DOCSLIB.ORG

145 the Influence of an English Background On

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
145 the Influence of an English Background On 145 THE INFLUENCE OF AN ENGLISH BACKGROUND ON FOUR JUDGES APPOINTED TO THE SUPREME COURTS OF THE TRANSVAAL AND ORANGE RIVER COLONY 1902-1910 by STEPHEND. GIRVIN(Nottingham) Introduction In this paper I shall evaluate the legal background and judicial careers of four judges appointed to the bench of the Transvaal and the Orange River Colony in the period 1902 to 1910 - the period after the South African War but prior to the Union of South Africa in 19101. In both colonies legislation ensured the retention of Roman-Dutch law as the common law; thus the Administration of Justice Proclamation, 1902, of the Transvaal2 provided in § 17 that 'the Roman- Dutch law except in so far as it is modified by legislative enactments shall be the law of this Colony' while § 1 of the Laws Settlement and Interpretation Ordinance, 1902, of the Orange River Colony3 laid down that 'the Roman- Dutch law shall be the common law of the Colony in so far as it has been in- troduced into, and is applicable to South Africa'. Much Cape legislation was received, especially in areas such as bills of exchange and succession; also import- ed was the Cape General Law Amendment Ordinance of 18794 which abolished the doctrine of laesio enormis and imported the English law as to fire, life and marine insurance, stoppage in transitu and bills of lading 5 The practice in British colonies both in Southern Africa and in other parts of the Empire was to appoint English-trained lawyers to judicial positions. This was the case in the Cape Colony6, following the First Charter of Justice in 1827, and also in Natah for most of the nineteenth century. Judges appointed to the bench in the two Boer Republics often came from an indigenous background with school education at the Cape and then at London University followed by call at one of the Inns of Court in London. It was rare for a judge to be a graduate of 1. The standard work on this period is still H.R. Hahlo and E. Kahn, The Union of South Africa, London 1960.See however also A.A. Roberts, A South African LegalBiblio- graphy, Pretoria 1942, especiallyat p. 347-384. 2. Proclamation No. 14 of 1902. 3. Ordinance No. 3 of 1902. 4. Act No. 8 of 1879. 5. See B. Beinart, The English legal contribution in South Africa: the interaction of civil and common law, Acta Juridica, 1981, p. 7-63. 6. See S.D. Girvin, The Establishment of the Supreme Court of the Cape of Good Hope and its History under the Chief Justiceship of Sir John Wylde,South African Law Journal 109(1992) p. 291-306, 652-665; ThreeIrish-born judges at the Cape 1861-1896, The Irish Jurist 24 (1993)p. 99-112. 7. See P.R. Spiller, A History of the District and Supreme Courts of Natal 1846-1910, Durban 1986. 146 a Dutch university'. Thus when a High Court was established in the Orange Free State in 18729, the first three judges (Francis Reitz, James Buchanan and Melius de Villiers) were all educated at the South African College in Cape Town. Reitz was called to the bar by the Inner Temple whilst both Buchanan and De Villiers were admitted to practice as advocates at the Cape barl°. In the South African Republic a High Court of Justice was established by a Proclamation of 187711 and John Gilbert Kotze was appointed as the judge and later Chief Justice. He was a London University graduate and was called to the bar by the Inner Templel2. After the retrocession in 1881, Kotze was joined on the bench by Christoffel Brand, Petrus Burgers and Jacobus de Wet. All three judges had been called to the bar by the Inner Temple. Brand was educated at the South African College, Cape Town, Burgers was an LL.D. of Leiden and de Wet was a London University graduate 13 Following the conclusion of the South African War and the annexation of the former Republics to Britain, further English appointments