“Here in the South, We Do Not Like Carnival” Subnational Identity As a Political Strategy in Southern Brazil
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
“Here in the South, we do not like Carnival” Subnational Identity as a Political Strategy in Southern Brazil Author: Alexine van Olst Student ID: 10000552 Supervisor: Prof. Dr. C.G. Koonings Second Reader: Dr. B. Hogenboom Master’s Thesis in Latin American Studies CEDLA Master’s Programme December 2017 Acknowledgements First and foremost, I sincerely would like to thank Professor C.G. Koonings for sharing his knowledge, for his enthusiasm and his insightful comments that lifted my thought process to a higher level throughout every stage of this thesis. Thank you to all leaders, members and supporters of O Sul É O Meu País who have been willing to explain me their outlook on life. In particular I would like to thank Wanderlei Salvador, who has been so kind to show me around the beautiful state of Santa Catarina. Furthermore, I would like to express my gratitude to Professor R.G. Oliven for sharing his knowledge with me. To everyone I discussed my thesis with over time: I am so glad all of you took the time to share your knowledge, opinions and doubts about this research with me. Last but certainly not least, a special thanks to my family, friends, and fellow CMP-students who have always encouraged me to work hard, to stay focused and to not forget to have fun every once in a while. 1 Abstract This thesis explores the role of subnational cultural identity in separatist movements. To do so, it focuses on a case study of the movement O Sul É O Meu País. This movement aims to establish an independent nation state for the three most southern states of the Brazilian federation, Paraná, Santa Catarina and Rio Grande do Sul. The findings in this thesis are based on a survey among members of the movement as well as interviews with leaders and supporters of the organisation. Through a combination of qualitative and quantitative research methods, the differences between the official narratives on cultural subnational identity, reasons for supporting the movement and possible outcomes are compared to the interpretations of these factors by members of the movement. Moreover, the differences in interpretations in Paraná, Santa Catarina and Rio Grande do Sul are explored, as to highlight the distinct reasons for support for independence in these three states. Regarding the importance of subnational cultural identity in this separatist movement, it is argued that although the cultural otherness is not considered the most important reason to support secessionist ideas, it forms the ‘cherry on top’ that lifts O Sul É O Meu País’s narratives from rational fiscal and political reasons to a narrative of a Sulista Self seeking independence from the Brazilian Other. Esta tese explora o papel da identidade cultural subnacional nos movimentos separatistas. Para isso, concentra-se em um estudo de caso do movimento O Sul É O Meu País. Este movimento visa estabelecer um Estado-nação independente para os três estados da região Sul da federação brasileira, Paraná, Santa Catarina e Rio Grande do Sul. As evidências nesta tese são principalmente baseadas em uma pesquisa entre os membros do movimento, bem como entrevistas com líderes e apoiadores da organização. Através de uma combinação de métodos de pesquisa qualitativa e quantitativa, são comparadas as diferenças entre as narrativas oficiais sobre a identidade subnacional cultural, as razões para apoiar o movimento e seus possíveis resultados e as interpretações desses fatores pelos membros do movimento. Além disso, são exploradas as diferenças de interpretação no Paraná, Santa Catarina e Rio Grande do Sul, para destacar os motivos distintos de apoio à independência nestes três estados. Em relação à importância da identidade cultural subnacional neste movimento separatista, argumenta-se que, embora a alteridade cultural não seja considerada a razão mais importante para apoiar ideias separatistas, ela forma a ‘cereja no bolo’ que levanta as narrativas de O Sul É O Meu País de razões fiscais e políticas a uma narrativa do Próprio Sulista buscando independência do Outro Brasileiro. 2 Contents Acknowledgements ...................................................................................................................................... 1 Abstract .......................................................................................................................................................... 2 Chapter 1. Brazil: Everyone’s Country? Subnationalism and Separatism in Southern Brazil ........... 5 Case Study: O Sul É O Meu País ................................................................................................. 6 Key Concepts and Research Question ........................................................................................ 8 Methodology.................................................................................................................................... 9 Structure of the Thesis ................................................................................................................. 13 Chapter 2. Key Concepts and Debates on (sub)National Identity and Separatism ......................... 14 National Thought in Europe and Latin America: a Comparative Overview ....................... 15 Decentralisation, Subnationalism and the Politics of Subnational Identities ....................... 18 Building Brasilidade: the Process of National Identity Construction in Brazil ................... 21 Brazilians by Choice: Subnationalism in the South of Brazil ................................................. 24 Conclusion ..................................................................................................................................... 29 Chapter 3. Manifestations and Direct Democracy: the Organisation O Sul É O Meu País ........... 30 National, Regional and Municipal: the Three Organisational Levels of O Sul É O Meu País .................................................................................................................................................. 30 From A-Political to Political Movement? ................................................................................. 33 Democratic Values and Unification of Região Sul: Objectives and Strategies .................... 35 Online and Offline Visibility: Building Support for the Cause .............................................. 36 Basta de Brasília: to the Streets for O Sul É O Meu País ....................................................... 37 Plebisul: Testing Secessionist Ideas on the General Public .................................................... 39 A New Political Strategy: Popular Law Initiatives (PLIP) ...................................................... 41 Conclusion ..................................................................................................................................... 43 Chapter 4. Subnational Cultural Identity in Região Sul ........................................................................ 44 Official Narratives on Sulista-culture in O Sul É O Meu País ............................................... 44 Interpretations of Sulista-culture among the Members of O Sul É O Meu País ................ 48 3 Cultural Differences between Região Sul and Brazil through the Eyes of Members ......... 52 Conclusion ..................................................................................................................................... 54 Chapter 5. Reasons to Support OSEOMP and Preferred Outcomes ................................................ 56 Eight Reasons for Supporting O Sul É O Meu País ............................................................... 56 Reasons for Support in Rio Grande do Sul, Santa Catarina and Paraná .............................. 57 “To feel Sulista and not Brazilian”: General Trends in Supporting O Sul É O Meu País 60 Let’s Dream: Preferred Outcomes of the Activities of O Sul É O Meu País ...................... 61 Looking Ahead: Outlines of an Independent Sulista Nation State ....................................... 63 Conclusion ..................................................................................................................................... 65 Chapter 6. Subnationalism and Separatism in Southern Brazil: Conclusions ................................... 66 The Construction of a Sulista Subnational Cultural Identity ................................................. 66 Small Bureaucracy and Participatory Democracy: the Politics of O Sul É O Meu País .... 68 Reflections on O Sul É O Meu País as a Movement in a broader Context ......................... 69 Appendix 1. Survey Questions in Portuguese and English .................................................................. 72 Appendix 2. Research Question, Subquestions and sub-Subquestions ............................................. 81 Appendix 3. Publicity Materials O Sul É O Meu País .......................................................................... 82 Appendix 4. Overview Place of Birth Respondents and Ancestors ................................................... 85 Appendix 5. Ranking of Importance of Factors for Support for O Sul É O Meu País .................. 89 Appendix 6. Original Quotes in Portuguese per Chapter .................................................................... 97 Bibliography .............................................................................................................................................. 102 4 Chapter 1. Brazil: Everyone’s Country? Subnationalism and Separatism in Southern