Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Statistical 2010 Orig. Final Parcel Parcel Parcel Parcel Planning 2014 2009 Census Land Land Deed Conveyance Conveyance Transfer Receipt Number Address Municipality Zip Area Ward Ward Tract Use Type Use Type Type Price Flag Date Number 140-01-019 15807 HARVARD AVE Cleveland 44128 Lee-Harvard 1 1 121700 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $30,000 11-Dec-18 140-02-021 3934 E 155 ST Cleveland 44128 Lee-Harvard 1 1 121700 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $20,000 12-Dec-18 140-03-008 3871 E 154 ST Cleveland 44128 Lee-Harvard 1 1 121700 Single family dwelling Single-Family AFF $0 3-Dec-18 140-03-037 15602 WALDEN AVE Cleveland 44128 Lee-Harvard 1 1 121700 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $62,500 3-Dec-18 140-04-085 16009 THROCKLEY AVE Cleveland 44128 Lee-Harvard 1 1 121700 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $40,100 27-Dec-18 140-06-003 16109 STOCKBRIDGE AVE Cleveland 44128 Lee-Harvard 1 1 121700 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 31-Dec-18 140-06-033 16400 GLENDALE AVE Cleveland 44128 Lee-Harvard 1 1 121700 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $58,000 4-Dec-18 140-06-085 16202 DELREY AVE Cleveland 44128 Lee-Harvard 1 1 121700 Single family dwelling Single-Family DIL $0 6-Dec-18 140-07-018 16409 GLENDALE AVE Cleveland 44128 Lee-Harvard 1 1 121700 Single family dwelling Single-Family PCT $0 31-Dec-18 140-07-018 16409 GLENDALE AVE Cleveland 44128 Lee-Harvard 1 1 121700 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $29,900 31-Dec-18 140-07-056 16113 TALFORD AVE Cleveland 44128 Lee-Harvard 1 1 121700 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $20,001 3-Dec-18 140-07-089 16114 TALFORD AVE Cleveland 44128 Lee-Harvard 1 1 121700 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $28,000 31-Dec-18 140-08-006 16201 WALDEN AVE Cleveland 44128 Lee-Harvard 1 1 121700 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 11-Dec-18 140-08-073 16404 INVERMERE AVE Cleveland 44128 Lee-Harvard 1 1 121700 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $16,667 21-Dec-18 140-09-017 16603 WALDEN AVE Cleveland 44128 Lee-Harvard 1 1 121700 Single family dwelling Single-Family PCT $0 7-Dec-18 140-09-066 16612 INVERMERE AVE Cleveland 44128 Lee-Harvard 1 1 121700 Single family dwelling Single-Family PCT $0 20-Dec-18 140-10-087 17103 WALDEN AVE Cleveland 44128 Lee-Harvard 1 1 121700 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $36,200 EMV 11-Dec-18 140-10-089 17111 WALDEN AVE Cleveland 44128 Lee-Harvard 1 1 121700 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $27,500 18-Dec-18 140-12-096 16604 WALDEN AVE Cleveland 44128 Lee-Harvard 1 1 121700 Single family dwelling Single-Family DEE $29,100 4-Dec-18 140-13-084 17012 GLENDALE AVE Cleveland 44128 Lee-Harvard 1 1 121700 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $35,800 EMV 28-Dec-18 140-15-039 16612 ELDAMERE AVE Cleveland 44128 Lee-Harvard 1 1 121700 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $124,900 24-Dec-18 140-15-040 16608 ELDAMERE AVE Cleveland 44128 Lee-Harvard 1 1 121700 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $50,000 21-Dec-18 140-15-070 16516 STOCKBRIDGE AVE Cleveland 44128 Lee-Harvard 1 1 121700 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $100,000 18-Dec-18 140-16-005 16918 BILTMORE AVE Cleveland 44128 Lee-Harvard 1 1 121700 Single family dwelling Single-Family CLE $0 21-Dec-18 140-17-055 17504 ELDAMERE AVE Cleveland 44128 Lee-Harvard 1 1 121700 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $10,000 4-Dec-18 140-19-049 3884 LEE HEIGHTS BLVD Cleveland 44128 Lee-Harvard 1 1 121800 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $36,500 5-Dec-18 140-19-089 3880 STRANDHILL RD Cleveland 44128 Lee-Harvard 1 1 121800 Single family dwelling Single-Family LIM $5,000 31-Dec-18 140-21-147 3984 WENDY DR Cleveland 44122 Lee-Harvard 1 1 121800 Single family dwelling Single-Family AFF $0 17-Dec-18 140-26-003 4000 E 189 ST Cleveland 44122 Lee-Harvard 1 1 121800 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $24,000 4-Dec-18 140-26-044 3984 E 190 ST Cleveland 44122 Lee-Harvard 1 1 121800 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $0 21-Dec-18 141-08-152 16322 NORTH LOTUS DR Cleveland 44128 Lee-Harvard 1 1 121900 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 31-Dec-18 141-09-011 16201 WESTVIEW AVE Cleveland 44128 Lee-Harvard 1 1 121900 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $23,950 13-Dec-18 141-09-011 16201 WESTVIEW AVE Cleveland 44128 Lee-Harvard 1 1 121900 Single family dwelling Single-Family COR $0 19-Dec-18 141-15-002 4161 E 187 ST Cleveland 44122 Lee-Harvard 1 1 122100 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $49,000 13-Dec-18 141-15-057 4085 E 186 ST Cleveland 44122 Lee-Harvard 1 1 122100 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $64,900 26-Dec-18 141-15-097 4129 FEINER DR Cleveland 44122 Lee-Harvard 1 1 122100 Single family dwelling Single-Family AFF $0 4-Dec-18 141-15-097 4129 FEINER DR Cleveland 44122 Lee-Harvard 1 1 122100 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $79,500 4-Dec-18 141-18-016 17209 LOTUS DR Cleveland 44128 Lee-Harvard 1 1 122100 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 20-Dec-18 141-18-104 4267 E 170 ST Cleveland 44128 Lee-Harvard 1 1 122100 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $73,500 5-Dec-18 141-20-032 4196 E 178 ST Cleveland 44128 Lee-Harvard 1 1 122100 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 20-Dec-18 141-21-080 18300 DEFOREST AVE Cleveland 44122 Lee-Harvard 1 1 122100 Single family dwelling Single-Family AFF $0 20-Dec-18 141-21-080 18300 DEFOREST AVE Cleveland 44122 Lee-Harvard 1 1 122100 Single family dwelling Single-Family FID $67,400 20-Dec-18 141-21-083 18108 DEFOREST AVE Cleveland 44128 Lee-Harvard 1 1 122100 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $122,000 11-Dec-18 141-22-084 4168 E 186 ST Cleveland 44122 Lee-Harvard 1 1 122100 Single family dwelling Single-Family LIM $21,933 3-Dec-18 Page 1 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Statistical 2010 Orig. Final Parcel Parcel Parcel Parcel Planning 2014 2009 Census Land Land Deed Conveyance Conveyance Transfer Receipt Number Address Municipality Zip Area Ward Ward Tract Use Type Use Type Type Price Flag Date Number 141-22-084 4168 E 186 ST Cleveland 44122 Lee-Harvard 1 1 122100 Single family dwelling Single-Family LIM $21,933 3-Dec-18 142-09-006 15206 JUDSON DR Cleveland 44128 Lee-Harvard 1 1 121500 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $43,000 24-Dec-18 143-07-057 16915 PALDA DR Cleveland 44128 Lee-Harvard 1 1 122100 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $40,000 EMV 20-Dec-18 143-07-057 16915 PALDA DR Cleveland 44128 Lee-Harvard 1 1 122100 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $61,900 20-Dec-18 143-09-014 4324 WYATT RD Cleveland 44128 Lee-Harvard 1 1 122100 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $0 13-Dec-18 143-09-031 4361 E 175 ST Cleveland 44128 Lee-Harvard 1 1 122100 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $33,000 6-Dec-18 138-20-105 4321 E 142 ST Cleveland 44128 Lee-Seville 1 1 121403 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $3,000 5-Dec-18 138-21-038 4363 E 143 ST Cleveland 44128 Lee-Seville 1 1 121403 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $13,334 12-Dec-18 138-22-029 4395 E 141 ST Cleveland 44128 Lee-Seville 1 1 121403 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 20-Dec-18 900911 138-22-029 4395 E 141 ST Cleveland 44128 Lee-Seville 1 1 121403 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $250,349 20-Dec-18 900913 138-24-022 4520 E 143 ST Cleveland 44128 Lee-Seville 1 1 121403 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $27,000 28-Dec-18 142-14-021 4413 E 158 ST Cleveland 44128 Lee-Seville 1 1 122200 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $35,000 21-Dec-18 142-17-031 4472 E 158 ST Cleveland 44128 Lee-Seville 1 1 122200 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $0 12-Dec-18 142-20-014 16114 SEVILLE RD Cleveland 44128 Lee-Seville 1 1 122200 Residential vacant land Land SHF $0 21-Dec-18 142-25-127 14817 NAPLES AVE Cleveland 44128 Lee-Seville 1 1 122200 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $37,500 11-Dec-18 142-27-147 15206 LINCOLN AVE Cleveland 44128 Lee-Seville 1 1 122200 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $37,500 12-Dec-18 143-15-004 17202 LIPTON AVE Cleveland 44128 Lee-Seville 1 1 122300 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $0 4-Dec-18 143-15-047 4597 E 174 ST Cleveland 44128 Lee-Seville 1 1 122300 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $14,000 12-Dec-18 143-15-053 4576 E 174 ST Cleveland 44128 Lee-Seville 1 1 122300 Single family dwelling Single-Family AFF $0 31-Dec-18 143-17-060 4776 E 174 ST Cleveland 44128 Lee-Seville 1 1 122300 Single family dwelling Single-Family PCT $0 4-Dec-18 143-19-061 4658 E 177 ST Cleveland 44128 Lee-Seville 1 1 122300 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $34,000 EMV 21-Dec-18 143-19-152 17610 TARKINGTON AVE Cleveland 44128 Lee-Seville 1 1 122300 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 5-Dec-18 143-20-129 4784 E 176 ST Cleveland 44128 Lee-Seville 1 1 122300 Single family dwelling Single-Family LIM $14,000 31-Dec-18 143-20-139 4744 E 176 ST Cleveland 44128 Lee-Seville 1 1 122300 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $32,000 6-Dec-18 130-15-062 14223 MILVERTON RD Cleveland 44120 Mount Pleasant 1 1 119900 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $23,434 24-Dec-18 130-16-140 3433 E 145 ST Cleveland 44120 Mount Pleasant 1 1 119900 Single family dwelling Single-Family PRV $0 13-Dec-18 130-18-046 14702 MILVERTON RD Cleveland 44120 Mount Pleasant 1 1 119900 Two family dwelling Two-Family SUR $85,000 17-Dec-18 130-18-071 3305 E 146 ST Cleveland 44120 Mount Pleasant 1 1 119900 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 7-Dec-18 139-19-027 3729 E 151 ST Cleveland 44120 Mount Pleasant 1 1 120801 Two family dwelling Two-Family LIM $0 17-Dec-18 139-20-107 3518 E 153 ST Cleveland 44120 Mount Pleasant 1 1 120801 Two family dwelling Two-Family LIM $28,350 4-Dec-18 139-20-107 3518 E 153 ST Cleveland 44120 Mount Pleasant 1 1 120801 Two family dwelling Two-Family LIM $28,350 4-Dec-18 139-20-107 3518 E 153 ST Cleveland 44120 Mount Pleasant 1 1 120801 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $56,700 EMV* 4-Dec-18 139-20-107 3518 E 153 ST Cleveland 44120 Mount Pleasant 1 1 120801 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 31-Dec-18 139-20-113 3533 E 151 ST Cleveland 44120 Mount Pleasant 1 1 120801 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $53,400 EMV 28-Dec-18 138-11-088 13305 FERRIS AVE Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 1 2 121401 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $44,000 7-Dec-18 138-11-137 4133 E 135 ST Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 1 1 121401 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $19,700 EMV 17-Dec-18 138-11-137 4133 E 135 ST Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 1 1 121401 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 26-Dec-18 138-12-121 4115 E 138 ST Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 1 1 121401 Two family dwelling Two-Family PCT $0 10-Dec-18 138-18-012 13721 CAINE AVE Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 1 1 121403 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $52,500 26-Dec-18 138-18-045 4290 E 139 ST Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 1 1 121403 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $0 10-Dec-18 139-06-081 3993 E 144 ST Cleveland 44128 Union-Miles 1 1 121500 Two family dwelling Two-Family SHF $0 4-Dec-18 139-15-080 3992 E 148 ST Cleveland 44128 Union-Miles 1 1 121500 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $48,300 EMV 10-Dec-18 139-15-148 3934 E 149 ST Cleveland 44128 Union-Miles 1 1 121500 Residential vacant land Land SHF $0 6-Dec-18 142-05-079 4067 E 147 ST Cleveland 44128 Union-Miles 1 1 121500 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 19-Dec-18 Page 2 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Statistical 2010 Orig. Final Parcel Parcel Parcel Parcel Planning 2014 2009 Census Land Land Deed Conveyance Conveyance Transfer Receipt Number Address Municipality Zip Area Ward Ward Tract Use Type Use Type Type Price Flag Date Number 134-13-077 7702 DORVER AVE Cleveland 44105 Broadway-Slavic Village 2 2 115800 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $0 21-Dec-18 134-14-087 8109 FORCE AVE Cleveland 44105 Broadway-Slavic Village 2 2 115800 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $44,500 13-Dec-18 134-14-097 8305 FORCE AVE Cleveland 44105 Broadway-Slavic Village 2 2 115800 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $12,000 EMV 10-Dec-18 134-18-088 7808 CONNECTICUT AVE Cleveland 44105 Broadway-Slavic Village 2 2 115900 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 17-Dec-18 134-18-089 7812 CONNECTICUT AVE Cleveland 44105 Broadway-Slavic Village 2 2 115900 Residential vacant land Land QTC $0 17-Dec-18 134-18-118 7610 NEW YORK AVE Cleveland 44105 Broadway-Slavic Village 2 2 115900 Two family dwelling Two-Family LND $0 20-Dec-18 134-18-127 7646 NEW YORK AVE Cleveland 44105 Broadway-Slavic Village 2 2 115900 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $38,000 EMV 10-Dec-18 134-18-135 7804 NEW YORK AVE Cleveland 44105 Broadway-Slavic Village 2 2 115900 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $44,600 EMV 20-Dec-18 134-18-142 8011 JEFFRIES AVE Cleveland 44105 Broadway-Slavic Village 2 2 115900 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $38,800 28-Dec-18 134-19-046 7916 NEW YORK AVE Cleveland 44105 Broadway-Slavic Village 2 2 115900 Residential vacant land Land SHF $0 6-Dec-18 134-19-094 8006 MARYLAND AVE Cleveland 44105 Broadway-Slavic Village 2 2 115900 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 7-Dec-18 134-21-088 8605 MACOMB AVE Cleveland 44105 Broadway-Slavic Village 2 2 115900 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $48,900 28-Dec-18 134-24-065 8417 ROSEWOOD AVE Cleveland 44105 Broadway-Slavic Village 2 2 115900 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $40,000 7-Dec-18 134-25-023 8909 VINEYARD AVE Cleveland 44105 Broadway-Slavic Village 2 2 115900 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $6,000 10-Dec-18 134-28-003 9721 ROSEWOOD AVE Cleveland 44105 Broadway-Slavic Village 2 2 115900 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $8,821 31-Dec-18 134-32-133 4430 BROOKS RD Cleveland 44105 Broadway-Slavic Village 2 2 115900 Single family dwelling Single-Family AFF $0 19-Dec-18 130-21-087 3410 E 118 ST Cleveland 44120 Mount Pleasant 2 6 120600 Single family dwelling Single-Family LIM $5,000 4-Dec-18 130-21-097 3375 E 117 ST Cleveland 44120 Mount Pleasant 2 6 120600 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 26-Dec-18 130-21-097 3375 E 117 ST Cleveland 44120 Mount Pleasant 2 6 120600 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $22,500 26-Dec-18 135-10-032 3565 EAST BLVD Cleveland 44105 Mount Pleasant 2 6 120600 Two family dwelling Two-Family AFF $0 14-Dec-18 899926 135-13-024 3675 E 112 ST Cleveland 44105 Mount Pleasant 2 6 120600 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $23,300 EMV 13-Dec-18 135-13-081 3666 E 114 ST Cleveland 44105 Mount Pleasant 2 6 120600 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $23,000 EMV 14-Dec-18 137-06-046 3577 E 139 ST Cleveland 44120 Mount Pleasant 2 2 120701 Two family dwelling Two-Family SHF $0 21-Dec-18 137-07-101 3576 E 120 ST Cleveland 44105 Mount Pleasant 2 6 120600 Two family dwelling Two-Family SHF $0 21-Dec-18 137-07-104 11813 REXFORD AVE Cleveland 44105 Mount Pleasant 2 6 120600 Residential vacant land Land SHF $0 6-Dec-18 139-01-087 3598 E 143 ST Cleveland 44120 Mount Pleasant 2 2 120802 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $28,000 7-Dec-18 139-02-178 3670 E 144 ST Cleveland 44120 Mount Pleasant 2 2 120802 Two family dwelling Two-Family SHF $0 21-Dec-18 139-04-062 14101 GLENDALE AVE Cleveland 44128 Mount Pleasant 2 2 120802 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 12-Dec-18 139-04-144 3872 E 142 ST Cleveland 44128 Mount Pleasant 2 2 120802 Residential vacant land Land QTC $0 31-Dec-18 139-12-106 3680 E 151 ST Cleveland 44120 Mount Pleasant 2 2 120801 Two family dwelling Two-Family PCT $0 28-Dec-18 139-12-107 3676 E 151 ST Cleveland 44120 Mount Pleasant 2 2 120801 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 27-Dec-18 139-14-026 14815 GLENDALE AVE Cleveland 44128 Mount Pleasant 2 2 120801 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $0 21-Dec-18 133-28-018 8809 HARVARD AVE Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 2 2 127501 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $3,100 20-Dec-18 133-28-061 3975 E 89 ST Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 2 2 127501 Two family dwelling Two-Family AFF $0 4-Dec-18 135-04-035 9504 DUNLAP AVE Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 2 5 120400 Two family dwelling Two-Family SUR $22,000 EMV 19-Dec-18 135-08-026 3633 E 106 ST Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 2 2 120500 Residential vacant land Land SHF $0 12-Dec-18 135-09-125 3704 E 106 ST Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 2 2 120500 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $28,000 21-Dec-18 135-10-096 3527 E 108 ST Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 2 6 120500 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 26-Dec-18 135-14-047 11122 GLENBORO DR Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 2 2 127501 Two family dwelling Two-Family AFF $0 14-Dec-18 899926 135-14-086 11117 GLENBORO DR Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 2 6 120600 Two family dwelling Two-Family AFF $0 14-Dec-18 899926 135-14-095 11224 EAST BLVD Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 2 6 120600 Single family dwelling Single-Family AFF $0 14-Dec-18 899926 135-14-099 11202 EAST BLVD Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 2 6 120600 Two family dwelling Two-Family AFF $0 14-Dec-18 899926 135-14-100 3692 EAST BLVD Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 2 6 120600 Two family dwelling Two-Family AFF $0 14-Dec-18 899926 135-17-114 9800 RENO AVE Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 2 2 127501 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 4-Dec-18 Page 3 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Statistical 2010 Orig. Final Parcel Parcel Parcel Parcel Planning 2014 2009 Census Land Land Deed Conveyance Conveyance Transfer Receipt Number Address Municipality Zip Area Ward Ward Tract Use Type Use Type Type Price Flag Date Number 135-18-005 10102 SANDUSKY AVE Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 2 5 127501 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $23,800 EMV 19-Dec-18 135-18-049 10330 GAY AVE Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 2 5 127501 Single family dwelling Single-Family PCT $0 31-Dec-18 135-19-003 10414 SANDUSKY AVE Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 2 2 127501 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $14,875 20-Dec-18 135-19-039 10413 WAY AVE Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 2 2 127501 Single family dwelling Single-Family LIM $0 7-Dec-18 135-20-103 11202 REVERE AVE Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 2 2 127501 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $0 18-Dec-18 136-02-072 E 97 ST Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 2 2 127501 Residential vacant land Land QTC $0 19-Dec-18 900580 136-03-120 10318 DOVE AVE Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 2 2 127501 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $4,000 21-Dec-18 136-04-025 10705 NELSON AVE Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 2 2 127501 Single family dwelling Single-Family LIM $34,500 17-Dec-18 136-06-003 11222 MATILDA AVE Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 2 2 127501 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $5,500 26-Dec-18 136-12-006 11402 AVON AVE Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 2 2 127501 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $12,750 4-Dec-18 136-13-056 9324 HARVARD AVE Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 2 2 121300 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 13-Dec-18 136-14-101 4148 E 97 ST Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 2 2 121300 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $0 21-Dec-18 136-16-108 4071 E 104 ST Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 2 2 121300 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $23,800 EMV 18-Dec-18 136-22-057 4221 E 96 ST Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 2 2 121300 Residential vacant land Land QTC $0 13-Dec-18 136-22-058 4223 E 96 ST Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 2 2 121300 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 13-Dec-18 136-25-031 4221 E 110 ST Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 2 2 121300 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $8,031 17-Dec-18 137-14-064 11717 GAY AVE Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 2 2 120600 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $46,500 21-Dec-18 137-20-064 11825 LENACRAVE AVE Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 2 2 121100 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $57,400 17-Dec-18 137-24-047 13208 GLENDALE AVE Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 2 2 121200 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $10,000 12-Dec-18 137-24-052 13201 GLENDALE AVE Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 2 2 121200 Single family dwelling Single-Family CLA $0 20-Dec-18 137-24-072 13412 CHAPELSIDE AVE Cleveland 44120 Union-Miles 2 2 121200 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $26,600 EMV 12-Dec-18 137-24-146 13202 COATH AVE Cleveland 44120 Union-Miles 2 2 121200 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $20,000 21-Dec-18 137-25-060 13702 GLENDALE AVE Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 2 2 121200 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $16,000 6-Dec-18 138-01-043 11708 EAST BLVD Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 2 2 121401 Single family dwelling Single-Family PCT $0 26-Dec-18 138-01-080 11709 PRINCETON AVE Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 2 2 121100 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $3,500 4-Dec-18 138-02-063 4014 E 123 ST Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 2 2 121401 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $12,000 18-Dec-18 138-02-119 3986 E 121 ST Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 2 2 121401 Residential vacant land Land SHF $0 6-Dec-18 138-02-121 3974 E 121 ST Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 2 2 121100 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $60,000 28-Dec-18 138-03-081 12405 BENWOOD AVE Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 2 2 121100 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $17,900 EMV 28-Dec-18 138-03-095 12600 WATTERSON AVE Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 2 2 121100 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $0 12-Dec-18 138-04-055 12810 CRENNELL AVE Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 2 2 121401 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $25,000 17-Dec-18 138-05-050 13400 CRENNELL AVE Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 2 2 121200 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 3-Dec-18 138-05-055 13216 CRENNELL AVE Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 2 2 121200 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 4-Dec-18 138-05-079 13501 CRENNELL AVE Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 2 2 121200 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $40,100 EMV 7-Dec-18 138-05-105 13113 BENWOOD AVE Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 2 2 121200 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $43,500 20-Dec-18 138-05-105 13113 BENWOOD AVE Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 2 2 121200 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $65,000 20-Dec-18 138-05-143 13204 EDGEWOOD AVE Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 2 2 121200 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $38,900 14-Dec-18 138-09-043 12400 HARVARD AVE Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 2 2 121401 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $20,000 20-Dec-18 138-09-126 4153 E 123 ST Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 2 2 121403 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $17,000 18-Dec-18 138-10-008 12814 HARVARD AVE Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 2 2 121401 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $24,900 EMV 26-Dec-18 138-15-159 4309 E 126 ST Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 2 2 121403 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 24-Dec-18 138-15-172 4259 EAST BLVD Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 2 2 121403 Single family dwelling Single-Family PCT $0 24-Dec-18 007-21-019 3237 SEYMOUR AVE Cleveland 44113 Clark-Fulton 3 14 103800 Two family dwelling Two-Family LIM $13,000 10-Dec-18 007-23-097 2569 W 27 ST Cleveland 44113 Clark-Fulton 3 14 103900 Single family dwelling Single-Family PCT $0 7-Dec-18 Page 4 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Statistical 2010 Orig. Final Parcel Parcel Parcel Parcel Planning 2014 2009 Census Land Land Deed Conveyance Conveyance Transfer Receipt Number Address Municipality Zip Area Ward Ward Tract Use Type Use Type Type Price Flag Date Number 007-23-107 2729 QUEEN AVE Cleveland 44113 Clark-Fulton 3 14 103900 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 5-Dec-18 101-09-492 1260 W 4 ST Cleveland 44113 Downtown 3 3 107101 Residential condominiums Condo SUR $375,000 21-Dec-18 101-29-430 750 PROSPECT AVE Cleveland 44115 Downtown 3 3 107701 Residential condominiums Condo SUR $110,000 17-Dec-18 002-13-063 1418 W 45 ST Cleveland 44102 Ohio City 3 15 103500 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $171,650 17-Dec-18 002-13-302 4612 FRANKLIN BLVD Cleveland 44102 Ohio City 3 15 103500 Residential condominiums Condo WAR $170,000 EMV* 27-Dec-18 002-34-065 1944 W 48 ST Cleveland 44102 Ohio City 3 15 103500 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $132,000 20-Dec-18 002-36-121 1809 W 50 ST Cleveland 44102 Ohio City 3 15 103500 Two family dwelling Two-Family SUR $0 7-Dec-18 003-15-353 2222 DETROIT AVE Cleveland 44113 Ohio City 3 3 103300 Residential condominiums Condo WAR $137,000 6-Dec-18 003-18-333 1237 WASHINGTON ST Cleveland 44113 Ohio City 3 3 103300 Residential condominiums Condo SUR $240,000 5-Dec-18 003-18-366 1237 CENTER ST Cleveland 44113 Ohio City 3 3 103300 Residential condominiums Condo WAR $262,500 27-Dec-18 003-26-120 VINE CT Cleveland 0 Ohio City 3 3 103602 Residential vacant land Land LIM $590,508 21-Dec-18 003-26-125 VINE CT Cleveland 0 Ohio City 3 3 103602 Residential vacant land Land SUR $670,000 17-Dec-18 003-26-303 3200 FRANKLIN AVE Cleveland 44113 Ohio City 3 3 103602 Residential condominiums Condo WAR $240,000 13-Dec-18 003-34-046 4215 BRIDGE AVE Cleveland 44113 Ohio City 3 3 103500 Apartments 1-6 units Apartments WAR $285,000 28-Dec-18 003-34-097 1988 W 44 ST Cleveland 44113 Ohio City 3 3 103500 Residential vacant land Land WAR $380,000 28-Dec-18 901787 003-34-115 1912 W 44 ST Cleveland 44113 Ohio City 3 3 103500 Three family dwelling Three-Family WAR $185,000 14-Dec-18 003-34-135 1990 W 44 ST Cleveland 44113 Ohio City 3 3 103500 Residential vacant land Land WAR $380,000 28-Dec-18 901787 003-38-381 1951 W 26 ST Cleveland 44113 Ohio City 3 3 103602 Residential condominiums Condo WAR $190,000 18-Dec-18 006-20-039 2074 W 44 ST Cleveland 44113 Ohio City 3 15 103500 Residential vacant land Land SUR $292,008 24-Dec-18 006-20-119 2053 W 48 ST Cleveland 44102 Ohio City 3 15 103500 Residential vacant land Land QTC $0 26-Dec-18 007-05-045 2087 W 38 ST Cleveland 44113 Ohio City 3 15 103800 Two family dwelling Two-Family SUR $134,400 4-Dec-18 007-06-091 2162 W 38 ST Cleveland 44113 Ohio City 3 15 103800 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 20-Dec-18 007-07-093 2226 FULTON RD Cleveland 44113 Ohio City 3 15 103800 Single family dwelling Single-Family LIM $295,000 24-Dec-18 007-08-158 2232 W 33 ST Cleveland 44113 Ohio City 3 3 103900 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $30,000 31-Dec-18 007-12-030 2821 YORK AVE Cleveland 44113 Ohio City 3 3 103900 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $45,000 28-Dec-18 016-07-020 3226 W 61 ST Cleveland 44102 Stockyards 3 15 102700 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $0 18-Dec-18 016-07-021 3224 W 61 ST Cleveland 44102 Stockyards 3 15 102700 Residential vacant land Land SHF $0 6-Dec-18 016-10-023 3198 W 58 ST Cleveland 44102 Stockyards 3 15 102700 Apartments 1-6 units Apartments WAR $80,000 7-Dec-18 016-10-023 3198 W 58 ST Cleveland 44102 Stockyards 3 15 102700 Apartments 1-6 units Apartments REF $0 26-Dec-18 016-11-014 3139 W 58 ST Cleveland 44102 Stockyards 3 15 102700 Two family dwelling Two-Family COR $0 28-Dec-18 016-11-161 3127 W 56 ST Cleveland 44102 Stockyards 3 15 102700 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $55,000 12-Dec-18 016-13-115 3217 W 46 ST Cleveland 44102 Stockyards 3 14 102800 Apartments 1-6 units Apartments WAR $45,000 19-Dec-18 016-14-117 3131 W 48 ST Cleveland 44102 Stockyards 3 15 102800 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $44,200 EMV 28-Dec-18 004-03-111 W 19 ST Cleveland 44113 Tremont 3 3 104100 Residential vacant land Land SUR $0 26-Dec-18 004-03-133 ABBEY AVE Cleveland 44113 Tremont 3 3 104100 Residential vacant land Land WAR $601,347 EMV* 7-Dec-18 004-07-026 2560 SCRANTON RD Cleveland 44113 Tremont 3 14 104100 Two family dwelling Two-Family SUR $180,000 21-Dec-18 004-12-071 2316 W 11 ST Cleveland 44113 Tremont 3 3 104200 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 13-Dec-18 004-12-311 2337 W 11 ST Cleveland 44113 Tremont 3 3 104200 Residential condominiums Condo WAR $229,000 31-Dec-18 004-17-008 843 JEFFERSON AVE Cleveland 44113 Tremont 3 3 104300 Apartments 1-6 units Apartments QTC $0 27-Dec-18 004-17-008 843 JEFFERSON AVE Cleveland 44113 Tremont 3 3 104300 Apartments 1-6 units Apartments WAR $305,000 27-Dec-18 004-18-079 2266 W 5 ST Cleveland 44113 Tremont 3 3 104300 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $390,000 20-Dec-18 004-18-088 2172 W 5 ST Cleveland 44113 Tremont 3 3 104300 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $425,000 28-Dec-18 004-18-089 2164 W 5 ST Cleveland 44113 Tremont 3 3 104300 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $475,000 28-Dec-18 004-21-053 2615 W 11 ST Cleveland 44113 Tremont 3 3 104400 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $240,900 5-Dec-18 Page 5 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Statistical 2010 Orig. Final Parcel Parcel Parcel Parcel Planning 2014 2009 Census Land Land Deed Conveyance Conveyance Transfer Receipt Number Address Municipality Zip Area Ward Ward Tract Use Type Use Type Type Price Flag Date Number 004-22-078 829 BRAYTON AVE Cleveland 44113 Tremont 3 3 104400 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $185,000 14-Dec-18 008-04-152 W 12 ST Cleveland 44113 Tremont 3 3 104400 Residential vacant land Land QTC $0 EMV* 24-Dec-18 008-04-152 W 12 ST Cleveland 44113 Tremont 3 3 104400 Residential vacant land Land WAR $40,000 EMV* 24-Dec-18 008-09-060 3021 W 11 ST Cleveland 44113 Tremont 3 3 104400 Three family dwelling Three-Family WAR $45,000 20-Dec-18 006-26-152 7804 DEARBORN AVE Cleveland 44102 West Boulevard 3 16 102402 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $31,000 13-Dec-18 006-28-015 7224 DEARBORN AVE Cleveland 44102 West Boulevard 3 15 102700 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $15,000 28-Dec-18 006-28-043 3198 W 71 ST Cleveland 44102 West Boulevard 3 15 102700 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $14,000 28-Dec-18 129-23-124 12015 CONTINENTAL AVE Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 4 4 119702 Residential vacant land Land SHF $0 12-Dec-18 129-25-072 3013 E 128 ST Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 4 4 119702 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $7,000 28-Dec-18 129-25-122 12613 GRIFFING AVE Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 4 4 119702 Residential vacant land Land SHF $0 12-Dec-18 129-26-058 11808 PARKHILL AVE Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 4 4 119702 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $32,000 26-Dec-18 129-26-058 11808 PARKHILL AVE Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 4 4 119702 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $32,000 31-Dec-18 129-29-022 13013 SOIKA AVE Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 4 4 119701 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $17,100 EMV 3-Dec-18 129-30-088 13409 LORENZO AVE Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 4 4 119701 Two family dwelling Two-Family SHF $0 21-Dec-18 144-03-010 3165 ASHWOOD RD Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 4 4 119701 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $135,000 17-Dec-18 144-04-042 3034 ASHWOOD RD Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 4 4 119701 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $31,300 26-Dec-18 144-05-058 2988 BECKET RD Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 4 4 119701 Single family dwelling Single-Family PCT $0 12-Dec-18 144-05-070 2910 HAMPTON RD Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 4 4 119701 Apartments 40 or more units (walk-up) Apartments LIM $1.875M 14-Dec-18 144-05-070 2910 HAMPTON RD Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 4 4 119701 Apartments 40 or more units (walk-up) Apartments LIM $2.150M 18-Dec-18 144-06-029 3076 ALBION RD Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 4 4 119701 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $0 31-Dec-18 144-07-028 13508 S WOODLAND BLVD Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 4 4 119701 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $42,000 24-Dec-18 144-09-013 2805 LUDLOW RD Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 4 4 119501 Apartments 7-19 units (walk-up) Apartments LIM $0 10-Dec-18 899208 144-09-013 2805 LUDLOW RD Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 4 4 119501 Apartments 7-19 units (walk-up) Apartments LIM $0 10-Dec-18 899199 144-10-011 2825 SOUTH MORELAND BLVD Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 4 4 119501 Apartments 7-19 units (walk-up) Apartments LIM $0 10-Dec-18 899206 144-10-011 2825 SOUTH MORELAND BLVD Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 4 4 119501 Apartments 7-19 units (walk-up) Apartments LIM $0 10-Dec-18 899199 144-10-012 2843 SOUTH MORELAND BLVD Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 4 4 119501 Apartments 7-19 units (walk-up) Apartments LIM $0 10-Dec-18 899206 144-10-012 2843 SOUTH MORELAND BLVD Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 4 4 119501 Apartments 7-19 units (walk-up) Apartments LIM $0 10-Dec-18 899199 144-10-013 2851 HAMPTON RD Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 4 4 119501 Apartments 20-39 units (walk-up) Apartments LIM $0 10-Dec-18 899208 144-10-013 2851 HAMPTON RD Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 4 4 119501 Apartments 20-39 units (walk-up) Apartments LIM $0 10-Dec-18 899199 144-12-324 13415 SHAKER BLVD Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 4 4 119501 Residential condominiums Condo SUR $90,000 27-Dec-18 144-12-422 13715 SHAKER BLVD Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 4 4 119501 Residential condominiums Condo WAR $157,000 17-Dec-18 144-12-441 13901 SHAKER BLVD Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 4 4 119501 Residential condominiums Condo SUR $450,000 28-Dec-18 144-12-802C 13500 SHAKER BLVD Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 4 4 119501 Residential condominiums Condo WAR $19,500 4-Dec-18 144-12-809C 13400 SHAKER BLVD Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 4 4 119501 Residential condominiums Condo SUR $100,000 31-Dec-18 144-13-006 2642 NORTH MORELAND BLVD Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 4 4 119501 Apartments 7-19 units (walk-up) Apartments LIM $0 10-Dec-18 899205 144-13-006 2642 NORTH MORELAND BLVD Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 4 4 119501 Apartments 7-19 units (walk-up) Apartments LIM $0 10-Dec-18 899199 144-13-007 2636 NORTH MORELAND BLVD Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 4 4 119501 Apartments 20-39 units (walk-up) Apartments LIM $0 10-Dec-18 899205 144-13-007 2636 NORTH MORELAND BLVD Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 4 4 119501 Apartments 20-39 units (walk-up) Apartments LIM $0 10-Dec-18 899199 144-13-008 2630 NORTH MORELAND BLVD Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 4 4 119501 Apartments 20-39 units (walk-up) Apartments LIM $0 10-Dec-18 899204 144-13-008 2630 NORTH MORELAND BLVD Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 4 4 119501 Apartments 20-39 units (walk-up) Apartments LIM $0 10-Dec-18 899199 144-13-010 2622 NORTH MORELAND BLVD Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 4 4 119501 Apartments 20-39 units (walk-up) Apartments LIM $0 10-Dec-18 899204 144-13-010 2622 NORTH MORELAND BLVD Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 4 4 119501 Apartments 20-39 units (walk-up) Apartments LIM $0 10-Dec-18 899199 144-13-011 2621 NORTH MORELAND BLVD Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 4 4 119501 Apartments 20-39 units (elevator) Apartments LIM $0 10-Dec-18 899204 144-13-011 2621 NORTH MORELAND BLVD Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 4 4 119501 Apartments 20-39 units (elevator) Apartments LIM $0 10-Dec-18 899199 Page 6 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Statistical 2010 Orig. Final Parcel Parcel Parcel Parcel Planning 2014 2009 Census Land Land Deed Conveyance Conveyance Transfer Receipt Number Address Municipality Zip Area Ward Ward Tract Use Type Use Type Type Price Flag Date Number 144-13-012 2635 NORTH MORELAND BLVD Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 4 4 119501 Apartments 20-39 units (elevator) Apartments LIM $0 10-Dec-18 899205 144-13-012 2635 NORTH MORELAND BLVD Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 4 4 119501 Apartments 20-39 units (elevator) Apartments LIM $0 10-Dec-18 899199 144-13-014 2653 NORTH MORELAND BLVD Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 4 4 119501 Apartments 7-19 units (elevator) Apartments LIM $0 10-Dec-18 899205 144-13-014 2653 NORTH MORELAND BLVD Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 4 4 119501 Apartments 7-19 units (elevator) Apartments LIM $0 10-Dec-18 899199 126-16-034 10005 CUMBERLAND AVE Cleveland 44104 Buckeye-Woodhill 4 4 114501 Two family dwelling Two-Family JUD $0 27-Dec-18 126-22-035 2707 E 89 ST Cleveland 44104 Buckeye-Woodhill 4 4 114501 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $24,400 EMV 17-Dec-18 128-14-013 2906 E 104 ST Cleveland 44104 Buckeye-Woodhill 4 4 119600 Apartments 1-6 units Apartments WAR $124,900 10-Dec-18 128-14-086 10201 PARKVIEW AVE Cleveland 44104 Buckeye-Woodhill 4 4 119600 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 17-Dec-18 128-14-086 10201 PARKVIEW AVE Cleveland 44104 Buckeye-Woodhill 4 4 119600 Two family dwelling Two-Family PCT $0 17-Dec-18 128-26-068 2930 E 114 ST Cleveland 44104 Buckeye-Woodhill 4 4 119600 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $10,000 12-Dec-18 128-26-076 11305 FOREST AVE Cleveland 44104 Buckeye-Woodhill 4 4 119600 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $10,000 17-Dec-18 128-26-077 11301 FOREST AVE Cleveland 44104 Buckeye-Woodhill 4 4 119600 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $21,000 20-Dec-18 128-27-001 11313 PARKVIEW AVE Cleveland 44104 Buckeye-Woodhill 4 4 119600 Two family dwelling Two-Family SHF $0 21-Dec-18 127-25-130 3415 E 106 ST Cleveland 44104 Kinsman 4 6 120500 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $19,000 EMV 17-Dec-18 127-26-019 3438 EAST BLVD Cleveland 44104 Kinsman 4 6 120600 Two family dwelling Two-Family AFF $0 14-Dec-18 899926 127-26-117 3379 E 110 ST Cleveland 44104 Kinsman 4 6 120600 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $0 4-Dec-18 128-19-088 3038 EAST BLVD Cleveland 44104 Kinsman 4 4 119600 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $100,000 10-Dec-18 128-20-024 3118 E 94 ST Cleveland 44104 Kinsman 4 4 120200 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $0 7-Dec-18 128-20-077 9414 DICKENS AVE Cleveland 44104 Kinsman 4 4 120200 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $20,900 EMV 27-Dec-18 128-21-018 3118 E 98 ST Cleveland 44104 Kinsman 4 4 120200 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 17-Dec-18 128-22-033 10010 HILGERT DR Cleveland 44104 Kinsman 4 4 120200 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 5-Dec-18 127-18-049 10234 PARK HEIGHTS RD Cleveland 44104 Mount Pleasant 4 4 120500 Single family dwelling Single-Family LIM $0 5-Dec-18 128-24-074 11130 CONTINENTAL AVE Cleveland 44104 Mount Pleasant 4 4 119600 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $23,700 EMV 10-Dec-18 128-24-074 11130 CONTINENTAL AVE Cleveland 44104 Mount Pleasant 4 4 119600 Two family dwelling Two-Family COR $0 21-Dec-18 128-24-074 11130 CONTINENTAL AVE Cleveland 44104 Mount Pleasant 4 4 119600 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $16,000 21-Dec-18 130-02-032 3310 E 119 ST Cleveland 44120 Mount Pleasant 4 4 119800 Two family dwelling Two-Family SHF $23,200 18-Dec-18 130-02-033 3306 E 119 ST Cleveland 44120 Mount Pleasant 4 4 119800 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $10,000 6-Dec-18 130-02-060 3291 E 117 ST Cleveland 44120 Mount Pleasant 4 4 119800 Two family dwelling Two-Family PCT $0 19-Dec-18 130-02-060 3291 E 117 ST Cleveland 44120 Mount Pleasant 4 4 119800 Two family dwelling Two-Family PCT $0 19-Dec-18 130-02-060 3291 E 117 ST Cleveland 44120 Mount Pleasant 4 4 119800 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $30,300 EMV 21-Dec-18 130-03-129 3269 E 119 ST Cleveland 44120 Mount Pleasant 4 4 119800 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $22,100 EMV 14-Dec-18 130-04-070 3339 E 123 ST Cleveland 44120 Mount Pleasant 4 4 119800 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $89,500 28-Dec-18 130-07-014 3283 E 128 ST Cleveland 44120 Mount Pleasant 4 4 119800 Residential vacant land Land SHF $0 6-Dec-18 130-07-087 3278 E 132 ST Cleveland 44120 Mount Pleasant 4 4 119800 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 20-Dec-18 900911 130-07-087 3278 E 132 ST Cleveland 44120 Mount Pleasant 4 4 119800 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $250,349 20-Dec-18 900913 130-08-044 3386 E 134 ST Cleveland 44120 Mount Pleasant 4 4 119800 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $0 4-Dec-18 130-08-068 3377 E 132 ST Cleveland 44120 Mount Pleasant 4 4 119800 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $27,000 EMV 21-Dec-18 130-11-111 3286 E 140 ST Cleveland 44120 Mount Pleasant 4 4 119800 Single family dwelling Single-Family LIM $10,000 20-Dec-18 130-11-113 3278 E 140 ST Cleveland 44120 Mount Pleasant 4 4 119800 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $0 4-Dec-18 130-12-072 3381 E 139 ST Cleveland 44120 Mount Pleasant 4 4 119800 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $47,900 7-Dec-18 130-21-053 3389 E 119 ST Cleveland 44120 Mount Pleasant 4 6 120701 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $0 4-Dec-18 130-22-092 3448 E 123 ST Cleveland 44120 Mount Pleasant 4 4 120701 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 12-Dec-18 130-22-120 3402 E 125 ST Cleveland 44120 Mount Pleasant 4 4 120701 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $19,000 3-Dec-18 130-23-067 3465 E 128 ST Cleveland 44120 Mount Pleasant 4 4 120701 Two family dwelling Two-Family PRV $25,000 14-Dec-18 Page 7 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Statistical 2010 Orig. Final Parcel Parcel Parcel Parcel Planning 2014 2009 Census Land Land Deed Conveyance Conveyance Transfer Receipt Number Address Municipality Zip Area Ward Ward Tract Use Type Use Type Type Price Flag Date Number 130-23-075 3421 E 128 ST Cleveland 44120 Mount Pleasant 4 4 120701 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $5,000 28-Dec-18 901993 130-23-076 3429 E 128 ST Cleveland 44120 Mount Pleasant 4 4 120701 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $5,000 28-Dec-18 901993 130-23-078 3425 E 128 ST Cleveland 44120 Mount Pleasant 4 4 120701 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $5,000 28-Dec-18 901993 130-23-079 3421 E 128 ST Cleveland 44120 Mount Pleasant 4 4 120701 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $5,000 28-Dec-18 901993 137-03-062 12701 BENHAM AVE Cleveland 44105 Mount Pleasant 4 4 120701 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 28-Dec-18 901892 137-03-062 12701 BENHAM AVE Cleveland 44105 Mount Pleasant 4 4 120701 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $131,830 28-Dec-18 901887 137-03-083 12710 BENHAM AVE Cleveland 44105 Mount Pleasant 4 4 120702 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 28-Dec-18 137-04-056 3525 E 131 ST Cleveland 44120 Mount Pleasant 4 4 120701 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $13,500 31-Dec-18 137-05-020 3542 E 138 ST Cleveland 44120 Mount Pleasant 4 4 120701 Residential vacant land Land SHF $0 12-Dec-18 137-05-095 3545 E 135 ST Cleveland 44120 Mount Pleasant 4 4 120701 Single family dwelling Single-Family PCT $0 17-Dec-18 137-10-047 12608 HOLBORN AVE Cleveland 44105 Mount Pleasant 4 4 120702 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $14,000 17-Dec-18 137-10-068 12609 HOLBORN AVE Cleveland 44105 Mount Pleasant 4 4 120702 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $14,000 17-Dec-18 137-13-073 3674 E 139 ST Cleveland 44120 Mount Pleasant 4 4 120702 Single family dwelling Single-Family AFF $0 20-Dec-18 137-18-133 13305 BARTLETT AVE Cleveland 44120 Mount Pleasant 4 4 120702 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $0 18-Dec-18 137-18-153 13412 MELZER AVE Cleveland 44120 Mount Pleasant 4 4 120702 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $60,000 21-Dec-18 137-15-085 12113 CORLETT AVE Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 4 2 121100 Three family dwelling Three-Family WAR $63,000 6-Dec-18 137-17-082 12711 GAY AVE Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 4 2 120702 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $37,000 11-Dec-18 123-19-059 4687 GALLUP AVE Cleveland 44127 Broadway-Slavic Village 5 5 110501 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $25,750 27-Dec-18 123-19-087 4444 DOUSE AVE Cleveland 44127 Broadway-Slavic Village 5 5 110501 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $23,750 26-Dec-18 123-20-095 4618 LESTER ST Cleveland 44127 Broadway-Slavic Village 5 5 110501 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $25,750 28-Dec-18 123-21-030 4700 LESTER ST Cleveland 44127 Broadway-Slavic Village 5 5 110501 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $25,750 28-Dec-18 125-10-027 3178 E 66 ST Cleveland 44127 Broadway-Slavic Village 5 12 114600 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $0 4-Dec-18 125-12-009 3027 E 65 ST Cleveland 44127 Broadway-Slavic Village 5 5 114600 Apartments 1-6 units Apartments QTC $6,500 EMV 19-Dec-18 125-14-005 2939 E 67 ST Cleveland 44127 Broadway-Slavic Village 5 12 114600 Two family dwelling Two-Family AFF $0 18-Dec-18 125-24-030 5687 HAMLET AVE Cleveland 44127 Broadway-Slavic Village 5 12 114900 Single family dwelling Single-Family AFF $0 13-Dec-18 125-27-139 5997 ENGLE AVE Cleveland 44127 Broadway-Slavic Village 5 12 114900 Single family dwelling Single-Family LIM $22,600 EMV 7-Dec-18 103-15-044 3206 PROSPECT AVE Cleveland 44115 Central 5 5 108701 Apartments 40 or more units (walk-up) Apartments QTC $0 3-Dec-18 103-21-109 2193 E 35 ST Cleveland 44115 Central 5 5 108701 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $50,000 19-Dec-18 103-31-045 2377 E 38 ST Cleveland 44115 Central 5 5 108701 Single family dwelling Single-Family AFF $0 4-Dec-18 118-29-077 2330 E 61 ST Cleveland 44104 Central 5 5 113801 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $60,000 4-Dec-18 124-13-022 2636 E 65 ST Cleveland 44104 Central 5 5 113801 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 31-Dec-18 124-27-018 7310 COLFAX RD Cleveland 44104 Kinsman 5 5 114700 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $23,334 26-Dec-18 126-27-062 8012 HOLTON AVE Cleveland 44104 Kinsman 5 5 114501 Apartments 1-6 units Apartments QTC $0 7-Dec-18 899133 126-27-062 8012 HOLTON AVE Cleveland 44104 Kinsman 5 5 114501 Apartments 1-6 units Apartments WHI $3,375 7-Dec-18 899130 126-27-062 8012 HOLTON AVE Cleveland 44104 Kinsman 5 5 114501 Apartments 1-6 units Apartments WHI $3,375 7-Dec-18 899127 126-27-062 8012 HOLTON AVE Cleveland 44104 Kinsman 5 5 114501 Apartments 1-6 units Apartments WAR $6,750 7-Dec-18 899121 126-27-063 HOLTON AVE Cleveland 44104 Kinsman 5 5 114501 Apartments 1-6 units Apartments QTC $0 7-Dec-18 899133 126-27-063 HOLTON AVE Cleveland 44104 Kinsman 5 5 114501 Apartments 1-6 units Apartments WHI $3,375 7-Dec-18 899130 126-27-063 HOLTON AVE Cleveland 44104 Kinsman 5 5 114501 Apartments 1-6 units Apartments WHI $3,375 7-Dec-18 899127 126-27-063 HOLTON AVE Cleveland 44104 Kinsman 5 5 114501 Apartments 1-6 units Apartments WAR $6,750 7-Dec-18 899121 125-30-052 3299 REGENT RD Cleveland 44127 Broadway-Slavic Village 6 12 114900 Residential vacant land Land WAR $63,000 19-Dec-18 900695 125-30-053 3303 REGENT RD Cleveland 44127 Broadway-Slavic Village 6 12 114900 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $63,000 19-Dec-18 900695 125-32-049 3460 REGENT RD Cleveland 44127 Broadway-Slavic Village 6 12 114900 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $36,500 EMV 5-Dec-18 133-07-032 8114 CROFOOT AVE Cleveland 44105 Broadway-Slavic Village 6 12 115300 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $19,750 14-Dec-18 Page 8 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Statistical 2010 Orig. Final Parcel Parcel Parcel Parcel Planning 2014 2009 Census Land Land Deed Conveyance Conveyance Transfer Receipt Number Address Municipality Zip Area Ward Ward Tract Use Type Use Type Type Price Flag Date Number 129-08-070 12008 CROMWELL AVE Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 6 6 119401 Two family dwelling Two-Family PCT $0 3-Dec-18 129-08-091 11618 CROMWELL AVE Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 6 6 119401 Single family dwelling Single-Family PCT $0 3-Dec-18 129-08-092 11614 CROMWELL AVE Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 6 6 119401 Two family dwelling Two-Family PCT $0 3-Dec-18 129-08-107 2719 E 116 ST Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 6 6 119401 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $110,000 