Arxiv:1901.04741V2 [Hep-Th] 15 Feb 2019 2
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Quantum scale symmetry C. Wetterich [email protected] Universität Heidelberg, Institut für Theoretische Physik, Philosophenweg 16, D-69120 Heidelberg Quantum scale symmetry is the realization of scale invariance in a quantum field theory. No parameters with dimension of length or mass are present in the quantum effective action. Quantum scale symmetry is generated by quantum fluctuations via the presence of fixed points for running couplings. As for any global symmetry, the ground state or cosmological state may be scale invariant or not. Spontaneous breaking of scale symmetry leads to massive particles and predicts a massless Goldstone boson. A massless particle spectrum follows from scale symmetry of the effective action only if the ground state is scale symmetric. Approximate scale symmetry close to a fixed point leads to important predictions for observations in various areas of fundamental physics. We review consequences of scale symmetry for particle physics, quantum gravity and cosmology. For particle physics, scale symmetry is closely linked to the tiny ratio between the Fermi scale of weak interactions and the Planck scale for gravity. For quantum gravity, scale symmetry is associated to the ultraviolet fixed point which allows for a non-perturbatively renormalizable quantum field theory for all known interactions. The interplay between gravity and particle physics at this fixed point permits to predict couplings of the standard model or other “effective low energy models” for momenta below the Planck mass. In particular, quantum gravity determines the ratio of Higgs boson mass and top quark mass. In cosmology, approximate scale symmetry explains the almost scale-invariant primordial fluctuation spectrum which is at the origin of all structures in the universe. The pseudo-Goldstone boson of spontaneously broken approximate scale symmetry may be responsible for dynamical dark energy and a solution of the cosmological constant problem. arXiv:1901.04741v2 [hep-th] 15 Feb 2019 2 Contents 6.12. Crossover in dimensionless fields 54 6.13. Quantitative scaling solutions 55 6.14. Infrared quantum gravity 57 1. Introduction3 6.15. Crossover in quantum gravity 59 6.16. Flow of effective scalar potential in quantum 2. Fixed points and scales7 gravity 60 2.1. Classical scale symmetry7 6.17. Quantum gravity predictions for the Higgs 2.2. Classically scale invariant standard model8 potential 62 2.3. Quantum scale symmetry9 6.17.1. Quartic scalar coupling 62 2.4. Quantum scale invariant standard model with 6.17.2. Prediction for the mass of the top gravity 11 quark 64 2.5. Spontaneous scale symmetry breaking 12 6.17.3. Prediction for the gauge hierarchy? 65 2.6. Quantum scale symmetry and quantum 6.17.4. Anomalous mass dimension 66 effective action 13 6.18. Quadratic and logarithmic running 67 2.7. Renormalizable quantum field theories and scale symmetry 14 7. Scale symmetry in cosmology 67 2.8. Relevant parameters 15 7.1. Primordial cosmic fluctuations 69 2.9. Relevant parameters and mass scales 16 7.2. Starobinski inflation 71 2.10. Exact and approximate quantum scale 7.3. Cosmon inflation 72 symmetry 17 7.4. Higgs inflation 75 7.5. Scale invariant inflation 77 3. Networks of fixed points and crossovers 18 7.5.1. Scale invariant Starobinski inflation 77 3.1. UV- and IR-fixed points 18 7.5.2. Scale invariant Higgs inflation 79 3.2. Particle scale symmetry 19 7.5.3. General scale invariant two-field 3.3. Sequence of particle physics fixed points 20 inflation 80 3.4. Predictivity in presence of several fixed points 7.6. Cosmological scaling solutions 81 or partial fixed points 20 7.6.1. Scaling solutions for exact scale 3.5. Crossover 21 symmetry 81 3.6. Flow diagram for particle physics and 7.6.2. Scaling solutions with intrinsic mass quantum gravity 21 scale 81 7.6.3. Runaway cosmologies 82 4. Flow in field space 23 7.6.4. Sliding systems of scales 83 4.1. Field dependent couplings 23 7.6.5. Quantitative scaling solutions 83 4.2. Spontaneous and explicit scale symmetry 7.6.6. Scaling solutions in the Einstein breaking 24 frame 84 4.3. Fixed points in field space 25 7.6.7. Mass of the cosmon 85 4.4. Crossover in field space 25 7.6.8. Beginning and end of scaling 4.5. Flow with momentum for fixed field 26 solution 86 7.7. Time variation of fundamental “constants” 86 5. Particle scale symmetry 28 7.7.1. Scale symmetry and varying 5.1. Scale symmetry and vacuum electroweak couplings 87 phase transition 28 7.7.2. Observable “fundamental 5.2. Anomalous mass dimension 30 constants” 87 5.3. Naturalness of the Fermi scale 31 7.7.3. Different pictures of the Universe 87 5.4. Scale invariant standard model with singlet 7.7.4. Time varying fundamental constants scalar 32 as test of explicit scale symmetry 5.5. Mass of the