1

IN THE HIGH COURT OF AT BANGALORE

DATED THIS THE 11 TH DAY OF OCTOBER 2013

PRESENT

THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE DILIP B BHOSALE

AND

THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE B MANOHAR

R.P.NO.281/2013 AND R.P.NO.814-885/2013

BETWEEN

1. K MUKUNDHA BHAT AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS S/O LATE SUBBARAYA BHAT KOWSTUBA NEAR BUS STAND TEKKATTE VILLAGE TALUK DISTRICT 576 231

2. LAKSHMINDRA BHAT AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS S/O LATE SADANANDA BHAT RAMANATH KRIPA R/A ULIYARGOLI VILLAGE KAPU,

3. SMT VANAJA SHETTY AGED ABOUT 65 YEARS D/O MUTTY SHETTY GURU EACHHE ULIYARGOLI VILLAGE KANP P.O SRI RAM NIVAS

4. SUNIL S KAMATH AGED ABOUT 66 YEARS S/O LATE SHESHAGIRI N KAMATH CANARA BANK BUILDING

2

R/A ULIYARGOLI VILLAGE, KAPU UDUPI DISTRICT

5. NEELADHAR L BANGERA AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS S/O LAXMAN B PUTTARAN MOOLUR VILLAGE POST UDILA, UDUPI DISTRICT 574 117

6. KATHEEJA AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS W/O MODIEEN MOHAMMED NEAR MASJID SHIRVA UDUPI TALUK UDUPI DISTRICT 574 116

7. M PRADEEP KUMAR AGED ABOUT 49 YEARS S/O PUTTAPPA SHETTY BITTUDA DHABA OPP POLICE OUT POST , UDUPI TALUK UDUPI DISTRICT

8. SHEIK SABAR ALI AGED ABOUT 64 YEARS S/O SHEIK UMAR SAHEB THENKA UDUPI TALUK & DISTRICT

9. MRS B FATHIMA BEGAM AGED ABOUT 64 YEARS W/O LATE ABDUL KHAR CANARA HOUSE YERMAL TENKA UDUPI DISTRICT

10. K VISHWANATH SHENOY AGED ABOUT 75 YEARS S/O LATE SARVOTHAM SHENOY PADU VILLAGE KAUP 574 106

3

11. S M NAUSHAD AGED ABOUT 66 YEARS S/O S M THAHIR KAUP POST 574 106

12. NAZEER ISMAIL AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS S/O LATE SHABUDDIN ISMAIL BIG HOUSE, KOMBAGUDDE KAUP POST, UDUPI 574 106

13. SMT KHATHIJABI D/O LATE SHABNAM MANZIL NEAR SUBASH ROAD UCHILA BADA, UDUPI TALUK UDUPI DISTRICT

14. MRS HAFEEZA ASGARI W/O S M NAUSHAD AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS SHABNAM MANZIL UCHILA POST, UDUPI TALUK UDUPI DISTRICT-574117

15. ASHOK RAJ AGED ABOUT 64 YEARS S/O Y S M HEGGDE AGRICULTURIST, YERMAL BEDU YERMAL 574 119 UDUPI TALUK UDUPI DISTRICT

16. RONALD LAWRANCE MARTIS AGED ABOUT 44 YEARS S/O VINCENT MARTIES OPP SRI VENKATARAMANA TEMPLE N H 17, POSAR MOODABETU VILLAGE KATAPADI 574 105 UDUPI TALUK AND UDUPI DISTRICT

4

17. REENA MARTIS AGED ABOUT 39 YEARS D/O VINCENT MARTIS OPP SRI VENKATARAMANA TEMPLE N H 17, POSAR, MOODABETTU VILLAGE KATAPADI 574 105 UDUPI TALUK & DISTRICT

18. K ANURADHA KAMATH AGED ABOUT 49 YEARS W/O K UMESH KAMATH VISHALA BEHIND SVK KALA BHAVAN N H 17 POSAR MODDABETTU VILLAGE KATAPADI 574 105 UDUPI TALUK & DISTRICT

19. K UMESH KAMATH AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS S/O LATE K PUNDALIKA KAMATH VISHALA BEHIND SVK KALA BHAVAN N H 17 POSAR MODDABETTU VILLAGE KATAPADI 574 105 UDUPI TALUK & DISTRICT

20. SMT SESI POOJARTHI AGED ABOUT 81 YEARS W/O LATE PIJJU POOJARI DEVI PRASAD HOUSE MODDABETTU VILLAGE KATAPADI 574 105 UDUPI TALUK & DISTRICT