12-Dec-18 129-09-034 12004 LARCHMERE AVE Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 6 6 119401 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $51,900 EMV 28-Dec-18 129-09-059 11807 BROWNING AVE Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 6 6 119401 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $54,500 EMV 14-Dec-18 129-09-065 11714 BROWNING AVE Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 6 6 119401 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $14,000 19-Dec-18 129-09-100 11909 HAMLEN AVE Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 6 6 119401 Two family dwelling Two-Family PCT $0 3-Dec-18 129-09-154 11909 CROMWELL AVE Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 6 6 119401 Two family dwelling Two-Family PCT $0 3-Dec-18 129-10-034 2679 E 121 ST Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 6 6 119401 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $25,000 4-Dec-18 129-11-114 2615 E 122 ST Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 6 6 119401 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $37,100 21-Dec-18 129-15-118 2820 E 120 ST Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 6 6 119402 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 31-Dec-18 129-16-130 2836 E 125 ST Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 6 6 119402 Two family dwelling Two-Family PCT $0 20-Dec-18 144-10-001 2880 SOUTH MORELAND BLVD Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 6 4 119501 Apartments 20-39 units (garden) Apartments LIM $0 10-Dec-18 899206 144-10-001 2880 SOUTH MORELAND BLVD Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 6 4 119501 Apartments 20-39 units (garden) Apartments LIM $0 10-Dec-18 899199 144-10-002 2880 SOUTH MORELAND BLVD Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 6 6 119501 Apartments 20-39 units (elevator) Apartments LIM $0 10-Dec-18 899206 144-10-002 2880 SOUTH MORELAND BLVD Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 6 6 119501 Apartments 20-39 units (elevator) Apartments LIM $0 10-Dec-18 899199 144-10-003 2880 SOUTH MORELAND BLVD Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 6 6 119501 Apartments 20-39 units (elevator) Apartments LIM $0 10-Dec-18 899206 144-10-003 2880 SOUTH MORELAND BLVD Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 6 6 119501 Apartments 20-39 units (elevator) Apartments LIM $0 10-Dec-18 899199 144-10-004 2870 SOUTH MORELAND BLVD Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 6 6 119501 Apartments 20-39 units (garden) Apartments LIM $0 10-Dec-18 899206 144-10-004 2870 SOUTH MORELAND BLVD Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 6 6 119501 Apartments 20-39 units (garden) Apartments LIM $0 10-Dec-18 899199 144-10-008 2822 SOUTH MORELAND BLVD Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 6 6 119501 Apartments 7-19 units (walk-up) Apartments LIM $0 10-Dec-18 899206 144-10-008 2822 SOUTH MORELAND BLVD Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 6 6 119501 Apartments 7-19 units (walk-up) Apartments LIM $0 10-Dec-18 899199 144-10-010 2804 SOUTH MORELAND BLVD Cleveland 44120 Buckeye-Shaker Square 6 6 119501 Apartments 20-39 units (walk-up) Apartments SHF $0 21-Dec-18 121-34-003 11412 WOODSTOCK AVE Cleveland 44104 Buckeye-Woodhill 6 6 119202 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $26,100 EMV 17-Dec-18 121-34-065 11417 NOTRE DAME AVE Cleveland 44104 Buckeye-Woodhill 6 6 119300 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $21,800 EMV 7-Dec-18 126-36-031 2947 E 92 ST Cleveland 44104 Buckeye-Woodhill 6 6 114501 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $4,000 EMV 20-Dec-18 126-37-048 9312 SOPHIA AVE Cleveland 44104 Buckeye-Woodhill 6 6 114501 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $3,334 4-Dec-18 128-03-120 2645 E 110 ST Cleveland 44104 Buckeye-Woodhill 6 6 119300 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $90,000 11-Dec-18 128-04-067 2656 E 115 ST Cleveland 44104 Buckeye-Woodhill 6 6 119300 Apartments 1-6 units Apartments WAR $40,000 21-Dec-18 128-06-017 10403 ROSEHILL AVE Cleveland 44104 Buckeye-Woodhill 6 6 119300 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $80,500 7-Dec-18 128-28-064 2901 E 111 ST Cleveland 44104 Buckeye-Woodhill 6 6 119600 Residential vacant land Land QTC $3,400 12-Dec-18 119-26-075 7920 AMOS AVE Cleveland 44104 Fairfax 6 6 196500 Single family dwelling Single-Family PCT $0 4-Dec-18 119-28-026 8018 CEDAR AVE Cleveland 44103 Fairfax 6 6 196500 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $18,700 EMV 31-Dec-18 119-28-061 2213 E 82 ST Cleveland 44103 Fairfax 6 6 196500 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $22,580 5-Dec-18 119-29-165 2253 E 83 ST Cleveland 44103 Fairfax 6 6 196500 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 28-Dec-18 119-34-056 2264 E 93 ST Cleveland 44106 Fairfax 6 6 113600 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $23,500 EMV 24-Dec-18 121-16-030 2206 E 100 ST Cleveland 44106 Fairfax 6 6 113600 Apartments 1-6 units Apartments QTC $20,800 EMV 28-Dec-18 121-17-069 2304 E 97 ST Cleveland 44106 Fairfax 6 6 113600 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $46,667 26-Dec-18 121-18-118 2216 E 101 ST Cleveland 44106 Fairfax 6 6 113600 Single family dwelling Single-Family VSD $0 4-Dec-18 126-04-064 2525 E 84 ST Cleveland 44104 Fairfax 6 6 114100 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $0 24-Dec-18 126-06-084 8805 NEVADA AVE Cleveland 44104 Fairfax 6 6 114100 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $12,600 EMV 11-Dec-18 127-11-108 9205 MARSHALL AVE Cleveland 44104 Kinsman 6 6 114501 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $11,700 EMV 11-Dec-18 127-16-116 9515 EASTON AVE Cleveland 44104 Kinsman 6 6 120400 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $25,000 10-Dec-18 Page 9 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Statistical 2010 Orig. Final Parcel Parcel Parcel Parcel Planning 2014 2009 Census Land Land Deed Conveyance Conveyance Transfer Receipt Number Address Municipality Zip Area Ward Ward Tract Use Type Use Type Type Price Flag Date Number 127-16-116 9515 EASTON AVE Cleveland 44104 Kinsman 6 6 120400 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $34,900 10-Dec-18 127-16-116 9515 EASTON AVE Cleveland 44104 Kinsman 6 6 120400 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $57,300 10-Dec-18 127-24-050 3454 E 105 ST Cleveland 44104 Kinsman 6 6 120500 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 13-Dec-18 135-02-066 BENHAM AVE Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 6 5 120400 Residential vacant land Land SHF $0 6-Dec-18 135-03-037 10011 ORLEANS AVE Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 6 5 120400 Single family dwelling Single-Family AFF $0 19-Dec-18 135-03-126 10103 BENHAM AVE Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 6 5 120400 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $12,500 7-Dec-18 135-04-082 9422 ORLEANS AVE Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 6 5 120400 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $8,500 11-Dec-18 135-06-014 10112 ORLEANS AVE Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 6 5 120400 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 28-Dec-18 901892 135-06-014 10112 ORLEANS AVE Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 6 5 120400 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $131,830 28-Dec-18 901887 135-06-016 3624 E 103 ST Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 6 5 120400 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 5-Dec-18 135-06-016 3624 E 103 ST Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 6 5 120400 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $31,000 EMV* 5-Dec-18 135-07-042 3544 E 104 ST Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 6 6 120500 Residential vacant land Land QTC $0 21-Dec-18 901234 135-07-043 3540 E 104 ST Cleveland 44105 Union-Miles 6 6 120500 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 21-Dec-18 901234 120-30-051 1965 COLTMAN RD Cleveland 44106 University 6 9 118800 Two family dwelling Two-Family AFF $0 5-Dec-18 120-30-052 1971 COLTMAN RD Cleveland 44106 University 6 9 118800 Three family dwelling Three-Family AFF $0 4-Dec-18 120-33-037 1903 WOODLAWN AVE Cleveland 44112 University 6 9 118800 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $0 7-Dec-18 121-04-032 2055 FAIRVIEW AVE Cleveland 44106 University 6 9 141100 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 11-Dec-18 899361 121-04-033 2057 FAIRVIEW AVE Cleveland 44106 University 6 9 141100 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 11-Dec-18 899361 121-04-841C 2043 RANDOM RD Cleveland 44106 University 6 9 118800 Residential condominiums Condo AFF $0 5-Dec-18 121-04-844C 2043 RANDOM RD Cleveland 44106 University 6 9 118800 Residential condominiums Condo WAR $300,000 31-Dec-18 121-05-057 2127 PRIOR CT Cleveland 44106 University 6 9 118800 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $0 21-Dec-18 121-14-320 11430 CEDAR GLEN PKWAY Cleveland 44106 University 6 6 119202 Residential condominiums Condo WAR $80,000 28-Dec-18 102-37-060 1737 E 33 ST Cleveland 44114 Goodrich-Kirtland Pk 7 8 108301 Two family dwelling Two-Family SHF $0 4-Dec-18 102-37-303 3608 PAYNE AVE Cleveland 44114 Goodrich-Kirtland Pk 7 8 108301 Residential condominiums Condo SUR $167,800 21-Dec-18 104-25-071 1607 E 47 ST Cleveland 44103 Goodrich-Kirtland Pk 7 8 108400 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 7-Dec-18 104-17-016 6306 DIBBLE AVE Cleveland 44103 Hough 7 7 112100 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $31,000 13-Dec-18 104-18-015 5603 LEXINGTON AVE Cleveland 44103 Hough 7 7 112301 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $6,667 12-Dec-18 104-18-095 5700 WHITE AVE Cleveland 44103 Hough 7 7 112301 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $129,900 31-Dec-18 104-21-069 6302 UTICA AVE Cleveland 44103 Hough 7 7 112301 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $0 28-Dec-18 106-04-108 7503 REDELL AVE Cleveland 44103 Hough 7 7 112100 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $9,700 EMV 4-Dec-18 106-07-009 1426 E 85 ST Cleveland 44106 Hough 7 7 112200 Single family dwelling Single-Family AFF $0 19-Dec-18 106-07-009 1426 E 85 ST Cleveland 44106 Hough 7 7 112200 Single family dwelling Single-Family PCT $0 19-Dec-18 106-07-009 1426 E 85 ST Cleveland 44106 Hough 7 7 112200 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 19-Dec-18 106-07-009 1426 E 85 ST Cleveland 44106 Hough 7 7 112200 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 19-Dec-18 106-07-068 1413 E 81 ST Cleveland 44103 Hough 7 7 112200 Apartments 1-6 units Apartments SHF $0 21-Dec-18 106-08-085 6806 ZOETER AVE Cleveland 44103 Hough 7 7 112400 Two family dwelling Two-Family PCT $0 10-Dec-18 106-09-055 1386 ZOETER ST Cleveland 44103 Hough 7 7 112400 Residential vacant land Land PCT $0 10-Dec-18 106-09-056 6812 ZOETER AVE Cleveland 44103 Hough 7 7 112400 Residential vacant land Land PCT $0 10-Dec-18 106-09-057 6816 ZOETER AVE Cleveland 44103 Hough 7 7 112400 Apartments 1-6 units Apartments PCT $0 10-Dec-18 106-09-061 ZOETER AVE Cleveland 44103 Hough 7 7 112400 Residential vacant land Land PCT $0 10-Dec-18 106-10-141 1471 E 71 ST Cleveland 44103 Hough 7 7 112400 Two family dwelling Two-Family JUD $0 6-Dec-18 106-21-140 8109 WHITETHORN AVE Cleveland 44103 Hough 7 7 112500 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $19,900 EMV 13-Dec-18 106-23-163 LINWOOD AVE Cleveland 44103 Hough 7 7 112500 Residential vacant land Land SHF $0 21-Dec-18 107-13-191 1408 E 95 ST Cleveland 44106 Hough 7 7 118602 Single family dwelling Single-Family LIM $0 7-Dec-18 Page 10 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Statistical 2010 Orig. Final Parcel Parcel Parcel Parcel Planning 2014 2009 Census Land Land Deed Conveyance Conveyance Transfer Receipt Number Address Municipality Zip Area Ward Ward Tract Use Type Use Type Type Price Flag Date Number 107-14-075 1338 E 88 ST Cleveland 44106 Hough 7 7 112200 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $22,400 EMV 12-Dec-18 107-15-076 1432 E 86 ST Cleveland 44106 Hough 7 7 112200 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $0 4-Dec-18 107-20-035 1611 HOLYROOD AVE Cleveland 44106 Hough 7 7 112600 Three family dwelling Three-Family WAR $30,000 11-Dec-18 107-21-018 1587 E 93 ST Cleveland 44106 Hough 7 7 118602 Two family dwelling Two-Family SHF $0 12-Dec-18 118-07-032 E 69 ST Cleveland 44103 Hough 7 7 112800 Residential vacant land Land PCT $0 19-Dec-18 118-07-033 E 69 ST Cleveland 44103 Hough 7 7 112800 Residential vacant land Land PCT $0 19-Dec-18 118-07-034 E 69 ST Cleveland 44103 Hough 7 7 112800 Residential vacant land Land PCT $0 19-Dec-18 118-07-035 1915 E 69 ST Cleveland 44103 Hough 7 7 112800 Two family dwelling Two-Family PCT $0 19-Dec-18 118-07-036 E 69 ST Cleveland 44103 Hough 7 7 112800 Residential vacant land Land PCT $0 19-Dec-18 118-07-037 1925 E 69 ST Cleveland 44103 Hough 7 7 112800 Residential vacant land Land PCT $0 19-Dec-18 118-07-114 1851 E 70 ST Cleveland 44103 Hough 7 7 112800 Residential vacant land Land WAR $0 31-Dec-18 119-01-040 1804 E 81 ST Cleveland 44103 Hough 7 7 112800 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 19-Dec-18 104-13-021 1172 NORWOOD RD Cleveland 44103 St.Clair-Superior 7 7 111500 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $19,000 11-Dec-18 104-15-081 1256 NORWOOD RD Cleveland 44103 St.Clair-Superior 7 7 111500 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $17,946 28-Dec-18 104-15-105 1224 E 61 ST Cleveland 44103 St.Clair-Superior 7 7 111500 Single family dwelling Single-Family PCT $0 10-Dec-18 105-21-052 1139 NORWOOD RD Cleveland 44103 St.Clair-Superior 7 7 111500 Three family dwelling Three-Family SHF $0 12-Dec-18 105-22-049 6807 BAYLISS AVE Cleveland 44103 St.Clair-Superior 7 7 111600 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $15,750 28-Dec-18 105-23-008 1172 ADDISON RD Cleveland 44103 St.Clair-Superior 7 7 111500 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $5,000 10-Dec-18 105-23-020 1248 ADDISON RD Cleveland 44103 St.Clair-Superior 7 7 111600 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $13,000 21-Dec-18 105-23-028 1247 ADDISON RD Cleveland 44103 St.Clair-Superior 7 7 111600 Two family dwelling Two-Family FID $0 10-Dec-18 105-24-105 1082 E 66 ST Cleveland 44103 St.Clair-Superior 7 7 111600 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $12,000 14-Dec-18 105-25-046 1100 E 68 ST Cleveland 44103 St.Clair-Superior 7 7 111600 Three family dwelling Three-Family QTC $45,100 EMV 11-Dec-18 105-25-059 1137 E 66 ST Cleveland 44103 St.Clair-Superior 7 7 111600 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $7,500 21-Dec-18 111-22-122 13616 RUGBY RD Cleveland 44110 Collinwood-Nottingham 8 10 117300 Three family dwelling Three-Family WAR $54,900 31-Dec-18 112-24-166 14505 DARWIN AVE Cleveland 44110 Collinwood-Nottingham 8 10 117102 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $39,000 21-Dec-18 115-24-030 15916 WHITCOMB RD Cleveland 44110 Collinwood-Nottingham 8 11 117400 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $16,000 14-Dec-18 115-24-059 805 E 156 ST Cleveland 44110 Collinwood-Nottingham 8 11 117400 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $27,100 7-Dec-18 115-26-089 818 RUDYARD RD Cleveland 44110 Collinwood-Nottingham 8 11 117500 Two family dwelling Two-Family PCT $0 21-Dec-18 115-26-145 813 ALHAMBRA RD Cleveland 44110 Collinwood-Nottingham 8 11 117500 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $30,000 6-Dec-18 115-26-165 816 LONDON RD Cleveland 44110 Collinwood-Nottingham 8 11 117500 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $39,900 4-Dec-18 115-30-063 925 NATHANIEL RD Cleveland 44110 Collinwood-Nottingham 8 11 117500 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $57,900 26-Dec-18 901424 115-31-034 976 NATHANIEL RD Cleveland 44110 Collinwood-Nottingham 8 11 117500 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $20,000 4-Dec-18 116-20-037 834 WAYSIDE RD Cleveland 44110 Collinwood-Nottingham 8 11 117500 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $58,000 17-Dec-18 900283 116-20-097 BRADDOCK AVE Cleveland 44110 Collinwood-Nottingham 8 11 117500 Residential vacant land Land WAR $58,000 17-Dec-18 900283 116-22-031 16512 BURNSIDE AVE Cleveland 44110 Collinwood-Nottingham 8 11 117500 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $46,000 26-Dec-18 111-11-141 523 E 124 ST Cleveland 44108 Glenville 8 10 116700 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 7-Dec-18 112-12-043 249 E 151 ST Cleveland 44110 North Shore Collinwood 8 11 117101 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 13-Dec-18 112-13-060 382 E 152 ST Cleveland 44110 North Shore Collinwood 8 10 117101 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $20,500 EMV 3-Dec-18 112-14-027 19 LAKESIDE BLVD Cleveland 44110 North Shore Collinwood 8 11 117201 Two family dwelling Two-Family AFF $0 19-Dec-18 900579 112-17-044 372 E 156 ST Cleveland 44110 North Shore Collinwood 8 11 117202 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 7-Dec-18 112-21-006 457 E 146 ST Cleveland 44110 North Shore Collinwood 8 10 117101 Two family dwelling Two-Family PRV $0 3-Dec-18 112-22-041 15001 UPTON AVE Cleveland 44110 North Shore Collinwood 8 10 117101 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $0 21-Dec-18 113-06-033 17918 BRAZIL RD Cleveland 44119 North Shore Collinwood 8 11 117600 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $0 5-Dec-18 113-08-040 18323 MARCELLA RD Cleveland 44119 North Shore Collinwood 8 11 117600 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $29,000 4-Dec-18 Page 11 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Statistical 2010 Orig. Final Parcel Parcel Parcel Parcel Planning 2014 2009 Census Land Land Deed Conveyance Conveyance Transfer Receipt Number Address Municipality Zip Area Ward Ward Tract Use Type Use Type Type Price Flag Date Number 113-15-089 15907 HUNTMERE AVE Cleveland 44110 North Shore Collinwood 8 11 117202 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 14-Dec-18 113-16-056 360 E 161 ST Cleveland 44110 North Shore Collinwood 8 11 117202 Single family dwelling Single-Family PCT $0 3-Dec-18 113-19-090 16118 PARKGROVE AVE Cleveland 44110 North Shore Collinwood 8 11 117202 Single family dwelling Single-Family LIM $124,900 3-Dec-18 113-20-030 395 E 161 ST Cleveland 44110 North Shore Collinwood 8 11 117202 Single family dwelling Single-Family REF $0 21-Dec-18 113-21-013 1028 E 169 ST Cleveland 44110 North Shore Collinwood 8 11 117201 Single family dwelling Single-Family VSD $0 4-Dec-18 113-21-080 1070 E 168 ST Cleveland 44110 North Shore Collinwood 8 11 117201 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $95,000 17-Dec-18 900334 113-22-014 1109 E 169 ST Cleveland 44110 North Shore Collinwood 8 11 117600 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 20-Dec-18 113-22-105 1152 E 168 ST Cleveland 44110 North Shore Collinwood 8 11 117600 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $24,600 19-Dec-18 113-24-123 1267 E 170 ST Cleveland 44110 North Shore Collinwood 8 11 117600 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $44,100 13-Dec-18 113-25-051 1059 E 174 ST Cleveland 44119 North Shore Collinwood 8 11 117600 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $43,500 21-Dec-18 113-26-024 1140 E 176 ST Cleveland 44119 North Shore Collinwood 8 11 117600 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $32,000 21-Dec-18 113-26-030 17503 GROVEWOOD AVE Cleveland 44119 North Shore Collinwood 8 11 117600 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $60,800 18-Dec-18 114-05-008 18316 EAST PARK DR Cleveland 44119 North Shore Collinwood 8 11 117700 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $47,500 3-Dec-18 114-06-005 17824 LANDSEER RD Cleveland 44119 North Shore Collinwood 8 11 117700 Single family dwelling Single-Family AFF $0 12-Dec-18 114-06-034 17709 INGLESIDE RD Cleveland 44119 North Shore Collinwood 8 11 117700 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $52,500 EMV 3-Dec-18 114-06-047 17618 INGLESIDE RD Cleveland 44119 North Shore Collinwood 8 11 117700 Single family dwelling Single-Family PCT $0 31-Dec-18 114-06-047 17618 INGLESIDE RD Cleveland 44119 North Shore Collinwood 8 11 117700 Single family dwelling Single-Family PCT $0 31-Dec-18 114-08-078 18101 SCHENELY AVE Cleveland 44119 North Shore Collinwood 8 11 117700 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $47,500 17-Dec-18 114-16-005 18905 PAWNEE AVE Cleveland 44119 North Shore Collinwood 8 11 117700 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $49,900 28-Dec-18 114-16-064 18811 MUSKOKA AVE Cleveland 44119 North Shore Collinwood 8 11 117700 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $64,500 28-Dec-18 114-17-072 19403 MUSKOKA AVE Cleveland 44119 North Shore Collinwood 8 11 117700 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $25,200 3-Dec-18 114-17-072 19403 MUSKOKA AVE Cleveland 44119 North Shore Collinwood 8 11 117700 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $37,200 3-Dec-18 114-21-088 19407 SHAWNEE AVE Cleveland 44119 North Shore Collinwood 8 11 117700 Single family dwelling Single-Family PRV $88,920 19-Dec-18 108-18-032 8919 EMPIRE AVE Cleveland 44108 Glenville 9 8 116400 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $46,700 EMV 28-Dec-18 108-21-029 9707 YALE AVE Cleveland 44108 Glenville 9 8 116400 Single family dwelling Single-Family PCT $0 18-Dec-18 108-21-032 9605 YALE AVE Cleveland 44108 Glenville 9 8 116400 Single family dwelling Single-Family PCT $0 3-Dec-18 108-21-112 10004 EMPIRE AVE Cleveland 44108 Glenville 9 8 116400 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 11-Dec-18 108-21-125 9901 PARMELEE AVE Cleveland 44108 Glenville 9 8 116400 Single family dwelling Single-Family JUD $0 13-Dec-18 108-22-008 10214 GARFIELD AVE Cleveland 44108 Glenville 9 8 116400 Single family dwelling Single-Family JOU $0 21-Dec-18 108-25-012 668 E 106 ST Cleveland 44108 Glenville 9 8 116500 Apartments 1-6 units Apartments WAR $70,000 31-Dec-18 108-25-028 754 PARKWOOD DR Cleveland 44108 Glenville 9 8 116500 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $0 7-Dec-18 108-25-037 10629 KIMBERLY AVE Cleveland 44108 Glenville 9 8 116500 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 6-Dec-18 108-25-037 10629 KIMBERLY AVE Cleveland 44108 Glenville 9 8 116500 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 6-Dec-18 108-25-037 10629 KIMBERLY AVE Cleveland 44108 Glenville 9 8 116500 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 6-Dec-18 108-25-037 10629 KIMBERLY AVE Cleveland 44108 Glenville 9 8 116500 Single family dwelling Single-Family PCT $0 6-Dec-18 108-26-133 10612 EVERTON AVE Cleveland 44108 Glenville 9 8 116500 Single family dwelling Single-Family JOU $0 21-Dec-18 108-29-060 735 PARKWOOD DR Cleveland 44108 Glenville 9 9 116500 Single family dwelling Single-Family JOU $0 21-Dec-18 109-02-004 9106 PARMALEE AVE Cleveland 44108 Glenville 9 8 116400 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $34,500 12-Dec-18 109-04-096 10110 ADAMS AVE Cleveland 44108 Glenville 9 8 116400 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $58,000 10-Dec-18 109-07-012 9805 SOUTH BLVD Cleveland 44108 Glenville 9 8 118101 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $305,000 13-Dec-18 109-08-083 10023 NORTH BLVD Cleveland 44108 Glenville 9 8 118101 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $52,900 13-Dec-18 109-09-192 10117 SOMERSET AVE Cleveland 44108 Glenville 9 8 118101 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $14,355 14-Dec-18 109-10-032 10001 HAMPDEN AVE Cleveland 44108 Glenville 9 8 118101 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $38,499 7-Dec-18 109-12-020 10615 AMOR AVE Cleveland 44108 Glenville 9 8 116500 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $8,000 EMV 21-Dec-18 Page 12 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Statistical 2010 Orig. Final Parcel Parcel Parcel Parcel Planning 2014 2009 Census Land Land Deed Conveyance Conveyance Transfer Receipt Number Address Municipality Zip Area Ward Ward Tract Use Type Use Type Type Price Flag Date Number 109-12-023 10627 AMOR AVE Cleveland 44108 Glenville 9 8 116500 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $6,500 26-Dec-18 109-13-035 10805 AMOR AVE Cleveland 44108 Glenville 9 8 116500 Single family dwelling Single-Family AFF $0 31-Dec-18 109-13-035 10805 AMOR AVE Cleveland 44108 Glenville 9 8 116500 Single family dwelling Single-Family PCT $0 31-Dec-18 109-13-061 10809 GREENLAWN AVE Cleveland 44108 Glenville 9 8 116500 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $19,700 EMV 20-Dec-18 109-13-076 10808 COLUMBIA AVE Cleveland 44108 Glenville 9 8 116500 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $30,200 EMV 6-Dec-18 109-15-068 10939 PASADENA AVE Cleveland 44108 Glenville 9 8 118200 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $7,500 26-Dec-18 109-17-032 10839 GRANTWOOD AVE Cleveland 44108 Glenville 9 8 118200 Two family dwelling Two-Family PCT $0 3-Dec-18 109-18-051 10600 HATHAWAY AVE Cleveland 44108 Glenville 9 8 118200 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $0 12-Dec-18 109-18-081 10720 OLIVET AVE Cleveland 44108 Glenville 9 8 118200 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $0 12-Dec-18 109-18-103 10521 OLIVET AVE Cleveland 44108 Glenville 9 8 118200 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 19-Dec-18 109-20-075 11109 GREENVIEW AVE Cleveland 44108 Glenville 9 9 116500 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $59,000 10-Dec-18 109-20-092 11111 BERKSHIRE AVE Cleveland 44108 Glenville 9 9 116500 Three family dwelling Three-Family QTC $0 24-Dec-18 109-23-059 1218 E 113 ST Cleveland 44108 Glenville 9 9 118200 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $18,300 EMV 17-Dec-18 110-22-128 944 E 123 ST Cleveland 44108 Glenville 9 9 116600 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $98,500 13-Dec-18 899920 110-22-133 918 E 123 ST Cleveland 44108 Glenville 9 9 116600 Apartments 7-19 units (walk-up) Apartments WAR $20,000 11-Dec-18 110-25-048 11805 CASTLEWOOD AVE Cleveland 44108 Glenville 9 9 118400 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $0 21-Dec-18 110-26-023 12001 OSCEOLA AVE Cleveland 44108 Glenville 9 9 118400 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 10-Dec-18 110-27-108 12405 CHESTERFIELD AVE Cleveland 44108 Glenville 9 9 118400 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 11-Dec-18 120-03-093 1325 E 111 ST Cleveland 44106 Glenville 9 9 118301 Two family dwelling Two-Family SHF $0 21-Dec-18 120-03-114 1372 E 111 ST Cleveland 44106 Glenville 9 9 118301 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $37,900 31-Dec-18 120-04-041 11710 BEULAH AVE Cleveland 44106 Glenville 9 9 118500 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $18,500 18-Dec-18 120-07-077 1453 E 109 ST Cleveland 44106 Glenville 9 9 118301 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 5-Dec-18 120-08-041 1448 E 112 ST Cleveland 44106 Glenville 9 9 118301 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $40,200 27-Dec-18 120-09-088 11215 ITASCA AVE Cleveland 44106 Glenville 9 9 118301 Two family dwelling Two-Family AFF $0 14-Dec-18 120-09-088 11215 ITASCA AVE Cleveland 44106 Glenville 9 9 118301 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 14-Dec-18 120-09-093 11309 ITASCA AVE Cleveland 44106 Glenville 9 9 118301 Residential vacant land Land SHF $0 6-Dec-18 120-11-010 1447 E 120 ST Cleveland 44106 Glenville 9 9 118500 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $0 27-Dec-18 120-13-072 1385 E 124 ST Cleveland 44106 Glenville 9 9 118500 Single family dwelling Single-Family LIM $36,000 12-Dec-18 120-22-086 1545 E 118 ST Cleveland 44106 Glenville 9 9 118700 Two family dwelling Two-Family FID $55,000 20-Dec-18 107-03-114 979 E 79 ST Cleveland 44103 St.Clair-Superior 9 8 111202 Two family dwelling Two-Family FID $0 10-Dec-18 120-20-024 11100 WADE PARK AVE Cleveland 44106 University 9 8 118700 Two family dwelling Two-Family SUR $225,000 21-Dec-18 111-22-094 13706 EARLWOOD RD Cleveland 44110 Collinwood-Nottingham 10 10 117300 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $9,300 EMV 28-Dec-18 111-27-017 13909 WOODWORTH AVE Cleveland 44112 Collinwood-Nottingham 10 10 116900 Single family dwelling Single-Family PCT $0 31-Dec-18 111-27-092 13814 CASTALIA AVE Cleveland 44110 Collinwood-Nottingham 10 10 116900 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $2,000 11-Dec-18 115-08-029 14809 PEPPER AVE Cleveland 44110 Collinwood-Nottingham 10 10 117300 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $7,250 31-Dec-18 115-08-029 14809 PEPPER AVE Cleveland 44110 Collinwood-Nottingham 10 10 117300 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $29,900 31-Dec-18 115-09-066 14808 PEPPER AVE Cleveland 44110 Collinwood-Nottingham 10 10 117300 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $45,000 4-Dec-18 115-13-030 1057 E 148 ST Cleveland 44110 Collinwood-Nottingham 10 10 116900 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $0 21-Dec-18 115-13-108 1061 E 146 ST Cleveland 44110 Collinwood-Nottingham 10 10 116900 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $24,300 EMV 18-Dec-18 115-13-108 1061 E 146 ST Cleveland 44110 Collinwood-Nottingham 10 10 116900 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $16,000 28-Dec-18 115-13-114 1037 E 146 ST Cleveland 44110 Collinwood-Nottingham 10 10 116900 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $29,200 EMV 13-Dec-18 115-14-015 14637 COIT RD Cleveland 44110 Collinwood-Nottingham 10 10 116900 Apartments 1-6 units Apartments SUR $70,000 14-Dec-18 116-15-032 1341 E 170 ST Cleveland 44110 Collinwood-Nottingham 10 11 117800 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 18-Dec-18 116-25-083 1445 E 172 ST Cleveland 44110 Collinwood-Nottingham 10 11 117800 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $31,800 EMV 21-Dec-18 Page 13 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Statistical 2010 Orig. Final Parcel Parcel Parcel Parcel Planning 2014 2009 Census Land Land Deed Conveyance Conveyance Transfer Receipt Number Address Municipality Zip Area Ward Ward Tract Use Type Use Type Type Price Flag Date Number 116-26-045 1473 E 175 ST Cleveland 44110 Collinwood-Nottingham 10 11 117800 Single family dwelling Single-Family AFF $0 19-Dec-18 900575 116-26-046 1469 E 175 ST Cleveland 44110 Collinwood-Nottingham 10 11 117800 Residential vacant land Land AFF $0 19-Dec-18 900575 116-26-057 1425 E 175 ST Cleveland 44110 Collinwood-Nottingham 10 11 117800 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $24,000 4-Dec-18 116-27-007 1522 E 172 ST Cleveland 44110 Collinwood-Nottingham 10 11 117800 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 21-Dec-18 116-27-013 1546 E 172 ST Cleveland 44110 Collinwood-Nottingham 10 11 117800 Two family dwelling Two-Family DEE $16,667 3-Dec-18 116-29-071 1395 CLEARAIRE RD Cleveland 44110 Collinwood-Nottingham 10 11 117800 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $10,990 4-Dec-18 116-29-160 1422 LARCHMONT RD Cleveland 44110 Collinwood-Nottingham 10 11 117800 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $0 18-Dec-18 116-30-018 1530 LARCHMONT RD Cleveland 44110 Collinwood-Nottingham 10 11 117800 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $12,000 26-Dec-18 116-31-068 1284 E 187 ST Cleveland 44110 Collinwood-Nottingham 10 11 117800 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $0 12-Dec-18 117-08-035 1665 HILLVIEW RD Cleveland 44112 Euclid-Green 10 10 117900 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $5,800 13-Dec-18 117-08-100 17901 OLYMPIA RD Cleveland 44112 Euclid-Green 10 10 117900 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $14,000 24-Dec-18 117-08-154 1646 AVALON RD Cleveland 44112 Euclid-Green 10 10 117900 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $30,100 EMV 31-Dec-18 117-09-009 1751 AVALON RD Cleveland 44112 Euclid-Green 10 10 117900 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $32,300 EMV 26-Dec-18 117-09-032 1725 CLIFFVIEW RD Cleveland 44112 Euclid-Green 10 10 117900 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $0 6-Dec-18 117-11-021 1732 CATALPA RD Cleveland 44112 Euclid-Green 10 10 117900 Three family dwelling Three-Family PRV $39,500 13-Dec-18 117-13-083 1853 MANNERING RD Cleveland 44112 Euclid-Green 10 10 117900 Three family dwelling Three-Family WAR $59,900 10-Dec-18 117-14-035 16704 HILLSBORO RD Cleveland 44112 Euclid-Green 10 10 117900 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $0 18-Dec-18 117-14-042 1954 WESTBURN RD Cleveland 44112 Euclid-Green 10 10 117900 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $19,900 EMV 28-Dec-18 117-23-028 1993 ROOKWOOD RD Cleveland 44112 Euclid-Green 10 10 126100 Single family dwelling Single-Family LIM $23,000 27-Dec-18 117-23-050 2171 BELVOIR BLVD Cleveland 44121 Euclid-Green 10 10 126100 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $46,100 EMV* 31-Dec-18 117-24-008 RUNNYMEDE BLVD Cleveland 44121 Euclid-Green 10 10 126100 Residential vacant land Land SHF $80,000 12-Dec-18 899564 117-25-012 1849 TORBENSON DR Cleveland 44112 Euclid-Green 10 10 126100 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 27-Dec-18 108-02-032 696 E 93 ST Cleveland 44108 Glenville 10 8 111401 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $15,500 EMV 3-Dec-18 108-02-108 672 E 91 ST Cleveland 44108 Glenville 10 8 111401 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $20,000 19-Dec-18 108-05-085 602 E 99 ST Cleveland 44108 Glenville 10 8 111401 Three family dwelling Three-Family QTC $27,500 17-Dec-18 108-07-087 700 E 96 ST Cleveland 44108 Glenville 10 8 111401 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 27-Dec-18 108-07-094 682 E 96 ST Cleveland 44108 Glenville 10 8 111401 Single family dwelling Single-Family PCT $0 27-Dec-18 108-07-139 714 E 95 ST Cleveland 44108 Glenville 10 8 111401 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $6,700 EMV 3-Dec-18 108-08-104 542 E 102 ST Cleveland 44108 Glenville 10 8 116100 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $5,000 12-Dec-18 108-10-025 565 E 102 ST Cleveland 44108 Glenville 10 8 116100 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $56,000 27-Dec-18 108-13-059 10638 DUPONT AVE Cleveland 44108 Glenville 10 9 116200 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $12,750 3-Dec-18 108-14-018 568 E 110 ST Cleveland 44108 Glenville 10 9 116200 Two family dwelling Two-Family SHF $0 21-Dec-18 110-06-056 660 E 126 ST Cleveland 44108 Glenville 10 10 116800 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $12,100 EMV 18-Dec-18 110-09-029 664 E 131 ST Cleveland 44108 Glenville 10 10 116800 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $10,000 18-Dec-18 110-09-095 12911 BRACKLAND AVE Cleveland 44108 Glenville 10 10 116800 Apartments 1-6 units Apartments QTC $75,000 EMV 20-Dec-18 110-09-105 13004 AUSTIN AVE Cleveland 44108 Glenville 10 10 116800 Two family dwelling Two-Family LIM $1,500 31-Dec-18 110-12-013 977 THORNHILL DR Cleveland 44108 Glenville 10 10 116600 Two family dwelling Two-Family JOU $0 21-Dec-18 110-12-045 914 EDDY RD Cleveland 44108 Glenville 10 10 116600 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $24,528 14-Dec-18 110-12-064 1003 EDDY RD Cleveland 44108 Glenville 10 10 116800 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $1,504 28-Dec-18 110-14-101 12617 EDMONTON AVE Cleveland 44108 Glenville 10 10 116800 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $47,900 13-Dec-18 110-15-003 751 E 128 ST Cleveland 44108 Glenville 10 10 116800 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $14,400 4-Dec-18 110-15-125 12806 EDMONTON AVE Cleveland 44108 Glenville 10 10 116800 Two family dwelling Two-Family SHF $0 12-Dec-18 110-16-009 911 PAXTON RD Cleveland 44108 Glenville 10 10 116800 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $0 7-Dec-18 110-16-042 12725 BARRINGTON AVE Cleveland 44108 Glenville 10 10 116800 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $0 5-Dec-18 Page 14 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Statistical 2010 Orig. Final Parcel Parcel Parcel Parcel Planning 2014 2009 Census Land Land Deed Conveyance Conveyance Transfer Receipt Number Address Municipality Zip Area Ward Ward Tract Use Type Use Type Type Price Flag Date Number 110-16-056 12635 IRVINGTON AVE Cleveland 44108 Glenville 10 10 116800 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $6,200 26-Dec-18 110-17-102 998 E 130 ST Cleveland 44108 Glenville 10 10 151800 Three family dwelling Three-Family SHF $18,000 12-Dec-18 111-02-039 507 E 112 ST Cleveland 44108 Glenville 10 9 116300 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $26,000 28-Dec-18 111-03-038 412 E 115 ST Cleveland 44108 Glenville 10 9 116300 Residential vacant land Land COR $0 19-Dec-18 900697 111-03-040 420 E 115 ST Cleveland 44108 Glenville 10 9 116300 Two family dwelling Two-Family COR $0 19-Dec-18 900697 111-05-068 491 E 118 ST Cleveland 44108 Glenville 10 10 116300 Single family dwelling Single-Family FID $20,000 14-Dec-18 111-05-111 519 E 117 ST Cleveland 44108 Glenville 10 9 116300 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $5,000 7-Dec-18 111-05-167 571 E 115 ST Cleveland 44108 Glenville 10 9 116300 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $50,000 14-Dec-18 111-07-063 11405 ABLEWHITE AVE Cleveland 44108 Glenville 10 9 116300 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $34,000 10-Dec-18 111-07-064 11409 ABLEWHITE AVE Cleveland 44108 Glenville 10 9 116300 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $27,500 10-Dec-18 111-07-075 11707 ABLEWHITE AVE Cleveland 44108 Glenville 10 9 116300 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $16,500 17-Dec-18 111-07-106 11604 ABLEWHITE AVE Cleveland 44108 Glenville 10 9 116300 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $10,000 4-Dec-18 111-11-054 548 E 128 ST Cleveland 44108 Glenville 10 10 116800 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 13-Dec-18 111-12-068 483 E 128 ST Cleveland 44108 Glenville 10 10 116700 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $52,900 4-Dec-18 111-16-053 456 CLEVELAND RD Cleveland 44108 Glenville 10 10 116700 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $36,900 11-Dec-18 111-16-056 12805 LOCKE AVE Cleveland 44108 Glenville 10 10 116700 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $25,200 EMV 6-Dec-18 111-16-105 12808 GRUSS AVE Cleveland 44108 Glenville 10 10 116700 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $6,500 26-Dec-18 104-07-025 1408 E 43 ST Cleveland 44103 Goodrich-Kirtland Pk 10 8 108201 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $50,000 18-Dec-18 104-09-027 1429 E 47 ST Cleveland 44103 Goodrich-Kirtland Pk 10 8 108201 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $0 21-Dec-18 105-12-049 1024 E 66 ST Cleveland 44103 St.Clair-Superior 10 7 111202 Two family dwelling Two-Family SHF $0 12-Dec-18 105-16-030 898 E 75 ST Cleveland 44103 St.Clair-Superior 10 7 111202 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 12-Dec-18 105-27-100 1043 E 71 ST Cleveland 44103 St.Clair-Superior 10 7 111700 Apartments 1-6 units Apartments VSD $0 21-Dec-18 105-27-125 1029 E 72 ST Cleveland 44103 St.Clair-Superior 10 7 111700 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $29,900 13-Dec-18 105-32-077 1120 E 76 ST Cleveland 44103 St.Clair-Superior 10 7 111700 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $0 4-Dec-18 019-13-071 12718 EMERY AVE Cleveland 44135 Bellaire-Puritas 11 17 196400 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $67,000 14-Dec-18 019-14-058 12406 EMERY AVE Cleveland 44135 Bellaire-Puritas 11 17 196400 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 11-Dec-18 019-15-116 12201 EMERY AVE Cleveland 44135 Bellaire-Puritas 11 17 196400 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $31,000 28-Dec-18 019-16-102 12714 MATHERSON AVE Cleveland 44135 Bellaire-Puritas 11 17 196400 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $25,500 7-Dec-18 019-16-119 12813 MATHERSON AVE Cleveland 44135 Bellaire-Puritas 11 17 196400 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 11-Dec-18 019-17-046 12308 MATHERSON AVE Cleveland 44135 Bellaire-Puritas 11 17 196400 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 11-Dec-18 019-18-051 11805 GUARDIAN BLVD Cleveland 44135 Bellaire-Puritas 11 17 196400 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $82,000 19-Dec-18 019-18-055 11705 GUARDIAN BLVD Cleveland 44135 Bellaire-Puritas 11 17 196400 Single family dwelling Single-Family LIM $25,000 11-Dec-18 019-18-120 12218 LEEILA AVE Cleveland 44135 Bellaire-Puritas 11 17 196400 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $0 26-Dec-18 019-21-074 12608 GRIMSBY AVE Cleveland 44135 Bellaire-Puritas 11 17 196400 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $29,400 EMV 5-Dec-18 019-21-079 12704 GRIMSBY AVE Cleveland 44135 Bellaire-Puritas 11 17 196400 Single family dwelling Single-Family LIM $44,200 EMV 31-Dec-18 019-21-113 12919 FIRSBY AVE Cleveland 44135 Bellaire-Puritas 11 17 196400 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $0 12-Dec-18 019-22-102 12305 WANDA AVE Cleveland 44135 Bellaire-Puritas 11 17 196400 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $0 4-Dec-18 001-13-005 1326 W 95 ST Cleveland 44102 Cudell 11 17 101101 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $75,000 3-Dec-18 001-13-046 1355 WEST BLVD Cleveland 44102 Cudell 11 17 101101 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $150,000 14-Dec-18 005-07-048 3067 W 116 ST Cleveland 44111 Cudell 11 17 101400 Two family dwelling Two-Family PRV $0 11-Dec-18 005-07-081 3057 W 115 ST Cleveland 44111 Cudell 11 17 101400 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 18-Dec-18 005-07-104 3044 W 114 ST Cleveland 44111 Cudell 11 17 101400 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 18-Dec-18 001-10-041 9700 BALTIC RD Cleveland 44102 Edgewater 11 17 101102 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $177,000 21-Dec-18 001-25-064 1411 W 110 ST Cleveland 44102 Edgewater 11 17 101300 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $0 21-Dec-18 901001 Page 15 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Statistical 2010 Orig. Final Parcel Parcel Parcel Parcel Planning 2014 2009 Census Land Land Deed Conveyance Conveyance Transfer Receipt Number Address Municipality Zip Area Ward Ward Tract Use Type Use Type Type Price Flag Date Number 001-25-065 1415 W 110 ST Cleveland 44102 Edgewater 11 17 101300 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $0 21-Dec-18 901001 001-25-066 1419 W 110 ST Cleveland 44102 Edgewater 11 17 101300 Apartments 7-19 units (walk-up) Apartments WAR $0 21-Dec-18 001-25-070 1437 W 110 ST Cleveland 44102 Edgewater 11 17 101300 Residential vacant land Land FID $128,000 21-Dec-18 901232 001-25-071 1441 W 110 ST Cleveland 44102 Edgewater 11 17 101300 Single family dwelling Single-Family FID $128,000 21-Dec-18 901232 018-02-096 3491 W 125 ST Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 11 17 124100 Single family dwelling Single-Family PRV $34,600 13-Dec-18 018-04-070 3477 W 120 ST Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 11 17 124100 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $81,000 10-Dec-18 018-04-138 3482 W 118 ST Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 11 17 124100 Two family dwelling Two-Family SUR $79,400 7-Dec-18 018-04-190 3496 W 117 ST Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 11 17 124100 Two family dwelling Two-Family DIL $0 3-Dec-18 018-05-059 3395 W 118 ST Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 11 17 124100 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $34,500 19-Dec-18 018-18-053 11721 MORTIMER AVE Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 11 17 124100 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $72,000 14-Dec-18 018-18-089 11720 WORTHINGTON AVE Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 11 17 124100 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $72,000 20-Dec-18 018-19-031 3738 W 117 ST Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 11 17 124100 Two family dwelling Two-Family SUR $190,000 27-Dec-18 901632 018-19-032 3732 W 117 ST Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 11 17 124100 Two family dwelling Two-Family SUR $190,000 27-Dec-18 901632 018-19-033 3726 W 117 ST Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 11 17 124100 Two family dwelling Two-Family SUR $190,000 27-Dec-18 901632 018-19-034 3720 W 117 ST Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 11 17 124100 Two family dwelling Two-Family SUR $190,000 27-Dec-18 901632 018-19-035 3714 W 117 ST Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 11 17 124100 Two family dwelling Two-Family SUR $190,000 27-Dec-18 901632 018-19-117 11720 WAYLAND AVE Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 11 17 124100 Single family dwelling Single-Family PCT $0 4-Dec-18 018-21-019 3617-19 W 120 ST Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 11 17 124100 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $45,000 27-Dec-18 018-22-013 12102 BROOKLAWN AVE Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 11 17 196400 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 11-Dec-18 018-22-050 12216 WORTHINGTON AVE Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 11 17 124100 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $55,000 20-Dec-18 018-23-080 12301 MARNE AVE Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 11 17 124100 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $32,300 5-Dec-18 018-25-044 3563 W 122 ST Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 11 17 124100 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $35,000 3-Dec-18 018-25-095 3571 W 123 ST Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 11 17 124100 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $70,500 11-Dec-18 018-25-102 12219 BETHANY AVE Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 11 17 124100 Single family dwelling Single-Family FID $57,000 21-Dec-18 018-25-125 3579 LLOYD RD Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 11 17 124100 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $69,900 12-Dec-18 018-26-033 3813 W 129 ST Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 11 17 124100 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $22,000 28-Dec-18 018-29-048 3587 W 129 ST Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 11 17 124100 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $0 3-Dec-18 018-29-107 3538 W 127 ST Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 11 17 124100 Two family dwelling Two-Family AFF $0 4-Dec-18 019-11-062 12212 SUMMERLAND AVE Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 11 17 196400 Single family dwelling Single-Family PCT $0 26-Dec-18 019-12-045 3889 W 118 ST Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 11 17 196400 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $0 4-Dec-18 019-12-075 11854 SUMMERLAND AVE Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 11 17 196400 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 11-Dec-18 005-09-103 3278 W 116 ST Cleveland 44111 West Boulevard 11 17 101400 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $86,000 5-Dec-18 005-11-051 3234 W 110 ST Cleveland 44111 West Boulevard 11 17 101400 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 21-Dec-18 005-11-127 3177 W 112 ST Cleveland 44111 West Boulevard 11 17 101400 Two family dwelling Two-Family SUR $0 21-Dec-18 005-14-046 3162 W 103 ST Cleveland 44111 West Boulevard 11 17 101603 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 7-Dec-18 005-14-154 3159 W 106 ST Cleveland 44111 West Boulevard 11 17 101400 Three family dwelling Three-Family TRS $50,000 4-Dec-18 005-19-095 3119 WEST BLVD Cleveland 44111 West Boulevard 11 16 101603 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $175,000 18-Dec-18 017-01-061 3204 W 98 ST Cleveland 44102 West Boulevard 11 16 102300 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $0 26-Dec-18 017-02-020 9000 DENISON AVE Cleveland 44102 West Boulevard 11 16 102402 Apartments 1-6 units Apartments WAR $225,000 7-Dec-18 017-03-038 3154 W 90 ST Cleveland 44102 West Boulevard 11 16 102402 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $13,334 21-Dec-18 017-03-081 3171 W 94 ST Cleveland 44102 West Boulevard 11 16 102402 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 5-Dec-18 017-03-087 3151 W 94 ST Cleveland 44102 West Boulevard 11 16 102402 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 17-Dec-18 017-03-103 3178 W 94 ST Cleveland 44102 West Boulevard 11 16 102402 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $40,000 6-Dec-18 017-03-123 3182 W 95 ST Cleveland 44102 West Boulevard 11 16 102300 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 13-Dec-18 899725 Page 16 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Statistical 2010 Orig. Final Parcel Parcel Parcel Parcel Planning 2014 2009 Census Land Land Deed Conveyance Conveyance Transfer Receipt Number Address Municipality Zip Area Ward Ward Tract Use Type Use Type Type Price Flag Date Number 017-09-022 3276 W 100 ST Cleveland 44111 West Boulevard 11 16 102200 Single family dwelling Single-Family PRV $27,939 19-Dec-18 017-10-032 10421 BERNARD AVE Cleveland 44111 West Boulevard 11 17 102200 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $81,000 13-Dec-18 017-10-048 10314 ALMIRA AVE Cleveland 44111 West Boulevard 11 17 102200 Two family dwelling Two-Family FID $89,900 28-Dec-18 017-11-001 10301 JOAN AVE Cleveland 44111 West Boulevard 11 17 102200 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $74,900 7-Dec-18 017-11-011 10302 BERNARD AVE Cleveland 44111 West Boulevard 11 17 102200 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $86,800 13-Dec-18 017-12-055 10313 ADELAIDE AVE Cleveland 44111 West Boulevard 11 16 102200 Two family dwelling Two-Family SHF $0 21-Dec-18 017-13-057 10228 UNITY AVE Cleveland 44111 West Boulevard 11 16 102200 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 20-Dec-18 017-13-105 10110 ADELAIDE AVE Cleveland 44111 West Boulevard 11 16 102200 Single family dwelling Single-Family FID $75,200 13-Dec-18 017-16-052 3602 W 102 ST Cleveland 44111 West Boulevard 11 16 102200 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $0 28-Dec-18 017-16-075 3675 W 103 ST Cleveland 44111 West Boulevard 11 16 102200 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 18-Dec-18 017-16-110 3631 W 104 ST Cleveland 44111 West Boulevard 11 16 102200 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 7-Dec-18 017-18-043 3728 W 103 ST Cleveland 44111 West Boulevard 11 16 102200 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $75,000 12-Dec-18 017-19-017 3272 W 98 ST Cleveland 44102 West Boulevard 11 16 102300 Two family dwelling Two-Family SUR $45,000 6-Dec-18 017-19-109 3223 W 100 ST Cleveland 44111 West Boulevard 11 16 102300 Single family dwelling Single-Family AFF $0 7-Dec-18 017-20-050 3384 W 99 ST Cleveland 44102 West Boulevard 11 16 102300 Single family dwelling Single-Family FID $0 18-Dec-18 017-24-050 3319 W 97 ST Cleveland 44102 West Boulevard 11 16 102300 