SPECIAL SECTION Harnessing Waves and Elastic Space

Liz Phillips

A s an artist, I use open systems to collaborate veillance through the use of bird- with audiences and to interact with the natural environment. call mimicry. When I walked along Sound in my work functions as a material (like steel or wood the tuned planks, the floors sang as or clay) and is both signal and music as it describes activity they once did to protect the castle’s in space. I began as a sculptor and migrated into music as original occupants [1]. Many large- electronic music opened up to include natural and electronic scale ancient architectural projects ABSTRACT sound and space. Sensing and harvesting sonic material al- were built with specific acoustics lows for dynamic transformations in composition. Stillness and made to respond to human inter- The author describes location, absence and presence, activity and nearness can be action. Churches with high bar- examples of her sculptural and abstracted from the material world. The creation of an inti- rel-vaulted ceilings enhance the installation works, which involve mate space and place for audience engagement (most often speaker’s voice, cause it to reverber- acoustics, electronics, visual in galleries and public spaces) provides one of the only ways ate and sound more “holy.” There elements and elements from natural environments. She also for the art audience to actively participate in abstraction. My is a long history of people harness- provides a background of histori- sound installation art is grounded in a consciousness of space, ing natural energy to enrich their cal works and influences. listening to architecture and an attention to the historical sig- environments. The early Greeks nificance of each site. designed the Aeolian harp, which is played when wind passes over its taut strings. ACOUSTIC STRUCTURES AND I responded to these older human-made acoustic structures. SOUND TECHNOLOGIES (I studied with the instrument-maker Gunnar Schoenbeck.) As The floors in the opening rooms in Ninomaru, a Japanese I began creating my own sound sculpture, I also embraced new imperial palace, are called the “nightingale floors.” Ninomaru technologies whose development I became involved in and was built in 1603 in Nijo Castle in Kyoto and designed for sur- that are crucial to my work. Early radio technology facilitated the creation by the Russian inventor Léon Theremin in 1919 of Liz Phillips (artist), 39-39 45th Street, Sunnyside, NY 11104, U.S.A. E-mail: . spond to a person’s movement in open space without physical

Fig 1. Windspun. (Photo © Liz Phil- lips) This was my working Input- Output Chart for the Hunts Point installation of Windspun.

©2009 ISAST LEONARDO MUSIC JOURNAL, Vol. 19, pp. 57–62, 2009 57 SOUND ART INFLUENCES Sound art did not develop independently; as a new art form it involved collaborative work with other people working in other media. The video artist , for example, was a mentor and colleague with whom I often shared ideas. He stud- ied music in Japan and electronic music in Germany before he created his first . In Magnet TV (1965), the im- age on a TV is “pulled” into shape by a large magnet above the TV. The electro- magnetic fields create abstractions. After this work, he created the Paik/Abe Video Synthesizer (1969) to gain more control of color and shape through electronic color processing and synthesis. Although this work was in another medium, its use of electronics to artistically shape output was highly influential in my work. One of the first stirring interactive sound sculptures was Jean Dupuy’s Heart Beats Dust (1967). I saw it at the Museum of Modern Art’s 1968 exhibition The Machine as Seen at the End of the Me- chanical Age. A cone of light shines into the box. Different exhibitions use a tape of heartbeats, and/or the visitor’s pulse as taken from a touch sensor. Ampli- fied heartbeats elevate red dust (Lithol Rubine, a pigment able to remain sus- pended in air for long periods). Human physicality becomes interactive when es- sential body rhythms activate space. In- teractive sound art has a unique ability to engage physical conditions such as the beating heart [3]. In my 1970 work Sound Structures, I was interested in how space becomes tangible for the audience. The theremin makes audible the distance between hands and antenna through sound; Jean Dupuy’s piece uses the sound of the hu- man heart to fill space with dust. In Sound Fig. 2. Windspun. (Photo © Mary Lucier) Opening event for Windspun at The Bronx Frontier Structures, a radio frequency capacitance Development Corporation. The art opening was sponsored by Creative Time at the Hunts field is radiated from a rectangle of metal Point alternative energy and composting site in 1981. under a rug. Sound is picked up on AM radios throughout the room. The sound contact [2]. Built with radio-frequency lations that were continuously changing. changes because one’s body conducts, oscillators, it responds to the distance With interactive sound, works traverse grounding the field. There is no sound between one’s hand and each antenna immediate performance and deal with until someone enters the threshold area with shifts in the pitch and amplitude of present, past and altered time. With at the outer edge of the field. As a person an oscillator. The theremin plays a single new electronic memory and digital con- moves toward the center, the frequency voice in response to immediate motion. trol, information and sounds change in of the sound emitted by the radios goes Analog sensing and synthesis made it inverse and proportional relationships higher and heterodynes through the ra- possible for me to create installations in and are delayed and accumulated. dios. People can experience the conduc- which changes in light or motion could Through sound synthesis, the ampli- tivity of their bodies in the space. As they be detected and played back as sound, tude, pitch, timbre, modulations and form chains (and touch things and each light and video. Sound could fill a space durations of sound events can be other), the surface area that their collec- and create an immersive tuned environ- activated and manipulated. An evolv- tive bodies are covering becomes larger. ment, whereas light could only be cast ing time- and space-specific artwork The conductivity to ground is stronger. on surfaces and/or seen in video on takes place without the presence of They hear these changes as changes in monitors. Analog sensing and synthesis the artist in a gallery or public space pitch. The frequency ranges become made it possible to create sound instal- setting. exponentially closer as the number of

