot-25%CF 10 ST=86 09 ST=87 09 Great Value at $25 WBlB 09 WBlB=89 09 RP=88-90 09 TWCI=87 08 WS=91 08 $19 WS 08 RP=85-87 08 TWCI=88 07 RP=84-86 07 WS=86 07 $22 WS 06 Very Successful Hachette 06 RP=86 06 WS=87 06 $33 WS 06 WE=84 Ch Beau-Sejour Becot St-Emilion GC 12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 WS=96-99 18 $68 wine.com 18 JD=95-97 18 RP=95-97 18 JS=95-96 16/15 TWCI=95 15 RP=93-95 15 TWCI=94-96 15 WS=95 15 $65 WS 15 JCLee=93 15 JR=16 (88) 14 WS=93 14 $51 WS 14 TWCI=93 14 JR=15.5 (86) 13 TWCI-91 12 Very Successful Hachette 16 12 JR=17 (92) 11 Vin Remarquable Hachette 15 12/11 TWCI=93 10 70%Merlot-25%CF-2,5%CS/CF 10 ST=89 10 $80+ ST 10/09 Very Successful Hachette 14/13 10/09 TWCI=94 09 ST=88 09 WBlB=93 09 RP=93-95 09 Decanter=4star 09 Decanter=18/20 08 Very Successful Hachette 12 08 WE=93-95 08 RP=91-93+ 08 WS=88-91 15
08 TWCI=93 07 RP=86-88 07 ST=87 07 TWCI=90 06 Vin Exceptionnel Hachette 10 06 RP=91 06 Coup de Coeur Hachette 10 06 WS=90 06 $62 WS 06 WE=94 06 ST=89-91 06 TWCI=92 Ch Beausejour Fronsac 13/14/15 13 Best Buy WE 13 WE=89 13 $13 WE
Montagne St-Emilion Pentimento 13/14/15 14 $25 Astor 10 CT=91 (14) 09 CT=89 (7) Ch Beausejour-Duffau- St-Emilion PGC 12/13/14/15/16 15 RP=91-93 15 $99-129 RP Lagarrosse 15 WS=96 15 $112 WS 15 TWCI=94-96 14 WS=94 14 $78 WS 13 WS=89 10 ST=90 09 WE=93 09 ST=87 09 WBlB=93 09 RP=96-98+ 09 One of Top 32 JJB 09 JJB=97-99 09 Decanter=4star 09 Decanter=17.5 08 RP=87-89 07 WE=91 07 $45 WE 07 RP=85-87? 07 ST=86 06 RP=89 06 WE=90 06 WS=89-91 06 ST=88-90 05 ST=91+ 05 Highly Rec’d W&S 4/06 05 W&S=2stars 05 WS=92-94 05 WE=89 05 RP=92-94 04 WS=91 04 $40 WS 04 ST=88 04 RP=90
St-Emilion Croix de Beausejour 13/14/15 15 WS=90
Ch Beau-Sejour Becot St-Emilion PGC 12/13/14/15/16 15 Cellar Selection WE 15 WE=96 15 $60 WE 15 WS=95 15 $65 WS 14 WS=93 14 $51 WS 13 WS=90 13 $50 WS 09 WE=95 08 JJB=90-92 08 JJB=88-90 08 WE=93-95 08 RP=91-93 08 WS=88-91 07 Cellar Selection WE 07 WE=93 07 $55 WE 06 WE=94 06 RP=90-92 06 ST=89-91 06 WS=85-88 05 Great balance, superb finish WW 06 05 WS=92-94 05 Very elegant SS in Decanter 06 05 SS=18.5/20 05 Vin Remarquable Hachette 09 05 ST=91-93 05 “Coup de Coeur” Hachette 09 05 WW=93-95 05 WE=93 16
Ch Beausejour Duffau- St Emilion GC 12/13/14/15 16 TWCI=98 16 $109-124 Lagarosse 15 TWCI=95 15 JR=17 (92) 14 WS=94 14 $78 WS 14 TWCI=95 13 TWCI=93 13 $75 JJB 12 TWCI=93 12 JR=16.5 (88) 11 TWCI=96 11 $88 Zachys 11 JR=16.5 (90) 10 TWCI=100 09 TWCI=99 08 Very Successful Hachette 12 08 TWCI=90 07 TWCI=87 07 JR=16 (88) 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 TWCI=88 06 JR=15 (84) 05 TWCI=93 St Emilion Croix de Beausejour GC 12/13/14/15 14 WS=89
Ch Beau-Site St-Esteph 13/14/15/16 16 TWCI=89 16 JR=16 (88) 15 TWCI=84 14 TWCI=87 13 WS=78 13 $42 WS 12/11 Cited Wine Hachette 16/15 12 $33 WineCh 11 JR=16.5 (90) 10 RP=86 10 TWCI=88 09 Silver Paris 11 08 Cited Wine Hachette 12 08 Comm’d Decanter 11 07 WS=84-87 06 WS=86 06 $25 WS Ch Beausoleil Bordeaux Sup 12/13/14 14 Bronze LA 17
Ch Beau Soleil Pomerol 13/14/15 15 RP=88-90 15 JR=16 (88) 14 RP=87 14 $22-28 RP 14 JR=15 984) 13 JCLee=83 12 Cited Wine Hachette 16 11 JCLee=87 10 very Successful Hachette 14 09 Great Value at $23 WBlB 09 WE=88 09 WBlB=88 09 RP=86-88 08 RP=88-90 07 100%Merlot 07 ST=87 07 Cited Wine Hachette 11 06 WS=90 06 $25 WS 06 ST=85-88 Be Bordo Bordeaux Le Deep Red CS 14/15/16 14 WS=84 14 $12 WS
Bordeaux Le Fruity Red 13/14/15 14 WS=83 14 $12 WS 14 W&S=NR 14 Vivino=4.0 (3) 13 Vivino=3.8 (3) 12 Vivino=3.3 (4) Begadan Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=85
Ch de Bel Bordeaux Superieur 13/14/15 15 Editor’s Choice WE 15 WE=90 15 $16 WE 14 WE=87 14 $20 WE 12 WE=86 12 Very Successful Hachette 16 12 RevueFr=13.5 11 Silver LA 11/10 11 RrevueFr=15.5 (86) 17
10 Silver LA 12 10 WS=89 10 $24 WS 10 90%Merlot-10%CabFranc 10 RP=89 10 WE=83 10 $15 WE 09 Gold Bordeauz; Silver LA 11 09 W&S=83 09 $20 W&S 08 Silver Paris 11 Ch de Bel Air Lalande-de-Pomerol 13/14/15/16 16 TWCI=88 15 WS=87 15 RP=88-90 15 TimAtkin=90 15 JR=16.5 (90) 14 WS=86 (88) 12 Very Successful Hachette 16 11 Cited Wine Hachette 15 09 JR=16 08 Gold Bordeaux; Bronze Macon 10 07 Silver Brussels 09 Pomerol 13/14/15 15 RP=84-86 15 $28 WAlert
Ch Bel Air Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=88 15 $13 WE 14 RP=86-88
Ch Bel-Air Lussac-St-Emilion 13/14/15 15 WS=86 15 $23 WS
Lussac-St-Emilion Jean & Gabriel 13/14/15 15 WS=87 15 $35 WS 15 RP=85-87 15 $25 WAlert 15 Vinous=86-88 15 $25 TW&M 14 Vinous=88-90 14 WS=86 14 RP=88 14 $30 RP 12 Vin Remarquable Hachette 16 12 WE=90 10 WE=92 09 WE=91
06 Cited Wine Hachette 10
Ch Bel-Air Puisseguin St-Emilion 12/13/14/15 12 Editor’s Choice WE 12 WE=90 12/10 $25 WE 10 WS=86 10 WE=90 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 Ch Bel Air Gloria Haut Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=89
Ch Belair-Monange (Moeiux)St-Emilion PGC 10/11/12/13/14/15 15 RP=95-97 15 $140-155 15 WS=96 15 $155 WS 15 TWCI=95-97 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=96 14 $160 WE 14 WS=95 14 $130 WS 13 Cellar Selection WE 13WE=94 13 $160 WE 13 WS=93 13 $140 WS 12 Cellar Selection WE 12 WE=94 12 $225 WE 10 ST=91 09 WE=95 09 ST=90 09 WBlB=93 09 RP=94-96+ 09 Decanter=4star 09 Decanter=18/20 08 JJB=88-90 08 RP=93-95+ 08 JJB=86-87 08 ST=89 Ch Bel-Air Ortet St-Estephe 12/13/14/15 12 Cellar Selection WE 12 WE=91 12 $30 WE
Ch Bel-Air-Ouy St-Emilion 10/11/12/13/14/15 15 TWCI=87-89 14 RP=87-89 10 70%Merlot-20%CF-10%CS 10 ST=87 18
09 WE=90 09 ST=87 08 WS=87 Ch Bel Air la Perponcher Bordeaux 12/13/14/15 15 RP=85-87 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=92 14 $35 WE 14 RP=85-87 14 $14-18 RP 09 Bronze Decanter 12 Bordeaux Reserve 10 Bronze Decanter; Comm’d IWC 12 08 Vin Remarquable Hachette 11 08 WS=87 08 Coeur Selection Hachette 11
Ch Bel-Air la Royere Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux Gourmandise 13/14/15 14 WS=85 14 $15WS 09 RP=87-88 08 WS=88 Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux L’Esprit 14/15/16 15 RP=87-89 15 $18-31 WineS 14 WS=87 14 $25 WS
Ch de Belcier Ch de Monrecueil Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=88 15 $13 WE
Castillon Cotes de Bordeaux 10/11/12/14/15 14 WS=88 14 $46 WS 13 WS=78 13 $31 WS 12 92%Merlot-5%CF-3%Malbec 12 CostcoBlog=88 12 $10 Costco 12 WE=91 11 “fantastic value” Vinology.com 11 RC=88 11 WE=91 11 CT=86 (13) 11 wine-s=89 10 WE=88 09 Comm’d Decanter 12 06 Comm’d Decanter 09 06 WS=84 Cotes de Castillon le Pin de Belcier 11/12/13/14 12 WE=90 12 $55 WE 10 WE=89 09 Silver Decanter 12 Ch Belgrave Haut-Medoc 12/13/14/15 15 RP=90-92 $24-73 WineS 15 WS=88 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=92 14 $49 WE 14 WS=89 10 ST=88 10 JJB=90 09 Great Value at $29 WBlB 09 WBlB=90 09 WE=89 09 ST=88 09 WS=92-95 09 RP=88-90+ 08 ST=86 08 RP=88-90 07 WS=82-85 07 RP=83-85 06 Bronze Decanter 09 06 RP=87 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 WS=88 06 $38 WS
05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 WE=89 05 RP=87-89 05 WS=91 05 $28 WS
Ch Belingard Belingard Rouge 14/15/16 14 Best Buy WE 14 WE=85 14 $10 WE
Cotes de Bergerac Res Red 12/13/14/15 14 Best Buy WE 14 WE=90 14 $12 WE 12 Best Buy WE 12 WE=88 12 $13 WE 10 Best Buy WE 10 WE=88 10 $13 WE Ch Belle Coline Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux 14/15/16 16 WS=87-90 15 Top Value WS 15 WS=90 15 $16 WS 15 JR=16 (88) 15 WS=87-89 14 WE=90 14 $20 WE 14 Vinous=90 14 $14 K&L 19
14 JS=89-90 14 WS=86-89 12 WE=86 12 $18 WE 12 WS=87 12 JR=15 (84) 11 G&G=86 Ch Bellefont-Belcier St-Emilion GC 12/13/14/15/16 15 TWCI=92-94 15 WS=92 15 $42 WS 15 RP=92-94 15 $36-40 RP 14 WS=89 14 $50 WS 13 WS=87 13 $40 WS 10 70 Merlot-20%CF-10%CS 10 ST=89 08 WS=87-90 07 RP=86-88 07 WS=87-90 07 ST=86 06 Cited Wine Hachette 10 06 RP=89-91 06 WS=86 06 $33 WS 06 ST=86-88
Ch Belle-Garde Bordeaux 14/15/16 14 WS=86 14 $19 WS 08 WS=86 08 $15 WS 07 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 07 Coup de Coeur Hachette 10 Ch Bellegrave Haut Medoc 12/13/14/15 15 RP=87 15 $16 RP 14 RP=83 10 52%Merlot-41%CS-4%PV-3%CF 10 TWCI=89-91 10 WS=88 10 $20 WS 09 Great Value at $21 WBlB 09 WBlB=87
08 WS=86 Pauillac Cru Bourgeois 14/15 15 RP=86-88 15 $24 WAlert 14 WS=89 14 $25 WS 14 RP=90 09 WE=92 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 WS=88 06 $19 WS
Bellerive Medoc Cru Bourgeois 13/14/15 15 RP=86 14/13 Gilbert&G=86 12 Silver Bordeaux 14 12 Concours Feminalise 14 Ch Belle-Vue Haut Medoc Cru Bourgeois 14/15/16 16 45%CS-35%Merlot-20%PV 16 WDecider=90 16 $17Millesima 16 TWCI=90 15/14 TWCI=91 15 RP=88-90 15 $15 RP 15 WDecider=91 15 $17 WHouse 15 JS=89-91 15 WS=89-91 15 JR=16.5 (90) 14 Editor’s Choice WE 14 WE=92 14 $17 WE 14 JS=91 14 $22 WHouse 14 WS=89 14 RP=88 14 WDecider=90 14 JR=16 (86) 14 JCLee=87 14 TWCVI=90 13 RP=84-86 13 $19 Millesima 13 WDecider=88 13 TWCI=87 13 WS=85 13 $22 WS+ 12/11 Very Successful Hachette 16 12 Decanter=16 (88) 12 JR=16.5 (90) 12/12 TWCI=88 11 Bargain JR 11 JR=17 (92) 11 WDecider=89 20
11 RP=88 10 50%Merlot-30%Malbec-20%PV 10 WS=91 10 $25 WS 10 Vin Remarquable Hachette 14 10 RP=89 10 TWCI=89 10 Decanter=90 09 Cab Sauv 09 RP=90-92 09 3 stars Hachette 14 09 WS=89-91 09 Outperformed Price JJB 09 JJB=91-93 09 TWCI=90 09 WDecider=90 08 WE=90 08 SS=16+/20 08 Decanter=3star 08 RP=88-90 08 TWCI=87 07 Selected by Vine Talk TV 07 WS=83 07 $14 WS 07 RP=88 07 ST=87 Cotes-de-Castillon VV 14/15/16 15 WS=86 15 $18 WS 14 W&S=91 14 $19 W&S 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 03 Cited Wine Hachette 07 St-Emilion GC 12/13/14/15 15 WS=93 15 $47 WS 15 RP=92-94 15 $45 WAlert 06 RP=92-94 05 Highly Rec’d W&S 4/06 05 W&S=2stars 05 WS=89-91 05 RP=94-96 05 SS=15/20 04 Very Successful Hachette 08 04 WS=88 04 $40 WS 04 ST=86-89 04 RP=88 Ch Bellevue Castillon Cotes de Bordeaux Cuvee VV 13/14/15 15 WS=86 15 $18 WS 14 W&S=91 14 $19 W&S Ch Bellevue Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 Silver Paris 16 14 Best Buy WE 14 WE=85 14 $10 WE 14 Gold Paris 15 14 Gilbert&G=82 14 $9 B&M 14 Gault&M=13.5 14/13 W&S=NR 13 $12 W&S 13 Silver Bordeaux 14 13 WE=85 12 WE=86 08 Gold Paris 09; Silver Bordeaux 10 09 RP=92-94
Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15 14 Cited Wine Hachette 17 14 W&S=NR 10 WS=86 10 $15 WS 10 WE=81trt St-Emilion GC 12/13/14/15/16 16 JS=96-98 16 $48 wine.com 16 Vinous=94-96 16 WE=92-94 16 Decanter=93 16 RP=90-92 15 100%Merlot 15 WS=93 15 $47 WS 15 RP=93-95 15 $41-47 RP 15 TWCI=92-94 14 WS=92 14 $39 WS 14 JS=94 14 WE=93 14 Vinous=91 13 WS=90 13 $36 WS 09 WBlB=90 08 ST=88 08 RP=91-93+ 08 JJB=90-92 08 WBlB=91
Bellevue Amphorae Blaye Coted de Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 WE=84 15 $45 WE 21
15 RP=84-86 Ch Belle Vue Belle Vue 14/15/16 15 RP=90 15 $20 WAlert
Ch Bellevue Claribes Bordeaux Sup 14/15/16 15 Gold Paris 16 14 Cited Wine Hachette 17 13 Gold Bruxelles; Silver Bordeaux 14 13 Gilbert&G=83 12/10 Very Successful Hachette 15/14 10 WS=82 10 $20 WS Ch Bellevue La Foret Fronton 12 Best Buy WE 12 WE=88 12 $12 WE 12 Vunum=14 10 WE=86 09 Gault&M=14 08 Vinum=14.5 Ch Bellevue-Mondotte St-Emilion 10/11/12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 JD=96-98 18 $145wine.com 18 JS=96-97 18 RP=95-97 15 WS=93 15 $149 WS 15 RP=91-93 15 $140-150 RP 14 WS=92 14/13 $138 WS 13 WS=90
09 90%M-5%CF-5%CS 09 ST=88 09 RP=95-100 09 One of Top 32 JJB 09 JJB=95-97
08 RP=96-98 08 ST=90 08 JJB=93-95 07 RP=94 07 WS=86-89 07 ST=93 06 Vin Temarquable Hachette 10 06 RP=95+ 06 ST=90-92 06 WS=92-94 05 ST=94 05 WS=97 05 $345 WS 05 RP=96-100 04 WS=92-94? 04 ST=89 04 RP=95
Ch Bellevue Peycharneau Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15/16 14 WS=86 14 $22 WS 13 Very Successful Hachette 17 10 WS=89 10 $18 WS 09 Silver LA 12 08 Gold LA 11 09 LA=93 07 Silver LA 10 Sainte-Foy-Bordeaux 14/15/16 13 Cited Wine Hachette 17
Bellevue La Randee Bordeaux 14/15/16 14 RP=86-88 14 $10 WineH 14 Vivino=3.4 (11) 13 WE=83 11 WS=87-90 09 WS=89
Ch Bellevue de Tayac Margaux 12/13/14/15/16 15 RP=86 14 Cellar Sel WE 14 WE=92 14 $35 WE 14WS=88 14 $30 WS 12 Editor’s Choice WE 12 WE=90 12 $30 WE 10 RP=87 10 ST=87 09 Great Value at $25 WBlB 09 WBlB=89 09 CT=80 (16) 08 RP=81-83 07 WS=81-84 06 Cited Wibe Hachette 10 06 ST=87-88 06 WS=87 22
06 RP=88-90 Ch Bellisle Mondotte St-Emilion GC 12/13/14/15/16 14 WS=92 14 $138 WS 10 90%Merlot-5%CS-5%CF 10 ST=90 09 WS=91-94 08 WS=88 07 WS=85-88 06 Bronze Decanter 10 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 WS=91 05 $30 WS
Ch Bel-Orme Tronquoy de Lalande Haut Medoc 13/14/15 13 RP=85 13 $12 RP 12 JR=14 (80) 10 WS=89 10 $18 WS 10 JR=16.5 (90) 10 CS 10 Decanter=83 09 RevueFr=15 (84) Ch Bel Ormeau Boisvert Cotes de Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 WS=87 15 $30 WS
Les Clos Cotes de Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 WS=87 15 $30 WS
Blaye Les Herits Cotes de Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 WS=89 15 $30 WS
Ch Belvue Bordeaux Cuvee Prestige 15 Vivino=3.3 (80) 12 Best Buy WE 12 WE=87 12 $12 WE
Ch Bensse de Bensse Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=89 13 Gold Paris 15 12 Comm’d IWC 15 12 Gilkbert&G=87 11 Bronze IWC 14 11 Gilbert&G=83 10 SilverBordeaux12; Bruxelles 13 10 JR=15 (84) 09 JR=16 (88) 09 $17 WineCh Ch Berliquet St-Emilion GC 12/13/14/15/16 16 TWCI=93 15 WS=92 15 $39 WS 15 RP=91-93 15 $36-45 RP 15 TWCI=92 14 #17 Top Value < $30 WS 14 WS=91 14 $29 WS 14 TWCI=89 13 WS=90 13 $25 WS 13 TWCI=87 12 TWCI=89 11 TWCI=90 10 ST=90 10 TWCI=91 09 Outperformed Price JJB 09 JJB=93-95 09 ST=87 09 RP=87-89 09 WS=93-96 09 WBlB=90 09 TWCI=90 08 WS=88 08 RP=87-88 08 TWCI=87 07 RP=85-88 07 WS=85-88 07 ST=87 St Emilion Les Ailes de Berliquet 14/15/16 14 WS=99 12 Gault&M=15.5 (86) 07 Gault&M=15 (84) Ch Bernadotte Haut Medoc Cru Bourgeois 13/14/15/16 15 WS=88 15 $40 WS 15 WS RP=88 14 WS=87 14 $40 WS 12 Editor’s Choice WE 12 WE=90 12 $16 WE 12/11 WS=85-88 11 RP=87-89 10 51.5%CS-Merlot 10 RP=89 10 WS=89-92 10 TWCI=88-90 23
10 CostcoBlog=91 09 56%CS-Merlot 09 ST=88 09 RP=89 09 WS=87 09 WBlB=89 08 ST=86 08 WS=87 08 SS=15.5/20 08 Decanter=3star 08 RP=87-88 07 Bronze Decanter, IWC 11 07 WS=83 07 JMQ=87 07 Decanter 16 (88) 07 JR=16 (88)
Ch du Bernat Bordeaux 13/14/15 14 Best Buy WE 14 WE=88 14 $12 WE 14 Bronze Decanter 16 14 RP=88 Ch Bernateau St-Emilion GC 13/14/15 15 TWCI=90 14 RP=88 14 $18 RP 14 Decanter=88 13 Comm’e Decanter 16 12 Cited Wine Hachette 16 12 Gilbert&G=85 12 Bronze Decanter 15 12 Comm’d IWC 15 11 Silver Bruxelles14 10 Comm’d IWC 12 09 Bronze Decanter 12 08 Bronze Decanter 12 08 WS=89 06 Bronze Decanter; Comm’d IWC 10 06 RP=86 06 WS=86 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 WS=90 05 Silver IWC 07
Ch Berthenon Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux 14/15/16 14 WS=87 14 $19 WS
Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux Cuvee Chloe 14/15/16 14 WS=88 14 $34 WS
Blaye Cotes de Cordeaux Cuvee Henri 14/15/16 14 WS=88 14 $29 WS
Ch Bertineau St-Vincent Lalande de Pomerol 13/14/15 15 RP=83-85 10 85%Merlot-15%CF 10 RP=86 10 $25 RP 10 ST=87 09 75%Merlot-25%CF 09 ST=87 09 RP=87-89 09 WBlB=89 08 WS=85 08 $30 WS 08 RP=85-87 Ch Bertinerie Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux 13/14/15 12 Editpr’s Choice WE 12 WE=91 12 $28 WE 10 Merlot-CS 10 WE=89 10 $19 WE
Ch Beychevelle St Julien 4th Cru Classe 11/12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 JD=95-97 18 $90 wine.com 18 WS=94-96 16 TWCI=97 16 $79 JJB 16 RP=96-98 16 $75 K&L 16 WE=94-96 16 $79 Zachys 16 WS=93-96 $160/1.5 wine.c 16 JS=94-95 16 Decanter=94 16 Vinous=91-94 16 WDecider=94 15 42%CS-47%Merlot-7%CF-4%PV 15 TWCI=93.5 15 $74 Sh-L 15 RP=92-94 15 $70 TW&M 15 WE=94 15 $70 K&L 15 JR=17 (92) 15 $71 JJB 15 WS=93 15 $74 Sh-L 15 JS=93 15 $75 Zachys 24
15 Decanter=92 15 $80 wine.com 15 TWCI=94/93 15 $87 WS 15/14 WDecider=92 15 JCLee=93 14 WS=92 14 $66 WS 14 51%Merlot-39%CS-5%PV-5%CF 14 RP=92 14 $73 wine.com 14 Vinous=94 14 $85 Zachys 14 WE=93 14 $77 WClub 14 WW=91 14 $100 TW&M 14 Decanter=90 14 TWCI=93.5 13 WS=89 13 $66 WS 13 TWCI=89/89 13 $80 TW&M 13 WDecider=88 12 47%CS-44%Merlot-4%CF-5%PV 12 WE=95 12/11 Vin Remarquable Hachette 16 12 RP=92 12 JS=92 12 WS=90 12 TWCI=91/91 12 WDecider=91 12 JR=16.5 (90) 11 Silver Macon 13 11 GDP=93 11 TWCI=88/90 11 WDecider=89 10 54%CS-38%Merlot-5%CF-3%PV 10 ST=88 10 $100 TW&M 10 JJB=93 10 WDecider=93 10 Very Successful Hachette 14 10/09 TWCI=94/93/90 09 Vin Remarquable Hachette 13 09 ST=89 09 RP=92-94+ 09 WBlB=92 09 TWCI=93/92/91/92 08 ST=88 08 RP=88-90 08 JJB=88-90 08/07 WDecider=90 08/07 TWCI=88 07 RP=89 07 WE=88 07 WS=84-87 07 ST=89 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 NM=90 & 87 06 Comm’d IWC 12 06 WE=90 06 RP=90 06 ST=88-89 06 WS=88 06 TWCI=90/90 06 JR=16.5 (90) 06 WDecider=89 05 Outstanding for price QWR 05 ST=90 05 Highly Rec’d to great W&S 4/06 05 W&S=2-3stars 05 Fine tannins, medium finish WW 06 05 WS=89 05 $60 WS 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 WE=95/93 05 RP=90-93 05 TWCI=93/91/90 05 JCLee=90 05 WDecider=91 Amiral de Beychevelle St Julien 13/14/15/16 16 TWCI=90 16 WDecider=91 16 JR=16 (88) 15 Cellar Selection WE 15 WE=92 15 $60 WE 15 WS=89 15 $50 WS 15 TWCI=90 15 $44-47Wine-s 15 JR=15 (84) 15 WDecider=90 14 WS=88 25
14 JS=90-91 14 Falstaff=90 14 WDecider=89 13 JS=86 13 WDecider=86 12 45%CS-47%Merlot-8%CF 12 JS=88 12 Gault&M=14 12 Falstaff=89 12 Bettane&D=15.5 12 WDecider=87 Les Bruliers de Beychevelle Haut Medoc 15 Editor’s Choice WE 15 WE=91 15 $31 WE 12 82%Merlot-18%CS 12 WE=90 12 Cited Wine Hachette 16 12 JR=16 10 Hachette=2star 09 Hachette=2star
See also: Ch Bateau
Ch Biac Cadillac Cotes de Bordeaux Cuvee Felix Biac 15 RP=84-86 14 W&S=87 14 $27 W&S
Ch Bibian Listrac-Medoc 13/14/15/16 15 WS=87 15 $20 WS 15 RP=85 14 RP=88 14 $18 RP 10 WS=87 10 $23 WS 10 RP=86 06 RP=86 06 $25 WS Ch Billeron Bouquey St Emilion Calice 14/15/16 15 WS=88 15/14 $20 WS 14 WS=87 Biofull Bordeaux Rouge Merlot 14/15/16 16 Gold LA 17 16 LA=92
Ch de Birot Cotes de Bordeaux 14/15/16 16 WDecider=90 15 WS=88 15 $20 WS 14 WS=84 14 $18 WS 09 RC=88 08 WS=85 08 JJB=84-86
Ch Biston-Brillette Moulis 13/14/15 15 RP=90 10 RP=90 10 $25 RP 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 WS=88 05/04 Very Successful Hachette 09/08 05 WS=90 Ch Blaignan Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=83 14 RP=80 10 Editor’s Choice WE 10 WE=92 10 $16 WE 10 WS=85 10 $22 WS 09 Silver Bruxelles, France Macon 12 09 WS=87 09 Comm’d Decanter 12 09 JR=15.5 (86) Blasson d’Issan Margaux 13/14/15/16 16/15 TWCI=88 15 RP=89-91 15 $26-31 RP 15 TWCI 14 RP=83-85 14 $25 RP 12 TWCI=85 11 TWCI=84 10 TWCI=87
Blason de L’Evangile See: Ch L’Evangile
Ch le Bocage Bordeaux Sup 15/16 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=87 15 $10 WE
Clos la Boheme Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 RP=84? 10 RP=99 10 $18 RP Ch du Bois Chantant Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=89 15 $14 WE 10 Comm’d Decanter 12
Bordeaux Sup Cuvee Laurence H 12/13/14/15 13 WS=84 13 $13 WS 26
12 Best Buy WE 12 WE=90 12 $13 WE 10 WS=86 10 $14 WS Ch du Bois Favereau Bordeaux Eleve en Fut de Chene 14/15/16 14 Very Suyccessful Hachette 17 07 Gold Bordeaux 09 Ch Bois-Malot Bordeaux Sup 14/15 (unoaked) 15 Bronze LA 17 14 WS=75 14 $12 WS 08 Silver LA 11
Bordeaux Sup Tradition 13/14/15 15 Silver LA 17 14 WS=86 14 $15 WS 09 Silver LA 12 08 Bronze LA 11 Bois Mondont Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=83
Ch Bois Noir Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15 15 RP=83-85
Ch Bois Petuis Bordeaux 14/15 15/14 Best Buy WE 15/14 WE=89 15/14 $12 WE 14 Vin Remarquable Hachette 17 12 Snooth=84 Ch Bois Redon Bordeaux Superieur 14/15/16 14 W&S=NR 14 $11 W&S 10 WE=85 10 $10 WE
Ch Bois de Rolland Bordeaus Sup VV 14/15/16 14 WS=85 14 $14 WS
Bordeaux Sup Cuvee Prestige 14/15/16 14 WS=86 14 $18 WS
Ch Bolaire Bordeaux Sup 14/15/16 16 WDecider=90 15 RP=89-91 15 $13 wine.com 15 JS=89-91 15 WS=85 15 $15 WS 15 WDecider=88 15 JR-15.5 (86) 15/14 TWCI=89 14 RP=90 14 WS=?? 14 WDecider=89 13 Best Buy WE 13 WE=86 13 $11 WE 13 WS=84 13 $10 WS 13 RP=87-89 13 WDecider=88 13 TWCI=86 12 Cited Wine Hachette 16 12 TWCI=88 12 JR=14.5 (92) 12 JCLee=81 12/11 WDecider=87 11/10 Vin Remarquable Hachette 15/14 11 TWCI=89 11 JR=16 988) 10 40%PV-35%Merlot-25%CS 10 RP=88 10 TWCI=88 10 WDecider=90 10 JCLee=86 09 TWCI=89 Ch Le Bon Pasteur Pomerol 12/13/14/15 15 RP=90-92 15 $70-80 RP 15 WS=91 15 $83 WS 14 WS=90 14/13 $60 WS 13 WS=89 11 GDP=93 10 ST=90+
Ch Bonalgue Pomerol 13/14/15/16 16 WDecider=89 16 $16/375 16/15 TWCI=89 WineH 15 RP=91-93 15 $24 WineS 15 WDecider=90 15 JR=17 (90) 14 WS=87 14 $54 WS 14 WDecider=91 27
14 TWCI=87 14 JR=16 (88) 13 WDecider=87 13 TWCI=85 12 Very Successful Hachette 16 12 WDecider=89 12 $30 WHouse 12 TWCI=87 12 JCLee=85 11 WDecider=87 10 WDecider=90 10 Gilbert&G=92 10 JCLee=90 10/09/08 TWCI=88 09 Great Value at $25 WBlB 09 WBlB=89 09 RP=89-91 09/08 WDecider=90 08 Gold Paris 11 08 RP=88-90 07/06 Very Successful Hachette 11/10 07 WDecider=87 Ch Le Bonnat Graves 13/14/15 15 WS=87 15 $20 WS 09 Bronze Decanter 12 09 WS=86 08 Comm’d Decanter 12 08 WS=85 09/08 $20 WS Ch Bonnet Bordeaux Res 13/14/15 15 WS=86 15 $16 WS
14 WS=85 14 $18 WS 14 RP=85 14/13 W&S=NR 14/13 $13 W&S 12 Snooth=84 10 Merlot-CS 10 WS=88 10 $15 WS 09 Gold BofClass LA 11 09 LA=93 07 WS=87 07 $15 WS 06 NM=87 Bordeaux Entr-Deux Mers Cuvee Divinus 14/15 14 RP=85-87
See also: Divinius de Ch Bonnet
Ch le Bon Pasteur Pomerol 12/13/14/15/16 16 TWCI=93 16 $80 K&L 15 TWCI 93/93 15 $80 K&L 15 RP=90-92 15 $70-80 RP 15 JCLee=92 15 JR=16.5 (90) 14 TWCI=91/90 14 $70 K&L 14 C$119 14 C$120 BCLS 13 TWCI=89/89 13 JR=14.5 (86) 12/11 Very Successful Hachette 16/15 12 TWCI=90/91 12 $70 TW&M 12 Dec=16 (88) 12 $80 TW&M 12 JR=16.5 (90) 12 $87 Astor 11 TWCI=90/90 11 $50 TrJ 11 WS=90 11 RP=90 10 80%Merlot-20%CF 10 ST=89 10 Vin Remarquable Hachette 14 10 TWCI=93/92 10 $100 TW&M 10 RP=95 10 JS=95 10 WS=91 09 Outpreformed Price JJB 09 JJB=94-96 09 $84 JJB 09/08 Very Successful Hachette 13/12 09 WE=93 09 ST=90 09 RP=92-94 09 TWCI=93 08 WS=87 08 RP=93-96 08 WE=91-93 08 TWCI=90 07 RP=89 07 ST=90 28
06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 RP=90 06 ST=88-90 06 WS=90 06 TWCI=90/90 05 Full-bodied, ripe fruit, long WW 06 05 WS=92 05 Vin Remarquable Hachette 09 05 ST=91+? 05 WE=91 05 TWCI=92/92/93 05 RP=94
Bord’Eaux Merlot du Clos des Moiselles 14/15/16 14 RP=85-87 10 RP=85/87 09 RP=87-88 08 RP=87-88 Ch le Boscq St-Estephe Cru Bourgeois Sup 13/14/15 15 WS=86 15 RP=91 15 $24 WAlert 15 TWCI=85-87 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=93 14 WS=89 14/13 $42 WS 13 WS=87 10 RP=90 09 WE=91 09 RP=87-88 09 Decanter=3star 09 Decanter=16+
Ch Boucasse Vieilles Vignes Madiran 12 Editor’s Choice WE 12/11 WE=94 12/11 $25 WE 12 RC=88 12 $20 K&L 10 Editor’s Choice WE 10 WE=94 19 $20 WE 06 WE=95 06 $50 WE 06 RC=89 Ch Clos Bourbon Cadillac de Bordeaux 14/15/16 14 Best Buy WE 14 WE=90 14 $15 WE
Ch la Bourdieu Medoc 13/14 15 15 RP=84
Ch Bourdieu Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=88 15 $9 WE
Ch le Bourdieu Vertheuil Haut-Medoc 13/14/15 14 Best Buy WE 14 WE=90 14/13 $15 WE 14 RP=87 13 Best Buy WE 13 WE=90 10 WE=84 10 $20 WE Bournac Bordeaux 14/15/16 15 RP=84-86 14 RP=86 Ch Clos Bourbon Cadillac Cotes de Bordeaux 14/15/16 14 Best Buy WE 14 WE=90 14 $15 WE 14 WS=86 Ch le Bourdieu Vertheuil Haut-Medoc 13/14/15 13 Best Buy WE 13 WE=90 13 $15 WE
Ch Bourgneuf Pomerol 12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 WS=93-96 18 $62 wine.com 18 RP=92-94 18 JS=93-94 18 JD=92-94+ 15 RP=90-92 15 $50 RP 15 WS-92 15/14 $48 WS 14 WS=92 14 WS=90 14 $32 WS 13 WS=88 13 $40 WS 10 ST=89 08 WS=89 08 JJB=85-87 07 WS=86-90 07 ST=84 06 RP=89 06 AG=89 Ch Bourgneuf-Vayron Pomerol 13/14/15/16 16 TWCI=90 29
15/14 TWCI=89 13 TWCI=86 12 TWCI=87 11 TWCI=88 10 TWCI=89 09 ST=89 09 WBlB=89 09 TWCI=86 09 RP=86-88 08 ST=88 08 RP=86-88 08 TWCI=85 07 RP=80-84 07 WS=88-89 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 RP=84 06 ST=87-89 06 WS=80 06 $37 WS
Ch Bournac Bordeaux 113/14/15 15 RP=84-86 15 $10 WineS 10 RP=86 10 $16 RP
Ch La Bourree Castillon Cotes de Bordeaux 14/15/16 14 #22 Top Values < $30 WS 14 WS=90 14 $18 WS 14 Cited Wine Hachette 17 14 W&S=88 Bouscat Caduce Bordeaux Sup 14/15/15 14 RP=84 14 $8-13 RP 13 RP=85-87 Bordeaux Sup Cuvee la Gargone 14/15/16 14 RP=87-89 14 $12-15 RP
Bouscaut Caduce Pessac-Leognan 13/14/15 15 RP=86-88 15 $7-13 WineS
Dom de Bouscat La Gargone Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 20%Merlot-20Malbec-18CF-2CS 15 RP=88-90
Ch Bouscaut Pessac-Leognan 13/14/15 15 50%Merlot-48%CS-Malbec 15 JCLee=93 15 JR=16.5 (90) 15 JS=93-96 15 WE=91-93 15 RP=88-90 15 $18-42 WineS 15/14 TWCI=88 14 WE=94/93 14 $50 WE 14 JS=92 14 $25 K&L 14 RP=90 13 Two Stars Hachette 16 13 WS=84 13 $33 WS 13 TWCI=84 13 JR=15 (84) 13 WE=92/89/88 12 Two Stars Coup Coeur Hachette 15 12 TWCI=87/87 12/11 One Star Hachette 16/15 12 JR=16 (88) 12 WE=93/92 11 TWCI=88 11 JR=15 (84) 10 55%Merlot-40%CS-5%Malbec 10 ST=88 10 TWCI=85/88 10 WE=91/91
Graves 14/14/15 15 WS=90 15 $45 WS
Dom Bouscaut La Gargone Cuvee Gargon 13/14/15/16 16 RP=88-90 15 RP=88-90 19 RP=91 14 RP=86 Dom Bouscat Portes l’Am Bordeaux 14/15/16 16 CS 16 RP=88-90 15 RP=88-90 Dom Bouscau Portes l’Am Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15 15 50%Merlot-25%Malbec-25CF 15 RP=90-92
Ch Boutillon Bordeaux 14/15/16 15 Gold LA 17 15 LA=93 30
Bordeaux Sup 14/15/16 14 Silver LA 17
Ch Boutillot Bordeaux Revelations d’Hubert de Bouard 14/15 15 WS=86 15 $17 WS
Ch Boutisse St Emilion 13/14/15 14 WS=88 14 $27 WS 14 RP=90 Ch de la Bouyere Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 WS=86 15/14 $15 WS 14 WS=85 13 WS=86 13 $10 WS 12 Best Buy WE 12 WE=84 12 $8 WE 10 Best Buy WE 10 WE=87 10 $10 WE 10 60%Merlot-30%CS-10%CF 06 WS=84 Ch Boyd-Cantenac Margaux 3rd Cru Classe 12/13/14/15/16 15 RP=91-93 15 $40-43WAlert 14 Decanter=90 13 Coup de Coeur 2 stars Hachette 17 10 Vin Exceptionelle Hachette 13 10 Hachette=4 star 10 Coups de Coeur Hachette 13 10 ST=87 09 Bronze Decanter 12 09 RP=90-92 08 RP=90-92 07 Bronze Decanter 10 07 RP=86-88 07 WS=85-88 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 RP=88 06 WE=87 06 WS=85-88
Ch Branaire-Ducru St-Julien 4th Cru 12/13/14/15/16 15 WS=94 15 $58 WS 15 RP=90-92 15 $50-56 RP 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=94 14 $46 WE 14 WS=93 14 $43 WS 13 Cellar Selection WE 13 WE=93 13 WS=90 13 $44 WS 11 GDP=91 10 70%CS-23.5%Merlot-4.5%CF 10 ST=90/92+ 10 JJB=94 09 ST=92 09 RP=92-95 08 Great Value WBlB 08 WBlB=92 08 RP=91 08 ST=91-93 08 JJB=89-91 07 63%CS-M-PV-CF 07 RP=90 07 WS=87-90 07 ST=90 06 Top Pick K&L 06 WD=15.5-16.5 06 Bronze Decanter 10 06 RP=90+ 06 Editor’s Choice WE 06 WE=92 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 NM=91 06 AG=92 06 ST=91-93
06 WS=90 06 $53 WS 06 WS=89-91 05 Highly Rec’d W&S 4/06 05 RP=94-96 05 #59 Top 100 Wines WE 05 WE=95 05Very Successful Hachette 09 05 W&S=2stars 05 Unusual character, top effort WD 05 WS=92 05 ST=94 05 WW=91-93 05 RW=17-18/20 05 #59 Top 100 wones WE 05 WE=94/95
St Julien Duluc de Branaire-Ducru 14/15/16 15 WS=90 14 WS=89
Ch Branas Grand Poujeaux Moulis-en-Medoc 12/13/14/15/16 15 RP=92 15 $28-30 RP
31
14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=91 14 $30 WE 14 WS=87 10/09 ST=87 09 Silver Decanter 12 09 Decanter=3star 09 Decanter=16+ 08 WS=87 06 Comm’d Decanter 09 06 WS=86 06 $35 WS 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 WE=90 05 Vin Exceptionnel Hachette 09 05 WS=90 05 $35 WS 05 “Coup de Coeur” Hachette 09 Ch du Branda Lussac St-EmilionCh Tour des Agasseaux 14/15 15 WS=86 15 $32 WS 08 ST=86 Lussac-St-Emilion Vieux Ch Chambeau 14/15 15 WS=86 15 $32 WS
Ch la Brande Castillon Cotes de Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 WS=87 15 $22 WS 15 RP=? 14 Editor’s Choice 14 WE=90 14 $18 WE Ch Brande-Bergere Bordeaux Sup Cuvee O’Byrne 13/14/15/16 16 WDecider=90 14 Editor’s Choice WE 14 WE=90 14 $18 WE 13 WS=86 13 $25 WS 09 Bronze Decanter 12 09 WS=87 09/08 $30 WS 08 WS=84 Ch de Brandey Bordeaux Rouge 14/15/16 15 Gold Paris 16 14$23/2btlsB&M 14 Gilbert&G=86 12 Vivino=3.2 (294) 12 CT=88 (1) 11 Gold Bruxelles 12 11 WW=90 11 Silver Bordeaux 12 11 CT=86 (14) 11 Bronze Bordeaux, Challenge Intl 12 10 Gold Bordeaux; Silver Challenge 11 Ch Brane-Cantenac Margaux 2nd Cru 12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 JS=95-96 18 $72 wine.con 18 WE=94-96 18 JD=94-96+ 18 Decanter=95 16 RP=95-98 16 JS=93-96 16 WE=94-96 16 CT=94 (1) 15 Cellar Selection WE 15 WE=96 15 RP=93-95 15 JS=92-94 15 WS=93 15 Decanter=93 15 $67 WS 15 JCLee=96 15 JR=17.5 ((94) 15 CT=96 (3) 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=95 14 $44 WE 14 WS=89 14 $45 WS 14 CT=90.4 (3) 14 $45 TrJ 14 Cecanter=91 13 WS=88 13 $48 WS 13 WE=89 13 JR=16 (88) 13 CT=89.7 (1) 12/11 Very Succesful Hachette 16 12 WE=93 12 WS=90-93 12 RP=90-92 12 CT=89.6 (19) 12 JS=91 12 ST=87-90 12 JR=16.5 (90) 11 CT=89.8 (7) 11 WE=93/92 10 62%CS-30%Merlot-8%CF 10 ST=92/94+ 10 $100 ST 10 Vin Remarquable Hachette 14 10 JJB=94 10 WE=94/93 32
09 53%CS-40%M-CF 09 ST=89 09/08 Very Successful Hachette 13 09 RP=93-95 09 Cellar Selection WE 09 WE=94 08 RP=90-93 08 JJB=88-90 08 CG=90 08 WE=93/90 07 RP=88 07 WE=90 07 WS=84-87 07 ST=88 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 RP=92 06 ST=87-90 06 WS=90 06 $51 WS 06 WE=92 06 JR=16.5 (90) 05 Bal’d, fine tannins, med finish WW 05 WS=92 05 $63 WS 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 ST=91+ 05 WE=94 05 RP=93-95 Margaux Baron de Brane 13/14/15 15 Cellar Selection WE 15 WE=92 15 $30 WE 15 WS=90 15 $32 WS 14 WS=86 14 $16 WS 14 WS=87 14 $32 WS 08 WS=86 08 $25 WS Ch la Branne (Ginestet) Medoc Cuvee Fernand Ginestet 14/15/16 14 RP=90 07 Comm’d Decanter 09/10
Medoc 12/13/14/15 15 WS=88 15 $25 WS 15 RP=89 14 WS=88 14 $20 WS 09 Comm’d Decanter 12 Ch Branon Pessac-Leognan 12/13/14/15 15 WS=94 14 WS=93 14 $62 WS 10 ST=88 09 50%CS-CF-CS 09 ST=91 09 RP=96-98+ 08 RP=94-97 08 ST=89 08 WS=89 07 RP=92-94 07 WS=86-89 07 ST=90 06 Very Good K&L 06 RP=93 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 ST=90-92 06 WS=90 06 $67 WS 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 WS=91 05 $86 WS 05 ST=92+? 05 RP=94-96
Ch de Brandy Bordeaux 14/15/16 16 Vivino=3.3 (6) $23 B&M 15 Gold Paris 16 15 Vivino=3.5 (135) 14 Gilbet&G=86 14 Vivino=3.4 (123) 14 CT=82 (1) 13 Vivino=2.8 (10( 12 Vivino=3.2 (307) 12 CT=88 (1) 12 Silver Bordeaux; Bronze Challenge 11 CT=86.4 (4) 09 Bronze Bordeaux, Challenge 10 09 WW=92 09 JR Ch de Braude (Montgravey Haut-Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=89 14 CS 14 WE=92 14 $25 WE 14 RP=90 14 $19 K&L 13 Bronze IWC 16 13 JR=16 (88) 33
13/12 G&G=86 12 Editor’s Choice WE 12 WE=91 12/19 $17 WE 12 Bronze IWC 15 12 G&G=88 11 Cited Wine Hachette 15 11 JR=16 (88) 10 Editor’s Choice WE 10 WE=91 10 Silver IWC 14 10 WS=89 10 $22 WS 10 Decanter=86 09 Gold IWC 12 07 Cab Sauv; Bronze IWC 10 06 Comm’d Decanter 09 06 WS=82 06 Very Successful Hachette 10
Ch Brehat Castillon Cotes de Bordeaus 13/14/15 14 Editor’s Choice WE 14 WE=90 14 $30 WE 14 WS=88 14 $18 WS Ch Brethous Cadillac Cotes de Bordeaux 13/14/15 14 Editor’s Choice WE 14 WE=91 14 $40 WE 12 Editor’s Choice WE 12 WE=91 12- $35 WE Ch du Breuil Haut-Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=85 14 Editoir’s Choice WE 14 WE=92 14 $17 WE
10 RP=85 Ch Brillette Moulis-en-Medoc 11/12/13/14 15 RP=85 14 Editor’s Choice WE 14 =92 14 $17 WE 14 WS=BT 09 Bronze Decanter 12 Ch Brisson Castillon Cotes de Bordeaux 10/11/12/13/14 15 WS=87 15/14 $20 WS 14 #9 Top Value < $30 WS 14 WS=91 10 RP=86 09 RP=87-89 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 04 Cited Wine Hachette 08 Brondelle Graves 13/14/15 15 RP=85 14 RP=82 Ch Brown (Yvon Mau) Pessac-Leognan 12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 WS=92-95 18 $30 wine.con 18 Decanter=92 18 JS=91-92 16 WDecider=90 15 Top Value < $30 WS 15 WS=91 15 $28 WS 15 RP=90-92 15 $27 RP 14 #1 Top Values < $30 WS 14 WS=92 14 $20 WS 09 Bronze Decanter, IWB 12 09 CS-Merlot-PV 08 WS=91 07 WS=84-87 06 Gold Paris 09 06 WS=88 06 $37 WS 06 vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 WE=89 06 $65 WE 05 Silver Decanter 07; IWC 09 05 ST=88 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 WE=91 05 WS=90 05 $26 WS
04 Comm’d Decanter, IWC 07 04 WE=88 Ch Brulieres de Beychevelle See: Ch beychevelle
Bruignac Bordeaux Ch Donjon 14/15/16 14 Gold LA 17 14 LA=92
Bordeaux Sup 14/15/16 15 Gold BofClass LA 17 15 LA=94
Ch Buisson-Revdon Bordeaux 13/14/15 14 Best Buy WE 14 WE=88 14 $10 WE 14 Gold LA 17 14 LA=92 08 Silver LA 10 Ch Bujeau la Grave Bordeauz 14/15/16 14 WS=84 14 $14 WS
Ch Busquet Lussac St-Emilion 13/14/15 15 RP=89-91 15 $16 K&L 15 WS=68 15 $24 WS 12 G&G=86
34
Ch la Cabanne Pomerol 13/14/15 15 95%Merlot-5CF 15 RP=92-94 15 $33-40WAlert 15 WS=89 15 $60 WS 13 Vin Remarquable Hachette 17 11 GDP=85 10 Bronze Challenge Int’l 13 10 ST=88 10 JJB=92 08 RP=86-88 06 WE=88 06 RP=88 06 WS=87 06 $39 WS 05 Cited Wine Hachette 09 05 WS=91 05 $49 WS 05 WE=88
CABS See: Meuliere CABS
Ch La Caderie Bordeaux Expression 14/15/16 16 Gold BofClass LA 17 16 LA=92
Bordeaux Sup Authentique 14 (org grapes) 14 Silver LA 17
Ch Cadet-Bon St-Emilion GC 13/14/15 Merlot-CF 15 WS=90 14 WS=86 09 Bronze Decanter 12 08 WS=85 08 RP=84-86 07 Com’d Decanter 07 07 RP=85-87 07 $25 RP 07 ST=87 06 Silver Decanter 07 06 RP=86 06 Bronze Decanter 09 06 ST=86-89 06 Cited Wine Hachette 10 06 WS=81 05 ST=90 Ch Cadet Soutard Bordeuax Sup 14/15/16 16 WDecider=86
Bordeaux Sup Dame de Coeur 14/15/16 16 WDecider=87
Ch Cailleteau Bergeron Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux Fut de Chene 13/14/15 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=90 14 $40 WE
Ch Calabre Rouge Bergerac 15/16 15 Decanter=85 15 $11 WHouse 09 Gilbert&G=87 08 Bronze Challenge Int’l du Vin 10 07 WE=84 07 $15 WE 04 RP=88 05 Bronze Bordeaux 06 Ch Calon Segur St-Estephe 3rd Cru 10/11/12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 JD=97-100 18 $118wine.com 18 WS=96-99 18 Vinous=96-99 18 JS=97-98 18 RP=96098 17 WineS=96 15 82%CS-16Merlot-2PV 15 RP=91-93 15 $73-93 RP 15 TWCI=90-92 15 WS=93 15 $79 WS 14 WS=93 14 $62 WS 13/12 Cellar Selection WE 13 WE=96 13 $65WE 13 WS=BT 12 WE=96 12 $70 WE 10 86%CS-7%M-2%PV 10 ST=94/94+ 09 ST=93 09 RP=92-94+ 09 ST=93-96 09 WS=93-96 09 One of Top 32 JJB 09 JJB=95-97 08 Great Value WBlB 08 WBlB=92 08 RP=90-93 08 ST=90 08 WS=88-91 08 JJB=89-91 35
07 RP=87 07 WS=87-90 07 ST=87 07 AG=88 06Very Successful Hachette 10 06 ST=89-92 06 RP=91 06 NM=93 06 WS=92 ` Capbean Gasquelton 15/16/17/18 18 JD=93-95 18 $29 wine.com 18 RP=92-94 15 WS=87 15 $29 WS 14 #23 Top Values < $30 WS 14 WS=90 14 $19 WS 10 ST=87-90 08 RP=85-87 06 RP=85 St Estephe Le Marquis de Calon Segur 13/14/15 13 Editor’s Choice WE 13 WE=92 13 $25 WE 13 WS=86 Calvet Bordeaux Res 11 (Merlot-CS) 11 Bronze Decanter 12 09 Bronze IWSC 12 08 Bronze IWC 10 06 Comm’d IWC 09/10 06 NM=87/86 06 AG=85
Ltd Release 15/16 16 WE=84 16 $10 WE
Grand Res Bordeaux Sup 14/15/16 16 WE=87 16 $17 WE
Ch de Camarsac Bordeaux Sup Cuvee Prestige 13/14/15 15 WS=86 15 $25 WS 10 WS=89 10 $20 WS Ch Cambon la Pelouse Haut-Medoc Cru Bourgeois 13/14/15 15 RP=88 15 $15-43 RP 15 WS-87 15 $20 WS 14 Editor’s Choice WE 14 WE=92 14 $20 WE 14 RP=85 14 WS=88 13 WS=86 13 $16 WS 13 RP=85-86 12 Editor’s Choice WE 12 WE=91 12 $16 WE 10 WS=90 10 $20 WS 10 RP=88 09 RP=90 09 WS=89 09 Bronze Decanter, IWC 12 09 WS=89 09 CS-Merlot-PV 09 RP=90 09 CT=87.5 (35) 09 JR=15.5 (86) 08 SS=15.5/20 08 Decanter=16 (88) Dom de Cambes Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 RP=89-91 15 $38-46WAlert
Ch de Camensac Haut-Medoc 11/12/13/14/15 14 RP=89 14 $26-28 RP 13 WS-BT 11 GDP=87 10 RP=87 10 ST=86 10 JJB=89 08 RP=79-81 07 WS=83-86 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 RP=87 06 WS=87 06 $25 WS 06 WE=90 06 WD=13.5-14.5 05 WW=88-91 Ch Canon St-Emilion PGC 10/11/12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 WS=96-99 18 $120wine.com 18 RP=97-99 18 JS=98-99 18 JD=98+ 36
18 WE=??=97 18 Decanter=97 17 WineS=96 16 JR=17+ 15 Editor’s Choice WE 15 WE=97 15 $190 WE 15 RP=98-100 15 $180-239 RP 15 WS=97 15 $228 WS 14 WS=94 14 $59 WS 14 Decanter=92 13 WS=87 13 $57 WS 11 GDP=94 10 80%Merlot-20%CF 10 ST=89 10 JJB=93 09 One of 10 Best Values Decanter 09 Decanter=5star 09 Comm’d Decanter 12 09 Decanter=18.5/20 09 ST=92 09 $158 ST 09 RP=93-95 08 Bronze Decanter 12 08 RP=90-93 07 RP=90 07 WS=87-90 07 ST=87 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 WE=94/93 06 RP=90 06 ST=87-90 06 WS=90 06 $87 WS 06 RP=89-92 05 Vin Remarquable Hachette 09 05 WS=94 05 $100 WS 05 Good RW 3/06 05 ST=90 05 Classic SS in Decanter 06 05 SS=18/20 05 Best value demanded wines QWR 05 WD=15.5-16.5 05 WE=93/93 05 RP=90-93
Ch Canon-La Gaffeliere St-Emilion GC 10/11/12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 WS=95-98 18 $85 wine.com 18 JD=94-97 18 WE=94-96 18 RP=94-96 15 WS=96 15 $84 WS 15 RP=93-95 14 WS=95 14 $61 WS 13 Cellar Selection WE 13 WE=93 13 WS=92 13 $62 WS 10 55%M-35%CF-10%CS 10 ST=88 /93+ 10 JJB=95 09 ST=89 09 RP=94-95 08 WE=93-95 08 RP=91-93 08 WS=89-92 08 JJB=91-93 07 RP=90 07 AG=88 07 WS=87-90 07 ST=90 06 Very good WD 06 WD=16-17+/20 06 RP=92 06 ST=90-92 06 WS=93 06 $76 WS 05 Great aromas, balanced, big WW 06 05 ST=92+? 05 Excellent WD 4/06 05 WS=95 05 $102 WS 05 One of their greatest Decanter 06 05 WW=92-94 05 RP=92=94 05 SS=18/20 05 WD=17.5-18.5 05 WE=93/94 Ch Cantelys Pessac-Leognan 13/14/15 15 WS=92 37
15 RP=87-89 14 RP=87-89 13 WS=86 13 $20 WS 09 WS=90 09 JS=93 08 WS=86 08 RP=87-88 07 WS=86-89 06 Cited Wine Hachette 10 06 WS=87 Ch Cantemerle Haut-Medoc GC 13/14/15/16 16 WS=88-91 16 $30 K&L 16 WE=94-96 16 $32 wine.com 16 JS=93-95 16 $33 JJB 16 Decanter=93 16 $33 Sh-L 16/15 WDecider=9116 $33 Zachys 15 59%CS-27Merlot-8CF-6PV 15 JCLee=91 15 $16/375ml 15 JR=16 (88) WHouse 15 WS=90 15 $30 wine.com 15 WDecider=91 15 $34 Zachys 15 JS=95-96 15 $33 K&L 15 WE=92-94 15 RP=90-92 15 WS=89-92 15 Decanter=91 15 JebDunnick=91 15 Decanter=91 14 WDecider=90 14 $29 WHouse 14 WS=90 14 $26 WS 14 WE=91-93 14 $33 TW&M 14 JS 93-94 14 $30 wine.com 14 Vinous=92 14 $30 K&L 14 $28 JJB 13 WDecider=87 13 $28 K&L 13 WS=86 13 $30 WS 13 RP= 13 $35 Zachys 13 WE=85-87 12 Very Successful Hachette 16 12 WDecider=88 12 $30 WHouse 12 Decanter=16 (88) 12 WS=86-89 12 $30 WClub 12 JS=92 12 $30 K&L 12 Vivino=3.8 (735)12 $37 Astor 12 WE=87-89 12 $40 Sh-L 12/11 JR=15 (84) 12 $39 WineCh 11 CS-Merlot-CF-PV 11 JS=90 11 $43 wine.com 11 Vin Remarquable Hachette 15 11 GDP=88 11 WDecider=89 11 WS=87-90 10/09/08 Very Successful Hachette 14 10 ST=90 10 $50 TW&M 10 JJB=90+ 10 WDecider=91 10 WS=91 10 $42 WS 10 WE=92 09 RP=92-94 09 $50 JJB 09 Cellar Selection WE 09 WE=92 09 WS=91 09 $38 WS 09 Decanter=4star 09 Decanter=17 (92) 09 WDecider=92 08 WS=87 08 $27 WS 08 RP=89-91 08 WDecider=89 08 WE=90-92 07 WS=85 07 $28 WS 07 ST=88 07 RP=90 07 WDecider=86
38
Ch Cantenac St-Emilion GC 12/13/14/15 14 Gilbert&G=90 13 Bronze Decanter 16 13 Gilbert&G=91 12 Cellar Selection WE 12 WE=91 12 $75 WE 12 Gilbert&G=89 11 Cited Wine Hachette 15 11 Gilbert&G=88 11 Silver Decanter, Feminalise 14 10 Gold Feminalise 13 10 Bronze Decanter 12 10 Gilbert&G=90 07 WS=84-87 06 Bronze Decanter 09 06 WS=85 06 $35 WS 05 Cited Wine Hachette 09 05 WS=87 05 $30 WS
Ch Cantenac-Brown Margaux 3rd Cru Classe 11/12/13/14/15/16 15 RP=92-94 15 $47-51 RP 15 WS=94 15 $52 WS 14 WS=94 14 $52 WS 13 WS=89 13 $40 WS 11 GDP=91 10 66%CS-34%Merlot 10 ST=91 10 JJB=93 09 ST=88 09 RP=94-96 09 WS=93-96 09 WE=94 08 ST=89 08 JJB=87-89 08 RP=90-921 07 WS=87 07 RP=86 07 ST=87 06 Good effort WD 06 WD=14-15/20 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 RP=90-92 06 WS=90 06 $73 WS 06 ST=86-88 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 WS=89-91 05 Might be a classic WD 4/06 05 ST=88+? 05 WD=16-17/20 05 WE=89/89 05 RP=87-88 See also second label: Brio de Cantenac Brown
Ch Cantin St Emilion 13/14/15 15 WS=87 15 $36 WS 15 RP=87-89 14 RP=86 14 $22-23 RP 13 WS=85 13 442 WS Ch Cantinot Cotes de Blaye 13/14/15 15 55%Merlot-35CS-10CF 15 RP=89-91 15 $30 RP
Ch Cantinot Orbite Cotes de Blaye 13/14/15 15 Malbec-Merlot 15 RP=87-89 15 $30 RP
Capbern (Gasqueton) St-Estephe 13/14/15/16/17 18 WS=91-94 18 $25 wine.com 18 JB=92-94 18 WE=92-94 18 JS=92-93 17 Most Affordable Pick WineS 17 WineS=91 15 68%CS-28Merlot-4CF 15 RP=88-90 15 $20-5WAlert 15 TWCI=87-89 15 $23 K&L 15 WE=93 15 JS=92 15 JebDunnuck=90 10 73%CS-27%Merlot 10 WS=89 10 $25 WS 10 ST=87 09 RP=85-87 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 Ch Capdet Listrac 13/14/15 15 RP=83
Ch Cap de Faugeres Cotes de Castillon 14/15/16 16 TWCI=91 16 $16 Sh-L 39
16 RP=90-92 16 $15 K&L 16 JS=91-93 16 $16 wine.com 16 Decanter=91 16 $16 Zachys 16/15 WDecider=89 16 CT=91 (2) 15 Top Value WS 15 WS=90 15 $16 WS 15 RP=? 15 $13-16 RP 15 TWCI=89 15 $14 WHouse 15 JS=91-93 15 JCLee=88 15 JR=16 (88) 15 CT=89 (1) 14 RP=87 14 $17 wine.com 14 JS=91 14 TWCI=89 14 JR=16.5 (90) 14 JCLee=86 14 WDecider=9 14 W&S=90 14 $18 W&S 14 CT=87 (2) 13 RP=87-89 13 TWCI=87 13 CT=89 (3) Mouleyre 15/16 16 TWCI=93 16 WDecider=89 15 80%Merlot-20%CF 15 RP=92-94 15 $24-26 15 TWCI=92 15/14 WDecider=92 11 TWCI=89 10 RP=92 10 TWCI=92 09 TWCI=93 Ch Cap Leon Veyrin Listrac-Medoc 10/11/12/13/14/15 15 RP=87 15 $9-10 WinerS 14 RP=87 14 $12-17 RP 13 Editor’s Choice WE 13 WE=90 13 $25 WE 13 WS=84 13 RP=65-70 10 WE=91 10 $30 WE 06 WS=85 Ch Cap de Mourlin St-Emilion GC 13/14/15 15 RP=87-89 15 $30 RP 14 RP=87 14 $27 RP 13 RP=74-76 09 RP=87-89 08 WS=87 08 RP=88-90 07 RP=87-88 07 WS=85-88 Cap St George St Emilion 13/14/15 15 RP=89-91 15 $17-18 RP 14 RP=87 13 RP=87-88 Ch Cap Saint-Martin Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=91 15 $13 WE
Ch Carbonnieux Pessac-Leognan GC 13/14/15/16/17/18 18 WS=93-96 18 $38 wine.com 18 WE=93-95 18 Decanter=94 16 JS=93-95 16 WE=93-95 16 RP=92-94 16 WS=90-93 16 Decanter=92 16 TWCI=87 15 TWCI=91 15 JCLee=91 15 JR=17 (92) 15 WE=93-95 15 WE=92-94 40
15 WS=92 15 $36 WS 15 RP=91-93 15 JCLee=91 14 Silver TEXSOM 17 14 TWCI=87 14 WE=92/92 14 WS=90 14 RP=92 13 Very Successful Hachette 16 13 WS=86 13 $31 WS 13 TWCI=86 13 WE=92/89 13 RP=89 13 WS=86 13 $31 WS 12 Cited Wine Hachette 16 12 TWCI=88 12 Very Successful Hachette 15 12 JR=16.5 (90) 12 Cellar Selection WE 12 WE=94/91 12 WS=90 12 $45 WS 12 RP=91 11 Cited Wine Hachette 15 11 WS=88 11 $30 WS 11 TWCI=87 11 JR=14.5 (82) 11 RP=90+ 10 60%CS-30%Merlot-7%CF 10 ST=88 10 WS=91 10 $40 WS 10 JJB=90 10 WE=93/93 10 RP=90 10/09 TWCI=89 09 ST=89 09 RP=91 09 WE=93/92 09 WS=91 09 $36 WS
08 WS=88 08 ST=88 08 RP=89 08 JJB=82-84 08 TWCI=88 08 WE=92 07 RP=89+ 07 ST=85 Ch la Cardonne Medoc Cru Bourgeois Sup 12/13/14/15 15 RP=89 13 WS=83 13 $25 WS 10 RP=90 10 $22 RP 07 Merlot 07 WE=89 07 $22 WE 06 Silver Challenge 10 06 WS=85 06/05 Very Successful Hachette 10/09 05 WS=87 05 $20 WS Le Carillon d’Angelus St-Emilion GC 13/14/15 15 50%Merlot-40CF-10CS 15 RP=90-92 15 $80-84WAlert 14 WS 09 ST=87 09 RP=88-90 05 WW=91-93 Ch de Carlmagnus Fronsac 12/13/14/15/16 16 RP=83-83 16 $14-15 RP 16 JS=88-90 15 #10 Top Value < $30 WS 15 WS=91 15 $18 WS 15 JS=90-91 14 #25 Top Values < $30 WS 14 WS=90 14 $20 WS 14 RP=90-92 14 $15 K&L 14 JCLee=88 13 RP=85-86 10/09 Cited Wine Hachette 14/13 10 WS=91 10 $18 WS 10 RP=87 10/09 JR=15.5 (86) 09 RP=88-90 09 WS=89-92 08 RP=89-91 Ch de Carles Haut Carles Fronsac 14/15/16 16 RP=89-91 41
15 RP=88-90 14 RP=84-86 13 WS=86 13 $14 WS 13 RP=87-89 09 RP=90-93 08 WS=87 08 RP=90-91+ 08 $25 RP Ch les Carmes-Haut-Brion Pessac-Leognan 12/13/14/15/16/17/18 (Ch Haut Brion) 18 JS=97-98 18 $115wine.com 18 WS=95-98 18 Decanter=98 18 JD=96-98 18 Vinous=95-98 16 TWCI=93 15 75%Merlot-25CS 15 RP=89-91 15 45%CF-30Merlot-25CS 15 RP=92-94 15 $63-73WAler 15 WS=95 15 $68 WS 13 WS=87 13 $51 WS 12 cellar Selection WE 12 WE=92 12 $60 WE 10 ST=88 09 Bronze Decanter 12 09 WE=93 09 ST=89 09 RP=90-92 08 ST=88 08 RP=88-90 07 RP=89 07 WS=83-86 07 ST=88 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 ST=86-89 06 RP=90 06 WS=90 06 $50 WS Ch Caroline Moulis 13/14/15 15 RP=85
Ch de Carolle Graves 13/14/15 15 WS=87 15 $23 WS 13 WS= 10 Comm’d Decanter 12 Ch Caronne-Ste-Gemme Haut-Medoc Cru Bourgeois 13/14/15/16 16 RP=89-91 16 $16 RP 15 RP=86-88 15 $16 RP 14 RP=87 10 Comm’d Decanter 12 10 RP=90 09 One of 10 Best Values Decanter 09 Dec=4star 09 60%CS-37%Merlot-PV 09 Dec=16.5 (90) 09 WS=90 09 RP=86 08 SS=16 (88) 08 Decanter=3star 07 Gold Bordeaux, Challenge 10 07 Comm’d IWC 12 06 Top Pick K&L 06 WS=88 06 $16 WS 06 Comm’d Decanter 09 06 Very Successful Hachette 1005 WS=91 Ch le Carre St-Emilion 12/13/14/15/16 15 85%Merlot-15CF 15 RP=90-92 15 $60-98 10 85%Merlot-15%CF 10 ST=88 09 80%Merlot-20%CF 09 ST=91 09 WE=91 09 RP=93-95+ 08 RP=93-95 07 RP=90 07 ST=87 06 RP=93 06 WE=92 06 WS=90 05 WE=93 05 $138 WE 05 WS=85 05 $120 WS 05 ST=90 Les Carruades de Lafite Pauillac 13/14/15/16/17/18 18 56.5%CS-28Merlot-CF 18 JS=95-96 18 $245wine.com 18 JD=94-96 42
18 RP=92-94 15 57%CS-36Merlot-7CF 15 RP=86-88 15 WS=91 15 $232 WS 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=94 14 $160 WE 14 Decanter=91 10 59%CS-42.5%M-5.1%CF-2.4%PV 10 ST=87 09 51%CS-42%Merlot-CF-PV 09 ST=86 09 RP=92-94+ 08 RP=91-93 08 ST=87 07 WE=87 07 $200 WE 07 ST=85-88 07 RP=90 07 WS=86-89 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 RP=90 06 ST=87-89 06 WS=89 06 $130 WS 05 One of Top 8 “Seconds” QWR 05 ST=91 05 Highly Rec’d to great W&S 4/06 05 W&S=2½stars/4 05 Gorgeous aromas, fine tannins WW 05 WS=89 05 $103 WS 05 Vin Remarquable Hachette 09 05 WE=91 05 RP=89-90 04 ST=88 04 WW=88-91 04 RP=87 04 $50 WS 04 WS=87
Ch Carteau St Emilion 14/15 14 RP=88 14 $14 RP
St-Emilion Cotes Daugay 14/15 15 RP=83-85 15 $18-19 RP 08 WS=89
Dom de Cartujac Haut Medoc Cru Bourgeois 13/14/15 15 RP=81
Ch Castagnac Bordeaux 14/15/16 16 Silver LA 17
Ch le Castelet Pomerol 13/14/15 15 WS=87 15 $60 WS 15 RP=91 Ch Castenet Bordeaux Sup 14/15/16 16 Gold LA 17 16 LA=91 12 Best Buy WE 12 WE=87 12 $12 WE
Ch Castera Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=89
Ch du Castillon Haut-Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=87 08 WE=88 Dom de la Castillon Cotes de Bordeaux 14/15 15 WS=92-95 14 WS=91 14 $49 WS Ch le Castelet St-Emilion 12/13/14/15 15 WS=87 15 $60 WS 14 RP=87-89 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 WS=87 15 $26 WS Ch Castera Medoc 12/13/14 14 RP=83 10 RP=85 10 WE=85 10 $24 WE 09 Comm’d Decanter 12
Cave du Marmandais Murets de Mez 14/15 14/15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=85 15/14 $10 WE 14 WE=86 Ch la Vielle Eglise Cote de Marmandais 14/15 15/14 Best Buy WE 15 WE=90 15/14 $15 WE 14 WE=90 Terrebert Malbec Cotes du MarmaNDAIS 14/15 12 Best Buy WE 12 WE=88 12 $$13 WE
Cave de Mesterrieux Bordeaux 15 15 W&S=NR 15 $12 W&S
Cave de Monsegur Bordeaux Res CF 15 15 Bronze LA 17
43
Oordeaux Heritage 14/15 14 Gold BofClass LA 17 14 LA=93
Cave de Rauzan Augey 14 /15 14 Best Buy WE 14 WE=85 14 $10 WE
Ch Cazenove Bordeaux Suoerieur 13/14/15 15 RP=88 06 Cited Wine Hachette 09 05 W&S=85 05 $17 W&S Ch de Cerons Graves 13/14/15 15 RP=88-90 15 $21 WineS
Ch Certan-Marzelle Pomerol 09 100% Merlot) 09 ST=87 09 RP=91-93 09/07 TWCI=91 08 RP=91-93 08 ST=89 08 JJB=85-87 08=100% Merlot 08 JJB=84-86 07 RP=87 07 WS=85-88 07 ST=85 Ch Certan de May Pomerol 10/11/12/13/14/15/16 15 RP=89-91 15 $125 WAlert 15 WS=92 15 $124 WS 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=94 14 $120 WE 14 WS=92 14 $95 WS 10 ST=85 09 ST=91 09 RP=93-95 09 Decanter=3star 09 Decanter=16/20 08 JJB=90-92 08 RP=91-93 08 ST=90 07 RP=87 07 WS=89-92 07 ST=90 06 Cited Wine Hachette 10 06 NM=89 06 WE=93 06 WS=88 06 $110 WS 06 RP=92 06 ST=89-92 06 WS=89-91 05 Best value QWR 05 WS=93/94 05 $135 WS 05 Vin Remarquable Hachette 09 05 ST=89+? 05 WE=93 05 RP=03-96 Ch de Chambrun Lalande-de-Pomerol 12/13/14 14 RP=85? 10 $18 JJB 09 RP=89-92 08 WS=89 08 RP=90-92 08 $30 RP Ch la Chandelliere Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=90 14 RP=88
Champ de Fleuret Bordeaux Sup 13/14/14/16 16 Silver LA 17 11 Gold BofClass LA 12 11 LA=93 10/09 Silver LA 11/10 Ch Champ du Moulin Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=86 15 $10 WE
Ch Champ des Treilles Bordeaux Le Petit Champs 14/15/16 15 W&S=NR 15 $16 W&S
Champs de Gaillard Bordeaux 14/15/16 15 Silver LA 16
Ch de Chantegrive Graves 14/15/16 16 RP=88-90 16 $15-16 RP 16 TWCI=88 16 CT=88 (2) 15 JCLee=88 15 $16 K&L 15 TWCI=87 14 Gold Mundus Vini 15 14 RP=86-88 14 WE=90-92 14 $16 K&L 44
14 TWCI=85/84 14 JR=16 (88) 13 RP=85-87 13 TWCI=83 13 JR=15.5 (86)
Ch Chantemerle Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux Tradition 13/14/15 14 Editor’s Choice WE 14 WE=91 14 $25 WE 14 RP=81 Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux 13/14/15 12 Editor’s Choice WE 12 WE=90 12 $25 WE
Le Chant des Grenouilles Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 W&S=NR
Le Chant des Grenouilles Boprdeaux 13/14/15 (org grapes) 15 Bronze LA 17
Ch La Chapelle Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 WS=82 15 $13 WS
La Chapelle St-Esteph 13/14/15 14 $20 Costco
Chapelle d’Ausone St-Emilion GC 10/11/12/13/14/15/16 16 56%CF-22Merlot-22CS 16 RP=93-95 16 $185 Zachys 16 WE=93-96 16 $199 JJB 16 Vinous=91-94 16 JS=93-94 16 TWCI=92/93 15 45%Merlot-45CF-10CS 15 JCLee=94 15 $176 JJB 15 JS=94 15 WE=94-96 15 TWCI=93-95 15 Vinous=90-93 15 RP=91-93 15/14 JR=16.5 (90) 14 JCLee=92 14 $170 Zachys 14 RP=92 14 Vinous=92 14 JS=96 13 TWCI=89 12 Cellar Selection WE 12 WE=93 12 $165 WE 12 Vin Remarquable Hachette 16 12 JR=16 (88) 12/11 TWCI=91 10 65%Merlot-20%CF-15%CS 10 ST=88 10 TWCI=92 09 RP=93-95 09 WS=90-93 09 ST=89 09 TWCI=92 08 ST=89 08 WS=89 08 RP=91-93 07 RP=89 07 WS=88 07 ST=87 07 WE=90 07 $140 WE- 06 RP=91 06 WE=92 06 ST=88-91 06 WS=89 06 $125 WS 05 RP=92-94 05 ST=92 05 WS=94 05 $160 WS 05 TWCI=95
La Chapelle de la Mission- Pessac-Leognan 12/13/14/15/16 16/15 TWCI=93 Haut-Brion 15 30%Merlot-25CF-45CS 15 RP=91-93 15 $78-90WAlert 15 WS=93 15 $84 WS 14 TWCI=89 13 TWCI=88 12 TWCI=90 45
11 TWCI=89 10 47%CS-27%merlot-26%CF 10 ST=88 10 TWCI=92 09 46%CS-44%Merlot-CF 09 RP=91-94 09 ST=87 09 TWCI=90 08 WE=91-93 08 RP=87-88+ 08 WS=89 07 64%Merlot-30%CS=6%CF 07 ST=87 07 RP=88 07 WS=85-88 06 WS=88 06 $48 WS 06 ST=88-90 06 TWCI=89 05 WE=90 05 WS=89 05 $52 WS 05 RP=89 05 ST=89+?