were made to the bench. In this paper I consider the role and influence of William Smith and Leonard Bristowe in the Transvaal and Daniel Ward and Archibald Fawkes in the Orange River Colony. These judges are distinguishable from their colleagues because they were born in England (or Ireland in the case of Ward) and practised at the English bar followed by service in one of the colonies. They were the product of colonial service, unlike the South African born judges previously or subsequently appointed. William James Smithl4 Smith was the younger son of John O'Connor Smith, a stockbroker of Syca- more Hill House, Birmingham, and was born in Cheltenham in 1853. He received his early education there and at Taunton School and then entered Trinity Hall, 8. But cf. Herman Arnold Ameshoff (judge of the Transvaal from 1889-1898), Samuel Gerhard Jorissen (judge of the Transvaal from 1886-1889) and Jules Anne Schagen Van Leeuwen(judge of the Transvaal 1898-1900). 9. Ordinance 4, 1872. 10. See Roberts (1942)p. 373, 351and 357. De Villierswas appointed to the chair of Roman-Dutch law at Leiden in 1905. 11. The South African Republicwas annexed by Britain between 1877and 1881.See M. Nathan The Republican Bench and Bar, South African Law Times 1 (1932),p. 13ff. 12. Roberts (1942),p. 367. Seehis autobiographicalstudy, Biographicalmemoirs and reminiscences,Cape Town 1949. 13. Roberts (1942),p. 350, 352, 358. 14. Sources: J. Foster, Men-at-the-Bar, London 1885, p. 436; The Law List, 1876, p. 171; 1879,p. 183, 236;1880, p. 189; 1881,p. 191; 1882,p. 195;Lincoln's Inn Admission Book, Vol. 26, p. 67; W.H. Mercer & A.E. Collins (ed.), Colonial Office List, London 1905,p. 576f; Roberts (1942),p. 376; E. Rosenthal, South African Dictionary of National Biography, London 1966,p. 350; R. Roxburgh(ed.), TheRecords of the Honourable Soci- ety of Lincoln's Inn: The Black Books, Vol. 5, London 1968, p. 415; W.A. Shaw, The Knights of England, London 1906,Vol. 2, p. 397; J. & J.A. Venn, Alumni Cantabrigienses 1752-1900, Cambridge 1940,p. 574; Who was who 1897-1915, p. 486; The Law Times 134 (1912),p. 99; Sir WilliamSmith Kt., South African Law Journal, 28 (1911),p. 465; The late Sir WilliamSmith, South African Law Journal 29 (1912),p. 368; The Times 155 November 1912; 18 November 1912; 21 November 1912. .
Load more

Recommended publications
  • South Africa
    CultureGramsTM Republic of World Edition 2014 South Africa provisions station at Cape Town. It supplied ships with fresh BACKGROUND foods as they sailed around the tip of the continent. French Huguenot refugees joined the Dutch colony in 1688 and Land and Climate Germans came later. The colonists became known as Boers Area (sq. mi.): 470,693 (farmers). They clashed at times with indigenous groups but Area (sq. km.): 1,219,090 stayed mainly in coastal areas. Britain gained formal possession of the Cape Colony in 1814. Dissatisfaction with South Africa is about the size of Peru, or slightly larger than British rule led many Boers to migrate to the interior between the U.S. states of Texas, New Mexico, and Oklahoma 1835 and 1848. Their migration, which they call the Great combined. The country's large interior plateau averages about Trek, led to war with the indigenous Zulu, Xhosas, and other 5,000 feet (1,500 meters) above sea level. Primarily savanna Africans. The Boers won most of the battles and took control and semidesert, the plateau is rimmed by a narrow coastal of large tracts of land. belt, which is subtropical along the east coast and has a After the discovery of gold and diamonds in these Boer Mediterranean climate along the southwestern cape. South territories in the late 19th century, Britain annexed parts of Africa's most important rivers are the Orange, Vaal, and the area. Tension erupted into the First Boer War (1880–81) Limpopo. and the Second Boer War (1899–1902), which is also called Snow is confined to the Drakensberg and Maluti the South African War.