21. GEORGE D SILVIA AGED ABOUT 64 YEARS S/O LATE LEWIS D SILVA HILTON COMPLEX N H 17 YENAGUDDA VILLAGE KATAPADI 574 105 UDUPI TALUK & DISTRICT

22. K PANDURANGA KINI AGED ABOUT 66 YEARS S/O ANANTHA KINI

5

SANGHA MITRA N H 17 POSAR MODDABETTU VILLAGE KATAPADI 574 105 UDUPI TALUK & DISTRICT

23. K NIRMALA BAI AGED ABOUT 65 YEARS W/O K PANDURANGA KINI SANGHA MITRA N H 17 POSAR MODDABETTU VILLAGE KATAPADI 574 105 UDUPI TALUK & DISTRICT

24. USMAN SAHEB AGED ABOUT 41 YEARS S/O LATE ABDUL SAHIB MODDABETTU VILLAGE KATAPADI 574 105 UDUPI TALUK & DISTRICT

25. VASUDEVA SHANBHAG AGED ABOUT 63 YEARS S/O LATE MADHAVA SHANBHAG DATTARAMA SANKEERNA VILLAGE UDUPI TALUK UDUPI DISTRICT 576122

26. ABDUL HAMMED AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS S/O MOHAMMED HUSSAIN SAFA MANZIL NH 17 POSAR MOODABETTU VILLAGE KATAPADI UDUPI TALUK UDUPI DISTRICT 574105

27. DR Y SHIVANANDA SHETTY AGED ABOUT 68 YEARS S/O SHETTY RATHINIVAS, BEHIND CANARA BANK THENKA YERMAL, UDUPI TALUK UDUPI DISTRICT 574119

6

28. Y G RASOOL AGED ABOUT 73 YEARS S/O SHEIK HAROON SAHEB GULSHAN BHAG NEAR CANARA BANK THENKA VILLAGE, YERMAL UDUPI TALUK UDUPI DISTRICT 574119

29. KHALEELULLA KHAN AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS S/O MOIDDIN KHAN AGRICULTURIST NEAR CANARA BANK TENKA YERMAL UDUPI TALUK AND DISTRICT

30. HIRAJA S SHETTY AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS S/O LATE SANKAPPA SHETTY AGRICULTURIST BADA YERMAL UDUPI TALUK UDUPI DISTRICT

31. M KISHORE SHETTY AGED ABOUT 47 YEARS S/O B B SHETTY AGRICULTURIST PANCHAVATHI BADA YERMAL 574 119 UDUPI TALUK, UDUPI DISTRICT

32. RAJENDRA CHOWTA AGED ABOUT 48 YEARS S/O MAHABALA SHETTY AGRICULTURIST RAJAHAMSA BADA YERMAL 574 119 UDUPI TALUK, UDUPI DISTRICT

33. SEFRABI AGED ABOUT 43 YEARS D/O KHAIRUNNISA NEAR JAIN BASADI

7

BADA YERMAL UDUPI TALUK UDUPI DISTRICT

34. RIZWAN AGED ABOUT 71 YEARS W/O SABU SAHEB AGRICULTURIST AANISH OPP BASADI YERMAL UDUPI TALUK, UDUPI DISTRICT

35. MEERA B HEGDE AGED ABOUT 73 YEARS W/O BOJA HEGDE AGRICULTURIST UCHILA, UDUPI TALUK UDUPI DISTRICT

36. SATHISH KUNDANTHAYA AGED ABOUT 51 YEARS S/O RAMA KRISHNA KUNDANTHAYA BAGA UCHILA UDUPI TALUK, UDUPI DISTRICT

37. GEETHA S BHAT AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS W/O SRIPATHI BHAT SUKANYA ASSOCIATES NH 17 UCHILA, UDUPI TALUK UDUPI DISTRICT-574117

38. RATNAKAR RAJ AGED ABOUT 76 YEARS S/O S A BALLAL AGRICULTURIST BEEDU VILLAGE AND PADUBIDRI UDUPI TALUK UDUPI DISTRICT

39. T SUKUMAR AGED ABOUT 62 YEARS

8

S/O RATHNAKAR ENGINEER IN CHIEF (RETD) FORMER SECRETARY PWD, RATNA VIHAR 4TH CROSS, NGO COLONY AJJARAKADU, UDUPI 576 101

40. SMT IRENE MARY LEWIS AGED ABOUT 67 YEARS W/O LATE DR E. J. LEWIS MANAGING DIRECTORS M/S BRAHAMAVARA CHEMICALS PRIVATE LIMITED, BRAHMAVARA UDUPI TALUK, UDUPI DISTRICT