Two family dwelling Two-Family LIM $28,900 4-Dec-18 017-25-055 3422 W 97 ST Cleveland 44102 West Boulevard 11 16 102300 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $63,500 28-Dec-18 017-28-061 3400 W 94 ST Cleveland 44102 West Boulevard 11 16 102401 Two family dwelling Two-Family SUR $0 5-Dec-18 017-28-112 3476 W 91 ST Cleveland 44102 West Boulevard 11 16 102401 Single family dwelling Single-Family LIM $0 28-Dec-18 017-29-021 3300 W 90 ST Cleveland 44102 West Boulevard 11 16 102401 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 21-Dec-18 017-29-129 3358 W 94 ST Cleveland 44102 West Boulevard 11 16 102402 Two family dwelling Two-Family SUR $0 31-Dec-18 017-31-053 3404 W 88 ST Cleveland 44102 West Boulevard 11 16 102401 Single family dwelling Single-Family LIM $9,000 7-Dec-18 018-06-071 11600 HEADLEY AVE Cleveland 44111 West Boulevard 11 17 102101 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $20,000 4-Dec-18 018-07-043 3336 W 110 ST Cleveland 44111 West Boulevard 11 17 102101 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $42,000 18-Dec-18 018-10-024 10718 FIDELITY AVE Cleveland 44111 West Boulevard 11 17 102101 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $87,900 17-Dec-18 018-10-074 10818 ALMIRA AVE Cleveland 44111 West Boulevard 11 17 102101 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $85,000 7-Dec-18 018-11-031 10903 PARKHURST DR Cleveland 44111 West Boulevard 11 17 102101 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $115,000 28-Dec-18 018-14-004 10809 FLORIAN AVE Cleveland 44111 West Boulevard 11 17 102101 Two family dwelling Two-Family SUR $78,000 24-Dec-18 018-16-010 11013 FORTUNE AVE Cleveland 44111 West Boulevard 11 17 102101 Two family dwelling Two-Family LIM $0 31-Dec-18 018-17-081 10609 DALE AVE Cleveland 44111 West Boulevard 11 17 102102 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $65,000 12-Dec-18 018-17-098 10722 DALE AVE Cleveland 44111 West Boulevard 11 17 102102 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $15,372 21-Dec-18 019-01-036 3746 W 116 ST Cleveland 44111 West Boulevard 11 17 102102 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $0 12-Dec-18 019-02-091 3826 W 116 ST Cleveland 44111 West Boulevard 11 17 102102 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $65,000 28-Dec-18 019-03-027 3608 W 114 ST Cleveland 44111 West Boulevard 11 17 102102 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $87,000 20-Dec-18 019-04-008 BOSWORTH RD Cleveland 44111 West Boulevard 11 17 102102 Residential vacant land Land PCT $0 4-Dec-18 898509 019-04-009 3714 BOSWORTH RD Cleveland 44111 West Boulevard 11 17 102102 Single family dwelling Single-Family PCT $0 4-Dec-18 898509 019-08-066 3849 BOSWORTH RD Cleveland 44111 West Boulevard 11 16 102102 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $24,000 26-Dec-18 131-32-097 3697 E 49 ST Cleveland 44105 Broadway-Slavic Village 12 12 110901 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $54,000 19-Dec-18 131-34-079 3619 E 53 ST Cleveland 44105 Broadway-Slavic Village 12 12 110901 Two family dwelling Two-Family SHF $0 4-Dec-18 131-34-079 3619 E 53 ST Cleveland 44105 Broadway-Slavic Village 12 12 110901 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $25,200 17-Dec-18 131-34-088 3604 E 53 ST Cleveland 44105 Broadway-Slavic Village 12 12 110901 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $3,000 28-Dec-18 131-35-046 3724 E 55 ST Cleveland 44105 Broadway-Slavic Village 12 12 110901 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $27,300 4-Dec-18 898458 131-35-047 3722 E 55 ST Cleveland 44105 Broadway-Slavic Village 12 12 110901 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $27,300 4-Dec-18 898458 131-35-143 3736 E 53 ST Cleveland 44105 Broadway-Slavic Village 12 12 110901 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $100 12-Dec-18 Page 17 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Statistical 2010 Orig. Final Parcel Parcel Parcel Parcel Planning 2014 2009 Census Land Land Deed Conveyance Conveyance Transfer Receipt Number Address Municipality Zip Area Ward Ward Tract Use Type Use Type Type Price Flag Date Number 131-37-082 3677 E 57 ST Cleveland 44105 Broadway-Slavic Village 12 12 115100 Single family dwelling Single-Family LIM $0 3-Dec-18 132-01-040 6007 KENYON AVE Cleveland 44105 Broadway-Slavic Village 12 12 115200 Three family dwelling Three-Family WAR $19,000 21-Dec-18 132-07-033 6811 FLEET AVE Cleveland 44105 Broadway-Slavic Village 12 12 115200 Residential vacant land Land WAR $71,500 14-Dec-18 132-07-107 3693 E 69 ST Cleveland 44105 Broadway-Slavic Village 12 12 115400 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 12-Dec-18 132-08-067 3668 E 65 ST Cleveland 44105 Broadway-Slavic Village 12 12 115200 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $6,000 6-Dec-18 132-10-071 3799 E 53 ST Cleveland 44105 Broadway-Slavic Village 12 12 110901 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $29,200 12-Dec-18 899625 132-12-069 5910 GERTRUDE AVE Cleveland 44105 Broadway-Slavic Village 12 12 115100 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $63,000 3-Dec-18 132-12-118 5907 LANSING AVE Cleveland 44105 Broadway-Slavic Village 12 12 115100 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 31-Dec-18 132-12-129 3875 E 57 ST Cleveland 44105 Broadway-Slavic Village 12 12 115100 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $48,500 14-Dec-18 132-13-003 6106 FLEET AVE Cleveland 44105 Broadway-Slavic Village 12 12 115100 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 31-Dec-18 132-13-131 6110 FLEET AVE Cleveland 44105 Broadway-Slavic Village 12 12 115100 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $3,000 5-Dec-18 132-14-147 6609 LANSING ST Cleveland 44105 Broadway-Slavic Village 12 12 115400 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $0 20-Dec-18 132-21-093 6902 INDIANA AVE Cleveland 44105 Broadway-Slavic Village 12 12 115400 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 18-Dec-18 132-21-093 6902 INDIANA AVE Cleveland 44105 Broadway-Slavic Village 12 12 115400 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 18-Dec-18 132-21-105 7005 INDIANA AVE Cleveland 44105 Broadway-Slavic Village 12 12 115400 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $70,000 18-Dec-18 132-25-165 6926 POLONIA AVE Cleveland 44105 Broadway-Slavic Village 12 12 115700 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 14-Dec-18 133-16-008 7527 OTTAWA RD Cleveland 44105 Broadway-Slavic Village 12 12 115800 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $8,000 27-Dec-18 133-17-036 7722 SPAFFORD PL Cleveland 44105 Broadway-Slavic Village 12 12 115800 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $23,900 EMV 4-Dec-18 133-18-014 3971 E 71 ST Cleveland 44105 Broadway-Slavic Village 12 12 115800 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 11-Dec-18 133-18-026 7420 OTTAWA AVE Cleveland 44105 Broadway-Slavic Village 12 12 115800 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $0 31-Dec-18 133-19-081 7412 WORLEY AVE Cleveland 44105 Broadway-Slavic Village 12 12 115800 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $3,750 21-Dec-18 134-01-037 7204 CLEMENT AVE Cleveland 44105 Broadway-Slavic Village 12 12 115800 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 10-Dec-18 134-01-093 7302 HARVARD AVE Cleveland 44105 Broadway-Slavic Village 12 12 115800 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $29,000 EMV 28-Dec-18 134-03-014 4082 E 78 ST Cleveland 44105 Broadway-Slavic Village 12 12 115800 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $2,000 13-Dec-18 134-05-001 4065 E 79 ST Cleveland 44105 Broadway-Slavic Village 12 12 115800 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $18,300 EMV 4-Dec-18 134-11-089 4332 E 73 ST Cleveland 44105 Broadway-Slavic Village 12 12 115800 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $0 4-Dec-18 134-11-089 4332 E 73 ST Cleveland 44105 Broadway-Slavic Village 12 12 115800 Single family dwelling Single-Family LIM $0 17-Dec-18 008-24-098 2404 FORESTDALE AVE Cleveland 44109 Brooklyn Centre 12 3 105602 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 20-Dec-18 900911 008-24-098 2404 FORESTDALE AVE Cleveland 44109 Brooklyn Centre 12 3 105602 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $250,349 20-Dec-18 900913 008-25-017 1928 FORESTDALE AVE Cleveland 44109 Brooklyn Centre 12 3 105602 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $7,500 EMV 19-Dec-18 008-28-084 3753-55 W 13 ST Cleveland 44109 Brooklyn Centre 12 3 105602 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $29,731 4-Dec-18 009-02-126 3945 W 23 ST Cleveland 44109 Brooklyn Centre 12 3 105602 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 20-Dec-18 900764 009-04-111 3904 W 19 ST Cleveland 44109 Brooklyn Centre 12 3 105602 Two family dwelling Two-Family SHF $19,000 6-Dec-18 009-04-152 1807 DENISON AVE Cleveland 44109 Brooklyn Centre 12 3 105602 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 11-Dec-18 899328 009-05-037 1521 BOTANY AVE Cleveland 44109 Brooklyn Centre 12 3 105602 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $23,450 4-Dec-18 014-02-048 3809 PHILENA AVE Cleveland 44109 Brooklyn Centre 12 14 105400 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $18,000 6-Dec-18 014-03-092 3904 W 34 ST Cleveland 44109 Brooklyn Centre 12 14 105400 Two family dwelling Two-Family WHI $95,000 31-Dec-18 014-03-112 3861 W 34 ST Cleveland 44109 Brooklyn Centre 12 14 105500 Two family dwelling Two-Family SHF $0 12-Dec-18 009-14-008 4233 W 21 ST Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 12 3 105700 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $32,000 31-Dec-18 009-16-006 3995 VALLEY RD Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 12 3 105700 Apartments 1-6 units Apartments WAR $75,000 18-Dec-18 009-16-058 1628 CRESTLINE AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 12 3 105700 Single family dwelling Single-Family AFF $0 21-Dec-18 009-16-058 1628 CRESTLINE AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 12 3 105700 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $42,300 EMV 21-Dec-18 009-16-081 1704 ELSTON AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 12 3 105700 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $25,000 31-Dec-18 902157 009-16-082 ELSTON AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 12 3 105700 Residential vacant land Land WAR $25,000 31-Dec-18 902157 Page 18 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Statistical 2010 Orig. Final Parcel Parcel Parcel Parcel Planning 2014 2009 Census Land Land Deed Conveyance Conveyance Transfer Receipt Number Address Municipality Zip Area Ward Ward Tract Use Type Use Type Type Price Flag Date Number 009-17-169 1521 TARLTON AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 12 3 105700 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 31-Dec-18 009-17-169 1521 TARLTON AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 12 3 105700 Single family dwelling Single-Family LIM $30,000 31-Dec-18 009-18-083 4168 PLYMOUTH RD Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 12 3 105700 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $115,000 28-Dec-18 009-18-089 4202 PLYMOUTH RD Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 12 3 105700 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $0 20-Dec-18 009-19-058 1910 MAYVIEW AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 12 3 105700 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 21-Dec-18 009-19-075 2102 MAYVIEW AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 12 3 105700 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 4-Dec-18 009-19-075 2102 MAYVIEW AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 12 3 105700 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 4-Dec-18 009-22-005 2064 BROADVIEW RD Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 12 3 106900 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $74,000 11-Dec-18 009-26-027 2006 TAMPA AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 12 12 106900 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $40,000 7-Dec-18 009-26-079 2007 TATE AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 12 12 106900 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $82,000 28-Dec-18 009-27-027 4515 BROADALE RD Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 12 12 106900 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $125,000 7-Dec-18 009-27-041 4459 BROADALE RD Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 12 12 106900 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 10-Dec-18 009-28-030 1123 SPRING RD Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 12 12 106900 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $120,000 17-Dec-18 009-28-091 4482 W 14 ST Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 12 12 106900 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $123,000 21-Dec-18 009-28-096 4502 W 14 ST Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 12 12 106900 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $80,000 21-Dec-18 009-30-026 4108 W 11 ST Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 12 3 105700 Single family dwelling Single-Family AFF $0 6-Dec-18 009-33-949C 4225 RIVER RIDGE DR Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 12 12 107000 Residential condominiums Condo SUR $113,000 4-Dec-18 010-03-029 4668 MORNINGSIDE DR Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 12 12 106900 Single family dwelling Single-Family AFF $0 20-Dec-18 010-05-063 4601 HILLAND AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 12 12 106900 Two family dwelling Two-Family AFF $0 13-Dec-18 010-05-063 4601 HILLAND AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 12 12 106900 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 13-Dec-18 010-18-048 4708 MARCIE DR Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 12 12 107000 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $123,000 28-Dec-18 010-29-004 720 WEST SCHAAF RD Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 12 12 107000 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 28-Dec-18 010-04-070 4747 W 20 ST Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106900 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $0 4-Dec-18 010-08-075 1715 MAYNARD AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106900 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $130,000 21-Dec-18 010-08-128 W 16 ST Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106900 Residential vacant land Land COR $0 3-Dec-18 898148 010-08-128 W 16 ST Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106900 Residential vacant land Land FID $157,000 3-Dec-18 898566 010-09-077 4820 W 14 ST Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106900 Single family dwelling Single-Family COR $0 3-Dec-18 898148 010-09-077 4820 W 14 ST Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106900 Single family dwelling Single-Family FID $157,000 3-Dec-18 898566 010-12-062 4926 W 13 ST Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106900 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $130,700 27-Dec-18 010-12-092 4883 W 13 ST Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106900 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $74,000 13-Dec-18 011-02-082 3514 BEHRWALD AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106600 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $73,900 31-Dec-18 011-02-100 4370 STATE RD Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106600 Apartments 7-19 units (walk-up) Apartments WAR $250,000 20-Dec-18 011-03-109 3118 RUBY AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106800 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $58,000 17-Dec-18 011-04-113 2805 NATCHEZ AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106800 Single family dwelling Single-Family PRV $55,000 6-Dec-18 011-05-139 4524 BROADVIEW RD Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106800 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 12-Dec-18 011-06-013 4306 STICKNEY AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106600 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $78,900 7-Dec-18 011-07-088 4591 W 41 ST Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106600 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 28-Dec-18 011-08-022 4500 STATE RD Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106600 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $0 3-Dec-18 011-08-062 3801 SCHILLER AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106600 Single family dwelling Single-Family PRV $0 19-Dec-18 011-08-065 3705 SCHILLER AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106600 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $40,000 7-Dec-18 011-09-052 3306 HILLCREST AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 105900 Single family dwelling Single-Family AFF $0 20-Dec-18 011-09-052 3306 HILLCREST AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 105900 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $95,000 20-Dec-18 011-09-103 3307 SARATOGA AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 105900 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $23,334 18-Dec-18 011-09-103 3307 SARATOGA AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 105900 Single family dwelling Single-Family LIM $43,100 28-Dec-18 Page 19 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Statistical 2010 Orig. Final Parcel Parcel Parcel Parcel Planning 2014 2009 Census Land Land Deed Conveyance Conveyance Transfer Receipt Number Address Municipality Zip Area Ward Ward Tract Use Type Use Type Type Price Flag Date Number 011-11-003 2423 TAMPA AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 105900 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 21-Dec-18 011-11-068 4534 BROADVIEW RD Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 105900 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 12-Dec-18 011-13-045 4405 GERMAINE AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106600 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $40,000 20-Dec-18 011-13-061 4105 GERMAINE AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106600 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $0 4-Dec-18 011-13-156 4322 ARCHMERE AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106600 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $35,000 26-Dec-18 011-16-050 3405 ARCHMERE AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 105900 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $120,000 17-Dec-18 011-16-053 3400 ARCHMERE AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 105900 Single family dwelling Single-Family AFF $0 14-Dec-18 011-18-040 2721 PORTMAN AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 105900 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $56,000 7-Dec-18 011-18-064 2614 OAK PARK AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 105900 Two family dwelling Two-Family SHF $40,500 26-Dec-18 011-19-099 2221 SCHELL AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 105900 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $36,000 6-Dec-18 011-22-009 3132 WALBROOK AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 105900 Single family dwelling Single-Family LIM $0 3-Dec-18 011-24-017 2209 RALPH AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 105900 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $0 24-Dec-18 011-24-017 2209 RALPH AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 105900 Single family dwelling Single-Family LIM $0 24-Dec-18 011-24-059 2213 FAIRDALE AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 105900 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $81,460 14-Dec-18 012-02-082 4419 W 57 ST Cleveland 44144 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106200 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $80,000 14-Dec-18 012-02-108 4472 W 56 ST Cleveland 44144 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106200 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $87,500 5-Dec-18 012-03-090 4437 W 51 ST Cleveland 44144 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106200 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $74,250 21-Dec-18 012-04-043 4464 W 47 ST Cleveland 44144 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106200 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 3-Dec-18 012-04-105 4712 GIFFORD AVE Cleveland 44144 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106200 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $23,000 19-Dec-18 012-05-010 4413 WOBURN AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106400 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $70,000 26-Dec-18 012-05-070 4512 ARDMORE AVE Cleveland 44144 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106400 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $103,500 21-Dec-18 012-06-081 4214 GIFFORD AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106400 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $0 4-Dec-18 012-06-081 4214 GIFFORD AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106400 Single family dwelling Single-Family LIM $0 21-Dec-18 012-09-093 4607 FULTON RD Cleveland 44144 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106500 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $98,000 14-Dec-18 012-15-022 4816 STICKNEY AVE Cleveland 44144 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106500 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $82,000 21-Dec-18 012-21-092 5701 FLOWERDALE AVE Cleveland 44144 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106500 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $0 31-Dec-18 012-25-014 4509 ARCHMERE AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106600 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $0 31-Dec-18 012-25-052 4521 BADER AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106600 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 21-Dec-18 012-25-126 4613 WETZEL AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106600 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 13-Dec-18 012-26-033 4104 BADER AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106600 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $55,000 21-Dec-18 012-26-123 4013 WETZEL AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106600 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $85,000 14-Dec-18 012-27-114 3606 BADER AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106600 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 3-Dec-18 013-11-031 4236 W 63 ST Cleveland 44144 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106100 Single family dwelling Single-Family PCT $0 18-Dec-18 013-12-025 7101 MEADOWBROOK AVE Cleveland 44144 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106100 Single family dwelling Single-Family EXC $89,900 14-Dec-18 013-12-132 6405 BROOKSIDE DR Cleveland 44144 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106100 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $145,000 14-Dec-18 013-12-142 6504 PLAINFIELD AVE Cleveland 44144 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106100 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $164,000 14-Dec-18 013-14-094 4195 W 59 ST Cleveland 44144 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106100 Single family dwelling Single-Family LIM $0 13-Dec-18 013-15-133 6210 DELLBANK DR Cleveland 44144 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106100 Single family dwelling Single-Family AFF $0 18-Dec-18 013-16-060 6100 PARK RIDGE AVE Cleveland 44144 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106100 Single family dwelling Single-Family AFF $0 28-Dec-18 013-16-060 6100 PARK RIDGE AVE Cleveland 44144 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106100 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $93,000 28-Dec-18 013-18-051 4200 W 56 ST Cleveland 44144 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106100 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $125,000 4-Dec-18 013-18-088 4256 W 57 ST Cleveland 44144 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106100 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $90,500 19-Dec-18 013-21-146 4105 W 50 ST Cleveland 44144 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106100 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $50,000 18-Dec-18 013-22-046 4175 W 48 ST Cleveland 44144 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106100 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 18-Dec-18 Page 20 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Statistical 2010 Orig. Final Parcel Parcel Parcel Parcel Planning 2014 2009 Census Land Land Deed Conveyance Conveyance Transfer Receipt Number Address Municipality Zip Area Ward Ward Tract Use Type Use Type Type Price Flag Date Number 013-22-147 4164 W 49 ST Cleveland 44144 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106100 Single family dwelling Single-Family PRV $39,167 3-Dec-18 013-24-055 4353 W 60 ST Cleveland 44144 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106200 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 6-Dec-18 013-26-015 4302 W 52 ST Cleveland 44144 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106200 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $102,000 21-Dec-18 013-27-119 4306 W 50 ST Cleveland 44144 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106200 Single family dwelling Single-Family LIM $0 10-Dec-18 014-07-019 4320 MEMPHIS AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106300 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $20,000 10-Dec-18 014-07-024 4300 MEMPHIS AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106300 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 14-Dec-18 014-08-070 4102 CLYBOURNE AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106300 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $89,900 27-Dec-18 014-11-045 4142 W 36 ST Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106300 Two family dwelling Two-Family PCT $0 20-Dec-18 014-12-036 3513 KRATHER RD Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106300 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $94,000 31-Dec-18 014-14-035 3914 HENRITZE AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106300 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $58,000 21-Dec-18 014-20-025 3207 COLBURN AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106800 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $45,000 EMV* 18-Dec-18 014-20-043 2809 COLBURN AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106800 Single family dwelling Single-Family AFF $0 21-Dec-18 014-20-113 3002 ROANOKE AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106800 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $37,500 20-Dec-18 014-21-092 2601 SEARSDALE AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106800 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $67,250 11-Dec-18 014-21-148 2807 ROANOKE AVE Cleveland 44109 Old Brooklyn 13 13 106800 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $46,500 14-Dec-18 013-05-068 3640 W 58 ST Cleveland 44102 Stockyards 13 15 105100 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $0 12-Dec-18 015-07-033 3838 MARVIN AVE Cleveland 44109 Brooklyn Centre 14 14 104900 Two family dwelling Two-Family SUR $54,500 19-Dec-18 015-10-186 2516 MARVIN AVE Cleveland 44109 Brooklyn Centre 14 14 104900 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $91,000 28-Dec-18 015-13-060 3517 DAISY AVE Cleveland 44109 Brooklyn Centre 14 14 105500 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $65,500 21-Dec-18 015-14-100 3205 LIBRARY AVE Cleveland 44109 Brooklyn Centre 14 14 105500 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $44,500 31-Dec-18 015-18-100 3715 RIVERSIDE AVE Cleveland 44109 Brooklyn Centre 14 14 105400 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $60,000 6-Dec-18 015-19-076 3411 RIVERSIDE AVE Cleveland 44109 Brooklyn Centre 14 14 105500 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $20,832 13-Dec-18 015-20-015 3636 W 32 ST Cleveland 44109 Brooklyn Centre 14 14 105500 Two family dwelling Two-Family SUR $104,000 10-Dec-18 015-23-108 3719 MACK AVE Cleveland 44109 Brooklyn Centre 14 14 105400 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 28-Dec-18 902002 015-23-110 3729 MACK AVE Cleveland 44109 Brooklyn Centre 14 14 105400 Single family dwelling Single-Family LIM $0 14-Dec-18 015-23-110 3729 MACK AVE Cleveland 44109 Brooklyn Centre 14 14 105400 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 14-Dec-18 015-23-110 3729 MACK AVE Cleveland 44109 Brooklyn Centre 14 14 105400 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $18,000 14-Dec-18 015-23-157 3807 W 38 ST Cleveland 44109 Brooklyn Centre 14 14 105400 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 10-Dec-18 015-23-164 3824 W 36 ST Cleveland 44109 Brooklyn Centre 14 14 105400 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $28,000 19-Dec-18 015-24-006 3791 W 36 ST Cleveland 44109 Brooklyn Centre 14 14 105400 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $59,280 12-Dec-18 015-24-082 3311 ARCHWOOD AVE Cleveland 44109 Brooklyn Centre 14 14 105500 Apartments 20-39 units (walk-up) Apartments LIM $1.625M 28-Dec-18 901817 015-24-083 3209 ARCHWOOD AVE Cleveland 44109 Brooklyn Centre 14 14 105500 Apartments 20-39 units (walk-up) Apartments LIM $1.625M 28-Dec-18 901817 007-26-096 3001 WALTON AVE Cleveland 44113 Clark-Fulton 14 14 103900 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $42,500 28-Dec-18 007-26-102 W 30 ST Cleveland 44113 Clark-Fulton 14 14 103900 Residential vacant land Land WAR $30,000 28-Dec-18 901783 007-26-103 3036 W 30 ST Cleveland 44113 Clark-Fulton 14 14 103900 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $25,000 28-Dec-18 901785 007-26-104 3038 W 30 ST Cleveland 44113 Clark-Fulton 14 14 103900 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $30,000 28-Dec-18 901783 007-26-105 W 30 ST Cleveland 44113 Clark-Fulton 14 14 103900 Residential vacant land Land WAR $25,000 28-Dec-18 901785 007-29-042 4006 HYDE AVE Cleveland 44109 Clark-Fulton 14 14 102900 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $45,000 21-Dec-18 007-29-112 4019 NEWARK AVE Cleveland 44109 Clark-Fulton 14 14 102900 Apartments 1-6 units Apartments QTC $0 26-Dec-18 007-30-121 3727 NEWARK AVE Cleveland 44109 Clark-Fulton 14 14 102900 Two family dwelling Two-Family SUR $0 5-Dec-18 007-31-124 3247 W 32 ST Cleveland 44109 Clark-Fulton 14 14 102900 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $48,000 EMV 3-Dec-18 015-03-021 3312 FULTON RD Cleveland 44109 Clark-Fulton 14 14 102900 Residential vacant land Land SHF $0 12-Dec-18 015-03-044 3633 HYDE AVE Cleveland 44109 Clark-Fulton 14 14 102900 Single family dwelling Single-Family AFF $0 28-Dec-18 015-03-068 3295 FULTON RD Cleveland 44109 Clark-Fulton 14 14 104900 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $52,000 3-Dec-18 Page 21 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Statistical 2010 Orig. Final Parcel Parcel Parcel Parcel Planning 2014 2009 Census Land Land Deed Conveyance Conveyance Transfer Receipt Number Address Municipality Zip Area Ward Ward Tract Use Type Use Type Type Price Flag Date Number 015-04-029 3281 W 33 ST Cleveland 44109 Clark-Fulton 14 14 104900 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $57,900 21-Dec-18 015-04-080 3217 W 35 ST Cleveland 44109 Clark-Fulton 14 14 104900 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $20,000 31-Dec-18 015-04-136 3622 SACKETT AVE Cleveland 44109 Clark-Fulton 14 14 104900 Single family dwelling Single-Family LIM $0 14-Dec-18 015-05-042 3312 W 30 ST Cleveland 44109 Clark-Fulton 14 14 104600 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $24,900 21-Dec-18 015-05-082 3282 W 31 ST Cleveland 44109 Clark-Fulton 14 14 104900 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $18,500 4-Dec-18 015-05-111 3259 W 31 ST Cleveland 44109 Clark-Fulton 14 14 104600 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $1,000 4-Dec-18 015-06-076 4144 WOODBRIDGE AVE Cleveland 44109 Clark-Fulton 14 14 105300 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $38,700 EMV 6-Dec-18 015-06-135 4207 SACKETT AVE Cleveland 44109 Clark-Fulton 14 14 102800 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $94,000 28-Dec-18 015-06-175 3470 W 41 ST Cleveland 44109 Clark-Fulton 14 14 105300 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $48,000 19-Dec-18 015-10-138 3344 W 31 ST Cleveland 44109 Clark-Fulton 14 14 104900 Single family dwelling Single-Family PCT $0 6-Dec-18 015-11-032 4314 DAISY AVE Cleveland 44109 Clark-Fulton 14 14 105300 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $16,800 7-Dec-18 015-11-110 4222 HODGSON AVE Cleveland 44109 Clark-Fulton 14 14 105300 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $30,000 EMV 17-Dec-18 016-02-036 3406 W 65 ST Cleveland 44102 Stockyards 14 15 102700 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $12,550 21-Dec-18 016-09-102 3311 W 54 ST Cleveland 44102 Stockyards 14 15 102700 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $10,000 12-Dec-18 016-09-102 3311 W 54 ST Cleveland 44102 Stockyards 14 15 102700 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $0 28-Dec-18 016-09-109 3279 W 54 ST Cleveland 44102 Stockyards 14 15 102700 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $22,000 18-Dec-18 900381 016-09-110 3275 W 54 ST Cleveland 44102 Stockyards 14 15 102700 Residential vacant land Land WAR $22,000 18-Dec-18 900381 016-10-070 3210 W 54 ST Cleveland 44102 Stockyards 14 15 102700 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 24-Dec-18 016-12-042 3346 W 48 ST Cleveland 44102 Stockyards 14 14 102700 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $39,000 7-Dec-18 016-15-033 3498 W 58 ST Cleveland 44102 Stockyards 14 15 105100 Single family dwelling Single-Family PRV $0 14-Dec-18 016-15-070 3489 W 60 ST Cleveland 44102 Stockyards 14 15 105100 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 20-Dec-18 900911 016-15-070 3489 W 60 ST Cleveland 44102 Stockyards 14 15 105100 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $250,349 20-Dec-18 900913 016-16-076 3409 W 60 ST Cleveland 44102 Stockyards 14 15 105100 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $24,000 6-Dec-18 016-17-025 3604 W 50 ST Cleveland 44102 Stockyards 14 14 105100 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $44,500 31-Dec-18 016-19-048 3445 W 52 ST Cleveland 44102 Stockyards 14 14 105100 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $23,200 EMV 14-Dec-18 016-19-126 3431 W 56 ST Cleveland 44102 Stockyards 14 15 105100 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 19-Dec-18 016-22-015 3613 W 50 ST Cleveland 44102 Stockyards 14 14 105100 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $23,000 13-Dec-18 016-22-109 3561 W 49 ST Cleveland 44102 Stockyards 14 14 105100 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $0 21-Dec-18 016-23-157 3478 W 46 ST Cleveland 44102 Stockyards 14 14 105300 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $26,500 12-Dec-18 899540 016-23-171 3461 W 47 ST Cleveland 44102 Stockyards 14 14 105300 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 21-Dec-18 016-23-171 3461 W 47 ST Cleveland 44102 Stockyards 14 14 105300 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $34,000 21-Dec-18 008-10-067 2324 PRAME AVE Cleveland 44109 Tremont 14 14 104600 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $25,000 3-Dec-18 008-10-067 2324 PRAME AVE Cleveland 44109 Tremont 14 14 104600 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 5-Dec-18 008-11-070 1734 HOLMDEN AVE Cleveland 44109 Tremont 14 14 104800 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $40,000 28-Dec-18 008-15-054 3298 SCRANTON RD Cleveland 44109 Tremont 14 14 104600 Two family dwelling Two-Family SHF $0 21-Dec-18 008-16-058 1905 BRAINARD AVE Cleveland 44109 Tremont 14 14 104800 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 27-Dec-18 017-05-097 3244 W 88 ST Cleveland 44102 West Boulevard 14 16 102402 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $29,500 21-Dec-18 017-05-098 3240 W 88 ST Cleveland 44102 West Boulevard 14 16 102402 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $0 4-Dec-18 017-30-039 3327 W 86 ST Cleveland 44102 West Boulevard 14 16 102401 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $37,000 17-Dec-18 017-33-020 3359 W 82 ST Cleveland 44102 West Boulevard 14 16 102401 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $47,000 7-Dec-18 899046 001-07-093 1304 W 93 ST Cleveland 44102 Cudell 15 16 101101 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 18-Dec-18 001-08-107 1355 W 89 ST Cleveland 44102 Cudell 15 16 101101 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $101,000 17-Dec-18 001-30-027 1975 W 93 ST Cleveland 44102 Cudell 15 16 101700 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 10-Dec-18 005-15-047 3078 W 105 ST Cleveland 44111 Cudell 15 16 101400 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $44,500 31-Dec-18 Page 22 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Statistical 2010 Orig. Final Parcel Parcel Parcel Parcel Planning 2014 2009 Census Land Land Deed Conveyance Conveyance Transfer Receipt Number Address Municipality Zip Area Ward Ward Tract Use Type Use Type Type Price Flag Date Number 005-16-017 2179 W 106 ST Cleveland 44102 Cudell 15 16 101400 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 20-Dec-18 900764 005-16-070 2182 W 104 ST Cleveland 44102 Cudell 15 16 101501 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 13-Dec-18 005-16-070 2182 W 104 ST Cleveland 44102 Cudell 15 16 101501 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $3,500 13-Dec-18 005-16-085 2235 W 104 ST Cleveland 44102 Cudell 15 16 101501 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 14-Dec-18 005-16-098 2191 W 104 ST Cleveland 44102 Cudell 15 16 101501 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $56,250 6-Dec-18 005-16-144 2183 W 103 ST Cleveland 44102 Cudell 15 16 101501 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $43,243 21-Dec-18 005-17-050 2142 W 105 ST Cleveland 44102 Cudell 15 16 101400 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $44,500 31-Dec-18 005-17-068 2121 W 105 ST Cleveland 44102 Cudell 15 16 101501 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $28,000 20-Dec-18 005-17-080 2076 W 104 ST Cleveland 44102 Cudell 15 16 101501 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 11-Dec-18 899328 005-17-116 2117 W 104 ST Cleveland 44102 Cudell 15 16 101501 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 13-Dec-18 899725 005-17-117 2113 W 104 ST Cleveland 44102 Cudell 15 16 101501 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 11-Dec-18 899328 005-17-126 2083 W 104 ST Cleveland 44102 Cudell 15 16 101501 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 11-Dec-18 899328 005-17-170 2095 W 103 ST Cleveland 44102 Cudell 15 16 101501 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $53,000 20-Dec-18 005-18-018 2023 W 106 ST Cleveland 44102 Cudell 15 16 101400 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 20-Dec-18 900764 005-18-019 2021 W 106 ST Cleveland 44102 Cudell 15 16 101400 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $0 12-Dec-18 005-18-072 2014 W 103 ST Cleveland 44102 Cudell 15 16 101501 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $14,500 EMV 26-Dec-18 005-18-082 2050 W 103 ST Cleveland 44102 Cudell 15 16 101501 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 11-Dec-18 899328 005-21-119 9825 GAMBIER AVE Cleveland 44102 Cudell 15 16 101603 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $15,000 19-Dec-18 005-22-046 2115 W 101 ST Cleveland 44102 Cudell 15 16 101603 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $0 4-Dec-18 005-22-121 9905 CUDELL AVE Cleveland 44102 Cudell 15 16 101603 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $74,500 10-Dec-18 005-22-133 9820 CUDELL AVE Cleveland 44102 Cudell 15 16 101603 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 11-Dec-18 005-23-130 2054 W 98 ST Cleveland 44102 Cudell 15 16 101603 Two family dwelling Two-Family PRV $15,000 13-Dec-18 005-25-094 9704 WILLARD AVE Cleveland 44102 Cudell 15 16 101603 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $25,000 14-Dec-18 005-26-019 2101 W 98 ST Cleveland 44102 Cudell 15 16 101603 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 21-Dec-18 005-27-080 2038 W 95 ST Cleveland 44102 Cudell 15 16 101603 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $48,000 7-Dec-18 005-28-028 W 91 ST Cleveland 44102 Cudell 15 16 101700 Residential vacant land Land WAR $26,000 17-Dec-18 900225 005-28-063 9015 WILLARD AVE Cleveland 44102 Cudell 15 16 101700 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $26,000 17-Dec-18 900225 005-29-031 8707 SAUER AVE Cleveland 44102 Cudell 15 16 101700 Single family dwelling Single-Family AFF $0 28-Dec-18 005-29-031 8707 SAUER AVE Cleveland 44102 Cudell 15 16 101700 Single family dwelling Single-Family TRS $0 28-Dec-18 005-29-084 8707 PLATTEN AVE Cleveland 44102 Cudell 15 16 101700 Single family dwelling Single-Family PCT $0 10-Dec-18 005-30-001 2115 W 93 ST Cleveland 44102 Cudell 15 16 101700 Two family dwelling Two-Family PRV $20,000 13-Dec-18 005-30-005 2101 W 93 ST Cleveland 44102 Cudell 15 16 101700 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $51,000 21-Dec-18 005-30-006 2097 W 93 ST Cleveland 44102 Cudell 15 16 101700 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $51,000 21-Dec-18 005-30-022 2082 W 91 ST Cleveland 44102 Cudell 15 16 101700 Single family dwelling Single-Family PRV $20,000 19-Dec-18 005-30-056 2086 W 89 ST Cleveland 44102 Cudell 15 16 101700 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $41,500 EMV 7-Dec-18 005-30-064 2113 W 89 ST Cleveland 44102 Cudell 15 16 101700 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $41,600 EMV 21-Dec-18 005-30-074 2079 W 89 ST Cleveland 44102 Cudell 15 16 101700 Single family dwelling Single-Family LIM $16,000 11-Dec-18 005-31-032 2016 W 85 ST Cleveland 44102 Cudell 15 16 101700 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $55,000 31-Dec-18 002-02-003 8316 LAKE AVE Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 101200 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $142,000 21-Dec-18 901198 002-02-004 8314 LAKE AVE Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 101200 Apartments 1-6 units Apartments WAR $142,000 21-Dec-18 901198 002-04-405 7525 BATTERY PARK AVE Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 101200 Residential condominiums Condo SUR $340,500 14-Dec-18 002-05-020 1365 W 76 ST Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 101200 Single family dwelling Single-Family CHN $0 6-Dec-18 002-05-057 7419 GOODWALT AVE Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 101200 Two family dwelling Two-Family SUR $0 4-Dec-18 002-05-057 7419 GOODWALT AVE Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 101200 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $92,000 10-Dec-18 Page 23 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Statistical 2010 Orig. Final Parcel Parcel Parcel Parcel Planning 2014 2009 Census Land Land Deed Conveyance Conveyance Transfer Receipt Number Address Municipality Zip Area Ward Ward Tract Use Type Use Type Type Price Flag Date Number 002-05-062 7501 GOODWALT AVE Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 101200 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $85,000 6-Dec-18 002-05-104 7413 RUTLEDGE AVE Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 101200 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $120,000 5-Dec-18 002-06-857C 1226 W 70 ST Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 101200 Residential condominiums Condo WAR $546,116 EMV* 12-Dec-18 002-08-048 1238 W 65 ST Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 101200 Two family dwelling Two-Family SUR $125,000 17-Dec-18 002-09-099 1341 W 67 ST Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 101200 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $444,000 18-Dec-18 002-10-024 HERMAN AVE Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 103100 Residential vacant land Land LIM $463,243 11-Dec-18 002-10-024 HERMAN AVE Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 103100 Residential vacant land Land REF $0 EMV* 27-Dec-18 002-10-025 HERMAN AVE Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 103100 Residential vacant land Land LIM $428,834 7-Dec-18 002-10-025 HERMAN AVE Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 103100 Residential vacant land Land REF $0 EMV* 27-Dec-18 002-10-026 HERMAN AVE Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 103100 Residential vacant land Land LIM $430,593 13-Dec-18 002-10-026 HERMAN AVE Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 103100 Residential vacant land Land REF $0 EMV* 27-Dec-18 002-11-012 FATHER CARUSO DR Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 103100 Residential vacant land Land SUR $452,500 27-Dec-18 002-11-033 1244 W 58 ST Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 103100 Residential vacant land Land SUR $568,488 17-Dec-18 002-12-030 5820 DETROIT AVE Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 103100 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 5-Dec-18 002-12-073 1358 W 59 ST Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 103100 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $95,500 27-Dec-18 002-12-117 1312 W 61 ST Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 103100 Two family dwelling Two-Family AFF $0 17-Dec-18 002-15-100 FRANKLIN BLVD Cleveland 44109 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 103400 Residential vacant land Land WAR $448,813 EMV* 18-Dec-18 002-21-030 7915 FERRELL AVE Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 101800 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $28,700 EMV 31-Dec-18 002-22-020 1914 W 74 ST Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 101800 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 11-Dec-18 002-23-046 7318 WAKEFIELD AVE Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 101901 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $154,500 5-Dec-18 002-23-063 1922 W 73 ST Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 101901 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $170,000 26-Dec-18 002-28-019 6007 WAKEFIELD AVE Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 103400 Three family dwelling Three-Family PLT $0 11-Dec-18 899334 002-28-040 6022 PEAR AVE Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 103400 Single family dwelling Single-Family AFF $0 31-Dec-18 002-28-106 6011 WAKEFIELD ST Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 103400 Residential vacant land Land PLT $0 11-Dec-18 899334 002-29-009 1889 W 65 ST Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 103400 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 21-Dec-18 002-29-029 5903 BRIDGE AVE Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 103400 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $26,350 4-Dec-18 002-29-072 6211 FIR AVE Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 103400 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $150,000 12-Dec-18 002-29-102 6300 FIR AVE Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 103400 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $403,000 27-Dec-18 002-30-002 6311 ELLEN AVE Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 103400 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 7-Dec-18 002-30-032 1836 W 58 ST Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 103400 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $255,000 31-Dec-18 002-31-135 1986 W 54 ST Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 103400 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $100,000 28-Dec-18 002-31-154 1950 W 52 ST Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 103400 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $69,900 26-Dec-18 002-32-034 1886 W 57 ST Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 103400 Residential vacant land Land SUR $316,116 31-Dec-18 002-32-173 5404 BRIDGE AVE Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 103400 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $165,000 21-Dec-18 002-33-117 5504 SCOTT CT Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 103400 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 20-Dec-18 002-35-004 1885 W 52 ST Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 103400 Single family dwelling Single-Family PLT $0 18-Dec-18 900415 002-35-222 W 52 ST Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 103400 Residential vacant land Land PLT $0 18-Dec-18 900415 003-09-064 5702 TILLMAN AVE Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 103100 Single family dwelling Single-Family PLT $0 5-Dec-18 898631 003-09-065 5710 TILLMAN AVE Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 103100 Residential vacant land Land PLT $0 5-Dec-18 898631 006-02-007 2161 W 85 ST Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 101700 Two family dwelling Two-Family LIM $0 14-Dec-18 006-02-007 2161 W 85 ST Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 101700 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $7,000 14-Dec-18 006-02-039 2132 W 83 ST Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 101700 Two family dwelling Two-Family SHF $19,100 6-Dec-18 006-03-019 2025 W 85 ST Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 101700 Single family dwelling Single-Family AFF $0 10-Dec-18 006-03-019 2025 W 85 ST Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 101700 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 17-Dec-18 Page 24 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Statistical 2010 Orig. Final Parcel Parcel Parcel Parcel Planning 2014 2009 Census Land Land Deed Conveyance Conveyance Transfer Receipt Number Address Municipality Zip Area Ward Ward Tract Use Type Use Type Type Price Flag Date Number 006-04-131 7811 EVE AVE Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 101800 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $25 5-Dec-18 006-04-158 7808 ELTON AVE Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 101800 Single family dwelling Single-Family AFF $0 10-Dec-18 006-05-093 7421 DUDLEY AVE Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 101800 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $0 7-Dec-18 006-06-022 7808 COLGATE AVE Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 101800 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $51,000 21-Dec-18 006-06-039 7907 COLGATE AVE Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 101800 Residential vacant land Land QTC $1,500 EMV 12-Dec-18 006-09-122 7009 MADISON AVE Cleveland 44102 Detroit Shoreway 15 15 101901 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $21,300 EMV 17-Dec-18 001-06-020 10119 EDGEWATER DR Cleveland 44102 Edgewater 15 16 101102 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 12-Dec-18 001-10-009 9715 LAKE AVE Cleveland 44102 Edgewater 15 16 101102 Single family dwelling Single-Family FID $167,000 EMV 17-Dec-18 001-10-023 