BACS Cover and Front Matter
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Journal of the British Association for Chinese Studies Volume 8, Issue 2, July 2018 ISSN 2048-0601 Journal of the British Association for Chinese Studies This e-journal is a peer-reviewed publication produced by the British Association for Chinese Studies (BACS). It is intended as a service to the academic community designed to encourage the production and dissemination of high quality research to an international audience. It publishes research falling within BACS’ remit, which is broadly interpreted to include China, and the Chinese diaspora, from its earliest history to contemporary times, and spanning the disciplines of the arts, humanities and social sciences. Editors Sarah Dauncey (University of Nottingham) Gerda Wielander (University of Westminster) Sub-Editor Scott Pacey (University of Nottingham) Editorial Board Tim Barrett (School of Oriental and African Studies) Jane Duckett (University of Glasgow) Harriet Evans (University of Westminster) Stephanie Hemelryk Donald (University of New South Wales) Stephan Feuchtwang (London School of Economics) Natascha Gentz (University of Edinburgh) Rana Mitter (University of Oxford) Qian Suoqiao (University of Newcastle) Caroline Rose (University of Leeds) Naomi Standen (University of Birmingham) Yao Shujie (University of Nottingham) Journal of the British Association for Chinese Studies Volume 8, Issue 2, July 2018 Contents Editors’ Introduction iv Articles Playful You in the Zhuangzi and Six Dynasties Literati Writing 1 Xiaofan Amy Li Empire and Visual Pleasure: Reinterpreting the Miao Albums of 29 Yunnan and Guizhou Jing Zhu Mainstream Film Production in a Country on the Cusp of Change: 63 An Army Officer’s View of Three Chinese Films of the Early 1980s Produced by the August First Film Studio Julian Ward Analysing Indonesian Media and Government Representation of 89 China Senia Febrica and Suzie Sudarman Essays The EU and China, 2006 to 2016: A Clash Between Interests and 120 Values Kerry Brown Working in No Man’s Land: Between Sociology and Chinese Studies 130 Norman Stockman Book Reviews Laurel Bossen and Hill Gates, Bound Feet, Young Hands: Tracking 144 the Demise of Footbinding in Village China (Lin Jiao) Michelle Tien King, Between Birth and Death: Female Infanticide in 147 Nineteenth-Century China (Ying-kit Chan) Lawton Robert Burns and Gordon G. Liu (eds.), China’s Healthcare 150 System and Reform (Pia Eskelinen) Steve Lau and John De Lucy (eds.), Chinese Labour Corps: 153 Photographs from the WJ Hawkings Collection (Craig Barclay & Rachel Barclay) Kristin Stapleton, Fact in Fiction: 1920s China and Ba Jin’s Family 156 (Ronald Torrance) Bret Hinsch, Women in Imperial China (Hang Lin) 160 James C.S. Lin and Xiuzhen Li, China’s First Emperor and the 162 Terracotta Warriors (Craig Barclay) Journal of the British Association for Chinese Studies, Vol. 8 (2), July 2018 ISSN 2048-0601 © British Association for Chinese Studies Editors’ Introduction We are very pleased to bring you issue 8.2 of JBACS. In this issue, four research articles are complemented by two thought-provoking essays and a selection of book reviews, once again demonstrating the wonderful variety and breadth of research undertaken under the broad umbrella of Chinese studies in the UK. The issue starts with two papers that were highly ranked in the 2017 BACS Early Career Researcher Prize competition. Amy Xiaofan Li’s article explores the notion of you in the Zhuangzi and Six Dynasties literati writing. From the more literal meanings—“swim in water”, “move in an unobstructed way”, “wander”, “travel afar”—to its extended meanings—"ramble in a carefree way”, “travel playfully”, “travel into foreign or unknown space”, or “enjoy a leisurely activity”—Li reveals the differences and similarities between its conceptualisation in the Zhuangzi and its interpretation and use in later neo- Daoist writing. Jing Zhu’s piece examines the Miao album (baimiao tu ), a genre of ethnographic illustration from the late-imperial period depicting the bodies, cultures and environments of ethnic minorities in the southwest of China. Zhu argues that these fascinating albums were not just consumed by government officials, their intended audience; they were also viewed for pleasure by a much more diverse population. Julian Ward’s piece focuses on the August First Film Studio and the changing cinema scene of the early 1980s. Drawing on evidence from key films of the period, including The Colourful Night (Caise de ye ), The Last Military Salute (Zuihou yige junli ) and Star of the Battleground (Zhandi zhi xing ), Ward shows that, despite contemporary criticism to the contrary, directors were starting to experiment with more challenging filmmaking methods. He also argues that campaigns