Eye (1987) 1, 585-592
Normal Rabbit Aqueous Humour, Fibronectin, and Fibroblast Conditioned Medium are Chemoattractant to Tenon's Capsule Fibroblasts
J. P. JOSEPH., I. GRIERSON and R. A. HITCHINGS London
Summary Some of the chemotactic and chemokinetic properties of rabbit Tenon's fibroblasts were examined in a 48-well micro-chemotaxis chamber. Normal rabbit aqueous humour, fibronectin, and fibroblast conditioned medium were used in the assay, and all were shown to be chemoattractant. In addition, aqueous humour was shown to be powerfully chemotactic. Since the failure of human trabeculectomies is associated with migration of fibroblasts to the operation site, the study of the chemoattractant influences acting on these cells may allow manipulation of their behaviour in order to influence favourably the outcome of surgery.
Of the trabeculectomies that fail the majority context. Although fibroblast chemotaxis has
do so because of fibrosisat the operation site. I been studied at other sites in the body, evi Factors leading to fibrosis and the role of dence suggests that fibroblasts in different aqueous humour in the success or failure of locations behave differently. It! The present the procedure are poorly understood. Teng et study was undertaken to elucidate some of the al." proposed that aqueous had a degenerative chemoattractant influences acting on ocular effect on collagen. Kornblueth et al.' pro fibroblasts and to determine the chemotactic posed that there is an inhibitory factor for activity of normal rabbit aqueous humour. fibroblast proliferation and iris tissue present in aqueous humour, while Herschler postu Material and Methods lated the existence of an inhibitory factor for Fibroblasts Biopsies of Tenon's capsule and fibroblastspresent in normal aqueous humour sclera were taken from 5 New Zealand White rab and absent in glaucomatous aqueous.�·5.6.7 In a bits. These primary explants were placed in 25 cm' model of failing fistulising surgery in the rab plastic tissue cultureflasks (Sterilin) and incubated at 37 degrees C in 5 per cent CO,/95 per cent air. bit, Miller et al. � have shown that fibroblast migration to the operation site, together with The cultures were fed twice weekly with FlO medium with 10 per cent new born calf serum. fibroblast proliferation, play a fundamental containing 100 units per ml of streptomycin and role in the obstruction of the fistula.I n spite of penicillin, and 0.25 units per ml of amphotericin B. work having been done on fibroblast anti Cells grown from the primary explants reached proliferative agents,9little attention has been confluence within 3 to 4 weeks. whereupon the paid to the chemotaxis of these cells in this cultures from thefive different animals were bulked
From The Institute of Ophthalmology. London. and Moorfields Eye Hospital. Correspondence to: Dr. Ian Grierson, The Institute of Ophthalmology. 17-25 Cayton Street. London ECI V9 9AT. This paper is based on a poster displayed at the Ophthalmological Society of the United Kingdom Annual Congress in April 1987. 586 J. P. JOSEPH ET AL.
degrees C for 20 minutes. They were then washed twice in glass distilled water, following which they were placed in a solution containing 5 mgll Porcine gelatin type 1, 300 bloom (Sigma) in distilled water at 100 degrees C for one hour. The membranes were then air dried, and subsequently placed in an oven 100 � at degrees C for one hour. II -' w (b) Fibronectin. Membranes were placed in solu U a tion of 100 Ilglml of bovine fibronectin (Sigma) I- �4eeZ in distilled water for 30 minutes and then air
w dried. " J: C (c) Poly-L-Lysine. Membranes were soaked in I '" per cent Poly-L-Lysine (MW>10Q,OOO Sigma) ... o in distilled water for two hours and then o z2ee - washed in distilled water for two hours.'�
-pvp +PVP G F P TYPE OF MEMBRANE
Fig. 1. Gmpll showing lire adherence rOle Ilfrabbit Tenoll's fibroblasts to vGriol(s kinds of polycorbontlle membr(llles: - PVP '" P/l!yvillyl-Pyrallidiue Free;
= =. + PV P Witl! Polyvillyl.Pyrollidble; G Gelatin and PVP;F = FibrolleClill alief PVP; P = Pal.v-L-Lysine lind PVP. The sClml! IIlll1lber of cells was a(/tied to chambers ct)nrainillg the 5 types of membrane. Aiter 4 hOllrs il/cuba/ioll. tile cdlsarrnchet!I{) the membranes ill fifdds indiviciual 20 !.ODDx were COWlIl!d. FOllr cham bers were COHIllI'dfor <'(ICh IIIl!lI1bmll€'. Bars show lhe
111(.'1111; lilies the S. E. M.
together and passaged. Split ratios varied from 1-4 to 1-10. Tenon'S fibroblasts were used between passages 2 and 4 in the chemotaxis experiments; Fig. 2(a). Seal/lling electroJl microgfllplr of a Telloll's
scleral fibroblastswere used to prepare conditioned fibrOblast with a pro"ess passing into all 8 wn diamecl!r medium at 2nd passage. pore (P) ill The po�vcarb(llltuemembrmle.