58 Phillips, Harnessing Waves and Elastic Space Fig. 3. Wavetable, metal table, transducer, water, amplifier, oscillators and aluminum bowl, 44 × 42 × 14 in, 2002. (Photo © CJ Cartiglia) The first Wavetable in my backyard in Sunnyside, NY. people increases. Each space conducts and go from silence. People standing still sound events in multiple time periods. differently. The sub-audio edge of the build up sounds with their presence. The During my first 4 years of making sound field is felt at a different distance based integrating and proportioning of stored sculptures, I was dealing with the human on the room’s conductivity, humidity potential energy based on activity in time figure in relationship to a room as an in- and the temperature. People gather in and space is a key element. Many layers strument using synthesized sound. Then groups to shift the “sound walls” because of sound work together, responding in I was commissioned to make a piece for of their collective energy. different ways to presence and absence, the opening year of Artpark, in Lewiston, After Sound Structures I continued to stillness and activity in threshold spaces. NY, near Niagara Falls, one of the first make some of the first open systems in Sometimes I want people to feel as if they parks made for showing outdoor tem- galleries, which asked audiences to work had gone for a walk in the woods and porary artworks. Instead of electronic collectively to hear their parameters. stepped on many plants, or damaged a sound, I decided to use the sound of the I wanted to make work that could be garden, or grabbed something and taken river and record the river at different shifted, with the potential for growth and it away with them, upon entering a space stages from the bank before and after dynamic transformation over time, and close to a sensor/object. Everyone plays a the waterfall. I used the movement of the involved the audience in the process of part in the resultant sound patterns left audience down a pathway in the park to sculpting space. In these later analog in- behind. carve (filter) through the sound that was stallations, an electrical charge is stored set in multiple speakers along the path- based on the directions of people’s move- way. My participation in Artpark gave me ment. As a visitor moves toward a sensor, if SOUND SCULPTURES a chance to use natural sound. After that the voltage gets higher this fills (charges) AND SOUNDSCAPES I began to explore the more active, cy- a large capacitor (with a diode). It re- I define elastic space as the experience clical parts of nature, such as wind, fish leases in its own time, or a switch sam- of audience members when they gesture, and water. In these works, I use similar ples and holds that voltage and thus that traverse across or stand still in space to processing and control systems but col- tuning. People cause a sound to move in shape sound events: They can stretch lect different material, timings, tunings real time as they walk toward an object. and manipulate and store potential and proportions. The sound remains when they leave and energy or digital material so that their My wind-activated sound installation fades slowly away. Speed and direction current movement takes on an altered Windspun for Minneapolis (1980) (Fig. of movement control how sounds come significance that manifests itself through 1) uses electronics as a tool to continu-

