DOCSLIB.ORG

2 / 2009 Ssophosophos Časopis Mladih Istraživača / a Young Researchers’ Journal

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
2 / 2009 Ssophosophos Časopis Mladih Istraživača / a Young Researchers’ Journal ISSN 1840-3859 No. 2 / 2009 SSOPHOSOPHOS ČASOPIS MLADIH ISTRAŽIVAČA / A YOUNG RESEARCHERS’ JOURNAL Znanstveno-istraživački inkubator (ZINK) Filozofski fakultet u Sarajevu Scien fi c & Research Incubator Faculty of Philosophy in Sarajevo 2 3 SOPHOS Časopis mladih istraživača A Young Researchers’ Journal Broj 2, Godina: 2009 No. 2, Year: 2009 Za izdavača Publisher represented by Nijaz Ibrulj Nijaz Ibrulj Lektorica za bosanski jezik Language editor for Bosnian Elma Durmišević Elma Durmišević Lektor za engleski jezik Language editor for English Michael Mehen Michael Mehen Tiraž Circula on 500 500 Cijena primjerka Cost per issue 5.00 KM za fi zička lica 2.50 € for individuals 10.00 KM za pravna lica 5.00 € for corporate Kontakt za informisanje Contact Informa on Znanstveno-istraživački inkubator Scien fi c & Research Incubator Filozofski fakultet u Sarajevu Faculty of Philosophy in Sarajevo Franje Račkog 1 Franje Račkog 1 71.000 Sarajevo 71.000 Sarajevo Bosna i Herzegovina Bosnia & Herzegovina Tel. +387 33 253 126 Tel. +387 33 253 126 Fax. +387 33 667 874 Fax. +387 33 667 874 Email: zink@ff .unsa.ba Email: zink@ff .unsa.ba URL: h p://www.ziink.wordpress.com URL: h p://www.ziink.wordpress.com SOPHOS je indeksiran u SOPHOS is indexed and abstracted znanstvenoj bazi podataka in the scien fi c database INDEX COPERNICUS INTERNATIONAL INDEX COPERNICUS INTERNATIONAL h p://www.indexcopernicus.com h p://www.indexcopernicus.com 4 Publisher © Scien fi c & Research Incubator Faculty of Philosophy in Sarajevo Co-Publisher ACADEMIA ANALITICA Society for Development of Logic and Analy c Philosophy in Bosnia and Herzegovina Founding Editor Nijaz Ibrulj Editor-in-Chief Kenan Šljivo Execu ve Editor Vedad Muharemović Editorial Staff Irma Duraković Armin Methadžević Jelena Gaković Tijana Okić Ljiljana Tunjić Ljiljana Nikolić Ekrem Hamidović Denis Džanić Editorial Board Andrej Ule Jan Wolenski University of Ljubljana (Slovenia) Jagiellonian University in Krakow (Poland) Werner Stelzner Andrew Schumann University of Bremen (Gemany) Belarusian State University in Minsk (Belarus) Jure Zovko Samir Arnautović University of Zadar (Croa a) University of Sarajevo (B&H) Irene Lagani Nijaz Ibrulj University of Macedonia in Thessaloniki (Greece) University of Sarajevo (B&H) Iryna Khomenko Volker Munz Na onal Taras Shevchenko University of Kyiv University of Graz (Austria) (Ukraine) 5 Izdavač © Znanstveno-istraživački inkubator Filozofski fakultet u Sarajevu Suizdavač ACADEMIA ANALITICA Društvo za razvoj logike i anali čke fi lozofi je u Bosni i Hercegovini Urednik - Osnivač Nijaz Ibrulj Glavni urednik Kenan Šljivo Izvršni urednik Vedad Muharemović Urednička redakcija Irma Duraković Armin Methadžević Jelena Gaković Tijana Okić Ljiljana Tunjić Ljiljana Nikolić Ekrem Hamidović Denis Džanić Urednički savjet Andrej Ule Jan Wolenski Univerzitet u Ljubljani (Slovenija) Jagiellonian Univerzitet u Krakovu (Poljska) Werner Stelzner Andrew Schumann Univerzitet u Bremenu (Njemačka) Bjeloruski državni Univerzitet u Minsku (Bjelorusija) Jure Zovko Univerzitet u Zadru (Hrvatska) Samir Arnautović Univerzitet u Sarajevu (BiH) Irene Lagani Makedonski univerzitet u Solunu (Grčka) Nijaz Ibrulj Univerzitet u Sarajevu (BiH) Iryna Khomenko Narodni univerzitet Taras Ševčenko u Kijevu Volker Munz (Ukrajina) Univerzitet u Gracu (Austrija) 6 CONTENTS I Ar cles Vedad MUHAREMOVIĆ RORTY’S CRITIQUE OF FOUNDATIONALISM (TOWARD A PHILOSOPHY OF SOCIAL SENSIBILITY) ...............................................................11 Ljiljana