DOCSLIB.ORG

Anterior Interval Release) to Treat Anterior Knee Pain After ACL Reconstruction

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Anterior Interval Release) to Treat Anterior Knee Pain After ACL Reconstruction Ch18.qxd 10/05/05 4:59 PM Page 295 18 Lysis of Pretibial Patellar Tendon Adhesions (Anterior Interval Release) to Treat Anterior Knee Pain after ACL Reconstruction Sumant G. Krishnan, J. Richard Steadman, Peter J. Millett, Kimberly Hydeman, and Matthew Close Abstract comes in the treatment of recalcitrant anterior We report the clinical results of an anterior knee pain after ACL reconstruction. interval release for recalcitrant anterior knee pain associated with decreased patellar mobility Introduction after anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) recon- Arthroscopic anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) struction. reconstruction has become one of the most Thirty consecutive patients with recalcitrant commonly performed procedures in orthopedic anterior knee pain and decreased patellar mobil- surgery and knee reconstruction.13,14,21 Over the ity after ACL reconstruction underwent an last decade, the results of arthroscopic ACL arthroscopic lysis of adhesions and scar of the dis- reconstruction have remained outstanding in tal patella tendon from the proximal anterior tibia most peer-reviewed series, regardless of surgical (anterior interval release). Anterior knee pain was technique.13,21 However, the published literature initially treated nonoperatively. Failure of nonop- regarding postoperative complications after erative treatment was defined by recalcitrant ACL reconstruction remains quite sparse.5,6,10,38 anterior knee pain and no improvement in func- Anterior knee pain is a well-documented com- tional outcome, assessed by Lysholm scores and plication after arthroscopic ACL reconstruction patient questionnaires. Minimum clinical follow- and has been reported as the most common com- up was 2 years. All anterior interval release proce- plaint after ACL surgery.1,6,10,19,30,31,34,38 While the dures were also performed by the senior author initial studies reported anterior knee pain after using a high inferolateral viewing portal in order patellar tendon autograft reconstruction, recent to arthroscopically evaluate the anterior interval work confirms a real incidence of anterior knee between the patella tendon and tibia. Prior to pain even after hamstring or allograft ACL recon- anterior interval release, Lysholm score aver- struction.1,32 Consequently, the etiology of this aged 68 (range 18–90). Postoperative Lysholm anterior knee pain remains elusive and contro- score averaged 85 (range 68–100) (P < 0.0001). versial.6,12,24,27,32 Postoperative range-of-motion did not change Paulos et al.26,27 were the first to describe the significantly. Postoperative instability examina- “infrapatellar contracture syndrome (IPCS),” an tions were all graded zero using the International “exaggerated pathologic fibrous hyperplasia” of Knee Documentation Committee (IKDC) system. soft tissue in the anterior knee after intra-articu- Average patient satisfaction at follow-up was 8.0 lar surgery and specifically after ACL reconstruc- (1 = very dissatisfied; 10 = very satisfied). tion. IPCS can create significant arthrofibrosis, Early operative intervention with an anterior loss of knee motion, decreased patellar mobility interval release has been shown in this series to (“patellar entrapment”), and even patella infera. result in significantly improved functional out- The diagnosis of IPCS according to these authors 295 Ch18.qxd 10/05/05 4:59 PM Page 296 296 Etiopathogenic Bases and Therapeutic Implications was based on a “decrease in patellar mobility as 90°, and no warmth of the knee relative to the compared with the opposite knee,” zero or nega- contralateral side.7,33 Intraoperatively, no tive passive patellar tilt, and less than 2 cm of patient demonstrated other ligament pathology superior/inferior patellar glide. Without appro- in addition to the ACL injury. Seventeen priate identification and aggressive treatment, patients underwent concurrent meniscus IPCS after ACL reconstruction results in signifi- trephination, and no patients underwent a cant functional morbidity. meniscus repair. Postoperative rehabilitation Several others have also documented the inci- followed the same protocol: full passive and dence of adhesions of the patellar tendon to the active range-of-motion exercises (with emphasis anterior tibia after arthroscopic proce- on terminal extension), crutches in the immedi- dures.2,4,8,15,16,20,22,26-29,33,36,37 