Tearing Down the Curtain, Opening the Gates
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Pirkkoliisa Ahponen & Pirjo jukarainen (eds.) TEARING DOWN THE CURTAIN, OPENING THE GATES Northern Boundariesin Change So Phi University of Jyvaskyla 2000 SoPhi 54 University of Jyvaskyla 2000 SoPhi publishes social sciences at the University ofJyvaskyla, Finland, and it is located at the Department of Social Sciences and Philosophy. It provides a forum for innovative studies in social policy, sociology, political science and philosophy SoPhi publishes 10-15 titles per year, both in Finnish and in English. Manuscripts are selected forpublication on the basis of expert opin ion. Correspondence should be sent to publications editor, Olli-Pekka Moisio, SoPhi, Dept. of Social Sciences and Philosophy, University of Jyvaskyla, P.O. Box 35 (MaB), FIN-40351 Jyvaskyla, Finland, tel. +358 14 2603123, fax+3 58 14 2603101, e-mail [email protected]. SoPhi is distributed world-wide by Drake International Services, Market House, Market Place, Deddington, Oxford OX15 OSE, UK, tel. (+44) 01869 338240, fax (+44) 01869 338310, e-mail: [email protected] .uk, website: www. drakeint.co.uk. In North America SoPhi is distributed by International Specialized Book Services, 5804 NE Hassalo Street, Portland, OR 9721 3-3644, U.S.A, tel. 503 287 3093 or 800944 6190 (toll free), fax 503 280 8832, e-mail: info@isbs. com, website: www.isbs.com. Visit SoPhi home page at http://www.jyu. fi/yhtfiVsophi ISBN 951-39-0705-8 ISSN 1238-8025 Copyright © authors and SoPhi 2000 Printed at Kopijyva Ltd., Jyvaskyla 2001 Cover printed at ER-Paino, Laukaa 2000 TABLE OF CONTENTS Introduction .................................... .............................................................. 5 Pirkkoliisa Ahponen & Pirjojukarainen l THE EMERGENCE AND DEVELOPMENT OF THE FINNISH-RUSSIAN BOUNDARY Knowledge and the state. The construction of Finland by bureaucrats and scientists . .......................... 11 ]ouni Hakli From Soviet 'Iron Curtain' to 'post-Soviet window to Europe'. Discursive reproduction of the Russian-Finnish border . .................... 25 Olga Brednikova Trade and population development across the Finnish-Russian border ......... 38 Dimitri Bazegski & Antti Laine Economic gap at the Finnish-Russian border ................. .................. ........... 55 Aku Alanen & Heikki Eskelinen Mental borders as barriers for industrial co-operation . ................................. 69 Markku Tykkylainen Il CHANGING DYNAMICS OF BORDERS AND BORDER AREAS IN THE EUROPEAN NORTH The Finnish-Russian border as a shifting discourse. Boundaries in the world of de-territorialisation . .. .................................... 85 Anssi Paasi The magic borders. Symbolic demarcations in current European societies . ....................................................... ............................ 101 Yrjo-PaavoHayrynen Changing politics along Finland's borders. From Norden to the Northern Dimension . ................................................ 114 Pertti ]oenniemi The reconstructed ideological boundaries after the fall of the Iron Curtain. Austria and Finland in the EU ...... .............................................................. 133 PirkkoliisaAhponen &JosefLanger Urban linkages across boundaries. Networking as a new type of transborder co-operation in the Baltic Sea region . ...................... ............... 155 ]anne Antikainen & Perttu Vartiainen Euregios in the making. The case of Euregio Karelia . .................................. 170 Tarja Cronberg Bordertown Vyborg. A local socio-economic system facing the new millennium . ........................................................... ...................... 184 Riitta Kosonen Authors ....... ............................................................................................... 198 Bibliography 199 Author Index ..... .............................................................................. .. 216 Subj ect Index .............................................................................................. 219 INTRODUCTION ould we imagine a world without boundaries? ls free entrance into any C place and everywhere possible, and would it be an ideal for global citizenship? It seems that the world is full of borders and they are built, crossed and replaced everywhere. So called 'natural borders', seen as un intentional obstacles of free communication, are increasingly crossed by technically constructed means. Geopolitical borders are constructed as human made barriers to separate members of certain nation-states from foreigners and make divisions between ideological coalitions. Boundaries are also used formarking symbols to identify cultural communities. Demands concerning ownership of historical heritages are justified by