Ch La Chapelle aux Moines Saint-Emilion 13/14/15 12 Editor’s Choice WE 12 WE=92 12 $22 WE
La Chapelle de Potensac Medoc 12/13/14/15 15 RP=87-89 15 $30 WineS 14 RP=84 10 RP=85 09 Decanter=3star 09 Decanter=15.5 08 RP=82-84 06 WS=83
Chapoutier, M See: Bila Haut
Ch Charmail Haut-Medoc Cru Bourgeois 14/15/16 16 RP=90-92 16 $17-18 RP 16 TWCI=92 16 $17 Millesima 16 JS=90-92 15 RP=90 15 $19 wine.com 15 JS=90-91 15 $19 JJB 15 TWCI=89 15 JCLee=88 15 JR=16.5 990) 14 Editor’s Choice WE 14 WE=90 14 $19 WE 14 RP=90 14 $20 wine.com 14 JS=91 14 TWCI=88 13 RP=87-88 13 $21 Millesima 13 TWCI=84 13 JR=16 (88) 12/11 Very Successful Hachette 16/15 12 TWCI=88 11 JS=90 11 TWCI=89 11 JR=15.5 (86)
Ch Chasse-Spleen Moulis-en-Medoc Cru Bourgeois 14/15/16 16 RP=92-94 16 $29-30 RP 16 TWCI=90 16 $33 K&L 16 CT=89.8 (2) 16 $33 Zachys 15 RP=87-89 15 $28-33WAlert 15 TWCI=88 15 CT=88 (1) 15 JCLee=88 15 JR=16 (88) 14 TWCI=88 14 $27 TrJ 14 JR=15.5 (86) 13 RP=84 13 TWCI=82 12/11 Very Succersful Hachettre 16/1512 TWCI=88/87 46
12 JR=15 (84) 11 Silver Paris 13 10 Vin Remarquable Hachette 14 10 RP=90 10 ST=86 10 JJB=91 10 TWCI=89 09 Very Successful Hachette 13 09 ST=87 09 RP=90-92 09 WE=91 09 ST=87-90 09 TWCI=88 08 ST=87
Ch Chauvin St-Emilion GC 13/14/15/16 16 TWCI=91 16 $39 Millesima 16 RP=92-94 16 $40 wine.com 16 JS=91-93 16 WS=88-90 16 Decanter=90 16 WDecider=92 16 JR=17 992) 16 CT=91.5 (1) 15 TWCI=91 15 $40 TrJ 15 80%Merlot-14%CF-6%CS 15 JCLee=90 15 $36 JJB 15 JS=93-94 15 $40 WClub 15 WS=89 15 $43 Millesima 15 RP=91-93 15 $60 WS 15 WDecider=93 15 JebDunnuck=92+ 15 JR=16 (88) 15 CT=90.3 (3) 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=93 14 $50 WE 14 TWCI=87 14 $44 Astor 14 JCLee=88 14 RP=86 14 WDecoder=90 14 CT=88 (1) 12 Vin Remarquable Hachette 16 13/12 TWCI=88 12 WDecider=90 11 TWCI=87 11 WDecider=89 10 Very successful Hachette 14 10 TWCI=91 10 JS=93 10 RP=90 10/09 WDecider=91 09 Cited Wine Hachette 13 09 RP=90-93 09 Silver Concours de Feminalism 12 09 TWCI=90 09 WS=90
Ch le Chemin Pomerol 13/14/15 15 RP=86-88
Ch Chemin Royale Moulis 13/14/15 15 #12 Top Value < $30 WS 15 WS=91 15 $18 WS 15 RP=89 La Chenade Lalande-de-Pomerol 13/14/15 15 80%Merlot-20CF 15 RP=91-93 15 $23 WAlert 15 WS=91 15 $18 WS 10 80%Merlot-20%CF 10 ST=87 10 WS=90 10 $21 WS 09 Merlot-CF 09 ST=87 08 WS=86 07 WW=87-89 06 WW=88 Les Chenes de Macquin St-Emilion 13/14/15 15 WS=90
Ch Cheval Blanc St-Emilion PGC 10/11/12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 JS=98-99 18 $700wine.com 18 Vinous=87-100 18 Decanter=98-100 47
18 JD=97-100 18 JS=98-99 18 RP=97-99 ` 17 WineS=95 16 JR=17+ (92+) 16 WineCelIns=97 16 JS=98-99 16 WE=97-99 16 RP=97-99 16 Decanter=98 16 Vinous=96-99 16 TWCI=92 15 JR=18.5 15 55%Merlot-45%CF/CS 15 G&M=19 15 RevueFR=19 15 Falstaff=97-99 15 JCLee=97 15 Vinous=95-97 15 JS=96-97 15 RP=97-99 15 WS=98 15 $781 WS 14 JR=17.5 14 JCLee=95 14 WS=97 14 $485 WS 14 Decanter=95 14 G&M=17.5 14 RevueFR=18.5 13 Cellar Selection WE 13 WE=95 13 $500 WE 13 JR=17 13 WS=93 13 RevueFR=17.5 13 WineCellar=91 13 JCLee=17 (92) 12 Cellar Selection WE 12 WE=95 12 Vinous=97 12 JCLee=91 12 RevueFR=18.5 12 Hachett=2stars 12 G&G=96 11 JR=18 11 G&G=96 11 JCLee=93 11 Falstaff=95 11RevueFR=18 11 Hachett=2stars 10 56%CF-44%Merlot 10 ST=95 10 JR=18.5 10 G&G=97 10 Falstaff=100 10 WineCellar=99 10 JCLee=96 10 Hachette=2stars 09 One of Top 15 Decanter 09 Decanter=5star 09 60%M-40%CF 09 Decanter=19/20 09 ST=96 09 RP=98-100 08 ST=91 08 RP=95-97 08 WE=95-97 08 WS=92-95 07 WS=89-92 07 ST=92 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 WE=97 06 RP=95 06 WE=97 06 ST=92-94 48
06 WS=95 05 Vin Remarquable Hachette 09 05 RP=96-100 05 Best of Vintage W&S 4/06 05 W&S=96 05 Complex, very long WW 05 ST=96+? 04 Top 10 WW 06 05 WS=97 05 WE=96/97 05 WW=97-99 05 SS=19/20 04 RP=90-92 04 ST=90+ 04 WW=97-100 04 WS=94 04/03 Vin Remarq. Hachette 08/07 03 WS=96 03 RP=89 03 ST=91 03 WW=89-92 02 RP=90 02 ST=91+ 02 WS=92 01 RP=93 01 WS=92 01 ST=92+ See also their second wine: Le Petit Cheval
Ch de Cheval Brun Saint-Emilion 13/14/15 15 WS=88 15 $27 WS 12 Editor’s Choice WE 12 WE=90 12 $25 WE
Dom de Chevalier Pessac-Leognan GC 12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 JS=99-100 18 $73 wine.com 18 JD=96-98 18 WS=94-97 15 65%CS-30Merlot-5PV 15 RP=95-97 15 WS=92 15 $69 WS 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=95 14 $55 WE 12 Cellar Selection WE 12 WE=94 10 63%CS-30%M-5%CF-2%PV 10 ST=92 10 JJB=94 09 CS-M-CH-PV 09 WE=94 09 ST=91 09 RP=94-96 09 $68-108 RP 08 Great Value WBlB 08 WBlB=92 08 RP=92-94 08 WS=90-93 08 ST=90 08 JJB=90-92 07 Value < $500 QRW 08 07 RP=91 07 Editor’s Choice WE 07 WE=91 07 $45 WE 07 ST=91 07 WS=88-91 07 ST=93-96 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 RP=92 06 WS=91 06 $46 WS 06 NM=92 06 ST=89-90 06 WD=15-16/20
Chevalier de Lascombes Margaux 13/14/15 15 WS=89 15 $35 WS
Ch Cissac Haut Medoc 12/13/14/15/16 16 RP=88=90 15 WS=88 15 $25 WS 15 RP=90 14 Editor’s Choice WE 14 WE=93 14 $22 WE 10 RP=87 09 Bronze Decanter 12
Ch Citran Haut Medoc Cru Bourgeois Sup 13/14/15/16 16 RP=89-91 16 $16 RP 16 CT=89 (2) 49
16 TWCI=89 15 RP=89-91 15 TWCI=85 15 RP=89-91 15 $17 WAlert 14 WE=891 14 $17 K&L 14 JS=90-91 14 C$35 LCBO 14 RP=89 14 TWCI=87 13 RP=84-86 12 RP=85 12/11 WE=91 11 GDP=86 11 RP=79 10 Very Successful Hachette 14 10 WS=90 10 RP=88 10 WE=89 10 ST=86 10 JS=90-91 10 JR=15.5 (86) 10 JCLee=88 10 TWCI=89
Ch Clairac Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux 14/15 14 Best Buy WE 14 WE=90 14 $15 WE
Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux Grande Res 14/15 14 WS=86 14 $20 WS
Dom du Claouset Bordeaux Sup Res 13/14/15/16 16 Silver LA 17 09/08 Silver LA 12/11
Ch la Clare Medoc 13/14/15 14 WS=88 14 $20 WS 14 RP=86 10 WS=84 10 $25 WS 10 WE=90 10 RP=88 09 70%CabSauv-30%Merlot 09 WS=90 08 WS=88 08 $25 WS
Clarendelle Bordeaux Rouge 14/15/16 16 TWCI=86 15 RP=88 15 $18-20 RP 15 WS=88 14 WS=87 14 $18 WS 14 RP=86 13 RP=85 10 RP=90 St-Emilion 13/14/15 15 WS=89
La Clarence du Haut-Brion Pessac-Leognan 12/13/14/15 15 57%Merlot-42CS-1CF 15 RP=91-93 15 $110-141 15 WS=94 15 $123 WS 13 WS=88 13 $81 WS 10 52%Merlot-36%CS-19%CF-2%PV 10 ST=87 09 ST=90 09 46%Merlot-39%CS-CF 09 RP=90-93 08 RP=89-91 08 WS=88 07 ST=86 07 RP=87 07 WS=85-88 06 ST=88-89 Ch La Clariere Castillon Cotes de Bordeaux 12/13/14/15 15 Silver LA 17 15 WS=87 15 $40 WS 12 Silver LA 17 Ch Clarisse Castillon Cotes de Bordeaux 13/14/15 14 WS=89
Puiseguin St-Emilion 13/14/15 15 86%Merlot-15CF 15 RP=90-92 15 WS=89 15 $30 WS 13 Cited Wine Hachette 17 Puiseguin St-Emilion VV 13/14/15 15 100%Merlot 15 WS=90 15 $40 WS 50
15 RP=90-92 Ch Clarke (Rothschild) Listrac-Medoc Cru Bourgeois Sup 14/15/16 16 JS=91-92 16 $24 K&L 16 Decanter=91. 15 RP=90-92 15 $22 RP 15 JCLee=89 15 $23 K&L 15 WS=88 15 $42 WS 15 RP=90-92 15 JR=16 (88) 15 Decanter=89 15 Falstaff=90-92 15 Gault&M=15.5 (86) 15/14 TWCI=85 14 WE=90-92 14 $20 K&L 14 JS=91 14 JR=16.5 (90) 14 JCLee=81 13 JR=16 (88) 12 Bronze Decanter 16 12 WE=89 12/11 One Star Hachette 16 12 TWCI=85/84 10 RP=87 10 Bronze Decanter 14 10 JJB=89 10 Two Stars Hachette 14 10 WE=91 10 TWCI=88 09 ST=87 09 One 0f 10 Best Values Decanter 09 Decanter=3star 09 Decanter=16/20 09 WS 90-93 09 WE=87 09 TWCI=89
Ch Clauzet St-Estephe Cru Bourgeois Sup 13/14/15 15 RP=88 15 $20 WAlert 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=92 14 $50 WE 10 WS=89 10 $25 WS 09 Silver Decanter 12 08 Bronze Paris 11 08 Decanter=3star 08 SS=15.5/20 Ch la Clemence Pomerol 12/13/14/154/16 15 RP=85-87 15 $92-97WineS 09 Bronze Decanter 12 09 WE=84 09 RP=88-90 08 RP=87-89+ 07 ST=90 07 RP=88-90 07 WS=85-88 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 RP=88+ 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 WS=91 05 $86 WS Ch Clement-Pichon Haut-Medoc Cru Bourgeois Sup 14/15/16/17/16 18 JS=92-93 18 $20 wine.com 18 Decanter=90 15 RP=89-91 15 WS=87 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=91 14 $30 WE 14 RP=84 10 70%Merlot-25%CS-5%CF 10 WS=90 10 $20 WS 10 RP=89 10 ST=86 10 WE=90-92 10 JR=16 (88) 09 RP=89-90 08 SS=15.5/20 08 Decanter=3star
Ch Clement Saint-Jean Medoc Cru Bourgeois 13/14/15 15 RP=78 10 Gold Bordeaux 12. 10 WS=85 10 $15 WS 10 WE=89 10 RP=90 10 JR=14.5 (84) 10 GdP=86 51
Clementin de Pape-Clement Pessac-Leognan 13/14/15 15 70%Merlot-30CS 15 RP=87-89 15 $35-38WAlert 09 RP=87-90 08 RP=88-89 05 WW=89-91 Ch Clerc Milon Paulliac PC 12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 Decanter=96 18 $85 wine.com 18 JS=95-96 18 WS=93-95 18 RP=93-95 15 RP=91-93 15 $59-75WAlert 15 WS=91 15 $68 WS 14 Decanter=91 13/12 Editor’s Choice WE 13 WE=93 13 $59 WE 12 WE=94 12 $62 WE 11 GDP=89 11 $65 GDP 10 50%CS-36%Merlot-11%CF-2%PV 10 ST=90/92+ 10 JJB=90 09 42%CS-40%M-CF-PV 09 ST=90 09 RP=90-92+ 09 Decanter=4star 09 Decanter=17.5 08 WE=93 08 ST=89 08 RP=89-91 08 WS=88-91 08 JJB=88-90 07 Value < $500 QRW Autumn 08 07 RP=88-90 07 WS=88-91 07 ST=89 06 very Successful Hachette 10 06 RP=91+ 06 WE=90 06 Top Pics K&L 06 ST=89-91 06 WS=91 05highly Rec’d WS 05 WS=95 05 Outstanding for price QWR 05 WW=89-91 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 ST=92 05 WE=91/91 04 WS=90 04 WE=90 04 RP=87-88 04 ST=89 04/03 Very Successful Hachette 08/07 Ch Clinet Pomerol 12/13/14/15/16 15 90%Merlot-9CS-1CF 16 RP=96-98 16 $105wine.com 16 WS=95-97 16 Decanter =97 16 JS=93-95 16 WE=92-94 15 RP=95-97 15 $95-117 15 WS=93 15 $117 WS 11 GDP=89 10 85%Merlot-12%CS-3%CF 10 ST=88 10 TWCI=95-96 10 JJB=95 09 ST=89 09 RP=97-100 08 RP=94-97 08 ST=88 08 WE=92-94 07 RP=91 07 WS=86-89 07 ST=90 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 RP=90+ 06 WS=90 06 $73 WS 06 WE=91 06 ST=88-91 05 Hughly Rec’d W&S 4/06 05 WS=93 05 $140 WS 05 Fine Tannins, delicious finish WW 05 ST=89-92 52
05 Vin Remarquable Hachette 09 05 W&S=2stars 05 WE=92/90 05 RP=93-95 04 Vin Remarquable Hachette 08 04 WS=88 04 ST=89 04 RP=90
Pomeol Fleur de Clinet 14/15/16 14 WS=88
Bordeaux Ronan 14/15 15 WS=86 15 $15 WS 14 WS=84 14 $13 WS Clos du Clocher Pomerol 12/13/14/15/16 16 79%Merlot-21%CF 16 WDecider=92 16 $50 K&L 16 TWCI=92 16 $52 JJB 16 JS=94-95 16 $50 WHouse 16 RP=93-95 16 WE=92-94 16 Vinous=90-93 15 81%Merlot-19%CF 15 WDecider=93 15 $30 JJB 15 TWCI=93-95 15 $47 WHouse 15 JR=16 (88) 15 $47 K&L 15 RP=92-94 15 JS=95-96 15 JebDunnick=90+ 14 WDecider=92 14 $38 WHouse 14 TWCI=90 14 $39 Millesima 14 JR=15 (84) 13 WDecider=90 13 TWCI=87 12 Cited Wine Hachette 16 12 WDecider=92 12 $40 WHouse 12 TWCI=92 11 JCLee=86 11/10 Very Successful Hachette 15/14 11 TWCI=89 11/10 WDecider=90 10 TWCI=91 09 Coups de Coeur 2 stars Hachette 13 09 WE=91 09 $45 WHouse 09 RP=89-91 09/08 TWCI=89 09/08 WDecider=91 08 Vin Remarquable Hachette 12 08 RP=88-90 07 WDecider=88 07 $55 WineCh 07 RP=83-85 07 ST=85 06 WS=89 06 $35 WS 06 RP=89 06 WDecider=90 Clos See: main/family name
Closserie du Bailli Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux Grande Res 13/14/15/16 16 WE=84 16 $35 WE 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=91 14 $37 WE Ch la Clotte St-Emilion GC 12/13/14/15/16 15 80%Merlot-15CF-5CS 15 RP=90-92 15 $59-122WinS 09 RP=92-94 08 RP=91-93 07 RP=89 07 WS=83-86 07 ST=85 06 Cited Wine Hachette 10 06 RP=89 06 ST=86-88 06 WS=89 05 Very Sussessful Hachette 09 05 ST=90 05 WS=92 05 $40 WS 05 RP=91-94 Ch La Coin Bordeaux 14/15/16 14 Silver LA 16
Ch de Come St-Estephe 12/13/14/15 15 RP=87 14 RP=86
53
13 WS=83 13 $35 10 RP=87 10 $23 RP 09 Bronze Decanter 12
Ch La Commanderie St-Estephe Cru Bourgeois 14/15/16 16 RP=88-90 15 RP=83-85 15 $16 WAlert 15 RP=88 15 JR=16.5 (90) 15 RP=88 14 Silver LA 16 14 RP=91 14 $26 WHouse 13 RP=87-88 12 Silver Bordeaux 14 12 JR=14.5 (82) 12 JCLee=80 12 Vivino=3.7 (152) 12 RP=88+ 12 Gault&M=15 (84) 11 Bronze Macon 13 11 IWReport=87 11 RP=87 10 Very Successful Hachette 14 10 RP=86 10 Decanter=86 10 JR=16.5 (90) 10 RP=86
Ch La Commanderie Pomerol 14/15/16 16 WE=92-94 15 RP=90-92 Ch Cone-Taillasson Sabourin Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux 14/15 14 WS=87 14 $14 WS
Ch la Confession St-Emilion GC 13/14/15 16/15 TWCI=93 15 71%-28CF 15 RP=? 15 $31-33WAlert 14 TWCI=92 13 TWCI=89 12 TWCI=91 11 TWCI=90 10 TWCI=93 09 Outperformed Price JJB 09 JJB=93-95 09 RP=90-93 09 TWCI=92 08 RP=92-94 08 TWCI=93 07 RP=87 07 WS=87-90 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 NM=91 06 RP=91 06 TWCI=91 Confidences Prieur-Lichine Margaux 14/15/16 16 TWCI=93 15 TWCI=93/93 15 $25 TrJ 15 WS=90 15 $35 WS 15 Decanter=87 15 CT=93 )1) 14 Bronze Decanter 16 14 Falstaff=90 14 Decanter=89 14 CT=88 (1) 12 Very Succesful Hachette 16 12 Gault&M=13.5 12/10 Bronze Decanter 15 12 Falstraff=90 12 CT=90 (2) 12 Vivino=3.6 (103) 11 Gault&M=17.5 10 CT=89.9 (26) 10 WineFront=92 10 WineAlign=92 10 Vivino=3.8 (476) Connetable de Talbot St-Julien 13/14/15/16 16 RP=84-86 16/15 $24 RP 15 RP=83-85 Ch les Conseillans Cotes de Bordeaux Res de Pre 13/14/15 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=90 15 $12 WE
54
Ch la Conseillante Pomerol 12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 83%Merlot-17CF 18 JD=97-100 18 $228wine.com 18 JS=97-98 18 RP=96-98+ 18 Decanter=97 16 TWCI=99 15 81%Merlot-19CF 15 RP=95-97 15 WS=95 15 $172 WS 14 WS=93 14/13 $93 WS 13 WS=90 11 GDP=92 10 ST=90 10 JJB=97 09 81%Merlot-CF 09 ST=92 09 RP=95-98 08 RP=92-94+ 08 WS=90-93 08 ST=90 07 ST=88 07 RP=89 07 WS=88-91 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 WE=91 06 $150 WE 06 Very good, excellent potential WD 06 WD=17.5-18.5 06 RP=93 06 ST=91-92 06 WS=94 06 $137 WS 05 Vin Exceptionnel Hachette 09 05 WS=97 05 $189 WS 05 Highly Rec’d W&S 4/06 05 W&S=2stars 05 Best in a long time WW 06 05 ST=93 05 Best value of demanded wines QWR05 WE=87/90 05Coup de Coeur Hachette 09 05 RP=93-95 05 W&S=96 05 $350 W&S 04 Vin Remarquable Hachette 08 04 WS=92 04 Coup de Coeur Hachette 08 04 ST=88 04 RP=89
See also: Duo Conseillante
Ch Le Conseiller Bordeaux Superieur 13/14/15 15 100% Merlot 15 RP=84-86 15 $18 WineS 10 RP=91 10 TWCI=88-89 09 RP=88-90 09 RP=90-91 07 RP=88 07 WS=86-89 Ch Corbin St-Emilion GC 13/14/15/16/17/18 18 JD=93-95 18 $40 wine.com 18 JS=93/94 18 Decanter=94 15 90%Merlot-10CF 15 RP=91-93 15 $35-40WAlert 15 WS=90 15 $35 WS 13 WS=87 13 $29 WS 09 RP=88-90 08 RP=86-88 07 WS=83-86 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 WS=87 06 $26 WS
Ch de Cornemps Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15 14 W&S=NR 14 $13 W&S
Bordeaux Sup Cuvee Prestige 14/15 14 Best Buy WE 14 WE=90 14 $15 WE 14 W&S=85 14 $17 W&S 10 WE=88 10 $14 WE Ch Cos d’Estournel St-Estephe GC 11/12/13/14/15/16 16 WDecider=93 15 75%CS-23.5Merlot-1.5CF 15 RP=92-94 15 $155-201 15 WS=92 15 $174 WS 15 TWCI=95-96 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=97 14 $145 WE 14 WS=94 14 $117 WS 55
13 WS=91 13 $133 WS 10 78%CS-19%Merlot-2%CF-1%PV 10 ST=93 09 65%CS-33%M-CF 09 ST=88 09 RP=98-100 09 WS=97-100 09 WE=94-96 09 One of 32 Top JJB 09 JJB=97-99 09 Decanter=5star 09 Decanter=18.5 08 WE=95 08 RP=94-96+ 08 WS=91-94 08 ST=91 08 JJB=92-94 07 RP=90 07 WS=90 07 ST=91 06 WE=94/95 06 RP=94 06 Top Pick K&L 06 ST=93 06 WS=93 06 $138 WS 05 Great Wine W&S 4/06 05 W&S=95 05 $300 W&S 05 Very racy WW 06 05 ST=96 05 WS=98 05 WW=96-98 05 #90 Top 100 Wines WE 05 WE=96/97 05 ST=94-96 05 RP=94-96 04 Collectible WS 3/31/07 04 WS=94 04 ST=91 04 RP=92 St-Estephe Les Pagodas de Clos 13/14/15 15 46.2%Merlot-44CS-5.8CF-4PV 15 RP=87-89 15 $44-50 RP 15 WS=87 15 $53 WS 15 TWCI-86-88 10 62%CS-38%Merlot 10 ST=88 09 ST=86 09 69%CS-30%M-PV 09 RP=91-94 08 WE=91 08 RP=90-92 07 RP=83-85 06 RP=88 06 WS=86 06 $38 WS 06 WE=89 05 WE=90 05 ST=87-89 05 WS=89 05 $43 WS 05 NM=90 05 RP=88-90
Ch Cos Labory St-Estephe 12/13/14/15 15 RP=86-88 15 TWCI=86-88 11 GDP=91 11 $40 GDP
Ch de Costis Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=87 15/14 $10 WE 15 Silver LA 17 14 Best Buy WE 14 WE=88 09 Silver LA 11 Ch Cote de Baleau St-Emilion 14/15/16 16 RP=90-92 16 $23 RP 15 #2 Top Value < $30 WS 15 WS=92 15 $22 WS 15 RP=92-94 14 #24 Top Values < $30 WS 14 WS=90 14 $19 WS 14 RP=89 10 WS=89 10 $23 WS 10 RP=91
56
09 RP=88-91+ 08 RP=87-89
Ch la Cottiere Cotes de Bourg 13/14/15 15 RP=87-89
Ch Coufran Haut Medoc Cru Bourgeois Sup 13/14/15 14 RP=86 13 RP=83 10 WS=88 10 $21 WS 10 RP=86 10 ST=87 10 JJB=89-90 09 RP=87-88 09 WE=91 09 WS=88 09 JS=92 09 JR=16.5 (90) 08 SS=16.0/20 08 Decanter=3star 08 RP=85-87 07 WS=83-86 06 Silver Brussels 10 06 RP=84 06 WS=87 Ch Couhins Pessac-Leognan 14/15/16 16 RP=90-92 16 $21 RP 13 WS=85 13 $25 WS 10 ST=86
Ch Couhins-Lurton Pessac-Leognan 12/13/14/15 Merlot-CS 15 RP=87-89 15 $28-31 RP 15 WS=90 14 RP=87 13 WS=87 13 $60 WS 07 WS=86 07 ST=85 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 WE=90 06 $47 WE 06 ST=86-89 06 WS=85 06 $35 WS Ch Coulogne Bordeaux Sup Hommage Malbec 14/15/16 15 W&S=88 15 $16 W&S
Ch de la Cour d’Argent Bordeaux 14/15/16 16 WDecider=87 15 RP=85-87 15 $10-16 15 Vivino=4 (1) 14 Silver LA 16 14 WE=89 14 RevueVin=16 12 Vin Remarquable Hachette 16 12 WE=88 12 $11 WineCh 12 Gold LA; Silver Bordeaux 14 11 JR=16 (88) 11 Very Succesful Hachette 14 11 WS=87 11 JR=16 (88) 10 WE=81 10 CostcoBlog=88 Bordeaux Sup 12/13/14/15 15 JS=90-92 15 $12 wine.com 15 RC=87 15 $9 Costco 15 $13 K&L 12/11/10 WS=87 12 $14 WS 12 RP=86-88 12 $11 WinerCh 12 WS=82 12 WE=85 11 RP=84-86 11 WS=86 11 WE=85 10 Bronze LA 12 10 RP=86 10 $16 WineCh 10 WS=84 10 CellarT 87.6 (9) 10 RC=87/87
57
Ch du Courlat Lussac-St-Emilion Cuvee Jean-Baptiste 14/15/16 16 RP=91-93 15 100%Merlot 15 RP=88-90 15 $11 WineS 14 RP=85 10 RP=90 09 RP=86-87 06 WS=83 06 $28 WS 05 Vin Remarquable Hachette 09 04 Very Successful Hachette 08 04 WE=89 04 WS=83 03 Very Successful Hachette 07 Lussac-St-Emilion 13/14/15/16 16 RP=91-93 06 Bronze Decanter 09 06 Cited Wine Hachette 10 Ch du Courlat Jean Baptiste 14/15/16 16 RP=89-91 15 RP=88-90 14 RP=85
Ch la Couronne St-Emilion GC 13/14/15 15 RP=82-84 14 RP=85-87 08 WS=88 08 $25 WS 06 Silver Brussels 09 06 Comm’d Decanter 09 06 WS=85
Ch Couronneau Bordeaux Superiere Pierre de Cartier 14/15 15 Grand Prix d’Excellence Millesime 17 14 CT=87 (4) 14 $13 WineH. 14 Vivino=3.6 (253) 11 Very Succesful Hachette 14 11 WE=86 11 415 WE 11 Silver Bordeaux 11 10 Very Successful Hachette 13 10 Bronze Bordeaux 12 09 Vin Remarquable Hachette 12 09 WE=87 09 CT=88 (11) 08 RevueFR-16.5
Ch Courreges Cadillac Cotes de Bordeaux Cap de Fer 14/15 14 WS=84 14 $18 WS
Dom de Courteillac Bordeaux Sup 14/15/16 Merlot-CS-CF 16 TWCI=87 16 $22 Millesima 15 WS=88 15 $22 WS 15 JR=16 (88) 15/14 TWCI=88 14/13 80%Merlot-10CS-CF 14 WS=86 14 $19 WS 14 $22 Millesima 14 WE=87 14 $22 WE 13/12 TWCI=85 12 Silver LA, Paris 15 10 Silver Paris 13 10 TWCI=87 10 Bronze Bordeaux 13 10 JCLee=88 10 JR=15 (84) 10/09/08 WS=87 10 $14 WS 10 ST=86 09 Vin Remarquable Hachette 13 09 WS=87 09 $18 WS 09 RP=88-89 09 TWCI=88 08 TWCI=86 08 RP=86-88 08/06 WS=86 Bordeaux C de Courteillac 13/14/15 15 WS=87
Ch de Courteillac Bordeaux 13/14/15 2nd label of Dom de Courteilla 15 Gilbert&G=85 15 Vinous=89-91 14 Gilbert&G=82 14 C$14 LCBO 14 WineAlign=86 14 $17 WineCh 13 80%Merlot-10CS=CF Ch la Couspaude St-Emilion 13/14/15 15 WS=91 13 WS=88
58
Ch Coutet St-Emilion 13/14/15/16/17/18 18 RP=93-95 18 $23/375 wine 15 WS=89 15 $40 WS Coutelin Merville St-Estephe 13/14/15 15 RP=90
Couvent des Jacobins St-Emilion 13/14/15 15 RP=90-92 15 $30 WAlert
Crabitey Graves 13/14/15 15 RP=86-88 15 $9 WineS
Ch de Cranne Bordeaux 13/14/15 14 Best Buy WE 14 WE=88 14 $13 WE
Cotes de Bordeaux 14/15/16 16 Coups de Coeur Dussert-Gerber 16 $14 WineH 15 Vivino=4.2 (3) 15 $15 Astor 14 85%Merlot-15%CS 14 WE=90 14 $16 WE 14 RP=86 14 CT=88 (2) 13 WS=86 13 $20 WS 13 Vivino=4.1 (4) 12 Gilbert&G=87 11 Vivino=3.1 (21) Cotes de Bordeaux Sixieme Generation 14/15 15 WE=89 15 $15 WE 14 Best Buy WE 14 WE=90 14 $15 WE 14 WS=82 Cotes de Bordeaux 7e 14/15 15 WS=83 14 $26 WS 15 WE=88 Ch la Creation (Ch Robert) Pomerol 13/14/15 15 RP=87-89 15 WS=88 Ch le Crock St-Estephe Cru Bourgeois Sup 12/13/14/15 15 50%CS-31Merlot-7PV-12CF 15 WS=85 15 $50 WS 15 TWCI=88-90 15 RP=89 15 $24 WAlert 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=93 14 $34 WE 13 Cellar Selection WE 13 WE=92 13 $40 WE 13 WS=85 13 $40 WS 12 Cellar Selection WE 12 WE=93 12 $35 WE 10 WS=90 10 $25 WS 09 WE=93 09 RP=90-92 09 WS=91-94 08 WS=89 08 RP=82-84+ 07 Value QRW Autumn 08 07 RP=85-87 07 Selected by Vine Talk TV 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 WS=85-88 La Croix de Beaucaillou See: Ch Ducru-Beaucaillou
Ch La Croix Blanche Bordeaux 14/15 14 Very Successful Hachette 17
Croix Canon St-Emilion 13/14/15 15 80%Merlot-20CF 15 RP=90-92
Croix Cardinale See: Ch Fleur Cardinale
La Croix du Casse Pomerol 13/14/15 15 WS=88 15 $29 WS 13 WS-83 13 $55 WS 09 RP=88-90 07 RP=87-89 07 WS=86 07 $29 WS
Ch La Croix de Gay Pomerol 12/13/14/15/16 16 WDecider=91 16 $38 Millesima 16 TWCI=87 16 $42 WHouse 16 $43 JJB 15 TWCI=88 15 $34 JJB 15 RP=90-92 15 $36 WHouse 15 WS=91 15 $40 Millesima 15 JCLee=90 15/14 WDecide=9014 $32 WHouse 14 TWCI=87 14 JR=16 (88) 59
14 JCLee=86 13 WS=88 13 $27 WS 13 TWCI=36 13 WDecider=87 12 Cited Wine Hachette 16 12 WDecider=89 12 TWCI=87 12 JR=15.5 (86) 11 Very Successful Hachette 11 11 WDecider=87 11 GDP=89 11 $30 GDP 11 JR=14 10 WDecider=90 10/09 TWCI=91 09 Cited Wine Hachette 13 09 ST=88 09 RP=91-93 08 RP=89-91 08 WDecider=91 07 Value Wine QRW Autumn 08 07 WS=86 07 $30 WS 07 RP=85-87 06 RP=88 06 WS=90 06 $32 WS Ch Croix de Labrie St-Emilion 12/13/14/15/16 15 WS=91 15 $95 WS 15 RP=91-93 15 $66-84WineS 13 WS=86 13 $65 WS 09 RP=92-95 08 RP=93-95 07 RP=93 07 ST=89 06 Cited Wine Hachette 10 06 RP=94 06 WS=85-88 06 ST=88-91 05 Vin Remarquable Hachette 09 05 RP=94-96 05 WS=89-91 05 ST=90-92 04 Vin Remarquable Hachette 08 04 RP=89 03 Very Successful Wine Hachette 07 03 WS=87 03 RP=93
Ch la Croix Lartigue Cotes de Castillon 13/14/15 13 ws=88 13 435 ws 09 WS=92-95 08 RP=84-86 06/04 Cited Wine Hachette 10/08 Ch Croix Mouton Haut Medoc Bordeaux Sup (Ch Mouton) 16 RP=88-90 16 WDecider=88 15 RP=86-88 15 $13-20WAlert 14 WS=85 14 $18 WS 14 RP=87 13 RP=85-87 12/11 RP=87-89 11 WS=90? 10 87%Merlot-12%CF-1%PV 10 RP=90 10 IWCI=87-88 10 NM=90-91 10 JS=89-90 10 CellarT=86 (7) 09 86%Merlot-CF-others 09 RP=90 09 Cellart=86 (26) 09 TWCI 87/85 08 RP=87 08 JJB=86-88 08 WS=85-88 Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15/16 16 TWCI=86 16 WDecider=87 15 RP=88-90 15 $30 RP 15 TWCI=88 14/13 TWCI=85 12 TWCI=87 60
Bordeaux Sup 20 Mille 12/13/14/15/16 16 TWCI=87 15 TWCI=90 14/13 TWCI=88 12 TWCI=89 11 TWCI=88 10 TWCI=90 10 100% Merlot 10 TWCI=89-91
La Croix du Prieure See: Bernard Magrez
La Croix St-Georges Pomerol 12/13/14/15 15 91%Merlot-9CF 15 RP=92-94 15 $52 WAlert 09 RP=90-92+ 08 RP=93-95 07 RP=88 07 WS=89-92 06 RP=91
Ch la Croix Saint-Pierre Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux 13/14/15 14 Best Buy WE 14 WE=89 14 $14 WE 14 Vin Remarquable Hachette 17 Blaye Cotes de Boedeaux Tradition 13/14/15 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=88 15 413 WE
Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux Grande Res 13/14/1515 Editor’s Choice WE 15 WE=91 15 $17 WE
Ch Crois du Trale Haut Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=81
Ch Croizet-Bages Paulliac GC 13/14/15 15 RP=86-88 15 $34 WAlert 15 WS=88 15 $45 WS 10 80%CS-17%Merlot-3%CF 10 ST=88 09 66%CS-31%Merlot-CF 09 RP=87-89 09 Decanter=3star 09 Decanter=16/20 08 WBlB=87 08 ST=87 07 RP=75-77 06 RP=77 06 WS=84 05 Cited Wine Hachette 09 05 WS=80-84 05 WE=89 05 RP=86-88
Ch la Croizille Cotes de Bourg 13/14/15 15 RP=87-89
Ch Cru Godard Franc Cotes de Bordeaux 14/15 14 WS=87 14 $17 WS
Cru Monplaisir Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 $18 wine.com 14 RP=86 10 WE=85 10 $24 WE
Ch Crusquet Sabourin Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux 13/14/15 14 WS=88 14 $18 WS
Ch de Cruzeau Pessac-Leognan 12/13/14/15 Cab Sauv 15 RP=90-92 15 WS=87 14 RP=89 07 Bronze Decanter 10 07 WS=83 07 NM=88 06 Comm’d IWC 10 06 WS=82 06 $35 WS 05 WS=90 05 $29 WS 04 WS=86 04 $23
Ch les Cruzelles Lalande-de-Pomerol 12/13/14/15 15 90%Merlot-10CF 15 RP=91-93 15 $26-31WAlert 15 $44 Top Values < $30 WS 15 WS=90 15 $28 WS 14 #29 Top Values < $30 WS 14 WS=90 14 $23 WS 11 90%Merlot-CF 11 NM=90-92 09 RP=90-93 61
09 ST=88 08 WS=85 08 $28 WS 08 RP=90-92 06 RP=88 06 ST=85-88 06 WS=87 06 $23 WS 06 WBlB=86
Cuma du Touyre Bordeaux Petit Chapeau 13/14/15 14 W&S=86 14 $14 W&S
Ch Dalem Fronsac 13/14/15/16 16 RP=91-93 15 WS=92 15 $34 WS 15 80%Merlot-20CF 15 RP=91-93 15 $20-22WAlert 14 #12 Top Value < $30 WS 14 WS=91 14 $25 WS 14 RP=89 10 WS=91 10 $23 WS 10 RP=89 09 RP=89-91 09 WS=90-93 08 WS=90 08/07 $25 WS 08 RP=86-88 07 WS=88 07 RP=87-88 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 RP=89 06 WS=87
Dallau Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15 15 RP=88-90 09 RP=89-91 08 RP=86-88 La Dame de Montrose St-Estephe 13/14/15/16 (Ch Montrose 2nd wine) Planted 60%CS-32Merlot-6CF-2PV 16 WE=93-95 16 $40 wine.com 16 JebDunnuck=93 16 $40 K&L 16 Decanter=92 16 $40 Zachys 16 TWCI=93 16 $42 Sh-L 16 RP=97-99 16 $44 Millesima 15 55%CS-41Merlot-4PV 15 RP=88-90 15 $37-62WAlert 15 WS=89 15 $47 WS 15 TWCI=88-90 15 $45 K&L 15 WE=91-93 15 $47 Millesima 15 Decanter=92 15 $55 TW&M 15 JebDunnuck=91 15 JCLee=91 15 JR=16.5 (90) 15 TWCI=89 14 TWCI=90 14 $31 Costco 14 JR=16 (88) 14 $37 K&L 14 JCLee=90 14 $40 Zachys 14 WS=90 14 $40 TW&M 14 Vinous=90-93 14 $51 WineCh 14 RP=89 13 TWCI=87 14 $39 Millesima 12 JR=16 (88) 12/11 TWCI=88 11 WE=91 11 JS=90 10 TWCI=91 09 RP=91-93 09 TWCI=90 08=56 %M-44%CS 08 RP=89-90 08 WE=91 07 RP=88 07 WW=87-88 07 TWCI=88 06 Cellar Selection WE 06 WE=90 06 RP=90 06 WS=80-84 62
06 ST=87-90 06 TWCI=86 La Dame de Onze Heures St-Emilion 13/14/15 15 RP=85-87
Ch Dassault St.-Emilion GC 13/14/15/16 Merlot 16 TWCI=91 15 Cellar Selection WE 15 WE=91 15 $32 WE 15 RP=87-89 15 $33-72WineS 15 WS=92 15 $37 WS 15 JCLee=92 15 JR=15.5 (86) 15/14 TWCI=90 14 #3 Top Value < $30 WS 14 WS=92 14 $28 WS 14 JS=92 14 $23 K&L 14 Vinous=92 14 WS=92 14 RP=90 14 JR=16 (88) 13 TWCI=89 13 JR=16.5 (90) 12 Very Successful Hachette 16 12 TWCI=90/90 11/10 Vin Remarquable Hachette 15 11 TWCI=89/88 11 JR=15.5 10 ST=87 10 JJB=91 10 TWCI=90 09 Very Succesful Hachatte 13 09 RP=86-88 09 TWCI=87 08 WS=90 08 RP=88-90 08 TWCI=88 07 Vin Remarquable Hachette 11 07 RP=89 07 WS=88-91 07 ST=85 06 RP=89 06 ST=87-89 06 WS=86 06 TWCI=90 Ch Dasvin Bel Air Haut Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=83
Daugay St-Emilion 12/13/14/15 15 RP=88-90 14 RP=86 09 RP=88-90 06 RP=89
Ch de la Dauphine Fronsac 11/12/13/14/15/16 16 JS=92-03 16 $20 K&L 16 WE=90-92 15 90%Merlot-10CF 15 RP=91-93 15 $19-20WAlert 14 Top Value < $30 WS 14 WS=90 14 $25 WS 14 JS=92 14 $20 K&L 14 RP=92 14 JCLee=87 13 JCLee=84 12 One Star Hachette 16 12 JR=16.5 (90) 12 Bronze Macon 14 11 Comm’d Decanter 15 11 JR=16.5 (90) 11 Cited Wine Hachette 15 11 Silver Decanter 14 10 90%Merlot-10%CF 10 RP=87 10 ST=86 10 WS=90-93 10 TWCI=89-90 10 Decanter=93 09 Silver Paris 11 09 ST=88 09 RP=88-90 09 WS=90-93 08 Silver Brussels 10 08 WS=89 08/07 $24 WS 63
08 Bronze Bordeaux 10 08 RP=88-90 07 Silver Brussels 09 07 WS=88 06 Cited Wine Hachette 10 06 RP=89 06 WS=86 06 $17 WS
Ch Dauzac Margaux 12/13/14/15/16 16 TWCI=90 16 $45 JJB 15 72%CS-28Merlot 15 RP=91-93 15 WS=93 15 $44 WS 15 TWCI=92 15 $42 JJB 15 JCLee=93 15 $45 K&L 15 JR=16 (88) 14 TWCI=89/89 14 $50 TW&M 14 JR=16.5 (90) 13 TWCI=87 12 Vin Remarquable Hachette 16 12 TWCI=86 12 $40 TrJ 12 JR=14.5 12 $54 TW&M 11 Very Successful Hachette 15 11 GDP=87 11 $50 GDP 11 TWCI=84 10/09 Very Succesful Hachette 14 10 TWCI=87 10 $54 TW&M 09 RP=88-90 09 $75 TW&M 09 TWCI=90 09 Decanter=95 08 Very Succesful Hachette 12 08 RP=88-91 08 $45 TW&M 08 TWCI=88 07 RP=84-87? 07 WS=86-89 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 RP=87 06 Cellar Selection WE 06 WE=91 06 ST=87-90 06 WS=88 05 Vin Remarquable Hachette 09 05 WE=92/93 05 $40 TW&M
05 ST=86-88 05 WS=92 05 $45 WS 05 RP=89-90 05 TWCI=90
Desmirail (Brane-Cantenac) Margaux13/14/15 15 RP=90-92 15 $34-42 RP 15 WS=91 15 $42 WS 09 ST=88 09 RP=85-87 09 $28-35 RP 08 WS=87 08 ST=86 08 JJB=87-89 07 RP=78-81 06 Cited Wine Hachette 10 06 RP=76 06 $35 RP 06 WE=87 05 WE=89
Ch Destieux St-Emilion GC12/13/14/14/16 15 RP=88-90 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=93 14 $60 WE 09 Bronze Decanter 12 09 RP=91-94 08 WS=88 08 RP=90-93 07 RP=88-90 07 WS=85-88 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 RP=90 06 Coup de Coeur Hachette 10 05 WS=92 05 $45 WS 05 ST=87-89 05 RP=92-94
Ch Devise d’Ardilley Haut-Medoc 14/15 14 Best Buy WE 14 WE=92 14 $12 WE 12 Editor’s Choice WE 12 WE=91 12 $25 WE Ch Deyrem-Valentin Margaux 14/15/16 16 TWCI=91 64
16 Vivino=3.6 (5) 15 TWCI=91 15 RP=91 15 $20-22WAlert 15 CT=3.7 (11) 15 JR=16.5 (90) 14 RP=90-92 14 $22 K&L 14 WE=91-93 14 $25 WE 14 TWSI=89 12 Bronze Decanter 16 12 TWCI=88 12 Silver outstanding IWSC 16 12 JR=16.5 (90) 12 JCLee=80 11 Cited Wine Hachette 15 11 JR=11 (88) 10 One Star Hachette 14 10 RP=89 10 Decanter=86 10 JR=17.5 (93) 10 /09TWCI=89 09 Two Stars Hachette 13 Ch Dillon Bordeaux Clarendale Red 12/13/14/15 15 RP=88 10 WS=88 10 $25 WS 10 RP=87 Domaine See: family/main name
Le Dome (Ch Teyssier) St-Emilion GC (Jonathan Maltus, OBE) 16/15/13/12/11/10 80%CF-20%Merlot 16 RP=93-95 16 WS=90-93 15 RP=94-96 15 $120wine.com 15 JR=17 (92) 15 $125 Zachys 15 JS=94-95 15 WS=90-93 15 RevueFR=18 15 Falstaff=94-96 15 WineCellar=95 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=96 14 $175 WE 14 JR=16.5 (90) 14 $105 JJB 14 Vinous=92-95 14 $110 Zachys 14 WS=91 14 $98 WS` 14 G&M=17.5 14 WineCellar=93 14 RevueFR=17.5 14 Decanter=95 13 WE=94 13 $155 WE 13 RP=91 13 WS=87 13 $190 WS 13 JR=17 (92) 13 JS=92 13 RevueFR=15.5 12 RP=93 12 WE=95 12 $235 WE 12 WE=94 barrel 12 JR=16 (88) 12 JS=92 12 WS=92 12 $107 WS 12 Vinous=94 11 WE=94 11 WE=93 barrel 11 RP=94 11 WS=91 11 $215 WS 10 RP=100 10 ST=90 10 WE=95 10 WE=94 barrel 10 WS=93 10 $235 WS 09 ST=93 09 Cellar Selection WE 09 WE=95 09 RP=99 09 WS=91 09 $268 WS 08 WS=90 08 $144 WS 65
08 ST=89 08 RP=94 08 WE=93 barrel 07 RP=92-94 07 WS=84-87 07 ST=89 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 RP=92 06 WE=93 06 $260 WE 06 ST=92 06 WS=90 05 WE=95 05 WS=93 05 $263 WS 05 ST=90-92
See also: Ch Teyssier
Ch Domeyne St-Estephe 13/14/15/16 Planted 60%Merlot-40CS 16 WS=90-93 15 WS=88 14 #5 Top Values < $30 WS 14 WS=91 14 $16 WS 14 $20 Costco 13/11 80%Merlot-CS 13 WS=85-88 12/10 60%Merlot-40CS 12 WS=89 12 $20 WS 11 WS=88 10 ST=86 09 WS=91-94 09 Vinum=15.5 09 CT=89 (41) 09 J-M Quarin=87 08 ST=86
Ch la Dominique St-Emilion GC 12/13/14/15/16/17 18 JS=95-96 18 $55 wine.com 18 WE=93-95 18 JD=93-95 18 Decanter=94 15 85%Merlot-13CF-2CS 15 RP=90-92 15 $49-50WAlert 15 WS=93 15 $54 WS 11 GDP=91 10 ST=88 10 JJB=92 09 WE=92 09 ST=89 09 RP=92-94 08 RP=90-93 07 RP=90 07 WS=85-88 07 ST=85 06 Silver Paris 09 06 RP=90 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 ST=88-90 06 WS=85 05 Caressing WW 06 05 WS=89 05 $50 WS 05 Rich, elegant, great future Dec 06 05 SS=17/20 05 Cited Wine Hachette 09 05 WE=90 05 ST=88 05 RP=90-92
Ch Donissan Listrac 13/14/15 15 RP=85-
Ch Dorleac Graves Revelations d’Hubert de Bouard 13/14/15 15 WS=88 15 $25 WS
Dourthe Bordeaux La Grande Cuvee 12/13/14/15 Merlot 15 WS=87 15/14 $13 WS 14 Very Successful Hachette 17 14 WS=85 14 Gold LA 17 14 LA=93 14 W&S=83/NR 10 Comm’d Decanter 12 See also: Ch Pey la Tour
66
Ch Doyac Haut-Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=90 14 RP=81 14 $12-17 RP 10 WS=88 10 $25 WS 08 WW=88 08 CellarT 86 (5) Ch le Doyenne Prem Cotes de Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 WS=88 15 $20 WS 14 WS=86 14 $20 WS 10 RP=86 09 RP=88-89 08 RP=88-90 08 WS=88 07 RP=90 06 RP=87 06 ST=86-89 06 WS=80-84 Ch la Doyenne Prem Cotes de Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 RP=86-88 15 $7 WineS 09 RP=88-89 Cadillac Cotes de Bprdeaux 13/14/15 14 Editor’s Choice WE 14 WE=90 14 $45 WE
Le Dragon de Quintus St-Emilion 13/14/15 15 76%Merlot-23CF-1CS 15 RP=90-92
Ch Dubois Grimon Cotes de Castillon 13/14/15 15 RP=87-89 14 RP=90 Ch Dubraud Blaye Coites de Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=90 15 $15 WE
Clos Dubreuil St-Emilion GC 13/14/15 15 80%Merlot-15CF-5CS 15 RP=92-94 15 $100 WAlert 10 90%Merlot-10%CF 10 ST=90 10 TWCI=91-92 09 RP=93-95 08 RP=92-94 07 RP=89 07 WS=83-85 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 RP=91 06 WS=90 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 RP=88-91 05 WS=90 05 WE=88 05 $150 WE Ch Ducasse Bordeaux 14/15/16 16 W&S=85 16 $17 W&S 15/13 W&S=NR 15/13 $16 W&S Ch Ducluzeau Listrac Cru Bourgeois 13/14/15 15 WS=88 15 $20 WS 15 RP=85-87 14 WS=88 Ch Ducru-Beaucaillou St-Julien 10/11/12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 JD=97-100 18 $195wine.com 18 JS=98-99 18 WS=96-99 18 RP=97-99 15 95%CS-5Merlot 15 RP=94-96 15 WS=97 15 $177 WS 14 #2 Top !00 of 2017 IWReport 14 IWReport=97 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=96 14 WS=95 14 $110 WS 13/12 Cellar Selection WE 13 WE=94 12 WE=95 10 90%CS-10%Merlot 10 ST=93 09 85% Cab Sauv-15%Merlot 09 WE=96 09 ST=93 09 RP=96-98+ 09 WS=96-99 09 One of Top 32 JJB 09 JJB=95-97 08 RP=96-98 08 WE=93-95 08 ST=90 07 RP=90 07 WE=93 07 $95 WE 07 WS=90 07=90%CS-10%Merlot 07 ST=91 67
06 RP=94 06 WE=94 06 ST=91-93 06 WS=95 06 $145 WS 05 Intense, big, silky WW 06 05 ST=94 05 WS=95 05 $221 WS 05 WE=95 05 RP=96 05 W&S=94 05 $270 W&S 04 WS=92 04 ST=90+ 04 RP=93
La Croix Ducru-Beaucaillou 13/14/15/16/17/18 18 JS=94-95 18 $48 wine.com 18 Decanter=93 18 JD=91-93 18 RP=91-93 17 Most Affordable Pick WineS 17 WineS=92 16 TWCI=92 15 42%CS-45Merlot-3PV 15 RP=91-93 15 WS=91 15 $48 WS 15 JCLee=93 15 JR=17 (92) 13 Editor’s Choice WE 13 WE=92 12 Very Successful Hachette 16 12 JR=15 (84) 11 Bronze Bordeaux 14 10 85%CS-15%Merlot 10 ST=87 10 Cited Wine Hachette 14 10 WE=86 09 75%CS-25%Merlot 09 ST=87 09 Very Successful Hachette 13 09 RP=88-90 09 $39-56 RP 09 WE=88 09 50%CS-45Merlot-4CF-1PV 09/08 JR=15 (84) 08 Cited Wine Hachette 12 08 RP=89-91 08 Vinum=15 (84) 07 WE=90 06 RP=87 06 WS=88 06 $36 WS 05 One of top 8 “Seconds” QWR 05 WS=91 05 $33 WS 05 NM=93
Ch Dudon Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 70%Merlot-17CF-13CS 15 RP=86-88
Ch Dudon Jean-Baptiste Cotes de Bordeaux 13/14/15 14 RP=85-87 10 70%CabSauv-15%CabFeanc 10 ST=86 Ch Duhart-Milon Paulliac 4th Cru 12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 JD=94-96+ 18 $78 wine.com 18 JS=95-96 18 Decanter=95 18 RP=93-95 15 73%CS-27Merlot 15 RP=90-93 13 Editor’s Choice WE 13 WE=92 10 73%CS-27%Merlot 10 ST=86 09 63%CS-37%Merlot 09 WE=93 09 ST=89 09 RP=94-96 08 Great Value WBlB 08 WBlB=92 08 RP=93-95 08 WE=91-93 08 ST=88 07 Value < $500/case QRW Aut 08 07 RP=90 07 WE=89 07 WS=86-89 07 ST=87 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 RP=92 06 Cellar Selection WE 06 WE=93 06 ST=89-91 68
06 WS=89 Paulliac Moulin de Duhart 12/13/14/15 15 WS=86 14 WS=88 08 WS=88
Duo de Conseillante Pomerol 13/14/15 15 RP=89-91
Ch Duplessis Moulis-en-Medoc 13/14/15 12 Editor’s Choice WE 12 WE=92 12 $25 WE 10 WS=88 10 $20 WS Duprais Bordeaux 13/14/15 14 W&S=NR 14 $7 W&S
Ch Durand Laplagne Puisseguin St-Emilion 13/14/15/16/17/18 18 RP=91-93+ 18 $11 wine.com 15 RP=91-93 14 RP=86-88 Ch Durfort-Vivens Margaux Cru 10-16 15/14 Cellar Selection WE 15 WE=97 15 RP=89-91 15 $44-45WineS 14 WE=93 14 $40 WE 14 Decanter=90 10 70%CS-26%Merlot-4%CF 10 ST=89 10 $54+ ST 10 JJB=91 09 WE=91 09 ST=88 09 RP=87-89+ 08 ST=88 08 JJB=82-84 07 Value < $500/case QRW Aut 08 07 RP=88 07 65%CS-25%Merlot-CF 07 WE=87 07 WS=86-89 07 ST=86 06 Unusual style WD 06 WS=88 06 WE=90/93 06 WD=14.5-15.5 06 ST=86-88 05 WS=85-88 06 WE=93 05 One of 15 Best Buys QWR 05 WS=92 05 $39 WS 05 WW=90-92 05 Nice aromar, fine fruit, zippy WW 05 WE=90/89 Ch Duthil Haut Medoc 13/14/15 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=91 14 $40 WE
Ch Dutruch Grand Poujeaux Moulis-en-Medoc 13/14/15 15 WS=87 15 $35 WS 12 Editor’s Choice WE 12 WE=92 12 $29 WE 09 WE=90 09 WS=89 09 JR=15 (84) 09 Cellart 87 (7) 08 WE=89 08 $35 WE 07 WS=89 07 $30 WS 07 WE=88
Echo de Lynch Bages Paulliac 13/14/15/16/17/18 18 JD=93-95 18 $42 wine.com 18 JS=93-94 18 Decanter=92 15 66%CS-34Merlot 15 RP=89-91 15 $37-45WAlert 15 WS=89 15 $39 WS 13 WS=BT
Clos l’Eglise Pomerol 18 18 RP=94-96 18 $90 wine.com 18 JD=94-96 18 WS=93-96 Ch Dom du l’Eglise Cotes de Castillon 113/14/15 15 Merlot-CF 15 RP=94-96 15 $76-101 15 WS=92 15 $84 WS 10 ST=86 10 TWCI=93-95 09 70%M-15%CF-CS
69
09 One of Top 32 JJB 09 JJB=95-97 08 ST=85 08 RP=87-89 08 JJB=90-92 08 WBlB=87 07 ST=86 06 RP=85 06 ST=87-90 06 WS=80-84 05 Juicy, velvety, long WW 06 05 WS=85-88 05 Cited Wine Hachette 09 05 ST=89 05 RP=89-90 03 Vin Tres Reussi Hachette 07 03 $25 WS 03 ST=89 Pomerol 12/13/14/15/16 16 TWCI=95 15 WS=89 15 $55 WS 09 90%M-10%CF 09 ST=90 09 RP=96-100 08 ST=90 08 RP=92-94+ 07 RP=90-93 07 WS=86-89 07 ST=91 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 RP=9 06 coup de Coeur Hachette 10 06 ST=91-93 06 WS=91 06 $104 WS 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 ST=95 05 WS=94 05 $158 WS 05 RP=96 04 very Successful Hachette 08 04 WE=89 04 WS=91 04 $100 WS 04 ST=91 04 RP=91
