Quantum Extensions of Classically Singular Spacetimes – the CGHS Model

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Quantum Extensions of Classically Singular Spacetimes – The CGHS Model Victor Taveras Pennsylvania State University Loops ’07 Morelia, Mexico 6/29/07 Work with Abhay Ashtekar and Madhavan Varadarajan CGHS Model Action: •Free Field Equation for f •Dilaton is completely determined by stress energy due to f. •Field Redefinitions: •Equations of motion Callan, Giddings, Harvey, and Strominger (1992) BH Collapse Solutions in CGHS Black Hole Solutions Physical spacetime has a singularity. True DOFs in f+ and f-. Hawking Effect •Trace anomaly •Conservation Law •Hawking Radiation Giddings and Nelson (1992) Numerical Work •Incorporated the backreaction into an effective term in the action •Equations discretized and solved numerically. Evolution breaks down at the singularity and near the endpoint of evaporation. Lowe (1993), Piran & Strominger (1993) Quantum Theory Operator Equations: + Boundary conditions • For an operator valued distribution and a positive operator • well defined everywhere even though may vanish • Ideally we would like to be able to specify (work in progress) • Even without one can proceed by making successive approximations to the full quantum theory Bootstrapping 0th order – Put Compute in the state This yields the BH background. 1st order – Interpret the vacuum on the of the BH background metric, this is precisely the Hawking effect. 2nd order - Semiclassical gravity (mean field approximation) : Ignore fluctuations in and , but not f. Use determined from the trace anomaly. Agreement with analytic solution near obtained by asymptotic analysis. Asymptotic Analysis •Expand and in inverse powers of x+. •Idea: We should have a decent control of what is going on near since curvatures and fluxes there are small •The Hawking flux and the Bondi mass go to 0 and the physical metric approaches the flat one. • agrees with background . Summary To 0th order we recover the black hole background. To higher orders in the truncation, not only do we recover the Hawking effect but we obtain a self-consistent system of semiclassical equations. of the semiclassical metric coincides with that of the background metric thus there is no information loss. The pure state resembles a thermal state in the past of The quantum spacetime is larger than the classical spacetime. Future Work Need to extend QFT on CST to QFT on QG..

Copy Link

Recommended publications

Semiclassical Gravity and Quantum De Sitter
Semiclassical gravity and quantum de Sitter Neil Turok Perimeter Institute Work with J. Feldbrugge, J-L. Lehners, A. Di Tucci Credit: Pablo Carlos Budassi astonishing simplicity: just 5 numbers Measurement Error Expansion rate: 67.8±0.9 km s−1 Mpc−1 1% today (Temperature) 2.728 ± 0.004 K .1% (Age) 13.799 ±0.038 bn yrs .3% Baryon-entropy ratio 6±.1x10-10 1% energy Dark matter-baryon ratio 5.4± 0.1 2% Dark energy density 0.69±0.006 x critical 2% Scalar amplitude 4.6±0.006 x 10-5 1% geometry Scalar spectral index -.033±0.004 12% ns (scale invariant = 0) A dns 3 4 gw consistent +m 's; but Ωk , 1+ wDE , d ln k , δ , δ ..,r = A with zero ν s Nature has found a way to create a huge hierarchy of scales, apparently more economically than in any current theory A fascinating situation, demanding new ideas One of the most minimal is to revisit quantum cosmology The simplest of all cosmological models is de Sitter; interesting both for today’s dark energy and for inflation quantum cosmology reconsidered w/ S. Gielen 1510.00699, Phys. Rev. Le+. 117 (2016) 021301, 1612.0279, Phys. Rev. D 95 (2017) 103510. w/ J. Feldbrugge J-L. Lehners, 1703.02076, Phys. Rev. D 95 (2017) 103508, 1705.00192, Phys. Rev. Le+, 119 (2017) 171301, 1708.05104, Phys. Rev. D, in press (2017). w/A. Di Tucci, J. Feldbrugge and J-L. Lehners , in PreParaon (2017) Wheeler, Feynman, Quantum geometrodynamics De Wi, Teitelboim … sum over final 4-geometries 3-geometry (4) Σ1 gµν initial 3-geometry Σ0 fundamental object: Σ Σ ≡ 1 0 Feynman propagator 1 0 Basic object: phase space Lorentzian path integral 2 2 i 2 i (3) i j ADM : ds ≡ (−N + Ni N )dt + 2Nidtdx + hij dx dx Σ1 i (3) (3) i S 1 0 = DN DN Dh Dπ e ! ∫ ∫ ∫ ij ∫ ij Σ0 1 S = dt d 3x(π (3)h!(3) − N H i − NH) ∫0 ∫ ij ij i Basic references: C.
