For Internal Use Only for Interal Use Only: Do Not Distribute
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
National Park Service U.S. Department of the Interior Golden Gate National Recreation Area California Draft General Management Plan Golden Gate National Recreation Area Comment Analysis Report FINAL REPORT February 2013 FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY FOR INTERAL USE ONLY: DO NOT DISTRIBUTE Golden Gate National Recreation Area, Draft General Management Plan Comment Analysis Report INTRODUCTION AND GUIDE ....................................................................................................................... 7 INTRODUCTION .............................................................................................................................. 7 THE COMMENT ANALYSIS PROCESS .............................................................................................. 7 DEFINITION OF TERMS ................................................................................................................... 9 GUIDE TO THIS DOCUMENT ........................................................................................................... 9 CONTENT ANALYSIS REPORT .................................................................................................................... 11 COMMENT/RESPONSE REPORT................................................................................................................. 13 RESPONSE TOPIC 1: RECREATION/CONSERVATION ................................................................................ 13 BALANCING PRESERVATION AND RECREATION ...........................................................................13 IMPORTANCE OF EDUCATION ......................................................................................................16 REGULATION OF ACCESS .............................................................................................................16 ECONOMIC VALUE.......................................................................................................................17 VISITOR SURVEYS.........................................................................................................................18 CLARIFICATION OF RECREATIONAL USES, INCLUDING ON NEW LANDS .......................................18 RECREATION IN MANAGEMENT ZONES .......................................................................................20 NEPA ANALYSIS AND DOG MANAGEMENT .................................................................................24 RESPONSE TOPIC 2: BIRDS AT ALCATRAZ ISLAND .................................................................................. 26 BIRDS AT ALCATRAZ ISLAND .......................................................................................................26 RESPONSE TOPIC 3: SENSITIVE RESOURCES ZONE .................................................................................. 31 KAYAK RECREATIONAL USE ........................................................................................................31 RESPONSE TOPIC 4: EQUESTRIAN FACILITIES AND USE .......................................................................... 33 EQUESTRIAN USES .......................................................................................................................33 RESPONSE TOPIC 5: MAINTENANCE AND DESIGN OF PARK FACILITIES ................................................ 35 MAINTAINING AND REPAIRING FACILITIES ...................................................................................35 FACILITY DESIGN ..........................................................................................................................36 RESPONSE TOPIC 6: TRANSPORTATION ................................................................................................... 38 IMPROVEMENTS TO TRANSPORTATION NETWORK ......................................................................38 BICYCLE AND MULTIMODAL ACCESS IN MARIN COUNTY............................................................39 CONGESTION MANAGEMENT TOOLS ..........................................................................................40 STATE ROUTE 1 AND THE PANORAMIC HIGHWAY AREA IMPROVEMENTS ..................................41 2 | Page FOR INTERAL USE ONLY: DO NOT DISTRIBUTE TRANSPORTATION OPPORTUNITIES AT FORT MASON ..................................................................42 PARTNERSHIPS TO IMPROVE ACCESS TO PHLEGER ESTATE ..........................................................42 TRANSPORTATION ON SWEENEY RIDGE ......................................................................................43 TRANSPORTATION IMPROVEMENTS AT THE MONTARA LIGHTHOUSE .........................................43 TRANSPORTATION FOR MARIN COUNTY, INCLUDING MUIR WOODS ..........................................44 PROPOSALS FOR MARIN COUNTY MAINTAINED ROADS ..............................................................45 RESPONSE TOPIC 7: ESTIMATED COSTS AND INVESTMENTS ................................................................. 46 FUNDING FOR SAN MATEO PRIORITY NEEDS ...............................................................................46 COST ESTIMATES FOR TENNESSEE VALLEY ..................................................................................47 RESPONSE TOPIC 8: TRAILS ....................................................................................................................... 48 INTERPRETIVE TRAILS IN MUIR WOODS NATIONAL MONUMENT .................................................48 TRAIL IMPROVEMENTS PLANNED AS PART OF THE TRAILS FOREVER PROGRAM ..........................48 MOUNTAIN BIKING ......................................................................................................................49 MARIN COUNTY TRAILS ...............................................................................................................49 RESPONSE TOPIC 9: HISTORIC RESOURCES FOR SAN MATEO COUNTY ................................................ 51 HISTORIC RESOURCES FOR SAN MATEO COUNTY .......................................................................51 RESPONSE TOPIC 10: COORDINATION WITH THE PRESIDIO TRUST ....................................................... 54 PRESIDIO TRUST ...........................................................................................................................54 FIRE DEPARTMENT OPERATION WITHIN THE PRESIDIO .................................................................56 RESPONSE TOPIC 11: SAN FRANCISCO PENINSULA WATERSHED LANDS ............................................. 58 ALTERNATIVES AND ENVIRONMENTAL CONSEQUENCES .............................................................58 EASEMENTS INFORMATION AND DISPLAY ...................................................................................61 PUC SCENIC EASEMENT AND LEGISLATION .................................................................................62 OCEAN BEACH MASTER PLAN – CONSIDERATIONS IN ANALYSIS .................................................62 RESPONSE TOPIC 12: BACKGROUND ........................................................................................................ 64 BACKGROUND: PROJECT INFORMATION AND BACKGROUND – GENERAL .......................................... 64 PARK RELATIONSHIPS WITH THE COAST MIWOK AND THE OHLONE TRIBES ................................64 COASTAL ZONE MANAGEMENT ACT CONSISTENCY FOR PUBLIC ACCESS AND NEW FACILITIES ..64 COORDINATION WITH ADDITIONAL AGENCIES AND GROUPS .....................................................65 MANAGEMENT POLICY AND MAP REVIEW ..................................................................................66 MAP CORRECTIONS AND SUGGESTIONS .....................................................................................67 BACKGROUND: MARIN COUNTY, DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS .................................................... 68 MARIN COUNTY, DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS .....................................................................68 PUBLIC COMMENT PERIOD AND PUBLIC MEETINGS .....................................................................69 ADDITION OF TERMS TO THE GLOSSARY .....................................................................................69 ANALYSIS OF THE ENVIRONMENTALLY PREFERRED ALTERNATIVE ...............................................70 3 | Page FOR INTERAL USE ONLY: DO NOT DISTRIBUTE REPLACEMENT OF EQUESTRIAN FACILITIES AT RANCHO CORRAL DE TIERRA WITH FIRE FIGHTING FACILITIES .......................................................................................................................71 RESPONSE TOPIC 13: THE ALTERNATIVES................................................................................................ 73 ALTERNATIVES – MANAGEMENT ZONES ................................................................................................. 73 ADDITIONAL SCENIC VALUES AND OPPORTUNITIES .....................................................................73 EXTENSION OF THE SENSITIVE RESOURCES ZONE ........................................................................74 ALTERNATIVES – ELEMENTS COMMON TO ALL ...................................................................................... 75 RECOMMENDED CHANGES BY NOAA .........................................................................................75 ALTERNATIVES – PARKWIDE ..................................................................................................................... 76 CONSTRUCTION AND BIRDS ON ALCATRAZ .................................................................................76