COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS APPEALS COURT 2017-P-0366 Exxon Mobil Corporation , Petitioner-Appellant., v. O ffice of the Attorney General , Respondent-Appellee. ON APPEAL FROM A FINAL ORDER OF THE SUPERIOR COURT IN SUFFOLK COUNTY BRIEF OF APPELLEE OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS MAURA HEALEY ATTORNEY GENERAL Melissa A. H offer (No . 641667) Richard A. Johnston (No. 253420) Chief, Energy and Environment Bureau Chief Legal Counsel Christophe G. COURCHESNE (No . 660507) Seth Schofield (No . 661210) Chief Environmental Protection Division Senior Appellate Counsel I. Andrew Goldberg (No . 560843) Assistant Attorneys General Assistant Attorneys General Energy and Environment Bureau Office of theAttorney General Office of the Attorney General One Ashburton Place, 18th Floor One Ashburton Place, 18th Floor Boston, Massachusetts 02108. Boston, Massachusetts 02108 (617) 963-2436 May 31, 2017
[email protected] TABLE OF CONTENTS Page Table' of Authorities.............................. iii Addendum Table of Contents ......................... ix Statement of the Issues............................. 1 Statement of the Case............................... 2 Statement of Legal and Factual Background ........... 6 I. The Massachusetts Consumer Protection Act and Civil Investigative Demands...........6 II. The Attorney General's Exxon Investigation................................ 9 A. The Bases for the Attorney General's Chapter 93A Investigation.................... 9 1. The Publicly Reported Evidence.............9