Municipal Equality Index Equality Municipal a NA Municipal Equality Index Equality Municipal a NA Municipal Equality Index Equality Municipal a NA
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
1640 Rhode Island Ave. N.W. Washington, DC 20036-3278 16401640 RhodeRhode IslandIsland Ave.Ave. N.W.N.W. Washington,Washington, DCDC 20036-327820036-3278 FRONT DESK: (202) 628-4160 TTY: (202) 216-1572 Municipal Equality Index TOLL-FREE: (800) 777-4723 FFRORONNTT D DESK:ESK: (202)(202) 628-4160628-4160 FAX: (202) 347-5323 A NATIONWIDE EVALUATION OF MUNICIPAL LAW TTTTYY:: (202)(202) 216-1572216-1572 MunicipalMunicipal EqualityEquality IndexIndex TTOLL-OLL-FFREE:REE: (800)(800) 777-4723777-4723 FAX:FAX: (202)(202) 347-5323347-5323 AA NNAATIOTIONNWIDEWIDE EVAEVALULUAATIOTIONN OFOF MUMUNNICIPICIPAALL LALAWW 2013 20132013 2013 Municipal Equality Index Municipal Equality 2013 2013 Municipal Equality Index Municipal Equality 2013 2013 Municipal Equality Index Municipal Equality 2013 A N A TIO N WIDE EVA LU A A N A N TIO N A A OF MU TIO TIO N N WIDE WIDE N ICIP A EVA EVA L LA W LU LU A A TIO TIO N N OF MU OF MU HRC-cover.indd 1 11/13/13 8:25 PM N N ICIP ICIP A A L LA L LA W W HRC-cover.indd 1 11/13/13 8:25 PM ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS TABLE OF CONTENTS Frequently Asked Questions An Introduction HOWABOUT WER ETH TEH ESEAUT HOR HOWTH EAR MEEI T HTEEAM SCORES CANWe O oweNLY many CITIES thanks IN toST JessieATES 4 TheA Municipal Letter from Chad Equality Griffin, PresidentIndex wouldof the Human not Rightshave Campaign been possible Foundation without the valuable 5 A Letter from Rebecca Isaacs, Executive Director of the Equality Federation Institute CITIESCathryn CH OakleyOSEN? is Legislative Counsel, CATheLCUL 2013ATED? MEI is a project that WITSheffield,H GOOD Sam LA Anderson,WS GET LimorGOOD Finkel contributions made by state and local advocates. A particular thanks therefore goes ThisState year, and the Municipal cities rated Advocacy are: the at the Citiesrequires are rated a significant on a scale breadth of 0-100, and SCOandR ES?Jennifer Pike who jumped in when 6 “Enduring Growth for Cities Is Driven by Diversity,” by Richard Florida 50 Humanstate capitals, Rights Campaign the 150 largest Foundation. Inbased depth on ofthe expertise city’s laws, to pullpolicies, off, and Definitelywe needed not. extraThe MEI hands, was and also to out to the following: citiesaddition in the to United conducting, States, managing, the 3 and benefits,fortunately and services. the team There of people are who specificallythe law fellows designed and tointerns measure who helpedthe largestpublishing cities theor municipalities Municipal Equality in Index, 100support standard this points project and is 20 more bonus than up lawsout and throughout policies theof the process. municipality, Paul eachshe state, is responsible the city home for assisting to the state pointsto the (bonus task. points are awarded for not Guequierrethe state. While has been state an lawindispensable might How It Works state’sand largestlocal legislators public university and advocates programming or actions that apply addfriend to a city’sto and score, a voice positive of municipal state 12 Executive Summary (includingin enacting undergraduate laws that further and LGBT to someAs ever, but this not project all cities). simply For would more not lawequality. is not necessary Aisha Satterwhite for a city has to been 14 2013 MEI Scorecard graduateequality. enrollment) She is a member and 75 of cities HRC informationhave been on possible the scoring without system, Sarah scorea patient 100 points. and helpful In fact, guide. some Janice cities 16 City Selection andFoundation’s municipalities field that team. have high seeWarbelow page 17. and Whitney Lovell, each withoutHughes positive and Bob state Villaflor law did made score sure 17 Scoring Criteria Parts I - VI proportions of same-sex couples of whom dispensed truly incredible 100everything points in wasthis beautiful,year’s index. informative 26 Acknowledging Context (seeCathryn page 16is afor member more information).of the Virginia WHERamountsE DID of wisdomTHE IN andFORMATIO support—notN and on time, and Soung Wiser and • Not All Cities Are Created Equal Futurebar andeditions practiced of the family Municipal law before FOtoR mentionTHESE elbowSCO RESgrease—and are IS TCarolineHIS A RANKIBrickell NofG The OF General THE • Accounting for City Size Equalityjoining Index the Human will continue Rights Campaignto COresponsibleME FROM? for making this project BESTDesign CITIES Co. are FO responsibleR LGBT PEOPLE for the • Balancing State and Local Laws increaseFoundation. the number She is aof graduate cities rated. of Theactually MEI team happen. conducted the TO incredibleLIVE IN? design. George Mason University School of research, compiled it into a draft No. This is not a ranking of a city’s • Understanding