PROPOSED VARIATION 2 TO THE PROPOSED CANTERBURY LAND AND WATER REGIONAL PLAN Summary of Decisions Requested Report PROVISION ORDER* Notified Saturday 13 December 2014 Further Submissions Close 5:00pm Friday 16 January 2015 * Please Note There is an Appendix B To This Summary That Contains Further Submission Points From The Proposed Canterbury Land And Water Regional Plan That Will Be Considered As Submissions To Variation 2. For Further Information Please See Appendix B. Report Number : R14/106 ISBN: 978-0-908316-05-2 (hard copy) ISBN: 978-0-908316-06-9 (web) ISBN: 978-0-908316-07-6 (CD) SUMMARY OF DECISIONS REQUESTED GUIDELINES 1. This is a summary of the decisions requested by submitters. 2. Anyone making a further submission should refer to a copy of the original submission, rather than rely solely on the summary. 3. Please refer to the following pages for the ID number of Submitters and Addresses for Service. 4. Environment Canterbury is using a new database system to record submissions, this means that the Summary of Decisions Requested will appear different to previous versions. Please use the guide below to understand the coding on the variation. Plan Provision tells Point ID is now you where in the the “coding “of plan the submission Submitter ID is the submission point is coded to now a 5 Digit point Number Sub ID Organisation Details Contact Name Address Line 1 Address Line 2 Address Line 3 Town/City Post Code 51457 Senior Policy Advisor Mr Lionel Hume PO Box 414 Ashburton 7740 Federated Farmers Combined Canterbury Branch 52107 Environmental Advisor NZPork Mrs Anita Murrell PO Box 4048 Wellington 6140 52186 Mr Keith Townshend 675 Lower Beach Road R.D.4 Ashburton 7774 52233 Nga Rūnanga and Te Rūnanga Mr James Caygill PO Box 13 046 Christchurch 8141 O Ngāi Tahu 52267 Horticulture New Zealand Mr Chris Keenan PO Box 10-232 Wellington 6143 52271 Dairy NZ Mr James Ryan PO Box 85006 Lincoln University Lincoln 7647 52278 Irrigation New Zealand Inc Mr Andrew Curtis 6 Sonter Road Wigram Christchurch 8042 52333 Fonterra Co-operative Group Ms Sue Ruston PO Box 417 Wellington 6140 Limited 53274 Chief Executive Fish and Game Mr Jay Graybill PO Box 150 Temuka 7948 Council Central South Island 53678 Bowden Environmental Ms Erin Harvey PO Box 404 Kaiapoi 7644 53682 Community & Public Health, Dr Alistair Humphrey PO Box 1475 Christchurch 8140 CDHB 53683 Dairy Holdings Ltd Mr Ben Williams C/- Ben Williams, Chapman Tripp PO Box 2510 Christchurch 8041 53688 Director General of Mr Herb Familton Private Bag 4715 Christchurch 8140 Conservation 53830 Bank of New Zealand, Mr Guy Ensor PO Box 1461 Christchurch 8140 Christchurch 53896 Gregory Partnership Mr and Mrs Wayne and 944 Valetta Westerfield Road RD 1 Ashburton 7771 Karen Gregory 53907 Hydrotrader Ltd Mr Warwick Pascoe PO Box 3132 Christchurch 8410 53967 Mr and Mrs G W B & T M 363 Anama Valetta Road RD 8 Ashburton 7778 Gallagher 54491 Synlait Milk Ltd Ms Laura Hull 1028 Heslerton Road RD 13 Rakaia 7783 56631 Assets Manager Ashburton Mr Andrew Guthrie 5 Baring Square West PO Box 94 Ashburton 7740 District Council 56632 Ms Joanne Burke 113 McKay's Road RD 12 Rakaia 7782 56639 Longbeach Dairies Mr Bill Thomas 233 Poplar Road R D 4 Ashburton 7774 56640 Mr Fraser Alister McKenzie 86 