Age of Pre-Neoglacial Cirque Moraines in the Central North
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Document generated on 09/24/2021 10:42 p.m. Géographie physique et Quaternaire Age of Pre-Neoglacial Cirque Moraines in the Central North American Cordillera L’âge des moraines de cirques pré-néoglaciaires du centre de la Cordillère nord-américaine Datierung der präneoglazialen Moränen im zentralen Norden der amerikanischen Kordilleren P. Thompson Davis and Gerald Osborn Volume 41, Number 3, 1987 Article abstract In the western mountains of the United States and Canada are pre-Neoglacial URI: https://id.erudit.org/iderudit/032692ar cirque moraines that lie up to about 3 km outside Neoglacial moraines. There is DOI: https://doi.org/10.7202/032692ar considerable uncertainty as to the ages of the outer moraines and whether or not they are age-equivalent from range to range. The variety of assigned See table of contents radiocarbon ages found in the literature may be partly due to some authors' use of minimum-limiting dates as near-absolute dates, and use of dates that cannot be definitely related to the deposits in question. With one possible Publisher(s) exception, all the dated moraines described in the literature could be as old as the type Temple Lake moraine of Wyoming which has a minimum age of about Les Presses de l'Université de Montréal 11,400 yrs BP based on a recently obtained radiocarbon date. Nearly all paleoecological proxy data from the North American Cordillera, generally ISSN derived from continuous sedimentary records, suggest that early Holocene climate was warmer than at present. Global circulation models also suggest an 0705-7199 (print) early Holocene thermal maximum in the Cordillera, probably due to 1492-143X (digital) Milankovitch forcing. For these reasons a proposal gaining popularity in the literature that widespread "Mesoglaciation" occurred in early Holocene time is Explore this journal premature. We hypothesize that most, if not all, of the moraines in question are correlative and date from Late Pleistocene time. Cite this article Thompson Davis, P. & Osborn, G. (1987). Age of Pre-Neoglacial Cirque Moraines in the Central North American Cordillera. Géographie physique et Quaternaire, 41(3), 365–375. https://doi.org/10.7202/032692ar Tous droits réservés © Les Presses de l'Université de Montréal, 1987 This document is protected by copyright law. Use of the services of Érudit (including reproduction) is subject to its terms and conditions, which can be viewed online. https://apropos.erudit.org/en/users/policy-on-use/ This article is disseminated and preserved by Érudit. Érudit is a non-profit inter-university consortium of the Université de Montréal, Université Laval, and the Université du Québec à Montréal. Its mission is to promote and disseminate research. https://www.erudit.org/en/ Géographie physique et Quaternaire, 1987, vol. XLI, n° 3, p. 365-375, 4 fig., 3 tabl. AGE OF PRE-NEOGLACIAL CIRQUE MORAINES IN THE CENTRAL NORTH AMERICAN CORDILLERA* P. Thompson DAVIS and Gerald OSBORN, Department of Natural Sciences, Bentley College, Waltham, Massachusetts 02254, U.S.A., and Department of Geology and Geophysics, University of Calgary, Calgary, Alberta T2N 1N4. ABSTRACT In the western mountains of RÉSUMÉ L'âge des moraines de cirques ZUSAMMENFASSUNG Datierung der the United States and Canada are pre- pré-néoglaciaires du centre de la Cordillère pràneoglazialen Morànen im zentralen Nor- Neoglacial cirque moraines that lie up to nord-américaine. Dans les montagnes de den der amerikanischen Kordilleren. In den about 3 km outside Neoglacial moraines. l'ouest des États-Unis et du Canada se westlichen Bergen der Vereinigten Staaten There is considerable uncertainty as to the trouvent des moraines de cirque qui s'éten und Kanadas gibt es prâneoglaziale Hoch- ages of the outer moraines and whether or dent jusqu'à quelque 3 km des moraines talmorânen, die sich bis zu ungefàhr 3 km not they are age-equivalent from range to néoglaciaires. On connaît mal l'âge de ces auBerhalb der neoglazialen Morânen beo- range. The variety of assigned radiocarbon moraines externes et on ignore s'il concor bachten lassen. Es besteht eine betrâcht- ages found in the literature may be partly de d'une chaîne à l'autre. La grande diver liche UngewiBheit, was das Alter der âuBe- due to some authors' use of minimum-limit sité des âges au radiocarbone que l'on ren Morànen betrifft, und ob sie von Stufe ing dates as near-absolute dates, and use trouve dans la littérature relève probable zu Stufe gleichaltrig sind oder nicht. Die in of dates that cannot be definitely related to ment en partie du fait que certains auteurs Verôffentlichungen vorgefundene Ver- the deposits in question. With one possible considèrent les dates minimales comme schiedenheit der Radiokarbondatierungen exception, all the dated moraines described des dates significatives ou exploitent des mag zum Teil darauf zurùckzufùhren zu in the literature could be as old as the type dates qui ne peuvent pas être parfaitement sein, daB manche Autoren die Minimal- Temple