    [Show full text]
  • The German Colonization of Southwest Africa and the Anglo-German Rivalry, 1883-1915
    University of Nebraska at Omaha DigitalCommons@UNO Student Work 7-1-1995 Doors left open then slammed shut: The German colonization of Southwest Africa and the Anglo-German rivalry, 1883-1915 Matthew Erin Plowman University of Nebraska at Omaha Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.unomaha.edu/studentwork Recommended Citation Plowman, Matthew Erin, "Doors left open then slammed shut: The German colonization of Southwest Africa and the Anglo-German rivalry, 1883-1915" (1995). Student Work. 435. https://digitalcommons.unomaha.edu/studentwork/435 This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by DigitalCommons@UNO. It has been accepted for inclusion in Student Work by an authorized administrator of DigitalCommons@UNO. For more information, please contact [email protected]. DOORS LEFT OPEN THEN SLAMMED SHUT: THE GERMAN COLONIZATION OF SOUTHWEST AFRICA AND THE ANGLO-GERMAN RIVALRY, 1883-1915. A Thesis Presented to the Department of History and the Faculty of the Graduate College University of Nebraska In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Master of Arts University of Nebraska at Omaha by Matthew Erin Plowman July 1995 UMI Number: EP73073 All rights reserved INFORMATION TO ALL USERS The quality of this reproduction is dependent upon the quality of the copy submitted. In the unlikely event that the author did not send a complete manuscript and there are missing pages, these will be noted. Also, if material had to be removed, a note will indicate the deletion. UMI Blsaartalibn Publish*rig UMI EP73073 Published by ProQuest LLC (2015). Copyright in the Dissertation held by the Author.
    [Show full text]
  • The Central Kwazulu-Natal Climate Change Compact, South Africa
    The Central KwaZulu-Natal Climate Change Compact, South Africa A platform fostering multi-level governance for climate change Created in 2014, the Central KwaZulu-Natal Climate Change Compact (Compact KZN) is a unique model of collaboration between cities of different sizes in the region of KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa. This platform fosters both the vertical (across different levels of government) and horizontal (across different organisations at the same government level) integration of climate change governance in South Africa. ICLEI Case Studies February 2020 Summary Compact KZN demonstrates that regional platforms for climate change are key places to foster cooperation between actors from different levels of government and different sectors in South Africa. The sharing of existing good practices that distinguishes this kind of cooperation supports the objective of the Urban-LEDS II project, which is to enhance multi-level climate change governance in all pilot countries. This case study provides an in-depth look at the institutional arrangements, effectiveness, and replicability of one such example in South Africa. Ultimately, this case study is intended to be a valuable resource for other governments looking to implement institutional arrangements that support multi-level governance for climate action. Facts & Figures Definitions Creation January 2014 Multi-level climate change governance: refers to the ways in which different tiers of government work together to achieve their climate objectives. It is the mix Municipal budget of policies, laws, mandates, finance, dialogue, reporting, coordination and eThekwini (Durban), Msunduzi, capacity that govern how climate change response is implemented at all tiers of uGu, iLembe District government and across all sectors.
    [Show full text]
  • The Imperial Map Cape Colony and Later Military Maps of the Cape Colony, South Africa
    The Imperial Map Cape Colony and later military maps of the Cape Colony, South Africa. Dr Christopher Board formerly Senior Lecturer in Geography, London School of Economics Abstract Attempts to compile maps for military use in the Cape Colony during the Anglo-Boer War 1899- 1902 left a legacy of incomplete and unstandardised mapping at the scale of 1:250,000 known as the Imperial Map Cape Colony. Aware of the need for good mapping to permit satisfactory administration and defence a congress of interested parties agreed in 1904 to a scheme for topographic mapping South Africa based on geodetic survey. Economic problems put an end to this project, but the War Office considered the NW Cape Colony worthy of a reconnaissance map at 1:250,000 which they would fund. Thus a special section of the War Office’s map of Africa G.S.G.S.1764 was designed and produced in a military version and as sales editions. The paper documents the progress of the survey and compilation of this map using surviving maps and other archival material in the UK. Introduction British military mapping of a large part of the Cape Colony, South Africa was achieved in great haste to meet the requirements of a mobile army in unfamiliar and poorly mapped, mostly open country at the end of the 19th century. The Imperial Map Cape Colony was compiled to meet the need for a map for planning and executing military operations, to deal with guerrilla war in the Colony itself. It was compiled from mapping available in the Surveyor General’s Department, supplemented by local observation and intelligence reports.