NIKOLIĆ JOHANN CRISTOPH GODTTSCHED AND IMMANUEL KANT: REPRESENTATIVES OF A NEW TURNING POINT ON THE BASIS OF A COMMON PHILOSOPHICAL HERITAGE ...............37 Kerim SUŠIĆ AL-FÂRÂBI’S POLITICAL PHILOSOPHY ....................................................................................55 Ekrem HAMIDOVIĆ DONALD DAVIDSON’S THEORY OF RADICAL INTERPRETATION AND HIS PRINCIPLE OF CHARITY ............................................................................................75 Melisa BEGIĆ HUME’S ANALYSIS OF CAUSALITY ..........................................................................................93 Aida GAVRIĆ THE READER AS A NEW FOCUS OF WRITING AND MEANING .............................................107 II Transla ons Donald DAVIDSON COULD THERE BE A SCIENCE OF RATIONALITY? Translated from English into Bosnian: Igor ŽONTAR ............................................................121 David HILBERT AXIOMATIC THOUGHT Translated from German into Bosnian: Ljiljana NIKOLIĆ ......................................................135 Robert FRENCH SUBCOGNITION AND THE LIMITS OF THE TURING TEST Translated from English into Bosnian: Armin METHADŽEVIĆ ..............................................143 John SEARLE INTENTIONALITY AND ITS PLACE IN NATURE Translated from English into Bosnian: Kenan ŠLJIVO ...........................................................155 Jan ASSMANN COLLECTIVE MEMORY AND CULTURAL IDENTITY Translated from English into Bosnian: Bojan ČAHTAREVIĆ ..................................................167 III Book Reviews Vedad MUHAREMOVIĆ UMUT ÖZKIRIMLI: CONTEMPORARY DEBATES ON NATIONALISM. A CRITICAL ENGAGEMENT (New York, Palgrave Macmillan, 227 pages) ........................................................................175 Kerim SUŠIĆ DEISEL T. SUZUKI: ZEN AND JAPANESE CULTURE (Beograd, Geopoe ka, 365 pages) ......................................................................................181 7 SADRŽAJ I Članci Vedad MUHAREMOVIĆ RORTYJEVA KRITIKA FUNDACIONALIZMA (KA FILOZOFIJI SOCIJALNOG SENZIBILITETA)..........................................................................11 Ljiljana NIKOLIĆ JOHANN CRISTOPH GODTTSCHED I IMMANUEL KANT: NOSIOCI OBRATA NA OSNOVAMA ZAJEDNIČKOG FILOZOFSKOG NASLIJEĐA .......................................37 Kerim SUŠIĆ AL-FÂRÂBIJEVA POLITIČKA FILOZOFIJA ..................................................................................55 Ekrem HAMIDOVIĆ TEORIJA RADIKALNE INTERPRETACIJE I PRINCIP MILOSRĐA KOD DONALDA DAVIDSONA ................................................................................75 Melisa BEGIĆ HUMEOVA ANALIZA UZROČNOSTI ........................................................................................93 Aida GAVRIĆ ČITATELJ KAO NOVA ŽIŽA PISANJA I ZNAČENJA ...................................................................107 II Prijevodi Donald DAVIDSON MOŽE LI POSTOJATI ZNANOST O RACIONALNOSTI? Preveo s engleskog: Igor ŽONTAR ........................................................................................121 David HILBERT AKSIOMATSKO MIŠLJENJE Prevela s njemačkog: Ljiljana NIKOLIĆ ................................................................................135 Robert FRENCH SUBKOGNICIJA I GRANICE TURINGOVOG TESTA Preveo s engleskog: Armin METHADŽEVIĆ ..........................................................................143 John SEARLE INTENCIONALNOST I NJENO MJESTO U PRIRODI Preveo s engleskog: Kenan ŠLJIVO .......................................................................................155 Jan ASSMANN KOLEKTIVNO PAMĆENJE I KULTURNI IDENTITET Preveo s engleskog: Bojan ČAHTAREVIĆ ..............................................................................167 III Pregledi knjiga Vedad MUHAREMOVIĆ UMUT ÖZKIRIMLI: CONTEMOPORARY DEBATES ON NATIONALISM. A CRTICAL ENGAGEMENT (New York, Palgrave Macmillan, 227 str.) ............................................................................175 Kerim SUŠIĆ DEISEL T. SUZUKI: ZEN I JAPANSKA KULTURA (Beograd, Geopoe ka, 365 str.) ...........................................................................................181 8 Članci / Ar cles 10 Izvorni znanstveni članak / original scien fi c ar cle UDK 11/12 primljen / received: 03. 