Ahmad et al.2 ate postoperative period with progressive full demonstrated the biomechanical effect of such weightbearing, and a hinged knee brace for the patellar tendon adhesions to the anterior tibia. first 6 postoperative weeks. Strengthening exer- These authors documented an effective patella cises did not begin until full range-of-motion infera when the patellar tendon was adhesed to was achieved. the anterior tibial cortex in this pretibial recess. All 30 patients complained of disabling ante- The adhesions were shown to significantly alter rior knee pain within 6 weeks of the ACL recon- both patellar and tibial kinematics and contact – struction. All Lachman examinations were potentially increasing patellofemoral and graded zero using the International Knee tibiofemoral contact forces that may eventually Documentation Committee system (IKDC). result in arthrosis.2,8,15,35,41 Physical examination demonstrated signifi- We have encountered a population of patients cantly restricted passive patellar and patellar with recalcitrant anterior knee pain after ACL tendon mobility relative to the contralateral reconstruction that have failed conservative side, both in medial/lateral and in superior/infe- treatment and have subtle alterations in patellar rior excursion. All patients demonstrated less mobility despite a full range of flexion and than 2 cm of superior/inferior passive patellar extension. To our knowledge, this clinical entity excursion, decreased medial/lateral passive and its appropriate treatment have not yet been patellar excursion relative to the contralateral described. We report here the clinical results of side, and an inability to passively “tilt” the infe- an arthroscopic release of pathologic adhesions rior pole of the patella away from the anterior in the pretibial recess (anterior interval release) tibial cortex (Figure 18.1).20,28 Range-of-motion in these patients to treat the anterior knee pain. in all 30 patients averaged 0° of extension (range 5° of hyperextension to a 3° lack to full exten- Materials and Methods sion) and 140° of flexion (range 130°–155°). No Between 1992 and 1998, 30 consecutive patients patients demonstrated either a 10° or greater with recalcitrant anterior knee pain after isolated loss of knee extension or a 25° or greater loss of ACL reconstruction underwent an arthroscopic knee flexion.20,28 anterior interval release by the senior author. All Initial treatment consisted of nonsteroidal 30 patients had previously undergone arthro- anti-inflammatory (NSAID) medication, patellar scopic ACL reconstruction by the senior author, mobilization exercises, and closed-chain quadri- using a 2-incision technique and an ipsilateral ceps-strengthening exercises for a minimum of bone-patellar tendon-bone autograft with inter- 12 weeks in all 30 patients. Failure of conservative ference screw fixation. Mean age at the time of treatment was identified by recalcitrant anterior ACL reconstruction was 32 years (range 16–43 knee pain and no further improvement in func- years). There were 14 men and 16 women tional outcome as assessed by a standardized patients. For all 30 patients, the ACL reconstruc- patient questionnaire and the scoring system of tion was the first surgery performed on that Lysholm and Gillquist.39 knee. Mean duration between injury and ACL The anterior interval release was performed reconstruction was 6 weeks (range 2–16 weeks). at a mean duration of 9 months after the ACL No patient demonstrated abnormal posterior, reconstruction (range 6–12 months). Postope- posterolateral, varus, or valgus examinations. rative rehabilitation consisted of immediate pas- Criteria required before proceeding with ACL sive patellar mobilization exercises, immediate reconstruction included ability to perform a progressive weightbearing with crutches, and no supine straight-leg raise, flexion greater than brace. Ch18.qxd 10/05/05 4:59 PM Page 297 Lysis of Pretibial Patellar Tendon Adhesions (Anterior Interval Release) to Treat Anterior Knee Pain after ACL Reconstruction 297 Figure 18.1. Normal passive “tilt” of the inferior pole of the patella away from the anterior tibial cortex. Minimum clinical follow-up after the ante- tionnaire. The questionnaire documents pain, rior interval release was 2 years. All patients stiffness, function during daily and sporting were objectively examined by the senior author, activities, and satisfaction based on a 10-point functionally evaluated using the scoring system scale (1 point = very dissatisfied; 10 points = of Lysholm and Gillquist,39 and subjectively very satisfied). Statistical significance for data evaluated using a standardized patient ques- analysis was set at P < 0.05. Ch18.qxd 10/05/05 4:59 PM Page 298 298 Etiopathogenic Bases and Therapeutic Implications Surgical Technique for Arthroscopic (at the level of the meniscus) to approximately 1 cm distal along the anterior tibial cortex Anterior Interval Release (Figure 18.4B). Great care was taken to avoid Arthroscopy was performed with the arthroscope cauterizing or burning the bone of the anterior in an inferolateral portal relative to the patella tibia or the patellar tendon. Meticulous hemo- and the
