Proposed City Hall Building Analysis City Project 4466 Minot, Nd Index Introduction Pages 1•2
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
PROPOSED CITY HALL BUILDING ANALYSIS CITY PROJECT 4466 MINOT, ND INDEX INTRODUCTION PAGES 1•2 FIRM INFORMATION PAGE 3 SITE PAGE 4 PROGRAM NEEDS PAGE 5 ZONING COMPLIANCE PAGE 6 BIG M BUILDING ASSESSMENT PAGE 7 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY PAGES 8•12 CONSTRUCTIONBUILDING CODE COMPLIANCECOSTS PAGES 13•16 BUILDINGESTIMATE ANALYSISOF PROBABLE COST PAGE 17 ENGINEERINGBUILDING PLANS ASSESSMENTS PAGES 18•26 WELLSBUILDING FARGOPLANS ASSESSMENT PAGES 27•29 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY CONSTRUCTIONWELLS FARGO COSTS ASSESSMENT PAGE 30 BUILDINGEXECUTIVE ANALYSIS SUMMARYSUMMARY PAGES 31•34 BUILDING CODE COMPLIANCE PAGES 35•37 ESTIMATE OF PROBABLE COST PAGE 38 ENGINEERING ASSESSMENTS PAGES 39•46 BUILDING PLANS PAGE 47 INTRODUCTION PROPOSED CITY HALL BUILDING ANALYSIS SCOPE OF WORK JLG Architects was hired by the City of Minot to lead a team of local professional, including architects, engineers and contracting, to evaluate two potential sites as potential locations for a relocation of City Hall for Minot, North Dakota. The two sites under consideration area the Midwest Federal Building (Big ‘M’ Building at 123 1st Street SW and the Wells Fargo Building located at 15 2nd Avenue SW, both in downtown Minot, North Dakota. The Scope of Work was to include the following tasks: Task 1: Review existing studies, and reports for both structures on file with the City of Minot Task 2: Conduct a walk-through analysis of both structures with the Architectural and Engineering Teams. It was highly recommended to review the structures with local contractors who have performed work in both buildings in the past. Task 3: Perform high-level probability analysis of potential hazardous materials in the Wells Fargo Building. This includes the probability of asbestos and lead based paint within the building. Task 4: Review the feasibility to move column locations within the Big ‘M’ Building to maximize space for public assembly. Task 5: Provide feasibility and high-level cost estimate for construction of bridges from either the Big ‘M’ Building or the Wells Fargo Building to the Renaissance Parking Structure. Task 6: Perform remodel cost analysis for each building. The estimates shall be completed on a square foot basis for each floor. The costs shall incorporate space analysis requirements as provided by the City of Minot. The cost estimates shall list construction costs, contingency percentages, architectural fees and all assumptions used in developing the costs. The construction cost analysis shall also include: 1. The cost to bring each building up to currently adopted building codes. 2. The cost to repair major building systems including mechanical, plumbing and electrical systems. Building systems must meet current energy codes. 3. The costs to abate hazardous material in the buildings, based on existing reports and on-site observations. 4. The costs to remodel each floor to meet modern office building standards with good quality finishes. ASSESSMENT SCHEDULE: JAN. 17, 2020 NOTIFICATION OF AWARD JLG Architects was notified they were awarded the contract to evaluate the two potential sites for potential relocation of City Hall. The City of Minot shared all available information they had on file which related to previous the pair of buildings including existing original construction documents, studies and reports for the Assessment Team to review and study prior to walking through the buildings. JLG Architects notified all team members of the award and distributed all City of Minot documents to the assessment teams. JLG prepared contracts for the work and began coordinating the work effort and scheduling a date for the walk-through assessments. JAN. 29, 2020 WALK THROUGH ANALYSIS A walk-through assessment was conducted at both structures was completed with the Architectural and Engineering Teams. The Wells Fargo Building was toured from 10:30 am to 12:00 pm. The Big ‘M’ Building was toured from 1:00 pm to 3:00 pm. 1 FEB. 6, 2020 ASSESSMENT REVIEW ROUNDTABLE A roundtable discussion was held at the Minot Office of JLG Architects with the Design Professional, the local group Contractors and the City of Minot review the initial assessment thoughts and cost estimates. The purpose of the meeting was to review the required tasks to be completed, review the revised schedule for completing the assessment report and to get expert feedback and confirmation on the condition of the existing building systems. The process intends to better inform the cost estimating process and ensure all parties were in agreement on the scope of work for each building. After all roundtable discussions were complete the Architectural and Engineering Team was instructed to complete the assessment