02. 2009 RORTYJEVA KRITIKA FUNDACIONALIZMA (KA FILOZOFIJI SOCIJALNOG SENZIBILITETA) Vedad MUHAREMOVIĆ Scien fi c & Research Incubator (ZINK) University of Sarajevo, Faculty of Philosophy Franje Račkog 1, 71000 Sarajevo, B&H E-mail: vedad.muharemovic@ff .unsa.ba ABSTRACT U tekstu razmatram neke od osnovnih karakteris ka Rortyjevog neopragma zma, unutar kojeg se mogu iščitava njegove kri ke svih esencijalis čki usmjerenih fi lozofi jskih formi koje svoju “zajedničku premisu” nalaze u onome što se naziva metafi zika. Težnjom ka fl eksibilnijim, prizemnijim i manje ambicioznim planovima kojima se fi lozofi ja profi lirala do sada, Rorty sugerira alterna vne načine kojima bi fi lozofi ja korespondirala u jednom mul disciplinarnom, interak vnom i an ekskluzivis čkom smislu sa znanos ma i sa drugim modusima ljudskog samopotvrđivanja, u cilju efektnijeg i konkretnijeg snalaženja i prak čnijeg “nošenja sa svijetom”. U tekstu, konačno, nastojim prikaza kako se vokabular metafi zike i metafi zička konstrukcija svijeta dekonceptualiziraju, ali i da je imenovanje vokabulara metafi zike “mrtvim metaforama”, u najmanju ruku, problema čno. Radi se o podjednako aktualnoj važnos svih oblika konačnih vokabulara u inkomenzurabilnom, dehijerarhizirajućem i mnogovrsno strukturiranom svijetu. Ključne riječi: metafi zika, konačni vokabulari, mrtve metafore, socijalni senzibilitet. RORTY’S CRITIQUE OF FOUNDATIONALISM (TOWARD A PHILOSOPHY OF SOCIAL SENSIBILITY) In this text I consider some of the fundamental characteris cs of Rorty’s neopragma sm, whence can be revealed Rorty’s cri cism of all essen alisms that fi nd their “common premises” in what Rorty calls metaphysics. By tending to provide more fl exible and less ambi ous philosophical projects Rorty suggests an alterna ve mode through which philosophy is able to correspond
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Nijaz Ibrulj Faculty of Philosophy University of Sarajevo BOSNIA PORPHYRIANA an OUTLINE of the DEVELOPMENT of LOGIC in BOSNIA AN
    UDK 16 (497.6) Nijaz Ibrulj Faculty of philosophy University of Sarajevo BOSNIA PORPHYRIANA AN OUTLINE OF THE DEVELOPMENT OF LOGIC IN BOSNIA AND HERZEGOVINA Abstract The text is a drought outlining the development of logic in Bosnia and Herzegovina through several periods of history: period of Ottoman occupation and administration of the Empire, period of Austro-Hungarian occupation and administration of the Monarchy, period of Communist regime and administration of the Socialist Republic and period from the aftermath of the aggression against the Republic of Bosnia and Herzegovina to this day (the Dayton Bosnia and Herzegovina) and administration of the International Community. For each of the aforementioned periods, the text treats the organization of education, the educational paradigm of the model, status of logic as a subject in the educational system of a period, as well as the central figures dealing with the issue of logic (as researchers, lecturers, authors) and the key works written in each of the periods, outlining their main ideas. The work of a Neoplatonic philosopher Porphyry, “Introduction” (Greek: Eijsagwgh;v Latin: Isagoge; Arabic: Īsāġūğī) , can be seen, in all periods of education in Bosnia and Herze - govina, as the main text, the principal textbook, as a motivation for logical thinking. That gave me the right to introduce the syntagm Bosnia Porphyriana. SURVEY 109 1. Introduction Man taman ṭaqa tazandaqa. He who practices logic becomes a heretic. 1 It would be impossible to elaborate the development of logic in Bosnia