Woodvale Road 8 R D Ashburton 7778 56641 Longbeach Estate Ltd Mr William David Thomas 1754 Longbeach Road R D 4 Ashburton 7774 56648 Mr Brendon Stack 456 Hinds River Road RD 4 Ashburton Ashburton 7774 56650 Mr Alastair Studholme 1400 Ealing Road Coldstream Ashburton RD3 7773 56651 Mr Dion Gordon 499 Windermere RD 4 Ashburton 7774 56652 Terralea Partnership Mr Warwick Green 161 Wheatstone Road RD4 Ashburton 7774 56653 Director Valetta Pastures Mrs Claire Roy 724 Mayfield Valetta RD 1RD Ashburton 7771 56654 Mr Daniel Stack 60 Arowhenua St Arundel RD 22 Geraldine 7992 56655 Mr Steve Schmack Wavelength Dairies Ltd 958 Moorhouse Road RD 8 Ashburton 7778 56656 Mr Christopher Allen 3856 Thompsons Track R.D.1 Ashburton 7771 56657 MR John De Veth 6 Maclean St Cambridge 3434 56658 Environmental Officer Align Ms Clare Buchanan P.O. Box 80013 Riccarton Christchurch 8041 Farm Partners 56659 Mr Ben McLauchlan 463 Quarry Road mt somers Ashburton rd8 7778 56661 Mr Athel PRICE Amberside 1066 Mayfield- RD8 Ashburton 77778 Klondyke Road 56665 Mr James Murdoch 5RD Ashburton Mid Canterbury 7775 56666 Mr William Kingston 200 Downings Road R D 3 Ashburton 7772 56667 Mr Deane Taylor 1471 Grahams Road RD 4 Ashburton 7774 56668 K J and M C Read 1633 Boundary Road 3 RD Ashburton 7773 56669 P Everest and Others Mr Phillip Everest 1030 Fords Road RD 4 Ashburton 7774 56670 Mr Gary Wilson Glenmorganvale 5 RD Ashburton 7775 56671 Mr Brent Schmack 204 Winslow Willowby Road RD 5 Ashburton 7775 56684 NZSF Rural Investments (No 1) Mr Cameron Glass P O Box 16147 Christchurch 8441 Ltd 56686 Aubrey Aitken 1980 Ealing Montalto Road RD 5 Ashburton 7775 56687 Ashburton Hinds Drainage Mr Craig Fleming 17 Taylors Road RD3 Ashburton 7773 Rating District Liaison Committee 56688 NL & GM Carr Family Trust Mr and Mrs N L and G M 593 Barnswood Road RD 5 Ashburton 7775 Carr 56689 Mr John Low 52 Torboltons Road Ashburton 7700 56691 Shepherds Bush 2004 Ltd Mr and Ms C M and E A 917 Shepherds Bush Road RD 8 Ashburton 7778 Olley and McAllister 56702 Ballance Agri-Nutrients Mr Nigel Sadlier Private Bag 12 503 Tauranga Mail Centre Tauranga 3143 Limited 56703 Mr John Tavendale RD 6 Ashburton 7775 56704 Fulton Hogan Limited Mr Peter Savage P O Box 16-064 Hornby Christchurch 8441 56705 Cannak Farms Limited Mr Gary Henson 684 Trevors Road RD 5 Ashburton 7775 56706 Rangitata Diversion Race Mr Gavin Kemble Ryder Consulting Limited Level 1 89 Grey Street Tauranga 3141 Management Limited 56707 Upper Hinds Plains Land User Mr Michael Salvesen 405 Upper Downs Road RD 8 Ashburton 7778 Group 56708 Ravensdown Fertiliser Co- Mr Chris Hansen P O Box 51-282 Tawa Wellington 5249 operative Limited 56709 Mr and Mrs G J and J R Early 8 RD Ashburton 7778 56711 Ortongreen Farm Limited Ms Fiona Sutton 225 Russells Road RD 4 Ashburton 7774 56712 Mayfield Hinds Irrigation Ms A C and P J Limmer and P O Box 442 Christchurch 8140 Limited Newland 56718 Balshando Farming Limited Mr and Mrs Andrew and 395 Bannswood Road 5 RD Ashburton 7775 Sarah Carr 56719 Surrey Hills Station Mr Paul Richard Grigg Surrey Hills Road RD 1 Ashburton 7771 56721 Mr Lyndsay Read 312 Surveyors Road RD 4 Ashburton 7774 56722 Lowcliffe Dairies Limited Mr Owen Mansill P O Box 42-105 Addington Christchurch 8149 56723 Valetta Irrigation