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Arthroscopic Soft Tissue Releases of the Knee
    12 Arthroscopic Soft Tissue Releases of the Knee Michael R. Chen and Jason L. Dragoo Stanford University Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, USA 1. Introduction Intra-articular fibrosis, which includes a family of disorders such as anterior interval scarring, posterior capsular contracture, a tight lateral retinaculum, as well as arthrofibrosis, may lead to alterations in joint biomechanics and can result in pain. 1, 2, 3 Specific releases for each region of fibrosis, along with characteristic physical examination findings, have been described. Familiarity with the diagnosis and arthroscopic treatment of these disorders may lead to improved treatment outcomes in this patient population. 2. Anterior interval release 2.1 History and physical examination The anterior interval has been defined as the space between the infrapatellar fat pad and patellar tendon anteriorly, and the anterior border of the tibia and transverse meniscal ligament posteriorly.1 Trauma or previous surgery may cause hemorrhage or inflammation of the fat pad (Hoffa’s Syndrome), which may be followed by fibrosis. If fibrosis occurs between the fat pad and transverse ligament or anterior tibia, it will lead to dysfunction of the anterior knee structures, such as decreased excursion of the patellar tendon and result in stretching of the surrounding synovial tissue, which may lead to pain or even loss of knee extension. 1 Fibrosis within the anterior interval can exist on a spectrum of severity. Paulos et al. described infrapatellar contracture syndrome, a severe form of anterior interval scarring, with fibrosis of the fat pad and severe limitations in range of motion. 5 Patients with anterior interval scarring complain of anterior knee pain, and frequently describe a sense of fullness within the knee, especially with extension.
    [Show full text]
  • Arthroscopic Releases for Arthrofibrosis of the Knee
    Review Article Arthroscopic Releases for Arthrofibrosis of the Knee Abstract Michael R. Chen, MD Intra-articular inflammation or fibrosis may lead to decreased soft- Jason L. Dragoo, MD tissue and capsular compliance, which may result in pain or loss of motion within the knee. Etiology of intra-articular fibrosis may include isolated anterior interval scarring and posterior capsular contracture, as well as fibrosis that involves the suprapatellar pouch or arthrofibrosis that involves the entire synovial space. Initial nonsurgical management, including compression, elevation, and physical therapy, can decrease knee pain and inflammation and maintain range of motion. Surgical management is indicated in the patient who fails conservative treatment. Surgical options include arthroscopic releases of the anterior interval, posterior capsule, and peripatellar and suprapatellar regions. Recent advances in arthroscopic technique have led to improved outcomes in patients with intra-articular fibrosis of the knee. nee stiffness is a common compli- management of these disorders may Kcation associated with trauma or lead to improved outcomes in this surgery and has been extensively patient population. studied.1-3 Risk factors include injury severity, timing of surgery, delayed Pathophysiology of postoperative rehabilitation, pro- longed immobilization, infection, Arthrofibrosis complex regional pain syndrome, The exact etiology of intra-articular From the Department of and technical errors during intra- tissue fibrosis is unknown, but sev- Orthopaedic Surgery, Stanford articular and extra-articular recon- eral theories exist. Platelet-derived Hospital and Clinics, Redwood City, structive procedures. Extra-articular CA. growth factor and transforming stiffness may be caused by muscular growth factor-beta 1 are inflamma- Dr. Dragoo or an immediate family fibrosis and contracture, heterotopic member serves as a paid consultant tory cytokines produced by the in- to Genzyme and Össur and has ossification, or myositis ossificans.
