Minutes of the Meeting of the Planning Committee, St Ives Town Council held via Zoom technology on Thursday 3rd December 2020 at 7.00pm.

PRESENT

Chairman – Councillor Lait R Vice-Chairman – Councillor Messenger K

COUNCILLORS

Mitchell A Tanner S Nicholls C Williams T

OFFICERS

Administrative Assistant

IN ATTENDANCE

Councillor Wells

P.41 APOLOGIES FOR ABSENCE

Apologies for absence were received from Councillor J Tanner, Councillor Harris, Councillor Burton and Councillor Symons.

P.42 MINUTES

RESOLVED – that the Chairman signs as a true and correct record the Notes of the meeting of the Committee held on 5th November 2020.

P.43 DECLARATIONS OF INTEREST

None.

P.44 PUBLIC SPEAKING

Item No. 3924 - PA20/10001 The Downes, Penbeagle Way, St Ives

One speaker in support of the application

Item No.3939 – PA20/09659 Southfield House, Southfield Place, St Ives

One speaker objecting to the application.

P.44 PLANNING APPLICATIONS

RESOLVED - that the Head of Development Management ( Council) be informed of the Council's observations on the planning applications set out in Annex 1 to these minutes.

P.45 NEIGHBOURHOOD DEVELOPMENT PLAN AND ACTION PLAN – UPDATE None Planning Minutes

P.46 ITEMS FOR DECISION

Naming of footpath

RESOLVED: that the footpath concerned should be named ‘St Michael’s Way’ – as suggested in the correspondence.

P.47 ITEMS FOR INFORMATION

(1) Enforcement Issue Members expressed concern regarding a local business operating from a premises without planning permission being granted. It was resolved that the Town Clerk should contact Planning Enforcement as soon as practicable.

P.48 ST IVES PLANNING APPLICATIONS TO BE DETERMINED BY – WEST SUB-AREA PLANNING COMMITTEE

None.

Meeting closed at 8.57pm Chairman

Planning Minutes

Appendix A St Ives Town Council Planning Schedule for meeting dated 3rd December 2020

Item CC Address Proposals Observations Ref 3917 PA20/0 Carndhu St Ives Road Construction of single storey extension, No objection. 9951 TR26 2JP (Mr Elwood And Mrs Dalton)

3918 PA20/1 Seascape 4 Headland Close Carbis Proposed front Juliet balconies, rear Application supported. 0034 Bay St Ives Cornwall TR26 2NX dormer extension and associated (Mr And Mrs Axton) works. 3919 PA20/1 Talland Garth Talland Road St Front and rear extensions to main Members do not support further changes to the original plans. 0000 Ives TR26 2DF bungalow including a covered outdoor Overdevelopment in a confined space. (Mr and Mrs Gibson) space and conversion of lower ground floor space and adjoining single garage to form self-contained annexe for holiday let purposes with variation of condition 2 in relation to decision notice PA18/10242 dated 24.12.2018

3920 PA20/1 11 St Eia Street St Ives TR26 1PQ Installation of Dormer Windows & Application not supported as it stands. However, Members are not 0085 (Mr and Mrs Cook) Associated Works against it in principle. The dormer is considered too large and dominant and out of proportion with the terrace. Members welcome the use of wooden windows. 3921 PA20/1 56 Polwithen Drive Carbis Bay St Proposed single storey extensions in No objection. 0061 Ives Cornwall TR26 2SP place of existing conservatories (Mr W Yabsley)

3922 PA20/1 Rosebud Riverside Lelant TR26 Application for tree works within a No objection. 0051 3DW Tree Preservation Order: Felling of (Ms Iona Sander) Sycamore (T1) Needs to be removed due to structural weakness resulting from basal/root decay (see Arborist report) Proposed works: felling of tree No replanting planned as the tree is Planning Minutes

situated behind a re-established Griselinia hedge (2017)

3923 PA20/0 Land SW Of Joannies Avenue Outline planning application with some Deferred until 7th January 2021. 9716 Halsetown Road St Ives Cornwall matters reserved (access/layout) for the (Walker Developments (SW) ltd) demolition of existing structures and development to provide an 80 bedroom hotel with associated facilities, 63 holiday villas, a community hub (providing reception facilities and an ancillary shop), associated infrastructure, landscaping, access and parking.

3924 PA20/1 The Downes Penbeagle Way St New 1st Floor over original Bungalow. Application supported. 0001 Ives TR26 2JQ (Mr and Mrs Simmons) 3925 PA20/0 1 Ros Lyn Carbis Bay TR26 2QE New 1st Floor over Bungalow with No objection providing not unneighbourly – with no overlooking 9999 Two-storey Rear Extension (Mr and Mrs Rogers) from the balcony. Would prefer other materials to be used for the windows. 3926 PA20/0 1 Godrevy Court Carbis Bay TR26 Proposed tree works to T1 Monterey Application supported. 9943 2RL Cypress ,G2 and G3 Sycamore (Mr D Rigby) 3927 PA20/1 Land South East Of Towans Farm Application for Permission in principle Objection to permission in principle. Contrary to NDP OS5, 0115 St Ives Road Lelant Cornwall for construction of up to 9 homes for extending the built edge of the settlement. Request an urgent pre- TR26 3EU older persons (over 55s) | application meeting for further information and clarification. (Mr P and G McCotter) 3928 PA20/0 High View St Ives Cornwall TR26 Certificate of Lawfulness for the No comment. 9239 1EN existing use of change of orientation of (Mr Paul Stayne) detached garage and change of access