Restrictive State Law DIDLaw YOU and K SmithNOW College. THAT ___ ISN’T scorecard,This year and the sentMEI owesit to the a particular city for atmosphereFINALLY, or BUT quality ESPECI of life. AItLLY, is WE • Effect of Enforcement and Lived Experience A CITY? review.debt Citiesof gratitude had an to opportunityMichael Porcello, to an evaluationTHANK OU of Rthe P ARcity’sTNER lawsS and AT THE Yes. A few of the places rated in reviewResearch the draft Fellow scorecard Extraordinaire, and offer who policiesEQU andALITY an examinationFEDERATIO ofN. how the MEI are “census-designated anyprovided feedback vital prior research, to publication. logistical, and inclusiveThis partnership city services has are been of aLGBT delight and places” that are not incorporated as moral support to the MEI 2013. The people.has brought Some high-scoringreal value to the cities project What We Found cities. In that case, we rated the local dramatic expansion of this project may not feel truly welcoming for all from the start. It has been a particular 38 Summary of Results government that actually serves that would not have been possible without LGBT people, and some low-scoring pleasure to work so closely with Ian 41 Table of 2013 Scores census-designated place, which is him, and the MEI benefited greatly from cities may feel more welcoming than Palmquist, and the MEI owes a real 54 Take Action for Equality usually the county. This is explained his months of hard work collecting, their policies might reflect. debt of gratitude to Ian, A.J. Bockelman, 55 Changes to the MEI in 2014 further on page 16. managing and assessing thousands of Brandie Balken, Chuck Smith, Katie 58 Acknowledgements pieces of data. We offer him a heartfelt Belanger and Ted Martin for sharing acknowledgement of everything that he their thoughtful advice about growing contributed to this project and we will and improving the MEI. We thank miss him next year. those Equality Federation partners who Success Stories shared their story in this publication. Research ProcessPamela O’Leary joined the MEI team The participation of so many state 13 San Antonio, Texas by Mayor Julian Castro this year and jumped in right away— leaders has made this project a much 18 Missoula, Montana by City Councilmember Caitlin Copple The information reflected in this Ourwe team are sentthankful out fora letter her enthusiasm, by Themore feedback robust window and useful lasted educational several tool, 22 Equality Maryland by Executive Director Carrie Evans publication was gathered by the emaildedication, and certified and many mail hardin April hours to of months.and a Finally,very special cities thanks were sentgoes out to 29 Atlanta, Georgia by Mayor Kasim Reed MEI team and compiled into draft mayorswork. and Her city contribution managers was notifying critical to theirevery final Equality scorecards Federation and information member who 40 Fairness Kentucky by Executive Director Chris Hartman scorecards using publicly available themthe that project’s their citiessuccess were and being we were glad aboutprovided the 2014 feedback— MEI inplease the same see the 44 South Carolina Equality by Executive Director Ryan Wilson information. Cities were then rated.to haveThe hadletter her was on followedboard. by way.facing Equality page Federation for the logos Institute of groups 49 Greater Philadelphia Chamber of Commerce by Director of Public Policy Joe Grace offered an opportunity to review a draft scorecard sent to the mayors statethat groups were alsoparticularly were able engaged to in 53 Equality Ohio by Deputy Executive Director Kim Welter the scorecards, ask any questions, and city managers in July also via reviewmaking the scorecardsthe MEI a success and provide this year. andFor submit questionsany additional information or additional email and certified information, mail. feedbackWe look to forward the MEI to team. working with you they wished for the MEI team again next year for MEI 2014! to consider.please contact [email protected]. © 2013 by the Human Rights Campaign Foundation. The Human Rights Campaign Foundation owns all right, title, and interest in and to this ISBN 978-1-934765-28-9 publication and all derivative works thereof. Permission for reproduction and redistribution is granted if the publication is (1) reproduced in its ISBN 1-934765-28-7 entirety and (2) distributed free of charge. The Human Rights Campaign and the Equality logo are trademarks of the Human Rights Campaign. The Human Rights Campaign Foundation and design incorporating the Equality logo are trademarks of the Human Rights Campaign Foundation. IFC258 AN W INTRHAT ODUCTIOWE FOUNDN hrc.org/meihrc.org/mei hrc.org/meihrc.org/mei WHAT WE FOUND 1 59 f-HRC-MEI.inddf-HRC-MEI.indd 2-1 58-59 11/13/1311/13/13 7:59 PM8:00 PM TABLE OF CONTENTS An Introduction 4 A Letter from Chad Griffin, President of the Human Rights Campaign