    [Show full text]
  • Intraarticular Arthrofibrosis of the Knee Alters Patellofemoral Contact Biomechanics Jacob D
    Mikula et al. Journal of Experimental Orthopaedics (2017) 4:40 Journal of DOI 10.1186/s40634-017-0110-8 Experimental Orthopaedics RESEARCH Open Access Intraarticular arthrofibrosis of the knee alters patellofemoral contact biomechanics Jacob D. Mikula1, Erik L. Slette1, Kimi D. Dahl1, Scott R. Montgomery1,2, Grant J. Dornan1, Luke O’Brien1,3, Travis Lee Turnbull1 and Thomas R. Hackett1,2* Abstract Background: Arthrofibrosis in the suprapatellar pouch and anterior interval can develop after knee injury or surgery, resulting in anterior knee pain. These adhesions have not been biomechanically characterized. Methods: The biomechanical effects of adhesions in the suprapatellar pouch and anterior interval during simulated quadriceps muscle contraction from 0 to 90° of knee flexion were assessed. Adhesions of the suprapatellar pouch and anterior interval were hypothesized to alter the patellofemoral contact biomechanics and increase the patellofemoral contact force compared to no adhesions. Results: Across all flexion angles, suprapatellar adhesions increased the patellofemoral contact force compared to no adhesions by a mean of 80 N. Similarly, anterior interval adhesions increased the contact force by a mean of 36 N. Combined suprapatellar and anterior interval adhesions increased the mean patellofemoral contact force by 120 N. Suprapatellar adhesions resulted in a proximally translated patella from 0 to 60°, and anterior interval adhesions resulted in a distally translated patella at all flexion angles other than 15° (p < 0.05). Conclusions: The most important finding in this study was that patellofemoral contact forces were significantly increased by simulated adhesions in the suprapatellar pouch and anterior interval. Anterior knee pain and osteoarthritis may result from an increase in patellofemoral contact force due to patellar and quadriceps tendon adhesions.
    [Show full text]
  • Posterolateral Corner Knee Injuries
    7/23/2018 POSTEROLATERAL CORNER KNEE INJURIES Vishnu Potini, MD Director of Sports Medicine St. Francis Orthopaedic Institute; Columbus, GA Team Doctor: Brookstone School OUTLINE • Case • Background • Anatomy • Biomechanics • Clinical/Radiographic Evaluation • Treatment • Case CASE PRESENTATION • 17yo male s/p bicycle crash into tree • CC: L-knee pain, swelling • PMH: None • PSH: None • Meds: None • Allergy: NKDA 1 7/23/2018 PHYSICAL EXAM • Significant swelling L-knee • Motor: 0/5 TA, 0/5 EHL • Sensory: Decreased sensation over dorsum of foot • Pulses: ABI: PT > 1, DP>1 • (+) Lachman’s, (+) anterior/posterior drawer • (+) unstable to varus stress, (+) posterolateral drawer X-RAYS MRI 2 7/23/2018 MRI BACKGROUND • Multi-ligamentous knee injuries account for less than 1% of all Orthopaedic injuries • Isolated PLC injuries account for less than 2% of acute knee ligament injuries • Injuries to the posterolateral corner are infequent, often missed injuries • These multi-ligamentous injuries are often the result of knee dislocations, which may present after spontaneous reduction ANATOMY • Four primary ligamentous stabilizers of the knee • Cruciate ligaments • ACL • PCL • Collateral ligaments • MCL • LCL 3 7/23/2018 ANATOMY • Posterolateral corner (arcuate ligamentous complex) • Lateral collateral ligament • Popliteus tendon • Popliteofibular ligament • Posterolateral capsule ANATOMY • LCL • Primary static restraint to varus opening of the knee • Femoral insertion proximal and posterior to epicondyle • Popliteofibular ligament • Course distally
    [Show full text]
  • Posteromedial Corner Knee Injuries: Diagnosis, Management, and Outcomes a Critical Analysis Review
