Trauma, Healing, and Pedagogical Shifts in an English Classroom
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA Los Angeles Literacies of Love: Trauma, Healing, and Pedagogical Shifts in an English Classroom A dissertation submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree Doctor of Philosophy in Education by Sharim Hannegan-Martinez 2020 © Copyright by Sharim Hannegan-Martinez 2020 ABSTRACT OF THE DISSERTATION Literacies of Love: Trauma, Healing, and Pedagogical Shifts in an English Classroom by Sharim Hannegan-Martinez Doctor of Philosophy in Education University of California, Los Angeles, 2020 Professor Daniel G. Solórzano, Chair Emerging research shows that more than half of all U.S. children have experienced some kind of trauma in the form of abuse, neglect, violence, or challenging household circumstances— and 35 percent of children have experienced more than one type of traumatic event (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 2016). In this study— Literacies of Love: Trauma, Healing and Pedagogical Shifts in an English Classroom—I draw from, blend, and synthesize existing research in the fields of public health, social epidemiology, psychiatry, psychotherapy, Ethnic Studies, and education to achieve a more robust understanding of trauma, its effects, and existing interventions. I then draw from these aforementioned fields to highlight a grotesquely under- theorized, but widely agreed upon intervention to child trauma: loving relationships (Ginwright, 2016; Duncan-Andrade, 2009; Perry, 2007; Siegel & Solomon, 2003, Van Der Kolk, 2014). Drawing on a corpus of data collected throughout my tenure as a teacher-researcher, I integrate student work, interviews, focus groups, reflections, videos, and journal entries to conceptualize love and illustrate how to cultivate loving relationships and literacies within an ii English classroom. Through qualitative analysis, including discourse, media, and document analysis, my dissertation highlights the strong corollary between literacy practices and loving relationships to self, classroom, and community. This research is timely, coinciding with significant shifts in the field towards trauma-informed pedagogies and social-emotional learning. Moreover, this study will make a valuable contribution to educational research at the intersection of trauma-informed pedagogies, critical literacy, and urban education. Keywords: Love, Critical Literacy, Pedagogy of Love, Literacies of Love, Critical Race Theory, Urban Education iii The dissertation of Sharim Hannegan-Martinez is approved. Dolores Delgado Bernal Tyrone Howard Hesham Samy Alim Daniel G. Solórzano, Committee Chair University of California, Los Angeles 2020 iv This dissertation is dedicated to: My students, every young person I have ever met or have yet to meet, to the babies still on their way here, and those who have left us too early: I love you. This work is for you. A reminder that you are loved, have always been loved even when this world would have you believe that it is untrue. May our love inoculate you against this loveless world. May we build a world where you always know how unequivocally loved and treasured you are. & My abuelita Ernestina Escalante, who prayed for me long before I was born, who taught me what it was to survive and live and love for our children and our children’s children. v TABLE OF CONTENTS ABSTRACT OF THE DISSERTATION ....................................................................................... ii DEDICATION ................................................................................................................................ v LIST OF FIGURES ..................................................................................................................... viii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ........................................................................................................... ix VITA ............................................................................................................................................ xiii CHAPTER ONE: INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................. 1 Trauma: A National Crisis .......................................................................................................... 3 Love as an Intervention to Trauma ............................................................................................. 6 Research Goals............................................................................................................................ 9 Overview of Chapters ............................................................................................................... 10 CHAPTER TWO: LITERATURE REVIEW ............................................................................... 12 Overview ................................................................................................................................... 12 Part I: Understanding Trauma ................................................................................................... 13 Defining Trauma ................................................................................................................... 13 Trauma, the Brain and the Body ........................................................................................... 15 Effects of Trauma ................................................................................................................. 17 Part II: Love as an Intervention to Trauma, Love as Healing ................................................... 23 The Importance of Loving Relationships ............................................................................. 23 Love, the Body and Brain ..................................................................................................... 25 Looking at Love .................................................................................................................... 27 Love as Political .................................................................................................................... 28 Love and Care in Education .................................................................................................. 29 Part III: Literacy, Healing, and Love ........................................................................................ 33 CHAPTER THREE: METHODOLOGY ..................................................................................... 38 Study 1: Compa Love Application and Reflection ................................................................... 39 Portraiture and Anticipatory Frameworks ................................................................................ 41 Portraiture’s Essential Features............................................................................................. 42 Anticipatory Frameworks, Cultural Intuition, and Theoretical Frameworks ....................... 43 Critical Race Theory and Critical Race Pedagogy ............................................................... 44 Culturally Sustaining Pedagogies ......................................................................................... 45 Chicana and Women of Color Feminist Epistemologies ...................................................... 46 Muralism: A Participatory Portraiture ...................................................................................... 46 Research-Collaborators ......................................................................................................... 50 vi Data Collection Methods and Analysis..................................................................................... 50 Pláticas .................................................................................................................................. 51 Data Analysis ............................................................................................................................ 56 Artist’s Statement...................................................................................................................... 57 Framing of the Findings ............................................................................................................ 58 CHAPTER FOUR: ALEX ............................................................................................................ 60 CHAPTER FIVE: LAY ................................................................................................................ 92 CHAPTER SIX: EMELIANO .................................................................................................... 119 CHAPTER SEVEN: TOWARDS PEDAGOGIES AND LITERACIES OF LOVE ................. 151 Compa Love Revisited ............................................................................................................ 151 Towards Pedagogies of Love .................................................................................................. 152 Pedagogy of Love ................................................................................................................... 154 Literacies of Love ................................................................................................................... 159 Curriculum Design .............................................................................................................. 160 Conclusion .............................................................................................................................. 164 Trauma, Love, and the Present Moment ................................................................................