    [Show full text]
  • MA Semester IV- History of South Africa 1850-1950 (HISKM 16) Dr
    MA Semester IV- History of South Africa 1850-1950 (HISKM 16) Dr. Mukesh Kumar UNIT-I Early European presence in the cape 1650-1800- The first Europeans to enter Southern Africa were the Portuguese, who from the 15th century edged their way around the African coast in the hope of outflanking Islam, finding a sea route to the riches of India, and discovering additional sources of food. They reached the Kongo Kingdom in northwestern Angola in 1482–83; early in 1488 Bartolomeu Dias rounded the southern tip of the continent; and just over a decade later Vasco da Gama sailed along the east coast of Africa before striking out to India. Although the voyages were initially unpromising, they marked the beginning of the integration of the subcontinent into the new world economy and the dominance of Europeans over the indigenous inhabitants. The Portuguese in west-central Africa Portuguese influence in west-central Africa radiated over a far wider area and was much more dramatic and destructive than on the east coast. Initially the Portuguese crown and Jesuit missionaries forged peaceful links with the kingdom of the Kongo, converting its king to Christianity. Almost immediately, however, slave traders followed in the wake of priests and teachers, and west- central Africa became tied to the demands of the Sao Tome sugar planters and the transatlantic slave trade. Until 1560 the Kongo kings had an effective monopoly in west-central Africa over trade with metropolitan Portugal, which showed relatively little interest in its African possessions. By the 1520s, however, Afro-Portuguese traders and landowners from Sao Tomé were intervening in the affairs of the Ndongo kingdom to the south, supporting the ruler, or ngola, in his military campaigns and taking his war captives and surplus dependents as slaves.
    [Show full text]
  • Board Christopher
    International Symposium on “Old Worlds-New Worlds”: The History of Colonial Cartography 1750-1950 Utrecht University, Utrecht, The Netherlands, 21 to 23 August 2006 Working Group on the History of Colonial Cartography in the 19th and 20 th centuries International Cartographic Association (ICA-ACI) The British War Office 1:250,000 mapping of Cape Colony 1906-1914 Dr Christopher Board formerly Senior Lecturer, London School of Economics [email protected] Abstract After the second Anglo-Boer War when the two coastal colonies were joined by two new ones previously Boer republics the British were keen to remap the entire territory of South Africa. Despite plans drawn up in 1903 only three projects were begun. There are a few references to similar mapping of the Southern Transvaal and a preliminary paper on the Cape Colony Reconnaissance series by Board. The latter series at 1:250,000 covered the north-west region of the Colony, 35 sheets were surveyed and/or compiled but only 33 were published. The Royal Engineer Survey teams responsible for mapping the Cape Colony were withdrawn in November 1911 leaving most of the rest of the Colony to rely on poor maps of varying accuracy and quality dating to the recent war or before it. This paper not only charts the progress of mapping the series known as GSGS1764 from analysing published maps, but draws on collections in London and Cambridge which contain unpublished compilation material and the elusive model sheet for the series. Its discovery and description throw light on the War Office’s requirements for mapping in the dying days of an era of colonial mapping.
    [Show full text]
  • ATOLL RESEARCH Bulletln
    ATOLL RESEARCH BULLETlN NO. 235 Issued by E SMTPISONIAIV INSTITUTION Washington, D.C., U.S.A. November 1979 CONTENTS Abstract Introduction Environment and Natural History Situation and Climate People Soils and Vegetation Invertebrate Animals Vertebrate Animals Material and Methods Systematics of the Land Crabs Coenobitidae Coenobi ta Coenobi ta brevimana Coenobi ta per1 a ta Coenobi ta rugosa Birgus Birgus latro Grapsidae Geogxapsus Geograpsus crinipes Geograpsus grayi Metopograpsus Metopograpsus thukuhar Sesarma Sesarma (Labuaniurn) ?gardineri ii Gecarcinidae page 23 Cardisoma 2 4 Cardisoma carnif ex 2 5 Cardisoma rotundum 2 7 Tokelau Names for Land Crabs 30 Notes on the Ecology of the Land Crabs 37 Summary 4 3 Acknowledgements 44 Literature Cited 4 5 iii LIST OF FIGURES (following page 53) 1. Map of Atafu Atoll, based on N.Z. Lands and Survey Department Aerial Plan No. 1036/7~(1974) . 2. Map of Nukunonu Atoll, based on N.Z. Lands and Survey Department Aerial Plan No. 1036/7~sheets 1 and 2 (1974). 3. Map of Fakaofo Atoll, based on N.Z. Lands and Survey Department Aerial Plan No. 1036/7C (1974). 4. Sesarma (Labuanium) ?gardineri. Dorsal view of male, carapace length 28 rnm from Nautua, Atafu. (Photo T.R. Ulyatt, National Museum of N. Z.) 5. Cardisoma carnifex. Dorsal view of female, carapace length 64 mm from Atafu. (Photo T.R. Ulyatt) 6. Cardisoma rotundurn. Dorsal view of male, carapace length 41.5 mm from Village Motu, Nukunonu. (Photo T.R. Ulyatt) LIST OF TABLES 0 I. Surface temperature in the Tokelau Islands ( C) Page 5 11. Mean rainfall in the Tokelau Islands (mm) 6 111, Comparative list of crab names from the Tokelau Islands, Samoa, Niue and the Cook islands, 3 5 IV.