    | Posteromedial Corner Knee Injuries: Diagnosis, Management, and Outcomes A Critical Analysis Review Mark E. Cinque, MS Abstract » The posteromedial corner of the knee comprises the superficial Jorge Chahla, MD, PhD medial collateral ligament (MCL), deep MCL, posterior oblique Bradley M. Kruckeberg, BA ligament, oblique popliteal ligament, and posterior horn of the medial meniscus. The main medial knee structure is the superficial MCL. Nicholas N. DePhillipo, MS, ATC, OTC » Injuries to the medial knee are the most common knee ligament injuries. A comprehensive history and physical examination are key to Gilbert Moatshe, MD the diagnosis of a posteromedial corner injury. Patients often present Robert F. LaPrade, MD, PhD with swelling and pain over the medial joint line after an injury involving a valgus and external rotation force. The valgus stress and anteromedial drawer tests can aid the clinician in deciphering whether Investigation performed at the an isolated medial structure was injured or if a complete posterome- Steadman Philippon Research dial corner injury is likely. Institute, Vail, Colorado » Valgus stress radiographs can be utilized to quantify the amount of medial joint gapping. A side-to-side difference in gapping of 3.2 mm is consistent with an isolated superficial MCL tear, and a side-to-side difference of $9.8 mm is consistent with a complete posteromedial corner injury. Magnetic resonance imaging is also a useful tool in the detection of medial-sided injuries and has been reported to have an 87% accuracy. » Although a large number of medial knee injuries can be treated nonoperatively, complete posteromedial corner injuries may require surgical treatment to restore joint stability and biomechanics.
    [Show full text]
  • Arthrofibrosis of the Knee
    Arthrofibrosis of the Knee David Magit, MD Abstract Andy Wolff, MD Better understanding of surgical timing, improved surgical Karen Sutton, MD technique, and advanced rehabilitation protocols has led to Michael J. Medvecky, MD decreased incidence of motion loss after anterior cruciate ligament injury and reconstruction. However, motion loss from high-energy, multiligament injuries continues to compromise functional outcome. Prevention, consisting of control of inflammation and early motion, remains the key element in avoiding motion loss. However, certain techniques, such as manipulation under anesthesia in conjunction with arthroscopic lysis of adhesions, are reliable treatment options. Open surgical débridement is rarely necessary and should be considered only as a salvage procedure. A greater understanding of the pathogenesis of arthrofibrosis and related inflammatory mediators may result in novel therapies for treating the patient with motion loss. Dr. Magit is Orthopaedic Surgeon, The Greenwich Sports and Shoulder oss of knee motion is a devastat- tients with arthrofibrosis.1 Service, Orthopaedic and Neurosurgery Ling consequence of both single- Arthrofibrosis represents a wide Specialists PC, Greenwich, CT. Dr. and multiligamentous injury and spectrum of disease, ranging from lo- Wolff is Fellow, Steadman Hawkins their reconstruction. Increased recog- calized to diffuse involvement of all Clinic, Vail, CO. Dr. Sutton is Resident, nition of this problem in the past two compartments of the knee and of the Department of Orthopaedics and decades has led to better prevention extra-articular soft tissues. Preven- Rehabilitation, Yale University School of and improved management of these tion of motion loss remains essential Medicine, New Haven, CT. Dr. Medvecky injuries. Despite these advances, to successful outcome.
    [Show full text]