[Show full text]
Notes on Semiclassical Gravity
ANNALS OF PHYSICS 196, 296-M (1989) Notes on Semiclassical Gravity T. P. SINGH AND T. PADMANABHAN Theoretical Astrophvsics Group, Tata Institute of Fundamental Research, Horn; Bhabha Road, Bombay 400005, India Received March 31, 1989; revised July 6, 1989 In this paper we investigate the different possible ways of defining the semiclassical limit of quantum general relativity. We discuss the conditions under which the expectation value of the energy-momentum tensor can act as the source for a semiclassical, c-number, gravitational field. The basic issues can be understood from the study of the semiclassical limit of a toy model, consisting of two interacting particles, which mimics the essential properties of quan- tum general relativity. We define and study the WKB semiclassical approximation and the gaussian semiclassical approximation for this model. We develop rules for Iinding the back- reaction of the quantum mode 4 on the classical mode Q. We argue that the back-reaction can be found using the phase of the wave-function which describes the dynamics of 4. We find that this back-reaction is obtainable from the expectation value of the hamiltonian if the dis- persion in this phase can be neglected. These results on the back-reaction are generalised to the semiclassical limit of the Wheeler-Dewitt equation. We conclude that the back-reaction in semiclassical gravity is ( Tlk) only when the dispersion in the phase of the matter wavefunc- tional can be neglected. This conclusion is highlighted with a minisuperspace example of a massless scalar field in a Robertson-Walker universe. We use the semiclassical theory to show that the minisuperspace approximation in quantum cosmology is valid only if the production of gravitons is negligible.
[Show full text]
Unitarity Condition on Quantum Fields in Semiclassical Gravity Abstract
KNUTH-26,March1995 Unitarity Condition on Quantum Fields in Semiclassical Gravity Sang Pyo Kim ∗ Department of Physics Kunsan National University Kunsan 573-701, Korea Abstract The condition for the unitarity of a quantum field is investigated in semiclas- sical gravity from the Wheeler-DeWitt equation. It is found that the quantum field preserves unitarity asymptotically in the Lorentzian universe, but does not preserve unitarity completely in the Euclidean universe. In particular we obtain a very simple matter field equation in the basis of the generalized invariant of the matter field Hamiltonian whose asymptotic solution is found explicitly. Published in Physics Letters A 205, 359 (1995) Unitarity of quantum field theory in curved space-time has been a problem long debated but sill unsolved. In particular the issue has become an impassioned altercation with the discovery of the Hawking radiation [1] from black hole in relation to the information loss problem. Recently there has been a series of active and intensive investigations of quantum ∗E-mail : [email protected] 1 effects of matter field through dilaton gravity and resumption of unitarity and information loss problem (for a good review and references see [2]). In this letter we approach the unitarity problem and investigate the condition for the unitarity of a quantum field from the point of view of semiclassical gravity based on the Wheeler-DeWitt equation [3]. By developing various methods [4–18] for semiclassical gravity and elaborating further the new asymptotic expansion method [19] for the Wheeler-DeWitt equation, we derive the quantum field theory for a matter field from the Wheeler-DeWittt equation for the gravity coupled to the matter field, which is equivalent to a gravitational field equation and a matrix equation for the matter field through a definition of cosmological time.
[Show full text]
Inflation Without Quantum Gravity
Inflation without quantum gravity Tommi Markkanen, Syksy Räsänen and Pyry Wahlman University of Helsinki, Department of Physics and Helsinki Institute of Physics P.O. Box 64, FIN-00014 University of Helsinki, Finland E-mail: tommi dot markkanen at helsinki dot fi, syksy dot rasanen at iki dot fi, pyry dot wahlman at helsinki dot fi Abstract. It is sometimes argued that observation of tensor modes from inflation would provide the first evidence for quantum gravity. However, in the usual inflationary formalism, also the scalar modes involve quantised metric perturbations. We consider the issue in a semiclassical setup in which only matter is quantised, and spacetime is classical. We assume that the state collapses on a spacelike hypersurface, and find that the spectrum of scalar perturbations depends on the hypersurface. For reasonable choices, we can recover the usual inflationary predictions for scalar perturbations in minimally coupled single-field models. In models where non-minimal coupling to gravity is important and the field value is sub-Planckian, we do not get a nearly scale-invariant spectrum of scalar perturbations. As gravitational waves are only produced at second order, the tensor-to-scalar ratio is negligible. We conclude that detection of inflationary gravitational waves would indeed be needed to have observational evidence of quantisation of gravity. arXiv:1407.4691v2 [astro-ph.CO] 4 May 2015 Contents 1 Introduction 1 2 Semiclassical inflation 3 2.1 Action and equations of motion 3 2.2 From homogeneity and isotropy to perturbations 6 3 Matching across the collapse 7 3.1 Hypersurface of collapse 7 3.2 Inflation models 10 4 Conclusions 13 1 Introduction Inflation and the quantisation of gravity.