Ch l’Eglise Clinet Pomerol 10/11/12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 JS=99-100 18 $290wine.com 18 WS=95-98 18 RP=96-98 18 JD=96-98 15 90%Merlot-10CF 15 RP=96-98 15 WS=94 15 $258 WS 14 WS=94 14 $182 WS 10 90%Merlot-10%CF 10 ST=95 09 One of Top 15 Decanter 09 Decanter=5star 09 Decanter=19/20 09 ST=95 09 RP=98-100 08 RP=94-96+ 08 ST-90 07 85%Merlot-15%CF 07 ST=92 07 RP=94 06 RP=96 06 ST=93-94 06 WS=93 06 $420 WS 05 Highly Rec’d to Great W&S 4/06 05 W&S=2½stars 05 Class, complex WW 06 05 WS=98 05 $382 WS 05 ST=95+? 05 RP=96-100 05 WW=95-98 04 WS=92 04 ST=91 04 RP=93 04 WW=93-96
La Petite Eglise Pomerol 10 100%Merlot 10 SR=86
Ch l’Enclos Pomerol 13/14/15/16 15 RP=89-91 15 $60 WAlert 70
15 WS=86 10 Bronze IWC; Comm’d Decanter 12 10 CF-Malbec-Merlot 08 Comm’d Decanter 10 08 RP=87-89 07 WE=90 07 $60 WE 07 RP=80-84 06 Cited Wine Hachette 10 06 WE=89 06 $59 WE 06 WS=88 06 RP=88 Inclos Tourmaline Pomerol 13/14/15 15 RP=91-93
Ch L’Escadre Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux 14/15 14 WS=87 17 WS
Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux Grand Res 13/14/15 15 Cellar Selection WE 15 WE=91 15 $35 WE
Ch d’Escot Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 RP=85 14 RP=88-90 Ch D’Escurac Medoc Cru Bourgeois 14/15/16 16 RP=88-90 14 RP=85 10 WS=88 10 $24 WS 10 WE=84 10 RP=89 09 RP=87-88 08 SS=16.0/20 08 Decanter=star 08 RP=88-89 07 Hachette=1star 07 CT=80 (7) 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 RP=87
Ch du l’Espereance Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux 14/15 14 Editor’s Choice WE 14 WE=90 14 $22 WE
Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux Les Origines 13/14/1515 Best Buy WE 14 WE=88 14 $10 WE
Blaye Cotes ede Bordeaux Esperance 13/14/15 14 Editor’s Choice WE 14 WE=90 14 $22 WE
Esprit de l’Eglise Pomerol 13/14/15 15 100%Merlot 15 RP=88-90 08 WS=90 Ch Esprit de Pavie Cotes de Castillon 13/14/15 15 65%Merlot-20CF-15CS 15 RP=96-88 14 RP=84
L’Etoile Lalande-de-Pomerol 14/15 14 WS=88
Ch L’Evangile Pomerol 10/11/12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 80%Merlot-20CF 18 JS=98-99 18 $238wine.com 18 RP=97-99 18 JD=96-98 18 Decanter=97 16 TWCI=98 15 84%Merlot-16CF 15 RP=96-98 15 WS=95 15 $223 WS 15 TWCI=99 14 WS=93 14 $125 WS 14 TWCI=92 13 TWCI=90 12 TWCI=95 11 TWCI=94 10 89%Merlot-11%CF 10 ST=92 10 TWCI=97 09 95%Merlot-CF 09 ST=93 09 RP=96-100 09 TWCI=100 08 RP=93-95 08 WS=90-93 08 ST=89 08 TWCI=93 07 ST=90 71
07 RP=88 07 WS=88-91 06 TWCI=94 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 WE=92 06 RP=93 06 WS=90 05 TWCI=99 05 Great Wine W&S 4/06 05 W&S=96 05 Vin Remarquable Hachette 09 05 WS=100 05 WE=93 05 ST=94 05 WW=94-97 05 RP=95
Pomerol Blason de L’Evangole 13/14/15 Merlot 15 WS=89 15 WDecider=94 14 WDecider=90 13 WDecider=87 12 Very Successful Hachette 16 12 JS=90 12 $50 JJB 12 Vivino=4.0 (40)
11 WDecider=87
10/09 WDecider=91 09 Great Value at $38 WBlB 09 WBlB=91 09 JR=16.5 (90) 09 JCLee=89 09 RP=90-92 08 WS=90 08 $50 JJB 08 JR=16.5 (90) 08 JCLee=87 08 WDecider=89 07 Value QRW Autumn 08 07 RP=80-83 07 JR=16.5 (90) 07 WDecider=86 06 RP=87 06 Great Value at $25 WBlB 06 WBlB=89 06 ST=90-92 06 WDecider=87
L’Everche St-Emilion 13/14/15 15 75%Merlot-20CF-other 15 RP=90-92
EXEM Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=88 15 $13 WE 15 W&S=85/83 15/14 $13 W&S 15 WS=83 14 WS=85 14/13 W&S=NR 11 Snooth=85 10 WS=85 10 $13 WS 10 WE=86 Ch Fage Graves de Vayres 13/14/15 15 WS=86 15 $15 WS
Ch Faizeau Montagne-St-Emilion Vieille Vignes 13/14/15 15 WS=85 15 $22 WS 15 RP=90-92 14 RP=88+ 10 Bronze Decxanter 12 09 RP=90-92 08 RP=88-90 Ch Faugeres St-Emilion 12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 JS=95-96 18 $45 wine.com 18 WS=92-95 18 JD=92-94 15 80%Merlot-15CF-5CS 15 RP=89-91 15 WS=93 15 $42 WS 09 WE=93 72
09 RP=90-93 08 Bronze Paris 09 08 RP=89-91 07=65%CS-25%Merlot-10%CF 07 RP=90 07 WS=87-90 07 ST=87 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 WE=93 06 RP=89 06 WS=91 06 $35 WS 06 WE=93 06 ST=87-89 05 Highly Rec’d W&S 4/06 05 ST=90 05 Vin Remarquable Hachette 09 05 WS=93 05 $41 WS 05 RP=91-93
Ch Faurie de Souchard St-Emilion GC 13/14/15 15 RP=? 09 Gold Paris 11 09 RP=87-89 09 Bronze Decanter 12 08 WS=88 06/05 Cited Wine Hachette 10/09 Ch Fayat Pomerol 13/14/15 15 100%Merlot 15 RP=88-90 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 $65 WE Ch Fayau Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15 15 Silver LA 17
Ch Feret-Lambert Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15 15 WS=89 15 $18 WS 14 WS=88 14 $20 WS 12 WS=87-90 11 RP=81-84 10 WS=89 10 $19 WS 10 RP=86 10 WE=86 10 $15 WE 09 Silver LA 12 09 LA=91 09 Bronze Decanter 12 09 RP=87 09 WS=90 08 Gold BofClass LA 11 08 RP=87-88 08 WS=88 08 $20 WS 07 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10
Bordeaux Sup Costes du Ch Feret Lambert 12 Best Buy WE 12 WE=90 12 $15 WE 10/09 WS=88 10 $19 WS 08 WS=87 Ch Ferran (Ginestet) Pessac-Leognan 13/14/15/16 16 RP=91-93 16 $17 wine.com 16 JS=89-91 16 Decanter=91 15 JS=91-93 15 $17 wine.com 15 RP=89-91 15 Decanter=90 14 RP=87-89 10 RP=90 09 Bronze LA 11 09 RP=88-90 09 WS=88-91 08 RP=85-87 07 RP=84-86 06 Gold Bordeaux 09 06 WS=87 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 WS=84 05 $25 WS 05 RP=87-88 Ch de Ferrand St-Emilion GC 13/14/15 15 RP=90-92 15 $17-39 WineS 15 WS=90 14 WS=89 12 Cellar Selection WE 12 WE=92 08 Gold Paris 11 08 WS=91 12 $40 WE 06 Gold Paris 09 06 Com’d Decanter 10 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 Ch Ferrand Lartigue St-Emilion GC 14/15/16 15 RP=90-92 09 RP=84-86 08 WS=87 73
08 RP=87-88+ 07 RP=85-87 07 ST=87 06 Gold Brussels 09; Challnege 10 06 RP=86 06 Cited Wine Hachette 10 06 ST=86-89 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 WS=88 05 $35 WS 05 RP=90 05 ST=89
Ch Ferrande (Castel) Graves Rouge 13/14/15 14 RP=86 10 Silver IWC; Bronze Decanter 12 10 CS-Merlot 09 RP=85-87 08 Silver Challenge 10 08 Bronze Bordeaux 10 08 Comm’d Decanter 10 08 RP=85-88 08 Vin Remarquable Hachette 11 08 Coeur Selection Hachette 11 07 Silver BinClass IWSC 09 07 Silver Paris 09 07 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 Very Successful Hachette 09 06 RP=84 05 Silver Bordeaux, Challenge, IWC 0705 WE=91 05 Bronze Decanter 09 05 Cited Wine Hachette 08 05 WS=86 05 $24 WS
Ch Ferriere Margaux 3rd Cru Classe 12/13/14/15 15 63%CS-33Merlot-3PV-1CF 15 RP=90-92 15 $40 WAlert 15 WS=91 15 $40 WS 11 GDP=87 10 66%CS-32%Merlot-2%CF 10 ST=88 09 WE=92 09 ST=89 08 WS=89 08 $25 WS 08 ST=88 08 WE=88-90 07 WE=87 07 $34 WE 07 WS=85-88 07 ST=84 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 WE=91 06 WD=16-17/20 06 ST=87-89 05 One of 15 Best Buys QWR 06 WS=87 06 $36 WS 05 Vintage’s most masterful WW 05 WS=91 05 $38 WS 05 Plenty of potential WD 4/06 05 ST=87+? 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 WW=91-93 05 WD=16.5-17.5 05 WE=91 Ch Feytit-Clinet Pomerol 12/13/14/15 15 RP=93-94 15 $61-79WAlert 09 Merlot95% CF5% 09 JJB=94-96 09 RP=93-95 08 RP=91-93 07 RP=89-91 07 WS=83-86 07 ST=88 06 Very good, some potential WD 06 WD=15-16/20 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 RP=91 06 ST=89-92 06 WS=90 06 $46 WS 05 Impressive WD 4/06 05 WD=17-18/20 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 WE=90 05 ST=92 05 WS=91 05 $65 WS 05 RP=91-93
Feytit-Guillot Pomerol 13/14/15 15 RP=84-86
74
Les Fiefs de Lagrange St-Julien 13/14/15 15 96%Merlot-4CF 15 RP=87-89 15 $20-45WineS 15 55%CS-41Merlot-4PV 15 RP=85-87 15 $23 WAlert 10 ST=86 07 WW=85-87 06 WW=87-89 05 Very Good SFCh 3/28/08 05 SFCh=2½star 05 $38 SFCh 05 WS=87 05 Rec’d to Highly Rec’d W&S 4/06 05 W&S=1½stars 05 Delicious, a true bargain WW 06 05 WW=87-89 04 WW=87-89 03 WS=88 Ch de Fieuzal Pessac-Leognan 12/13/14/15/16 16 TWCI=91 16 WE=94-96 16 WS=92-94 16 JS=91-93 15 RP=92-94 15 $36-40WAlert 15 WS=91 15 $40 WS 15 WE=93-95 15 JS=92-94 15 TWCI=92 15 JCLee=93 15 JR=16 (88) 14 TWCI=90 14 $33 WHouse 14 WS=90 14 WE=93 14 JS=92 14 Decanter=91 14 RP=90 13 TWCI=89 12 Cellar Selection WE 12 WE=93 12/11 Very Successful Hachette 16/15 12 JR=16.5 (90) 12 WS=90 12/11 TWCI=90 10 45%CS-40%Merlot-10%CF-5%PV 10 ST=91 10 Vin Renarquable Hachette 14 10 JJB=93 10 TWCI=91 10 CHLee=90 09 45%CS-Merlot 09 ST=87 09 RP=91-93 09/08 TWCI=90 08 WS=90 08 $30 WS 08 ST=88 08 RP=90-93 08 JJB=86-88 07 Value QRW Autumn 08 07 WS=90 07 $30 WS 07 RP=87 07 ST=88 07 TWCI=89 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 RP=87 06 WE=87 06 WS=88 06 $30 WS 06 ST=89 06 JR=16 (88)
Pessac-Leognan l’Abeille de Fieuzal 12/13/14 14 WS=88 08 WS=89
Ch Figeac St-Emilion PGC 10/11/12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 37%Merlot-33CS-30CF 18 WS=97-100 18 247wine.com 18 JS=98-99 18 WE=97-99 18 RP=97-99 18 JD=97-99 18 Vinous=96-99 18 Decanter=98 17 WineS=95 16 JR=17+ 75
16 RP=98-100 16 WE=97-99 16 WS=96-98 16 Decanter 98 16 JS=94-97 15 RP=97-99 15 JS-95-98 15 WS=96 15 $175 WS 14 WS=94 14 $87 WS 14/13 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=97 14 $90 WE 14 JS=93=96 14 Vinous=94-96 14 Decanter=92 13 WE=94 12 WE=94 12 WS=93 12 JS=92 10 35%CF-35%CS-30%Merlot 10 ST=88 10 JJB=96 09 WE=93 09 ST=88 09 WS=97-199 09 ST=90 09 Decanter=5star 09 Decanter=18.5 08 JJB=84-86 07 WE=92 07 $90 WE 07 ST=87 07 RP=91-93 06 Cellar Selection WE 06 WE=93/94 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 RP=90 06 Really very good WD 06 WD=16.5-17.5 06 ST=87-90 06 WS=91 06 $100 WS 05 Highly Rec’d W&S 4/06 05 W&S=1½-2½star 05 Great Figeac WW 06 05 WS=95 05 $118 WS 05 Best value of demanded wines QWR05 ST=92 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 SS=17.5/20 05 WE=92/93 05 RP=91-94 04 Very Successful Hachette 08 04 ST=88 04 RP=86 St-Emilion Petit Figeac 13/14/15 15 WS=91 15 $42 WS
Ch la Fleur St-Emilion GC 13/14/15 16 Merlot-CF 16 $34 Millesima 15 WS=90 15 RP=86-88 15 JR=15.5 (86) 14 JS=93 14 $35 K&L 14 WS= 14 W&S=90 13 $44 WineCh 12 JCLee=86 11 Cited wine Hachette 15 11 JR=16 (88) 10/09 Very Successful Hachette 14 10 JCLee=89 09 WE=94 08 Cited Wine Hachette 13 07 RP=87-89 07 WS=84-87 07 JCLee=83 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 RP=88 06 WS=86
La Fleur d’Arthus St-Emilion 13/14/15 15 RP=87-89 15 $24 WineS 09 WE=87 76
09 RP=88-90 08 WS=90 07 RP=85 07 ST=85-87
Fleur Balestre St-Emilion 13/14/15 15 RP=89-91
La Fleur de Bouard Lalande-de-Pomerol 13/14/15/16 16 TWCI=91 16 $30 JJB 16/15 $30 K&L 15 TWCI=92 15 $30 Zachys 15 JR=16 (88) 15 RP=87-89 15 $28-35WAlert 15 WS=90 15 $29 WS 14 Vinous=90-92 14 $25 K&L 14 RP=89-91 14 JS=90 14 WS=87-90 14 TWCI=89 14 JR=16 (88) 14 JCLee=88 13 IWCI=88/89 13 JCLee=90 12 JS=91 12 RP=91 12 Vinous=90 12/11 TWCI=90 11 $42 WineCh 10/09 100%Merlot 10 ST=89 10 Cited Wine Hachette 14 10 TWCI=90/91/91 09 Very Successful Hachette 13 09 RP=91-93 09 TWCI=91/91/90 08 Cited Wine Hachette 12 08 WS=90 08 $29 WS 08 RP=90-93 08 TWCI=90
Lalande Pomerol le Plus 12/13/14/15 15100%Merlot 15 RP=90-92 15 $90-95WAlert 09 ST=89 08 WS=90 08 RP=93-95 07 RP=91 07 ST=87 07 WS=84-87 06 RP=92+ 06 WS=85-88 06 ST=88-91 05 ST=91-93 05 WS=89-91
Ch Fleur Cardinale St-Emilion GC 12/13/14/15 15 70%Merlot-25CF-5CS 15 RP=90-92 15 $37-53WAlert 15 WS=93 15 $46 WS 11 WS 90-93 11 RP=92-94 10/09 70%Merlot-25%CF-5%CS 10 ST=86 10 TWCI=93-95 09 Outperformed Price JJB 09 JJB=94-96 09 Bronze Decanter 12 09 ST=89 09 RP=90-92 09 WS=92-95 08 RP=91-93 08 WS=88-91 08 JJB=90-92 07 RP=91-93 07 WS=84-87 07 ST=90 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 RP=91 06 WS=89 06 $40 WS 06 ST=89-91 77
05 Bronze Decanter 09 05 ST=92+? 05 Vin Remarquable Hachette 09 05 WS=93 05 $53 WS 05 RP=93-95 St-Emilion La Croix Cardinale 14/15/16 16 RP=91-93 15 72%Merlot-28CF 15 RP=91-92 15 $22-35WineS 15 WS=88 15 $36 WS 11 JS=90 11 RP=90-92
Ch la Fleur de Gay Pomerol 12/13/14/15 15 RP=91-93 15 $80-109Wale 15 WS=92 15 $97 WS 13 WS=88 13 $81 WS 10 ST=87 09 WE=92 09 ST=90 09 RP=93-96 08 RP=93-95+ 07 RP=88-90 07 ST=90 06 RP=92 06 ST=89-91 06 WS=88 06 $82 WS 05 Balanced WW 06 05 WS=91 05 $110 WS 05 ST=89+? 05 WE=92 05 RP=94-96
Ch Fleur Haut Gaussens Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15 15 85%Merlot-5Malbec-5CS-5CF 15 RP=88 15 $10 WineS 14 WS=86 14 $14 WS 14 RP=85 10 WS=88 10 $18 WS 08 Vin Renarquable Hachette 11 07 Gold LA 10 06 Bronze LA 10 Bordeaux Sup Malbec La Viminiere 13/14/15 15 Editor’s Choice WE 15 WE=90 15 $32 15 WS=86 15 $30 WS 15 RP=88-90 15 $15 RP Ch la Fleur Mongiron Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 RP=86-88
Ch la Fleur Moran St-Emilion GC 12/13/14/15/16 16 TWCI=93 15 RP=91-93 15 $38-84WineS 12 RP=92-94+ 11 RP=92-94+ 10 RP=94+ 09 Silver Decanter 12 09 RP=96+ 08 RP=94 07 Bronze Decanter 09 07 RP=92 07 70%Merlot-CF 07 ST=90 06 Gold Decanter 10 06 RP=88 06 $100 Dec 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 ST=89-92 09 Coup de Coeur Hachette 10 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 RP=92-94 05 ST=91-93 04 Very Successful Hachette 08 04 RP=88 St-Emilion Cuvee Matilde 13/14/15 15 RP=91-93 15 $21-24WAlert 12 RP=87-89 11 RP=90-92 11 JS=88-89 11 CT 89 (4) 10 RP=93 09 RP=92 08 RP=92 07 RP=87 07 ST=89 06 RP=89 06 ST=86-89 78
Ch Fleur la Mothe Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=90 14 WS=87 14 $20 WS 13 ws=84 13 $19 WS 10 Bronze IWC; Comm’d Decanter 12 10 WS=90 10 $20 WS 10 CS-Merlot 10 WE=85 10 RP=88 09 Gold Bruxelles, France-Macon 11 09 RP=90 09 Silver Bordeaux 12. 09 JR=16.5 (90) 09 Bronze IWC Fleur de Pedesclaux Paulliac 13/14/15 15 74%Merlot-6CF-20CS 15 RP=85-87
Ch la Fleur-Petrus Pomerol 10/11/12/13/14/15/16 15 93%Merlot-7PF 15 RP=94-96 15 $170-177 15 WS=95 15 $170 WS 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=95 14 $165 WE 13 WS=90 13 $120 WS 10 ST=92 09 WE=94 09 ST=87 09 RP=96-98+ 08 Vin Remarquable Hachette 12 08 ST=89 08 Coeur Selection Hachette 12 08 RP=92-94+ 08 JJB=92-94 07 RP=90 07 WS=88-91 07 ST=87 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 WE=93 06 RP=90+ 06 ST=89-92 06 WS=92 06 $175 WS 05 Great Wine W&S 4/06 05 W&S=96 05 $149 W&S 05 Best value most demanded QWR 05 RP=92-94 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 WS=95 05 ST=92+? 05 WE=93/94
Ch la Fleur Peyrabon Paulliac Cru Bourgeois 10-16 16 TWCI=90 15 RP=89-91 15 $26 WAlert 15 TWCI=85 15 JCLee=87 14 Silver Mundus Vini 17 14 WE=92 14 $29 WE 14 Vinous=90 14 $18 K&L 14 JR=15.5 (86) 13 Bronze Decanter, IWSC 16 13 Gilbert&G=90 13 WE=89 13 JR=15.5 (86) 12/10 Cellar Selection WE 12/10 WE=93 12 Silver Decanter 15 12 TWCI=88 12 Cited wine Hachette 16 12 Gilbert&G=90 10 RP=91 10 TWCI=90 09 Dbl Gold IWC; Comm’d Dec 12 09 WE=91 09 CS-Merlot-PV 09 TWCI=89 07 Silver Brussels 10 07 Bronze Decanter, IWC 10 06 Bronze IWC 09 06 Cited Wine Hachette 10
Haut-Medoc 13/14/15/16 16 TWCI=88
Ch Fleur-Pourret St Emilion 13/14/15 15 WS=87 14 WS=88 Ch Fleur Ribeyrolles Bordeaux Sup 14/15 14 WS=85 14 $13 WS
Ch Fleur Saint-Antoine Bordeaux Superieur 13/14/15 15 WS=86 15 $15 WS
79
14 Silver LA 17 14 Vin Remarquable Hachette 17 10 WS=87 10 $18 WS 07 Gold Challenge 10 Ch Floreal Laguens Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15 12 Editor’s Choice WE 12 WE=90 12 $40 WE
Clos Floridene Graves Rouge 12/13/14/15 15 Top Value < $30 WS 15 WS=90 15 $20 WS 15 RP=90-92 15 $18-30 RP 14 WS=89 14 $17 WS 14 RP=89-91 10 75%CS-25%Merlot 10 ST=88 09 60%CS-Merlot 09 ST=88 09 RP=88-90 08 ST=88 07 Comm’d IWC 10 Ch Fombrauge (Magrez) St-Emilion GC 13/14/15/16/17/18 18 JD=93-95 18 $30 wine.com 18 JS=93-94 18 RP=92-94 18 WS=91-94 16 93%Merlot-7%CF 16 RP=91-93 16 WE=93-95 16 WE=94-96 16 WE=909-92 16 JS=93-95 16 Vinous=91-94 16 WDecider=90 16 CT=90 (1) 16/15 TWCI=90 15 95%Merlot-5CF 15 RP=91-93 15 Top Value WS 15 WS=91 15 $28 WS 15 WE=93-95 15 JS=92-94 15 WDecider=91 15 JCLee=87 15/14 JR=16.5 (90) 15 CT=89.5 (2) 14 RP=93 14 JS=92 14 WDecider=90 14 CT=88 (4) 14 WE=91-93 14 WE=88-90 14 JR=16.5 (90) 14 Vinous=93 14/13 TWCI=88 13 WS=87 13 $25 WS
13 Silver Decanter 16 13 WDecider=88 13 WE=93-95 13 WE=91-93 13 CT=898.5 (6) 12 Silver Decanter 15; TEXSOM 17 12 WDecider=90 12 $35 wine.com 12 Vin Remarquable Hachette 15 12 TWCI=91 12 $36 WineCh 12 RP=94 12 WS=90 12 JS=90 12 WE=92-94 12 Gilbert&G=94 11 Cited Wine Hachette 15 11 TWCI=89 11 WE=90-92 11 JR=15.6 (86) 11/10 WDecider=89 10 RP=91 10 $50 TW&M 10 TWCI=90 09 WDecider=91 09 TWCI=92 80
09 WE=87/85 08 Gold Bordeaux 10 08 WS=88 08 $27 WS 08 Silver Paris 11 08 RP=90-92 08 $37 WineCh 08 Cellar Selection WE 08 WE=92/90 08 WDecider=88 08 TWCI=89 07 RP=87-89 07 WS=86 07 $28 WS 07 ST=88 07 WDecider=87 07/06 TWCI=87 06 Gold Paris 09; Brussels 10 06 RP=88/92 06 Silver IWSC 09 06 WD=16-17+/20 06 Bronze Decanter 09 06 ST=91 06 Cited Wine Hachette 10 06 WS=88/90 06 $40 WS 06 WE=93 06 WDecider=90 05 77%M-14% CF-CS 05 ST=90 05 Ample, made with care Decanter 06 05 WS=91 05 $37 WS 05 Silver Bordeaux 07 05 ST=88-91 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 WE=89-91 05 SS=16/20 05 14.5-15.5/20 05 RP=90-92 05 WDecider=92 05 TWCI=90 05 WineAnorak=94 Prelude de Fombrauge 13/14/15 15 RP=85-87 15 WDecider=86 14 WDecider=90
Ch Fonbadet Paulliac Cru Bourgeois Sup 13/14/15 15 RP=88 15 $21-16WineS 08 Cellar Selection WE 08 WE=92 06 Cited Wibe Hachette 10 06 WS=89 06 $40 WS 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 WS=87 05 $30 WS 05 RP=86-88 04 Cited Wine Hachette 08 04 WE=91 04 WS=89 03 Cited Wine Hachette 08/07 03 WS=91 03 $30 WS Ch de Fonbel St-Emilion 13/14/15/16 16 RP=88-90 15 80%Merlot-10CS-5Carmenere-5PV 15 RP=90-92 15 15 $25WAlert 13 WS=87 13 $52 WS 11 RP=89 10 RP=87 09 65%M-25%CS-7%PV 09 ST=87 09 WE=86 09 WS=88-91 08 WS=86 08 $22 WS 08 RP=88-90 07 RP=85-89 06 RP=89 06 NM=90 06 WE=88 06 ST=87 06 WS=86 06 $20 WS Ch Fonfroide Bordeaux 14/15 15 RC=87 13 W&S=NR 13 $15 W&S 12 Snooth=84 Ch Fongaban Castillon Cotes de Bordeaux 13/14/15 14 Editor’s Choice WE 14 WE=90 14 $17 WE
Saint-Emilion Puisseguin 13/14/15 15 Editor’s Choice WE 15 WE=91 15 $21 WE
Ch Fonpiqueyre Haut Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=82
Ch Fonplegade St-Emilion GC 11/12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 WS=93-96 18 $40 wine.com 18 RP=93-95 81
18 Decanter=94 15 WS=92 15 $41 WS 15 RP=90-92 13 WS=90 13 $49 WS 11 RP=92-94 11 JS=90-91 09 Vin Exceptionnel Hachette 13 09 Hachette=3 star 09 Coeur Selectionnel Hachette 13 09 Bronze Decanter 12 08 Comm’d Decanter 10 07 WE=91 07 $80 WE 07 ST=88 07 RP=87-89 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 RP=91 06 Coup de Coeur Hachette 10 06 WE=91 06 $79 WE ? 06 ST=87-90 06 WS=87 06 $54 WS 05 Cited Wine Hachette 09 05 WE=92 05 WS=91 05 $69 WS 05 ST=89+? 05 RP=90-92
St-Emilion Fleur de Fonplegade GC 09 Bronze Decanter 12 07 WE=87 07 $45 WE 06 WE=87 06 $44 WE 05 WE=88 05 $50 WE Ch Fonreaud (Magrez) Listrac-Medoc Cru Bourgeois Sup 13/14/15/16 16 RP=91-93 16 WE=91-93 16 JS=90-92 16 WDecider=90 15 JCLee=90 15 RP=92 14 RP=90 14 JCLee=91 14 RC=88.5 13 Editor’s Choice WE 13 WE=90 13 $21 WE 13 WS=83 13 JR=16.5 (90) 12 WE=90 12 $35 WE 12 JR=15 (84) 12 RP=86 11 RP=75 10 WS=89 10 $25 WS 10 RP=87 09 Cab Sauv 09 ST=87-89 09 WS=88-91 09/08 WE=88 08 WBlB=86 08 ST=86 08 Decanter=3star 08 SS=15.0/20 08 RP=84-86 07 Comm’d IWC 10 07 WE=88 Ch Fonroque St Emilion GC 13/14/15 15 RP=91-93 15 $24-46 WineS 15 WS=90 15 $40 WS 13 WS=87 13 $22 WS 08 RP=90-92 07 RP=87-89 07 WS=82-85
Ch Fontaine de Genin Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 Merlot-CS 15 RP=84-86 10 Gold Paris 11 05 W&S=83 05 $11 W&S Ch Fontbonne Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 Bronze LA 17 14 Silver LA 16 09 Silver LA 12 08 Gold LA 08 LA=93 82
Bordeaux Cuvee Marie 14/15/16 14 Silver LA 16
Ch de Fontenille Cadillac Cotes de Bordeaux 13/14/15 14 W&S=NR 14 $13 W&S
Ch Fontesteau Haut-Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=91 14 RP=88 10 WE=90 10 $25 WE Ch Fontenil Fronsac 13/14/15/16 16 RP=90-92 15 RP=89-91 15 $18-30WineS 14 RP=89-91 13 WS=BT 13 RP=86-88 10 100%Merlot 10 RP=91 10 ST=89 09 WE=91 09 WS=91-94 09 WS=90 09 $33 WS 07 RP=87-89 07 ST=88 07 WS=87 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 RP=88 06 AG=89 06 RP=90-92 06 ST=87-89 06 WS=90 05 Cited Wine Hachette 09 05 ST=89+? 05 RP=90-92 05 Excellent WW 06 05 WS=91 05 $72 WS See also their second wine: Le Defi de Fontenil
Fontinil le Defi de Fontenil Fronsac 13/14/15 15 RP=90-92
Ch de Fontenille Bordeaux 11/12/13/14 14 Best Buy WE 14 WE=88 14 $14 WE 10 WE=85 10 $14 WE 09 Bronze IWC 12 Ch Fortet St-Emilion 11/12/13/14/15/16 14 WS=95 14 $7 WS 11 GDP=94 11 $85 GDP 05 Rich, full-bodied, velvety, long WW 05 WW=92-94 05 WS=85 Ch Fontis Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=88 08 WE=89 07 Gold Bordeaux 10 07 WE=84 06 WS=82 06 WE=86 Les Forts de Latour Pauillac 10/11/12/13/14/15/16 16 TWCI=94 15 63%CS-35.6Merlot-0.5CF-0.9PV 15 RP=92-94 15 WS=91 15/14 TWCI=92 14 Decanter=92 13 TWCI=89 12 TWCI=91 11 TWCI=92 10 72.5%CS-25.5%Merlot-2%PV 10 ST=87 10 $250+ ST 10 TWCI=94 09 65%CS-32%Merlot-PV 09 ST=89 09 RP=93-95 09 WS=92-95 09 WE=92-94 09 Decanter=4star 09 Decanter=18/20 09 TWCI=94 08 RP=91-93 08 WS=88-91 08 JJB=88-90 08 JJB=87-89
83
08 TWCI=90 07 WE=92 07 $100 WE 07 WS=87-90 07 ST=90 07 RP=90-92 07 AG=89 06 Editor’s Choice WE 06 WE=91 06 Top Pick K&L 06 RP=92 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 ST=88-91 06 WS=89 06/05 TWCI=92 05 Highly Rec’d W&S 4/06 05 W&S=1½-2½star 05 Fine aroma, minerally, long WW 05 RP=92 05 Vin Remarquable Hachette 09 05 WE=92/92 05 ST=92 05 WS=94 05 WW=92-94 La Fortune Margaux 12/13/14/15 15 RP=91
Ch Fourcas-Borie Listrac 13/14/15 15 RP=90 15 WS=90 14 RP=89-91 14 WS=88 10 TWCI=88-90 08 WS=86 08 $25 WS Ch Fourcas-Dupre Listrac-Medoc Cru Bourgeois Sup 14/15/16 CS 16 RP=91-93 16 $16 wine.com 16 WDecider=89 15 RP=91-93 15 $16 wine.com 15 WDecider=91 15 JR=16.5 (90) 14 WE=91 14 RP=89 14 WS=87 14 WDecider=90 14 JR=16 (88) 14 JCLee=89 14 W&S=NR 13 JR=16.5 (90) 13 WE=87 12 Gold Mundus Vini 15 12 WE=89 12 $28 WineCh 12 Silver Bruxelles 16 12 RP=85 12 $29 WE 12 Bronze Decanter 15 11 Cited Wine Hachette 15 11 WE=87 11 RP=84 10 JS=92 10 WE=91 10/09 WS=88 09 Bronze Decanter 121 09 WE=90 09 JR=16 Listrac Hattes Terres du Fourcas Dupre 10 WS=89 10 $25 WS
Ch Fourcas-Hosten Listrac-Medoc Cru Bourgeois Sup 14/15/16 16 RP=87-89 16 $19 K&L 16 WDecider=87 15 JCLee=85 15 RP=85-87 15 $14-29WineS 15 JR=16 (88) 14 JS=91 14 $16 K&L 13 CT=83.2 (5) 13 JR=15.5 (86) 13 TWCI=75 12 Cited Wine Hachette 16 12 Comm’d decanter 15 11 Gold Brussels 16 11 Bronze Decanter, IWSWC 16 10 Editor’s Choice WE 10 WE=91 10 $22 WE 10 RP=86 10 $50/1.5 K&L 84
10 ST=86 10 C$43 BCLS 10 CT=87.6 (20) 09 WE=87 09 $32 Astor 09 CT=87.7 (36) 09 JR=16.5 (90) 07 Comm’d Decanter 10 06 Comm’d Decanter 10 06 WE=87 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 WS=85
Fourney St-Emilion 13/14/15 15 RP=84-86
Clos Fourtet St-Emilion PGC 12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 WS=96-99 18 $115wine.com 18 JS=96-97 18 WE=95-97 18 RP=95-97 18 JD=95-97 18 Decanter=97 16 TWCI=96 15 90%Merlot-7CS-3CF 15 RP=95-97 15 WS=96 15 $105 WS 14 WS=95 14 $74 WS 14 Decanter=93 13 Cellae Selection WE 13 WE=93 10 JJB=95 09 WE=96 09 ST=88 09 RP=95-98 09 One of top 32 JJB 09 JJB=95-97 09 Decanter=4star 09 Decanter=17.5 08 85 %M-10%CS-CF 08 RP=92-94 08 WE=90-92 08 ST=88 08 JJB=91-93 08 JJB=89-91 07 RP=91 07 WE=89 07 $60 WE 07 WS=86-89 07 ST=88 06 Good, for this vintage WD 06 RP=91 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 WE=92 06 Coup de Coeur Hachette 10 06 WS=88 06 $56 WS 06 WD=16-17/20 06 ST=88-91 05 Best value QWR 05 WS=95 05 Vin Exceptionnel Hachette 09 05 WE=93/94 05 Coup de Coeur Hachette 09 05 ST=92 05 RP=98 05/04 WE=93 See also: Closerie de Fourtet
Ch Franc-Cardinal Bordeaux Cotes de Francs 13/14/15 14 Editor’s Choice WE 14 WE=91 14 $16 WE 14 Cited Wine Hachette 17 Ch Franc Magnus Bordeaux 14/15 14 JS=90-91 14 $10 K&L 14 WS=87-90 Franc-Maillet Pomerol Cuvee Jean Baptiste 07 07 RP=87-89 07 WS=88-91 05 Cited Wine Hachette 09
Ch Franc Mayne St-Emilion GC 13/14/15/16 16 TWCI=91 16 $33 Zachys 16 RP=91-93 16 WS=90-93 16 /15WE=88-90 15 TWCI=91 15 JCLee=91 85
15 RP=93-95 15 JS=92-93 15 WS=92 15 $31 WS 15 Decanter=90 15 Vinopus=88-90 15 JR=16.5 (90) 14 WS=87 14 RP=90+ 14 WE=92-94 14 JR=16.5 (90) 14/13 TWCI=88 13 WS=88 13/12 WE=88-90 13 RP=87-89 12/11/10 Very Successful Hachette 16 13/12 JR=15 (82) 12 TWCI=90 12 $35 TW&M 12 WS=90 12 $31 WS 11 TWCI=89 11 $34 JJB 11 RP=82 11 WE=91 11 WS=88 11 $35 WS 10 Merlot 10 RP=89+ 10 ST=86 10 WS=92 10 $50 WS 09 Vin Remarquable Hachette 13 10/09 TWCI=91 09 Bronze Decanter 12 09 RP=90 09 WS=91 09 $37 WS 08 TWCI=89 08 RP=88 08 WS=89 08 $30 WS 07 Comm’d Decanter 10 07 WE=88 07 Bronze Decanter 13 07 RP=83-86 07 WS=88 07 TWCI=87
Franc les Cerisiers Cotes de Francs 13/14/15 15 90%Merlot-10CS
Ch la France Bordeaux Superieur 13/14/15 15 Silver LA 17 14 WS=84 14 $12 WS 10 Silver LA 12 10 Bronze LA 12 08 Silver LA; Bronze Decanter 10 08 Very Syccessful Hachette 11 Bordeaux Sup Cuvee Gallus 13/14/15 15 Gold BofClass LA 17 15 LA=93 09 Silver LA 11
La France Delhomme Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=85
Ch de France Pessac-Leognan 14/15/16/17/18 18 JS=92-93 18 $22 wine.com 18 JD=90-92 18 Decanter=90 16 TWCI=89/88 16 WE=94-96 16 WS=90-92 15 Top Value < $30 WS 15 WS=90 15 $27 WS 15 TWCI=89 15 $25 wine.com 15 WE=93-95 15 JS=91-93 15/14 JR=17 (92) 14 WS=88 14 $12 WS 14 RP=86 14 JS=91 14 TWCI=86 14 WE=96 14 WW=90 13 WS=86 13 TWCI=82 86
13 JR=15 (84) 13 JCLee=87 12 Very Successful Hachette 16 12 TWCI=84 12 JR=15.5 (86) 11 Vin Remarquable Hachette 15 10 Very Successful Hachette 13 10 WS=93 10 JJB=90 10 TWCI=88 09 Vin Remarquable Hachette 12 09 TWCI=87
Ch de Francs Francs Cotes de Bordeaux Les Cerisiers 13/14/15 13 WS=83 13 $20 WS 10 WS=90 10 $14 WS 09 ST=87 08 Gold Bordeaux, Silver Brussels 10 08 WS=87 08 $13 WS 08 90%Merlot-10%CS 07 Silver Paris 09 Ch Fredignac Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux 13/14/15 12 Editor’s Choice WE 12 WE=90 12 $45 WE
Ch la Freynelle Bordeaux Cab Sauv 14/15/16 16 Gold LA 17 16 LA=93 15 WS=87 15 $13 WS 15 $13 wine.com 14 Gold LA 16 14 LA=92 13 WS=80 13 $17 WS 10 Gold LA 12 10 LA=92 10 WS=86 10 $12 WS 09 Silver LA 11 08 Bronze LA 10 Fugue de Nenin Pomerol (Ch Nenin second label) 15 90%Merlot-10CF 15 RP=88-90 15 $28 WAlert 15 WS=88 15 $38 WS 10 RP=85 09 81%Merlot-19%CF 09 ST=87 08 WS=87 08 $28 WS 07 WE=86 06 RP=87 06 WE=87 06 WS=88 Ch Gabachot Bordeaux 14/15 15 Silver LA 17
Bordeaux Sup Cuvee 1956 – 13/14/15 15 Silver LA 17
Ch Gabaron Bordeaus 13/14/15 15 Gilbert&G 84 15 $10 K&L 10 WE=84 G Acte 7 Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15 15 61%Merlot-39CF 15 RP=90-92
Ch la Gaffeliere St-Emilion PGC 12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 WE=95-97 18 $68 wine.com 18 WS=94-97 18 JS=95-96 18 Decanter=96 16 TWCI=93 15 70%Merlot-30CF 15 RP=92-94 15 WS=95 15 $66 WS 14 WS=93 14 $49 WS 13 Cellar Selection WE 13 WE=94 13 WS=89 13 $50 WS 10 ST=87 09 WE=94 09 ST=89 09 RP=94-96 09 WS=92-95 09 Decanter=4star 09 Decanter=18/20 08 WE=91-93 08 RP=93 08 JJB=90-92 08 JJB=88-90 07 RP=89 87
07 WE=91 07 $50 WE 07 WS=85-88 07 ST=87 06 Cellar Selection WE 06 WE=93 06 Cited Wine Hachette 10 06 RP=89+ 06 ST=87-89 06 WS=85-88 05 Potentially great SS in Decanter 06 05 SS=18/20 05 Vin Remarquable Hachette 09 05 WS=93 05 $79 WS 05 ST=91+? 05 WE=91/90 05 RP=92-95
St-Emilion Dame Gaffeliere 13/14/15 15/14 Cellar Selection WE 15/14 WE=93 15 $45 WE 14 $49 WE St-Emilion Clos la Gaffeliere 13/14/15 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=93
Bordeaux Sup Ch Chapelle d’Alienor 13/14/15 14 Editor’s Choice WE 14 WE=90 14 $20 WE
Galaxies Romanile St-Emilion 13/14/15 15 RP=85-87
Ch de la Garde Pessac-Leognan 12/13/14/15 15 Top Value WS 15 WS=91 15 $30 WS 15 RP=86-88 15 $24 WAlert 13 WS=87 13 $50 WS 10 RP=88 10 ST=86 09 WE=93 09 RP=88-90 08 Gold Bordeaux 10 08 Bronze Challenge 10 08 Bronze Decanter, IWC 10 07 Silver Brussels, Challenge, Paris 09 07 Silver IWC 09; 07 Comm’d IWC 09 07 WS=85-88 07 Merlot
Ch le Gardera Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=90 15 $15 WE 15 WS=87 10 Gold LA 12 10 LA=92 08 WS=89 08 $15 WS Ch Garraud Lalande-de-Pomerol 13/14/15 15 RP=87-89 15 $16-24 WineS 10 Bronze IWC 12 10 CF-CS-Merlot 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 WS=87
Ch la Garricq Moulis 13/14/15 15 WS=88 15 $25 WS 15 RP=84 13 WS=83 13 $25 WS
Ch Gaudin Paulliac 13/14/15 12 Editor’s Choice WE 12 WE=91 12 $30 WE
Ch Gauthier Blaye Cotes de Boirdeaux 13/14/15 14 Editor’s Choice WE 14 WE=90 14 $40 WE
Ch le Gay Pomerol 12/13/14/15 15 90%Merlot10CF 15 RP=94-96 15 $98-126 15 WS=89 15 $112 WS 10 80%Merlot-20%CF 10 TWCI=92-94 09 ST=87 09 RP=91-93 08 WS=91 08 RP=95-98 07 RP=91 07 WS=86-89 07 ST=87 06Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 RP=93 06 Coup de Coeur Hachette 10 06 ST=89-91 06 WS=90 06 $110 WS 88
Ch Gazin Pomerol 10/11/12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 WE=94096 18 $86 wine.com 18 WS=93-96 18 JD=94-96 18 JS=94-95 16 RP=94-96 16 JS=94-95 16 WS=91-94 16 TWCI=95 15 JCLee=93 15 JR=17 (92) 15 Decanter=88 15 TWCI=95/94/95 15 WS=93 15 $73 WS 15 RP=94-96 14 TWCI=92/91 14 WS=93 13 Decanter=89 13 TWCI=90/90/90 12 JR=18 (94) 12 Decanter=17 12 TWCI=93/92/92 11 GDP=88 11 TWCI=91/90 10 ST=86/92+ 10 CF-Malbec-Merlot 10 JJB=94 10 TWCI=95/93/92 09 90%Merlot-10%CS 09 TWCI=96/92 09 One of 10 Best Values Decanter 09 Decanter=4star 09 Decanter=17.5 09 ST=88 09 RP=94-96 09 WS=92-95 09 ST=88-91 08 Bronze IWC 10 08 RP=94-96 08 WE=91-93 08 WS=88-91 08 TWCI=92/92/92 07 RP=84-86 07 WS=88-91 07 TWCI=90 06 Vin Exceptionnel Hachette 10 06 WE=90 06 Pretty, not very substantial WD 06 WD=14-15/20 06 Coup de Coeur Hachette 10 06 RP=92 06 WS=93 06 $66 WS 06 JR=17 (92) 06 TWCI=91 05 Vin Exceptionnel Hachette 09 05 WS=94 05 $71 WS 05 Very good potential WD 4/06 05 ST=89-92 05 Coup de Coeur Hachette -9 05 WE=89/88 05 RP=90-93 05 WD=17-18/20 05 TWCI=90
Canon Fronsac 13/14/15 13 Comm’d Decanter 15 12 Gold Paris; Silver IWSC, IWC 14 11 Siulver IWSC 13 11 JR=15 (84) 10 Bronze IWC; Comm’d Decanter 12 10 CT=88 (7) 09 Silver Bordeaux 10 09 JR=14 08 CT=88 (7) Ch Gazin Rocquencourt Pessac-Leognan 13/14/15 15 60%CS-40Merlot 15 RP=90-92 15 WS=89 10 RP=90 09 One of 10 Best Values Decanter 09 Decanter=3star
89
09 Decanter=16/20 08 WS=87 06 very Successful Hachette 10 06 WS=84 05 Vin Exceptionnel Hachette 09 05 WS=89 05 $30 WS 05 Coup de Coeur Hachette 09 05 WE=87 05 RP=87-89 04 Very Successful Hachette 08
Ch Gemeillan Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=85
Georges Vigouroux Le Temps des Vendanges Malbec-Merlot 15 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=85 15 $9 WE
Ch de Genibon Cortes de Bourg Cuvee Prestige 14/15 14 Best Buy WE 14 WE=88 14 $13 WE
Ch German Castillon Cotes de Bordeaux 14/15 14 WE=90 14 $15 wine.com 14 WS=89 14 Gilbert&G=86 14 IWReport=91 13 Siulver Bordeaux 14 12 Very Successful Hachette 16 12 Cited Wine Hachette 15 11/10 Bronze Challenge Int’I di Vin 14/12
Ch Gigault Prem Cote de Blaye CuveeViva 13/14/15 15 Top Value < $30 WS 15 WS=90 15 $19 WS 15 RP=89-91 15 $10 WineS 14 JS=91 14 $13 K&L 14 WE=86 14 $20 WE 14 RP=85-87 12 Very Successful Hachette 16 12 JCLee=82 11 $18 WClub 10 WS=90 10 $19 WS 10 RP=88 10 G&G=88 09 99%Merlot-1%CS 09 WS=89 09 JS=92 09 RP=90 09 CellarT 89 (7) 08 WS=86 Ginestet Bordeaux 14/15/16 16 60%Merlot-30%CS-CF 16 Decanter=86 15 Bronze Decanter 16 15 Gilbert&G=82 14 Bronze IWSC 15 14 W&S=85 14 $13 W&S 14 WE=84 13 Comm’d Decanter, IWC 14 12 Comm’d IWC 14 12 WE=83 12 $14 WE 10 Silver LA; Comm’d Decanter 12 09 Bronze Decanter 10 08 Bronze Challenge (FR) 09 Graves 13/14/15 15 WS=86 15 $22 WS 12 Vivino=3 (1) Haut Medoc 13/14/15 15 WS=87 15 $29 WS 13 Vivino=3.2 (9) Ch Lalande de Pomerol 13/14/15 15 WS=86 15 $28 WS
St-Julien 13/14/ 15 15 WS=87 15 $35 WS
Margaux 13/14/15 15 WS=87 15 $39 WS 14 Vivino=3.3 (12) 09 Gold Bruxelles 11 St-Emilion 13/14/15 15 WS=86 15 $32 WS 10 Bronze IWSC; Comm’d IWC 12
St-Estephe 13/14/15 15 WS=87 15 $39 WS
See also: Ch la Branne
Ch Mouchet 90
Ch Pierre de Montignac Ch Girolate Bordeaux 13/14/15/16 16 WDecider=89/90 16 TWCI=90 15 RP=89-91 15 $41-52WineS 12 JR=16.5 (90) 11 JR=16 (88) 10 ST=86 10 JR=16.5 (90) 09 100%Merlot 09 WE=92 09 ST=87 09 JR=16 (88) 08 WS=88 08 JR=17 (92) Ch de Gironville Haut Medoc Cru Bourgeois13/14/15 15 WS=89 15 $24 WS 15 RP=85 10 50%Merlot-40%CS-10%PV 10 WS=89 10 $18 WS 10 Editor’s Choice WE 10 WE=91 10 RP=88 10 ST=86 10 TWCI=87-90 09 Outperformed Price JJB 09 JJB=92-94 09 RP=89-91 09 WS=86-89 09 RC=88 08 WS=87 08 $17 WS 08 WE=86 08 SS=15.5/20 08 Decanter=3star
Ch Giscours Margaux 3rd Cru Classe 12/13/14/15/16/17/17 18 JS=96-97 18 $125wine.com 18 WE=95-97 18 WS=93-96 18 Decanter=95 16 TWCI=95 16 WE=96-98 16 JS=96-97 16 WS=92-95 16 RP=93-93 16 Decanter=94 16 CT=93.7 (3) 16 Vinous=91-94 15 70%CS-25Merlot-5PV 15 RP=94-96 15 Cellar Selection WE 15 WE=97 15 WS=93 15 $61 WS 15 JS=95-97 15 WE=94-96 15 RP=94-96 15 TWCI=95/95 15 JCLee=94 15 JR17 (92) 15 CT=94 (4) 14 TWCI=92/92 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=96 14 JS=95 14 RP=92 14 Decanter=90 14 CT=90.8 (7) 13 Cellar Selection WE 13 WE=93 13 TWCI=89/90 13 CT=88.6 (5) 12/11 Very Succesful Hachette 16 12 TWCI=91/91 12 WE=95 12 JS=92 12 WS=90 11 TWCI=90/91 10 71%CS-29%Merlot) 10 ST=92 91
19 Vin Remarquable Hachette 14 10 JJB=93 10 TWCI=93/93/94 10 JR=16 (88) 09 Remarquable Coup Coeuyr Hach 13 09 WE=95 09 ST=90 09 TWCI=94/93/92 08 Cited Wine Hachette 12 08 WE=94 08 WS=87-90 08 RP=88-90 08 ST=87 08 JJB=89-91 08 TWCI=91/91 07 Cellar Selection WE 07 WE=93 07 $50 WE 07 Selected by Vine Talk TV 07 RP=85-87 07 WS=85-88 07 ST=86 06 #31 Top 100 Cellar Selections WE 06 WE=94 06 Good effort WD 06 WD=16-17/20 06 Top Pick K&L 06 RP=88 06 Gold Decanter 09 06 ST=88-90 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 WS=91 06 $52 WS 06 TWCI=89/89/87 06 JR=15 (84) 05 Rec’d-Highly Rec’d W&S 4/06 05 W&S=1½stars 05 Very big, long, best ever? WW 06 05 WS=93 05 $65 WS 05 Excell RD 4/06 05 ST=91 05 Vin Remarquable Hachette 09 05 RP=91-94 05 Outstanding for price QWR 05 WD=17-18/20 05 Cellar Selection WE 05 WE=94/95 05 $75 WE 05 WW=91-92 05 TWCI=92/92/92
See also: La Sirene de Giscours Petit Serene
Ch du Glana St-Julien 14/15/16 16 RP=88-90 15 RP=88-90 15 $18-46 WineS 14 RP=90 10 WS=90 10 $25 WS 10 WE=91-93 10 JS=90-91 09 WE=94 09 WS=91-94 08 WS=88 08 Cellar Selection WE 08 WE=92 Ch Gloria St-Julien 13/14/15/16/17/18 18WS=93-96 18 $42 wine.com 16 TWCI=94 16 JCLee=90 15 60%CS-27Merlot-7CF-6PV 15 RP=90-92 15 WS=93 15 $44 WS 15 JCLee=91 15 JR=17 (92) 15/14 TWCI=92 14 #19 Top Values < $30 WS 14 WS=91 14 $30 WS 14 WE=94-96 14 JS=94 14 Vinous=04 14 RP=89-91 13 TWCI=89 12 Very Successful Hachettre 16 12 TWCI=90 11 Vin Remarquable Hachette 15 11 TWCI=91 10 66%CS-28%Merlot-6%PV 10 ST=88 10/09 Very Successful Hachette 14/13 10/09 TWCI=92 09 ST=87 09 WE=92 08 Very Successful Hachette 12 08 ST=87 92
08 RP=90-93 08 JJB=89-91 08 TWCI=90 07 RP=87-89 07 WS=87 07 $29 WS 07 ST=85 07 JR=16.5 (90) 07 TWCI=87 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 RP=90 06 ST=87-88 06 WS=90 06 $34 WS 05 Rec’d W&S 4/06 05 W&S=1star 05 Velvety, long, rich finish WW 06 05 WS=92 05 $37 WS 05 Vin Exceptionnel Hachette 09 05 ST=88+? 05 RP=90-92
Ch Godeau St-Emilion GC 13/14/15/16 Planted 90%Merlot-10CF 16 TWCI=90 16 Vivino=3.5 (2) 15 #16 Top Value < $30 WS 15 WS=91 15 $25 WS 15 RP=89-91 15 $15 RP 15 Vinous=93+ 15 JS=91 15 TWCI=91 15 Vivino=4.0 (13) 15 CT=90.5 (2) 14 TWCI=89 14 Vivino=3.7 (35) 14 Vivino=90 (3) 14 Decanter=83 13 TWCI=87 13 Vivino=3.4 (7) 12 JCLee=85 12 Comm’d Decanter 15 12 TWCI=90 11 Silver Bruxelles 14 11 TWCI=89 11 Comm’d Decanter 14 10 Vin Remarquable Hachette 14 10 JCLee=89 10 C$46 SAQ 10 J$=15.5 (86) 10 TWCI=91 09 TWCI=92 08 WS=87 07 ST=87
Ch Gombaude-Guillot Pomerol 13/14/15 15 75%Merlot-25CF 15 RP=88-90 15 WS=89 06 WS=88
Ch la Gorce Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=86
Ch la Gorre Medoc 12/13/14 14 RP=84 10 WE=84 10 $25 WE Ch Goudichaud Graves de Vayres 13/14/15 15 WS=87 15 $18 WS
Bordeaux 13/14/15 14 W&S=NR 14 $18W&S
Goulee Medoc 13/14/15 15 77%Merlot-19CS-4CF 15 RP=85-87 15 $36 WineS 15 WS=88 15 $34 WS 10 80%CS-20%Merlot 10 ST=86 10 $27+ ST 10 RP=90 10 TWCI=90-92 09 80%CS-20%Merlot 09 WE=91 09 ST=87 09 RP=89-91 09 WS 88-91 07 RP=87-89 07 ST=86 Ch la Grace Dieu St-Emilion 13/14/15 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=93 14 $35 WE 93
Ch Gracia St-Emilion GC 12/13/14/15/16 16 TWCI=95 15 75%Merlot-25CF-5CS 15 RP=92-94 15 $36 WineS 10 ST=91 09 ST=88 08 RP=94-97 07 60%Merlot-40%CF 07 ST=90 07 RP=92-94 06 RP=93+ 06 ST=91-92 05 RP=94-96 05 ST=93+?