    [Show full text]
  • Mantık Ve Felsefe Eğitiminin Bosna-Hersek'teki Tarihsel Gelişimi1
    Mayıs 2012 Cilt:20 No:2 Kastamonu Eğitim Dergisi 689-700 MANTIK VE FELSEFE EĞİTİMİNİN BOSNA-HERSEK’TEKİ TARİHSEL GELİŞİMİ1 Deniz KUNDAKÇI Kastamonu Üniversitesi, Felsefe Bölümü, Fen-Edebiyat Fakültesi, Kastamonu, Türkiye. İlk Kayıt Tarihi: 21.06.2011 Yayına Kabul Tarihi:27.12.2011 Özet Bu metinde, Osmanlı Dönemi’nde Bosna’da felsefe ve özellikle mantık eğitimi alanında yapılan çalışmalar incelendikten sonra, günümüzde Bosna-Hersek’te felsefenin toplumsal uzlaşı ve hoşgörü açısından taşıdığı önem üzerine odaklanılacaktır. Bu manada, özet ifadelerle de olsa, tarihsel bir takım sistem, kurum ve doktrinlerin değişmesiyle birlikte Bosna eğitim sistemi ve bir bilgi türü olarak felsefenin üzerindeki yansımaları izlenecektir. Çalışma boyunca üzerinde önemle durulacak konular ise, Aristoteles mantığının Osmanlı dönemi Bosna’sındaki etkileri, bu dönem Bosna’da hem Müslüman hem de Hıristiyan nüfusun mantık ve felsefe alanında yaptıkları çalışmalar ve dönemin eğitim kurumlarının özellikleri ve Yugoslavya’nın bir parçası olarak Bosna-Hersek’te felsefe alanında yapılan gelişmeler olacaktır. Son olarak da günümüz Bosna-Hersek’indeki mevcut felsefe kurumları ve eğitim alanındaki formel gelişmeler ele alınacaktır. Metin tarihsel ve felsefi süreci betimleyici ve kısmen de yorumlayıcı bir metotla kaleme alınmıştır. Çalışmada genel anlamıyla verilmek istenen mesaj ise, “Bosna-Hersek’te tarihsel bağlamda köklü bir felsefe ve mantık geleneğinin olduğu” “mevcut etnik ve kültürel farklılıkların ayrımcılık yerine zenginlik olarak yorumlamanın gerekli olduğu”
    [Show full text]
  • Nijaz Ibrulj Faculty of Philosophy University of Sarajevo BOSNIA
    SURVEY_2009:Layout 1 16.3.2010 9:46 Page 109 UDK 16 (497.6) Nijaz Ibrulj Faculty of Philosophy University of Sarajevo BOSNIA PORPHYRIANA AN OUTLINE OF THE DEVELOPMENT OF LOGIC IN BOSNIA AND HERZEGOVINA Abstract The text is a drought outlining the development of logic in Bosnia and Herzegovina through several periods of history: period of Ottoman occupation and administration of the Empire, period of Austro-Hungarian occupation and administration of the Monarchy, period of Communist regime and administration of the Socialist Republic and period from the aftermath of the aggression against the Republic of Bosnia and Herzegovina to this day (the Dayton Bosnia and Herzegovina) and administration of the International Community. For each of the aforementioned periods, the text treats the organization of education, the educational paradigm of the model, status of logic as a subject in the educational system of a period, as well as the central figures dealing with the issue of logic (as researchers, lecturers, authors) and the key works written in each of the periods, outlining their main ideas. The work of a Neoplatonic philosopher Porphyry, “Introduction” (Greek: Eijsagwgh;v Latin: Isagoge; Arabic: Īsāġūğī) , can be seen, in all periods of education in Bosnia and Herze - govina, as the main text, the principal textbook, as a motivation for logical thinking. That gave me the right to introduce the syntagm Bosnia Porphyriana. Key words : logic, education, Isagoge, Bosnia Porphyriana, schoolsystem in Bosnia and Hercegovina SURVEY 109 SURVEY_2009:Layout 1 16.3.2010 9:46 Page 110 1. Introduction Man taman ṭaqa tazandaqa. He who practices logic becomes a heretic.