Phillips, Harnessing Waves and Elastic Space 59 ously carve a soundscape from the sur- emometer causes sounds to strengthen up and abbreviated during stronger roundings in which the work is heard. and fade, up and down. When the wind winds. These shaped envelopes of sound Windspun was formed with lower-power starts it sounds like breathing. Faster imitate the process of the wind forming microcircuits. It responds to its environ- winds become rhythms. The fastest cre- sand dunes by pushing, dropping and ment by sensing wind speed and direc- ate drones. Each anemometer functions sliding masses of particles. The total ef- tion and the presence of each person in as a small windmill, generating more fect of these voices ranges from chatter to the installation space. Atmospheric ki- energy as the wind blows at higher ve- clusters of notes to surprising improvisa- netics create wind patterns that in turn locities. One anemometer is on the wa- tory singing and bellowing. are changed into sound patterns. An ter. The other is placed higher, with the My second installation with this wind/ erector-set construction that stands in weathervane, to pick up more general sound synthesis system, Windspun, took the pool supports the weathervane and wind. The eight directions of the wind are place at Bronx Frontier Development two anemometers. It carries circuits and picked up by the weathervane and shift Corporation’s alternative energy site on also supports a bronze screen embedded the pitched tunings of the two drones. the East River, in cooperation with Cre- in clear Plexiglas. This screen radiates The drones tell the direction and speed ative Time [4] (Fig. 2). A wind turbine radio frequency capacitance fields that of the wind. A trigger is caused by com- powers the site-specific installation. The sense the presence, speed and direction paring the changing voltages of the two speakers are contained in the wind tower of people walking on stepping stones. anemometers, creating a gong sound. It and tuned to resonate up and down the The audience/participants listen and shifts pitch and timbre with the wind di- inner chamber. The piece is tuned to manipulate details of the wind/sound rection. The gong is like a bell buoy. play in relation to the low shifting hum construct. Wild sounds improvise with the ges- of the turbine’s blades in motion. Birds tures of the wind. These electronic voices nested inside the turbine and sang with create pitches sampled from comparing the “voices” of the piece. One of the WIND-ACTIVATED the amplitudes of the two anemometers. “drawbacks” was that at night, when the SOUND PIECES With stronger wind, the pitches occur pitches were high, wild dogs came and Extraordinary weather conditions aided in a wider range of frequencies. The howled at the piece. Windspun for Minneapolis, my first wind- wind direction determines the scales of In 1984, I made a piece called Zephyr, activated sound piece. The New Music the pitches chosen. Single-tone voices a wind-activated installation that commu- America Festival 1980 coincided with a (notes) are activated when the winds nicated over larger spaces, using phone tornado watch, so the wind was active and slow. Larger envelopes of sound (lots of lines connected to anemometers to send would rapidly change direction. Each an- notes) are shaped, combined and faded information from two distinct locations

Fig. 4. Ginkgo Afterglow, Safe-T Gallery installation: four paper banner speakers with pressed leaves made by Rii Kanzaki, photos of ginkgo leaves on pathway by Heidi Howard made into 15-ft-long wall print, radiometer field sensing light and motion using infrared light, MIDI- controlled synthesizer and amplifier, 2007. (Photo © Liz Phillips; courtesy of Don Burmeister, Safe-T Gallery)

60 Phillips, Harnessing Waves and Elastic Space Fig. 5. Ginkgo Afterglow, Safe-T Gallery installation: detail of radiometer, 2007. (Photo © Don Burmeister) in Minneapolis. The lobby of the Walker emanates two kinds of responses to the them to create a minimum of controlled Art Center and the gallery of the Univer- ambient sounds picked up by a single feedback. There is a call-and-response sity of Minnesota offered playback areas, microphone. The first response comes relationship between the wavetable and and parts were broadcast by the college from low-frequency oscillators tuned to the audience. The tempo of events and radio station. Anemometers and weather- the resonant frequencies of the table. curves of response are a result of the vanes were set up outside of both loca- All these low frequencies make differ- coordination of the audience and the tions, with the data sent on phone lines ent waves. Waves fade up and down in parameters and tunings of the elec- through a homemade modem. Changes response to audience loudness, pitches tronic sound system. It is always chang- in wind speed and direction and weather and the sequence of events (using sev- ing and must be reconfigured in each across the city are audible. Because of the eral envelope followers and their inverse location. new possibility of communicating world- integrated [smoothed] curves). The Ginkgo Afterglow (2007), first installed wide through satellites and the Internet, second kind of audio is digitally delayed at Safe-T gallery in Brooklyn, used radi- larger weather installations can now be and transposed audio voices and whistles ometers and infrared to pick up audi- modeled. responding to the room’s ambience. A ence activity and changes in light to make Wavetable (2003) elaborated on my ex- homespun limiter function makes the sound that was played back through ploration of waves (Fig. 3). In Wavetable quietest sounds in the room enough to homemade paper and dry leaf banners, an aluminum table is tuned like a steel create changes in the table’s waves. The which became the loudspeakers (Fig. drum, with resonant frequencies, and audience talks, walks, sings and whistles, 4). Rii Kanzaki (who created the paper played by a transducer attached to the constantly shifting ranges and responsive with pressed gingko and maple leaves) bottom of the table to move the water in voices (whether consciously or unaware). and I stretched these paper speakers at the table into visible wave patterns and The system responds in multiple ways. It angles across ceilings and down walls to to create tuned audio voices. This table also takes the loudest sounds and lowers cause sound to emanate throughout the