Les Angelots de Gracia 10 ST=89
Ch Grand Barrail Lamarzelle St-Emilion GC 13/14/15 15 RP=82-84 13 Cited Wine Hachette 17 09 WE=90 09 RP=88-90 08 RP=84-86 07 WS=85-88 07 RP=85-87 06 Comm’d Decanter 09 06 WS=79 06 $40 WS 06 Cited Wine Hachette 10 05 Cited Wine Hachette 09 05 WS=88 Ch Grand Bateau Secret de Grand Batard 14/15/16 16 WE=87 16 $15 WE
Ch Grand Belair Bordeaux Sup 14/15/16 16 $8 TrJ 15 Vivino=3.6 (74) 14 Gilbert&G=83 13 Vivino=3.3 (253) 09 Silver Macon 10 Ch Grand Billard Bordeaux 13/14/15/16 16 Gold LA 17 16 LA=92 15 Silver LA 16 10 Bronze LA 12 Ch Grand Bouchon Medoc Revelations d’Hubert de Bouard 14/15 15 WS=87 15 $30 WS
Ch Grand Bourgeau Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux 14/15/16 16 WE=86 16 $15 WE
Ch Grand Chai Bordeaux 14/15 15 Silver LA 17
Ch Grand Corbin St-Emilion 13/14/15 15 77%Merlot-18CF-5CS 15 RP=86-88 15 WS=90 Ch Grand Destieu St-Emilion GC 13/14/15 15 RP=91-93 15 $20 WineS 07 RP=88-90 06 Silver Paris 09 06 RP=91-93 06 ST=86-89 06 WS=88 06 $34 WS 06 WE=89 05 WE=87/90 05 WS=87 05 $40 WS 05 RP=88-90 04 WS=87 04 $50 WS 04 WE=89 Grand-Enclosde Ch Cerons St-Emilion 13/14/15 15 RP=87-89
Ch Le Grand Faurie St-Emilion GC 13/14/15 12 WE=89 12 $35 WE 12stars (1) 09 60%Merlot-35CF-CS-Malbec 09 CT=88.1 (6) 09 $18 TrJ 08 CT=87 (1) Ch Grand Ferrand Terre Bordeaux Sup 14/15 15 Silver LA 17 Amoureuse Ch Grand Francais Bordeaux Suo Grand Cuvee 14/15 15 Silver LA 17
Bordeaux Sup Cuvee Heritage 14/15 15 Silver LA 17 94
Ch Grand Jean Bordeaux 14/15/16 16 Bronze LA 17 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=87 15 $12 WE 15 Gold LA 17 15 LA=92 15 WS=86 10 Bronze LA 12 10 WE=84 10 $14 WE 09 Bronze LA 10 09 WE=82 Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15 15 WS=85 15 $18 WS 14 WS=86 14 $15 WS 09 Silver LA 10 09 WE=85 09 $15 WE 08 Silver LA 10 Bordeauz Sup Res 13/14/15 14 WS=86 14 $15 WS 10 Gold BofClass LA 11 10 LA=93 09 WS=86 09 $18 WS 06 Cited Wine Hachette 10 Ch Grand Lacaze Medov 14/15/16 16 JR=14 16 frw.co.uk=85 15 Vivino=3.6 (192)15 $9 Costco 15 CT=87 (6) 14 Vivino=3.5 (2) 12 Vivino=2 (1) 08 Very Successful Hachette 12 Ch Grand Marchand Bordeaux Sup 14/15/16 16 Silver LA 17 15 Silver LA 16 12 Best Buy WE 12 WE=88 12 $10 we Ch Grand Meynau Bordeaux 14/15/16 16 WE=85 16 $11 WE
Ch Grand-Puy-Lacoste 14/15/16/17/17 18 JS=94-95 18 $78 wine.com 18 WS=92-95 18 RP=92-94+ Ch Le Grand Verdus Bordeaux Sup 14/15 15 Bronze LA 17
Ch Les Grands Chenes Medoc 14/15/16 16 RP=87-89 16 $15 WHouse 16 TWCI=89 16 Decanter=90 16 JS=91-93 16 WE=90-92 16 CT=89 (1) 15 RP=86-88 15 74%Merlot-26CS 15 TWCI=86-88 15 $20 JJB 15 JCLee=84 15 JR=15.5 (86) 14 JS=91-93 14 WE=92 14 $25 wine.com. 14 WW 92. 14 $45 WE 14 RP=88 14 TWCI=88 14 JR=17 (92) 13 Comm’d Decanter 16 13 RP=88 13 JR=16 (88) 13 WE=92 12 Very Successful Hachette 16 12 TWCI=88/88 12 $17 K&L 12 Comm’d Decanter 15 12 Gilbert&G=93 12 $22 WineCh 11/10 Editor’s Choice WE 11/10 WE=90 11 TWCI=89 11 $18 JJB
See also: La Serenite des Grands Chenesb
Ch Grand-Mayne St-Emilion GC 13/14/15 15 WS=88 15 $43 WS 15 RP=92-94 15 JCLee=91 15 JR=16.5 (90) 14 JR=16 (88) 14 $35 WHouse 14 JCLee=89 14 WS=91 95
14 TWCI=90 14 RevueFR=16 13 JR=16.5 (90) 12 Very Successful Hachette 16 11 Cited Wine Hachette 15 10 80%Merlot-15%CF-5%CS 10 ST=86 10 Vin Remarquable Hachette 14 10 JJB=90 08/07 Very Successful Hachette 12/11 07 WE=90 07 $30 WE 07 RP=82-85 07 WS=84-87 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 RP=88 06 WS=88 05 Full, round, long WW 06 05 WS=90 05 $48 WS 05 Big round wine SS in Decanter 06 05 WE=93/93 05 Vin Remarquable Hachette 09 05 RP=90-92 05 SS=15/20
Ch Grand Ormeau Lalande-de-Pomerol 13/14/15 15 RP=909-92 10/09 Comm’d Decanter 12 Lalande-de-Pomerol Cuvee Madeleine 08 ST=87 07 RP=87-90 06 WS=86 06 RP=89 06 $35 RP 05 Cited Wine Hachette 09 05 WS=89 05 $32 WS 05 RP=88-90 Ch Grand-Pontet St-Emilion GC 13/14/15 16 TWCI=90 16 $29 Millesima 15 RP=91-92 15 $26-36WAlert 15 TWCI=91 15 $29 Zachys 15 JCLee=85 15 JR=16.5 (90) 14 TWCI=88 13 TWCI=86 12 Very Successful Hachette 16 12 TWCI=89 12 Grand Gold Bruxelles 15 12 Gilbert&G=91 11 Very Successful Hachette 15 11 TWCI=86 10 Coup de Coeur 3 stars Hachette 14 10 TWCI=89 10 Gold Bruxelles 13 09 TWCI=91 09 $50 K&L 07 RP=85-87 07 JR=17 (92) 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 WS=87 06 $35 WS 05 Full, fruity, potential WW 06 05 WS=92 05 $41 WS 05 Big spicy lacking finesse Decanter 05 SS=15/20 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 RP=91-93 05 TWCI=91
Ch Grand-Portail Bordeaux La Croix Blanche 14/15 15 WS=84 15/14 $13 WS 14 WS=84 Ch Grand-Puy-Ducasse Paulliac 5th Cru 14/15/16/17/18 18 Vinous=92-95 18 $40 wine.com 18 WS=92-95 18 JS=93-94 15 RP=90-92 15 WS=88 15 $42 WS 11 GDP=88 10 60%CS-40%Nerlot 10 ST=86 10 JJB=90+ 09 Silver Decanter 12 09 WE=90 09 ST=88 08 Decanter=4star 09 Decanter=16.5 08 JJB=87-89 07 WE=86 07 $27 WE 07 RP=85-87 07 WS=84-87 06 Comm’d Decanter 10 06 RP=90 96
06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 WE=90 06 NM=93 06 ST=84-87 06 WS=88 06 $32 WS
Ch Grand-Puy-Lacoste Paulliac GC Classe 12/13/14/15/16 16 TWCI=96 16 $45 Zachys 15 74%CS-23Merlot-3CF 15 RP=94-96 15 TWCI=94/94 15 JCLee=93 15 JR=17 (92) 15 WS=92 15 $75 WS 14 TWCI=95/94 14 Decanter=92 13 TWCI=90/89 12 TWCI=91/91 12 JR=17.5 (94) 11 GDP=92 11 IWCI=90/91 11 JR=16 (88) 10 83%CS-17%Merlot 10 ST=91/94+ 10 $120 ST 10 JJB=94 10 TWCI=95/95/95 09 ST=88 09 Decanter=4star 09 Decanter=18/20 09 TWCI=94/93/93 08/07 Very Successful Hachette 12/11 08 ST=89 08 RP=89-91+ 08 JJB=88-90 08 TWCI=90/90/90 07 Celebrity Fav Vine Talk TV 07 RP=89-91 07 WS=88-91 07 ST=88 07 TWCI=90/88 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 RP=92 06 ST=90-91 06 WS=91 06 TWCI=93/92/93 06 JR=17 (90) 05 Fine tannins, chewy, beautiful WW 05 ST=93 05 Best value of demanded wines QWR05 WS=93 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 RP=95 05 TWCI=95/96/94 04 Vin Remarquable Hachette 08 04 WS=91 04 ST=89 04 RP=89 04 TWCI=90/90
Ch le Grand Verdus Bordeaux Sup 14/15 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=88 15 $12 WE 14 Silver LA; Comm’d Decanter 16 14 WE=88 14 Gilbert&G=83 13 Cited Wine Hachette 16 12 Comm’d Decanter 15 12 Gault&M=14 (82) 12 Very Successful Hachette 15 12 WE=83 10 Gault&M=15.5 (86)
Ch Grand Village Bordeaux Sup 14/15/16 16 RP=89-91 16 $13-19RP 15 RP=89-91 15 $9-31 RP 13 RP=84 11 75%Merlot-25%CF 10 75%Merlot-25%CF 10 WS=89 10 $25 WS 10 RP=89 10 ST=88-91 10 TWCI=89-91 09 ST=87 09 WS=87 97
Bordeaux Sup G 10 WS=90-93 09 60%Merlot-40%CabFranc 09 ST=89 Dom de la Grande Courraye Castillon Cotes de Bordeaux 14/15 14 WS=88 14 $18 WS
Ch Les Grandes Murailles St-Emilion 13/14 15 15 RP=89-91 15 $45WAlert 15 WS=93 15 $55 WS Ch les Grands Chenes Medoc 14/15/16 16 JS=91-93 16 $15 WHouse 16 WE=90-92 16 $16 K&L 16 Decanter=90 16 $17 wine.com 16 RP=87-89 16 TWCI=89 16 CT=89 (1) 15 TWCI=87 15 $20 JJB 15 100%Merlot 15 RP=86-88 15 WS=87 15 $20 WS 15 JCLee=84 15 JR=15.5 (86) 14 JS=91-93 14 $25 wine.com 14 WE=92 14 WW=92 14 RP=88 14 JR=17 (92) 14/13/12 TWCI=88 13 Comm’ed Decanter 13 13 JR=16 (88) 12 Very Successful Hachette 16 12 $22 WineCh 12 Comm’d Decanter 15 11 TWCI=89 11 $22 WineCh 10 Very Successful Hachtette 14 10/09 TWCI=90 10 Gold Challenge Int’l 13 09 58%Merlot-40%CS 09 ST=87 08 WS=87
Ch Les Grands Marechaux Prem Cotes de Blaye 14/15/16 15 WS=89 15 $14 WS 10 TWCI=87-89 09 RC=87/87 09 RP=90 09 WS=88 09 CellarT-89 (15) 08 WS=87 08 $17 WS 06 WS=87 06 $18 WS
Ch La Grange St-Julien 12/134/14/15/16 16 70%CS-24Merlot-6PV 16 TWCI=93 16 $50 wine.com 16 JS=95-96 16 $45 Zachys 16 RP=94-96 16 $55 K&L 16 Decanter=95 16 WE=93-95 16 WS=92-95 16 Vinous=909-93 15 TWCI-91 15 $45 TrJ 15 JCLee=90 15 $41 JJB 15 JR=16.5 (90) 15 $45 wine.com 15 $45 Zachys 15 $50 Millesima 14 TWCI=89 14 438 JJB 14 $38 WHouse 14 $40 K&L 14 $50 TW&M 13 TWCI=87 12 Vin Remarquable Hachette 16 12 TWCI=90 12 Comm’d Decanter 15 12/11 JR=16 (88) 11/10/09 Very Successful Hachette 15 11 TWCI=90 10/09 TWCI=91 08 TWCI=88 07 TWCI=89 Ch la Grange Clinet Prem Cotes de Bordeaux 14/15 14 WS=85 14 $16 WS 10 CellarT=86 (32) 98
06 WS=83 06 $14 WS 05 Vin Remarquable Hachette 09 05 WE=88 05 WS=80-84 04 Gold Paris 07
Clos Grangeneuve Pomerol 13/14/15 15 RP= 15$23 RP
Domaine de Grange Neuve Bergerac La Fleur Lily Red 14/15 14 Best Buy WE 14 WE=87 14 $12 WE 14 RP=83 Ch la Grangere St-Emilion 13/14/15 15 RP=79-81 08 WS=89 07 Silver Brussels 10 Ch La Grave Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=82 10 Silver Bruxelles, Decanter 12 10 GdP=84 10 Bronze IWC 12 10 CF-CS-Merlot
Ch la Grave a Pomerol Pomerol 12/13/14/15 15 91%Merlot 9CF 15 RP=90-92 15 $47-50WAlert 15 WS=92 15 $50 WS 10 ST=87 09 ST=88 08 WS=89 08 RP=88-90 08 JJB=87-89 07 RP=86-87 07 WS=87-90 07 ST=86 06 Cited Wine Hachette 10 06 WE=89 06 RP=80 06 ST=86-89 06 WS=88 06 $42 WS
Ch La Gravette Lacombe Medoc 14/15 15 WS=87 15 $20 WS 14 WS=87 14 $15 WS 10 Editor’s Chouce WE 10 WE=91 10 $18 WE 10 WS=87 Ch la Graviere Lalande-de-Pomerol 13/14/15 15 RP=87-89 08 RP=86-88 07 RP=87-88
Ch les Gravieres St-Emilion GC 12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 RP=94-96 18 $22 wine.com 18 JD=92-94 18 Vinous=91-94 15 RP=84-86 14 WS=88 14 $19 WS 12 RP=87-89 11 RP=84-86 10 100% Merlot 10 RP=89-92 09 RP=93 08 RP=91 07 Silver Bordeaux 10; Paris 09 07 RP=88-90 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 RP=88 06 Coup de Coeur Hachette 10 06 WS=85-88 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 WS=89 05 $37 WS 05 RP=91
Ch des Gravieres Grave Cuvee Prestige 14/15/16 14 Cited Wine Hachette 17 10 Bronze Decanter 12 05 Cited Wine Hachette 08 Ch les Gravieres de Brabdille Bordeaux Sup 14/15 14 W&S=87 14 $16 W*S
Ch Grenet Bordeaux Bio 14/15/16 16 Gold LA 17 16 LA=91
Bordeaux Le Fruit de Bordeaux 14/15/16 16 Silver LA 17 15 Silver LA 17 99
Ch Greteau Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15 15 Silver LA 17 15WS=86 15 $22 WS 09 Gold LA 11 09 LA=91 08 Silver LA 11 Bordeaux Sup Medeville 13/14/15 15 Bronze LA 17
Ch Greysac Medoc Cru Bourgeois Sup 13/14/15 15 RP=91 14 WS=87 14 $20 WS 10 WS=88 10 $22 WS 10 RP=86 10 WE=89 09 Merlot 09 WE=89 08 Bronze Decanter 12 08 WS=88 08 WE=87 08 CellarT=86 (22) 08 SS=15.5 (86) 08 JR=15.5 (86) 08 G&M=14.5 (82) 08 Decanter=3star 07 Silver Bordeaux 10 07 WS=81-84 06 Silver Bordeaux 10 06 Bronze Decanter 10 06 WS=87 06 Cited Wine Hachette 10/09 Les Griffons de Pichon Baron See: Pichon-Longueville Baron
Ch Griviere Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=81 07 WE=86 07 $26 WE 06 Silver Bordeaux 10 06 WS=84 06 Bronze Challenge 10 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10
Ch Gruaud-Larose St-Julien 2nd Cru 12 /13/14/15 15 60%CS-31Merlot-9CF 15 RP=909-91 15 $60-75WAlert 15 WS=92 15 $69 WS 12 WS=89-92 11 WS=90-93 10 66%CS-28%Merlot-6%PV 10 ST=92 10 JJB=90 09 65%CS-35%Merlot 09 WE=94 09 ST=92 09 WS=92 08 RP=89-91 08 WS=90 07 WE=91 07 $50 WE 07 RP=87-90 07 $38-73 RP 07 WS=90 07 $55 Zachys 07 ST=88 07 $66 B&M 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 WE=91 06 Good WD 06 WD=15-16/20 06 $90 B&M 06 RP=84 06 $30-104 RP 06 WS=90 06 $59 WS 06 ST=89-90 05 Outstanding for price QWR 05 WE=95/94 05 $130 B&M 05 WS=91 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 ST=90 05 Good WD 10/05 05 WD=16-17/20 04 WS=89 04 $42 B&M 04 WE=89 04 ST=88 04 RP=87 06 Coup de Coeur Hachette 08 04 Top 10 WW 06 04 WW=92-96
04 Vin Remarquable Hachette 08 See also: Sarget de Gruard-Larose St-Julien
Ch Guibeau Castillon Cotes de Bordeaux 13/14/15 14 Best Buy WE 14 WE=88 14 $13 WE 100
Ch Guibot Puisseguin-St-Emilion la Fourvieille 14/15 15 $22Astor 08 WS=89 Ch la Cuillaumette Bordeaux 14/15 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=86 15 $10 WE
Ch Guillot-Clauzel Pomerol 12/13/14/15 15 RP=82-85 15$34-38WineS 06 WS=87 Ch Guitignan Moulis en Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=88 10 Silver Decanter; Bronze IWC 12 10 WS=89 10 $23 WS 10 CS-Merlot-PV Ch la Gurgue Margaux Cru Bourgeois 13/14/15 15 #18 Top Vlaue < $30 WS 15 WS=91 15 $25 WS 15 RP=89-91 15 $25 WAlert 14 WS=87 14 $16 WS 10 ST=86 08 SS=15.0/20 08 Decanter=3star 07 WS=83-86 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 AG=87 06 C$35 AG 06 WE=87 06 WS=89 06 $37 WS
Ch La Haie Bordeaux 13/14/15 13 W&S=NR 13 $21
Ch D’Hanteillan Haut-Medoc 14/15/16 16 TWCI=88 15 WS=88 15 $13 WS 15 TWCI=87 15 RP=86 15 JR=16 (88) 14 RP=91 14 $14 K&L 14 WS=88 14 $18 wine.com 12 JS=90 12 JR=15 (84) 11 G&G=86 10 Cellar Selection WE 10 WE=92 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 WS=82
Ch Haura Graves 14/15/16 16 Decanter=?? 15 RP=90-92 15 $16 wine.com 15 WS=88 15 $18 WS 15 Decanter=91 14 WS=87 14 $15 WS 14 JR=15.5 (86) 14 CT=89.5 (1) 13 Decanter 86 12./11 Very Successful Hachette 16/15 12 JR=15 (84) 12 $25 TW&M 12 JCLee=83 10 Gault&M=15 (84) 09 60%CS-40%Merlot 09 ST=88 09 JR=16 (88) 09 G&M=16 (88) 09 Gilbert&G=86 09 JMQ=89 08 Very Successful Hachette 12 08 Bronze Decanter, IWC 11 07 Bronze IWC; Comm’d Decanter 10 06 Comm’d Decanter 08 06 Cited Wine Hachette 09 Haut Bacalan Pessac-Leognan 13/14/15 15 RP=88-90
Ch Haut-Bages-Liberal Paulliac 5th Cru Classe 12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 JS=96-97 18 $45 wine.com 18 Dec=92 15 65%CS-35Merlot 15 RP=88-90 15 $37-40WAlert 15 Editor’s Choice WE 15 WE=94 15 $37 WE 15 WS=89 15 $41 WS 13 WS=86-89 11 GDP=90 101
10 70%CS-23%Merlot 10 ST=91 10 JJB=92 09 WE=92 09 ST=90 08 WS=89 08 $29 WS 08 ST=89 08 JJB=83-85 07 RP=83-85 07 WS=87 07 $27 WS 07 WE=87 06 Good at best WD 06 WD=14.5-15.5 06 Top Pick K&L 06 WS=92 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 RP=89 06 ST=87-89 05 Highly Rec’d W&S 4/06 05 W&S=2stars 05 Breath-taking, almost 95-100 WW 05 ST=89 05 Vin Remarquable Hachette 09 05 WS=93 05 WE=93 05 RP=88-90 05 Very good value WD 4/06 05 WD=16.5-17.5
Ch Haut-Bailly Pessac-Leognan 11/12/13/14/15/16 15 60%CS-36Merlot-4PV 15 RP=95-97 15 $95-140 15 WS=95 15 $127 WS 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=95 14 $75 WE 14 WS=94 14 $62 WS 13 WS=89-92 12 Cellar Selection WE 12 WE=94 12 $80 WE 11 GDP=89 10 64%CS-30%Merlot-6%CF 10 ST=88 10 JJB=93 09 ST=92 09 WE=95-98 09 RP=96-98 08 ST=89 08 WE=92-94 08 RP=95-97 07 WE=91 07 $58 WE 07 ST=89 07 RP=90-92 06 Top Pick K&L 06 RP=95 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 WE=92 06 AG=91 06 ST=90+? 06 WS=92 06 WD=14.5-15.5 05 Vin Remarquable Hachette 09 05 WE=92/94 05 Wonderful TW 3/06 05 ST=92+? 05 Highly Rec’d W&S 4/06 05 W&S=1½-2stars 05 Wonderful WD 4/06 05 WD=18-19/20 05 WS=95 05 RP=93-95 04 WE=93 04 ST=90+ 04 WS=91 04 Vin Remarquable Hachette 07 04 RP=93
Pessac-Leognan la Parde de Haut-Baillu 13/14/15 15 WS=90 15 $34 WS 14 WS=90 13 WS=87-90 Ch Haut Barrail Medoc 13/14/15 15 WS=87 15 $25 WS 10 Comm’d IWC 12 10 WE=87 10 $14 WE 10 CS-Merlot
Ch Haut Batailley Paulliac GC Classe 12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 JS=94-95 18 $65 wine.com 18 JD=93-95
102
18 WS=92-95 15 72% CS-28Merlot 15 RP=92-94 15 WS=91 15 $45 WS 13 WS=87 13 $36 WS 09 Decanter=4star 09 Decanter=17.5 08 RP=88-90 08 JJB=89-91 07 Value < $500/case QRW Aut 08 07 RP=85-87 07 ST=85 07 WS=87-90 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 RP=89 06 ST=87-89 06 WS=89 06 $35 WS 05 One of 15 Best Buys QWR 05 ST=89 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 WS=93 05 RP=90-92 04 Vin Remarquable Hachette 08 04 ST=85-87 04 WS=88 04 RP=88
Ch Haut-Beausejour St-Estephe Cru Bourgeois 12/13/14/15 15 55%CS-45Merlot 15 RP=88-90 15 $64 WineS 15 WS=88 15 $30 WS 15 TWCI=85-87 14 WS=90 08 WS=89 08 $28 WS 08 SS=16.0/20 08 Decanter=3star 07 WS=85 06 WE=89 06 RP=85 06 $36 RP 06 WS=82 06 $22 WS 05 WS=86 05 $22 WS 05 SS=16/20 05 RP=81-83 05 RC=88 04 Very Successful Hachette 08 04 WS=88 04 WE=89 Ch Haut Bergey Pessac-Leognan 14/15/16/16/17/18 18 WE=92-94 18 $24 wine.com 18 Dec=93 18 JS=91-92 16 WS=91-93 16 JS=89-91 16 Decanter=90 16 WDecider=88 16 TWCI=88 15 #17 Top Value < $30 WS 15 WS=91 15 $25 WS 15 JS=91-93 15 $22 WHouse 15 WS=90-92 15 JCLee=86 15 JR=15.5 (88) 15/14 TWCI=90 15/14/13 WDecider=89
14 #10 Top Values < $30 WS 14 WS=91 14 $23 WS 14 AG=90-93 14 WE=90/92 14 RP=89-91 14 Vinous=90-93 14 JR=17 (92) 13 Cited Wine Hachette 16 13 WS=85 13 $35 WS 13 WE=89/88 13 TWCI=89 12 Cellar Selection WE 12 WE=90 12 WS-90-93 12 Cellar Selection WE 12 WE=90/91/92 103
12 RP=90-93 12 TWCI=90 12 JS=90 12 JR=16.5 (90) 12/11/10 WDecider=90 11 WS=90-93 11 WE=90/89 10 ST=88 10 TWCI=92 10 JJB=91 10 WE=91 09 60%CS-40%Merlot 09 WE=88 09 Very Successful Hachette 13 09 ST=90 09 Vin Remarquable Hachette 12 09 RP=92-94 09 WS=91-94 09 WDecider=92 09/08 TWCI=91 08 Outstanding Value WBlB 08 WBlB=92 08 Very Successful Hachette 11 08 WS=87 08 $28 WS 08 RP=92-94 08 $37 WHouse
08 WE=92 08 ST=89 08 WDecider=90 07 RP=90-93 07 WS=86 07 ST=90 07 WE=93 07/06 TWCI=90 07/06/05 WDecider=91 06 RP=91 06 $36 WineCh
06 ST=90-91 06 WS=89 06 WE=89 Passac-Leognan l’Etoile de Bergey 08 WS=86
Ch Haut Bertinerie Prem Cotes de Bordeaux 13/14/15 14 RP=84-86 07 WE=88 07 $24 WE
Ch Haut Breton Larigaudiere Margaux 13/14/15 15 RP=88
Ch Haut-Brion Pessac-Leognan 10/11/12/13/14/15/16/17 17 WineS=95 15 50%Merlot-8CF-42CS 15 RP=98-100 15 $510-637 15 WS=98 15 $570 WS 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=97 14 $330 WE 14 WS=96 14 $323 WS 13 WS=91 13 $344 WS 12 Cellar Selection WE 12 WE=96 10 57%CS-23%Merlot-20%CF 10 ST=97 09 46%Merlot-40%CS-CF 09 One of Top 15 Decanter 09 Decanter=5star 09 Decanter=19.5/20 09 WE=96 09 ST=97 09 One of Top 32 JJB 09 JJB=95-97 08 ST=92 08 RP=95-97 08 WE=94-96 08 WS=93-96 07 WE=94 07 $450 WE 07 AG=92 07 RP=91-94 07 WS=89-92 07 ST=94 06 Cellar Selection WE 06 WE=96 104
06 Top Pick K&L 06 RP=96 06 Vin Exceptionnel Hachette 10 06 ST=92-94 06 Coup de Coeur Hachette 10 06 WS=94 06 $575 WS 05 Vin Exceptionnel Hachette 09 05 RP=96-100 05 Great Wine W&S 4/06 05 W&S=98 05 Coup de Coeur Hachette 09 05 WS=100 05 $930 W&S 05 Cellar Selection WE 05 WE=96/98 05 ST=97 05 WW=95-98 04 Collectable WS 3/31/07 04 WS=95 04 RP=90-92 04 WE=96 04 Vin Exceptionel Hachette 08 04 ST=91+ 03 Vin Remarquable Hachette 07 03 RP=95 03 WS=96 03 ST=94 03 WW=95-98 See also their second wine: Ch Bahans Haut-Brion
See also: Le Clarence de Haut-Brion
Ch Haut Brisson St-Emilion GC 13/14/15 15 RP=91-93 15 $23-24WAlert 10 RP=90 06 90%Merlot-CS-CF 06/05 Very Successful Hachette 10/09 06 RP=89 St-Emilion La Reserve GC 08 Comm’d Decanter 12 07 Gold Bordeaux 10 07 RP=90-92 06 Silver Decanter 10 06 RP=90
04 Silver Paris 07 04 Bronze Decanter 07 03 Comm’d Decanter 07 00 RP=88 St-Emilion La Grave 09 Comm’d IWC 12 09 CF-CS-Merlot 06 Silver Decanter 09 06 RP=89 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 Ch Haut-Cadet St-Emilion GC 13/14/15 15 WS=89 15 $18 WS 15 $25 WhFoods 11 Gold Bordeaux 13 10 Silver Bordaeux 13 Ch Haut-Carles Fronsac 13/14/15 15 RP=88-90 15 $21-34WineS 10 ST=86 09 WE=89 09 ST=88 07 RP=87-89 07 ST=88 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 ST=88-91 06 Coup de Coeur Hachette 10 06 WS=88 06 WBlB=87 05 Vin Remarquable Hachette 09 05 RP=88-90 05 WS=91 05 $34 WS 04 Vin Remarquable Hachette 08 04 RP=86-88 04 WS=87 03 RP=89 03 WS=88 01 WS=85 Ch Haut-Chaigneau Lalande-de-Pomerol 13/14/15 15 RP=88-90 15 $21-34WineS 15 WS=89 14 WS=87 14 $13 WS 13 Cited Wine Hachette 17 13 WS=84 13 $30 WS 08 WS=88 Ch Haut Claribes Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15 15 Silver Paris 16 15 Vivino=3.8 (15) 15 $13 Astor 14 Gilbert&G=85 14 Vivino=3.2 (64) 13/12 Gold Bordeaux 14/13 13 Vivino=
105
Bordeaux Grande Res 12 Best Buy WE 12 WE=88 12 $13 WE
Ch Haut Colombier Prem Cotes de Blaye 14/15/16 14 Cited Wine Hachette 17 14 WS=87 14 $15 WS 10 WS=89 10 $20 WS
08 Very Successful Hachette 11 08 WS=86 08 $14 WS 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 04 Very Successful Hachette 08 Ch Haut Condissas Medoc 13/14/15 (Rollan de By) 10 TWCI=89-91 09 One of 10 Best Values Decanter 09 Decanter=4star 09 Merlot 09 Decanter=17/20 08 Silver Decanter 12 07 RP=88-91 06 RP=91 05 Silver IWC 09 05 RP=90-92 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 04 RP=90 Medoc Prestige 13/14/15 15 RP=90-92 15 $37-97WineS 10 ST=87 07 Grand Gold Brussels 09 07 ST=87 06 Gold Brussels; Silver Decanter 10 06 RP=90-92 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 ST=89+? 05 WS=88 05 RP=89-91 Ch Haut Gaussens Bordeaux Sup 14/15/16 14 Very Successful Hachette 17 09 Silver LA 11 08 Bronze LA 10 Ch Haut Grignon Medoc 13/14/15 15 WS=87 15/14 $15 WS 14 WS=87
Ch Haut Guillebot Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15 14 W&S=NR 14 $15 W&S 09 Bronze LA; Comm’d Decanter 12 Les Hauts de Lagarde See: Vignobles Raymond
Ch Haut-Lagrange Pessac-Leognan 13/14/15 15 RP=? 15 $16 WineS 08 WS=85 06 Cited Wine Hachette 10 06 WS=84
Ch Haut-Landon Bordeaux Sup 14/15 14 WS=86 14 $10 WS
Haut Logat Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=78
Ch Haut-Maillet Pomerol 13/14/15 13 Cited Wine Gachette 17 06 WS=88 06 $50 WS 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 WS=88 04 Cited Wine Hachette 08 04 WS=87 04 $42 WS Ch Haut-Marbuzet St-Estephe Cru Bourgeois Except 13/14/15 15 50%CS-40Merlot-5CF-5PV 15 RP=84-86 15 $38 WAlert 10 ST=91 09 WE=94 08 Vin Remarquable Hachette 12 08 SS=16.0/20 08 Coeur Selection Hachette 12 08 Decanter=3star 07=50%CS-40%Merlot-10%CF) 07 WS=87 07 ST=87 07 RP=83-85 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 RP=87 06 Decent WD 06 WD=15-16/20 06 WS=88 06 $40 WS 06 ST=88-89 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 WS=91 05 $48 WS 05 ST=92 05 RP=89-91 Ch Hayt Maurin Sauv Bordeaux 14/15/16 16 W&S=NR 16 $12 W&S 14 W&S=NR 14 $13 W&S
Ch Haut-Mazieres 14 Bordeaux 14/15 14 RC=88 14 Decanter=95 14 JR=16/20 106
Ch Haut Millet Blaye de Bordeaux VV 14/15/16 16 WE=87 16 $25 WE
Ch Haut Nouchet Pessac-Leognan 13/14/15 15 RP=87-89 15 WS=91 12 Celar Selection WE 12 WE=92 12 $40 WE Ch Haut Peyrefaire Blaye Cotes de Boprdeaux 13/14/15/16 16 WE=88 16 $24 WE
Ch Haut la Pereyre Bordeaux Sup 12/13/14/15 15 WS=84 15 $17 WS 06 Very Successful Hachette 09 06 Hach=1star Cadillac Cotes de Bordeaux Hachette 11
Ch Haut Peyruguey Bordeaux 15/16 16 WE=85 16 $12 WE 10 WS=85 10 $10 WS Ch Haut Phillippon Bordeaux 13/14/15/16 16 Silver LA 17 10 Bronze LA 11 Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15/16 16 Silver LA 17
Ch Haut la Pointe Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux 14/15/16 16 WE=87 16 $25 WE
Ch Haut Rian Bordeaux 15/16 16 W&S=NR 16 $14 W&S
Ch Haut Selve Graves 13/14/15 15 WS=88 15 $23 WS 15 RP=84-86 15 $13-14 WineS 14 RP=83 09 Bronze IWC; Comm’d Decanter 12 09 CS-Merlot 08 WS=86 08 $24 WS 07 Silver Paris 09 Ch Haut Simard St-Emilion 13/14/15 15 60%Merlot-40CF 15 RP=92-95 09 70%Merlot-30%CF 09 WE=89 09 ST=87 08 WS=86 Ch Haut Sociondo Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux Cuvee Prestige 14/15 15 WE=89 15 $25 WE 15 Vivino=3.2 (199) 14 Could command $20 CostcoBlog 14 CostcoBlog=89 14 $7 Costco
Ch Haut-Sorillon Bordeaux Sup 15/16 (org grapes) 16 Gold/Silver LA 17 16 LA=92 16 $8 TrJ 16 Vivino=3.8 (9) 16 RC=87.5/86 16 CT=87 (2) 15 Gold LA 16 15 CT=86.5 (4) 13 Gold LA 14; Bronze LA 15 12 Best Buy WE 12 WE=85 12 $9 WE 12 Gold LA 14 12 CT=87 (22) 11 Silver Bordeaux 13 10 Silver LA 12 10 CT=87 (3) 09 WE=87 07 RC=85 06 RC=86 Ch Haut le Valette Blaye Cotes Bordeaux Cuvee Caracteres 14/15 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=88 15 $13 WE 14 Vin Remarquablke Hachette 17 Ch Haut-Vigneau Pessac-Leognan 13/14/15 15 JS=91-92 15 $19 K&L 15 WS=99 15 $19 WS 14 Vivino=3.6 (187)14 $13 K&L 13 WE=90 13/12 $24 WE 12 WE=88 11 Comm’d Decanter 13 11 Decanter=86 10/09 Bronze Decanter 12/11 10 WS=89 10 $23 WS 10 JS=90 10 JR=17 (92) 09 JR=16.5 990) 08 Comm’d IWC 10 08 WS=88 08 $23 WS 07 Comm’d Decanter 09; IWC 10 08/07 JR=16 (88) 107
07 Cited Wine Hachette 10 06 WS=88 06 $15 WS 06 NM=88
Ch les Hauts-Conseillants Lalande de Pomerol 13/14/15 15 90%Merlot-10CF 15 RP=90-92 15 $10-17WineS 06 WS=87 06 $35 WS 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 WS=86 05 $38 WS 05 NM=90 04/03 Very Successful Hachette 08/07 04 WE=87
Les Hauts de la Gaffeliere Bordeaux Sel d’Excellence 14/15 15 W&S=NR 15 $13 W&S 15 WS=83
Ch Les Hauts de Palette Cotes de Bordeaux 14/15 14 WS=84 14 $20 WS
Les Hauts de Smith Pessac-Leognan 13/14/15/16 16 TWCI=90 15 55%Merlot-45CS 15 RP=88-90 15 $24 WineS 15 WS=89 14 W&S=NR 14 $18 W&S
Ch La Haye St-Estephe 13/14/15 15 RP=86
Clos L’Hermitage Lalande de Pomerol 12/13/14/15 15 RP=89-91 14 RP=83-85 09 RP=87-88 L’Hermitage Lescours Alba St-Emilion 13/14/15 15 RP=87-89
L’Hermitage Lescours St-Emilion 13/14/15 15 RP=88-90
Ch Herve-Laroque Fronsac 14/15 15 WS=89 14 WS=87 14 $20 WS Ch Hosanna Pomerol 12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 JD=97-99 18 $170wine.com 18 WS=95-98 18 RP=95-97 18 JS=95-96 18 RP=95-97 16 JR=17+ 15 82%Merlot-18CF 15 RP=95-97 15 $145-175 15 WS=94 15 $153 WS 14 WS=93 14 $129 WS 10 ST=92 09 Merlot-CF 09 ST=92 09 WE=95 08 ST=91 08 RP=96-98 08 JJB=89-91 08 JJB=92-94 07 RP=89-91 07 WS=88-91 07 ST=89 06 Barrel Selection WE 06 WE=93/93 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 RP=94 06 ST=90-92 06 WS=90 06 $135 WS 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 ST=94 05 WE=93/95 05 WS=96 05 $163 WS 05 RP=94-96 Ch Hostens-Picant Ste-Foy Bordeaux 14/15/16 16 TWCI=88 15 WS=89 15/14 TWCI=87 13/12 TWCI=84 10 RP=85 10/09 TWCI=85
108
09 Silver Paris 11; Comm’d IWC 12 09 CF-Merlot 08 Cited Wine Hachette 11 08 WS=88 07 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 WS=85 05 Bronze Bordeaux 07 06 ST=87-89 05 Comm’d Decanter 09 05 WS=80-84 04 Very Successful Hachette 08 03 RP=88-90
Ste-Foy Bordeaux Lucullus 14/15/16 16/15 TWCI=91 14/12 TWCI=88 10 TWCI=90
Ch Hourtin-Ducasse Haut-Medoc 13/14/15 14 RP=84 10 WS=89 10 $20 WS 10 RP=87 09 Bronze IWC 12 09 CF-CS-Merlot Ch de la Huste Fronsac 14/15/16 15 #11 Top Value < $30 WS 15 WS=91 15 $18 WS 15 RP=89-91 14 WS=89 14 $20 WS 13 WS=87 13 $16 WS+ 10 WS=90 10 $25 WS 09 WS=89-92 07 Bronze Challenge 10 07 WS=86 07 $20 WS 06 WS=87 05 WS=88 Ch Hyot Castillon Cotes de Bordeaux 13/14/15 14 #27 Top Values < $30 WS 14 WS=90 14 $20 WS 14 Editor’s Choice WE 14 WE=91 14 $25 WE 14 JS=90 14 $13 K&L 14 RC=89 14 $15 wine.com 10 Smart Buy WS 10 WS=90 10 $17 WS 10 Gold Bordeaux, France-Macon 11 10 JS=89 08 WS=88 08 $17 WS 06 WS=84 05 WS=87 Ch L’If St Emilion 13/14/15 15 80%Merlot-20CS 15 RP=92-94 15 $328-414 RP 15 WS=93 14 WS=92
Ignatus Bordeaux 14/15/16 10 Best Buy WE 16 WE=87 16 $10 WE
Ch l’Isle Fort Bordeauz Sup 14/15/16 16 WDecider=89 10 ST=90 09 Bronzr Decanyer 12 08 WS=86 Ch d’Issan Margaux 3rd Cru Classe 12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 Decanter=96 18 $65 wine.com 18 JS=95-96 18 RP=94-96 18 JD=93-95 16/15 TWCI=95 15 65%CS-35Merlot 15 RP=93-95 15 $55-70WAlert 14 TWCI=92 13 WS=86 13 $47 WS 13 TWCI=90 12 TWCI=93 11 TWCI=92 10 69%CS-31%Merlot 10 ST=91 10/09 TWCI=95 09 60%Merlot-CS 09 RP=93-95 09 ST=89 09 WE=89-91 08 ST=89 08 RP=91-93 08 WS=87-90 08 JJB=91-93 08 TWCI=83 109
07 RP=87-90 07 WS=84-87 07 ST=88 07 TWCI=89 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 ST=88-89 09 NM=95 06 WE=92 06 RP=94 06 WS=89 06 $48 WS 06 TWCI=92 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 ST=89 05 Highly Rec’d W&S 4/06 05 W&S=2stars 05 Stunning concentration WW 05 WS=92 05 $61 WS 05 RP=92-94 05 WW=92-93 05 TWCI=94 Ch Clos des Jacobins St-Emilion GC 13/14/15 13 RP=88-90 13 $24 RP 10 RP=90 10 ST=87 10 TWCI=90-93 09 75%M-23%CF-CS 09 WE=91 09 ST=87 09 RP=92-94 08 RP=89-91 07 WS=86 06 RP=90 06 ST=88-91 06 WS=92 06 $35 WS
Ch Jamin Bordeaux 14/15 15 Silver LA 17; Silver LA 16 15 WS=84 15 $12 WS
Ch La Jarre Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15 15 Gold LA 17 15 LA=92 15 100%Malbec 15 RP=88 Clos du Jaugueyron Margaux 12/13/14/15/16 16 TWCI=90 10 RP=89 09 CS-Merlot 09 RP=88-90 08 RP=85-87 07 RP=87-88 07 ST=86 06 RP=89+ 06 ST=86-88 05 ST=88-90
Ch Jean L’Arc Bordeaux Rouge 14/15/16 16 Bronze LA 17 09 Silver LA 11 Bordeaux Sup 14/15/16 15 Gold LA 17 15 LA=92
Ch Jean de Bel Air Bordeaux Rouge 14/15/16 16 Gold LA 17 16 LA=92
Jean Marc Barthez Bordeaux 13/14/15 14 W&S=NR 14 $13 W&S
Ch Jean-Faure St-Emilion GC 13/14/15/16/17/18 18 WS=92-95 18 $34 wine.com 18 JD=93-95 18 Decanter=93 15 RP=89-91 15 $31-73 WineS 13 WS=90 10 ST=90 10/ 09 54%CF-40%M-Malbec 9 ST=89 08 WS=87 08 ST=89 07 Bronze Challenge 10 07 WE=87 07 ST=87 07 RP=85-87 06 Cited Wine Hachette 10 06 WBlB=86 06 ST=87-89 06 WS=80-84 05 Vin Remarquable Hachette 09 05 WS=86 05 $40 WS 110
05 WE=89 05 ST=91 Ch Jean Faux Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15 15 Top Value < $30 WS 15 WS=90 15 $25 WS 14 W&S=89 14 $28 W&S 14 WS=89 13 WS=87 13 $30 WS 10 RP=89 09 WS=88-91 09/08 RP=87-89 08 Silver LA 11 07 WS=88 07 $28 WS 07 RP=85-87 06 Vin Remarquabls Hachette 10 Bordeaux Sup Les Sources 13/14 15 15 WS=87 15 $20 WS 14 WS=87
Ch Jean de Gue Lalande-de-Pomerol 13/14/15 13 WS=BT 08 Gold Challenge 10 08 WS=88 08 $25 WS 06 Cited Wine Hachette 10 06 RP=91
Ch Jeanguillon Bordeaux Sup 14/15 12 Best Buy WE 12 WE=88 12 $11 WE
Jean-Luc T unevin Mauvais See: Mauvais
Jean Medeville Bordeaux 13/14/15 14 W&S=NR 14 $14 W&S
Jean-Pierre Mouiex St-Emilion 13/14/15 15 “Top Value” WineFront.com.au. 09 JR=15.5 (86) 06 WS=87 05 Comm’d Decanter 09 05 WE=87 05 $24 WE 05 WS=85 Ch Joanin Becot Cotes de Castillon 12/13/14/15/16 16 TWCI=90 16 Decanter=89 16 CT=90 (1) 15 Cellar Selection WE 15 WE=92 15 $35 WE 15 TWCI=91 15 $21 JJB 15 80%Merlot-20CF 15 RP=90-92 15 $21 WAlert 15 #3 Top Value < $30 WS 15 WS=92 15 $23 WS 15 CT=91 (1) 14 JS=90-91 14 $20 K&L 14 RP=91 14 Vinous=90 14 WS=90 14 TWCI=89 14 W&S=NR 14 $20 W&S 13 WS=86-89 14 CT=89 (2) 13 TWCI=88 13 JCLee=82 13 CT=88 (1) 12 Best Buy WE 12 WE=91 12 $15 WE 12 Great Value JR 12 JR=16.5 (90) 12 $22 JJB 12 Two Stars Hachette 16 12 JS=90 12 $28 Zachys 12 Vinous=91 12 $30 TW&M 12 RP=90 12 JCLee=82 12/11/10 TWCI=89 12 $20 K&L 11 One Star Hachette 15 11 JR=17 (92) 11 $23 wine.com 09 75%Merlot-CF 10 RP=89 10 ST=86 10 JR=16 (88) 09 ST=87 09 RP=91-93 09 WS=89-92 09 TWCI=92 111
08 One Star Hachette 12 08 RP=90-92 08 WS=87-90 08 JBB=89-91 08 TWCI=91/90 07 Two Stars Hachette 11 07 WS=84 07 $22 WS 07 RP=88-91 07 ST=89
Ch Joinin Bordeaux 14/15 15 WS=86 15 $17 WS 14 Very Successful Hachette 127 14 WS=85 14 $14 WS 10 Silver Decanter 12 10 WS=90 10 $12 WS
Ch le Joyeux Bordeaux 14/15 12 Best Buy WE 12 WE=87 12 $12 WE 10 Silver LA 11 Ch des Judes Bordeaux 15/16 16 WE=87 16 $13 WE
Ch du Juge Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 Silver LA 17 11 Bronze LA 12 Bordeaux Sup 14/15 15 Bronze LA 17
Ch Julien Bordeaux 14/15 15 Silver LA 17
Ch Julian Bordeaux Sup 14/15 14 WS=87 14 $15 WS 12 Best Buy WE 12 WE=88 12 $13 WE 11 Bronze LA 12 10 Silver LA 12 10 WE=85 10 $14 WE 09 WE=84 09 $15 WE 08/07 Cited Wine Hachette 10 Clos Junet St-Emilion 13/14/15 15 RP=90-92
Dom des Justices Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15 15 WS=88 14 WS=87 14 $19 WS 14 W&S=85 Kirkland Sig (Costco) Bordeaux Sup 14/15 15 Ch Petit Freylon 15 RC=87 15 $8 Costco 15CostcoBlog=87 15 Vivino=2.9 (12) 13 Best Buy WE 13 WE=87 13 $9 WE 13/12 SCEA Gongfrier Freres 12 Best Buy WE 12 WE=85 12 $7 WE 12 WS=82 11 WE=85 11 WS=86 10 RC=87 10 WS=84 10 Best Buy WE 10 WE=85 10 $7 WE Medoc (Unimedoc A. F.) 13 Best Buy WE 13 WE=87 13 $9 WE 13 WS=84 09 68%CS-32%Merlot 09 RC=87 09 CellarT 86.5 (24) 09 CostcoBlog 86 Pauillac 14/15 15 Big name, budget price ReverseWS15 CostcBlog=92 15 $23 Costco 15 WE=90 15 RC=89 14 WE=89 14 CostcBlog=91 14 $23 Costco
Ch Kirwan Margaux GC Classe 12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 WE=94-96 18 $45 wine.com 18 WS=92-95 18 Decanter=93 15 Editor’s Choice WE 15 WE=96 15 $41 WE 15 RP=89-91 15 WS=92 15 $49 WS 14 Edotor’s Choice WE 14 WE=94 14 $45 WE 14 Decanter=90 112
13 Editor’s Choice WE 13 WE=92 13 WS=84-87 11 GDP=92 11 $50 GDP 10 JJB=92 10 WE=94 10 RP=92+ 09 Dec=4.5star 09 WE=94 09 WS=90 09 ST=88 09 RP=90-92 08 RP=88-90 07 Cellar Selection WE 07 WE=91 07 $45 WE 07 RP=89-92 07 WS=86-89 07 ST=87 06 Top Pick K&L 06 WD=16-17/20 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 RP=88 06 Coup de Coeur Hachette 10 06 WE=91 06 ST=88-90 06 WS=90 06 $47 WS
Margaux K de Kirwan 12/13/14/15 12 Cellar Selection WE 12 WE=90 12 $30 WE
See their second wine: Les Charmes de Kirwan
Kressman Bordeaux Grande Res 14/15 15 Silver LA 17 15 Merlot-CS-CF 13 Very successful Hachette 16 11 Bettane&D=13.5 08 Bettane&D=14 07 Bronze Challenge 09 Ch Labadie Medoc 14/15/16 15 WS=88 15 $19 WS 15 RP=90 14 RP=84 14 $9-13 RP 10 RP=89 09 Vin Exceptionel Hachette 13 09 Hachette=3 star 09 Couer Selection Hachette 13 Ch Labat Haut-Medoc Cru Bourgeois 13/14/15 15 RP=82 14 RP=88 14 $15-22 RP 13 WS=78-81 07 Silver Bordeaux 10 07 Comm’d Decanter 10 07 WE=88 07 $25 WE
Ch Lalatut Grand Res Bordeaux Sup Cuvee Prestige 13/14/15 15 50%CF-30Merlot-20CS 14 WS=86 14 $14 WS
Coted de Bordeaux Premiere 13/14/15 15 RP=89-91 15 $22 MSRP
Ch Labegorce Margaux Cru Bourgeois 12/13/14/15/16 16 TWCI=92 16 $30/2WHouse 16 RP=94-96 16 $32 wine.com 16 WE=94-96 16 $35 K&L 16 JS=93-95 15 50%CS-44%Merlot-4%PV-2%CF 15 TWCI=92 15 $29 WHouse 15 Editor’s Choice WE 15 WE=95 15 $30 WE 15 JS=93-94 15 $28 K&L 15 WE=94-96 15 $34 Milesima 15 WS=88 15 RP=91-93 15 JR=16+ (89) 15 JCLee=94 14 58%Merlot-40%CS-2%PV 14 TWCI=91 14 $25 K&L 14 WE=90-92 14 $35 TW&M 14 Vinous=91-94 14 RP=93 14 JS=90-91 14 WS=87-90 113
13 WS=89 13 $25 WS 13 TWCI=88 12 Coup de Coeurs 3 stars Hachette 16 12 TWCI=89 12 $35 TW&M 12 JR=16.5 (90) 12 C$45.50 SAQ 11 Vin remarquable 2 stars Hachette 15 11 GDP=88 11 $30 TW&M 11 NM=91-93 11 $45 WineCh 11 JS=90-91 11 TWCI=90 10 45%CS-45%Merlot-6%CF-4%PV 10 RP=87 10 $39 Millesima 10 Cited Wine Hachette 14 10 ST=87 10 JJB=88 10 TWCI=91 09 Silver Decanter 12 09 WE=95 09 Very Successful 1 star Hachette 13 09 RP=90 09 WS=90 09 ST=88-90 09 Decanter=3star 09 Decanter=16/20 09 TWCIU=89 08 WS=88 08 ST=87 08 WBlB=86 08 SS=16.0/20 08 Decanter=3star 08 RP=82-84 08 TWCI=88 08 JR=16 (88) 07 WE=90 07 RP=83-85 07 WS=82-85 07 ST=85
Ch Laborde Haut Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=84
Ch Clos Labory St-Estephe 5th Cru Classe 14/15/16 16 TWCI=90 15 TWCI=87 14 TWCI=90 12 TWCI=87 10 65%CS-35%Merlot 10 ST=87 10 JJB=92+ 10 TWCI=88 09 ST=86 09 RP=87-88+ 09 $36-52 RP 09 TWCI=87 08 ST=88 08 RP=84-86 08 WBlB=87 08 TWCI=84 07 RP=86-88 07 ST=85 07 WS=85-88 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 ST=88 06 WS=86 06 $30 WS 06 RP=89-91/77 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 WE=89 05 ST=88-90 05 Comm’d IWC 07 05 WS=87 05 TWCI=88
Ch Labrousse Blaue Cotes de Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=89 15 $8 WE 14 Best Buy WE 14 WE=86 14 $7 WE 12 Snooth=88 Ch Lacaussade At-Martin Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux Trois Moulins 14/15 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=87 15 $10 WE
Ch Lacombe Noaillac Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=83 114
10 WE=86 10 $18 WE 09 Bronze Decanter; Comm’d IWC 12 09 CF-CS-Merlot Lacoste-Borie Paulliac 13/14/15 15 60%CS-30Merlot-10CF 15 RP=87-89
Lacour Jacquet Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=85
Ch Ladignac Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=88
Ch Ladonnet Bordeaux 12/13/14/15 15 WS-85 15 $14 WS
Ch Laffitte Carcasset St-Estephe 13/14/15 15 RP=84 15 $12-30 WineS 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=92 14 $45 WE Ch Lafitte Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 RP=84-86
Ch Lafite Monteil Bordeaux Sup 14/15 14 Silver LA 17
Ch Lafite Rothschild Paulliac PGC 10/11/12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 91%CS-8.5Merlot-0.5PV 18 RP=98-100 18 650wine.com 18 JS=99-100 18 Decanter=98-100 15 91%CS-9Merlot 15 RP=94-96 15 WS=95 15 $585 WS 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=97 14 $450 WE 14 WS=95 14 $425 WS 14 Decanter=95 13/12 Cellar Selection WE 13 WE=94 12 WE=96 12 $550 WE 10 87.2%CS-12.8%Merlot 10 ST=95 09 82%CS-17%Merlot-CF 09 One of Top 15 Decanter 09 Decanter=5star 09 Decanter=19.5/20 09 WE=96 09 ST=96 09 RP=98-100 09 One of Top 32 JJB 09 JJB=95-97 08 WS=87 08 ST=92 08 RP=98-100 08 WBlB=96 07 RP=94 07 WE=94 07 $455 WE 07 ST=90 07 WS=89-92 06 Cellar Selection WE 06 WE=96/96 06 Top Pick K&L 06 RP=97 06 Vin Exceptionnel Hachette 10 06 WBlB=96 06 Coup de Coeur Hachette 10 06 ST=92-95 06 WS=95 06 $590 WS 06 AG=94 05 Best of Vintage W&S 4/06 05 W&S=98 05 Elegant, very refined, long WW 05 WS=98 05 Vin Exceptionnel Hachette 09 05 RP=94-98 05“Coup de Coeur Hachette 09 05 ST=97 05 WS=92-94 05 Cellar Selection WE 05 WE=97/99 05 WW=98-100 04 Vin Exceptionnel Hachette 08 04 WE=96 04 Coup de Coeur Hachette 08 04 WS=93 04 RP=92-94 04 ST=93 04 WW=96-98 04/03 Vin Exceptionnel Hachette 08/07 03 RP=100 03 WE=97 03 WS=96 03 ST=93+ 02 WS=95 115
02 RP=94 02 ST=92+ 01 WS=96 01 RP=94 00 WS=100 00 RP=100
See also their second wine: Carruades de Lafite
See also: Pensee de Lafleur
Ch Lafleur Pomerol 10/11/12/13/14/15/16/17 17 WineS=96+ 16 JR=17+ 15 51%Merlot-49CF 15 RP=97-99 15 $850 WAlert 10 62%CF-38%Merlot 10 ST=96 10 $1299+ ST 09 53%CF-47%Merlot 09 One of Top 15 Decanter 09 Decanter=5star 09 Decanter=19.5/20 09 ST=95 09 RP=94-97 09 $1338+ RP 09 RP=94-96+ 08 ST=92 07 Wonderful WS 07 WS=90-93 07 ST=90 07 RP=90 07 $462-899 RP 06 RP=95 06 $799+ RP 06 ST=92-94 06 C$999 BCLS 06 WS=95-100 05 ST=95 05 $1499 K&L 05 WS=100 05 $2000 WS 05 RP=94-96 05 $1895 RP 04 WS=94 04 ST=91 04 RP=94 03 WS=97 03 RP=95 02 ST=89 02 RP=89 02 WS=89 Les Pensees de Lafleur Pomerol 12/13/14/15/16 16/15 TWCI=91 14 TWCI=90 13 TWCI=88 12 TWCI=89 10 62%Merlot-CF 10 ST=87 10 TWCI=91 09/08/06 TWCI=90 07 ST=85 06 ST=86-88 06 WS=85-88 05 ST=88-91 05 WS=92-94 04 RP=87 04 WS=89-91 03 RP=86-88 03 RP=84 Ch Lafleur-Gazin Pomerol 12/13/14/15/16 18 JS=94=95 18 $50 wine.com 18 WS=91-94 18 Decanter=93 18 RP=91-93 16/15 TWCI=90 16 $50 wine.com 16 $50 K&L 15 98%Merlot-2CF 15 RP=85-87 15 $47-50WAlert 15 WS=91 15 $47 WS 15 JCLee=91 15 $50 Zachys 15 JR=16 (88) 15 $50 K&L 14 TWCI=87 14 $42 wine.com 116