    [Show full text]
  • Filozofska Pot Andreja Uleta
    Filozofska pot Andreja Uleta Ljubljana, 2019 Filozofska_pot_Uleta_FINAL.indd 1 19.4.2019 14:54:08 FILOZOFSKA POT ANDREJA ULETA Urednici: Olga Markič, Maja Malec Recenzenta: Mirt Komel, Zvezdan Pirtošek Lektoriranje prispevkov v slovenščini: Nina Petek Lektoriranje prispevkov v angleščini: Leonard Ciocan Oblikovanje in prelom: Irena Hvala Fotografija na naslovnici: Paul Klee – Rich Harbour Založila: Znanstvena založba Filozofske fakultete Univerze v Ljubljani Izdal: Oddelek za filozofijo Za založbo: Roman Kuhar, dekan Filozofske fakultete Univerze v Ljubljani Tisk: Birografika Bori, d. o. o. Ljubljana, 2019 Prva izdaja Naklada: 300 izvodov Cena: 24,90 EUR To delo je ponujeno pod licenco Creative Commons Priznanje avtorstva-Deljenje pod enakimi pogoji 4.0 Medna- rodna licenca. / This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License. Knjiga je izšla s podporo Javne agencije za raziskovalno dejavnost RS. Raziskovalni program št. P6-0252 je sofinancirala Javna agencija za raziskovalno dejavnost Republike Slovenije iz državnega proračuna. Prva e-izdaja. Publikacija je v digitalni obliki prosto dostopna na https://e-knjige.ff.uni-lj.si/ DOI: 10.4312/9789610601876 Kataložna zapisa o publikaciji (CIP) pripravili v Narodni in univerzitetni knjižnici v Ljubljani Tiskana knjiga COBISS.SI-ID=299629568 ISBN 978-961-06-0182-1 E-knjiga COBISS.SI-ID=299637504 ISBN 978-961-06-0187-6 (pdf) Filozofska_pot_Uleta_FINAL.indd 2 19.4.2019 14:54:08 Kazalo 3 Kazalo Uvod 5 Govor o neobstoju brez dodatnih ontoloških predpostavk
    [Show full text]
  • Prepričanje V Umno Prakso, Epistemsko Družbenost in Epistemsko Kulturo 239
    Prepričanje v umno prakso, epistemsko družbenost in epistemsko kulturo 239 Prepričanje v umno prakso, epistemsko družbenost in epistemsko kulturo Nijaz Ibrulj Filozofska fakulteta Univerze v Sarajevu Posvečeno praznovanju 70. obletnice rojstva filozofa Andreja Uleta Povzetek V besedilu, ki je posvečeno slovenskemu filozofu in logiku, univerzitetnemu profesorju in piscu znanstvenih del Andreju Uletu, izkazujem spoštovanje ob njegovem visokem jubileju in pri- znanje za njegov ogromni prispevek h komunikacijski skupnosti filozofov in znanstvenikov v evropskem okolju ter za uspešno dolgoletno sodelovanje pri razvoju filozofske in znanstvene misli v Bosni in Hercegovini. Na eni strani navajam ključna vprašanja sodobne filozofije in logi- ke, sodobne družbe in tehnologije, ki so zaznamovala delo Andreja Uleta, po drugi pa v članek umeščam sekvence iz filozofskega življenja v Bosni in Hercegovini, in sicer zaradi vpliva, ki ga je Andrej Ule kot človek in kot filozofski mislec, cenjen v širši regiji, imel oziroma ga še vedno ima. Ključne besede: Andrej Ule, Sarajevo, filozofija, logika, družba, znanje Belief in Rational Practice, Epistemic Sociality and Epistemic Culture – Abstract In Celebration of Prof. Andrej Ule’s 70th Birthday The paper, dedicated to the Slovenian philosopher, logician, professor and scientific author Andrej Ule, is a tribute to his work at the time of his jubilee and an acknowledgment of his extensive contribution to the European philosophical and scientific community as well as of his continued engagement in the development of philosophical and scientific thought in Bosnia and Herzegovina. On the one hand, I highlight the key issues within contemporary philosophy and logic, modern society and technology, which have influenced his works, and on the other, I mention the stages in the development of philosophical life in Bosnia and Her- zegovina in order to show Professor Ule’s enduring influence as a philosopher in this region.