9802 CLIFTON BLVD Cleveland 44102 Edgewater 15 16 101102 Two family dwelling Two-Family PCT $0 31-Dec-18 001-10-074 9803-05 LAKE AVE Cleveland 44102 Edgewater 15 16 101102 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $485,000 7-Dec-18 001-14-015 10209 BALTIC RD Cleveland 44102 Edgewater 15 16 101102 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $154,000 7-Dec-18 001-15-005 1270 W 103 ST Cleveland 44102 Edgewater 15 16 101102 Single family dwelling Single-Family AFF $0 4-Dec-18 001-22-031 1599 W 116 ST Cleveland 44102 Edgewater 15 16 101300 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $65,000 18-Dec-18 001-23-027 1500 W 116 ST Cleveland 44102 Edgewater 15 16 101300 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $20,000 20-Dec-18 001-24-037 1432 W 114 ST Cleveland 44102 Edgewater 15 16 101300 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 31-Dec-18 006-16-022 2240 W 53 ST Cleveland 44102 Stockyards 15 15 102700 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 21-Dec-18 020-05-095 13511 BENNINGTON AVE Cleveland 44135 Bellaire-Puritas 16 18 124600 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $76,000 6-Dec-18 898868 020-05-096 BENNINGTON AVE Cleveland 44135 Bellaire-Puritas 16 18 124600 Residential vacant land Land WAR $76,000 6-Dec-18 898868 020-06-108 13220 CROSSBURN AVE Cleveland 44135 Bellaire-Puritas 16 18 124600 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $0 10-Dec-18 020-07-004 13435 ASTOR AVE Cleveland 44135 Bellaire-Puritas 16 18 124600 Single family dwelling Single-Family DEE $24,200 27-Dec-18 020-07-021 13612 CROSSBURN AVE Cleveland 44135 Bellaire-Puritas 16 18 124600 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $20,000 14-Dec-18 020-07-071 13700 SPRECHER AVE Cleveland 44135 Bellaire-Puritas 16 18 124600 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $60,000 21-Dec-18 020-09-114 12820 LONGMEAD AVE Cleveland 44135 Bellaire-Puritas 16 18 124600 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 12-Dec-18 020-10-006 12418 LENA AVE Cleveland 44135 Bellaire-Puritas 16 18 124600 Single family dwelling Single-Family LIM $0 3-Dec-18 020-10-060 12302 LONGMEAD AVE Cleveland 44135 Bellaire-Puritas 16 18 124600 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $31,000 7-Dec-18 020-10-066 12112 LONGMEAD AVE Cleveland 44135 Bellaire-Puritas 16 18 124600 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $52,000 19-Dec-18 020-12-159 12610 MCGOWAN AVE Cleveland 44135 Bellaire-Puritas 16 18 124600 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $35,194 4-Dec-18 898425 020-12-160 MCGOWAN AVE Cleveland 44135 Bellaire-Puritas 16 18 124600 Residential vacant land Land SUR $35,194 4-Dec-18 898425 020-13-048 12322 MCGOWAN AVE Cleveland 44135 Bellaire-Puritas 16 18 124600 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $42,500 20-Dec-18 900870 020-13-049 MCGOWAN AVE Cleveland 44135 Bellaire-Puritas 16 18 124600 Residential vacant land Land WAR $42,500 20-Dec-18 900870 020-15-026 12821 SPRECHER AVE Cleveland 44135 Bellaire-Puritas 16 18 124600 Two family dwelling Two-Family SUR $99,900 18-Dec-18 020-16-007 12411 BENNINGTON AVE Cleveland 44135 Bellaire-Puritas 16 18 124600 Single family dwelling Single-Family AFF $0 4-Dec-18 020-16-007 12411 BENNINGTON AVE Cleveland 44135 Bellaire-Puritas 16 18 124600 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $40,500 10-Dec-18 022-24-063 13512 TERMINAL AVE Cleveland 44135 Bellaire-Puritas 16 18 124300 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $0 31-Dec-18 023-02-036 14829 SPRENGEL AVE Cleveland 44135 Bellaire-Puritas 16 18 124202 Single family dwelling Single-Family AFF $0 19-Dec-18 023-04-050 4396 W 145 ST Cleveland 44135 Bellaire-Puritas 16 18 124202 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $95,000 28-Dec-18 023-09-042 13521 BELLAIRE RD Cleveland 44135 Bellaire-Puritas 16 18 124300 Two family dwelling Two-Family QTC $0 11-Dec-18 023-09-090 13602 SHERRY AVE Cleveland 44135 Bellaire-Puritas 16 18 124300 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $79,900 4-Dec-18 023-09-095 13514 SHERRY AVE Cleveland 44135 Bellaire-Puritas 16 18 124300 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $83,500 27-Dec-18 023-15-180 4481 W 146 ST Cleveland 44135 Bellaire-Puritas 16 18 124500 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $0 20-Dec-18 023-19-115 4468 W 138 ST Cleveland 44135 Bellaire-Puritas 16 18 124500 Single family dwelling Single-Family AFF $0 18-Dec-18 023-20-064 4460 W 136 ST Cleveland 44135 Bellaire-Puritas 16 18 124500 Single family dwelling Single-Family LIM $45,000 19-Dec-18 023-21-037 13340 THORNHOPE AVE Cleveland 44135 Bellaire-Puritas 16 18 124500 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $22,500 26-Dec-18 027-23-122 15632 PURITAS AVE Cleveland 44135 Bellaire-Puritas 16 18 124202 Single family dwelling Single-Family PCT $0 28-Dec-18 Page 25 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Statistical 2010 Orig. Final Parcel Parcel Parcel Parcel Planning 2014 2009 Census Land Land Deed Conveyance Conveyance Transfer Receipt Number Address Municipality Zip Area Ward Ward Tract Use Type Use Type Type Price Flag Date Number 027-26-053 15205 ALDENE AVE Cleveland 44135 Bellaire-Puritas 16 18 124202 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $0 13-Dec-18 899849 028-26-013 4658 W 158 ST Cleveland 44135 Bellaire-Puritas 16 18 124500 Single family dwelling Single-Family AFF $0 5-Dec-18 028-26-013 4658 W 158 ST Cleveland 44135 Bellaire-Puritas 16 18 124500 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $68,000 5-Dec-18 028-26-043 4740 W 157 ST Cleveland 44135 Bellaire-Puritas 16 18 124500 Single family dwelling Single-Family AFF $0 6-Dec-18 028-34-061 15201 LOUIS AVE Cleveland 44135 Bellaire-Puritas 16 18 124500 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $96,500 21-Dec-18 021-21-025 11924 TRISKETT RD Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 16 17 123501 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $54,000 4-Dec-18 021-21-042 3211 W 121 ST Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 16 17 123501 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $38,000 31-Dec-18 021-21-065 3209 W 120 ST Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 16 17 123501 Single family dwelling Single-Family CHN $0 24-Dec-18 021-21-065 3209 W 120 ST Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 16 17 123501 Single family dwelling Single-Family JUD $0 24-Dec-18 021-24-011 3326 W 122 ST Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 16 17 123501 Residential vacant land Land SHF $0 6-Dec-18 021-25-059 3266 W 128 ST Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 16 17 123501 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 27-Dec-18 021-26-072 3300 W 128 ST Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 16 17 123501 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $69,000 28-Dec-18 021-27-042 3425 W 130 ST Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 16 17 123501 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $82,500 14-Dec-18 021-27-148 3380 W 127 ST Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 16 17 123501 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $110,000 28-Dec-18 021-27-166 3375 W 127 ST Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 16 17 123501 Single family dwelling Single-Family PRV $73,850 13-Dec-18 021-30-045 3454 W 133 ST Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 16 17 123501 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $40,700 EMV 12-Dec-18 021-32-029 3370 W 135 ST Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 16 18 123501 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $60,000 11-Dec-18 022-02-081 14101 CARRYDALE AVE Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 16 18 124201 Single family dwelling Single-Family LIM $0 7-Dec-18 022-03-020 3657 W 140 ST Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 16 18 123900 Two family dwelling Two-Family LND $0 31-Dec-18 022-03-029 3640 W 139 ST Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 16 18 123900 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $101,300 21-Dec-18 022-04-077 3721 W 139 ST Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 16 18 123900 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $100,000 3-Dec-18 022-05-072 3769 W 139 ST Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 16 18 123900 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $115,000 14-Dec-18 022-06-017 3573 W 136 ST Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 16 18 123900 Two family dwelling Two-Family SUR $92,000 4-Dec-18 022-06-061 3644 W 134 ST Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 16 18 123900 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $65,000 21-Dec-18 022-07-106 3687 W 137 ST Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 16 18 123900 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $53,000 4-Dec-18 022-09-006 3846 W 134 ST Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 16 18 123900 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $104,259 24-Dec-18 022-10-032 3592 W 133 ST Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 16 18 123900 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 18-Dec-18 022-12-109 3802 W 133 ST Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 16 18 123900 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $47,268 14-Dec-18 022-13-034 13324 WEST AVE Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 16 18 123900 Single family dwelling Single-Family AFF $0 11-Dec-18 022-13-043 3861 W 134 ST Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 16 18 123900 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $43,000 EMV 20-Dec-18 022-13-048 3841 W 134 ST Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 16 18 123900 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $88,000 20-Dec-18 022-14-137 3913 VICTORY BLVD Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 16 18 124300 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $83,000 21-Dec-18 022-16-105 13801 WAINSTEAD AVE Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 16 18 124300 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 31-Dec-18 022-18-006 3982 BROOKSIDE BLVD Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 16 18 124300 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $0 13-Dec-18 899831 022-19-001 13701 COURTLAND AVE Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 16 18 124300 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $84,900 6-Dec-18 022-19-069 13709 CLIFFORD AVE Cleveland 44135 Jefferson 16 18 124300 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $52,400 3-Dec-18 022-26-023 14018 COURTLAND AVE Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 16 18 124201 Two family dwelling Two-Family WAR $110,000 21-Dec-18 022-26-066 14012 VIOLA AVE Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 16 18 124201 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $46,000 7-Dec-18 022-26-070 14210 VIOLA AVE Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 16 18 124201 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $0 13-Dec-18 899831 022-27-168 14213 LEROY AVE Cleveland 44135 Jefferson 16 18 124201 Two family dwelling Two-Family SUR $0 31-Dec-18 023-03-016 14825 TERMINAL AVE Cleveland 44135 Jefferson 16 18 124201 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $0 4-Dec-18 027-35-047 14505 FAIRLAWN AVE Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 16 18 124201 Single family dwelling Single-Family EXC $37,000 21-Dec-18 027-36-041 14504 VIOLA AVE Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 16 18 124201 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $65,000 27-Dec-18 027-37-008 3992 W 146 ST Cleveland 44111 Jefferson 16 18 124201 Single family dwelling Single-Family FID $44,000 31-Dec-18 Page 26 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Statistical 2010 Orig. Final Parcel Parcel Parcel Parcel Planning 2014 2009 Census Land Land Deed Conveyance Conveyance Transfer Receipt Number Address Municipality Zip Area Ward Ward Tract Use Type Use Type Type Price Flag Date Number 027-38-077 4088 W 143 ST Cleveland 44135 Jefferson 16 18 124201 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $0 13-Dec-18 899831 021-06-062 3103 W 136 ST Cleveland 44111 Kamm's 16 19 123200 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $100,000 21-Dec-18 021-07-032 3244 W 139 ST Cleveland 44111 Kamm's 16 19 123200 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 21-Dec-18 021-07-032 3244 W 139 ST Cleveland 44111 Kamm's 16 19 123200 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $120,000 21-Dec-18 021-07-055 3177 W 139 ST Cleveland 44111 Kamm's 16 19 123200 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $0 14-Dec-18 021-08-007 3233 JOSLYN RD Cleveland 44111 Kamm's 16 19 123200 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $35,000 11-Dec-18 024-34-098 14312 GRAMATAN AVE Cleveland 44111 Kamm's 16 19 123502 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $0 13-Dec-18 899849 024-35-127 14224 GRAMATAN AVE Cleveland 44111 Kamm's 16 19 123502 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $0 13-Dec-18 899849 024-36-057 3320 W 140 ST Cleveland 44111 Kamm's 16 19 123502 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $0 13-Dec-18 021-01-019 14140 TRISKETT RD Cleveland 44111 Kamm's 17 19 123200 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $115,000 12-Dec-18 024-05-141 3134 W 162 ST Cleveland 44111 Kamm's 17 19 123100 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $168,000 4-Dec-18 024-09-010 15841 EDGECLIFF AVE Cleveland 44111 Kamm's 17 19 123100 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $275,000 6-Dec-18 024-12-033 3411 W 157 ST Cleveland 44111 Kamm's 17 19 123100 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $162,000 7-Dec-18 024-16-011 14729 ALGER RD Cleveland 44111 Kamm's 17 19 123100 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 10-Dec-18 024-25-015 14627 BIRCHWOOD AVE Cleveland 44111 Kamm's 17 19 123200 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $92,000 10-Dec-18 024-26-057 14410 ALGER RD Cleveland 44111 Kamm's 17 19 123200 Single family dwelling Single-Family AFF $0 20-Dec-18 024-27-034 14416 BROXTON AVE Cleveland 44111 Kamm's 17 19 123200 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $120,000 12-Dec-18 024-27-037 14401 ROXBORO AVE Cleveland 44111 Kamm's 17 19 123200 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 14-Dec-18 024-30-017 3562 W 146 ST Cleveland 44111 Kamm's 17 19 123502 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $118,000 12-Dec-18 024-34-026 14412 RAINBOW RD Cleveland 44111 Kamm's 17 19 123502 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 20-Dec-18 024-35-030 14139 TUCKAHOE AVE Cleveland 44111 Kamm's 17 19 123502 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $58,000 19-Dec-18 025-04-072 17521 OXFORD AVE Cleveland 44111 Kamm's 17 19 123400 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $154,000 19-Dec-18 025-13-044 3436 W 159 ST Cleveland 44111 Kamm's 17 19 123400 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $163,000 6-Dec-18 025-15-022 3624 W 159 ST Cleveland 44111 Kamm's 17 19 123400 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 13-Dec-18 025-15-022 3624 W 159 ST Cleveland 44111 Kamm's 17 19 123400 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $200,000 13-Dec-18 025-15-047 16207 WEST PARK AVE Cleveland 44111 Kamm's 17 19 123400 Single family dwelling Single-Family PLT $0 13-Dec-18 899789 025-15-048 16203 WEST PARK AVE Cleveland 44111 Kamm's 17 19 123400 Single family dwelling Single-Family PLT $0 13-Dec-18 899789 025-15-048 16203 WEST PARK AVE Cleveland 44111 Kamm's 17 19 123400 Single family dwelling Single-Family COR $0 13-Dec-18 025-16-039 17003 FERNDALE AVE Cleveland 44111 Kamm's 17 19 123400 Single family dwelling Single-Family AFF $0 26-Dec-18 025-18-016 3524 GRANTON AVE Cleveland 44111 Kamm's 17 19 123400 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $160,000 28-Dec-18 025-22-076 3610 ROCKPORT AVE Cleveland 44111 Kamm's 17 19 123400 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $158,500 5-Dec-18 025-26-027 16725 BRADGATE AVE Cleveland 44111 Kamm's 17 19 123603 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $170,000 17-Dec-18 025-31-064 3895 W 157 ST Cleveland 44111 Kamm's 17 19 123603 Single family dwelling Single-Family FID $33,000 17-Dec-18 026-05-081 17805 SUSAN AVE Cleveland 44111 Kamm's 17 19 123603 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $149,900 5-Dec-18 026-06-042 17705 NAOMI AVE Cleveland 44111 Kamm's 17 19 123603 Single family dwelling Single-Family JUD $0 13-Dec-18 026-07-006 18025 LARCHWOOD AVE Cleveland 44135 Kamm's 17 19 123602 Single family dwelling Single-Family PRV $45,834 28-Dec-18 026-07-051 4182 RUSTIC RD Cleveland 44135 Kamm's 17 19 123602 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $152,500 6-Dec-18 026-10-018 4299 W 180 ST Cleveland 44135 Kamm's 17 19 123602 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 28-Dec-18 026-19-026 4350 W 189 ST Cleveland 44135 Kamm's 17 19 123602 Single family dwelling Single-Family AFF $0 18-Dec-18 026-23-039 18140 PURITAS AVE Cleveland 44135 Kamm's 17 19 123602 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $103,000 20-Dec-18 026-24-898C 4538 LITTLE MET PL Cleveland 44135 Kamm's 17 19 123700 Residential condominiums Condo WAR $117,000 3-Dec-18 026-25-057 19124 APELT AVE Cleveland 44135 Kamm's 17 19 123700 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $50,500 6-Dec-18 026-28-038 18226 FAIRVILLE AVE Cleveland 44135 Kamm's 17 19 123700 Single family dwelling Single-Family LND $0 7-Dec-18 026-28-084 18200 FLAMINGO AVE Cleveland 44135 Kamm's 17 19 123700 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $145,000 6-Dec-18 Page 27 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Statistical 2010 Orig. Final Parcel Parcel Parcel Parcel Planning 2014 2009 Census Land Land Deed Conveyance Conveyance Transfer Receipt Number Address Municipality Zip Area Ward Ward Tract Use Type Use Type Type Price Flag Date Number 026-32-042 18513 FERNCLIFFE AVE Cleveland 44135 Kamm's 17 19 123700 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $105,000 28-Dec-18 026-32-045 18420 ROCKLAND ST Cleveland 44135 Kamm's 17 19 123700 Single family dwelling Single-Family SHF $53,000 6-Dec-18 027-01-068 4027 ROCKY RIVER DR Cleveland 44135 Kamm's 17 19 123603 Apartments 20-39 units (walk-up) Apartments WAR $931,250 12-Dec-18 027-02-048 4022 W 166 ST Cleveland 44135 Kamm's 17 19 123603 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $124,000 12-Dec-18 027-02-079 16806 MELGRAVE AVE Cleveland 44135 Kamm's 17 19 123603 Single family dwelling Single-Family AFF $0 10-Dec-18 027-02-110 16814 LARCHWOOD AVE Cleveland 44135 Kamm's 17 19 123603 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 21-Dec-18 027-02-110 16814 LARCHWOOD AVE Cleveland 44135 Kamm's 17 19 123603 Single family dwelling Single-Family FID $18,250 21-Dec-18 027-03-052 4031 W 161 ST Cleveland 44135 Kamm's 17 19 123601 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 7-Dec-18 027-04-024 4045 W 157 ST Cleveland 44135 Kamm's 17 19 123601 Single family dwelling Single-Family QTC $0 18-Dec-18 900485 027-05-062 17105 SEDALIA AVE Cleveland 44135 Kamm's 17 19 123601 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $0 26-Dec-18 027-06-029 16722 SEDALIA AVE Cleveland 44135 Kamm's 17 19 123601 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $129,000 27-Dec-18 027-06-122 16700 WOODBURY AVE Cleveland 44135 Kamm's 17 19 123601 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $179,000 7-Dec-18 027-10-069 16908 ELSIENNA AVE Cleveland 44135 Kamm's 17 19 123601 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $85,000 26-Dec-18 027-10-116 16920 LAVERNE AVE Cleveland 44135 Kamm's 17 19 123601 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $112,000 17-Dec-18 027-11-064 16604 ELSIENNA AVE Cleveland 44135 Kamm's 17 19 123601 Single family dwelling Single-Family AFF $0 14-Dec-18 027-14-032 16809 MILBURN AVE Cleveland 44135 Kamm's 17 19 123601 Single family dwelling Single-Family AFF $0 19-Dec-18 027-20-043 15902 WESTDALE AVE Cleveland 44135 Kamm's 17 19 123601 Single family dwelling Single-Family SUR $100,797 21-Dec-18 028-03-131 4529 W 172 ST Cleveland 44135 Kamm's 17 18 123800 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $75,000 28-Dec-18 029-03-009 4630 GRAYTON RD Cleveland 44135 Kamm's 17 18 123700 Single family dwelling Single-Family WAR $145,000 21-Dec-18

Page 28 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable Taxable Taxable Taxable Auditor Number of Assessed Assessed Assessed Estimated Total EMV Ratio Filing Parcels Property Building Land Total Market Mult. Recpt. Price to Buyer Seller Number Combined ($) Class Value Value Value Value Est. Mkt. Val. Est. Mkt. Val. Name Name 1 Residential $11,165 $2,835 $14,000 $40,000 0.75 GOD CAN DO IT LLC SS HOLDINGS GROUP L L C 1 Residential $19,600 $6,300 $25,900 $74,000 0.27 M&T BANK RATCLIFF, TASHUNDA N 1 Residential $13,125 $2,555 $15,680 $44,800 0 THOMAS-MURRAY, DARLENE THOMAS, EUGENE H 1 Residential $22,470 $6,020 $28,490 $81,400 0.77 ABELEDA, EDNA MFR 5 LLC 1 Residential $27,720 $6,825 $34,545 $98,700 0.41 THREE BLACK KNIGHTS, LLC US BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION 1 Residential $14,175 $5,775 $19,950 $57,000 0 FIRST EQUITY CAPITAL LLC EMMET, INC 1 Residential $12,005 $5,775 $17,780 $50,800 1.14 BROWN, JAMES E COLVIN CONSTUCTION INC 1 Residential $35 $5,775 $5,810 $16,600 0 U S BANK TRUST, N A WOODS, SHANDALYN N 1 Residential $15,610 $5,775 $21,385 $61,100 0 HENDRICKS, ANGELA L KING, MARGARET CYNTHIA FKA STEVENSO 1 Residential $15,610 $5,775 $21,385 $61,100 0.49 PROPERTY IMPROVEMENT SPECIALISTS, I HENDRICKS, ANGELA L 1 Residential $15,855 $5,880 $21,735 $62,100 0.32 WM CAPITAL PARNTERS 68 LLC PORTFOLIO, HARBOUR VII, LP 1 Residential $19,040 $5,950 $24,990 $71,400 0.39 AT POSH INVESTMENTS, LLC NEVARC GROUP INC DBA NEVARC PROPERT 1 Residential $19,740 $5,880 $25,620 $73,200 0 MCCALL JR , ROBERT C MCCALL, CATHERINE J (TRS) 1 Residential $8,225 $6,335 $14,560 $41,600 0.4 CITIMORTGAGE, INC WILLIAMS, BONNIE A 1 Residential $17,535 $6,230 $23,765 $67,900 0 SPENCER, JEANARRE M & ALIA M SPENCER ODITH 1 Residential $23,100 $6,685 $29,785 $85,100 0 GIBBS, MARIAN C GIBBS LUTHER O 1 Residential $6,615 $6,055 $12,670 $36,200 1 TIGIE'S HOME DESIGNERS, LLC STEEL, LORENZO 1 Residential $23,240 $6,055 $29,295 $83,700 0.33 LIGHTNING GROUP, LLC LEMON, LESLIE 1 Residential $27,580 $6,125 $33,705 $96,300 0.3 PROPERTY IMPROVEMENT SPECIALISTS IN STEVE, IDA J 1 Residential $6,475 $6,055 $12,530 $35,800 1 ROBINSON, DINESHA HARDMAN, ELAINE MAHONE 1 Residential $1,960 $6,790 $8,750 $25,000 5 SINGLETON, JANEAN T PROPERTY IMPROVEMENT SPECIALISTS, I 1 Residential $22,085 $6,790 $28,875 $82,500 0.61 U S BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION WRIGHT, CAROLYN 1 Residential $21,490 $6,825 $28,315 $80,900 1.24 DIVVY HOMES WAREHOUSE I LLC ACEARELLY HOMES LLC 1 Residential $19,775 $6,195 $25,970 $74,200 0 LEGGETT, CHARLOTTE IRVIN, LUKE, LIFE EST & LEGGETT, CH 1 Residential $350 $6,580 $6,930 $19,800 0.51 PROF-2013-S3 LEGAL TITLE TRUST IV LEWIS, ROBERT W 1 Residential $23,485 $4,690 $28,175 $80,500 0.45 KCW RENTALS LLC MISCHA HILL ASSOCIATES, LLC 1 Residential $21,875 $5,110 $26,985 $77,100 0.06 BCD PROPERTEIS, INC LAKESIDE REO VENTURES LLC 1 Residential $20,650 $4,865 $25,515 $72,900 0 ORR, BETTYE ORR WILLIAM H 1 Residential $22,960 $4,935 $27,895 $79,700 0.3 DEUTSCHE BANK NATIONAL TRUST COMPAN LEWIS, LISA S 1 Residential $21,700 $5,145 $26,845 $76,700 0 RONALD SLY INVESTMENTS LLC GREEN, DIANE 1 Residential $13,335 $2,835 $16,170 $46,200 0 FIRST EQUITY CAPITAL LLC EMMET INC 1 Residential $13,405 $3,360 $16,765 $47,900 0.5 WATSON, EVELYN & MORRISON-HEARN, M WATSON, EVELYN 1 Residential $13,405 $3,360 $16,765 $47,900 0 MORRISON-HEARN, MARY E WATSON, EVELYN & MORRISON-HEARN, M 1 Residential $23,835 $4,235 $28,070 $80,200 0.61 HILL, MERIDITH D THOMAS, CAROLYN 1 Residential $19,355 $4,935 $24,290 $69,400 0.94 CLASSIC AFFORDABLE PROPERTIES, LLC RDC REAL ESTATE DEVELOPMENT, LLC 1 Residential $20,020 $5,075 $25,095 $71,700 0 MALLY, WANDA AND BONNER, RENEE HOWARD, BETTY JO 1 Residential $20,020 $5,075 $25,095 $71,700 1.11 WOODS, JAMES MALLY, WANDA AND BONNER, RENEE 1 Residential $2,380 $5,495 $7,875 $22,500 0 WAGNER, KEVIN H KW REHIBILITATION AND DESIGN SPECIA 1 Residential $22,190 $3,710 $25,900 $74,000 0.99 TERRELL, LUCIOUS R OLIVER, SHERI L 1 Residential $20,790 $5,145 $25,935 $74,100 0 CRUMB, ROSLYN DENISE SMITH GEORGE L & ANNETTE 1 Residential $26,495 $4,935 $31,430 $89,800 0 ANDERSON, BYRON TRUSTEE TWYNE, LUTHER E & PAULINE M TRU 1 Residential $26,495 $4,935 $31,430 $89,800 0.75 TURNER, REGINA O ANDERSON, BYRON TRUSTEE 1 Residential $23,100 $4,795 $27,895 $79,700 1.53 ARNOLD, BONDEZ W AND REDDING, SANY CORNERSTONE RENOVATIONS, LLC 1 Residential $19,460 $4,830 $24,290 $69,400 0.32 UNDERWOOD, SANDRA UNDERWOOD, CLARENCE JR & SANDRA Page 29 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable Taxable Taxable Taxable Auditor Number of Assessed Assessed Assessed Estimated Total EMV Ratio Filing Parcels Property Building Land Total Market Mult. Recpt. Price to Buyer Seller Number Combined ($) Class Value Value Value Value Est. Mkt. Val. Est. Mkt. Val. Name Name 1 Residential $19,460 $4,830 $24,290 $69,400 0.32 UNDERWOOD, CLARENCE JR & SANDRA UNDERWOOD, ANGELA & CLARENCE JR & 1 Residential $1,120 $3,360 $4,480 $12,800 3.36 MJB INVESTMENT PROPERTIES LLC TOOTLE, ARKESHA P 1 Residential $9,275 $4,725 $14,000 $40,000 1 IMMOBILIER CLEVELAND, LLC HURFIESH BUILDERS LLC 1 Residential $9,275 $4,725 $14,000 $40,000 1.55 PUYLOUB INVESTMENT LLC IMMOBILIER CLEVELAND, LLC 1 Residential $13,580 $4,690 $18,270 $52,200 0 SECRETARY OF HOUSING AND URBAN DEVE CITIMORTGAGE, INC 1 Residential $14,875 $6,790 $21,665 $61,900 0.53 SUMMERVILLE, DWAIN JR & WOODS, ALI WHEELER-MILLER, RHONDA 1 Residential $4,410 $2,100 $6,510 $18,600 0.16 LBR HOMES, LLC WHITE, BRANDON 1 Residential $4,900 $2,100 $7,000 $20,000 0.67 US BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION FITTS, GEORGE W JR 4 Residential $7,000 $2,100 $9,100 $26,000 $118,600 0 GUARDIAN FUND, LLC HOME PARTNERS, LLC 4 Residential $7,000 $2,100 $9,100 $26,000 $118,600 2.11 PHILLIPS, KENT L & PHILLIPS, PATRI GUARDIAN FUND, LLC 1 Residential $7,700 $2,065 $9,765 $27,900 0.97 TOTH, CHRISTOPHER IVY HILL PROPERTIES LLC 1 Residential $7,280 $2,135 $9,415 $26,900 1.3 BONDARU, SARATH KRISHNA & TIRUMALAS FARADAY BUILDS LLC 1 Residential $6,545 $2,135 $8,680 $24,800 0 STOKES, IVORY DWYER, TIMOTHY MICHAEL 1 Residential $0 $3,220 $3,220 $9,200 0 CLEVELAND LAND REUTILIZATION PROGRA SMITH, WILLIAM 1 Residential $2,625 $3,360 $5,985 $17,100 2.19 MOR, ALEX A-Z AUTO SALES LLC 1 Residential $6,475 $4,060 $10,535 $30,100 1.25 CALI-LIBA-2, LLC VALLOIRE, LLC 1 Residential $7,385 $3,675 $11,060 $31,600 0 THREE BLACK KNIGHTS LLC GRATTON, LAURIE 1 Residential $12,005 $3,220 $15,225 $43,500 0.32 COMMUNITY RESTORATION CORPORATION BUSH, ANGELA J 1 Residential $7,875 $3,500 $11,375 $32,500 0 COLEMAN, KEITH & KENNETH COLEMAN ADDIE L 1 Residential $7,700 $3,220 $10,920 $31,200 0 FARRIS, SR , KEVIN L ETAL FARRIS DORIS 1 Residential $8,225 $3,675 $11,900 $34,000 1 DRC CONSTRUCTION CO AOB CONSTRUCTION, LLC 1 Residential $8,190 $3,395 $11,585 $33,100 0 HICKS, MEL & MONICA UPGRADW LLC 1 Residential $9,030 $3,675 $12,705 $36,300 0.39 GAITAN, SONIA VINCOY CITIMORTGAGE, INC 1 Residential $6,545 $3,570 $10,115 $28,900 1.11 DILLON, ANDREW NATIONWIDE INVESTMENTS LLC 1 Residential $22,470 $2,800 $25,270 $72,200 0.32 GROVEWOOD PROPERTIES, LLC HOLMES, HILARY A 1 Residential $6,720 $2,975 $9,695 $27,700 0 FANNIE MAE ROBINSON, BLANCHE 1 Residential $16,450 $2,800 $19,250 $55,000 1.55 CAGLAR, LEVENT & ARTAR, EMEL PREMIER HOMES, CLE LLC 1 Residential $14,315 $2,590 $16,905 $48,300 0 FORD, BERNICE & ATKINS, VICKIE & ST STEWART, BEDFORD & FORD, BERNICE & 1 Residential $9,940 $2,800 $12,740 $36,400 0 CUYAHOGA COUNTY LAND REUTILIZATION FEDERAL NATIONAL MORTGAGE ASSOCIATI 1 Residential $18,480 $2,975 $21,455 $61,300 0.46 DIXON, DOUGLAS H DIXON, DOUGLAS H & BISHOP, JENNIFE 1 Residential $18,480 $2,975 $21,455 $61,300 0.46 ABANDONED HOMES PROJECT SCATTERED S DIXON, DOUGLAS H 1 Residential $18,480 $2,975 $21,455 $61,300 0.92 TO INVESTMENTS LLC ABANDONED HOMES PROJECT SCATTERED S 1 Residential $18,480 $2,975 $21,455 $61,300 0 SA CAPITAL LLC TO INVESTMENTS LLC 1 Residential $15,715 $2,975 $18,690 $53,400 1 TATUM, RICKY LANIER, LORENZO 1 Residential $13,335 $2,870 $16,205 $46,300 0.95 OZEKICI, SEDAT OZ, ERHAN 1 Residential $4,025 $2,870 $6,895 $19,700 1 GREEN, II , ARTO MIDWEST PROPERTIES LLC 1 Residential $4,025 $2,870 $6,895 $19,700 0 GREEN, ARTONIA GREEN, II , ARTO 1 Residential $6,335 $2,870 $9,205 $26,300 0 PROFIT, MILTON MELVIN JR PROFIT MILTON M & BRENDA 1 Residential $10,430 $1,610 $12,040 $34,400 1.53 EQUITY TRUST COMPANY CUSTODIAN A 1 REALTY LLC 1 Residential $4,445 $1,505 $5,950 $17,000 0 SECRETARY OF HOUSING & URBAN DEVE PENNYMAC LOAN SERVICES LLC 1 Residential $11,270 $3,150 $14,420 $41,200 0 FEDERAL NATIONAL MORTGAGE ASSOCIATI HILL, RASHAUN 1 Residential $13,405 $3,500 $16,905 $48,300 1 MOORE, GEORGE (TRS) MOORE, JOAN 1 Residential $0 $525 $525 $1,500 0 CLEVELAND LAND REUTILIZATION PROGRA COOPER JR, JOHN H 1 Residential $12,670 $2,660 $15,330 $43,800 0 GRAVES, WILLIAM G GRAVES, VALISHA Page 30 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable Taxable Taxable Taxable Auditor Number of Assessed Assessed Assessed Estimated Total EMV Ratio Filing Parcels Property Building Land Total Market Mult. Recpt. Price to Buyer Seller Number Combined ($) Class Value Value Value Value Est. Mkt. Val. Est. Mkt. Val. Name Name 1 Residential $11,865 $2,555 $14,420 $41,200 0 TAN CAPITAL HOLDINGS LLC GATES, KIMBERLY 1 Residential $8,085 $2,135 $10,220 $29,200 1.52 BEREAN FOUR, LLC SECUREVEST PROPERTIES LLC 1 Residential $2,240 $1,960 $4,200 $12,000 1 ABDULLAH, KAMAL ROBERTSON, JOLYNN 1 Residential $13,195 $2,450 $15,645 $44,700 0 KING, GLENN SR NOWDEN, GLENN 1 Residential $0 $2,065 $2,065 $5,900 0 KING, GLENN SR NOWDEN, GLENN 1 Residential $12,145 $2,450 $14,595 $41,700 0 HERZBRUN, GARY L HERZBRUN, GARY L 1 Residential $10,850 $2,450 $13,300 $38,000 1 MATTHEWS, GALLON AFFORDABLE MEDICAL EDUCATION HOUSIN 1 Residential $13,160 $2,450 $15,610 $44,600 1 HEREFORD, TERRENCE (TRS) DMN OH HOLDINGS LLC 1 Residential $12,705 $2,905 $15,610 $44,600 0.87 MORGAN-CARGO, MARGUERITE MATHIS, MICHAEL 1 Residential $0 $2,450 $2,450 $7,000 0 CLEVELAND LAND REUTILIZATION PROGRA HWIC PROPERTIES, LLC 1 Residential $16,240 $2,450 $18,690 $53,400 0 HOLLOWELL, MERCEDES SADE HOLLOWELL, TARA 1 Residential $13,160 $2,415 $15,575 $44,500 1.1 HOWARD WEST PREMIER INVESTMENT PROPERTIES, LLC 1 Residential $15,575 $3,640 $19,215 $54,900 0.73 ABX INVESTMENTS LLC VANILLA BEAN VENTURES, LLC 1 Residential $15,260 $3,640 $18,900 $54,000 0.11 VASIL, ALFRED J BOWLES, THERESA M 1 Residential $10,920 $4,235 $15,155 $43,300 0.2 CROSSOVER PROPERTIES LLC FINI, LORI A & NIKEIL, JEFFREY M 1 Residential $40,250 $10,885 $51,135 $146,100 0 SCOTT, MARY KAY SCOTT, THOMAS G 1 Residential $5,145 $2,345 $7,490 $21,400 0.23 BILAL, MUHAMMED & BILAL, ISHIA EXR, LLC 1 Residential $5,495 $2,310 $7,805 $22,300 0 MOUNT PLEASANT NOW DEVELOPMENT CORP PLEASANT PROPERTIES, L P 1 Residential $5,495 $2,310 $7,805 $22,300 1.01 BEN HOLDINGS LLC MOUNT PLEASANT NOW DEVELOPMENT CORP 7 Residential $15,995 $2,520 $18,515 $52,900 $305,399 0 LATTIMORE, ROCHELLE A & STITT, M LATTIMORE, FRED TRS 1 Residential $6,335 $1,820 $8,155 $23,300 1 GUGLIARDO, KENISHA ALL STAR RENOVATIONS 1 Residential $6,125 $1,925 $8,050 $23,000 1 SCRUGGS, LATANYA E MITHQALA INVESTMENT LLC 1 Residential $2,940 $2,345 $5,285 $15,100 0 3577 EAST STREET LLC ALEXANDER SHIRLEY V 1 Residential $350 $2,380 $2,730 $7,800 0 CUYAHOGA COUNTY LAND REUTILIZATION TROUTMAN, LYNDA 1 Residential $0 $525 $525 $1,500 0 CLEVELAND LAND REUTILIZATION PROGRA MERK-N-DIRT INC 1 Residential $16,800 $2,415 $19,215 $54,900 0.51 CLEVELAND AM INVESTMENTS, LLC HOLLAMAN, DEOTIS 1 Residential $10,395 $2,485 $12,880 $36,800 0 CUYAHOGA COUNTY LAND REUTILIZATION RICHLI OHIO, LLC 1 Residential $11,445 $2,625 $14,070 $40,200 0 LANKFORD, AMANDA L MILLER, REV VINCENT R 1 Residential $0 $2,730 $2,730 $7,800 0 THE ALEGNA GROUP LLC HAYES, ANGELA D 1 Residential $12,600 $2,800 $15,400 $44,000 0 GLADDEN, CECILIA & ROBIN & CATHERIN GRAY, ANDREW JR 1 Residential $12,425 $2,800 $15,225 $43,500 0 ISAAC, YVONNE R & DARRYL W & BRIAN ISAAC, YVONNE R & ISAAC, DARRYL W-E 1 Residential $7,245 $2,240 $9,485 $27,100 0 BEAVERDAM PROPERTIES MULLINS, CHARLOTTE 1 Residential $350 $1,470 $1,820 $5,200 0.6 KAYODE, STEPHEN OWOYELE AMOF PROPERTIES LLC 1 Residential $4,585 $1,540 $6,125 $17,500 0 SCHACK, ALLEN BABUCH, WALTER 1 Residential $5,670 $2,030 $7,700 $22,000 1 DANIELS, REGINALD & SANDRA SAEED, SIDDIQ 1 Residential $0 $1,785 $1,785 $5,100 0 CLEVELAND LAND REUTILIZATION PROGRA MCQUEEN, AYESHA 1 Residential $8,050 $1,785 $9,835 $28,100 1 ERBAY, SUAYIP DOGAN LANDAVERDE, HECTOR LUIS 1 Residential $2,975 $1,820 $4,795 $13,700 0 SHAVER, DARVINNA DARVIN & DARVINA SHAVER 7 Residential $7,945 $1,995 $9,940 $28,400 $305,399 0 LATTIMORE, ROCHELLE A & STITT, M LATTIMORE, FRED TRS 7 Residential $11,865 $2,240 $14,105 $40,300 $305,399 0 LATTIMORE, ROCHELLE A & STITT, M LATTIMORE, FRED TRS 7 Residential $11,060 $2,450 $13,510 $38,600 $305,399 0 LATTIMORE, ROCHELLE A & STITT, M LATTIMORE, FRED TRS 7 Residential $16,310 $2,590 $18,900 $54,000 $305,399 0 LATTIMORE, ROCHELLE A & STITT, M LATTIMORE, FRED TRS 7 Residential $14,175 $2,555 $16,730 $47,800 $305,399 0 LATTIMORE, ROCHELLE A & STITT, M LATTIMORE, FRED TRS 1 Residential $5,180 $2,940 $8,120 $23,200 0 RODGERS, ROBERT ALLGOOD, JOHN Page 31 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable Taxable Taxable Taxable Auditor Number of Assessed Assessed Assessed Estimated Total EMV Ratio Filing Parcels Property Building Land Total Market Mult. Recpt. Price to Buyer Seller Number Combined ($) Class Value Value Value Value Est. Mkt. Val. Est. Mkt. Val. Name Name 1 Residential $6,370 $1,960 $8,330 $23,800 1 LAUDERDALE, MICHAEL M MELTON, MARLENE 1 Residential $7,560 $1,645 $9,205 $26,300 0 MCCOY, VINCE ETAL EDWARD MCCOY 1 Residential $5,110 $1,750 $6,860 $19,600 0.76 HARRIS, DENISE MIDWEST PROPERTIES LLC 1 Residential $5,740 $1,820 $7,560 $21,600 0 CAEZ, MIGUEL FEDERAL NATIONAL MORTGAGE ASSOCIATI 1 Residential $7,630 $1,925 $9,555 $27,300 0 FEDERAL NATIONAL MORTGAGE ASSOCIATI WASHINGTON WM B 4 Residential $0 $350 $350 $1,000 $74,500 0 MEECH 1, LLC CLOAK & HANGER CLEANERS, LLC 1 Residential $6,475 $1,855 $8,330 $23,800 0.17 MOORE, RAFAEL G LUCINDA HOLDER WITH IPLAN GROUP AS 1 Residential $0 $980 $980 $2,800 12.32 GIBSON AFFORDABLE PROPERTIES LLC KEYBANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION 1 Residential $6,265 $1,505 $7,770 $22,200 0.25 MAKUPSON INVESTMENT CORP LLC WALKER, VIOLA 1 Residential $7,595 $2,240 $9,835 $28,100 0.45 US BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION AS TRU A NEW BEGINNING SOBER LIVING INC 1 Residential $525 $525 $1,050 $3,000 0 DARBY, AMOS JONES SHARON 1 Residential $7,280 $1,820 $9,100 $26,000 0 JOHNSON, JILLIAN FEDERAL HOME LOAN MORTGAGE CORPORAT 1 Residential $6,650 $1,680 $8,330 $23,800 1 EPIC AUTO SALES LLC SMITH, RODNIE C & HICKS, ERICKA D 1 Residential $0 $280 $280 $800 0 GALLOWAY, MELVIN L GALLOWAY, KEVIN M & CAROLYN D 1 Residential $11,095 $2,030 $13,125 $37,500 0 GALLOWAY, MELVIN L GALLOWAY, KEVIN & CAROLYN 1 Residential $350 $525 $875 $2,500 3.21 ASKREN INVESTMENTS LLC RIGHT-A-WAY INVESTMENTS LLC 1 Residential $10,430 $2,170 $12,600 $36,000 1.29 PUNJ PROPETIES, LLC SIMON, JR , FREDERICK J ETAL 1 Residential $8,995 $2,345 $11,340 $32,400 1.77 ELI INVESTING LLC SBAR HOLDINGS LLC 1 Residential $8,085 $2,450 $10,535 $30,100 0.33 DEUTSCHE BANK NATIONAL TRUST COMPAN CHARLES, MARY 1 Residential $7,000 $2,450 $9,450 $27,000 0 13201 GLENDALE PROPERTIES LLC 13201 GLENDALE PROPERTIES LLC 1 Residential $6,825 $2,485 $9,310 $26,600 1 DOWNING, DENISE D COOPER, AKI AND OTIS JR , LEE 1 Residential $5,740 $2,485 $8,225 $23,500 0.85 YEREMIAN, HAROUTIUN SELLERS, EDWARD J SR (ETAL) 1 Residential $10,535 $2,450 $12,985 $37,100 0.43 KMB 1 LLC Q BYRDS LLC 1 Residential $9,590 $2,555 $12,145 $34,700 0 CHAPPELL, YOLANDA ETAL CHAPPELL YVONNE 1 Residential $5,880 $2,380 $8,260 $23,600 0.15 GAMBOA, YUDITH & GAMBOA, RAUL CORE CAPITAL PROPERTIES, LLC 1 Residential $5,740 $2,485 $8,225 $23,500 0.51 NIMMER, JOSEPH GOINS, MONROE B SR 1 Residential $0 $2,380 $2,380 $6,800 0 CLEVELAND LAND REUTILIZATION PROGRA JEFFERSON, ANNA 1 Residential $7,105 $2,240 $9,345 $26,700 2.25 EL TEPE, LLC SIERRA PROPERTY GROUP, LLC 1 Residential $3,850 $2,415 $6,265 $17,900 1 MOSLEY, ONI O LEWIS MOSLEY, JEFFREY 1 Residential $11,305 $2,345 $13,650 $39,000 0 A Z QUALITY CONTRACTING & LANDSCAPI CASTANON, FRANCISCO BUGIDOS 1 Residential $12,460 $3,430 $15,890 $45,400 0.55 WEST, EBONY UZI ZVULUN, LLC 1 Residential $8,645 $2,800 $11,445 $32,700 0 SWEMA REAL ESTATE LLC ENBOM, MATS 1 Residential $17,955 $3,010 $20,965 $59,900 0 ABU YUSRA LIMITED, LLC ELTAYEB, ABDALLA OSMAN 1 Residential $11,235 $2,800 $14,035 $40,100 1 RICHMOND, REGINALD LINDSAY, MELINDA 1 Residential $11,270 $3,010 $14,280 $40,800 1.07 IMMOBILIER CLEVELAND, LLC DOE VENTURES LLC 1 Residential $11,270 $3,010 $14,280 $40,800 1.59 SUNBURST LLC IMMOBILIER CLEVELAND, LLC 1 Residential $9,135 $2,415 $11,550 $33,000 1.18 CQLH ENTERPRISES, LLC GOLD STAR SERIES 6, LLC 1 Residential $9,310 $2,415 $11,725 $33,500 0.6 PARKER PROPERITES UNLTD LLC JJK HOLDING LLC 1 Residential $10,325 $1,540 $11,865 $33,900 0.5 TEFERA, HENOK MCGHEE EBONY 1 Residential $6,300 $2,415 $8,715 $24,900 1 BOYD, AUDREY LAMB, DAWN 1 Residential $7,140 $1,540 $8,680 $24,800 0 KAPPA MANAGEMENT LLC CREATIVE FINANCE 4 ALL LLC 1 Residential $6,090 $1,750 $7,840 $22,400 0 KILLINGSWORTH, NICOLE ETAL KILLINGSWORTH, NICOLE & NYARY ET AL 1 Residential $13,720 $2,170 $15,890 $45,400 0.29 TORRES, MERCEDES EQUITY FIRST FUNDING LLC 1 Residential $9,870 $4,935 $14,805 $42,300 0 GONAZLES, KATHERINE ETAL GONZALES, RALPH Page 32 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable Taxable Taxable Taxable Auditor Number of Assessed Assessed Assessed Estimated Total EMV Ratio Filing Parcels Property Building Land Total Market Mult. Recpt. Price to Buyer Seller Number Combined ($) Class Value Value Value Value Est. Mkt. Val. Est. Mkt. Val. Name Name 1 Residential $7,630 $7,910 $15,540 $44,400 0 AMERICAN DREAM HOLDINGS LLC EIGHT SEVENTEEN PROPERTIES LLC 1 Residential $4,200 $11,060 $15,260 $43,600 8.6 OSTROWSKE, JOSEPH M AND OSTROWSKE, CHELM JAYNA 1 Residential $10,640 $2,695 $13,335 $38,100 2.89 PADGETT, DAVID A & PADGETT, MELI BRASKICH, JR ROBERT A 1 Residential $32,305 $10,325 $42,630 $121,800 1.41 STATES, BRANDON I KRANZ, ROBERT J 1 Residential $0 $0 $0 $0 AYERS, ABBY MANSION SUITES,LLC 1 Residential $14,945 $16,205 $31,150 $89,000 1.48 PEREZ, RAYMOND PEREZ, CONCEPCION JOSE 1 Residential $24,325 $14,175 $38,500 $110,000 0 MARRERO, ANA VELEZ & RASTATTER JR , RASTATTER JR , MICHAEL 1 Residential $0 $4,830 $4,830 $13,800 9.93 STEGER, JADE A HEINES, KRISTIN E 1 Residential $0 $6,755 $6,755 $19,300 12.44 SCHULTZ, CHARLES A & SCHULTZ, MA DIMEGLIO, J CORBIN 1 Residential $0 $6,755 $6,755 $19,300 13.6 MITCHELL, EDWARD CARPENTER, PHILIP R 1 Residential $0 $10,920 $10,920 $31,200 18.93 LEONHARD, KOREY VINE COURT TOWNHOMES LLC 1 Residential $0 $13,300 $13,300 $38,000 17.63 FIELDS, ANGELO & MCLAUGHLIN, MEGAN VINE COURT TOWNHOMES LLC 1 Residential $8,190 $7,525 $15,715 $44,900 5.35 CHERNIKOFF, ROCHELLE A CUI, SHUO 1 Commercial $37,380 $5,495 $42,875 $122,500 2.33 WOODS, MATTHEW JOHN MAURER, CRAIG 3 Residential $0 $2,520 $2,520 $7,200 $257,700 1.47 KOLLAB PROPERTIES, LLC NISER JAMAL 1 Residential $42,245 $11,340 $53,585 $153,100 1.21 LATHAM, CRAIG LOHSER, JACOB A 3 Residential $0 $2,695 $2,695 $7,700 $257,700 1.47 KOLLAB PROPERTIES, LLC NISER, JAMAL 1 Residential $20,860 $6,090 $26,950 $77,000 2.47 VAN DUSEN, GRAHAM C KOKAL, GREGORY A 1 Residential $0 $4,900 $4,900 $14,000 20.86 HELSCHER, CHRISTOPHER M & HELSCHER, B R KNEZ CONSTRUCTION, INC 1 Residential $0 $525 $525 $1,500 0 UCS PROPERTY II LLC PM FOUNDATIONS, INC 1 Residential $9,275 $7,035 $16,310 $46,600 2.88 DELIANIDES, PHILLIP & DELIANIDES, CORDOVES, FRANCISCO 1 Residential $8,225 $6,370 $14,595 $41,700 0 AMF PROPERTIES, LLC BUTLER, JEFFREY AND BUTLER, MARY KA 1 Residential $7,700 $5,845 $13,545 $38,700 7.62 DORENKOTT, BRIAN J CLEVELAND BRICKS LLC 1 Residential $4,130 $5,005 $9,135 $26,100 1.15 CLEVELAND BRICKS LLC RED HORIZON GROUP, LLC 1 Residential $14,490 $7,945 $22,435 $64,100 0.7 JAM HOLDINGS, LLC LENZ, HEATHER 1 Residential $6,720 $2,205 $8,925 $25,500 0 TORRES, MELEEDES KING, MARY DIANE 1 Residential $0 $2,065 $2,065 $5,900 0 CLEVELAND LAND REUTILIZATION PROGRA ZEVEL LLC 1 Commercial $21,385 $4,060 $25,445 $72,700 1.1 AKKATI, VIJAYPAL R & KASARIA, SU FARADAY BUILDS, LLC 1 Commercial $21,385 $4,060 $25,445 $72,700 0 AKKATI, VIJAYPAL R & KASARLA SU AKKATI, VIJAYPAL R & KASARIA, SU 1 Residential $9,485 $2,310 $11,795 $33,700 0 PROSPERCLE, LLC PROSPERCLE, LLC 1 Residential $5,145 $2,275 $7,420 $21,200 2.59 ANCHOR INVESTMENT HOLDINGS, LLC BESAID LLC 1 Commercial $14,000 $5,040 $19,040 $54,400 0.83 ENRIQUEZ, RUDY & ONGRUNGOUNG, PENSR REGNIER, DAVID 1 Residential $13,265 $2,205 $15,470 $44,200 1 HS PLANNING LLC SCHMITZ, STEFAN 1 Residential $0 $7,280 $7,280 $20,800 0 EBNER, MARK D & EBNER,BRONWYN K 1901 FREEMAN LLC 1 Residential $0 $0 $0 $0 MICHAELS, WILLIAM D LIVING IN OHIO CITY, LLC 1 Residential $61,810 $8,715 $70,525 $201,500 0.89 SINGLETON, KARL E JR & YALONDA RE BRADLEY, WANDA RENEE 1 Residential $0 $22,120 $22,120 $63,200 0 ZELLER, TIMOTHY C & LINSAY BROCK ZELLER, TIMOTHY C & LINSAY BROCK 1 Residential $71,960 $7,980 $79,940 $228,400 1 PHILLIP, CHRISTOPHER D HEINEN, DALE AFN201812270224 1 Commercial $48,545 $15,260 $63,805 $182,300 0 R AND V PROPERTY VENTURES LLC RIVILLA, RAPHAEL & VICTOR C AFN201812270222 1 Commercial $48,545 $15,260 $63,805 $182,300 1.67 RIVILLA, RAPHAEL & VICTOR C LIM, GENE M 1 Residential $0 $17,745 $17,745 $50,700 7.69 KWEI, JOSEPH AND ANDERSON, CHRISTIN LEIBOLD, DONNA 1 Residential $0 $16,625 $16,625 $47,500 8.95 BLAZE VENTURE LLC COY JR, WILLIAM V & SUSAN S 1 Residential $0 $16,625 $16,625 $47,500 10 KUMAR, NIKHIL AHMED ALI H & ELIZABETH C CO-TRS 1 Residential $19,565 $22,050 $41,615 $118,900 2.03 KLINE,KAITLIN TRZASKA, MICHAEL J Page 33 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable Taxable Taxable Taxable Auditor Number of Assessed Assessed Assessed Estimated Total EMV Ratio Filing Parcels Property Building Land Total Market Mult. Recpt. Price to Buyer Seller Number Combined ($) Class Value Value Value Value Est. Mkt. Val. Est. Mkt. Val. Name Name 1 Residential $34,020 $20,230 $54,250 $155,000 1.19 DAVIS, HANNAH L THE RALLY GROUP, LLC 1 Residential $0 $3,220 $3,220 $9,200 0 FAIRFIELD REDEVELOPMENT IV LLC KAMIS PROPERTIES, LLC 1 Residential $0 $3,220 $3,220 $9,200 4.35 DOMINGUEZ, JOSE L JR FAIRFIELD REDEVELOPMENT IV LLC 1 Residential $13,440 $5,180 $18,620 $53,200 0.85 WEST ELEVEN LLC CLOUGH, NEIL T 1 Residential $12,600 $2,975 $15,575 $44,500 0.7 MOLINA, LUIS A TORRES, BRENDA 1 Residential $11,305 $2,310 $13,615 $38,900 0.39 STYLISH SPACES, LLC LYLE, INC 1 Residential $6,125 $2,310 $8,435 $24,100 0.58 SUHY, LARRY HURLEY GENE E 1 Residential $0 $490 $490 $1,400 0 CLEVELAND LAND REUTILIZATION PROGRA BARKSDALE, ERIC 1 Residential $3,920 $2,310 $6,230 $17,800 0.39 SCOTT BROCK CLEVELAND, LLC DEUTSCHE BANK NATIONAL TRUST COMPAN 1 Residential $0 $525 $525 $1,500 0 CLEVELAND LAND REUTILIZATION PROGRA WILLIAMS, CYTONIA M 1 Residential $5,495 $1,890 $7,385 $21,100 1.52 TRUE PAIR LLC RAMIREZ, EURIC & VANINETTI, ANGEL 1 Residential $5,495 $1,890 $7,385 $21,100 1.52 OLADIPO, LASEINDE AKINOLA TRUE PAIR LLC 1 Residential $4,130 $1,855 $5,985 $17,100 1 BARRETT, RICHARD CONTINENTAL CONTRACTING CONSTRUCTIO 1 Residential $1,120 $2,100 $3,220 $9,200 0 CUYAHOGA COUNTY LAND REUTILIZATION BROOKS, W R 1 Residential $23,905 $8,820 $32,725 $93,500 1.44 HAMPTON, LENA AND PITTS, MONISA L LARRY CHAUNDRIA 1 Residential $21,035 $7,875 $28,910 $82,600 0.38 GROVEWOOD PROPERTIES, LLC WYLEY CAROLYN 1 Residential $245 $8,890 $9,135 $26,100 0 WILSON, CHRISTOPHER M & WILSON, JR WILSON, TRACY A 1 Commercial $239,330 $53,515 $292,845 $836,700 2.24 KPL DEVELOPMENT, INC AUXANO PROPERTIES LLC 1 Commercial $239,330 $53,515 $292,845 $836,700 2.57 HAMPTON2 LLC KPL DEVELOPMENT, INC 1 Residential $29,505 $9,275 $38,780 $110,800 0 STOVALL, DARRYL D'LYT, SYN 1 Residential $26,530 $9,940 $36,470 $104,200 0.4 DESKINS, NAILA DESKINS-JOHNSON, DOROTHY & GWIN, MA 3 Commercial $67,935 $66,290 $134,225 $383,500 $1,632,100 0 HATZ FOUR LLC SIG SHAKER SUBSIDIARY LLC 18 Commercial $67,935 $66,290 $134,225 $383,500 $9,243,800 0 SIG SHAKER SUBSIDIARY LLC SIG SHAKER SQUARE LLC 8 Commercial $114,905 $44,170 $159,075 $454,500 $3,001,800 0 HATZ THREE LLC SIG SHAKER SUBSIDIARY LLC 18 Commercial $114,905 $44,170 $159,075 $454,500 $9,243,800 0 SIG SHAKER SUBSIDIARY LLC SIG SHAKER SQUARE LLC 8 Commercial $75,915 $14,490 $90,405 $258,300 $3,001,800 0 HATZ THREE LLC SIG SHAKER SUBSIDIARY LLC 18 Commercial $75,915 $14,490 $90,405 $258,300 $9,243,800 0 SIG SHAKER SUBSIDIARY LLC SIG SHAKER SQUARE LLC 3 Commercial $234,535 $34,020 $268,555 $767,300 $1,632,100 0 HATZ FOUR LLC SIG SHAKER SUBSIDIARY LLC 18 Commercial $234,535 $34,020 $268,555 $767,300 $9,243,800 0 SIG SHAKER SUBSIDIARY LLC SIG SHAKER SQUARE LLC 1 Residential $20,650 $2,310 $22,960 $65,600 1.37 SNYDER, KEITH A & SNYDER, GINA M GOOD, BARBARA ANN 1 Residential $24,980 $2,776 $27,755 $79,300 1.98 SAUNDERS, JAMES D MEHLER, EDWARD A 1 Residential $44,100 $4,900 $49,000 $140,000 3.21 CLARK, PAUL G & JILL G BRODKEY, ARIELLE K (TRUSTEE) 1 Residential $13,356 $1,484 $14,840 $42,400 0.46 ERVIN, RICHARD A GELFAND, DANIEL M 1 Residential $19,404 $2,156 $21,560 $61,600 1.62 WAGNER, MARY GRACE & JAMES, CARL G BALBO, THOMAS 4 Commercial $86,555 $31,325 $117,880 $336,800 $2,023,600 0 HATZ TWO LLC SIG SHAKER SUBSIDIARY LLC 18 Commercial $86,555 $31,325 $117,880 $336,800 $9,243,800 0 SIG SHAKER SUBSIDIARY LLC SIG SHAKER SQUARE LLC 4 Commercial $187,565 $33,355 $220,920 $631,200 $2,023,600 0 HATZ TWO LLC SIG SHAKER SUBSIDIARY LLC 18 Commercial $187,565 $33,355 $220,920 $631,200 $9,243,800 0 SIG SHAKER SUBSIDIARY LLC SIG SHAKER SQUARE LLC 3 Commercial $184,765 $36,155 $220,920 $631,200 $2,586,300 0 HATZ ONE LLC SIG SHAKER SUBSIDIARY LLC 18 Commercial $184,765 $36,155 $220,920 $631,200 $9,243,800 0 SIG SHAKER SUBSIDIARY LLC SIG SHAKER SQUARE LLC 3 Commercial $192,465 $29,995 $222,460 $635,600 $2,586,300 0 HATZ ONE LLC SIG SHAKER SUBSIDIARY LLC 18 Commercial $192,465 $29,995 $222,460 $635,600 $9,243,800 0 SIG SHAKER SUBSIDIARY LLC SIG SHAKER SQUARE LLC 3 Commercial $381,115 $80,710 $461,825 $1,319,500 $2,586,300 0 HATZ ONE LLC SIG SHAKER SUBSIDIARY LLC 18 Commercial $381,115 $80,710 $461,825 $1,319,500 $9,243,800 0 SIG SHAKER SUBSIDIARY LLC SIG SHAKER SQUARE LLC Page 34 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable Taxable Taxable Taxable Auditor Number of Assessed Assessed Assessed Estimated Total EMV Ratio Filing Parcels Property Building Land Total Market Mult. Recpt. Price to Buyer Seller Number Combined ($) Class Value Value Value Value Est. Mkt. Val. Est. Mkt. Val. Name Name 4 Commercial $151,130 $33,600 $184,730 $527,800 $2,023,600 0 HATZ TWO LLC SIG SHAKER SUBSIDIARY LLC 18 Commercial $151,130 $33,600 $184,730 $527,800 $9,243,800 0 SIG SHAKER SUBSIDIARY LLC SIG SHAKER SQUARE LLC 4 Commercial $143,535 $41,195 $184,730 $527,800 $2,023,600 0 HATZ TWO LLC SIG SHAKER SUBSIDIARY LLC 18 Commercial $143,535 $41,195 $184,730 $527,800 $9,243,800 0 SIG SHAKER SUBSIDIARY LLC SIG SHAKER SQUARE LLC 1 Residential $8,085 $2,800 $10,885 $31,100 0 SUTTON, HASSAN L SUTTON, HASSAN L & SUTTON, TRACI 1 Residential $7,770 $770 $8,540 $24,400 1 316 RIVERSIDE LLC BOYD, ALAIYNA 1 Commercial $10,640 $1,470 $12,110 $34,600 3.61 NIDAL MANAGEMENT LLC PREMIER INVESTMENT PROPERTIES LLC 1 Residential $1,855 $2,170 $4,025 $11,500 0 JERNIGAN, DEBRA MURPHY, STELLA L 1 Residential $1,855 $2,170 $4,025 $11,500 0 MURPHY, STELLA L MURPHY, LEWIS 1 Residential $5,075 $2,555 $7,630 $21,800 0.46 US BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION AS TRU BARROW, GARY & DELOIS 1 Residential $4,130 $2,100 $6,230 $17,800 0.56 T D REALTY LLC THE BANK OF NEW YORK MELLON 1 Residential $6,370 $2,100 $8,470 $24,200 0.87 BWB LIFE, LLC GREEN PEARL & CHARLES WALTER 1 Residential $3,500 $2,275 $5,775 $16,500 0 11313 PARKVIEW AVENUE LLC SMITH, RONDA 1 Residential $4,830 $1,820 $6,650 $19,000 1 SMITH & PRICE FAMILY INVESTMENTS SMITH, JAKE 7 Residential $12,530 $2,660 $15,190 $43,400 $305,399 0 LATTIMORE, ROCHELLE A & STITT, M LATTIMORE, FRED TRS 1 Residential $6,265 $1,925 $8,190 $23,400 0 TRUST GOD INVESTMENTS LLC COUSIN, DAVID A SR 1 Residential $15,505 $2,415 $17,920 $51,200 1.95 DIVVY HOMES WAREHOUSE I, LLC BATTS, E EILEEN TRUSTEE 1 Residential $5,530 $2,100 $7,630 $21,800 0 3118 EAST 94TH STREET TRUST SANDERS SCOTT 1 Residential $5,145 $2,170 $7,315 $20,900 1 MOORE, MARIO MOORE, JOHAH 1 Residential $8,015 $2,100 $10,115 $28,900 0 NOBLES, GLADYS EZELL MANAGEMENT LLC 1 Residential $6,790 $2,170 $8,960 $25,600 0 I IMAN ENTERPRISES, LLC MUMIN, SULIEMAN MANSUR 1 Residential $7,665 $1,960 $9,625 $27,500 0 PUBLIC SQUARE CAPITAL RE, LLC EDMONDS, FRANK III 1 Residential $6,580 $1,715 $8,295 $23,700 1 ABDULLAH, KAMAL SHAHEED, MOHMOUD 1 Residential $6,580 $1,715 $8,295 $23,700 0 ABDULLAH, KAMAL ABDULLAH, KAMAL 1 Residential $6,580 $1,715 $8,295 $23,700 0.68 SBAR HOLDINGS LLC ABDULLAH, KAMAL 1 Residential $7,315 $2,415 $9,730 $27,800 0.83 KEYBANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION EVANS HERMAN A & JULIA M 1 Residential $7,105 $2,415 $9,520 $27,200 0.37 HORNE, GROVER BANKS, SARAH L 1 Residential $8,190 $2,415 $10,605 $30,300 0 EVANS, CORA A EVANS, LILLIAN B 1 Residential $8,190 $2,415 $10,605 $30,300 0 EVANS, LILLIAN B EVANS T C & LILLIAN B 1 Residential $8,190 $2,415 $10,605 $30,300 1 HMEIDAN, MOHAMMED BADER EVANS, CORA A 1 Residential $5,460 $2,275 $7,735 $22,100 1 SHARPE, DONTEZ SMITH, NANCY 1 Residential $420 $2,415 $2,835 $8,100 11.05 SAXON, OLA L KERCO, LLC 1 Residential $0 $2,485 $2,485 $7,100 0 CLEVELAND LAND REUTILIZATION PROGRA HILL, TANISHA 4 Residential $6,930 $1,960 $8,890 $25,400 $118,600 0 GUARDIAN FUND, LLC HOME PARTNERS LLC 4 Residential $6,930 $1,960 $8,890 $25,400 $118,600 2.11 PHILLIPS, KENT L & PHILLIPS, PATRI GUARDIAN FUND, LLC 1 Residential $6,965 $2,240 $9,205 $26,300 0 MAKUPSON, DARRELL PCD MANAGEMENT, LLC 1 Residential $7,350 $2,100 $9,450 $27,000 1 JOHNSON, CAJUANUS L JOHNSON, MICHAEL T 1 Residential $11,235 $2,905 $14,140 $40,400 0.25 MLC INVESTMENT PROPERTIES, LLC THE HUNTINGTON NATIONAL BANK 1 Residential $6,300 $3,395 $9,695 $27,700 0 THREE BLACK KNIGHTS LLC MT PLEASANT HOMES III LP 1 Residential $6,580 $2,450 $9,030 $25,800 1.86 SHEALY, BERNARD L CHAMBLISS JR , ALFORNIECE 1 Residential $7,630 $2,485 $10,115 $28,900 0 MCMILLON DEVELOPMENT LLC MCMILLON, LAWRENCE 1 Residential $10,570 $2,485 $13,055 $37,300 0 THOMPSON, JULIUS W THOMPSON, JULIA ANN 1 Residential $9,905 $2,485 $12,390 $35,400 0.54 RD MANAGEMENT GROUP, LLC FULSE, PRESCOTT 1 Residential $8,855 $2,555 $11,410 $32,600 0.77 LAKEVIEW LOAN SERVICING LLC KING, TATIANNA D Page 35 