14 JCLee=89 14 JR=16.5 (90) 13 TWCI-86 13 $50 Zachys 13 JCLee=88 13 $57 wine.com 12 Very Successful Hachette 16 12/11 TWCI=87 10 Cited Wine Hachette 14 10 ST=88 10 TWCI=89 09 80%Merlot-20% CF 09 WE=90 09 $55 WHouse 09 Very Successful Hachette 13 09 ST=88 09 RP=87-89 09/08 TWCI=86 08 RP=88-89 08 JJB=90-92 07 RP=83-85 07 WS=84-87 07 ST=88 07 W&S=NR 07 $54 W&S 07 TWCI=84 Ch Lafleur-Petrus Pomerol 12/13/14/15/16 16/15 TWCI=95 15 WS=95-98 14 WS=94 14 $125 WS 14/13 TWCI=93 12 TWCI=94 11 TWCI=93 10 TWCI=95 09 TWCI=97 08 JJB=91-93 08 TWCI=94 07 62%Merlot-CF 07 ST=85 06 TWCI=91 C Lafleur du Roy Pomerol Cuvee Excellence 13/14/15 15 Cellar Selection WE 15 WE=92 15 $35 WE 14 Best Buy WE 14 WE=92 14 $39 WE Ch Lafon-Rochet St-Estephe PGC 12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 JS=93-94 18 $46 wine.com 18 Decanter=94 18 WS=90-93 15 54%CS-35Merlot-6CF 15 RP=90-92 15 Cellar Selection WE 15 WE=95 15 $42 WE 15 WS=89 15 $46 WS 15 TWCI=88-90 11 GDP=89 10 66%CS-31%Merlot-3%PV 10 ST=90 10 JJB=91 07 60%CS-35%Merlot-CF-PV 09 WE=89 09 ST=91 09 RP=91-93 09 Decanter=4star 09 Decanter=17.5 08 RP=87-90 08 ST=87 07 RP=87 07 WE=88 07 $35 WE 07 ST=85 07 WS=84-87 06 Good Character WD 06 WD=16-17/20 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 RP=88 06 ST=88-90 06 WS=85-88 05 Outstanding for price QWR 05 WE=90 05 Good WD 05 WD=16-17/20 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 WS=90 05 ST=91 05 RP=90-93 04 Vin Remarquable Hachette 08 04 WS=88 04 ST=87 04 RP=90 Ch Lafont Fourcat Bordeaux 15/16 16 Jeff Leve=89 117
15 $10 K&L 11 Jeff Leve=86 10 WE=82 10 $20 WE 10 CT=89 (11)
Ch Laforet Bordeaux 14/15/16 16 Silver LA 17 14 Very Successful Hachette 17 Bordeaux Sup 14/15/16 16 Bronze LA 17
Ch Laforge St-Emilion GC 11/12/13/14/15 15 90%Merlot-10CF 15 RP=90-92 15 $28-46WineS 19 Merlot-CF 08 RP=92-94 07 RP=89 07 ST=88 06 WE=91 06 $50 WE 06 WS=87 06 RP=93 06 ST=87-90
Ch de Lagarde Bordeaux En Memoire 14/15/16 16 WE=88 16 $14 WE
Le Petit du Ch de Lagarde 14/15/16 16 WE=86
Les Hauts de Lagarde 13/14/15/16 16 WE=86 16 $13 WE 15 WS=85 15 $15 WS Bordeaux Sup Grand Millesime 14/15 org grapes 15 Bronze LA 17
Ch Lagarosse Prem Cotes de Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 RP=85-87 06 Bronze Paris 09 06 WE=87 06 $15 WE 6 WS=85 Ch de Lagorce Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=85 15 $10 WE
Ch Lagrange Pomerol 13/14/15 15 WS=90 15 $68 WS
Ch Lagrange St Julien 3rd Cru 12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 RP=93-95+ 18 $48 wine.com 18 WE=93-95 18 JS=94-95 16 JS=94-96 16 RP=94-96 16 WS=93-95 16 WE=93-95 16 Decanter=95 15 75%CS-17Merlot-8PV 15 RP=90-92 15 WS=91 15 $46 WS 11 GDP=88 10 75%CS-25%Merlot 10 ST=88 09 73%CS-27%Merlot 09 WE=94 09 ST=89 09 RP=90-93 08 WE=91 08 RP=90-92 08 ST=89 08 WS=88-91 08 JJB=88-90 07 RP=90 07 WE=90 07 $45 WE 07 ST=90 07 WS=84-87 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 WE=93/92 06 Coup de Coeur Hachette 10 06 WS=90 Best value generally F&W 06 06 WD=14.5-15.5 06 Top Pick K&L 06 RP=91 06 Good WD 06 ST=89-91 06 WS=93 See their second wine: Les Fifes de Lagrange 118
Ch Lagrave-Martillac See Ch Latour-Martillac
Ch Lagrezette Chevalier du Ch Malbec-Merlot 13/14/15 15 Editor’s Choice WE 15 WE=92 15 $34 WE
Ch Lague Fronsac 13/14/15 15 RP=86-88
Ch la Lagune Haut Medoc 12/13/14/15/16 16 TWCI=94 15 RP=88-90 15 $45-48WAlert 15 TWCI=93 15 JCLee=88 15 JR=17 (92) 14 TWCI=91 14 $45 TrJ 14 $44 WHouse 14 $50 Millesima 14 $50 TW&M 13 TWCI=90 12/11/10 Coup de Coeurs Hachette 16 12 TWSCi-91 12 JR=14 11 TWCI=90 11 JR=16 988) 11 GDP=90 11 $50 GDP 10 50%CS-40%Merlot-10%PV 10 ST=88 10 JJB=91 10/09 TWCI=94 09 60%CS-25%Merlot-15%PV 09 ST=89 09 Vin Remarquable Hachette 13 09 RP=94-96 08 Great Value WBlB 08 WBlB=92 08 Vin Remarquable Hachette 12 08 RP=92-94 08 ST=90 08 Classic Bordeaux JJB 08 JJB=91-93 08 TWCI-91 07 AG=87 07 RP=90 07 WS=84-87 07 ST=88 07 TWCI=88 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 RP=91 06 ST=90-91 06 WS=85-88 06 TWCI=91 05 Outstanding for price QWR 05 WS=91 05 $50 WS 05 Vin Remarquable Hachette 09 05 ST=92 05 WE=93 05 RP=92-94 05 WS=89-91 05 TWCI=94
Ch Lalande St-Julien Cru Bourgeois 13/14/15/16 15 WS=89 15 $39 WS 12 Gilbert&G=90 11 Gault&M=16 (88) 09 CT=87 (8) 09 Silver Bordeaux 10 08 Silver Bordeaux 10 06 Cited Wine Hachette 10
Ch Lalande-Borie St-Julien 12/13/14/15/16 16 55%Merlot-CS 16 TWCI=91 16 $28 wine.com 16 WineDecider=9216 $30 Zachys 16/15 WE=92-94 16 $56/1.5 K&L 16 C$52 LCBO 15 55%Merlot-45CS 15 RP=89-91 15 $27-31WAlert 15 Top Value < $30 WS 15 WS=90 15 $26 WS 15 TWCI=88 15 JCLee=90 15 JR=16.5 (90) 15 $26 Sh-L 119
15 WineDecider=91 14 WE=92 14 $25 K&L 14 Vinous=91 14 $?? WE 14 JS=91-92 14 C$45.25 SAQ 14 TWCI=89 14 $33 Millesima 14 WineDecider=89 13 TWCI=86 13 WineDecider=88 12 WE=90 12 $32 WineCh 12 TWCI=87/87 12 JCLee=87 12 JR=15.5 (86) 12 WineDecider=88 12 CT=89 (17) 11 WE=91 11 $56/1.5Costco 11 TWCI=88 11 WineDecider=86 10 WE=91 10 RP=87 10 ST=86 10 WineDecider=89 10 TWCI=90/91/90 10/ 09 50%CS-40%Merlot-10%CF 09 WE=92 09 $40 K&L 09 One Star Hachette 13 09 ST=90/87 09 RP=88-90 09 TWCI=90 09 WS=90 09 JS=91 09 WineDecider=90 08 WS=89 08 $25 WS 08 RP=88-90 08 WineDecider=89 08 WE=90 07 WS=86 07 $21 WS 07 RP=83-85 07 WE=89 07 WineDecider=87 06 Cited Wine Hachette 10 06 WE=88 06 RP=87 06 ST=86-88 06 WS=87 06 $23 WS 06 WineDecider=88 05 Vin Remarquable Hachette 09 05 WS=85 05 $23 WS 05 RP=85-87 05 $40 K&L 05 WE=90 05 TWCI=87/90 05 WineDecider=89
Lalande de Pomerol See: Ginistet
Ch de Lamarque Haut-Medoc Cru Bourgeois 14/15/16 16 TWCI=90 16 CT=90 (1) 15 CT=88 (1) 15 RP=90-92 15 $17 WineS 15/14 TWCI=88 14 WS=87 14 $20 WS 14 JS=92 14 $22 K&L 14 RP=90 14 C$40 LCBO 14 Vinous=90 14 WE=90 13 TWCI=84 12/10/09 TWCI=88 12 $25 TW&M
10 RP=87 10 Decanter=90 10 CT=89.5 (15) 120
09 RP=86-88 09 CT=86.8 (15) 08 SS=15.5/20 08 Decanter-3star 08 RP=85-86 08 TWCI=87
Ch Lamartine Cahors Malbec-Merlot 13/14/15 13 Best Buy WE 13 WE=89 13 $13 WE
Ch Lamartre St Emilion Etrange Rumeur 13/14/15 14 WS=87
St Emilion Passage Secret 13/14/15 14 WS=87
Ch Lamothe Bordeaux 13/14/15 14 W&S=NR 14 $16 W&S 12 Best Buy WE 12 WE=87 12 $12 WE Ch Lamothe-Bergeron Haut-Medoc 15/16 16 RP=89-91 15 RP=86 13 RP=82-84 10 WS=90 10 $24 WS 10 RP=87 10 WE=91 10 JR=15.5 (86) 10 Decanter=16 (88) Ch Lamothe Castera Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 WE=86 15 $13 WE 15 Gilbert&G=85 15 $10 K&L Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15 15 WE=84 15 $15 WE 15 Gilbert&G=87 14 Gilbert&G=86 Ch Lamothe-Cissac Haut-Medoc VV 12/13/14/15 15 RP=88 14 RP=89 12 Cellar Selection WE 12 WE=91 12 $30 WE 10 WS=87 10 $25 WS 09 Bronze Decanter 12 Ch Lamothe de Haux Cadillac Cotes de Bordeaux Prem Cuvee 13/14/15 15 WS=86 15 $20 WS 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=91 14 $30 WE 14 WS=86 14 $19 WS 08 Very Successful Hachatte 11 08 Silver Bordeaux 09 Ch Lamothe-Vincent Bordeaux 14/15 15 WS=84 15 $12 WS 12 Best Buy WE 12 WE=85 12 $10 WE Bordeaux Cuvee Selection 12/13/14 14 Best Buy WE 14 WE=88 14 $13 WE 10 Best Buy WE 10 WE=87 10 $12 WE 10 Gold Paris 11 09 Gold Bordeaux 10 08 Silver Bordeaux 09 08 WS=88 08 $20 WS
Bordeaux Merlot 14/15/16 15 Gold LA 17 15 LA=92
Bordeaux Merlot-Cab Sauv 13/14/15/16 16 Silver LA 17 15 WS=84 15 $12 WS 10 Gold Paris 11 10 JR=16 (88) Bordeaux Intense 14/15/16 16 Silver LA 17 CS-Merlot 14 Best Buy WE 14 WE=88 14 $13 WE 14 Gold LA 17 14 LA=92 10 Gold Paris 11 10 JR=16 (88) 09 Silver Bordeaux 10 Bordeaux Sup Heritage 13/14/15 15 Silver LA 17 10 Comm’d Decanter 12 10 WE=88 10 $15 WE 09 Silver Paris 11 08 Comm’d Decanter, IWC 10 Bordeaux Sup Le Grand Rossignol 13/14/15 15 Gold LA 17 15 LA=93
Ch Landat Haut-Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=90
121
14 WS=87 14 $20 WS 10 WS=86 10 $20 WS
Ch Landereau Bordeaux Clairet 13/14/15 14 W&S=85 14 $17 W&S
Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15 14 W&S=NR 14 $18 W&S 09 Gold LA 12 09 LA=93
Ch Des Landes Lalande-de-Pomerol Maltus 13/14/15 15 WS=88 15 $48 WS
Ch de Landiras Graves 14/15 15 G&G=86 14 Platinum Best in Show Dec 16 14 Decanter=95 14 $13 K&L 14 RC=89/88 14 $15 wine.com 14 G&G=85 14 C$25 LCBO 14 WW=93 14 CT=88.1 (26) 14 Vivino=3.9 (293) 13 Cited Wine Hachette 16 13 Silver Brussels, Paris 15 13 Bronze Decanter 15 10 W&S=85 Ch Lanessan Haut-Medoc Cru Bourgeois Sup 14/15/16 16 JS-92-93 16 $16 K&L 16 RP=90-92 16 $16 wine.com 16 Decanter=91 16 $15 WHouse 16 TWCI=92 15 JS=91-93 15 $17 K&L 15 RP=90-92 15 $25 TW&M 15 TWCI=89 15 $17 wine.com 15 Decanter=91 15 $16 WHouse 15 JCLee=86 15 JR=16.5 (90) 14 Vinous=91 14 $15 K&L 14 RC=88 14 TWCI=87 14 WE=91 14 RP=90 14 Top Value WS 14 WS=90 14 JS=90 14 JR=16 (88) 12 TWCI=85 12 $21 WineCh 12 JR=15.5 (86) 11 TWCI=87 11 $21 WineCh 10 RP=87 10 TWCI=88 09 RP=90-92 09 $15 TW&M 09 TWCI=89 08 RP=88-90 08 TWCI=86
Ch Langoa-Barton St-Julien 3rd Cru 12/13/14/15/16 15 Cellar Selection WE 15 WE=95 15 $44 WE 15 WS=93 15 $50 WS 15 54%CS-38Merlot-8CF 15 RP=88-90 15 $44-50WAlert 14 WS=93 14 $42 WS 11 GDP=92 10 73%CS-17%Merlot-10%CF 10 ST=88 09 60%CS-30%Merlot-CF 09 WE=95 09 ST=87 09 RP=90-92+ 08 WS=91 08 ST=89 08 RP=88-90+ 08 WE=96 07 Good price:qual ratio QRW 08 07 RP=87 07 WE=91 07 $55 WE 07 ST=87 07 WS=92 122
06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 WE=91 06 Good WD 06 WD=15.5-16.5 06 Top Pick K&L 06 RP=89+ 06 ST=89-90 06 WS=91 05 Almost 95-100. Great value WW 05 WS=92 05 Favorite vintage Langoa RW 3/06 05 ST=90 05 Super potential WD 4/06 05 RW=18-19/20 05 Best value of demanded wines QWR05 WD=18-19 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 NM=90 05 WE=89/92 05 RP=90-92 04 WS=91 04 WE=90 04 ST=88 04 RP=90 04 Very Successful Hachette 08 Laplagnotte-Bellvue St-Emilion 13/14/15 15 RP=83-85
Ch Larcis-Ducasse St-Emilion GC 10/11/12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 JS=97-98 18 $70 wine.ocm 18 RP=96-98 18 JD=95-97+ 18 WS=94-97 18 Vinous=94-97 15 87%Merlot-13CS-13CF 15 RP=94-96 15 WS=95 15 $79 WS 14 WS=93 14 $54 WS 14 Decanter=92 10 85%Merlot-15%CF 10 ST=90/97+ 10 JJB=93 09 ST=91 09 RP=91-94 09 One of Top 32 JJB 09 JJB=96-98 08 RP=95-97 08 JJB=93-95 08 WS=90-93 07 Value < $500/case QRW Aut 08 07 RP=92 07 WS=87-90 07 ST=89 06 Good WD 06 WD=14-15/20 06 RP=91 06 AG=90 06 ST=89-92 06 WS=90 06 $52 WS 05 Great wine SS in Decanter 06 05 SS=18/20 05 WD=15.5-16.5 05 ST=94 05 WS=95 05 $210 WS 05 RP=96-100 04 WS=91 04 Merlot-89%-CF15% 04 RP=92
St Emilion Murmure de Larcis-Ducasse 13/14/15 15 WS=91 14 WS=89
Ch Larmande St-Emilion GC 13/14/15 15 RP=86-88 15 $22-34WineS 09 RP=86-88 08 WS=87 07 WS=86 07 $28 WS 07 RP=83-85 07 ST=84 06 RP=75 06 WS=88 05 Full-bodied, long, caressing WW 05 WS=92 05 $30 WS 05 Cited Wine Hachette 09 05 WE=89/89 05 ST=87-88 123
05 WS=89-91 Ch Laronde Desormes Bordeaux Sup 14/15 15 Silver LA 17
Ch Laroque St-Emilion GC 13/14/15/16 Merlot 16 WS=-92-94 16 $30 wine.com 16 JS=92-94 16 Decanter=93 16 RP=92 16 WE=90-92 15 #7 Top Value < $30 WS 15 WS=92 15 $29 WS 15 RP=90-92 15 $8-12 WAlert 12 Cellar Selection WE 12 WE=91 12 $45 WE 09 RP=87-88 08 Gold Paris 09 08 WS=87 08 Silver Decanter 12 08 RP=80-83 07 Comm’d IWC 10 07 WS=85-88 06 Bronze Decanter 09 06 WS=88 Ch Larose-Perganson Haut-Medoc Cru Bourgeois 13/14/15 15 RP=86 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=92 14 $27 WE 12 Editor’s Choice WE 12 WE=91 12 $25 WE 10 RP=88 09 Silver IWC; Bronze Decanter 12 09 CS-Merlot 08 Gold Paris 11; Bordeaux 10 07 Comm’d Decanter 10 06 Cited Wine Hachette 10 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05/04 Silver Brussels 07/06 04 WS=87 04 Vin Remarquable Hachette 08 Ch Larose-Trintaudon Haut Medoc Cru Bourgeois 13/14/15/16 16 CT=88 (1) 15 WS=87 15 $27 WS 15 RP=86 15 JR=15.5 (86) 15 CT=86.7 (3) 14 RP=91 14 $28 Millesima 14 CT=88.3 (3) 13 Editor’s Choice WE 13 WE=91 13 $25 WE 13 55%Merlot-45CS-4PV 13 JR=15.5 (86) 13 $13/375 Sh-L 12 Very Successful Hachette 16 12 JR=16 (88) 12 Editor’s Choice WE 12 WE=91 12 $25 WE 12 Silver Bruxelles, Decanter 15 12 Silver Munduz Vini 15 12 JS=90 12 Bronze IWC 15 10 WS=87 10 $20 WS 10 RP=89 10 JR=14.5 (82) 10 JS=90 10 Decanter=86 09 Silver IWC; Bronze Decanter 12 09 Dec 16.75 (91) 09 60%CS-40Merlot 09 JR=15.5 (86) 09 Comm’d Decanter 13 09 RP=91 09 Silver Bordeaux, IWC, MundusVivi 09 Decanter=4star 09 JR=16 (88) 09 WS=89-92 08 JR=15 (84)5 07 WE=87 07 $20 WE
Ch Laroze St-Emilion GC 13/14/15 15 RP=86 15 $27-28WAlert 14 #2 Top Value < $30 WS 14 WS=92 14 $22 WS 10 Merlot 10 ST=87 09 RP=86-88 08 WS=90 07 Silver IWC 10 07 WS=83-86 06 Gold Brussels 09 06 WS=87 06 Comm’d IWC 10 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 05 WE=88 124
05 WS=90 05 RP=88-90 04 WS=89 Larrivaux Haut-Medoc 14/15/16 16 53%Merlot-33CS-9PV-5CF 16 RP=89-91 16 $15 WHouse 15 41%Merlot-38CS-11CF-10PV 15 JCLee=89 15 $15 WHouse 15 WE=92 15 $28 WE 15 WS=88 15 $20 WS 15 JR=15 (84) 15 RP=88-90 15/14 Decanter=87 14 WS=88 14 $13 WS 14 RP=89 14 JCLee=87 14 JR=16.5 (90) 14 NealMartin=88-90 14 Coups de Coeur Gault&Millau 14 Gault&M- 14.5-15.5 14 Excellent Vino 14 Le Point=14.4 14 72%Merlot-17CS-5PV-8CF 14 RevueFR-13.3-14.5 14 Le Figaro=15.5 14 WinePatriot=87 13 41%Merlot-35CS-13CF-11PV 13 JCLee=72 13 RP=84 13 WE=86 13 $28 WE 13 NealMartin=85-87 13 Decanter 15.75 (85+) 13 ALarson 15.75 (85+) 12 Very Successful Hachette 16 12 JR=15.5 886) 12 58%Merlot-28CS-12CF-2PV 12 RP=85 12 Very Successful Hachette 16 12 WE=90 12 11 Editor’s Choice WE 11 WE=90 11 $19 WE 11/10/09/08 Cited Wine Hachette 15/14 11/10 RP=86 10 WS=88 10 $16 WS 10 RP=86 10 Vivino=3.6 (240) 09 RP=87 09 $26 Sh-L 08 WS=86 06 Cited Wine Hachette 10 Ch Larrivet-Haut-Brion Pessac-Leognan 13/14/15/16 16 TWCI=90 16 RP=89-91 16 $35-38WAlert 15 RP=91 15 $32-41WAlert 15 TWCI=92 15 $35 WHouse 15 JCLee=93 15 $35 K&L 15 JR=16.5 (90) 15 $35 wine.com 15 WS=91 15 $37 WS 15 JS=94 15 JDunnuck=93 15 Vinous=90-93 15 Decanter=91 14 Comm’d Decanter 16 14 TWCI=90 14 Silver Mundus Vini 16 14 JR=16 (88) 14 RP=88 13 TWCI=87 13 RP=84 13/12 JR=16 (88) 12 Very Succesful Hachette 15 12 TWCI=90 12/11 RP=90 11 TWCI=88 10 Vin Remarquable Hachette 14 10 ST=90 10 TWCI=90 10/09 RP=91 09 Very Successful Hachette 13 09 WE=91 09 RP=91-93 09 TWCI=89 08 ST=87 08 RP=90 08 WS=87-90 125
08 JJB=88-90 08 TWCI=90 07 RP=88 07 ST=87 06 WS=87 06 $30 WS 06 TWCI=88 06 RP=89
Ch Larteau Bordeaux Sup 14/15 15 RP=85-87 15 JCLee=89 14 Silver LA 17 14 WS=85 14 $10 WS 14 JCLee=87 12 Very Successful Hachette 16 12 JCLee=88 12 Silver Bruxelles, LA 15 12 Vivino=3.2 (19) 12 Bronze Decanter 15 11 Coup de Coeur 2 stars Hachette 15 11 JCLee=85 10 Merlot 10 WE=86 10 $17 WE 10 JCLee=87 09 CostcoBlog=88 09 RP=86-87 Ch Lary Bordeaux 14/15 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=86 15 $10 WE
Ch Lascombes Margaux 2nd Cru Classe 11/12/13/14/15/16 15/14/13/12 Cellar Selection WE 15 WE=96 15 $69 WE 15 RP=89-91 15 $68-85WAlert 15 WS=92 15 $77 WS 14 /13WE=93 14 $70 WE 12 WE=93 11 GDP=93 10 50%CS-45%Merlot-5%PV 10 ST=88 10 JJB=94 09 WE=93 09 ST=90 09 RP=94-96+ 09 WS=92-95 09 One of Top 32 JJB 09 JJB=96-98 08 WS=87 08 RP=91-94 08 WE=92-94 08 JJB=89-90 07 RP=91 07 WE=90 07 WS=88 07 AG=90 07 W&S=88 07 $100 W&S 07 ST=89 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 WE=90 06 RP=90 06 ST=90-91 06 WS=90 06 $79 WS 05 Great aroma, great intensity WW 05 RP=94-96 05 Vin Remarquable Hachette 09 05 ST=89-92 05 WS=93 05 $85 WS 05 WE=92/91 05 W&S=94 05 $100 W&S 04 WS=88 04 Vin Remarquable Hachette 08 04 WE=88 04 Coup de Coeur Hachette 08 04 ST=91 04 RP=93 03 Very Successful Hachette 07 03 WE=90 03 WS=91 03 ST=91 03 RP=92 03 WD=17/20 02 RP=93 02 WS=87 01 WS=90 126
01 RP=92 00 WS=89 See also: Chevalier de Lascombe
Ch Lassegue St-Emilion 12/13/14/15 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=92 14 $75 WE 09 60%M-20%CF-20%CS) 09 WE=88 09 ST=88 09 RP=90-92 07 ST=89 06 RP=89-91 06 ST=89-91 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 ST=89+ 05 RP=90-92 04 Very Successful Hachette 08 04 WE=92 04 ST=88 04 RP=90-91 03 RP=87-89 Ch Lastours Gaillac 14/15 14 Best Buy WE 14 WE=87 14 $12 WE
Ch Latour Paulliac PGC 10/11/12/13/14/15/16/17 17 WineS=96-98 16 TWCI=99 15 97%CS-3Merlot 15 RP=95-97 15 WS=97 15 JCLee=98 15/14 TWCI=97 14 WS=97 14 Decanter=96 14 TWCI=94 13 TWCI=94 12 Coup de Coeurs 3 stars Hachette 16 12 TWCI=95 11 Coup de Coeurs 3 stars Hachette 15 11 WS=96 11 $690 WS 11 TWCI=96 10 90.5%CS-8.5%Merlot-0.5%CF-PV 10 ST=96 10 $1491WineCh 10 Coup de Coeurs 3 stars Hachette 14 10/09 TWCI=100 10 $1750Millesi 10 $1500TW&M 09 91%CS-5%Merlot 09 One of Top 15 Decanter 09 Decanter=5star 09 $1508 JJB 09 Coup de Coeurs 3 stars Hachette 13 09 Decanter=19.5 09 $1600 Astor 09 WE=97 09 $1800TW&M 09 ST=97 09 $1999WineCh 09 RP=98-100 09 One of Top 32 JJB 09 JJB=96-98 08 3 stars Hachette 12 08 ST=92 08 $696 JJB 08 RP=96-98 08 $797 WineCh 08 TWCI=97 07 RP=92+ 07 WE=95 07 $500 WE 07 ST=92 07 WS=89-92 06 Cellar Selection WE 06 WE=96 06 Top Pick K&L 06 RP=93-96 06 Vin Exceptionnel Hachette 10 06 ST=93-95 06 Coup de Coeur Hachette 10 06 WS=95 06 TWCI=96 06 JR=12 05 Vin Exceptionnel Hachette 09 05 RP=96-99 05 Coup de Coeur Hachette 09 05 WS=99 05 $1110 WS 05 Best of Vintage W&S 4/06 05 W&S=100 05 ST=98 05 WW=99-100 05 Cellar Selection WE 05 WE=99/100 05 $2000 WE 05 TWCI=99 04 Vin Remarquable Hachette 08 04 WS=95 04=89% CS-10%M-1% PV 04 RP=94-96 04 WE=97 04 Collectible WS 3/31/07 04 ST=94 127
04 Top 10 WW 06 04 WW=96-98 04 TWCI=95 03 Vin Exceptionnel Havhette 07 03 WS=98 03 ST=97 03 TWCI=100 02 RP=96 02 #20 Top 100 WS 05 02 ST=94+ 02 WS=96 02/01 TWCI=95 01 RP=95 01 WS=95 01 ST=92+ 00 RP=98 00 WS=100 00 ST=97 00 TWCI=100 00 JCLee=98 00 JR=18 (92) Pauillac de Ch Latour 12/13/14/15/16 16 TWCI=92 15 WS=89 15 TWCI=90 14 TWCI=92 13 TWCI=85 12 TWCI=91 11 TWCI=96 10 55%CS-44.5%Merlot-0.5%CF 10 ST=86 10/09 TWCI=91 See their second wine: Les Forts de Latour
Ch Latour Martillac Pessac-Leognan 12/13/14/15 15 54%CS-40Merlot7PV 15 RP=92-94 15 $33-35WAlert 15 WS=89 15 $36 WS 11 GDP=90 11 $30 GDP 10 JJB=92 09 WE=89 09 RP=90-92 08 WS=90 08 RP=87-88 08 JJB=86-88 07 RP=87 07 WE=89 07 WS=85-88 07 ST=86 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 WE=87 06 RP=87 06 WS=88 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 ST=88 05 WS=89 05 $31 WS 05 WE=92 Pessac-Leognan Lagrave-Martillac 13/14/15 15 WS=88 15 $30 WS
Ch Latour a Pomerol Pomerol 10/11/12/13/14/15/16 15 96%Merlot-CF 15 RP=93-95 15 $90-100 15 WS=93 15 $95 WS 14 WS=93 14 $100 WS 10 ST=91 09 Merlot-CF 09 WE=93 09 ST=91 09 RP=92-94 08 ST=88 08 JJB=91-93 08 RP=90-92+ 08 SY=88-91 08 WE=89-91 07 RP=88 07 WS=90 07 ST=86 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 WE=92 128
06 RP=89 06 WS=90 06 ST=87-90 05 Best value of demanded wines QWR05 RP=90 05 Cited Wine Hachette 09 05 ST=91 05 WE=91/90 05 WS=93 05 $89 WS 04 WE=91 04 RP=87-88 04 WS=90 04 $45 WS 04 ST=88 Ch Laubes Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=87 15 $10 WE
Ch Lauduc Bordeaux Sup Tradition VV 14/15/16 14 Very Successful Hachette 17 09 Bronze LA 11 05 Silver Paris 07 04 Silver IWC 07 04 WS=81 04 $13 WS 04 All for only $10 WR 03 WR=88
Ch Laujac Medoc 13/14/15 15 WS=88 15 $25 WS 15 RP=88 14 Grand Gold Bruxelles 16 14 Decanter=88 12 Very Successful Hachette 16 12 WE=85 12 Bronze Decanter 14 12 JR=11 (84) 11 Comm’d Decanter 14 10 Bettane&D=14 Ch Laulan Ducos Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 RP=81 10 RP=87 10 $20 RP Ch Laulerie Comtesse de Segur Montravel 13/14/15 14 Editor’s Choice WE 14 WE=90 14 $20 WE 12 Editor’s Choice WE 12 WE=90 12 $19 WE 09 60% Merlot-30% Malbec-10% CF 09 GdP=87 Laurence (La Laurence) Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15 15 RP=90-92
Ch Lauretan Bordeaux Sup 14/15 (org grapes) 15 Silver LA 17 15 WE=88 15 $16 WE 14 WE=85 14 $17 WE Ch des Laurets Puisseguin-St-Emilion 13/14/15 15 WS=87 15 $25 WS 14 RP=85 10 WS=90 10 $23 WS 09 ST=87 08 Merlot-CS 08 WS=88 08 $25 WS 07 NM=88 Puisseguin-St-Emilion Sel Parcellaire 13/14/15 15 WS=86 15 $49 WS
Ch de Laussac Castillon Cotes de Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 RP=91-93 14 $12-15 RP 09 RP=87-88 08 WS=89 08 $30 WS Castillon Cuvee Sacha 13/14/15 15 RP=88-90
Ch Lauzanet Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=86 15 $10 WE
Ch La Lauzettr-Declercq Listrac 13/14/15 15 RP=88-90 15 $45-48WAlert
Ch Laville Bordraux Sup 13/14/15 15 Silver LA 17
Bordeaux Sup Eximus 13/14/15 15 Silver LA 17 10 Gold LA 12 10 LA=92 09 Silver LA 11 Ch Leboscq Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=83? 10 RP=88 10 WE=88 10 $19 WE 09 Gold Paris 11 07 WE=86 07 $15 WE 06 Bronze Decanter 09 06 WE=87 06 $19 WE 06 WS=84 Ch Lecuyer Pomerol 13/14/15/16 16 RP=90-92 16 $27 P 129
15 RP=89-91 15 $37 WineS 15 WS=88 15 $59 WS 13 Cellae Selection WE 13 WE=92 13 $60 WE
10 Silver Decanter 12 08 Silver Decanter 10 Ch Leognan Pessac-Leognan 12/13/14/15 12 Cellar Selection WE 12 WE=92 12 $55 WE
Leon Nony Bordeaux Merlots 13/14/15 14 W&S=83 14 $15 W&S
Ch Leoville-Barton St-Julien 2nd Cru 12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 WS=96-99 18 $180wine.com 18 WE=95-97 18 JD=95-97+ 18 Decanter=96 15 80%CS-14Merlot 15 RP=94-96 15 WS=95 15 $98 WS 15/14/13 Cellar Selection WE 15 WE=97 14 WE=95 14 $75 WE 14 WS=94 14 $65 WS 13 WE=93 11 GDP=93 10 77%CS-21%Merlot-2%CF 10 ST=93 10 JJB=96 09 77%CS-22%Merlot-CF 09 One of Top 15 Decanter 09 Decanter=5star 09 Decanter=19/20 09 WE=97 09 ST=91 09 WS=92-95 09 RP=93-95+ 08 Great Value WBlB 08 WBlB=92 08 WE=96 08 ST=90 08 RP=92-94 08 WS=90-93 08 JJB=92-94 07 Cellar Selection WE 07 WE=94 07 $65 WE 07 Good price/qual ratio QRW Aut 08 07 RP=89+ 07 ST=90 07 WS=92 06Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 WD=16-17/20 06 RP=91+ 06 ST=91-93 06 Highly Rec’s WS 06 WS=94 05 Highly Rec’d W&S 4/06 05 W&S=2-2½star 05 Great future WD 4/06 05 WD=17-18/20 05 Fantastic aromas, big, velvety WW 05 WS=96 05 Best value of demanded wines QWR05 ST=94 Best value generally F&W 06 05 WE=96/97 05 Vin Exceptionnel Hachette 09 05 WW=91 05 Coup de Coeur Hachette 09 05 WD=17-18+/20 St-Jilien La Res de Leoville Barton 13/14/15 15 WS=91
Ch Leoville-las-Cases St-Julien 2nd Cru 10/11/12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 JS=99-100 18 $250wine.com 18 JD=98-100 18 RP=98-100 18 WS=97-100 18 Decanter=98 18 WE ??-98 17 WineS=95-97 15 85%Merlot-9CF 15 RP=95-97 15 $182-233 15 WS=97 15 $202 WS 14 #48 Top 100 of 2017 IWReport 14 IWReport=96 14/13/12 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=97 14 $150 WE 14 WS=95 14 $135 WS 13 WE=95 13/12 $140 WE 130
12 WE=96 10 82%CS-10%Merlot-8%CF 10 ST=94 09 76%CS-15%Merlot–9%CF 09 One of Top 15 Decanter 09 Decanter=5star 09 Decanter=19/20 09 WE=97 09 ST=94 09 RP=96-100 09 One of 32 Top JJB 09 JJB=98-100 08 RP=95-97+ 08 WE=94-96 08 WS=91-94 08 ST=92 07 RP=91+ 07 WE=94 07 $160 WE 07 ST=92 07 AG=91 07 WS=89-92 06 Cellear Selection WE 06 WE=95/95 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 RP=95 06 Coup de Coeur Hachette 10 06 ST=92-94 06 WS=95 05 Vin Exceptionnel Hachette 09 05 WS=100 05 Coup de Coeur Hachette 09 05 WE=96 05 Best of Vintage W&S 4/06 05 W&S=98 05 RP=98 05 ST=95+? 05 WW=94-96 04 Collectible WS 3/31/07 04 WS=95 04 Vin Remarquable Hachette 08 04 WE=95 04 ST=90+ 04 Top 10 WW 06 04 WW=94-97
St-Julien Le Petit Lion 13/14/15 15 WS=91 15 $52 WS
See their second wine: Clos du Marquis
Ch Leoville-Poyferre St-Julien 2nd Cru 11/12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 JD=96-99 18 $92 wine.com 18 JS=97-98 18 WS=95-98 18 Decanter=97 15 65%CS-26Merlot-6PV-3CF 15 RP=92-94 15 WS=95 15 $84 WS 15 Cellar Selection WE 15 WE=96 14 WS=93 14 $63 WS 13 Cellar Selection WE 13 WE=94 13 WS=90 13 $68 WS 11 GDP=89 10 61%CS-30%Merlot-6%PV-3%CF 10 ST=90 09 60%CS-20%M-6%PV-CF 09 WE=94 09 ST=92 09 RP=97-100 08 Great Value WBlB 08 WBlB=92 08 ST=89 08 RP=92-94 08 WS=90-93 08 ST=89-92 08 JJB=91-93 07 Cellar Selection WE 07 WE=93 07 $60 WE 07 RP=89 07 ST=90 07 WS=86-89 07 RC=92 06 Cellar Selection WE 06 WE=93/94/93 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 WD=16-17/20 06 RP=91 131
06 ST=90-92 06 WS=90 05 Rec’d to Highly Rec’d W&S 4/06 05 W&S=95 05 Alluring flavors, lusty end WW 05 ST=93 05 Outstanding for price QWR 05 WS=92 05 Vin Remarquable Hachette 09 05 WW=92-95 05 WE=93/94 04 WS=90 04 WE=93 04 ST=90
See their second wine: Ch Moulin Riche
Ch Lescalle Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15 15 Silver LA 17 10 Comm’d IWC 12 10 WS=88 10 $17 WS 10 CF-CS-Merlot Ch Lespault-Martillac Pessac-Leognan 13/14/15 16 RP=89-91 16 $24-25 RP 15 Top Value < $30 WS 15 WS=90 15 $26 WS 15 RP=87-89 15 $24-25WAlert 13 WS=87 13 $24 WS 10 RP=89-91 Ch Lestage Listrac-Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=88+ 13 WS=79 13 $21 WS 10 RP=87 10 $18 RP 08 Merlot 08 WE=87 07 Bronze IWC 10 06 Comm’d IWC 09 06 WE=87 06 WS=83 05 WE=88 04 Vin Remarquable Hachette 08 Lestage Chevillon Medoc 13/14/15 15 JR=15.5 (86) 15 RP=? 14 Comm’d Decanter 16 14 Gilbert&G=86 08 Gold Bordeaux 10 Ch Lestage-Simon Haut-Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=87 15 $12 WineS 13 WS=84 13 $35 WS 10 Comm’d Decanter 12 10 RP=86 10 $20 RP 09 Bronze Decanter 12 08 WE=88 06 WS=82 05 WS=88 Lestonnat Bordeaux Sup Merlot CS 13/14/15 12 60%Merlot-40 CS 15 WS=85 15 $13 WS 12 Rec’d ReverseWineSnob 12 Vivino=3.5 (153) Ch Lestruelle Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=91 13 WS=83 13 $30 WS 10 WE=87 10 $25 WE 09 Comm’d Decater 11 09 WS=90 09 UWS=90 08 WS=87 Liber Pater Graves Denarius 14/15/16 16 TWCI=94 16 80%CS-14PV-1Merlot-5Others 15 RP=88-90 06 WS=85 05 WS=75 Liber Pater Clos Landiras Graves 13/14/15 15 50%CS-50Merlot 15 RP=87-89
Liber Pater Denarius Graves 13/14/15 15 90%CS-10Merlot 15 RP=87-88
Ch Lieujean Haut-Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=91 13 WS=86 13 $20 WS 10 WE=90 10 $20 WE 07 WE=88 07 $17 WE 06 Comm’d Decanter 09 06 WE=86 06 $24 WE 06 WS=83 L’if St-Emilion GC 12/13/14/15/16 16 TWCI=96 15 TWCI=97 15 JR=17 (92) 132
15 TinAtkin=94 14 JS=98 14 $279 Zachys 14 Vinous=94 14 WS=92 14 TWCI=93 14 RP=92 14 JR=16.5 (88) 13 TWCI=92 12 JS=98 12 $319 Zachys 12 TWCI=95 11 JR=17 (92) Ch Lilian Ladouys St-Estephe Cru Bourgeois Sup 14/15/16/17/18 18 JS=93-94 18 $23 wine.com 18 JD=91-94 18 WS=90-93 16 TWCI=93 16 JS=93-94 16 RP=91-93 16 WS=90-93 16 Decanter 91 16 Vinous=88-91 15 TWCI=88 15 JCLee=89 15 WS=88 15 $24 WS 15 JS=92 15 WE=89-91 15 RP=88-90 15 JR=15.5 (86) 15 JebDunnick=90 15 TWCI=88-90 14 #30 Top Values < $30 WS 14 WS=90 14 $24 WS 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=93 14 JS=93 14 RP=90 14 Vinous=90 13 WS=85 13 $24 WS 14 TWCI=91/90 14 JCLee=91 13 TWCI=88 13 Cellar Selection WE 13 JS=91 13 WE=91 13 JR=16 (88) 12 Cellar Selection WE 12 WE=92 12 $35 WE 12/11/10 One star Hachette 16/15/14 12 WS=86-89 12 WE=91 12 JR-15 (84) 12/11 TWCI=89 11 WS 89-92 10 RP=88 10 WS=89 10 $32 WS 10 JS=90-91 10 WE=94 10 TWCI=90 09 Outperformed Price 09 JJB=92-94 09 Two Stars Hachette 13 09 WE=93 09 RP=84-86 09 WS 92-95 09 TWCI=88
Ch Lion Beaulieu Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 RP=87-89 15 $10 WineS 10 RP=87 08 WS=88 08 RP=82-84 06 RP=87 06 WS=86
133
Ch de Lisennes Bordeaux Sup Cuvee Tradition 13/14/15 15 Silver LA 17 08 Bronze LA 12 Ch Liversan Haut Medoc Cru Bourgeois Sup 13/14/15/16 16 Vivino=3.5 (9) 15 RP=90 15 Vivino=3.4 (22) 14 Vivino=3.3 (134) 14 JR=15.5 (86) 14 CT=85 (3) 13 WS=80 13 $20 WS 13 Silver Paris 15 13 Vivino=3.4 (36) 13 JR=15.5 (86) 12 Editor’s Choice WE 12 WE=90 12 $26 WE 12 Gold Paris 14 12 Vivino=3.5(797) 12 Bronze Decanter 15 12 JR=15.5 (86) 12 Cited Wine Hachette 16 11 Vivino (436) 11 Gilbert&G=86 10 RP=86 10 CostcBlog=90 10 WE=91 10 $20 WE 10 JR=15 (84) 09 Comm’d Decanter 12 09 WS=89-91 09 RC=88 09 CostcoBlog=89 Ch Loirac Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=89 12 Gilbert&G=85 12 WE=85 12 Gilbert&G=86 11 Silver Hong Kong 14 10 JR=15.5 (86) Ch La Loubiere Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15 15 Silver LA 17
Ch Loudenne Medoc Cru Bourgeois Sup 13/14/15 15 RP=86 10 WS=88 10 $24 WS 10 RP=85 10 WE=88 09 Silver Decanter 12 07 Silver Bordeaux 10 07 WS=80-83 Ch Louis St-Emilion 14/15/16 16 TWCI=90 15 WS=88 15 $41 WS 15 TWCI=91 14/12 TWCI=89 11 TWCI=88 10 TWCI=91 09 TWCIU=90
Ch Loumelat Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux Cuvee JJ Lesgourgues 15 WS=86 15 $15 WS
Ch Lousteauneuf Medoc 13/14/15 15 WS=87 15 $20 WS 15 RP=? 14 RP=86 10 RP=89 10 WE=87 10 $16 WE 09 WS=89-91
Ch la Louviere Pessac-Leognan 12/13/14/15 15 WS=91 14 Editor’s Choice WE 14 WE=94 14 $50 WE 13 WS=87 13 $75 WS 11 GDP=90 10 RP=85-87 10 ST=88 10 JJB=92 09 WE=90 09 ST=88 08 RP=84-86 07 RP=87 134
07 WS=86 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 RP=87 06 ST=85-87 06 WS=86 06 $57 WS 05 Vin Remarquable Hachette 09 05 WE=90/89 05 Coup de Coeur Hachette 09 05 WS=90 05 $44 WS 05 ST=87-89 Ch Loyasson Bordeaux 14/15 15 Gold Paris 16 15/12 WE=85 15 $11 WE 15 $11 K&L 15 $10 Sh-L 13/12/11 Gold Bordeaux 14/13/12 10 Silver Challenge 12 Ch Lucia St-Emilion GC 13/14/15 15 WS=91 13 WS=88 13 $27 WS 12 JCLee=82 10 JR=14 09 Outperformed Price 09 JJB=92-94 09 RP=90-92 08 WS=88 08 RP=88-90 07 RP=90-92 07 ST=90 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 RP=85 06 ST=87-90 05 WS=87 05 $58 WS 05 ST=90+? 04 ST-90 Clos de Lunes Lune d”Argent 18 18 JS=92-93 18 $17 wine.com 18 WS=90-93 18 JD=90-92 Clos les Lunelles Cotes de Castillon 13/14/15/16/17/18 18 JD=93-95 18 $25 wine.com 18 RP=92-94 15 Top Value under $30 WS 15 WS=91 15 $28 WS 15 RP=90-92 13 WS=BT 10/09=80%M-10%CF-10%CS 10 RP=91 10 ST=87 09 ST=88 09 RP=92-94 09 WS=87-90 09 RP=92-94 09 ST=88-91 08 85%CS-13%Merlot-CF 08 ST=87 08 80%Merlot-15%CF-15%CS 08 JJB=89-91 08 RP=90-93+ 07 RP=90 07 ST=88 07 RP=90-92 07 ST=87-89 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 ST=89-90 06 RP=91 06 ST=87-90
Ch de Lussac (Yvon Mau) Lussac-St-Emilion 13/14/15 15 RP=89-91 15 $10-24WineS 14 $15 WineCh 12 Silver Paris 15; Comm’d IWC 14 12 JCLee=82 11 Very Successful Hachette 15 11 Gold Bordeaux 14 10 Silver Paris 13 10 JR-14 (82) 09 Comm’d Decanter 12 09 JR=16 (88) 08 JR=15 (94) 98 Gikbert&G=88 07 Comm’d Decanter 10 07 ST=85-87 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 WS=87 06 ST=87-89 Ch Lussan Bordeaux 15/16 16 WE=85 16 $11 WE 135
Ch Lusseau St-Emilion GC 14/15/16 16 WDecider=92 16 $19 WHouse 16 JS=90-92 16/15 RP=91-93 15 #13 Top Value < $30 WS 15 WS=91 15 $22 WS 15 WDecider=90 15 RP=91-93 15 $18-24 WineS 15 JCLee=91 15 JR=16.5 (90) 15 Vivino-3.4 (6) 14 WDecider=88 14 RP=85 14 JR=15.5 (86) 14 JCLee=86 13 WS=BT 13 WDecider=87 13 JCLee=87 13 RP=85-87 12 WDecider=88 12 RP=88 11 WDecider=87 11 RP=87 10 75%Merlot-25%CF 10 RP=85 10 TWCI=89-91 10/09 WDecider=90
Graves 13/14/15 15 WS=87 15 $30 WS
Ch Lynch-Bages Paulliac GC 10/11/12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 WS=96-99 18 $130wine.com 18 JS=97-98 18 JD=96-98+ 18 RP=96-98 18 WE=??-97 18 Decanter=97 15 70%CS-24Merlot-4CF-2PV 15 RP=93-95 15 $110-144 15 Cellar Selection WE 15 WE=96 15 $115 WE 15 WS=94 15 $124 WS 14 #16 Top 100 of 2017 14 IWReport=96 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=95 14 $100 WE 14 WS=94 14 $88 WS 14 Decanter=92 13 Cellar Selection WE 13 WE=94 13 WS=91 13 $85 WS 10 79%CS-18%Merlot-2%CF-1%PV 10 ST=90 10 JJB=94 09 76%CS-M-CF-PV 09 WE=96 09 ST=90 09 RP=94-96+ 09 WS=96-99 09 One of Top 32 JJB 09 JJB=94-96 09 Decanter=4star 09 Decanter=18/20 08 WE=94 08 RP=91-93+ 08 ST=89 08 WS=89-92 08 Decanter=4star 08 JJB=90-92 07 RP=89 07 WE=93 07 $75 WE 07 ST=88 07 WS=85-88 06 WE=94/94 06 Top Pick K&L 06 RP=92 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 ST=89-91 06 WS=92 136
05 Vin Remarquable Hachette 09 05 WS=93 05 One of 15 Best Buys QWR 05 WE=96 05 Highly Rec’d W&S 4/06 05 W&S=96 05 #3 Top 100 Wines WE 08 05 ST=91+? 05 Oustanding for price QWR 05 WW=91-92 04 ST=89 04 WW=90-92 04 WS=89 04 WE=94 04 Vin Remarquable Hachette 08 See also: Echo de Lynch Bages
Ch Lynch-Moussas Paulliac GC Classe 13/14/15/16/17/18 18 WE=92-94 18 $40 wine.com 18 RP=91-93+ 15 70%CS-21Merlot 15 RP=92-94 15 WS=89 15 $41 WS 13 WS=86 13 $33 WS 10 JJB=91 09 WE=95 09 RP=88-90 09 Decanter=3star 09 Decanter=16/20 08 RP=88-89 08 JJB=85-87 08 JJB=84-86 07 RP=87 07 WE=88 07 $35 WE 07 WS=80-83 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 WE=86 06 RP=89 06 WS=88 06 $30 WS 06/05 ST=87-89 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 WS=86/89-91 05 $38 WS 05 WE=90/89 04 WS=88 04/03 Very Successful Hachette 08/07 Lynsolence St-Emilion 13/14/15/16/17/18 18 JD=93-95 18 $37 wine.com 18 RP=93-95 18 JS=93-94 15 RP=89-91 13 WS=89 13 $28 WS 10 ST=86 09 100%Merlot 09 ST=87 09 RP=90-92 08 WS=91 08 RP=87-88 07 RP=85-87? 06 RP=90+ 06 ST=87-89 06 WS=85-88 Ch de Macard Bordeaux Sup 14/15 15 WS=84 15 $20 WS 14 Best Buy Cellar selection BTI 14 BTI=92 14 Gold Paris 16 14 IWReport=90 14 Gilbert&G=82 10 WS=88 10/09/08 $15 WS 09 WS=90 08 WS=72 Bordeaux Sup Cuvee Eloi 13/14/15 15 WS=78 15 $20 WS
Clos de la Madeleine St-Emilion 13/14/15 15 RP=89-91 15 $28-30 WineS 09 75%Merlot-25%CS 10/09 ST=87 07 WS=89 07 $30 WS 07 RP=90-92 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 RP=87 06 $30 RP 06 ST=87-89 06 WS=80-84 137
Ch Magdelaine St-Emilion PGC Planted 90%Merlot-10CF 11 WE=94 11 $75 Costco 11/10 Vin Remarquable Hachette 15/14 11 WS=91 $77-110 WineS 11/10/09 TWCI=90 10 ST=88 09 ST=91 09 $50+ ST 09 RP=92-94+ 09 $72-89 RP 09 Decanter=4star 09 Decanter=17.5 09 JR=16+/20 08 ST=90 08 RP=92-94 08 JJB=86-88 08 TWCI=88 07 RP=87 07 WS=87 07 WE=89 07 $28 WE 07 W&S=85 07 $99 W&S 07 ST=88 06 WE=91 06 RP=90+ 06 ST=90 06 WS=87 06 $65 WS 06 JR=16.5 (90) 05 WS=92 05 $79 WS 05 WE=92/93 05 TWCI=91 05 JCLee=92 05 JR=16.5 (90) Magnan la Gaffeliere St-Emilion 13/14/15 15 RP=88-90
Ch Magnol (B&G) Haut-Medoc 13/14/15 15 WS=88 15 $30 WS 14 RP=84 10 WS=83 10 $25 WS 10 WE=85 09 Bronze Decanter 12
Ch Magrez Fombrauge St-Emilion GC 13/14/15/16 16 TWCI=95 15 70%Merlot-30CF 15 WS=93 15 $110 WS 15 TWCI=93 15 RP=88-90 14 TWCI=91 13 TWCI=90 12/11 TWCI=92 10 ST=88 10 TWCI=94 07 80%Merlot-20%CF 09 RP=92-95+ 09 TWCI=95 08 RP=92-94+ 08 TWCI=93 07 RP=90 07 ST=87 07 WS=85-88 06 RP=92 06 ST=89-91 06 WS=90 06 $160 WS 06 TWCI=92 05 ST=91 05 WE=90 05 WS=93 05 $208 WS 05 RP=93-95 05 TWCI=93 04 ST=90 04 WS=89 04 RP=91 04 TWCI=92
138
Ch Maillet Pomerol 13/14/15 15 RP=89-91
Ch Maison Blanche Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=87 13 WS=80 13 $30 WS 10 WE=88 10 $30 WE 09 Gold France-Macon 11 09 WS=91 09 $15 K&L 09 Silver Bruzelles 11 09 Bronze Paris, Challenge Int’L 11 08 WS=87 Maison Castel Bordeaux 14/15 15 Silver LA 17
Maison Delor Bordeaux Delor Res 14/15 15 Bronze LA 17
Maison Hebrard Bordeaux 13/14/15 14 W&S=85 14 $13 W&S
Ch Saint Seurin Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=88 15 $10 WE
Ch Les Graves de Barrau 13/14/15 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=87 15 $10 WE
Ch Maison Noble Bordeaux Clairet 14/15/16 16 WE=85 16 $15 WE
Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15 15 Silver LA 17 13 Best Buy WE 13 WE=86 13 $10 WE
Bordeaux Sup Saint Martin 14/15 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=90 15 $15 WE
Maison Sichel Bordeaux Sirius 13/14/15 14 Best Buy WE 14 WE=88 14 $13 WE
Malagar Premieres Cotes de Bordeaux 113/14/15 15 65%Merlot-20CS-15CF 15 RP=84-86 10 50%Merlor-50%CS 10 ST=87 Ch Malartic-Lagraviere Pessac-Leognan 10/11/12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 WE=94-96 18 $50 wine.com 18 WS=95-98 18 Decanter=95 18 JS=93-94 15 JS=96-97 15 Vinous=95-97 15 RP=94-96 15 RP=94-96 15 WE=94-96 15 WS=92 15 $53 WS 15 Decanter=93 15 JebDunnick=92 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=95 14 JS=94 14 Vinous=94 14 RP=92 14 WS=91 13 WS=88 13 $44 WS 12 Cellar Selection WE 12 WE=94 10 45%Merlot-45%CS-8%CF-2%PV 10 ST=86/95+ 10 JJB=91 09 59%CS-38%M-3%PV 09 WE=94 09 ST=91 09 RP=93-95+ 09 ST=91-94 09 IWR=92+ 08 RP=91-94 08 WE=93 08 ST=87 08 IWR=94 08 WS=88-91 07 Value < $500/case QRW Aut 08 07 RP=90 07 WS=87 07 WE=90 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 09 06 WE=92 06 RP=90 139
06 ST=87-89 06 WS=88 06 $39 WS 05 Vin Exceptionnel Hachette 09 05 WE=92/90 05 WS=90 05 RP=91-93 05 ST=89 Ch Malbec Bordeaux Rouge 14/15 15 Decanter=83 12 Silver Bordeaux 14 11 Gold Bordeaux 13 11 Bronze Challenge Int’l 13 11 Gilbert&G=87 10 CF-CS-Merlot 10 WS=88 10 $14 WS 10 Bronze Decanter, IWC 12 10 Gilbert&G=85 09 Vin Remarquable Hachette 12
Ch Malescasse Haut-Medoc 14/15/16 15 RP=90 15 $17 WAlert 15 WS=89 15 $17 WS 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=92 14 WS=93 14 $45 WS 10 WS=90 10 $17 WS 09 WE=88 09 ST=87 08 WBlB=86 08 ST=87 08 SS=15.0/20 08 Decanter=3star 08 WS=87-90 08 RP=83-85 08 WE=87
Ch Malescot-St-Exupery Margaux 3rd Cru Classe 12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 JS=97-98 18 $58 wine.ocm 18 WS=93-96 18 JD=94-96 18 RP=94-96+ 15 RP=93-95 15 WS=95 15 $68 WS 13 WS=88-91 10 ST=93+ 10 JJB=94+ 09 WE=89 09 ST=91 09 RP=95-97 09 WS=97-100 09 One of Top 32 JJB 09 JJB=96-98 08 RP=91-93 08 WS=90-93 08 WE=90-92 08 JJB=90-92 07 RP=89 07 WS=90 07 ST=88 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 WE=92 06 Top Pick K&L 06 RP=91+ 05 Fabulous, best ever WW 06 06 ST=90-92 06 WS=92-94 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 ST=93 05 WS=97 05 WE=92 05 WW=93-95 See also: Les Hauts de la Gaffeliere