producing evidence forthe correctness of certain borderlines. The complexity of the border can be understood by comparing the mean ing of border with that of boundaries, barriers, frontiers, edges, or faultlin es; border, as a phenomenon and a concept, becomes more evident the more its construction, functioning and conceptualising become subj ects of research. In particular, after the so-called Cold vVar or Iron Curtain era the restructur ing of boundaries has gained wider and wider interest among scholars repre senting various disciplines. According to Anssi Paasi, borders are no longer discussed only in the field of political geography (see Paasi's chapter in this book) ; they have become a truly multidisciplinary topic. In order to show the multi-faceted essence of borders, the authors dealing with these questions in the present book are experts in various academic fields: regional studies, human geography, cultural studies, sociology, political sciences, regional eco nomics and history. In the course of these chapters, mental and symbolic boundaries, political and administrative borders and economic barriers are discussed as interwoven - approaching the subject both from the perspec tive of history and that of contemporary development. The principal aim of this book is to improve understanding of the multi ple meanings of borders. It deals with the questions of why borders exist, how they are constructed and how they may be changed. A basic aspect in each and every chapter is that borders are fundamentally human-made social 5 constructions, and therefore they can be - and definitely are - also de- and reconstructed by people themselves. The human-made borders have often been contrasted as artificial and contingent with natural boundaries, that is, those restrictions of free movement which have come into existence through nature as real and inevitable, like seas, rivers and mountains. Here we, how ever, agree with Leimgruber (1991) and Houtum (1997) that the term natu ral border is at least confusing if not completely misleading in the sense that it suggests that a true nature-shaped or God-given border should be taken forgranted and it cannot - or at least should not - be challenged or replaced. This also implies that a geopolitical border between nation-states will be eternal as prescribed by a natural order. In the beginning of the 20th century this term became notorious, as it was used by geopoliticians to justify prac tises that aimed to enlarge state-territories, even by violent means. States were expected to develop freely likeliving organisms until they would reach their natural limits. (Agnew 1998, 96.) Yet, as Houtum (1997, 14) aptly points out, if natural is equated with biological, then every social and political boundary among people can actu ally be claimed to be natural. The urge to establish boundaries for self-pres ervation (i.e. territorial behaviour) would then be understood as a funda mental aspect of human life, as one aspect of its animal-like character. There fore, to choose a differentway of interpretation, we will not speak here about natural and unnatural borders but only make a distinction between physio graphic obstacles for human interaction and borders that are created by people in their conscious and unconscious activities by political and cultural means. As well as for conceptualising boundaries, this book was written to give concrete and illustrative examples of how borders are constructed and re constructed. Therefore the chapters of this book are geographically specific; they deal with particular geographically defined spaces. The focus of the book is on the European North, in particular on the multi-faceted Finnish Russian border. vVhatmakes this borderland particularly interesting is that it has long been an area between the so called 'Eastern' and 'vVestern' spheres of cultural, economic and political influence. Before going into the issues of contemporary restructuring and change of boundaries, the book starts by highlighting various practices by means of which social, economic cultural, and ideological divisions were constructed between Finland and Russia in the course of history The aim here is to show how the Finnish-Russian border emerged and developed, and what kind of particular characteristics it gained over time. As stated by jouni Hakli in this book, both bureaucrats and scientists - as confidential servants of the state - contributed to the discursive construction of Finland as a particular society, having a right to its own territory. This borderline became a deep mental and 6 ideological barrier between Russian and Finnish societies - there was an other world on the other side of the border. In the chapters of this book this divide is examined from different angles, from both sides of the boundary,