    [Show full text]
  • 1 Univerzitet U Sarajevu Filozofski Fakultet U Sarajevu Odsjek Za Filozofiju Iii Ciklus Studija Na Univerzitetu U Sarajevu Suvre
    UNIVERZITET U SARAJEVU FILOZOFSKI FAKULTET U SARAJEVU ODSJEK ZA FILOZOFIJU III CIKLUS STUDIJA NA UNIVERZITETU U SARAJEVU SUVREMENA FILOZOFIJA (Studijska linija 2.) NOSITELJ STUDIJA: FILOZOFSKI FAKULTET U SARAJEVU ODSJEK ZA FILOZOFIJU SARAJEVO 30.04.2017. 1 SADRŽAJ PROGRAMA 1. ELABORAT O POKRETANJU DOKTORSKOG STUDIJA IZ FILOZOFIJE -STUDIJSKA LINIJA 2: SUVREMENA FILOZOFIJA 1.1. NAUČNA OPRAVDANOST ORGANIZIRANJA DOKTORSKOG STUDIJA FILOZOFIJE 1.2. EKONOMSKA OPRAVDANOST ORGANIZIRANJA DOKTORSKOG STUDIJA FILOZOFIJE 1.3. DRUŠTVENA OPRAVDANOST ORGANIZIRANJA DOKTORSKOG STUDIJA FILOZOFIJE 2. NASLOV STUDIJSKOG PROGRAMA I OBRAZLOŽENJE 3. ORGANIZATOR / NOSITELJ DOKTORSKOG STUDIJA 4. AKADEMSKI STUPANJ I OPIS ZVANJA 5. UVJETI UPISA I KRITERIJI IZBORA POLAZNIKA 6. ORGANIZACIJA STUDIJA 7. STRUKTURA STUDIJSKOG PROGRAMA 8. NASTAVNI PLAN I PROGRAM 9. PRAĆENJE REALIZACIJE I EVALUACIJA USPJEŠNOSTI STUDIJSKOG PROGRAMA 10. NASTAVNI SADRŽAJ PO PREDMETIMA I SEMINARIMA ( SILABUSI) 11. GENERALNI RASPORED IZVOĐENJA DOKTORSKOG STUDIJA 2012 – 2015 2 1. ELABORAT O POKRETANJU DOKTORSKOG STUDIJA IZ FILOZOFIJE -STUDIJSKA LINIJA 2: SUVREMENA FILOZOFIJA Bolonjski doktorski studij, za razliku od prethodnog načina stjecanja doktorskog zvanja, doveo je u međuovisnost sve nivoe obrazovanja u jednoj državi na taj način što je ustanovio ne samo hijerarhiju obrazovnih sadržaja nego i upotrebljivost stručnih kvalifikacija i zvanja koja se dobijaju. Sve do doktorskog stupnja nivoi obrazovanja se na ovaj ili onaj način smatraju smo strukovnim znanjima koja imaju potencijalnost dovršetka u doktorskom studiju i znanstvenoj kompetenciji koju ovaj studij daje.Promjenjeni način stjecanja, strukture, upotrebe i transfera znanja i tehnologija na univerzitetima u Bosni i Hercegovini traži adekvatnu organizaciju i uskladjivanje svih nivoa studiranja, dodiplomskog, diplomskog i postdiplomskog / doktorskog kako po kriterijima bodovanja, po modulima / predmetima tako i po broju sati i kvalitetu programa.
    [Show full text]
  • Studia Humana Volume 1:3/4 (2012), Pp.17—31 the Adjustment of Identity: Inquiries Into Logic and Semantics of an Uncertain
    Studia Humana Volume 1:3/4 (2012), pp.17—31 The Adjustment of Identity: Inquiries into Logic and Semantics of an Uncertain World Nijaz Ibrulj University of Sarajevo, Faculty of Philosophy [email protected] Abstract: In this article I present some characteristics of logic and semantics of an uncertain world. I confront two-valued and fuzzy logic. I use Kafka’s novel Process as an example, which is designed as an uncertain context with words which are rigid designators without rigid meaning. That produces an uncertain world of logical and semantical relations. In presentation of problems I introduce basic concepts of Frege’s, Wittgenstein’s, Tarsky’s, Searle’s, Quine’s and Davidson’s philosophy of language. I distinguish the logical and semantical identification of identity. Further, I make difference between reference and inference, or representation and identification as two components which are fundamental for the identification of identity. I ground this difference on the role of logical unification and granulation of predicates in the structure of thought and semantical unification and granulation of attributes in the structure of statements and their relation to ontology of context. Confronting the logical and semantical unification and granulation I find that the limits of logic are not also the limits of language. The semantical unification goes beyond the highest genre and below the lowest species. That enables the extra-logical, non-scientific, confessional, prophetic, artistic, and ordinary use of language. Who was that? A friend? A good person? Somebody who was taking part? Somebody who wanted to help? Was he alone? Was it everyone? Would anyone help? Were there objections that had been forgotten? There must have been some.