Ch de Malleret Haut-Medoc 14/15/16 16 WDecider=87 16 Decanter=88 16 RP=84-86 15 WDecider=89 15 $20 WHouse 15 Top Value < $30 WS 15 WS=90 15 $23 WS 15 RP=85 140
15 WE=91-93 15 JR=16 (88) 14 Silver Vinales Int’l 17 14 WE=91 14 RP=79-81 14 WS=88 14 $20 WS 14 WDecider=87 14 JR=15.5 (86) 14 JCLee=90 14 Vivino=3.8 (92) 14 Gilbert&G=88 13 Silver LA 16 13 Decanter=85 13 Gilbert&G=85/89 13 Decanter=85 12 Cited Wine Hachette 16 12 WDecider=86 12 Comm’d IWC 15 12 Gilbert&G=89 12 WS=86 12 $30 WS 11 Editor’s Choice WE 12/11 WE=90 11 Very Successful Hachette 15 11 WDecider=84 11/10 WS=89 10 RP=87 10 $20 WHouse
10 WDecider=91 10 Gilbert&G=94 09 Gold Paris 12; Bordeaux, Macon 13 09 WDecider=89 09 WS=87 08 WDecider=90 07 Silver Challenge 10 07 WDecider=86
Margaux M Margaux 13/14/15/16 16 WDecider=86 13 WDecider=85 11 WDecider=88 Ch Malmaison Moulis-en-Medoc 13/14/15 15 WS=87 15 $35 WS 15 RP=88-90 10/09 WS=87 10 $25 WS 08 WS=88 07 WS=86 Ch Malrome Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 RP=85-87
Ch Mangot 18 RP=93-95 18 $20 wine.com 18 JD=91-93 18 JS=91-92 Manoir de Gay Pomerol 13/14/15 15 RP=89-91 15 $21-36 RP 10 RP=88 09 WS=89-92 05 WS=87 Clos Manon Medoc 14/15/16 16 TWCI=88 15 RP=87-89 15 $20-33 WineS 10 RP=90 09 RP=89-91 09 WS=89-92 08 RP=87-88
Medoc Petit Manon 13/14/15 15 WS=89 15 $24 WS
Ch Clos Mansio Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux 13/14/15 13 WS=87 13 $17 WS
Clos Margalaine Margaux13/14/15 15 59%CS-50Merlot 15 RP=90-92 15 $20-43 WineS 10 RP=89 09 WE=91 07 RP=85-87 07 WS=84-87 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 ST=86-89 06 WS=85-88 06 $17-20 RP
Ch Margaux Margaux PGC 10/11/12/13/14/15/16/17 17 WineS=95 16 WE=94-96 16 $330 wine.c 141
16 JS=92-95 16 RP=91-93 16 Decanter=92 15 87%CS-8Merlot-3CF-2PV 15 RP=98-100 15 $978WAlert 15 WS=99 15 $958 WS 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=97 14 $450 WE 14 WS=95 14 $350 WS 14 Decanter=95 13/12 Cellar Selection WE 13 WE=95 13 $395 WE 13 WS=91 13 $346 WS 12 WE=95 09 One of Top 15 Decanter 09 Decanter=5star 09 87%CS-9%M-CF-PV 09 Decanter=20/20 09 ST=97 09 One of Top 32 JJB 09 JJB=97-99 08 WS=87 08 WE=96 08 ST=91 08 JJB=91-93 08 RP=95-97 08 JJB=91-93 07 WE=93 07 $450 WE 07 RP=92-94 07 WS=89-92 07 ST=93 07 JJB=90-92 06 WE=95/95 06 Top pick K&L 06 WD=12-13/20 06 RP=94 06 WS=95 06 $650 WS 06 ST=93-95 06 JJB=90-92 05 Great to Best of Vintage W&S 4/06 05 W&S=94 05 $1800 W&S 05 Great aroma, balanced, long WW 05 RP=98-100 05 Vin Exceptionnel Hachette 09 05 WS=100 05 $1080 WS 05 “Coup de Coeur” Hachette 09 05 ST=98+? 05 WE=98/98 05 WW=99-100 04 WE=96 04 WS=93 04 Top 10 WW 06 04 RP=92-94 04 ST=94 04 WW=93-95 04 Coup de Coeur Hachette 08 04 WW=94-96 ? 04/03 Vin Exceptionnel Hach 08/07 03 RP=99 03 WS=98 03 WE=96 03 WW=94-97 03 ST= 96 02 RP=93 02 WS=92 01 RP=93 01 WS=92 See their second wine: Pavillon Rouge
Ch Marjosse Bordeaux 14/15 15 JS=89-91 15 $12 wine.com 15 RP=87-89 15 $13-15 12 JR=16.5 (90) 11 JR=16 (88) 10/09 78%Merlot-11%CS-11%CF 10 RP=85 10 Bronze Decanter 12 10 ST=88 10 RC=87/87 10 JR=16 (88) 09 ST=87 09 $11 ST 09 JR=16 (88) 142
Bordewaux Res de Ch 13/14/15 13 W&S=NR
Marojalla Margaux 12/13/14/15 15 RP=91-93 15 $45-49 RP 15 WS=93 15 $46 WS 10 ST=89 09 Bronze Decanter 12 09 WE=89 08 WS=90 08 RP=88-90+ 08 $66-82 RP 07 Comm’d Decanter 10 07 WS=89-91 07 $61-76 RP 07 RP=89-91 06 RP=91 06 $58-100 RP 06 WS=88 06 $86 WS 06 ST=89-91 Margaux Clos Margalaine 13/14/15 15 WS=89 15 $27 WS
Ch la Maroutine Prem Cotes de Bordeaux 13/14/15 14 Best Buy WE 14 WE=88 14 $13 WE
Clos du Marquis St-Julien 12/13/14/15/16 (Ch Leoville-las-Cases) 16 TWCI=92 15 66%CS-31Merlot-3CF 15 RP=91-93 15 $50-63WAlert 15 WS=92 15 $58 WS 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=94 14 $45 WE 12 Cellar Selection WE 12 WE=94 12 $50 WE 10 75%CS-17%Merlot-8%CF 10 ST=86 09 WE=93 09 70%CS-20%M-8%CF-2%PV 09 RP=91-93 09 ST=89 08 RP=90-93 08 WS=90 08 ST=89 07 Value< $500/case QRW 08 07 RP=89 07 WE=91 07 $40 WE 07 ST=87 07 WS=87-90 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 WE=91 06 RP=90 06 NM=92 06 ST=90-91 06 WS=92 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 WS=92-94 05 One of Top 8 “Seconds” QWR 05 ST=90 05 Very solid, silky, long WW 06 05 WS=93 05 Highly Rec’d W&S 4/06 05 W&S=2-2½stars 05 RP=89-91 See also: La Petite Marquis do Clos du Marquis
Ch Marquis d’Alesme Margaux 14/15 14 WS=91 $33 WS 09 Silver Decanter 12 Marquis d’Alesme-Becker Margaux 3rd Cru Classe 12/13/14/15 15 WS=93 15 $42 WS 15 RP=91-93 15 $40-48 RP
13 WS=88 13 $35 WS 09 RP=81-83 08 WS=89 08 RP=83-85 08 JJB=85-87 07 Editor’d Choice WE 07 WE=01 07 Bronze Decanter 10 07 RP=72-75 07 WS=85-88
Marquis de Bern Bordeaux 14/15/16 14 Cited Wine Hachette 17 10 WS=81 10 $12 WS Marquis de Calon St-Estephe 14/15/16 16 WE=93-95 16 $28 K&L 16 JS=92-93 16 $29 Sh-L 16 Vinous=90-93 16 C$49 LCBO
143
16 Decanter=91 16/TWCI=91 15 JCLee=88 15 $26 JJB 15 JR=16.5 (90) 15 $29 K&L 15 $30 Zachys 14 WE=93 14 $?? WE 14 JS=92 14 $25 K&L 14 Vinous=92 14 TWCI=87 13 JR=16 (88) 12 WE=92 12 $30 WE 12 JR=15 (84) 12 $32 Sh 11 JR=16 (88) 11 $30 WineCh 10 Bronze Decanter 15
Marquis de Chasse See: Ginestet
Ch Marquis de Terme Margaux 4th Cru Classe 12/13/14/15 15 RP=92-94 15 $42-50 WE 15 WS=92 15 $46 WS 11 GDP=90 09 CS-Merlot-PV 10/09 ST=88 09 Bronze IWC 12 09 WE=89 09 RP=89-91 08 WS=88 08 RP=85-87 07 RP=72-75 06 Bronze Decanter, IWC 10 06 WE=88 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 RP=82 06 WS=80-84
Clos Marsalette Pessac-Leognan 14/15/16/17/18 18 WS=93-96 18 $24 wine.com 16/15 TWCI=91 16 WS=92-95 16 RP=90-92 15 50%CS-48Merlot-2CF 15 JCLee=87 15 JR=16.5 (90) 15 #19 Top Value < $30 WS 15 WS=91 15 $25 WS 15 RP=88-90 15 JS=92-93 15 Falstaff=91-93 15 TimAtkin=93 15 RP=88-90 15 JebDunnuck=91 15 Vinous=90-93 14 #15 Top Values < $30 WS 14 WS=91 14 $27 WS 14 TWCI=90 14 RP=86-88 13 WS=86 14 $32 WS 13 TWCI=87 13 RP=89-91 12 Very Successful Hachette 16 12 JCLee=87 12 Cited Wine Hachette 15 12 JR=16 (88) 12 WS=90 12$#21 WS 12 RP=92 12 WE=88 12/11/10 TWCI=90 11 Vin Remarquable Hachette 14 11 JCLee=83 11 Bronze Decanter 13 11 WS=91 11 $25 WS 11 RP=93 10 RP=89 10 WS=93 10 $30 WS 09 WS=92 09 $30 WS 09 60%Merlot-CS-CF 09 ST=88 09 Vin Remarquable Hachette 12 09 TWCI=91 09/08 RP=91 08/07 WS=87 08 $34 WS 144
07/06 RP=90 07 ST=85 07 WS=83-86 Ch de Marsan Bordeaux Clairet 14/15/16 16 WE=84 16 $12 WE 14 C$18 LCBO Bordeaux Sup 14/15/16 14 Very Successful Hachette 17 08 Vin Remarquable Hachette 11
Ch Marsau (Dourthe) Bordeaux Cote de Francs 14/15/16 16 JS=92-94 16 $20 wine.com 16 WS=91-93 16 $17 WHouse 16 WE=88-90 16 $20 JJB 16 $20 K&L 15 100%Merlot 15 JS=91-93 15 $19 wine.com 15 Top Value < $30 WS 15 WS=90 15 $19 WS 15 WS=89-92 15 $19 JJB 15 RP=89-91 15 $19 WHouse 15 JCLee=91 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=90 14 $0 WE 14 JCLee=88 14 $20 JJB 12 Coup de Coeur 2 stars Hachette 16 12 WE=92 12 $18 wine.com 12 JS=90 12 JCLee=89 11 Vin Remarquable Hachette 15 10 Very Successful Hachette 14 10 WS=89 10 $23 WS 10 Comm’d Decanter 13 10 RP=87 10 Bronze IWC 13 09 Bronze Decanter, IWC 12 09 JCLee=88 09 Merlot Ch Marzin Prem Cotes de Blaye 13/14/15 15 RP=86-88 06 Gold Paris 09
Ch la Marzelle St-Emilion GC 12/13/14/15 15 WS=89 15 $25 WS 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=93 14 $60 WE 14 RP=90-92 09 Silver Decanter 12 08 WS=89 07 RP=84-86 06 ST=86-88 06 WS=85 05 Cited Wine Hachette 09 05 ST=89 05 WS=90 Ch Maucaillou Moulis-en-Medoc Cru Bourgeois Sup 13/14/15 15 RP=90-92 15 $31 WAlert 11 GDP=90 10 RP=86 10 ST=85 09 WE=92 09 ST=87 08 WS=86 08 $21 WS 08 ST=87 08 Decanter=3star 08 SS=15.5/20 08 RP=85-87 Ch Maucamps Haut Medoc Cru Bourgeois 13/14/15 15 RP=90 09 Bronze Decanter 12 08 Cab Sauv 08 SS=15.5/20 08 Decanter=3star 07 Comm’d IWC 10 06 Cited Wine Hachette 10 Ch Maurac Haut-Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=89 12 Editor’s Choice WE 12 WE=91 12 $25 WE 10 Bronze IWC 12 10 WS=90 10 $25 WS 10 CS-Merlot 10 RP=87 09 Bronze Decanter 12
Mauvais (Thunevin) Mauvais Garcon (Bad Boy) 13/14/15 15 100%Merlot 15 RP=87-89 15 $17 WAlert 12 WS=88-91 145
11 WS=87-90 10 WS=90 10 $16 WS 09 WS=90 09 $16 WS 09 JS=93 09 WE=88 09 RP=87-89 09 ST=88 09 RC=88+ Ch de Maune Graves 13/14/15 15 WS=87 15 $20 WS
Ch Mayne Guyon Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux 14/15/16 16 Decanter=90 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=88 15 $8 WE 15 Silver Decanter 16 15 C$18 LCBO 14 Best Buy WE 14 WE=86 14 $7 WE 14 Cited Wine Hachette 2017 14 Gilbert&G=87 14 Silver Paris15; Vinales Int’l 16 13 Cited Wine Hachette 16 12 Vin Remarquable Hachette 15 09 Gilbert&G=86 Ch Mayne Mazerolles Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=88 15 $9 WE
Ch Le Mayne Turon Bordeaux 14/15/16 16 Gold LA 17 16 LA=92 15 Silver LA 16 Ch Mayne-Vieil Fronsac 14/15 14 WE=90 14 $17 WE 14 $13 wine.com 13/12 WE=91 12 RevueVin=14.5 11 RevueVin=15 11 CostcoBlog=88 Fronsac Cuvee Alienor 12/13/14 14 WE=92 14 $24 WE 14 WW=92 14 $18 wine.com 13 Editor’s Choice WE 13 WE=91 13 $22 WE 12 Decanter=89 11 WS=88 11 $20 WS 11 CostcoBlog=88 Ch Mazeyres Pomerol 13/14/15/16 16 RP=88-90 16 $30 WHouse 16 JR=16.5 (90) 16 $28 Millesima 16 TWCI=88 16 WS=89-92 15 RP=91-93 15 $35 WAlert 15 WS=90 15 $35 WS 15 JR=16 (88) 14 WS=88 14 $35 WS 14 JR=15.5 (86) 13 JCLee=84 13 $26 Millesima 13 WS=86 13 $24 WS 12 Silver Decanter 15 12 JCLee=86 12 WS=87 12 $28 WS 11 Very Successful Hachette 15 11 WS=86 11 $25 WS 10 Cited Wine GHachette 14 10 WS=89 10 $27 Ws 09 Very Successful Hachette 13\ 09 Gilbert&G=91 09 WS=85 09 $28 WS 08 Very Successful Hachette 12
Ch Mejean Graves 13/14/15 15 RP=89-91 15 $20 WineS 07 Very Successful Hachette 10 07 RP=87-89 07 ST=87 06 RP=89 En Memoire du Malbec Bordeaux 14/15/16 16 Silver LA 17
Domaine de Menard Cotes de Gascogne Merlot-CS 15/16 16/15 Best Buy WE 16 WE=88 16/15 $10 WE 15 WE=86 Clos des Menuts Bordeaux Menut 13/14/15 12 Best Buy WE 12 WE=87 12 $12 WE
Ch Mercier Cotes de Bourg Cuvee Prestige 13/14/15 15 RP=86-88 09 Bronze Decanter 12 146
07 Bronze Decanter 09/10 07 Cited Wine Hachette 10
Ch Meric Medoc Cru Bourgeois 13/14/15 15 RP=84
Ch Merlet Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=88 15 $10 WE
Ch Metaire Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux 13/14/15 12 Editpr’s Choice WE 12 WE=91 12 $26 WE
Ch de la Meuliere Prem Cotes de Bordeaux 13/14/15 15$26/2btlsB&M 11 50%Merlot-CabSauv 09 Silver LA 15 08 WW=89 08 RC=86 08 CellarT 86.7 (3) Ch Meyney St-Estephe Cru Bourgeois Sup 13/14/15/16 16/15 WDecider=91 15 RP=88-90 15 $30-40WAlert 15 WS=87 15 $32 WS 15 TWCI=88-90 14 #11 Top Values < $309 WS 14 WS=91 14 $24 WS 14 WDecider=92 13 WDecider=89 12 WDecider=90 11 WS=90-93 10 WDecider=91 09 Outperformed Price 09 JJB=92-94 09 RP=86-88 09 WDecider=91 08 JJB=82-83 08 RP=89-91 08 WDecider=88
Ch Meyre Haut Medoc Cru Bourgeois 13/14/15 15 RP=85 15 Decanter=87 14 RP=86 14 $17-19 RP 14 $19 WHouse 13 WE=87 12 Very Successful Hachette 16 12 WE=88 12 Bronze IWC 15 11 Cited Wine Hachette 15 11 WDecider=86 10 WS=89 10 $20 WS 10 Decanter=83 10/09 JR=15.5 (86) 09 WDecider=88 06 WDecider=83 Michel Lynch Bordeaux Merlot 14/15 15 WS=85 15 $12 WS
Bordeaux Merlot Nature 14/15 15 WS=86 15 $15 WS
Bordeaux Merlot-CS 14/15 15 WS=85 15 $12 WS
Medoc Res 14/15 15 WS=86 15 $20 WS
Ch Minvieille Bordeaux Merlot-CS 15/16 16/15 Silver LA 17/16
Ch Mirambeau Papin Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15 14 Editor’s Choice WE 14 WE=90 14 $20 WE 09 RP=87-89 Ch Mirefleurs Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15 15 Silver LA 17 12 Editor’s Choice WE 12 WE=90 12 $16 WE Bordeaux Sup Res 13/14/15 15 Gold LA 17 15 LA=91 12 Editor’s Choice WE 12 WE=90 12 $16 WE 09 WE=88 09 $15 WE 06 Silver Challenge 08 06 WE=83 06 $16 WE Ch la Mission-Haut-Brion Pessac-Leognan 10/11/12/13/14/15/16/17 17 WineS=97 16 TWCI=98 15 58%Merlot-36CS-7CF 15 RP=97-99 15 $389-501 147
15 WS=96 15 $430 WS 15 TWCI=97 14 WS=94 14 $200 WS 14 TWCI=94 13 TWCI=93 12 Cellar Selection WE 12 WE=96 12 $275 WE 12 TWCI=96 11 TWCI=93 10 62%CS-37%Merlot-1%CF 10 ST=94 10/09 TWCI=98 09 One of Top 15 Decanter 09 Decanter=5star 09 47%CS-47%Merlot-CF 09 Decanter=19/20 09 WE=96 09 ST=93 09 RP=98-100 09 One of Top 32 JJB 09 JJB=96-98 08 ST=90 08 WE=95-97 08 RP=94-96+ 08 WS=91-94 08 TWCI=96 07 RP=92 07 WE=93 07 $360 WE 07 WS=88-91 07 ST=90 07 TWCI=93 06 Cellar Selection WE 06 WE=95/96 06 Top Pick K&L 06 RP=95 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 WS=95 06 $645 WS 06 ST=94-96 06 TWCI=94 05 Vin Exceptionnel Hachette 09 05 WS=97 05 RP=96-100 05 W&S=97 05 WE=94/97 05 ST=94 +? 05 WW=93-96 05 TWCI=100 04 WE=94 04 WS=91 04 RP=89-91 04 ST=91 04 TWCI=92 04/03 Vin Remarq. Hachette 08/07 03 WS=94 03 RP=94 03 ST=93 03/02 TWCI=90 02 RP=89 02 WS=91 02 ST=91+ See also their second wine: La Chapelle
Clos des Moiselles Cotes de Bourg 14/15/16 16/14 TWCI=88 14 RP=86 14 $12 RP 14 C$20 LCBO 11 WE=87 10 WS=87 10 $13 WS 10 TWCI=85 10 Vinous=88 09 Silver LA 12 Ch Monbousquet St-Emilion 12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 WS=94-97 18 $52 wine.com 18 JS=94-95 18 RP=93-95 18 JD=92-94 15 WS=95 15 $53 WS
148
15 RP=90-92 14 WS=93 14 $40 WS 10 ST=88/95+ 09 60%Merlot-30%CF-CS 09 Outperformed Price JJB 09 JJB=94-96 09 ST=89 09 RP=92-94 08 RP=92-94 08 WS=89-92 08 JJB=90-92 07 RP=90 07 WS=87-90 07 ST=89 06 WE=87 06 WS=89-91 06 RP=92 06 ST=89-90 05 Wonderful complexity Decanter 06 05 SS=17.5/20 05 Cited Wine Hachette 09 05 ST=93 05 WS=91 05 $75 WS 05 WE=89 05 RP=94-96
Ch Monbrison Margaux Cru Bourgeois Sup 13/14/15 15 RP=90-92 15 WS=89 15 $33 WS 11 GDP=89 10 ST=86 09 ST=88 09 WE=89 08 ST=87 08 SS=16+/20 08 Decanter=3star 07 WS=84 07 $25 WS 07 WE=89 07 RP=90-93 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 RP=88 06 WE=87 06 WS=87 05 Cited Wine Hachette 09 05 WE=91 05 WS=91
Ch Moncets Lalande de pomerol 14/14/15 15 RP=83-85 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=92 14 $25 WE
Ch la Mondette Castillon cotes de Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=87 15 $10 WE
Ch Mondorion St-Emilion 14/15/16 15 WS=89 15 RP=88-90 Ch la Mondotte St-Emilion GC 10/11/12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 WS=96-99 18 $230wine.com 18 JS=87-98 18 JD=95-97 15 85%Merlot-15CF 15 RP=94-96 15 WS=98 15 $305 WS 14 WS=96 14 $149 WS 10 80%Merlot-20%CF 10 ST=93 09 80%Merlot-20%CF 09 ST=91 09 RP=95-98+ 08 ST=90 08 RP=93-95+ 07 RP=91 07 WS=90 07 ST=93 06 RP=97 06 WS=93 06 $250 WS 06 ST=91-93 05 ST=96 149
05 SS=19/20 05 WS=97 05 RP=96-100 04 ST=90+ 04 WS=93 04 RP=93
Ch de Monrecueil Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15 15 Silver LA 17 10 Silver LA 12 09 Bronze LA 11 Ch Monregard la Croix Pomerol 13/14/15 15 RP=88-90 15 $40 WineS
Ch Montcabrier Bordeaux Sup 09 09 Silver Decanter 12 06 Silver LA 10 Ch Montcanon Canon-Fronsac 06 06 WS=84
Ch Monteil a’Arsac Haut Medoc 13/14 15 15 RP=86
Ch Montet (Haut Guillebot) Bordeaux 14/15/16 16 W&S=NR 16/14 $12 W&S 14 W&S=NR 09 Bronze LA 11 08 Gold BofShow BofClass LA 10 08 Very Successful Hachette 11
Bordeaux 13/14/15 14 W&S=NR 14 $13 W&S
Bordeaux Sup Cuvee Prestige 13/14/15 14 W&S=88 14 $23 W&S
Ch Montlabert St-Emilion GC 13/14/15 15 RP=89-91 15 $21-25 WineS 10 Silver IWC; Bronze Decanter 12 10 WS=92 10 $20 WS 07 RC=91 Ch Montlandrie Cotes de Castillon 13/14/15 15 #20 Top Value < $30 WS 15 WS=91 15 $27 WS 15 RP=91-93 15 $25-33WAlert 14 #6 Top Value < $30 WS 14 WS=91 14 $18 WS 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=91 14 $25 WE 11 NM=90-92 10 70%Merlot-30%CF 10 ST=87 09 75%Merlot-25%CF 09 ST=89 09 RP=88-89+ Ch Mont-Perat Prem Cotes de Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 RP=84-86 15 $17-26 RP 10 RP=86 10 JR=16 (88) 09 Merlot 09 WE=89 09 RP=87-88 08 “Sleeper of the category” JJB 08 WS=86 08 JJB=87-89 Ch Montrose St-Estephe 2nd Cru 12/13/14/15/16 16 RP=97-99 15 67%CS-29Merlot-4CF 15 WS=92 15 $146 WS 15 TWCI=94-96 15 RP=93-95 15 $135-179WAl 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=97 14 $135 WE 14 WS=95 14 $124 WS 14 RP=96 12/13 Cellar Selection WE 13WE=95 12 WE=95 10 53%CS-37%Merlot-9%CF-1%PV 10 ST=91 09 65%CS-M-CF-PV 09 One of Top 15 Decanter 09 Decanter=5star 09 Decanter=19/20 09 WE=96 09 ST=94 09 RP=96-100 09 WS=97-100 09 ST=94-97 09 Onr of Top 32 JJB 09 JJB=98-100
150
08 WE=94 08 RP=95-97 08 ST=88 07 Serlected by Vine Talk TV 07 RP=91 07 ST=88 07 WS=87-90 06 Cellar Selection WE 06 WE=94/94 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 RP=94+ 06 Coup de Coeur Hachette 10 06 ST=88-89 06 WS=93 06 AG=91 05 Outstanding for price QWR 05 WS=94 05 Vin Remarquable Hachette 09 05 ST=93+? 05 RP=96 05 WW=94-96
See also their second wine: Dame de Montrose
Ch Montviel Pomerol 13/14/15 15 RP=86-88 15 $48 WAlert 15 WS=92 15 $44 WS 10 TWCI=86-88 09 WE=89 09 ST=87 09 RP=87-90 08 WS=90 08 RP=87-89 07 RP=84-86 07 WS=86-89 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 WS=88 06 $37 WS 05 RP=87-89 05 WS=89 05 $44 WS
Ch la Mothe du Barry Bordeaux Sup 14/15 12 Best Buy WE 12 WE=88 12 $12 WE
Bordeaux Sup Vieilles Vignes 13/14/15 12 Best Buy WE 12 WE=90 12 $13 WE ` 10 WE=89 10 $21 WE 10 WS=87 08 Very Successful Hachette 11 Ch Clos Moulin Bordeaux Sup 14/15 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=90 15 $14 WE
Ch Moulin de Blanchon Haut Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=83
Ch Moulin de Canhaut Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=89
La Mouline Moulis 13/14/15 15 RP=85
Ch Moulin Haut-Laroque Fronsac 13/14/15 15 #14 Top Value < $30 WS 15 WS=91 15 $22 WS
Ch Clos Moulin Pontet Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15 14 Best Buy WE 14 WE=90 14 $14 WE 14 Vin Remarquable Hachette 17 10 GdP=87 Ch Moulin Riche St-Julien (Leoville-Poyferre’s second wine) 15 RP=89-91 15 $60 WAlert 15 WS=92 15 $55 WS 08 WS=88
Ch du Moulin Rouge Haut-Medoc Cru Bourgeois 14/15 15 RP=88 15 $14 WAlert 10 WS=87 10 $14 WS 10 RP=88 09 Gold Bordeaux 11 09 JR=15 (84) 09 Bronze Decanter 11 09 Dec=15.5 (86)
Ch Moulin-St-Georges St-Emilion GC 12/13/14/15 15 RP=90-92 15 $44 WAlert 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=92 10 80%Merlot-20%CF 10 ST=88 09 WE=91 09 ST=87 151
09 RP=88-90 08 RP=89-91 07 RP=90 07 WE=87 07 $42 WE 07 WS=86-89 07 ST=87 06 WE=90 06 RP=90 06 ST=90 06 WS=88
Ch Moulin a Vent Moulis 13/14/15 15 RP=83
Mouton Cadet See: Rothschild
Ch Mouton Rothschild Paulliac PGC 10/11/12/13/14/15/16/17 17 WineS=96 16 TWCI=99 15 RP=97-99 15 $515-650Wal 15 WS=96 15 $552 WS 15/14 TWCI=97 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE =96 14 $400 WE 14 WS=96 14 $338 WS 14 Decanter=95 13/12 Cellar Selection WE 13 WE=96 13 $400 WE 13 TWCI=93 12 WE=97 12 $363 WE 12 TWCI=96 11 TWCI=93 10 94%CS-6%Merlot 10 ST=95 10/09 TWCI=99 09 88%CS-12%Merlot 09 One of Top 15 Decanter 09 Decanter=5star 09 Decanter=19/20 09 ST=95 09 WE=98 09 RP=96-98+ 09 One of Top 32 JJB 09 JJB=96-98 08 RP=94-96 08 WE=95-97 08 ST=92 08 JJB=92-94 08 TWCI=94 07 RP=92 07 WE=95 07 ST=93 07 WS=90-93 07 TWCI=93 06 Cellar Selection WE 06 WE=97/97 06 Vin Exceptionnel Hachette 10 06 ST=93-96 06 Coup de Coeur Hachette 10 06 WE=97 06 WS=94 06 RP=98+ 06 ST=94-95 06 TWCI=97 05 Von Exceptionnel Hachette 09 05 RP=93-95 05 Coup de Coeur Hachette 09 05 WS=93 05 Highly Rec’d to Great W&S 4/06 05 W&S=2½stars 05 WE=95/95 05 ST=95 0/045 TWCI=92 04 Vin Remarquable Hachette 08 04 WE=93 04 Coup de Coeur Hachette 08 04 RP=91-93 04 ST=92 04 WS=93 03 Vin Remarq. Hachette 08/07 03 RP=95 152
03 WS=94 03 WE=91/94 03 WW=91-94 03 ST=93 03 TWCI=96 02 RP=93 02 WS=91 02 ST=94 02 TWCI=93
See also their second wine: Le Petit Mouton
Ch Nenin Pomerol 12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 JS=96-97 18 $70 wine.com 18 WS=93-96 18 RP=93-95 16 TWCI=93 16 JS=95-96 16 WE=93-95 16 WS=91-94 16 RP=92-94 16 Vinous=90-93 16 Decanter=93 15 TWCI=92 15 JCLee=93 15 WS=93 15 $64 WS 15 JR=17 (92) 15 JS=95 15 WS=93 15 RP=92-94 14 TWCI=90/90 14 WS=92 14 RP=92 14 WE=91 13 TWCI=89 12 Cellar Selection WE 12 WE=92 12 $50 WE 12 TWCI=91/90 12 WE=92 12 JS=91 12 WS=91 12 JR=16 (88) 11 TWCI=87/89 10 82%Merlot-18%CF 10 ST=87 10 TWCI=90/90 10 JCLee=92 09 80%Merlot-20%CF 09 ST=89 09 WE=92 09 RP=91-93 09 THCI=90/89 08 RP=90-93 08 TWCI=89 07 RP=89 07 WE=89 07 $45 WE 07 ST=87 07 WS=87-90 07 TWCI=86 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 RP=91 06 WE=93/90 06 WS=91 06 $68 WS 06 JR=16 (88) 05 Cited Wine Hachette 09 05 WE=91 05 WS=93 05 ST=89 05 RP=90-92 05 TWCI=90/89
153
See also: Fugue de Nenin
Ch Noaillac Medoc13/14/15 15 RP=88 15 $21 WineS 10 RP=88 Ch Olivier Pessac-Leognan GC 13/14/15/16/17/18 18 WE=94-96 18 $32 wine.com 18 WS=92-95 18 Decanter=94 18 RP=92-94 16 RP=91-93 16 WE=94-96 16 WS=91-93 16 JS=90-92 16 Decanter=94 15 TWCI=90 15 JCLee=91 15 RP=91-92 15 WS-91 15 $33 WS 15 JR=16.5 (90) 15 Decanter=93 15 JS=92-93 15 WE=91-93 15 RP=91-92 15 WS=90-92 15 Vinous=90-92 14 #13 Top Values < $30 WS 14 WS=91 14 $25 WS 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=94 14 $35 WE 14 RP=86 14 TWCI=88 13 Very Successful Hachette 16 13 JR=14.5 (82) 13 TWCI=86 12 Cited Wine Hachette 15 12 TWC=89 12/11 JR=15.5 (86) 11 Very Successful Hachette 15 11 TWCI=86 11 Vin Remarquable Hachette 14 10 60%CS-40%Merlot 10 ST=86 10 JJB=92 10 TWCI=89 09 83%CS-17%Merlot 09 WE=92 09 ST=88 09 TWCI=88 08 WS=88 08 $26 WS 08 ST=88 07 RP=70-73 07 WS=88 06 TWCI=87 Ch L’Orangerie Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=87 15 $12 WE 15 WS=84 14 Very Successful Hachette 17 Clos de l’Oratoire St-Emilion GC 13/14/15/16/17/18 18 WS=94-97 17 $40 wine.com 18 JS=94-95 18 JD=93-95 15 WS=94 15 $41 WS 15 90%Merlot-10CF 15 RP=91-93 15 WS=94 15 $41 WS 14 RP=91 10 95%Merlot-5%CF 10 ST=87 09 RP=91-93 08 95%M-5%CF 08 WE=91-93 08 RP=89-91 08 WS=88-91 08 JJB=88-90 08 JJB=86-88 07 RP=90 07 WS=86-89 07 ST=88 06 RP=91 154
06 Not a great effort WD 06 WD=14.5-15.5 06 ST=89-91 06 WS=91 06 $41 WS
Ch les Ormes-de-Pez St-Estephe Cru Bourgeois Except 13/14/15/16/17/18 18 JS=93-94 18 $31 wine.com 18 WS=90-93 18 JD=91-93 18 Decanter=93 16 TWCI=91 16 WE=93-95 16 JS=92-94 16 RP=92-94 16 WS=91-93 16 Decanter=93 15 44%CS-49Merlot-6CF-1PV 15 RP=87-89 15 TWCI=87 15 JS=90-92 15 WS=87 15 $34 WS 15 JCLee=93 15 JR=16 (88) 14 TWCI=90 14 JS=93 14 RP=92 14 Vinous=92 JDunnick=91 13 TWCI=86 13/12 JR=16 12 Vin Remarquable Hachette 16 12 TWCI=87 12 JS=92 11 WE=92-94 11 JS=90-91 11 TWCI=89 10 57%CS-34%Merlot-7%CF-2%PV 10 ST=88 10 Very Successful Hachette 14 10 JJB=92+ 10 TWCI=91 10 JS=95 10 WE=93 10 WS=91 10 Decanter=90 09 Coup de Coeur 2 stars Hachette 13 09 WE=91 09 RP=88-90 09 TWCI=92 09 Decanter=4star 09 Decanter=17/20 08 Cited Wine Hachette 12 08 WS=88 08 $26 WS 08 WE=91 08 ST=87 08 RP=89-91 08 TWCI=90 08 Decanter =4star 08 SS=16.5/20 07 Cellar Selection WE 07 WE=91 07 $28 WE 07 Cited Wine Hachette 11 07 RP=86-88 07=56%CS-36%Merlot-6%CF-2%PV 07 ST=86 07 WS=84-87 07 TWCIU=84
Ch Les Ormes-Sorbet Medoc13/14/15 15 RP=91 10 RP=87 08 WE=87 07 WE=86 06 Cited Wine Hachette 10 06 WE=87 06 WS=80
Les Pagodes de Cos See: Ch Cos-D’Estournel 155
Ch Palmer Margaux 3rd Cru 10/11/12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 WS=97-100 18 $336wine.com 18 Decanter=98-100 18 WE=97-99 18 RP=97-99 18 Vinous=95-98 15 RP=95-97 15 WS=96 15 $310 WS 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=97 14 $210 WE 14 WS=94 14 $217 WS 14 Decanter=93 13/12 Cellar Selection WE 13 WE=94 12 WE=95 10 54%Merlot-40%CS-6%PV 10 ST=90 09 52%Merlot-41%CS-PV 09 One of Top 15 Decanter 09 Decanter=5star 09 Decanter=19/20 09 ST=88 09 WE=99 09 RP=94-96 09 One of Top 32 JJB 09 JJB=96-98 08 RP=95-97 08 WE=93-95 08 ST=91 08 JJB=90-92 07 RP=89 07 ST=91 07 WS=90
06 Top Pick K&L 06 RP=92 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 WE=94 06 AG=93 06 ST=91-93 06 WS=93 06 $215 WS
05 Highly Rec’d W&S 4/06 05 RP=95-100 05 $230 05 Opulent, big, chewy WW 06 05 WE=95/96 05 Vin Remarquable Hachette 09 05 W&S=96 05 $350 W&S 05 “Coup de Coeur” Hachette 09 05 WS=95 05 $271 WS 05 ST=94 04 Very Successful Hachette 08 04 WE=90 04 WS=91 04 $124 WS 04 ST=92
See also their second wine: Alter Ego de Palmer
Ch Paloumey Haut Medoc Cru Bourgeois Sup 13/14/15 55%CS-40Merlot-5CF 16 WE=92-94 16 $16 wine.com 16 WS=89-91 16 RP=88-90 16 JS=89=90 16 Decanter=?? 16 WDecider=89 16 TWCI=88 15 WE=92-94 15 $16 wine.com 15 RP=91 15 $18 K&L 15 WS=88 15 $18 WS 15 JCLee=91 15 Vinous=?? 15 WDecider=90 15 TWCI=86 14 JCLee=85 14 WDecider=89 14 TWCI=87 14 /13 Editor’s Choice WE 14/13 WE=90 14 $21 WE 13 WS=83 13 JCLee=84 13 $20 WE 156
13 WDecider=87 13 $22 WineCh 12 Editor’s Choice WE 12 WE=91 12 $20 WE 12 Vin Remarquable Hachette 16 12 TWCI=87 11 JR=15.5 (86) 11 Cited Wine Hachette 15 11 Vivino=3.5 (216) 11 Bronze Decanter 14 10 Very Successful Hachette 14 10 JR=16 (88) 09 Bronze Decanter 13 09 TWCI=87 Ch Panchille Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15 15 WS=87 15 $16 WS
Ch Panigon Medoc 13/14/15 15 WS=87 15 $20 WS 15 RP=88 10 WS=88 10 $25 WS 10 WE=88 10 $20 WE Ch Le Pape Pessac-Leognan 13/14/15 15 75%Merlot-CS 15 WS=89 15 RP=90-92 Ch Pape Clement Pessac-Leognan GC 10/11/12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 WS=95-98 18 $555wine.com 18 JS=97-98 18 RP=96-98 18 JD=95-97 15 RP=95-97 15 WS=95 15 $100 WS 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=94 14 $120 WE 14 WS=93 14 $71 WS 13 WS=86 13 $84 WS 10 62%CS-37%Merlot-1%PV 10 ST=94 10 JJB=96 09 55%CS-40%Merlot-PV 09 WE=93 09 ST=93 09 RP=95-97+ 09 WS=94-97 09 ST=93-96 08 RP=94-96 08 ST=90 08 WS=90 08 JJB=91-93 07 RP=92 07 WE=91 07 $130 WE 07 ST=92 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 RP=95 06 WD=16.5-17.5+ 06 ST=91-93 06 WS=91 06 WE=92 05 Vin Remarquable Hachette 09 05 RP=98 05 Highly Rec’d W&S 4/06 05 WE=93 05 W&S=94 05 ST=94 05 WD=18-19/20 05/04 WS=96
Le Clementin de Pape Clement 12/13/14/15 14 RP=87-89 15 $35-45WAlert 10 55%CS=45%Merlot 10 ST=87
Les Cles de Pape Clement Pessac-Leognan 15 Celle Selcetion WE 15 WE=93 15 $50 WE
Ch du Parc St-Emilion 13/14/15 15 RP-85-87 14 RP=88 13 WS=86 13 $46 WS La Parde de Haut-Bailly Pessac-Leognan 13/14/15 15 RP=88-90 15 $29-34WAlert 10 RP=87 05 WS=88
Ch de Parenchere Bordeaux Clairet 15/16 16 WE=82 16 $14 WE
157
Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15 (CS) 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=90 15 $15 WE 10 WS=88 10 $17 WS 10 WE=85 09 Bronze Decanter, IWC 12 09 CF-CS-Merlot 08 Comm’d IWC 12 Bordeaux Sup Cuvee Raphael 13/14/15 13 WS=78 13 $22 WS 10 Comm’d Decanter 12 10 WS=87 10 $24 WS 09 Bronze IWC; Comm’d Decanter 12 08 Silver LA 11 Ch Pas de l’Ane St-Emilion13/14/15 15 RP=90-92 10 ST=87 06 ST=87-89 05 Cited Wine Hachette 09 05 ST=90 04 Very Successful Hachette 08 03 RP=87-90 02 WS=85-88 Ch Pas de Rauzan Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=90 15 $15 WE
Ch les Pasquets Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 WS=81 15 $15 WS 15/14 W&S=NR 15 $12 W&S 14 $13 W&S 13 WS=86 13 $19 WS 10 45%Merlot-45%CS-5%PV) 10 WE=84 10 $16 WE
Ch la Patache Medoc Cab Sauv 13/14/15 15 86%Merlot-15CF 15 RP=89-91 15 WS=86 15 $50 WS 10 Bronze Decanter 12 06 WE=85 06 $12 WE 06 WS=84 Pomerol Badine 13/14/15 15 WS=86 15 $50 WS
Ch Patache d’Aux Medoc Cru Bourgeois Sup 13/14/15 15 RP=88 15 $14-17 WineS 15 WS=898 15 $23 WS 13 Best Buy WE 13 WE=87 13 $27 WE 13 WS=83 10 WS=90 10 $25 WS 10 RP=89 10 WE=87 10 $20 WE 09 Silver Decanter 12 08 Bronze Bordeaux 10 08 SS=15.0/20 08 Decanter=3star
Ch Patris Querre St-Emilion 13/14/15 15 RP=89-91 15 $20-32 WineS 10 90% Merlot 10 WS=89 10 $25 WS 10 RP=88 10 $23 RP 10 TWCI=87-89 Ch Pauillac Paulliac 13/14/15 15 RP=90-92 09 RP=91-93 08=45%CS-55%M 08 JJB=88-91 08 RP=88-90 07 RP=88 06 RP=88 Pauillac de Ch Latour Pauillac 13/14/15/16 16 TWCI=92 15 %54.2%CS-41.7Merlot-4.1PV 15 RP=86-88 15 $29 WAlert 09 Decanter=3star 09 Decanter=16/20 06 WS=85-88 05 WS=90 04 WS=85-88 03 WS=88 06 WS=85-88 05 ST=86-89 05 WS=92-94 05 ST=87-89 05 RP=90-92 158
04 WS=87 04 $65 WS 04 ST=87-89 04 RP=87 03 ST=87-89 03 RP=87 03/02 WS=85-88 02 ST=87-91 Ch Paveil de Luze Margaux Cru Bourgeois 13/14/15/16 16 TWCI=90 15 RP=86 15 $35 WAlert 15 WS=89 15 $25 WS 15 TWCI=90 15 JR=16 (88) 14 65%CS-30Merlot-5CF 14 TWCI=87 14 $37 Andys 14 WE=91 14 JR=15 (82) 13 WS=82 13 JR=16.5 (90) 12 TWCI=85 12 JR=16 (88) 10 RP=92 10 TWCI=90 10 JR=16.5 (90) 09 WE=88 09 TWCI=89 08 WE=90 08 ws=87 08 JR=16 (88) 08 SS=15.5/20 08 Decanter=3star 06 RP=87
Ch Pavie St-Emilion PGC 10/11/12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 60%Merlot-22CF-18CS 18 JD=98-100 18 $380wine.com 18 RP=97-100 18 WS=96-99 18 JS=98-99 15 RP=96-98 15 WS=98 15 $351 WS 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=95 14 WS=96 14 $245 WS 13 WS=93 13 $268 WS 10/09 70%Merlot-20%CF-10%CS 10 ST=93 09 ST=94 09 WE=96 09 RP=96-100 09 One of Top 32 JJB 09 JJB=97-99 09 Decanter=4star 09 Decanter=18/20 08 RP=96-98 08 WS=92-95 08 ST=92 08 JJB=93-95 07 RP=94 07 WE=93 07 $210 WE 07 WS=89-92 07 ST=93 06 Cellar Selection WE 06 WE=95 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06/05 WS=95-100 06 Coup de Coeur Hachette 10 06 RP=96 06 ST=92-94 05 Profound, extraordinary purity WW 05 RP=98-100 05 Monumental flavors Decanter 06 05 SS=19/20 05 WE=89 05 ST=96 05 WS=100 05 $405 WS 05 WD=14.5-15.5 04 Vin Remarquable Hachette 08 04 WS=89-91 159
04 ST=93
See also: St-Emilion Aromes de Pavie
Ch Pavie-Decesse St-Emilion GC 12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 JD=97-100 18 $126wine.com 18 JS=97-98 18 WS=95-88 18 RP=96-98 15 RP=93-95 15 WS=96 15 $140 WS 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=93 14 $240 WE 14 WS=94 14 $109 WS 13 WS=91 13 $100 WS 10/09 90%Merlot-10%CF 10 ST=91 09 ST=93 09 RP=93-96 09 One of Top 32 JJB 09 JJB=95-97 08 RP=94-96 08 WS=89-92 08 JJB=92-94 07 RP=93 07 WS=87-90 07 ST=92 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 WS=89-91 06 RP=94+ 06 ST=94 05 WS=96 05 $300 WS 04 Very Successful Hachette 08 04 WS=89-91 04 ST=92 03 WS=93 02 WS=89 Ch Pavie de Luze Margaux 13/14/15 65%CS-30Merlot-5CF 16 JR=16 (88) 16/15 TWCI=90 14 TWCI=87 14 JR=15 (84) 13 JR=16.5 (90) 12 TWCI=85 12 JR=16 (88) 10 TWCI=90 09 TWCI=89 Ch Pavie-Macquin St-Emilion PGC 12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 JD=97-99 18 $75 wine.com 18 WS=95-98 18 Decanter=98 18 RP=95-97 15 WS=96 15 $81 WS 15 RP=91-93 14 WS=94 14 $59 WS 13 WS=92 13 $53 WS 10/09 ST=91 10 JJB=93 09 WE=92 09 RP=94-96+ 09 Decanter=4star 09 Decanter=18/20 08 WE=94 08 RP=93-95 08 ST=90 08 WS=90-93 08 JJB=91-93 07 Editor’s Choice WE 07 WE=90 07 $55 WE 07 RP=91 07 WS=88-91 07 ST=91 06 WE=92 06 Good WD 06 WD=15.5-16.5 06 WS=93 06 $72 WS 160
06 RP=92+ 06 ST=91-93 05 Noble, great future SS in Decanter 05 SS=18/20 05 RW=14.5-15.5 05 Cellar Selection WE 05 WE=92/94 05 RP=98 05 W&S=94 05 WS=96 05 ST=95
See also: St-Emilion Les Chenes de Macquin
Pavillon Rouge du Ch M Margaux (Ch Margaux’s second wine) 16 84%CS-13Merlot-3PV 16 RP=91-93 16 $150 Sh-L 15 JCLee=94 15 $150wine.com 15 WS=94 15 $154 WS 15 JR=17.5 (94) 14 Decanter=91 14 $120 TW&M 12/11/10/09 Vin Remarquable Hachette 12/10 JR=17.5 (84) 09 Outperformed Price JJB 09 JJB=92-94 09 67%CS-29%M-4%PV 09 RP=91-93 09 $160-326 RP 09 ST=90 09 Decanter=4star 09 Decanter=18/20 08 Very Successful Hachette 12 08 RP=90-92 08 WS=87-90 08 WE=89-91 08 ST=87 07 RP=88 07=58%CS-37%Merlot-5%PV 07 ST=87-88 07 WS=85-88 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 WE=90 06 RP=86 06 WS=88 06 WW=87-88 05 One of Top 8 “Seconds” QWR 05 WE=91/92 05 Gorgeous aromas, silky WW 06 05 ST=89-92 05 Vin Remarquable Hachette 09 05 WS=92 05 RP=91-93 04 Very Successful Hachette 08 04 WS=88 04 RP=89-91 04 ST=91-93 04 WW=90-92
Ch le Payral Bergerac Red 13/14/15 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=90 15 $13 WE
Ch Peby-Faugeres St-Emilion GC 10/11/12/13/14/15/16 15 RP=91-93 15 $130-176WAl 14 WS=93 14 $91 WS 13 WS=88-91 10 ST=88 09 RP=93-96 08 RP=92-94 08 JJB=92-94 07 RP=90+ 07 WS=87-90 06 RP=93+ 06 WS=92 06 $84 WS 05 WS=94 05 $94 WS Ch Pedesclaux Paulliac 13/14/15/16/17/18 18 JD=93-95 18 $44 wine.com 18 RP=92-94 18 Decanter=93 15 WS=87 15 $44 WS 15 RP=90-92 09 Outperformed Price JJB 09 JJB=92-94 09 WE=91 09 WS=90-93
161
09 RP=85-87 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 Ch Penin Bordeaux CF 14/15 15 Silver LA 17
Bordeaux Clairet 14/15/16 16 WE=88 14 W&S=NR Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15 15 Gold LA 17 15 LA=92 14 Very Successful Hachette 17 10 Bronze LA 12 Ch La Pensee Lalande de Pomerol 13/14/15 16 Vivino=4.0 (1) 15/14 100%Merlot 15 Vivino=4.3 (5) 15 C$39 SAQ 14 Vivino=3.5 (25) 13 Very Successful Hachette 17 13 Vivino=3.7 (33) Les Pensees de Lafleur Pomerol 13/14/15 15 54%Merlot-46CF 15 RP=01-03 15 $159-170 07 62%Merlot-CF 09 RP=89-91 08 RP=89-91 07 ST=85-88 07 WS=85-88 05 WS=94 05 $145 WS Les Pensees de l Tour Carnet Haut Medoc 13/14/15 15 85%Merlot-15CS 15 RP=85-87 New 2nd wine of Ch La Tour Carnet Le Pepin Vin de France CS-Merlot 14/15 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=85 15 $6 WE
Ch de Perenchere Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=90 15 $15 WE
Ch de Perier Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=83
Ch Perron Graves 13/14/15 13 WS=87 13 $25 WS
Ch Petit Bocq St-Estephe Cru Bourgeois Sup 13/14/15 15 RP=85? 15 $18-43 WineS 15 TWCI=85-87 10 RP=88 09 Merlot 08 Bronze Decanter, IWC 10 08 WS=87 08 RP=86-87 08 JJB=86-88 Petit Chapeau Bordeaux 13/14/15 13 W&S=NR 13 $14 W&S
Le Petit Cheval St-Emilion 13/14/15 Cheval Blanc’s 2nd wine 14 Cellar Selecxtion WE 14 WE=92 10 75%Merlot-25%CF 10 ST=87 09 65%CF-35%Merlot 09 ST=89 09 RP=91-93 08 RP=90-92 07 ST=89 07 RP=85-87 07 WS=84-87 06 RP=89 06 ST=86-89 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 WE=90 04 Cited Wine Hachette 08 05 WS=89 05 $137 WS Ch Petit Clos du Roy Bordeaux 14/15 2nd label of Clos de Roy 15 Bettane&D=14 15 $16.24 Cost+ 13 CT=85 (5) 13 Bettane*D=14 13 CT=84 (6) Petit Clos Taillefer Pomerol 13/14/15 15 RP=86-88
Ch Petit-Faurie-de-Soutard St-Emilion 14/15 15 RP=86-88 15 $11-27 WineS 08 RP=85-87 07 WS=84-87 Ch Petit Figeac See: Ch Figeac
Ch Petit-Freylon Bordeaux Cuvee Michael 14/15 15 WS=84 15 $13 WS 12 Best Buy WE 12 WE=86 12 $11 WE 10 WS=86 10 $11 WS Bordeaux Sup Cuvee Sarah 14/15 15 WS=86 15 $15 WS 162
Ch Petit-Gravet-Aine St-Emilion GC 13/14/15 15 RP=92-94 15 $37-40 RP
07 80%CF-20%Merlot 09 RP=88-91 08 RP=89-91 07 ST=87
Le Petit Haut Lafitte Pessac-Leognan (Haut Lafitte’s 2ndwine) 15 10%CS-40Merlot 15 JR=18/20 15 $88 K&L 15 GaultMillau=18 15 $87 Sh-L 15 RevueVinFR=1915 $90 wine.com 15 WS=88-92 15 $90 Zachys 15 RP=90-92 15 $170/1.5L JJB 14 WineInsider=94 14 $70 K&L 14 JR=16.5/20 14 GaultMillau=17 14 RevueVinFR=18 14 WS=88-91 13 JS=91-94 13 Vinous=90-93 13 WS=86 13 WE=89-91 12 60%CS-40%Merlot 12 WS=89 12 CT=91.4 (33) 12 WE=92 12 JR=17/20 12 JeanieLee=88 12 GilbertGaillard=91 12 RevueVinFR=18.5 12 WineInsider=94 11 JS=94 11 WS=88 11 JR=16/20 11 WindInsider=93 11 JeanieLee=90 11 GaultMillau=18 10 WS=91 10 JS=91 09 WS=90 09 JS=93 La Petit Lion St-Julien 13/14/15 15 60%Merlot-49CS 15 RP=88-90 09 RP=87-89 Ch Le Petit Mouton Pauillac 12/13/14/15/16 (Ch Mouton’s 2nd wine) 15 WS=91 15 $160 WS 15 70%CS-17Merlot-5CF 15 RP=91-93 15 $150-315WAl 09 RP=90-92 08 ST=87 08 RP=89-91 08 JJB=88-90 08 JJB=86-88 07 WE=87 07 $75 WE 07 ST=88 07 RP=84-87 07 WS=85-88 06 WE=89 06 RP=90 06 WS=87 05 ST=87-90 05 WS=89 05 $89 WS 05 RP=90 03 WS=88 Ch Petit-Village Pomerol 12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 WS=92-95 18 $72 wine.com 18 WE=92-94 15 WS=92 15 $71 WS 13 WS=88 13 $59 WS 10 75%Merlot-18%CF-7%CS 10 ST=90 09 75%Merlot-17%CS-8%CF 09 ST=88 09 WE=92 163
09 RP=88-90 08 ST=89 08 RP=87-88 07 Value < $500/case QRW Aut 08 07 RP=78-82 07 ST=88 06 Cellar Selection WE 06 WE=91 06 RP=88 06 Interesting WD 06 WD=14.5-15.5 06 ST=88-89 06 WS=88 06 $49 WS 05 Outstanding for price QWR 05 WE=90/93 05 Vin Remarquable Hachette 09 05 WS=92 05 $56 WS 05 ST=89 05 WD=15-16/20 05 RP=86-88 04 WS=90
Le Jardin de petit Village 12/13/14/15 15 RP=90-92 15 $68-75 WAl
La Petite Marquise du Clos St-Jilien 14/15 15 2nd label of Clos du Marquis 15 RP=86-88 15 $24-34WineS
Petite Serene (Ch Giscours) Bordeaux 14/15 15 Gold LA 16 15 WS=85 15 $20 WS
Ch Les Petits Arnaud Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux Tradition 13/14/15 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=90 15 $13 WE
Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux Cuvee Non-Sulfite 15 Editor’s Choice WE 15 WE=91 15 $21 WE
Ch Petrus Pomerol 17 WineS=95 16 JR=17+ 16 $2800 wine.c 16 WE=98-100 16 $2999 K&L 16 JS=97-100 16 $2950Millesin 16 WS=98-100 16 RP=96-98 16 Decanter=98 16 TWCI=99 15 RP=98-100 14 $2850WAlert 15 WS=96 15 $2900 WS 15 JCLee=99 15 JR=18.5 (98) 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=96 14 WS=95 14 $1764 WS 14 TWCI=96 13 Cellar Selection WE 13 WE=95 13 $2400 WE 13 WS=92 13 $2097 WS 13 TWCI=94 12 Cellar Selection WE 12 WE=97 12 Coup de Coeur 3 stars Hachette 16 12 WS=96 12 $2150 WS 12 TWCI=98 11 Coup de Coeur 2 stars Hachette 15 11 TWCI=96 10/09 100%Merlot 10 ST=96 10 $3800TW&M 10/09/08 Coup Coeur 3 stars Hachette 10/09 TWCI=100 09 One of Top 15 Decanter 09 Decanter=5star 09 $3800TW&M 09 Decanter=19/20 09 WE=98 09 ST=97 09 RP=96-100 08 ST=93 08 RP=98-100 08 JJB=97-99 08 JJB=92-94 08 TWCI=98 07 RP=91 07 WS=89-92 07 ST=92 06 Cellar Selection WE 06 WE=96/97 06 Vin Exceptionnel Hachette 10 06 RP=93+ 06 Coup de Coeur Hachette 10 06 ST=92-94 164
06 WS=94 06 $2000 WS 06 JR=16 (88) 05 RP=98-100 05 Great wine W&S 4/06 05 W&S=3stars 05 Vin Remarquable Hachette 09 05 WE=96/100 05 WS=100 05 $4975 WS 05 ST=96+? 04 RP=90-93 04 #49 Top 50 Cellar Selections WE 07 04 WE=97 04 WS=93 04 ST=93 04/03 Vin Remarq. Hachette 08/07 03 RP=95 03 WS=98 03 ST=93+ 02 RP=90 02 WS=93 02 ST=92 01 RP=95 01 WS=95 01 ST=92+ 01 TA=5stars 01 TWCI=97 00 RP=100 00 WS=98 00 ST=96 00 TWCI=100 See also: Ch La Fleur-Petrus