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable Taxable Taxable Taxable Auditor Number of Assessed Assessed Assessed Estimated Total EMV Ratio Filing Parcels Property Building Land Total Market Mult. Recpt. Price to Buyer Seller Number Combined ($) Class Value Value Value Value Est. Mkt. Val. Est. Mkt. Val. Name Name 4 Residential $7,770 $1,120 $8,890 $25,400 $102,400 0.05 FARADAY BUILDS LLC LOVELACE, VONNETTE & SHONDA 4 Residential $7,770 $1,260 $9,030 $25,800 $102,400 0.05 FARADAY BUILDS LLC LOVELACE, VONNETTE & SHONDA 4 Residential $7,770 $1,120 $8,890 $25,400 $102,400 0.05 FARADAY BUILDS LLC LOVELACE, VONNETTE & SHONDA 4 Residential $7,770 $1,260 $9,030 $25,800 $102,400 0.05 FARADAY BUILDS LLC LOVELACE, VONNETTE & SHONDA 2 Residential $11,270 $2,345 $13,615 $38,900 $65,999 0 GUARDIAN FUND, LLC HOME PARTNERS LLC 2 Residential $11,270 $2,345 $13,615 $38,900 $65,999 2 HOME PARTNERS LLC HOME PARTNERS LLC 1 Residential $5,915 $2,345 $8,260 $23,600 0 M BEAR REALTY INVESTMENTS LLC M A REALTY INVESTMENTS, LLC 1 Residential $6,510 $2,065 $8,575 $24,500 0.55 PARKER PROPERTIES UNLIMITED LLC CRUMPTON, REGINALD LYNN JR 1 Residential $0 $525 $525 $1,500 0 CLEVELAND LAND REUTILIZATION PROGRA COLLINS, MARIO 1 Residential $6,720 $2,555 $9,275 $26,500 0 GRIMES, VERSHAWN JACKSON, CHARLES L 1 Residential $5,250 $2,345 $7,595 $21,700 0.65 SIERRA PROPERTY GROUP, LLC TRUSTWORTHY CONSTRUCTION 1 Residential $5,320 $2,345 $7,665 $21,900 0.64 SIERRA PROPERTY GROUP, LLC TASHARA HOME CARE SERVICES 1 Residential $10,395 $2,345 $12,740 $36,400 0 WEN, AHSE CODY, LILLIE B & WEN, ASHE 1 Residential $4,025 $2,275 $6,300 $18,000 0 FEDERAL HOME LOAN MORTGAGE CORPORAT EMBRY, PEGGY ANN 1 Residential $7,700 $2,240 $9,940 $28,400 2.11 KAPPA MANAGEMENT LLC G&M INVESTMENTS LLC 1 Residential $16,275 $3,010 $19,285 $55,100 1.14 MAKAKAUFAKI, SIAOSI SINGH, DAVID C 1 Residential $5,285 $2,345 $7,630 $21,800 1.7 NAHUM, ASHIR SEMBIRA PARRISH JR , FREDDIE L & MICHELLE 1 Residential $0 $1,960 $1,960 $5,600 4.6 SPEARS, TYRONE C CHN HOUSING PARTNERS 1 Residential $11,480 $1,645 $13,125 $37,500 0.63 LLOYD, NICOLE MARIE CLEVELAND HOUSING NETWORK INC 1 Residential $17,045 $1,890 $18,935 $54,100 0.48 PATTERSON, LEVI J CLEVELAND HOUSING NETWORK INC 1 Residential $13,545 $2,030 $15,575 $44,500 0.58 DUDLEY, JENNIFER M CLEVELAND HOUSING NETWORK INC 1 Residential $2,800 $1,750 $4,550 $13,000 0 SIMS, DAVID E DUNLAP VICTORIA R 1 Commercial $350 $1,925 $2,275 $6,500 1 TORRES, ANTHONY HERNANDEZ, ALEX J 1 Residential $5,075 $1,610 $6,685 $19,100 0 PAVICH, NICK PAVICH, JOHN 1 Residential $3,780 $1,715 $5,495 $15,700 0 UDOVIC, MARGARET UDOVIC, MARGARET & OBUSZEWSKI, KENN 1 Residential $5,705 $2,205 $7,910 $22,600 1 TURNER, WADE OGR HOUSES, LLC ETAL 1 Commercial $191,520 $41,720 $233,240 $666,400 0 PLAZA SUITES CLEVELAND LLC FIRST PROSPECT DEVELOPMENT, LLC 1 Residential $4,375 $8,820 $13,195 $37,700 1.33 2193 E 35TH, LLC WU, YONG & YU, WEI JING 1 Residential $0 $11,235 $11,235 $32,100 0 GREEN, GLENDA JOHNSON, ALTHEA & JOHNSON-GREEN GL 1 Residential $35,630 $7,455 $43,085 $123,100 0.49 WELLS FARGO BANK NA BOGAN, WAYNE 1 Residential $1,610 $1,225 $2,835 $8,100 0 STALLWORTH, JUDY S & PEACOCK, DA PEACOCK, DOROTHY D 1 Residential $15,470 $2,100 $17,570 $50,200 0.46 GREATER CLEVELAND HABITAT FOR HUMAN SIMON, SHARONDA 2 Commercial $700 $1,050 $1,750 $5,000 $5,500 0 CITY OF CLEVELAND ET AL THE ZONE, LLC ET AL 2 Commercial $700 $1,050 $1,750 $5,000 $5,500 0.61 THE ZONE, LLC ET AL THE ZONE, LLC ET AL 2 Commercial $700 $1,050 $1,750 $5,000 $5,500 0.61 THE ZONE, LLC ET AL THE ZONE, LLC ET AL 2 Commercial $700 $1,050 $1,750 $5,000 $5,500 1.23 THE ZONE, LLC ET AL SIMUEL, ROBERT ET AL 2 Commercial $0 $175 $175 $500 $5,500 0 CITY OF CLEVELAND ET AL THE ZONE, LLC ET AL 2 Commercial $0 $175 $175 $500 $5,500 0.61 THE ZONE, LLC ET AL THE ZONE, LLC ET AL 2 Commercial $0 $175 $175 $500 $5,500 0.61 THE ZONE, LLC ET AL THE ZONE, LLC ET AL 2 Commercial $0 $175 $175 $500 $5,500 1.23 THE ZONE, LLC ET AL SIMUEL, ROBERT ET AL 2 Residential $0 $525 $525 $1,500 $52,500 1.2 PEACOCK, KATHY PODSEDLY, DAVID E & PODSEDLY, NA 2 Residential $15,610 $2,240 $17,850 $51,000 $52,500 1.2 PEACOCK, KATHY PODSEDLY, DAVID E 1 Residential $11,305 $1,470 $12,775 $36,500 1 WILSON, ROBERT O JR AULT, RONALD F 1 Residential $7,525 $1,470 $8,995 $25,700 0.77 JACKSON, SHELLE M CHN HOUSING PARTNERS Page 36 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable Taxable Taxable Taxable Auditor Number of Assessed Assessed Assessed Estimated Total EMV Ratio Filing Parcels Property Building Land Total Market Mult. Recpt. Price to Buyer Seller Number Combined ($) Class Value Value Value Value Est. Mkt. Val. Est. Mkt. Val. Name Name 1 Residential $17,675 $5,985 $23,660 $67,600 0 ALEXANDER II, ALFRED AND ALEXANDER ALEXANDER, ALFRED 1 Residential $16,065 $7,035 $23,100 $66,000 0 ALEXANDER II, ALFRED AND ALEXANDER ALEXANDER, ALFRED SR 1 Residential $22,855 $6,650 $29,505 $84,300 0 ALEXANDER II, ALFRED AND ALEXANDER ALEXANDER, ALFRED SR 1 Residential $39,480 $7,770 $47,250 $135,000 0.81 LUDWIG, JESSICA & GOODWIN, EDWARD MONOCLE GO LLC 1 Residential $12,880 $5,285 $18,165 $51,900 1 COE, STEPHANIE L ROBINSON, ANN & PARKER, IZE 1 Residential $13,300 $5,775 $19,075 $54,500 1 FLETCHER RENOVATIONS LLC RILEY, BRENDA PAYNE 1 Residential $16,730 $5,775 $22,505 $64,300 0.22 DISTINCTION GROUP LLC EQUITY TRUST COMPANY 1 Residential $17,640 $5,740 $23,380 $66,800 0 ALEXANDER II, ALFRED AND ALEXANDER ALEXANDER, ALFRED 1 Residential $15,050 $5,740 $20,790 $59,400 0 ALEXANDER II, ALFRED AND ALEXANDER ALEXANDER, ALFRED 1 Residential $25,340 $8,365 $33,705 $96,300 0.26 CHAMBERS, DARLING AUSTIN, DARETHA, & CHAMBERS, DARLEN 1 Residential $0 $1,260 $1,260 $3,600 10.31 CORNERSTONE RENOVATIONS LLC PETERSON, CHAMIA 1 Residential $2,625 $1,925 $4,550 $13,000 0 THE ALEGNA GROUP LLC HAYES, ANGELA D 1 Residential $5,250 $1,785 $7,035 $20,100 0 GIBBS, MARIAN C GIBBS, LUTHER O 8 Commercial $274,365 $17,185 $291,550 $833,000 $3,001,800 0 HATZ THREE LLC SIG SHAKER SUBSIDIARY LLC 18 Commercial $274,365 $17,185 $291,550 $833,000 $9,243,800 0 SIG SHAKER SUBSIDIARY LLC SIG SHAKER SQUARE LLC 8 Commercial $0 $13,230 $13,230 $37,800 $3,001,800 0 HATZ THREE LLC SIG SHAKER SUBSIDIARY LLC 18 Commercial $0 $13,230 $13,230 $37,800 $9,243,800 0 SIG SHAKER SUBSIDIARY LLC SIG SHAKER SQUARE LLC 8 Commercial $0 $13,230 $13,230 $37,800 $3,001,800 0 HATZ THREE LLC SIG SHAKER SUBSIDIARY LLC 18 Commercial $0 $13,230 $13,230 $37,800 $9,243,800 0 SIG SHAKER SUBSIDIARY LLC SIG SHAKER SQUARE LLC 8 Commercial $311,150 $39,690 $350,840 $1,002,400 $3,001,800 0 HATZ THREE LLC SIG SHAKER SUBSIDIARY LLC 18 Commercial $311,150 $39,690 $350,840 $1,002,400 $9,243,800 0 SIG SHAKER SUBSIDIARY LLC SIG SHAKER SQUARE LLC 8 Commercial $105,735 $13,335 $119,070 $340,200 $3,001,800 0 HATZ THREE LLC SIG SHAKER SUBSIDIARY LLC 18 Commercial $105,735 $13,335 $119,070 $340,200 $9,243,800 0 SIG SHAKER SUBSIDIARY LLC SIG SHAKER SQUARE LLC 1 Commercial $27,090 $14,560 $41,650 $119,000 0 LANDES, RAKEFET SHAKERTOWN APT LTD , 1 Residential $7,000 $2,135 $9,135 $26,100 1 SMITH & PRICE FAMILY INVESTMENTS LL SIZEMORE, WILLIAM S 1 Residential $5,320 $2,310 $7,630 $21,800 1 GILLIAM, BRANDON FORD, KEITH 1 Residential $735 $665 $1,400 $4,000 1 THOMAS, DAVID HUGHES, CYNTHIA E 1 Residential $1,120 $735 $1,855 $5,300 0.63 WELLS FARGO BANK NA SHORTER, JULIA MAE 1 Residential $0 $2,765 $2,765 $7,900 11.39 BELCHER, LAQUITA GREATER CLEVELAND HABITAT FOR HUMAN 1 Commercial $13,930 $1,820 $15,750 $45,000 0.89 MREV SHAKER HEIGHTS LLC HARMON, SOPHIA B 1 Residential $3,710 $2,940 $6,650 $19,000 4.24 AMY HINSON INVESTMENTS, LLC AND DEC PREMIER INVESTMENT PROPERTIES, LLC 1 Residential $175 $2,205 $2,380 $6,800 0.5 LIGHT, JOSEPH LIGHT LEVAN 1 Residential $5,845 $2,240 $8,085 $23,100 0 LEE, DOROTHEA A ROBERT ARNOLD 1 Residential $4,725 $1,820 $6,545 $18,700 1 FARHADI, SHAHRIAR JASON WILLIAMS, CHRISTIAN LEE 1 Residential $10,710 $2,030 $12,740 $36,400 0.62 TEFERA, HENOK MANA REAL ESTATE, LLC AFN201812280371 1 Residential $6,860 $2,100 $8,960 $25,600 0 FOXWORTH, CHRISTOPHER J FOXWORTH-APPLING, TARA 1 Residential $5,705 $2,520 $8,225 $23,500 1 MUTALA, KILADI N & THELMA GOMEZ, MATTHEW 1 Commercial $4,235 $3,045 $7,280 $20,800 1 ROBERTS, KIANA B MORHAVEN REAL ESTATE INVESTMENT GRO 1 Residential $29,120 $2,660 $31,780 $90,800 0.51 WELLS FARGO BANK, N A SPRATT, SHAWANA T 1 Residential $6,860 $1,960 $8,820 $25,200 0 ANDERSON, MILTON & MONICA CUYAHOGA COUNTY LAND REUTILIZATION 1 Residential $3,780 $3,290 $7,070 $20,200 0 SMITH, VALERIE SMITH, ROSETTA 1 Residential $175 $4,235 $4,410 $12,600 1 MCCOY, ANGELO STUBBS, DAISJA 1 Residential $1,470 $2,625 $4,095 $11,700 1 MCCOY, ANGELO COLE KYANN 1 Residential $8,610 $2,695 $11,305 $32,300 0.77 LAKE FINANCIAL SOLUTIONS LLC LETOURNEAU, BRIAN PAUL Page 37 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable Taxable Taxable Taxable Auditor Number of Assessed Assessed Assessed Estimated Total EMV Ratio Filing Parcels Property Building Land Total Market Mult. Recpt. Price to Buyer Seller Number Combined ($) Class Value Value Value Value Est. Mkt. Val. Est. Mkt. Val. Name Name 1 Residential $8,610 $2,695 $11,305 $32,300 1.08 IMMOBILIER CLEVELAND LLC LAKE FINANCIAL SOLUTIONS LLC 1 Residential $8,610 $2,695 $11,305 $32,300 1.77 SUNBURST LLC IMMOBILIER CLEVELAND LLC 1 Residential $9,905 $1,785 $11,690 $33,400 0 JONES, SALINA JONES, YOLANDA 1 Residential $0 $1,575 $1,575 $4,500 0 CLEVELAND LAND REUTILIZATION PROGRA BRYANT CLARENCE BOB 1 Residential $6,860 $2,065 $8,925 $25,500 0 CUNNINGHAM JR , CHARLIE E WARREN ANNIE M 1 Residential $910 $1,715 $2,625 $7,500 1.67 SWEJO REAL ESTATE LLC PINCZUK, DANIEL 1 Residential $9,800 $1,890 $11,690 $33,400 0.25 ASKREN INVESTMENTS LLC KAJA HOLDINGS 2, LLC 2 Residential $7,560 $1,925 $9,485 $27,100 $65,999 0 MCKINLEY, DAVID J GUARDIAN FUND, LLC 2 Residential $7,560 $1,925 $9,485 $27,100 $65,999 2 GUARDIAN FUND, LLC HOME PARTNERS, LLC 1 Residential $6,265 $1,680 $7,945 $22,700 0 PHIPPS, NICHOLAS OHIO EQUITY PROJECT LLC 1 Residential $6,265 $1,680 $7,945 $22,700 1.37 OHIO EQUITY PROJECT LLC COMBRINK, IGNATIUS LEOPOLDUS 2 Residential $0 $1,330 $1,330 $3,800 $25,100 0 WALTON, TAMMIE STORER, JIMMIE L 2 Residential $5,985 $1,470 $7,455 $21,300 $25,100 0 WALTON, TAMMIE STORER, JIMMIE L 1 Residential $26,565 $14,140 $40,705 $116,300 0 FIORILLI, FRANK FIORILLI FRANK 1 Residential $23,590 $14,140 $37,730 $107,800 0 FIORILLI, FRANK FIORILLI FRANK F 1 Residential $6,825 $1,645 $8,470 $24,200 0 WILLIAMS, JENNIFER L & CLARENCE L WILLIAMS, JENNIFER 2 Residential $12,460 $14,000 $26,460 $75,600 $153,700 0 CAPORALE, LOUIS (ET AL) CAPORALE, DOMENIC & THERESA 2 Residential $13,335 $14,000 $27,335 $78,100 $153,700 0 CAPORALE, LOUIS (ET AL) CAPORALE, DOMENIC & THERESA 1 Residential $59,675 $6,615 $66,290 $189,400 0 FIORILLI, FRANK FIORILLI, FRANK 1 Residential $75,705 $8,400 $84,105 $240,300 1.25 KENNEDY, ROBERT J KABAT, ANDREW A 1 Residential $25,025 $14,350 $39,375 $112,500 0 KEMPEROAK FIRST, LLC HO, SHIH-SHIAN 1 Residential $27,475 $3,045 $30,520 $87,200 0.92 SUN, BOWEN KHOSLA, CHANDA S 1 Residential $3,850 $2,310 $6,160 $17,600 0 VJH HOMES LLC BYRGE, GLEN ET AL 1 Residential $53,865 $5,950 $59,815 $170,900 0.98 TINGLE, MARISA R & GALEN N SNYDER, DONALD A 1 Residential $4,690 $2,800 $7,490 $21,400 0 HU, YU HUA MAI, JING 1 Residential $12,075 $1,400 $13,475 $38,500 0.81 O'CONNOR, AUGUST SEAN YAZHIN, DMITRY 1 Residential $4,235 $4,830 $9,065 $25,900 0.26 THE BANK OF NEW YORK MELLON HENDERSON, MICHAEL 1 Residential $0 $1,855 $1,855 $5,300 24.51 TEID, RAYNEIA T CORNERSTONE RENOVATIONS LLC 1 Residential $3,430 $2,485 $5,915 $16,900 0 BUCKLEY, INA GRACE & LUTRICIA BUCKLEY INA GRACE 1 Residential $2,380 $1,015 $3,395 $9,700 1 NOTTINGHAM CAPITAL LLC TECHNOBEACON OHIO PARTNERS LLP 1 Residential $5,110 $1,435 $6,545 $18,700 0 HOPKINS, LEROY HOPKINS LEROY & HOPKINS FLORIDA 1 Residential $5,110 $1,435 $6,545 $18,700 0 HOPKINS-EBERHARDT, GWENZELL-ETAL HOPKINS, LEROY 1 Residential $5,110 $1,435 $6,545 $18,700 0 HOPKINS, LEROY S HOPKINS, LEROY S 1 Residential $5,110 $1,435 $6,545 $18,700 0 HOPKINS, LEROY S HOPKINS-EBERHARDT, GWENZELL-ETAL 1 Commercial $350 $1,470 $1,820 $5,200 0 CUYAHOGA COUNTY LAND REUTILIZATION JONES JOHN H 1 Residential $5,040 $1,820 $6,860 $19,600 0 GREEN, R B GREEN R B & LILLIE JEAN 1 Residential $0 $1,820 $1,820 $5,200 0 GREEN, R B GREEN R B & L J 1 Residential $0 $1,820 $1,820 $5,200 0 GREEN, R B GREEN, R B 1 Commercial $8,295 $2,065 $10,360 $29,600 0 GREEN, R B GREEN R B & L J 1 Residential $0 $1,715 $1,715 $4,900 0 GREEN, R B GREEN R B 1 Residential $5,635 $1,855 $7,490 $21,400 0 GREEN, JAMES G & GREEN, SCOTTEDWAR STATE OF OHIO FORF CV # 867131 1 Residential $5,215 $1,750 $6,965 $19,900 1 BRISKER, VALERIE L BRISKER, EVELYN ,LIFE EST 1 Residential $0 $3,325 $3,325 $9,500 0 CLEVELAND LAND REUTILIZATION PROGRA ROSS, ARCHI 1 Residential $8,505 $1,365 $9,870 $28,200 0 FLIP ONE LLC CUYAHOGA COUNTY LAND BANK Page 38 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable Taxable Taxable Taxable Auditor Number of Assessed Assessed Assessed Estimated Total EMV Ratio Filing Parcels Property Building Land Total Market Mult. Recpt. Price to Buyer Seller Number Combined ($) Class Value Value Value Value Est. Mkt. Val. Est. Mkt. Val. Name Name 1 Residential $6,195 $1,645 $7,840 $22,400 1 WRIGHT, MICHAEL HARRIS, CATHY 1 Residential $5,320 $1,785 $7,105 $20,300 0 FEDERAL NATIONAL MORTGAGE ASSOCIATI WILSON, RAMONA 1 Residential $4,690 $1,680 $6,370 $18,200 1.65 RXB VENTURES LLC RODGERS, VIOLA L 1 Residential $8,925 $1,610 $10,535 $30,100 0 FEDERAL HOME LOAN MORTGAGE CORPORAT SILER, LORNA C 1 Residential $0 $700 $700 $2,000 0 CRAIN, VERLENER ETAL ADAMS, MATTIE MAE 1 Residential $0 $805 $805 $2,300 0 CRAIN, VERLENER ETAL ADAMS, MATTIE M 1 Residential $0 $210 $210 $600 0 CRAIN, VERLENER ETAL ADAMS, MATTIE MAE 1 Residential $7,245 $3,500 $10,745 $30,700 0 CRAIN, VERLENER ETAL ADAMS, MATTIE M 1 Residential $0 $840 $840 $2,400 0 CRAIN, VERLENER ETAL ADAMS, MATTIE M 1 Residential $0 $735 $735 $2,100 0 CRAIN, VERLENER ETAL ADAMS, MATTIE M 1 Residential $0 $525 $525 $1,500 0 STOVALL, AJ STOVALL BENJAMIN F 1 Residential $70,595 $8,960 $79,555 $227,300 0 MACON, ESTHER MACON, ESTHER & CLARK, MICHELE JE 1 Residential $4,060 $1,120 $5,180 $14,800 1.28 PARKER PROPERTIES UNLIMITED LLC COLEMAN, ROBIN C 1 Residential $4,620 $1,085 $5,705 $16,300 1.1 SANDERS, DWAYNE MOUNTAINSIDE REALTY VENTURES LLC 1 Residential $20,965 $1,225 $22,190 $63,400 0 BROWN, PAUL DYER, CLARA M 1 Residential $5,670 $1,085 $6,755 $19,300 0 LANIGAN, JOSEPH A LOVRINIC, ROBERT 1 Residential $3,325 $840 $4,165 $11,900 1.32 WILEY, SHAUNTAY A CLEVELAND HOUSING NETWORK INC 1 Residential $3,675 $1,155 $4,830 $13,800 0.36 M&S REAL ESTATE, LLC HOCEVAR, JOSEPH V 1 Residential $14,980 $560 $15,540 $44,400 0.29 BAGWELL, KEISHA L CLEVELAND HOUSING NETWORK INC 1 Residential $3,570 $1,155 $4,725 $13,500 0 JOHNSON, ANTIONETTE G TULLIO JR , JOHN R SUC-TRS 1 Residential $9,940 $1,050 $10,990 $31,400 0.38 P&S CASHFLOW PROPERTIES LLC SEVEN MILE INVESTMENTS, LLC 1 Residential $14,805 $980 $15,785 $45,100 1 CARTER, JUANITA CASSEL, DAVON 1 Residential $2,415 $980 $3,395 $9,700 0.77 COLE, PAUL PCM REAL ESTATE, LLC 1 Residential $4,900 $2,765 $7,665 $21,900 2.51 MOMO COMPANY, LLC GARDNER, MELEA L 1 Residential $6,300 $1,505 $7,805 $22,300 1.75 OZEKICI, SEDAT AJR MILLENNIOM, LLC 1 Residential $2,660 $5,250 $7,910 $22,600 0.71 DAVIS, DAVE KOWALSKY, ROBERT ALAN 1 Residential $3,885 $3,710 $7,595 $21,700 1.25 MJB INVESMENT PROPERTIES LLC WILMINGTON SAVINGS FUND SOCIETY FSB 1 Residential $9,275 $3,675 $12,950 $37,000 0 COSTANTINI, DOMINIC & SORIANO, ANA COSTANTINI, ANTONIO 1 Residential $16,975 $2,975 $19,950 $57,000 0.53 MJB INVESTMENT PROP LLC ALLEN, SONYA 1 Residential $8,505 $3,045 $11,550 $33,000 1.21 ANTAR, AVRAHAM KARDER INVESTMENTS, LTD 2 Residential $12,145 $2,975 $15,120 $43,200 $44,100 1.31 SEMBIRA, AYELET REHAB KINGS, LLC 1 Residential $10,325 $3,185 $13,510 $38,600 0.52 PREMIER INVESTMENT PROPERTIES LLC COBBIEN, CAROLYN D 2 Residential $9,520 $2,695 $12,215 $34,900 $35,800 1.62 MY SWEET ESTATE LLC SBAR HOLDINGS LLC 2 Residential $0 $315 $315 $900 $35,800 1.62 MY SWEET ESTATE LLC SBAR HOLDINGS LLC 1 Residential $11,130 $2,975 $14,105 $40,300 1.14 NOAM HERZ, LLC SIMS, DAVID E 1 Residential $3,115 $1,365 $4,480 $12,800 0 MADDOX, DEBANIECE A MADDOX JOHN W 1 Residential $22,155 $7,875 $30,030 $85,800 0 MANNING, GARY B MANNING, GARY B & GAINELLE D 1 Residential $5,250 $1,925 $7,175 $20,500 1 SH HOLDINGS LLC PAPAGEORGE, FOTIOS 2 Residential $22,680 $15,785 $38,465 $109,900 $129,300 0 MOODRY, JUDITH F MOODRY, ANDREW J 1 Residential $9,135 $4,305 $13,440 $38,400 0 HERNANDEZ, DANIEL KILROY, ELIZABETH 1 Residential $8,330 $1,680 $10,010 $28,600 0 FEDERAL NATIONAL MORTGAGE ASSOCIATI GENMONCHA, LLC 1 Residential $6,545 $1,680 $8,225 $23,500 0 CUYAHOGA COUNTY LAND REUTILIZATION TSE PROPERTIES, LLC 1 Residential $5,845 $6,160 $12,005 $34,300 0 MOURZINE, INGRIDA J YANUSHAUSKIENE, ELENA 1 Residential $15,190 $6,895 $22,085 $63,100 0.46 WILMINGTON SAVINGS FUND SOCIETY FSB DANIELSON, MARY ANN Page 39 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable Taxable Taxable Taxable Auditor Number of Assessed Assessed Assessed Estimated Total EMV Ratio Filing Parcels Property Building Land Total Market Mult. Recpt. Price to Buyer Seller Number Combined ($) Class Value Value Value Value Est. Mkt. Val. Est. Mkt. Val. Name Name 1 Residential $8,855 $3,360 $12,215 $34,900 0 LAYTON, DAN HUNTMERE AVENUE TRUST, OHIO HOUSES 1 Residential $14,630 $2,975 $17,605 $50,300 0 COLEMAN, HOWARD WITHERSPOON, RHENETTA 1 Residential $35 $3,780 $3,815 $10,900 11.46 NORMAN, BRENDA GREENE MYREIA LLC 1 Residential $15,435 $3,115 $18,550 $53,000 0 RSN HOLDINGS DELAWARE LLC ES4 INVESTMENTS, LLC (VENDOR) 1 Residential $11,795 $3,535 $15,330 $43,800 0 OJ'S CONSTRUCTION INC CUYAHOGA COUNTY LAND REUTILIZATION 2 Residential $12,250 $3,850 $16,100 $46,000 $131,400 0.72 RSN HOLDINGS DELAWARE LLC BERES ADAM ONE LLC 1 Residential $18,200 $3,535 $21,735 $62,100 0 MIDWEST VISTA, LLC ELLISON, SHAWN & ELLISON, CARMELL 1 Residential $9,065 $3,220 $12,285 $35,100 0.7 HALL, LATOSHA WEBSTER, RICO 1 Residential $13,160 $2,520 $15,680 $44,800 0.98 MFR 5, LLC US INVESTORS 513, INC 1 Residential $19,985 $4,655 $24,640 $70,400 0.62 MJB INVESTMENT PROPERTIES LLC DAVIS ANTOINETTE P 1 Residential $20,160 $3,990 $24,150 $69,000 0.46 BALTIC INVESTMENTS, LLC COCHRAN PHILLIPS REAL ESTATE, LLC 1 Residential $1,610 $3,780 $5,390 $15,400 3.95 US BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION SANDERS, KIMBERLY RENE 1 Residential $18,550 $5,180 $23,730 $67,800 0.7 AZZAM, MAJDI M CYMBALINE GROUP, LLC 1 Residential $24,885 $8,470 $33,355 $95,300 0 BIONDOLILLO, CHRISTINE J BIONDOLILLO, ROBERT J & CHRISTINE 1 Residential $12,110 $6,265 $18,375 $52,500 1 MCGUCKIN, BRIAN WJP PROPERTIES, LLC 1 Residential $23,450 $6,265 $29,715 $84,900 0 NASVYTIS, VILIJA NASVYTIS-KLIMAS, VILIJA & NASVYTIS, 1 Residential $23,450 $6,265 $29,715 $84,900 0 NASVYTIS-KLIMAS, VILIJA & NASVYTIS, NASVYTIS, REGINA 1 Residential $10,850 $4,935 $15,785 $45,100 1.05 RSN HOLDINGS DELAWARE, LC LRL ONE, LLC (VENDOR) 1 Residential $12,285 $4,725 $17,010 $48,600 1.03 RAAQIM, KHALEEL LEEWAY PROPERTY GROUP LLC 1 Residential $13,195 $3,990 $17,185 $49,100 1.31 CUNNINGHAM, LEVANDER & SANDRA OPEKA ESTELLE MARIE 1 Residential $11,900 $3,500 $15,400 $44,000 0.57 CORNERSTONE RENOVATIONS LLC CROWN, KEVIN M 1 Residential $11,900 $3,500 $15,400 $44,000 0.85 GROVEWOOD PROPERTIES LLC CORNERSTONE RENOVATIONS LLC 1 Residential $1,260 $3,990 $5,250 $15,000 5.93 U S BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION ADAMS, RICHARD A 1 Residential $14,665 $1,680 $16,345 $46,700 1 LIFE OF SEASONS LLC SEEDS LLC 1 Residential $8,575 $2,030 $10,605 $30,300 0 BOOKER, LESHON B & BOOKER, LASHON BOOKER, SHIRLEY FAE 1 Residential $8,120 $2,030 $10,150 $29,000 0 MILLER, VALECIA ADAMS, ESSIE M 1 Residential $7,105 $1,645 $8,750 $25,000 0 GULLEY, VANCE TRS GOLDEN GENERATION II, L L C 1 Residential $7,700 $1,645 $9,345 $26,700 0 MCPHERSON, PAMELA MOUNTIANSIDE REALTY VENTURES LLC 1 Residential $6,895 $1,960 $8,855 $25,300 0 GINYARD-DENSON, MILDRED L CUYAHOGA COUNTY LAND REUTILIZATION 1 Commercial $19,775 $2,380 $22,155 $63,300 1.11 BONDARU, SARATH KRISHNA & TIRUMALAS GOODSANDS LLC 1 Residential $8,960 $1,295 $10,255 $29,300 0 754 PARKWOOD DRIVE TRUST SANDERS SCOTT 1 Residential $4,340 $1,260 $5,600 $16,000 0 CHEEKS, RICHARD E ET AL PARKER, LARANCE A ET AL 1 Residential $4,340 $1,260 $5,600 $16,000 0 CHEEKS, RICHARD E CHEEKS, RICHARD E ET AL 1 Residential $4,340 $1,260 $5,600 $16,000 0 CHEEKS, RICHARD E ET AL CHEEKS, RICHARD E ET AL 1 Residential $4,340 $1,260 $5,600 $16,000 0 CHEEKS JR , RICHARD E ETAL CHEEKS, RICHARD E JR 1 Residential $5,460 $1,260 $6,720 $19,200 0 OHIO EIRE PROPERTIES STATE OF OHIO FORF CV # 871624 1 Residential $1,540 $1,715 $3,255 $9,300 0 GIBBS, DARRELL CUYAHOGA COUNTY LAND REUTILIZATION 1 Residential $8,260 $1,680 $9,940 $28,400 1.21 PERKINS, ILONA T BRIGGS, PATRICIA MCGOWAN 1 Residential $3,605 $1,890 $5,495 $15,700 3.69 BARLIN INVEST LLC SBAR HOLDINGS, LLC 1 Residential $37,310 $6,720 $44,030 $125,800 2.42 BISSELLE, MARY F HOWARD, TED L & SHANNON M 1 Residential $3,675 $1,715 $5,390 $15,400 3.44 ULTIMATE PRODUCTS, LLC MCCALL, NATHAN TIMOTHY 1 Residential $7,105 $1,890 $8,995 $25,700 0.56 CALDWELL, JAMEL MOUNTAINSIDE REALTY VENTURES LLC 1 Residential $0 $1,715 $1,715 $4,900 7.86 CASPER ENTERPRISE GROUP, INC WELLS FARGO BANK NA 1 Residential $1,750 $1,050 $2,800 $8,000 1 RIGHTERXYZ INVESTMENTS, LLC RIGHT INVESTMENTS LLC Page 40 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable Taxable Taxable Taxable Auditor Number of Assessed Assessed Assessed Estimated Total EMV Ratio Filing Parcels Property Building Land Total Market Mult. Recpt. Price to Buyer Seller Number Combined ($) Class Value Value Value Value Est. Mkt. Val. Est. Mkt. Val. Name Name 1 Residential $2,520 $1,050 $3,570 $10,200 0.64 PARKER PROPERTIES UNLIMITED LLC DTH REO INC 1 Residential $4,550 $1,050 $5,600 $16,000 0 GOSHAY ANNIE C GOSHAY WILLIAM F & ANNIE C 1 Residential $4,550 $1,050 $5,600 $16,000 0 GOSHAY, MICHAEL & BROOKS, JOE C & GOSHAY ANNIE C 1 Residential $5,845 $1,050 $6,895 $19,700 1 THERMITUS, NIXON & REDGINE ENDLESS LINEAGE 1 Residential $9,520 $1,050 $10,570 $30,200 1 TAYLOR, TERRELL JORDAN DARLENE 1 Residential $8,890 $1,365 $10,255 $29,300 0.26 NEW RESIDENTIAL MORTGAGE LOAN TRUST JACKSON, MARY A 1 Residential $5,425 $1,540 $6,965 $19,900 0 COUSIN WINNIE (ET AL) COUSIN WINNIE 1 Residential $0 $175 $175 $500 0 CLEVELAND LAND REUTILIZATION PROGRA JACKSON, FELICIA 1 Residential $0 $175 $175 $500 0 CLEVELAND LAND REUTILIZATION PROGRA MOST VALUABLE PURPOSE, INC 1 Residential $3,360 $1,225 $4,585 $13,100 0 PELTIER, ALLISON M ALLEN5 HOLDINGS, LLC 1 Residential $4,095 $1,610 $5,705 $16,300 3.62 SANDBAY PROPERTIES INVEST LLC SBAR HOLDINGS, LLC 1 Residential $2,835 $1,890 $4,725 $13,500 0 HARSLEY, DARNELL N HARSLEY, DARRIN W SR 1 Residential $5,145 $1,260 $6,405 $18,300 1 SHAKIR, WALI NOTABLE REAL ESTATE AND DEVELOPMENT 3 Residential $10,045 $2,170 $12,215 $34,900 $197,600 0.5 ORIT, LLC MISHORY INVESTMENTS, LLC 1 Commercial $350 $1,540 $1,890 $5,400 3.7 PARKER PROPERTIES UNLIMITED LLC PERKINS, CARLOS DURAN 1 Residential $4,830 $1,365 $6,195 $17,700 0 MERRIWEATHER, DIANNE A FLETCHER, ROBERT 1 Residential $5,460 $1,295 $6,755 $19,300 0 YANNA ALL N ONE PAYEE SERVICES & MO PIQUE, EIAHNNA 1 Residential $7,910 $1,365 $9,275 $26,500 0 GULLEY, VANCE TRS JOHNSON, CHERYL D TRS 1 Residential $5,250 $2,765 $8,015 $22,900 0 CUYAHOGA COUNTY LAND REUTILIZATION CRIGLER LIZZIE 1 Residential $3,605 $2,030 $5,635 $16,100 2.35 NC LAR, LLC SYNERGY PROPERTY INVESTMENTS LLC 1 Residential $5,915 $2,205 $8,120 $23,200 0.8 FAMICOS FOUNDATION BEULAH AVENUE, LLC 1 Residential $5,950 $2,065 $8,015 $22,900 0 BURNETT, ERIC-TRUSTEE & BURNETT, SA BURNETT ERIC L 1 Residential $0 $1,925 $1,925 $5,500 7.31 DAMM, ROBERT ETAL KEYBANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION 1 Residential $6,195 $2,450 $8,645 $24,700 0 CLAY, CLIFTON CLAY, CLIFTON 1 Residential $6,195 $2,450 $8,645 $24,700 0 CLAY-ARGIEARD, LLC CLAY, CLIFTON 1 Residential $0 $1,120 $1,120 $3,200 0 CLEVELAND LAND REUTILIZATION PROGRA HANDLER DAVID M 1 Residential $20,545 $2,205 $22,750 $65,000 0 CUYAHOGA COUNTY LAND REUTILIZATION FEDERAL HOME LOAN MORTGAGE CORPORAT 1 Residential $16,800 $2,065 $18,865 $53,900 0.67 WHITE, MICHAEL L HUNTINGTON REAL ESTATE LLC 1 Residential $18,725 $10,080 $28,805 $82,300 0.67 1551 EAST 118, LLC BROWN, LEARLEAN 1 Residential $350 $1,050 $1,400 $4,000 0 JOHNSON, LEONARD W TULLIO JR , JOHN R SUC-TRS 1 Residential $34,755 $23,485 $58,240 $166,400 1.35 MATTHEWS, ELI R & MATTHEWS, VERNA WILLIAMS-JACKSON, RENEE AFN201812280396 1 Residential $315 $2,940 $3,255 $9,300 1 UPSCALE PROPERTIES UNLIMITED, LLC OHIO PROPERTIES, LLC 1 Residential $6,335 $2,835 $9,170 $26,200 0 MCDUFFIE, DARRYL B & MCDUFFIE, CORT MCDUFFIE, BETTY M 1 Residential $1,680 $2,765 $4,445 $12,700 0.16 PARKER PROPERTIES UNLIMITED LLC PERKINS, CARLOS DURAN 1 Residential $3,605 $3,185 $6,790 $19,400 0.37 SYNERGY PROPERTY INVESTMENTS, LLC TOP DESIGNER LANDSCAPING, LLC 1 Residential $3,605 $3,185 $6,790 $19,400 1.54 COX, PETERGAIL SYNERGY PROPERTY INVESTMENTS, LLC 1 Residential $4,725 $2,870 $7,595 $21,700 2.07 TADIPARTY, SOAMI CHARAN DAS AMERICAN ESTATE AND TRUST 1 Residential $2,590 $2,345 $4,935 $14,100 0 CUYAHOGA COUNTY LAND REUTILIZATION WILLIAMS, PETER SCOTT 1 Residential $5,810 $2,695 $8,505 $24,300 1 TAYLOR MADE SOLUTIONS, INC SMITH, MYRON 1 Residential $5,810 $2,695 $8,505 $24,300 0.66 SBAR HOLDINGS, LLC TAYLOR MADE SOLUTIONS, INC 1 Residential $7,560 $2,660 $10,220 $29,200 1 CLEVELAND PROPERTY MANAGEMENT FOUND HESTER, SOPHIA 1 Commercial $25,830 $2,065 $27,895 $79,700 0.88 MADDINENI, RAMBABU & KOLLU, SREEN WALLACE, JOHANNAH 1 Residential $4,585 $2,100 $6,685 $19,100 0 HOGUE, JR , WILLIAM L HOGUE, WILLIAM L SR 1 Residential $8,645 $2,485 $11,130 $31,800 1 REEVES, SR , ANDRE ARLITA INVESTMENTS LLC Page 41 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable Taxable Taxable Taxable Auditor Number of Assessed Assessed Assessed Estimated Total EMV Ratio Filing Parcels Property Building Land Total Market Mult. Recpt. Price to Buyer Seller Number Combined ($) Class Value Value Value Value Est. Mkt. Val. Est. Mkt. Val. Name Name 2 Residential $4,235 $2,765 $7,000 $20,000 $21,300 0 BAKER, GINGER GALE BOWEN BOWEN, ERMAL L 2 Residential $0 $455 $455 $1,300 $21,300 0 BAKER, GINGER GALE BOWEN BOWEN, ERMAL L 1 Residential $10,675 $2,485 $13,160 $37,600 0.64 RD MANAGEMENT, LLC THE MAHDI GROUP, LLC 1 Residential $10,360 $2,310 $12,670 $36,200 0 ANNIKEY, VEDA HENRY, VEDA ANNIKEY AND HENRY, DENN 1 Residential $11,270 $2,310 $13,580 $38,800 0.43 NATIONSTAR MORTGAGE LLC ABRAMS, BRIAN K 1 Residential $5,985 $1,785 $7,770 $22,200 0.5 SH HOLDINGS LLC MACY MANAGEMENT GROUP, LLC 1 Residential $10,675 $2,310 $12,985 $37,100 0 WARD, LEROY JR & HELEN WARD JR, LEROY 1 Residential $9,835 $2,310 $12,145 $34,700 0.35 WELLS FARGO BANK, N A ADAMS, ROBERT E 1 Residential $7,350 $3,045 $10,395 $29,700 0 FEDERAL NATIONAL MORTGAGE ASSOCIATI TEMESI, MATT 1 Residential $8,715 $1,505 $10,220 $29,200 0.2 PEARL PROPERTY MANAGEMENT LLC SEKERAK, CHARLES 1 Residential $8,855 $1,575 $10,430 $29,800 0.47 SRW ROCKET, LLC STANLEY JR, THALLES 1 Residential $8,855 $1,680 $10,535 $30,100 1 FARHADI, SHAHRIAR JASON WILLIAMS, CHRISTIAN L 1 Residential $9,520 $1,785 $11,305 $32,300 1 GREGG, BRANDON A GREGG MICHAEL R 1 Residential $0 $350 $350 $1,000 0 CLEVELAND LAND REUTILIZATION PROGRA DANIELS JR, GEORGE 1 Residential $10,675 $1,330 $12,005 $34,300 1.15 DAVIS, ROBERT LOUIS MIDFIRST BANK 1 Residential $6,615 $1,680 $8,295 $23,700 2.53 ULTIMATE PRODUCTS LLC MAKUPSON DARRELL 1 Residential $9,205 $1,610 $10,815 $30,900 0 CUYAHOGA COUNTY LAND REUTILIZATION MUJAHEED, SHAREEF (ET AL) 1 Residential $5,530 $1,435 $6,965 $19,900 1 EJR GROUP, LLC JOLLAR, GERALD H 1 Residential $9,100 $2,170 $11,270 $32,200 0.71 BROOKS, MARSHALL KEYBANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION 1 Residential $2,660 $0 $2,660 $7,600 6.07 COLONIAL IMPACT FUND II, LLC COLONIAL FUND 17, LP 2 Residential $0 $945 $945 $2,700 $152,000 0.53 HARVEY, LELA & DIXSON, HERBERT REV HARVEY, LELA & DIXSON, HERBERT REV 1 Residential $13,405 $1,855 $15,260 $43,600 0 JONES, R L JONES, R L 1 Residential $3,465 $1,960 $5,425 $15,500 1 MOORE, DAMON & WORLD CLASS BARBERSH MAYO, SHERRI 1 Residential $3,150 $1,960 $5,110 $14,600 1.37 TJI LLC NEXT LEVEL WORKSHOP, LLC 1 Residential $19,670 $2,835 $22,505 $64,300 0.43 KARDER INVESTMENTS LTD AW 3/, LLC 1 Residential $5,880 $1,470 $7,350 $21,000 0 BROWN, JR , CARL BROWN, SHERRY 1 Residential $5,250 $1,470 $6,720 $19,200 0 MCINTOSH, REGINA & SUTTLES, MICHAEL SUTTLES, BERNICE O 1 Residential $875 $1,470 $2,345 $6,700 1 SMITH, RONDA JONES CHRISTOPHER 1 Residential $735 $2,100 $2,835 $8,100 0.62 JIREH REAL ESTATE INVESTMENTS OH, L EQUITY TRUST COMPANY CUSTODIAN FBO 1 Residential $16,590 $2,240 $18,830 $53,800 1.04 EQUITY TRUST COMPANY CUSTODIAN FBO B&M REAL ESTATE INVESTMENTS LLC 1 Residential $6,860 $2,065 $8,925 $25,500 0.5 HUNTER, BRANDI HUNTER, BRANDI & KEY, SOMALIA 1 Residential $5,215 $1,750 $6,965 $19,900 0 CUYAHOGA COUNTY LAND REUTILIZATION CRANFIELD, CHARLES 1 Residential $2,940 $1,295 $4,235 $12,100 1 TAYLOR, JR , LT WINSTON, JAZMINE 1 Residential $6,615 $1,295 $7,910 $22,600 0.44 SYNERGY PROPERTY INVESTMENTS, LLC HUNTER, MARY W 1 Commercial $23,905 $2,345 $26,250 $75,000 1 BRACKLAND LLC JRCV NIYA OHIO FAMILY LTD 1 Residential $350 $1,260 $1,610 $4,600 0.33 KING, HARRY L JR MATRIX FINANCIAL SERVICES CORP 1 Residential $7,350 $1,960 $9,310 $26,600 0 ENGRAM, MARLOW CUYAHOGA COUNTY LAND REUTILIZATION 1 Residential $7,140 $1,820 $8,960 $25,600 0.96 HARRIS, DENISE COLEMAN, KYLYNN 1 Residential $350 $1,610 $1,960 $5,600 0.27 MARTIN, STEVE HB 2014-C LLC 1 Residential $6,580 $1,120 $7,700 $22,000 2.18 ULTIMATE PRODUCTS, LLC VAUGHN, REGINA IDA 1 Residential $3,325 $1,085 $4,410 $12,600 1.14 KEYBANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION HARRIS, GARY & BEATRICE D 1 Residential $4,165 $1,225 $5,390 $15,400 0 THREE BLACK KNIGHTS LLC WORTHY, LOREN ET AL 1 Residential $6,335 $1,680 $8,015 $22,900 0 911 PAXTON ROAD TRUST SANDERS, SCOTT 1 Residential $3,850 $945 $4,795 $13,700 0 HILLIARD, LESTER EUGENE-TRUSTEE & H HILLARD LESTER E Page 42 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable Taxable Taxable Taxable Auditor Number of Assessed Assessed Assessed Estimated Total EMV Ratio Filing Parcels Property Building Land Total Market Mult. Recpt. Price to Buyer Seller Number Combined ($) Class Value Value Value Value Est. Mkt. Val. Est. Mkt. Val. Name Name 1 Residential $4,270 $1,120 $5,390 $15,400 0.4 TAWEEL, ALAA DARAL JETER, CHRISTINE 1 Residential $4,060 $1,085 $5,145 $14,700 1.22 HSBC BANK USA NATIONAL ASSOCIATION EXUM JAMES EDGAR AFN201812280512 1 Residential $6,510 $1,540 $8,050 $23,000 1.13 JERIDO, WILLIE BRODNAX, ZAHNE 3 Residential $0 $1,505 $1,505 $4,300 $32,100 0 FREEALLBIRDS,LLC BROOKS, EDDIE 3 Residential $7,140 $1,435 $8,575 $24,500 $32,100 0 FREEALLBIRDS,LLC FREEALLBIRDS,LLC 1 Residential $5,565 $1,400 $6,965 $19,900 1.01 EDWARDS, HARRY CRAWFORD, PAULINE D 1 Residential $6,510 $3,325 $9,835 $28,100 0.18 B & M REAL ESTATE INVESTMENTS LLC HORIZON TRUST COMPANY 1 Residential $11,900 $2,765 $14,665 $41,900 1.19 TWIN HOUSING PROPERTIES LLC I AM BW LLC 1 Residential $3,010 $1,365 $4,375 $12,500 2.72 MOORE, ALEX CARTER, NORMAN A & CARTER, BETTI 1 Residential $7,245 $1,365 $8,610 $24,600 1.12 MOORE, ALEX CARTER, NORMAN A & CARTER, BETTI 1 Residential $5,740 $1,365 $7,105 $20,300 0.81 BRADY, DONOVAN THREE BLACK KNIGHTS 1 Residential $6,265 $1,435 $7,700 $22,000 0.45 WILLLIAMS, VALERIE RISBY, ESTELLE 1 Residential $4,865 $1,890 $6,755 $19,300 0 BOWERSOCK, LEILANI LMB REAL PROPERTIES LLC 1 Residential $5,600 $1,435 $7,035 $20,100 2.63 SAMUEL, SAJAY & FARAGE, SAMAR SYNERGY PROPERTY INVESTMENTS LLC 1 Residential $3,150 $1,575 $4,725 $13,500 2.73 MIRANDA, RAPHAEL DE PAULA AND DE AZ REHAB KINGS, LLC 1 Residential $7,280 $1,540 $8,820 $25,200 1 HARRIS, DENISE MCBEE, QUENTTIN 1 Residential $6,440 $1,540 $7,980 $22,800 0.29 PREMIER INVESTMENT PROPERTIES, LLC OBLETON ALFRED R 1 Residential $1,645 $1,750 $3,395 $9,700 5.15 SIMMONS, LEAH MARIE CHIU, ANNIE Y L 1 Residential $4,060 $2,170 $6,230 $17,800 0 CUYAHOGA COUNTY LAND REUTILIZATION LIANG, FANG & YUE J 1 Residential $0 $385 $385 $1,100 0 CLEVELAND LAND REUTILIZATION PROGRA POTOCNIK VALENTINE 1 Residential $3,815 $805 $4,620 $13,200 0 BEATY, NORMAN BROWN, ORLANDIS 1 Commercial $350 $1,785 $2,135 $6,100 0 TRUITT, GABRIEL J CUYAHOGA COUNTY LAND REUTILIZATION 1 Residential $4,935 $700 $5,635 $16,100 1.86 CNGRUN, LLC COLE, PAUL 1 Residential $3,780 $735 $4,515 $12,900 0 TRUST GOD INVESTMENTS LLC ROSE, MARGARET A 1 Residential $12,705 $2,415 $15,120 $43,200 1.55 COLLAZO, YOLANDA & ROSARIO, JOSE AN PROSPERITY GROUP LLC 1 Residential $8,435 $2,415 $10,850 $31,000 0 GULLEY, CLAUDE TRS JOHNSON, CHERYL (TRS) 1 Residential $8,610 $2,415 $11,025 $31,500 0.98 GEORDIK, LLC SHEOBILAS, ROY & SANICHAR, RAECHEL 1 Residential $8,120 $2,415 $10,535 $30,100 0.85 HARDWAYS LLC GREENLIGHT IV, LLC 1 Residential $9,975 $2,450 $12,425 $35,500 0 GULLEY, VANCE TRS JOHNSON, CHERYL D (TRS) 1 Residential $10,920 $4,480 $15,400 $44,000 0 JONSHON, CHERYL D GOLDEN GENRATION II, LLC 1 Residential $10,885 $2,485 $13,370 $38,200 2.15 HAMILTON, YOLANDA GREATER CLEVELAND HABITAT FOR HUMAN 1 Residential $9,800 $2,485 $12,285 $35,100 0.71 STEEL, RATOYA MAKINA MANAGEMENT, INC 1 Residential $6,195 $2,345 $8,540 $24,400 0 FEDERAL HOME LOAN MORTGAGE CORPORAT JELEN, ROBERT A 1 Residential $7,840 $2,450 $10,290 $29,400 1 RUSSELL, SHAWNTERRA LUCZAK DAVID 1 Residential $12,950 $2,520 $15,470 $44,200 1 ZRAIQAT, KHALIL M ELDUR, ABED AIHALLEEM 1 Residential $9,275 $3,500 $12,775 $36,500 0 FEDERAL HOME LOAN MORTGAGE CORPORAT JELEN, ROBERT A 1 Residential $15,645 $2,590 $18,235 $52,100 0 LOWRY, KIMBERLY JONES DELOIS C 1 Residential $21,525 $6,090 $27,615 $78,900 0.95 UR HOME PROPERTIES LLC CAPOROSSI, FRANK 1 Residential $24,920 $6,510 $31,430 $89,800 1.67 TRASKOVA, OLGA BABCHIC MANAGEMENT CORP LLC 1 Residential $17,815 $3,780 $21,595 $61,700 0 NATIONSTAR MORTGAGE LLC LOWE, JIMMY A 1 Residential $10,290 $3,710 $14,000 $40,000 0 MEPHAM, DENNIS MEPHAM, DENNIS & MICHAEL T 1 Residential $10,500 $3,920 $14,420 $41,200 0 MEPHAM, DENNIS MEPHAM, DENNIS & MICHAEL 1 Residential $34,510 $8,190 $42,700 $122,000 1.45 VIOLETTE, AISHA BASINGER, LEE ERIC 2 Residential $13,055 $4,200 $17,255 $49,300 $99,800 0 KLINKO, RHONDA PARADISE PROPERTIES Page 43 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable Taxable Taxable Taxable Auditor Number of Assessed Assessed Assessed Estimated Total EMV Ratio Filing Parcels Property Building Land Total Market Mult. Recpt. Price to Buyer Seller Number Combined ($) Class Value Value Value Value Est. Mkt. Val. Est. Mkt. Val. Name Name 2 Residential $13,475 $4,200 $17,675 $50,500 $99,800 0 KLINKO, RHONDA PARADISE PROPTERTIES 1 Commercial $87,745 $7,525 $95,270 $272,200 0 KLINKO, RHONDA PARADISE, PROPERTIES MANAGEMENT CO 2 Residential $0 $315 $315 $900 $75,500 1.7 BREDE, EDWARD INK, JANET 2 Residential $21,525 $4,585 $26,110 $74,600 $75,500 1.7 BREDE, EDWARD INK, JANET 1 Residential $16,100 $3,885 $19,985 $57,100 0.61 BEIT KABEER MANAGEMENT LLC COX, KERRY S & MELANIE A 1 Residential $15,155 $3,885 $19,040 $54,400 1.49 BERMUDEZ, ALBERT SAINI SANJIV 1 Residential $17,045 $3,885 $20,930 $59,800 1.33 AMADOR, FELIPE JR & AMADOR, JESSICA GARG, AVINEET & GARG, TATYANA 1 Residential $20,930 $3,955 $24,885 $71,100 0 DEUTSCHE BANK TRUST COMPANY AMERICA CALDWELL, BELINDA 1 Residential $18,130 $3,885 $22,015 $62,900 0.55 SEMARY, ALEJANDRO AND SEMARY, GEORG DEUTSCHE BANK NATIONAL TRUST COMPAN 1 Residential $13,440 $3,885 $17,325 $49,500 1.45 HARDEO, MAHINDRA SANTOS, JUANA 1 Residential $16,135 $3,815 $19,950 $57,000 1.26 GEORGES, SAM DIGENNARO, DIANE G 5 Residential $15,330 $3,920 $19,250 $55,000 $256,798 0.74 MONTERROSO, EVER A & IRMA M GF & STRAUCH, LUCIA M 5 Residential $13,335 $3,675 $17,010 $48,600 $256,798 0.74 MONTERROSO, EVER A & IRMA M GF & STRAUCH, LUCIA M 5 Residential $13,335 $3,675 $17,010 $48,600 $256,798 0.74 MONTERROSO, EVER A & IRMA M GF & STRAUCH, LUCIA M 5 Residential $13,510 $3,885 $17,395 $49,700 $256,798 0.74 MONTERROSO, EVER A & IRMA M GF & STRAUCH, LUCIA M 5 Residential $15,295 $3,920 $19,215 $54,900 $256,798 0.74 MONTERROSO, EVER A & IRMA M GF & STRAUCH, LUCIA M 1 Residential $16,555 $3,990 $20,545 $58,700 0 ZITNEY, MICHAEL J BAKOS, MAURA VIRGINIA 1 Residential $10,710 $4,095 $14,805 $42,300 1.06 LEVEL II MANAGEMENT & CONSULTANTS, LEE-CHEUNG, CHRISTINE 1 Residential $18,060 $5,530 $23,590 $67,400 0 GULLEY, VANCE TRS GOLDEN GENERATION II, LLC 1 Residential $13,930 $3,990 $17,920 $51,200 1.07 A & R FAMILY INVESTMENT LLC GONZALEZ, LUIS J 1 Residential $18,830 $3,780 $22,610 $64,600 0.5 LLAPA, FLOR E LLAPA, FLOR E & PINO, NAUM 1 Residential $13,720 $3,885 $17,605 $50,300 0.7 HARDWAYS LLC SHIVA TRADING INC 1 Residential $3,815 $3,885 $7,700 $22,000 3.2 SCHAEFER, ERIKA ETAL EIBEN, WILLIAM J 1 Residential $13,440 $4,515 $17,955 $51,300 1.11 QUINONES, NATASHA CORIANO WILDS, HELEN 1 Residential $16,135 $4,130 $20,265 $57,900 1.21 ROSARIO, JOSE A BURKE, DANIEL J 1 Residential $15,610 $4,130 $19,740 $56,400 0.39 QUEST PROPERTY HOLDINGS LLC MIKOS, JOANN ELIZABETH 1 Residential $12,670 $3,885 $16,555 $47,300 0 MULDREW, LAWRENCE AND MULDREW, VICK MULDREW, LAWRENCE 1 Residential $14,105 $4,165 $18,270 $52,200 0 SEGUL, WAYNE L SEGUL, WAYNE L 1 Residential $8,610 $4,270 $12,880 $36,800 0 HGHTOWER, LINDA G HIGHTOWER ADDIE B 1 Residential $14,000 $4,060 $18,060 $51,600 0 MOORE, JAMES ATKINS, BONITA ROSS & ADRIAN 1 Residential $11,340 $3,780 $15,120 $43,200 0 GULLEY, CLAUDE TRS GOLDEN GENERATION II, LLC 1 Residential $16,975 $4,550 $21,525 $61,500 1.4 OPSAHL JR , ROBERT D & OPSAHL SR , PRUITT,ARIC E 1 Residential $20,265 $4,200 $24,465 $69,900 0 OLD BROOKLYN PROPERTIES, LLC KASSAY, JAMES W 1 Residential $13,475 $4,025 $17,500 $50,000 0 CROW, DAVID E & CROW, TONI L CROW DAVID E 1 Residential $19,495 $2,800 $22,295 $63,700 0 EMIR PROPERTIES, LLC ABEID, EMIR 1 Residential $7,105 $2,520 $9,625 $27,500 1.82 EQUITY TRUST COMPANY CUSTODIAN FBO HESS JEFFREY B & MERIDITH LEE CO-T 1 Residential $36,015 $7,595 $43,610 $124,600 1.4 JOHNSON, CAMERON M MICHAELS SALLY 1 Residential $13,580 $2,695 $16,275 $46,500 0 WHITLOCK , RONALD E JR WHITLOCK NUCLEAR SERVICES, LLC 1 Commercial $31,360 $9,520 $40,880 $116,800 1.93 LBJS LLC 9000 DENISON LLC 1 Residential $10,500 $2,450 $12,950 $37,000 0.36 SRW ROCKET LLC SIMMONS EDDIE E 1 Residential $8,890 $2,660 $11,550 $33,000 0 AMERICAN DREAM HOLDINGS LLC EIGHT SEVENTEEN PROPERTIES LLC 1 Residential $9,870 $2,660 $12,530 $35,800 0 JERMARIE INVESTMENTS, OH LLC WILLIAMS, JERMAINE 1 Residential $14,070 $2,765 $16,835 $48,100 0.83 HEBEN, PATRICIA A SNYDER, MARTHA L 2 Residential $9,170 $2,695 $11,865 $33,900 $63,100 0 DIONISOPOULOS, NICK D TRS DIONISOPOULOS, NICHOLAS Page 44 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable Taxable Taxable Taxable Auditor Number of Assessed Assessed Assessed Estimated Total EMV Ratio Filing Parcels Property Building Land Total Market Mult. Recpt. Price to Buyer Seller Number Combined ($) Class Value Value Value Value Est. Mkt. Val. Est. Mkt. Val. Name Name 1 Residential $9,345 $3,290 $12,635 $36,100 0.77 NATIONSTAR MORTGAGE LLC DBA MR COOP PERAZA, JOSELIZ 1 Residential $14,770 $4,515 $19,285 $55,100 1.47 BEREAN FOUR, LLC PROSPERCLE, LLC 1 Residential $20,475 $4,515 $24,990 $71,400 1.26 MORALES, JORGE & CARMEN L GIORDANO JAMES V TRS 1 Residential $16,205 $4,515 $20,720 $59,200 1.27 MARROQUIN, ELTON L WEISMAN, GAIL M 1 Residential $13,125 $4,515 $17,640 $50,400 1.72 VARGAS, VIDAL CRESPO WILL, TRACY L 1 Residential $20,615 $3,395 $24,010 $68,600 0 FEDERAL NATIONAL MORTGAGE ASSOCIATI MCCOWAN, MARK H 1 Residential $16,870 $3,360 $20,230 $57,800 0 CUNG, FRANCIS H & DENISE CUNG, YEN T 1 Residential $16,520 $3,500 $20,020 $57,200 1.31 SEAMAN, ROSALIE FAITH KAMENEC, TERENCE M TRUSTEE 1 Residential $20,510 $3,325 $23,835 $68,100 0 PINE VALLEY INVESTMENTS, LLC EDGAR, AYUMI T 1 Residential $5,005 $3,045 $8,050 $23,000 0 ACDC INNOVATIVE INVESTMENTS LLC CASTILLO, DIEGO 1 Residential $11,760 $2,870 $14,630 $41,800 0 EMIR PROPERTIES, LLC ABEID, EMIR Y 1 Residential $17,850 $2,765 $20,615 $58,900 1.27 POLASKO, JEAN B EDWARDS, DALE THOMAS 1 Residential $12,250 $3,815 $16,065 $45,900 0.98 POTRUCH, ERIC H & POTRUCH, LISA MCCLURE III, MINYARD 1 Residential $14,980 $3,185 $18,165 $51,900 0 ANDERSON, JOANNE ANDERSON, LUTHER B 1 Residential $13,230 $3,010 $16,240 $46,400 0 KOTLARZ, DONNA M CARL GENE STEINHOFF 1 Residential $21,560 $3,430 $24,990 $71,400 0.4 CARIBBEAN REEF 1 LLC NRZ REO VI-B LLC 1 Residential $13,300 $3,990 $17,290 $49,400 1.29 SANTOS, STEPHANIE A DELOS YANIK, BARBARA G TRS 1 Residential $19,075 $3,185 $22,260 $63,600 0 VICARIO, EIRA M & PONTICELLI, MA VICARIO, JOSE M 1 Residential $12,355 $2,415 $14,770 $42,200 0 SINGH, PREAMNAUTH FEDERAL NATIONAL MORTGAGE ASSOCIATI 1 Residential $14,280 $2,765 $17,045 $48,700 0 COLUMBIA PROPERTY MANAGEMENT, LLC KASSAY, JAMES W 1 Residential $17,115 $3,325 $20,440 $58,400 0 NORCIA, PANCHWATIE & PERSAUD, SAH NORCIA, PANCHWATIE 1 Residential $10,150 $3,360 $13,510 $38,600 0.23 216 RENTALS LLC SENQUIZ MARIA S 1 Residential $14,805 $4,515 $19,320 $55,200 0.36 LOWRY FAMILY COMPANY LTD LOWRY MARTIN D 1 Residential $16,695 $4,550 $21,245 $60,700 0.69 PLUTE, GREGG HOVAN, JOHN T 1 Residential $13,860 $4,515 $18,375 $52,500 1.67 WIGGINS, MICHELLE PATEL, JAYCHANDRA 1 Residential $17,045 $4,515 $21,560 $61,600 1.38 OGANDO, JACINTO QUEZADA AND PEREZ, WILSON, JOSEPH 1 Residential $18,900 $5,040 $23,940 $68,400 1.68 RODRIGUEZ, RICHARD D & HERNANDEZ, ANDERKO, FRANK 1 Residential $16,590 $4,445 $21,035 $60,100 1.3 JOHNSON, SAUNDRA (ETAL) MAGANA, ANA JUDITH 1 Residential $18,235 $4,165 $22,400 $64,000 0 BOSWORTH HOLDINGS LLC FEDERAL HOME LOAN MORTGAGE CORPORAT 1 Residential $17,115 $4,165 $21,280 $60,800 1.07 DOYLE, MARY AND PERSINGER, ETHAN HEYER, DEBORAH J 1 Residential $12,600 $4,165 $16,765 $47,900 0.32 BURGOS, ISRAEL MOUNTAINSIDE REALTY VENTURES LLC 1 Residential $14,245 $3,080 $17,325 $49,500 0 TLC HOME IMPROVEMENT INC BEDNARSKI, ANTHONY J 1 Residential $12,005 $3,185 $15,190 $43,400 1.5 HARRIS, PAUL D WLDL HOLDINGS, LLC 1 Residential $13,405 $4,410 $17,815 $50,900 1.71 STOFFER, ERIC AND KHOURI, ANNABEL LIOGKY DANIEL 2 Residential $0 $280 $280 $800 $62,500 0 ROHDE, CHIP ROHDE, EDWARD 2 Residential $17,010 $4,585 $21,595 $61,700 $62,500 0 ROHDE, CHIP ROHDE, EDWARD 1 Residential $9,835 $3,430 $13,265 $37,900 0.63 KEYBANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION KEITH FRANKLIN B 1 Residential $0 $2,450 $2,450 $7,000 7.71 BEACHAM, WILLIAM J HAWKEYE PROPERTIES, LLC 1 Residential $3,710 $2,590 $6,300 $18,000 0 THREE BLACK KNIGHTS LLC HARRIS, JASON C 1 Residential $3,710 $2,590 $6,300 $18,000 1.4 RECYCLED MONEY LLC THREE BLACK KNIGHTS LLC 1 Residential $5,145 $2,450 $7,595 $21,700 0.14 GHAZAL, MOHANAD ROBINSON, CORY DANTE 2 Residential $1,260 $2,415 $3,675 $10,500 $27,300 1 KING, MELISSA BUGARCIC MIKE 2 Residential $3,465 $2,415 $5,880 $16,800 $27,300 1 KING, MELISSA BUGARCIC MIKE 1 Residential $4,760 $3,010 $7,770 $22,200 0 THIRD FEDERAL SAVINGS AND LOAN ASSO LAYLLE MARIE Y Page 45 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable Taxable Taxable Taxable Auditor Number of Assessed Assessed Assessed Estimated Total EMV Ratio Filing Parcels Property Building Land Total Market Mult. Recpt. Price to Buyer Seller Number Combined ($) Class Value Value Value Value Est. Mkt. Val. Est. Mkt. Val. Name Name 1 Residential $8,470 $2,870 $11,340 $32,400 0 ZABKA, HEDY SECRETARY OF VETERANS AFFAIRS 1 Residential $6,055 $3,080 $9,135 $26,100 0.73 PARKER PROPERTIES UNLIMITED LLC WATERS, ELMO DANIEL JR 1 Residential $10,570 $1,785 $12,355 $35,300 2.03 CHRISTOFFERSON, AMY GALAT, TIMOTHY JAMES & SARAH LYNN 1 Residential $35,315 $2,380 $37,695 $107,700 0 IRA SERVICES TRUST COMPANY CFBO ROB HORIZON TRUST & INVESTMENT MANAGEME 1 Residential $11,130 $2,730 $13,860 $39,600 0.15 WITHROW, CURTIS FAY, EDYTHE AKA GALISH, EDITH 2 Residential $6,825 $2,870 $9,695 $27,700 $27,700 1.05 HAYS, RICKY L KLAUS, EUGENE B 1 Residential $10,255 $2,695 $12,950 $37,000 1.7 HSU, ALEX SARANG, LLC 1 Residential $6,755 $2,485 $9,240 $26,400 0 GMS SERVICES, LLC ANGELINA, MARIA 1 Residential $35 $2,380 $2,415 $6,900 7.03 RENCZ, JOSEPH & RENCZ, ANNA L SLAVIC VILLAGE RECOVERY LLC 1 Residential $6,300 $2,520 $8,820 $25,200 0 GMS SERVICES, LLC PANGIHUTAN, SAMUEL 1 Residential $4,655 $2,520 $7,175 $20,500 0.15 BOLDEN, LINA READY CUT LLC 1 Residential $10,780 $2,590 $13,370 $38,200 0 BIALOZYT, STANISLAW & BIALOZYT, MAL BIALOZYT STANISLAV 1 Residential $14,700 $2,870 $17,570 $50,200 0 SLAVIC VILLAGE RECOVERY LLC SLAVIC VILLAGE DEVELOPMENT 1 Residential $14,700 $2,870 $17,570 $50,200 0 SLAVIC VILLAGE DEVELOPMENT BROIDA, CLARK 1 Residential $11,865 $2,870 $14,735 $42,100 1.66 KANE, RYAN M & KANE, REBEKAH J MCCALLIAN, MICHAEL E 1 Residential $12,670 $2,380 $15,050 $43,000 0 WORKMAN, SANDRA WORKMAN, SANDRA K 1 Residential $20,930 $3,010 $23,940 $68,400 0.12 SEDER, BELAELL BANK OF AMERICA, N A 1 Residential $5,915 $2,450 $8,365 $23,900 1 OLSZEWSKI HOUSE, LLC MANTKOWSKI, MARY ANN 1 Residential $6,300 $1,610 $7,910 $22,600 0 PONYIK, JAMES-TRUSTEE STEWART, MARY P 1 Residential $14,595 $2,870 $17,465 $49,900 0 SVADBA, SR , JOHN A & SVADBA, JU SVADBA JOHN A & JUDITH A 1 Residential $10,955 $2,940 $13,895 $39,700 0.09 JEFFRIES, DEMETRIUS MCLOYD, TIM 1 Residential $4,550 $2,835 $7,385 $21,100 0 DUNCAN, DAVE L , III DUNCAN, DAVE L , III & HOUSTON, DEM 1 Residential $7,210 $2,940 $10,150 $29,000 1 CAMPBELL, LARRIE LADELL JAMES, JOHN 1 Residential $1,085 $3,010 $4,095 $11,700 0.17 DONALDSON, ROGER ROY EXR, LLC 1 Residential $4,515 $1,890 $6,405 $18,300 1 CROFT, CANDACE LEE KOVACIC, JR , JOHN VINCENT 1 Residential $5,810 $2,485 $8,295 $23,700 0 FEDERAL NATIONAL MORTGAGE ASSOCIATI MOSIER, CHARLES EDWARD 1 Residential $5,810 $2,485 $8,295 $23,700 0 CUYAHOGA COUNTY LAND REUTILIZATION FEDERAL NATIONAL MORTGAGE ASSOCIATI 4 Residential $9,415 $2,835 $12,250 $35,000 $118,600 0 GUARDIAN FUND, LLC HOME PARTNERS, LLC 4 Residential $9,415 $2,835 $12,250 $35,000 $118,600 2.11 PHILLIPS, KENT L & PHILLIPS, PATRI GUARDIAN FUND, LLC 1 Residential $350 $2,275 $2,625 $7,500 1 FISHER HOMES, LLC RIVERA RICHELL 1 Residential $9,590 $3,360 $12,950 $37,000 0.8 SK2 PROPERTIES LLC THE BANK OF NEW YORK MELLON TRUST C 3 Residential $5,565 $3,010 $8,575 $24,500 $89,500 0 DIONISOPOULOS, NICK D (TRS) DIONISOPOULOS, NICHOLAS D 1 Residential $8,505 $2,695 $11,200 $32,000 0.59 MATHERS, WALKER, & BURKE INC COVER CHARLES W 6 Residential $6,755 $3,430 $10,185 $29,100 $267,000 0 DIONISOPOULOS, NICK D-TRUSTEE DIONISOPOULOS, NICK 1 Residential $13,195 $2,835 $16,030 $45,800 0.51 NATIONSTAR MORTGAGE LLC REYES, LUIS D 1 Residential $12,635 $4,690 $17,325 $49,500 0.36 SRW ROCKET LLC REICH, HANS ERICH 1 Residential $21,035 $3,500 $24,535 $70,100 1.36 TREBILCOCK, JR , MICHAEL D STEPSKI, VANESSA R 1 Residential $20,195 $3,640 $23,835 $68,100 0 FEDERAL NATIONAL MORTGAGE ASSOCIATI PARKER, MARJORIE L 1 Residential $12,460 $4,305 $16,765 $47,900 0.67 PAWLAK JR , JAMES & CALVILLO, AMAND U S HOME OWNERSHIP, LLC 1 Commercial $17,780 $12,180 $29,960 $85,600 0.88 JENNINGS, CRAIG YOUNG MICHAEL E 1 Residential $11,305 $3,500 $14,805 $42,300 0 SWOL JOHN J SWOL JOHN J 1 Residential $11,305 $3,500 $14,805 $42,300 1 SCHAEFER, ERROL SWOL JOHN J 2 Residential $22,680 $4,830 $27,510 $78,600 $89,400 0.28 SKYMOUNT PROPERTIES, LLC SCHMUCK JOURDAN, PAUL A 2 Residential $0 $3,780 $3,780 $10,800 $89,400 0.28 SKYMOUNT PROPERTIES, LLC SCHMUCK JOURDAN, PAUL A Page 46 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable Taxable Taxable Taxable Auditor Number of Assessed Assessed Assessed Estimated Total EMV Ratio Filing Parcels Property Building Land Total Market Mult. Recpt. Price to Buyer Seller Number Combined ($) Class Value Value Value Value Est. Mkt. Val. Est. Mkt. Val. Name Name 1 Residential $11,025 $4,060 $15,085 $43,100 0 BROAD STREET FUNDING TRUST I REVERSE MORTGAGE SOLUTIONS INC 1 Residential $11,025 $4,060 $15,085 $43,100 0.7 COX, GARY BROAD STREET FUNDING TRUST I 1 Residential $23,415 $7,385 $30,800 $88,000 1.31 HICKOCK, JEFFREY & HICKOK, CHRISTIN MAGANA LUDOVINA C 1 Residential $19,740 $6,790 $26,530 $75,800 0 ROJAS, KELLY F & ROJAS, LUIS G KELLET, DAVID 1 Residential $20,230 $4,270 $24,500 $70,000 0 OLD BROOKLYN PROPERTIES, LLC KASSAY, JAMES W 1 Residential $19,110 $4,375 $23,485 $67,100 0 TRAFFIS, JOANN ET AL TRAFFIS, JOANN ET AL 1 Residential $19,110 $4,375 $23,485 $67,100 0 SERVA, ROBERT TRAFFIS, JOANN ET AL 1 Residential $12,705 $4,445 $17,150 $49,000 1.51 SCIALABBA, FRANK J AND SCIALABBA, JMR ACQUISITIONS 1 Residential $22,260 $6,405 $28,665 $81,900 0.49 KELLER, DOUGLAS J GRAHAM MICHAEL O & L K 1 Residential $11,935 $6,720 $18,655 $53,300 1.54 BERK, DAVID GEIHSLER FAMILY INVESTMENTS LLC 1 Residential $31,185 $7,770 $38,955 $111,300 1.12 SIBERT, HARRISON & ZUBER, KATELYN GREIFENSTEIN, SARAH M & KAZIMER, P 1 Residential $22,645 $6,965 $29,610 $84,600 0 SPRINKLE ROAD & CORK STREET LLC WEINMAN, FREDERICK 1 Residential $24,395 $7,385 $31,780 $90,800 1.32 REGULA, JOHN AND REGULA, MARIE GLISIC MICHAEL D & LORRAINE 1 Residential $19,285 $8,470 $27,755 $79,300 1.55 LANPHEAR, SARAH SAWYER BLAZY, DANIEL M 1 Residential $21,350 $8,470 $29,820 $85,200 0.94 TOTH, MARC ANTHONY BRENTS, NOAH 1 Residential $19,600 $6,825 $26,425 $75,500 0 KOLZ, MICHAEL F & MARES, JEANNE L KOLZ, MARY ANN 1 Residential $30,065 $3,325 $33,390 $95,400 1.18 TETTERTON-WILLIAMS, CYNTHIA & WILLI CLAY, DARRELL A 1 Residential $24,535 $7,525 $32,060 $91,600 0 OBERG, JACQUELINE L OBERG JOHN W 1 Residential $24,150 $8,960 $33,110 $94,600 0 BASTOCK, AMY & WALTER, META BUELOW, ELEANORE 1 Residential $24,150 $8,960 $33,110 $94,600 0 BASTOCK, AMY & WENNING, ALISE BASTOCK, AMY & WALTER, META 1 Residential $31,220 $6,685 $37,905 $108,300 1.14 HOWELL, JOSHUA VALE, MARK M 1 Residential $28,595 $6,580 $35,175 $100,500 0 WILSON, GERALD L WILSON, JONOTHAN 1 Residential $48,545 $8,750 $57,295 $163,700 0 SGRO, JOSEPH C & SGRO, CRYSTAL E SGRO, JOSEPH C 1 Residential $20,965 $9,450 $30,415 $86,900 1.5 ELLINGTON, ADAM N ROCHA, WILLIAM & LINDA 2 Residential $0 $280 $280 $800 $132,200 0 SOLOMOND PAUL & BLOCH CORI JO TRUST SOLOMOND PAUL & BLOCH CORI JO TRUST AFN201812030579 2 Residential $0 $280 $280 $800 $132,200 1.19 SMITH, SR , RONALD O SOLOMOND PAUL & BLOCH CORI JO TRUST 2 Residential $39,935 $6,055 $45,990 $131,400 $132,200 0 SOLOMOND PAUL & BLOCH CORI JO TRUST SOLOMOND PAUL & BLOCH CORI JO TRUST AFN201812030579 2 Residential $39,935 $6,055 $45,990 $131,400 $132,200 1.19 SMITH, SR , RONALD O SOLOMOND PAUL & BLOCH CORI JO TRUST 1 Residential $28,245 $5,425 $33,670 $96,200 1.36 THOMSON, BRIAN L GARCIA, LESLIE K 1 Residential $27,160 $5,425 $32,585 $93,100 0.79 BAYS, ANTHONY M PARENTE, GUISEPPE 1 Residential $18,550 $4,200 $22,750 $65,000 1.14 HANCOCK, DANIEL ERICK & HANCOCK, IR CATALINO, JOSEPH R 1 Commercial $97,930 $9,555 $107,485 $307,100 0.81 RESSLER, ADAM RAYMOND SOPKA, MIROSLAV 1 Residential $13,650 $4,305 $17,955 $51,300 1.13 KING, DENNIS M & KING, LINDA K HERTZING, RONALD L TRUSTEE 1 Residential $15,960 $4,270 $20,230 $57,800 0.95 U S BANK TRUST, N A TRUSTEE SILOY, STEVEN B 1 Residential $12,705 $4,270 $16,975 $48,500 0 OLD BROADVIEW, LLC MCDONALD, MANUEL G 1 