41. JAYANTHI PAI B P AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS S/O LATE SRINIVAS PAI B P PAI PAN AND GENERAL STORES N H 17 BRAHMAVARA UDUPI TALUK UDUPI DISTRICT 576 213

42. ELIZABETH FERNANDES AGED ABOUT 48 YEARS S/O ALWYN FERNANDES SACRED HEART CONVENT BHARMAVARA UDUPI TALUK UDUPI DISTRICT

43. U ANANDA SHEVEGAR AGED ABOUT 64 YEARS S/O GANAPAYYA SHERVEGAR HOSAMEN HAREBETU POST, UDUPI TALUK UDUPI DISTRICT 576 105

44. K GOPAL GANIGA AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS S/O K MANJAYYA CANARA REFRIGERATION WORKS PARIVARA SANSKRIT COLLEGE ROAD UDUPI TALUK & DISTRICT

9

45. SMT K SHANTHA BAI AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS W/O B JAYANTH NGO COLONY, AJJARAKADU UDUPI TALUK & DISTRICT

46. SMT FARAHATH AGED ABOUT 48 YEARS W/O SALAHUDDIN NO.4-4-8A KINNY MULKY UDUPI TALUK & DISTRICT

47. BHASKAR SHETTIGAR AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS S/O K GIRIYAPPA KALYAN PURA HOUSE NGO COLONY, KINNI MULKI UDUPI TALUK & DISTRICT

48. BABURAY SHENOY AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS S/O A RAGAVENDRA SHENOY RAMANATH KINNY MULKY NGO COLONY UDUPI TALUK & DISTRICT

49. SMT M ROOPA AGED ABOUT 41 YEARS D/O M SWAMY KADEKARU VILLAGE SRI SUBRAMANYA SADANA D NO.4-2-81 A, NGO COLONY AJJARA KADU, UDUPI TALUK & DISTRICT

50. WILFRED FERNANDES AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS S/o. PETER FERNANDES DONUM DEI NH17 NEAR LVT SHCOOL P O SANTHEKATTE KALYANAPURA UDUPI TALUK & DISTRICT 576 105

10

51. N VITTAL PRABHU AGED ABOUT 61 YEARS S/O NAGAPPA PRABHU PRABHU GENERAL STORES P O SANTHEKATTE KALYANAPURA UDUPI TALUK & DISTRICT 576 105

52. P TULSIDAS NAYAK AGED ABOUT 68 YEARS S/O LATE KRISHNARAYA NAYAK SRI GANESH NEAR ASHIRWAD TALKIES PUTTUR VILLAGE SANTHEKATTE UDUPI TALUK & DISTRICT 576 105

53. SMT ALPHONSE FERNANDES AGED ABOUT 65 YEARS W/O RONALD FERNANDES MARINA OPP VIJAYA BANK SANTHEKATTE POST UDUPI TALUK & DISTRICT

54. JAGADISHA NAYAK AGED ABOUT 36 YEARS S/O TULSIDAS NAYAK KRISHNA LEELA SANTHEKATTE UDUPI TALUK & DISTRICT

55. B ASHRAM SHETTY AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS S/O LATE H S SHETTY (GPA HOLDER) FOR A. SUNDAR SHETTY SANIDHI CPC LAYOUT UDUPI TALUK & DISTRICT 576103

56. SMT SHAIKILA A SHETTY AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS W/O B ASHRAM SHETTY SANIDHI CPC LAYOUT UDUPI

57. G MOHAMMED AGED ABOUT 51 YEARS

11

S/O G HASSAN MUDANIDAMBUR BEACH ROAD UDUPI TALUK & DISTRICT

58. MOHAMMED SHOAIB AGED ABOUT 25 YEARS S/O LATE ABDUL GANI HOUSE NO.4-4-8A KINNIMULKY UDUPI TALUK & DISTRICT

59. SMT SAROSHCHADNRA SHETTY AGED ABOUT 49 YEARS W/O LATE B RAJARAM SHETTY NO.405, ARCHAN ARCADE KUNJIBETTU UDUPI

60. SMT KALAVATHI AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS W/O M PARAMESHWARA LAKSHMI SHARADA NILAYA KANNARPADY KADEKARU VILLAGE UDUPI TALUK & DISTRICT