Ch Petrus Gaia Bordeaux Superieur 10 ST=86 09 Outperformed Price JJG 09 JJB=92-94 09 $16 JJB 09 RP=88-90 09 $16-19 RP 09 WS=88-91 09 $19 K&L 08 RP=87-89 08 JR=15.5 (86) Ch le Pey Medoc 13/14/15 15 Editor’s Choice WE 15 WE=90 15 $19 WE 14 RC=88+ 14 C$23 LCBO 14 WE=91 Ch Peybrun Cadillac Cotes de Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 WS=88 15 $20 WS
Pey-Bonhomme Les-Tours Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux 13/14/15 14 W&SNR 14 $20 W&S
Ch Pey de Pont Medoc Cru Bourgeois 12/13/14/15 15 RP=88 14 RP=81 14 $10-15 RP 14 CostcoBlog=90 14 $11 Costco
Ch Pey la Tour (Dourthe) Bordeaux 14/14/15 15 Silver Mundus Vini 17 15 RP=90-92 15 $10-14 WineS 15 Vivino=3.6 (132) 14 Merlot-CS 14 JCLee=86 14 WE=85 14 $14 WE 14 RP=86 12 Bronze Decanter, IWC, IWSC 14 12 RP=85-86 12 Bronze Macon 14 12 WE=86 11 JR=15 (84) 11 JCLee=85 11 WE=84 10 WS=86 10 $15 WS 10 RP=87 10 JCLee=87 09 Besdt Buy WE 09 WE=89 09 $13 WE 09 JR=14.5 (82) 08 WS=83 08 $13 WS Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15/16 16/15 TWCI=89 15 Bronze LA 17 14 JCLee=86 14 C$16+ BCLS 14 RP=84-86 12 TWCI=89 165
12 JR=15.5 (86) 10 Bronze Decanter, IWC 12 10 WE=85 10 $13 WE 10 CF-CS-Merlot 10 RC=87 10 RP=86-88 10 TWCI=87 10 WE=85 10 $13 WE 09 Silver Brussels 10 09 TWCI=85 09 Bronze Decanter 10 09/08 RP=87 08 AG=84 08 WS=83 08 $13 WS 08 NM=87 Bordeaux Sup Res de Ch 13/14/15/16 org grapes 16 RP=86-88 15 RP=88-90 15 $13-22 WineS 15 WS=87 15 $19 WS 15 JR=16 (88) 14 Silver LA 17 14 WS=85 14 $19 WS 14 WE=89 14 TWCI=88 14 RP=89 14 JR=15.5 (86) 12 Silver Decanter 16 12 WS=87-90 12 Bronze IWSC 16 12 WE=85 12 $19 WE 11 Silver LA 16; Decanter 15 11 WS=86 11 $19 WS 11 RP=86-87 10 Silver LA; Bronze IWC 12 10 RP=86-88 10 CS-Merlot-PV 10 JR=15 (84) 10 Bronze Decanter 15 10 WS=89 10 $25 WS 09 Merlot-CS 09 RP=87-89 09 Comm’d IWC 10 09 WS=87 09 WE=87 09 JR=15.5 (86) 08 Gold Paris 09 08 WS=87 08 $15 WS 08 Silver Brussels 10; Decanter 09 08 WE=88 08 $18 WE 08 Very Successful Hachette 11
Ch Peychaud Cotes de Bourg 14/15/16 14 Very Successful Hachette 17 12 Best Buy WE 12 WE=89 12 $14 WE Peyfaures Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15 15 RP=84-86 10 RP=88/87 10 $20 RP
Dame de Coeur 13/14/15 15 RP=86-88 10 RP=88 Ch Peymouton St.-Emilion GC 13/14/15 13 Editor’s Choice WE 13 WE=90 13 $30 WE 06 WS=89 Ch Peynaud-Bagnac Bordeaux 14/15/16 16/15 Silver LA 17/16 12 Best Buy WE 12 WE=89 12 $10 WE 09 Gold BofClass LA 11 09 LA=92 09 Silver LA 10
Ch Peyrabon Haut Medoc Cru Bourgeois 13/14/15/16 16 RP=87-89 16 $?? WE 16 Vinous=90 16 $13 K&L 16 TWCI=88 (904) 16 CT=88.5 (1) 15 RP=89-91 15 $14-20WAlert 15 JR=16 (88) 15 JCLee=84 14 WE=91 14 $17 WE 14 RP=89 14 C$29 LCBO 13 Comm’d Decanter 16 13 WE=90 13 $42 WE 13 Bronze IWSC 16 13 WS=82-85 13 Gilbert&G=87 12 Editor’s Choice WE 12 WE=92 12 $25 WE 12 Silver IWSC 15 12 RC=88 12 Bronze Decanter 15 12 WE=92 12 Editor’s Choice WE 12 WE=92 12 WS=86 12/11 $25 WS 166
12 Gilobert&G=88 12 RP=82 11 Comm’d Decanter 14 11 WS=87 11 RP=87 10 WS=91 10 $25 WS 10 RP=86 10 WE=90 10 JCLee=88 09 Bronze IWC; Comm’d Decanter 12 09 RP=88 g 09 CS-Merlot-PV
Haut Medoc La Fleur 13/14/15/16 16 RP=90-92 16 TWCI=90 15 RP=89-91 15 TWCI=85 (1308) 14 RP=86 12/12 RP=87 Peyredon-Lagravette 13/14/15 15 RP=86 15 $17-29 WineS
Ch le Peyrat Castillon Cotes de Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 WS=86 15 $15 WS 15 RP=99 12 Best Buy WE 12 WE=88 12 $12 WE
Ch Peyrat-Fourthon Haut-Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=89 10 RP=88 10 $22 RP 09 Silver Decanter 12 Ch Peyrat de Pont Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=88
Ch Peyredon Lagravette Haut-Medoc 13/14/15 13 WS=85 13 $22 WS
Ch la Peyrere Bordeaux Sup 14/15/16 16 Silver LA 17
Ch de Pez St-Estephe Cru Borgeois 13/14/15 15 44%CS-51Merlot-2CF-3PV 15 WS=88 15 $49 WS 15 RP=88-90 15 TWCI=87-89 13 WS=88 13 $37 WS 11 GDP=88 10 52.5%CS-47.5%Merlot 10 ST=86 09 47%CS-47M-PV 09 ST=90 08 Decanter=4star 08 SS=16.5/20 07 Value QRW Autumn 08 07 WS=85 07 RP=87-88 07 W&S=NR 07 $46 W&S 06 Cellar Selection WE 06 WE=91 06 Cited Wine Hachette 10 06 RP=88 06 WS=87 06/05 $39 WS Ch Phelan-Segur St-Estephe Cru Bourgeois Except 14/15/16/16/18 18 RP=93-95 18 $45 wine.com 18 JD=92-94+ 18 Decanter=94 15 RP=91-93 15 WS=89 15 $46 WS 15 TWCI=86-88 11 GDP=92 10 59%Merlot-42%CS 10 ST=88 10 JJB=90 09 Bronze Decanter 12 09 WE=90 09 ST=87 09 RP=90-92 08 WS=87 08 $29 WS 08 WE=90 08 RP=88-90 08 JJB=82-83 08 SS=16+/20 08 Decanter=3star 07 WE=90 07 $33 WE 167
07 RP=86-88 07 WS=84-87 07 ST=85
Ch Pibran Paulliac Cru Bourgeois 13/14/15/16 16 JS=92-94 16 WS=91-93 16 RP=90-92 16 TWCI=89 15 RP=89-91 15 WS=90 15 $36 WS 15 JCLee=91 15 JR=16.5 (90) 14 JR=16 (88) 13 JCLee=88 11 Very Successful Hachette 15 10 50%Merlot-50%CS 10 ST=87 10 Coup de Coeur 3 stars Hachette 14 09 60%Merlot-40%CS 09 WE=91 09 ST=88 09 Decanter=4star 09 Decanter=16.5 08 Cited Wine Hachette 12 08 SS=16+/20 08 Decanter=3star 07 Value QRW Autumn 08 07 WS=86 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 11 07 ST=86 06 Not impressive WD 06 WD=13-14/20 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 ST=87-89 06 WS=90 06 $56 WS 05 12 outstanding Values QRW 06 05 WS=92 05 $25 WS 05 Vin Remarquable Hachette 09 05 WE=89 05 ST=87-89 05 RP=86-88 Ch PichonLongueville Baron Paulliac 2nd Cru 10/12/13/14/15/16 15/14/13 Cellar Selection WE 15 WE=98 15 $137 WE 15 RP=96=98 15 $137-167Wal 15 WS=94 15 $144 WS 14 WE=95 14 $130 WE 14 WS=93 14 $92 WS 14 Decanter=92 13 WE=94 11 RP=90-92 11 WS=92-95 11 WE=93-95 11 ST=91-93 11 JS=92-93 11 NM=93-95 10 79%CS-21%Merlot 10 ST=93 10 JJB=100 09 67%CS-Merlot 09 WE=96 09 ST=93 09 RP=93-95 09 Decanter=5star 09 Decanter=18.5 08 WS=91 08 ST=90 08 RP=92-94 08 WE=91-96 08 JJB=89-91 08 JJB=97-89 07 WE=93 07 RP=90-92 07 ST=91 07 WS=88-91 07 WS=88-92 06 Cellar Selection WE 06 WE=93/93 06 Top Pick K&L 06 WS=92 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 RP=92 168
06 ST=91-93 05 Vin Exceptionnel Hachette 09 05 WS=94 05 Coup de Coeur Hachette 09 05 W&S=96 05 Cellar Selection WE 05 WE=96/93 05 Geogeous intensity, powerful WW 05 RP=94 05 Balanced, elegant RW 3/06 05 RW=17-18/20 05 Could be very good indeed WD 05 WD=17-18/20 05 Highly Rec’d W&S 4/06 05 ST=94+? 05 WW=92-94 Les Griffons de Pichon Baron 13/14/15 15/16/17 17 Most Affordable Picj WineS 17 WineS=91 15 60%CS-40Merlot 15 RP=91-93 15 $48-56WAlert 15 WS=90 15 $48 WS Les Tourelles de Longueville 13/14/15 15 WS=88 15 $34 WS
Ch Pichon-Longueville Paulliac GC 10/11/12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 Dec=98-100 18 $180wine.com Comtesse de Lalande 18 WS=97-100 18 JS=98-99 18 RP=98-99 15 RP=95-97 15/14 Cellar Selection WE 15 WE=96 15 $137 WE 15 WS=95 15 $143 WS 14 WS=94 14 $97 WS 14 WE=94 14 $115 WE 11 GDP=91 10 66%CS-24%Merlot-7%CF-3%PV 10 ST=85 10 JJB=94 09 75%CS-20%M-PV 09 WE=95 09 ST=93 09 RP=96-98 09 WS=95-98 09 Decanter=5star 09 Decanter=18.5 08=88 08 RP=94-96 08 WE=94 08 WS=89/91 08 JJB=92-94 08 JJB=88-90 07 RP=89 07 WE=91 07 ST=89 07 AG=88 07 WS=88-91 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 WE=94/94 06 RP=95 06 Top Pick K&L 06 ST=91-93 06 WE=94/94 06 WS=92 05 Outstanding for price QWR 05 WS=93 05 Fine intensity, perky finish WW 05 WE=95 05 Vin Remarquable Hachette 09 05 ST=90 05 WW=93=94 05 RP=88-90 04 WE=94 04 $70 B&M 04 WS=90 04 ST=90 4/03 Vin Remarqable Hachette 08/07 04 RP=92 03 ST=93 Res de la Comtesse 15/16/17/18 18 RP=92-94+ 18 $45 wine.com 18 JS=93-94 18 WS=90-93 15 RP=90-92 Ch Picoron Castillon Cotes de Bordeaux Cuvee Prestige 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=89 15 $13 WE
Ch Picque Caillon Pessac-Leognan 12/13/14/15 15 WSA=89 15 $40 WS 14 RP=90 14 $14-28 RP 169
13 Editor’s Choice WE 13 WE=92 13 $36 WE 12 Cellar Selection WE 12 WE=90 10 JS=91-92 10 CellarT 88 (6) 09 WS=90-93 09 ST=87
Ch Pierhem Pomerol 13/14/15 15 RP=86-88 08 RP=82-84 Ch Pierrail Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15 15 WS=87 15 $22 WS 10 Silver LA 12 10 WE=89 10 $30 WE
Ch Pierre St Emilion GC 14/15/16/17/18 18 JS=90-92 18 $18 wine.ocm 18 RP=89-91 15 JS=93-95 15 WS=88-90 Ch Pierre de Lune St-Emilion 13/14/15 15 RP=? 15 $28 WineS 09 RP=92-94 07 RP=91 07 ST=86 Ch Pierre de Montignac Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=86 10 WE=89 10 $25 WE
Ch Pilet Bordeaux 14/15/16 15 WS=85 15 $15 WS 14 Very Successful Hachette 17 Cotes de Bordeaux Cuvee Prestige 13/14/15 15 Editor’s Choice WE 15 WE=92 15 $25 WE 15 WS=85 15 $18 WS Le Pin Pomerol 10/11/12/13/14/15/16/17 17 WineS=96 16/15 TWCI=99 16 JR=17+ (92+) 15 RP=96-98 15 $3257 WAlert 15 WS=97 15 $3075 WS 14 WS=97 14 $1800 WS 14 $3022 JJB 13 TWCI=95 12 TWCI=97 12 $3146 JJB
12 JR=17 (92) 11 TWCI=94 10/09 100%Merlot 10 ST=94 10 TWCI=100 09 ST=93 09 RP=95-98 09/08 TWCI=95 08 WS=93 08 ST=93 08RP=94-96 07 RP=89 07 ST=87 07 WS=90-93 06 Gold Bordeaux, Paris 07 06 RP=93 06 ST=91-93 05 Silver Bordeaux 07 06 WS=93 06 $2500 WS 06 TWCI=96 06 JR=18.5 (95) 05 WW=98-100 05 ST=91-93 05 WS=94 05 $2500 WS 05 RP=94-96 05 TWCI=97 04 WS=92 04 RP=95 04 TWCI=94 02 WS=93 01 WS=95 01 TWCI=97 170
Ch Pindefleurs St-Emilion 13/14/15 15 RP=92-91 15 $10-24 WineS
Ch du Pin Franc Bordeaux 14/15 12 Best Buy WE 12 WE=88 12 $10 WE
Ch de Piote Bordeaux Sup Cuvee Sup 13/14/15 (org grapes) 15 32%Merlot-32CS-36Malbec 15 RP=86-88 14 Cited Wine Hachette 17 10 Silver LA 12
Ch Pipeau St-Emilion GC 13/14/15 15 RP=88-90 11 RP=87-89 09 Comm’d Decanter 12 09 RP=90-92 08 RP=89-91 07Gold Brussels; Comm’d Decante 10 07 WS=87 07 $26 WS 06 Silver Brussels 09 06 RP=88 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 WS=90 06 NM=88 06 ST=87-90 Ch la Pirourette Medoc 13/14/15 15 60%CS-40Merlot 15 RP=89
Ch de Pitray Cotes de Bordeaux 14/15/16 16 RP=88-90 16 $10 RP 15 Good Value JR 15 JR=16.5 (88) 15 75%Merlot-23%CF-2%Malbec 15 RP=89-91 15 $11 RP 15 CT=87 (1) 14 RP=87-89 14 $13 WineH 12 Editor’s Choice WE 12 WE=90 12 $17 WE 12 Typical of the best 2012s WineSoc 12 Vivino=3.6 (42) 12 Gold Bruxelles 15 12 CT=85.6 (10) 11 Gold Bordeaux 14 11 JR=16.5 (90) 10 JR=15.5 (86) 09 RC=87+ 09 RP=87-89
Ch Plain-Point Fronsac 14/15/16 16 TWCI=91
Canon-Fronsac 14/15/16 16 TWCI=90
Ch Plaisance Bordeaux Sup Grand Vin 13/14/15 15 Silver LA 17 08 Very Successful Hachette 09
Ch Plantey Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 RP=91 15 $10-2WAlert 10 RP=89
Ch Plince Pomerol 13/14/15/16 16 TWCI=90 15 RP=89-91 15 $39-43WAlert 15 WS=90 15 $39 WS 10 ST=86 09 WE=89 09 ST=87 09 JR=16.5/20 08 RP=85-87 08 JJB=87-89 08 JR=16/20 07 RP=79-82 07 WS=83-86 07 ST=84 07 JR=15.5/20 06 Gold Paris 09 06 ST=86-89 06 Cited Wine Hachette 10 06 WS=89 06 JR=16.5/20 Le Plus de Fleur de Bouard See Ch la Fleur de Bouard
Ch Poesia St-Emilion GC 13/14/15/16/17/18 18 RP=94-96 18 $34 wine.ocm 18 JD=94-96+ 18 JS=95-96 18 WS=93-96 16 TWCI=92 171
15 RP=92-94 15 WS=89 15 $45 WS Ch la Pointe Pomerol 12/13/14/15 15 84%Merlot-16CF 15 RP=91-93 15 WS=91 15 $45 WS 11 GDP=91 10 ST=87 09 85%Merlot-CF 09 ST=91 09 RP=88-90 08 ST=87 08 RP=87-89 07 RP=87 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 WE=89 06 RP=88 06 WS=90 05 Full-bodied, soft and long WW 06 05 WS=91 05 $80 WS ? 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 WE=92 05 RP=85-87 04 WS=88 04 RP=87 04/03 Very Successful Hachette 08/07 03 WS=89 03 RP=86 Ch Poitevin Medoc Cru Bourgeois 12/13/14/15 15 WS=87 15 $20 WS 15 RP=91 14 RP=88 14 $24 10 Merlot-CS-PV 10 WS=90 10 $15 WS 10 Silver Bordeaux 12 10 RP=85 10 WE=90 10 CellarT 89 (11) 10 JR=14.5 (82) 09 Bronze IWC 12 Ch Pomeys Haut-Medoc Moulis 14/15 15 RP=90 14 RP=81 14 $14 RP 09 WE=88 08 Bronze Bordeaux 10 St-Estephe 04/06 06/04 Very Successful Hachette 10/08
Ch La Pontet St-Emilion 13/14/15 15 85%Merlot-15CF Their furst issue 15 RP=93-95
Ch Pontet-Canet Paulliac 5th Cru 13/14/15/16/17/18 18 RP=97-99 18 120wime.com 18 JD=96-98 18 WE=96-98 18 Decanter=96 16 TWCI=98 15 #8 Top VaLUE < $30 WS 15 WS=94 15 $117 WS 15 RP=94-96 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=96 14 $110 WE 14 WS=93 14 $95 WS 14 Decanter=95 13 Cellar Selection WE 13 WE=95 13 $105 WE 10 65%CS-30%M-4%CF-1%PV 10 ST=94 09 WE=99 09 ST=91 09 RP=97-100 09 WS=95-98 09 One of Top 32 JJB 09 JJB=95-97 09 Decanter=5star 09 Decanter=18.5 08 WE=95 08 RP=96-98 08 ST=91 08 WS=90-93 08 JJB=93-95 08 JJB=90-92 07 Editor’s Choice WE 07 WE=94 08 $75 WE 07 RP=91-94 07 WS=88-91 172
07 ST=92 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 WE=92 06 RP=95+ 06 Top Pick K&L 06 ST=91-94 06 WS=93 05 Best ever! WW 06 05 ST=95 05 Outstanding for price QWR 05 WS=96 05 Very good indeed RW 3/06 05 WE=93/94 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 WD=16.5-17.5 05 RP=93-95 04 WS=93 05 WE=93 05 WW=95-98 05 WD=16.5-17.5
Paulliac les Hauts de Pontet-Canet 08 WS=88 08 $27 WS
Ch Pontoise Cabarrus Haut-Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=90 15 $14-66WineS 12 Editor’s Choice WE 12 WE=90 12 $18 WE 10 Editor’s Choice WE 10 WE=90 10 $19 WE 10 WS=89 10 RP=89 Ch Porte Chic Pomerol 13/14/15 15 70%Merlot-25CF-5CS 15 RP=89-91
Les Portes de Bordeaux Fronsac 15/16 16 $6 TrJ 11 RC=85
Haut Medoc 12 12 RC=85 12 $7 TrJ
Ch Potensac Medoc Delon 14/15/16/17/18 18 JS=93-94 18 $27 wine.com 18 JD=91-93+ 17 Most Affordable Pick WineS 17 WineS=92 16 TWCI=91 16 JS=93-94 16 RP=90-92 16 Vinous=89-91 16 WE=90-92 16 WS=88-91 16 Decanter=90 15 TWCI=88 15 JCLee=88 15 JR=16.5 (90) 15 JS=90-91 15 WS=90 15 $29 WS 15 RP=89-91 14 JS=91-92 14 WE=90 14 $25 WE 14 Vinous=90 14 RP=90 14 WS=87 14 TWCI=89/89 13 Editor’s Choice WE 13 WE=91 13 TWCI=87 12 TWCI=88/88 12 WE=90 12 RP=90 12 JR=16.5 (90) 11 Cellar Selection WE 11/10 WE=91 11 $25 WE 11 52%Merlot-34%CS-14%CF 11 JR=90 11 Cited Wine Hachette 15 11 TWCI=86/88 10 Two Stars Hachette 14 10 WE=90-92 10 RP=88 10 TWCI=89/89 09 Merlot-CS-CF 09 ST=89 09 $25+ ST 09 One Star Hachette 13 09 WE=92 09 RP=89-91 173
09 Decanter=3star 09 Decanter=16/20 09 TWCI=91 08/07 One Star Hachette 12 08 RP=90-92 08 ST=87 08 WE=91 08 WS=87 08 SS=16+/20 08 $26 WS 08 Decanter=3star 08 TWCI=88
Ch Pouget Margaux 4th Cru Classe 14/15/16 16 TWCI=90 09 Cab Sauv 09 RP=85-87 09 WS=93-96 08 Silver Bordeaux, Challenge 10 08 WS=87 08 $24 WS 07 Silver Decanter; Bronze IWC 10 07 WS=86 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 WS=85-88
Ch Poujeaux Moulis-en-Medoc Cru Bourgeois 13/14/15/16 16 TWCI=92 16 $30 WHouse 16 Great Value Decanter 16 Decanter=93 16 $30 K&L 16 RP=91-93 16 $33 Zachys 16 JS=91-92 16 WS=88-91 16 Vinous=88-90 15 TWCI=90 15 $29 JJB 15 50%CS-42%Merlot-6%PV-2%CF 15 JCLee=91 15 $34 K&L 15 JS=92-93 15 $34 Zachys 15 RP=90-92 15 $36 Millesima 15 WS=89 15 $33 WS 15 Decanter=90 15 Vinouis=88-90 15 Decanter=90 14 60%CS-35%Merlot-5%PV 14 JS=91-92 14 $30 wine.com 14 WS=87-90 14 $40 TW&M 14 TWCI=91 14 $32 K&L 13 TWCI=88 14 $30 WHouse 13 JR=15 (84) 12 WE=93 12 $35 TW&M 12 JS=90 12 $35 Millesima 12/11 Very Successful Hachette 16/15 12 JR=14.5 (82) 12/11 TWCI=91 11 GDP=89 11 $35 GDP 11 WE=91 11 JS=90 10 55%CS-40%Merlot-5%PV 10 RP=90 10 $40 Millesima 10 Coup de Coeurs 2 stars Hachette 14 10 ST=88 10 $57 Millesima 10/09 TWCI=92 10 JJB=90 09 Vin Remarquable Hachette 13 09 WE=91 09 $45 JJB 09 ST=90 09 RP=90-93 09 JS=93 09 WS=94-94 09 RP=91-93 08 Vin Remarquable Hachette 11 08 RP=89-91 08 Coup de Coeur2 stars Hachette 12 08 WS=87 08 $27 WS 08 SS=16+/20 08 Decanter=3star 08 TWCI=91 07=65%CS-30%Merlot-5%PV 07 WS=88 07 $28 WS 07 Editor’s Choice WE 07 WE=90 07 ST=85 06 Not a great success WD 06 RP=89 06 Cellar Selection WE 06 WE=92 06 WS=89 06 WD=12-13/20 174
06Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 ST=87-89 06 TWCI=88 06 JR=15 (84)
Ch Pouroutou Bordeaux 14/15/16 14 Silver LA 16
Ch la Prade Bordeaux Cotes de Francs 14/15/16 16 TWCI=90 15 Top Value < $30 WS 15 WS=90 15 $18 WS 15 85%Merlot-15CF 15 RP=89-91 15 $15-58WineS 14 #20 Top Values < $30 WS 14 WS=90 14 $15 WS 10 WS=90 10 $17 WS 10 RP=86+ 10 TWCI=89-90 09 RP=87-88 08 WS=85 08 $20 WS 08 RP=88-89 08 JJB=85-87
Premius See: Yvon Mau
Ch de Pressac (B Magrez) St-Emilion GC 13/14/15/16 16 JS=95-96 16 $30 wine.com 16 Vinous=90-93 16 $32 Zachys 16 WS=89-91 16 Decanter=90 15 RP=85-87 15 $28-30WAlert 15 WS=90 15 $29 WS 15 JCLee=88 15 $28 JJB 15 JR=17 (92) 15 $30 Zachys 14 JR=16.5 (90) 14 JCLee=89 14 Gilbert&G=93 12 Vin Remarquable Hachette 16 12 RP=90 12 Silver Decanter 14 12 JS=90 11 Very Successful Hachette 15 11 Gold Paris 13 10 Comm’d Decanter 12 10 RP=89 10 Cited Wine Hachette 14 10 ST=87 09 Bronze Decanter 12 08 Gold Brussels 10 08 WS=90 08 Bronze Bordeaux 10 St-Emilion Ch Your de Pressac 13/14/15 15 WS=88
Ch Preuillac (Yvon Mau) Medoc Cru Bourgeois 13/14/15 16 TWCI=89 15 RP=88 10 Bronze IWC; Comm’d Decanter 12 10 RP=88 10 CS-Merlot 09 Silver IWSC; Bronze Decanter 12 08 Merlot 08 WS=89 08 SS=15.0/20 08 Decanter=3star 07 Bronze Paris 09; Decanter 10 07 Comm’d IWC 10 06 Silver Brussels 09 06 NM=91 06 Bronze Decanter, IWC 09 06 WE=90 06 $30 WE 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 WS=87 06 $34 WS Ch du Prieur Bordeaux 14/15 15 Silver LA 17
Ch Le Prieure St-Emilion 13/14/15 15 RP=90-92 15 $40 WAlert
Ch Prieure-Lichine Margaux 4th Cru Classe 12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 WE=94-9 18 $45 wine.com 18 Vinous=92-95 18 JS=93-94 16 TWCI=93 15 WS=90 15 $42 WS 15 TWCI=93/93 175
15 RP=88-90 14 TWCI=92/91 13 TWCI=88/89 12 TWCI=89/91 11 GDP=89 11 $55 GDP 11 TWCI=90/90 10 65%CS-30%Merlot-5%PV 10 ST=86 10 TWCI=91/92 09 WE=93 09 ST=88 09 RP=91-93 09 TWCI=92/93/91 08 WS=88-91 08 JJB=83-85 08 TWCI=91 07 Comm’d Decanter 10 07 RP=88 07 WE=90 07 $40 WE 07 WS=87-90 07 ST=88 07 TWCI=90 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 WE=88 06 RP=90 06 ST=88-90 06 WS=89 06 $41 WS 06 TWCI=90 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 WE=93 05 WS=92 05 $50 WS 05 ST=90 05 TWCI=93 See als: Confidence de Prieur-Lichine
Clos de Prince St-Emilion 13/14/15 15 RP=97-89 15 $24-34 WineS
Producta Vignobles Bordeaux Arnozan Res des Chartrons 13/14/15 12 Best Buy WE 12 WE=88 12 $10 WE
Bordeaux Ch de Laborde 13/14/15 13 W&S=NR 13 $15 W&S
Bordeaux La Cabane aux Oiseaux 13/14/15 13 W&S=NR 13 $17 W&S
Ch la Providence Pomerol 12/13/14/15 12 Cellar Selection WE 12 WE=93 10 ST=92 09 ST=89 09 $130+ ST 09 RP=92-95 08 WE=92 08 RP=95-97 08 JJB=93-95 08 JJB=89-91 07 RP=89+ 07 ST=87 07 AG=86 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 RP=93 06 WE=92 06 WS=89 06 $103 WS 05 Vin Exceptionnel Hachette 09 05 WE=90 05 Coup de Ceour Hachette 09 05 ST=89 05 WS=95 05 $93 WS 05 RP=90-92
Ch Puyanche Francs Cotes de Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 WS=88 15 $16 WS 14 Editor’s Choice WE 14 WE=90 14 $22 WE Clos Puy-Arnaud Cotes de Castillon 13/14/15/16 16 RP=87-89 16 $27 RP 16 TWCI=87 15 Top Value WS 15 WS=92 15 $35 WS 15 RP=86-88 15 $20-30 WineS 14 Cellar Selcetion WE 14 WE=91 13 WS=BT 176
10 RP=87 09 One of 10 Best Values Decanter 09 Decanter=4star 09 Decanter=16.5/20 09 RP=89-91+ 08 RP=88-91+ 08 Cited Wine Hachette 11 08 JBB=87-89 07 WS=90 07 $21 WS 07 RP=80 07 ST=86 06 Cited Wine Hachette 10 Cotes de Castillon Cuvee les Ormeaux 13/14/15 15 WS=90 14 Editor’s Choice WE 14 WE=91 14 $18 WE 14 WS=87 14 $15 WS
Cotes de Castillon Cuvee Pervenche 13/14/15 13 WS=86 13 $22 WS
Ch Puy-Blanquet St-Emilion GC 13/14/15/16/17/18 18 JD=92-94 18 $25 wine.com 18 JS=92-93 16 TWCI=87 16 CT=87 (1) 15 RP=87-89 15 $28WAlert 15 WS=89 15 $20 WS 15 TWCI=86 15 JCLee=91 15/14 JR=16.5 (90) 14 JS=90 14 $18 K&L 14 JR=16.5 (90) 14 $20 wine.com 14 JCLee=86 14/12 TWCI=85 10 ST=86 10 RP=88-90 10 TWCI=86 09 Bargain Snooth.com 09 ST=87 09 WE=90 09 JS=90 09 JR=15.5 (86) 08 JJB=87-89 06 WS=82 06 $18 WS Ch Puygueraud Bordeaux-Cotes-de-Francs 14/15/16 16 TWCI=90 15 Top Value WS 15 WS=90 15 $16 WS 15 WS=-91-93 15 $16 wine.com 15 JS=91-93 15 C$29 LCBO 15 RP=88-90 15 $15-25WAl 15 Decanter=90 15 TWCI=89 14 TWCI-89/88 12 TWCI=87/88 11 TWCI=87/87 10 80%Merlot-15%CF-5%Malbec 10 WS=89 10 $17 WS 10 RP=87 10 TWCI=89/89/88 10 JS=92 09 RP=90 09 WS=89 09 JS=92 09 TWCI=88-85
Cotes de Francs Cuvee George 10 WS=91 10 $20 WS 10 RP=89 10 JCLee=88 10 JR=15 (84) 10 TWCI=89 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 RP=83 06 WS=90 06 $22 WS 06 ST=87-90 06 AG=86 Ch Puy Servain Rouge VV Montravel 14/15 14 80%Merlot-20CF 14 Gilbert&G=87 14 $19 WHouse 177
13 RevueFR=13.5 11 Bronze Challenge 14 10 Gault&M=15 09 Very Successful Hachette 13 09 Gilbert&G=87 Ch Quinault L’Enclos St Emilion GC 13/14/15/16/17/18 18 Decanter=94 18 $35 wine.com 18 JS=93-94 18 RP=92-94 18 JD=92-94 16 TWCI=90 15 TWCI=93 15 69%Merlot-19%CS-12%CF 15 WS=89 15 $37 WS 15 JR=17 (92) 15 JDunnick=95 15 JS=93-94 15 RP=91-93 15 Vinous=89-92 15 WE=90-92 15 JCLee=91 14 TWCI=91 14 JCL=89 14 WS=89 14 $31 WS 14 JR=16.5 (90) 12/11 TWCI=90 12 JR=16 (88) 12 WS=88 11 $30 WS 11 TWCI=89 10 Very Successful Hachette 14 10 WS=90 10 $40 WS 10/09 TWCI=91 09 WE=91 09 RP=90-92 09 WS=92 09 $35 WS 08 Very Successful08 RP=90-92 08 WS=91 08 $38 WS 08 JJB=91-93 08 TWCI=87 07 Vin Remarquable Hachette 11 07 RP=91-93 07 WS=86 07 $40 WS 07 ST=89 See also their second wine: Lafleur de Quinault
Ch Quintus St-Emilion 13/14/15/16 16 TWCI=94 15 RP=92-94 15 WS=92 15 $135 WS St-Emilion GC Le Dragon de Quintus 13/14/15/16 16 TWCI=89 15 RP=90-92 15 WS=90 15 $36 WS Ch Rahoul Graves 14/15/16 16 TWCI=84 15 RP=89-91 15 WS=88 15 $25 WS 15 JCLee=90 15 JR=16 (88) 14 TWCI=86 14 JCLee=85 13 Coup de Coeur 2 stars Hachette 16 13 JR=15 (84) 12 TWCI=84 12 Bronze Dec 16; Comm’d Dec 15 11 Bronze Dec 15; Comm’d Dec 14 09 WE=91 09 ST=87 09 RP=82-85 08 RP=85-87
Ch Ramafort Medoc Cru Bourgeois 12/13/14/15 15 RP=89 14 RP=85 Ch Ramage la Batisse Bordeaux 13/14/15/16 16 TWCI=84 09 Comm’d IWC 12 09 CF-CS-Merlot 178
Ch Les Rambauds Bordeaux Cuvee Crème de Fut 14/15/16 15 Gold LA 17 15 LA=92
Bordeaux Cuvee Excellence 14/15/16 15 Silver LA 16
Ch du Raux Haut Medoc 13/14 15 15 RP=85 14 Best Buy WE 14 WE=85 14 $10 WE Cave de Rauzan Augey See: Aigey
Ch Rauzan-Despagne Bordeaux Grand Vin de Bordeaux 14/15 15 RP=86-88 15 $13 WineS 14 RP=82-84 13 RP=82-85 10 WS=85 10 $15 WS 09 RP=88-90 07 Very Successful Hachette 10 08 WS=86 07 Silver Bordeaux 09 Ch Rauzan Gassies Margaux 2nd Cru Classe 12/13/14/15/16 16 TWCI=88 15 RP=86=88 15 $60 WAlert 15 WS=86 15 $60 WS 13 Cellar Selection WE 13 WE=92 10 85%CS-13%Merlot-2%PV 10 ST=88 09 WE=91 09 ST=88 09 RP=89-91 08 JJB=85-87 08 RP=88-90 07 WE=86 07 RP=81-84 06 Cited Wine Hachette 10 06 WE=87 06 RP=89 06 WS=87 06 $34 WS 05 Rec’d to Highly Rec’d W&S 4/06 05 W&S=1½stars 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 WE=92 05 WS=85-88 05 ST=85-87 05 RP=89-92 04 ST=84-87 04 RP=87 03 Very Successful Hachette 07 03 WS=88 03 RP=89 02 WS=89 02 RP=87 01 WS=87 01 RP=88 Ch Rauzan-Segla Margaux 2nd Cru Classe 12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 JS=99-100 18 $100wine.com 18 WS=96-99 18 RP=97-99+ 16 TWCI=97 15/14/13/12 Cellar Selection WE 15 WE=96 15 $80 WE 15 WS=95 15 $94 WS 15 RP=96-98 14 WE=95 14 $55 WE 14 Decanter=93 13 WE=93 13 $54 WE 12 WE=94 10 60%CS-35%M-3.5%PV-1.5%CF 10 ST=91 10 JJB=93 09 58%CS-Merlot) 09 WE=95 09 ST=90 09 RP=92-95 09 WS=93-96 09 One of Top 32 JJB 09 JJB=94-96 08 WS=86 08 ST=88 08 RP=91-93 08 JJB=87-89 179
07 Cellar Selection WE 07 WE=92 07 $70 WE 07 Comm’d Decanter 10 07 RP=89+ 07 ST=91 07 WS=88-91 06 Comm’d Decanter 10 06 RP=93 06 Editor’s Choice WE 06 WE=93/93 06Comm’d Decanter 12 06 WD=16-17+/20 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 ST=90-92 06 WS=92 05 Rec’d to Highly Rec’d W&S 4/06 05 W&S=96 05 $150 W&S 05 WS=97 05 Certainly has potential WD 4/06 05 WE=94/96 05 Vin Remarquable Hachette 09 05 ST=92 05 RP=94 05 WD=16-17/20
Margaux Segla 13/14/15 15 WS=89 15 $55 WS
Raymond, Vignobles Bordeaux Les Hauts de Lagarde 13/14/15/16 16 W&S=N$16 $13 W&S 15/14 W&S=85 15/14 $13 W&S 14 W&S=85/NR 14 $10 W&S 13 WS=81 13 $13 WS 10 WS=81 10 $13 WS
Le Petit de Ch de Lagarde 14/15/16 16 W&S=NR 16 $14 W&S
Ch Reaut Bordeaux 14/15/16 16 RP=909-92 16 $13 wine.com 16 JS=89-91 16 Decanter=90 15 RP=89-91 15 $10-24 WineS 14 Very Successful Hachette 17+ 10 RP=85 Ch Recougne Bordeaux 14/15/ 16 16 W&S=86 16 $11 W&S 14 W&S=NR 14 $10 W&S Vielles Vignes 13/14/15 14 RP=89-91
Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15 15 W&S=87 15 $19 W&S 15 WS=86 Coup de Coeur 2 stars Hachette 17 13 WS=82 13 $15 WS 12 Editor’s Choice WE 12 WE=90 12 $18 WE 10 WE=82 10 $19 WE 06 WS=83 06 $14 WS 03 WR=89 Regaud Bordeaux 14/15 15 W&S=NR 15 $10 W&S
Ch de Reignac Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15/16 16 TWCI=89 15 RP=86-88 14 Gold Best of Class LA 17 14 Silver LA 16 13 WS=82 13 $35 WS 10 Merlot 10 ST=87 09 Gold Paris 11 09 RP=87-89+ 09 WS=88-91 08 Gold Bordeaux 10 08 WS=87 08 $21 WS 08 Vin Remarquable Hachette 11 08 RP=90-93 09 Coeur Selection Hachette 11
07 Gold Paris 09 07 ST=88 06 RP=91 06 WS=85 05 Gold Challenge 07 06 ST=86-88 Bordeaux Sup Grand Vin de Reignac 14/15/16 16 WDecider=88
Bordeaux Balthus 13/14/15/16 16 WDecider=92
180
15 RP=? 10 TWCI=88-90 06 RP=91 06 WS=88 05 Vin Remarquable Hachette 07 05 WS=85-88 04 $80 WS 03 Bronze Decanter 06 04 WS=88 03 WS=88 Bordeaux Sup Balthus 13/14/15/16 16 WDecider=90 13 WS=83 13 $60 WS 08 WS=88 05 ST=89-91 04 WS=88 04 $80 WS 04 ST=87-89
Ch Relais de Poste Bordeaux Cuvee Malbec 13/14/15 15 RP=? 15 $17 RP 14 RP=87 Les Collines des Barrails 13/14/15 15 RP=88 15 422 RP
Clos Rene Pomerol 13/14/15/16 16 WDecider=90 16 TWCI=90 15 70%Merlot-20CF-10Malbec 15 RP=91-93 15 WDecider=92 15 $33 WHouse 15 TWCI=88 15 $30 JJB 15 JR=17 (92) 14 WDecider=89 14/13 TWCI=87 13 WDecider=86 13 JCLee=78 12 Cited Wine Hachette 16 12 WDecider=89 12 TWCI=88 11 Very Successful Hachette 15 11 WDecider=87 11 TWCI=87 11 JR=16.5 (90) 11 JCLee=85 10 Vin Remarquable Hachette 14 10 WDecider=91 10 TWCI=89 10 Gilbert&G=95 10/09 ST=87 09 Cited Wine Hachette 13 09 RP=88-90 09 $45 WHouse 09 TWCI=88 09/08 WDecider=90 08 ST=86 08 RP=88-90 07 Very Successful Hachette 11 07 RP=85-87 07 $55 WineCh 07 WDecider=88 06 WDecider=90
Res de la Comtesse Paulliac 13/14/15 15 WS=89 15 $43 WS
La Res de Leoville-Barton See Ch Leoville-Barto
La Reserve de Malartic Pessac-Leognan 14/15/16 16/15 TWCI=94 14 WE=95 14 $20 K&L 14 JS=94 14 Vinous=94 14 RP=92 14 WS=91 14 TWCI=93/93 13 Cited Wine Hachette 16 13 RevueFR 13.5 13 TWCI=91/91 12 TWCI=93/91 11 TWCI=89/90 10 TWCI=94/93/93 10 G&G=88 09 TWCI=93/93/93 181
09 G&G=87 Ch Respide-Medeville Graves 14/15/16 15 WS=88 14 RP=87 08 WS=87 08 $30 WS 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 WE=86 06 $35 WE Ch du Retout Haut-Medoc Cru Bourgeois 13/14/15/16 16 RP=?? 16 WS=91 16 JS=90 15 RP=87 15 $9-17 WineS 14 #26 Top Values < $30 WS 14 WS=89 14 $18 WS 14 Editor’s Choice WE 14 WE=90 14 $20 WE 14 RP=91 14 $16 K&L 14 Decanter=92 14 JS=90 13 WS=87 13 $20 WS 13 RP=86-88 12 JR=16 (88) 11 JR=16 (88) 10 Top Buy WBB 10 WS=91 10 $18 WS 10 RP=88 10 JS=90-91 10 CellarT=89 (11) 10 JR=16.5 (90) 10 Wine-S 87 09 JR=16 (88) 09 JR=15 (84)
Ch Reverdi Listrac-Medoc 13/14/15 14 RP=88-90 13 WS=85 13 $25 WS 10 WS=88 10 $25 WS 09 Bronze Decanter 12 Ch Reynon Bordeaux Rouge 15/16 16 JS=89-91 16 $14 wine.com 16 RP=89-91 16 WE=88-90 15 RP=89-91 09 Silver LA 11 Cadillac Prem Cotes de Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 RP=89-91 15 WS=89 13 WS=85 13 $18 WS 10 WS=90 10 $20 WS 10 RP=86 10 ST=87 09 80%Merlot-10%CS-10%PV 09 ST=87-90 09 Silver Decanter 12; Comm’d 11 09 WS=90 09 WA=88-89 09 JR=16 (88) 08 Vin Remarquable Hachette 11 08 WS=89 08 $16 WS 08 ST=85 08 JJB=87-89
Ch Reysson Haut Medoc Cru Bourgeois Sup Res de Ch 16 TWCI=89 15 RP=85 15 $15 WineS 13 WS=81 13 $24 WS 12 Editor’s Choice WE 12 WE=90 12 $24 WE 10 RP=86 09 Bronze Decanter, IWC 12 09 CS-Merlot 08 WS=86 08 $30 WS
La Ribaud Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=84
Ch de Riberon Bordeaux Sup 14/15/16 15 WE=91 15 $8 Costco 15 RC=87 15 CT=89 (11) 14 Gold Paris 16 14 BTI=84 14 $20 BTI 14 Gilbert&G=83 182
14 CT=85 (40 Ch de Ricaud Cadillac Cotes de Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 WS=87 15 $16 WS 15 RP=89-91 13 WS=84 13 $19 WS Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux Quartet 13/14/15 15 Cellar Selection WE 15 WE=91 15 $20 WE
Ch Ripeau St-Emilion GC 13/14/15/16 16 TWCI=91 15 RP=89-91 15 $29-78WineS 10 RP=86 08 WS=87 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 05 ST=88 Ch de la Riviere Fronsac 13/14/15 15 RP=90-93 15 $20WAlert 13 WS=87 13 $40 WS 10 WS=91 10 $23 WS 10 RP=85 09 Bargain Snooth.com 09 Gold Paris 11 09 RP=85-87 08 Bronze Bordeaux 10uui 08 WS=90 08 $24 WS 07 WS=88 07 $24 WS 07 JR=15.5 (86) Ch du Roc Cotes de Castillon Libelula 13/14/15 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=90 14 $50 WE 09 WS=91-94 Les Rocs du Barry Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15/16 16 Silver LA 17
Ch Roc de Boisseaux St-Emilion 13/14/15 15 RP-88-90
Ch Roc de Cambes Cotes de Bourg 13/14/15 15 RP=90-92 15 $50-70WAlert 10 75%Merlot-20%CS-5%Malbec 10 ST=90 10 TWCI=88-90 09 70%Merlot-25%CS-Malbec 09 ST=90 07 ST=85 06 ST=88-90 05 ST=90 04 ST=88 03 RP=86-88 Ch Roc de Levraut Bordeaux Sup 14/15 14 Best Buy WE 14 WE=89 14 $12 WE 14 Vin Remarquable Hachette 16 12 Snooth=86 10 Best Buy WE 10 WE=88 10 $13 WE Ch Roc de Mininielle Bordeaux 14/15/16 16 Silver LA 17 10 GdP=85 10 $12 GdP Bordeauz Cuvee Tourelles 14/15/16 15 Gold LA 17
Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15 15 Silver LA 17
Ch Roc de Segur Bordeaux 13/14/15 15/14/13 Best Buy WE 15/14/13 WE=86 15 $11 WE 14 $10 WE 10 WS=85 10 $12 WS 10 WE=85 Ch la Roche Bazin Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux 14/15 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=89 15 $10 WE 14 Best Buy WE 14 WE=90 14 $10 WE 12 Best Buy WE 12 WE=88 12 $10 WE Roche Darjac Bordeaux 14/15 15 RP=85 15 $9-15 WAlert 12 Best Buy WE 12 WE=87 12 $12 WE Ch Rochebelle St-Emilion 14/15/16 16 TWCI=86
Ch de Rochemorin Pessac-Leognan 13/14/15 15 RP=87-89 15 WS=89 14 RP=84 13 WS=81 13 $28 WS 07 Comm’d Decanter 10 07 WS=86 06 WS=82 06 $33 WS Ch Rocheyron St-Emilion 13/14/15/16 16 TWCI=94 15 70%Merlot-30CF 15 RP=93-95 15 $124 WAlert 15 WS=93 15 $119 WS Ch Roc Meynard Bordeaux Sec 14/15 14 W&S=87 14 $16 W&S 183
Ch Rol de Valentin St-Emilion GC 13/14/15/16 16 TWCI=92 15 RP=90-92 15 $36-37WAlert 15 WS=92 15 $36 WS 13 WS=87 13 $30 WS 10 ST=88 09 Outperformed Price JJB 09 JJB=95-97 09 WE=91 09 ST=89 09 $39+ ST 09 RP=87-90 09 Decanter=4star 09 Decanter=16.5 08 RP=87-89+ 07 RP=89 07 ST 90
Ch Rolland de By Medoc Cru Bourgeois 13/14/15/16 16 TWCI=88 15 RP=99 15 $17-27WineS 13 WS=85 13 $35 WS 11 WS=90 11 RP=90 10 RP=90 09 Gold Paris 11 09 RP=90-92 08 WS=90 08 $30 WS 08 RP=87-88 07 RP=87-88 06 Gold Paris 09; Bronze Decanter 10 06 RP=89 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 Ch Rolland-Maillet St-Emilion GC 13/14/15 15 RP=89-91 15 $25 WineS 15 WS=90 13 WS=87 13 $40 WS 10 RP=87 09 WE=89 09 WS=89-92 09 ST=87 09 RP=87-88 08 WS=91 08 $30 WS 08 RP=86-88 06 WS=90 06 ST=87-90 Clos Romanile St -Emilion GC 14/15/16 16 TWCI=90 15 RP=84-86 15 $24 WineS 15 WS=90 14 WS=88 Ch la Roncheraie Cotes de Castillon 12/13/14 14 RP=89-91 10 RP=89-91+ Ch Roquefort Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 W&S=NR 15/13 $15 W&S 14 Silver LA 16 13 W&S=88 10 JR=14.5 (82) 09 90%Merlot-10%CF 07 Very Successful Hachette 10
Ch Roques Mauriac Bordeaux Damnation 13/14/15 15 RP=89 15 $25 WineS
Bordeaux Grand Vin 13/14/15 15 RP=88 15 422 RP
Ch Roquetaillade la Grange Graves 13/14/15 Cab Sauv-Merlot 15 WS=87 15 $28 WS 15 RP=89-91 14 RP=85 13 WS=87 13 $30 WS 09 Silver Decanter 12; Bronze IWC 10 07 Bronze IWC 10 06 NM=89 06 WS=83 05 NM=90 184
05 WS=90 05 WE=89 Ch Roquevieille Cotes de Castillon 14/15 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=90 15 $9 WE 15 WS=88 15/14 $15 WS 14 #21 Top Value < $30 WS 14 WS=90 08 Bronze Bordeaux `0 08 WS=87
Ch la Rose Figeac Pomerol 13/14/15 15 RP=87-89 15 $25-37 RP
Ch la Rose de Vitrac Bordeaux 13/14/15 14 Best Buy WE 14 WE=85 14 $10 WE
Dom Barons de Rothschild Bordeaux Reserve Speciale 13/14/15 15 WS=86 15 $18 WS 14 W&S=86 14 $18 W&S 13 WS=84 13 $18 WS 10 WE=85 10 $15 WE 06 IWR=87 06 WE=85 Bordeaux Legende 13/14/15 15 W&S=85 15 $17 W&S
Medoc Legende 13/14/15 13 WS=87 13 $25 WS
St-Emilion Legende 12/13/14/15 13 WS=82 13 $35 WSyt
Baron Philippe Rothschild Mouton Cadet 14/15/16 Merlot-CS-CF 15 Decanter=86 14 Bronze Decanter 16 14 WE=85 14 $6 wine.com 14 Falstaff=89 14 $8 TW&M 13 Comm’d IWC 16 13 WS=81 13 $11 WS 13 Falstaff=88 12 Silver LA 15 12 WE=85
07 W&S=84 07 $18 W&S
Mouton Cadet Cup Sel 14/15 14 WW=89 14 $10 wine.com 12 Falstaff=90 Ch le Roudier Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15 15 RP=88-90 14 Best Buy WE 14 WE=90 14 $15 WE Ch Rouget Pomerol 15/16 16 TWCI=92 09 RP=91-93 08 RP=90-93 07 ST=88 07 RP=88 07 WS=85-88
Ch Rougi Bordeaux 14/15 14 Best Buy WE 14 WE=88 14 $10 WE
Ch Rougier Bordeaux 14/15 15 Silver LA 17 15 WS=86 15 $12 WS 14 Gold LA 17 14 LA=92 Ch de Rouillac Pessac-Leognan 13/14/15 15 RP=87-89 15 $27 WineS 10 RP=87 10 $24 RP 06 Cab Sauv 06 Cited Wine Hachette 10 06 WS=80-84 Ch de Rouquette Bordeaux 15/16 16 Best Buy WE 16 WE=88 16 $13 WE 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=88 15 $13 WE Ch la Rouselle Fronsac 13/14/15 15 RP=? 15 $14-25WineS 09 WS=91-94 08 WS=87 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 05 Vin Remarquable Hachette 09 05 WS=88 05 $18 WS Ch Rousset-Caillau Bordeaux 14/15/16 16 Gold LA 17 16 LA=92
Bordeaux Sup 14/15/16 16 Silver LA 17 15 W&S=NR 15 $16 W&S 12 Best Buy WE 12 WE=90 12 $15 WE
185
Ch Roustaing Bordeaux Vieilles Vignes 14/15/16 16 Best Buy WE 16 WE=88 16 $12 WE 14 Best Buy WE 14 WE=86 14 $11 WE 10 Silver Challenge Int’l du Vin 11 10 WE=89 10 $15 WE 10 Bronze Bruxelles 11 10 JR=14.5 (82) 10 WS=86 08 Gold Bordeaux 09
Ch Roux de Beauces Grand Vin de Bordeaux 14/15/16 16 Gold BofClass LA 17 16 LA=92 10/09 Bronze LA 11/10 Bordeaux Sup 14/15/16 16 Gold LA 17 16 LA=90
Ch Clos du Roy Bordeaux 14/15 15 JS=93 15 $14 wine.com 15 RP=92 Froncas 13/14/15 15 RP=90-92 13 Very Successful Hachetter 17 See also: Ch Petit Clos du Roy
Ch Roylland St-Emilion 13/14/15 15 RP=? 15 $17-31WineS 07 Editor’s Choice WE 07 WE=90 07 $33 WE
Domaine de Sabines Lalande de Pomerol 13/14/15/16 16 RP=90-92 15 90%Merlot-10CF 15 RP=89-90 15 $21 WAlert 15 WS=89 14 RP=91-93 10 RP=87 08 WS=87 Ch Saincrit Bordeaux Sup Ytopia 13/14/15 15 65%Merlot-20CS-10CF5Malbec 15 RP=85-87 15 $17-25WAlert
Ch Saint Ahon Haut-Medoc 13/14/15 14 RP=85 10 WE=90 10 $23 WE Clos Saint Andre Pomerol 13/14/15 15 RP=85-87
Ch Saint-Andre Corbin Saint-Georges-Saint-Emilion 13/14/15 14 Editor’s Choice WE 14 WE=90 14 $25 WE
Ch Saint-Aubin Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 RP=87 10 RP=86 10 $18 RP Ch Saintayme St-Emilion 13/14/15/16 16 TWCI=89 15 #1 Top Value < $30 WS 15 WS=92 15 $20 WS 15 RP=90-92 15 TWCI=90 15 JCLee=90 15 JR=16 (88) 14 TWCI=88 14 JR=16.5 (90) 14 #7 Top Values < $30 WS 14/13 JCLee=84 13 $18 WineCh 14 WS=91 14 $18 WS 13/12 TWCI=88 13 $19 Sh-L 11 TWCI=86 10/09 100%Merlot 10 ST=86 09 ST=87-89 09 WS=90 08 WS=88
Ch Saint Barbe Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 Silver LA 17 07 Gold LA 10 08 <$15 Bordeaux Merlot de Sainre-Barbe 13/14/15 12 Best Buy WE 12 WE=87 12 $10 WE
Bordeaux Sup 13/14 14 Silver LA 17
Ch Saint-Corbian St-Estephe Cuveeb Prestige 13/14/15 12 Cellar Selection WE 12 WE=92 12 $34 WE
Ch Saint-Didier-Parnac Ch de Grezels Prestige Malbec-Merlot 15 15 Editor’s Choice WE 15 WE=91 15 $21 WE
Ch Clos St Emilion Philippe Medoc 13/14/15 100%Merlot 15 RP=88=90
186
St-Emilion Cuvee Prephylloxerique 13/14/15 100%Merlot 15 RP=90-92
Ch Saint-Florioan Bordeaux 14/15/16 16 WE=85 16 $12 WE .com
Ch Saint Georges Cote Pavie 15/16/17/18 18 JS=94-95 18 $37 wine.com 18 RP=93-95+ Cotes de Castillon 14/15/16 14 RP=83-85
Dom de Saint-Guirons Paulliac 13/14/15 14 Edotor’s Choice WE 14 WE=91 14 $44 WE
Ch Saint-Hilaire Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=83
Ch Saint-Louis Montagne-Saint-Emilion 14/15/16 16 Vivino=3.3 (2) 15 Merlot+? 15 RC=87 15 $10 TrJ 15 CT=87.3 (3) 15 Vivino=3.6 (174) 14 WE=84 14 $17 WE 14 CT=88 (3) 14 Vivino=3.3 (154) 13 Vivino=3.7 (5) 10 CT=85 (15) Ch de Saint Pey St-Emilion 13/14 15 15 RP=89-91
Ch Saint-Pierre Pomerol 13/14/15 15 RP=88-90 15 $55 WAlert
Ch Saint-Pierre St-Julien 4th Cru Clase 12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 JD=94-97 18 $60 wine.com 18 RP=94-96 18 WS=92-95 17 Most Affordable pick WineS 17 WineS=91 15 RP=91-93 15 $48-89WAlert 11 GDP=92 11 $60 GDP 10 ST=88/94+ 10 $105 ST 10 JJB=87 09 81%CS-Merlot 09 WE=96 09 ST=91 09 RP=94-98 09 ST=91-94 08 WE=93 08 ST=90 08 RP=92-94 08 JJB=90-92 07 WE=90 07 $55 WE 07 RP=90-92 07 ST=89 07 WS=87-90 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 WS=90 06 ST=88-90 06 RP=93 05 WS=93 05 Vin Exceptionnel Hachette 09 05 ST=92 05 Coup de Coeur Hachette 09 05 RP=92-94 Clos Saint Vincent St Emilion 14/15 14 RP=81-83
Ch Sainte-Barbe Bordeaux Superieur 13/14/15 14 Silver LA 16 12 Best Buy WE 12 WE=89 12 $23 WE 10 Gold LA 12 10 LA=93 10 RP=85 10 WE=84 10 $18 WE 09 RP=87-89 08 Silver Brussels 10 07 Gold Brussels 09 07 Silver LA 10 07 Cited Wine Hachette 10 Bordeaux Merlot 14/15 12 Best Buy WE 12 WE=87 12 $10 WE 10 Gold LA 12 10 LA=92 187
08 Silver Bordeaux, Brussels 10 08 Cited Wine Hachette 11 06 WE=84 06 $12 WE
Ch Sainte Marie Cotes de Bordeaux Alios 13/14/15 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=85
Ch de Sales Pomerol 14/15/16/17/18 18 RP=91-93 18 $35 wine.com 18 JS=91-92 18 Vibous=92 16 RP=88-90 15 RP=84-86 15 $25-40WAlert 09 ST=87-90 08 ST=86 06 WS=87 06 $25 WS