Chemotaxis Chemotaxis was undertaken in .a 48-well micro-chemotaxis chamber (Neuro Probe, Cabin John, Maryland), based on the original Boy x 80 den Chamber. II Polycarbonate membranes25 8 mm, \0 j.un thick and with pores �un in diameter were llsed (Nucleopore, Pleasanton, California). Membranes are available with or without the wet PVP). ting agent polyvinyl-pyrrolidine (+ PVP or - As obtained from the manufacturer, membranes with polyvinyl-pyrrolidine would not allow satis factory adherence of fibroblasts and the morphol ogy of cells adherent to the PYP free membranes was highly abnormal. Accordingly, membranes Fig. 2(b). Lighl micrograph showing cells that II(/Ile with PYP were treated in the following way to slIccess/iclly migraled through the pores and lire promote the adherence of the cells: adherent (0 the membrane. Blllrs illlhe background are in (a) Gelatin. Membranes were placed a glass cells adherfnl to the membrane Ihlll h(llfp. /lot yet beilker containing 0.5 per cent acetic acid at 50 migraTed. T!;NON'S CAPSULE FIBROBLASTS 587
from the chamber, placed in 100 per cent ethanol lee - for 30 seconds, air dried, and stained with haematoxylin. Membranes were mounted on a glass slide and then examined with a light microscope at 1,000x ge - magnification (Olympus, Tokyo). The number of cells that had migrated through the pores, towards the chemoattractant. was estimated by counting cell nuclei on the distal side of the membrane. I/) 60 ..... Twenty fields were examined for each of the 48 ..... w chambers. This represented 0.54 mm2 or IflSth of (J Ll. the membrane corresponding to each chamber. A o c5 40 membrane was also prepared for scanning and Z transmission electron microscopy (Fig. 2).
20 - Fibronec/in Bovine fibronectin (Sigma) was stored at -20 degrees C until used. In all chem otaxis assays of fibroblast conditioned medium and
aqueous humour, fibronectin was run as a positive
FIBRONECTIN (pg/ml)
Fig. 3. Dose response curve offibronectin. Cells that have successfully migrated through the pores haye been counted in 20 1,000x fields (0.54 mml). Each point is the meall of three chambers. Bars are standard errOrS of the mean.
Membranes with PVP. treated with gelatin, allowed the greatest fibroblastadherence rate (Fig. 1) as well as normal fibroblast morphology. Accordingly, gelatinised membranes were used in all the chemoattraction experiments. All mem branes were used shiny side up in the chemotaxis chamber, according to the manufacturer's instruc tions. Chemoattractants were added to the lower chambers of the array and dilutions were made with serum free FlO medium. The fibroblasts were used just on becoming con fluent, approximately4-7 days after passaging. The cells were removed from their culture flasksby brief exposure (3 minutes) to 0.25 per cent Trypsin and 0.02per centEDTA. Exposure totrypsin for longer DAYS SINCE PREPARATION than this leads to a reduction of chemotactic Fig. 4. Graph showing rhe decline in the relatiye activity.12 Cells were suspended in 10 ml FIO with 10 chemoatrractiveness offibroblast conditioned medium per cent new born calf serum, and centrifuged at over time. The medil{m was stored at -20 degrees C. 300 g for 10 minutes, following which they were The chemoallractive activity was measured as the ratio washed once with serum free FlO. Cell counts were of the number of cells in 20 1,00OXfields migrating to made using a Coulter counter, and they were finally fibroblast conditioned medium versus the number of cells in 20 1 ,000x fieldsmigrating to an optimal dose of suspended at a concentration of 7 lOs cells/ml. x fibronectin. Initially fibroblast conditioned medium Fifty fAl of cell suspension was added to each of the 2 was to 3 times asactive asfibronectin; afrel' storage for top chambers of the array. 28 days this had reduced to about 0.5 times the activity. The micro-chemotaxis chamber was incubated at Each poim is the mean of 3 observations. Sumdard 37 degrees C in 5 per cent COl/95 per cent air for 4 errors of the mean for fibroblast conditioned medium hours. The polycarbonate membrane was removed were al/ less than 16 per cem. 588 J. P. JOSEPH ET AL. control, with serum free FlO medium as a negative aqueous retained its chemotactic activity for at least control. 6weeks.