narratives and cost estimate to Doug Larson, Project Manager for JLG Architects, by the end of day on Tuesday, February 11, 2020 FEB. 13, 2020 SUBMIT DRAFT ASSESSMENT DOCUMENT FEB. 18, 2020 DRAFT REVIEW WITH CITY HALL TECHNICAL COMMITTEE FEB. 26, 2020 ISSUE DRAFT REPORT MARCH 9, 2020 CITY COUNCIL WALK-THROUGH OF BUILDINGS 4:30 pm Wells Fargo Walk-through 6:00 pm Big ‘M’ Walk-through MARCH 10, 2020 CITY HALL TECHNICAL COMMITTEE MEETING MARCH 12, 2020 FINAL REPORT DUE MARCH 16, 2020 REPORT PRESENTATION TO CITY COUNCIL ASSESSMENT TEAM: ARCHITECTURAL ASSESMENTS: JLG ARCHITECTS Scott Jordan-Denny Principal-in-Charge Douglas Larson Project Manager / General Assessments Tom Behm Cost Estimating ENGINEERING ASSESMENTS: PRAIRIE ENGINEERING, PC Jason Hunze Electrical Assessments / Electrical Cost Estimating Caleb Bulow Mechanical Assessments / Mechanical Cost Estimating CW STRUCTURAL ENGINEERS Kody Scharosch Structural Assessments AE2S Mark Lambrecht Civil Estimating ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENTS: MATERIALS TESTING SERVICES Jim Kunzelman Environmental Consultant / Assessments LOCAL CONTRACTOR RESOURCES: ROLAC CONTRACTING General Contractor Jason Sanders Expert on General Construction - Big ‘M’ Building MOWBRAY & SON Mechanical Contractor Wayne Burbach Expert on Mechanical Systems - Big ‘M’ Building C&C PLUMBING&HEATING Mechanical Contractor Jamie Lach Expert on Mechanical Systems - Wells Fargo Building FARGO GLASS Glazing Contractor Joe Haider Glazing, Curtain Wall, Storefront, Door & Hardware Expert TECTRA AMERICA DAKOTAS Roofing Contractor Kevin Pederson Roofing Assessments / Cost Estimates 2 FIRM INFORMATION JLG Architects Year Firm Established: 1989 WE DESIGN FOR LIFE We know that it takes more than just bricks and mortar to build a community. It takes passionate local stewardship, progressive leaders, and designers who understand how to turn a small idea into a big future. For over 31 years, our 150 JLGers have raised the bar on what is expected from architecture in North Dakota, Minnesota and South Dakota so that we can continuously improve the quality of life of our clients, our neighbors, and our families, while remaining dedicated to our clients’ bottom lines, today, tomorrow and for the next generation to come. We are inspired by the future, and work passionately to make our impact go beyond a building. As a result, JLG has been identified as one of the hottest architecture firms in the United States by Inc., Architectural Record, the Zweig Group, and the Minneapolis-St. Paul Business Journal and is a “Best Place to Work” according to Prairie Business magazine, the Zweig Group, GGF Young Professionals and the National American Institute of Architects Intern Development Program. WE MIX GOOD DESIGN AND GOOD SENSE At our heart, JLG lives and breathes design excellence; it counts – at every level and for every position. We balance innovative design with borderline-obsessive budget control to generate solutions that are as creative as they are practical. Function is the baseline; form is what lifts up the spirit; and innovation elevates the experience for our clients, their visitors, and the region as a whole. JLG has over 100 design awards in our portfolio because we are committed to elevating expectations for our clients and our communities. WE ARE HOME We believe it takes people who are an active, engaged part of a community to truly understand what matters to the people living there. We have a lifetime of vested interest in the communities in which we work. Conservation: At JLG, Sustainable Design means creating high performance solutions that meet our clients’ present profitability goals without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own. We do that by designing to a LEED Certified minimum on all of our projects to lower long-term maintenance costs and, since the most sustainable thing you can do is reuse your building, we design to last – creating flexible and organic solutions that are nimble and able to adapt to new parameters. LOWERED LONG-TERM COSTS JLG’s green buildings At JLG, our clients’ budgets are as intertwined in our design solutions as the architecture itself, and so it stands to reason this concern would carry on throughout the project’s reduce energy use on lifespan. To that end, we design to align to today’s bottom line while remaining average by % cost effective to maintain, especially in the areas of energy and water savings. 23 IMPROVED HEALTH We live in a region in which 90% of our time is spent indoors. Study after study has shown the effects of indoor air quality, daylighting and other environmental factors as they relate to the health and well-being of a building’s occupants. JLG maximizes indoor design opportunities to increase attention spans, lower sick days and raise productivity. 3 BIG M BUILDING CITY PARKING GARAGE WELLS FARGO DOWNTOWN MINOT, ND 58702 4 CITY OF MINOT