Ch Sanctus St-Emilion 14/15/16 16 TWCI=91 15 RP=87-89 15 $24-38 WineS 15 WS=92 09 WE=93 09 RP=91-93 08 RP=91-94 07 RP=89+ 07 ST=87 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 RP=88 06 ST=87-89 St-Emilion La Bienfaisance 13/14/15 15 Top Value < $30 WS 15 WS=90 15 $24 WS
Ch Sansonnet St-Emilion GC 13/14/15/16/17/18 18 JD=94-96+ 18 $36 wine.com 18 JS=95-96 18 WS=93-96 16 TWCI=94 15 RP=90-92 15 WS=92 15 $35 WS 14 #14 Top Values < $30 WS 14 WS=91 14 $27 WS 10 ST=90 09 RP=90-92 09 WA=88-91 08 WS=87 07 RP=85-87 07 WS=82-85 07 ST=85 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 RP=84 06 WS=87 06 ST=86-89 05 Vin Remarquable Hachette 09 05 WS=92 05 Coup de Coeur Hachette Saransot-Dupre Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 RP=86 10 RP=91 10 $22 RP Ch Sarcley Bordeaux 13/14/15/16 16 Silver LA 17
Sarget de Gruard-Larose St-Julien 13/14/15 (Ch Gruard Larose) 15 RP=84-86 14 WS=88 14 $20 WS 10 70%CS-23%Merlot-4%PV 10 ST=86 10 WS=90 09 WS=89 09 $25 WS 08 WS=89 08 $19 WS 08 CellarT 85.3 (11)
Clos de Sarpe St-Emilion 13/14/15 15 85%Merlot-5CF 15 RP=84-86
Ch le Sartre Pessac-Leognan le S de Sartre 13/14/15 15 RP=89-91 15 $14-25WineS 09 Silver Decanter 12 07 Bronze Decanter 10 06 Silver Brussels 09 Ch Sauman Cotes de Bourg 14/15 14 Best Buy WE 14 WE=87 14 $12 WE
See also Langloise-Ch Sauman 188
Schroder & Schyler Chartron la Fleur Merlot Cab 13/14/15 12 Best Buy WE 12 WE=87 12/10 $12 WE 10 Best Buy WE 10 WE=88 La Croix Barton Merlot-CS 13/14/15 12 Best Buy WE 12 WE=85 12 $10 WE
Segla Margaux 13/14/15/16 16 TWCI=89 15 RP=90-92 15 $55 WineS
Ch Segonzac Prem-Cotes-de-Blaye VV 14/15 14 WE=87 14 $14 WE 14 $10 K&L 12 Gilbert&G=87 11 Silver Paris 15 11 WE=84 11 ST=89 10 Comm’d Decanter, IWC 12 10 JR=14.5 10 CS-Malbec-Merlot 09 60%Merlot-20%CS-10%CF 08 Silver Brussels 10 07 Silver Paris 09 Ch Seguin Pessac-Leognan 14/15/16 16 TWCI=91 15 RP=89-91 10 RP=90 10 $28 JJB 09 Bronze Decanter 12 09 RP=91-93 08 RP=90-91 07 RP=85-87 06 RP=89 Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux 14/15/16 14 Very Successful Hachette 17
Ch de Seguin Bordeaux Sup Cuvee Prestige 13/14/15 15 Silver LA 17 15 WS=87 15 $11 WS 14 Gilbert&G=82 14 $11TrJ 14 CT=90.2 (2) 13 Silver Paris 15 13 JR=16 (88) 13 Gilbert&G=82 12 Silver Vinalies Int’l 14 12 Gilbert&G=82 10 Gold Bordeaux, Paris 12. 10 WS=89 10 $15 WS 10 Gold Paris; Silver Challenge 12 10 Gilbert&G=86 10 Bronze Decanter 12 09 Gold Paris, LA 11 09 LA=93 09 WS Blog 85/86 09 $15 MSRP 09 Bronze LA 11 09 CellarT 85 (15) 09 JR=16 (88) 09 G&M 14 (80) Bordeaux Sup Cuvee Carpe Diem 14/15 15 Silver LA 17
Domaine D’en Segur Cotes de Tarn Cuvee Germain 13/14/15 15/13 Editor’s Choice WE 15 WE=90 15 $16 WE 13 Editor’s Choice WE 13 WE=92 13 $20 WE
Ch Senejac Haut Medoc Cru Bourgeois Sup 13/14/15/16/17/18 18 RP=90-92 18 $16 wine.com 16 TWCI=91 16 RP=91-93 16 JS=91-93 16 Decanter=91 16 WDecider=91 15 TWCI=89-91 15 JS=91-93 15 RP=89-91 15 JCLee=90 15 JR=16.5 (90) 15 WDecider=91 14 WE=91 14 RP=90 14 JS=90 14 TWCI=90 14 JR=16 (88) 14 JCLee=90 14 WDecider=88 13 WDecider=87 189
12 Silver Decanter 16 12 TWCI=90/88 12 WE=91 12 JS=90 12 Vivino=3.6 (479) 12 WDecider=88 11/10 Bronze Decanter 15/14 11 WDecider=87 10 WS=88 10 $19 WS 10 RP=89 10 TWCI=89 10 WDecider=89 09 RP=89-91 09 WDecider=90 08 65%CS-27%M-7%CF-1%PV 08 ST=87 08 Silver IWC 11 08 RP=88-90 08 WS=88 08 $21 WS 08 SS=16.0/20 08 Decanter=3star
Ch Sergeant Lalande-de-Pomerol 13/14/15 15 WS=87 15 $28 WS 10 WS=87 10 $20 WS 07 Silver Paris 09 06 WS=84 06 $28 WS
Ch la Sergue Lalande-de-Pomerol 13/14/15/16 16/15 WDecider=90 15 RP=87-89 15 $24-35WineS 15 WS=89 15 Decanter=93 15 JR=15.5 (86) 14 WDecider=91 13/12/11 WDecider=88 12 JCLee=82 11 Coup de Coeur 2 stars Gachette 15 11 Gold Bordeaux; Silver Bruxelles 14 10 Very Successful Hachette 14 10 ST=86 10 Gold Bordeaux 12 10/09 WDecider=90 09 RP=87-89 09 Gilbert&G=87 09 JR=15.5 (86) 08 WS=89 08 RP=86-88 08 WDecider=89 08 Gilbert&G=88 07 Value QRW Autumn 08 07 RP=87-88 07 Silver Brussels 09 07 ST=86 07/06 WDecider=88 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 RP=88 06 ST=86-88 06 WS=86 Ch Serilhan St-Estephe 13/14/15 15 RP=90-92 15 $17-40WineS 12 Cellar Selection WE 12 WE=92 10 Editor’s Choice WE 10 WE=92 10 $23 WE 10 WS=89 10 $25 WS 10 RP=87 10 WE=92 10 ST=86 09 RP=87-88 08 55%CS-43%M-CF 08 WBlB=87 08 WS=89 08 ST=87 08 RP=85-87 07 Bronze Decanter 09
Ch Siaurac Lalande-de-Pomerol 14/15/16 16 TWCI=91 15 Top Value < $30 WS 15 WS=90 15 $22 WS 15 RP=90-92 15 $22 WAlert 10 WS=90 10 $25 WS 190
10 RP=86 09 Comm’d Decanter 12 09 RP=89-91 09 WS=88-91 08 Gold Paris 11 08 WS=89 08 RP=87-88 See also: Plaisir de Siurac
Ch Siran Margaux Cru Bourgeois Except 13/14/15/16/17/18 18 WS=92-95 18 $30 wine.com 18 JS=94-95 18 WE=93-95 16 TWCI=92 16 WE=94-96 16 JS=95 16 RP=92-94 16 Decanter 93 16 WS=90-92 15 TWCI=93/92 15 #9 Top Value < $30 WS 15 WS=92 15 $30 WS 15 JR=17 (92) 15 JS=94-95 15 RP=92-94 15 WE=92-94 15 Decanter=90 15 Vinous=88-91 14 JS=92 14 WE=92 14 $30 WE 14 RP=90-92 14 TWCI=91/90 14 JR=16.5 (90) 13 WE=86 13 $30 WE 13 JR=15.5 (86) 13 TWCI=84 12 WE=89 12 JR=16 (88) 12 TWCI=87/85 12 Gilbert&G=90 11 TWCI=85 10 WE=92 10 46%CS-42%Merlot-12%PV 10 ST=88 10 Very successful Hachette 14 10 RP=86 10 JJB=91 10 TWCI=87 09/08/07 Very successful Hachette 13 09 WE=90 09 ST=88 09 $30+ ST 09 RP=87-88+ 09 TWCI=89 08 WS=88 08 $28 WS 08 Decanter=4star 08 SS=16.5/20 07 WS=87 07 $24 WS 07 WE=85 07 RP=79-82 06 RP=86 06 WE=89 06 ST=85-88 06 WS=87 06 $28 WS 01 WS=87 Margaux S de Siran 13/14/14 15 RP=87-89 15 $22-25 WineS 08 WS=86 08 $20 WS La Sirene de Gisgours Bordeaux Petite Sirene 13/14/15 15 WS=85 15 $20 WS 15 65%CS-30Merlot-5CF 15 RP=89-91 15 $21-50WineS 11 TWCI=85 10 TWCI=86
Ch Smith Haut Lafitte Pessac-Leognan 12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 JD=97-100 18 $110wine.com 18 JS=98-99 191
18 RP=98-99 18 WS=95-98 18 Decanter=98 16/15 TWCI=97 15 WS=96 15 $89 WS 15 JCLee=95 15 JR=18 (96) 14 TWCI=97 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=96 14 $75 WE 14 WS=94 14 $67 WS 14 TWCI=95 13 Vin Remarquable Hachette 16 13 TWCI=90 12 Cellar Selection WE 12 WE=94 12 Very Successful Hachette 16 12 TWCI=94 12 JR=17 (92) 11 Vin Remarquable Hachette 15 11 GDP=93 11 Very Successful Hachette 14 11 TWCI=93 10 64%CS-30%Merlot-5%CF-1%PV 10 ST=88 10 Vin Remarquable Hachette 14 10 JJB=96 10 JCLee=93 10/09 TWCI=97 09 WE=94 09 ST=92 09 RP=96-98+ 08 ST=87 08 RP=93-95 08 WE=93 08 WS=88/91 08 JJB=91-93 08 TWCI=92 07 RP=91 07 WE=90 07 $60 WE 07 WS=88-91 07 ST=91 07 TWCI=90 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 WE=90 06 WD=13-15/20 06 RP=93 06 ST=92 06 WS=92 06 $60 WS 06 NM=94 06 TWCI=93 Pesac-Leognan Le Petit 14/15/16 16 TWCI=91 15 TWCI=90 12 TWCI=88 Pessac-Leognan Le Petit Haut Lafitte 13/14/15 15 RP=90-92 15 $27-40WineS 15 WS=90 15 $32 WS See also: Les Hauts de Smith
Ch Sociando-Mallet Haut-Medoc 12/13/14/15/16 16 TWCI=93 15 RP=85-87 15 $33-40WAlert 10 59%CS-45%Merlot-5%PV 10 ST=85 10 $39+ ST 09 CS-M-CF 09 ST=89 09 RP=90-92+ 08 ST=91 08 RP=87-89+ 07 WS=85-88 07 ST=88 06 #74 Top 100 Cellar Selections WE 06 WE=93 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 AG=86 06 WD=15.5-16.5 06 RP=90 06 NM=90 06 ST=88-89 06 WS=85-88
192
Ch Soleil Lussac-St-Emilion 13/14/15 15 RP=88-90
Dom de la Solitude Pessac-Leognan 14/15/16 16 TWCI=90/89 15 Top Value < $30 WS 15 WS=91 15 $27 WS 14 $31 Millesima Ch Soudars Haut Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=81-83 08 WE=91 08 $24 WE 07 WS=81-84 06 Silver Brussels 10 06 WS=87 06 Cited Wine Hachette 10
Ch de Sours La Fleur d’Amelie 14/15 14/13 W&S=NR 14/13 $15 W&S 10 WE=84 10 $15 WE
Bordeaux13/14/15 14/13 W&S=NR 14/13 $18 W&S 10 WE=88 10 $21 WE La Source 12/13/14/15 12 JR=16 (88) 11/10 JR=15.5 (86) 09/08 JR=15.5 (86) Ch Soutard St-Emilion 13/14/15/16 16 TWCI=90 15 RP=89-91 15 $40-54WAlert 09 RP=88-90 08 WS=88 08 RP=91-93+ 07 RP=86-88 07 ST=85 06 RP=84 06 WS=80-84 Ch Soutard-Cadet St-Emilion 13/14/15 15 90%Merlot-10CF 15 RP=92-94 15 $35 WAlert
Ch St-Georges St-Emilion 13/14/15 15 RP=88-90 08 WS=88 Clos St Julien St-Emilion 13/14/15 15 RP=91-93 15 $45-49WAlert 09 RP=91-93+ 09 $35-40 RP 08 RP=90-93 07 RP=92 07 ST=87 06 RP=89 06 ST=86-89
Ch St-Louis Montagne St-Emilion 14/15 15 CT=87 (2) 15 $10 TrJ
Clos St-Martin St-Emilion GC 12/13/14/15 15 90%Merlot-5CF-5CS 15 RP=90-92 15 $55-100 15 WS=92 15 $75 WS 09 RP=92-94+ 08 RP=93-95 08 JJB=91-93 08 JJB=87-89 07 RP=89+ 07 WS=87-90 06 RP=92-94 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 WS=91 05 ST=88-91 05 RP=96-98 Ch St-Pierre St-Julien 13/14/15 15 WS=93 15 $62 WS
Pomerol 13/14/15 15 WS=92 15 $55 WS
Ch St-Sulpice Bordeaux Sup Cuvee Prestige 13/14/15 15 Bronze LA 17
Stephan Motut Bordeaux 14/15 15 W&S=NR 15 $10 W&S
Ch Suau Cotes de Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 Editor’s Choice WE 15 WE=91 15 $18 WE 15 WS=91 15 RP=87-89 Subilaux Bordeaux 14/15 15 Vinous=85-87 193
14 WW=91 14 $12wine.com 14 Vinous=88-90 14 Vivino=2.9 (54) 11 Gold Bordeaux 12 11 ST=85-88 10 Silver Bordeaux 11 Blaye Cote de Bordeaux 14/15 14 Vivino=3.2 (38)
Ch de Tabuteau Lussas Saint-Emilion 13/14/15 15 RP=88-90 15 $16 WineS 12 Best Buy WE 12 WE=90 12 $15 WE
Ch du Taillan Haut-Medoc 13/14/15 15 Editor’s Choice WE 15 WE=92 15 $23 WE 15 RP=88 14 Editor’s Choice WE 14 WE=91 14 $25 WE 10 WS=83 10 $23 WS 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 WS=82
Ch Taillefer (Moueix) Pomerol 13/14/15 15 RP=91-93 15 $25-36WAlert 10 WS=91 10 $24 WS 10 RP=85 10 $22-29 RP 09 Bronze IWC 12 09 CF-Merlot 09 WE=90 08 WS=89
Ch Talbot St-Julien 4th Cru Classe 12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 WS=93-96 18 $60 wine.com 18 JS=94-95 16/15 TWCI=92 15 WS=92 15 $61 WS 15 JCLee=94 15 JR=16.5 (90) 14 TWCI=90 13 TWCI=88 13 JR=16 (88) 12 Very Successful Hachette 16 12 TWCI=90 12 JR=16.5 (90) 11 very Successful Hachette 15 11 GDP=87 11/10 TWCI=89 10 63%CS-32%Merlot-5%PV 10 ST=86 10 Coup de Coeur 2 stars Hachette 14 10 JJB=93 09 CS-Merlot-PV 09 ST=88 09 Vin Remarquable Hachette 13 09 WE=94 09 RP=92-94 09 WS=92-95 09 TWCI=90 08 Very Successful Hachette 12 08 RP=89-91 08 ST=88 08 TWCI=91 07 Value < $500/case QRW Aut 08 07 RP=86 07 WE=89 07 $45 WE 07 ST=86 07 WS=91 07 TWCI=84 06 Not inspiring WD 06 WD=13.5-14.5 06 Very Suyccessful Hachette 10 06 RP=89 06 ST=87-90 06 TWCI=89 St-Julien Connetable Talbot 13/14/15 15 RP=83-85 15 $30 WAlert 15 RP=88-90 15 $54-81WAlert 08 WS=86
Ch Tanesse Cadillac Cotes de Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 Editor’s Choice WE 15 WE=91 15 $18 WE 10 WS=89 10 $14 WS 10 WE=89 10 $25 WE 08 Silver Brussels 10 08 WS=87 08 $15 WS Ch Tassin Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=89 15 $14 WE 15 WS=84 194
Ch Taussin Bordeaux 14/15/16 16 WE=86 16 $12 WE
Bordeaux Premium 13/14/15 14 Best Buy WE 14 WE=85 14 $7 WE
Ch Tauzinat L’Hermitage St-Emilion GC 13/14/15 15 RP=90-92 15 $16-20WAlert 10 RP=85 09 WS=90-93 Ch Tayac Margaux Cru Bourgeois 14/15/16 ?? $20 TrJ 09 Bronze Decanter 12 07 Bronze Challenge 10 07 Comm’d Decanter 10 Ch Techeney Bordeaux Sup 14/15 15 Bronze LA 17
Ch le Temple Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=90
Ch les Terrasses de Bouey Bordeaux 13/14/15 14 Best Buy WE 14 WE=85 14 $10 WE
Terrasses de St-Chrsitophe St-Emilion GC 12/13/14 2nd wine of Tour St Christophe 14 Decanter=95 14 $16 K&L 14 JS=90 13 Cited Wine Hachette 17 12 Silver Paris 14 12 RevueFR=14 12 417 K&L 12 Cited Wine Hachetter 12 CT=85 (3) 12 Vivino=3.5 (31) Ch Terre Blanque Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 WS=85 15 $15 WS
Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux 14/15/16 16 Silver LA 17 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=87 15 $9 WE 15 WS=85 15 $15 WS Ch Terrefort-Quancard Bordeaux Sup 14/15 Merlot 14 Gilbert&G=83 14 $12 TW&M 13 Gilbert&G=84 12 Very Successful Hachette 15 12 Silver Macon 14 11 Gold Paris; Cited Wine Hachette 14 11 WE=85 11 $17 WE 10 WE=87 09 Silver Bruxelles 13 09 WE=89 08 Silver LA 11 08 WW=87 08 WE=85 08 WS=84 08 CellarT=87 (5) 07 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 WW=88 06 NM=87 See also: Cheval Quancard
Ch Terres Douces Bordeaux 14/15 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=85 15/14 $10 WE 15 WS=86 14 Best Buy WE 14 WE=87 Terre de Vignerons Atlantique Le Phare CS 14/15/16 16 Best Buy WE 16 WE=85 16 $10 WE
Ch de Tertre Bordeaux 13/14/15 13 W&S=NR 13 $11 W&S
Ch du Tertre Margaux 5th Cru Classe 12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 WE=94-96 18 $42 wine.com 18 JS=95-96 18 WS=91-94 15 70%CS-10PV-10CF-10Merlot 15 RP=91-93 15 Cellar Selection WE 15 WE=96 15 WS=93 15 $41 WS 15 WE=96 15 JS=94-95 15 RP=91-93 15 Decanter=92 15 Vinous=01 11 GDP=89 11 $45 GDP 10 70%CS-20%Merlot-10%PV 10 ST=91 10 JJB=93+ 195
09 CS-M-CF-PV 09 WE=93 09 ST=89 09 $32 ST 08 JJB=87-89 07 Value QRW Autumn 08 07 WE=91 07 $35 WE 07 RP=87-89 07 WS=83-86 07 ST=88 06 Bronze Decanter 09 06 RP=86 06 Cellar Selection WE 06 WE=93 06 Pretty good WD 06 WD=15.5-16.5 06 ST=87-89 06 WS=82 06 $37 WS
Ch Tertre de Belves Castillon Cotes de Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 Cellar Selection WE 15 WE=91 15 $19 WE
Tertre du Moulin St-Emilion GC Cuvee Millesimee 14/15 14 CT=84.7 (3) 14 $15 TrJ 14 RC=87/88 13 Gilbert&G=83 13 CT=88.5 (2) Ch le Tertre Roteboeuf St-Emilion 11/12/13/14/15/16 16 JR=17+ 15 RP=97-99 15 $165-250 10 ST=94 09 80%Merlot-CF 09 ST=93 09 $230+ ST 09 One of Top 32 JJB 09 JJB=97-99 08 RP=94-96 07 ST=89 06 RP=87 06 ST=89-92 06 WS=92-94 05 ST=94 05 $250 ST
Ch Tessendey Fronsac 14/15/16 16 WE=87 16 $20 WE 14 WE=91 14 $20 WE 14 G&G 87 14 $15 K&L 13 G&G=87 12 WE=88 11 WE=87 Ch Teyssier St-Emilion GC 14/15/16 16 TWCI=90 15 RP=88-90 15 $9-20 WAlert 11 85% Merlot-15%CF 11 RP=89-91 09 ST=87 09 WE=89 09 RP=89-91
Ch Thieuley Bordeaux Francis Courselle Res 13/14/15 15 WS=87 15 $25 WS 15 RP=86-88 15 $10-13WineS 15 WS=87 15 $25 WS 11 WS=87 11 $20 WS 10 WS=89 10 $20 WS 10 RP=87-89 09 RP=87-89 09 JR=15.5 (86) 08 Silver Bordeaux 10 08 WS=87 08 ST=87 08 JR=16 (88) 07 Bronze Challenge (FR) 09 06 RP=88 06 $25 RP
Bordeaux 14/15/16 16 TWCI=88 15 WS=86 15 $18 WS 15 RP=86-88 15 $7-13 WineS 14 Very Successful Hachette 17 12 JR=16+ (88+) 11 WS=87 11 $15 WS 11 JR=15.5 (86) 10 Merlot-CS 10 WS=88 10 $13 WS 10 Vin Remarquable Hachette 13 10 Hachette=2 star 196
10 Coeur Selection Hachette 13 10 RP=86 10 ST=86 10 JR=15.5 (86) 10 RC=88 09 Gold Paris 11 09 RP=87-88 08 Gold Challenge 08 WS=86 08 $14 WS 08 Very Successful Hachette 11
Ch le Thil Pessac-Leognan Comte Clary 13/14/15/16 16 JS=92-93 16 $25 K&L 16 WE=91-93 16 $25 Zachys 16 TWCI=90 16 WS=89-92 15 RP=86-88 15 $27 K&L 15 100%Merlot 15 Vinous=88-91 15 WS=89 15 $27 WS 15 JCLee=87 15 JR=16 (88) 14 #8 Top Values < $30 WS 14 WS=91 14 $20 WS 14 RP=88-90 14 $24 JJB 14 TWCI=88 14 $29 Zachys 14 JS=90 14 Vinous=92 14 JCLee=87 13 WS=887 13 $30 WS 13 TWCI=85 12 TWCI=89 12 WS=90 12 $26 WS 12 JR=16.5 (90) 11 TWCI=88 11 WS=89-92 11 JR=16 (88) 10 RP=91-93 10 Very Successful Hachette 14 10 WS=91 10 $25 WS 10/09/08 TWCI=90 09 Outperformed Price JJB 09 JJB=91-93 09 Merlot-CS 09 WS=92 09 $20 WS 08 WS=91 08 $18 WS 08 RP=90-92 07 RP=86-87 07 ST=86
Thomas Barton See: B&G Barton & Guestier
Ch Thunevin Bordeaux Mauvais Garcon Bad Boy 14/15 15 RP=87-89 15 $17 RP 14 RP=84-86 10 RP=88 10 TWCI=88-90 Bordeaux Mauvais Garcon Bad Boy Syrah 14/15 14 RP=85-87 14 $15-30 RP
Ch Timberlay Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15 Merlot 15 WS=85 15 $17 WS 14 W&S=NR 14 $17 W&S 08 Comm’d IWC 10 07 NM=87 07 C$16 NM Bordeaux Clairet 13/14/15 14 W&S=NR 14 $17 W&S
Tire Pe Bordeaux Diem 13/14/15 15/14 W&S=NR 15 $12 Astor 15/14 $14 W&S 13 W&S=NR 13 09 RP=88-90 08 RP=89-91 Ch la Tonnelle Haut Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=?
Ch Toudenac Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=88 15 $13 WE
Ch Tour Bayard Montagne St-Emilion L’Angelot 13/14/15 15 RP=84-86 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=91 14 $25 WE 197
10 Silver Decanter 12 10 RP=88 09 Comm’d Decanter 12 08 Silver Bordeaux 10
Ch la Tour de Bessan Margaux 13/14/15 15 RP=90-92 15 $23-30WAlert 10 WS=88 10 $20 WS 09 Bronze Decanter 12 09 WS=91-94
Ch Tour de Bigorre Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=87 15 $10 WE 14 Vin Remarquable Hachette 17 Ch la Tour-de-By Medoc Cru Bourgeois Sup 13/14/15 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=92 14 $29 WE 10 RP=86 10 JJB=89 09 Cab Sauv 09 WE=88 09 ST=88-91 08 SS=15.0/20 08 Decanter=3star 08 RP=85-86 07 Comm’d Decanter 10 06 Cited Wine Hachette 10 06 WS=87 06 $17 WS 05 12 outstanding Values QRW 06 05 WE=87 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 RP=87-88
Ch La Tour Carnet (Magrez) Haut-Medoc GC 13/14/15/16 16/15 WDecider=9016 $30 WHouse 16 TWCI=91 16 $30 Millesima 16 JS=93-95 16 $30 K&L 16 RP=91-93 16 $31.50 Sh-L 16 Decanter=92 16 WS=90 15 70%Merlot-30%CS 15 TWCI=88 15 $29 JJB 15 RP=91-93 15 $30 wine.com 15 JS=91-92 15 $35 K&L 15 Decanter=93 15 $34 Zachys 15 WS=87 15 $32 WS 15 JCLee=86 15 JR=16.5 (90) 14 WDecider=90 14 $32 K&L 14 TWCI=89 14 $30 WHouse 14 WE=91-93 14 JS=91 14 RP=91 14 Vinous=91 14 JR=16 (88) 13 Bronze Decanter 16 13 W&S=82 13 $30 WS 13 WDecider=88 13 TWCI=86 12 Very Successful Hachette 16 12 WDecider=90 12 Silver Decanter 15 12 TWCI=89 11 Coupde Coeurs 2 sta rs Hachette 15 11 GDP=87
11 WDecider=89 11 RP=90 11 WS=90 11/10 TWCI=90 10 RP=93 10 $49 Zachys 10 JS=92 10 $58 WineCh 10 WE=90-92 10 $60 Sh-L 10 ST=87/91 10 TWCI=89-91 10 WDecider=92 09 CS-Merlot 09 WE=91 09 $66 WineCh 09 Bronze TEXSOM 17 09 RP=91-93 09 WDecider=92 09 TWCI=92 08 RP=90-93 08 ST=87 198
08 WDecider=91 08 TWCI=89 07 Bronze Decanter 10 07 RP=89+ 07 WS=83-86 07 ST=88 07/06 WDecider=89 Haut-Medoc Cuvee les Douves 12 WDecider=85 10 WDecider=87 09 Comm’d Decanter 12 09 WDecider=84
See also their second wine: Servitude Voluntaire
Ch Tour Chapoux Bordeaux 14/15/16 14 Cited Wine Hachette 17 11 Bronze IWC; Comm’d Decanter 12 11 CF-CS-Merlot 10 WS=83 10 $12 WS 10 WE=86 09 Bronze LA 11 Ch des Tourelles Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=88
Les Tourelles Lomgueville Paulliac 13/14/15 15 55%Merlot-30CS-10CF-5PV 15 RP=90-92 15 $35 WAlert
Ch la Tour Figeac St-Emilion GC 13/14/15 15 RP=89-92 15 $37-102 15 WS=92 15 $40 WS 13 WS=88 13 $25 WS 10 75%Merlot-25%CF 10 ST=88 09 Outperformed Price JJB 09 JJB=92-94 09 WE=93 09 RP=91-93 08 Vin Remarquable Hachette 12 08 WS=90 08 $28 WS 08 Coeur Selection Hachette 12 08 RP=90-92 07 WE=90 07 RP=90-92 07 WS=85-88 07 ST=90
Ch Tour des Gendres Beregerac Malbec-Merlot 14/15/16 16 Best Buy WE 16 WE=89 16 $14 WE
Ch Tour Grand Mayne Castillon Cotes de Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=92 15 $15 WE
Ch Tour des Gendres Bergerac 13/14/15 15 W&S=90 15 $16 wine.com 15 WE=88 15 $14 WE 10 WE=87 10 $14 WE
Ch la Tour-Haut-Brion Pessac-Leognan 14 JCLee=92 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 RP=89-91 05 ST=90-92 05 WS=93 05 $73 WS 05 WE=91/89 05 TWCI=90 05 JCLee=90
Ch Tour Haut-Caussan Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=89 15 $15-66 WineS 10 RP=90 10 WE=90 10 $22 WE
Ch Tour d’Honorable Castillon Cotes de Bordeaux 14/15/16 16 WE=88 16 $23 WE
Ch Tour Maillet Pomerol 13/14/15 15 RP=88-90 15 $28 WineS 09 RP=86-88 09 WS=90 09 Decanter 16.8 08 RP=86-88 07 RP=86-88 06 Cited Wine Hachette 10 06 RP=86 06 $38 RP
199
Ch Tour de Mirambeau Bordeaux Sup Cuvee Passion 13/14/15 14 RP=86-88 12 JR=15.5 (86) 11 JR=15.5 (86) 10 RP=89 10 JR=15.5 (86) 08 WS=86 08 $16 WS 07/06 Very Successful Hachette 10/09 06 RP=86
Ch la Tour de Mons Margaux Cru Bourgeois Sup 13/14/15 15 Value Wine < $30 WS 15 WS=90 15 $28 WS 15 RP=92 15 $20-25WAlert 14 Editor’s Choice WE 14 WE=93 14 $21 WE 13 WS=86 13 $25 WS 10 WS=89 10 $21 WS 10 RP=87 09 Comm’d Decanter 12 09 WS=92-95 08 RP=87 08 $25 WS
Tour du Pas St-Georges St-Emilion 13/14/15 15 RP=88 15 $11-25WineS 08 ST=85
Ch les Tours de Peyrat Prem Cotes de Blaye Vieilles Vignes 14/15/16 14 Cited Wine Hachette 127 06 $15 K&L Ch Tour de Pez St-Estephe Cru Bourgeois Sup 13/14/15 15 RP=86 15 $25 WAlert 14/13 Editor’s Choice WE 14 WE=91 14 $24 WE 13 WE=90 13 $21 WE 13 WS=83 12 Editor’s Choice WE 12 WE=90 12 $19 WE 09 Bronze Decanter 12 09 WE=90 08 Cellar Selection WE 08 WE=92 08 SS=15.0/20 08 Decanter=3star
Ch Tour-Prignac (Castel) Medoc Cru Bourgeois 13/14/15 15 JR=15 (84) 14 Silver Bruxelles 16 14 WE=89 14 $19 WhFoods 14 Bronze Decanter, Paris 16 14 CT=87.5 (2) 14 $19 WneCh 14 $18 WE 13 Gold Paris 15 13 Silver Bruxelles 15 11 Gilbert&G=85 10 WS=82 10 $18 WS 10 JR=15 (82) 10 Gilber&G=86 09 Bronze Paris 11 09 Gilbert&G=88 09 JR=15.5 986) 08 Silver France-Macon 10 08 WS=88 08 Bronze Decanter, IWC 10 08 JR=16.5 (90) 08 G&G=86 07 Silver BinClass IWSC 09
Ch Tour St-Germain Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux Cuvee du Moulin 15 15 WS=88 15 $13 WS 14 Very Successful Hachette 17 Blaye Cotes de Boprdeaux Cuvee Elegance 15 WS=86 15 $15 WS 14 Cited Wine Hachette 17
Ch Tour St Bonnet Medoc Cru Bourgeois 13/14/15 15 RP=85-87 10 RP=90 10 CellarT 88 (2) 10 JR=14.5 (84)
Ch Tour Saint Christophe St Emilion GC 14/15/16 16 TWCI=95 16 $27 K&L 16 JS=96-97 16 $27 WHouse 16 RP=92-94 16 $28 JJB 16 Top 30 Bordeaux Values Vinous 16 16 Vinous=91-94 16 $28 wine.com 16 CT=95 (1) 16 $28 Zachys 16 $29 Morrell 15 TWCI=94 15 $28 WHouse 200
15 JS=94-96 15 $30 K&L 15 Vinous=91-94 15 $33 Zachys 15 RP=92-94 15 CT=94 (2) 14 Vin Remarquable Hachette 16 14 TWCI=91 14 JS=94 14 RP=93 14 CT=90.6 (7) 13 TWCI=89 13 $24 JJB 12 TWCI=90/88 12 JS=93 12 RP=90 Ch Tour Saint-Joseph Haut-Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=84 09 Comm’d Decanter 12 07 WE=85 07 $25 WE 05 NM=89 Ch Tour Seran Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=90 13 WS=82 13 $35 WS 10 RP=89 09 Gold Paris 11 09 RP=89-91 08 RP=85-86+ 07 Bronze Paris 09 06 Silver Brussels 10 06 RP=88 06 Vert Successful Hachette 10
Ch Tour des Termes St-Estephe Cru Bourgeois 13/14/15 15 RP=89 15 $17-38 WineS 15 WS=88 13 WS=83 13 $30 WS 10 ST=87 09 WS=92-95 08 SS=16.0/20 08 Decanter=3star
Ch Tournefeuille Lalande-de-Pomerol 13/14/15 15 WS=88 15 $36 WS 14 RP=91 13 WS=86 13 $36 WS
13 RP=85-86 10 Bronze Decanter 12 10 ST=86 08 WS=89 07 Bronze Decanter 09 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 WS=87 06 $38 WS
Ch Tourteran Haur-Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=86+ 13 WS=85 13 $33 WS 07 WE=85 Ch de Tourteyron Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=75? 13 WS=84 13 $20 WS Ch Toutigeac Bordeaux Rouge 13/14/15 15 Silver LA 17 10 Bronze LA 11 Bordeaux Rouge Grande Res 14/ 15 Silver LA 17
Les Tresquots Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=90
Ch Trianon St-Emilion 13/14/15/ 16 16 TWCI=90 15 Top Value < $30 WS 15 WS=90 15 $25 WS 15 RP=87-89 13 WS=85-88 La Tribune Margaux 13/14/15 15 RP=92
Ch les Trois Croix Fronsac 13/14/15 15 #6 Top Value < $30 WS 15 WS=92 15 $28 WS 15 RP=91-93 15 $13-29WineS 13 WS=88 13 $35 WS 10 RP=87-89 09 RP=87-88 201
08 RP=86-88 06 Very Succesasful Hachette 10 06 RP=87 06 WS=88
Ch les Trois Manoirs Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=85
Ch Trois Moulins Haut Medoc Cru Bourgeois 13/14/15 14 RP=83 10 WS=88 10 $22 WS 08 Bronze Bordeaux 10 08 WE=88 08 $16 WE
Ch Tronquoy-Lalande St-Estephe Cru Bourgeois 16 TWCI=94 16 RP=89-91 15 RP=87 15 $28-60 WineS 15 WS=89 15 TWCI=88 15 JCLee=91 15 JR=16.6 (90) 14 TWCI=91 14 RP=89 14 $32-35WAlert 13 TWCI=88 13 RP=86 12 Gilbert&G=88 12 TWCI=90 12 Cited Wine Hachette 16 12 RP=89+ 11 TWCI=87 11 RP=88 10 50%CS-40%Merlot-10%PV 10 ST=87 10 Very Successful Hachette 14 10 JCLee=90 10 RP=92 10/09 TWCI=92 09 51%Merlot-CS 09 WE=92 09/08 Very Successful Hachette 13/12 09 JR=16 (88) 09 ST=88 09 RP=91 08 SS=16.0/20 08 Decanter=3star 08 TWCI=89 08 RP=90 07 Value QRW Autumn 08 07 RP=86-88 07 Vin Remarquable Hachette 11 07 TWCI=88 07 RP=87 06 WS=85-88 06 TWCI=90 06 RP=88
Ch Troplong Mondot St-Emilion GC 12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 WS=95-98 18 $105wine.com 18 JS=97-98 18 WE=95-87 18 Decanter=97 16 TWCI=97 15 RP=92-94 15 $115-166Wal 15 WS=95 15 $123 WS 14 WS=94 14 $83 WS 13 Cellar Selection WE 13 WE=93 13 WS=90 13 $88 WS 10 83%Merlot-14%CS-3%CF 10 ST=90 10 JJB=95 09 Vin Remarquable Hachette 13 09 Hachette=2star 09 Coeur Selection Hachette 13 09 WE=94 09 RP=94-97 09 One of Top 32 JJB 09 JJB=97-99 09 Decanter=5star 09 Decanter=18.5 08 ST=90
202
08 RP=95-97 08 WE=93-95 08 WS=91-94 08 JJB=87-89/84-86 07 RP=93 07 WE=89 07 $80 WE 07 ST=91 07 WS=90 06 RP=93 06 Cellar Selection WE 06 WE=95/94 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 ST=91-93 06 WS=91 06 $135 WS 05 Rec’d W&S 4/06 05 W&S=1star 05 Velvety, flavorful, seductive WW 05 WS=96 05 Great wine SS in Decanter 06 05 SS=19/20 05 Vin Remarquable Hachette 09 05 RP=96-100
St-Emilion Mondot 13/14/15 15 WS=90
Ch Trotanoy Pomerol 10/11/12/13/14/15/16 16 TWCI=96 16 JR=17+ (95) 15 RP=94-96 15 WS=96 15 $250 WS 14/13/12 Cellar selection WE 14 WE=95 14 $250 WE 14 WS=95 14 $208 WS 13WE=94 13 $250 WE 13 WS=92 13 $200 WS 12 WE=94 12 $325 WE 09 ST=95 09 WE=96 09 RP=97-100 09 One of Top 32 JJB 09 JJB=97-99 08 ST=92 08 90%Merlot-10%CF 08 RP=96-100 08 JJB=95-97 07 RP=89+ 07 WS=88-91 07 ST=90 06 Cellar Selection WE 06 WE=94/95 06 Vin Exceptionnel Hachette 10 06 RP=93 06 WS=93 06 $137 WS 06 ST=91-93 05 Cellar Selectio WE 05 WE=94/96 05 $250 WE 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 WS=95 05 $190 WS 05 ST=94+? 04 Vin Remarquable Hachette 08 04 WS=92 04 $80 WS 04 WE=94 04 ST=90+
Ch TrotteVieille St-Emilion PGC 11/12/13/14/15/16 16 TWCI=92 15 WS=93 15 $99 WS 15 RP=94-96 13 WS-88 13 $125 WS 11 GDP=92 10 ST=86 09 67%CF-31%M-2%CS 09 WE=95 09 ST=88 09 RP=91-93 09 Decanter=4star 09 Decanter=17.5 08 WS=89 08 RP=90-93 07 RP=89+ 07 WS=88 07 WE=88 07 ST=87 203
06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 WE=93/93 06 RP=89+ 06 WS=90 06 $110 WS 06 ST=86-88 05 Vin Remarquable Hachette 09 05 WE=92/93 05 WS=92 05 $106 WS 05 ST=91 05 RP=93-95 04 WS=87 St-Emilion Dame de Trotte Vieille 13/14/15 15 WS=89
Ch Tuilerie Pages Bordeaux 14/15/16 16 Silver LA 17 12 Best Buy WE 12 WE=85 12 $10 WE 10 WE=85 10 $14 WE Ch les Tuileries Bordeaux 14/15/16 16 Bronze LA 17 14 Very Successful Hachette 17 10 Bronze LA 11 09 Gold Bordeaux 10 09 Silver LA 10 09 Bronze Challenge 10 Bordeaux Sup 14/15/16 16 Gold BofClass LA 17 16 LA=92
Ch Turcard Bordeaux Clairet 14/15/16 16 WE=87 16 $14 WE 14 W&S=NR 14 $14 W&S 10 Best Buy WE 10 WE=88 10 $12 WE
Ch Turcaud Bordeaux Sup Cuvee Majeure 13/14/15 14 W&S=NR 14 $18 W&S 10 WE=87 10 $18 WE 09 Cited Wine Hachette 11 Ch D’Uza Graves 13/14/15 15 WS=87 15 $25 WS 13 WS=87 13 $20 WS Ch la Valade Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 W&S=NR 15 $15 W&S 14 Best Buy WE 14 WE=87 14 $12 WE 14W&S=85
Ch Valandraud St-Emilion GC 10/11/12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 WS=96-99 18 $180wine.com 18 JS=97-98 18 WE=96-98 18 JD=96-98 18 RP=95-97+ 16 TWCI=97 15 85%Merlot-10CF-5CS 15 RP=95-97 15 WS=95 15 $182 WS 14/13 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=96 14 $200 WE 14 WS=95 14 $118 WS 14 Decanter=93 13 WS=91 13 $300 WS 13 WE=94 13 $164 WE 10 ST=91 09 80%Merlot-CF 09 ST=91 09 WE=95 09 One of Top 32 JJB 09 JJB=96-98 08 ST=89 07 RP=90-93 07 WS=85-88 07 ST=91 06 Very Successful Hachette 10 06 RP=92 06 ST=90-92 06 WS=92 06 $225 WS 05 Vin Remarquable Hachette 09 05 WE=91 05 Coup de Coeur Hachette 09 05 ST=94 05 WS=95 05 $315 WS 05 RP=93-95
204
3 de Valandraud St-Emilion 13/14/15 15 RP=88-90 15 $39 WineS 10 ST=87 Le Virginie de Valandraud 13/14/15 15 RP=90-92 15 WS=91 15 $39 WS Ch Val Beylie Bordeaux Demoiselles 13/14/15 15 W&S=NR 15/14 $13 W&S 14 W&S=84 Bordeaux Plaisir 13/14/15 14 W&S=NR 14 $15 W&S
Ch Valentons Canteloup Bordeaux Sup 14/15 15 Silver LA 17
Ch du Vallier Prem Cotes de Bordeaux 13/14/15 12 Editor’s Choice WE 12 WE=91 12 $50 WE 08 WE=86 08 $25 WE
Dom de Valmengaux Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 RP=86-88 09 Silver Decanter 12 06 RP=87 Verdillac Bordeaux 13/14/15 13 W&S=NR 13 $10 W&S
Ch Vermont Bordeaux Sup Prestige 14/15/16 14 WS=84 14 $13 WS
Bordeaux Sup Res 14/15/16 14 Cited Wine Hachette 17
Ch la Verriere Bordeaux Sup 14/15 15 WE=88 15 $15 WE 14 Gold Paris 16 14 CostcoBlog=89 14 $9 Costco 14 Vin Remarquable Hachette 17 14 WE=85 13 WS=83 13 $11 WS 13 WE=84 13 WS=83 12 Best Buy WE 12 WE=90 12 $14 WE12 12 Very Successful Hachette 15 12 Gold Paris 14 12 Gold Aquitaine 14 11 Very Successfulk Hachette 14 10 WE=81 09 WS=88 09 $15 WS
Ch Veyry Cotes de Castillon 14/15 15 RP=84-86 15 $11 WineS 10 RP=87 09 RP=87-88 09 WS=88
Ch de Viaud 14/15 14 RP=90
Ch Victoria Haut Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=84
Ch la Vieille Cure Fronsac 12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 RP=92-94 18 $22 wine.com 18 JS=92-93 18 JD=91-93 18 Decanter=94 16/15 TWCI=91 16 WS=91-94 15 JR=15.5 (86) 15 RP=90-92 15 WS=92 13 $23 WS 14 #4 Top Values < $30 WS 14 WS=92 14 $30 WS 14 TWCI=90 14 JR=16 (88) 14 JCLee=89 13 WS=88 13 $25 WS 13 TWCI=88 12 Cited Wine Hachette 16 12 TWCI=90 12 JR=16.5 (90) 12 WS=88-91 11 Very Successful 1 star Hachette 15 11 RP=90-92 11 WS=90 11 $30 WS 11 TWCI=90 10 Coup de Coeurs 2 stars Hachette 14 10 RP=91 205
10 WS=92 10 $35 WS 10/09 TWCI=92 09 Bargain Snooth.com 09 WE=92 09/08 Cited Wine Hachette 13/12 09 RP=90-93 09/08 WS=90 09 $27 WS 08 RP=88-90 08 TWCI=88 07 RP=87-89 07 WS=89 07 $33 WS Clos de la Vieille Eglise Pomerol 13/14/15 15 RP=909-92 15 $58-62 WineS 09 Merlot 09 Bronze Paris 11 07 WS=83-86 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 Coup de Coeur Hachette 10 06 WS=87 05 Gold Paris 07, Brussels 07 05 WS=87 05 Silver Bordeaux 07 05 RP=87-89 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 WE=90 05 $100 WE 04 Gold Brussels 07 04 WE=91 04 $59 WE 04 Vin Remarquable Hachette 08 04 Coup de Coeur Hachette 08 Bordeaux Sup 14/15/16 16 Silver LA 17
Ch de la Vieille Tour Bordeaux Sup Merlot-CS 14/15 15 Silver LA 17 13 WS=81 13 $15 WS 09 Silver LA 12 08 Silver LA 11 Ch Vieux Bonneau Montagne-St-Emilion 14/15 15 WS=86 15 $25 WS
Vieux-Chateau-Certan Pomerol 10/11/12/13/14/15/16/17/18 18 70%Merlot-30CF 18 JS=99-100 18 $300wine.com 18 Decanter=98-100 18 WE=98-100
17 WineS=97+ 16 TWCI=99 16 JR=17+ (=92+) 15 RP=98-100 15 $265-376WA 15 WS=97 15 $320 WS 15 TWCI=97 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=97 14 $130 WE 14 WS=96 14 $167 WS 14 TWCI=95 13 TWCI=90 12 Cellar Selection WE 12 WE=95 12 TWCI=93 11 TWCI=92 10 86%Merlot-8%CF-6%CS 10 ST=94 10 TWCI=100 09 84%M-8%CF-8%CS 09 ST=92 09 RP=96-99 09 TWCI=99 08 RP=92-94 08 ST=91 08 TWCI=94 07 RP=89 07 WS=88-91 07 ST=89 07 TWCI=90 06 WE=96 06 RP=96 06 ST=91-93 06 WS=95 06 TWCI=95 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 WS=97 05 ST=92+? 05 WW=98-100 206
10 TWCI=96 St-Emilion La Gravette de Certan 13/14/15 15 WS=90 15 $68 WS 15 TWCI=89 12 WS=90 10 WS=92 09 HuonHooke=96 Vieux Ch des Combes St-Emilion 13/14/15 14 Best Buy WE 14 WE=90 14 $15 WE
Ch Vieux Coutelin St-Estephe 13/14/15 15 RP=87
Vieux Ch Lamothe Bordeaux 13/14/15 13 W&S=NR 13 $9 W&S
Ch Vieux Maillet Pomerol 13/14/15 15 RP=85-87 15 $27-36WineS 15 WS=88 14 WS=89 Vieux Ch Mazerat St-Emilion 12/13/14/15 15 RP=91-93 15 $82-169 14/13/12 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=95 14 $150 WE 13 WE=94 13/12 $130 WE 12 WE=95 Vieux Manoir Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 Gold LA 17 15 LA=91
Vieux Ch Palon Montagne-St-Emilion 13/14/15 15 RP=90-92 10 TWCI=85-87 10 WS=88-91 Vieux Manoir Bordeaux Cuvee Prestige 14/15 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=88 15 $11 WE 12 Best Buy WE 12 WE=86 12 $11 WE Ch Vieux Manoir Bordeaux 12/13/14 14 WS=84 14 $11 WS 10 Bronze Decanter, IWC12 10 WE=86 10 $10 WE 10 CF-CS-Merlo Ch Vieux Moulin Listrac 13/14/15 15 RP=84
Vieux Ch Palon Montagne St-Emilion 13/14/15 15 RP=90-92 15 $29 WineS 10 RP=87-88 08 Gold Paris 11 08 WS=88 07 Gold Bordeaux 10 07 ST=88 07 75%Merlot-CF
Ch Vieux Poirier Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 RP=82-84 14 Best Buy WE 14 WE=86 14 $11 WE Ch du Vieux Puit Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux 13/14/15 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=90 15 $15 WE 14 Vin Remarquable Hachette 17 Vieux Ch St Andre Montagne-St-Emilion 13/14/15 15 RP=89-91 15 $21-35WineS 10/09 85%Merlot-CF 10 ST=86 09 ST=88 08 ST=88 05 WS=84 Vieux Clos St-Emilion Montagne St-Emilion 13/14/15 15 RP=90-92 15 $22 WineS 09 RP=85-87 08 RP=89-90 07 RP=89-90
Vignerons Reunis Monsegur Bordeaux Romantique 14/15 12 Best Buy WE 12 WE=86 12 $10 WE
Bordeaux Luna B 14/15 14 W&S=NR 12 Best Buy WE 12 WE=86 12 $10 WE Bordeaux Romantigue 14/15 12 Best Buy WE 12 WE=86 12 $10 WE
Bordeaux Ch Mayne Turon 13/14/15 14 W&S=84 14 $12 W&S
Bordeaux Ch Arnaucosse 13/14/15 14 W&S=83 14 $12 W&S
Bordeaux Ch Grand Billard 13/14/15 14 W&S=NR 14 $12 W&S
Bordeaux Ch Grand Marchand 13/14/15 14 W&S=NR 14 $12 W&S
Bordeaux Luna B Res Cab Franc 13/14/15 14 W&S=NR 14 $20 W&S 207
Ch Au Vignoble Bordeaux Sup Revelations d’Hubert de Bouard 15 WS=86 15 $20 WS
Vignobles Arbo Malbec Cotes de Bordeaux 13/14/15 14 WS=86 14 $15 WS 14 WE=88 14 $22 WE Vignobles Carreau Selection Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux Amiral 13/14/15 14 Editor’s Choice WE 14 WE=90 14 $27 WE
Vignobles Ducourt Bordeaux Ch de Beauregard Ducourt 13/14/15 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=88 15 $12 WE
Vignobles Falgueyret-Leglise Bordeaux Monsieur Moustache 13/14/14 14 WS=84 14 $12 WS
Vignobles Fontan Cotes de Gascogne Lou Campagno 13/14/15 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=85 15 $10 WE
Vignobles Jolivet Bordeaux Ch de Coudraie 13/14/15 13 W&S=NR 13 $15 W&S
Vignobles K Pomeral Badine de la Patache 12/13/14/15 14 Cellar Selection WE 14 WE=93 14 $55 WE
Vignobles Raymond Bordeaux Le Petit de de Ch Lagarde 14/15/16 16 W&S=NR 16 $14 W&S 09 Silver LA 10
Bordeaux Les Hauts de Lagarde 14/15/16 16 W&S=NR 16/15 $13 W&S 15 W&S=85/NR 14 W&S=85/NR 14 $15 W&S 13 W&S=NR 13$13 W&S 10 Bronze LA 12 10 WE=83 10 $13 WE Bordeaux En Memoire du Malbec 14/15 15 W&S=NR 15 $14 W&S
Vignobles Siozard Bordeaux Sup Ch de Claouset 14/15 15 WS=87 15 $20 WS
Ch Vignol Bordeaux Clairet 14/15/16 16 WE=86 16 $17 WE
Ch Villa Bel-Air Graves 13/14/15 Cab Sauv 15 WS=88 15 $20 WS 15 Silver IWSC 16 15 JR=16.5 (90) 14 Silver IWC 16 14 WS=86 13 Bronze Decanter 16 13 WS=88 13 $22 Sh-L 12 Silver IWSC 16 12 Cited Wine Hachette 16 09 Bronze Decanter, IWC 12 09 CF-CS-Merlot 08 WS=85 08 $25 WS 07 Gold Paris 09 07 Bronze IWC; Comm’d Decanter 10 Ch de Villambis Haut Medoc 13/14/15 15 RP=90 10 RP=90 10 JR=15 (84) Ch Villars Fronsac 14/15/16 16 TWCI=91 15 RP=87-89 15 $13-25 WineS 10 RP=90 09 RP=90-92+ 08 WS=60 08/07 $24 WS 08 RP=87-89 07 WS=60 07 $24 WS 07 RP=87-88 Ch de Villegeorge Haut-MedocCru Bourgeois Sup 13/14/15/16 16 RP=91-93 10 RP=86 06/05 Very Successful Hachette 10/09 05 RP=84-86 Ch Villemaurine St-Emilion GC 14/15/16 16 TWCI=93 15 RP=87-89 15 $13-25WineS 12 Cellar Selection WE 12 WE=92 12 $40 WE 10 ST=87 09 Bronze Decanter 12 08 WS=87 05 Very Successful Hachette 09 05 WS=89 Ch la Violette Pomerol 10/11/12/13/14/15/16 16 TWCI=97 15 100%Merlot 15 RP=92-94 208
15 WS=93 15 $275 WS 15 TWCI=98 15 JR=16 (88) 14 TWCI=95 14 JCLee=94 13 TWCI=92 13 JCLee=91 12 TWCI=96 11 TWCI=93 10 100% Merlot 10 ST=90 10 TWCI=99 09 100%Merlot 09 ST=88 09 One of Top 32 JJB 09 JJB=96-98 09 RP=92-94 09 TWCI=98 08 WS=87 08 RP=96-98 08 ST=92 08 WS=96 08 JCLee=95 07 RP=90 07 WS=85-88 07 ST=90-92 07 TWCI=92 06 RP=92 06 WS=86 06 $202 WS 06 ST=89-92 06 TWCI=93 06 JR=15.5 (86) Ch Vircoulon Bordeaux 14/15 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=86 15 $10 WE 14 Cited Wine Hachette 17 Bordeaux Sup 13/14/15 15 Best Buy WE 15 WE=88 15 $10 WE 14 Very Successful Hachette 17 Ch de Virecourt Pillebourse Bordeaux Sup 14/15 14 WS=84 14 $15 WS 10 Merlot 10 WS=88 10 $16 WS 08 Gold Brussels 10 08 Bronze Bordeaux 10 08 Comm’d Decanter, IWC 10 08 $12 Dec 05 WE=82 05 $10 WE
Virginie Thunevin Bordeaux 14/15 15 RP=88-90 15 $15 WAlert
Ch Vrai Canon Bouche Canon Fronsac 13/14/15 15 #15 Top Value < $30 WS 15 WS=91 15 $22 WS 12 RP=90-92 11 RP=87-89 10 95%Merlot-3%CF-2%Malbec 10 WS=89 10 $25 WS 10 RP=92 10 TWCI=88-90 09 Merlot-CF 09 RP=91-93 08 RP=91-94 07 100% Merlot 07 RP=89 07 ST=89 07 JMQ=87
Ch Vray-Croix-de-Gay Pomerol 12/13/14/15/16 95%Merlot-CF 16 TWCI=93 16 $64 JJB 16 WDecider=92 16 $65 K&L 16 CT=87 (1) 16 $67 Millesima 15 RP=89-91 15 $55-70WAlert 15 WS=89 15 $62 WS 15 TWCI=91 15 $58 JJB 15 JCLee=88 15 $70 Millesima 15 WDecider=93 15 JR=16.5 (90) 14 CT=88.5 (2) 14 TWCI=90 14 $79 Millesima 14 JR=16 (88) 209
14 WDecider=90 13 TWCI=88 13 JCLee=86 13 WDecider=89 12 Very Successful Hachette 16 12 JR=16.6 (90) 12 WDecider=91 12/11 TWCI=89 11/10/09/08 Very Successful Hachette 11 WDecider=90 10/09 WDecider=92 10/09 TWCI=90 09 RP=90-93 08 WS=89 08 RP=87-89 08 TWCI=89 08 WDecider=90 07 WE=88 07 $67 WE 07 WS=87 07 ST=87 07 WDecider=87 06 Vin Remarquable Hachette 10 06 ST=87-90 06 WS=88 06 $48 WS 06/05 WDecider=89 05 Vin Remarquable Hachette 09 05 WE=91 05 WS=91 05 $114 WS 05 RP=88-90 05 TWCI=86
Xavier Flouret Blaye Cotes de Bordeaux Quai Lumiere 13/14/15 14 WS=86 14 $20 WS
Ch Yon-Figeac St-Emilion GC 12/13/14/15/16 16 TWCI=88 15 RP=87-89 15 $30 WAlert 09 Bronze Decanter 12 08 WS=86 07 Comm’d Decanter 10 06 Bronze Decanter 09 06 WE=92 06 $36 WE 06 WS=87 Yvon Mau Bordeaux Premius 14/15/16 14 Cited Wine Hachette 17 10 Bronze Decanter 12 08 Silver Brussels 10 See also: Ch Brown Ch Ducla Ch Lapellatrie Ch de Lussac Ch Preuillac Ch Taillefer Ch Tauzinat Ch Trimoulet
*Alphabetical by family/main name
6/18/19
210