Residential $19,845 $5,355 $25,200 $72,000 1.1 HEALD & HEALD PROPERTIES I LLC CATALINO, JOSEPH RIZZO 1 Residential $16,415 $2,695 $19,110 $54,600 0 LION OF JUDAH CHRISTIAN FAMILY CENT BILL & BOB'S LLC 1 Residential $11,060 $4,410 $15,470 $44,200 0 ZMUDZINSKI, SUSAN & ZMUDZINSKI, ANT ZMUDZINSKI, SUSAN 1 Residential $19,285 $4,725 $24,010 $68,600 0 FEDERAL NATIONAL MORTGAGE ASSOCIATI YINGST, JEANNE M 1 Residential $18,970 $5,075 $24,045 $68,700 0.58 KELLY, SEAN P WOOTAN, JACQUELINE 1 Residential $20,230 $5,005 $25,235 $72,100 0 WENSEL, DAVID P AND WENSEL, MARK S WENSEL HERMAN R 1 Residential $20,230 $5,005 $25,235 $72,100 1.32 DELIZ, ANGEL M AND MALAVE, YONAIRA WENSEL, DAVID P AND WENSEL, MARK S 1 Residential $16,450 $4,200 $20,650 $59,000 0.4 DOLLAR BANK FEDERAL SAVINGS BANK MOSKO GEORGE 1 Residential $16,450 $4,200 $20,650 $59,000 0.73 FRANGIAS, DEMETRIOS DOLLAR BANK FEDERAL SAVINGS BANK Page 47 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable Taxable Taxable Taxable Auditor Number of Assessed Assessed Assessed Estimated Total EMV Ratio Filing Parcels Property Building Land Total Market Mult. Recpt. Price to Buyer Seller Number Combined ($) Class Value Value Value Value Est. Mkt. Val. Est. Mkt. Val. Name Name 1 Residential $17,290 $4,375 $21,665 $61,900 0 SHOREWAY MANAGEMENT, LLC KASSAY, JAMES & SKROVAN, THOMAS 1 Residential $17,605 $5,215 $22,820 $65,200 0 OLD BROADVIEW, LLC MCDONALD, MANUEL, 1 Residential $18,760 $4,655 $23,415 $66,900 0.6 IRACE, DAVID M BROWN, JAMES & BROWN, DONNA 1 Residential $14,945 $4,655 $19,600 $56,000 0 PASCA, REMUS P FURFARO, MARTIN J 1 Residential $17,255 $4,235 $21,490 $61,400 0.57 JPMORGAN CHASE BANK YEAROUT, MICHAEL S 1 Residential $12,670 $4,830 $17,500 $50,000 2.4 GROEZINGER, LESLIE R SZCZEPANEK, KONRAD PETER 1 Residential $19,635 $4,760 $24,395 $69,700 0 KILCOYNE, CHRISTOPHER KILCOYNE, BERNICE G 1 Residential $22,960 $4,865 $27,825 $79,500 0.7 KRAMER, ASHLEY MUIR, KEVIN R & MUIR, SANDRA J 1 Residential $19,495 $4,865 $24,360 $69,600 0.58 ROGERS, DAVID K JR MATTHEWS, WILLIAM A 1 Residential $21,630 $7,455 $29,085 $83,100 0.43 GAINES, WILLIAM DANCZAK EDWARD F & SHIRLEY A 1 Residential $17,605 $7,175 $24,780 $70,800 0 KILEY, MICHAEL J SECRETARY OF VETERANS AFFAIRS 1 Residential $19,145 $5,565 $24,710 $70,600 0 CARRINGTON MORTGAGE SERVICES LLC TORRES, JOHN & JIMENEZ, LESLIE A 1 Residential $19,145 $5,565 $24,710 $70,600 0 SECRETARY OF VETERANS AFFAIRS CARRINGTON MORTGAGE SERVICES LLC 1 Residential $23,345 $5,565 $28,910 $82,600 0.99 LATORRE, ERIK & FOSS, JUSTYCE G SOEDER, JAMES H 1 Residential $19,985 $5,110 $25,095 $71,700 1.12 OROZCO, FERNANDO KANTOR, GREG 1 Residential $18,305 $5,110 $23,415 $66,900 1.31 SZOPO, TODD W COSTANZO, PATRICK C 1 Residential $11,935 $4,620 $16,555 $47,300 1.57 STEWART, TRAVIS M AND STEWART, SAR PIWINSKI, CLAUDE F 1 Residential $15,680 $3,955 $19,635 $56,100 0 MARTINEZ, RAFAEL & AIDA MARTINEZ, BETSY 1 Residential $14,630 $5,565 $20,195 $57,700 0.4 DILLON, MATTHEW B SR RICE, PAUL - LIFE EST 1 Residential $16,555 $4,760 $21,315 $60,900 1.15 LEELI, ALEJANDRO C DZIK, FRANK 1 Residential $16,870 $4,130 $21,000 $60,000 1.73 TURNER, LORRIE A BREZINA, DAVID 1 Residential $13,265 $4,620 $17,885 $51,100 0 FEDERAL NATIONAL MORTGAGE ASSOCIATI KRAUSHAAR, NORBERT 1 Residential $13,265 $4,620 $17,885 $51,100 0 MILES, GERALD A FEDERAL NATIONAL MORTGAGE ASSOCIATI 1 Residential $9,170 $4,900 $14,070 $40,200 2.44 HERNANDEZ, JESUS & KAROL J GANDARILLA, LUIS 1 Residential $22,575 $5,285 $27,860 $79,600 1.03 RAKIC, VLASTIMIR AND RAKIC, SVETLAN STAHNKE KENNETH C 1 Residential $18,165 $4,130 $22,295 $63,700 0 FEDERAL HOME LOAN MORTGAGE CORPORAT ZAMBO, DAVID P 1 Residential $23,240 $5,600 $28,840 $82,400 0 COONS, CLINT (TRS) YIM, NICHOLE HYUNJOO 1 Residential $21,770 $5,215 $26,985 $77,100 0 KRUPAR, ANGELA NEFF, MARY ELLEN, NEFF, THOMAS, KRU 1 Residential $19,810 $5,320 $25,130 $71,800 0 KRIVOY, OLEG KRYVAYA, KLAVDIYA 1 Residential $17,325 $5,705 $23,030 $65,800 0.84 BRENMAR PROPERTIES, LTD GARAY, ROBIN 1 Residential $18,760 $5,145 $23,905 $68,300 1.24 CHOROMANSKI, NICHOLAS WHITEHILL, PAMELA J 1 Residential $16,030 $5,985 $22,015 $62,900 0 ALMAN, DEBORAH ALMAN JEFFREY J 1 Residential $24,220 $5,985 $30,205 $86,300 0 ALTIER, DONALD ALTIER DONALD D & LAVERNE M 1 Residential $24,220 $5,845 $30,065 $85,900 1.05 ARCHACKI, NICHOLAS R RUSSELL, VIRGINIA E 1 Residential $33,600 $6,335 $39,935 $114,100 1.27 REITZ, MATTHEW M & WILSON-REITZ, M MRAZ, BEVERLY M 1 Residential $25,095 $5,845 $30,940 $88,400 1.86 LOCKYER, MATTHEW P JZS 1 Residential $20,790 $6,195 $26,985 $77,100 0 CHN HOUSING PARTNERS FEDERAL NATIONAL MORTGAGE ASSOCIATI 1 Residential $24,885 $5,845 $30,730 $87,800 0 HORTON, JOSEPH R HORTON, JOSEPH R 1 Residential $25,795 $5,775 $31,570 $90,200 0 ROSEMARK, JULIANNA A ROSEMARK, FRANK A 1 Residential $25,795 $5,775 $31,570 $90,200 1.03 DUKE, THOMAS J ROSEMARK, JULIANNA A 1 Residential $23,065 $4,970 $28,035 $80,100 1.56 RAMIREZ, SANDRA I & CINTRON, EFRAIN RITEWAY HOME SERVICES, LLC 1 Residential $21,630 $4,655 $26,285 $75,100 1.21 PEPERA, JOSEPH K & CRYSTAL S THOMAY, DARLENE M 1 Residential $19,565 $4,725 $24,290 $69,400 0.72 LAKEVIEW LOAN SERVICING LLC BLESSING, MITCHELL J 1 Residential $9,170 $4,620 $13,790 $39,400 0 BETTER BUSINESS PROPERTY, LLC CAMPBELL, ERIK Page 48 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable Taxable Taxable Taxable Auditor Number of Assessed Assessed Assessed Estimated Total EMV Ratio Filing Parcels Property Building Land Total Market Mult. Recpt. Price to Buyer Seller Number Combined ($) Class Value Value Value Value Est. Mkt. Val. Est. Mkt. Val. Name Name 1 Residential $19,495 $4,410 $23,905 $68,300 0.57 U S BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION SANTANA, ARMANDO JR 1 Residential $25,725 $6,125 $31,850 $91,000 0 MAKRAI, NATALIE MAKRAI JOHN 1 Residential $23,450 $4,935 $28,385 $81,100 1.26 HOLMOK, EDWARD MIEZIN, JEFF 1 Residential $13,335 $3,815 $17,150 $49,000 0 HOLZ, SCOTT MICHAEL & HAGAN, JOAN HOLZ, SCOTT 1 Residential $16,800 $3,780 $20,580 $58,800 0.34 CRAFT, CHARLES BASIL TRUST PROPERTIES LLC 1 Residential $15,855 $3,850 $19,705 $56,300 0 NEHEMIAH COLLABORATIVE CUYAHOGA COUNTY LAND REUTILIZATION 1 Residential $16,170 $4,480 $20,650 $59,000 1.52 GONZALEZ, JOSE ROTH, RONALD R 1 Residential $12,355 $4,585 $16,940 $48,400 0 DOWELL, CHRISTOPHER (ETAL) DOWELL, MARIETTA 1 Residential $13,055 $4,130 $17,185 $49,100 1.91 CLAIR, MICHAEL SCOTT T L C HOME IMPROVEMENT INC 1 Residential $17,850 $4,515 $22,365 $63,900 0.91 BROOKS, STEVE & BROOKS, DEBBIE ANN STURIK, MARK M & JULIANNE 1 Residential $12,285 $4,305 $16,590 $47,400 0.95 RJA PROPERTIES LLC COSTELLO, DEAN C 1 Residential $14,665 $4,130 $18,795 $53,700 0 ROOKS, BRIAN & ROOKS, CHARLES M ET ROOKS, CHARLES R 1 Residential $10,290 $3,815 $14,105 $40,300 0.93 EQUITY TRUST COMPANY NIMALE, LLC 1 Residential $14,560 $4,200 $18,760 $53,600 1.25 FEBLES, JOSUE & MAZQUITA, ELVIA MAR POPOV, SPIRIDON & MUNTEAN, ELEONORA 1 Residential $9,765 $3,535 $13,300 $38,000 1.22 PUBLIC SQUARE C APITAL RE, LLC NIMALE LLC 1 Residential $1,750 $2,065 $3,815 $10,900 0 WEBB, MELISSA R PLATT, SEAN 1 Residential $11,620 $3,395 $15,015 $42,900 1.27 FINE, JOEL A & TRUONG, VI LEE, CALVIN AND LEE, MATTHEW 1 Residential $21,770 $2,940 $24,710 $70,600 1.29 EAGLES, JADE LYLE INC 1 Residential $16,240 $3,780 $20,020 $57,200 1.15 MENCINI JR , DAVID A ARRIGHI, GERALDINE A 1 Residential $12,985 $3,185 $16,170 $46,200 0.96 FFCR, LLC FISCHER AND PAYNE LLC 1 Residential $12,495 $3,115 $15,610 $44,600 1.35 ANCHOR INVESTMENT HOLDINGS, LLC USA REGROWTH FUND LLC 1 Residential $19,775 $3,465 $23,240 $66,400 0.31 CLAUDIO, BENITO JR MYTRUSTS LLC TRUSTEE 1 Residential $20,790 $3,850 $24,640 $70,400 1.48 PACIC, MARKO AND RAMIREZ, JESUS CAMP JR , ROY M 2 Residential $18,585 $3,045 $21,630 $61,800 $114,300 0 CAL HOME SERVICES, LLC HOME CONSULTING SOLUTIONS, LLC 1 Residential $11,340 $3,080 $14,420 $41,200 0 CUYAHOGA COUNTY LAND REUTILIZATION SECRETARY OF HOUSING & URBAN DEVE 1 Residential $11,340 $3,080 $14,420 $41,200 0 DETROIT SHOREWAY COMMUNITY DEVE ORG CUYAHOGA COUNTY LAND REUTILIZATION 1 Residential $11,340 $3,080 $14,420 $41,200 0.44 NGEMBA, MAYELE DETROIT SHOREWAY COMMUNITY DEVE ORG 1 Residential $8,435 $3,115 $11,550 $33,000 0 DIONISOPOULOS, NICK D TRUSTEE DIONISOPOULOS, NICHOLAS D 1 Residential $9,695 $2,450 $12,145 $34,700 0.81 KHMER DRAGON LLC MAKHAM, SUDHAKER 1 Residential $9,905 $3,395 $13,300 $38,000 1.56 JPMORGAN CHASE BANK NATIONAL ASSOCI GARCIA JOSE A & GARCIA RAQUEL 2 Commercial $66,990 $15,890 $82,880 $236,800 $473,600 3.43 MREV ARCHWOOD LLC ARCHWOOD REALTY, LLC 2 Commercial $64,610 $18,270 $82,880 $236,800 $473,600 3.43 MREV ARCHWOOD LLC ARCHWOOD REALTY, LLC 1 Residential $14,490 $2,065 $16,555 $47,300 0.9 THE CLEVELAND REAL ESTATE PROJECT, JTC REALVEST, LLC 2 Residential $0 $245 $245 $700 $17,500 1.71 THE CLEVELAND REAL ESTATE PROJECT, GT REALVEST LLC 2 Residential $5,215 $1,330 $6,545 $18,700 $19,400 1.29 THE CLEVELAND REAL ESTATE PROJECT, GT REALVEST LLC 2 Residential $4,550 $1,330 $5,880 $16,800 $17,500 1.71 THE CLEVELAND REAL ESTATE PROJECT, GT REALVEST LLC 2 Residential $0 $245 $245 $700 $19,400 1.29 THE CLEVELAND REAL ESTATE PROJECT, GT REALVEST LLC 1 Residential $6,580 $2,520 $9,100 $26,000 1.73 DILTS, BRIAN C 2020 CAPITAL LLC 1 Commercial $15,400 $2,310 $17,710 $50,600 0 TRIZIO, BARBARA R TRUSTEE WISE, ROSE M 1 Residential $11,165 $2,415 $13,580 $38,800 0 SHIVNARINE, BHOOMESHWAR & SHIVNARIN SHIVNARINE, BHOOMESHWAR 1 Residential $13,020 $3,780 $16,800 $48,000 1 KEYLINK GLOBAL, LLC DEUTSCHE BANK NATIONAL TRUST COMPAN 1 Residential $0 $525 $525 $1,500 0 CLEVELAND LAND REUTILIZATION PROGRA REHOR RALPH 1 Residential $7,350 $2,520 $9,870 $28,200 0 ROMAN, LUZ ROMAN, LUZ & ISRAEL 1 Residential $15,680 $2,205 $17,885 $51,100 1.02 KLEIN, NICOLINA ROSS, MIKE Page 49 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable Taxable Taxable Taxable Auditor Number of Assessed Assessed Assessed Estimated Total EMV Ratio Filing Parcels Property Building Land Total Market Mult. Recpt. Price to Buyer Seller Number Combined ($) Class Value Value Value Value Est. Mkt. Val. Est. Mkt. Val. Name Name 1 Residential $10,395 $2,590 $12,985 $37,100 1.56 NTIRAMPEBA, SUZANA GONZALEZ, WILLIAM 1 Residential $4,550 $1,785 $6,335 $18,100 1.1 PROSPERCLE LLC WEST SIDE REALTY GROUP LLC 1 Residential $5,775 $2,555 $8,330 $23,800 0 SOLIS, DEBRA SECRETARY OF HOUSING AND URBAN DEVE 1 Residential $6,790 $2,660 $9,450 $27,000 0.92 LE PROPERTY GROUP, LLC DEFLORIA PROPERTIES, LLC 1 Residential $12,600 $2,345 $14,945 $42,700 0.43 USA REGROWTH FUND, LLC PHILIPOOM, DWIGHT 1 Residential $6,510 $2,345 $8,855 $25,300 0.04 FLIP MY CITY INVESTORS, LLC INTERPACIFIC PROPERTY HOLDINGS LC 1 Residential $11,060 $2,485 $13,545 $38,700 1 ACOSTA, OLGA TIPTON, ROBERT M JR 1 Residential $13,720 $2,520 $16,240 $46,400 2.03 JARRETT, KEVIN M CORRIGAN, VALERIE M 1 Residential $11,620 $2,450 $14,070 $40,200 1.19 PAPAGIANIS, KONSTANTINOS IWENOFU, ANTHONY 1 Residential $8,435 $2,345 $10,780 $30,800 0 QUEENER, DORIS GENE QUEENER DORIS G & JEAN K 1 Residential $9,240 $2,520 $11,760 $33,600 0.5 PINEDO, JAMES PINEDO, JAMES & TORRES, AIDA 1 Residential $8,400 $2,100 $10,500 $30,000 1 ANDINO, JENNIFER M PABON, MIGDALIA 1 Residential $3,710 $2,730 $6,440 $18,400 0.68 FF INVERSIONES, LLC NGUYEN, LE H 1 Residential $6,405 $2,310 $8,715 $24,900 0.4 JPMORGAN CHASE BANK NATIONAL ASSOCI SCHILLING, RICHARD G 1 Residential $6,405 $2,310 $8,715 $24,900 0 THE SECRETARY OF VETERANS AFFAIRS JPMORGAN CHASE BANK NATIONAL ASSOCI 2 Residential $20,755 $2,310 $23,065 $65,900 $66,700 0.33 S & P PROPERTY MGMT LLC DEUTSCHE BANK TRUST COMPANY AMERICA 2 Residential $0 $280 $280 $800 $66,700 0.33 S & P PROPERTY MGMT LLC DEUTSCHE BANK TRUST COMPANY AMERICA 1 Residential $9,625 $2,275 $11,900 $34,000 0 STERN, CHAUNCEY ALLAN STERN, CHAUNCEY, ALLAN & MELISSA K 1 Residential $4,725 $2,275 $7,000 $20,000 1.95 PORE, DOROTHY GEORGIA , AUSTIN JR 1 Residential $8,015 $2,380 $10,395 $29,700 0 FEDERAL NATIONAL MORTGAGE ASSOCIATI THOMPSON, JAMES & MARZENA 4 Residential $8,400 $2,870 $11,270 $32,200 $118,600 0 GUARDIAN FUND, LLC HOME PARTNERS LLC 4 Residential $8,400 $2,870 $11,270 $32,200 $118,600 2.11 PHILLIPS, KENT L & PHILLIPS, PATRI GUARDIAN FUND, LLC 1 Residential $6,685 $2,555 $9,240 $26,400 0.91 HOMES TO RENT LLC MOHOS DEREK G & LISETTE A 1 Residential $8,715 $2,660 $11,375 $32,500 1.37 FFCR, LLC FISCHER AND PAYNE LLC 1 Residential $5,215 $2,905 $8,120 $23,200 1 NGUYEN, MARY PHAM, QUOC L 1 Residential $2,310 $2,555 $4,865 $13,900 0 SCHUMANN, PAUL D TRS , SCHUMANN, KULHANEK, CHRISTOPHER 1 Residential $7,315 $3,045 $10,360 $29,600 0.78 OHIO CITY DEVELOPMENT GROUP, LLC WALNUT DEVELOPMENT, LLC 1 Residential $910 $2,765 $3,675 $10,500 0 CUYAHOGA COUNTY LAND REUTILIZATION BARTLEY, JAMES R 2 Residential $9,625 $2,590 $12,215 $34,900 $38,400 0.69 FIRST AMERICAN FUNDING LLC URAM, JEANNE 1 Residential $4,515 $2,590 $7,105 $20,300 0 PINEIRO, DARIO PINEIRO, GERMAN 1 Residential $4,515 $2,590 $7,105 $20,300 1.67 BRUMFIELD, AUSTIN PINEIRO, DARIO 1 Residential $13,755 $3,710 $17,465 $49,900 0.5 RAEE, SHADIE BEASLEY JR , LAWRENCE & RAEE, SHADI 1 Residential $13,755 $3,710 $17,465 $49,900 0 RAEE, SALWA RAEE, SHADIE 1 Residential $16,065 $5,950 $22,015 $62,900 0.64 WHITE, CHARLES E & TAMMY L RIDER, VERNELL 1 Residential $16,345 $4,305 $20,650 $59,000 0 CUYAHOGA COUNTY LAND REUTILIZATION MERRIMAN ROBERT G &JEANETTE 1 Residential $18,515 $4,480 $22,995 $65,700 0 SMALL HOLDING GROUP, LLC SMALL, JOSEPH J 1 Residential $8,540 $2,730 $11,270 $32,200 0.92 JFA PARTNERS LLC CHONDRITE REO LLC (1) 1 Residential $9,275 $2,730 $12,005 $34,300 0 SRW ROCKET, LLC LENIZ, LOUIS 1 Residential $8,890 $3,290 $12,180 $34,800 1.06 MABELA, MADELEINE PHUOE, LAM THANH 2 Residential $12,040 $2,975 $15,015 $42,900 $45,200 1.04 SCOTT, NIGEL ROBERTS, BETTY A 1 Residential $16,730 $7,560 $24,290 $69,400 0 CHEN, ZOE XIU WENG, YUMAN 1 Residential $17,710 $6,475 $24,185 $69,100 1.46 REIDL, JAMES M AND SCHULZ, AMANDA DEMKO, CHRISTIAN L & KELLY A 1 Residential $7,210 $3,290 $10,500 $30,000 0 DIONISOPOULOS, NICK D TRUSTEE DIONISOPOULOUS, NICK 1 Residential $4,760 $2,065 $6,825 $19,500 2.28 FFCR, LLC FISCHER AND PAYNE LLC Page 50 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable Taxable Taxable Taxable Auditor Number of Assessed Assessed Assessed Estimated Total EMV Ratio Filing Parcels Property Building Land Total Market Mult. Recpt. Price to Buyer Seller Number Combined ($) Class Value Value Value Value Est. Mkt. Val. Est. Mkt. Val. Name Name 3 Residential $12,495 $2,345 $14,840 $42,400 $89,500 0 DIONISOPOULOS, NICK D (TRS) DIONISOPOULOS, NICHOLAS D 1 Residential $7,910 $2,485 $10,395 $29,700 0 CUDELL IMPROVEMENT INC CUYAHOGA COUNTY LAND REUTILIZATION 1 Residential $7,910 $2,485 $10,395 $29,700 0.12 SMART DEVELOPMENT INC CUDELL IMPROVEMENT INC 1 Residential $7,210 $2,450 $9,660 $27,600 0 DIONISOPOULOS, NICK D (TRS) DIONISOPULOS, NICHOLAS 1 Residential $11,445 $2,485 $13,930 $39,800 1.41 ANCHOR INVESTMENT HOLDINGS, LLC MYRTLE HILL LLC 1 Residential $8,155 $2,345 $10,500 $30,000 1.44 OH PAZ HOLDINGS, LLC 2183 W 103RD LLC 1 Residential $6,230 $2,590 $8,820 $25,200 1.77 FFCR, LLC FISCHER AND PAYNE LLC 1 Residential $10,220 $2,590 $12,810 $36,600 0.77 GREEN TREE HOLDINGS, LLC QASEM, MOHAMED KH M 6 Residential $9,555 $2,905 $12,460 $35,600 $267,000 0 DIONISOPOULOS, NICK D-TRUSTEE DIONISOPOULOS, NICK 2 Residential $7,735 $2,485 $10,220 $29,200 $63,100 0 DIONISOPOULOS, NICK D TRS DIONISOPOULOS, NICHOLAS 6 Residential $4,970 $2,450 $7,420 $21,200 $267,000 0 DIONISOPOULOS, NICK D-TRUSTEE DIONISOPOULOS, NICK 6 Residential $7,280 $2,485 $9,765 $27,900 $267,000 0 DIONISOPOULOS, NICK D-TRUSTEE DIONISOPOULOS, NICK 1 Residential $9,030 $2,345 $11,375 $32,500 1.63 JAOUDE, AMANDA ABOU HICKS, SHANNON M & HICKS, AMY E 3 Residential $5,915 $1,995 $7,910 $22,600 $89,500 0 DIONISOPOULOS, NICK D (TRS) DIONISOPOULOS, NICHOLAS D 1 Residential $7,035 $1,995 $9,030 $25,800 0 PETRY, HEATHER ROBINSON, MARTHA E 1 Residential $2,695 $2,380 $5,075 $14,500 1 HUGHES, CHRISTOPHER BOZAK, SANDRA 6 Residential $7,000 $2,520 $9,520 $27,200 $267,000 0 DIONISOPOULOS, NICK D-TRUSTEE DIONISOPOULOS, NICK 1 Residential $11,445 $3,290 $14,735 $42,100 0.36 JULIUS PATRICK INDUSTRIES LLC ZAGAMI, FRANK 1 Residential $12,285 $3,745 $16,030 $45,800 0 IWAIS, WESAM MOLONGLO CORP 1 Residential $13,405 $3,780 $17,185 $49,100 1.52 INFANTE, BELKYS S BORTS, WILLIAM F & REBEKAH 1 Residential $9,275 $3,780 $13,055 $37,300 0 THROWER, ALBERT SAINT ANTHONY THE GREAT ROMANIAN O 1 Residential $13,125 $3,640 $16,765 $47,900 0.31 US BANK TRUST-TRUSTEE SMITH, HAROLD 1 Residential $10,185 $3,185 $13,370 $38,200 0.65 SOUEIDI, JUSTIN CLE HOMES LLC 1 Residential $9,415 $2,800 $12,215 $34,900 0 COLUMBIA PROPERTY MANAGEMENT, LLC KASSAY, JAMES W 1 Residential $13,895 $3,640 $17,535 $50,100 0.96 KOJANI, ZMAR SAPP KENETH K & EMRICH COLLETTA 2 Residential $0 $315 $315 $900 $37,000 0.7 GARCIA, EMMANUEL H MILLER, VICTORIA A 2 Residential $10,185 $2,450 $12,635 $36,100 $37,000 0.7 GARCIA, EMMANUEL H MILLER, VICTORIA A 1 Residential $10,325 $3,395 $13,720 $39,200 0 DERY, MICHAEL J & DERY, FRANK J S LEAR, LORETTA - TRUSTEE OF 1 Residential $10,325 $3,395 $13,720 $39,200 0 DERY, MICHAEL J DERY, MICHAEL J & DERY, FRANK J S 1 Residential $9,870 $3,395 $13,265 $37,900 0 TURCZYK, MELISSA RENEE HALK JOYCE L 1 Residential $9,835 $3,815 $13,650 $39,000 0.51 THE BARKLEY COMPANY LLC PENA, RICARDO A 1 Residential $8,890 $3,815 $12,705 $36,300 1.4 FFCR, LLC FESS, ALBERT R 1 Residential $9,520 $3,815 $13,335 $38,100 1.34 FFCR, LLC FESS, AL 1 Residential $11,305 $3,360 $14,665 $41,900 0.48 NATIONSTAR MORTGAGE LLC GIELINK, CHRISTOPHER 1 Residential $11,200 $3,325 $14,525 $41,500 1 MOHAMMAD, NAHSSEMH K & PEDROZA, CH 3612 CLARK AVENUE INC 1 Residential $11,200 $3,360 $14,560 $41,600 1 WISCONSIN INVESTMENT GROUP, LLC ZAGG HOLDINGS, LLC 1 Residential $9,975 $3,360 $13,335 $38,100 0.42 JEFFERSON, ERNESTA CLEVELAND CAPITAL DEVELOPERS, LLC 1 Residential $14,105 $3,570 $17,675 $50,500 1.09 BROOKS, STEVEN & BROOKS, DEBBIE ANN ASGARD REALTY LLC 2 Residential $8,995 $5,180 $14,175 $40,500 $133,200 1.07 EISENBERG, JEFF RACHITSKIY ANTON 2 Commercial $26,110 $6,335 $32,445 $92,700 $133,200 1.07 EISENBERG, JEFF RACHITSKIY ANTON 1 Residential $0 $11,655 $11,655 $33,300 10.23 READINGER, MICHAEL J & VINKLER JR DEAL, JEB S & MEGAN L 1 Residential $83,440 $8,750 $92,190 $263,400 0 ANTAL, KELLY A ORZECH, KELLY 1 Residential $36,050 $10,150 $46,200 $132,000 0 VAZQUEZ, REUBEN & VAZQUEZ, MERCEDES VAZQUEZ, REUBEN (ETAL) 1 Residential $36,050 $10,150 $46,200 $132,000 0.7 SMALL HOLDING GROUP LLC VAZQUEZ, REUBEN & VAZQUEZ, MERCEDES Page 51 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable Taxable Taxable Taxable Auditor Number of Assessed Assessed Assessed Estimated Total EMV Ratio Filing Parcels Property Building Land Total Market Mult. Recpt. Price to Buyer Seller Number Combined ($) Class Value Value Value Value Est. Mkt. Val. Est. Mkt. Val. Name Name 1 Residential $29,610 $10,990 $40,600 $116,000 0.73 VLACH INC PARRISH, YONNIE & PARRISH, BREYON 1 Residential $22,960 $9,100 $32,060 $91,600 1.31 BCD PROPERTIES, INC SMITH PATSY ANN 1 Residential $0 $0 $0 $0 PAPANIA, BEAU BATTERY PARK DEVELOPMENT, LLC 1 Residential $20,615 $10,430 $31,045 $88,700 1.41 KURILCHICK, JARED & ROBERTS, CHRIST DURST, JOLENE 1 Residential $14,210 $8,190 $22,400 $64,000 6.94 ZELLER, LINDSAY SJ BROCK FRANCIS PHILIP SCOTT 1 Residential $0 $4,130 $4,130 $11,800 39.26 APT, MICHAEL A CYAN PARK INC 1 Residential $0 $4,130 $4,130 $11,800 0 APT, MICHAEL A APT, MICHAEL A 1 Residential $0 $4,130 $4,130 $11,800 36.34 VOIERS, SCOTT CYAN PARK INC 1 Residential $0 $4,130 $4,130 $11,800 0 VOIERS, SCOTT VOIERS, SCOTT 1 Residential $0 $4,130 $4,130 $11,800 36.49 STOREY, JOHN O AND STOREY, CANDICE CYAN PARK INC 1 Residential $0 $4,130 $4,130 $11,800 0 STOREY, JOHN O & CANDICE L STOREY, JOHN O AND STOREY, CANDICE 1 Residential $0 $4,620 $4,620 $13,200 34.28 REINOSO, MICHAL R & SCHLATHER, HALL BREAKWATER BLUFFS, LLC 1 Residential $0 $5,320 $5,320 $15,200 37.4 MAKOVICKA, JOSEPH P & MAKOVICA, MA BREAKWATER BLUFFS, LLC 1 Residential $36,505 $7,455 $43,960 $125,600 0 AMERICAN DREAM HOLDINGS LLC NORRIS, BRIAN W 1 Residential $22,995 $8,505 $31,500 $90,000 1.06 WANDER HOME LLC VLACH, GEOFFREY 1 Residential $27,860 $7,980 $35,840 $102,400 0 PISANO, MICHAEL J PISANO, MICHAEL J & MARY S 1 Residential $0 $8,785 $8,785 $25,100 17.88 TERRY, ALLISON J JAMES ALVES 1 Residential $7,805 $2,240 $10,045 $28,700 1 SUMMERSON, JAMES & PAULA FAIN, RONALD D 1 Residential $23,205 $13,965 $37,170 $106,200 0 LOWSTETTER, JOHN LOWSTETTER PATRICIA E 1 Residential $21,875 $12,390 $34,265 $97,900 1.58 RUTHERFORD, HAYDEN CPD REALTY & HOLDINGS LLC 1 Residential $32,620 $13,230 $45,850 $131,000 1.3 TAYLOR, WILLIAM J SEVERINO, WILLIAM G AFN201812110170 2 Residential $12,705 $13,790 $26,495 $75,700 $79,000 0 6007-6009 WAKEFIELD LLC 6007-6009 WAKEFIELD LLC 1 Residential $15,085 $13,790 $28,875 $82,500 0 STARKEY, BILLY ETAL MANHART, MARTHA E , AFN201812110170 2 Residential $0 $1,155 $1,155 $3,300 $79,000 0 6007-6009 WAKEFIELD LLC 6007-6009 WAKEFIELD LLC 1 Residential $37,065 $15,085 $52,150 $149,000 0 SHOREWAY MANAGEMENT, LLC SKROVAN, THOMAS B & KASSAY, JAMES 1 Residential $22,120 $13,405 $35,525 $101,500 0.26 KEARNEY, ELLEN MARIE KEARNEY, ELLEN MARIE & BITTNER, PAM 1 Residential $7,210 $13,790 $21,000 $60,000 2.5 CASA ALEGRE, LLC DE OLAZAVAL, ANTOINE AMADO AND DAVI 1 Residential $13,545 $15,260 $28,805 $82,300 4.9 THOMAS, TRENT H & TARA D TOM'S COMPLETE CONSTRUCTION AND REN 1 Residential $20,895 $12,075 $32,970 $94,200 0 MURRELL, MARGARET & BUCEY, RONALD MURRELL, MARGARET 1 Residential $36,190 $12,215 $48,405 $138,300 1.84 HOGG, JAMES W & FARDELL, SHAINA KODRIN, MATTHEW 1 Residential $17,710 $13,580 $31,290 $89,400 1.12 DMF LAND, LLC ANDREKO FRANK 1 Residential $22,400 $10,220 $32,620 $93,200 0.75 FEDERMANN, KARL R PROSPERCLE, LLC 1 Residential $0 $12,075 $12,075 $34,500 9.16 YEAGER, III, PAUL L & YEAGER, CA B R KNEZ CONSTRUCTION, INC 1 Residential $58,590 $6,930 $65,520 $187,200 0.88 SCARPELLI, JOSEPH A BERKOWITZ, MICHAEL 1 Residential $6,650 $9,100 $15,750 $45,000 0 AMF PROPERTIES, LLC BUTLER, JEFFREY AND BUTLER, MARY KA AFN201812180197 2 Residential $35 $11,095 $11,130 $31,800 $33,600 0 PERZ, ALEX & WHALE, JESSICA PERZ, ALEX & WHALE, JESSICA AFN201812180197 2 Residential $0 $630 $630 $1,800 $33,600 0 PERZ, ALEX & WHALE, JESSICA PERZ, ALEX & WHALE, JESSICA AFN201812050206 2 Residential $0 $12,530 $12,530 $35,800 $37,600 0 MEYERS-KIOUSIS, ALANNA L TRS MEYERS-KIOUSIS, ALANNA L TRS AFN201812050206 2 Residential $0 $630 $630 $1,800 $37,600 0 MEYERS-KIOUSIS, ALANNA MEYERS-KIOUSIS, ALANNA 1 Residential $7,350 $3,640 $10,990 $31,400 0 DETROIT SHOREWAY COMMUNITY DEVELOPM FEDERAL NATIONAL MORTGAGE ASSOCIATI 1 Residential $7,350 $3,640 $10,990 $31,400 0.22 MATTERN, CHRIS DETROIT SHOREWAY COMMUNITY DEVELOPM 1 Residential $18,830 $4,060 $22,890 $65,400 0.29 BODA, MOZES HERNANDEZ, MIGUEL A 1 Residential $12,145 $3,640 $15,785 $45,100 0 SAA, GEORGETT J SAA BUTROS J 1 Residential $12,145 $3,640 $15,785 $45,100 0 SAA, FARES B SAA, GEORGETT J Page 52 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable Taxable Taxable Taxable Auditor Number of Assessed Assessed Assessed Estimated Total EMV Ratio Filing Parcels Property Building Land Total Market Mult. Recpt. Price to Buyer Seller Number Combined ($) Class Value Value Value Value Est. Mkt. Val. Est. Mkt. Val. Name Name 1 Residential $5,040 $2,520 $7,560 $21,600 0 GRAYLAIN, LLC MOUNTAINSIDE REALTY VENTURES LLC 1 Residential $8,785 $2,520 $11,305 $32,300 0 GOODSPEED, DELMAR AND GOODSPEED, BU GOODSPEED MARY 1 Residential $350 $1,995 $2,345 $6,700 0 7421 DUDLEY AVENUE TRUST HOGHEAD SOLUTIONS, LLC 1 Residential $13,825 $2,520 $16,345 $46,700 1.09 FFCR, LLC FESS ALBERT A 1 Residential $0 $525 $525 $1,500 1 SCHNEIDER, MARK C & FORD, REBECCA ALLPHASE DEVELOPMENT GROUP LTD 1 Residential $6,020 $1,435 $7,455 $21,300 1 BETTER BUSINESS PROPERTY, LLC MURPH, RICARDO II 1 Residential $106,365 $30,135 $136,500 $390,000 0 NORMAN, MATTHEW T NORMAN, MATTHEW T & JERLSTROM, STE 1 Residential $39,060 $19,390 $58,450 $167,000 1 MURRAY, CHRISTOPHER PUCEK, ANTHONY 1 Residential $54,040 $10,115 $64,155 $183,300 0 NEBESH, INGRID L & BOHDAN A & LI NEBESH, INGRID L & BOHDAN A & JAT 1 Residential $100,065 $27,370 $127,435 $364,100 1.33 REALIFE MANAGEMENT GROUP LLC 9803 LAKE AVENUE, L L C 1 Residential $25,480 $8,925 $34,405 $98,300 1.57 MELLINO, CALDER AND MELLINO, JENNIF CUMMINGS DAVID JOSEPH & ASHLEE DANI 1 Residential $32,655 $10,220 $42,875 $122,500 0 CASAREGOLA, CONCETTA I CASAREGOLA, JOSEPH L & CASAREGO 1 Residential $11,165 $3,045 $14,210 $40,600 1.6 LESLIE, REG G CAPITAL FUNDING LLC 1 Residential $12,425 $4,235 $16,660 $47,600 0.42 LUBLIN, JEREMY M & NICOLE L BONDS, JAMES C 1 Residential $20,055 $5,215 $25,270 $72,200 0 HEISEY, MATTHEW D & TROTT-HEISEY, HEISEY, MATT 1 Residential $1,470 $2,240 $3,710 $10,600 0 WISCONSIN INVESTMENT GROUP, LLC INVICTUS ASSET MANAGEMENT, LLC 2 Residential $28,980 $3,010 $31,990 $91,400 $95,700 0.79 PEGUERO, JESSICA G FRANCIS, CRYSTAL 2 Residential $0 $1,505 $1,505 $4,300 $95,700 0.79 PEGUERO, JESSICA G FRANCIS, CRYSTAL 1 Residential $12,565 $3,010 $15,575 $44,500 0 FREDERICK, DONNA TRUSTEE FREDERICK JOHN A 1 Residential $14,210 $3,010 $17,220 $49,200 0.49 DEMKO, VLADIMIR SAUERS, PHILIP L 1 Residential $9,555 $3,010 $12,565 $35,900 0.56 KOVALCIK, JAMES IACANO, JOSEPH M AND IACANO, KAREN 1 Residential $9,940 $3,430 $13,370 $38,200 1.57 MARCONI, HEATHER R TKACH VITALIY 1 Residential $10,080 $3,255 $13,335 $38,100 0 PARDEE, CATHERINE PARDEE, CATHERINE & ROSA, HECTOR 1 Residential $9,940 $3,255 $13,195 $37,700 0 RENT, INC GONZALEZ, ANA MARLENE 1 Residential $10,290 $3,220 $13,510 $38,600 0.8 SINGH, DICK P THE BANK OF NEW YORK MELLON -TRUSTE 1 Residential $10,675 $3,220 $13,895 $39,700 1.31 BRESSLER, CONNIE L GREATER CLEVELAND HABITAT FOR HUMAN 2 Residential $5,355 $2,520 $7,875 $22,500 $24,000 1.47 MIKHAEL, ANTOINE & HINNAWI, JOANN NIMALE, LLC 2 Residential $0 $525 $525 $1,500 $24,000 1.47 MIKHAEL, ANTOINE & HINNAWI, JOANN NIMALE, LLC 2 Residential $8,820 $2,380 $11,200 $32,000 $32,500 1.31 ALDEA INVESTMENTS, LLC SJH RENTALS LLC 2 Residential $0 $175 $175 $500 $32,500 1.31 ALDEA INVESTMENTS, LLC SJH RENTALS LLC 1 Residential $17,570 $3,115 $20,685 $59,100 1.69 SPANGLER, MARK BLANE & SPANGLER, KI PROSPERCLE, LLC 1 Residential $19,530 $2,800 $22,330 $63,800 0 SOPKO, ELIZABETH A ET AL SWARM, RICHARD H 1 Residential $19,530 $2,800 $22,330 $63,800 0.63 CLE RENOVATION GROUP, LLC SOPKO, ELIZABETH A ET AL 1 Residential $12,495 $4,410 $16,905 $48,300 0 HUMPHREY, MICHAEL D UNITED AEROSPACE SOLUTIONS, LLC 1 Residential $27,020 $6,930 $33,950 $97,000 0 RILEY, VINCENT C RILEY VINCENT C 1 Residential $20,230 $4,480 $24,710 $70,600 1.35 TORRES, JEFFREY SZYARTO, ELIZABETH J & STEPHEN J 1 Residential $23,100 $6,265 $29,365 $83,900 0 GULLEY, VANCE TRS JOHNSON, CHERYL D (TRS) 1 Residential $12,320 $4,410 $16,730 $47,800 1.67 BROWN, JAMES RBR INVESTMENTS, INC 1 Residential $18,620 $4,410 $23,030 $65,800 1.27 LOPEZ, ELIUS J ROSARIO & RODRIGUEZ SCHWETER, ALAN M 1 Residential $16,485 $3,780 $20,265 $57,900 0 SPROSTY, ALEA R SPROSTY, PAUL J 1 Residential $12,880 $3,780 $16,660 $47,600 0 REEVES, MARGARET A REEVES, LARRY J 1 Residential $16,555 $3,780 $20,335 $58,100 0.77 SOLEIMAN, HANNA AND SOLEIMAN, AIDA WELLS FARGO BANK NA 1 Residential $12,040 $5,145 $17,185 $49,100 0.46 BCM RENOVATION LTD REDMOND WINONA 1 Residential $13,475 $4,200 $17,675 $50,500 0 JIROUSEK, THOMAS A, JR & JIROUSEK, JIROUSEK, MICHELLE & JIROUSEK, THOM Page 53 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable Taxable Taxable Taxable Auditor Number of Assessed Assessed Assessed Estimated Total EMV Ratio Filing Parcels Property Building Land Total Market Mult. Recpt. Price to Buyer Seller Number Combined ($) Class Value Value Value Value Est. Mkt. Val. Est. Mkt. Val. Name Name 3 Residential $16,345 $3,710 $20,055 $57,300 $136,899 0 TAYEH PROPERTIES, LLC TAYEH, JOSEPH 1 Residential $18,060 $4,340 $22,400 $64,000 0 MALCOLM, KENNETH H & MALCOLM, KEVIN MALCOLM, DAVID S , TRUSTEE 1 Residential $18,060 $4,340 $22,400 $64,000 1.06 LITCHNEY, MARSHA MALCOLM, KENNETH H & MALCOLM, KEVIN 1 Residential $29,750 $7,665 $37,415 $106,900 0 SMITH, PATRICIA A SMITH, GARY E 1 Residential $23,450 $6,160 $29,610 $84,600 1.14 LORIA, ANTHONY M EQUITY TRUST COMANY FBO MICHAEL SWE 1 Residential $15,295 $5,075 $20,370 $58,200 0.93 WILMINGTON SAVINGS FUND SOCIETY FSB YOUSEF, AHMAD S 1 Residential $11,305 $3,640 $14,945 $42,700 0.89 PROSPERCLE, LLC MEPHAM, DENNIS R 1 Residential $15,855 $3,885 $19,740 $56,400 0 MELENDEZ, SILVIA AVERY, SILVIA 1 Residential $15,855 $3,885 $19,740 $56,400 0 AVERY, SILVIA AVERY, AARON MITCHELL 1 Residential $0 $525 $525 $1,500 0 CLEVELAND LAND REUTILIZATION PROGRA DIONISOPOULOS, NICK D TRUSTEE 1 Residential $17,185 $4,410 $21,595 $61,700 0 BURDETTE, MELISSA ET AL BURDETTE, JOSEPH ET AL 1 Residential $21,280 $4,060 $25,340 $72,400 0.95 LIAO, ALBERT MAHMOUD MUNER 1 Residential $19,635 $3,815 $23,450 $67,000 1.23 MORGANTI, NICHOLAS J WANOUS, ROBERT J & MATTHEW J 1 Residential $20,230 $3,955 $24,185 $69,100 1.59 CURRY, SHERRI BRENT MOORE DBA 360 REHAB 1 Residential $17,465 $3,640 $21,105 $60,300 1.22 U S BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION CASSIDY, STEPHEN J 1 Residential $10,010 $4,235 $14,245 $40,700 1 KENNEDY, GEORGE R KALISTA, JAMES W & MICHELE 1 Residential $8,575 $3,045 $11,620 $33,200 1.81 DHARMAVARAM, SANTOSH RK & PRATHIP BARRACUDA 1, LLC 1 Residential $19,495 $5,040 $24,535 $70,100 0 DTAYLORG INVESTMENTS LTD FEDERAL NATIONAL MORT ASSOC 1 Residential $22,575 $5,320 $27,895 $79,700 0 KWOON, BETTY KWOON, BETTY 1 Residential $24,290 $5,460 $29,750 $85,000 1.19 GUTHREY, BRENT R PEACOCK, JASON W 1 Residential $21,595 $5,180 $26,775 $76,500 1.31 BURKHALTER, ELIZABETH M & BURKHALTE HASSAN, MOHAMED 1 Residential $16,380 $5,460 $21,840 $62,400 1.84 LEONARDI, CHARLES JAMES LYLE, INC 1 Residential $18,900 $4,550 $23,450 $67,000 1.37 MCGEE, SKYLA & ROBINSON, ANTHONY DORMANN, STEPHEN R & ELIZABETH A 1 Residential $8,295 $5,285 $13,580 $38,800 1.68 SWANSON, ALBERT DICKERSON ZAREFOSS, MICHAELL F & BEVERLEY 1 Residential $18,060 $5,355 $23,415 $66,900 0.79 THE HUNTINGTON NATIONAL BANK THOMPSON, JAMES 1 Residential $18,690 $5,530 $24,220 $69,200 1.51 COLLINS, IVELISSE & COLLINS, RASHAU RIEGELMAYER, KRISTIN A 1 Residential $24,640 $5,250 $29,890 $85,400 0 3592 WEST 133RD LLC BRADIGAN, ANDREW J 1 Residential $20,965 $5,600 $26,565 $75,900 0.62 A & R FAMILY INVESTMENT LLC SEEHOLZER, LOIS A 1 Residential $13,055 $4,410 $17,465 $49,900 0 SINGER, MARK R & SINGER, DOUGLAS W SINGER, SYLVIA A 1 Residential $9,450 $5,600 $15,050 $43,000 1 JAX REINV1 LLC DIOY, LLC 1 Residential $22,435 $5,600 $28,035 $80,100 1.1 BURROW, DANIEL J SAVARINO PROPERTIES LLC 1 Residential $20,650 $5,320 $25,970 $74,200 1.12 SUMAILI, LOPEMBE BODA MOZES 1 Residential $24,150 $4,410 $28,560 $81,600 0 ADAMCZYK, WAYNE T ADAMCZYK, WAYNE T 3 Residential $13,160 $5,005 $18,165 $51,900 $151,000 0 TAYEH PROPERTIES II, LLC TAYEH, JOSEPH 1 Residential $24,150 $4,410 $28,560 $81,600 1.04 AYERS, MALISSA HORNE, LINDA A 1 Residential $22,855 $4,375 $27,230 $77,800 0.67 BIAS, RICHARD US BANK -TRUSTEE 1 Residential $22,505 $4,900 $27,405 $78,300 1.4 GRUBER, LAWRENCE GREENE JR , STEPHEN MICHAEL 1 Residential $8,680 $4,655 $13,335 $38,100 1.21 LYON, SAMANTHA L HEIMSOTH, CALEB S 3 Residential $11,550 $4,690 $16,240 $46,400 $151,000 0 TAYEH PROPERTIES II, LLC TAYEH, JOSEPH 1 Residential $30,415 $4,340 $34,755 $99,300 0 CABAN, ANGEL O & CASTRO, JAZMINE L CABAN, ANGEL O 1 Residential $20,125 $6,860 $26,985 $77,100 0 GRAYLYN PROPERTIES LTD RYBAR, JACK E 1 Residential $12,775 $4,830 $17,605 $50,300 0.74 BACKSTREETS REAL ESTATE LLC SCHERF, DENNIS H 1 Residential $19,740 $4,830 $24,570 $70,200 0.93 MCINTYRE, ABIGAIL BAUCUM ROSE R & SUSAN R 1 Residential $13,335 $4,725 $18,060 $51,600 0.85 NOSA OFOHIO, L L C GROSS DONALD Page 54 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable Taxable Taxable Taxable Auditor Number of Assessed Assessed Assessed Estimated Total EMV Ratio Filing Parcels Property Building Land Total Market Mult. Recpt. Price to Buyer Seller Number Combined ($) Class Value Value Value Value Est. Mkt. Val. Est. Mkt. Val. Name Name 3 Residential $13,475 $4,970 $18,445 $52,700 $151,000 0 TAYEH PROPERTIES II, LLC TAYEH, JOSEPH 1 Residential $21,945 $7,350 $29,295 $83,700 1.19 WALCOTT, AMANDA B & WALCOTT, DION ORLANDO, RAYLEEN M & ORLANDO, CH 1 Residential $19,110 $7,595 $26,705 $76,300 0 H & S ENTERPRISES OF OHIO, LLC H & S ENTERPRISES OF OHIO, LLC 1 Residential $19,110 $7,595 $26,705 $76,300 1.57 KAREEM, ABUBAKER H & S ENTERPRISES OF OHIO, LLC 1 Residential $23,765 $6,090 $29,855 $85,300 0 MARSHALL, MICHAEL C-TRUSTEE & MARSH ELAINE M & MICHAEL MARSHALL 1 Residential $21,700 $8,015 $29,715 $84,900 0.41 CENTANNE, MASON FOUTZ, JOYCE MARIE TRS 3 Residential $8,645 $2,800 $11,445 $32,700 $136,899 0 TAYEH PROPERTIES, LLC TAYEH, JOSEPH 3 Residential $13,615 $2,800 $16,415 $46,900 $136,899 0 TAYEH PROPERTIES, LLC TAYEH JOSEPH 1 Residential $7,700 $2,695 $10,395 $29,700 0 TAYEH PROPERTIES III, LLC TAYEH, JOSEPH 1 Residential $21,455 $6,755 $28,210 $80,600 1.43 VIHTELIC, STEVEN R JONES JR , CLEM 1 Residential $36,155 $10,570 $46,725 $133,500 1.26 MCBRIDE, MARTIN & MCBRIDE, MARY RICHARDSON TIMOTHY K 1 Residential $61,040 $14,105 $75,145 $214,700 1.28 KELLER, RANDALL S & KELLER, VANE COCITA JAMES M & RACHEL N 1 Residential $34,125 $13,195 $47,320 $135,200 1.2 TOOMEY, MICHAEL W LANGHOLZ, CHRISTOPHER D & WILLENBER 1 Residential $31,395 $6,860 $38,255 $109,300 0 PERRY, SHONDA LYNN PERRY, SHONDA L & YATES, LUANNA 1 Residential $26,775 $7,280 $34,055 $97,300 0.95 TM INVESTMENT HOLDINGS LLC THE CLEVELAND POLICE CREDIT UNION I 1 Residential $27,020 $6,055 $33,075 $94,500 0 SOLLENNE, SUSAN J SOLLENNE, GERALD A & SUSAN J 1 Residential $24,290 $7,210 $31,500 $90,000 1.33 MEPHAM, MICHAEL T MEPHAM, DENNIS 1 Residential $32,900 $7,175 $40,075 $114,500 0 CLOSE, TIMOTHY M & PEGGY O (CO TR CLOSE, TIMOTHY M & CLOSE, PEGGY OK 1 Residential $26,950 $9,835 $36,785 $105,100 1.12 BORIS, MATTHEW & BORIS, MARIA PAULLIN, CRAIG & LAURIE LYNN 1 Residential $25,865 $8,645 $34,510 $98,600 0 ROCK, CHERYL L (AKA) BECK, CHERYL L ROCK, STEVEN C 1 Residential $12,075 $2,835 $14,910 $42,600 1.36 SAAD, KAFI H FLASHER, MARGARET AKA FLASHER, MAR 1 Residential $42,490 $12,215 $54,705 $156,300 0.99 MAXWELL, SEAN T & MAXWELL, SHARLEA SCHNEIDER, JAMES J 1 Residential $29,155 $8,645 $37,800 $108,000 1.51 WILLIAMS, KARIN BENNING MIODRAGOVIC, JONATHAN H & HARTLEY, 1 Residential $28,385 $8,890 $37,275 $106,500 0 PROPERTY PLACEMENT GROUP, LLC RUSSO, SAL 1 Residential $28,385 $8,890 $37,275 $106,500 1.88 VASEK, TAMMIE PROPERTY PLACEMENT GROUP, LLC AFN201812130499 2 Residential $40,390 $15,015 $55,405 $158,300 $292,800 0 WATERS WILLIAM J & CATHERINE WATERS WILLIAM J & CATHERINE AFN201812130499 2 Residential $32,060 $15,015 $47,075 $134,500 $292,800 0 WATERS, GRACE ANNE WATERS, GRACE ANNE 1 Residential $32,060 $15,015 $47,075 $134,500 0 WATERS, GRACE ANNE WATERS, GRACE ANNE 1 Residential $36,505 $11,585 $48,090 $137,400 0 LAUENT, BRUCE C LAURENT BRUCE C 1 Residential $34,090 $8,540 $42,630 $121,800 1.31 CHEN, MING YU STITTS, JESSICA M 1 Residential $33,705 $9,870 $43,575 $124,500 1.27 COSTANZO, PATRICK & HORD, KRISTEN STEFANCIN PATRICK R 1 Residential $33,075 $8,890 $41,965 $119,900 1.42 PERKOVIC, ZVONIMIR & JESSICA L HOPKINS, MELODY J 1 Residential $29,085 $8,540 $37,625 $107,500 0.31 MURRAY, CHRISTOPHER A MURRAY, CHRISTOPHER A & PUCEK, ANT 1 Residential $29,295 $7,525 $36,820 $105,200 1.42 GARCIA-CRUZ, LINDA V & GARCIA, LUIS SUHADOLNIK JOHN J JR 1 Residential $29,260 $7,525 $36,785 $105,100 0 DEUTSCHE BANK NATIONAL TRUST COMPAN DEUTSCHE BANK NATIONAL TRUST COMPAN 1 Residential $23,520 $8,120 $31,640 $90,400 0.51 THE BANK OF NEW YORK MELLON-TRUSTEE WANDA TONKIN 1 Residential $32,060 $9,835 $41,895 $119,700 1.27 KISS, THOMAS & KISS, SUSAN M GRAY, PATRICIA L 1 Residential $24,710 $8,260 $32,970 $94,200 0 KOTT, BRYAN J KOTT, JACK C 1 Residential $20,335 $5,005 $25,340 $72,400 0 RUSSELL, MICHELE J RUSSELL, JOHN K & MICHELE J 1 Residential $20,965 $7,420 $28,385 $81,100 1.27 MOORE, DANIEL J COOPER, LORETTA J 1 Residential $23,835 $7,070 $30,905 $88,300 1.33 SAINATO, JUSTIN J O'REILLY, KELLY M 1 Residential $20,965 $6,860 $27,825 $79,500 0.64 MESHI, LINDIOR POTA, MICHAEL 1 Residential $21,350 $7,035 $28,385 $81,100 0 LACH, WAYNE F LACH, WAYNE F 1 Residential $24,395 $5,075 $29,470 $84,200 1.72 ALDHBAIB, JESSICA LYNNE STUCZYNSKI JOSEPH A Page 55 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable Taxable Taxable Taxable Auditor Number of Assessed Assessed Assessed Estimated Total EMV Ratio Filing Parcels Property Building Land Total Market Mult. Recpt. Price to Buyer Seller Number Combined ($) Class Value Value Value Value Est. Mkt. Val. Est. Mkt. Val. Name Name 1 Residential $19,040 $7,035 $26,075 $74,500 1.41 GIGANTE, MELINDA CRISTINE MARRERO, ROBERTO & JOHANNA 1 Residential $23,590 $4,795 $28,385 $81,100 0.65 BOUKHENNOU, KARIMA PACHECO, RICHARD 1 Commercial $247,520 $65,450 $312,970 $894,200 1.04 INVCLE150, LLC PARKVIEW KENT LLC 1 Residential $23,555 $9,310 $32,865 $93,900 1.32 GALE, KATHERINE SARKIS, HAMID 1 Residential $30,030 $8,050 $38,080 $108,800 0 TODOROV, KAREN A (SUCC TRS) KNAPP, RUTH E SUC-TRS 1 Residential $19,810 $10,185 $29,995 $85,700 0 KELLEY, MARY K KELLEY, MARY K 1 Residential $19,810 $10,185 $29,995 $85,700 0.21 MONDELLO INVESTMENT GROUP, LLC KELLEY, MARY K 1 Residential $28,070 $7,595 $35,665 $101,900 0 COGAR, KAREN (TRS) COGAR, ROBERT P & DOROTHY MAY 2 Residential $24,990 $7,735 $32,725 $93,500 $95,200 0 FANNIE MAE U S BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION 1 Residential $29,680 $7,875 $37,555 $107,300 0 BURGESS, RICKIE D & LORALEE BURGESS, RICKIE D 1 Residential $31,045 $7,350 $38,395 $109,700 1.18 NORTHEAST COMMERCIAL PROPERTIES, IN WANCHISN, ASHELY L 1 Residential $24,185 $9,415 $33,600 $96,000 1.86 DEFIEBRE, JESSE KENNEY, ANDREW AND KENNEY, AMANDA C 1 Residential $26,390 $8,645 $35,035 $100,100 0.85 WARD, JEFFREY J BEAVIN, DALE A 1 Residential $33,495 $8,645 $42,140 $120,400 0.93 TASEFF, BRADLEY B & SMITH, BRIAN PFEUFFER JENNIFER L 1 Residential $29,085 $8,645 $37,730 $107,800 0 HANRAHAN, THOMAS J HANRAHAN VIRGINIA K 1 Residential $29,470 $7,665 $37,135 $106,100 0 MCDERMOTT JR , JOHN S MCDERMOTT, JOHN S JR & JEAN M 1 Residential $19,425 $5,880 $25,305 $72,300 1.39 CLARK STREET, RONNIE L AND CLARK WAYNER, MARK J 1 Residential $13,020 $4,480 $17,500 $50,000 1.5 HARRIS, PAUL D QUEST CAPITAL FUNDING LLC 1 Residential $24,570 $17,010 $41,580 $118,800 1.22 FAUST, BRIAN S MARCONI, JUSTIN & ODELL, HEATHER

Page 56 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable + 2000 Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Old Non-Taxable Census Dupl. Name Address Municipality State Zip code SPA Name Est.Mkt.Val. Tract Flag GOD CAN DO IT LLC 15807 HARVARD AVE CLEVELAND OH 44128 Lee-Miles $20,600 121700 0 M&T BANK 475 CROSSPOINT PKWY GETZVILLE NY 14068 Lee-Miles $67,900 121700 0 THOMAS-MURRAY, DARLENE 3871 E 154 ST CLEVELAND OH 44128 Lee-Miles $41,700 121700 0 ABELEDA, EDNA 3328 WHISPERING PALMS PICO RIVERA CA 90660 Lee-Miles $77,100 121700 0 THREE BLACK KNIGHTS, LLC 902 CIELO E TERRA DR MACEDONIA OH 44056 Lee-Miles $80,600 121700 0 FIRST EQUITY CAPITAL LLC 23400 MERCANTILE RD BEACHWOOD OH 44122 Lee-Miles $67,300 121700 0 BROWN, JAMES E 16400 GLENDALE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44128 Lee-Miles $40,800 121700 0 U S BANK TRUST, N A 13801 WIRELESS WAY OKLAHOMA CITY OK 73134 Lee-Miles $120,400 121700 0 PROPERTY IMPROVEMENT SPECIALISTS, I 16409 GLENDALE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44128 Lee-Miles $51,900 121700 0 PROPERTY IMPROVEMENT SPECIALISTS, I 16409 GLENDALE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44128 Lee-Miles $51,900 121700 0 WM CAPITAL PARNTERS 68 LLC 100 CONGRESS AVE AUSTIN TX 78701 Lee-Miles $58,200 121700 0 AT POSH INVESTMENTS, LLC 4456 N ABBE RD SHEFFIELD LAKE OH 44054 Lee-Miles $57,300 121700 0 MCCALL JR , ROBERT C 16201 WALDEN AVE CLEVELAND OH 44128 Lee-Miles $60,300 121700 0 CITIMORTGAGE, INC 1000 TECHNOLOGY DR O'FALLON MO 63368 Lee-Miles $34,700 121700 0 SPENCER, JEANARRE M 16603 WALDEN AVE CLEVELAND OH 44128 Lee-Miles $61,600 121700 0 GIBBS, MARIAN C 26391 RED FOX TR WHOLE VILLAGE OH 44146 Lee-Miles $75,700 121700 0 TIGIE'S HOME DESIGNERS, LLC 17103 WALDEN AVE CLEVELAND OH 44128 Lee-Miles $66,800 121700 0 LIGHTNING GROUP, LLC 17111 WALDEN AVE CLEVELAND OH 44128 Lee-Miles $66,300 121700 0 PROPERTY IMPROVEMENT SPECIALISTS IN 10663 ANGELA DR WILLOUGHBY OH 44094 Lee-Miles $82,100 121700 0 ROBINSON, DINESHA 17012 GLENDALE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44128 Lee-Miles $73,400 121700 0 SINGLETON, JANEAN T 16612 ELDAMERE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44128 Lee-Miles $74,000 121700 0 RUSHMORE LOAN MANAGEMENT SERVICES 15480 LAGUNA CANYON RD IRVINE CA 92618 Lee-Miles $76,300 121700 0 DIVVY HOMES WAREHOUSE I LLC 530 HOWARD ST SAN FRANCISCO CA 94105 Lee-Miles $71,900 121700 0 LEGGETT, CHARLOTTE 16918 BILTMORE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44128 Lee-Miles $67,700 121700 0 PROF-2013-S3 LEGAL TITLE TRUST IV 939 W NORTH AVE CHICAGO IL 60642 Lee-Miles $74,100 121700 0 KCW RENTALS LLC 21 W 131 ST NEW YORK NY 10037 Lee-Miles $65,600 121800 0 BCD PROPERTEIS, INC 1202 MIDDLE AVE ELYRIA OH 44035 Lee-Miles $59,000 121800 0 ORR, BETTYE 3984 WENDY DR CLEVELAND OH 44122 Lee-Miles $57,200 121800 0 DEUTSCHE BANK NATIONAL TRUST COMPAN 1600 S DOUGLASS RD ANAHEIM CA 92806 Lee-Miles $65,900 121800 0 RONALD SLY INVESTMENTS LLC 19130 APPLETON ST DETROIT MI 48219 Lee-Miles $60,400 121800 0 FIRST EQUITY CAPITAL LLC 5495 N WOODS LN SOLON OH 44139 Lee-Miles $54,000 121900 0 MORRISON-HEARN, MARY E 430 HARRIS RD RICHMOND HTS OH 44143 Lee-Miles $60,000 121900 0 MORRISON-HEARN, MARY E 430 HARRIS RD RICHMOND HTS OH 44143 Lee-Miles $60,000 121900 0 HILL, MERIDITH D 4161 E 187 ST CLEVELAND OH 44122 Lee-Miles $54,100 122100 0 CLASSIC AFFORDABLE PROPERTIES, LLC 1057 NELAVIEW CLEVELAND HTS OH 44112 Lee-Miles $50,200 122100 0 WOODS, JAMES 4129 FEINER DR BEACHWOOD OH 44122 Lee-Miles $55,800 122100 0 WOODS, JAMES 4129 FEINER DR BEACHWOOD OH 44122 Lee-Miles $55,800 122100 0 WAGNER, KEVIN H 17209 LOTUS DR CLEVELAND OH 44128 Lee-Miles $42,100 122100 0 TERRELL, LUCIOUS R 4267 E 170 PLACE CLEVELAND OH 44128 Lee-Miles $67,500 122100 0 CRUMB, ROSLYN DENISE 4196 E 178 ST CLEVELAND OH 44128-2666 Lee-Miles $56,100 122100 0 TURNER, REGINA O 18300 DEFOREST AVE CLEVELAND OH 44122 Lee-Miles $61,800 122100 0 TURNER, REGINA O 18300 DEFOREST AVE CLEVELAND OH 44122 Lee-Miles $61,800 122100 0 ARNOLD, BONDEZ W AND REDDING, SANY 18108 DEFOREST AVE CLEVELAND OH 44128 Lee-Miles $61,100 122100 0 UNDERWOOD, SANDRA 4168 E 186 ST BEACHWOOD OH 44122 Lee-Miles $51,500 122100 0 Page 57 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable + 2000 Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Old Non-Taxable Census Dupl. Name Address Municipality State Zip code SPA Name Est.Mkt.Val. Tract Flag UNDERWOOD, SANDRA 4168 E 186 ST BEACHWOOD OH 44122 Lee-Miles $51,500 122100 1 MJB INVESTMENT PROPERTIES LLC 1441 DILLE RD EUCLID OH 44117 Corlett $119,900 121500 0 PUYLOUB INVESTMENT LLC 16915 PALDA DR CLEVELAND OH 44128 Lee-Miles $36,300 122100 0 PUYLOUB INVESTMENT LLC 16915 PALDA DR CLEVELAND OH 44128 Lee-Miles $36,300 122100 0 SECRETARY OF HOUSING AND URBAN DEVE 4324 WYATT RD CLEVELAND OH 44128 Lee-Miles $46,200 122100 0 SUMMERVILLE, DWAIN JR & WOODS, ALI 4055 E 108 ST CLEVELAND OH 44105 Lee-Miles $47,400 122100 0 LBR HOMES, LLC 4321 E 142 ST CLEVELAND OH 44128 Corlett $18,600 121600 0 US BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION 4801 FREDERICA ST OWENSBORO KY 42301 Corlett $21,100 121600 0 PHILLIPS, KENT L & PHILLIPS, PATRI 5440 LOUIE LN RENO NV 89511 Corlett $20,600 121600 0 PHILLIPS, KENT L & PHILLIPS, PATRI 5440 LOUIE LN RENO NV 89511 Corlett $20,600 121600 0 TOTH, CHRISTOPHER 49 KITCHELL RD DENVILLE NJ 7834 Corlett $32,300 121600 0 BONDARU, SARATH KRISHNA & TIRUMALAS 2424 MAIDENHAIR WAY SAND RAMON CA 94582 Lee-Miles $32,700 122200 0 STOKES, IVORY 1133 OXFORD RD CLEVELAND OH 44121 Lee-Miles $30,900 122200 0 CLEVELAND LAND REUTILIZATION PROGRA 601 LAKESIDE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44114 Lee-Miles $23,200 122200 0 MOR, ALEX 14817 NAPLES AVE CLEVELAND OH 44128 Lee-Miles $4,500 122200 0 CALI-LIBA-2, LLC 473 JAMES RD PALO ALTO CA 94306 Lee-Miles $27,300 122200 0 THREE BLACK KNIGHTS LLC 2400 ORANGE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44101 Lee-Miles $37,600 122300 0 COMMUNITY RESTORATION CORPORATION 323 5 ST EUREKA CA 95501 Lee-Miles $49,500 122300 0 COLEMAN, KEITH 4576 E 174 ST CLEVELAND OH 44128 Lee-Miles $37,400 122300 0 KEVIN FARRIS, SR 4776 E 174 ST CLEVELAND OH 44128 Lee-Miles $34,700 122300 0 DRC CONSTRUCTION CO 4658 E 177 ST CLEVELAND OH 44128 Lee-Miles $22,400 122300 0 HICKS, MEL & MONICA P 18489 CLEVELAND OH 44118 Lee-Miles $37,800 122300 0 GAITAN, SONIA VINCOY 4784 E 176 ST CLEVELAND OH 44128 Lee-Miles $43,500 122300 0 DILLON, ANDREW 621 W RIVERSIDE DR PARKER AZ 85344 Lee-Miles $34,100 122300 0 GROVEWOOD PROPERTIES, LLC 503 E 200 ST EUCLID OH 44119 Mt. Pleasant $60,000 119900 0 FANNIE MAE 14221 DALLAS PKWY DALLAS TX 75254 Mt. Pleasant $26,100 119900 0 CAGLAR, LEVENT 14702 MILVERTON RD CLEVELAND OH 44120 Mt. Pleasant $56,400 119900 0 FORD, BERNICE 3305 E 146 ST CLEVELAND OH 44120 Mt. Pleasant $48,800 119900 0 CUYAHOGA COUNTY LAND REUTILIZATION 812 HURON RD CLEVELAND OH 44115 Mt. Pleasant $42,100 120801 0 SA CAPITAL LLC ?? PO BOX 20418 RD SHAKER HTS OH 44120 Mt. Pleasant $56,700 120801 0 SA CAPITAL LLC ?? PO BOX 20418 RD SHAKER HTS OH 44120 Mt. Pleasant $56,700 120801 1 SA CAPITAL LLC ?? PO BOX 20418 RD SHAKER HTS OH 44120 Mt. Pleasant $56,700 120801 0 SA CAPITAL LLC ?? PO BOX 20418 RD SHAKER HTS OH 44120 Mt. Pleasant $56,700 120801 0 TATUM, RICKY 3533 E 151 ST CLEVELAND OH 44120 Mt. Pleasant $45,100 120801 0 OZEKICI, SEDAT 200 W MADISON AVE CHICAGO IL 60606 Corlett $41,700 121401 0 GREEN, ARTONIA 4133 E 135 ST CLEVELAND OH 44105 Corlett $24,000 121401 0 GREEN, ARTONIA 4133 E 135 ST CLEVELAND OH 44105 Corlett $24,000 121401 0 PROFIT, MILTON MELVIN JR 5818 DOOLITTLE BLVD HOUSTON TX 77033 Corlett $28,000 121401 0 EQUITY TRUST COMPANY CUSTODIAN 2443 FILLMORE ST SAN FRANCISCO CA 94115 Corlett $42,000 121402 0 SECRETARY OF HOUSING & URBAN DEVE 2401 NW 23 ST OKLAHOMA CITY OK 73107 Corlett $23,700 121402 0 FEDERAL NATIONAL MORTGAGE ASSOCIATI ?? PO BOX 650043 DALLAS TX 75265 Corlett $46,100 121500 0 MOORE, GEORGE (TRS) 11900 EDGEWATER DR LAKEWOOD OH 44107 Corlett $59,400 121500 0 CLEVELAND LAND REUTILIZATION PROGRA 601 LAKESIDE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44114 Corlett $7,500 121500 0 GRAVES, WILLIAM G 4067 E 147 ST CLEVELAND OH 44128 Corlett $39,000 121500 0 Page 58 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable + 2000 Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Old Non-Taxable Census Dupl. Name Address Municipality State Zip code SPA Name Est.Mkt.Val. Tract Flag TAN CAPITAL HOLDINGS LLC 2152 RALPH AVE BROOKLYN NY 11234 South Broadway $27,800 115800 0 BEREAN FOUR, LLC ?? P O BOX 581087 ELK GROVE CA 95758 South Broadway $23,000 115800 0 ABDULLAH, KAMAL 8305 FORCE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44105 South Broadway $27,800 115800 0 KING, GLENN SR 7808 CONNECTICUT AVE CLEVELAND OH 44105 South Broadway $35,600 115900 0 KING, GLENN SR 7812 CONNECTICUT AVE CLEVELAND OH 44105 South Broadway $5,900 115900 0 GARY L HERZBRUN 27965 PERGL RD SOLON OH 44139 South Broadway $33,500 115900 0 MATTHEWS, GALLON 7646 NEW YORK AVE CLEVELAND OH 44105 South Broadway $35,000 115900 0 DMN OH HOLDINGS LLC 303 S BROADWAY ST DENVER CO 80209 South Broadway $34,000 115900 0 MORGAN-CARGO, MARGUERITE 8011 JEFFERIES AVE CLEVELAND OH 44105 South Broadway $35,200 115900 0 CLEVELAND LAND REUTILIZATION PROGRA 601 LAKESIDE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44114 South Broadway $21,000 115900 0 HOLLOWELL, MERCEDES SADE 8006 MARYLAND AVE CLEVELAND OH 44105 South Broadway $54,900 115900 0 HOWARD WEST 59 RIVERVIEW AVE TONAWANDA NY 14150 South Broadway $33,200 115900 0 ABX INVESTMENTS LLC 1166 S ALADEN AVE SAN JOSE CA 95110 South Broadway $53,700 115900 0 VASIL, ALFRED J 8909 VINEYARD AVE CLEVELAND OH 44105 South Broadway $45,400 115900 0 CROSSOVER PROPERTIES LLC 9721 ROSEWOOD AVE CLEVELAND OH 44105 South Broadway $38,200 115900 0 SCOTT, MARY KAY 4430 BROOKS RD CLEVELAND OH 44105 South Broadway $111,500 115800 0 BILAL, MUHAMMED & BILAL, ISHIA 16625 KIPLING AVE CLEVELAND OH 44110 Mt. Pleasant $27,300 120600 0 BEN HOLDINGS LLC 615 CAPE CORAL PKWY CAPE CORAL FL 33914 Mt. Pleasant $22,300 120600 0 BEN HOLDINGS LLC 615 CAPE CORAL PKWY CAPE CORAL FL 33914 Mt. Pleasant $22,300 120600 0 LATTIMORE, ROCHELLE A & STITT, M 22600 EMERY RD CLEVELAND OH 44128 Mt. Pleasant $57,800 120600 0 GUGLIARDO, KENISHA 3675 E 112 ST CLEVELAND OH 44105 Mt. Pleasant $29,000 120600 0 SCRUGGS, LATANYA E 2 AVALON RD SHAKER HTS OH 44120 Mt. Pleasant $29,300 120600 0 3577 EAST STREET LLC 19406 N PALO VERDE D SUN CITY AZ 85373 Mt. Pleasant $32,700 120701 0 CUYAHOGA COUNTY LAND REUTILIZATION 812 HURON RD CLEVELAND OH 44115 Mt. Pleasant $14,900 120600 0 CLEVELAND LAND REUTILIZATION PROGRA 601 LAKESIDE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44114 Mt. Pleasant $14,700 120600 0 CLEVELAND AM INVESTMENTS, LLC 3598 E 143 ST CLEVELAND OH 44120 Mt. Pleasant $48,200 120802 0 CUYAHOGA COUNTY LAND REUTILIZATION 812 HURON RD CLEVELAND OH 44115 Mt. Pleasant $44,500 120802 0 LANKFORD, AMANDA L 14101 GLENDALE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44128 Mt. Pleasant $39,400 120802 0 THE ALEGNA GROUP LLC 13940 CEDAR RD UNIVERSITY HTS OH 44118 Mt. Pleasant $7,800 120802 0 GLADDEN, CECILIA 3680 E 151 ST CLEVELAND OH 44120 Mt. Pleasant $52,100 120801 0 ISAAC, YVONNE R 3676 E 151 ST CLEVELAND OH 44120 Mt. Pleasant $53,400 120801 0 BEAVERDAM PROPERTIES 4568 MAYFIELD RD CLEVELAND OH 44121 Mt. Pleasant $33,200 120801 0 KAYODE, STEPHEN OWOYELE 5011 CALICO CT HILLIARD OH 43026 Union-Miles Park $8,900 115500 0 SCHACK, ALLEN 3975 E 89 ST CLEVELAND OH 44105 Union-Miles Park $17,700 115500 0 DANIELS, REGINALD 9504 DUNLAP AVE CLEVELAND OH 44105 Union-Miles Park $20,600 120400 0 CLEVELAND LAND REUTILIZATION PROGRA 601 LAKESIDE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44114 Union-Miles Park $5,400 120500 0 ERBAY, SUAYIP DOGAN 200 W MADISON AVE CHICAGO IL 60606 Union-Miles Park $31,000 120500 0 SHAVER, DARVINNA 3527 E 108 ST CLEVELAND OH 44105 Union-Miles Park $15,600 120500 0 LATTIMORE, ROCHELLE A & STITT, M 22600 EMERY RD CLEVELAND OH 44128 Union-Miles Park $36,300 127500 0 LATTIMORE, ROCHELLE A & STITT, M 22600 EMERY RD CLEVELAND OH 44128 Mt. Pleasant $41,700 120600 0 LATTIMORE, ROCHELLE A & STITT, M 22600 EMERY RD CLEVELAND OH 44128 Mt. Pleasant $40,800 120600 0 LATTIMORE, ROCHELLE A & STITT, M 22600 EMERY RD CLEVELAND OH 44128 Mt. Pleasant $52,200 120600 0 LATTIMORE, ROCHELLE A & STITT, M 22600 EMERY RD CLEVELAND OH 44128 Mt. Pleasant $47,400 120600 0 ROBERT RODGERS 9800 RENO AVE CLEVELAND OH 44105 Union-Miles Park $24,600 127500 0 Page 59 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable + 2000 Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Old Non-Taxable Census Dupl. Name Address Municipality State Zip code SPA Name