[Show full text]
Open Dissertation-Final.Pdf
The Pennsylvania State University The Graduate School The Eberly College of Science CORRELATIONS IN QUANTUM GRAVITY AND COSMOLOGY A Dissertation in Physics by Bekir Baytas © 2018 Bekir Baytas Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy August 2018 The dissertation of Bekir Baytas was reviewed and approved∗ by the following: Sarah Shandera Assistant Professor of Physics Dissertation Advisor, Chair of Committee Eugenio Bianchi Assistant Professor of Physics Martin Bojowald Professor of Physics Donghui Jeong Assistant Professor of Astronomy and Astrophysics Nitin Samarth Professor of Physics Head of the Department of Physics ∗Signatures are on file in the Graduate School. ii Abstract We study what kind of implications and inferences one can deduce by studying correlations which are realized in various physical systems. In particular, this thesis focuses on specific correlations in systems that are considered in quantum gravity (loop quantum gravity) and cosmology. In loop quantum gravity, a spin-network basis state, nodes of the graph describe un-entangled quantum regions of space, quantum polyhedra. We introduce Bell- network states and study correlations of quantum polyhedra in a dipole, a pentagram and a generic graph. We find that vector geometries, structures with neighboring polyhedra having adjacent faces glued back-to-back, arise from Bell-network states. The results present show clearly the role that entanglement plays in the gluing of neighboring quantum regions of space. We introduce a discrete quantum spin system in which canonical effective methods for background independent theories of quantum gravity can be tested with promising results. In particular, features of interacting dynamics are analyzed with an emphasis on homogeneous configurations and the dynamical building- up and stability of long-range correlations.
[Show full text]
SEMICLASSICAL GRAVITY and ASTROPHYSICS Arundhati Dasgupta, Lethbridge, CCGRRA-16 WHY PROBE SEMICLASSICAL GRAVITY at ALL
SEMICLASSICAL GRAVITY AND ASTROPHYSICS arundhati dasgupta, lethbridge, CCGRRA-16 WHY PROBE SEMICLASSICAL GRAVITY AT ALL quantum gravity is important at Planck scales Semi classical gravity is important, as Hawking estimated for primordial black holes of radius using coherent states I showed that instabilities can happen due to semi classical corrections for black holes with horizon radius of the order of WHY COHERENT STATES useful semiclassical states in any quantum theory expectation values of the operators are closest to their classical values fluctuations about the classical value are controlled, usually by `standard deviation’ parameter as in a Gaussian, and what can be termed as `semi-classical’ parameter. in SHM coherent states expectation values of operators are exact, but not so in non-abelian coherent states LQG: THE QUANTUM GRAVITY THEORY WHERE COHERENT STATES CAN BE DEFINED based on work by mathematician Hall. coherent states are defined as the Kernel of transformation from real Hilbert space to the Segal-Bergman representation. S e & # 1 h A = Pexp$ Adx! I I −1 e ( ) $ ∫ ! Pe = − Tr[T h e * E h e ] % e " a ∫ EXPECTATION VALUES OF OPERATORS Coherent State in the holonomy representation The expectation values of the momentum operator non-polynomial corrections CORRECTIONS TO THE HOLONOMY GEOMETRIC INTERPRETATION Lemaitre metric does not cancel when corrected The corrected metric does not transform to the Schwarzschild metric WHAT DOES THIS `EXTRA TERM’ MEAN It is a `strain’ on the space-time fabric. Can LIGO detect such changes from the classical metric? This is a linearized perturbation over a Schwarzschild metric, and would contribute to `even’ mode of a spherical gravity wave, though cannot be anticipated in the polynomial linearized mode expansion unstatic-unspherical semiclassical correction THE STRAIN MAGNITUDE A.