against films perceived to be hostile towards communism served as a strong indication of the continuing importance of “patriotic” film to the state. Senia Febrica and Suzie Sudarman vi Sarah Dauncey and Gerda Wielander examine how China’s relations with Indonesia (and Southeast Asia more broadly) are represented in Indonesian media and government discourse. Their content analysis of government documents and media reports from 2008-2015, and findings from interviews with Indonesian government officials, reveal Indonesia’s apparent ambiguity in dealing with China. The two essays in this issue have been provided by two of the top scholars in their fields. Kerry Brown’s essay examines two major communications from the European Commission in 2006 and 2016 on relations with the People’s Republic of China and, in particular, how to defend and promote rule of law, human rights and associated freedoms. Norman Stockman’s essay presents his reflections on his career working as a sociologist with a particular interest in China. He argues that theoretical and political disputes and dilemmas, combined with institutional and organisational factors within higher education, have operated to create and maintain barriers to fruitful interaction between disciplines and area studies, and between sociology and Chinese studies more particularly. The views and conclusions expressed are his own and we invite other scholars to respond with their own views and experiences to create a debate around this important tension. Please use the journal submission link to submit your response: http://bacsuk.org.uk/journal. Judging for the 2018 ECR Prize is currently underway. We have been extremely impressed by the quality of the work submitted. For those of you interested in participating next year (or for supervisors with doctoral students who may be eligible to take part), detailed information has already been circulated via the BACS mailing list and BACS social media accounts; it can also be found here: http://bacsuk.org.uk/ecr-prize. The winner will be announced in September at the forthcoming BACS annual conference at KCL. Schedule and registration details are available on the BACS website: http://bacsuk.org.uk/conferences/annual-conference. Finally, a reminder that JBACS is looking to fill one co-editor position as Sarah will have fulfilled her five years’ service at the end of this academic year. We are looking for an established academic with substantive experience in reviewing research for journals, academic presses and research funders, and a proven ability to engage with Chinese-language-based research that may come from a Journal of the British Association for Chinese Studies vii wide range of disciplines. Ideally, this person should be based at a UK institution in order to be able to attend editorial meetings, most of which coincide with BACS Council meetings. This is a voluntary (unpaid) position, but the rewards are great, and we would encourage anyone considering nominating themselves to get in touch with either one of us as soon as possible. We are also looking to appoint an editorial assistant (paid) to support the editors one day a month (eight hours). Here we are looking for an enthusiastic PhD student or post-doc with excellent command of English, who would like to learn about editorial processes by aiding the editors in their correspondence with peer reviewers and authors. Again, please contact us directly if you are interested. JBACS is a rigorously peer-reviewed, fully open-access journal which, unlike the vast majority of open-access journals, does not charge article production fees. We are a democratic, collaborative community that relies entirely on voluntary work. You can support our work and the future of independent academic publishing by submitting your work to JBACS. We are continuously striving to improve the journal and welcome all feedback. If you do have any comments or suggestions for future special issues, please do get in touch. Sarah Dauncey and Gerda Wielander Journal of the British Association for Chinese Studies, Vol. 8 (2), July 2018 ISSN 2048-0601 © British Association for Chinese StuDies Playful You in the Zhuangzi and Six Dynasties Literati Writing Xiaofan Amy Li University of Kent Abstract This essay explores the notion of you in the Zhuangzi and Six Dynasties literati writing through a comparative reading. Used interchangeably with its variant you , you has various uses and meanings, from the more literal “swim in water”, “move in an unobstructed way”, “wander”, and “travel afar”, to its extended meanings including “ramble in a carefree way”, “travel playfully”, “travel into foreign or unknown space”, or “enjoy a leisurely activity”. You is also, significantly, combined with other characters to form compound expressions specifying different