    [Show full text]
  • Archival Research in the United States: a South African's Mission1
    Archival Research in the United 1 States: A South African's Mission Downloaded from http://meridian.allenpress.com/american-archivist/article-pdf/17/2/135/2743419/aarc_17_2_lx59207w33103450.pdf by guest on 25 September 2021 By H. M. MOOLMAN Embassy of the Union of South Africa ITHERTO little-known and often unsuspected American- South African relationships in the spheres of history and H culture are being uncovered by archival research conducted in the United States under a project of the Union of South Africa. This project aims at supplementing the South African Government archives, by microfilm or other copies of material of historic inter- est relating to South Africa known or believed to be available abroad. In 1951 three archivists were appointed for overseas research, their fields including Great Britain and other Common- wealth countries, Europe, and the North American Continent. The fruits of their research will be preserved in South Africa's National Archives for study by future historians and other research work- ers, possibly even from America and other countries. The "New World" was allocated to a South African historian and former Rhodes scholar, Dr. C. F. J. Muller, faculty member of the University of South Africa. With Washington, D. C, as his headquarters, his research field included also Canada, Bermuda, and any other adjoining territory or island whence historical data relating to South Africa might be culled. A big field and a huge task for one man! Dr. Muller, however, rolled up his sleeves in the Nation's capital and delved into the most obvious repositories of historical material on South Africa, the National Archives and the Library of Congress.
    [Show full text]
  • 19Th Century Tragedy, Victory, and Divine Providence As the Foundations of an Afrikaner National Identity
    Georgia State University ScholarWorks @ Georgia State University History Theses Department of History Spring 5-7-2011 19th Century Tragedy, Victory, and Divine Providence as the Foundations of an Afrikaner National Identity Kevin W. Hudson Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarworks.gsu.edu/history_theses Part of the History Commons Recommended Citation Hudson, Kevin W., "19th Century Tragedy, Victory, and Divine Providence as the Foundations of an Afrikaner National Identity." Thesis, Georgia State University, 2011. https://scholarworks.gsu.edu/history_theses/45 This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the Department of History at ScholarWorks @ Georgia State University. It has been accepted for inclusion in History Theses by an authorized administrator of ScholarWorks @ Georgia State University. For more information, please contact [email protected]. 19TH CENTURY TRAGEDY, VICTORY, AND DIVINE PROVIDENCE AS THE FOUNDATIONS OF AN AFRIKANER NATIONAL IDENTITY by KEVIN W. HUDSON Under the DireCtion of Dr. Mohammed Hassen Ali and Dr. Jared Poley ABSTRACT Apart from a sense of racial superiority, which was certainly not unique to white Cape colonists, what is clear is that at the turn of the nineteenth century, Afrikaners were a disparate group. Economically, geographically, educationally, and religiously they were by no means united. Hierarchies existed throughout all cross sections of society. There was little political consciousness and no sense of a nation. Yet by the end of the nineteenth century they had developed a distinct sense of nationalism, indeed of a volk [people; ethnicity] ordained by God. The objective of this thesis is to identify and analyze three key historical events, the emotional sentiments evoked by these nationalistic milestones, and the evolution of a unified Afrikaner identity that would ultimately be used to justify the abhorrent system of apartheid.