[Show full text]
Approximate Solution to the CGHS Field Equations for Two-Dimensional
Approximate solution to the CGHS field equations for two-dimensional evaporating black holes Amos Ori Department of Physics, Technion-Israel Institute of Technology, Haifa 32000, Israel November 6, 2018 Abstract Callan, Giddings, Harvey and Strominger (CGHS) previously in- troduced a two-dimensional semiclassical model of gravity coupled to a dilaton and to matter fields. Their model yields a system of field equations which may describe the formation of a black hole in gravita- tional collapse as well as its subsequent evaporation. Here we present an approximate analytical solution to the semiclassical CGHS field equations. This solution is constructed using the recently-introduced formalism of flux-conserving hyperbolic systems. We also explore the asymptotic behavior at the horizon of the evaporating black hole. 1 Introduction arXiv:1007.3856v1 [gr-qc] 22 Jul 2010 The semiclassical theory of gravity treats spacetime geometry at the classi- cal level but allows quantum treatment of the various fields which reside in spacetime. This theory asserts that a quantum field living on a black-hole (BH) background will usually be endowed with non-trivial fluxes of energy- momentum. These fluxes, represented by the renormalized stress-Energy ten- ^ sor Tαβ, originate from the field’s quantum fluctuations, and typically they do not vanish even in the (incoming) vacuum state. The Hawking radiation 1 [1], and the consequent black-hole (BH) evaporation, are perhaps the most dramatic manifestations of these quantum fluxes. In the framework of semiclassical gravity the spacetime reacts to the quan- tum fluxes via the Einstein equations, which now receive the extra quantum ^ contribution Tαβ at their right-hand side.
[Show full text]
Quantum Gravity: a Primer for Philosophers∗
Quantum Gravity: A Primer for Philosophers∗ Dean Rickles ‘Quantum Gravity’ does not denote any existing theory: the field of quantum gravity is very much a ‘work in progress’. As you will see in this chapter, there are multiple lines of attack each with the same core goal: to find a theory that unifies, in some sense, general relativity (Einstein’s classical field theory of gravitation) and quantum field theory (the theoretical framework through which we understand the behaviour of particles in non-gravitational fields). Quantum field theory and general relativity seem to be like oil and water, they don’t like to mix—it is fair to say that combining them to produce a theory of quantum gravity constitutes the greatest unresolved puzzle in physics. Our goal in this chapter is to give the reader an impression of what the problem of quantum gravity is; why it is an important problem; the ways that have been suggested to resolve it; and what philosophical issues these approaches, and the problem itself, generate. This review is extremely selective, as it has to be to remain a manageable size: generally, rather than going into great detail in some area, we highlight the key features and the options, in the hope that readers may take up the problem for themselves—however, some of the basic formalism will be introduced so that the reader is able to enter the physics and (what little there is of) the philosophy of physics literature prepared.1 I have also supplied references for those cases where I have omitted some important facts.
[Show full text]
Canonical Quantum Gravity and the Problem of Time
Imperial/TP/91-92/25 Canonical Quantum Gravity and the Problem of Time 1 2 C.J. Isham Blackett Laboratory Imperial College South Kensington London SW7 2BZ United Kingdom August 1992 Abstract The aim of this paper is to provide a general introduction to the problem of time in quantum gravity. This problem originates in the fundamental conflict between arXiv:gr-qc/9210011v1 21 Oct 1992 the way the concept of ‘time’ is used in quantum theory, and the role it plays in a diffeomorphism-invariant theory like general relativity. Schemes for resolving this problem can be sub-divided into three main categories: (I) approaches in which time is identified before quantising; (II) approaches in which time is identified after quantising; and (III) approaches in which time plays no fundamental role at all. Ten different specific schemes are discussed in this paper which also contain an introduction to the relevant parts of the canonical decomposition of general relativity. 1Lectures presented at the NATO Advanced Study Institute “Recent Problems in Mathematical Physics”, Salamanca, June 15–27, 1992. 2Research supported in part by SERC grant GR/G60918. Contents 1 INTRODUCTION 4 1.1 Preamble ................................... 4 1.2 PreliminaryRemarks ............................. 4 1.3 Current Research Programmes in Quantum Gravity . ..... 6 1.4 OutlineofthePaper ............................. 8 1.5 Conventions.................................. 9 2 QUANTUMGRAVITYANDTHEPROBLEMOFTIME 9 2.1 Time in Conventional Quantum Theory . .. 10 2.2 Time in a Diff( )-invariantTheory . 12 M 2.3 ApproachestotheProblemofTime. 16 2.4 Technical Problems With Time . 19 3 CANONICALGENERALRELATIVITY 20 3.1 IntroductoryRemarks ............................ 21 3.2 Quantum Field Theory in a Curved Background .