Est.Mkt.Val. Tract Flag LAUDERDALE, MICHAEL M 10102 SANDUSKY AVE CLEVELAND OH 44105 Union-Miles Park $22,300 127500 0 MCCOY, VINCE ETAL 3873 SALISBURY SOUTH EUCLID OH 44121 Union-Miles Park $28,900 127500 0 HARRIS, DENISE 1127 E 177 ST CLEVELAND OH 44119 Union-Miles Park $25,100 127500 0 CAEZ, MIGUEL 1243 CLEVELAND HTS BLVD CLEVELAND HTS TX 4412 Union-Miles Park $28,300 127500 0 FEDERAL NATIONAL MORTGAGE ASSOCIATI P 650043 DALLAS TX 75265 Union-Miles Park $32,700 127500 0 MEECH 1, LLC 740 W SCHAAF RD CLEVELAND OH 44109 Union-Miles Park $900 127500 0 MOORE, RAFAEL G 10318 DOVE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44105 Union-Miles Park $29,800 127500 0 GIBSON AFFORDABLE PROPERTIES LLC ?? PO BOX 6673 WAY CLEVELAND OH 44101 Union-Miles Park $72,900 127500 0 MAKUPSON INVESTMENT CORP LLC 14006 BECKETT RD SHAKER HEIGHTS OH 44120 Union-Miles Park $28,000 127500 0 US BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION AS TRU 1661 WORTHINGTON RD WEST PALM BEACH FL 33409 Union-Miles Park $30,400 127500 0 DARBY, AMOS 9324 HARVARD AVE CLEVELAND OH 44105 Union-Miles Park $8,200 121300 0 JOHNSON, JILLIAN 10512 EARLE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44108 Union-Miles Park $27,900 121300 0 EPIC AUTO SALES LLC 4071 E 104 ST CLEVELAND OH 44105 Union-Miles Park $27,400 121300 0 GALLOWAY, MELVIN L 10428 MULVANEY CIR LAS VEGAS NV 89141 Union-Miles Park $800 121300 0 GALLOWAY, MELVIN L 10428 MULVANEY CIR LAS VEGAS NV 89141 Union-Miles Park $37,000 121300 0 ASKREN INVESTMENTS LLC 26895 ALISO CREEK RD ALISO VIEJO CA 92656 Union-Miles Park $12,800 121300 0 PUNJ PROPETIES, LLC 990 WOODRUFF ST ISELIN NJ 8830 Mt. Pleasant $33,400 120600 0 ELI INVESTING LLC 1621 NORTHLAND AVE LAKEWOOD OH 44107 Corlett $31,600 121100 0 DEUTSCHE BANK NATIONAL TRUST COMPAN 1661 WORTHINGTON RD WEST PALM BEACH FL 33409 Corlett $34,400 121200 0 13201 GLENDALE PROPERTIES LLC 2205 MORELAND DR TWINSBURG OH 44087 Corlett $29,900 121200 0 DOWNING, DENISE D 13412 CHAPELSIDE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44120 Corlett $27,900 121200 0 YEREMIAN, HAROUTIUN 13202 COATH AVE CLEVELAND OH 44120 Corlett $26,500 121200 0 KMB 1 LLC 834 BLACKWOOD DR WHALES FL 33898 Corlett $35,400 121200 0 CHAPPELL, YOLANDA ETAL 11708 EAST BLVD CLEVELAND OH 44106 Corlett $34,500 121401 0 GAMBOA, YUDITH & GAMBOA, RAUL 4807 W HAZELWOOD ST PHOENIX AZ 85031 Corlett $26,800 121100 0 NIMMER, JOSEPH 5523 E 141 MAPLE HEIGHTS OH 44137 Corlett $25,000 121401 0 CLEVELAND LAND REUTILIZATION PROGRA 601 LAKESIDE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44114 Corlett $23,500 121401 0 EL TEPE, LLC 3511 SE J STREET BENTONVILLE AR 72712 Corlett $25,400 121100 0 MOSLEY, ONI O LEWIS 12405 BENWOOD AVE CLEVELAND OH 44105 Corlett $20,800 121100 0 A Z QUALITY CONTRACTING & LANDSCAPI 15710 STOCKBRIDGE RD CLEVELAND OH 44128 Corlett $42,100 121100 0 WEST, EBONY 12810 CRENNELL AVE CLEVELAND OH 44105 Corlett $43,700 121401 0 SWEMA REAL ESTATE LLC 13400 CRENNELL AVE CLEVELAND OH 44105 Corlett $29,500 121200 0 ABU YUSRA LIMITED, LLC 48377 VAN DYKE AVE UTICA MI 48317 Corlett $58,400 121200 0 RICHMOND, REGINALD 24451 LAKESHORE BLVD EUCLID OH 44123 Corlett $45,600 121200 0 SUNBURST LLC 13113 BENWOOD AVE CLEVELAND OH 44105 Corlett $32,900 121200 0 SUNBURST LLC 13113 BENWOOD AVE CLEVELAND OH 44105 Corlett $32,900 121200 0 CQLH ENTERPRISES, LLC 9967 BERRYMAN WAY LAS VEGAS NV 89148 Corlett $30,700 121200 0 PARKER PROPERITES UNLTD LLC 1401 N 29 ST PHILADELPHIA PA 19121 Corlett $39,900 121401 0 TEFERA, HENOK 424 ROSS RD COLUMBUS OH 43213 Corlett $33,200 121402 0 BOYD, AUDREY 12814 HARVARD AVE CLEVELAND OH 44105 Corlett $27,500 121401 0 KAPPA MANAGEMENT LLC 9300 S DADELAND BLV MIAMI FL 33156 Corlett $32,300 121402 0 KILLINGSWORTH, NICOLE ETAL 4259 EAST BLVD CLEVELAND OH 44105 Corlett $28,300 121402 0 TORRES, MERCEDES 3237 SEYMOUR AVE CLEVELAND OH 44113 Ohio City/Near West Side $56,800 103800 0 GONAZLES, KATHERINE ETAL 2344 PROSPECT AVE CLEVELAND OH 44115 Ohio City/Near West Side $42,500 103900 0 Page 60 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable + 2000 Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Old Non-Taxable Census Dupl. Name Address Municipality State Zip code SPA Name Est.Mkt.Val. Tract Flag AMERICAN DREAM HOLDINGS LLC 3200 FRANKLIN BLVD CLEVELAND OH 44113 Ohio City/Near West Side $6,100 103900 0 OSTROWSKE, JOSEPH M AND OSTROWSKE, 1260 W 4 ST CLEVELAND OH 44113 Downtown $349,100 107100 0 PADGETT, DAVID A 750 PROSPECT AVE CLEVELAND OH 44115 Downtown $92,700 107700 0 STATES, BRANDON I 1418 W 45 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 Detroit-Shoreway $78,100 103500 0 AYERS, ABBY 4612 FRANKLIN BLVD CLEVELAND OH 44102 Detroit-Shoreway 103500 0 PEREZ, RAYMOND 1944 W 48 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 Detroit-Shoreway $61,500 103500 0 MARRERO, ANA VELEZ 1294 W 103 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 Detroit-Shoreway $77,600 103500 0 STEGER, JADE A 2222 DETROIT AVE CLEVELAND OH 44113 Ohio City/Near West Side $180,600 103300 0 SCHULTZ, CHARLES A 1237 WASHINGTON ST CLEVELAND OH 44113 Ohio City/Near West Side $193,200 103300 0 MITCHELL, EDWARD 2700 ADELBERT AVE LOS ANGELES CA 90039 Ohio City/Near West Side $225,000 103300 0 LEONHARD, KOREY 3107 CLINTON AVE CLEVELAND OH 44113 Ohio City/Near West Side $0 103200 0 FIELDS, ANGELO 3107 CLINTON AVE CLEVELAND OH 44113 Ohio City/Near West Side $0 103200 0 CHERNIKOFF, ROCHELLE A 820 CINNAMON LN DUARTE CA 91010 Ohio City/Near West Side $220,400 103200 0 WOODS, MATTHEW JOHN 4215 BRIDGE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44113 Detroit-Shoreway $87,700 103500 0 KOLLAB PROPERTIES, LLC 4402 LORAIN AVE CLEVELAND OH 44113 Detroit-Shoreway $1,500 103500 0 LATHAM, CRAIG 1912 W 44 ST CLEVELAND OH 44113 Detroit-Shoreway $74,200 103500 0 KOLLAB PROPERTIES, LLC 4402 LORAIN AVE CLEVELAND OH 44113 Detroit-Shoreway $1,600 103500 0 VAN DUSEN, GRAHAM C 1951 W 26 ST CLEVELAND OH 44113 Ohio City/Near West Side $155,600 103600 0 HELSCHER, CHRISTOPHER M 2074 W 44 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 Detroit-Shoreway $14,000 102600 0 UCS PROPERTY II LLC 4909 LORAIN RD CLEVELAND OH 44102 Detroit-Shoreway $1,500 102600 0 DELIANIDES, PHILLIP & DELIANIDES, 1837 GRANADA DR CONCORD CA 94519 Ohio City/Near West Side $22,900 103800 0 AMF PROPERTIES, LLC 19885 DETROIT RD ROCKY RIVER OH 44116 Ohio City/Near West Side $18,200 103800 0 DORENKOTT, BRIAN J 2226 FULTON RD CLEVELAND OH 44113 Ohio City/Near West Side $18,700 103800 0 CLEVELAND BRICKS LLC 1925 ST CLAIR AVE CLEVELAND OH 44114 Ohio City/Near West Side $21,700 103900 0 JAM HOLDINGS, LLC 590 FARRINGTON HWY KAPOLEI HI 96707 Ohio City/Near West Side $36,200 103900 0 TORRES, MELEEDES 21340 ROBINHOOD AVE FAIRVIEW PARK OH 44126 Stockyards $32,200 102700 0 CLEVELAND LAND REUTILIZATION PROGRA 601 LAKESIDE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44114 Stockyards $9,500 102700 0 AKKATI, VIJAYPAL R & KASARLA SU 45335 POTAWATAMI DR FREMONT CA 94539 Stockyards $62,600 102700 0 AKKATI, VIJAYPAL R & KASARLA SU 45335 POTAWATAMI DR FREMONT CA 94539 Stockyards $62,600 102700 0 PROSPERCLE, LLC 1548 LAKEWOOD AVE LAKEWOOD OH 44107 Stockyards $37,900 102700 0 ANCHOR INVESTMENT HOLDINGS, LLC 101 N WOODLAND BLV DELAND FL 32720 Stockyards $24,400 102700 0 ENRIQUEZ, RUDY & ONGRUNGOUNG, PENSR 41429 SANDALWOOD PL QUARTZ HILL CA 93536 Clark-Fulton $37,900 102800 0 HS PLANNING LLC 32735 SEAGATE DR RANCHO PALOS VERDES CA 90275 Clark-Fulton $25,200 102800 0 EBNER, MARK D 1901 FREEMAN AVE CLEVELAND OH 44113 Tremont $10,700 104100 0 MICHAELS, WILLIAM D 2105 ABBY RD CLEVELAND OH 44113 Tremont 104100 0 SINGLETON, KARL E JR 2560 SCRANTON RD CLEVELAND OH 44113 Tremont $119,000 104100 0 ZELLER, TIMOTHY C 2314 W 11 ST CLEVELAND OH 44113 Tremont $403,300 104200 0 PHILLIP, CHRISTOPHER D 2337 W 11 ST CLEVELAND OH 44113 Tremont $182,700 104200 0 R AND V PROPERTY VENTURES LLC 4140 EAST STATE ST HERMITAGE PA 16148 Tremont $45,500 104500 0 R AND V PROPERTY VENTURES LLC 4140 EAST STATE ST HERMITAGE PA 16148 Tremont $45,500 104500 0 KWEI, JOSEPH AND ANDERSON, CHRISTIN 2266 W 5 ST CLEVELAND OH 44113 Tremont $327,000 104300 0 BLAZE VENTURE LLC 1743 STONY HILL RD HINCKLEY OH 44233 Tremont $424,800 104300 0 KUMAR, NIKHIL 2164 W 5 ST CLEVELAND OH 44113 Tremont $399,900 104300 0 KLINE,KAITLIN 2615 W 11 ST CLEVELAND OH 44113 Tremont $44,200 104702 0 Page 61 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable + 2000 Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Old Non-Taxable Census Dupl. Name Address Municipality State Zip code SPA Name Est.Mkt.Val. Tract Flag DAVIS, HANNAH L 829 BRAYTON AVE CLEVELAND OH 44113 Tremont $44,700 104702 0 DOMINGUEZ, JOSE L JR 2809 W 12 ST CLEVELAND OH 44113 Tremont 104702 0 DOMINGUEZ, JOSE L JR 2809 W 12 ST CLEVELAND OH 44113 Tremont 104702 0 WEST ELEVEN LLC 3027 W 11 ST CLEVELAND OH 44113 Tremont $63,300 104702 0 MOLINA, LUIS A 7701 DEARBORN AVE CLEVELAND OH 44102 West Boulevard $52,700 102402 0 STYLISH SPACES, LLC 7224 DEARBORN AVE CLEVELAND OH 44102 Stockyards $53,600 102700 0 SUHY, LARRY 3198 W 71 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 Stockyards $34,600 102700 0 CLEVELAND LAND REUTILIZATION PROGRA 601 LAKESIDE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44114 Buckeye-Shaker $7,000 119702 0 SCOTT BROCK CLEVELAND, LLC 60 E SIMPSON AVE JACKSON WY 83001 Buckeye-Shaker $24,300 119702 0 CLEVELAND LAND REUTILIZATION PROGRA 601 LAKESIDE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44114 Buckeye-Shaker $24,800 119702 0 OLADIPO, LASEINDE AKINOLA 11808 PARKHILL AVE CLEVELAND OH 44120 Buckeye-Shaker $32,800 119702 0 OLADIPO, LASEINDE AKINOLA 11808 PARKHILL AVE CLEVELAND OH 44120 Buckeye-Shaker $32,800 119702 0 BARRETT, RICHARD 3262 E 121 CLEVELAND OH 44120 Buckeye-Shaker $24,800 119701 0 CUYAHOGA COUNTY LAND REUTILIZATION 812 HURON RD CLEVELAND OH 44115 Buckeye-Shaker $10,100 119701 0 HAMPTON, LENA AND PITTS, MONISA L 3165 ASHWOOD RD CLEVELAND OH 44120 Buckeye-Shaker $72,500 119701 0 GROVEWOOD PROPERTIES, LLC 503 E 200 ST EUCLID OH 44119 Buckeye-Shaker $70,400 119701 0 WILSON, CHRISTOPHER M 2988 BECKET RD CLEVELAND OH 44120 Buckeye-Shaker $159,900 119701 0 HAMPTON2 LLC 160 W CAMINO REAL BOCA RATON FL 33432 Buckeye-Shaker $834,200 119701 0 HAMPTON2 LLC 160 W CAMINO REAL BOCA RATON FL 33432 Buckeye-Shaker $834,200 119701 0 STOVALL, DARRYL 13415 CORMERE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44120 Buckeye-Shaker $91,700 119701 0 NAILA DESKINS 1571 IVYDALE RD CLEVELAND HTS OH 44118 Buckeye-Shaker $78,300 119701 0 HATZ FOUR LLC 4403 15 AVE BROOKLYN NY 11219 Buckeye-Shaker $731,500 119501 0 HATZ FOUR LLC 4403 15 AVE BROOKLYN NY 11219 Buckeye-Shaker $731,500 119501 1 HATZ THREE LLC 4403 15 AVE BROOKLYN NY 11219 Buckeye-Shaker $708,700 119501 0 HATZ THREE LLC 4403 15 AVE BROOKLYN NY 11219 Buckeye-Shaker $708,700 119501 1 HATZ THREE LLC 4403 15 AVE BROOKLYN NY 11219 Buckeye-Shaker $245,900 119501 0 HATZ THREE LLC 4403 15 AVE BROOKLYN NY 11219 Buckeye-Shaker $245,900 119501 1 HATZ FOUR LLC 4403 15 AVE BROOKLYN NY 11219 Buckeye-Shaker $701,700 119501 0 HATZ FOUR LLC 4403 15 AVE BROOKLYN NY 11219 Buckeye-Shaker $701,700 119501 1 SNYDER, KEITH A & SNYDER, GINA M 1199 DORSH RD CLEVELAND OH 44121 Buckeye-Shaker $31,800 119501 0 SAUNDERS, JAMES D 1660 W 2 ST CLEVELAND OH 44113 Buckeye-Shaker $46,700 119501 0 CLARK, PAUL G 13901 SHAKER BLVD CLEVELAND OH 44120 Buckeye-Shaker $122,300 119501 0 ERVIN, RICHARD A 13500 SHAKER BLVD CLEVELAND OH 44120 Buckeye-Shaker $49,300 119501 0 WAGNER, MARY GRACE 13400 SHAKER BLVD CLEVELAND OH 44120 Buckeye-Shaker $66,600 119501 0 HATZ TWO LLC 4403 15 AVE BROOKLYN NY 11219 Buckeye-Shaker $323,100 119501 0 HATZ TWO LLC 4403 15 AVE BROOKLYN NY 11219 Buckeye-Shaker $323,100 119501 1 HATZ TWO LLC 4403 15 AVE BROOKLYN NY 11219 Buckeye-Shaker $491,400 119501 0 HATZ TWO LLC 4403 15 AVE BROOKLYN NY 11219 Buckeye-Shaker $491,400 119501 1 HATZ ONE LLC 4403 15 AVE BROOKLYN NY 11219 Buckeye-Shaker $508,200 119501 0 HATZ ONE LLC 4403 15 AVE BROOKLYN NY 11219 Buckeye-Shaker $508,200 119501 1 HATZ ONE LLC 4403 15 AVE BROOKLYN NY 11219 Buckeye-Shaker $464,700 119501 0 HATZ ONE LLC 4403 15 AVE BROOKLYN NY 11219 Buckeye-Shaker $464,700 119501 1 HATZ ONE LLC 4403 15 AVE BROOKLYN NY 11219 Buckeye-Shaker $951,800 119501 0 HATZ ONE LLC 4403 15 AVE BROOKLYN NY 11219 Buckeye-Shaker $951,800 119501 1 Page 62 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable + 2000 Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Old Non-Taxable Census Dupl. Name Address Municipality State Zip code SPA Name Est.Mkt.Val. Tract Flag HATZ TWO LLC 4403 15 AVE BROOKLYN NY 11219 Buckeye-Shaker $465,200 119501 0 HATZ TWO LLC 4403 15 AVE BROOKLYN NY 11219 Buckeye-Shaker $465,200 119501 1 HATZ TWO LLC 4403 15 AVE BROOKLYN NY 11219 Buckeye-Shaker $546,200 119501 0 HATZ TWO LLC 4403 15 AVE BROOKLYN NY 11219 Buckeye-Shaker $546,200 119501 1 SUTTON, HASSAN L 10003 CUMBERLAND AVE CLEVELAND OH 44104 Kinsman $38,400 114500 0 316 RIVERSIDE LLC P 46345 BEDFORD OH 44146 Kinsman $32,600 114400 0 NIDAL MANAGEMENT LLC 1 KING ST TORONTO ON M5H1A1 Woodland Hills $34,300 119600 0 JERNIGAN, DEBRA 10201 PARKVIEW AVE CLEVELAND OH 44104 Woodland Hills $32,500 119600 0 JERNIGAN, DEBRA 10201 PARKVIEW AVE CLEVELAND OH 44104 Woodland Hills $32,500 119600 1 US BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION AS TRU 1661 WORTHINGTON RD WEST PALM BEACH FL 33409 Woodland Hills $31,300 119600 0 T D REALTY LLC 4040 NORTHFIELD RD HIGHLAND HILLS OH 44122 Woodland Hills $25,200 119600 0 BWB LIFE, LLC 11301 FOREST AVE CLEVELAND OH 44104 Woodland Hills $38,300 119600 0 11313 PARKVIEW AVENUE LLC 19406 N PALO VERDE D SUN CITY AZ 85373 Woodland Hills $47,000 119600 0 SMITH & PRICE FAMILY INVESTMENTS LL 3415 E 106 ST CLEVELAND OH 44104 Union-Miles Park $19,000 120500 0 LATTIMORE, ROCHELLE A & STITT, M 22600 EMERY RD CLEVELAND OH 44128 Mt. Pleasant $32,200 120600 0 TRUST GOD INVESTMENTS LLC 6917 GERTRUDE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44105 Mt. Pleasant $28,700 120600 0 DIVVY HOMES WAREHOUSE I, LLC 530 HOWARD ST SAN FRANCISCO CA 94105 Woodland Hills $41,200 119600 0 3118 EAST 94TH STREET TRUST 3225 MCLEOD DR LAS VEGAS NV 89121 Woodland Hills $32,900 120200 0 MOORE, MARIO 9414 DICKENS AVE CLEVELAND OH 44104 Woodland Hills $31,200 120200 0 NOBLES, GLADYS 3118 E 98 ST CLEVELAND OH 44104 Woodland Hills $47,900 120200 0 I IMAN ENTERPRISES, LLC 1541 E 219 ST EUCLID OH 44117 Woodland Hills $41,200 120200 0 PUBLIC SQUARE CAPITAL RE, LLC 7201 PLEASANT ST CLEVELAND OH 44130 Union-Miles Park $27,500 120500 0 SBAR HOLDINGS LLC 11130 CONTINENTAL AVE CLEVELAND OH 44104 Woodland Hills $5,700 119600 0 SBAR HOLDINGS LLC 11130 CONTINENTAL AVE CLEVELAND OH 44104 Woodland Hills $5,700 119600 0 SBAR HOLDINGS LLC 11130 CONTINENTAL AVE CLEVELAND OH 44104 Woodland Hills $5,700 119600 0 KEYBANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION 127 PUBLIC SQ CLEVELAND OH 44113 Mt. Pleasant $37,000 119800 0 HORNE, GROVER 3090 ASHWOOD RD CLEVELAND OH 44120 Mt. Pleasant $34,200 119800 0 HMEIDAN, MOHAMMED BADER 1615 DENISON AVE CLEVELAND OH 44109 Mt. Pleasant $39,400 119800 0 HMEIDAN, MOHAMMED BADER 1615 DENISON AVE CLEVELAND OH 44109 Mt. Pleasant $39,400 119800 1 HMEIDAN, MOHAMMED BADER 1615 DENISON AVE CLEVELAND OH 44109 Mt. Pleasant $39,400 119800 0 SHARPE, DONTEZ 4315 QUINCY AVE CLEVELAND OH 44104 Mt. Pleasant $27,000 119800 0 SAXON, OLA L 3339 E 123 ST CLEVELAND OH 44120 Mt. Pleasant $57,500 119800 0 CLEVELAND LAND REUTILIZATION PROGRA 601 LAKESIDE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44114 Mt. Pleasant $7,100 119800 0 PHILLIPS, KENT L 4395 E 141 ST CLEVELAND OH 44105 Mt. Pleasant $29,400 119800 0 PHILLIPS, KENT L 4395 E 141 ST CLEVELAND OH 44105 Mt. Pleasant $29,400 119800 0 MAKUPSON, DARRELL ?? PO BOX 200671 CLEVELAND OH 44120 Mt. Pleasant $32,500 119800 0 JOHNSON, CAJUANUS L 4923 ANNETTE PL WARRENSVILLE HTS OH 44120 Mt. Pleasant $33,700 119800 0 MLC INVESTMENT PROPERTIES, LLC 16781 CHAGRIN BLVD SHAKER HTS OH 44120 Mt. Pleasant $50,000 119800 0 THREE BLACK KNIGHTS LLC 2400 ORANGE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44101 Mt. Pleasant $27,700 119800 0 SHEALY, BERNARD L 3381 E 139 ST CLEVELAND OH 44120 Mt. Pleasant $32,200 119800 0 MCMILLON DEVELOPMENT LLC 3519 DEARMES ST NEW ORLEANS LA 70114 Mt. Pleasant $37,400 120701 0 THOMPSON, JULIUS W 3448 E 123 ST CLEVELAND OH 44120 Mt. Pleasant $53,700 120701 0 RD MANAGEMENT GROUP, LLC 22 AVON GATE WINNIPEG MB R3P 1L1 Mt. Pleasant $37,400 120701 0 LAKEVIEW LOAN SERVICING LLC 3465 E 128 ST CLEVELAND OH 44120 Mt. Pleasant $37,800 120701 0 Page 63 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable + 2000 Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Old Non-Taxable Census Dupl. Name Address Municipality State Zip code SPA Name Est.Mkt.Val. Tract Flag FARADAY BUILDS LLC 306 COVENTRY RD WEST HEMPSTEAD NY 11552 Mt. Pleasant $14,400 120701 0 FARADAY BUILDS LLC 3421 E 128 ST CLEVELAND OH 44120 Mt. Pleasant $14,400 120701 0 FARADAY BUILDS LLC 3421 E 128 ST CLEVELAND OH 44120 Mt. Pleasant $14,400 120701 0 FARADAY BUILDS LLC 3421 E 128 ST CLEVELAND OH 44120 Mt. Pleasant $14,400 120701 0 MCKINLEY, DAVID J 1012 ORLEANS AVE CLEVELAND OH 44105 Mt. Pleasant $37,700 120701 0 MCKINLEY, DAVID J 1012 ORLEANS AVE CLEVELAND OH 44105 Mt. Pleasant $37,700 120701 0 M BEAR REALTY INVESTMENTS LLC 4968 E 90 ST GARFIELD HTS OH 44125 Mt. Pleasant $30,800 120702 0 PARKER PROPERTIES UNLIMITED LLC 3525 E 131 ST CLEVELAND OH 44120 Mt. Pleasant $20,200 120701 0 CLEVELAND LAND REUTILIZATION PROGRA 601 LAKESIDE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44114 Mt. Pleasant $1,500 120701 0 GRIMES, VERSHAWN 5473 DALEWOOD AVE MAPLE HEIGHTS OH 44137 Mt. Pleasant $28,300 120701 0 SIERRA PROPERTY GROUP, LLC 3600 DALLAS HWY ATLANTA GA 30364 Mt. Pleasant $28,300 120702 0 SIERRA PROPERTY GROUP, LLC 3600 DALLAS HWY ATLANTA GA 30364 Mt. Pleasant $23,200 120702 0 WEN, AHSE 3674 E 139 ST CLEVELAND OH 44105 Mt. Pleasant $32,700 120702 0 FEDERAL HOME LOAN MORTGAGE CORPORAT 8200 JONES BRANCH DR MC LEAN VA 22102 Mt. Pleasant $19,000 120702 0 KAPPA MANAGEMENT LLC 9300 S DADELAND BLV MIAMI FL 33156 Mt. Pleasant $32,700 120702 0 MAKAKAUFAKI, SIAOSI 726 MATTHEWSON AVE PLACENTIA CA 92870 Corlett $38,400 121100 0 NAHUM, ASHIR SEMBIRA 12711 GAY AVE CLEVELAND OH 44105 Mt. Pleasant $22,800 120702 0 SPEARS, TYRONE C 4687 GALLUP AVE CLEVELAND OH 44114 North Broadway $106,300 110400 0 LLOYD, NICOLE MARIE 4444 DOUSE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44127 North Broadway $37,500 110400 0 PATTERSON, LEVI J 4618 LESTER ST CLEVELAND OH 44127 North Broadway $54,100 110500 0 DUDLEY, JENNIFER M 4700 LESTER ST CLEVELAND OH 44127 North Broadway $44,500 110500 0 SIMS, DAVID E 10713 PRINCE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44105 North Broadway $16,000 114600 0 TORRES, ANTHONY 79 CHATHAM LN YOUNGSTOWN OH 44505 North Broadway $10,200 114600 0 PAVICH, NICK 2939 E 67 ST CLEVELAND OH 44127 North Broadway $21,700 114600 0 UDOVIC, MARGARET 5687 HAMLET AVE CLEVELAND OH 44127 North Broadway $20,400 114900 0 TURNER, WADE 13817 GLENDALE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44105 North Broadway $26,400 114900 0 PLAZA SUITES CLEVELAND LLC 3206 PROSPECT AVE CLEVELAND OH 44115 Central $600,000 108700 0 2193 E 35TH, LLC 1525 PEACH DR AVON OH 44011 Central $26,400 108700 0 GREEN, GLENDA 2377 E 38 ST CLEVELAND OH 44115 Central $169,600 108900 0 WELLS FARGO BANK NA 3476 STATEVIEW BLVD FORT MILL SC 29715 Central $113,900 113700 0 STALLWORTH, JUDY S 2636 E 65 ST CLEVELAND OH 44104 Central $8,100 114200 0 GREATER CLEVELAND HABITAT FOR HUMAN 2110 W 110 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 Kinsman $55,000 114700 0 CITY OF CLEVELAND ET AL 601 LAKESIDE CLEVELAND OH 44114 Kinsman $9,400 114800 0 CITY OF CLEVELAND ET AL 601 LAKESIDE CLEVELAND OH 44114 Kinsman $9,400 114800 0 CITY OF CLEVELAND ET AL 601 LAKESIDE CLEVELAND OH 44114 Kinsman $9,400 114800 1 CITY OF CLEVELAND ET AL 601 LAKESIDE CLEVELAND OH 44114 Kinsman $9,400 114800 0 CITY OF CLEVELAND ET AL 8012 HOLTON AVE CLEVELAND OH 44104 Kinsman $400 114800 0 CITY OF CLEVELAND ET AL 8012 HOLTON AVE CLEVELAND OH 44104 Kinsman $400 114800 0 CITY OF CLEVELAND ET AL 8012 HOLTON AVE CLEVELAND OH 44104 Kinsman $400 114800 1 CITY OF CLEVELAND ET AL 8012 HOLTON AVE CLEVELAND OH 44104 Kinsman $400 114800 0 PEACOCK, KATHY 3303 REGENT RD CLEVELAND OH 44127 North Broadway $5,500 114900 0 PEACOCK, KATHY 3303 REGENT RD CLEVELAND OH 44127 North Broadway $45,600 114900 0 WILSON, ROBERT O JR 6630 CHARTER AVE CLEVELAND OH 44127 North Broadway $26,400 114900 0 JACKSON, SHELLE M 2999 PAYNE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44114 South Broadway $25,700 115300 0 Page 64 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable + 2000 Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Old Non-Taxable Census Dupl. Name Address Municipality State Zip code SPA Name Est.Mkt.Val. Tract Flag ALEXANDER II, ALFRED AND ALEXANDER 11618 CROMWELL AVE CLEVELAND OH 44120-1904 Buckeye-Shaker $60,800 119401 0 ALEXANDER II, ALFRED AND ALEXANDER 11618 CROMWELL AVE CLEVELAND OH 44120 Buckeye-Shaker $46,800 119401 0 ALEXANDER II, ALFRED AND ALEXANDER 11618 CROMWELL AVE CLEVELAND OH 44120 Buckeye-Shaker $69,000 119401 0 LUDWIG, JESSICA 2719 E 116 ST CLEVELAND OH 44120 Buckeye-Shaker $104,200 119402 0 COE, STEPHANIE L 6371 ALMONT DR BROOK PARK OH 44142 Buckeye-Shaker $51,400 119401 0 FLETCHER RENOVATIONS LLC 11807 BROWNING AVE CLEVELAND OH 44120 Buckeye-Shaker $40,600 119401 0 DISTINCTION GROUP LLC 33760 BAINBRIDGE RD SOLON OH 44139 Buckeye-Shaker $66,400 119401 0 ALEXANDER II, ALFRED AND ALEXANDER 11618 CROMWELL AVE CLEVELAND OH 44120-1904 Buckeye-Shaker $53,200 119401 0 ALEXANDER II, ALFRED AND ALEXANDER 11618 CROMWELL AVE CLEVELAND OH 44120-1904 Buckeye-Shaker $46,700 119401 0 CHAMBERS, DARLING 2679 E 121 ST CLEVELAND OH 44120 Buckeye-Shaker $67,900 119401 0 CORNERSTONE RENOVATIONS LLC 23875 COMMERCE PK BEACHWOOD OH 44122 Buckeye-Shaker $80,600 119401 0 THE ALEGNA GROUP LLC 13940 CEDAR RD UNIVERSITY HTS OH 44118 Buckeye-Shaker $15,800 119402 0 GIBBS, MARIAN C 26391 RED FOX TR WHOLE VILLAGE OH 44146 Buckeye-Shaker $31,500 119402 0 HATZ THREE LLC 4403 15 AVE BROOKLYN NY 11219 Buckeye-Shaker $651,200 119501 0 HATZ THREE LLC 4403 15 AVE BROOKLYN NY 11219 Buckeye-Shaker $651,200 119501 1 HATZ THREE LLC 4403 15 AVE BROOKLYN NY 11219 Buckeye-Shaker $50,400 119501 0 HATZ THREE LLC 4403 15 AVE BROOKLYN NY 11219 Buckeye-Shaker $50,400 119501 1 HATZ THREE LLC 4403 15 AVE BROOKLYN NY 11219 Buckeye-Shaker $50,400 119501 0 HATZ THREE LLC 4403 15 AVE BROOKLYN NY 11219 Buckeye-Shaker $50,400 119501 1 HATZ THREE LLC 4403 15 AVE BROOKLYN NY 11219 Buckeye-Shaker $795,300 119501 0 HATZ THREE LLC 4403 15 AVE BROOKLYN NY 11219 Buckeye-Shaker $795,300 119501 1 HATZ THREE LLC 4403 15 AVE BROOKLYN NY 11219 Buckeye-Shaker $257,400 119501 0 HATZ THREE LLC 4403 15 AVE BROOKLYN NY 11219 Buckeye-Shaker $257,400 119501 1 LANDES, RAKEFET 23742 GREENLAWN AVE BEACHWOOD OH 44122 Buckeye-Shaker $115,500 119501 0 SMITH 11412 WOODSTOCK AVE CLEVELAND OH 44104 University $26,900 119202 0 GILLIAM, BRANDON 11417 NOTRE DAME AVE CLEVELAND OH 44104 Woodland Hills $24,400 119300 0 THOMAS, DAVID 2947 E 92 ST CLEVELAND OH 44104 Kinsman $4,000 114800 0 WELLS FARGO BANK NA 3476 STATEVIEW BLVD FORT MILL SC 29715 Kinsman $8,500 114800 0 BELCHER, LAQUITA 2645 E 110 ST CLEVELAND OH 44104 Woodland Hills $67,400 119300 0 MREV SHAKER HEIGHTS LLC 100 BORDER AVE DEL MAR CA 92014 Woodland Hills $32,500 119300 0 AMY HINSON INVESTMENTS, LLC AND DEC 1302 CLARK BROTHERS DR BUDA TX 78610 Woodland Hills $23,500 119300 0 LIGHT, JOSEPH & LIGHT, LEVAN 2901 E 111 ST CLEVELAND OH 44104 Woodland Hills $1,500 119600 0 LEE, DOROTHEA A 7920 AMOS AVE CLEVELAND OH 44104 Fairfax $20,000 113400 0 FARHADI, SHAHRIAR JASON 3393 E SCARBOROUGH CLEVELAND OH 44118 Fairfax $13,200 113400 0 TEFERA, HENOK 424 ROSS RD COLUMBUS OH 43213 Fairfax $38,900 113400 0 FOXWORTH, CHRISTOPHER J 2253 E 83 ST CLEVELAND OH 44103 Fairfax $14,600 113400 0 MUTALA, KILADI N & THELMA PO 6603 CLEVELAND OH 44101 Fairfax $20,700 113600 0 ROBERTS, KIANA B 2206 E 100 ST CLEVELAND OH 44106 Fairfax $16,800 113600 0 WELLS FARGO BANK, N A 3476 STATEVIEW BLVD FORT MILL SC 29715 Fairfax $78,100 113600 0 ANDERSON, MILTON 2216 E 101 ST CLEVELAND OH 44106 Fairfax $6,500 113600 0 SMITH, VALERIE 2525 E 84 ST CLEVELAND OH 44104 Fairfax $15,800 114100 0 MCCOY, ANGELO 8805 NEVADA AVE CLEVELAND OH 44104 Kinsman $12,600 114400 0 MCCOY, ANGELO 9205 MARSHALL AVE CLEVELAND OH 44104 Kinsman $12,200 120100 0 SUNBURST LLC 9515 EASTON AVE CLEVELAND OH 44104 Union-Miles Park $38,000 120400 0 Page 65 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable + 2000 Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Old Non-Taxable Census Dupl. Name Address Municipality State Zip code SPA Name Est.Mkt.Val. Tract Flag SUNBURST LLC 9515 EASTON AVE CLEVELAND OH 44104 Union-Miles Park $38,000 120400 0 SUNBURST LLC 9515 EASTON AVE CLEVELAND OH 44104 Union-Miles Park $38,000 120400 0 JONES, SALINA 3454 E 105 ST CLEVELAND OH 44104 Union-Miles Park $30,900 120500 0 CLEVELAND LAND REUTILIZATION PROGRA 601 LAKESIDE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44114 Union-Miles Park $4,500 120400 0 CUNNINGHAM JR , CHARLIE E 10011 ORLEANS AVE CLEVELAND OH 44105 Union-Miles Park $18,300 120400 0 SWEJO REAL ESTATE LLC 5386 MAJESTIC PKWY BEDFORD OH 44146 Union-Miles Park $32,600 120400 0 ASKREN INVESTMENTS LLC 26895 ALISO CREEK RD ALISO VIEJO CA 92656 Union-Miles Park $33,500 120400 0 GUARDIAN FUND, LLC 5440 LOUIE LN RENO NV 89511 Union-Miles Park $23,100 120400 0 GUARDIAN FUND, LLC 5440 LOUIE LN RENO NV 89511 Union-Miles Park $23,100 120400 0 PHIPPS, NICHOLAS 4456 N ABBE RD SHEFFIELD LAKE OH 44054 Union-Miles Park $31,000 120400 0 PHIPPS, NICHOLAS 4456 N ABBE RD SHEFFIELD LAKE OH 44054 Union-Miles Park $31,000 120400 0 WALTON, TAMMIE 3540 E 104 RD CLEVELAND OH 44105 Union-Miles Park $3,800 120500 0 WALTON, TAMMIE 3540 E 104 ST CLEVELAND OH 44105 Union-Miles Park $23,000 120500 0 FIORILLI, FRANK 1971 COLTMAN RD CLEVELAND OH 44106-1917 University $58,100 118800 0 FIORILLI, FRANK 1971 COLTMAN RD CLEVELAND OH 44106-1917 University $57,100 118800 0 WILLIAMS, JENNIFER L 1903 WOODLAWN AVE CLEVELAND OH 44112 University $15,800 118800 0 CAPORALE, LOUIS (ET AL) 1344 BELVOIR BLVD CLEVELAND OH 44121 University $39,400 118800 0 CAPORALE, LOUIS (ET AL) 2055 FAIRVIEW AVE CLEVELAND OH 44106 University $45,400 118800 0 FIORILLI, FRANK 1971 COLTMAN RD CLEVELAND OH 44106-1917 University $179,400 118800 0 KENNEDY, ROBERT J 2043 RANDOM RD CLEVELAND OH 44106 University $246,700 118800 0 KEMPEROAK FIRST, LLC 2127 PRIOR CT CLEVELAND OH 44106 University $63,700 118800 0 SUN, BOWEN 11430 CEDAR GLEN PKWAY CLEVELAND OH 44106 University $103,100 119202 0 VJH HOMES LLC 1400 LLOYD RD WICKLIFFE OH 44092 Goodrich/Kirtland Park $19,600 108300 0 TINGLE, MARISA R 3608 PAYNE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44114 Goodrich/Kirtland Park $100,000 108300 0 HU, YU HUA 1607 E 47 ST CLEVELAND OH 44103 Goodrich/Kirtland Park $27,800 108400 0 O'CONNOR, AUGUST SEAN 6306 DIBBLE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44103 St.Clair-Superior $53,700 111200 0 THE BANK OF NEW YORK MELLON 1661 WORTHINGTON RD WEST PALM BEACH FL 33409 Hough $14,200 112300 0 TEID, RAYNEIA T 5700 WHITE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44103 Hough $125,500 112300 0 BUCKLEY, INA GRACE 6302 UTICA AVE CLEVELAND OH 44103 Hough $11,100 112300 0 NOTTINGHAM CAPITAL LLC 17628 NOTTINGHAM RD CLEVELAND OH 44119 Hough $15,300 112100 0 HOPKINS, LEROY S 1426 E 85 ST CLEVELAND OH 44103 Hough $15,100 112200 0 HOPKINS, LEROY S 1426 E 85 ST CLEVELAND OH 44103 Hough $15,100 112200 1 HOPKINS, LEROY S 1426 E 85 ST CLEVELAND OH 44103 Hough $15,100 112200 2 HOPKINS, LEROY S 1426 E 85 ST CLEVELAND OH 44103 Hough $15,100 112200 3 CUYAHOGA COUNTY LAND REUTILIZATION 812 HURON RD CLEVELAND OH 44115 Hough $7,900 112200 0 GREEN, R B 6806 ZOETER AVE CLEVELAND OH 44103 Hough $21,400 112400 0 GREEN, R B 6806 ZOETER AVE CLEVELAND OH 44103 Hough $8,000 112400 0 GREEN, R B 6806 ZOETER AVE CLEVELAND OH 44103 Hough $6,600 112400 0 GREEN, R B 6806 ZOETER AVE CLEVELAND OH 44103 Hough $36,800 112400 0 GREEN, R B ?? ZOETER AVE CLEVELAND OH 44103 Hough $6,200 112400 0 GREEN, JAMES G 1471 E 71 ST CLEVELAND OH 44128 Hough $26,000 112400 0 BRISKER, VALERIE L 8109 WHITEHORN AVE CLEVELAND OH 44103 Hough $16,800 112500 0 CLEVELAND LAND REUTILIZATION PROGRA 601 LAKESIDE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44114 Hough $9,500 112500 0 FLIP ONE LLC 1904 S TAYLOR RD CLEVELAND HEIGHTS OH 44118 Hough $23,700 118602 0 Page 66 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable + 2000 Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Old Non-Taxable Census Dupl. Name Address Municipality State Zip code SPA Name Est.Mkt.Val. Tract Flag WRIGHT, MICHAEL 1338 E 88 ST CLEVELAND OH 44106 Hough $21,100 112200 0 FEDERAL NATIONAL MORTGAGE ASSOCIATI 14221 DALLAS PKWY DALLAS TX 75254 Hough $17,700 112200 0 RXB VENTURES LLC 1611 HOLYROOD AVE CLEVELAND HTS OH 44106 Hough $16,400 112600 0 FEDERAL HOME LOAN MORTGAGE CORPORAT 8200 JONES BRANCH DR MC LEAN VA 22102 Hough $33,400 118602 0 CRAIN, VERLENER ETAL 1915 E 69 ST CLEVELAND OH 44103 Hough $1,600 112800 0 CRAIN, VERLENER ETAL 1915 E 69 ST CLEVELAND OH 44103 Hough $1,800 112800 0 CRAIN, VERLENER ETAL 1915 E 69 ST CLEVELAND OH 44103 Hough $500 112800 0 CRAIN, VERLENER ETAL 1915 E 69 ST CLEVELAND OH 44103 Hough $15,300 112800 0 CRAIN, VERLENER ETAL 1915 E 69 ST CLEVELAND OH 44103 Hough $1,900 112800 0 CRAIN, VERLENER ETAL 1915 E 69 ST CLEVELAND OH 44103 Hough $1,700 112800 0 STOVALL, AJ 145 E RUST COLLEGE HOLLY SPRINGS MS 38635 Hough $1,800 112800 0 MACON, ESTHER 1804 E 81 ST CLEVELAND OH 44103 Hough $177,200 112800 0 PARKER PROPERTIES UNLIMITED LLC 3020 REDNER ST PHILADELPHIA PA 19121 St.Clair-Superior $20,600 111500 0 SANDERS, DWAYNE 1256 NORWOOD RD CLEVELAND OH 44103 St.Clair-Superior $25,900 111500 0 BROWN, PAUL 1224 E 61 ST CLEVELAND OH 44103 St.Clair-Superior $64,300 111500 0 LANIGAN, JOSEPH A 1051 W WALLINGS RD BROADVIEW HEIGHTS OH 44147 St.Clair-Superior $28,900 111500 0 WILEY, SHAUNTAY A 6807 BAYLISS AVE CLEVELAND OH 44103 St.Clair-Superior $11,900 111600 0 M&S REAL ESTATE, LLC PO BOX 1021 GATES MILLS OH 44040 St.Clair-Superior $22,200 111500 0 BAGWELL, KEISHA L 1248 ADDISON RD CLEVELAND OH 44103 St.Clair-Superior $44,400 111600 0 JOHNSON, ANTIONETTE G 1247 ADDISON RD CLEVELAND OH 44103 St.Clair-Superior $21,700 111600 0 P&S CASHFLOW PROPERTIES LLC 22 AVON GATE MANITOBA, CANADA R3P ILI St.Clair-Superior $57,800 111600 0 CARTER, JUANITA 1100 E 68 ST CLEVELAND OH 44103 St.Clair-Superior $34,200 111600 0 COLE, PAUL 6618 BLISS AVE CLEVELAND OH 44103 St.Clair-Superior $21,600 111600 0 MOMO COMPANY, LLC 13616-18 RUGBY RD CLEVELAND OH 44110 Collinwood $35,200 117300 0 OZEKICI, SEDAT 200 W MADISON AVE CHICAGO IL 60606 North Shore Collinwood $37,400 117102 0 DAVIS, DAVE 6525 CLEARAIR DR MENTOR OH 44060 Collinwood $28,200 117400 0 MJB INVESMENT PROPERTIES LLC 1441 DILLE RD EUCLID OH 44117 Collinwood $86,600 117400 0 COSTANTINI, DOMINIC 818 RUDYARD RD CLEVELAND OH 44110 Collinwood $44,100 117500 0 MJB INVESTMENT PROP LLC 1441 DILLE RD EUCLID OH 44117 Collinwood $64,700 117500 0 ANTAR, AVRAHAM 816 LONDON RD CLEVELAND OH 44110 Collinwood $34,100 117500 0 SEMBIRA, AYELET 925 NATHANIEL RD CLEVELAND OH 44110 Collinwood $43,300 117500 0 PREMIER INVESTMENT PROPERTIES LLC 3600 DALLASH HWY MARIETTA GA 30064 Collinwood $42,400 117500 0 MY SWEET ESTATE LLC 1621 NORTHLAND AVE LAKEWOOD OH 44107 Collinwood $33,600 117500 0 MY SWEET ESTATE LLC 1621 NORTHLAND AVE LAKEWOOD OH 44107 Collinwood $900 117500 0 NOAM HERZ, LLC 16512 BURNSIDE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44110 Collinwood $44,200 117500 0 DEBANIECE A MADDOX 523 E 124 TH ST CLEVELAND OH 44108 Forest Hills $18,100 116700 0 MANNING, GARY B 249 E 151 ST CLEVELAND OH 44110 North Shore Collinwood $61,400 117101 0 SH HOLDINGS LLC ?? P O BOX 261 PAINESVILLE OH 44077 North Shore Collinwood $31,000 117101 0 MOODRY, JUDITH F 29 CHARLESTON SQ EUCLID OH 44132 North Shore Collinwood $42,600 117201 0 HERNANDEZ, DANIEL 372 E 156 ST CLEVELAND OH 44110 North Shore Collinwood $35,000 117202 0 FEDERAL NATIONAL MORTGAGE ASSOCIATI 9990 RICHMOND HOUSTON TX 77042 North Shore Collinwood $49,200 117101 0 CUYAHOGA COUNTY LAND REUTILIZATION 812 HURON RD CLEVELAND OH 44115 North Shore Collinwood $51,700 117101 0 MOURZINE, INGRIDA J 17922 BRAZIL AVE CLEVELAND OH 44119 North Shore Collinwood $28,000 117600 0 WILMINGTON SAVINGS FUND SOCIETY FSB 333 S ANITA DR ORANGE CA 92868 North Shore Collinwood $45,300 117600 0 Page 67 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable + 2000 Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Old Non-Taxable Census Dupl. Name Address Municipality State Zip code SPA Name Est.Mkt.Val. Tract Flag LAYTON, DAN 1578 W JACKSON ST PAINESVILLE OH 44077 North Shore Collinwood $26,100 117202 0 COLEMAN, HOWARD 360 E 161 ST CLEVELAND OH 44110 North Shore Collinwood $47,200 117202 0 NORMAN, BRENDA GREENE 16118 PARKGROVE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44110 North Shore Collinwood $70,100 117202 0 RSN HOLDINGS DELAWARE LLC 17830 ENGLEWOOD DR MIDDLEBURG HTS OH 44130 North Shore Collinwood $49,900 117202 0 OJ'S CONSTRUCTION INC 1028 E 169 ST CLEVELAND OH 44110 North Shore Collinwood $19,700 117201 0 RSN HOLDINGS DELAWARE LLC 17830 ENGLEWOOD DR MIDDLEBURG HTS OH 44130 North Shore Collinwood $49,900 117201 0 MIDWEST VISTA, LLC 40 WOODCLIFF CT OAKLAND CA 94605 North Shore Collinwood $60,000 117600 0 HALL, LATOSHA 4600 NORTHERN BLVD COLUMBUS OH 43229 North Shore Collinwood $34,800 117600 0 MFR 5, LLC 50 CAMBORNE AVE SAN CARLOS CA 94070 North Shore Collinwood $46,600 117600 0 MJB INVESTMENT PROPERTIES LLC 1441 DILLE RD EUCLID OH 44117 North Shore Collinwood $63,500 117600 0 BALTIC INVESTMENTS, LLC 16816 GROVEWOOD CLEVELAND OH 44110 North Shore Collinwood $68,400 117600 0 US BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION 4801 FREDERICA ST OWENSBORO KY 42301 North Shore Collinwood $99,600 117600 0 AZZAM, MAJDI M 5386 MAJESTIC PKWY BEDFORD HTS OH 44146 North Shore Collinwood $60,000 117700 0 BIONDOLILLO, CHRISTINE J 29518 EUCLID AVE WICKLIFFE OH 44092 North Shore Collinwood $82,400 117700 0 MCGUCKIN, BRIAN 17801 INGLESIDE RD CLEVELAND OH 44119 North Shore Collinwood $42,300 117700 0 NASVYTIS, VILIJA 17618 INGLESIDE RD CLEVELAND OH 44119 North Shore Collinwood $80,200 117700 0 NASVYTIS, VILIJA 17618 INGLESIDE RD CLEVELAND OH 44119 North Shore Collinwood $80,200 117700 1 RSN HOLDINGS DELAWARE, LC 17830 ENGLEWOOD DR CLEVELAND OH 44130 North Shore Collinwood $39,000 117700 0 RAAQIM, KHALEEL 18905 PAWNEE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44119 North Shore Collinwood $58,400 117700 0 CUNNINGHAM, LEVANDER 18811 MUSKOKA AVE CLEVELAND OH 44119 North Shore Collinwood $56,200 117700 0 GROVEWOOD PROPERTIES LLC 503 E 200 ST EUCLID OH 44119 North Shore Collinwood $46,500 117700 0 GROVEWOOD PROPERTIES LLC 503 E 200 ST EUCLID OH 44119 North Shore Collinwood $46,500 117700 0 U S BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION 4801 FREDERICA ST OWENSBORO KY 42301 North Shore Collinwood $126,000 117700 0 LIFE OF SEASONS LLC PO 603718 CLEVELAND OH 44103 Glenville $36,500 116400 0 BOOKER, LESHON B 9707 YALE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44108 Glenville $23,900 116400 0 MILLER, VALECIA 9605 YALE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44108 Glenville $22,000 116400 0 GULLEY, VANCE TRS 24720 TWICKENHAM DR BEACHWOOD OH 44122 Glenville $23,100 116400 0 MCPHERSON, PAMELA 9901 PARMALEE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44108 Glenville $26,300 116400 0 GINYARD-DENSON, MILDRED L 10214 GARFIELD AVE CLEVELAND OH 44108 Glenville $22,600 116400 0 BONDARU, SARATH KRISHNA 668 E 106 ST CLEVELAND OH 44108 Glenville $46,500 116500 0 754 PARKWOOD DRIVE TRUST 3225 MCLEOD DR LAS VEGAS NV 89121 Glenville $27,900 116500 0 CHEEKS, RICHARD E 10629 KIMBERLY AVE CLEVELAND OH 44108 Glenville $21,700 116500 0 CHEEKS, RICHARD E 10629 KIMBERLY AVE CLEVELAND OH 44108 Glenville $21,700 116500 1 CHEEKS, RICHARD E 10629 KIMBERLY AVE CLEVELAND OH 44108 Glenville $21,700 116500 2 CHEEKS, RICHARD E 10629 KIMBERLY AVE CLEVELAND OH 44108 Glenville $21,700 116500 3 OHIO EIRE PROPERTIES 10612 EVERTON AVE CLEVELAND OH 44108 Glenville $23,300 116500 0 GIBBS, DARRELL 735 PARKWOOD DR CLEVELAND OH 44108 Glenville $13,900 116500 0 ILONA T PERKINS 9106 PARMELEE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44108 Glenville $23,200 116400 0 BARLIN INVEST LLC 1621 NORTHLAND AVE LAKEWOOD OH 44107 Glenville $11,100 116400 0 BISSELLE, MARY F 9805 SOUTH BLVD CLEVELAND OH 44108 St.Clair-Superior $66,100 111901 0 ULTIMATE PRODUCTS, LLC 10023 NORTH BLVD CLEVELAND OH 44108 Glenville $13,000 118100 0 CALDWELL, JAMEL 10117 SOMERSET AVE CLEVELAND OH 44108 Glenville $24,200 118100 0 CASPER ENTERPRISE GROUP, INC 494 E 200 ST EUCLID OH 44119 Glenville $109,200 118100 0 RIGHTERXYZ INVESTMENTS, LLC 3904 N DRUID HILLS DECATUR GA 30033 Glenville $3,000 116500 0 Page 68 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable + 2000 Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Old Non-Taxable Census Dupl. Name Address Municipality State Zip code SPA Name Est.Mkt.Val. Tract Flag PARKER PROPERTIES UNLIMITED LLC 1401 N 29 ST PHILADELPHIA PA 19121 Glenville $15,600 116500 0 DAVIS, PATRICIA 10805 AMOR AVE CLEVELAND OH 44108 Glenville $20,700 116500 0 DAVIS, PATRICIA 10805 AMOR AVE CLEVELAND OH 44108 Glenville $20,700 116500 1 THERMITUS, NIXON 10809 GREENLAWN AVE CLEVELAND OH 44108 Glenville $30,800 116500 0 TAYLOR, TERRELL 10808 COLUMBIA AVE CLEVELAND OH 44108 Glenville $48,500 116500 0 NEW RESIDENTIAL MORTGAGE LOAN TRUST 8950 CYPRESS WATERS BLVD COPPELL TX 75019 Glenville $27,700 118200 0 COUSIN WINNIE (ET AL) 10839 GRANTWOOD AVE CLEVELAND OH 44108 Glenville $22,500 118200 0 CLEVELAND LAND REUTILIZATION PROGRA 601 LAKESIDE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44114 Glenville $12,000 118200 0 CLEVELAND LAND REUTILIZATION PROGRA 601 LAKESIDE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44114 Glenville $12,400 118200 0 PELTIER, ALLISON M 10607 PASADENA AVE CLEVELAND OH 44108 Glenville $16,400 118200 0 SANDBAY PROPERTIES INVEST LLC 1621 NORTHLAND AVE LAKEWOOD OH 44107 Glenville $23,900 116500 0 DARNELL N HARSLEY 11201 BERKSHIRE RD CLEVELAND OH 44108 Glenville $16,600 116500 0 WALI SHAKIR 535 E 117 ST CLEVELAND OH 44108 Glenville $22,100 118200 0 ORIT LLC 26 HAGOLAN ST TEL-AVIV ISRAEL 6971829 Forest Hills $34,300 116600 0 PARKER PROPERTIES UNLIMITED LLC 1401 N 29 ST PHILADELPHIA PA 19121 Forest Hills $19,800 116600 0 MERRIWEATHER, DIANNE A 3001 BECKET RD SHAKER HEIGHTS OH 44120 Forest Hills $23,500 118400 0 YANNA ALL N ONE PAYEE SERVICES & MO 12003 OSCEOLA CLEVELAND OH 44108 Forest Hills $25,000 118400 0 GULLEY, VANCE TRS 24720 TWICKENHAM DR BEACHWOOD OH 44122 Forest Hills $31,300 118400 0 CUYAHOGA COUNTY LAND REUTILIZATION 812 HURON RD CLEVELAND OH 44115 Glenville $15,800 118300 0 NC LAR, LLC 1372 E 111 ST CLEVELAND OH 44106 Glenville $14,900 118300 0 FAMICOS FOUNDATION 1325 ANSEL RD CLEVELAND OH 44106 Glenville $21,900 118500 0 BURNETT, ERIC-TRUSTEE 1453 E 109 ST CLEVELAND OH 44106 Glenville $21,800 118300 0 DAMM, ROBERT ETAL 23999 WESTWOOD RD WESTLAKE OH 44145 Glenville $68,300 118300 0 CLAY-ARGIEARD, LLC 11215 ITASCA AVE CLEVELAND OH 44106 Glenville $17,300 118300 0 CLAY-ARGIEARD, LLC 11215 ITASCA AVE CLEVELAND OH 44106 Glenville $17,300 118300 1 CLEVELAND LAND REUTILIZATION PROGRA 601 LAKESIDE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44113 Glenville $15,100 118300 0 CUYAHOGA COUNTY LAND REUTILIZATION 812 HURON RD CLEVELAND OH 44115 Glenville $48,800 118500 0 WHITE, MICHAEL L 1385 E 124 ST CLEVELAND OH 44106 Glenville $50,000 118500 0 1551 EAST 118, LLC 22720 FAIRVIEW CENTER DR CLEVELAND OH 44126 University $50,400 118700 0 JOHNSON, LEONARD W 979 E 79 ST CLEVELAND OH 44103 Glenville $14,200 111402 0 MATTHEWS, ELI R 11100 WADE PARK AVE CLEVELAND OH 44106 University $115,200 118700 0 UPSCALE PROPERTIES UNLIMITED LLC 2445 ST CLAIR AVE CLEVELAND OH 44114 Collinwood $8,200 117300 0 MCDUFFIE, DARRYL B 13909 WOODWORTH AVE CLEVELAND OH 44112 Collinwood $39,000 116900 0 PARKER PROPERTIES UNLIMITED LLC 1401 N 29 ST PHILADELPHIA PA 19121 Collinwood $11,200 116900 0 COX, PETERGAIL 14809 PEPPER AVE CLEVELAND OH 44110 Collinwood $23,300 117300 0 COX, PETERGAIL 14809 PEPPER AVE CLEVELAND OH 44110 Collinwood $23,300 117300 0 TADIPARTY, SOAMI CHARAN DAS 540 STEDFORD LN DULUTH GA 30097 Collinwood $29,600 117300 0 CUYAHOGA COUNTY LAND REUTILIZATION 812 HURON RD CLEVELAND OH 44115 Collinwood $16,200 116900 0 SBAR HOLDINGS, LLC 2357 STONEGATE DR WELLINGTON FL 33414 Collinwood $35,600 116900 0 SBAR HOLDINGS, LLC 2357 STONEGATE DR WELLINGTON FL 33414 Collinwood $35,600 116900 0 CLEVELAND PROPERTY MANAGEMENT FOUND 3691 S GREEN RD BEACHWOOD OH 44122 Collinwood $46,000 116900 0 MADDINENI, RAMBABU 14637 COIT RD CLEVELAND OH 44110 Collinwood $13,200 116900 0 HOGUE, JR , WILLIAM L 1341 E 170 ST CLEVELAND OH 44110 Collinwood $20,500 117800 0 REEVES, SR , ANDRE 7805 LAUMAR AVE CLEVELAND OH 44105 Collinwood $35,600 117800 0 Page 69 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable + 2000 Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Old Non-Taxable Census Dupl. Name Address Municipality State Zip code SPA Name Est.Mkt.Val. Tract Flag BAKER, GINGER GALE BOWEN ?? PO BOX 234 LORADO WV 25630 Collinwood $18,600 117800 0 BAKER, GINGER GALE BOWEN 1473 E 175 ST CLEVELAND OH 44110 Collinwood $1,300 117800 0 RD MANAGEMENT, LLC 1425 E 175 ST CLEVELAND OH 44110 Collinwood $30,500 117800 0 ANNIKEY, VEDA 1522 E 172 ST CLEVELAND OH 44110 Collinwood $46,400 117800 0 NATIONSTAR MORTGAGE LLC 15480 LAGUNA CANYON RD IRVINE CA 92618 Collinwood $44,000 117800 0 SH HOLDINGS LLC 1075 PINEVIEW CIR LIVE OAK FL 32064 Collinwood $27,200 117800 0 WARD, LEROY JR 1422 LARCHMONT RD CLEVELAND OH 44110 Collinwood $38,800 117800 0 WELLS FARGO BANK, N A 3476 STATEVIEW BLVD FORT MILL SC 29715 Collinwood $44,500 117800 0 FEDERAL NATIONAL MORTGAGE ASSOCIATI ?? PO BOX 650043 DALLAS TX 75265 Collinwood $32,700 117800 0 PEARL PROPERTY MANAGEMENT LLC 1665 HILLVIEW RD CLEVELAND OH 44112 Euclid-Green $28,000 117900 0 SRW ROCKET, LLC 1318 W 95 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 Euclid-Green $22,600 117900 0 FARHADI, SHAHRIAR JASON 3393 E SCARBOROUGH CLEVELAND OH 44118 Euclid-Green $24,300 117900 0 GREGG, BRANDON A 1751 AVALON RD CLEVELAND OH 44112 Euclid-Green $24,300 117900 0 CLEVELAND LAND REUTILIZATION PROGRA 601 LAKESIDE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44114 Euclid-Green $11,800 117900 0 DAVIS, ROBERT LOUIS 459 LORRAWAY DR CASTLE ROCK CO 80108 Euclid-Green $30,900 117900 0 ULTIMATE PRODUCTS LLC 1853 MANNERING RD CLEVELAND OH 44112 Euclid-Green $34,700 117900 0 CUYAHOGA COUNTY LAND REUTILIZATION 812 HURON RD CLEVELAND OH 44115 Euclid-Green $29,000 117900 0 EJR GROUP, LLC 10313 AVON AVE CLEVELAND OH 44105 Euclid-Green $25,000 117900 0 BROOKS, MARSHALL 16009 STEINWAY BLVD MAPLE HEIGHTS OH 44137 Euclid-Green $40,100 126100 0 38,300 2171 BELVOIR BLVD STE 110 SO TX Euclid-Green $46,100 126100 0 HARVEY, LELA 3643 RUNNYMEDE BLVD CLEVELAND HEIGHTS OH 44121 Euclid-Green $3,800 126100 0 JONES, R L 1849 TORBENSON DR CLEVELAND OH 44112 Euclid-Green $50,900 126100 0 MOORE, DAMON & WORLD CLASS BARBERSH 15465 EULCID AVE CLEVELAND OH 44112 Glenville $21,100 111401 0 TJI LLC 711 E MAIN ST WALHALLA SC 29691 Glenville $8,400 111401 0 KARDER INVESTMENTS LTD 20821 BURGUNDY DR STRONGSVILLE OH 44149 Glenville $45,500 111401 0 CARL BROWN 700 E 96 ST CLEVELAND OH 44108 Glenville $34,800 111401 0 MCINTOSH, REGINA S 10800 GREENLAWN AVE CLEVELAND OH 44108 Glenville $31,300 111401 0 SMITH, RONDA 714 E 95 ST CLEVELAND OH 44108 Glenville $21,300 111401 0 JIREH REAL ESTATE INVESTMENTS OH, L 26 DOMINY DR AJAX ON L1T 3H6 Glenville $25,900 116100 0 EQUITY TRUST COMPANY CUSTODIAN FBO 749 ROSEWOOD DR WALNUT CREEK CA 94596 Glenville $58,400 116100 0 HUNTER, BRANDI 13909 MELZER AVE CLEVELAND OH 44120 Glenville $41,200 116200 0 CUYAHOGA COUNTY LAND REUTILIZATION 812 HURON RD CLEVELAND OH 44115 Glenville $30,800 116200 0 L T TAYLOR 660 E 126 ST CLEVELAND OH 44108 Forest Hills $14,300 116800 0 SYNERGY PROPERTY INVESTMENTS, LLC 664 E 131 ST CLEVELAND OH 44108 Forest Hills $21,100 116800 0 BRACKLAND LLC 12911 BRACKLAND AVE CLEVELAND OH 44108 Forest Hills $75,000 116800 0 KING, HARRY L JR 7800 E UNION AVE DENVER CO 80237 Forest Hills $2,900 116800 0 ENGRAM, MARLOW 977 THORNHILL DR CLEVELAND OH 44108 Forest Hills $43,400 116600 0 HARRIS, DENISE 1127 E 177 ST CLEVELAND OH 44119 Forest Hills $42,300 116600 0 MARTIN, STEVE 1806 WESLEY CHAPEL RD CALIFORNIA KY 41007 Forest Hills $6,700 116800 0 ULTIMATE PRODUCTS, LLC 12617 EDMONTON AVE CLEVELAND OH 44108 Forest Hills $23,800 116800 0 KEYBANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION 4910 TIEDEMAN RD BROOKLYN OH 44144 Forest Hills $8,800 116800 0 THREE BLACK KNIGHTS LLC 2400 ORANGE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44114 Forest Hills $16,800 116800 0 911 PAXTON ROAD TRUST 3225 MCLEOD DR LAS VEGAS NV 89121 Forest Hills $37,400 116800 0 HILLIARD, LESTER EUGENE-TRUSTEE 12725 BARRINGTON AVE CLEVELAND OH 44108 Forest Hills $16,100 116800 0 Page 70 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable + 2000 Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Old Non-Taxable Census Dupl. Name Address Municipality State Zip code SPA Name Est.Mkt.Val. Tract Flag TAWEEL, ALAA DARAL 5610 W LONGRIDGE DR SEVEN HILLS OH 44131 Forest Hills $16,300 116800 0 HSBC BANK USA NATIONAL ASSOCIATION 1661 WORTHINGTON RD WEST PALM BEACH FL 33409 Forest Hills $18,200 116800 0 JERIDO, WILLIE 507 E 112 ST CLEVELAND OH 44108 Forest Hills $20,700 116300 0 FREEALL BIRDS, LLC P BOX 32630 EUCLID OH 44132 Forest Hills $8,200 116300 0 FREEALLBIRDS,LLC P BOX 32360 EUCLID OH 44132 Forest Hills $41,900 116300 0 EDWARDS, HARRY 491 E 118 ST CLEVELAND OH 44108 Forest Hills $32,700 116300 0 B & M REAL ESTATE INVESTMENTS LLC 926 BRUNSWICK RD CLEVELAND HTS OH 44112 Forest Hills $34,300 116300 0 TWIN HOUSING PROPERTIES LLC 14 LINDSEY CT BOLINGBROOK IL 60440 Forest Hills $41,900 116300 0 MOORE, ALEX 11405 ABLEWHITE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44108 Forest Hills $17,700 116300 0 MOORE, ALEX 14629 ARDENALL AVE CLEVELAND OH 44112 Forest Hills $42,500 116300 0 BRADY, DONOVAN 11705 ABELWHITE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44108 Forest Hills $33,500 116300 0 WILLLIAMS, VALERIE 11601 ABLEWHITE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44108 Forest Hills $36,800 116300 0 BOWERSOCK, LEILANI 3106 BRADLEY RD WESTLAKE OH 44145 Forest Hills $29,100 116800 0 SAMUEL, SAJAY 483 E 128 ST CLEVELAND OH 44108 Forest Hills $32,900 116700 0 MIRANDA, RAPHAEL DE PAULA AND DE AZ 456 CLEVELAND RD CLEVELAND OH 44108 Forest Hills $18,600 116700 0 HARRIS, DENISE 1127 E 177 ST CLEVELAND OH 44119 Forest Hills $43,100 116700 0 PREMIER INVESTMENT PROPERTIES, LLC 3600 DALLAS HWY MARIETTA GA 30064 Forest Hills $37,700 116700 0 SIMMONS, LEAH MARIE 1408 E 43 ST CLEVELAND OH 44103 Goodrich/Kirtland Park $12,400 108200 0 CUYAHOGA COUNTY LAND REUTILIZATION 812 HURON RD CLEVELAND OH 44115 Goodrich/Kirtland Park $20,500 108200 0 CLEVELAND LAND REUTILIZATION PROGRA 601 LAKESIDE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44114 St.Clair-Superior $3,000 111300 0 BEATY, NORMAN 898 E 75 ST CLEVELAND OH 44103 St.Clair-Superior $18,700 111300 0 TRUITT, GABRIEL J 1043 E 71 ST CLEVELAND OH 44103 St.Clair-Superior $8,300 111700 0 CNGRUN, LLC 1029 E 72 ST CLEVELAND OH 44103 St.Clair-Superior $34,000 111700 0 TRUST GOD INVESTMENTS LLC 6917 GERTRUDE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44105 St.Clair-Superior $16,700 111700 0 COLLAZO, YOLANDA 12718 EMERY AVE CLEVELAND OH 44135 Puritas-Longmead $20,000 124400 0 GULLEY, CLAUDE TRS 1939 GREEN RD CLEVELAND OH 44121 Puritas-Longmead $34,800 124400 0 GEORDIK, LLC 6026 SQUIRREL HOLLOW LN STRONGSVILLE OH 44136 Puritas-Longmead $11,600 124400 0 HARDWAYS LLC 8194 W DEER VALLEY PEORIA AZ 85382 Puritas-Longmead $31,800 124400 0 GULLEY, VANCE TRS 24720 TWICKENHAM DR BEACHWOOD OH 44122 Puritas-Longmead $40,500 124400 0 JONSHON, CHERYL D 24720 TWICKENHAM DR BEACHWOOD OH 44122 Puritas-Longmead $31,800 124400 0 HAMILTON, YOLANDA 11805 GUARDIAN BLVD CLEVELAND OH 44135 Puritas-Longmead $43,300 124400 0 STEEL, RATOYA 3746 W 138 ST CLEVELAND OH 44111 Puritas-Longmead $32,800 124400 0 FEDERAL HOME LOAN MORTGAGE CORPORAT 8200 JONES BRANCH DR MC LEAN VA 22102 Puritas-Longmead $28,200 124400 0 RUSSELL, SHAWNTERRA 12608 GRIMSBY AVE CLEVELAND OH 44135 Puritas-Longmead $31,400 124400 0 ZRAIQAT, KHALIL M 18338 FERNCLIFFE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44135 Puritas-Longmead $28,600 124400 0 FEDERAL HOME LOAN MORTGAGE CORPORAT 8200 JONES BRANCH DR MC LEAN VA 22102 Puritas-Longmead $30,100 124400 0 LOWRY, KIMBERLY 4266 W 22 ST CLEVELAND OH 44109 Puritas-Longmead $47,000 124400 0 UR HOME PROPERTIES LLC 4793 CARSTEN LN NORTH OLMSTED OH 44070 Edgewater $38,000 101101 0 TRASKOVA, OLGA 1355 WEST BLVD CLEVELAND OH 44102 Edgewater $81,800 101101 0 NATIONSTAR MORTGAGE LLC 1555 LAKE SHORE DR COLUMBUS OH 43204 Cudell $64,700 101400 0 MEPHAM, DENNIS 14617 LAKE AVE LAKEWOOD OH 44107 Cudell $14,600 101400 0 MEPHAM, DENNIS 14617 LAKE AVE LAKEWOOD OH 44107 Cudell $37,500 101400 0 VIOLETTE, AISHA 9700 BALTIC RD CLEVELAND OH 44102 Edgewater $120,900 101102 0 KLINKO, RHONDA 11820 EDGEWATER DR LAKEWOOD OH 44107 Edgewater $46,600 101300 0 Page 71 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable + 2000 Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Old Non-Taxable Census Dupl. Name Address Municipality State Zip code SPA Name Est.Mkt.Val. Tract Flag KLINKO, RHONDA 1411 W 110 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 Edgewater $46,600 101300 0 KLINKO, RHONDA 11820 EDGEWATER #722 DR LAKEWOOD OH 44107 Edgewater $251,000 101300 0 BREDE, EDWARD 1441 W 110 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 Edgewater $900 101300 0 BREDE, EDWARD 5525 SNELL DR MENTOR OH 44060 Edgewater $63,200 101300 0 BEIT KABEER MANAGEMENT LLC 4758 RIDGE RD BROOKLYN OH 44144 Jefferson $64,900 124100 0 BERMUDEZ, ALBERT 3477 W 120 ST CLEVELAND OH 44111 Jefferson $60,400 124100 0 AMADOR, FELIPE JR & AMADOR, JESSICA 7341 HAZELTINE AVE VAN NUYS CA 91405 Jefferson $62,000 124100 0 DEUTSCHE BANK TRUST COMPANY AMERICA 1761 E ST ANDREW PL SANTA ANA CA 92705 Jefferson $76,500 124100 0 SEMARY, ALEJANDRO AND SEMARY, GEORG 4020 W 63 ST CLEVELAND OH 44144 Jefferson $67,500 124100 0 HARDEO, MAHINDRA 11721 MORTIMER AVE CLEVELAND OH 44111 Jefferson $55,400 124100 0 GEORGES, SAM 812 MALIBU POINT WAY OCEANSIDE CA 92508 Jefferson $58,900 124100 0 MONTERROSO, EVER A 2506 CRENSHAW BLVD LOS ANGELES CA 90016 Jefferson $54,100 124100 0 MONTERROSO, EVER A 2506 CRENSHAW BLVD LOS ANGELES CA 90016 Jefferson $54,000 124100 0 MONTERROSO, EVER A 2506 CRENSHAW BLVD LOS ANGELES CA 90016 Jefferson $54,000 124100 0 MONTERROSO, EVER A 2506 CRENSHAW BLVD LOS ANGELES CA 90016 Jefferson $54,000 124100 0 MONTERROSO, EVER A 2506 CRENSHAW BLVD LOS ANGELES CA 90016 Jefferson $54,000 124100 0 MICHAEL ZITNEY 11720 WAYLAND AVE CLEVELAND OH 44111 Jefferson $64,800 124100 0 LEVEL II MANAGEMENT & CONSULTANTS, 2155 WAYNOKA AVE EUCLID OH 44117 Jefferson $71,700 124100 0 GULLEY, VANCE TRS 24720 TWICKENHAM DR BEACHWOOD OH 44122 Puritas-Longmead $61,300 124400 0 A & R FAMILY INVESTMENT