Lake moraine of Wyoming which attribuées aux dépôts étudiés. Toutes les grenzwerte als nahezu absolute Werte has a minimum age of about 11,400 yrs BP moraines, sauf peut-être l'une d'entre elles, benutzen und sich auf Daten stùtzen, die based on a recently obtained radiocarbon pourraient être aussi vieilles que la moraine nicht einwandfrei zu den betreffenden Ab- date. Nearly all paleoecological proxy data de référence de Temple Lake, au Wyo lagerungen in Beziehung gesetzt werden from the North American Cordillera, gener ming, dont l'âge minimal est de 11 400 BP kônnen. Mit einer môglichen Ausnahme ally derived from continuous sedimentary selon une datation au radiocarbone récen kônnen all in den Verôffentlichungen records, suggest that early Holocene cli te. Presque toutes les données paléoécolo beschriebenen datierten Morànen so alt mate was warmer than at present. Global giques indirectes trouvées dans la Cordillè sein wie der Typus der Temple-Lake- circulation models also suggest an early re nord-américaine, qui proviennent Moràne von Wyoming, welche ein Mini- Holocene thermal maximum in the Cor généralement de séquences sédimentai- malalter von ungefàhr 11 400 BP. hat, dillera, probably due to Milankovitch forc res, démontrent que le climat au début de gestùtzt auf eine neuere Radiokarbon- ing. For these reasons a proposal gaining l'Holocène était plus chaud que mainte datierung. Fast aile palàoôkologischen popularity in the literature that widespread nant. Les modèles de circulation générale Proxy-Datierungen von den nordamerika- "Mesoglaciation" occurred in early Holo laissent également croire que la Cordillère nischen Kordilleren, die im allgemeinen cene time is premature. We hypothesize a connu un maximum thermique au début aus kontinuierlichen Sediment-Aufzei- that most, if not all, of the moraines in ques de l'Holocène. Pour toutes ces raisons, chnungen abgeleitet sind, lassen anneh- tion are correlative and date from Late l'hypothèse selon laquelle une mésoglacia men, daB das Klima im frùhen Holozàn Pleistocene time. tion répandue se serait produite au début warmer war als in der Jetztzeit. Globale Zir- de l'Holocène est pour le moins prématu kulationsmodelle legen auch ein ther- rée. Les auteurs croient plutôt que la plus misches Maximum in den Kordilleren im grande partie, sinon toutes les moraines frùhen Holozàn nahe, welches wahrschein- dont il est question ici, sont corrélatives et lich durch den Milankovitch-Effekt hervor- datent du Pleistocene supérieur. gerufen wurde. Aus ail diesen Grùnden ist eine Interpretation, die in den Verôffent lichungen immer populàrer wird, wohl voreilig, daB im frùhen Holozàn eine aus- gedehnte "Mesoglaziation" stattfand. Wir stellen die Hypothèse auf, daB die meisten wenn nicht gar aile betreffenden Morânen zusammenhângen und aus dem spàten Pleistozàn stammen. * Contribution du premier symposium de la CANQUA, sous la direction de René W. Barendregt. 366 PT. DAVIS and G. OSBORN INTRODUCTION TABLE I In numerous mountain ranges of western North America, Pre-Neoglacial Cirque Moraines some moraines lie up to about 3 km beyond more obvious and almost always present Neoglacial (post-Altithermal) moraines. These outer moraines represent depressions in BRITISHCOLUMBIA equilibrium-line altitudes up to about 100 m below Neogla 1. Mt. Tatlow, Coast Ranges (Ricker, 1983) cial values. The moraines are known in some cases, and in 2. Shuswap Highland (Duford and Osborn, 1978) ferred in others, to be early Holocene or older in age, and 5. Purcell Mountains (Osborn, unpubl.) 6. Kokanee Park, Selkirks (Osborn, unpubl.) are commonly designated only as "pre-Altithermal" (e.g., 7. Elk valley (Ferguson, 1978) CURREY, 1974). There is considerable uncertainty as to the specific age(s) of these moraines and whether or not ALBERTA 3. Jasper National Park they are equivalent in age from range to range (DAVIS, (Luckman and Osborn, 1979) 4. Banff National Park (Luckman and Osborn, 1979) 1984). 8. Highwood Pass (Gardner et al., 1983) This paper seeks to establish some order from the confu 9. Waterton Lakes National Park (Osborn, 1985) sion concerning distribution and ages of pre-Neoglacial cir MONTANA que moraines in the Cordillera of the conterminus United 10. Glacier National Park (Osborn, 1985) States and adjacent Canada. We (1) review the available 19. Eastern Tobacco Root Range (Hall and Heiny, 1983) radiocarbon ages and show that few can be closely related 22. Beartooth Mountains (Graf, 1971) to the ice advances they supposedly date, (2) review theo WASHINGTON retical paleoclimatic and proxy climatic data, and (3) con 11. Mt. Baker (Easterbrook and Burke, clude that the early Holocene was not a likely time for even 1972; Fuller era/., 1983) a minor glacial advance in the North American Cordillera. 12. Glacier Peak (Beget, 1981,1983) 13. Enchantment Lakes (Waitt efa/., 1982) The conventional Holocene/late Pleistocene boundary of 14. Mt. Rainier (Crandell and Miller, 1974) 10,000 yrs BP is used in this paper. We use the terms "Al- OREGON tithermal" and "Hypsithermal" interchangeably to mean 15.