Fibroblast Conditioned Medium A confluent cul- Results ture of scleral fibroblasts was washed three times Fibronectin is chemoattractant to rabbit Ten with phosphate buffered saline. It was then washed on's fibroblasts with an optimal dose of 20 twice with 10 ml of serum free FlO medium. and a r-tg/ml (Fig. 3). At doses higher than this there further 5 ml of this medium was incubated in the flask for 24 hours. This fibroblast conditioned is a slow decrease in effect. This continues to medium was centrifuged at 300 g for ten minutes to occur between 100 r-tg/ml and 1,000 ftg/ml remove floating cells. The supernatant was then (data not shown). The optimal dose of 20 aliquoted and frozen at -20 degrees C until used in r-tg/ml fibronectin has been used as a positive the chemotaxis assay." control in subsequent experiments. Boiling a solution containing this dose for 5 minutes is Aqueous Humour Nine New Zealand White rab sufficient to deactivate the chemoattractive bits (18 eyes) weighing approximately 2 kg were effect. used in the study. The rabbits were sacrificed by an Scleral fibroblast conditioned medium is overdose of barbiturates. Immediately post mor also strongly chemoattractant to Tenon's tem, a paralimbal transcorneal paracentesis was fibroblasts. When the conditioned medium made using a 25G needle and the aqueous humour 3 was allowed to drip from the end of the needle. was first prepared it was 2 to times as potent Approximately 100 III was obtained from each ani in its chemoattractive effect as an optimal mal. The aqueous was either used immediately or dose of fibronectin. After storage for 20 days was stored at -20 degrees C. Stored in this way the at -20 degrees C, fibroblast conditioned medium was approximately half as potent as fibronectin (Fig. 4). 2ee The response of the cells to the chemo I attractants varies considerably depending on S0 the conftuency of the culture, the time since
160 passaging, the time since the last feeding, and probably a number of other undefined factors. 140 - This makes comparison of results obtained on different days unreliable, in spite of using cnl20 .... positive and negative controls in each run. .... �Iee However, all the specimens of normal rabbit 0... aqueous humour were strongly chemoattrac S0 - 0 T tant, and the effect seen was always consider Z -- - 1------} --- � ------_J - -- - - ably greater than that of the optimal dose of 60 - - fibronectin. An initial dose response curve 40 F' was obtained using the aqueous from two eyes, as seen in Figure 5, where it is apparent 20 that the optimal concentration is between 10
0 per cent and 20 per cent aqueous humour. o 10 20 30 40 50 60 This dose response curve has been confirmed CONCENTRATION OF AQUEOUS HUMOUR (flo) four times. Using a smaller range of con Fig. 5. Graph showing the chemoallractive activity of centrations of aqueous humour it has been normal rabbit aqueous humour ( ) and of similar -- possible to compare 14 specimens (8 different aqueous humour that has been boiled for 5 minutes (- --i. The cell count was made in 20 I,OOOx fields. Each animals) simultaneously (Fig. 6). point is the mean of four chambers. The normal aque In a Zygmond-Hirsch 17 chequer board ous was taken from one eye of2 rabbits, while the boiled analysis of a sample of aqueous humour (Fig. aqueous was derived from their other eyes. Bars are 1 7), it appears that the aqueous exerts a pre S. E.M. 20 Ilglmlfibronectin caused 90 cells to migrate. dominantly chemotactic effect, while at low For 20 per cent aqueous, boiling reduces the chemoat tractiveness activity by about 65 per cent (p = 0.014 concentrations there is a chemokinetic effect, Mann- Whitney U test). which falls off at higher doses. Boiling rabbit ' TENON S CAPSULE FIBROBLASTS 589 20 f.lg/mlwas the optimal dose of fibronectin, a8 T the literature is confused on this and optimal T� doses of 1.2 f.lg/ml,16 20 f.lg/mPI and 100 f.lgl m115.22 have been mentioned. This may relate to differences in the measurement or prep aration of fibronectin, as well as to the source of the fibroblastsused in the assay, since fibro blasts of diverse origins may respond dif ferently to the same chemical mediator.1O Fibroblast conditioned medium is also a chemoattractant for rabbit Tenon's fibro blasts. This is interesting