61. SMT P MEERA AGED ABOUT 67 YEARS W/O SANJEEVA K HANUMANTHA NAGARA PUTTUR VILLAGE UDUPI 576103

62. SMT SAVITHRI S PALAN AGED ABOUT 51 YEARS W/O LATE DR U SANJEEVA PALAN R/A SANTHEKATTE UDUPI 576 125

63. DR B MOHAN DAS SHETTY AGED ABOUT 67 YEARS S/O VANJAKSHI SHEDTHY

12

PRASHANTHI CLINIC VILLAGE BRAHMAVARA UDUPI TALUK AND DISTRICT

64. MANOHAR S SHETTY AGED ABOUT 41 YEARS S/O SUNDAR K SETTY ULIYARGOLI VILLAGE KAMP ROAD UDUPI TALUK

65. G SHANKAR AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS S/O SOMA BANGERA SHAMILI, AMBALAPDI UDUPI 576 103

66. RATNA KUMAR AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS S/O LATE S KRISHNA SHIVATHAYA “PRITHVI” SARALAYA COMPOUND VALAK-ADU UDUPI TALUK UDUPI DISTRICT 576 101

67. DR K SUKHANANDA SHENOY AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS S/O K ANANTH SHENOY SRI GANESH , N H 17 AMBALPADY, UDUPI 576 103

68. CHANDRASHEKAR SHETTY AGED ABOUT 67 YEARS S/O LATE VASU SHETTY R/A CHANDRA NIVAS NADSAL VILLAGE PADUBIDRI UDUPI 574 111

69. SMT SHAMBAVI V SHETTY W/O VASU SHETTY R/A CHANDRA NIVAS NADSAL VILLAGE PADUBIDRI, UDUPI 574 111

13

70. SMT K VASANTHA KINI AGED ABOUT 64 YEARS S/O ANANTHA KINI R/A ANANTHA NIVAS MOODABETTU VILLAGE KATAPADI, UDUPI TALUK UDUPI DISTRICT 574 105

71. SHASHIKANTH R SHETTY AGED ABOUT 51 YEARS S/O LATE RAMANNA SHETTY R/A CHOKKADI YENAGUDDE VILLAGE KATAPADI UDUPI 574 105

72. JULIAN MARK D MELLO AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS S/O MOURIS D MELLO R/A YENAGUDDE VILLAGE KATAPADI 574 105

73. SMT M LEELAVATHI AGED ABOUT 63 YEARS S/O LATE M ANANTHA KRISHNA RAO D NO.4-2-77, GANGA PRASAD NGO COLONY CROSS, III CROSS UDUPI TALUK & DISTRICT .. PETITIONERS

(By Sri. G BALAKRISHNA SHASTRY, ADV.,)

AND

1. THE UNION OF MINISTRY OF SHIPPING ROAD TRANSPORT AND HIGHWAYS REPRESENTED BY ITS PROJECT DIRECTOR NATIONAL HIGHWAY AUTHORITY OF INDIA PROJECT IMPLEMENTATION UNIT BISHOP COMPOUND VALENCIA KANAKANADY POST MANGALORE 575 002

14

2. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA REPRESENTED BY ITS CHIEF SECRETARY VIDHANA SODUHA DR AMBEDKAR VEEDHI BANGALORE 560 001

3. THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER NATIONAL HIGH WAY 17 OFFICE OF THE ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER KUNDAPUR UDUPI DISTRICT 586 201

4. THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER UDUPI DISTRICT UDUPI 576 101 ... RESPONDENTS

THESE REVIEW PETITIONS ARE FILED UNDER ORDER 47 RULE 1 OF CPC, PRAYING THIS HON'BLE COURT TO REVIEW THE ORDER DATED 21/02/2013 PASSED IN W.A NO.336/2012 TO 363/2012, W.A.844/2012 TO 901/2012, W.A. 902/2012 TO 954/2012, W.A. NO.955/2012 TO 1012/2012 AND 1520/2012 TO 1544/2012, ON THE FILE OF THE HON'BLE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, BANGALORE.

THESE REVIEW PETITIONS COMING ON FOR ORDERS THIS DAY, Dilip B. Bhosale J. MADE THE FOLLOWING:

PC:

On 7.10.13, at the request of learned counsel for the petitioners, we kept these petitions today with clear understanding that we would hear them for admission irrespective of the objections raised by the office. Learned

15

counsel for the petitioners submits that he has already paid deficit court fee.

In view thereof, we have heard learned counsel for the petitioners on merits. Learned counsel for the petitioners, at the outset and in all fairness submitted that the petitioners are seeking review on the basis of the subsequent events that occurred after the writ appeals were disposed of vide judgment dated 21.2.13. He invited our attention to paragraph 11 of the memorandum of review petition wherein the petitioners have stated about the discrimination made by the National Highways authority in respect of the width of the highway. We have, in fact, considered this aspect also while disposing of the writ appeals more particularly in paragraph-35 of the judgment. In any case, in our opinion, no case for review is made out.

Hence, the review petitions are dismissed.

Sd/- JUDGE

Sd/- JUDGE

TL