    [Show full text]
  • South Africa: Historical Background Greg Moran
    Third World Legal Studies Volume 14 The Governance of Internal Security Forces Article 8 in Sub-Saharan Africa 1-8-1997 Human Rights and the Structure of Internal Security Forces – South Africa: Historical Background Greg Moran Follow this and additional works at: http://scholar.valpo.edu/twls Recommended Citation Moran, Greg (1997) "Human Rights and the Structure of Internal Security Forces – South Africa: Historical Background," Third World Legal Studies: Vol. 14, Article 8. Available at: http://scholar.valpo.edu/twls/vol14/iss1/8 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Valparaiso University Law School at ValpoScholar. It has been accepted for inclusion in Third World Legal Studies by an authorized administrator of ValpoScholar. For more information, please contact a ValpoScholar staff member at [email protected]. HUMAN RIGHTS AND THE STRUCTURE OF INTERNAL SECURITY FORCES SOUTH AFRICA: HISTORICAL BACKGROUND By Greg Moran* The apartheid policies that characterised most of the period of colonial rule, both formally (after 1948) and informally before, left an indelible mark on the consciousness of South Africans, (and on the map of the country prior to 1994). The policy of creating separate homelands for each of the black ethnic groupings and pushing these to independence to ensure the survival of white South Africa, lead to the creation of numerous police and armed forces. The records of all of these are severely blemished and their histories steeped in blood. At present, moves are afoot to incorporate all of these security forces into unified bodies: the South African National Defense Force (SANDF) and the South African Police Services (SAPS).
    [Show full text]
  • REVIEW REPORT on Tokelau's Clinical Health Services and Patient
    REVIEW REPORT on Tokelau’s Clinical Health Services and Patient Referrals Scheme Prepared by: Tracie Mafile’o, Sunia Foliaki, Tanya Koro, Helen Leslie*, Michelle Redman- MacLaren, Caryn West, Matthew Roskrudge November 2019 *Helen Leslie contributed to the review report as a review team member up until July 2019 Table of Contents LIST OF FIGURES ..............................................................................................................................................III LIST OF TABLES ...............................................................................................................................................III ACRONYMS .................................................................................................................................................... IV GLOSSARY ...................................................................................................................................................... IV ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ................................................................................................................................... V EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ................................................................................................................................... VI PURPOSE .............................................................................................................................................................. VI APPROACH ...........................................................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Statute of Westminster, 1931. [22 GEO
    Statute of Westminster, 1931. [22 GEO. 5. CH. 4.] ARRANGEMENT OF SECTIONS. A.D. 1931. Section. 1. Meaning of " Dominion" in this Act. Validity of laws made by Parliament of a Dominion. Power of Parliament of Dominion to legislate extra- territorially. 4. Parliament of United Kingdom not to legislate for Dominion except by consent. 5. Powers of Dominion Parliaments in relation to merchant shipping. 6. Powers of Dominion Parliaments in relation to Courts of Admiralty. 7. Saving for British North America Acts and application of the Act to Canada. 8. Saving for Constitution Acts of Australia and New Zealand. 9. Saving with respect to States of Australia. 10. Certain sections of Act not to apply to Australia, New Zealand or Newfoundland unless adopted. 11. Meaning of " Colony " in future Acts. 12. Short title. i [22 GEO. 5.] Statute of Westminster, 1931. [CH. 4.] CHAPTER 4. An Act to give effect to certain resolutions passed A.D. 1931. by Imperial Conferences held in the years 1926 and 1930. [11th December 1931.] HEREAS the delegates of His Majesty's Govern- W ments in the United Kingdom, the Dominion of Canada, the Commonwealth of Australia, the Dominion of New Zealand, the Union of South Africa, the Irish Free State and Newfoundland, at Imperial Conferences holden at Westminster in the years of our Lord nineteen hundred and twenty-six and nineteen hundred and thirty did concur in making the declarations and resolutions set forth in the Reports of the said Conferences : And whereas it is meet and proper to set out by way of preamble to this
    [Show full text]