as it helps to explain the self perpetuating nature of scarring, Once 28 a few fibroblastshave been attracted to a heal ing trabeculectomy, they are able to call up reinforcements, and the process continues. Some of the factors known to be synthesised by fibroblasts are collagen, fibronectin, and proteoglycans. The former two are known to CONCENTRATION OF AQUEOUS HUMOUR (t.) be chemotactic to further fibroblasts.15,16.21.23 Fig. 6. Dose response curve of chemoallractive However, Mensing et at. proposed that there activity of normal rabbit aqueous humour. At 0 per cent is another, as yet unidentified, chemotactic aqueous (serum free FlO medium), point is the mean of 3 observations. Other points are the means of 14 aque ous specimens taken from 8 rabbits and run simul UPPER CHAMBERS taneously in a single 48-well chemotaxis chamber. Cells have been counted in 20 I ,000x fieldsfor each sample. Bars are I S. E. M. 20 !J.glml fibronectin caused 45 cells % Aqueous 0 4 10 20 to migrate. 4 per cent aqueous causes a highly signifi cant increase in the number of cells migrating across the membrane (p
moderate chemokinetic effect seen at low Tapper et at. .15 examined the migration of cap concentrations of aqueous was reduced at 20 illary endothelial cells in response to normal per cent aqueous, mitigates against a disrup rabbit aqueous humour, and found no stim tion of the barrier. Since protein can be chem ulatory activity. okinetic one would anticipate a far greater Rabbit eyes are known to exhibit a marked chemokinetic effect which would increase inflammatory response and to heal up a with higher concentrations of aqueous, had fistulising wound within 17 days.H A major ' TENON S CAPSULE FIBROBLASTS 591 part of this healing response may be attributa the mobilization of capillary endothelium. Inv ble to the intrinsic chemotactic activity of Mer 1'985,.5: 193-205. I'Seniot' RM. Gr�ffin GL, Mecham R1": Chemotactic 'fl(')rmal aqueous humour, for fibroblasts, as responses of fibroblasts to tropoelastin and elas demonstrated in this paper. The role of aque tin-derived peptides. ] Clin Invest 1982, 70: ous humour in the failure of human tra 614-8. beculectomies remains to be clarified, and 15 Mensing H, Pontz BF, Miiller PK, Gauss-MiillerV: further studies are currently being undertaken A study on fibroblast chemotaxis using fibronec to this end. tin and conditioned medium as chemoattrac tants. EurJ Cell Bioi 1983, 29: 268-73. 16Postlethwaite AE, Keski-Oja J, Balian G. Kang AH: Induction of fibroblast chemotaxis by fibro We gratefully acknowledge the generous financial nectin. Localization of the chemotactic region to support provided by the T. F. C. Frost Charitable a 140,000-molecular weight non-gelatin-binding Trust, the International Glaucoma Association and fragment. ] Exp Med 1981,153: 494-9. a MoorfieldsEndowment Grant. 17 Zigmond SH and Hirsch JG: Leukocyte locomotion and chemotaxis. New methods for evaluation, and demonstration of a cell-derived chemotactic References factor.] Exp Med 1973. 137: 387-410.
I Hitchings RA and Grierson I: Clinico pathological IX Grinnell F, Billingham RE,Burgess L: Distribution correlation in eyes with failedfistulizing surgery. of fibronectin during wound healing in vivo. ] Trans Opthalmol Soc UK 1983, 103: 84-8. Invest Dermatol1981, 76: 181-9.
2 Teng Cc, Chi HH, Katzin HM: Aqueous degenera 19 Hynes RO: Fibronectins. Scientific Am July 1983: tive effect and the protective role of endothelium 32-41. in eye pathology. Am ] Ophthalmol 1960, 50: 211 Reid T, Kenney MC, Waring G: Isolation and 365-79. characterization of fibronectin from bovine aque
3 Kornbleuth W and Tenebaum E: The inhibitory ous humor. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 1982, 22: effect of aqueous humour on the growth of cells 57-61.
in tissue culture. Am ] Ophthalmol 1956. 42: 21 Seppa HEJ, Yamada KM, Seppa ST, el at.: The cell 70-4. binding fragment offibronectin is chemotactic for 'Herschler J, Claflin AJ, Fiorentino G: The effect of fibroblasts. Cell Bioi In! Rep 1981,5: 813-9.
aqueous humor on the growth of subconjunctival 22 Albini A,Richter H. Pontz BF: Localization of the fibroblastsin tissue culture and is implications for chemotactic domain in fibronectin. FEBS 1983, glaucoma surgery. Am] Ophthalmol 1980; 89: 156: 222-6.