pseudo-Goldstone boson 33 breaking 88 7.7.5. Approach to the standard model fixed 6. Scale symmetry in quantum gravity 35 point 89 6.1. Quantum Einstein Gravity 36 7.7.6. Time varying couplings from beyond 6.2. Dilaton quantum gravity 40 standard model physics 90 6.3. Simple scale invariant effective actions 41 7.8. Dynamical dark energy 91 6.4. Weyl scaling 42 2 7.8.1. Crossover quintessence 92 6.5. Einstein gravity with R -term 43 7.8.2. Growing neutrino quintessence 96 6.6. Scale invariant R2-gravity 44 6.7. Scale invariance with variable Planck mass 45 8. Conclusions 97 6.8. Flowing couplings and fixed points 46 6.9. Asymptotic safety 50 A. Quantum dilatation current 100 6.10. Relevant parameters 51 6.11. Scaling potential for dilaton gravity 53 References 101 3 1. Introduction non-perturbative, associated to an ultraviolet (UV) fixed point with non-vanishing interactions. The presence of Scale symmetry is associated to the absence of intrinsic such a fixed point is called “asymptotic safety” [24]. While mass or length scales. Do we see scale symmetry in particle established first only in the vicinity of two dimensions, physics and cosmology? There are two well known fields non-perturbative computations have become available for where approximate scale symmetry plays a central role. The four dimensions by the modern form of functional renor- first is the approximately scale invariant power spectrum malization [25], [26]. Since the pioneering work of Reuter of the primordial cosmic fluctuations. These fluctuations on functional renormalization for gravity [27], substantial are the seed for the structure in the Universe, and therefore evidence in favor of the existence of an UV-fixed point for of our existence. Their approximate scale invariance hints four-dimensional gravity – the Reuter fixed point – has to a role of scale symmetry in the very early inflationary accumulated [28–31]. cosmology [1–7] or other variants of primordial cosmology. As for any fixed point, the UV-fixed point for quantum The second is the approximate scale invariance of particle gravity realizes exact scale symmetry. Close to a fixed physics at high momenta if the standard model of particle point one should observe approximate scale symmetry. It physics [8–10] can be extrapolated sufficiently above the is tempting to associate the approximate scale symmetry of the primordial cosmic fluctuations with the vicinity of Fermi scale ϕ0 = 174.1 GeV, where the electroweak gauge symmetry is spontaneously broken [11–13]. With the ab- the UV-fixed point in quantum gravity [32]. sence of new physics in the present findings of the large The aim of the present work is a discussion of the rela- hadron collider (LHC), the possibility of such an extrapo- tions between different facets of scale symmetry in particle lation is accepted more and more widely. In a momentum physics, cosmology and quantum gravity, and to put them range above 1 TeV the dimensionless couplings in the stan- into a common context. A central theme of this work is dard model are all small. Effects of their running are at least the presence of several types of scale symmetry in particle quadratic in the couplings, often even cubic or quartic, and physics coupled to quantum gravity. They are related to therefore even smaller. The role of a possible intrinsic mass the presence of different (approximate) fixed points. The scale associated to the Fermi scale, or to the characteristic most prominent ones are: (1) The “gravity scale symmetry” “confinement scale” ΛQCD for quantum chromodynamics associated to the UV-fixed point used for the definition (QCD), is tiny for characteristic momenta p above 1 TeV, of a renormalizable quantum field theory for gravity. (2) 2 2 2 2 The “particle scale symmetry” of the standard model (SM) being typically suppressed by powers of ϕ0/p or ΛQCD/p . Scale symmetry holds in this high momentum range with without gravity, seen as an effective low energy theory below rather high accuracy. the Planck mass. This is related to the (almost) second Scale symmetry, often also called dilatation symmetry, order character of the electroweak phase transition, and and sometimes somewhat inaccurately conformal symmetry, reflected by the presence of a SM-fixed point. (3) The has played an important role in the theoretical discussion of “cosmic scale symmetry”, related to the infrared (IR)-fixed several fundamental questions in particle physics, cosmology point. This matters for the properties of the Universe at the and quantum gravity. Approximate scale symmetry has largest distances and concerns the issue of the cosmological been advocated [14–16] for ensuring the naturalness of the constant. observed small value of the Fermi scale as compared to the The overall situation can be summarized by the flow 18 −17 Planck mass M = 2.436·10 GeV, namely ϕ0/M ≈ 7·10 , diagram Fig.1.