    [Show full text]
  • Nijaz Ibrulj the Adjustment of Identity: Inquiries Into Logic and Semantics of an Uncertain World
    Nijaz Ibrulj The Adjustment of Identity: Inquiries into Logic and Semantics of an Uncertain World Studia Humana nr 3/4, 17-31 2012 Studia Humana Volume 1:3/4 (2012), pp.17—31 The Adjustment of Identity: Inquiries into Logic and Semantics of an Uncertain World Nijaz Ibrulj University of Sarajevo, Faculty of Philosophy [email protected] Abstract: In this article I present some characteristics of logic and semantics of an uncertain world. I confront two-valued and fuzzy logic. I use Kafka’s novel Process as an example, which is designed as an uncertain context with words which are rigid designators without rigid meaning. That produces an uncertain world of logical and semantical relations. In presentation of problems I introduce basic concepts of Frege’s, Wittgenstein’s, Tarsky’s, Searle’s, Quine’s and Davidson’s philosophy of language. I distinguish the logical and semantical identification of identity. Further, I make difference between reference and inference, or representation and identification as two components which are fundamental for the identification of identity. I ground this difference on the role of logical unification and granulation of predicates in the structure of thought and semantical unification and granulation of attributes in the structure of statements and their relation to ontology of context. Confronting the logical and semantical unification and granulation I find that the limits of logic are not also the limits of language. The semantical unification goes beyond the highest genre and below the lowest species. That enables the extra-logical, non-scientific, confessional, prophetic, artistic, and ordinary use of language.
    [Show full text]
  • Nijaz-Ibrulj-Stoljece-Rearanziranja
    Nijaz IBRULJ STOLJEĆE REARANŽIRANJA Eseji ο identitetu, znanju i društvu Biblioteka Eidos FILOZOFSKO DRUŠTVO THEORIA Sarajevo 2005. Izdavač: FILOZOFSKO DRUŠTVO THEORIA Recenzenti: Ljubomir Berberović Samir Arnautović Biblioteka: Eidos Odgovorni urednik: Damir Marić CIP - Katalogizacija u publikaciji Nacionalne i univerzitetske biblioteke Bosne i Hercegovine, Sarajevo 316.33:111] IBRULJ, Nijaz Stoljeće rearanžiranja: eseji ο identitetu, znanju i društvu / Nijaz Ibrulj. - Sarajevo; Filozofsko društvo Theoria, 2005. - 255 str. ; 20 cm - (Biblioteka Eidos) Bibliografija: str. 248-255 ISBN 9958-9419-0-2 COBISS.BH-ID 14248966 Na osnovu Mišljenja Federalnog ministarstva obrazovanja i nauke broj 04-15-1837/05 od 23.05.2005. godine, knjiga "STOLJEĆE REA­ RANŽIRANJA ", autora Nijaza Ibrulja, oslobođena je plaćanja poreza na promet proizvoda. Sadržaj Uvod 7 Esej 1 Šta jeste a šta treba biti identitet? 17 Esej 2 Nanoznanost, nanotehnologija i rearanžiranje identiteta .... 49 Esej 3 Podešavanje identiteta (Istraživanja ο logici i semantici nepreciznog svijeta) 93 Esej 4 Holizam identiteta 125 Esej 5 Stoljeće rearanžiranja: nanoznanost i globalno društvo ... 151 Esej 6 Identitet i društvena ontologija 179 Esej 7 Kognitivni aspekti obrazovanja u humanističkim znanostima 193 Uvod Zbirka eseja ο identitetu, znanju i društvu sabranih pod nas­ lovom "Stoljeće rearanžiranja" posvećena je konceptualnim is­ traživanjima logike društvene triangulacije koju sačinjavaju identitet, znanje i društvena ontologija. Eseji se bave interakci­ jom identiteta i znanja u logičkom, jezičkom, znanstvenom, te­ hnološkom, društvenom, metafizičkom, matematičkom, ontološ­ kom i literarnom području. Ovim pristupom se želi ukazati na složenost i mnogoznačnost pojma identiteta, na različite tipove upotrebe znaka identiteta u filozofiji logike jezika i na holizam identiteta u konstrukciji ontologije prvog lica i društvene ontolo­ gije.