245-9. 23 Postlethwaite AE, Seyer JM, Kang AH: Chemotac .\ Herschler J: The inhibitory factor in aqueous humor. tic attraction of human fibroblasts to type I, II, Vis Res 1981, 21: 163. and III collagens and collagen-derived peptides.
o Burke J, Foster S, Herschler J: Aqueous humor as a Proc Nat Acad Sci 1978,75: 871-5. modulator of growth in fibroblast cultures. Curr 2' SeniorRM, GriffinGL, MechamRP, et al. : Val-Gly Eye Res 1983,2: 835-41. Val-Ala-Pro-Gly, a repeating peptide in elastin,
7 Radius RL, Herschler J, Claflin A, Fiorentino G: is chemotactic for fibroblasts and monocytes. ] Aqueous humor changes after experimental fil Cell Bioi 1984,99: 870-4.
tering surgery. Am ] Ophthalmol 1980, 89: 25 Seppa H, Grotendorst G, Seppa S, et al. : Platelet 250-4. derived growth factor is chemotactic for fibro
x Miller MH, Joseph NH, Ennis KW,et al. : An animal blasts. ] Cell Bioi 1982, 2: 179-201. model of filtration surgery. Trans Ophthalmol 26 Mensing H and Czarnetzki BM: Leukotriene B, Soc UK 1985, 104: 893-97. induces in vitro fibroblast chemotaxis. ] Invest
9 Gressel MG, Parrish RK, Folberg R: 5-Flourouracil Dermatol1094, 82: 9-12. and glaucoma filtering surgery: I. An animal 27 Senior RM, Skogen WF, Griffin GL, Wilner GD: model. Ophthalmol1984, 91: 378-83. Effects of fibrinogen derivatives upon the inflam
10 FreundlichB, Bomalaski JS, Neilson E, Jiminez SA: matory response. Studies with humanfibrinopep Regulation of fibroblast proliferation and col tide B.] Clin Invest 1986,77: 1014-9.
lagen synthesis by cytokines. Immunul Today 2X Wahl SM and Wahl LM: Modulation of fibroblast 1986, 7: 303-7. growth and function by monokines and Iympho II Boyden S: The chemotactic effect of mixtures of kines. Lymphokines 1981, 2: 179-201.
antibody and antigen on polymorphonuclear leu 29 Postlethwaite AE, SnydermanR, Kang AH: Gener kocytes. ] Exp Med 1962. 115: 453-66. ation of a fibroblast chemotactic factor in serum I� Postletbwaite AE, Snyderman R, Kang AH: The by activation of complement.] Clin Invest 1979, chemotactic attraction of human fibroblasts to a 64: 1379-85.
lymphocyte-derived factor.] Exp Med 1976,144: 10 Rosenbaum JT, Wong K, Perez HD, et al. : Charac 1188-201. terization of endotoxin-induced C5-derived
11 Ungari S, Katari RS, Alesandri G, Gullino PM: chemotactic activity in aqueous humor. Invest Cooperation between fibronectin and heparin in Ophthalmol Vis Sci 1984, 25: 1184-91. 592 J. P. JOSEPH ET AL.
epithelial cells. Arch Ophthalmol 1985, 103: 31 ZetterBR , Martin GR , Birdwell CR , Gospodarwicz D: Role of high-molecular weight glycoprotein in 576-9. Rosenbaum lT, Raymond W, Seymour BW, et al.: cellular morphology, adhesion and differentia 3' The effect of corticosteroids or nitrogen mustard tion. Ann NY Acad Sci1978, 312: 299 on aqueous humor chemotactic acivity induced Worthen D M and Cleveland PH: Fibronectin pro 32 by intravitreal endotoxin. c/in Immunol Immu duction by cultured human trabecular meshwork nopath1986,39: 414-20. cells. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 1982, 23: 265-9. 35 Tapper D, Scheimer C, Frissora H, Zetter B: The 33 Campochiaro P A and Glaser BM: Platelet-derived stimulation of capillary endothelial cell migration growth factor is chemotactic for human pigment by aqueous humor. J Surg Res1981, 30: 262-8.