LLC 13792 NEWTON RD MIDDLEBURG HTS OH 44130 Jefferson $57,200 124100 0 LLAPA, FLOR E 12301 MARNE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44111 Jefferson $56,100 124100 0 HARDWAYS LLC 8194 W DEER VALLEY PEORIA AZ 85382 Jefferson $53,600 124100 0 SCHAEFER, ERIKA ETAL 36-35 167 ST FLUSHING NY 11358 Jefferson $46,900 124100 0 QUINONES, NATASHA CORIANO 12219 BETHANY AVE CLEVELAND OH 44111 Jefferson $49,200 124100 0 ROSARIO, JOSE A 3579 LLOYD RD CLEVELAND OH 44111 Jefferson $62,300 124100 0 QUEST PROPERTY HOLDINGS LLC 6885 ROYALTON RD NORTH ROYALTON OH 44133 Jefferson $58,600 124100 0 MULDREW, LAWRENCE AND MULDREW, VICK 3587 W 129 ST CLEVELAND OH 44111 Jefferson $50,300 124100 0 WAYNE SEGUL 8490 STEARNS RD OLMSTED FALLS OH 44138-1737 Jefferson $52,200 124100 0 HGHTOWER, LINDA G 37834 MAGNOLIA DR AVON OH 44011 Puritas-Longmead $38,300 124400 0 MOORE, JAMES 1244 W 69 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 Puritas-Longmead $34,900 124400 0 GULLEY, CLAUDE TRS 1939 GREN RD CLEVELAND OH 44121 Puritas-Longmead $48,400 124400 0 OPSAHL JR , ROBERT D 3278 W 116 ST CLEVELAND OH 44111 Cudell $61,500 101400 0 OLD BROOKLYN PROPERTIES, LLC 6728 COLUMBIA RD OLMSTED FALLS OH 44138 Cudell $72,400 101400 0 CROW, DAVID E & CROW, TONI L 911 MANOR CIR HOWARD OH 43028 Cudell $49,900 101400 0 EMIR PROPERTIES, LLC 10423 LORAIN AVE CLEVELAND OH 44111 Cudell $67,200 101500 0 EQUITY TRUST COMPANY CUSTODIAN FBO PO 38472 OLMSTED FALLS OH 44138 Cudell $24,000 101400 0 JOHNSON, CAMERON M 3119 WEST BLVD CLEVELAND OH 44102 Cudell $109,200 101500 0 WHITLOCK , RONALD E JR 2352 CLOVER LN RED WING MN 55066 West Boulevard $50,100 102300 0 LBJS LLC 829 OXFORD AVE MARINA DEL REY CA 90292 West Boulevard $105,000 102402 0 SRW ROCKET LLC 1318 W 95 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 West Boulevard $45,400 102402 0 AMERICAN DREAM HOLDINGS LLC 3200 FRANKLIN BLVD CLEVELAND OH 44113 West Boulevard $40,000 102402 0 JERMARIE INVESTMENTS, OH LLC 1840 BARCELONA TERRACE POMPANO BEACH FL 33063 West Boulevard $40,000 102402 0 HEBEN, PATRICIA A 39253 HAWTHORNE DR AVON OH 44011 West Boulevard $49,900 102402 0 DIONISOPOULOS, NICK D TRS 4710 WOODLAWN AVE PARMA OH 44134 West Boulevard $39,200 102300 0 Page 72 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable + 2000 Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Old Non-Taxable Census Dupl. Name Address Municipality State Zip code SPA Name Est.Mkt.Val. Tract Flag NATIONSTAR MORTGAGE LLC DBA MR COOP 8950 CYPRESS WATERS BLVD COPPELL TX 75019 West Boulevard $41,700 102200 0 BEREAN FOUR, LLC ?? P O BOX 581087 ELK GROVE CA 95758 West Boulevard $25,000 102200 0 MORALES, JORGE 10314 ALMIRA AVE CLEVELAND OH 44111 West Boulevard $69,600 102200 0 MARROQUIN, ELTON L 10301 JOAN AVE CLEVELAND OH 44111 West Boulevard $58,100 102200 0 VARGAS, VIDAL CRESPO 10302 BERNARD AVE CLEVELAND OH 44111 West Boulevard $43,400 102200 0 FEDERAL NATIONAL MORTGAGE ASSOCIATI ?? PO BOX 650043 DALLAS TX 75265 West Boulevard $77,300 102200 0 CUNG, FRANCIS H & DENISE 5109 HARTWELL LN BRUNSWICK OH 44212 West Boulevard $45,500 102200 0 SEAMAN, ROSALIE FAITH 10110 ADELAIDE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44111 West Boulevard $61,500 102200 0 PINE VALLEY INVESTMENTS, LLC 1122 CHESTNUT AVE BROOKLYN NY 11230 West Boulevard $63,000 102200 0 ACDC INNOVATIVE INVESTMENTS LLC 123 44 ST UNION CITY NJ 7087 West Boulevard $12,000 102200 0 EMIR PROPERTIES, LLC 10423 LORAIN AVE CLEVELAND OH 44111 West Boulevard $47,900 102200 0 POLASKO, JEAN B 3728 W 103 ST CLEVELAND OH 44111 West Boulevard $57,400 102200 0 POTRUCH, ERIC H & POTRUCH, LISA 7566 COWAN AVE LOS ANGELES CA 90045 West Boulevard $52,600 102300 0 ANDERSON, JOANNE 3223 W 100 ST CLEVELAND OH 44111 West Boulevard $56,300 102300 0 KOTLARZ, DONNA M 3384 W 99 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 West Boulevard $54,300 102300 0 CARIBBEAN REEF 1 LLC 3141 FULTON RD CLEVELAND OH 44109 West Boulevard $71,200 102300 0 SANTOS, STEPHANIE A DELOS 1613 CORTEZ ST MILPITAS CA 95035 West Boulevard $48,900 102300 0 VICARIO, EIRA M & PONTICELLI, MA 4502 PROPHET AVE NORTH PORT FL 34287 West Boulevard $69,300 102401 0 SINGH, PREAMNAUTH 281 BONDS PKWY BEREA OH 44017 West Boulevard $53,300 102401 0 COLUMBIA PROPERTY MANAGEMENT, LLC 6728 COLUMBIA RD OLMSTED FALLS OH 44138 West Boulevard $49,600 102401 0 NORCIA, PANCHWATIE 3358 W 94 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 West Boulevard $59,400 102402 0 216 RENTALS LLC 10301 LAKE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44102 West Boulevard $43,200 102401 0 LOWRY FAMILY COMPANY LTD 3068 YOST RD LITCHFIELD OH 44253 West Boulevard $50,600 102101 0 PLUTE, GREGG 3438 MALVERN DR BRUNSWICK OH 44212 West Boulevard $58,700 102101 0 WIGGINS, MICHELLE 10718 FIDELITY AVE CLEVELAND OH 44111 West Boulevard $53,300 102101 0 OGANDO, JACINTO QUEZADA AND PEREZ, 10818 ALMIRA AVE CLEVELAND OH 44111 West Boulevard $64,600 102101 0 RODRIGUEZ, RICHARD D 10903 PARKHURST DR CLEVELAND OH 44111 West Boulevard $67,100 102101 0 JOHNSON, SAUNDRA (ETAL) 9820 SUNRISE AVE NORTH ROYALTON OH 44133 West Boulevard $54,600 102101 0 BOSWORTH HOLDINGS LLC 11013 FORTUNE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44111 West Boulevard $63,800 102101 0 DOYLE, MARY AND PERSINGER, ETHAN 10609 DALE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44111 West Boulevard $48,300 102102 0 BURGOS, ISRAEL 10722 DALE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44111 West Boulevard $51,500 102102 0 TLC HOME IMPROVEMENT INC 26525 HENRY RD BAY VILLAGE OH 44140 West Boulevard $58,200 102102 0 HARRIS, PAUL D 2500 H ST EUREKA CA 95501 West Boulevard $38,000 102102 0 STOFFER, ERIC AND KHOURI, ANNABEL 3612 W 114 ST CLEVELAND OH 44111 West Boulevard $59,300 102102 0 ROHDE, CHIP 3714 BOSWORTH RD CLEVELAND OH 44111 West Boulevard $800 102102 0 ROHDE, CHIP 3714 BOSWORTH RD CLEVELAND OH 44111 West Boulevard $64,300 102102 0 KEYBANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION 4910 TIEDEMAN RD BROOKLYN OH 44144 West Boulevard $45,300 102102 0 BEACHAM, WILLIAM J 2268 STILLMAN RD CLEVELAND OH 44118 South Broadway $101,800 110900 0 RECYCLED MONEY LLC 926 BRUNSWICK RD CLEVELAND HTS OH 44112 South Broadway $10,000 110900 0 RECYCLED MONEY LLC 926 BRUNSWICK RD CLEVELAND HTS OH 44112 South Broadway $10,000 110900 0 GHAZAL, MOHANAD 6975 MCKINZE RD OLMSTED FALLS OH 44138 North Broadway $20,500 110800 0 KING, MELISSA 7415 CANTON AVE CLEVELAND OH 44105 South Broadway $6,800 110900 0 KING, MELISSA 7415 CANTON AVE CLEVELAND OH 44105 South Broadway $11,300 110900 0 THIRD FEDERAL SAVINGS AND LOAN ASSO 3736 E 53 ST CLEVELAND OH 44105 South Broadway $18,600 110900 0 Page 73 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable + 2000 Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Old Non-Taxable Census Dupl. Name Address Municipality State Zip code SPA Name Est.Mkt.Val. Tract Flag ZABKA, HEDY ?? P O BOX 20065 CLEVELAND OH 44120 South Broadway $32,000 115100 0 PARKER PROPERTIES UNLIMITED LLC 1401 N 29 ST PHILADELPHIA PA 19121 South Broadway $34,300 115200 0 CHRISTOFFERSON, AMY 6811 FLEET AVE CLEVELAND OH 44105 South Broadway $35,300 115200 0 IRA SERVICES TRUST COMPANY CFBO ROB 3693 E 69 ST CLEVELAND OH 44105 South Broadway $112,900 115400 0 WITHROW, CURTIS 1689 MAXWELL BLVD BRUNSWICK OH 44212 South Broadway $32,000 115200 0 HAYS, RICKY L 3800 E 53 ST CLEVELAND OH 44105 South Broadway $24,500 110900 0 HSU, ALEX 350 E MISSION ST SAN JOSE CA 95112 South Broadway $33,900 115100 0 GMS SERVICES, LLC 4023 E 27 ST NEWBURGH HTS OH 44105 South Broadway $30,600 115100 0 RENCZ, JOSEPH 3875 E 57 ST CLEVELAND OH 44105 South Broadway $21,500 115100 0 GMS SERVICES, LLC 4023 E 27 ST NEWBURGH HTS OH 44105 South Broadway $24,100 115100 0 BOLDEN, LINA 10803 JOAN AVE CLEVELAND OH 44111 South Broadway $22,100 115100 0 BIALOZYT, STANISLAW & BIALOZYT, MAL 6609 LANSING ST CLEVELAND OH 44105 South Broadway $40,200 115400 0 SLAVIC VILLAGE RECOVERY LLC 5620 BROADWAY AVE CLEVELAND OH 44127 South Broadway $45,800 115400 0 SLAVIC VILLAGE RECOVERY LLC 5620 BROADWAY AVE CLEVELAND OH 44127 South Broadway $45,800 115400 1 KANE, RYAN M 7005 INDIANA AVE CLEVELAND OH 44105 South Broadway $44,600 115400 0 WORKMAN, SANDRA 6926 POLONIA AVE CLEVELAND OH 44105 South Broadway $41,900 115700 0 SEDER, BELAELL 32815 BOULDER DR NORTH RIDGEVILLE OH 44039 South Broadway $60,300 115800 0 OLSZEWSKI HOUSE, LLC 1295 FRY AVE LAKEWOOD OH 44107 South Broadway $22,200 115800 0 PONYIK, JAMES-TRUSTEE 3971 E 71 ST CLEVELAND OH 44105 South Broadway $20,100 115800 0 SVADBA, SR , JOHN A & SVADBA, JU 12332 BOSTON RD NORTH ROYALTON OH 44133 South Broadway $41,700 115800 0 JEFFRIES, DEMETRIUS 7412 WORLEY AVE CLEVELAND OH 44105 South Broadway $42,500 115800 0 DUNCAN, DAVE L , III 7204 CLEMENT AVE CLEVELAND OH 44105 South Broadway $19,800 115800 0 CAMPBELL, LARRIE LADELL 7302 HARVARD AVE CLEVELAND OH 44105 South Broadway $29,000 115800 0 DONALDSON, ROGER ROY 2291 GULF TO BAY BLVD CLEARWATER FL 33765 South Broadway $14,500 115800 0 CROFT, CANDACE LEE 4065 E 79 ST CLEVELAND OH 44105 South Broadway $22,300 115800 0 CUYAHOGA COUNTY LAND REUTILIZATION 812 HURON RD CLEVELAND OH 44115 South Broadway $25,900 115800 0 CUYAHOGA COUNTY LAND REUTILIZATION 812 HURON RD CLEVELAND OH 44115 South Broadway $25,900 115800 0 PHILLIPS, KENT L 4395 E 141 ST CLEVELAND OH 44105 Brooklyn Centre $35,800 105602 0 PHILLIPS, KENT L 4395 E 141 ST CLEVELAND OH 44105 Brooklyn Centre $35,800 105602 0 FISHER HOMES, LLC 4448 E 131 GARFIELD HTS OH 44105 Brooklyn Centre $7,500 105602 0 SK2 PROPERTIES LLC 2017 E 9 ST CLEVELAND OH 44115 Brooklyn Centre $26,800 105602 0 DIONISOPOULOS, NICK D (TRS) 2023 W 106 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 Brooklyn Centre $20,900 105602 0 MATHERS, WALKER, & BURKE INC 118 BEACHDALE DR AVON LAKE OH 44012 Brooklyn Centre $39,700 105602 0 DIONISOPOULOS, NICK D-TRUSTEE 4710 WOODROW AVE PARMA OH 44134 Brooklyn Centre $33,100 105602 0 NATIONSTAR MORTGAGE LLC 8950 CYPRESS WATERS BLVD COPPELL TX 75019 Brooklyn Centre $49,300 105602 0 SRW ROCKET LLC 1318 W 95 ST LAKEWOOD OH 44107 Brooklyn Centre $44,900 105400 0 TREBILCOCK, JR , MICHAEL D 3904 W 34 ST CLEVELAND OH 44109 Brooklyn Centre $61,200 105400 0 FEDERAL NATIONAL MORTGAGE ASSOCIATI 1 S WACKER DR CHICAGO IL 60606 Brooklyn Centre $65,100 105500 0 PAWLAK JR , JAMES 4233 W 21 ST CLEVELAND OH 44109 Old Brooklyn $41,300 105700 0 JENNINGS, CRAIG ?? PO BOX 391981 ANZA CA 92539 Old Brooklyn $70,000 105700 0 SCHAEFER, ERROL 1628 CRESTLINE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44109-3024 Old Brooklyn $41,900 105700 0 SCHAEFER, ERROL 1628 CRESTLINE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44109-3024 Old Brooklyn $41,900 105700 0 SKYMOUNT PROPERTIES, LLC 4220 ABBE RD SHEFFIELD VILLAGE OH 44035 Old Brooklyn $69,300 105700 0 SKYMOUNT PROPERTIES, LLC 4220 ABBE RD SHEFFIELD VILLAGE OH 44035 Old Brooklyn $10,800 105700 0 Page 74 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable + 2000 Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Old Non-Taxable Census Dupl. Name Address Municipality State Zip code SPA Name Est.Mkt.Val. Tract Flag COX, GARY 1521 TARLTON AVE CLEVELAND OH 44109 Old Brooklyn $42,500 105700 0 COX, GARY 1521 TARLTON AVE CLEVELAND OH 44109 Old Brooklyn $42,500 105700 0 HICKOCK, JEFFREY 4168 PLYMOUTH RD CLEVELAND OH 44109 Old Brooklyn $69,700 105700 0 ROJAS, KELLY F & ROJAS, LUIS G 4202 PLYMOUTH RD CLEVELAND OH 44109 Old Brooklyn $70,500 105700 0 OLD BROOKLYN PROPERTIES, LLC 6728 COLUMBIA RD OLMSTED FALLS OH 44138 Old Brooklyn $64,900 105700 0 SERVA, ROBERT 2102 MAYVIEW AVE CLEVELAND OH 44109 Old Brooklyn $63,200 105700 0 SERVA, ROBERT 2102 MAYVIEW AVE CLEVELAND OH 44109 Old Brooklyn $63,200 105700 1 SCIALABBA, FRANK J AND SCIALABBA, 2500 W 14 ST CLEVELAND OH 44113 Old Brooklyn $45,000 106900 0 KELLER, DOUGLAS J 1201 E SCHAAF RD INDEPENDENCE OH 44131 Old Brooklyn $70,600 106900 0 BERK, DAVID 2007 TATE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44109 Old Brooklyn $25,500 106900 0 SIBERT, HARRISON 4515 BROADALE RD CLEVELAND OH 44109 Old Brooklyn $93,700 106900 0 SPRINKLE ROAD & CORK STREET LLC 16700 PILGRIM AVE CLEVELAND OH 44111 Old Brooklyn $67,600 106900 0 REGULA, JOHN AND REGULA, MARIE 1123 SPRING RD CLEVELAND OH 44109 Old Brooklyn $72,200 106900 0 LANPHEAR, SARAH SAWYER 4482 W 14 ST CLEVELAND OH 44109 Old Brooklyn $64,306 106900 0 TOTH, MARC ANTHONY 4502 W 14 ST CLEVELAND OH 44109 Old Brooklyn $76,200 106900 0 KOLZ, MICHAEL F & MARES, JEANNE L 4514 RIVER ST WILLOUGHBY OH 44094 Old Brooklyn $74,100 105700 0 TETTERTON-WILLIAMS, CYNTHIA 4225 RIVER RIDGE DR CLEVELAND OH 44109 Old Brooklyn $88,800 107000 0 OBERG, JACQUELINE L 4668 MORNINGSIDE DR CLEVELAND OH 44109 Old Brooklyn $87,900 106900 0 BASTOCK, AMY & WENNING, ALISE 7335 MARKAL DR CLEVELAND OH 44130 Old Brooklyn $80,600 106900 0 BASTOCK, AMY & WENNING, ALISE 7335 MARKAL DR CLEVELAND OH 44130 Old Brooklyn $80,600 106900 1 HOWELL, JOSHUA 4708 MARCIE DR CLEVELAND OH 44113 Old Brooklyn $72,100 107000 0 WILSON, GERALD L 20 MARKO LN BROOKLYN HTS OH 44131 Old Brooklyn $90,100 107000 0 SGRO, JOSEPH C 4747 SOUTH HILLS DR CLEVELAND OH 44109 Old Brooklyn $153,700 106900 0 ELLINGTON, ADAM N 1715 MAYNARD AVE CLEVELAND OH 44109 Old Brooklyn $69,900 106900 0 SMITH, SR , RONALD O 4820 W 14 ST CLEVELAND OH 44109 Old Brooklyn $800 106900 0 SMITH, SR , RONALD O 4820 W 14 ST CLEVELAND OH 44109 Old Brooklyn $800 106900 0 SMITH, SR , RONALD O 4820 W 14 ST CLEVELAND OH 44109 Old Brooklyn $107,100 106900 0 SMITH, SR , RONALD O 4820 W 14 ST CLEVELAND OH 44109 Old Brooklyn $107,100 106900 0 THOMSON, BRIAN L 4926 W 13 ST CLEVELAND OH 44109 Old Brooklyn $80,400 106900 0 BAYS, ANTHONY M 7375 BALDWIN CREEK DR MIDDLEBURGH HTS OH 44130 Old Brooklyn $89,200 106900 0 HANCOCK, DANIEL ERICK & HANCOCK, IR ?? PO BOX 2042 TOMBALL TX 77377 Old Brooklyn $40,000 106600 0 RESSLER, ADAM RAYMOND 4370 STATE RD CLEVELAND OH 44109 Old Brooklyn $295,200 106600 0 KING, DENNIS M 3118 RUBY AVE CLEVELAND OH 44109 Old Brooklyn $50,100 106800 0 U S BANK TRUST, N A TRUSTEE 13801 WIRELESS WAY OKLAHOMA CITY OK 73134 Old Brooklyn $56,900 106800 0 OLD BROADVIEW, LLC 8934 BRECKSVILLE RD BRECKSVILLE OH 44141 Old Brooklyn $51,900 106800 0 HEALD & HEALD PROPERTIES I LLC 2069 REVERE RD CLEVELAND HTS OH 44118 Old Brooklyn $69,900 106600 0 LION OF JUDAH CHRISTIAN FAMILY CENT 4591 BIDDULPH AVE CLEVELAND OH 44109 Old Brooklyn $59,200 106600 0 ZMUDZINSKI, SUSAN & ZMUDZINSKI, ANT 4500 STATE RD CLEVELAND OH 44109 Old Brooklyn $39,400 106600 0 FEDERAL NATIONAL MORTGAGE ASSOCIATI P 650043 DALLAS TX 75265 Old Brooklyn $69,000 106600 0 KELLY, SEAN P 9146 DEVONSHIRE OLMSTED FALLS OH 44138 Old Brooklyn $68,800 106600 0 DELIZ, ANGEL M AND MALAVE, YONAIRA 3306 HILLCREST AVE CLEVELAND OH 44109 Old Brooklyn $66,800 105900 0 DELIZ, ANGEL M AND MALAVE, YONAIRA 3306 HILLCREST AVE CLEVELAND OH 44109 Old Brooklyn $66,800 105900 0 FRANGIAS, DEMETRIOS 7596 DAYTONA DR PARMA OH 44134 Old Brooklyn $57,200 105900 0 FRANGIAS, DEMETRIOS 7596 DAYTONA DR PARMA OH 44134 Old Brooklyn $57,200 105900 0 Page 75 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable + 2000 Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Old Non-Taxable Census Dupl. Name Address Municipality State Zip code SPA Name Est.Mkt.Val. Tract Flag SHOREWAY MANAGEMENT, LLC 6728 COLUMBIA RD OLMSTED FALLS OH 44138 Old Brooklyn $57,400 105900 0 OLD BROADVIEW, LLC 8934 BRECKSVILLE RD BRECKSVILLE OH 44141 Old Brooklyn $58,600 105900 0 IRACE, DAVID M 3409 LUCERNE AVE PARMA OH 44134 Old Brooklyn $59,000 106600 0 PASCA, REMUS P 6961 EDGERTON RD NORTH ROYALTON OH 44133 Old Brooklyn $51,200 106600 0 JPMORGAN CHASE BANK 3415 VISION CIR COLUMBUS OH 43219 Old Brooklyn $61,700 106600 0 GROEZINGER, LESLIE R 3405 ARCHMERE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44109 Old Brooklyn $39,200 105900 0 KILCOYNE, CHRISTOPHER 3400 ARCHMERE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44109 Old Brooklyn $78,200 105900 0 KRAMER, ASHLEY 1120 W SPRAGUE RD NORTH ROYALTON OH 44133 Old Brooklyn $74,500 105900 0 ROGERS, DAVID K JR 2401 PORTMAN AVE CLEVELAND OH 44109 Old Brooklyn $66,500 105900 0 GAINES, WILLIAM 7202 CLARK AVE CLEVELAND OH 44102 Old Brooklyn $74,900 105900 0 KILEY, MICHAEL J 13494 N BOONE RD COLUMBIA STATION OH 44028 Old Brooklyn $75,500 105900 0 SECRETARY OF VETERANS AFFAIRS 3401 WEST END AVE NASHVILLE TN 37203 Old Brooklyn $73,100 105900 0 SECRETARY OF VETERANS AFFAIRS 3401 WEST END AVE NASHVILLE TN 37203 Old Brooklyn $73,100 105900 1 LATORRE, ERIK 2213 FAIRDALE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44109 Old Brooklyn $76,700 105900 0 OROZCO, FERNANDO 4419 W 57 ST CLEVELAND OH 44144 Old Brooklyn $67,100 106200 0 SZOPO, TODD W 4472 W 56 ST CLEVELAND OH 44144 Old Brooklyn $63,300 106200 0 STEWART, TRAVIS M AND STEWART, SAR 4437 W 51 ST CLEVELAND OH 44144 Old Brooklyn $42,800 106200 0 MARTINEZ, RAFAEL 4464 W 47 ST CLEVELAND OH 44144 Old Brooklyn $54,800 106200 0 DILLON, MATTHEW B SR 4712 GIFFORD AVE CLEVELAND OH 44144 Old Brooklyn $50,600 106200 0 LEELI, ALEJANDRO C 4413 WOBURN AVE CLEVELAND OH 44109 Old Brooklyn $55,600 106400 0 TURNER, LORRIE A 4512 ARDMORE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44144 Old Brooklyn $59,000 106400 0 MILES, GERALD A 4214 GIFFORD AVE CLEVELAND OH 44109 Old Brooklyn $48,500 106400 0 MILES, GERALD A 4214 GIFFORD AVE CLEVELAND OH 44109 Old Brooklyn $48,500 106400 0 HERNANDEZ, JESUS 4607 FULTON RD CLEVELAND OH 44144 Old Brooklyn $66,000 106500 0 RAKIC, VLASTIMIR AND RAKIC, SVETLAN 4816 STICKNEY AVE CLEVELAND OH 44144 Old Brooklyn $76,000 106500 0 FEDERAL HOME LOAN MORTGAGE CORPORAT 8950 CYPRESS WATERS BLVD COPPELL TX 75019 Old Brooklyn $51,500 106500 0 COONS, CLINT (TRS) 3225 MCLEOD DR LAS VEGAS NV 89121 Old Brooklyn $81,200 106600 0 KRUPAR, ANGELA 4521 BADER AVE CLEVELAND OH 44109 Old Brooklyn $81,500 106600 0 KRIVOY, OLEG 4613 WETZEL AVE CLEVELAND OH 44109 Old Brooklyn $74,700 106600 0 BRENMAR PROPERTIES, LTD 4104 BADER AVE CLEVELAND OH 44109 Old Brooklyn $68,800 106600 0 CHOROMANSKI, NICHOLAS 4013 WETZEL AVE CLEVELAND OH 44109 Old Brooklyn $64,400 106600 0 ALMAN, DEBORAH 3606 BADER AVE CLEVELAND OH 44109 Old Brooklyn $59,400 106600 0 ALTIER, DONALD 4236 W 63 ST CLEVELAND OH 44144 Old Brooklyn $76,100 106100 0 ARCHACKI, NICHOLAS R 7101 MEADOWBROOK AVE CLEVELAND OH 44144 Old Brooklyn $79,200 106100 0 REITZ, MATTHEW M 6405 BROOKSIDE DR CLEVELAND OH 44144 Old Brooklyn $101,000 106100 0 LOCKYER, MATTHEW P 6504 PLAINFIELD AVE CLEVELAND OH 44144 Old Brooklyn $90,200 106100 0 CHN HOUSING PARTNERS 2999 PAYNE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44114 Old Brooklyn $70,000 106100 0 HORTON, JOSEPH R 6210 DELLBANK DR CLEVELAND OH 44144 Old Brooklyn $84,200 106100 0 DUKE, THOMAS J 6100 PARK RIDGE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44144 Old Brooklyn $88,000 106100 0 DUKE, THOMAS J 6100 PARK RIDGE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44144 Old Brooklyn $88,000 106100 0 RAMIREZ, SANDRA I 4200 W 56 ST CLEVELAND OH 44144 Old Brooklyn $69,000 106100 0 PEPERA, JOSEPH K 4256 W 57 ST CLEVELAND OH 44144 Old Brooklyn $68,900 106100 0 LAKEVIEW LOAN SERVICING LLC 5151 CORPORATE DR TROY MI 48098 Old Brooklyn $65,800 106100 0 BETTER BUSINESS PROPERTY, LLC 4175 W 48 ST CLEVELAND OH 44144 Old Brooklyn $32,900 106100 0 Page 76 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable + 2000 Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Old Non-Taxable Census Dupl. Name Address Municipality State Zip code SPA Name Est.Mkt.Val. Tract Flag U S BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION 15480 LAGUAN CANYON RD IRVINE CA 92618 Old Brooklyn $66,800 106100 0 MAKRAI, NATALIE 4353 W 60 ST CLEVELAND OH 44144 Old Brooklyn $78,000 106200 0 HOLMOK, EDWARD 4302 W 52 ST CLEVELAND OH 44144 Old Brooklyn $75,200 106200 0 HOLZ, SCOTT MICHAEL 4306 W 50 ST CLEVELAND OH 44144 Old Brooklyn $54,500 106200 0 CRAFT, CHARLES BASIL 2885 PEASE DR ROCKY RIVER OH 44116 Old Brooklyn $12,400 106300 0 NEHEMIAH COLLABORATIVE 2038 W 29 ST CLEVELAND OH 44113 Old Brooklyn $74,900 106300 0 GONZALEZ, JOSE 4102 CLYBOURNE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44109 Old Brooklyn $62,600 106300 0 DOWELL, CHRISTOPHER (ETAL) 4142 W 36 ST CLEVELAND OH 44109 Old Brooklyn $50,400 106300 0 CLAIR, MICHAEL SCOTT 3513 KRATHER RD CLEVELAND OH 44109 Old Brooklyn $47,300 106300 0 BROOKS, STEVE 3914 HENRITZE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44109 Old Brooklyn $59,200 106300 0 RJA PROPERTIES LLC 16491 S RED ROCK STRONGSVILLE OH 44136 Old Brooklyn $45,000 106800 0 ROOKS, BRIAN ET AL 2809 COLBURN AVE CLEVELAND OH 44109-4045 Old Brooklyn $52,100 106800 0 EQUITY TRUST COMPANY P 451340 WESTLAKE OH 44145 Old Brooklyn $24,300 106800 0 FEBLES, JOSUE 2601 SEARSDALE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44109 Old Brooklyn $51,100 106800 0 PUBLIC SQUARE C APITAL RE, LLC 7005 ORCHARD GROVE AVE WESTLAKE OH 44145 Old Brooklyn $49,700 106800 0 WEBB, MELISSA R 3658 W 58 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 Stockyards $18,700 105100 0 FINE, JOEL A & TRUONG, VI 19880 SEAGULL WAY SARATOGA CA 95070 Clark-Fulton $43,500 104900 0 JADE EAGLES 2516 MARVIN AVE CLEVELAND OH 44109 Clark-Fulton $82,200 104900 0 MENCINI JR , DAVID A 3517 DAISY AVE CLEVELAND OH 44109 Brooklyn Centre $53,800 105500 0 FFCR, LLC 1037 NE 65 ST SEATTLE WA 98115 Brooklyn Centre $46,200 105500 0 ANCHOR INVESTMENT HOLDINGS, LLC 101 N WOODLAND BLV DELAND FL 32720 Brooklyn Centre $43,400 105400 0 CLAUDIO, BENITO JR 3411 RIVERSIDE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44109 Brooklyn Centre $67,400 105500 0 PACIC, MARKO AND RAMIREZ, JESUS 3636 W 32 ST CLEVELAND OH 44109 Clark-Fulton $62,000 105500 0 CAL HOME SERVICES, LLC 5110 GREENHURST AVE MAPLE HEIGHTS OH 44137 Brooklyn Centre $65,400 105400 0 NGEMBA, MAYELE 3202 MAPLEDALE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44109 Brooklyn Centre $40,600 105400 0 NGEMBA, MAYELE 3202 MAPLEDALE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44109 Brooklyn Centre $40,600 105400 1 NGEMBA, MAYELE 3202 MAPLEDALE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44109 Brooklyn Centre $40,600 105400 0 DIONISOPOULOS, NICK D TRUSTEE 3807 W 38 ST CLEVELAND OH 44109 Brooklyn Centre $39,200 105400 0 KHMER DRAGON LLC 3755 51 ST SAINT PETERSBURG FL 33710 Brooklyn Centre $37,800 105400 0 JPMORGAN CHASE BANK NATIONAL ASSOCI 3415 VISION DR COLUMBUS OH 43219 Brooklyn Centre $43,700 105400 0 MREV ARCHWOOD LLC 331-3209 ARCHWOOD AVE CLEVELAND OH 44109 Brooklyn Centre $226,000 105500 0 MREV ARCHWOOD LLC 3901-3311 ARCHWOOD AVE CLEVELAND OH 44109 Brooklyn Centre $226,000 105500 0 THE CLEVELAND REAL ESTATE PROJECT, 3001 WALTON AVE CLEVELAND OH 44113 Ohio City/Near West Side $51,700 103900 0 THE CLEVELAND REAL ESTATE PROJECT, 14312 KINSMAN RD CLEVELAND OH 44120 Ohio City/Near West Side $900 103900 0 THE CLEVELAND REAL ESTATE PROJECT, 3036 W 30 ST CLEVELAND OH 44113 Ohio City/Near West Side $30,200 103900 0 THE CLEVELAND REAL ESTATE PROJECT, 14312 KINSMAN RD CLEVELAND OH 44120 Ohio City/Near West Side $27,500 103900 0 THE CLEVELAND REAL ESTATE PROJECT, 3036 W 30 ST CLEVELAND OH 44113 Ohio City/Near West Side $900 103900 0 DILTS, BRIAN C 15900 AIRPORT RD NEVADA CITY CA 95959 Clark-Fulton $13,700 102900 0 TRIZIO, BARBARA R TRUSTEE 4019 NEWARK AVE CLEVELAND OH 44109 Clark-Fulton $46,200 102900 0 SHIVNARINE, BHOOMESHWAR 3727 NEWARK AVE CLEVELAND OH 44109 Clark-Fulton $47,300 102900 0 KEYLINK GLOBAL, LLC 3115 MELROSE DR CARLSBAD CA 92010 Clark-Fulton $42,800 102900 0 CLEVELAND LAND REUTILIZATION PROGRA 601 LAKESIDE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44114 Clark-Fulton $1,500 102900 0 ROMAN, LUZ 3633 HYDE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44109 Clark-Fulton $34,800 102900 0 KLEIN, NICOLINA 3295 FULTON RD CLEVELAND OH 44109 Clark-Fulton $58,500 104900 0 Page 77 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable + 2000 Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Old Non-Taxable Census Dupl. Name Address Municipality State Zip code SPA Name Est.Mkt.Val. Tract Flag NTIRAMPEBA, SUZANA 3281 W 33 ST CLEVELAND OH 44108 Clark-Fulton $45,200 104900 0 PROSPERCLE LLC 1548 LAKEWOOD AVE LAKEWOOD OH 44107 Clark-Fulton $30,500 104900 0 SOLIS, DEBRA 3622 SACKETT AVE CLEVELAND OH 44109 Clark-Fulton $32,700 104900 0 LE PROPERTY GROUP, LLC 4522 WEST VILLAGE DR TAMPA FL 33618 Clark-Fulton $30,000 104900 0 USA REGROWTH FUND, LLC 16869 SW 65 ST LAKE OSWEGO OR 97075 Clark-Fulton $54,700 104900 0 FLIP MY CITY INVESTORS, LLC 33923 WASHINGTON BLVD NORTH RIDGEVILLE OH 44039 Clark-Fulton $22,500 104900 0 ACOSTA, OLGA 20621 ROYALTON RD STRONGSVILLE OH 44136 Clark-Fulton $40,800 105300 0 JARRETT, KEVIN M 4207 SACKETT AVE CLEVELAND OH 44109 Clark-Fulton $52,900 102800 0 PAPAGIANIS, KONSTANTINOS 9906 BIDDULPH RD CLEVELAND OH 44144 Clark-Fulton $46,600 105300 0 QUEENER, DORIS GENE 3344 W 31 ST CLEVELAND OH 44109 Clark-Fulton $43,000 104900 0 PINEDO, JAMES 4314 DAISY AVE CLEVELAND OH 44109 Clark-Fulton $33,800 105300 0 ANDINO, JENNIFER M 4222 HODGSON AVE CLEVELAND OH 44109 Clark-Fulton $34,200 105300 0 FF INVERSIONES, LLC 16309 LAVERNE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44135 Stockyards $22,500 102700 0 THE SECRETARY OF VETERANS AFFAIRS 3401 W END AVE NASHVILLE TN 37203 Stockyards $27,500 102700 0 THE SECRETARY OF VETERANS AFFAIRS 3401 W END AVE NASHVILLE TN 37203 Stockyards $27,500 102700 0 S & P PROPERTY MGMT LLC ?? P O BOX 71 LODI OH 44254 Stockyards $63,100 102700 0 S & P PROPERTY MGMT LLC 3279 W 54 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 Stockyards $800 102700 0 STERN, CHAUNCEY ALLAN 930 ALLENDALE DR HAMPTON VA 23669 Stockyards $38,600 102700 0 PORE, DOROTHY 3346 W 48 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 Stockyards $19,400 102700 0 FEDERAL NATIONAL MORTGAGE ASSOCIATI 3900 WISCONSIN AVE WASHINGTON DC 20016 Stockyards $21,200 105100 0 PHILLIPS, KENT L 4395 E 141 ST CLEVELAND OH 44105 Stockyards $31,200 105100 0 PHILLIPS, KENT L 4395 E 141 ST CLEVELAND OH 44105 Stockyards $31,200 105100 0 HOMES TO RENT LLC 3409 W 60 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 Stockyards $28,600 105100 0 FFCR, LLC 1037 NE 65 ST SEATTLE WA 98115 Stockyards $34,600 105200 0 NGUYEN, MARY 3445 W 52 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 Stockyards $33,200 105100 0 SCHUMANN, PAUL D TRS , SCHUMANN, 27137 BUTTERNUT RIDGE RD NORTH OLMSTED OH 44070 Stockyards $19,000 105100 0 OHIO CITY DEVELOPMENT GROUP, LLC 7202 HAGUE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44102 Stockyards $32,900 105200 0 CUYAHOGA COUNTY LAND REUTILIZATION 812 HURON RD CLEVELAND OH 44115 Stockyards $11,200 105200 0 SEDLACEK, HILLARY M 3474 W 46 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 Clark-Fulton $39,000 105300 0 BRUMFIELD, AUSTIN 3461 W 47 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 Clark-Fulton $24,800 105300 0 BRUMFIELD, AUSTIN 3461 W 47 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 Clark-Fulton $24,800 105300 0 RAEE, SALWA 3169 SCRANTON RD CLEVELAND OH 44109 Clark-Fulton $54,400 104600 0 RAEE, SALWA 3169 SCRANTON RD CLEVELAND OH 44109 Clark-Fulton $54,400 104600 0 WHITE, CHARLES E 1734 HOLMDEN AVE CLEVELAND OH 44109 Tremont $51,900 104800 0 CUYAHOGA COUNTY LAND REUTILIZATION 812 HURON RD CLEVELAND OH 44115 Clark-Fulton $55,300 104600 0 SMALL HOLDING GROUP, LLC 3790 W 117 ST CLEVELAND OH 44111 Tremont $65,100 104800 0 JFA PARTNERS LLC 11680 HAWKE RD COLUMBIA STATION OH 44028 West Boulevard $37,000 102402 0 SRW ROCKET, LLC 1100MT OVERLOOK AVE CLEVELAND OH 44102 West Boulevard $40,300 102402 0 MABELA, MADELEINE 3327 W 86 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 West Boulevard $37,400 102401 0 SCOTT, NIGEL 3359 W 82 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 West Boulevard $50,200 102401 0 CHEN, ZOE XIU 1304 W 93 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 Edgewater $34,700 101101 0 REIDL, JAMES M AND SCHULZ, AMANDA 1355 W 89 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 Edgewater $56,200 101101 0 DIONISOPOULOS, NICK D TRUSTEE 4710 WOODROW AVE CLEVELAND OH 44134 Cudell $35,000 101700 0 FFCR, LLC 1037 NE 65 ST SEATTLE WA 98115 Cudell $27,900 101400 0 Page 78 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable + 2000 Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Old Non-Taxable Census Dupl. Name Address Municipality State Zip code SPA Name Est.Mkt.Val. Tract Flag DIONISOPOULOS, NICK D (TRS) 2023 W 106 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 Cudell $24,700 101400 0 SMART DEVELOPMENT INC 2185 MCKINLEY AVE LAKEWOOD OH 44107 Cudell $26,900 101500 0 SMART DEVELOPMENT INC 2185 MCKINLEY AVE LAKEWOOD OH 44107 Cudell $26,900 101500 0 DIONISOPOULOS, NICK D (TRS) 2235 W 104 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 Cudell $31,400 101500 0 ANCHOR INVESTMENT HOLDINGS, LLC 101 N WOODLAND BLV DELAND FL 32720 Cudell $44,700 101500 0 OH PAZ HOLDINGS, LLC 2183 W 103 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 Cudell $50,300 101500 0 FFCR, LLC 1037 NE 65 ST SEATTLE WA 98115 Cudell $30,500 101400 0 GREEN TREE HOLDINGS, LLC 2121 W 105 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 Cudell $50,200 101500 0 DIONISOPOULOS, NICK D-TRUSTEE 4710 WOODROW AVE PARMA OH 44134 Cudell $29,600 101500 0 DIONISOPOULOS, NICK D TRS 4710 WOODLAWN AVE PARMA OH 44134 Cudell $31,000 101500 0 DIONISOPOULOS, NICK D-TRUSTEE 4710 WOODROW AVE PARMA OH 44134 Cudell $25,600 101500 0 DIONISOPOULOS, NICK D-TRUSTEE 4710 WOODROW AVE PARMA OH 44134 Cudell $32,800 101500 0 JAOUDE, AMANDA ABOU 2095 W 103 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 Cudell $44,700 101500 0 NICK DIONISOPOULOS (TRS) 4710 WOODROW AVE PARMA OH 44134 Cudell $34,900 101400 0 PETRY, HEATHER 5783 COLUMBIA RD NORTH OLMSTED OH 44070 Cudell $38,000 101400 0 HUGHES, CHRISTOPHER 2014 W 103 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 Cudell $13,400 101500 0 DIONISOPOULOS, NICK D-TRUSTEE 4710 WOODROW AVE PARMA OH 44134 Cudell $31,400 101500 0 JULIUS PATRICK INDUSTRIES LLC 5845 ELM DR SOLON OH 44139 Cudell $47,800 101600 0 IWAIS, WESAM 1907 MAYNARD AVE CLEVELAND OH 44109 Cudell $34,700 101600 0 INFANTE, BELKYS S 9905 CUDELL AVE CLEVELAND OH 44102 Cudell $48,600 101600 0 THROWER, ALBERT PO 602637 CLEVELAND OH 44102 Cudell $32,600 101600 0 US BANK TRUST-TRUSTEE 13801 WIRELESS WAY OKLAHOMA CITY OK 73134 Cudell $46,700 101600 0 SOUEIDI, JUSTIN 20647 STERLING WAY STRONGSVILLE OH 44149 Cudell $27,200 101600 0 COLUMBIA PROPERTY MANAGEMENT, LLC 6728 COLUMBIA RD OLMSTED FALLS OH 44138 Cudell $39,500 101600 0 KOJANI, ZMAR 2049 W 95 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 Cudell $50,100 101600 0 GARCIA, EMMANUEL H ?? W 91 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 Cudell $900 101700 0 GARCIA, EMMANUEL H 9015 WILLIARD AVE CLEVELAND OH 44102 Cudell $38,900 101700 0 DERY, MICHAEL J 8707 SAUER AVE CLEVELAND OH 44102 Cudell $41,000 101700 0 DERY, MICHAEL J 8707 SAUER AVE CLEVELAND OH 44102 Cudell $41,000 101700 1 TURCZYK, MELISSA RENEE 7615 PLEASANT HILLS DR PARMA OH 44134 Cudell $40,000 101700 0 THE BARKLEY COMPANY LLC 20747 ERIE RD ROCKY RIVER OH 44116 Cudell $42,400 101700 0 FFCR, LLC 2101 W 93 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 Cudell $33,400 101700 0 FFCR, LLC 2097 W 93 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 Cudell $31,600 101700 0 NATIONSTAR MORTGAGE LLC 7070 STATE RD CLEVELAND OH 44134 Cudell $44,000 101700 0 MOHAMMAD, NAHSSEMH K & PEDROZA, CH 9917 DENISON CLEVELAND OH 44102 Cudell $42,600 101700 0 WISCONSIN INVESTMENT GROUP, LLC 6201 BARBERSON CLEVELAND OH 44102 Cudell $45,500 101700 0 ERNESTA JEFFERSON 2079 W 89 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 Cudell $39,300 101700 0 BROOKS, STEVEN & BROOKS, DEBBIE ANN 42161 OAK CREST CIR ALDIE VA 20105 Cudell $49,900 101700 0 EISENBERG, JEFF 75 SOUTH LN CHAGRIN FALLS OH 44022 Detroit-Shoreway $40,900 101200 0 EISENBERG, JEFF 75 SOUTH LN CHAGRIN FALLS OH 44022 Detroit-Shoreway $88,400 101200 0 READINGER, MICHAEL J 1259 W 75 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 Detroit-Shoreway $279,400 101200 0 ANTAL, KELLY A 1365 W 76 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 Detroit-Shoreway $63,400 101200 0 SMALL HOLDING GROUP LLC 7419 GOODWALT AVE CLEVELAND OH 44102 Detroit-Shoreway $61,000 101200 0 SMALL HOLDING GROUP LLC 7419 GOODWALT AVE CLEVELAND OH 44102 Detroit-Shoreway $61,000 101200 0 Page 79 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable + 2000 Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Old Non-Taxable Census Dupl. Name Address Municipality State Zip code SPA Name Est.Mkt.Val. Tract Flag VLACH INC 3112 STONE WALL SQ AVON OH 44011 Detroit-Shoreway $87,200 101200 0 BCD PROPERTIES, INC 7413 RUTLEDGE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44102 Detroit-Shoreway $58,000 101200 0 PAPANIA, BEAU 1226 W 70 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 Detroit-Shoreway 101200 0 KURILCHICK, JARED & ROBERTS, CHRIST 2499 W 7 CLEVELAND OH 44113 Detroit-Shoreway $53,900 101200 0 ZELLER, LINDSAY SJ BROCK 1341 W 67 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 Detroit-Shoreway $56,000 101200 0 APT, MICHAEL A 3893 WASHINGTON BLVD CLEVELAND OH 44118 Detroit-Shoreway $0 103100 0 APT, MICHAEL A 3893 WASHINGTON BLVD CLEVELAND OH 44118 Detroit-Shoreway $0 103100 0 VOIERS, SCOTT 5806 HERMAN AVE CLEVELAND OH 44115 Detroit-Shoreway $0 103100 0 VOIERS, SCOTT 5806 HERMAN AVE CLEVELAND OH 44115 Detroit-Shoreway $0 103100 0 STOREY, JOHN O 15808 HERMAN AVE CLEVELAND OH 44115 Detroit-Shoreway $0 103100 0 STOREY, JOHN O 15808 HERMAN AVE CLEVELAND OH 44115 Detroit-Shoreway $0 103100 0 REINOSO, MICHAL R 1203 W 65 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 Detroit-Shoreway $0 103100 0 MAKOVICKA, JOSEPH P 1203 W 65 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 Detroit-Shoreway $0 103100 0 AMERICAN DREAM HOLDINGS LLC 3200 FRANKLIN BLVD CLEVELAND OH 44113 Detroit-Shoreway $74,600 103100 0 WANDER HOME LLC 3112 STONE WHEEL ST AVON OH 44011 Detroit-Shoreway $77,700 103100 0 PISANO, MICHAEL J 1312 W 61 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 Detroit-Shoreway $78,900 103100 0 TERRY, ALLISON J 5720 FRANKLIN BLVD CLEVELAND OH 44102 Detroit-Shoreway 103400 0 SUMMERSON, JAMES 7915 FERRELL AVE CLEVELAND OH 44102 Detroit-Shoreway $35,700 101800 0 LOWSTETTER, JOHN 1914 W 74 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 Detroit-Shoreway $51,600 101800 0 RUTHERFORD, HAYDEN 7318 WAKEFIELD AVE CLEVELAND OH 44102 Detroit-Shoreway $53,400 101900 0 TAYLOR, WILLIAM J 1922 W 73 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 Detroit-Shoreway $89,100 101900 0 6007-6009 WAKEFIELD LLC 6112 PEAR AVE CLEVELAND OH 44102 Detroit-Shoreway $79,100 103400 0 STARKEY, BILLY ETAL 6022 PEAR AVE CLEVELAND OH 44102 Detroit-Shoreway $30,500 103400 0 6007-6009 WAKEFIELD LLC 6112 PEAR AVE CLEVELAND OH 44102 Detroit-Shoreway $3,300 103400 0 SHOREWAY MANAGEMENT, LLC 6728 COLUMBIA RD OLMSTED FALLS OH 44138 Detroit-Shoreway $98,100 103400 0 KEARNEY, ELLEN MARIE 5903 BRIDGE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44102 Detroit-Shoreway $52,700 103400 0 CASA ALEGRE, LLC 3349 ELSMERE RD SHAKER HTS OH 44120 Detroit-Shoreway $49,500 103400 0 THOMAS, TRENT H 6300 FIR AVE CLEVELAND OH 44102 Detroit-Shoreway $53,800 103400 0 MURRELL, MARGARET 6311 ELLEN AVE CLEVELAND OH 44102 Detroit-Shoreway $49,900 103400 0 HOGG, JAMES W 1836 W 58 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 Detroit-Shoreway $92,500 103400 0 DMF LAND, LLC 1422 W 81 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 Detroit-Shoreway $32,600 103400 0 FEDERMANN, KARL R 1950 W 52 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 Detroit-Shoreway $34,800 103400 0 YEAGER, III, PAUL L 1886 W 57 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 Detroit-Shoreway $13,800 103400 0 SCARPELLI, JOSEPH A 5404 BRIDGE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44102 Detroit-Shoreway $128,000 103400 0 AMF PROPERTIES, LLC 19885 DETROIT RD ROCKY RIVER OH 44116 Detroit-Shoreway $24,300 103400 0 PERZ, ALEX 1885 W 52 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 Detroit-Shoreway $144,000 103400 0 PERZ, ALEX 1885 W 52 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 Detroit-Shoreway $1,800 103400 0 MEYERS-KIOUSIS, ALANNA L TRS 5702 TILLMAN AVE CLEVELAND OH 44102 Detroit-Shoreway $368,600 103100 0 MEYERS-KIOUSIS, ALANNA 5702 TILLMAN AVE CLEVELAND OH 44102 Detroit-Shoreway $1,800 103100 0 MATTERN, CHRIS 2063 MORRISON AVE LAKEWOOD OH 44107 Cudell $33,400 101700 0 MATTERN, CHRIS 2063 MORRISON AVE LAKEWOOD OH 44107 Cudell $33,400 101700 0 BODA, MOZES 3913 VICTORY BLVD CLEVELAND OH 44111 Cudell $54,100 101700 0 SAA, FARES B 2025 W 85 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 Cudell $42,800 101700 0 SAA, FARES B 2025 W 85 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 Cudell $42,800 101700 0 Page 80 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable + 2000 Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Old Non-Taxable Census Dupl. Name Address Municipality State Zip code SPA Name Est.Mkt.Val. Tract Flag GRAYLAIN, LLC 3661 W 134 ST CLEVELAND OH 44111 Detroit-Shoreway $29,300 101800 0 GOODSPEED, DELMAR AND GOODSPEED, BU 7808 ELTON AVE CLEVELAND OH 44102 Detroit-Shoreway $39,300 101800 0 7421 DUDLEY AVENUE TRUST 3225 MCLEOD DR LAS VEGAS NV 89121 Detroit-Shoreway $20,300 101800 0 FFCR, LLC 7808 COLGATE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44102 Detroit-Shoreway $52,000 101800 0 SCHNEIDER, MARK C & FORD, REBECCA 7909 COLGATE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44102 Detroit-Shoreway $1,500 101800 0 BETTER BUSINESS PROPERTY, LLC 10200 UNITY CLEVELAND OH 44111 Detroit-Shoreway $24,500 101900 0 NORMAN, MATTHEW T 10119 EDGEWATER DR CLEVELAND OH 44102 Edgewater $373,800 101102 0 MURRAY, CHRISTOPHER 9715 LAKE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44102 Edgewater $167,000 101102 0 NEBESH, INGRID L & BOHDAN A & LI 1949 W PLEASANT VAL CLEVELAND OH 44134 Edgewater $192,100 101102 0 REALIFE MANAGEMENT GROUP LLC 6900 PHILIPS HIGHWAY DR JACKSONVILLE FL 32216 Edgewater $217,600 101102 0 MELLINO, CALDER AND MELLINO, JENNIF 10209 BALTIC RD CLEVELAND OH 44102 Edgewater $74,100 101102 0 CASAREGOLA, CONCETTA I 20770 LORAIN RD FAIRVIEW PARK OH 44126 Edgewater $91,900 101102 0 LESLIE, REG G 2384 PEACHWOOD CIR ATLANTA GA 30345 Edgewater $46,300 101300 0 LUBLIN, JEREMY M & NICOLE L 1409 HOPKINS AVE LAKEWOOD OH 44107 Edgewater $49,800 101300 0 HEISEY, MATTHEW D 1432 W 114 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 Edgewater $68,100 101300 0 WISCONSIN INVESTMENT GROUP, LLC 2240 W 53 ST CLEVELAND OH 44102 Detroit-Shoreway $12,200 102600 0 PEGUERO, JESSICA G 13511 BENNINGTON AVE CLEVELAND OH 44135 Puritas-Longmead $47,000 124600 0 PEGUERO, JESSICA G 13511 BENNINGTON AVE CLEVELAND OH 44135 Puritas-Longmead $4,300 124600 0 FREDERICK, DONNA TRUSTEE 13220 CROSSBURN AVE CLEVELAND OH 44135 Puritas-Longmead $45,500 124600 0 DEMKO, VLADIMIR 17021 BEAVER CIR STRONGSVILLE OH 44136 Puritas-Longmead $43,300 124600 0 KOVALCIK, JAMES 30 PARK DR BEREA OH 44017 Puritas-Longmead $43,600 124600 0 MARCONI, HEATHER R 13700 SPRECHER AVE CLEVELAND OH 44135 Puritas-Longmead $40,700 124600 0 PARDEE, CATHERINE 12820 LONGMEAD AVE CLEVELAND OH 44135 Puritas-Longmead $41,600 124600 0 RENT, INC 10301 LAKE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44102 Puritas-Longmead $41,600 124600 0 SINGH, DICK P 39184 WOODLAND TR AVON OH 44011 Puritas-Longmead $41,800 124600 0 BRESSLER, CONNIE L 12112 LONGMEAD AVE CLEVELAND OH 44135 Puritas-Longmead $46,800 124600 0 MIKHAEL, ANTOINE 12610 MCGOWAN AVE CLEVELAND OH 44135 Puritas-Longmead $37,300 124600 0 MIKHAEL, ANTOINE 12610 MCGOWAN AVE CLEVELAND OH 44135 Puritas-Longmead $3,600 124600 0 ALDEA INVESTMENTS, LLC 4769 COSY COTTAGE PL NORTH LAS VEGAS NV 89031 Puritas-Longmead $32,000 124600 0 ALDEA INVESTMENTS, LLC 12322 MCGOWAN AVE CLEVELAND OH 44135 Puritas-Longmead $2,900 124600 0 SPANGLER, MARK BLANE & SPANGLER, KI 5528 MORNING STAR DR RANCHO CUCAMONGA CA 91737 Puritas-Longmead $28,000 124600 0 CLE RENOVATION GROUP, LLC 11320 PINE ACRES LN CHESTERLAND OH 44026 Puritas-Longmead $58,600 124600 0 CLE RENOVATION GROUP, LLC 11320 PINE ACRES LN CHESTERLAND OH 44026 Puritas-Longmead $58,600 124600 0 HUMPHREY, MICHAEL D 1000 SENTRY RIDGE SUWANEE GA 30024 Puritas-Longmead $49,800 124300 0 RILEY, VINCENT C 14829 SPRENGEL AVE CLEVELAND OH 44135 Jefferson $79,100 124202 0 TORRES, JEFFREY 4396 W 145 ST CLEVELAND OH 44135 Jefferson $63,500 124202 0 GULLEY, VANCE TRS 24720 TWICKENHAM DR BEACHWOOD OH 44122 Puritas-Longmead $67,600 124300 0 BROWN, JAMES 3069 W 115 ST CLEVELAND OH 44111 Puritas-Longmead $51,600 124300 0 LOPEZ, ELIUS J ROSARIO 13514 SHERRY AVE CLEVELAND OH 44135 Puritas-Longmead $63,900 124300 0 SPROSTY, ALEA R 4481 W 146 ST CLEVELAND OH 44135 Puritas-Longmead $56,900 124500 0 REEVES, MARGARET A 4468 W 138 ST CLEVELAND OH 44135 Puritas-Longmead $45,500 124500 0 SOLEIMAN, HANNA AND SOLEIMAN, AIDA 3624 W 114 ST CLEVELAND OH 44111 Puritas-Longmead $60,600 124500 0 BCM RENOVATION LTD 13340 THORNHOPE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44135 Puritas-Longmead $45,100 124500 0 JIROUSEK, THOMAS A, JR 15632 PURITAS AVE CLEVELAND OH 44135 Jefferson $50,600 124202 0 Page 81 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable + 2000 Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Old Non-Taxable Census Dupl. Name Address Municipality State Zip code SPA Name Est.Mkt.Val. Tract Flag TAYEH PROPERTIES, LLC 14224 GRAMATAN AVE CLEVELAND OH 44111 Jefferson $47,500 124202 0 LITCHNEY, MARSHA 4658 W 158 ST CLEVELAND OH 44135 Puritas-Longmead $64,600 124500 0 LITCHNEY, MARSHA 4658 W 158 ST CLEVELAND OH 44135 Puritas-Longmead $64,600 124500 0 SMITH, PATRICIA A 4740 W 157 ST CLEVELAND OH 44135 Puritas-Longmead $116,700 124500 0 LORIA, ANTHONY M 15201 LOUIS AVE CLEVELAND OH 44135 Puritas-Longmead $79,900 124500 0 WILMINGTON SAVINGS FUND SOCIETY FSB 3000 BAYPORT DR TAMPA FL 33607 Jefferson $57,200 123300 0 PROSPERCLE, LLC 1548 LAKEWOOD AVE LAKEWOOD OH 44107 Jefferson $44,100 123300 0 MELENDEZ, SILVIA 3209 W 120 ST CLEVELAND OH 44111 Jefferson $59,000 123300 0 MELENDEZ, SILVIA 3209 W 120 ST CLEVELAND OH 44111 Jefferson $59,000 123300 1 CLEVELAND LAND REUTILIZATION PROGRA 601 LAKESIDE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44114 Jefferson $1,500 123501 0 BURDETTE, MELISSA ET AL 3266 W 128 ST CLEVELAND OH 44111 Jefferson $66,800 123501 0 LIAO, ALBERT 1700 MAGNOLIA WAY FORT WAYNE IN 46804 Jefferson $64,500 123501 0 MORGANTI, NICHOLAS J 3425 W 130 ST CLEVELAND OH 44111 Jefferson $69,400 123501 0 CURRY, SHERRI 3380 W 127 ST CLEVELAND OH 44111 Jefferson $58,400 123501 0 U S BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION 4801 FREDERICA ST OWENSBORO KY 42301 Jefferson $55,400 123501 0 KENNEDY, GEORGE R 3454 W 133 ST CLEVELAND OH 44111 Jefferson $42,900 123501 0 DHARMAVARAM, SANTOSH RK & PRATHIP 11 WESMONT DR WOOD RIDGE NJ 7075 Jefferson $15,600 123501 0 DTAYLORG INVESTMENTS LTD 7291 CHARTER CUP LN WEST CHESTER OH 45069 Jefferson $70,900 124201 0 KWOON, BETTY 31591 DETROIT RD WESTLAKE OH 44145 Jefferson $77,800 123900 0 GUTHREY, BRENT R 3640 W 139 ST CLEVELAND OH 44111 Jefferson $59,700 123900 0 BURKHALTER, ELIZABETH M 3721 W 139 ST CLEVELAND OH 44111 Jefferson $71,100 123900 0 LEONARDI, CHARLES JAMES 3769 W 139 ST CLEVELAND OH 44111 Jefferson $61,000 123900 0 MCGEE, SKYLA 3573 W 136 ST CLEVELAND OH 44111 Jefferson $54,700 123900 0 SWANSON, ALBERT DICKERSON 3644 W 134 ST CLEVELAND OH 44111 Jefferson $35,200 123900 0 THE HUNTINGTON NATIONAL BANK 5555 CLEVELAND AVE COLUMBUS OH 43231 Jefferson $63,200 123900 0 COLLINS, IVELISSE 3846 W 134 ST CLEVELAND OH 44111 Jefferson $66,400 123900 0 3592 WEST 133RD LLC 3592 W 133 ST CLEVELAND OH 44111 Jefferson $74,200 123900 0 A & R FAMILY INVESTMENT LLC 3802 W 133 ST CLEVELAND OH 44111-4411 Jefferson $57,700 123900 0 SINGER, MARK R 13324 WEST AVE CLEVELAND OH 44111 Jefferson $54,400 123900 0 JAX REINV1 LLC 23811 CHAGRIN BLVD BEACHWOOD OH 44122 Jefferson $66,000 123900 0 BURROW, DANIEL J 3841 W 134 ST CLEVELAND OH 44111 Jefferson $77,500 123900 0 SUMAILI, LOPEMBE P 6656 CHICAGO IL 60680 Puritas-Longmead $66,900 124300 0 ADAMCZYK, WAYNE T 13801 WAINSTEAD AVE CLEVELAND OH 44111 Jefferson $79,400 124300 0 TAYEH PROPERTIES II, LLC 8624 WHIPPOORWILL LN PARMA OH 44130 Puritas-Longmead $49,900 124300 0 AYERS, MALISSA 13701 COURTLAND AVE CLEVELAND OH 44111 Puritas-Longmead $70,500 124300 0 BIAS, RICHARD 3785 GRAFTON RD BRUNSWICK OH 44212 Puritas-Longmead $65,800 124300 0 GRUBER, LAWRENCE 2200 SEVERN AVE METAIRIE LA 70001 Jefferson $66,400 124201 0 LYON, SAMANTHA L 14779 PEARL RD STRONGSVILLE OH 44136 Jefferson $34,500 124201 0 TAYEH PROPERTIES II, LLC 3982 BROOKSIDE BLVD CLEVELAND OH 44111 Jefferson $45,800 124201 0 CABAN, ANGEL O 14213 LEROY AVE CLEVELAND OH 44135 Jefferson $94,800 124201 0 GRAYLYN PROPERTIES LTD 1199 RIVER VALLEY TR HINCKLEY OH 44233 Jefferson $69,500 124201 0 BACKSTREETS REAL ESTATE LLC 14505 FAIRLAWN AVE CLEVELAND OH 44111 Jefferson $48,800 124201 0 MCINTYRE, ABIGAIL 14504 VIOLA AVE CLEVELAND 44111 Jefferson $53,900 124201 0 NOSA OF OHIO, L L C 6302 NORTH SACRAMENTO AV CHICAGO IL 60659 Jefferson $47,900 124201 0 Page 82 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable + 2000 Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Old Non-Taxable Census Dupl. Name Address Municipality State Zip code SPA Name Est.Mkt.Val. Tract Flag TAYEH PROPERTIES II, LLC 3982 BROOKSIDE BLVD CLEVELAND OH 44111 Jefferson $29,000 124201 0 WALCOTT, AMANDA B 3103 W 136 ST CLEVELAND OH 44111 Kamms Corners $74,600 123200 0 KAREEM, ABUBAKER 3244 W 139 ST CLEVELAND OH 44111 Kamms Corners $53,800 123200 0 KAREEM, ABUBAKER 3244 W 139 ST CLEVELAND OH 44111 Kamms Corners $53,800 123200 0 MARSHALL, MICHAEL C-TRUSTEE 3177 W 139 ST CLEVELAND OH 44111 Kamms Corners $91,900 123200 0 CENTANNE, MASON 3233 JOSLYN RD CLEVELAND OH 44111 Kamms Corners $85,800 123200 0 TAYEH PROPERTIES, LLC 14224 GRAMATAN AVE CLEVELAND OH 44111 Jefferson $44,700 123502 0 TAYEH PROPERTIES, LLC 8624 WHIPPOORWILL PARMA OH 44130 Jefferson $48,000 123502 0 TAYEH PROPERTIES III, LLC 8624 WHIPPOORWILL LN PARMA OH 44130 Jefferson $21,000 123502 0 VIHTELIC, STEVEN R 14140 TRISKETT RD CLEVELAND OH 44111 Kamms Corners $78,000 123200 0 MCBRIDE, MARTIN 3134 W 162 ST CLEVELAND OH 44111 Kamms Corners $136,300 123100 0 KELLER, RANDALL S 15841 EDGECLIFF AVE CLEVELAND OH 44111 Kamms Corners $173,900 123100 0 TOOMEY, MICHAEL W 3411 W 157 ST CLEVELAND OH 44111 Kamms Corners $130,500 123100 0 PERRY, SHONDA LYNN 14729 ALGER RD CLEVELAND OH 44111 Kamms Corners $110,100 123100 0 TM INVESTMENT HOLDINGS LLC 17008 SCULLIN DR CLEVELAND OH 44112 Kamms Corners $93,100 123200 0 SOLLENNE, SUSAN J 14410 ALGER RD CLEVELAND OH 44107 Kamms Corners $87,700 123200 0 MEPHAM, MICHAEL T 141 DORCHESTER BOSTON MA 2127 Kamms Corners $78,700 123200 0 CLOSE, TIMOTHY M 14401 ROXBORO AVE CLEVELAND OH 44114 Kamms Corners $126,700 123200 0 BORIS, MATTHEW 3562 W 146 ST CLEVELAND OH 44111 Jefferson $85,600 123502 0 ROCK, CHERYL L (AKA) BECK, CHERYL L 14412 RAINBOW RD CLEVELAND OH 44111 Jefferson $66,000 123502 0 SAAD, KAFI H 14139 TUCKAHOE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44111 Jefferson $52,400 123502 0 MAXWELL, SEAN T & MAXWELL, SHARLEA 17521 OXFORD AVE CLEVELAND OH 44111 Kamms Corners $143,000 123400 0 WILLIAMS, KARIN BENNING 3436 W 159 ST CLEVELAND OH 44111 Kamms Corners $109,800 123400 0 VASEK, TAMMIE 3181 W 14 ST CLEVELAND OH 44109 Kamms Corners $97,000 123400 0 VASEK, TAMMIE 3181 W 14 ST CLEVELAND OH 44109 Kamms Corners $97,000 123400 0 WM J WATERS 16207 W PARK RD CLEVELAND OH 44111-3959 Kamms Corners $144,100 123400 0 GRACE ANNE WATERS 16203 WEST PARK AVE CLEVELAND OH 44111 Kamms Corners $120,600 123400 0 GRACE ANNE WATERS 16203 WEST PARK AVE CLEVELAND OH 44111 Kamms Corners $120,600 123400 1 LAURENT, BRUCE C 17003 FERNDALE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44111 Kamms Corners $125,000 123400 0 CHEN, MING YU 3743 W 165 ST CLEVELAND OH 44111 Kamms Corners $109,100 123400 0 COSTANZO, PATRICK 3610 ROCKPORT AVE CLEVELAND OH 44111 Kamms Corners $101,500 123400 0 PERKOVIC, ZVONIMIR 16725 BRADGATE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44111 Kamms Corners $110,700 123603 0 MURRAY, CHRISTOPHER A 9715 LAKE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44102 Kamms Corners $45,100 123603 0 GARCIA-CRUZ, LINDA V 17805 SUSAN AVE CLEVELAND OH 44111 Kamms Corners $107,700 123603 0 DEUTSCHE BANK NATIONAL TRUST COMPAN 1661 WORTHINGTON RD WEST PALM BEACH FL 33409 Kamms Corners $100,100 123603 0 THE BANK OF NEW YORK MELLON-TRUSTEE 8950 CYPRESS WATERS BLVD COPPELL TX 75019 Kamms Corners $73,300 123602 0 KISS, THOMAS 4182 RUSTIC RD CLEVELAND OH 44135 Kamms Corners $95,700 123602 0 KOTT, BRYAN J 4299 W 180 ST CLEVELAND OH 44135 Kamms Corners $90,100 123602 0 RUSSELL, MICHELE J 4350 W 189 ST CLEVELAND OH 44135 Kamms Corners $61,500 123602 0 MOORE, DANIEL J 18140 PURITAS AVE CLEVELAND OH 44135 Kamms Corners $77,300 123602 0 SAINATO, JUSTIN J 4538 LITTLE MET PL CLEVELAND OH 44135 Kamms Corners $85,300 123700 0 MESHI, LINDIOR 1470 WAGAR RD ROCKY RIVER OH 44116 Riverside $64,600 123700 0 LACH, WAYNE F 18226 FAIRVILLE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44135 Riverside $75,500 123700 0 ALDHBAIB, JESSICA LYNNE 1515 RIDGEWOOD AVE LAKEWOOD OH 44107 Riverside $74,400 123700 0 Page 83 of 84 Residential Sales for Cleveland Wards, December 2018 Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Office Prepared by Northern Ohio Data and Information Service (NODIS), Levin College of Urban Affairs, Cleveland State University

Taxable + 2000 Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Tax Mailing Old Non-Taxable Census Dupl. Name Address Municipality State Zip code SPA Name Est.Mkt.Val. Tract Flag GIGANTE, MELINDA CRISTINE 18513 FERNCLIFFE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44135 Riverside $74,100 123700 0 BOUKHENNOU, KARIMA 3826 WILLOW RUN WESTLAKE OH 44145 Riverside $70,600 123700 0 INVCLE150, LLC 4859 DOVER CENTER RD NORTH OLMSTED OH 44070 Kamms Corners $890,000 123603 0 GALE, KATHERINE 4022 W 166 ST CLEVELAND OH 44135 Kamms Corners $87,800 123603 0 TODOROV, KAREN A (SUCC TRS) 16806 MELGRAVE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44135 Kamms Corners $91,900 123603 0 MONDELLO INVESTMENT GROUP, LLC 4302 VIRGINIA DR FAIRVIEW PARK OH 44126 Kamms Corners $75,500 123603 0 MONDELLO INVESTMENT GROUP, LLC 4302 VIRGINIA DR FAIRVIEW PARK OH 44126 Kamms Corners $75,500 123603 0 COGAR, KAREN (TRS) 4031 W 161 ST CLEVELAND OH 44135 Kamms Corners $97,600 123601 0 FANNIE MAE PO 650043 DALLAS TX 75265 Kamms Corners $90,400 123601 0 BURGESS, RICKIE D & LORALEE 3341 ACUMINATA DR WEST SALEM OH 44287 Kamms Corners $93,600 123601 0 NORTHEAST COMMERCIAL PROPERTIES, IN P 1863 YOUNGSTOWN OH 44501 Kamms Corners $95,400 123601 0 DEFIEBRE, JESSE 16700 WOODBURY AVE CLEVELAND OH 44135 Kamms Corners $87,800 123601 0 WARD, JEFFREY J 16908 ELSIENNA AVE CLEVELAND OH 44135 Kamms Corners $98,100 123601 0 TASEFF, BRADLEY B & SMITH, BRIAN 2992 W 12 ST CLEVELAND OH 44113 Kamms Corners $113,500 123601 0 HANRAHAN, THOMAS J 16604 ELSIENNA AVE CLEVELAND OH 44135 Kamms Corners $102,400 123601 0 MCDERMOTT JR , JOHN S 16809 MILBURN AVE CLEVELAND OH 44135 Kamms Corners $94,600 123601 0 CLARK STREET, RONNIE L AND CLARK 15902 WESTDALE AVE CLEVELAND OH 44135 Kamms Corners $74,300 123601 0 HARRIS, PAUL D 2500 H ST EUREKA CA 95501 Kamms Corners $27,000 123800 0 FAUST, BRIAN S 4630 GRAYTON RD CLEVELAND OH 44135 Riverside $87,600 123700 0

Page 84 of 84