[Show full text]
Energy Conditions in Semiclassical and Quantum Gravity
Energy conditions in semiclassical and quantum gravity Sergi Sirera Lahoz Supervised by Professor Toby Wiseman Imperial College London Department of Physics, Theory Group Submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Science of Imperial College London MSc Quantum Fields and Fundamental Forces 2nd October 2020 Abstract We explore the state of energy conditions in semiclassical and quantum gravity. Our review introduces energy conditions with a philosophical discussion about their nature. Energy conditions in classical gravity are reviewed together with their main applications. It is shown, among other results, how one can obtain singularity the- orems from such conditions. Classical and quantum physical systems violating the conditions are studied. We find that quantum fields entail negative energy densities that violate the classical conditions. The character of these violations motivates the quantum interest conjecture, which in turn guides the design of quantum energy conditions. The two best candidates, the AANEC and the QNEC, are examined in detail and the main applications revisited from their new perspectives. Several proofs for interacting field theories and/or curved spacetimes are demonstrated for both conditions using techniques from microcausality, holography, quantum infor- mation, and other modern ideas. Finally, the AANEC and the QNEC will be shown to be equivalent in M4. i Acknowledgements First of all, I would like to express my gratitude to Prof. Toby Wiseman for supervising this dissertation. Despite the challenges of not being able to meet in person, your guidance and expertise have helped me greatly to stay on track. The simple and clear way in which you communicate ideas has stimulated my interest in the topic and deepened my comprehension.
[Show full text]
Black Hole Evaporation and Semiclassicality at Large D
PHYSICAL REVIEW D 102, 026016 (2020) Black hole evaporation and semiclassicality at large D † ‡ Frederik Holdt-Sørensen ,1,2,* David A. McGady,1,2,3, and Nico Wintergerst 1, 1Niels Bohr Institute, Blegdamsvej 17, DK-2100 Copenhagen Ø, Denmark 2Niels Bohr International Academy, Blegdamsvej 17, DK-2100 Copenhagen Ø, Denmark 3Nordita, KTH Royal Institute of Technology and Stockholm University, Roslagstullsbacken 23, SE-106 91 Stockholm, Sweden (Received 29 August 2019; accepted 16 June 2020; published 15 July 2020) Black holes of sufficiently large initial radius are expected to be well described by a semiclassical analysis at least until half of their initial mass has evaporated away. For a small number of spacetime dimensions, this holds as long as the black hole is parametrically larger than the Planck length. In that case, curvatures are small, and backreaction onto geometry is expected to be well described by a time-dependent classical metric. We point out that at large D, small curvature is insufficient to guarantee a valid semiclassical description of black holes. Instead, the strongest bounds come from demanding that the rate of change of the geometry is small and that black holes scramble information faster than they evaporate. This is a consequence of the enormous power of Hawking radiation in D dimensions due to the large available phase space and the resulting minuscule evaporation times. Asymptotically, only black holes with entropies S ≥ DDþ3 log D are semiclassical. We comment on implications for realistic quantum gravity models in D ≤ 26 as well as relations to bounds on theories with a large number of gravitationally interacting light species.
[Show full text]
Energy Conditions in General Relativity and Quantum Field Theory Arxiv:2003.01815V2 [Gr-Qc] 5 Jun 2020
Energy conditions in general relativity and quantum field theory Eleni-Alexandra Kontou∗ Department of Mathematics, University of York, Heslington, York YO10 5DD, United Kingdom Department of Physics, College of the Holy Cross, Worcester, Massachusetts 01610, USA Ko Sanders y Dublin City University, School of Mathematical Sciences and Centre for Astrophysics and Relativity, Glasnevin, Dublin 9, Ireland June 8, 2020 Abstract This review summarizes the current status of the energy conditions in general relativity and quantum field theory. We provide a historical review and a summary of technical results and applications, complemented with a few new derivations and discussions. We pay special attention to the role of the equations of motion and to the relation between classical and quantum theories. Pointwise energy conditions were first introduced as physically reasonable restrictions on mat- ter in the context of general relativity. They aim to express e.g. the positivity of mass or the attractiveness of gravity. Perhaps more importantly, they have been used as assumptions in math- ematical relativity to prove singularity theorems and the non-existence of wormholes and similar exotic phenomena. However, the delicate balance between conceptual simplicity, general validity and strong results has faced serious challenges, because all pointwise energy conditions are sys- tematically violated by quantum fields and also by some rather simple classical fields. In response to these challenges, weaker statements were introduced, such as quantum energy inequalities and averaged energy conditions. These have a larger range of validity and may still suffice to prove at least some of the earlier results. One of these conditions, the achronal averaged null energy arXiv:2003.01815v2 [gr-qc] 5 Jun 2020 condition, has recently received increased attention.
[Show full text]