    [Show full text]
  • Chapter One. the Logical Discourse and the Modern Cultural Climate
    Chapter One. The Logical Discourse and the Modern Cultural Climate National Dogmatism or the Logic of Consociation? Nijaz Ibrulj Department of Philosophy and Sociology, University of Sarajevo, Faculty of Philosophy, Sarajevo, Bosnia and Hercegovina. [email protected] Abstract: The text examines the contemporary social and political ontology of Bos- nia and Herzegovina as a basis for understanding the social and historic presuppositions of the accession of Bosnia and Herzegovina to the European Union. The basic thesis is that the status functions of the social ontology in Bosnia and Herzegovina lack a ration- ally acceptable structure because they produce contradictory institutional objects, facts, processes and states of affairs, while the status functions of political ontology fail to pro- duce deontic values/rights because they create separate intentional contents and a contra- dictory attitude to them. These contradictions are connected to a hyper-national attitude and lead to nationalism. The thesis is argued through the confrontation of the contents of three dogmas of nationalism and three conditions for a normal consociation of the nations in Bosnia and Herzegovina. The text suggests that Bosnia and Herzegovina does not have a paradigm for a rigid-ideological, militaristic or religious state community in EU mem- ber states, rather a paradigm for consociation of nations and a state of free citizens who, through their social and political ontology, need to collectively accept common deontic capabilities/rights, which the European Union also accepts through its status functions. 1. Introduction 1.1.Rational and speculative social ontology 1.2. Social ontology and the character of collective interpretation 1.3.
    [Show full text]
  • AFTERWORD Nijaz Ibrulj PHENOMENOLOGY of ANOMALOUS CAUSALITY
    1 AFTERWORD Nijaz Ibrulj PHENOMENOLOGY OF ANOMALOUS CAUSALITY “Sociology is a more advanced science than is ordinarily believed, even among sociologists. Perhaps a good criterion of the position of a social scientist in his or her discipline might be how high his idea is of what he must master in order to be abreast of the achievements of his science. The propensity to evolve an unpretentious grasp of your scientific capabilities cannot but increase as your knowledge of the most recent achievements in matters of method, techniques, concepts or theories, grows. But sociology is yet little codified and little formalized. ” Pierre Bourdieu, an Invitation to Reflexive Sociology. p 223 Introduction Does sociology expand the theoretical knowledge of social phenomena, or does it merely codify and formalize repeated social practices explored through empirical methods; either way, regardless if it deals with social structures, mechanisms, or mere social actors, the term “sociology” legitimately evokes a science of society: a science that reveals “true logic” and “true nature” of that which we call “society.” However, that which (theoretical) sociologists truly know — or could and should know about a given society in real time and space — cannot be contained in a single universal sociological theory or a single general principles that applies to all theoretically and empirically plausible (social) worlds, nor for that matter in a single extensive 2 discipline derived from such a principle. Only together can social sciences and the humanities offer an intensive or fundamental exploration or demarcation of human nature 1 , and broaden it to an exploration of general nature of human relationships.
    [Show full text]
  • Studia Humana Volume 1 3 4
    Studia Humana Volume 1:3/4 (2012) List of contents ANALYTIC APOSTERIORITY AND ITS RELEVANCE TO TWENTIETH-CENTURY PHILOSOPHY……………………………………………………………………………………...3 THE ADJUSTMENT OF IDENTITY: INQUIRIES INTO LOGIC AND SEMANTICS OF AN UNCERTAIN WORLD……………………………………………………………………….17 IS IDENTITY A LOGICAL CONSTANT AND ARE THERE ACCIDENTAL IDENTITIES?...................................................................................................................................32 THERE IS NO METAPHYSICAL A POSTERIORI NECESSITY…………………………...36 ABSTRACT INCOMPLETENESS THEOREMS AND THEIR INFLUENCE IN METHODOLOGY………………………………………………………………………………...43 INTENSIO: LEIBNIZ IN CREATING A NEW TERM FOR THE MODAL LOGIC……….59 ON AXIOMATIZATION OF NON-CARTESIAN LOGICS…………………………………..66 PRAGMATICO-LINGUISTIC AND SEMIOTIC TOOLS IN ANALYSIS OF ELECTRONIC CONVERSATION………………………………………………………………………………...70 THE DIAL OF THE CIRCULAR COMPLEMENTARITY OF THE DESIGNATED AND ANTIDESIGNATED PAIRS……………………………………………………………………...73 IS THE POLISH LOGIC ONE OF THE BEST TRADITIONS STILL?..................................78 CHARTING THE SEA OF THE A FORTIORI………………………………………………...83 2 Studia Humana Volume 1:3/4 (2012), pp. 3—16 Analytic Aposteriority and its Relevance to Twentieth-Century Philosophy Stephen R. Palmquist Hong Kong Baptist University [email protected] Abstract: This article begins with an overview of the fourfold epistemological framework that arises out of Kant’s distinctions between analyticity and syntheticity and between apriority and aposteriority. I challenge Kant’s
    [Show full text]