Limited Ms Pip Newland Tavendale and Partners P O Box 442 Christchurch 8140 56724 Valetta Farms Limited and Mr David Clark 884 Mayfield Valetta Road RD 1 Ashburton 7771 Valetta Holdings Limited 56725 Fertiliser Association of New Mr Greg Sneath P O Box 11519 Manners Street Central Wellington 6142 Zealand 56726 Strathern Farms Limited Mr Peter Anthony Blain 1587 Grahams Road RD 4 Ashburton 7774 56727 Beef +Lamb New Zealand Mr Ben O'Brien P O Box 121 Wellington 6140 Limited 56728 Mr Edward Winchester C/- HydroServices Attn: Warwick Pascoe P O Box 3132 Christchurch 8140 56729 Mr George Lumsden 91 Hollands Road RD 1 Ashburton 7771 56730 Hinds Plains Land and Water Mr Rob McDowel Mayfield 5 RD Ashburton 7775 Partnership 56731 Barrhill Chertsey Irrigation Mr Ben Williams C/- Ben Williams Chapman Tripp PO Box 2510 Christchurch 8041 Scheme 56756 N Stoddart Limited Mr Denis Stoddart 12 Millibrook Place Tinwald 7700 56757 M and M Stoddart Limited Mr Malcolm Stoddart 58 Montgomerys Road 4 RD ASHBURTON 7774 56797 Mr Stephen Bishop EMAIL ONLY [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] 56798 Eiffelton Community Group Mr Ian Mackenzie Akanui 902 Longbeach Road RD 4 Ashburton 7774 Irrigation Scheme 56799 Eiffelton Community Group Mr Ben Williams C/- Chapman Tripp PO Box 2510 Christchurch 8041 Irrigation Scheme Inc 56802 Bodiam Dairies Ltd Mr and Mrs Ben and 1026 Westerfield School Road RD 1 Ashburton 7771 Shannon Johnson 56811 Synlait Farms Ltd Ms Lucy Johnson PO Box 99 Darfield 7541 Plan Provision Point ID Sub ID Submitter Name Support/ Summary of Decision Requested Oppose Proposed Variation 2 to the Proposed Canterbury Land and V2 pLWRP-4 56632 Ms Joanne Burke Oppose I support the Federated Farmers submission in its entirety. Water Regional Plan - Section 13 Ashburton - Proposed Variation 2 to the Proposed Canterbury Land and V2 pLWRP-8 56648 Mr Brendon Stack Oppose Don't change the minimum flows on the drains in the Hinds catchment area. [this point has also been put against 13.4.19 and Table 13(e)] Water Regional Plan - Section 13 Ashburton - No need to have minimum distances at which these fences need to be. Let the farmer be responsible for fencing off waterway the best practical way to keep stock and machinery out. [this point has also been put against Schedule 24a(d)(ii)] Proposed Variation 2 to the Proposed Canterbury Land and V2 pLWRP-10 56651 Mr Dion Gordon Oppose Adopts in Full the submission of Eiffelton Community Group Irrigation Scheme Water Regional Plan - Section 13 Ashburton - Proposed Variation 2 to the Proposed Canterbury Land and V2 pLWRP-11 56653 Valetta Pastures Oppose No more restrictions on farming. Water Regional Plan - Section 13 Ashburton - Proposed Variation 2 to the Proposed Canterbury Land and V2 pLWRP-12 56655 Mr Steve Schmack Oppose I support the submissions from Dairy NZ Water Regional Plan - Section 13 Ashburton - Proposed Variation 2 to the Proposed Canterbury Land and V2 pLWRP-13 56656 Mr Christopher Support I support Combined Provinces of Federated Farmers of New Zealand submission in its entirety Water Regional Plan - Section 13 Ashburton - Allen Proposed Variation 2 to the Proposed Canterbury Land and V2 pLWRP-16 56657 Mr John De Veth Oppose Do not want any impact on farming business.