Ref CC Site Proposal No. Ref (Applicant) Planning Minutes

3929 PA20/ Carn Brea 8 Talland Road St Ives Change of use from single residential Support new catered accommodation returning to the local tourism TR26 2DF dwelling to B&B/Guesthouse and 09620 market. (Mr and Mrs Howell) various minor external alterations including new flat roofed dormer and

Cabrio rooflights 3930 PA20/ Halsetown Inn B3311 Between Listed Building Consent: Create new Application supported – trusting that the Conservation Officer will Halsetown Road And Glew Hill steel stairs to form means of escape 09589 look at the style of the proposed stairs. Halsetown TR26 3NA from first floor managers accommodation in accordance with The (Halsetown Inn) Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005

3931 PA20/ 4 Tre Pol Pen, Annexe Street An Proposed extension to annex Objection. Inappropriate use of materials and window and door Pol St Ives TR26 2DS 09835 design. Possible issue of overlooking. (Mr Oswald)

3932 PA20/ Pentreath Bishops Road St Ives Proposed rear extension and link Strongest possible objection. This is an overbearing development TR26 2BY building 09700 which is highly visible from the other side of the valley. Strong (Mr Reynolds) concerns over the loss of green amenity space. 3933 PA20/ Former Treloyhan Manor Trelyon Various tree works Members request a full assessment of the site by the Tree Officer Avenue St Ives TR26 2AL 09730 and would welcome a planting scheme to replace the felled trees (Mr Shaun Fox) with semi-mature trees. Concerns expressed about the number of trees felled on this exposed site. Suggestion of regular maintenance to protect existing trees. 3934 PA20/ Sunny Cottage 27 Virgin Street St Replace timber single glazed sash Objection. The windows should be wooden. However, no objection Ives TR26 1HP windows with UPVC double glazed 08918 to the double glazing. (Mrs E Huggett) sash conservation windows

3935 PA20/ 1 Godrevy Court Carbis Bay TR26 Proposed tree works to T1 Monterey No objection. 2RL Cypress ,G2 and G3 Sycamore. 09943 (Mr David Rigby) 3936 PA20/ Seascape Carthew Way St Ives Proposed Extension and Alterations Application supported. TR26 1RJ Planning Minutes

08907 (Mr and Mrs Roldan)

3937 PA20/ Easter Cottage Church Road Replace section of roof Application supported. Lelant St Ives Cornwall TR26 3LB 07358 (Susan Wilson)

3938 PA20/ Trelandry Church Lane Lelant Application for tree works subject to a No objection. TR26 3DZ Tree Preservation Order: Various works 09387 (Mark Stewart) to sycamore and beech trees. 3939 PA20/ Southfield House Southfield Place Two storey extension in place of Strongest possible objection. Request for application to be called St Ives Cornwall TR26 1RE existing garage 09659 to committee should the Case Officer be minded to approve. (Mr and Mrs J Binney) Contravenes NDP policies GD1and OS3. This application, if approved, will cause huge harm to neighbouring properties – particularly those residing in Ayr House, Kenwyn Place and Southfield Terrace. 3940 PA20/ 33A Fore Street St Ives TR26 1HE Listed Building Consent: External Application supported. works: replacement of 2x PVCu 09030 (K Sorrell) double-glazed windows and removal of external bars; replacement of frosted glass in high-level window and removal of external bars; re-make fixed window to open by tilting inwards; new extractor vent through external wall; insert porthole into existing door.

3941 PA20/ 2 Orchard Cottage The Stennack Construction of Extension and Internal Application supported. St Ives TR26 1QR Alterations 09356 (Miss Georgina Bradley)

3942 PA20/ Miramar St Ives Road Carbis Bay Non-material amendment in relation to No objection. TR26 2JR Decision Notice PA20/01147 dated 21st 09857 (P Hillman) May 2020.

Planning Minutes

Ref CC Site Proposal No. Ref (Applicant) 3943 PA20/ 241 Treva Croft St Ives Holiday Construction of 93 replacement holiday Application supported, but need to ensure that it is not full time Village Lelant TR26 3HX houses and bungalows, construction of 09371 occupancy. (Shelley Mair) 52 additional car parking spaces with variation of condition 2 in relation to Decision Notice W1/90/P/1077/F.

3944 PA20/ Land Off Polwithen Drive Submission of details to discharge Members did not vote on this application. Polwithen Drive Carbis Bay condition 8 (materials) of decision 10033 Cornwall TR26 2SP PA19/07842 dated 09/07/2020. (Mr Will Morris)

3945 PA20/ 21 The Terrace St Ives TR26 2BP Submission of details to discharge Members did not vote on this application. (Chris Jopson) conditions 3, 4 and 6 in relation to 10004 decision notice PA16/00358. 3946 PA20/ Monteray Park an Gonwyn Carbis Application for tree works: works to Application supported, but replanting is imperative. Bay trees subject to a tree preservation order 09502 TR26 2LG (TPO) Application: T1 Monterey Pine - (David Smith) Fell due to dense root activity close to house.