Phillips, Harnessing Waves and Elastic Space 61 Fig. 6. Elastic Space, performance/ installation, bronze screen, armature wire, capacitance fields, computer, synthesizer, speak- ers, amplifier, pedestals, 2008. (Photo©Jodi Chang) This work in progress was created in the Sculpture Atrium at University of California at Santa Barbara, as part of my IHC Residency project in January 2008. Audience/ participant Adam Cruz is first to connect into the human sculpture.

gallery. The sound comes from samples mation to create extremely elastic MIDI References of walking on paths of dry leaves and controls directly from the radio oscillator 1. . particles scattering. The sounds are ac- information. In another rendition of this 2. . tivated and shifted by changes in the air, project, I attach wire to volunteer per- light and heat in the gallery. An array of formers from the audience so that they 3. . radiometers (Fig. 5) and infrared sensors become transmitters and receivers on the shift the MIDI controls. There is also a pedestals. As the performers change po- 4. Creative Time, a not-for-profit art organization, helped to sponsor the opening events, publicity and 15-foot-long print (made from photos by sition, they shift the shape and sound of posters and act as a financial sponsor for this work. Heidi Howard) of fallen leaves on a path- the fields radiated around them. Other 5. Simon-Philippe Breton and Geir Moe, Renewable way. The sound installation is intended audience members/participants move Energy: An International Journal 34, No. 3 (2009) pp. to capture the scattered leaf pattern and in to be a part of this dynamic audience 646--654. yellow pool of light that I observed on sculpture. the pathway. Leaves and paper share a common sound character that transposes WIND AND ENERGY, well through the paper speakers in this Manuscript received 2 January 2009. installation. FUTURE PROJECTS Elastic Space (2008) was first shown as As a result of limited fossil fuels, world- New York-based artist Liz Phillips (b. 1951) a work in progress during my residency wide demand for clean renewable wind has been making interactive multi-media at the University of California, Santa energy is rapidly increasing. Setting an installations for the past 40 years. Phillips received a B.A. from Bennington College in Barbara, in the sculpture atrium (Fig. example, Denmark currently receives 1973. In 1981, she co-founded Parabola Arts 6). The sensors’ data can self-adapt to 20% of its electricity from wind and plans Foundation, a not-for-profit organization changing conditions in the gallery. Elas- to reach 50% [5]. With the increase in that provides funding for art-related projects. tic Space uses the capacitance fields radi- turbine production, there is greater Phillips has made and exhibited interactive ated and received from a group of four space for an artistic response. New po- sound and multimedia installations at ven- brass screen objects/sculptures on ped- tentials for harvesting energy from waves, ues including The Whitney Museum of Amer- estals. I used armature wire to create the using piezo fibers so that the motion of ican Art, Milwaukee Art Museum, the San simplest forms and sew the screening to the waves can create enough energy to Francisco Museum of Modern Art, the Spoleto them. Their specific size and shape cre- run microcircuits, suggest the possibility Festival USA, the Walker Art Museum, Ars ates fragile human-scale fields with which of setting up monitoring stations on the Electronica, Jacob’s Pillow, The Kitchen and Creative Time. Phillips has also collaborated an audience can interact. Slight changes oceans. New types of rechargeable bat- with many artists, including the Merce Cun- in activity between these objects alter the teries can store sun and wind energy for ningham Dance Company, Nam June Paik, sound in the space. Sound is constantly continuous transmissions. I hope to use Earl Howard, Yoshimasa Wada and Alison evolving based on accumulated activity my sensitivities to nature, space and tech- Knowles. She also teaches classes in sound and processed by the computer program. A nology in my future work to celebrate interactive media at Purchase College and cu- hybrid computer system collects infor- these new energy sources. rates sound and space exhibitions.

62 Phillips, Harnessing Waves and Elastic Space